Crafty 23.2 released.

[Kirill Kryukov]

Is it possible to run this version throuh WB2UCI adapter? That's the only way I can test it, but how can it run if it does not use the crafty.rc file?

Running okay here using the wb2uci adapter. You still get the parameter options showing up.

Thanks! I'll then put it into my testing queue.

[Dr.Wael Deeb]

Thanks for the new release but I prefer to wait for JA compiles....
Dr.D

JA compiles?

http://homepages.tesco.net/henry.ablett/jims.html

[Togga]

after only 10 games i can clearly say that the version 23.2 is better than 23.1 :))

timecontrol 2min + 2 sec:

Crafty-23.2-win32 - Crafty_23.1_ja : 6,5/10 5-2-3 (=01==10111) 65% +108

bad: 2 games got lost:(

games soon:


question to:

Crafty-23.2 2661 3 3 40000 60% 2583 23%
Crafty-23.1 2638 3 3 40000 57% 2583 23%

what timecontrol was it?

[govert]

after only 10 games i can clearly say that the version 23.2 is better than 23.1 )

timecontrol 2min + 2 sec:

Crafty-23.2-win32 - Crafty_23.1_ja : 6,5/10 5-2-3 (=01==10111) 65% +108

bad: 2 games got lost:(

games soon:


question to:

Crafty-23.2 2661 3 3 40000 60% 2583 23%
Crafty-23.1 2638 3 3 40000 57% 2583 23%

what timecontrol was it?

No. It's not clear. But it's somewhat likely. (A lot of people will even object to this conclusion. Read further...)

Bayeselo:
=========

Code: Select all

ResultSet-EloRating>ratings
Rank Name   Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws
   1 23.2    39   86   80    10   65%   -39   30%
   2 23.1   -39   80   86    10   35%    39   30%

ResultSet-EloRating>los   (likelyhood of superiority)
        23.1 23.2
23.2         83
23.1    16

So, it's 83% likely that 23.2 is stronger than 23.1
83% is not sufficient at all to conclude that something is clearly stronger.

By the way. A lot of people will simply disregards the calculation of los=83% and simply claim that you should _never_ draw _any_ conclusions from only 10 games played. Of course this is also wrong. You can draw _some_ conclusions, but the conclusions will not be strong.

It's all in the wording, and no matter how you word it, someone will twist it the wrong way.

[Togga]

why crafty 23.2 lost 2 games when it is better than 23.1?
the opening start positions were draw:
1.d4 d5 2.c4
1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5


[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "D07"]
[Opening "QGD"]
[Variation "Chigorin, 3.cxd5, Main Line, 7.bxc3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "64"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.d4 d5 2.c4 Nc6 {-0.02/14} 3.cxd5
{+0.07/14} Qxd5 {+0.07/14} 4.e3 {+0.19/14} e5 {-0.09/14} 5.Nc3 {-0.22/13} Bb4 {-0.03/13}
6.Bd2 {-0.20/13} Bxc3 {-0.11/14} 7.bxc3 {-0.06/14} exd4 {+0.07/14} 8.cxd4 {+0.01/15}
Nf6 {+0.12/14} 9.Ne2 {+0.14/14} O-O {+0.20/14} 10.Nf4 {+0.19/14} Qd6 {+0.20/14}
11.Bd3 Nb4 {+0.22/13} 12.Bc4 {+0.31/13} Ne4 {+0.22/13} 13.O-O {+0.35/13} Nxd2
{+0.27/14} 14.Qxd2 {+0.36/13} Bf5 {+0.27/13} 15.Rac1 {+0.46/12} Rae8 {+0.34/12} 16.Bb3
{+0.47/12} Be4 {+0.41/13} 17.f3 {+0.56/13} Bc6 {+0.49/13} 18.Rc5 {+0.58/13} b6 {+0.46/12}
19.Rc3 {+0.65/12} Bb7 {+0.52/12} 20.a3 {+0.58/12} Nc6 {+0.57/13} 21.Rfc1 {+0.62/12}
Na5 {+0.53/12} 22.Ba2 {+0.66/11} c6 {+0.52/12} 23.Qc2 {+0.57/11} Qh6 {+0.45/12}
24.Qd3 {+0.45/12} Re7 {+0.33/12} 25.d5 {+0.42/11} c5 {+0.25/12} 26.Rd1 {+0.28/12} Rd8
{+0.25/12} 27.Kh1 {+0.22/11} a6 {+0.20/11} 28.Qb1 {+0.22/11} c4 {+0.01/12} 29.Qf5
{+0.08/12} Bc8 {-0.01/12} 30.Qb1 {+0.01/13} Bb7 {-0.01/14} 31.Qf5 {+0.01/13} Bc8
{-0.01/14} 32.Qb1 {+0.01/15} Bb7 {-0.01/15} {3-fold repetition} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "2"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "D30"]
[Opening "QGD"]
[Variation "3.Nf3 Nf6 4.e3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "248"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 {-0.09/13} 3.Nf3
{-0.13/13} Nf6 {-0.02/13} 4.e3 {-0.01/13} Nc6 {+0.05/13} 5.Nc3 {+0.05/14} Be7 {+0.07/13}
6.Ne5 {+0.16/14} O-O {+0.14/14} 7.Nxc6 {+0.24/15} bxc6 {+0.38/15} 8.Qa4 {+0.26/15}
dxc4 {+0.16/12} 9.Bxc4 {+0.46/14} Nd5 {+0.21/13} 10.Qc2 {+0.37/14} Bd6 {+0.31/13}
11.O-O {+0.55/13} Qh4 {+0.32/12} 12.f4 {+0.70/12} Bd7 {+0.41/11} 13.e4 {+0.82/13} Nxc3
{+0.47/13} 14.Qxc3 {+0.87/14} Rab8 {+0.63/12} 15.Be3 {+0.87/13} f5 {+0.68/13} 16.e5
{+1.11/13} Be7 {+0.90/12} 17.Rf3 {+1.12/13} Qg4 {+0.93/12} 18.Rg3 {+1.25/14} Qh5
{+1.03/13} 19.Rh3 {+1.25/15} Qf7 {+1.04/13} 20.Rc1 {+1.25/14} Rfd8 {+1.04/12} 21.Qd2
{+1.25/13} Rb7 {+1.06/12} 22.Qe2 {+1.25/13} a5 {+0.97/12} 23.b3 {+1.19/12} Ba3 {+0.95/12}
24.Rc2 {+1.25/12} Ra8 {+0.85/13} 25.Qe1 {+1.22/12} Be7 {+0.89/13} 26.a4 {+1.25/13} h6
{+0.94/13} 27.Qf2 {+1.25/14} Kh8 {+0.98/14} 28.Bd2 {+1.25/14} Qg8 {+1.03/13} 29.Bc3
{+1.29/12} Qf7 {+1.05/13} 30.Qe1 {+1.26/13} Rba7 {+1.10/13} 31.Qe3 {+1.26/12} Rb7
{+1.03/13} 32.Qf2 {+1.26/14} Kg8 {+0.98/13} 33.Rc1 {+1.29/12} Kh8 {+0.94/12} 34.Qe1
{+1.26/13} Rba7 {+1.13/13} 35.Qd2 {+1.25/12} Bc8 {+1.13/13} 36.Rg3 {+1.25/12} Bb7
{+1.05/11} 37.Kh1 {+1.25/13} Bh4 {+1.13/13} 38.Re3 {+1.25/14} Be7 {+1.13/13} 39.Rd3
{+1.25/14} Ba6 {+1.08/13} 40.Bxa6 {+1.25/13} R7xa6 {+0.88/12} 41.Qe1 {+1.25/12} Qe8
{+0.76/12} 42.Qe2 {+1.11/13} Rb6 {+0.67/12} 43.Be1 {+1.10/13} Qd7 {+0.73/12} 44.Qf3
{+1.09/13} g6 {+0.71/13} 45.Bd2 {+1.04/13} Kg7 {+0.67/12} 46.Rc4 {+1.04/13} Ra7 {+0.63/13}
47.Qe3 {+0.94/12} Rbb7 {+0.63/13} 48.Qe1 {+0.95/13} Qd5 {+0.56/13} 49.Qd1 {+0.94/12}
Rb8 {+0.55/13} 50.Rh3 {+0.87/11} Ra6 {+0.55/12} 51.Qc1 {+0.85/12} Rab6 {+0.55/14}
52.Qc2 {+0.58/13} Ba3 {+0.51/13} 53.Rg3 {+0.69/12} Be7 {+0.55/13} 54.Qd1 {+0.70/13}
Kf7 {+0.52/13} 55.Rh3 {+0.68/13} Bb4 {+0.29/12} 56.Bc1 {+0.68/13} Kg7 {+0.41/13}
57.Rg3 {+0.68/14} Be7 {+0.34/11} 58.Rd3 Ra6 {+0.41/12} 59.Be3 {+0.77/13} Rb4
{+0.38/12} 60.Rcc3 {+0.78/13} Qe4 {+0.44/11} 61.Qf1 {+0.76/12} Qd5 {+0.42/12} 62.Bf2
{+0.80/13} Ra8 {+0.47/12} 63.Qc1 {+0.72/13} Rb6 {+0.47/12} 64.Rc4 {+0.67/13} Rab8
{+0.45/13} 65.Qc2 {+0.58/13} Rd8 {+0.34/12} 66.Be1 {+0.58/12} g5 {+0.24/12} 67.Rf3
{+0.49/12} Rdb8 {+0.21/12} 68.Rg3 {+0.53/11} g4 {+0.16/13} 69.Bd2 {+0.41/13} h5 {-0.01/14}
70.Rd3 {+0.41/13} h4 {-0.01/14} 71.Kg1 {+0.19/14} Ra6 {-0.01/14} 72.Be1 {+0.41/12}
Rab6 {-0.01/14} 73.Bf2 {+0.33/12} Rd8 {-0.01/13} 74.Kf1 {+0.42/12} Rdb8 {-0.01/13}
75.Rdc3 {+0.32/11} Bb4 {-0.01/13} 76.Re3 {+0.33/13} Rh8 {-0.25/12} 77.Qd3 {+0.27/13} g3
{-0.27/13} 78.hxg3 {+0.70/14} h3 {+0.22/13} 79.gxh3 Qh1+ {+0.21/11} 80.Ke2 {+0.79/13} Rxh3
{+0.10/13} 81.Qd1 {+0.66/13} Qd5 {+0.28/13} 82.Qf1 {+0.19/12} Rh2 {-0.01/13} 83.Kd1
{+0.01/13} Rb8 84.Kc1 {+0.01/12} Rh1 {-3.51/13} 85.Bg1 {-3.34/13} Rbh8 {-3.60/13} 86.Re2
{-3.58/14} Rxg1 {-3.88/14} 87.Qxg1 {-3.58/16} Rh1 {-3.97/14} 88.Qxh1 {-3.63/16} Qxh1+
{-4.00/14} 89.Kb2 {-3.57/16} Qf3 {-3.99/16} 90.Rec2 c5 {-4.04/15} 91.dxc5 {-3.87/15} Qxg3
{-4.15/15} 92.c6 {-3.72/15} Be1 {-4.37/15} 93.Ka2 {-4.07/14} Qe3 {-4.67/15} 94.Kb2
{-4.99/16} Bd2 {-5.15/16} 95.Ka2 {-5.25/16} Qd3 {-5.77/16} 96.Rb2 {-5.47/17} Kf7
{-5.77/18} 97.Ka3 {-5.88/17} Be3 {-6.59/17} 98.Ka2 {-6.08/15} Qf1 {-6.70/17} 99.Rb1
{-6.66/15} Qf3 {-6.74/16} 100.Rb2 {-6.94/16} Bxf4 {-6.89/16} 101.Rc5 {-6.99/16} Qe4
{-7.34/15} 102.Rxa5 {-7.26/14} Bxe5 {-7.76/14} 103.Rxe5 {-7.67/14} Qxe5 {-8.66/14} 104.b4
{-9.43/13} f4 {-9.46/12} 105.b5 {-9.45/12} Qd5+ {-10.21/12} 106.Ka1 {-10.56/12} Qd1+
{-10.69/12} 107.Ka2 {-12.66/13} Qxa4+ {-12.77/12} 108.Kb1 f3 {-13.45/12} 109.b6 {-13.53/12}
Qe4+ {-13.63/11} 110.Ka2 {-13.75/12} Qc4+ {-13.82/11} 111.Kb1 {-13.93/12} Qf1+
{-13.89/11} 112.Ka2 {-14.18/12} f2 {-14.40/12} 113.Rb1 {-14.31/11} Qa6+ {-14.70/11} 114.Kb3
{-14.60/11} Qxb6+ {-15.06/11} 115.Kc2 Qxb1+ {-18.68/11} 116.Kxb1 {-M22/13} f1=Q+ {-M22/11}
117.Kc2 {-M21/12} e5 {-M12/12} 118.Kd2 {-M8/12} e4 {-M8/12} 119.Ke3 Qd3+ {-M6/11}
120.Kf2 {-M5/12} e3+ 121.Kg3 {-M4/11} Qe4 122.Kh2 {-M3/11} e2 123.Kh3 e1=Q 124.Kh2
Q4h1# {Mate} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "3"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C48"]
[Opening "Four Knights"]
[Variation "Spanish Variation"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "224"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 {+0.15/14} Nc6 {+0.29/14}
3.Nc3 {+0.18/14} Nf6 {+0.27/14} 4.Bb5 {+0.20/14} Bd6 {+0.10/14} 5.d3 {+0.15/14} a6
{+0.08/16} 6.Ba4 {+0.15/15} b5 {+0.01/15} 7.Bb3 {+0.19/15} Na5 {+0.09/15} 8.Bg5 {+0.26/14}
O-O {+0.17/14} 9.Nd5 {+0.26/14} Be7 {+0.14/14} 10.Nxe7+ {+0.20/14} Qxe7 {+0.10/14}
11.O-O {+0.20/14} d6 {+0.08/14} 12.Qe2 {+0.26/13} Bg4 {+0.07/14} 13.Kh1 {+0.19/14} c6
{+0.06/13} 14.Bd2 {+0.16/14} Nxb3 {+0.08/14} 15.axb3 {+0.17/13} Rfe8 {+0.09/14} 16.h3
{+0.28/13} Bd7 {+0.12/14} 17.Ra5 {+0.33/14} Bc8 {+0.10/13} 18.Rfa1 {+0.26/14} Bb7
{+0.04/13} 19.Nh4 {+0.35/13} Qe6 {-0.02/13} 20.Nf5 {+0.27/13} d5 {+0.05/13} 21.f3
{+0.25/12} Kh8 {+0.18/13} 22.b4 {+0.45/11} Ng8 {+0.06/12} 23.Bg5 {+0.43/12} f6 {-0.01/13}
24.Bd2 {+0.20/12} Ne7 {-0.02/13} 25.g4 {+0.26/12} Rac8 {-0.11/12} 26.Qf2 {+0.21/12}
Nxf5 {-0.21/13} 27.gxf5 {+0.06/12} Qe7 {-0.18/12} 28.Qc5 {+0.06/13} Qf7 {-0.27/12}
29.Rg1 {+0.10/13} Qh5 {-0.29/13} 30.Kg2 {+0.04/12} Rcd8 {-0.29/13} 31.Raa1 {-0.11/11}
Rd7 {-0.39/12} 32.Qf2 {-0.06/11} g6 {-0.36/11} 33.fxg6 {+0.04/12} Rg7 {-0.39/12}
34.h4 {-0.08/11} hxg6 {-0.28/12} 35.Rgh1 {-0.12/11} Rc7 {-0.50/10} 36.Rae1 {-0.13/11}
Rh7 {-0.44/11} 37.Qc5 {-0.08/12} Rd7 {-0.42/12} 38.Kf2 {-0.03/11} Rb8 {-0.19/10}
39.Rhg1 {+0.04/11} Rg8 {-0.28/11} 40.Rgh1 {-0.03/11} Re8 {-0.18/11} 41.Rhg1 {+0.01/11}
dxe4 {-0.20/11} 42.Rxe4 {+0.23/12} Rd5 {-0.01/12} 43.Qb6 {+0.25/12} Re7 {+0.06/12}
44.Reg4 {+0.52/13} Rg7 {+0.27/13} 45.Ke2 {+0.54/12} Kh7 {+0.31/12} 46.R1g2 {+0.71/11}
Kg8 {+0.36/12} 47.Bc3 {+0.55/11} Rd6 {+0.26/11} 48.Qg1 {+0.58/12} Kf7 {+0.28/12}
49.Qc5 {+0.49/11} Rd5 {+0.15/12} 50.Qb6 {+0.53/12} Rd7 {+0.27/12} 51.R2g3 {+0.49/11}
Re7 {+0.34/11} 52.Kd1 {+0.55/12} Bc8 {+0.28/12} 53.Re4 {+0.25/13} Bf5 {+0.26/11}
54.Re1 {+0.07/13} Qxh4 {-0.01/13} 55.Rgg1 {+0.02/12} Bd7 {-0.01/12} 56.Rgh1 {+0.01/13}
Qf4 {-0.01/13} 57.Ref1 {+0.01/13} Ke6 {-0.01/13} 58.Rhg1 {+0.01/13} Kf7 59.Rgh1
{+0.01/15} Ke6 60.Rhg1 {+0.01/15} Re8 {-0.05/11} 61.Qc5 {-0.28/11} g5 {-0.45/12} 62.Rgh1
{-0.27/10} Rgg8 {-0.81/11} 63.d4 {-0.14/11} Red8 {-0.03/11} 64.Rh6 {-0.08/11} Be8
{-0.64/12} 65.Rh7 {-0.75/12} Rd5 {-1.01/12} 66.Qe7+ {-0.51/12} Kf5 67.Qb7 {-0.51/11} Kg6
{-1.18/11} 68.Re7 {-1.25/11} exd4 {-1.75/13} 69.Bd2 {-1.54/13} Qf5 {-1.77/12} 70.Qb8
{-1.65/12} Re5 {-1.74/13} 71.Rxe5 {-1.72/12} fxe5 72.Qd6+ {-1.80/11} Qf6 {-2.22/13}
73.Qxf6+ {-2.08/12} Kxf6 74.Ke2 {-2.22/13} Bg6 {-2.43/13} 75.c3 {-2.24/12} Rh8
{-2.37/13} 76.cxd4 {-2.23/13} exd4 {-2.30/13} 77.Rg1 {-2.34/13} Rh2+ {-2.58/13} 78.Ke1
{-2.34/13} Bc2 {-2.64/13} 79.Bxg5+ {-2.76/14} Kf5 {-3.03/14} 80.Bd2 {-2.76/14} d3
{-3.03/14} 81.Bc1 {-3.95/14} Bb3 {-4.12/13} 82.Rg5+ {-3.99/14} Ke6 {-4.39/14} 83.Rg6+
{-4.46/14} Kf7 {-4.64/15} 84.Rxc6 {-4.53/14} Re2+ {-4.57/14} 85.Kf1 d2 {-4.54/14} 86.Bxd2
{-4.77/15} Rxd2 87.Rxa6 Bc4+ {-4.68/13} 88.Ke1 {-4.79/13} Re2+ {-5.01/13} 89.Kd1
{-5.03/14} Rxb2 90.Ke1 {-5.11/13} Rxb4 {-5.27/13} 91.Kf2 {-5.26/13} Rb3 {-5.32/12} 92.f4
{-5.43/12} b4 {-5.51/12} 93.Rb6 {-5.75/13} Be6 {-5.74/13} 94.Rb8 {-5.75/12} Bg4 {-5.73/12}
95.Kg2 {-5.94/12} Kf6 {-6.09/13} 96.Rb5 {-6.27/13} Bd7 {-6.42/13} 97.Rb6+ {-6.53/13}
Kf5 {-6.43/13} 98.Rd6 {-6.54/13} Be8 {-6.67/14} 99.Rd4 {-6.53/12} Bc6+ {-6.81/13}
100.Kf1 {-6.77/13} Be4 {-7.44/14} 101.Ke2 {-7.25/14} Kxf4 {-7.47/14} 102.Kd2
{-11.13/14} Kf3 {-15.88/15} 103.Rc4 {-M12/14} Rd3+ {-M11/14} 104.Kc2 {-M11/14} Rc3+
{-M10/14} 105.Kb2 {-M9/15} Rxc4 {-M8/15} 106.Kb3 {-M7/14} Bd5 {-M7/13} 107.Ka4 Rc6
{-M6/11} 108.Kxb4 {-M5/20} Ke3 109.Kb5 Kd4 110.Kb4 Bc4 111.Ka5 Kc3 112.Ka4 Ra6# {Mate} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "4"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C47"]
[Opening "Four Knights"]
[Variation "Scotch, Main Line"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "152"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 {+0.21/14} Nc6 {+0.19/13}
3.Nc3 {+0.23/14} Nf6 {+0.21/14} 4.d4 {+0.25/14} exd4 {+0.14/15} 5.Nxd4 {+0.33/14} Bb4
{+0.04/14} 6.Nxc6 {+0.24/15} bxc6 {+0.06/14} 7.Bd3 {+0.18/15} O-O {+0.21/14} 8.O-O
{+0.24/14} d6 {+0.16/13} 9.Bg5 {+0.28/13} h6 {+0.09/13} 10.Bh4 {+0.21/13} Qe7 {+0.17/12}
11.f4 {+0.35/12} Re8 {+0.22/11} 12.Na4 {+0.51/13} Qe6 {+0.28/12} 13.c3 {+0.55/13} Ba5
{+0.37/14} 14.Re1 {+0.63/13} Qg4 {+0.36/14} 15.Qxg4 {+0.85/14} Nxg4 {+0.73/14} 16.e5
{+0.87/13} dxe5 {+0.63/14} 17.h3 {+0.72/14} Nf6 {+0.66/14} 18.Rxe5 {+0.82/15} Rxe5
{+0.74/15} 19.fxe5 {+0.86/14} Nd5 20.Bf2 {+0.93/14} Be6 {+0.92/14} 21.Be4 {+1.00/14} Bb6
{+0.94/14} 22.Nc5 {+0.99/15} Rb8 {+0.73/14} 23.Rb1 {+0.90/15} Bxc5 {+0.80/14} 24.Bxc5
{+0.99/14} a6 {+0.85/15} 25.Ba7 {+1.12/14} Ra8 {+0.86/15} 26.Bd4 {+1.14/15} Ne7 {+0.88/15}
27.b3 {+1.18/15} Bf5 {+0.96/14} 28.Re1 {+1.19/16} Bxe4 {+1.02/15} 29.Rxe4 Rd8
{+1.09/14} 30.e6 {+1.18/14} fxe6 {+0.95/14} 31.Rxe6 {+1.08/15} Kf7 {+0.94/14} 32.Re2
{+1.02/14} Nf5 {+0.89/13} 33.Be5 {+1.09/14} Rd1+ {+0.96/12} 34.Kf2 {+1.11/13} Nd6
{+0.89/12} 35.g4 {+1.15/11} c5 {+0.85/12} 36.h4 {+1.04/12} c4 {+0.75/12} 37.b4 {+1.05/12}
g6 {+0.71/13} 38.a4 {+0.85/13} h5 {+0.65/13} 39.gxh5 {+0.70/13} gxh5 {+0.52/14}
40.Ke3 {+0.70/13} Ke6 {+0.51/12} 41.Bh8 {+0.60/12} Kf5 {+0.42/13} 42.Rf2+ {+0.57/13}
Ke6 {+0.45/13} 43.Rf6+ {+0.60/13} Kd5 {+0.41/13} 44.Rg6 {+0.58/13} Rf1 {+0.15/13}
45.a5 {+0.42/13} c6 {0.00/13} 46.Rg5+ {+0.19/14} Nf5+ {-0.01/14} 47.Kd2 {+0.20/15}
Ke6 {+0.04/14} 48.Bd4 {+0.19/14} Rf4 {-0.01/14} 49.Rxh5 {+0.15/14} Rxh4 {-0.01/15}
50.Rxh4 {+0.01/14} Nxh4 {-0.08/16} 51.Kc2 {-0.07/18} Ng2 {-0.08/18} 52.Kd2 {-0.02/18}
Kd5 {-0.02/18} 53.Bc5 {+0.01/19} Ke4 {-0.02/20} 54.Bd4 {+0.01/20} Nf4 {-0.02/19}
55.Bc5 {+0.01/20} Nd3 {-0.01/19} 56.Be7 {+0.01/20} Kd5 {-0.01/20} 57.Ke3 {+0.01/20} c5
{-0.01/20} 58.Bxc5 {+0.01/21} Nxc5 {-0.01/22} 59.bxc5 {+0.01/23} Kxc5 {-0.01/31} 60.Ke4
{+0.01/60} Kb5 {-0.01/60} 61.Kd5 Kxa5 62.Kxc4 Ka4 63.Kd5 a5 64.c4 Kb4 65.c5 a4 66.c6 a3
67.c7 a2 68.c8=Q a1=Q 69.Qb8+ Ka3 70.Qa8+ Kb2 71.Qh8+ Kb1 72.Qh7+ Kb2 73.Qg7+ Kb1
74.Qg6+ Kb2 75.Qf6+ Kb1 76.Qf5+ Kb2 {Draw by mutual agreement} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "5"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A04"]
[Opening "Reti Opening"]
[Variation "1...e6 2.g3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "157"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.g3 e6 {-0.19/16} 2.Nf3 {-0.16/15} Nf6
{-0.13/16} 3.Bg2 {-0.14/15} Bb4 {-0.13/16} 4.O-O {-0.08/15} O-O {-0.08/15} 5.a3 {-0.07/14}
Be7 {-0.15/15} 6.Nc3 {0.00/14} d5 {-0.08/14} 7.d4 {-0.02/14} c5 {-0.10/14} 8.dxc5
{-0.04/14} Bxc5 {-0.10/13} 9.Bg5 {0.00/13} Nc6 {-0.25/12} 10.e4 {+0.01/13} dxe4 {-0.01/14}
11.Qxd8 {+0.14/14} Rxd8 {-0.09/15} 12.Bxf6 {-0.05/16} gxf6 {-0.18/16} 13.Nxe4
{-0.06/15} Be7 {-0.15/15} 14.Rad1 {+0.01/14} Rd7 {-0.10/15} 15.Nc3 {+0.01/14} Na5
{-0.14/14} 16.Nd2 {+0.07/13} Rb8 {+0.04/14} 17.Rfe1 {+0.04/13} Kg7 {-0.01/13} 18.h3
{+0.03/13} b5 {-0.09/13} 19.b4 {-0.09/14} Rc7 {-0.14/14} 20.Re3 {-0.23/14} Nc6 {-0.05/14}
21.Ne2 {-0.17/13} Ne5 {-0.11/13} 22.Nd4 {-0.22/13} Bd7 {-0.15/12} 23.f4 {-0.27/13} Ng6
{-0.19/12} 24.Be4 {-0.32/13} f5 {-0.23/12} 25.Bg2 {-0.12/13} Rbc8 {-0.18/12} 26.N2b3
{-0.06/12} Be8 {-0.09/13} 27.Bf3 {-0.07/12} R7c3 {-0.03/13} 28.Kf2 {+0.01/13} R3c7
{-0.01/12} 29.Be2 {+0.08/12} a6 {+0.04/12} 30.Bf3 {+0.01/12} Bd7 {-0.01/12} 31.Re2
{+0.06/12} Ra7 {+0.22/12} 32.Red2 {+0.17/11} e5 {+0.10/12} 33.fxe5 {+0.06/12} f4
{+0.22/12} 34.gxf4 {+0.25/11} Nxf4 {+0.20/11} 35.Kg3 {+0.15/11} Ng6 {+0.64/11} 36.Re2
{+0.34/11} Kh8 {+0.56/11} 37.Bg4 {+0.19/11} Bxg4 {+0.30/11} 38.hxg4 {+0.26/12} Rd7
{+0.42/11} 39.Rf1 {-0.03/12} Nxe5 {+0.07/12} 40.Nf5 {-0.09/12} Rc3+ {+0.27/12} 41.Kg2
{+0.10/13} Ng6 {+0.25/12} 42.Nxe7 {+0.21/13} Rxe7 {+0.23/14} 43.Rxe7 {+0.11/13} Rxc2+
{+0.27/13} 44.Kg3 {+0.25/14} Nxe7 45.Rxf7 {+0.09/14} Nc6 {+0.22/13} 46.Nc5 {+0.10/13} Ne5
47.Rf8+ {+0.09/12} Kg7 48.Ne6+ {+0.10/12} Kg6 {+0.06/12} 49.g5 {+0.35/13} Kh5
{+0.20/13} 50.Rf6 {+0.24/12} Rc3+ {-0.03/13} 51.Kf4 {+0.02/13} Ng6+ {-0.03/13} 52.Ke4
{+0.01/14} Rxa3 {-0.01/13} 53.Kd4 {+0.01/13} Kg4 {-0.07/13} 54.Rf7 {-0.11/13} Rh3
{-0.17/13} 55.Kd5 {-0.28/13} Rh1 {-0.43/12} 56.Kd6 {-0.39/12} Rd1+ {-0.51/12} 57.Kc5
{-0.59/13} Ne5 {-0.55/13} 58.Rxh7 {-0.70/12} Nd3+ {-0.57/12} 59.Kb6 {-0.34/12} Nxb4
{-0.08/12} 60.g6 {-0.04/12} Kf5 {+0.47/11} 61.Nf8 {+0.26/11} Rg1 {+0.32/11} 62.Rf7+
{+0.32/11} Ke5 {+0.30/11} 63.Re7+ {+0.19/11} Kf6 {+0.08/12} 64.Rd7 {+0.03/12} Rg2
{+0.04/12} 65.Kc5 {+0.11/12} Na2 {+0.17/11} 66.Ra7 {+0.13/11} Rc2+ {+0.44/11} 67.Kd4
{+0.64/11} Rc4+ {+0.64/11} 68.Ke3 {+0.50/12} a5 {+0.34/12} 69.Rxa5 {+0.29/11} Nc3
{+0.26/12} 70.Ra7 {+0.12/11} Nd5+ {+0.02/11} 71.Kf2 {+0.02/11} Rc7 {-0.01/12} 72.Ra6+
{-0.02/12} Ke5 {-0.02/13} 73.Ne6 Re7 {-0.01/13} 74.Nd8 {+0.01/13} Rg7 {-0.01/13} 75.Kf3
{+0.01/13} Kf5 {-0.01/14} 76.Ne6 {+0.01/14} Rxg6 {-0.01/14} 77.Nd4+ {+0.01/14} Kg5
{-0.01/14} 78.Rxg6+ {+0.01/15} Kxg6 {-0.01/18} 79.Nxb5 {+0.01/20} {Insufficient material} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "6"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "A00"]
[Opening "Benko Opening"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "125"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.g3 Nc6 {-0.23/15} 2.Nf3 {-0.18/15}
Nf6 {-0.10/15} 3.Bg2 {-0.16/16} e5 {-0.13/15} 4.O-O {-0.11/14} e4 {+0.03/15} 5.Ng5
{+0.12/15} d5 {+0.07/14} 6.c4 {+0.01/14} dxc4 {+0.19/14} 7.Qa4 {+0.09/14} Qd5 {+0.14/13}
8.d3 {+0.11/13} cxd3 {+0.17/13} 9.exd3 Qxd3 {+0.14/12} 10.Nc3 {+0.59/12} Bf5
{+0.46/12} 11.Bf4 {+0.56/11} Be7 {+0.60/12} 12.Rfd1 {+0.71/12} Qa6 {+0.42/13} 13.Qxa6
{+1.04/14} bxa6 {+0.95/14} 14.Ngxe4 {+0.89/14} Nxe4 {+0.94/14} 15.Nxe4 {+1.15/14} Rc8
{+1.16/14} 16.Rac1 {+1.29/14} Nd8 {+1.17/13} 17.Bxc7 {+1.29/14} Bxe4 {+1.26/15} 18.Bxe4
{+1.42/15} O-O {+1.34/15} 19.Be5 {+1.43/15} Ne6 {+1.46/14} 20.Rxc8 {+1.63/15} Rxc8
{+1.57/14} 21.Rd7 {+1.75/15} Re8 {+1.62/14} 22.Rxa7 {+1.89/15} Bc5 {+1.71/15} 23.Ra8
{+2.04/16} Rxa8 {+1.83/15} 24.Bxa8 {+1.87/15} g6 {+1.82/15} 25.Bd5 {+2.09/14} Kf8
{+1.99/14} 26.Bc3 {+2.13/15} Bd4 {+1.89/15} 27.Bxd4 {+2.00/16} Nxd4 {+1.83/15} 28.f3
{+1.93/16} Ke7 {+1.76/15} 29.Kf2 {+2.00/15} f5 {+1.71/16} 30.Ke3 {+1.91/15} Nc2+
{+1.68/14} 31.Kd3 {+1.95/16} Kd6 {+2.02/15} 32.Bg8 {+2.36/17} Nb4+ {+1.96/15} 33.Kc4
{+2.22/17} Nc6 {+2.02/16} 34.Bxh7 {+2.15/16} Ne7 {+1.90/17} 35.h4 {+2.05/17} Ke5
{+1.89/17} 36.Kc5 {+2.33/18} Kf6 {+2.40/17} 37.Kd6 {+2.30/18} Nc8+ {+2.34/17} 38.Kd7
{+2.35/19} Nb6+ {+2.44/18} 39.Kc7 {+2.35/18} Nc4 {+2.36/18} 40.Bg8 {+2.56/18} Nxb2
{+2.30/17} 41.Kb6 {+2.65/17} f4 {+2.54/16} 42.g4 {+2.67/17} Nd3 {+2.69/16} 43.Kxa6
{+3.22/17} Kg7 {+3.26/17} 44.Bc4 {+3.67/17} Ne1 {+4.44/17} 45.Be2 {+5.01/18} Nc2
{+5.53/17} 46.a4 {+5.66/18} Nd4 {+6.13/18} 47.Kb6 {+6.83/18} Nxe2 {+6.95/18} 48.a5
{+7.00/18} Nd4 {+7.26/17} 49.a6 {+7.40/17} Nxf3 {+7.78/16} 50.a7 {+8.38/16} Nxh4
{+7.96/15} 51.a8=Q {+8.51/15} g5 {+8.43/14} 52.Kc6 {+10.29/14} Ng6 {+10.28/13} 53.Kd6
{+10.95/14} f3 {+10.60/12} 54.Qxf3 {+13.74/14} Nf4 {+14.18/13} 55.Ke5 {+M20/13} Ng6+
{+M11/13} 56.Ke6 {+M11/14} Nf8+ {+M10/13} 57.Kf5 Kf7 {+M9/13} 58.Qe4 {+M7/13} Kg8
{+M5/14} 59.Qe7 {+M5/11} Nh7 {+M4/14} 60.Kg6 Nf8+ {+M3/13} 61.Kh5 Nh7 {+M2/14} 62.Kh6
Nf8 {+M1/14} 63.Qg7# {Mate} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "7"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B13"]
[Opening "Caro-Kann"]
[Variation "Exchange Variation, 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "133"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 {+0.72/13} Nf6
{+0.58/14} 4.Bd3 {+0.49/13} cxd5 {+0.33/14} 5.Nc3 {+0.19/14} Nc6 {+0.27/14} 6.Nf3
{+0.25/14} Bg4 {+0.24/13} 7.Be3 {+0.18/13} Qb6 {+0.31/13} 8.Qd2 {+0.28/12} O-O-O
{+0.16/14} 9.Na4 {+0.25/13} Qb4 {+0.10/15} 10.Qxb4 {+0.13/14} Nxb4 {+0.05/14} 11.Ne5
{+0.21/14} Bh5 {0.00/14} 12.O-O {+0.20/13} e6 {+0.09/13} 13.Nc3 {+0.09/13} Nxd3 {+0.20/13}
14.cxd3 {+0.17/13} Kb8 {+0.16/13} 15.Bf4 {+0.32/14} Ka8 {+0.23/14} 16.Rfc1 {+0.30/14}
Ng4 {+0.18/14} 17.Nb5 {+0.25/15} Nxe5 {+0.12/15} 18.dxe5 {+0.23/14} Bb4 {+0.25/14}
19.a3 {+0.36/15} Ba5 {+0.19/15} 20.b4 {+0.30/15} Bb6 21.a4 {+0.23/15} a6 {+0.03/14}
22.Nd6 f6 {-0.38/14} 23.Ra2 {-0.39/13} Bd4 {-0.01/14} 24.exf6 {+0.16/14} Bxf6
{-0.01/14} 25.Re1 {+0.12/14} Bc3 {-0.01/15} 26.Rxe6 {+0.17/13} Bxb4 {-0.01/14} 27.Nb5
{+0.01/13} Ba5 {-0.31/13} 28.Nd6 {-0.22/12} Rhf8 {-0.32/13} 29.Be5 {-0.10/13} Rd7
{-0.36/14} 30.f4 {-0.15/12} d4 {-0.22/11} 31.Rc2 {+0.01/12} Bd1 {-0.01/13} 32.Rc5
{+0.01/13} b6 {-0.01/14} 33.Rc8+ {+0.01/14} Rxc8 {-0.01/16} 34.Nxc8 Kb7 {-0.01/15} 35.Nd6+
{+0.01/13} Kc6 36.Ne8+ {+0.01/13} Kc5 {-0.04/14} 37.Nxg7 {+0.02/13} Bxa4 {-0.23/13} 38.Re8
{-0.06/12} Bd2 {-0.24/12} 39.Ne6+ {-0.11/11} Kb4 {-0.23/12} 40.Kf2 {-0.09/11} Be3+
{0.00/11} 41.Ke2 {+0.18/13} Bb5 {-0.01/12} 42.Rb8 {+0.14/13} Kc3 {+0.27/14} 43.Rc8+
{+0.31/13} Kb2 {+0.33/14} 44.Nc7 {+0.36/14} Re7 {+0.31/14} 45.g3 {+0.40/14} Bd7 {+0.32/14}
46.Rg8 {+0.44/14} Be6 {+0.46/13} 47.Nxe6 {+0.38/13} Rxe6 {+0.56/13} 48.Kf3 {+0.59/13}
Rh6 {+0.95/13} 49.Ke4 {+0.72/12} Rxh2 {+1.11/13} 50.f5 {+0.82/12} Rf2 {+2.07/13}
51.f6 {+2.36/12} Kc3 {+2.35/12} 52.Bf4 {+6.52/13} Bc1 {+7.28/13} 53.Rc8+ {+7.96/13}
Kb3 {+7.90/14} 54.Rxc1 {+8.34/14} Re2+ {+8.72/14} 55.Kd5 {+8.96/14} Re8 {+10.75/14}
56.Bd6 {+12.18/14} a5 {+12.35/14} 57.f7 {+14.25/14} Rh8 {+15.04/14} 58.Rb1+
{+14.58/12} Kc3 {+14.82/13} 59.Re1 {+15.44/13} b5 {+16.01/12} 60.Re8 {+17.50/13} Rxe8
{+16.15/11} 61.fxe8=Q {+17.80/11} Kxd3 {+17.88/10} 62.Qxb5+ {+19.68/10} Kc3 {+M5/10}
63.Qc4+ {+M5/9} Kb2 {+M4/11} 64.Kxd4 h5 {+M3/11} 65.Kd3 Ka1 {+M2/10} 66.Be5+ Kb1
67.Qc2# {Mate} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "8"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B13"]
[Opening "Caro-Kann"]
[Variation "Exchange, 4.Nf3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "129"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 {+0.71/14} cxd5
{+0.54/13} 4.Nf3 {+0.51/14} e6 {+0.62/14} 5.Bd3 {+0.43/13} Nc6 {+0.51/15} 6.O-O {+0.47/14}
Nf6 {+0.50/14} 7.Nc3 {+0.37/14} Be7 {+0.40/14} 8.Bg5 {+0.31/13} O-O {+0.40/13}
9.Re1 {+0.27/12} Bd7 {+0.36/13} 10.Ne5 {+0.38/12} Rc8 {+0.36/12} 11.Qd2 {+0.36/12}
Be8 {+0.38/11} 12.Rab1 {+0.25/11} Qb6 {+0.30/11} 13.a3 {+0.27/11} a6 {+0.47/11}
14.Red1 {+0.27/11} Kh8 {+0.34/11} 15.Be2 {+0.18/12} Ne4 {+0.18/13} 16.Nxe4 {+0.18/12}
dxe4 {+0.09/12} 17.Bxe7 {+0.08/12} Nxe7 {+0.04/12} 18.c4 {+0.05/13} Qc7 {+0.07/12}
19.b3 {+0.01/13} f6 {+0.04/13} 20.Ng4 {-0.04/13} Bg6 {-0.09/13} 21.Rbc1 {-0.06/13}
Rfd8 {-0.10/12} 22.Ne3 {-0.06/12} f5 {-0.07/12} 23.Qb2 {-0.03/13} Qf4 {-0.05/13}
24.g3 {+0.02/13} Qb8 {-0.12/11} 25.Ng2 {+0.06/14} Bf7 {-0.01/12} 26.Nf4 {+0.01/13}
Qd6 {-0.01/12} 27.Rc2 {+0.06/12} Rc7 {-0.02/11} 28.Kh1 {0.00/11} Rcd7 {-0.07/11}
29.Rcd2 {+0.01/12} Qc6 {-0.07/11} 30.Kg1 {+0.04/11} b6 {-0.02/11} 31.Bh5 {+0.09/13}
Bxh5 {-0.01/13} 32.Nxh5 Qd6 {+0.09/12} 33.Nf4 {+0.05/12} Qc6 {+0.09/12} 34.Rc1
{+0.12/12} Rc7 {+0.19/13} 35.Rcc2 {+0.35/13} Qd7 {+0.24/13} 36.d5 {+0.21/14} exd5
{+0.49/15} 37.cxd5 {+0.43/14} Rxc2 {+0.81/15} 38.Rxc2 {+0.69/14} Qd6 {+0.81/14} 39.Rc7
{+0.92/14} Rg8 {+0.85/13} 40.Rb7 {+1.05/13} a5 {+1.04/13} 41.Qd4 {+1.22/14} Qxa3
{+1.28/13} 42.Rxb6 {+1.41/13} Nc8 {+3.52/13} 43.Rh6 {+3.50/14} Rd8 {+3.56/13} 44.Qe5
{+3.19/13} Ne7 {+3.54/12} 45.h3 {+3.09/12} e3 {+3.05/12} 46.Qxe7 {+3.13/13} Qxe7
{+3.43/14} 47.Ng6+ {+3.88/16} Kg8 48.Nxe7+ {+4.06/16} Kf7 {+3.86/15} 49.Re6 {+4.00/16}
exf2+ {+3.97/15} 50.Kxf2 {+3.96/16} Rxd5 {+3.96/15} 51.Nxd5 {+3.83/16} Kxe6
{+3.85/16} 52.Ne3 {+3.95/16} g6 {+4.25/17} 53.Kf3 {+4.45/17} Kd6 {+4.54/17} 54.Nc4+
{+4.52/16} Kc5 {+4.58/18} 55.Nxa5 {+4.62/17} Kb4 {+4.58/16} 56.g4 {+6.04/16} Kc5
{+6.16/16} 57.gxf5 {+7.01/18} gxf5 {+7.38/18} 58.Kf4 {+8.20/17} Kb4 {+7.38/16} 59.Kxf5
{+16.13/17} h5 {+14.00/17} 60.Kg5 {+16.83/17} Kb5 {+17.01/16} 61.b4 {+20.70/17} h4
{+21.04/15} 62.Nc4 {+20.61/15} Ka4 {+M22/15} 63.b5 {+M22/15} Kb4 {+M21/14} 64.b6 Kb5
{+M17/13} 65.b7 {+M17/13} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "9"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B30"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "2...Nc6 3.Nc3 Nf6"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "242"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 {+0.70/15} Nc6 {+0.56/15}
3.Nc3 {+0.67/14} Nf6 {+0.54/14} 4.d4 {+0.46/14} d5 {+0.43/14} 5.exd5 {+0.78/15} Nxd5
{+0.39/14} 6.dxc5 {+0.71/15} Nxc3 {+0.44/15} 7.Qxd8+ {+0.59/14} Nxd8 {+0.38/15} 8.bxc3
{+0.56/15} f6 {+0.38/15} 9.Be3 {+0.59/14} e5 {+0.42/14} 10.Nd2 {+0.51/13} f5 {+0.56/13}
11.f3 {+0.55/13} Bd7 {+0.44/14} 12.O-O-O {+0.66/15} Rc8 {+0.25/14} 13.Nb3 {+0.51/14}
Be7 {+0.50/14} 14.Bc4 {+0.76/12} Nc6 {+0.58/14} 15.Rd2 {+0.87/14} Rd8 {+0.60/14}
16.Rhd1 {+0.79/14} Bc8 {+0.62/13} 17.Bd5 {+0.86/12} Bf6 {+0.63/13} 18.Re1 {+0.77/13}
Rd7 {+0.48/13} 19.Rd3 {+0.80/13} Kd8 {+0.40/13} 20.Red1 {+0.57/12} Kc7 {+0.27/13}
21.Kb2 {+0.63/12} Rhd8 {+0.24/13} 22.a4 {+0.57/13} Re8 {+0.05/13} 23.Re1 {+0.48/11}
Red8 {+0.08/13} 24.Bc4 {+0.36/12} g5 {+0.14/12} 25.Bg1 {+0.38/12} h5 {-0.11/13}
26.Re2 {+0.21/12} g4 {-0.11/12} 27.Be3 {+0.29/12} Kb8 {-0.01/12} 28.a5 {+0.20/12} Kc7
{-0.01/12} 29.Ka3 {+0.05/11} f4 {-0.25/14} 30.Bf2 {+0.02/13} Rg7 {-0.25/14} 31.Red2
{-0.10/13} gxf3 {-0.31/14} 32.gxf3 {-0.09/13} Rg2 {-0.26/14} 33.Be1 {-0.26/13} Rxd2
{-0.26/15} 34.Rxd2 {-0.12/14} Rxd2 {-0.29/14} 35.Bxd2 {-0.25/14} Ne7 {-0.42/14} 36.Bd3
{-0.27/13} Nf5 {-0.53/13} 37.Be1 {-0.25/13} Ne3 {-0.40/13} 38.Kb4 {-0.24/12} Nd5+
{-0.31/13} 39.Kc4 {-0.25/13} Be6 {-0.27/13} 40.Bf2 Bd8 {-0.55/10} 41.h4 {-0.39/11} Kd7
{-0.67/11} 42.Be4 {-0.33/12} Nf6+ {-1.29/13} 43.Kd3 {-1.00/14} Nxe4 {-1.33/15} 44.Kxe4
{-1.25/15} Bc7 {-1.39/14} 45.Kd3 {-1.26/14} Bf5+ {-1.32/14} 46.Kd2 {-1.25/14} Bd8
{-1.35/15} 47.c4 {-1.16/14} Kc6 {-1.39/14} 48.Be1 {-1.25/14} Bg6 {-1.48/15} 49.Kd1
{-1.31/14} Bf6 {-1.52/14} 50.Kd2 {-1.31/15} Bh7 {-1.48/15} 51.Bf2 {-1.25/15} Bd8
{-1.48/15} 52.Be1 {-1.23/15} Bf5 {-1.37/15} 53.Bf2 {-1.25/16} Bg6 {-1.39/16} 54.Be1
{-1.25/15} a6 {-1.39/16} 55.Kc3 {-1.30/15} Bf6 {-1.39/15} 56.Kd2 {-1.30/15} Bf5 {-1.39/16}
57.Bf2 {-1.19/15} Bd8 {-1.39/16} 58.Kc3 {-1.24/16} Kd7 {-1.39/15} 59.Kd2 {-1.24/15}
Bh7 {-1.39/15} 60.Be1 {-1.25/15} Bf5 {-0.01/15} 61.Bf2 {+0.01/17} Kc7 {-1.39/15}
62.Nc1 {-1.25/15} Kc8 {-1.39/16} 63.Nb3 {-1.28/16} Kd7 {-1.39/15} 64.Kc3 {-1.30/16}
Bf6 {-1.39/15} 65.Kd2 {-1.30/15} Bh7 {-1.39/15} 66.Nc1 {-1.28/15} Bd8 {-1.39/15}
67.Nb3 {-1.24/15} Kc6 {-1.39/16} 68.Kc3 {-1.30/16} Bf5 {-1.39/16} 69.Be1 {-1.30/16}
Bf6 {-1.39/16} 70.Kd2 {-1.30/16} e4 {-1.39/15} 71.fxe4 {-1.09/15} Bxe4 {-1.46/15}
72.Bf2 {-1.09/15} Kd7 {-1.27/14} 73.Ke2 {-0.90/13} Ke7 {-1.26/14} 74.Nd4 {-1.28/14}
Be5 {-1.37/14} 75.Nf3 {-1.19/15} Bc7 {-1.26/15} 76.Be1 {-1.17/15} Bxc2 {-1.30/14}
77.Bb4 {-1.22/14} Kd7 {-1.31/13} 78.Bc3 {-1.17/14} Be4 {-1.31/14} 79.Ng5 {-1.10/14}
Bf5 {-1.30/14} 80.Kf3 {-1.01/14} Kc6 {-1.28/15} 81.Bb4 {-0.96/15} Bd7 {-1.33/16}
82.Ke4 {-1.26/15} Bg4 {-1.57/17} 83.Kd4 {-1.35/16} f3 {-1.65/17} 84.Be1 {-1.40/16}
Bxa5 {-1.65/16} 85.Nxf3 {-1.57/16} Bc7 86.Ng5 {-1.65/15} Bd8 {-1.85/15} 87.Nf7
{-1.79/15} Bf6+ {-1.74/15} 88.Ke4 {-1.75/15} Be6 {-1.93/14} 89.Nd6 {-1.82/13} Kxc5
{-2.22/14} 90.Nxb7+ {-1.77/14} Kxc4 {-1.98/15} 91.Nd6+ Kc5 {-2.03/15} 92.Ne8 {-1.81/15}
Bd8 {-2.06/14} 93.Ng7 {-1.91/14} Bg4 {-2.25/14} 94.Nf5 {-2.24/14} a5 {-2.25/14}
95.Bf2+ {-2.25/13} Kc6 {-2.27/15} 96.Nd4+ {-2.25/14} Kb7 {-2.29/15} 97.Nb5 {-2.26/14}
a4 {-2.25/13} 98.Nc3 {-2.26/14} Bd7 {-2.29/13} 99.Kd5 {-2.26/13} Be7 {-2.53/13}
100.Bg3 {-2.30/14} a3 {-3.00/13} 101.Bd6 {-3.06/14} Bc6+ {-3.57/15} 102.Ke6 {-3.53/17}
Bxd6 {-3.60/16} 103.Kxd6 {-3.72/19} Kb6 {-4.12/19} 104.Na2 {-4.04/19} Kb5 {-5.07/18}
105.Nc1 {-4.74/17} Bg2 {-8.77/18} 106.Ke5 {-10.98/17} Kc4 {-11.00/17} 107.Kf4
{-10.90/16} Bf1 {-11.94/17} 108.Kg5 {-13.41/16} Kc3 {-15.83/16} 109.Kxh5 {-15.99/16} Kb2
{-16.09/15} 110.Na2 Kxa2 {-M13/16} 111.Kg6 {-M12/14} Kb3 {-M12/14} 112.Kf6 {-M11/14} a2
{-M11/12} 113.Ke5 {-M10/11} a1=Q+ {-M10/10} 114.Kf5 {-M9/11} Qg7 {-M9/10} 115.h5 {-M7/10}
Be2 {-M7/10} 116.h6 {-M6/11} Qxh6 {-M6/11} 117.Ke5 Kc3 118.Kf5 Kd3 119.Ke5 Bg4
120.Kd5 Qb6 121.Ke5 Qd4# {Mate} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "10"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B30"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "2...Nc6 3.Nc3 Nf6"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "133"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 {+0.60/15} Nc6 {+0.71/14}
3.Nc3 {+0.54/15} Nf6 4.Bb5 {+0.47/14} e5 {+0.44/14} 5.Bxc6 {+0.46/15} dxc6 {+0.41/15}
6.Nxe5 {+0.37/15} Bd6 {+0.39/15} 7.Nc4 {+0.37/14} Bc7 {+0.39/13} 8.d3 {+0.34/14} Bg4
{+0.45/14} 9.f3 {+0.32/13} Be6 {+0.59/13} 10.O-O {+0.33/12} b5 {+0.46/12} 11.Ne3
{+0.36/13} Qb8 {+0.53/12} 12.g3 {+0.46/13} O-O {+0.50/12} 13.Ng2 {+0.51/12} c4 {+0.54/12}
14.Bf4 {+0.67/12} b4 {+0.75/12} 15.Na4 {+0.71/12} Rd8 {+0.87/13} 16.d4 {+1.18/13} Nh5
{+1.07/13} 17.Bxc7 {+1.26/14} Qxc7 {+1.29/13} 18.Nc5 Qe7 {+1.56/12} 19.c3 {+1.71/12} Rab8
{+1.70/12} 20.Qa4 {+1.96/13} bxc3 {+1.95/13} 21.bxc3 {+1.98/13} Bh3 {+2.00/12} 22.Rab1
{+1.96/13} Rxb1 {+1.99/12} 23.Rxb1 {+2.07/12} Qg5 {+2.14/12} 24.Qc2 {+2.25/12} Bxg2
{+1.82/14} 25.Kxg2 {+2.15/14} Nf4+ {+1.94/14} 26.Kh1 {+2.05/15} Ne6 {+1.75/15} 27.Nxe6
{+1.84/15} fxe6 28.f4 {+1.87/14} Qa5 {+1.78/13} 29.Qd2 c5 {+1.94/13} 30.d5 {+2.09/13} exd5
{+1.82/14} 31.exd5 {+2.15/14} Qc7 {+1.80/13} 32.Rd1 {+2.13/13} Qe7 {+1.82/13} 33.Kg2
{+2.21/14} Qe4+ {+1.83/14} 34.Kf2 Kf7 35.h3 {+2.02/13} Rd6 {+1.80/13} 36.Qe3 {+2.02/14}
Qxe3+ {+1.67/14} 37.Kxe3 {+1.95/15} Rh6 {+1.80/15} 38.h4 {+2.21/15} Rb6 {+1.91/15}
39.Ke4 {+2.13/15} Ke7 {+1.97/15} 40.Ke5 {+2.13/15} Kd7 {+2.11/15} 41.d6 {+2.10/15} h5
{+2.11/15} 42.Rd5 {+2.23/16} Rc6 {+2.27/15} 43.Ke4 {+2.31/16} g6 {+2.29/15} 44.Ke5
{+2.26/16} Rc8 {+2.29/16} 45.Kf6 {+2.47/16} a5 {+2.26/15} 46.Kg7 {+2.52/15} Re8 {+2.56/15}
47.Re5 {+2.46/15} Rc8 {+2.62/16} 48.Rg5 {+3.14/15} Re8 {+2.56/16} 49.Rxg6 {+2.71/15}
Re3 {+3.62/16} 50.f5 {+3.23/16} Rxc3 {+3.10/16} 51.f6 {+4.57/16} Rf3 {+6.26/16}
52.f7 {+6.51/16} Rxf7+ {+7.36/17} 53.Kxf7 {+6.40/17} c3 {+8.97/17} 54.Re6 {+11.47/17}
a4 {+11.24/16} 55.Re1 {+14.11/17} Kxd6 {+14.24/16} 56.g4 {+15.24/17} hxg4
{+14.96/15} 57.h5 {+15.81/15} c2 {+15.72/14} 58.h6 {+17.18/14} g3 {+17.27/13} 59.h7
{+18.58/13} g2 {+17.65/11} 60.h8=Q {+18.94/11} g1=Q {+M8/10} 61.Qd8+ {+M7/10} Kc6 62.Rxg1
{+M6/10} a3 {+M5/9} 63.Rg6+ {+M5/9} Kb5 {+M4/9} 64.Qb6+ Kc4 65.Qb3+ Kd4 66.Rg4+ Ke5
67.Qe6# {Mate} 1-0

[Togga]

but you can not dispute that I and Robert Hyatt got the same result: that crafty 23.2 is better.

I got it after 10 games, he after 40 000 games.

fortuity? no no.

[Togga]

what timecontrol was it?

[Togga]

is it ok so? for play as winboard engine under Arena.


egtb
#adaptive 750K 24M 192M 24M 48M
tbpath=c:\tb
cache=32M
ponder off
#
# (for use use with ponder on)
# mode=tournament
#
# (Allows Crafty to try to win drawn games (according to Endgame Tables))
swindle off
#
# (default)
learn 0
#
# (default)
#book random 1
#
#bookw freq 0.7
#bookw ratio 0.8
#bookw eval 0.6
#bookw learn 1
#bookw cap 0.5
#book width 4
#
#(default = book on)
book off
#
show book
log=off
#
# (Increases Crafty's MaxThreads to 2 for a dual CPU computer )
#mt=2
#
# (Make Crafty not use cpu on opponents time)
#smpnice=1
#
# (Makes crafty use a lot more time on the first 8 moves out of book)
timebook 80 8
#adaptive NPS a
hash=256M
hashp=16M
exit

[Togga]

this compile of 23.2 32 bit is on my computer faster than JA 23.1 32 bit compile.

[mariaclara]

Thanks for the new release but I prefer to wait for JA compiles....
Dr.D

JA compiles?

http://homepages.tesco.net/henry.ablett/jims.html

Got it.

Thanks...