new epd test suite

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderators: hgm, Dann Corbit, Harvey Williamson

Forum rules
This textbox is used to restore diagrams posted with the [d] tag before the upgrade.
Dann Corbit
Posts: 12040
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:57 pm
Location: Redmond, WA USA
Contact:

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Dann Corbit » Wed Oct 21, 2009 7:26 pm

Paloma wrote:You forgot problem 38. :-)
It seems the score is very close to different moves in the unsolved problems.
and in the solved too. :(
[d]2r5/p4pk1/3Qbqp1/1p2p2p/2r1P2P/1NP2P2/PP4P1/1K1R3R w - - acd 21; acn 138824907; acs 583; bm Rd3; ce 36; fmvn 22; hmvc 0; id "Michael Hart.038"; pv Rd3 b4 Na5 R4c5 cxb4 Rc2 Rd2 Qxh4 Rhd1 Rxd2 Qxd2 Qg3 b5 h4 Nc6;

Code: Select all

38) Rd2; id "Michael Ha 
    Searching move: Rd1-d2
    Best move (Rybka 3): Rd1-d3
    Not found in: 11:00
      2	00:00	         412	421.888	+0.83	Qd6a6
      2	00:00	         524	536.576	+0.84	Nb3d2
      2	00:00	         755	773.120	+0.87	Rh1e1
      3	00:00	       1.304	1.335.296	+0.84	Rh1e1
      4	00:00	       2.292	138.059	+0.70	Rh1e1
      4	00:00	       2.450	147.576	+0.79	Nb3d2
      4	00:00	       3.051	183.777	+0.83	Rd1d2
      5	00:00	       3.216	193.716	+0.84	Rd1d2 b5b4
      6	00:00	       4.925	296.658	+0.74	Rd1d2 a7a6 Qd6xa6
      7	00:00	      12.842	208.733	+0.70	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1
      8	00:00	      22.869	212.889	+0.72	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Qh4f4 Qb3d5 a7a6
      9	00:00	      32.317	233.046	+0.72	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Qh4f4 Qb3d5 a7a6
     10	00:00	      45.909	230.445	+0.72	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Qh4f4 Qb3d5 a7a6
     11	00:00	      92.611	208.884	+0.75	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Qh4f4 a2a3 a7a6 Rd2d7 h5h4
     12	00:01	     212.856	211.410	+0.75	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Qh4f4 a2a3 a7a6 Rd2d7 h5h4
     13	00:02	     396.071	213.012	+0.73	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc6c4 a2a3 Qh4g5 Qb3a4 Rc4c7 Qa4b5 h5h4
     14	00:04	     844.332	225.213	+0.73	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc6c4 a2a3 Qh4g5 Qb3a4 Rc4c7 Qa4b5 h5h4 Qb5d5
     15	00:05	   1.193.133	224.342	+0.73	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc6c4 a2a3 Qh4g5 Qb3a4 Rc4c7 Qa4b5 h5h4 Qb5d5
     16	00:09	   2.026.376	228.903	+0.73	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc6c4 a2a3 Qh4g5 Qb3a4 Rc4c7 Qa4b5 h5h4 Qb5d5 Qg5g3
     17	01:37	  23.901.514	250.462	+0.50	Rd1d3 a7a6 Qd6xa6 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4xb4 Qa6d6 Rc8b8 Rd3c3 Qf6f4 Qd6e7 Kg7h6 Rh1c1 Be6xb3 a2xb3 Rb4b7 Qe7d6 Kh6h7
     18	01:54	  26.896.868	242.050	+0.50	Rd1d3 a7a6 Qd6xa6 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4xb4 Qa6d6 Rc8b8 Rd3c3 Qf6f4 Qd6e7 Kg7h6 Rh1c1 Be6xb3 a2xb3 Rb4b7 Qe7d6 Kh6h7
     19	02:18	  32.807.098	242.945	+0.50	Rd1d3 a7a6 Qd6xa6 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4xb4 Qa6d6 Rc8b8 Rd3c3 Qf6f4 Qd6e7 Kg7h6 Rh1c1 Be6xb3 a2xb3 Rb4b7 Qe7d6 Kh6h7
     20	04:47	  69.044.911	246.217	+0.36	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4g3 b4b5 h5h4 Na5c6
     21	09:43	 138.824.907	243.533	+0.36	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4g3 b4b5 h5h4 Na5c6
   10/21/2009 6:32:59 AM, Time for this analysis: 00:11:00, Rated time: 1:10:18
multi-pv analysis:

Code: Select all

38) Rd2; id "Michael Ha 
    Searching move: Rd1-d2
    Best move (Rybka 3 multi-pv): g2-g3
    Not found in: 10:00
      2	00:00	       2.060	124.084	+0.82	g2g3
      2	00:00	       1.938	116.736	+0.82	Rd1d2
      2	00:00	       1.664	1.703.936	+0.82	Rh1g1
      2	00:00	       2.078	125.168	+0.86	Rd1d3
      2	00:00	         947	969.728	+0.86	Rh1e1
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
      3	00:00	       3.836	122.752	+0.78	Qd6d2
      3	00:00	       3.437	207.028	+0.80	Rh1g1
      3	00:00	       3.847	123.104	+0.82	Nb3d2
      3	00:00	       3.056	184.079	+0.84	Rd1d3
      3	00:00	       3.833	230.881	+0.86	Rd1d2
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
      4	00:00	       5.960	190.720	+0.74	Qd6d2
      4	00:00	       5.566	178.112	+0.76	Rh1g1
      4	00:00	       4.531	144.992	+0.77	Nb3d2
      4	00:00	       5.962	190.784	+0.81	Rh1e1
      4	00:00	       3.862	123.584	+0.83	Rd1d2
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
      5	00:00	      11.948	111.225	+0.68	Qd6d3 b5b4
      5	00:00	      11.936	111.113	+0.73	Rh1g1 Rc4c7
      5	00:00	       8.134	173.525	+0.73	Rd1d2 a7a6
      5	00:00	      10.500	170.666	+0.76	Rh1e1 a7a6
      5	00:00	      11.939	111.141	+0.81	Rd1d3 Rc4c7 Qd6b4
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
      6	00:00	      34.996	134.721	+0.68	Kb1a1 Rc4c7 Qd6b4
      6	00:00	      29.010	126.409	+0.68	Qd6d3 Qf6f4 Qd3d2
      6	00:00	      15.806	128.455	+0.74	Rd1d2 a7a6 Qd6xa6
      6	00:00	      14.460	117.516	+0.76	Rh1e1 a7a6 Qd6xa6
      6	00:00	      12.544	116.773	+0.80	Rd1d3 a7a6 Qd6xa6
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
      7	00:00	      81.172	166.240	+0.54	a2a3 Rc4c7 Qd6b4 a7a6
      7	00:00	      71.211	166.484	+0.64	Qd6d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 b4xc3
      7	00:00	      88.765	171.177	+0.68	Qd6d2 Rc4c6 Qd2g5 Qf6xg5
      7	00:00	      60.798	159.225	+0.72	Rh1e1 a7a6 Re1h1 Rc4c6
      7	00:00	      64.330	161.852	+0.73	Rd1d2 a7a6 Rd2d3 Rc4c6
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
      8	00:01	     160.388	187.699	+0.51	Rh1g1 b5b4 c3xb4
      8	00:01	     144.243	185.326	+0.62	a2a3 Rc4c7 Qd6b4 a7a6 Nb3c1 Rc8d8
      8	00:01	     119.956	178.799	+0.66	Rh1e1 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2
      8	00:01	     128.300	182.724	+0.68	Qd6d2 Rc4c6 Qd2g5 Rc6b6 Qg5xf6+
      8	00:01	     106.422	174.361	+0.72	Rd1d2 a7a6 Rd2d3 Rc4c6 Qd6b4
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
      9	00:02	     287.528	202.774	+0.66	Rh1e1 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2
      9	00:02	     431.823	199.542	+0.67	Rh1f1 a7a6 Rf1h1 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 a2xb3 b5b4
      9	00:02	     385.831	202.506	+0.69	Rd1d3 b5b4
      9	00:02	     282.849	201.697	+0.72	Qd6d2 Rc4c6 Qd2g5 b5b4 Qg5xf6+ Kg7xf6 c3xb4 Be6xb3
      9	00:02	     268.623	202.555	+0.75	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
     10	00:05	     676.371	202.693	+0.50	Rh1f1 Rc4c6 Qd6b4 Qf6xh4 Qb4xb5 Qh4g3 Qb5a5 Rc6b6 Qa5xa7 Rc8b8
     10	00:05	     572.561	199.830	+0.59	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4g3 b2b3 h5h4
     10	00:05	   1.066.161	210.113	+0.66	Kb1a1 Rc8c6 Qd6d8 Rc6a6 Qd8xf6+ Kg7xf6 Ka1b1 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4xb4 Nb3c1
     10	00:05	     527.713	200.140	+0.73	Qd6d2 Rc4c7 Nb3a5 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc7c2 Qd2xc2 Be6xa2+ Kb1c1 Rc8xc2+ Kc1xc2 Qf6b6
     10	00:05	     456.286	199.588	+0.75	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6c4
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
     11	00:08	   1.550.045	211.491	+0.50	Rh1f1 Rc4c6 Qd6b4 Qf6xh4 Qb4xb5 Qh4g3 Qb5a5 Rc6b6 Qa5xa7 Rc8b8 Rd1d2 Rb8b7 Qa7a8
     11	00:08	   1.727.365	209.551	+0.52	Rh1e1 Rc4c6 Qd6b4 Qf6xh4 Qb4xb5 Qh4g3 Qb5a5 Be6c4 Re1g1 Bc4e2
     11	00:08	   1.321.238	213.062	+0.54	Qd6d2 Qf6e7 Qd2g5 Qe7c7 Rd1d3 b5b4 c3xb4
     11	00:08	   1.454.094	213.017	+0.59	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4g3 b2b3 h5h4
     11	00:08	   1.160.443	210.952	+0.75	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6c4 Qd3e3 Bc4xb3 Qe3xb3
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
     12	00:18	   3.819.263	212.804	+0.47	a2a3 Rc4c7 Qd6b4 a7a6 Nb3c1 Rc8d8 Rd1xd8 Qf6xd8 Qb4a5 Qd8d6 Rh1d1 Qd6xd1 Qa5xc7 Kg7f6 f3f4 e5xf4 Qc7xf4+ Kf6g7 Qf4e3 Qd1f1
     12	00:18	   2.105.823	210.048	+0.47	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4g3 b2b3 h5h4 Na5b7 h4h3
     12	00:18	   3.192.448	211.658	+0.48	Rh1f1 Rc4c6 Qd6b4 a7a6 Nb3a5 Rc6c7 Rf1h1 Rc8d8 a2a3 Rc7d7 Rd1xd7
     12	00:18	   2.523.972	212.108	+0.56	Qd6d2 Qf6e7 Qd2g5 Qe7c7 Rd1d3 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4xb4 Rh1c1 Rb4c4 Rd3c3 a7a5
     12	00:18	   1.845.230	210.249	+0.74	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6c4 Qd3e3 Bc4xb3 Qe3xb3
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
     13	00:34	   4.645.573	213.532	+0.35	Qd6d2 Qf6e7 a2a3 Rc4c7 Nb3c1 Rc7d7 Qd2e3 Be6c4 Rd1xd7 Qe7xd7 Rh1g1 Rc8d8
     13	00:34	   7.173.888	214.133	+0.40	Kb1a1 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Na5b7 Rc8c6 Qd6d3 Rc2xg2 Nb7c5
     13	00:34	   6.552.338	212.281	+0.47	a2a3 Rc4c7 Qd6b4 a7a6 Nb3c1 Rc8d8 Rd1xd8 Qf6xd8 Qb4a5 Qd8d6 Rh1d1 Qd6xd1 Qa5xc7 Kg7f6 f3f4 e5xf4 Qc7xf4+ Kf6g7 Qf4e3 Qd1f1
     13	00:34	   6.493.838	213.015	+0.54	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4h2 b2b3 Rc8c7 Rd1c1 Rc7d7 Qd2b2 Qh2f4
     13	00:34	   4.125.646	212.550	+0.71	Rd1d2 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6c4 Qd3e3 Bc4xb3 Qe3xb3
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
     14	01:12	  15.500.566	217.964	+0.30	Qd6d2 Qf6e7 Qd2g5 f7f6 Qg5d2 Qe7f7 a2a3 Rc4c6 Nb3a1 Be6a2+ Kb1c1 a7a5 Na1c2 Rc6c7 g2g4
     14	01:12	  10.122.698	216.221	+0.36	a2a3 Rc4c7 Qd6b4 a7a6 Nb3c1 Rc8d8 Rd1xd8 Qf6xd8 Qb4a5 Qd8d6 Rh1d1 Qd6xd1 Qa5xc7 Kg7f6 f3f4 e5xf4 Qc7xf4+ Kf6g7 Qf4e3 Qd1f1 Qe3d4+ f7f6
     14	01:12	  10.504.529	217.029	+0.38	Kb1a1 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Na5b7 Rc8c6 Qd6d3 Rc2xg2 Nb7c5 Rg2f2 Rd1f1 Rf2g2 Rf1c1
     14	01:12	   9.774.865	216.397	+0.54	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4h2 b2b3 Rc8c7 Rd1c1 Rc7d7 Qd2b2 Qh2f4
     14	01:12	   8.948.306	215.307	+0.55	Rd1d2 Rc4c6 Qd6b4 a7a6
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
     15	03:04	  39.476.469	219.206	+0.18	Rh1f1 Rc4c6 Qd6b4
     15	03:04	  34.915.494	219.463	+0.26	Qd6d2 Qf6e7 Qd2g5 f7f6 Qg5d2 Qe7f7 a2a3 Rc4c6 Nb3a1 Rc6c7 Na1c2 Rc7d7 Qd2c1 Rc8d8 Nc2b4 Be6c4
     15	03:04	  23.639.079	217.930	+0.46	Rd1d2 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Rc6b6 Qd3e3 Qf6e7 Rh1c1 Rc8c7
     15	03:04	  25.138.740	216.691	+0.53	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4h2 b2b3 Rc8c7 Rd1c1 Rc7xc1+ Kb1xc1 h5h4 Na5c6 Qh2h1+ Kc1b2 h4h3 g2xh3 Qh1xf3 Qd2c2 Qf3xh3 Nc6xe5 f7f6 Qc2c7+
     15	03:04	  29.120.906	216.600	+0.62	Kb1a1 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Qb3e3 Qh4e7 a2a3 Rc6c2 Rd1c1 Rc2xc1+ Rh1xc1 Rc8xc1+ Qe3xc1 Qe7h4 Qc1c2 Qh4e1+ Ka1a2
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
     16	05:19	  69.412.307	222.331	+0.20	Rh1e1 Rc4c6 Qd6d3
     16	05:19	  56.620.147	221.289	+0.26	Qd6d2 Qf6e7 Qd2g5 f7f6 Qg5d2 Qe7f7 a2a3 Rc4c6 Nb3a1 Rc6c7 Na1c2 Rc7d7 Qd2c1 Rc8d8 Nc2b4 Be6c4
     16	05:19	  54.416.383	220.447	+0.44	Rd1d2 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Rc6b6 Qd3e3 Qf6e7 Rh1c1 Qe7xh4 Nb3c5 Qh4e7 Nc5xe6+ Rb6xe6 Rc1d1 b5b4 c3xb4 Qe7xb4 Qe3xa7 Re6b6 Qa7d7 Qb4c3 Qd7d3 Qc3b4
     16	05:19	  48.533.339	222.452	+0.51	Kb1a1 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Qb3e3 Qh4e7 a2a3 Rc6c2 Rd1d2 Rc8c4 Rd2xc2 Rc4xc2 g2g3 Rc2g2 Rh1g1 Rg2xg1+ Qe3xg1 Qe7d7 Qg1c5 Qd7d1+
     16	05:19	  52.595.185	221.334	+0.53	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4c5 c3xb4 Rc5c2 Rd3d2 Qf6xh4 Rh1d1 Rc2xd2 Qd6xd2 Qh4h2 b2b3 Rc8c7 Rd1c1 Rc7xc1+ Kb1xc1 h5h4 Na5c6 Qh2h1+ Kc1b2 h4h3 g2xh3 Qh1xf3 Qd2c2 Qf3xh3 Nc6xe5 f7f6 Qc2c7+ Kg7h6
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
     17	08:15	 108.967.332	225.245	+0.20	Rh1e1 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Rc6b6 Re1h1 b5b4 c3xb4 Rb6xb4
     17	08:15	  87.021.663	227.920	+0.23	Rd1d3 b5b4 Nb3a5 Rc4d4 Rd3xd4 e5xd4 Qd6xd4 b4xc3 Qd4xf6+ Kg7xf6 Rh1c1 Kf6e5 b2b4 f7f5 b4b5
     17	08:15	 105.474.276	226.098	+0.26	Qd6d2 Qf6e7 Qd2g5 f7f6 Qg5d2 Qe7f7 a2a3 Rc4c6 Nb3a1 Rc6c7 Na1c2 Rc7d7 Qd2c1 Rc8d8 Nc2b4 Be6c4
     17	08:15	  97.768.158	225.327	+0.43	Rd1d2 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Rc6b6 Qd3e3 Qf6e7 Rh1c1 Qe7xh4 Nb3c5 Qh4e7 Nc5xe6+ Rb6xe6 Rc1d1 b5b4 c3xb4 Qe7xb4 Qe3xa7 Re6c6 Qa7e3 Rc6c7 Qe3g5 Qb4c5 a2a3 Rc7b7 Kb1a1
     17	08:15	  92.618.579	227.017	+0.47	Kb1a1 b5b4 c3xb4 Rc4c6 Qd6d3 Be6xb3 Qd3xb3 Qf6xh4 Qb3e3 Qh4g3 a2a3 Rc6c2 Rd1d2 Rc2xd2 Qe3xd2 Rc8c4 b4b5 Rc4d4 Qd2c2 Qg3g5 Qc2c5 h5h4 Ka1a2 Rd4d2 Rh1g1 Rd2d7
   10/20/2009 6:59:44 AM, Time for this analysis: 00:09:59, Rated time: 6:00:00

Jouni
Posts: 2393
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:15 pm

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Jouni » Thu Oct 22, 2009 2:54 pm

"I can tune an engine {with an automated procedure} so that it EASILY aces a given test suite, but then it will play games a lot worse."
I think this is not posssible - I am not talking about tactical positions but others = positionally oriented suite of course.

BTW still the best public test suite seems to be Swisstest4! I got correlation
0,90 to real strength (CEGT + CCRL) and linear regression formula:

ELO = 3376 - 6,38 * used time (minutes)

Jouni

Gian-Carlo Pascutto
Posts: 1231
Joined: Sat Dec 13, 2008 6:00 pm
Contact:

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Gian-Carlo Pascutto » Thu Oct 22, 2009 3:20 pm

Jouni wrote:"I can tune an engine {with an automated procedure} so that it EASILY aces a given test suite, but then it will play games a lot worse."
I think this is not posssible
Of course it is possible. There will be a limit depending on the engine, but pretty much any engine can be tuned to score better on a given testset, with the results obviously having no bearing on the real strength.

Dann Corbit
Posts: 12040
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:57 pm
Location: Redmond, WA USA
Contact:

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Dann Corbit » Thu Oct 22, 2009 6:35 pm

Jouni wrote:"I can tune an engine {with an automated procedure} so that it EASILY aces a given test suite, but then it will play games a lot worse."
I think this is not posssible - I am not talking about tactical positions but others = positionally oriented suite of course.

BTW still the best public test suite seems to be Swisstest4! I got correlation
0,90 to real strength (CEGT + CCRL) and linear regression formula:

ELO = 3376 - 6,38 * used time (minutes)

Jouni
I have code that I can attach to any chess engine to do this and I have done it many times.

I just fit a parabolic curve through the data for each paramater that maximizes the score for the test set.

P.S.
Where can I get a copy of swissetest4?

Dann Corbit
Posts: 12040
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:57 pm
Location: Redmond, WA USA
Contact:

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Dann Corbit » Thu Oct 22, 2009 6:39 pm

Three of the positions made a recovery upon deep analysis:

Code: Select all

Analysis from C:\test\mh-tough.epd   
10/21/2009 6:07:40 PM Level: 5000 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Rybka 3

1) h5; id "Michael Hart 
    Searching move: h4-h5
    Best move (Rybka 3): Bf1-b5
    Not found in: 1:23:20
      2	00:09	          87	89.088	+0.54	h4h5
      3	00:09	         105	107.520	+0.54	h4h5
      4	00:09	         123	125.952	+0.54	h4h5
      5	00:09	         196	12.544	+0.35	h4h5 a5a4
      5	00:09	       2.667	85.344	+0.49	Qf4d2 Rb8e8
      6	00:09	       8.476	137.768	+0.50	Qf4d2 Rb8d8 Bf1e2
      7	00:10	      12.458	135.712	+0.51	Qf4d2 Rb8d8 Bf1e2 Ra8c8
      8	00:10	      62.749	178.486	+0.35	Nd4b5 Qc7c6 h4h5 a5a4 Nb5d4 Qc6c7
      9	00:10	      62.763	178.525	+0.35	Nd4b5 Qc7c6 h4h5 a5a4 Nb5d4 Qc6c7
     10	00:10	      87.440	190.913	+0.35	Nd4b5 Qc7c6 Bf1e2 a5a4 Nb5d4 Qc6c7
     11	00:10	     197.256	196.106	+0.49	Nd4b5 Qc7c6 Qf4d2 Ne5f3 Qd2d1 Nf3e5 Nb5d4 Qc6b7
     11+	00:11	     277.179	187.471	+0.55	Qf4d2
     11	00:12	     474.697	197.116	+0.55	Qf4d2 Rb8c8 Bf1b5 Ra8b8 Rh1f1 Qc7b7 Nd4f5 Be7f8 Bb5d3
     12	00:12	     550.377	190.079	+0.58	Qf4d2 Rb8c8 Bf1b5 Ra8b8 Rh1f1 Qc7b7 Nd4f5 Be7f8 Bb5d3
     13	00:15	   1.133.151	198.315	+0.50	Qf4d2 Rb8c8 Bf1b5 Qc7b6 Nd4f5 Be7f8 Bb5e2 Qb6b7
     14	00:21	   2.215.839	192.894	+0.56	Qf4d2 Rb8c8 Bf1b5 Qc7b7 Rh1d1 Be7f8 Bb5a4 Ne5c4 Qd2f4 Qb7c7 Rd5b5
     15	00:29	   3.753.093	196.762	+0.54	Qf4d2 Rb8c8 Bf1b5 Qc7b7 Rh1d1 Be7f8 Bb5a4 Ne5c4 Qd2f4 g7g6 Qf4f2 Qb7e7
     16	00:42	   6.455.910	200.833	+0.55	Qf4d2 a5a4 Nd4b5 Qc7b6
     17	01:05	  11.008.309	204.234	+0.55	Qf4d2 a5a4 Nd4b5 Qc7b6 Qd2xb4 Qb6e3
     18	03:32	  41.177.608	208.380	+0.57	Qf4d2 Qc7c3 Nd4f5 Be7f8 Bf1e2 a5a4 Nf5xd6 Bf8xd6 Rd5xd6 Qc3g3 Rh1d1 g7g6 Qd2d5 a4a3
     18+	04:56	  55.357.510	197.644	+0.75	Bf1b5
     18	07:34	  79.340.332	182.600	+0.81	Bf1b5 a5a4 Qf4d2 Ne5c4 Bb5xc4 Qc7xc4 Qd2d3 Qc4c8 Rh1f1 Rb8b7 Nd4f5 Be7f8 Nf5xd6 Bf8xd6 Rd5xd6 b4b3 c2xb3
     19	09:10	  97.648.668	185.059	+0.81	Bf1b5 a5a4 Qf4d2 Ne5c4 Bb5xc4 Qc7xc4 Qd2d3 Qc4c8 Rh1f1 Be7f8 h4h5 g7g6 Nd4b5 g6xh5 Rd5f5 b4b3 c2c4 b3xa2+ Kb1xa2 Bf8g7 Rf5xf7 Qc8e6 Ka2b1 a4a3
     20	16:38	 180.896.761	187.298	+0.83	Bf1b5 a5a4 Qf4d2 Ne5c4 Bb5xc4 Qc7xc4 Qd2d3 Qc4c8 Rh1f1 Be7f8 h4h5 g7g6 h5xg6 h7xg6 Nd4b5 b4b3 c2xb3 a4xb3 Qd3xb3 Qc8e6 Qb3f3 Rb8xb5 Rd5xb5 Qe6xa2+ Kb1c2 Ra8c8+ Kc2d2 Bf8e7 Qf3b3 Qa2xb3 Rb5xb3
     21	23:48	 263.350.408	190.168	+0.83	Bf1b5 a5a4 Qf4d2 Ne5c4 Bb5xc4 Qc7xc4 Qd2d3 Qc4c8 Rh1f1 Be7f8 h4h5 g7g6 h5xg6 h7xg6 Nd4b5 b4b3 c2xb3 a4xb3 Qd3xb3 Qc8e6 Qb3f3 Rb8xb5 Rd5xb5 Qe6xa2+ Kb1c2 Ra8c8+ Kc2d2 Bf8e7 Qf3b3 Qa2xb3 Rb5xb3
     22	33:54	 396.088.389	200.304	+0.76	Bf1b5 a5a4 Qf4d2 Ne5c4 Bb5xc4 Qc7xc4 Qd2d3 Qc4c8 Rh1f1 Be7f8 h4h5 g7g6 h5xg6 h7xg6 Nd4b5 b4b3 c2xb3 a4xb3 Qd3xb3 Qc8e6 Qb3f3 Rb8xb5 Rd5xb5 Qe6xa2+ Kb1c2 Ra8c8+ Kc2d2 Bf8e7 Qf3b3 Qa2xb3 Rb5xb3
     23	53:37	 654.691.163	209.000	+0.76	Bf1b5 a5a4 Qf4d2 Ne5c4 Bb5xc4 Qc7xc4 Qd2d3 Qc4c8 Rh1f1 Be7f8 h4h5 g7g6 h5xg6 h7xg6 Nd4b5 b4b3 c2xb3 a4xb3 Qd3xb3 Qc8e6 Qb3f3 Rb8xb5 Rd5xb5 Qe6xa2+ Kb1c2 Ra8c8+ Kc2d2 Bf8e7 Qf3b3 Qa2xb3 Rb5xb3
   10/21/2009 7:31:16 PM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:19, Rated time: 1:23:20

2) Qb6; id "Michael Har 
    Searching move: Qd8-b6
    Best move (Rybka 3): Qd8-b6
    identical moves! Found in: 10:56
      2	00:00	         414	13.248	+0.42	Qd8d6
      3	00:00	         777	24.864	+0.37	Qd8d6
      4	00:00	       2.931	62.528	+0.39	Qd8d6
      5	00:00	       3.510	74.880	+0.36	Qd8d6 Qd2f2
      6	00:00	       5.217	111.296	+0.23	Qd8d6 Qd2f2 Nf5d4
      6	00:00	      14.940	139.077	+0.35	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Re8f8
      7	00:00	      22.685	163.587	+0.40	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Re8f8 d5d6 Rc4d4
      8	00:00	      39.773	173.308	+0.29	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Re8f8 d5d6 Rc4d4 Qd2e1
      9	00:00	      79.606	186.110	+0.32	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Rc4d4 Qd2e1 Rd4d3 Bg2f1
     10	00:00	     122.225	181.916	+0.23	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 e5e4 Bg2f1 Rc4d4 Qd2f2 e4e3 Qf2f3
     11	00:03	     624.890	199.031	+0.14	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 e5e4 Bg2f1 e4e3 Qd2d3 Rc4d4 Bg5xe3 Rd4xd3 Be3xb6 Nf5g3+ Kh1g2 Ng3xf1 Kg2xf1 Kg8f7 Bb6xa7 Bg6e4 Kf1e2 Be4f5+ Ke2f2
     12	00:05	   1.042.137	195.412	+0.14	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 e5e4 Bg2f1 e4e3 Qd2d3 Rc4d4 Bg5xe3 Rd4xd3 Be3xb6 Nf5g3+ Kh1g2 Ng3xf1 Kg2xf1 Kg8f7 Bb6xa7 Bg6e4 Kf1e2 Be4f5+ Ke2f2
     13	00:14	   2.758.824	202.540	+0.26	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Rc4d4 Qd2e1 e5e4 Bg2f1 a7a6 Bf1e2 Qb6d6 Be2g4 Re8f8 Rg1g2 Qd6e5
     14	00:16	   3.307.165	203.432	+0.26	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Rc4d4 Qd2e1 e5e4 Bg2f1 a7a6 Bf1e2 Qb6d6 Be2g4 Re8f8 Rg1g2 Qd6e5
     15	00:28	   5.882.596	210.533	+0.30	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Rc4d4 Qd2e1 e5e4 Bg2f1 Kg8g7 Nc3b5 Rd4xd5 Qe1c3+ Kg7h7 Qc3c7+ Qb6xc7 Nb5xc7 Rd5d4 Nc7xe8 Bg6xe8 Bf1g2 Be8c6 Rg1e1 Rd4c4
     16	00:46	   9.213.292	204.238	+0.23	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Rc4d4 Qd2e1 e5e4 Bg2f1 Kg8g7 Bg5f4 a7a6 Bf1e2 Kg7h7 Be2g4 Qb6f6 Qe1e2 e4e3 Bg4h5
     16	03:25	  44.102.251	219.959	+0.32	Qd8d6 Nc3b5 Qd6d7 d5d6
     17	03:47	  48.666.328	219.400	+0.28	Qd8d6 Nc3b5 Qd6d7 d5d6 Kg8h7 Qd2d5 Rc4c6 Qd5f3 Re8f8 Qf3g4 Rc6c2 a2a4 Qd7f7 Rd1d3 Rc2c4 Qg4e2
     18	06:59	  90.651.881	221.452	+0.14	Qd8d6 Nc3b5 Qd6d7 d5d6 Kg8h7 Qd2d5 Rc4c6 Qd5f3 Kh7g7 Kh1g1 a7a6 Nb5c7 Re8c8 Qf3e2 e5e4 Bg5f4 Nf5xd6 Bf4e5+ Kg7g8 Nc7d5 Qd7e6 Nd5f6+ Kg8f8 Qe2e3
     18	10:56	 146.814.777	229.070	+0.27	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Rc4d4
     19	23:26	 328.329.952	239.028	+0.33	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Rc4d4 Qd2f2 e5e4 Bg2f1 e4e3 Qf2f3 Rd4d2 Bg5f4 Kg8h7 Bf1b5 Re8e7 Qf3g4 Qb6f6 Bf4g5 Qf6e5
     20	25:10	 356.171.572	241.506	+0.33	Qd8b6 Rd1g1 Rc4d4 Qd2f2 e5e4 Bg2f1 e4e3 Qf2f3 Rd4d2 Bg5f4 Kg8h7 Bf1b5 Re8e7 Qf3g4 Qb6f6 Bf4g5 Qf6e5
     21	1:05:07	 920.991.784	241.360	+0.31	Qd8b6 Qd2e1 Qb6xb2 d5d6 Qb2xc3 d6d7 Qc3xe1+ Rd1xe1 e5e4 Kh1g1 Nf5g7 d7xe8Q+ Ng7xe8 h3h4 Rc4a4 h4h5 Bg6xh5 Re1xe4 Ra4xe4 Bg2xe4 Ne8d6 Be4h1 Kg8f8 Kg1f2 Bh5f7 a2a3 b7b5 Bg5e3 a7a5
   10/21/2009 8:54:37 PM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:20, Rated time: 1:34:16

3) Nd4; id "Michael Har 
    Searching move: Nc6-d4
    Best move (Rybka 3): Nc6-d4
    identical moves! Found in: 17:26
      2	00:00	         134	137.216	-0.38	Nc6d4
      3	00:00	         202	206.848	-0.49	Nc6d4
      4	00:00	         470	481.280	-0.54	Nc6d4
      4	00:00	         728	745.472	-0.37	g7g6
      5	00:00	         848	868.352	-0.41	g7g6 Bd2c3
      6	00:00	       1.110	1.136.640	-0.42	g7g6 Bd2c3 Be6d5
      7	00:00	       1.829	1.872.896	-0.45	g7g6 Bd2c3 Be6d5 g2g3
      7	00:00	       3.428	206.486	-0.32	Nc6d4 Bc2b1 g7g6 Kf2e3 Nd4b3
      8	00:00	       4.154	250.217	-0.40	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5
      9	00:00	       5.171	311.476	-0.39	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3c2
     10	00:00	      12.838	208.668	-0.37	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3c2 Nc5e4+ Bc2xe4 f5xe4 Kf2e3 Be6d5 Bc3e5
     11	00:00	      15.079	245.093	-0.37	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3c2 Nc5e4+ Bc2xe4 f5xe4 Kf2e3 Be6d5 Bc3e5
     12	00:00	      18.830	202.967	-0.37	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3c2 Nc5e4+ Bc2xe4 f5xe4 Kf2e3 Be6d5 Bc3e5
     13	00:00	      31.577	229.325	-0.37	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3c2 Nc5e4+ Bc2xe4 f5xe4 Kf2e3 Be6d5 Bc3e5
     14	00:00	      53.725	219.180	-0.34	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3c2 Nc5e4+ Bc2xe4 f5xe4 Kf2e3 Be6d5 Bc3e5 g7g6
     15	00:00	      95.008	230.540	-0.36	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3b1 Nc5e4+ Bb1xe4 f5xe4 Kf2e3 Be6d5 h2h3 b7b6 g2g4
     16	00:01	     221.186	216.533	-0.35	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3b1 Nc5e4+ Bb1xe4 f5xe4 Kf2e3 Be6d5 h2h3 b7b6 g2g4 g7g6
     17	00:01	     360.916	211.429	-0.36	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2c3 Nb3c5 Bd3b1 Nc5e4+ Bb1xe4 f5xe4 Kf2e3 Be6d5 h2h3 b7b6 g2g4 g7g6 b2b4
     18	00:03	     709.388	198.094	-0.36	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2b4 g7g6 Kf2e3 Be6d5 Bb4c3 a7a6 g2g3 Kf7e6 Bd3e2 Nb3c1 Be2d1 Nc1b3
     19	00:05	   1.162.596	209.042	-0.36	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2b4 g7g6 Kf2e3 Be6d5 g2g3 Kf7e6 Bb4c3 h6h5 Bd3b5 Bd5c6 Bb5f1 Bc6d5 Bf1e2 a7a6 Be2d1
     20	00:11	   2.301.010	207.159	-0.36	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2b4 g7g6 Kf2e3 Be6d5 g2g3 Kf7e6 Bb4c3 h6h5 Bd3b5 Bd5c6 Bb5f1 Bc6d5 Bf1e2 Bd5c6
     21	00:26	   5.653.762	224.641	-0.36	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2b4 g7g6 Kf2e3 Be6d5 g2g3 Bd5e6 Bb4c3
     21	00:50	  11.970.932	242.742	-0.35	g7g6 g2g3 Be6d5 Kf2e3 Kf7e6
     22	01:12	  17.834.900	251.486	-0.35	g7g6 g2g3 Be6d5 Kf2e3 Kf7e6 Bd2c3 h6h5 Bc2a4 a7a6 Ba4d1 Nc6e7 Ke3d4 Ne7c8 Bc3b4 Nc8b6 a3a4 Nb6c4 Bb4c3 Nc4d6
     23	01:58	  29.146.888	252.835	-0.35	g7g6 g2g3 Be6d5 Kf2e3 Kf7e6 Bd2c3 h6h5 Bc2a4 a7a6 Ba4d1 Nc6e7 Ke3d4 Ne7c8 Bc3b4 Nc8b6 a3a4 Nb6c4 Bb4c3 Nc4d6 Kd4d3 b7b6 Bc3d4
     24	03:05	  45.553.440	251.547	-0.35	g7g6 g2g3 Be6d5 Kf2e3 Kf7e6 Bd2c3 h6h5 Bc2a4 a7a6 Ba4d1 Nc6e7 Ke3d4 Ne7c8 Bc3b4 Nc8d6 Bd1e2 Nd6e4 Be2f1 Ne4f6 a3a4 Nf6g4
     25	05:03	  73.755.047	248.667	-0.35	g7g6 g2g3 Be6d5 Kf2e3 Kf7e6 Bd2c3 h6h5 Bc2a4 a7a6 Ba4d1 Bd5e4 Bd1e2 Be4d5 b2b4 b7b5 Bc3g7 Nc6b8 Bg7d4 Nb8c6
     26	07:56	 114.940.602	247.401	-0.35	g7g6 g2g3 Be6d5 Kf2e3 Kf7e6 Bd2c3 h6h5 Bc2a4 a7a6 Ba4d1 Bd5e4 Bd1e2 Be4d5 b2b4 b7b5 Bc3g7 Nc6b8 Bg7d4 Nb8c6
     27	15:10	 198.348.474	223.047	-0.36	g7g6 Kf2e3 Be6d5 g2g3 Kf7e6 Bd2c3 h6h5 Bc2a4 a7a6 Bc3d4 b7b5 Ba4d1 Bd5g2 Bd4c3 Bg2d5 Bc3d2 Ke6f7 Bd2e1
     27	17:26	 231.034.415	226.083	-0.35	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2b4 g7g6 Kf2e3 Be6d5 g2g3 h6h5 Bd3b5 a7a6 Bb5e2 Kf7e6
     28	20:58	 274.828.282	223.669	-0.35	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2b4 g7g6 Kf2e3 Be6d5 g2g3 h6h5 Bd3b5 a7a6 Bb5e2 Kf7e6
     29	28:43	 370.791.773	220.377	-0.35	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 Nd4b3 Bd2b4 g7g6 Kf2e3 Be6d5 g2g3 h6h5 Bd3b5 a7a6 Bb5e2 Kf7e6
     30	1:04:34	 884.182.857	233.719	-0.36	Nc6d4 Bc2d3 g7g6 Kf2e3 Nd4c6 g2g3 Be6b3 Bd2c3 Kf7e6 Ke3d2 Ke6f7 Bd3f1 a7a6 Bf1g2 Kf7e6 Bc3g7 h6h5 Bg2f1 b7b5
   10/21/2009 10:17:58 PM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:20, Rated time: 1:51:42

4) Rfe8; id "Michael Ha 
    Searching move: Rf8-e8
    Best move (Rybka 3): Kg8-h8
    Not found in: 1:23:20
      2	00:00	         272	17.408	-0.14	Kg8h8
      3	00:00	         540	34.560	-0.28	Kg8h8
      3	00:00	       1.774	113.536	-0.16	f7f5
      4	00:00	       2.049	131.136	-0.30	f7f5
      4	00:00	       2.827	180.928	-0.06	Kg8h8
      5	00:00	       4.076	130.432	-0.01	Kg8h8 Qe4d3
      6	00:00	       4.876	156.032	-0.08	Kg8h8 Qe4d3 Qc3a5
      7	00:00	      11.266	183.117	-0.08	Kg8h8 Rd7d2 f7f5 Qe4e2
      8	00:00	      13.953	180.859	-0.07	Kg8h8 Rd7d2 f7f5 Qe4e2 Rf8e8
      9	00:00	      28.336	205.787	-0.13	Kg8h8 Rd7d5 Rf8e8 Rd5d2 Qc3c5 Rd2c2
      9	00:00	      57.209	207.737	-0.03	Rc8c5 Rd1g1 Kg8h8 Qe4d3 Kh8g8 Qd3f5
     10	00:00	      93.562	218.738	-0.03	Rc8c5 Rd1g1 Kg8h8 Qe4d3 Kh8g8 Qd3f5 Rc5b5
     11	00:01	     273.570	233.057	-0.11	Rc8c5 Rd7d2 Rc5c8 Rd2c2 Qc3a5 Rc2g2 Kg8h8 Rd1d5 Qa5a3 Rg2g1
     11	00:02	     423.891	215.630	-0.03	Rc8c6 Rd7e7 Rf8b8 Qe4d3 Qc3c5 Re7d7 Rc6c7 Rd7d5
     12	00:02	     555.208	219.510	-0.11	Rc8c6 Rd7d8 Rc6c8 Rd8d2 Qc3c7 Rd2e2 f7f6 Re2g2 Qc7a7 Rg2d2
     12	00:02	     584.560	216.723	-0.07	Rc8a8 Rd1c1 Qc3a5
     13	00:03	     789.185	231.223	-0.09	Rc8a8 Rd1c1 Qc3a5 a2a4 Ra8d8 Rc1c7 Rd8xd7 Rc7xd7 Qa5c3 Qe4d3 Qc3c5 Kb1b2 Rf8c8
     14	00:05	   1.283.962	248.587	-0.13	Rc8a8 Rd1c1 Qc3a5 a2a4 Ra8d8 Rc1c7 Rd8xd7 Rc7xd7 Qa5c3 Qe4d3 Qc3c5 Kb1b2 Rf8c8 Qd3d2
     14	00:08	   2.008.554	259.005	-0.11	Kg8h8 Rd7d5 Rc8c5 Rd5d6 Rc5c8 Rd6d2 f7f5
     14	00:08	   2.117.240	255.908	-0.08	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 Qd3f5 Kg8h8 Rd7d6 Qc6c7 Rd6d2 Qc7b7 Kb1b2 Rc8a8
     15	00:09	   2.271.199	258.814	-0.08	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 Qd3f5 Kg8h8 Rd7d6 Qc6c7 Rd6d2 Qc7b7 Kb1b2 Rc8a8
     16	00:11	   3.036.104	264.300	-0.08	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 Qd3f5 Kg8h8 Rd7d6 Qc6c7 Rd6d2 Qc7b7 Kb1b2 Rc8a8
     17	00:15	   3.944.858	258.414	-0.09	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 Qd3f5 Kg8h8 Rd7d6 Qc6c7 Rd6d2 Qc7b7
     18	00:30	   7.499.064	255.576	-0.09	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 Qd3f5 Kg8h8 Rd7d6 Qc6c7 Rd6d2 Qc7b7
     19	00:42	  10.688.894	258.708	-0.09	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 Qd3f5 Kg8h8 Rd7d6 Qc6c7 Rd6d2 Qc7b7 Kb1b2
     20	01:44	  26.142.322	255.812	-0.09	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 a2a4 Rc8b8 Kb1a2
     21	04:10	  60.127.418	246.212	-0.11	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 a2a4 Rc8b8 Kb1a2 e5e4 f3xe4 Re8xe4 Rd7d6 Qc6b7 Rd1d2 Re4e5 Rd6d7 Qb7b6 Rd7d8+ Re5e8 Rd8xe8+ Rb8xe8 Rd2e2 Re8d8 Qd3c3 Qb6b7 a4a5 Rd8a8
     22	09:17	 138.856.770	255.261	-0.11	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Qc3c6 a2a4 Rc8b8 Kb1a2 e5e4 f3xe4 Re8xe4 Rd7d6 Qc6b7 Rd1d2 Re4e5 Rd6d7 Qb7b6 Rd7d8+ Re5e8 Rd8xe8+ Rb8xe8 Rd2e2 Re8d8 Qd3c3 Qb6b7 a4a5 Rd8a8
     23	31:39	 469.176.070	252.967	-0.18	Rf8e8 Qe4d3 Re8f8 Qd3xc3 Rc8xc3 Rd1d3 Rc3xd3 Rd7xd3 g7g6 Rd3d5 f7f6 h5xg6 Kg8g7 a2a4 h6h5 Rd5d2 Rf8b8 Kb1c2 Kg7xg6 Rd2h2 Rb8a8 Kc2c3 Kg6g5 Kc3b4 Ra8b8+ Kb4a3 f6f5
     23	1:07:14	1.015.057.881	257.652	-0.10	Kg8h8 Qe4d3 Qc3c5 Rd7d5 Qc5c7 a2a4 Qc7e7 Kb1b2 Qe7g5 a4a5 Qg5xh5 b3b4 Rc8a8 Kb2b3 Qh5g5 Qd3e2 Rf8e8 Rd5d6 Ra8b8
     24	1:16:27	1.152.257.795	257.210	-0.10	Kg8h8 Qe4d3 Qc3c5 Rd7d5 Qc5e7 Qd3e4 Rf8e8 Qe4f5 Qe7c7
   10/21/2009 11:41:19 PM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:20, Rated time: 3:15:02

5) Rd1; id "Michael Har 
    Searching move: Rd6-d1
    Best move (Rybka 3): Nb3-a5
    Not found in: 1:23:20
      2	00:00	         682	698.368	-1.44	Nc3d1
      2	00:00	         711	728.064	-0.08	Nb3a5
      3	00:00	       1.159	1.186.816	-0.50	Nb3a5
      4	00:00	       2.464	148.419	-0.69	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+
      4	00:00	       2.466	148.540	-0.58	Rd6d3 Rd8xd3
      5	00:00	       2.470	148.781	-0.58	Rd6d3 Rd8xd3
      6	00:00	       8.104	172.885	-0.85	Rd6d3 Rd8xd3 c2xd3 Rf8c8 Nc3d1 Bc6b5
      7	00:00	      14.120	225.920	-0.91	Rd6d3 Rd8xd3 c2xd3 Rf8c8 g2g3 Bc6d7 Nc3e2
      7	00:00	      17.780	191.649	-0.76	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 Rf8c8 Bh5e2 f7f6
      8	00:00	      25.186	204.686	-0.80	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 Rf8c8 Bh5e2 f7f6 e5xf6+ Kg7xf6 Kg1f2 Bc6e4
      9	00:00	      43.675	219.231	-0.80	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 Rf8c8 Bh5e2 f7f6 e5xf6+ Kg7xf6 Kg1f2 Bc6d5 Nd1e3
     10	00:00	      68.589	235.688	-0.84	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 Rf8c8 Bh5e2 f7f6 e5xf6+ Kg7xf6 Kg1f2 Bc6d5 Nd1e3
     11	00:00	     112.812	231.038	-0.79	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 Rf8c8 Bh5e2 Bc6d5 Nd1e3 Bd5xb3 c2xb3 Rc8c5 Kg1f2 Rc5xe5
     12	00:00	     165.375	235.527	-0.91	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 Rf8c8 Bh5e2 Bc6d5 Nd1e3 Bd5xb3 c2xb3 Rc8c5 Kg1f2 Rc5xe5 Ne3c4 Re5c5 a2a4
     13	00:02	     503.515	210.448	-0.76	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 Rf8c8 c2c4 f7f6 e5xf6+ Kg7xf6 Bh5e2 Rc8d8 Kg1f2 f5f4 c4c5 e6e5 Nb3a5
     14	00:03	     596.190	212.569	-0.76	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 Rf8c8 c2c4 f7f6 e5xf6+ Kg7xf6 Bh5e2 Rc8d8 Kg1f2 f5f4 c4c5 e6e5 Nb3a5
     15	00:07	   1.368.132	206.419	-0.91	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 b7b5 Nb3c5 a6a5 Nc5b3 Rf8c8 a2a3 Bc6e4 c2c3 Be4c2
     16	00:12	   2.786.161	226.881	-0.99	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 b7b5 Bh5e2 Rf8c8 Be2d3 Bc6d5 Nd1e3 Bd5xb3 a2xb3 Rc8c5 Kg1f2 Rc5xe5 Kf2f3 a6a5 c2c4 b5xc4 Ne3xc4 Re5d5 Kf3e3 Kg7h6
     17	00:23	   5.359.746	236.425	-1.06	Rd6d1 Rd8xd1+ Nc3xd1 b7b5 Bh5e2 Rf8c8 Be2d3 Bc6d5 Nd1e3 Bd5xb3 a2xb3 Rc8c5 Kg1f2 Rc5xe5 Kf2f3 a6a5 c2c4 b5xc4 Ne3xc4 Re5b5 Bd3c2 Rb5d5 Kf3e3 Kg7f6 g2g3 Kf6g5
     17	00:28	   6.603.874	235.959	-1.03	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6
     18	00:39	   8.891.112	234.000	-0.97	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8d8 Na5xc6 b7xc6 Bh5e2 a6a5 Nc3b1 Rd8xd6 Nb1a3 a5a4 Na3c4 Rd6d5 Kg1f2 Kg7f6 c2c3 e6e5 g2g3 Rd5b5 Be2d1 Rb5c5 Bd1e2 Kf6e6 Kf2f3 Rc5b5
     19	00:49	  11.294.336	236.322	-0.97	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8d8 Na5xc6 b7xc6 Bh5e2 a6a5 Nc3b1 Rd8xd6 Nb1a3 a5a4 Na3c4 Rd6d5 Kg1f2 Kg7f6 c2c3 e6e5 g2g3 Rd5b5 Be2d1 Rb5c5 Bd1e2 Kf6e6 Kf2f3 Rc5b5
     20	01:10	  16.398.438	237.927	-0.96	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8d8 Na5xc6 b7xc6 Bh5e2 a6a5 Nc3b1 Rd8xd6 Nb1a3 a5a4 Kg1f2 Kg7f6 Na3c4 Rd6d5 c2c3 e6e5 g2g3 Rd5b5 Be2d1 Rb5c5 Bd1e2 Rc5d5 Kf2e3
     21	02:01	  28.639.186	242.626	-0.97	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8d8 Na5xc6 b7xc6 Bh5e2 a6a5 Nc3b1 Rd8xd6 Nb1a3 a5a4 Kg1f2 Kg7f6 Na3c4 Rd6d5 c2c3 e6e5 g2g3 Rd5b5 Be2d1 a4a3 Bd1c2 Rb5c5 Bc2b3 Kf6g5 Kf2e2
     22	03:49	  54.622.580	244.339	-0.95	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8d8 Na5xc6 b7xc6 Bh5e2 a6a5 Nc3d1 Rd8xd6 Nd1e3 a5a4 Kg1f2 Kg7f6 Ne3c4 Rd6d5 c2c3 e6e5 g2g3 Rd5b5 Be2d1 a4a3 Bd1c2 Rb5c5 Bc2b3 Kf6g5 h2h4+ Kg5h5 Kf2f3
     23	05:28	  79.687.137	248.465	-0.95	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8d8 Na5xc6 b7xc6 Bh5e2 a6a5 Nc3d1 Rd8xd6 Nd1e3 a5a4 Kg1f2 Kg7f6 Ne3c4 Rd6d5 c2c3 e6e5 g2g3 Rd5b5 Be2d1 a4a3 Bd1c2 Rb5c5 Bc2b3 Kf6g5 h2h4+ Kg5h5 Kf2f3
     24	09:22	 136.728.233	248.867	-0.95	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8d8 Na5xc6 b7xc6 Bh5e2 a6a5 Nc3d1 Rd8xd6 Nd1e3 a5a4 Kg1f2 Kg7f6 Ne3c4 Rd6d5 c2c3 e6e5 g2g3 Rd5b5 Be2d1 a4a3 Bd1c2 Rb5c5 Bc2b3 Kf6g5 h2h4+ Kg5h5 Kf2f3
     25	29:40	 420.756.428	242.003	-0.95	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8c8 Nc3d1 Bc6e8 Na5xb7 Rc8xc2 Nd1e3 Rc2xa2 Ne3c4 Be8b5 Bh5f3 Kg7f6 h2h3
     26	51:01	 744.474.886	249.019	-1.02	Nb3a5 Rd8xd6 e5xd6 Rf8c8 Nc3d1 Bc6e8 Na5xb7 Rc8xc2 Nd1e3 Rc2xa2 Ne3c4 Be8b5 Bh5f3 Kg7f6 h2h3 h7h6 Nc4a5 Ra2c2 Kg1h2 Bb5e8 Na5b3 e6e5 Bf3d5 e5e4 Nb3c5 e4e3 d6d7 Be8xd7 Nc5xd7+ Kf6e7 Nd7e5
   10/22/2009 1:04:40 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:20, Rated time: 4:38:22

6) Rfe1; id "Michael Ha 
    Searching move: Rf1-e1
    Best move (Rybka 3): Rd1-d4
    Not found in: 1:23:20
      2	00:00	         255	261.120	-0.08	Rf1e1
      3	00:00	         507	519.168	-0.06	Rf1e1
      4	00:00	       1.053	63.427	+0.02	Rf1e1
      5	00:00	       1.868	112.519	+0.10	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+
      6	00:00	       4.695	150.240	+0.12	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Rd8e8
      7	00:00	       6.761	216.352	+0.13	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Rd8e8 Ne1d3
      8	00:00	      13.396	173.639	+0.13	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 g7g6 Ne1c2 Rd8c8
      9	00:00	      26.242	189.238	+0.06	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1f3 Kf8e7 g2g3
     10	00:00	      51.938	199.941	+0.04	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1f3 Kf8e7 g2g3 g7g6
     11	00:00	      73.815	201.028	+0.05	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1f3 Kf8e7 g2g3 g7g6 Bb3a2
     12	00:00	     133.869	208.966	+0.06	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1f3 Kf8e7 g2g3 g7g6 Rd1e1+ Ke7f6 Nf3e5
     13	00:01	     199.851	211.412	+0.10	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1f3 Kf8e7 g2g3 g7g6 Rd1e1+ Ke7f6 Nf3e5 a7a5
     14	00:01	     358.992	218.035	+0.09	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1f3 Kf8e7 g2g3 h7h6 Nf3d4 a7a6 Nd4f5+ Ke7f6 Nf5e3
     15	00:03	     735.520	217.428	+0.13	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1f3 Kf8e7 g2g3 g7g6 Rd1e1+ Ke7f6 Nf3e5 h7h6 f2f3 h6h5 f3f4
     16	00:12	   2.682.580	217.099	+0.19	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1c2 Kf8e7 Nc2d4 a7a6 Nd4f5+ Ke7f6 Nf5g3 Kf6e7 f2f3 a6a5 Kg1f2 h7h6 Ng3f5+ Ke7f6 Bb3c2 Bb7c8
     17	00:15	   3.155.790	218.037	+0.16	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1c2 Kf8e7 Nc2d4 a7a6 Nd4f5+ Ke7f6 Nf5g3 Kf6e7 f2f3 Bb7a8 Kg1f2 g7g6 Ng3e4 f7f5 Ne4c5
     18	00:19	   4.187.668	219.366	+0.16	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1c2 Kf8e7 Nc2d4 a7a6 Nd4f5+ Ke7f6 Nf5g3 Kf6e7 f2f3 Bb7a8 Kg1f2 g7g6 Ng3e4 f7f5 Ne4c5
     19	00:28	   5.992.298	219.366	+0.18	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1c2 Kf8e7 Nc2d4 a7a6 Nd4f5+ Ke7f6 Nf5g3 Kf6e7 f2f3 Bb7a8 Kg1f2 g7g6 Ng3e4 f7f5 Ne4c5 a6a5
     20	00:47	  10.002.640	218.273	+0.19	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1c2 Kf8e7 Nc2d4 a7a6 Nd4f5+ Ke7f6 Nf5g3 Kf6e7 f2f3 Rd8d7 Kg1f2 g7g6 Ng3e4 Nd5b6 Rd1xd7+ Nb6xd7 Ne4g5 Nd7e5 Kf2e3 h7h6
     21	02:01	  27.151.634	229.403	+0.17	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1c2 Kf8e7 Nc2d4 a7a6 Nd4f5+ Ke7f6 Nf5g3 Kf6e7 f2f3 Rd8d7 Bb3a2 a6a5 Rd1e1+ Ke7f8 Ng3e4 Nd5f4 Ne4c5 Rd7c7 Nc5xb7 Rc7xb7 Ba2b1 g7g6 g2g3 Nf4e6 Kg1f2 Rb7d7
     22	03:27	  47.887.032	237.034	+0.17	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1c2 Kf8e7 Nc2d4 a7a6 Nd4f5+ Ke7f6 Nf5g3 Kf6e7 f2f3 Rd8d7 Bb3a2 a6a5 Rd1e1+ Ke7f8 Ng3e4 Nd5f4 Ne4c5 Rd7c7 Nc5xb7 Rc7xb7 Ba2b1 g7g6 g2g3 Nf4e6 Kg1f2 Rb7d7
     23	09:16	 127.841.400	235.288	+0.14	Rf1e1 Re8xe1+ Nf3xe1 Kg8f8 Ne1c2 Rd8d7 f2f3 Kf8e7 Kg1f2 g7g6 Nc2e3 Nd5f6 Rd1xd7+ Nf6xd7 Ne3d5+ Bb7xd5 Bb3xd5 Nd7c5 Kf2e3 Nc5e6 Bd5xe6 Ke7xe6 Ke3e4 Ke6d6 g2g4 Kd6e6 Ke4d4 Ke6d6
     23	15:45	 212.815.637	230.475	+0.19	Rd1d4 Nd5f6 Rf1d1 Bb7xf3 Rd4xd8 Bf3xd1 Rd8xd1 g7g6 Kg1f1 Re8e7 f2f3 Re7c7 Kf1f2 Kg8f8 g2g4 Nf6d7 h2h4 Nd7b6 Rd1d2 Kf8e7 Kf2g3
     24	19:04	 253.418.160	226.859	+0.16	Rd1d4 Nd5f6 Rf1d1 Bb7xf3 Rd4xd8 Bf3xd1 Rd8xd1 g7g6 Kg1f1 Re8e7 f2f3 Re7c7 Kf1f2 Kg8f8 g2g4 Nf6d7 h2h4 Nd7b6 Rd1d2 Kf8e7 Rd2d4 Ke7f6 Kf2e3 h7h6 h4h5
     25	25:16	 339.653.220	229.393	+0.16	Rd1d4 Nd5f6 Rf1d1 Bb7xf3 Rd4xd8 Bf3xd1 Rd8xd1 g7g6 Kg1f1 Re8e7 f2f3 Re7c7 Kf1f2 Kg8f8 g2g4 Nf6d7 h2h4 Nd7b6 Rd1d2 Kf8e7 Rd2d4 Ke7f6 Kf2e3 h7h6
     26	42:39	 570.452.464	228.252	+0.17	Rd1d4 Nd5f6 Rf1d1 Bb7xf3 Rd4xd8 Bf3xd1 Rd8xd1 g7g6 Kg1f1 Re8e7 f2f3 Re7c7 Rd1d6 Nf6d7 Rd6d5 Nd7c5 Bb3d1 a7a6 Rd5d6 Rc7d7 Rd6xd7 Nc5xd7 Kf1e2 Kg8g7 Ke2e3 f7f5
   10/22/2009 2:28:01 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:20, Rated time: 6:01:42

7) Qd2; id "Michael Har 
    Searching move: Qe1-d2
    Best move (Rybka 3): Bb2-a1
    Not found in: 1:23:20
      2	00:00	         299	306.176	+0.21	Qe1d2
      2	00:00	         360	368.640	+0.33	Re2d2
      3	00:00	         458	468.992	+0.36	Re2d2
      4	00:00	       1.822	1.865.728	+0.30	Qe1d2
      5	00:00	       2.098	2.148.352	+0.37	Qe1d2 Re8d8
      6	00:00	       3.028	182.392	+0.27	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3
      7	00:00	       4.324	260.457	+0.17	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Ba8c6
      8	00:00	      12.530	203.662	+0.14	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Ba8c6 b3b4 Nc5a4
      9	00:00	      27.384	178.606	+0.26	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Ba8c6 b3b4 Nc5a4 Nc3xa4 Bc6xa4 Rd1c1 Qb8c7
     10	00:00	      53.177	183.344	+0.26	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Ba8c6 b3b4 Nc5a4 Nc3xa4 Bc6xa4 Rd1c1 Qb8c7
     11	00:00	      77.020	180.065	+0.26	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Ba8c6 b3b4 Nc5a4 Nc3xa4 Bc6xa4 Rd1c1 Qb8c7
     12	00:01	     142.005	179.080	+0.22	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Ba8c6 Re2e1 Qb8c7 Kh1g1 Qc7d7 b3b4
     13	00:01	     276.351	183.160	+0.18	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Ba8c6 Re2e1 Qb8c7 Kh1g1 Qc7a7 b3b4 Nc5a4
     14	00:05	     956.162	181.889	+0.10	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Nf6e8 Ne3g4 b6b5 b3b4 Nc5d7
     15	00:16	   3.101.317	198.397	+0.07	Qe1d2 Re8d8 Nc2e3 Nf6e8 Ne3g4 b6b5 c4xb5 a6xb5 Ng4h6+ Bg7xh6 Qd2xh6 b5b4 Nc3d5 Ba8xd5 e4xd5 e6e5 f3f4 f7f6 f4xe5 d6xe5 Bg2h3 Rc8c7 Qh6h4
     15	01:07	  11.977.973	183.655	+0.21	Bb2a1 Nc5d7 Nc2b4 Ba8b7 Re2d2 Bg7f8 Qe1e3 d6d5 a2a3 a6a5 Nb4c2 d5xc4
     16	01:14	  13.301.344	183.654	+0.15	Bb2a1 Nc5d7 Nc2b4 Ba8b7 Re2d2 Re8d8 Qe1e3 Qb8c7 Nb4c2 Nf6e8 Nc2d4 Nd7e5 Bg2h3
     17	01:36	  16.965.017	179.581	+0.20	Bb2a1 Nc5d7 Nc2b4 Ba8b7 Re2d2 Re8d8 Qe1e3 Qb8c7 Nb4c2 Nf6e8 Nc2d4 Nd7e5 Bg2h3 Qc7e7
     18	02:27	  25.195.596	175.586	+0.16	Bb2a1 Nc5d7 Nc2b4 Ba8b7 Re2d2 Re8d8 Qe1e3 Qb8c7 Nb4c2 Nf6e8 Nc2d4 Nd7e5 Bg2h3 Qc7e7 Nc3a4
     19	04:15	  45.526.458	182.663	+0.13	Bb2a1 Nc5d7 Nc2b4 Ba8b7 Re2d2 Re8d8 Qe1e3 Qb8c7 Nb4c2 Nf6e8 Nc2d4 Qc7c5 Kh1g1 Bb7c6
     20	09:16	 103.424.514	190.478	+0.13	Bb2a1 Nc5d7 Qe1d2 Bg7f8 Nc2d4 Qb8c7 Ba1b2 Rc8b8 Kh1g1 Rb8c8 Qd2d3 Rc8b8 Re2f2 Nd7e5 Qd3e3 Bf8g7 Rf2d2
     21	16:14	 182.671.088	192.043	+0.13	Bb2a1 Nc5d7 Qe1d2 Bg7f8 Nc2d4 Qb8c7 Ba1b2 Rc8b8 Kh1g1 Rb8c8 Qd2d3 Rc8b8 Re2e1 Ba8b7 Qd3e3 Rb8d8 Re1e2 Nd7e5
     22	45:13	 525.016.704	198.185	+0.11	Bb2a1 Nc5d7 Qe1d2 Bg7f8 Nc2d4 Qb8c7 Ba1b2 Rc8b8 Kh1g1 Rb8c8 Qd2d3 Rc8b8 Re2e1 Ba8b7 Nd4c2 Nd7e5 Qd3e3 Rb8c8 Rd1d2
   10/22/2009 3:51:22 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:20, Rated time: 7:25:02

8) Nc3; id "Michael Har 
    Searching move: Nb1-c3
    Best move (Rybka 3): Nb1-c3
    identical moves! Found in: 17:06
      2	00:00	         573	586.752	+0.22	Nb1c3
      3	00:00	         736	753.664	+0.23	Nb1c3
      4	00:00	       1.038	1.062.912	+0.26	Nb1c3
      5	00:00	       2.908	175.164	+0.25	Nb1c3 c5xd4
      6	00:00	       4.831	290.996	+0.26	Nb1c3 c5c4 Bh4g3
      7	00:00	       9.017	192.362	+0.19	Nb1c3 a7a6 d4xc5 Rc8xc5 e3e4
      8	00:00	      12.403	198.448	+0.22	Nb1c3 a7a6 d4xc5 Rc8xc5 e3e4 Rf8c8
      9	00:00	      33.267	196.909	+0.27	Nb1c3 c5c4 Bh4g3 a7a6 e3e4 Qb7b6
     10	00:00	      49.466	201.805	+0.24	Nb1c3 c5c4 e3e4 a7a6 Qe2d2 Qb7b6 Bh4f2
     11	00:00	      76.107	191.482	+0.26	Nb1c3 c5c4 e3e4 a7a6 Qe2d2 Rf8d8 d4d5 Qb7b6+ Bh4f2
     12	00:00	     111.301	186.839	+0.26	Nb1c3 c5c4 e3e4 a7a6 Qe2d2 Rf8d8 Rf1e1 Rd8e8 Bh4g3
     13	00:01	     217.767	190.429	+0.24	Nb1c3 c5c4 e3e4 a7a6 Qe2d2 Qb7b6 Bh4f2 Rf8d8 Rf1e1 Qb6b7
     14	00:02	     416.892	192.556	+0.24	Nb1c3 c5c4 e3e4 a7a6 Qe2d2 Qb7b6 Bh4f2 Rf8d8 Rf1e1 Qb6b7 Bf2h4 Rd8e8 Bh4g3 Qb7b6 h2h3
     15	00:03	     675.513	193.543	+0.24	Nb1c3 c5c4 e3e4 a7a6 Qe2d2 Qb7b6 Bh4f2 Rf8d8 Rf1e1 Qb6b7 Bf2h4 Rd8e8 Bh4g3 Qb7b6 h2h3
     16	00:15	   3.091.229	213.792	+0.15	Nb1c3 b5b4 a3xb4 c5xb4 Nc3a4 Qb7c6 Rd1a1 e6e5 Bh4xf6
     16	00:26	   5.214.930	202.299	+0.21	d4xc5 Rc8xc5 Nb1c3
     17	00:52	  10.217.318	201.578	+0.19	d4xc5 Rc8xc5 Nb1c3 a7a5 e3e4 b5b4 a3xb4 a5xb4 Nc3a4 Rc5c7 Bh4f2 Rf8c8 Rd1d2 Nf6h5 g2g3 Nh5f6 Kg1g2
     18	01:05	  13.027.015	204.809	+0.20	d4xc5 Rc8xc5 Nb1c3 a7a5 e3e4 b5b4 a3xb4 a5xb4 Nc3a4 Rc5c7 Bh4f2 Rf8c8 Rd1d2 Nf6h5 g2g3 Nh5f6 Kg1g2 Qb7c6 b2b3
     19	01:52	  23.035.186	209.742	+0.23	d4xc5 Rc8xc5 Nb1c3 a7a5 e3e4 b5b4 a3xb4 a5xb4 Nc3a4 Rc5c7 Bh4f2 Rf8c8 Rd1d2 Nf6h5 g2g3 Nh5f6 Kg1g2 Qb7c6 b2b3 e6e5 Rf1d1 Qc6e6 Qe2d3
     20	04:16	  51.420.399	205.657	+0.26	d4xc5 Rc8xc5 e3e4 Rf8c8 Nb1c3 a7a5 Bh4f2 Rc5c4 Rd1d2 b5b4 a3xb4 a5xb4 Nc3a4 Qb7c7 b2b3 Rc4c1
     21	06:52	  87.659.947	217.980	+0.18	d4xc5 Rc8xc5 e3e4 Rf8c8 Nb1c3 a7a5 Bh4f2 Rc5c4 Rd1d2 Nd7e5 Rf1d1 b5b4 a3xb4 Rc4xb4 Nc3a2 Rb4a4 Na2c1 Ra4a1 Rd2d8+ Rc8xd8 Rd1xd8+ Kg8h7 Rd8d1 Qb7c7 Qe2d2 a5a4
     21	17:06	 203.347.774	202.808	+0.30	Nb1c3 b5b4 a3xb4 c5xb4 Nc3a4 Qb7c6 Rd1a1 e6e5 e3e4 e5xd4 Qe2d2 Qc6b5 Qd2xd4 a7a5 b2b3 Rc8c2 Rf1d1 Rf8c8 Rd1d2 Rc2c1+ Ra1xc1 Rc8xc1+ Rd2d1 Rc1c2
     22	22:19	 260.614.372	199.243	+0.26	Nb1c3 b5b4 a3xb4 c5xb4 Nc3a4 Qb7c6 Rd1a1 Qc6c2 Qe2xc2 Rc8xc2 Bh4xf6 Nd7xf6 Rf1f2 Rc2c7 Na4c5 Rf8c8 Rf2d2 Nf6d7 Nc5d3 b4b3 Rd2d1 Nd7b6 Nd3c5 Nb6c4 Rd1d3 e6e5 Ra1c1 Nc4xb2 Rd3xb3 Nb2a4 Rb3b5
     23	27:58	 323.487.192	197.425	+0.26	Nb1c3 b5b4 a3xb4 c5xb4 Nc3a4 Qb7c6 Rd1a1 Qc6c2 Qe2xc2 Rc8xc2 Bh4xf6 Nd7xf6 Rf1f2 Rc2c7 Na4c5 Rf8c8 Rf2d2 Nf6d7 Nc5d3 b4b3 Rd2d1 Nd7b6 Nd3c5 Nb6c4 Rd1d3 e6e5 Ra1c1 Nc4xb2 Rd3xb3 Nb2a4 Rb3b5
     24	1:00:55	 741.337.424	207.652	+0.26	Nb1c3 b5b4 a3xb4 c5xb4 Nc3a4 Qb7c6 b2b3 Qc6c2 Qe2xc2 Rc8xc2 Rd1c1 Rf8c8 Na4c5 Rc2xc1 Rf1xc1 Nf6d5 Bh4e1 a7a5 Kg1f2 Nd7xc5 d4xc5 Kg8f8 Be1d2 Nd5e7 Kf2e2 Kf8e8 e3e4 Ne7c6 Bd2e3
   10/22/2009 5:14:41 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:19, Rated time: 7:42:08

9) Qg7; id "Michael Har 
    Searching move: Qf7-g7
    Best move (Rybka 3): g6xf5
    Not found in: 1:23:20
      2	00:00	         486	497.664	-0.37	Nf6d5
      2	00:00	         882	903.168	-0.21	Qf7a2
      3	00:00	       1.546	1.583.104	-0.32	Nf6d5
      3	00:00	       1.903	1.948.672	-0.18	Nf6e4
      4	00:00	       2.140	2.191.360	-0.22	Nf6e4
      4	00:00	       3.317	199.800	-0.13	Rf8g8
      5	00:00	       6.174	197.568	-0.12	Nf6e4 Qg3e5+
      6	00:00	       9.181	195.861	-0.28	Nf6e4 Qg3e5+ Ne4f6 Rc1f1
      7	00:00	      20.016	215.751	-0.20	Nf6e4 Qg3e5+ Ne4f6 Rc1f1 Rd6d5 Qe5c7
      8	00:00	      55.301	212.888	-0.34	Nf6e4 Qg3e5+ Ne4f6 Rc1f1 Rd6d5 Qe5c7 Rd5b5
      8	00:01	     165.895	213.144	-0.33	g6xf5
      8	00:01	     184.328	212.080	-0.17	Qf7g7
      9	00:01	     199.233	214.076	-0.17	Qf7g7 Qg3g5 Nf6d5 Rc1f1 Rf8g8
     10	00:01	     350.924	217.127	-0.20	Qf7g7 Kh2h1 Nf6h5 Qg3h2 Nh5f6 Qh2e5 Nf6h5
     11	00:02	     433.996	217.316	-0.20	Qf7g7 Kh2h1 Nf6h5 Qg3h2 Nh5f6 Qh2e5 Nf6h5 Qe5e4
     12	00:03	     599.498	218.542	-0.18	Qf7g7 Kh2h1 Nf6h5 Qg3h2 Nh5f6 f5xg6 h7xg6 Rc1f1 Nf6d5 Rf1xf8+ Qg7xf8 Qh2e5+
     13	00:04	     936.828	220.379	-0.17	Qf7g7 Kh2h1 Nf6h5 Qg3h2 Nh5f6 f5xg6 h7xg6 Rc1f1 Nf6d5 Rf1xf8+ Qg7xf8 Qh2e5+ Kh8h7 Rg1g3 Rd6f6
     14	00:10	   2.092.232	217.971	-0.18	Qf7g7 Kh2h1 Nf6h5 Qg3h2 Nh5f6 f5xg6 h7xg6 Rc1f1 Nf6d5 Rf1xf8+ Qg7xf8 Qh2e5+ Kh8h7 Rg1g3 Rd6f6
     14	00:13	   2.958.516	229.526	-0.06	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5
     15	00:20	   4.721.981	234.986	-0.09	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Rg1g2 e7e5
     16	00:41	   9.210.779	229.966	-0.10	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Rf1f3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 Kh2h3 c6c5 Rg1g5 b7b6 Bf5c2 Re5e6 Bc2b3 Re6e8
     17	00:50	  11.391.488	229.786	-0.10	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Rf1f3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 Kh2h3 c6c5 Rg1g5 b7b6 Bf5c2 Re5e6 Bc2b3 Re6e8
     18	01:30	  20.575.964	233.869	-0.07	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Rf1f3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 b2b4 Rd6d8 Bf5b1 Re5e6 Kh2h3 Rd8e8 e3e4 Nf6xe4 Rf3f7 Re8b8
     19	02:38	  36.154.274	233.695	-0.10	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Rf1f3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 Kh2h3 c6c5 Bf5b1 Rd6e6 e3e4 c5c4 a3a4 a7a6 b2b3 c4xb3 Rf3xb3 b7b6 Rb3f3 h7h5
     20	05:17	  72.127.423	232.480	-0.09	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Kh2g3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 e3e4 Rd6d2 Rf1d1 Nf6xe4+ Bf5xe4 Rd2xd1 Rg1xd1 Re5xe4 Rd1d8+ Kh8g7 Rd8d7+ Kg7g6 Rd7xb7 a7a5 Rb7b6 Re4c4 b2b3 Rc4c2
     21	08:52	 120.225.943	231.400	-0.09	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Kh2g3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 e3e4 Rd6d2 Rf1d1 Nf6xe4+ Bf5xe4 Rd2xd1 Rg1xd1 Re5xe4 Rd1d8+ Kh8g7 Rd8d7+ Kg7g6 Rd7xb7 a7a5 Rb7b6 Re4c4 b2b3 Rc4c5
     22	16:06	 218.983.023	232.021	-0.09	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Kh2g3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 e3e4 Rd6d2 Rf1d1 Nf6xe4+ Bf5xe4 Rd2xd1 Rg1xd1 Re5xe4 Rd1d8+ Kh8g7 Rd8d7+ Kg7g6 Rd7xb7 a7a5 Rb7b6 Re4c4 b2b3 Rc4c5
     23	24:37	 325.641.681	225.775	-0.09	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Kh2g3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 e3e4 Rd6d2 Rf1d1 Nf6xe4+ Bf5xe4 Rd2xd1 Rg1xd1 Re5xe4 Rd1d8+ Kh8g7 Rd8d7+ Kg7g6 Rd7xb7 a7a5 Rb7b6 Re4c4 b2b3 Rc4c5
     24	46:40	 617.789.384	225.890	-0.09	g6xf5 Bh3xf5 Nf6h5 Qg3e5+ Qf7f6 Qe5xf6+ Nh5xf6 Rc1f1 Rf8e8 Kh2g3 e7e5 d4xe5 Re8xe5 e3e4 Rd6d2 Rf1d1 Nf6xe4+ Bf5xe4 Rd2xd1 Rg1xd1 Re5xe4 Rd1d8+ Kh8g7 Rd8d7+ Kg7g6 Rd7xb7 a7a5 Rb7b6 Re4c4 b2b3 Rc4c5
   10/22/2009 6:38:02 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:19, Rated time: 9:05:28

10) c4; id "Michael Har 
    Searching move: c5-c4
    Best move (Rybka 3): Kg8-h7
    Not found in: 1:23:20
      2	00:00	         479	490.496	+0.11	c5c4
      2	00:00	         597	611.328	+0.52	Nc6e7
      3	00:00	         745	762.880	+0.58	Nc6e7
      4	00:00	       1.223	1.252.352	+0.35	Nc6e7
      5	00:00	       1.718	103.484	+0.30	Nc6e7 Bc3e1
      6	00:00	       4.472	269.372	+0.27	Nc6e7 Bc3e1 Rd8d4 Ne4xc5
      7	00:00	       7.984	170.325	+0.25	Nc6e7 Bc3e1 Rd8d4 Ne4xc5 Rd4xf4+ Kf2g1 Na4xc5
      7	00:00	      14.439	187.158	+0.30	Nc6d4 Bc3xd4 Rd8xd4 Ne4xc5 Na4xc5 Rc1xc5 Rd4xf4+ Kf2e1 Kg8h7
      8	00:00	      17.539	189.051	+0.26	Nc6d4 Bc3xd4 Rd8xd4 Ne4xc5 Na4xc5 Rc1xc5 Rd4xf4+ Kf2e1 Kg8h7 Rc5c7 Kh7g6
      9	00:00	      27.243	197.849	+0.35	Nc6d4 Bc3xd4 Rd8xd4 Ne4xc5 Na4xc5 Rc1xc5 Rd4xf4+ Kf2e1 Kg8h7 Rc5c6 Rf4d4 Rc6c7
      9+	00:00	      46.169	215.876	+0.46	c5c4
      9+	00:00	      53.230	217.161	+0.66	c5c4
      9	00:00	      54.661	222.999	+0.64	c5c4 Re2e3 Nc6e7 Re3xd3 Rd8xd3 Rc1b1 Ne7d5
     10	00:00	     103.634	212.242	+0.64	c5c4 Kf2e1 Nc6e7 Re2d2 Rd3e3+ Ke1f2 Rd8d3 Rd2xd3
     11	00:01	     173.575	206.915	+0.80	c5c4 Rc1b1 Na4xc3 Ne4xc3 Nc6d4 Re2e3 Rd3d2+ Kf2g1 Nd4f5 Re3e2 Rd2xe2 Nc3xe2 Rd8d2
     12	00:01	     327.028	198.621	+0.67	c5c4 Re2e3 Rd3xe3 Kf2xe3 Nc6e7 Ne4d6 Ne7f5+ Ke3e4 Nf5xd6+ e5xd6 Na4xc3+ Rc1xc3 Rd8xd6 Ke4e3 Rd6d1
     13	00:03	     552.691	180.413	+0.51	c5c4 Ne4d6 Na4xc3 Rc1xc3 Rd3xc3 b2xc3 Rd8a8 Kf2e3 Ra8a4 Re2b2 Nc6a5 Nd6b5 Kg8h7 g2g3 Na5c6 Nb5d6 Kh7g6
     14	00:04	     799.198	184.693	+0.56	c5c4 Ne4d6 Na4xc3 Rc1xc3 Rd3xc3 b2xc3 Rd8a8 Kf2e3 Ra8a4 Re2b2 g7g5 g2g3 Kg8g7 Ke3e4 g5xf4 g3xf4 Nc6a5 Nd6b5 Kg7g6
     15	00:06	   1.176.826	187.471	+0.55	c5c4 Ne4d6 Na4xc3 Rc1xc3 Rd3xc3 b2xc3 Rd8a8 Kf2e3 Ra8a4 Re2b2 g7g5 g2g3 Kg8g7 h2h3 Kg7g6 Ke3f3 g5xf4 g3xf4 Kg6g7
     15+	00:15	   3.126.263	206.229	+0.76	Kg8h7
     15	00:28	   5.688.092	205.026	+0.74	Kg8h7 g2g3 c5c4 Kf2f1 Kh7g6 Kf1e1 Nc6d4 Bc3xd4 Rd8xd4 Ne4f2 Rd3f3 Rc1d1 Rd4xd1+ Nf2xd1 h6h5 Re2d2 c4c3 b2xc3 Na4xc3 a3a4 Nc3xd1 Ke1xd1 Rf3f1+ Kd1e2 Rf1a1
     16	00:29	   5.828.319	206.340	+0.74	Kg8h7 g2g3 c5c4 Kf2f1 Kh7g6 Kf1e1 Nc6d4 Bc3xd4 Rd8xd4 Ne4f2 Rd3f3 Rc1d1 Rd4xd1+ Nf2xd1 h6h5 Re2d2 c4c3 b2xc3 Na4xc3 a3a4 Nc3xd1 Ke1xd1 Rf3f1+ Kd1e2 Rf1a1
     17	01:50	  24.029.254	222.841	+0.87	Kg8h7 h2h3 Kh7g6 Kf2e1 c5c4 Ne4d6 Na4xc3 Rc1xc3 Rd3xc3 b2xc3 Rd8a8 Nd6xc4 Ra8a4 Nc4d6 Ra4xf4 Re2b2 Nc6a5 c3c4 Na5xc4 Nd6xc4 Rf4xc4 Rb2xb3 Rc4e4+ Ke1f2 Re4xe5 a3a4 Re5a5 Rb3g3+ Kg6f6 Rg3g4 g7g5
     18	02:13	  29.244.489	225.491	+0.87	Kg8h7 h2h3 Kh7g6 Kf2e1 c5c4 Ne4d6 Na4xc3 Rc1xc3 Rd3xc3 b2xc3 Rd8a8 Nd6xc4 Ra8a4 Nc4d6 Ra4xf4 Re2b2 Nc6a5 c3c4 Na5xc4 Nd6xc4 Rf4xc4 Rb2xb3 Rc4e4+ Ke1d2 Re4xe5 Rb3g3+ Kg6f6 a3a4 Re5a5 Rg3g4 g7g5
     19	03:04	  41.032.449	227.404	+0.87	Kg8h7 h2h3 Kh7g6 Kf2e1 c5c4 Ne4d6 Na4xc3 Rc1xc3 Rd3xc3 b2xc3 Rd8a8 Nd6xc4 Ra8a4 Nc4d6 Ra4xf4 Re2b2 Nc6a5 c3c4 Na5xc4 Nd6xc4 Rf4xc4 Rb2xb3 Rc4e4+ Ke1d2 Re4xe5 Rb3g3+ Kg6f6 a3a4 Re5a5 Rg3g4 g7g5
     20	10:47	 141.490.388	223.703	+0.81	Kg8h7 Bc3e1 Nc6d4 Ne4xc5
     21	12:52	 168.279.434	223.254	+0.81	Kg8h7 Bc3e1 Nc6d4 Re2d2 Nd4c2 Ne4d6 Rd3xd2+ Be1xd2 Na4xb2 Rc1b1 Nb2d3+ Kf2e2 c5c4 Nd6xc4 Nd3c5 Bd2c3 Nc2d4+ Bc3xd4 Rd8xd4 Nc4d2 Rd4xf4 Nd2xb3 Rf4e4+ Ke2f3 Re4xe5 Nb3xc5 Re5xc5 a3a4 Rc5a5 Rb1b4 Kh7g6
     22	22:50	 304.252.027	227.354	+0.86	Kg8h7 Bc3e1 Nc6d4 Re2d2 Nd4c2 Ne4d6 Rd3xd2+ Be1xd2 Na4xb2 Rc1b1 Nb2d3+ Kf2e2 c5c4 Nd6xc4 Nd3c5 Bd2c3 Kh7g6 Nc4d6 Rd8b8 Bc3b2 Nc5a4 Ke2d3 f7f5 e5xf6/ep Rb8d8 f6xg7 Na4xb2+ Rb1xb2 Rd8xd6+ Kd3c4 Kg6xg7
     23	36:47	 497.827.916	230.952	+0.86	Kg8h7 Bc3e1 Nc6d4 Re2d2 Nd4c2 Ne4d6 Rd3xd2+ Be1xd2 Na4xb2 Rc1b1 Nb2d3+ Kf2e2 c5c4 Nd6xc4 Nd3c5 Bd2c3 Kh7g6 Nc4d6 Rd8b8 Bc3b2 Nc5a4 Ke2d3 f7f5 e5xf6/ep Rb8d8 f6xg7 Na4xb2+ Rb1xb2 Rd8xd6+ Kd3c4 Kg6xg7
   10/22/2009 8:01:22 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:23:19, Rated time: 10:28:48

3 of 10 matching moves
10/22/2009 8:01:23 AM, Total time: 1:53:42 PM
Rated time: 10:28:48 = 37728 Seconds

Paloma
Posts: 1010
Joined: Thu Dec 25, 2008 8:07 pm

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Paloma » Thu Oct 22, 2009 6:53 pm

Hi Dann,

from Walter Eigenmann, see here:
http://glareanverlag.wordpress.com/2008 ... uehrungen/

have fun with it.

Dann Corbit
Posts: 12040
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:57 pm
Location: Redmond, WA USA
Contact:

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Dann Corbit » Thu Oct 22, 2009 7:13 pm

Paloma wrote:Hi Dann,

from Walter Eigenmann, see here:
http://glareanverlag.wordpress.com/2008 ... uehrungen/

have fun with it.
RapidShare is becoming more and more of a joke.

Now, frequently, it makes me wait for 100 seconds, and I often get this:

"Error
You want to download the following file:
http://rapidshare.com/files/135681872/S ... enmann.zip | 40 KB

We regret that currently we have no available slots for free users. Unfortunately you will have to wait 2 minutes, this will allow us to continue to provide our service to our Premium users. Afterwards it will be checked again if you can access the file. If you do not want to wait that long, become Premium member

Please note, the server is not going to check again within the next 2 minutes if downloading is possible again. To provide a fair platform, all user get the same options."

Paloma
Posts: 1010
Joined: Thu Dec 25, 2008 8:07 pm

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Paloma » Thu Oct 22, 2009 7:45 pm

I try it, here works. PM me, and i will send you the suite.

Dann Corbit
Posts: 12040
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:57 pm
Location: Redmond, WA USA
Contact:

Re: new epd test suite

Post by Dann Corbit » Thu Oct 22, 2009 7:52 pm

Paloma wrote:I try it, here works. PM me, and i will send you the suite.
Thanks. Eventually, I managed to collect it.

Post Reply