Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

Hurnavich
Posts: 732
Joined: Wed Jun 19, 2013 8:14 pm

Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by Hurnavich »

AMD 1100T 6 core
Syzygy Full 6 man on SSD
Eco 25 Test Suite


Ponder off

40Min+4 sec

50 Games
"May your next game be your best"
Hurnavich
Posts: 732
Joined: Wed Jun 19, 2013 8:14 pm

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by Hurnavich »

Game 1

[pgn][Event "Komodo 11.01 LTC vs Houdini 5.01 Pro, R"]
[Site "Hurnavich-PC"]
[Date "2017.05.22"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Komodo 11.01 64-bit LTC"]
[Black "Houdini 5.01 Pro x64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A00"]
[Annotator "-0.40;-0.51"]
[PlyCount "84"]
[TimeControl "2400+4"]

{AMD Phenom(tm) II X6 1100T Processor 3625 MHz W=30.9 plies; 7,236kN/s; 4,344,
423 TBAs B=26.8 plies; 10,989kN/s; 225,648 TBAs} 1. h3 e5 2. c3 d5 3. d4 Nc6
4. Be3 Nf6 {Both last book move} 5. dxe5 {-0.40/28 51} Nxe5 {-0.51/25 90} 6.
Bf4 {-0.33/29 56} Ng6 {-0.40/27 68} 7. Bh2 {-0.30/30 41} Bd6 {-0.45/26 54} 8.
Bxd6 {-0.29/29 28} Qxd6 {-0.49/26 50} 9. Nf3 {-0.30/30 118 (e3)} O-O {-0.42/25
46 (Bf5)} 10. e3 {-0.29/28 55} Re8 {-0.33/25 230 (Bf5)} 11. Nbd2 {-0.27/30 137}
Bf5 {-0.37/24 45} 12. Be2 {-0.30/27 47} c5 {-0.36/22 36 (h6)} 13. O-O {-0.29/
27 54} Rad8 {-0.35/23 63 (h6)} 14. b4 {-0.29/27 40 (Qa4)} cxb4 {-0.40/23 80}
15. cxb4 {-0.24/29 39 (Nd4)} Qxb4 {-0.54/24 40} 16. a3 {-0.33/27 38 (Nd4)} Qe7
{-0.31/25 69 (Qd6)} 17. Nd4 {-0.39/27 37} Be4 {-0.47/24 48} 18. Rc1 {-0.29/29
51 (Bb5)} a6 {-0.20/26 84} 19. Qb3 {-0.37/29 42} Ne5 {-0.31/26 50} 20. Rfd1 {
-0.25/28 24 (a4)} h6 {-0.52/24 23} 21. a4 {-0.32/29 36} Bh7 {-0.43/28 70 (Rd7)}
22. N2f3 {-0.23/32 71 (Rc3)} Nxf3+ {-0.50/26 27} 23. Bxf3 {-0.37/32 26} Be4 {
-0.25/23 15} 24. Qc3 {-0.29/32 31 (a5)} Bxf3 {-0.45/26 34} 25. Nxf3 {-0.22/31
33} Ne4 {-0.38/28 89} 26. Qb3 {-0.30/32 80} Rd6 {-0.45/28 42 (Qd7)} 27. a5 {-0.
20/31 32} Qd7 {-0.55/28 32 (Red8)} 28. Rc2 {-0.48/26 23} Rc8 {-0.47/26 11} 29.
Rdc1 {-0.27/31 90} Rxc2 {-0.61/27 46 (Rcc6)} 30. Rxc2 {-0.30/30 27} Qe7 {-0.55/
26 9} 31. Qb4 {-0.20/35 66 (Rc8+)} Kh7 {-0.45/29 50} 32. Nd4 {-0.26/32 19 (Rc8)
} Rd7 {-0.38/28 42} 33. Qxe7 {-0.24/33 18} Rxe7 {-0.35/27 63} 34. Nf5 {-0.13/
34 29 (h4)} Rd7 {-0.30/30 52} 35. f3 {-0.09/32 20} Ng5 {-0.20/25 6} 36. Nd4 {
-0.11/34 61 (Kf2)} Ne6 {-0.28/28 26 (Kg6)} 37. Kf2 {-0.08/33 23} Kg6 {-0.16/29
47} 38. g4 {0.00/33 24} Nxd4 {-0.13/29 93 (Kg5)} 39. exd4 {0.00/36 18} Kf6 {0.
00/34 42 (Kg5)} 40. h4 {0.00/37 26} Ke7 {0.00/33 31 (Ke6)} 41. Ke3 {0.00/37 23
(Kg3)} Kd6 {0.00/32 26} 42. Kf4 {0.00/39 27} b5 {0.00/33 46 (Re7) Draw accepted
} 1/2-1/2[/pgn]
"May your next game be your best"
Hurnavich
Posts: 732
Joined: Wed Jun 19, 2013 8:14 pm

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by Hurnavich »

Game 2

[pgn][Event "Komodo 11.01 LTC vs Houdini 5.01 Pro, R"]
[Site "Hurnavich-PC"]
[Date "2017.05.22"]
[Round "2"]
[White "Houdini 5.01 Pro x64"]
[Black "Komodo 11.01 64-bit LTC"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A00"]
[Annotator "-0.42;-0.44"]
[PlyCount "117"]
[TimeControl "2400+4"]

{AMD Phenom(tm) II X6 1100T Processor 3625 MHz W=26.8 plies; 10,111kN/s; 35,
532 TBAs B=30.7 plies; 7,357kN/s; 3,225,213 TBAs} 1. h3 e5 2. c3 d5 3. d4 Nc6
4. Be3 Nf6 {Both last book move} 5. dxe5 {-0.42/26 84} Nxe5 {-0.44/27 25} 6.
Nd2 {-0.44/26 157 (Bf4)} Bd6 {-0.37/28 54 (c5)} 7. Ngf3 {-0.47/27 43} O-O {-0.
42/30 63 (c6)} 8. Nxe5 {-0.41/26 45} Bxe5 {-0.43/29 23} 9. Nf3 {-0.34/25 19}
Bd6 {-0.33/29 25} 10. Bg5 {-0.36/27 114} Be6 {-0.38/29 36} 11. Qd4 {-0.36/27
52 (e3)} Be7 {-0.41/29 47} 12. e3 {-0.32/26 62} c5 {-0.33/29 36} 13. Qa4 {-0.
23/25 27} Ne4 {-0.37/30 82} 14. Bxe7 {-0.31/26 55} Qxe7 {-0.30/29 22} 15. Bd3 {
-0.27/25 39} Bd7 {-0.28/27 37} 16. Qc2 {-0.23/25 54} Rfe8 {-0.30/30 97 (Rad8)}
17. O-O {-0.28/24 61} Rad8 {-0.24/29 88} 18. Rad1 {-0.18/24 66} Bc6 {-0.38/28
31} 19. a3 {-0.30/25 304 (Rfe1)} h6 {-0.40/29 66 (g6)} 20. Rfe1 {-0.28/23 61}
Nd6 {-0.26/29 132 (Qf6)} 21. b4 {-0.20/24 207 (Bh7+)} b6 {-0.31/27 37} 22. Nd2
{-0.12/26 164} Qd7 {-0.23/30 58} 23. Qb1 {-0.12/25 25} Qe7 {-0.26/32 93 (Ba4)}
24. Qc2 {-0.12/36 25} c4 {-0.22/34 73 (Qd7)} 25. Bf1 {-0.17/24 49 (Be2)} Qf6 {
-0.26/28 20} 26. a4 {-0.12/25 49 (Nf3)} Bd7 {-0.27/28 28 (a6)} 27. Nf3 {-0.12/
27 106} Bf5 {-0.22/29 26} 28. Qb2 {-0.12/26 4} Ne4 {-0.20/33 56} 29. Nd4 {-0.
12/24 0} Bd7 {-0.14/36 171} 30. f3 {-0.12/28 25} Ng3 {-0.19/34 82} 31. Qf2 {-0.
32/22 4 (b5)} Nxf1 {-0.23/36 43 (Qg5)} 32. Kxf1 {-0.11/29 16} Bxa4 {-0.16/34 36
} 33. Ra1 {-0.11/26 5} b5 {-0.10/32 15} 34. Qg3 {-0.11/29 28} Ra8 {0.00/32 57
(a6)} 35. Qg4 {-0.11/30 23} a5 {-0.14/30 16 (Qd8)} 36. bxa5 {-0.11/30 33} Rxa5
{0.00/32 30} 37. Qd7 {-0.11/30 9 (Qf5)} Rea8 {-0.20/30 27 (Rd8)} 38. Qb7 {-0.
11/28 24 (Qf5)} Qe5 {-0.01/31 36} 39. e4 {-0.11/27 4} dxe4 {0.00/33 33} 40.
Rxe4 {-0.11/29 24} Qf6 {0.00/36 41 (Qd6)} 41. Qe7 {-0.11/27 29 (Rae1)} Qb6 {-0.
12/29 38 (Qg6)} 42. Rae1 {-0.11/29 22} R5a6 {0.00/33 35 (b4)} 43. Qb4 {-0.11/
24 22} Kh7 {0.00/35 36} 44. h4 {-0.11/26 27 (Qb1)} Qd6 {0.00/32 84} 45. Qxd6 {
-0.11/26 5 (Qb1)} Rxd6 {-0.05/31 18} 46. Rb1 {-0.04/24 40} Rb8 {-0.05/33 46
(g6)} 47. h5 {-0.04/24 42} Rd7 {0.00/35 35} 48. Ra1 {-0.04/26 17 (Ke2)} Bb3 {
0.00/34 26 (Rdb7)} 49. Rb1 {-0.04/28 16} Ra8 {0.00/35 20} 50. Re5 {-0.04/28 3
(g4)} Ra2 {0.00/37 28 (b4)} 51. Rxb5 {0.04/28 11} Bc2 {0.06/36 86 (Re7)} 52.
R1b2 {0.13/24 41 (Re1)} Bd3+ {0.00/36 11} 53. Kf2 {0.00/29 32} Ra3 {0.00/37 15}
54. Rb7 {-0.04/29 3} Rxb7 {0.00/36 10} 55. Rxb7 {-0.04/28 0} Kg8 {0.00/35 10}
56. Rb8+ {0.00/31 12 (Nb5)} Kh7 {0.00/5 0} 57. Rb7 {0.00/29 3} Kg8 {0.00/37 20}
58. Rb8+ {0.00/34 12 (Nb5)} Kh7 {0.00/5 0} 59. Rb7 {0.00/35 20 Draw accepted}
1/2-1/2[/pgn]
"May your next game be your best"
shrapnel
Posts: 1339
Joined: Fri Nov 02, 2012 9:43 am
Location: New Delhi, India

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by shrapnel »

Hey Hurnavich bro ! Why are you after poor ol' Houdini's life ?
It hasn't been updated in simply AGES !
A Komodo win is a given.
Pit Komodo against the latest Stockfish, for a more fair and interesting fight !
i7 5960X @ 4.1 Ghz, 64 GB G.Skill RipJaws RAM, Twin Asus ROG Strix OC 11 GB Geforce 2080 Tis
Hurnavich
Posts: 732
Joined: Wed Jun 19, 2013 8:14 pm

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by Hurnavich »

In my previous match 40+4
Houdini won 10.4
So I thought I would test new Komodo
"May your next game be your best"
Hurnavich
Posts: 732
Joined: Wed Jun 19, 2013 8:14 pm

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by Hurnavich »

Game 3

[pgn][Event "Komodo 11.01 LTC vs Houdini 5.01 Pro, R"]
[Site "Hurnavich-PC"]
[Date "2017.05.22"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Komodo 11.01 64-bit LTC"]
[Black "Houdini 5.01 Pro x64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A31"]
[Annotator "0.28;0.43"]
[PlyCount "93"]
[TimeControl "2400+4"]

{AMD Phenom(tm) II X6 1100T Processor 3625 MHz W=33.0 plies; 7,939kN/s; 63,
301,382 TBAs B=26.6 plies; 11,570kN/s; 374,868 TBAs} 1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 c5 3. Nf3
cxd4 4. Nxd4 e5 {Both last book move} 5. Nb5 {0.28/28 35} d6 {0.43/25 112} 6.
N1c3 {0.30/31 76} Be6 {0.46/26 94 (a6)} 7. Nd5 {0.31/29 57 (e4)} Bxd5 {0.37/26
45 (Nxd5)} 8. cxd5 {0.40/27 22} Qa5+ {0.43/26 71 (Nbd7)} 9. Nc3 {0.37/29 29}
Nbd7 {0.48/26 105 (Be7)} 10. Rb1 {0.38/29 95} Ne4 {0.52/26 43 (Be7)} 11. b4 {
0.54/30 31} Nxc3 {0.58/25 0} 12. bxa5 {0.50/29 25} Nxd1 {0.62/26 102} 13. Kxd1
{0.53/30 35} Nc5 {0.61/25 17} 14. e4 {0.55/29 55} g6 {0.66/26 119 (0-0-0)} 15.
Be3 {0.73/27 26} O-O-O {0.70/25 67 (Rb8)} 16. Bb5 {0.64/30 76 (f3)} a6 {0.63/
24 67} 17. Bxc5 {0.53/30 25} dxc5 {0.63/25 36} 18. Bd3 {0.58/31 56 (Bc4)} Bd6 {
0.63/25 60 (Rd7)} 19. Ke2 {0.53/31 51} Rd7 {0.58/26 75} 20. Rhc1 {0.49/30 43
(Rb2)} c4 {0.49/26 30 (Rc7)} 21. Bxc4 {0.51/31 61} Rc7 {0.49/24 0} 22. Bb3 {0.
41/31 58} Rd8 {0.48/26 42} 23. Ba4 {0.51/29 25 (g4)} f5 {0.54/27 87 (f6)} 24.
Rxc7+ {0.53/34 120 (exf5)} Bxc7 {0.55/27 49} 25. exf5 {0.53/32 27} gxf5 {0.55/
27 48} 26. Bc2 {0.44/33 42 (Rd1)} e4 {0.57/28 78} 27. Rd1 {0.63/29 23} h5 {0.
75/24 9 (Bxa5)} 28. f3 {0.50/32 63 (g3)} Rg8 {0.40/26 44 (Bxh2)} 29. g3 {0.23/
33 118} h4 {0.50/27 66} 30. d6 {0.25/33 60} Bxa5 {0.40/26 12} 31. fxe4 {0.30/
35 57} fxe4 {0.43/28 58} 32. Bb3 {0.29/36 47 (Kf2)} Rg6 {0.20/24 21} 33. g4 {
0.35/36 48 (Bf7)} Kd7 {0.31/28 52} 34. h3 {0.14/35 48} Rf6 {0.40/25 12} 35. Bc2
{0.06/36 53} Bb6 {0.23/27 20} 36. Bxe4 {0.05/35 32} Rf2+ {0.23/25 1} 37. Kd3 {
0.03/35 48} Kxd6 {0.23/30 42} 38. Bxb7 {0.00/36 51 (Rd2)} Rxa2 {0.20/27 30} 39.
Ke4+ {0.00/38 48} Kc7 {0.20/29 7} 40. Bd5 {0.00/39 31} Ra3 {0.14/30 101} 41.
Rc1+ {0.00/37 24 (Rd3)} Kd8 {0.05/27 50} 42. Rc2 {0.00/40 54 (Rc6)} Rxh3 {0.00/
30 24} 43. Rc6 {0.00/40 21} Bg1 {0.00/28 6 (Bf2)} 44. Kf5 {0.00/41 32 (Rxa6)}
a5 {0.00/29 28 (Rg3)} 45. Ra6 {0.00/42 50 (g5)} Ra3 {0.00/29 27 (Rg3)} 46. Rh6
{0.00/36 27 (g5)} h3 {0.00/30 33} 47. g5 {0.00/37 18 Draw accepted} 1/2-1/2[/pgn]
"May your next game be your best"
Hurnavich
Posts: 732
Joined: Wed Jun 19, 2013 8:14 pm

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by Hurnavich »

Game 4

[pgn][Event "Komodo 11.01 LTC vs Houdini 5.01 Pro, R"]
[Site "Hurnavich-PC"]
[Date "2017.05.22"]
[Round "4"]
[White "Houdini 5.01 Pro x64"]
[Black "Komodo 11.01 64-bit LTC"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A31"]
[Annotator "0.57;0.22"]
[PlyCount "108"]
[TimeControl "2400+4"]

{AMD Phenom(tm) II X6 1100T Processor 3625 MHz W=27.1 plies; 10,833kN/s; 560,
324 TBAs B=31.9 plies; 7,227kN/s; 27,595,515 TBAs} 1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 c5 3. Nf3
cxd4 4. Nxd4 e5 {Both last book move} 5. Nb5 {0.57/25 91} d6 {0.22/29 73} 6.
N5c3 {0.47/25 67 (g3)} a6 {0.29/28 72 (Nc6)} 7. e4 {0.50/24 48 (g3)} Be6 {0.23/
29 127 (Nc6)} 8. Na3 {0.43/25 60 (Be2)} Nc6 {0.24/29 76} 9. f3 {0.45/26 54
(Bd3)} Be7 {0.36/29 59} 10. Be3 {0.56/24 49} O-O {0.11/27 43} 11. Nc2 {0.33/24
72} Qb8 {0.16/27 34 (Rc8)} 12. Rb1 {0.38/23 61} Bd8 {0.24/28 83} 13. Bf2 {0.22/
25 170} Ne7 {0.33/27 56 (b5)} 14. a4 {0.45/24 23} Nd7 {0.22/28 53} 15. Be2 {0.
38/22 11} Bb6 {0.31/29 41} 16. Bxb6 {0.36/24 107} Nxb6 {0.12/27 27} 17. b3 {0.
38/24 74} f5 {0.15/27 39 (Qc7)} 18. exf5 {0.38/25 62 (a5)} Nxf5 {0.20/28 100
(Bxf5)} 19. O-O {0.57/21 25} Nd7 {0.26/30 118 (Qc7)} 20. Qd2 {0.56/24 37} Qc7 {
0.22/27 30} 21. Rfd1 {0.54/23 50} Rad8 {0.22/30 70 (Kh8)} 22. Bd3 {0.44/25 55}
Nc5 {0.17/30 38} 23. Bxf5 {0.52/25 40} Bxf5 {0.20/29 17} 24. b4 {0.42/27 79
(Nd5)} Ne6 {0.21/30 43} 25. Nd5 {0.40/24 7} Qd7 {0.12/30 38} 26. Ra1 {0.40/27
45} Bg6 {0.26/29 57 (Rde8)} 27. a5 {0.40/28 90} Rde8 {0.15/30 46} 28. Rf1 {0.
46/28 49 (Re1)} Qd8 {0.27/33 229 (Nf4)} 29. Rad1 {0.37/27 64} Qh4 {0.23/31 16}
30. Nce3 {0.36/26 36} Qg5 {0.24/29 25} 31. h3 {0.28/26 43 (Qf2)} e4 {0.20/29
50 (Nd4)} 32. fxe4 {0.31/26 51} Bxe4 {0.11/30 63} 33. Rxf8+ {0.25/28 46} Nxf8 {
0.26/31 25} 34. Nf1 {0.21/26 6} Ne6 {0.24/31 30 (Qxd2)} 35. Qxg5 {0.31/26 22}
Nxg5 {0.14/31 18} 36. Nc3 {0.23/27 97} Re6 {0.14/30 24} 37. Rd4 {0.31/25 32}
Bc2 {0.11/31 47} 38. h4 {0.37/26 28} Nf7 {0.14/29 16} 39. Nd2 {0.18/25 45} Kf8
{0.15/31 39} 40. Nde4 {0.21/27 47} Rh6 {0.11/31 37 (Ke7)} 41. g3 {0.18/27 48}
Bxe4 {0.07/30 35} 42. Nxe4 {0.23/29 28} Ke7 {0.11/31 24} 43. Kf2 {0.18/28 32}
Kd7 {0.05/29 17 (Rh5)} 44. Ke3 {0.24/25 28} Kc6 {0.00/31 13} 45. Rd5 {0.03/29
59 (Kf3)} Ne5 {0.00/34 11} 46. Kd4 {0.00/30 11} Nf3+ {0.00/35 16} 47. Kd3 {0.
00/30 19} Ne5+ {0.00/36 19} 48. Kc3 {0.00/30 9} Rg6 {0.00/35 11 (Re6)} 49. h5 {
0.20/24 13 (Nxd6)} Rg4 {0.00/37 21 (Re6)} 50. Nxd6 {0.00/34 31} Rxc4+ {0.00/44
40} 51. Nxc4 {0.00/34 0} Kxd5 {0.00/45 12} 52. Nxe5 {0.00/38 20} Kxe5 {0.00/49
11} 53. Kc4 {0.00/41 4} Kd6 {0.00/51 11} 54. g4 {0.00/50 20 (b5)} Kc6 {0.00/56
14 Draw accepted} 1/2-1/2[/pgn]
"May your next game be your best"
gogamoga
Posts: 33
Joined: Sat May 21, 2016 9:45 am

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by gogamoga »

Hurnavich wrote:In my previous match 40+4
Houdini won 10.4
So I thought I would test new Komodo
Has Komodo played with contempt 10 or 0? You didn't specify what settings are you using.
Hurnavich
Posts: 732
Joined: Wed Jun 19, 2013 8:14 pm

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by Hurnavich »

Contempt = 0
"May your next game be your best"
User avatar
Nordlandia
Posts: 2821
Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 9:38 pm
Location: Sortland, Norway

Re: Komodo 11.01 vs Houdini 5.01 Pro 40+4 sec

Post by Nordlandia »

Table memory: 256
Contempt: 0
Overhead ms: 500 (compensate for transmission delay)
Ponder: On
TC: 30m+30s
Hash: 2048 Mb
GUI: Fritz 15 [Patch 23]
OS: Windows 10
CPU: i5-5200U

[pgn][Event "DESKTOP-DD1B2QU, Rapid 30m+30s"]
[Site "DESKTOP-DD1B2QU"]
[Date "2017.05.23"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Komodo 11.01 64-bit"]
[Black "Houdini 5.01 Pro x64-pext"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[Annotator "0.07;-0.15"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "rnbqkbnr/pp1ppppp/8/2p5/4P3/N7/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "182"]
[TimeControl "1800+30"]

1... d6 {-0.15/23 48 Both last book move} 2. g3 {0.07/27 160} Nc6 {-0.02/26 110
} 3. Bg2 {0.03/27 0} g6 {0.15/26 219 (Nf6)} 4. Ne2 {0.14/28 119 (c3)} Bg7 {
-0.03/24 79} 5. O-O {0.03/29 54 (d3)} h5 {-0.17/24 46 (Nf6)} 6. h4 {0.07/28 131
} e5 {-0.16/26 0 (Bg4)} 7. Nc4 {-0.08/29 110} b5 {-0.15/25 7} 8. Ne3 {-0.07/29
55} Nf6 {-0.19/25 30 (Rb8)} 9. d3 {-0.13/28 141} Rb8 {-0.08/26 15} 10. Bd2 {
-0.14/28 165 (c4)} O-O {-0.28/22 42} 11. b3 {-0.10/28 55 (Nc3)} b4 {-0.40/23
77 (Bd7)} 12. a3 {-0.11/26 65 (Re1)} a5 {-0.28/27 123} 13. axb4 {-0.23/29 0
(Nc4)} cxb4 {-0.29/26 70 (axb4)} 14. Ra2 {-0.10/25 61 (Ra4)} Qc7 {-0.28/26 175}
15. c3 {-0.08/28 8 (Re1)} bxc3 {-0.28/24 82} 16. Nxc3 {-0.07/29 0} Be6 {
-0.31/25 197 (Qb7)} 17. Ncd5 {-0.35/30 141} Bxd5 {-0.30/27 41} 18. exd5 {
-0.23/28 18} Nb4 {-0.26/26 51} 19. Ra1 {-0.16/30 61} Rfc8 {-0.41/24 50 (Rb5)}
20. Qe2 {0.00/29 124} Qd8 {-0.31/25 8} 21. Nc4 {0.00/30 65} Rc5 {-0.23/26 91}
22. Be3 {-0.20/30 0 (Bg5)} Rcb5 {-0.45/23 42} 23. Na3 {-0.09/29 58 (Bg5)} R5b7
{0.09/25 187} 24. Bg5 {-0.06/33 0} Qd7 {0.05/25 51} 25. Nc4 {0.00/33 39} Nfxd5
{-0.03/27 24} 26. Rxa5 {0.00/32 29 (Rfc1)} Rb5 {-0.01/29 121} 27. Rxb5 {
0.06/33 0} Rxb5 {0.02/28 80} 28. Ra1 {0.07/31 33} Nc7 {0.10/25 0 (Rb8)} 29. d4
{0.15/28 52} exd4 {0.10/29 161} 30. Ra7 {0.14/32 0} Bf8 {0.10/29 54} 31. Qf3 {
0.00/29 58 (Qe4)} Rc5 {0.10/27 56} 32. Rb7 {0.00/31 93 (Qb7)} Rb5 {0.10/28 64
(Qe8)} 33. Bf1 {0.13/34 282 (Ra7)} Rxb7 {0.10/27 60 (d3)} 34. Qxb7 {0.14/29 43}
Nbd5 {0.15/29 0} 35. Bd2 {0.18/29 62 (Bg2)} Nf6 {0.25/28 120} 36. Ba5 {0.14/31
0 (Nb6)} Ne6 {0.14/27 35} 37. Qxd7 {0.23/31 11} Nxd7 {0.10/27 47} 38. Nb6 {
0.27/31 19} Ne5 {0.10/28 57} 39. f4 {0.20/32 55} Nc6 {0.37/33 115} 40. Be1 {
0.14/36 0} Nc7 {0.37/30 8} 41. Bc4 {0.16/37 122 (Bg2)} d5 {0.28/31 41} 42. Nxd5
{0.16/37 17} Nxd5 {0.28/36 0} 43. Bxd5 {0.07/39 51} Nb4 {0.28/36 8} 44. Bc4 {
0.08/38 40} Kg7 {0.28/37 0} 45. Kf1 {0.39/41 122 (Kf2)} f5 {0.28/39 49 (Bc5)}
46. Ke2 {0.28/43 50} Kf6 {0.28/37 0 (Bc5)} 47. Kd1 {0.29/42 66 (Bf2)} Bc5 {
0.28/36 55} 48. Kd2 {0.29/43 13 (Bf2)} Kg7 {0.28/36 83 (Bb6)} 49. Bb5 {0.30/40
59 (Bf2)} Kf6 {0.29/36 62} 50. Be8 {0.31/39 0 (Kc1)} Bb6 {0.28/34 44 (Bf8)} 51.
Ba4 {0.29/41 75 (Bf2)} Ke7 {0.00/30 25 (Bc5)} 52. Bb5 {0.28/44 67 (Bf2)} Bc5 {
0.29/36 99} 53. Ke2 {0.28/43 0 (Kd1)} Kf6 {0.29/33 31} 54. Bc4 {0.28/42 11
(Bd2)} Bf8 {0.00/63 27 (Be7)} 55. Kd1 {0.28/41 29 (Kf3)} Bc5 {0.00/42 35 (Bd6)}
56. Bd2 {0.27/41 37 (Bf2)} Bd6 {0.29/34 34 (Nc6)} 57. Kc1 {0.31/34 25 (Bb5)}
Ke7 {0.35/31 47 (Bc5)} 58. Kb2 {0.29/36 32} Nc6 {0.29/31 0} 59. Bb5 {0.27/37
52 (Bd3)} Nb4 {0.29/33 37} 60. Ka3 {0.25/36 18 (Be1)} Nc2+ {0.29/31 34} 61. Ka2
{0.25/37 38} Ne3 {0.29/35 30 (Ke6)} 62. Ba5 {0.24/37 86 (Kb2)} Nd1 {0.28/31 31}
63. Ba6 {0.25/38 23} Nc3+ {0.28/31 0} 64. Kb2 {0.25/38 38} Ne4 {0.28/33 20} 65.
Be1 {0.24/35 11} Nc3 {0.28/35 0} 66. Bf1 {0.18/38 52 (Bc4)} Nd5 {0.20/33 34}
67. Bb5 {0.18/39 23 (Be2)} Bc5 {0.19/31 33} 68. Kc1 {0.20/39 19} Nb4 {0.19/32 0
} 69. Bc4 {0.20/43 66 (Kd1)} Nc6 {0.18/32 40 (Bd6)} 70. Kd2 {0.18/45 78 (Kb1)}
Nb4 {0.15/36 75} 71. Ke2 {0.18/43 6} Kf8 {0.10/33 13 (Kf6)} 72. Kd1 {0.18/42 53
} Ke7 {0.06/35 4} 73. Bd2 {0.18/40 24} Nc6 {0.06/32 0 (Bd6)} 74. Kc1 {0.18/37
25 (Kc2)} Ba3+ {0.13/32 128 (Nb4)} 75. Kc2 {0.08/37 38 (Kb1)} Bc5 {0.00/33 34}
76. Bb5 {0.08/38 0 (Be1)} Nb4+ {0.00/34 41} 77. Kb2 {0.08/37 0 (Kd1)} Bd6 {
0.00/37 38} 78. Ka3 {0.27/33 0} Nc2+ {0.00/40 39} 79. Ka4 {0.17/35 86} Ne3 {
0.28/30 52} 80. Be1 {0.13/35 26 (Bd3)} Nd5 {0.16/28 16 (Nd1)} 81. Bc4 {0.09/37
62} Nc3+ {0.15/31 0} 82. Ka5 {0.09/36 24} Bc7+ {0.15/33 24} 83. Ka6 {0.08/37 0}
Bd6 {0.15/32 7} 84. Kb6 {0.02/39 65} Ke8 {0.15/32 0 (Bb4)} 85. Kc6 {0.00/37 64}
Bb4 {0.14/33 0 (Be7)} 86. Bf2 {0.00/40 35 (Bd3)} Ne4 {0.14/33 55} 87. Bg1 {
0.00/40 4 (Bxd4)} Bc3 {0.00/30 29 (Nxg3)} 88. Kd5 {0.00/43 48 (Bd3)} Ke7 {
0.00/33 52} 89. Bxd4 {0.00/47 2} Nf6+ {0.00/36 5} 90. Ke5 {0.00/50 41 (Kc5)}
Nd7+ {0.00/44 41} 91. Kd5 {0.00/55 0} Nf6+ {0.00/54 9} 92. Ke5 {0.00/54 32
(Kc5) Time} 1/2-1/2

[/pgn]