For Komodo 10,4 at long time controls, the recommended settings were
King Safety 105
Dynamism 93
Selectivity 131
Any changes here for v.11?
Komodo 11 settings
Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Thu Mar 30, 2006 2:08 pm
Re: Komodo 11 settings
I do not really have any convincing evidence that anything other than the default settings are best for Komodo 11 at longer time controls. If someone can show an improvement at longer time controls with new values, please let us know.cma6 wrote:For Komodo 10,4 at long time controls, the recommended settings were
King Safety 105
Dynamism 93
Selectivity 131
Any changes here for v.11?
Since parts of the dynamic evaluation, parts of king safety and parts of selectivity all changed from Komodo 10.4 to 11.01, then all three values might still matter.
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Thu May 29, 2014 5:58 pm
Re: Komodo 11 settings
OK, then I should go back to the default settings in K11 for these 3 parameters. Can you give me the defaults for these 3?mjlef wrote:I do not really have any convincing evidence that anything other than the default settings are best for Komodo 11 at longer time controls. If someone can show an improvement at longer time controls with new values, please let us know.cma6 wrote:For Komodo 10,4 at long time controls, the recommended settings were
King Safety 105
Dynamism 93
Selectivity 131
Any changes here for v.11?
Since parts of the dynamic evaluation, parts of king safety and parts of selectivity all changed from Komodo 10.4 to 11.01, then all three values might still matter.
-
- Posts: 282
- Joined: Mon Sep 02, 2013 8:23 am
Re: Komodo 11 settings
And for 11.1 for deep analysis of position - these settings would be 'optimal'?cma6 wrote:For Komodo 10,4 at long time controls, the recommended settings were
King Safety 105
Dynamism 93
Selectivity 131
Any changes here for v.11?
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Thu May 29, 2014 5:58 pm
Re: Komodo 11 settings
Hi Brian:
Were you answering "Yes" or ?
Were you answering "Yes" or ?
-
- Posts: 282
- Joined: Mon Sep 02, 2013 8:23 am
Re: Komodo 11 settings
I was asking a question of Mark.
-
- Posts: 5960
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 am
- Location: Maryland USA
Re: Komodo 11 settings
The defaults are still 73 for King Safety and also (by coincidence) for Selectivity, and 120 for Dynamism. The numbers you mention are pretty far from these, and we would never have suggested them; do you recall where you got these recommended numbers? There is some slight evidence that longer time controls justify higher values for all three parameters, but we don't have enough games at long time controls to warrant any particular alternate recommendation to the default.cma6 wrote:OK, then I should go back to the default settings in K11 for these 3 parameters. Can you give me the defaults for these 3?mjlef wrote:I do not really have any convincing evidence that anything other than the default settings are best for Komodo 11 at longer time controls. If someone can show an improvement at longer time controls with new values, please let us know.cma6 wrote:For Komodo 10,4 at long time controls, the recommended settings were
King Safety 105
Dynamism 93
Selectivity 131
Any changes here for v.11?
Since parts of the dynamic evaluation, parts of king safety and parts of selectivity all changed from Komodo 10.4 to 11.01, then all three values might still matter.
Komodo rules!
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Thu May 29, 2014 5:58 pm
Re: Komodo 11 settings
My parameters are for correspondence deep analysis, e.g., 15-30 minutes/move. 131 for Selectivity must have been used in an earlier version of Komodo 10.lkaufman wrote:The defaults are still 73 for King Safety and also (by coincidence) for Selectivity, and 120 for Dynamism. The numbers you mention are pretty far from these, and we would never have suggested them; do you recall where you got these recommended numbers? There is some slight evidence that longer time controls justify higher values for all three parameters, but we don't have enough games at long time controls to warrant any particular alternate recommendation to the default.cma6 wrote:OK, then I should go back to the default settings in K11 for these 3 parameters. Can you give me the defaults for these 3?mjlef wrote:I do not really have any convincing evidence that anything other than the default settings are best for Komodo 11 at longer time controls. If someone can show an improvement at longer time controls with new values, please let us know.cma6 wrote:For Komodo 10,4 at long time controls, the recommended settings were
King Safety 105
Dynamism 93
Selectivity 131
Any changes here for v.11?
Since parts of the dynamic evaluation, parts of king safety and parts of selectivity all changed from Komodo 10.4 to 11.01, then all three values might still matter.
Dynamism of 93 was my compromise between recommended 110 and my inclination for a low value. My understanding, at least for v. 10, was that the higher Dynamism was above 100, the greater the loss in playing strength.
Aren't your defaults aimed for fast time controls?
-
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Thu Mar 30, 2006 2:08 pm
Re: Komodo 11 settings
We do not know. Long time control games just take too long to get the many thousands of games needed to confirm these parameter changes. Now if someone has a cluster free for a few months....leavenfish wrote:And for 11.1 for deep analysis of position - these settings would be 'optimal'?cma6 wrote:For Komodo 10,4 at long time controls, the recommended settings were
King Safety 105
Dynamism 93
Selectivity 131
Any changes here for v.11?
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Thu May 29, 2014 5:58 pm
Re: Komodo 11 settings
The indications for the best settings for very long time controls would likely come from high level correspondence players who could, if so inclined, present anecdotal evidence of what worked best for them.