Crafty 23.2 released.

[Graham Banks]

Is it possible to run this version throuh WB2UCI adapter? That's the only way I can test it, but how can it run if it does not use the crafty.rc file?

Running okay here using the wb2uci adapter. You still get the parameter options showing up.

[mariaclara]

Thanks for the new release but I prefer to wait for JA compiles....
Dr.D

JA compiles?

[michiguel]

Let me add a couple of notes...

If you use a newer xboard/winboard, crafty supports the new "cores" and "memory" GUI->engine commands. But with some exceptions.

If you want to use the winboard/xboard menu to set memory (which is combined hash + pawn hash) or number of threads, then you must _not_ use the mt=n command, nor set the hash=n or phash=n options in your .craftyrc/crafty.rc configuration file. If you specify hash sizes or max threads there, crafty will not use the winboard cores/memory commands. So make certain that if you want to use the new winboard options, you remove those lines from the crafty config file.

If you want to use the memory option from winboard/xboard, you specify the size in megabytes. You need to give some thought to this number. The regular hash table must be a power of 2. Ditto for the pawn hash. A good setting would be 288, which would be interpreted as follows:

1. Crafty finds the largest power of two value in that number (which is 256m above) and uses that for the primary hash.

2. It then subtracts 256m from the above value, and then finds the largest power of two remaining and uses that as the pawn hash size. Any extra memory is unused.

Not very elegant, but I could not think of a better solution. Probably is easier to use the .craftyrc file to set those options, which will make the xboard settings irrelevant.

I actually just realized that you _must_ set the engine parameters in Winboard no matter what. The Crafty.rc file isn't being used at all. If you try setting the Winboard parameters to nothing, it of course defaults to the last used.

I have set Winboard to use max 1024 for HASH, but have 2048 in my rc file. Winboard is controlling the hash at a max of 1024.

Either way, Winboard is controlling the settings, not Crafty at all.

I am not sure I like this. Those are supposed to be polyglot options, not options for _all_ engines, including Winboard engines.

I think that intention is that those are options for all engines, including winboard engines. In that way, you can set them up all from winboard/xboard rather than editing each ini file.

Is Crafty supporting engine settings (feature option)? Those are really nice.
http://sites.google.com/site/gaviotache ... figuration

Miguel

[Kirill Kryukov]

Is it possible to run this version throuh WB2UCI adapter? That's the only way I can test it, but how can it run if it does not use the crafty.rc file?

Running okay here using the wb2uci adapter. You still get the parameter options showing up.

Thanks! I'll then put it into my testing queue.

[Dr.Wael Deeb]

Thanks for the new release but I prefer to wait for JA compiles....
Dr.D

JA compiles?

http://homepages.tesco.net/henry.ablett/jims.html

[Togga]

after only 10 games i can clearly say that the version 23.2 is better than 23.1 :))

timecontrol 2min + 2 sec:

Crafty-23.2-win32 - Crafty_23.1_ja : 6,5/10 5-2-3 (=01==10111) 65% +108

bad: 2 games got lost:(

games soon:


question to:

Crafty-23.2 2661 3 3 40000 60% 2583 23%
Crafty-23.1 2638 3 3 40000 57% 2583 23%

what timecontrol was it?

[govert]

after only 10 games i can clearly say that the version 23.2 is better than 23.1 )

timecontrol 2min + 2 sec:

Crafty-23.2-win32 - Crafty_23.1_ja : 6,5/10 5-2-3 (=01==10111) 65% +108

bad: 2 games got lost:(

games soon:


question to:

Crafty-23.2 2661 3 3 40000 60% 2583 23%
Crafty-23.1 2638 3 3 40000 57% 2583 23%

what timecontrol was it?

No. It's not clear. But it's somewhat likely. (A lot of people will even object to this conclusion. Read further...)

Bayeselo:
=========

Code: Select all

ResultSet-EloRating>ratings
Rank Name   Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws
   1 23.2    39   86   80    10   65%   -39   30%
   2 23.1   -39   80   86    10   35%    39   30%

ResultSet-EloRating>los   (likelyhood of superiority)
        23.1 23.2
23.2         83
23.1    16

So, it's 83% likely that 23.2 is stronger than 23.1
83% is not sufficient at all to conclude that something is clearly stronger.

By the way. A lot of people will simply disregards the calculation of los=83% and simply claim that you should _never_ draw _any_ conclusions from only 10 games played. Of course this is also wrong. You can draw _some_ conclusions, but the conclusions will not be strong.

It's all in the wording, and no matter how you word it, someone will twist it the wrong way.

[Togga]

why crafty 23.2 lost 2 games when it is better than 23.1?
the opening start positions were draw:
1.d4 d5 2.c4
1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5


[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "D07"]
[Opening "QGD"]
[Variation "Chigorin, 3.cxd5, Main Line, 7.bxc3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "64"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.d4 d5 2.c4 Nc6 {-0.02/14} 3.cxd5
{+0.07/14} Qxd5 {+0.07/14} 4.e3 {+0.19/14} e5 {-0.09/14} 5.Nc3 {-0.22/13} Bb4 {-0.03/13}
6.Bd2 {-0.20/13} Bxc3 {-0.11/14} 7.bxc3 {-0.06/14} exd4 {+0.07/14} 8.cxd4 {+0.01/15}
Nf6 {+0.12/14} 9.Ne2 {+0.14/14} O-O {+0.20/14} 10.Nf4 {+0.19/14} Qd6 {+0.20/14}
11.Bd3 Nb4 {+0.22/13} 12.Bc4 {+0.31/13} Ne4 {+0.22/13} 13.O-O {+0.35/13} Nxd2
{+0.27/14} 14.Qxd2 {+0.36/13} Bf5 {+0.27/13} 15.Rac1 {+0.46/12} Rae8 {+0.34/12} 16.Bb3
{+0.47/12} Be4 {+0.41/13} 17.f3 {+0.56/13} Bc6 {+0.49/13} 18.Rc5 {+0.58/13} b6 {+0.46/12}
19.Rc3 {+0.65/12} Bb7 {+0.52/12} 20.a3 {+0.58/12} Nc6 {+0.57/13} 21.Rfc1 {+0.62/12}
Na5 {+0.53/12} 22.Ba2 {+0.66/11} c6 {+0.52/12} 23.Qc2 {+0.57/11} Qh6 {+0.45/12}
24.Qd3 {+0.45/12} Re7 {+0.33/12} 25.d5 {+0.42/11} c5 {+0.25/12} 26.Rd1 {+0.28/12} Rd8
{+0.25/12} 27.Kh1 {+0.22/11} a6 {+0.20/11} 28.Qb1 {+0.22/11} c4 {+0.01/12} 29.Qf5
{+0.08/12} Bc8 {-0.01/12} 30.Qb1 {+0.01/13} Bb7 {-0.01/14} 31.Qf5 {+0.01/13} Bc8
{-0.01/14} 32.Qb1 {+0.01/15} Bb7 {-0.01/15} {3-fold repetition} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "2"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "D30"]
[Opening "QGD"]
[Variation "3.Nf3 Nf6 4.e3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "248"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 {-0.09/13} 3.Nf3
{-0.13/13} Nf6 {-0.02/13} 4.e3 {-0.01/13} Nc6 {+0.05/13} 5.Nc3 {+0.05/14} Be7 {+0.07/13}
6.Ne5 {+0.16/14} O-O {+0.14/14} 7.Nxc6 {+0.24/15} bxc6 {+0.38/15} 8.Qa4 {+0.26/15}
dxc4 {+0.16/12} 9.Bxc4 {+0.46/14} Nd5 {+0.21/13} 10.Qc2 {+0.37/14} Bd6 {+0.31/13}
11.O-O {+0.55/13} Qh4 {+0.32/12} 12.f4 {+0.70/12} Bd7 {+0.41/11} 13.e4 {+0.82/13} Nxc3
{+0.47/13} 14.Qxc3 {+0.87/14} Rab8 {+0.63/12} 15.Be3 {+0.87/13} f5 {+0.68/13} 16.e5
{+1.11/13} Be7 {+0.90/12} 17.Rf3 {+1.12/13} Qg4 {+0.93/12} 18.Rg3 {+1.25/14} Qh5
{+1.03/13} 19.Rh3 {+1.25/15} Qf7 {+1.04/13} 20.Rc1 {+1.25/14} Rfd8 {+1.04/12} 21.Qd2
{+1.25/13} Rb7 {+1.06/12} 22.Qe2 {+1.25/13} a5 {+0.97/12} 23.b3 {+1.19/12} Ba3 {+0.95/12}
24.Rc2 {+1.25/12} Ra8 {+0.85/13} 25.Qe1 {+1.22/12} Be7 {+0.89/13} 26.a4 {+1.25/13} h6
{+0.94/13} 27.Qf2 {+1.25/14} Kh8 {+0.98/14} 28.Bd2 {+1.25/14} Qg8 {+1.03/13} 29.Bc3
{+1.29/12} Qf7 {+1.05/13} 30.Qe1 {+1.26/13} Rba7 {+1.10/13} 31.Qe3 {+1.26/12} Rb7
{+1.03/13} 32.Qf2 {+1.26/14} Kg8 {+0.98/13} 33.Rc1 {+1.29/12} Kh8 {+0.94/12} 34.Qe1
{+1.26/13} Rba7 {+1.13/13} 35.Qd2 {+1.25/12} Bc8 {+1.13/13} 36.Rg3 {+1.25/12} Bb7
{+1.05/11} 37.Kh1 {+1.25/13} Bh4 {+1.13/13} 38.Re3 {+1.25/14} Be7 {+1.13/13} 39.Rd3
{+1.25/14} Ba6 {+1.08/13} 40.Bxa6 {+1.25/13} R7xa6 {+0.88/12} 41.Qe1 {+1.25/12} Qe8
{+0.76/12} 42.Qe2 {+1.11/13} Rb6 {+0.67/12} 43.Be1 {+1.10/13} Qd7 {+0.73/12} 44.Qf3
{+1.09/13} g6 {+0.71/13} 45.Bd2 {+1.04/13} Kg7 {+0.67/12} 46.Rc4 {+1.04/13} Ra7 {+0.63/13}
47.Qe3 {+0.94/12} Rbb7 {+0.63/13} 48.Qe1 {+0.95/13} Qd5 {+0.56/13} 49.Qd1 {+0.94/12}
Rb8 {+0.55/13} 50.Rh3 {+0.87/11} Ra6 {+0.55/12} 51.Qc1 {+0.85/12} Rab6 {+0.55/14}
52.Qc2 {+0.58/13} Ba3 {+0.51/13} 53.Rg3 {+0.69/12} Be7 {+0.55/13} 54.Qd1 {+0.70/13}
Kf7 {+0.52/13} 55.Rh3 {+0.68/13} Bb4 {+0.29/12} 56.Bc1 {+0.68/13} Kg7 {+0.41/13}
57.Rg3 {+0.68/14} Be7 {+0.34/11} 58.Rd3 Ra6 {+0.41/12} 59.Be3 {+0.77/13} Rb4
{+0.38/12} 60.Rcc3 {+0.78/13} Qe4 {+0.44/11} 61.Qf1 {+0.76/12} Qd5 {+0.42/12} 62.Bf2
{+0.80/13} Ra8 {+0.47/12} 63.Qc1 {+0.72/13} Rb6 {+0.47/12} 64.Rc4 {+0.67/13} Rab8
{+0.45/13} 65.Qc2 {+0.58/13} Rd8 {+0.34/12} 66.Be1 {+0.58/12} g5 {+0.24/12} 67.Rf3
{+0.49/12} Rdb8 {+0.21/12} 68.Rg3 {+0.53/11} g4 {+0.16/13} 69.Bd2 {+0.41/13} h5 {-0.01/14}
70.Rd3 {+0.41/13} h4 {-0.01/14} 71.Kg1 {+0.19/14} Ra6 {-0.01/14} 72.Be1 {+0.41/12}
Rab6 {-0.01/14} 73.Bf2 {+0.33/12} Rd8 {-0.01/13} 74.Kf1 {+0.42/12} Rdb8 {-0.01/13}
75.Rdc3 {+0.32/11} Bb4 {-0.01/13} 76.Re3 {+0.33/13} Rh8 {-0.25/12} 77.Qd3 {+0.27/13} g3
{-0.27/13} 78.hxg3 {+0.70/14} h3 {+0.22/13} 79.gxh3 Qh1+ {+0.21/11} 80.Ke2 {+0.79/13} Rxh3
{+0.10/13} 81.Qd1 {+0.66/13} Qd5 {+0.28/13} 82.Qf1 {+0.19/12} Rh2 {-0.01/13} 83.Kd1
{+0.01/13} Rb8 84.Kc1 {+0.01/12} Rh1 {-3.51/13} 85.Bg1 {-3.34/13} Rbh8 {-3.60/13} 86.Re2
{-3.58/14} Rxg1 {-3.88/14} 87.Qxg1 {-3.58/16} Rh1 {-3.97/14} 88.Qxh1 {-3.63/16} Qxh1+
{-4.00/14} 89.Kb2 {-3.57/16} Qf3 {-3.99/16} 90.Rec2 c5 {-4.04/15} 91.dxc5 {-3.87/15} Qxg3
{-4.15/15} 92.c6 {-3.72/15} Be1 {-4.37/15} 93.Ka2 {-4.07/14} Qe3 {-4.67/15} 94.Kb2
{-4.99/16} Bd2 {-5.15/16} 95.Ka2 {-5.25/16} Qd3 {-5.77/16} 96.Rb2 {-5.47/17} Kf7
{-5.77/18} 97.Ka3 {-5.88/17} Be3 {-6.59/17} 98.Ka2 {-6.08/15} Qf1 {-6.70/17} 99.Rb1
{-6.66/15} Qf3 {-6.74/16} 100.Rb2 {-6.94/16} Bxf4 {-6.89/16} 101.Rc5 {-6.99/16} Qe4
{-7.34/15} 102.Rxa5 {-7.26/14} Bxe5 {-7.76/14} 103.Rxe5 {-7.67/14} Qxe5 {-8.66/14} 104.b4
{-9.43/13} f4 {-9.46/12} 105.b5 {-9.45/12} Qd5+ {-10.21/12} 106.Ka1 {-10.56/12} Qd1+
{-10.69/12} 107.Ka2 {-12.66/13} Qxa4+ {-12.77/12} 108.Kb1 f3 {-13.45/12} 109.b6 {-13.53/12}
Qe4+ {-13.63/11} 110.Ka2 {-13.75/12} Qc4+ {-13.82/11} 111.Kb1 {-13.93/12} Qf1+
{-13.89/11} 112.Ka2 {-14.18/12} f2 {-14.40/12} 113.Rb1 {-14.31/11} Qa6+ {-14.70/11} 114.Kb3
{-14.60/11} Qxb6+ {-15.06/11} 115.Kc2 Qxb1+ {-18.68/11} 116.Kxb1 {-M22/13} f1=Q+ {-M22/11}
117.Kc2 {-M21/12} e5 {-M12/12} 118.Kd2 {-M8/12} e4 {-M8/12} 119.Ke3 Qd3+ {-M6/11}
120.Kf2 {-M5/12} e3+ 121.Kg3 {-M4/11} Qe4 122.Kh2 {-M3/11} e2 123.Kh3 e1=Q 124.Kh2
Q4h1# {Mate} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "3"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C48"]
[Opening "Four Knights"]
[Variation "Spanish Variation"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "224"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 {+0.15/14} Nc6 {+0.29/14}
3.Nc3 {+0.18/14} Nf6 {+0.27/14} 4.Bb5 {+0.20/14} Bd6 {+0.10/14} 5.d3 {+0.15/14} a6
{+0.08/16} 6.Ba4 {+0.15/15} b5 {+0.01/15} 7.Bb3 {+0.19/15} Na5 {+0.09/15} 8.Bg5 {+0.26/14}
O-O {+0.17/14} 9.Nd5 {+0.26/14} Be7 {+0.14/14} 10.Nxe7+ {+0.20/14} Qxe7 {+0.10/14}
11.O-O {+0.20/14} d6 {+0.08/14} 12.Qe2 {+0.26/13} Bg4 {+0.07/14} 13.Kh1 {+0.19/14} c6
{+0.06/13} 14.Bd2 {+0.16/14} Nxb3 {+0.08/14} 15.axb3 {+0.17/13} Rfe8 {+0.09/14} 16.h3
{+0.28/13} Bd7 {+0.12/14} 17.Ra5 {+0.33/14} Bc8 {+0.10/13} 18.Rfa1 {+0.26/14} Bb7
{+0.04/13} 19.Nh4 {+0.35/13} Qe6 {-0.02/13} 20.Nf5 {+0.27/13} d5 {+0.05/13} 21.f3
{+0.25/12} Kh8 {+0.18/13} 22.b4 {+0.45/11} Ng8 {+0.06/12} 23.Bg5 {+0.43/12} f6 {-0.01/13}
24.Bd2 {+0.20/12} Ne7 {-0.02/13} 25.g4 {+0.26/12} Rac8 {-0.11/12} 26.Qf2 {+0.21/12}
Nxf5 {-0.21/13} 27.gxf5 {+0.06/12} Qe7 {-0.18/12} 28.Qc5 {+0.06/13} Qf7 {-0.27/12}
29.Rg1 {+0.10/13} Qh5 {-0.29/13} 30.Kg2 {+0.04/12} Rcd8 {-0.29/13} 31.Raa1 {-0.11/11}
Rd7 {-0.39/12} 32.Qf2 {-0.06/11} g6 {-0.36/11} 33.fxg6 {+0.04/12} Rg7 {-0.39/12}
34.h4 {-0.08/11} hxg6 {-0.28/12} 35.Rgh1 {-0.12/11} Rc7 {-0.50/10} 36.Rae1 {-0.13/11}
Rh7 {-0.44/11} 37.Qc5 {-0.08/12} Rd7 {-0.42/12} 38.Kf2 {-0.03/11} Rb8 {-0.19/10}
39.Rhg1 {+0.04/11} Rg8 {-0.28/11} 40.Rgh1 {-0.03/11} Re8 {-0.18/11} 41.Rhg1 {+0.01/11}
dxe4 {-0.20/11} 42.Rxe4 {+0.23/12} Rd5 {-0.01/12} 43.Qb6 {+0.25/12} Re7 {+0.06/12}
44.Reg4 {+0.52/13} Rg7 {+0.27/13} 45.Ke2 {+0.54/12} Kh7 {+0.31/12} 46.R1g2 {+0.71/11}
Kg8 {+0.36/12} 47.Bc3 {+0.55/11} Rd6 {+0.26/11} 48.Qg1 {+0.58/12} Kf7 {+0.28/12}
49.Qc5 {+0.49/11} Rd5 {+0.15/12} 50.Qb6 {+0.53/12} Rd7 {+0.27/12} 51.R2g3 {+0.49/11}
Re7 {+0.34/11} 52.Kd1 {+0.55/12} Bc8 {+0.28/12} 53.Re4 {+0.25/13} Bf5 {+0.26/11}
54.Re1 {+0.07/13} Qxh4 {-0.01/13} 55.Rgg1 {+0.02/12} Bd7 {-0.01/12} 56.Rgh1 {+0.01/13}
Qf4 {-0.01/13} 57.Ref1 {+0.01/13} Ke6 {-0.01/13} 58.Rhg1 {+0.01/13} Kf7 59.Rgh1
{+0.01/15} Ke6 60.Rhg1 {+0.01/15} Re8 {-0.05/11} 61.Qc5 {-0.28/11} g5 {-0.45/12} 62.Rgh1
{-0.27/10} Rgg8 {-0.81/11} 63.d4 {-0.14/11} Red8 {-0.03/11} 64.Rh6 {-0.08/11} Be8
{-0.64/12} 65.Rh7 {-0.75/12} Rd5 {-1.01/12} 66.Qe7+ {-0.51/12} Kf5 67.Qb7 {-0.51/11} Kg6
{-1.18/11} 68.Re7 {-1.25/11} exd4 {-1.75/13} 69.Bd2 {-1.54/13} Qf5 {-1.77/12} 70.Qb8
{-1.65/12} Re5 {-1.74/13} 71.Rxe5 {-1.72/12} fxe5 72.Qd6+ {-1.80/11} Qf6 {-2.22/13}
73.Qxf6+ {-2.08/12} Kxf6 74.Ke2 {-2.22/13} Bg6 {-2.43/13} 75.c3 {-2.24/12} Rh8
{-2.37/13} 76.cxd4 {-2.23/13} exd4 {-2.30/13} 77.Rg1 {-2.34/13} Rh2+ {-2.58/13} 78.Ke1
{-2.34/13} Bc2 {-2.64/13} 79.Bxg5+ {-2.76/14} Kf5 {-3.03/14} 80.Bd2 {-2.76/14} d3
{-3.03/14} 81.Bc1 {-3.95/14} Bb3 {-4.12/13} 82.Rg5+ {-3.99/14} Ke6 {-4.39/14} 83.Rg6+
{-4.46/14} Kf7 {-4.64/15} 84.Rxc6 {-4.53/14} Re2+ {-4.57/14} 85.Kf1 d2 {-4.54/14} 86.Bxd2
{-4.77/15} Rxd2 87.Rxa6 Bc4+ {-4.68/13} 88.Ke1 {-4.79/13} Re2+ {-5.01/13} 89.Kd1
{-5.03/14} Rxb2 90.Ke1 {-5.11/13} Rxb4 {-5.27/13} 91.Kf2 {-5.26/13} Rb3 {-5.32/12} 92.f4
{-5.43/12} b4 {-5.51/12} 93.Rb6 {-5.75/13} Be6 {-5.74/13} 94.Rb8 {-5.75/12} Bg4 {-5.73/12}
95.Kg2 {-5.94/12} Kf6 {-6.09/13} 96.Rb5 {-6.27/13} Bd7 {-6.42/13} 97.Rb6+ {-6.53/13}
Kf5 {-6.43/13} 98.Rd6 {-6.54/13} Be8 {-6.67/14} 99.Rd4 {-6.53/12} Bc6+ {-6.81/13}
100.Kf1 {-6.77/13} Be4 {-7.44/14} 101.Ke2 {-7.25/14} Kxf4 {-7.47/14} 102.Kd2
{-11.13/14} Kf3 {-15.88/15} 103.Rc4 {-M12/14} Rd3+ {-M11/14} 104.Kc2 {-M11/14} Rc3+
{-M10/14} 105.Kb2 {-M9/15} Rxc4 {-M8/15} 106.Kb3 {-M7/14} Bd5 {-M7/13} 107.Ka4 Rc6
{-M6/11} 108.Kxb4 {-M5/20} Ke3 109.Kb5 Kd4 110.Kb4 Bc4 111.Ka5 Kc3 112.Ka4 Ra6# {Mate} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "4"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C47"]
[Opening "Four Knights"]
[Variation "Scotch, Main Line"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "152"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 {+0.21/14} Nc6 {+0.19/13}
3.Nc3 {+0.23/14} Nf6 {+0.21/14} 4.d4 {+0.25/14} exd4 {+0.14/15} 5.Nxd4 {+0.33/14} Bb4
{+0.04/14} 6.Nxc6 {+0.24/15} bxc6 {+0.06/14} 7.Bd3 {+0.18/15} O-O {+0.21/14} 8.O-O
{+0.24/14} d6 {+0.16/13} 9.Bg5 {+0.28/13} h6 {+0.09/13} 10.Bh4 {+0.21/13} Qe7 {+0.17/12}
11.f4 {+0.35/12} Re8 {+0.22/11} 12.Na4 {+0.51/13} Qe6 {+0.28/12} 13.c3 {+0.55/13} Ba5
{+0.37/14} 14.Re1 {+0.63/13} Qg4 {+0.36/14} 15.Qxg4 {+0.85/14} Nxg4 {+0.73/14} 16.e5
{+0.87/13} dxe5 {+0.63/14} 17.h3 {+0.72/14} Nf6 {+0.66/14} 18.Rxe5 {+0.82/15} Rxe5
{+0.74/15} 19.fxe5 {+0.86/14} Nd5 20.Bf2 {+0.93/14} Be6 {+0.92/14} 21.Be4 {+1.00/14} Bb6
{+0.94/14} 22.Nc5 {+0.99/15} Rb8 {+0.73/14} 23.Rb1 {+0.90/15} Bxc5 {+0.80/14} 24.Bxc5
{+0.99/14} a6 {+0.85/15} 25.Ba7 {+1.12/14} Ra8 {+0.86/15} 26.Bd4 {+1.14/15} Ne7 {+0.88/15}
27.b3 {+1.18/15} Bf5 {+0.96/14} 28.Re1 {+1.19/16} Bxe4 {+1.02/15} 29.Rxe4 Rd8
{+1.09/14} 30.e6 {+1.18/14} fxe6 {+0.95/14} 31.Rxe6 {+1.08/15} Kf7 {+0.94/14} 32.Re2
{+1.02/14} Nf5 {+0.89/13} 33.Be5 {+1.09/14} Rd1+ {+0.96/12} 34.Kf2 {+1.11/13} Nd6
{+0.89/12} 35.g4 {+1.15/11} c5 {+0.85/12} 36.h4 {+1.04/12} c4 {+0.75/12} 37.b4 {+1.05/12}
g6 {+0.71/13} 38.a4 {+0.85/13} h5 {+0.65/13} 39.gxh5 {+0.70/13} gxh5 {+0.52/14}
40.Ke3 {+0.70/13} Ke6 {+0.51/12} 41.Bh8 {+0.60/12} Kf5 {+0.42/13} 42.Rf2+ {+0.57/13}
Ke6 {+0.45/13} 43.Rf6+ {+0.60/13} Kd5 {+0.41/13} 44.Rg6 {+0.58/13} Rf1 {+0.15/13}
45.a5 {+0.42/13} c6 {0.00/13} 46.Rg5+ {+0.19/14} Nf5+ {-0.01/14} 47.Kd2 {+0.20/15}
Ke6 {+0.04/14} 48.Bd4 {+0.19/14} Rf4 {-0.01/14} 49.Rxh5 {+0.15/14} Rxh4 {-0.01/15}
50.Rxh4 {+0.01/14} Nxh4 {-0.08/16} 51.Kc2 {-0.07/18} Ng2 {-0.08/18} 52.Kd2 {-0.02/18}
Kd5 {-0.02/18} 53.Bc5 {+0.01/19} Ke4 {-0.02/20} 54.Bd4 {+0.01/20} Nf4 {-0.02/19}
55.Bc5 {+0.01/20} Nd3 {-0.01/19} 56.Be7 {+0.01/20} Kd5 {-0.01/20} 57.Ke3 {+0.01/20} c5
{-0.01/20} 58.Bxc5 {+0.01/21} Nxc5 {-0.01/22} 59.bxc5 {+0.01/23} Kxc5 {-0.01/31} 60.Ke4
{+0.01/60} Kb5 {-0.01/60} 61.Kd5 Kxa5 62.Kxc4 Ka4 63.Kd5 a5 64.c4 Kb4 65.c5 a4 66.c6 a3
67.c7 a2 68.c8=Q a1=Q 69.Qb8+ Ka3 70.Qa8+ Kb2 71.Qh8+ Kb1 72.Qh7+ Kb2 73.Qg7+ Kb1
74.Qg6+ Kb2 75.Qf6+ Kb1 76.Qf5+ Kb2 {Draw by mutual agreement} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "5"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A04"]
[Opening "Reti Opening"]
[Variation "1...e6 2.g3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "157"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.g3 e6 {-0.19/16} 2.Nf3 {-0.16/15} Nf6
{-0.13/16} 3.Bg2 {-0.14/15} Bb4 {-0.13/16} 4.O-O {-0.08/15} O-O {-0.08/15} 5.a3 {-0.07/14}
Be7 {-0.15/15} 6.Nc3 {0.00/14} d5 {-0.08/14} 7.d4 {-0.02/14} c5 {-0.10/14} 8.dxc5
{-0.04/14} Bxc5 {-0.10/13} 9.Bg5 {0.00/13} Nc6 {-0.25/12} 10.e4 {+0.01/13} dxe4 {-0.01/14}
11.Qxd8 {+0.14/14} Rxd8 {-0.09/15} 12.Bxf6 {-0.05/16} gxf6 {-0.18/16} 13.Nxe4
{-0.06/15} Be7 {-0.15/15} 14.Rad1 {+0.01/14} Rd7 {-0.10/15} 15.Nc3 {+0.01/14} Na5
{-0.14/14} 16.Nd2 {+0.07/13} Rb8 {+0.04/14} 17.Rfe1 {+0.04/13} Kg7 {-0.01/13} 18.h3
{+0.03/13} b5 {-0.09/13} 19.b4 {-0.09/14} Rc7 {-0.14/14} 20.Re3 {-0.23/14} Nc6 {-0.05/14}
21.Ne2 {-0.17/13} Ne5 {-0.11/13} 22.Nd4 {-0.22/13} Bd7 {-0.15/12} 23.f4 {-0.27/13} Ng6
{-0.19/12} 24.Be4 {-0.32/13} f5 {-0.23/12} 25.Bg2 {-0.12/13} Rbc8 {-0.18/12} 26.N2b3
{-0.06/12} Be8 {-0.09/13} 27.Bf3 {-0.07/12} R7c3 {-0.03/13} 28.Kf2 {+0.01/13} R3c7
{-0.01/12} 29.Be2 {+0.08/12} a6 {+0.04/12} 30.Bf3 {+0.01/12} Bd7 {-0.01/12} 31.Re2
{+0.06/12} Ra7 {+0.22/12} 32.Red2 {+0.17/11} e5 {+0.10/12} 33.fxe5 {+0.06/12} f4
{+0.22/12} 34.gxf4 {+0.25/11} Nxf4 {+0.20/11} 35.Kg3 {+0.15/11} Ng6 {+0.64/11} 36.Re2
{+0.34/11} Kh8 {+0.56/11} 37.Bg4 {+0.19/11} Bxg4 {+0.30/11} 38.hxg4 {+0.26/12} Rd7
{+0.42/11} 39.Rf1 {-0.03/12} Nxe5 {+0.07/12} 40.Nf5 {-0.09/12} Rc3+ {+0.27/12} 41.Kg2
{+0.10/13} Ng6 {+0.25/12} 42.Nxe7 {+0.21/13} Rxe7 {+0.23/14} 43.Rxe7 {+0.11/13} Rxc2+
{+0.27/13} 44.Kg3 {+0.25/14} Nxe7 45.Rxf7 {+0.09/14} Nc6 {+0.22/13} 46.Nc5 {+0.10/13} Ne5
47.Rf8+ {+0.09/12} Kg7 48.Ne6+ {+0.10/12} Kg6 {+0.06/12} 49.g5 {+0.35/13} Kh5
{+0.20/13} 50.Rf6 {+0.24/12} Rc3+ {-0.03/13} 51.Kf4 {+0.02/13} Ng6+ {-0.03/13} 52.Ke4
{+0.01/14} Rxa3 {-0.01/13} 53.Kd4 {+0.01/13} Kg4 {-0.07/13} 54.Rf7 {-0.11/13} Rh3
{-0.17/13} 55.Kd5 {-0.28/13} Rh1 {-0.43/12} 56.Kd6 {-0.39/12} Rd1+ {-0.51/12} 57.Kc5
{-0.59/13} Ne5 {-0.55/13} 58.Rxh7 {-0.70/12} Nd3+ {-0.57/12} 59.Kb6 {-0.34/12} Nxb4
{-0.08/12} 60.g6 {-0.04/12} Kf5 {+0.47/11} 61.Nf8 {+0.26/11} Rg1 {+0.32/11} 62.Rf7+
{+0.32/11} Ke5 {+0.30/11} 63.Re7+ {+0.19/11} Kf6 {+0.08/12} 64.Rd7 {+0.03/12} Rg2
{+0.04/12} 65.Kc5 {+0.11/12} Na2 {+0.17/11} 66.Ra7 {+0.13/11} Rc2+ {+0.44/11} 67.Kd4
{+0.64/11} Rc4+ {+0.64/11} 68.Ke3 {+0.50/12} a5 {+0.34/12} 69.Rxa5 {+0.29/11} Nc3
{+0.26/12} 70.Ra7 {+0.12/11} Nd5+ {+0.02/11} 71.Kf2 {+0.02/11} Rc7 {-0.01/12} 72.Ra6+
{-0.02/12} Ke5 {-0.02/13} 73.Ne6 Re7 {-0.01/13} 74.Nd8 {+0.01/13} Rg7 {-0.01/13} 75.Kf3
{+0.01/13} Kf5 {-0.01/14} 76.Ne6 {+0.01/14} Rxg6 {-0.01/14} 77.Nd4+ {+0.01/14} Kg5
{-0.01/14} 78.Rxg6+ {+0.01/15} Kxg6 {-0.01/18} 79.Nxb5 {+0.01/20} {Insufficient material} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "6"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "A00"]
[Opening "Benko Opening"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "125"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.g3 Nc6 {-0.23/15} 2.Nf3 {-0.18/15}
Nf6 {-0.10/15} 3.Bg2 {-0.16/16} e5 {-0.13/15} 4.O-O {-0.11/14} e4 {+0.03/15} 5.Ng5
{+0.12/15} d5 {+0.07/14} 6.c4 {+0.01/14} dxc4 {+0.19/14} 7.Qa4 {+0.09/14} Qd5 {+0.14/13}
8.d3 {+0.11/13} cxd3 {+0.17/13} 9.exd3 Qxd3 {+0.14/12} 10.Nc3 {+0.59/12} Bf5
{+0.46/12} 11.Bf4 {+0.56/11} Be7 {+0.60/12} 12.Rfd1 {+0.71/12} Qa6 {+0.42/13} 13.Qxa6
{+1.04/14} bxa6 {+0.95/14} 14.Ngxe4 {+0.89/14} Nxe4 {+0.94/14} 15.Nxe4 {+1.15/14} Rc8
{+1.16/14} 16.Rac1 {+1.29/14} Nd8 {+1.17/13} 17.Bxc7 {+1.29/14} Bxe4 {+1.26/15} 18.Bxe4
{+1.42/15} O-O {+1.34/15} 19.Be5 {+1.43/15} Ne6 {+1.46/14} 20.Rxc8 {+1.63/15} Rxc8
{+1.57/14} 21.Rd7 {+1.75/15} Re8 {+1.62/14} 22.Rxa7 {+1.89/15} Bc5 {+1.71/15} 23.Ra8
{+2.04/16} Rxa8 {+1.83/15} 24.Bxa8 {+1.87/15} g6 {+1.82/15} 25.Bd5 {+2.09/14} Kf8
{+1.99/14} 26.Bc3 {+2.13/15} Bd4 {+1.89/15} 27.Bxd4 {+2.00/16} Nxd4 {+1.83/15} 28.f3
{+1.93/16} Ke7 {+1.76/15} 29.Kf2 {+2.00/15} f5 {+1.71/16} 30.Ke3 {+1.91/15} Nc2+
{+1.68/14} 31.Kd3 {+1.95/16} Kd6 {+2.02/15} 32.Bg8 {+2.36/17} Nb4+ {+1.96/15} 33.Kc4
{+2.22/17} Nc6 {+2.02/16} 34.Bxh7 {+2.15/16} Ne7 {+1.90/17} 35.h4 {+2.05/17} Ke5
{+1.89/17} 36.Kc5 {+2.33/18} Kf6 {+2.40/17} 37.Kd6 {+2.30/18} Nc8+ {+2.34/17} 38.Kd7
{+2.35/19} Nb6+ {+2.44/18} 39.Kc7 {+2.35/18} Nc4 {+2.36/18} 40.Bg8 {+2.56/18} Nxb2
{+2.30/17} 41.Kb6 {+2.65/17} f4 {+2.54/16} 42.g4 {+2.67/17} Nd3 {+2.69/16} 43.Kxa6
{+3.22/17} Kg7 {+3.26/17} 44.Bc4 {+3.67/17} Ne1 {+4.44/17} 45.Be2 {+5.01/18} Nc2
{+5.53/17} 46.a4 {+5.66/18} Nd4 {+6.13/18} 47.Kb6 {+6.83/18} Nxe2 {+6.95/18} 48.a5
{+7.00/18} Nd4 {+7.26/17} 49.a6 {+7.40/17} Nxf3 {+7.78/16} 50.a7 {+8.38/16} Nxh4
{+7.96/15} 51.a8=Q {+8.51/15} g5 {+8.43/14} 52.Kc6 {+10.29/14} Ng6 {+10.28/13} 53.Kd6
{+10.95/14} f3 {+10.60/12} 54.Qxf3 {+13.74/14} Nf4 {+14.18/13} 55.Ke5 {+M20/13} Ng6+
{+M11/13} 56.Ke6 {+M11/14} Nf8+ {+M10/13} 57.Kf5 Kf7 {+M9/13} 58.Qe4 {+M7/13} Kg8
{+M5/14} 59.Qe7 {+M5/11} Nh7 {+M4/14} 60.Kg6 Nf8+ {+M3/13} 61.Kh5 Nh7 {+M2/14} 62.Kh6
Nf8 {+M1/14} 63.Qg7# {Mate} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "7"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B13"]
[Opening "Caro-Kann"]
[Variation "Exchange Variation, 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "133"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 {+0.72/13} Nf6
{+0.58/14} 4.Bd3 {+0.49/13} cxd5 {+0.33/14} 5.Nc3 {+0.19/14} Nc6 {+0.27/14} 6.Nf3
{+0.25/14} Bg4 {+0.24/13} 7.Be3 {+0.18/13} Qb6 {+0.31/13} 8.Qd2 {+0.28/12} O-O-O
{+0.16/14} 9.Na4 {+0.25/13} Qb4 {+0.10/15} 10.Qxb4 {+0.13/14} Nxb4 {+0.05/14} 11.Ne5
{+0.21/14} Bh5 {0.00/14} 12.O-O {+0.20/13} e6 {+0.09/13} 13.Nc3 {+0.09/13} Nxd3 {+0.20/13}
14.cxd3 {+0.17/13} Kb8 {+0.16/13} 15.Bf4 {+0.32/14} Ka8 {+0.23/14} 16.Rfc1 {+0.30/14}
Ng4 {+0.18/14} 17.Nb5 {+0.25/15} Nxe5 {+0.12/15} 18.dxe5 {+0.23/14} Bb4 {+0.25/14}
19.a3 {+0.36/15} Ba5 {+0.19/15} 20.b4 {+0.30/15} Bb6 21.a4 {+0.23/15} a6 {+0.03/14}
22.Nd6 f6 {-0.38/14} 23.Ra2 {-0.39/13} Bd4 {-0.01/14} 24.exf6 {+0.16/14} Bxf6
{-0.01/14} 25.Re1 {+0.12/14} Bc3 {-0.01/15} 26.Rxe6 {+0.17/13} Bxb4 {-0.01/14} 27.Nb5
{+0.01/13} Ba5 {-0.31/13} 28.Nd6 {-0.22/12} Rhf8 {-0.32/13} 29.Be5 {-0.10/13} Rd7
{-0.36/14} 30.f4 {-0.15/12} d4 {-0.22/11} 31.Rc2 {+0.01/12} Bd1 {-0.01/13} 32.Rc5
{+0.01/13} b6 {-0.01/14} 33.Rc8+ {+0.01/14} Rxc8 {-0.01/16} 34.Nxc8 Kb7 {-0.01/15} 35.Nd6+
{+0.01/13} Kc6 36.Ne8+ {+0.01/13} Kc5 {-0.04/14} 37.Nxg7 {+0.02/13} Bxa4 {-0.23/13} 38.Re8
{-0.06/12} Bd2 {-0.24/12} 39.Ne6+ {-0.11/11} Kb4 {-0.23/12} 40.Kf2 {-0.09/11} Be3+
{0.00/11} 41.Ke2 {+0.18/13} Bb5 {-0.01/12} 42.Rb8 {+0.14/13} Kc3 {+0.27/14} 43.Rc8+
{+0.31/13} Kb2 {+0.33/14} 44.Nc7 {+0.36/14} Re7 {+0.31/14} 45.g3 {+0.40/14} Bd7 {+0.32/14}
46.Rg8 {+0.44/14} Be6 {+0.46/13} 47.Nxe6 {+0.38/13} Rxe6 {+0.56/13} 48.Kf3 {+0.59/13}
Rh6 {+0.95/13} 49.Ke4 {+0.72/12} Rxh2 {+1.11/13} 50.f5 {+0.82/12} Rf2 {+2.07/13}
51.f6 {+2.36/12} Kc3 {+2.35/12} 52.Bf4 {+6.52/13} Bc1 {+7.28/13} 53.Rc8+ {+7.96/13}
Kb3 {+7.90/14} 54.Rxc1 {+8.34/14} Re2+ {+8.72/14} 55.Kd5 {+8.96/14} Re8 {+10.75/14}
56.Bd6 {+12.18/14} a5 {+12.35/14} 57.f7 {+14.25/14} Rh8 {+15.04/14} 58.Rb1+
{+14.58/12} Kc3 {+14.82/13} 59.Re1 {+15.44/13} b5 {+16.01/12} 60.Re8 {+17.50/13} Rxe8
{+16.15/11} 61.fxe8=Q {+17.80/11} Kxd3 {+17.88/10} 62.Qxb5+ {+19.68/10} Kc3 {+M5/10}
63.Qc4+ {+M5/9} Kb2 {+M4/11} 64.Kxd4 h5 {+M3/11} 65.Kd3 Ka1 {+M2/10} 66.Be5+ Kb1
67.Qc2# {Mate} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "8"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B13"]
[Opening "Caro-Kann"]
[Variation "Exchange, 4.Nf3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "129"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 {+0.71/14} cxd5
{+0.54/13} 4.Nf3 {+0.51/14} e6 {+0.62/14} 5.Bd3 {+0.43/13} Nc6 {+0.51/15} 6.O-O {+0.47/14}
Nf6 {+0.50/14} 7.Nc3 {+0.37/14} Be7 {+0.40/14} 8.Bg5 {+0.31/13} O-O {+0.40/13}
9.Re1 {+0.27/12} Bd7 {+0.36/13} 10.Ne5 {+0.38/12} Rc8 {+0.36/12} 11.Qd2 {+0.36/12}
Be8 {+0.38/11} 12.Rab1 {+0.25/11} Qb6 {+0.30/11} 13.a3 {+0.27/11} a6 {+0.47/11}
14.Red1 {+0.27/11} Kh8 {+0.34/11} 15.Be2 {+0.18/12} Ne4 {+0.18/13} 16.Nxe4 {+0.18/12}
dxe4 {+0.09/12} 17.Bxe7 {+0.08/12} Nxe7 {+0.04/12} 18.c4 {+0.05/13} Qc7 {+0.07/12}
19.b3 {+0.01/13} f6 {+0.04/13} 20.Ng4 {-0.04/13} Bg6 {-0.09/13} 21.Rbc1 {-0.06/13}
Rfd8 {-0.10/12} 22.Ne3 {-0.06/12} f5 {-0.07/12} 23.Qb2 {-0.03/13} Qf4 {-0.05/13}
24.g3 {+0.02/13} Qb8 {-0.12/11} 25.Ng2 {+0.06/14} Bf7 {-0.01/12} 26.Nf4 {+0.01/13}
Qd6 {-0.01/12} 27.Rc2 {+0.06/12} Rc7 {-0.02/11} 28.Kh1 {0.00/11} Rcd7 {-0.07/11}
29.Rcd2 {+0.01/12} Qc6 {-0.07/11} 30.Kg1 {+0.04/11} b6 {-0.02/11} 31.Bh5 {+0.09/13}
Bxh5 {-0.01/13} 32.Nxh5 Qd6 {+0.09/12} 33.Nf4 {+0.05/12} Qc6 {+0.09/12} 34.Rc1
{+0.12/12} Rc7 {+0.19/13} 35.Rcc2 {+0.35/13} Qd7 {+0.24/13} 36.d5 {+0.21/14} exd5
{+0.49/15} 37.cxd5 {+0.43/14} Rxc2 {+0.81/15} 38.Rxc2 {+0.69/14} Qd6 {+0.81/14} 39.Rc7
{+0.92/14} Rg8 {+0.85/13} 40.Rb7 {+1.05/13} a5 {+1.04/13} 41.Qd4 {+1.22/14} Qxa3
{+1.28/13} 42.Rxb6 {+1.41/13} Nc8 {+3.52/13} 43.Rh6 {+3.50/14} Rd8 {+3.56/13} 44.Qe5
{+3.19/13} Ne7 {+3.54/12} 45.h3 {+3.09/12} e3 {+3.05/12} 46.Qxe7 {+3.13/13} Qxe7
{+3.43/14} 47.Ng6+ {+3.88/16} Kg8 48.Nxe7+ {+4.06/16} Kf7 {+3.86/15} 49.Re6 {+4.00/16}
exf2+ {+3.97/15} 50.Kxf2 {+3.96/16} Rxd5 {+3.96/15} 51.Nxd5 {+3.83/16} Kxe6
{+3.85/16} 52.Ne3 {+3.95/16} g6 {+4.25/17} 53.Kf3 {+4.45/17} Kd6 {+4.54/17} 54.Nc4+
{+4.52/16} Kc5 {+4.58/18} 55.Nxa5 {+4.62/17} Kb4 {+4.58/16} 56.g4 {+6.04/16} Kc5
{+6.16/16} 57.gxf5 {+7.01/18} gxf5 {+7.38/18} 58.Kf4 {+8.20/17} Kb4 {+7.38/16} 59.Kxf5
{+16.13/17} h5 {+14.00/17} 60.Kg5 {+16.83/17} Kb5 {+17.01/16} 61.b4 {+20.70/17} h4
{+21.04/15} 62.Nc4 {+20.61/15} Ka4 {+M22/15} 63.b5 {+M22/15} Kb4 {+M21/14} 64.b6 Kb5
{+M17/13} 65.b7 {+M17/13} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "9"]
[White "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Black "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B30"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "2...Nc6 3.Nc3 Nf6"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "242"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 {+0.70/15} Nc6 {+0.56/15}
3.Nc3 {+0.67/14} Nf6 {+0.54/14} 4.d4 {+0.46/14} d5 {+0.43/14} 5.exd5 {+0.78/15} Nxd5
{+0.39/14} 6.dxc5 {+0.71/15} Nxc3 {+0.44/15} 7.Qxd8+ {+0.59/14} Nxd8 {+0.38/15} 8.bxc3
{+0.56/15} f6 {+0.38/15} 9.Be3 {+0.59/14} e5 {+0.42/14} 10.Nd2 {+0.51/13} f5 {+0.56/13}
11.f3 {+0.55/13} Bd7 {+0.44/14} 12.O-O-O {+0.66/15} Rc8 {+0.25/14} 13.Nb3 {+0.51/14}
Be7 {+0.50/14} 14.Bc4 {+0.76/12} Nc6 {+0.58/14} 15.Rd2 {+0.87/14} Rd8 {+0.60/14}
16.Rhd1 {+0.79/14} Bc8 {+0.62/13} 17.Bd5 {+0.86/12} Bf6 {+0.63/13} 18.Re1 {+0.77/13}
Rd7 {+0.48/13} 19.Rd3 {+0.80/13} Kd8 {+0.40/13} 20.Red1 {+0.57/12} Kc7 {+0.27/13}
21.Kb2 {+0.63/12} Rhd8 {+0.24/13} 22.a4 {+0.57/13} Re8 {+0.05/13} 23.Re1 {+0.48/11}
Red8 {+0.08/13} 24.Bc4 {+0.36/12} g5 {+0.14/12} 25.Bg1 {+0.38/12} h5 {-0.11/13}
26.Re2 {+0.21/12} g4 {-0.11/12} 27.Be3 {+0.29/12} Kb8 {-0.01/12} 28.a5 {+0.20/12} Kc7
{-0.01/12} 29.Ka3 {+0.05/11} f4 {-0.25/14} 30.Bf2 {+0.02/13} Rg7 {-0.25/14} 31.Red2
{-0.10/13} gxf3 {-0.31/14} 32.gxf3 {-0.09/13} Rg2 {-0.26/14} 33.Be1 {-0.26/13} Rxd2
{-0.26/15} 34.Rxd2 {-0.12/14} Rxd2 {-0.29/14} 35.Bxd2 {-0.25/14} Ne7 {-0.42/14} 36.Bd3
{-0.27/13} Nf5 {-0.53/13} 37.Be1 {-0.25/13} Ne3 {-0.40/13} 38.Kb4 {-0.24/12} Nd5+
{-0.31/13} 39.Kc4 {-0.25/13} Be6 {-0.27/13} 40.Bf2 Bd8 {-0.55/10} 41.h4 {-0.39/11} Kd7
{-0.67/11} 42.Be4 {-0.33/12} Nf6+ {-1.29/13} 43.Kd3 {-1.00/14} Nxe4 {-1.33/15} 44.Kxe4
{-1.25/15} Bc7 {-1.39/14} 45.Kd3 {-1.26/14} Bf5+ {-1.32/14} 46.Kd2 {-1.25/14} Bd8
{-1.35/15} 47.c4 {-1.16/14} Kc6 {-1.39/14} 48.Be1 {-1.25/14} Bg6 {-1.48/15} 49.Kd1
{-1.31/14} Bf6 {-1.52/14} 50.Kd2 {-1.31/15} Bh7 {-1.48/15} 51.Bf2 {-1.25/15} Bd8
{-1.48/15} 52.Be1 {-1.23/15} Bf5 {-1.37/15} 53.Bf2 {-1.25/16} Bg6 {-1.39/16} 54.Be1
{-1.25/15} a6 {-1.39/16} 55.Kc3 {-1.30/15} Bf6 {-1.39/15} 56.Kd2 {-1.30/15} Bf5 {-1.39/16}
57.Bf2 {-1.19/15} Bd8 {-1.39/16} 58.Kc3 {-1.24/16} Kd7 {-1.39/15} 59.Kd2 {-1.24/15}
Bh7 {-1.39/15} 60.Be1 {-1.25/15} Bf5 {-0.01/15} 61.Bf2 {+0.01/17} Kc7 {-1.39/15}
62.Nc1 {-1.25/15} Kc8 {-1.39/16} 63.Nb3 {-1.28/16} Kd7 {-1.39/15} 64.Kc3 {-1.30/16}
Bf6 {-1.39/15} 65.Kd2 {-1.30/15} Bh7 {-1.39/15} 66.Nc1 {-1.28/15} Bd8 {-1.39/15}
67.Nb3 {-1.24/15} Kc6 {-1.39/16} 68.Kc3 {-1.30/16} Bf5 {-1.39/16} 69.Be1 {-1.30/16}
Bf6 {-1.39/16} 70.Kd2 {-1.30/16} e4 {-1.39/15} 71.fxe4 {-1.09/15} Bxe4 {-1.46/15}
72.Bf2 {-1.09/15} Kd7 {-1.27/14} 73.Ke2 {-0.90/13} Ke7 {-1.26/14} 74.Nd4 {-1.28/14}
Be5 {-1.37/14} 75.Nf3 {-1.19/15} Bc7 {-1.26/15} 76.Be1 {-1.17/15} Bxc2 {-1.30/14}
77.Bb4 {-1.22/14} Kd7 {-1.31/13} 78.Bc3 {-1.17/14} Be4 {-1.31/14} 79.Ng5 {-1.10/14}
Bf5 {-1.30/14} 80.Kf3 {-1.01/14} Kc6 {-1.28/15} 81.Bb4 {-0.96/15} Bd7 {-1.33/16}
82.Ke4 {-1.26/15} Bg4 {-1.57/17} 83.Kd4 {-1.35/16} f3 {-1.65/17} 84.Be1 {-1.40/16}
Bxa5 {-1.65/16} 85.Nxf3 {-1.57/16} Bc7 86.Ng5 {-1.65/15} Bd8 {-1.85/15} 87.Nf7
{-1.79/15} Bf6+ {-1.74/15} 88.Ke4 {-1.75/15} Be6 {-1.93/14} 89.Nd6 {-1.82/13} Kxc5
{-2.22/14} 90.Nxb7+ {-1.77/14} Kxc4 {-1.98/15} 91.Nd6+ Kc5 {-2.03/15} 92.Ne8 {-1.81/15}
Bd8 {-2.06/14} 93.Ng7 {-1.91/14} Bg4 {-2.25/14} 94.Nf5 {-2.24/14} a5 {-2.25/14}
95.Bf2+ {-2.25/13} Kc6 {-2.27/15} 96.Nd4+ {-2.25/14} Kb7 {-2.29/15} 97.Nb5 {-2.26/14}
a4 {-2.25/13} 98.Nc3 {-2.26/14} Bd7 {-2.29/13} 99.Kd5 {-2.26/13} Be7 {-2.53/13}
100.Bg3 {-2.30/14} a3 {-3.00/13} 101.Bd6 {-3.06/14} Bc6+ {-3.57/15} 102.Ke6 {-3.53/17}
Bxd6 {-3.60/16} 103.Kxd6 {-3.72/19} Kb6 {-4.12/19} 104.Na2 {-4.04/19} Kb5 {-5.07/18}
105.Nc1 {-4.74/17} Bg2 {-8.77/18} 106.Ke5 {-10.98/17} Kc4 {-11.00/17} 107.Kf4
{-10.90/16} Bf1 {-11.94/17} 108.Kg5 {-13.41/16} Kc3 {-15.83/16} 109.Kxh5 {-15.99/16} Kb2
{-16.09/15} 110.Na2 Kxa2 {-M13/16} 111.Kg6 {-M12/14} Kb3 {-M12/14} 112.Kf6 {-M11/14} a2
{-M11/12} 113.Ke5 {-M10/11} a1=Q+ {-M10/10} 114.Kf5 {-M9/11} Qg7 {-M9/10} 115.h5 {-M7/10}
Be2 {-M7/10} 116.h6 {-M6/11} Qxh6 {-M6/11} 117.Ke5 Kc3 118.Kf5 Kd3 119.Ke5 Bg4
120.Kd5 Qb6 121.Ke5 Qd4# {Mate} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.04"]
[Round "10"]
[White "Crafty-23.2-win32"]
[Black "Crafty_23.1_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B30"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "2...Nc6 3.Nc3 Nf6"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "133"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 {+0.60/15} Nc6 {+0.71/14}
3.Nc3 {+0.54/15} Nf6 4.Bb5 {+0.47/14} e5 {+0.44/14} 5.Bxc6 {+0.46/15} dxc6 {+0.41/15}
6.Nxe5 {+0.37/15} Bd6 {+0.39/15} 7.Nc4 {+0.37/14} Bc7 {+0.39/13} 8.d3 {+0.34/14} Bg4
{+0.45/14} 9.f3 {+0.32/13} Be6 {+0.59/13} 10.O-O {+0.33/12} b5 {+0.46/12} 11.Ne3
{+0.36/13} Qb8 {+0.53/12} 12.g3 {+0.46/13} O-O {+0.50/12} 13.Ng2 {+0.51/12} c4 {+0.54/12}
14.Bf4 {+0.67/12} b4 {+0.75/12} 15.Na4 {+0.71/12} Rd8 {+0.87/13} 16.d4 {+1.18/13} Nh5
{+1.07/13} 17.Bxc7 {+1.26/14} Qxc7 {+1.29/13} 18.Nc5 Qe7 {+1.56/12} 19.c3 {+1.71/12} Rab8
{+1.70/12} 20.Qa4 {+1.96/13} bxc3 {+1.95/13} 21.bxc3 {+1.98/13} Bh3 {+2.00/12} 22.Rab1
{+1.96/13} Rxb1 {+1.99/12} 23.Rxb1 {+2.07/12} Qg5 {+2.14/12} 24.Qc2 {+2.25/12} Bxg2
{+1.82/14} 25.Kxg2 {+2.15/14} Nf4+ {+1.94/14} 26.Kh1 {+2.05/15} Ne6 {+1.75/15} 27.Nxe6
{+1.84/15} fxe6 28.f4 {+1.87/14} Qa5 {+1.78/13} 29.Qd2 c5 {+1.94/13} 30.d5 {+2.09/13} exd5
{+1.82/14} 31.exd5 {+2.15/14} Qc7 {+1.80/13} 32.Rd1 {+2.13/13} Qe7 {+1.82/13} 33.Kg2
{+2.21/14} Qe4+ {+1.83/14} 34.Kf2 Kf7 35.h3 {+2.02/13} Rd6 {+1.80/13} 36.Qe3 {+2.02/14}
Qxe3+ {+1.67/14} 37.Kxe3 {+1.95/15} Rh6 {+1.80/15} 38.h4 {+2.21/15} Rb6 {+1.91/15}
39.Ke4 {+2.13/15} Ke7 {+1.97/15} 40.Ke5 {+2.13/15} Kd7 {+2.11/15} 41.d6 {+2.10/15} h5
{+2.11/15} 42.Rd5 {+2.23/16} Rc6 {+2.27/15} 43.Ke4 {+2.31/16} g6 {+2.29/15} 44.Ke5
{+2.26/16} Rc8 {+2.29/16} 45.Kf6 {+2.47/16} a5 {+2.26/15} 46.Kg7 {+2.52/15} Re8 {+2.56/15}
47.Re5 {+2.46/15} Rc8 {+2.62/16} 48.Rg5 {+3.14/15} Re8 {+2.56/16} 49.Rxg6 {+2.71/15}
Re3 {+3.62/16} 50.f5 {+3.23/16} Rxc3 {+3.10/16} 51.f6 {+4.57/16} Rf3 {+6.26/16}
52.f7 {+6.51/16} Rxf7+ {+7.36/17} 53.Kxf7 {+6.40/17} c3 {+8.97/17} 54.Re6 {+11.47/17}
a4 {+11.24/16} 55.Re1 {+14.11/17} Kxd6 {+14.24/16} 56.g4 {+15.24/17} hxg4
{+14.96/15} 57.h5 {+15.81/15} c2 {+15.72/14} 58.h6 {+17.18/14} g3 {+17.27/13} 59.h7
{+18.58/13} g2 {+17.65/11} 60.h8=Q {+18.94/11} g1=Q {+M8/10} 61.Qd8+ {+M7/10} Kc6 62.Rxg1
{+M6/10} a3 {+M5/9} 63.Rg6+ {+M5/9} Kb5 {+M4/9} 64.Qb6+ Kc4 65.Qb3+ Kd4 66.Rg4+ Ke5
67.Qe6# {Mate} 1-0

[Togga]

but you can not dispute that I and Robert Hyatt got the same result: that crafty 23.2 is better.

I got it after 10 games, he after 40 000 games.

fortuity? no no.

[Togga]

what timecontrol was it?