Page 11 of 12
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Sun Nov 26, 2017 10:37 am
by Guenther
Formatted table as real data. (pics vanish and cannot be used for anything)
CCRL 40/40 Rating List - Custom engine selection (November 18, 2017)
Code: Select all
Name Rating Err1 Err2 Score AvgOpp. Draws Games
Andscacs 0.921 64-bit 4CPU 3274 +67 -71 26.6% +138.8 50.0% 64
Andscacs 0.91 64-bit 4CPU 3239 +22 -22 42.5% +47.6 59.2% 596
Andscacs 0.89 64-bit 4CPU 3232 +21 -21 45.9% +28.8 55.0% 662
Andscacs 0.88 64-bit 4CPU 3228 +37 -37 33.2% +100.4 53.5% 217
Andscacs 0.90 64-bit 4CPU 3216 +24 -24 50.3% +1.9 55.1% 515
Andscacs 0.872 64-bit 4CPU 3209 +24 -24 51.3% -5.0 58.8% 476
Andscacs 0.92 64-bit 3161 +15 -15 53.1% -15.7 52.6% 1344
Andscacs 0.86 64-bit 4CPU 3154 +22 -22 40.0% +64.1 54.6% 639
Andscacs 0.85 64-bit 4CPU 3142 +25 -25 43.9% +42.7 53.1% 467
Andscacs 0.91 64-bit 3140 +16 -16 44.0% +37.7 56.4% 1189
Andscacs 0.921 64-bit 3138 +31 -31 42.7% +49.4 50.2% 307
Andscacs 0.90 64-bit 3127 +17 -17 48.4% +13.0 53.8% 1048
Andscacs 0.89 64-bit 3119 +17 -17 43.4% +44.2 54.4% 1029
Andscacs 0.88 64-bit 3114 +15 -15 43.6% +41.4 54.1% 1266
Andscacs 0.83 64-bit 4CPU 3113 +29 -29 46.6% +18.5 51.2% 338
Andscacs 0.872 64-bit 3107 +14 -14 43.8% +41.1 52.1% 1603
Andscacs 0.82 64-bit 4CPU 3090 +29 -29 50.6% -3.2 55.2% 330
Andscacs 0.86 64-bit 3090 +21 -21 44.7% +34.9 51.3% 678
Andscacs 0.81 64-bit 4CPU 3085 +31 -32 48.7% +5.3 49.3% 300
Andscacs 0.85 64-bit 3061 +18 -18 44.9% +33.6 48.3% 918
Andscacs 0.84 64-bit 3041 +26 -26 45.1% +32.3 46.8% 470
Andscacs 0.80 64-bit 4CPU 3030 +31 -31 50.2% -1.1 46.7% 317
Andscacs 0.83 64-bit 3014 +30 -30 47.5% +14.7 50.8% 317
Andscacs 0.82 64-bit 3010 +24 -24 47.8% +12.4 50.1% 509
Andscacs 0.81 64-bit 3003 +26 -26 55.1% -31.5 47.3% 442
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Sun Nov 26, 2017 12:51 pm
by tpoppins
Günther, the point of my post was the color -- something your carefully formatted text table fails to convey. ;)
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Sun Nov 26, 2017 2:28 pm
by kasinp
tpoppins wrote:Günther, the point of my post was the color -- something your carefully formatted text table fails to convey.
Here is what I see:
a) 4-CPU direct comparison between 0.921 and 0.92 is not available (ver. 0.92 not having been tested with 4CPUs)
b) However, a comparison between single CPU performance indicates that ver. 0.921 (based on some 300 games) is 23 ELO *below* that of 0.92.
c) Therefore the fact that 0.921 is leading the charts for 4CPUs is misleading, and probably only because 0.92 was not tested with 4CPUs.
This would support the hypothesis that 0.921 may have have introduced an issue, irrespective of the illegal move played in one of the TCEC games.
PK
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Sun Nov 26, 2017 3:07 pm
by cdani
kasinp wrote:... irrespective of the illegal move played in one of the TCEC games.
The bug of the illegal move was there from very old versions. Only that seems that a lot of cores and bad luck are necessary to manifest it.
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Sun Nov 26, 2017 3:25 pm
by kasinp
cdani wrote:kasinp wrote:... irrespective of the illegal move played in one of the TCEC games.
The bug of the illegal move was there from very old versions. Only that seems that a lot of cores and bad luck are necessary to manifest it.
Got it, thank you for the clarification. I suppose this still leaves the question of a direct comparison between 0.92 and 0.921, for which I suppose 300+ games is probably still a small sample size.
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Sun Nov 26, 2017 5:53 pm
by Guenther
tpoppins wrote:Guenther, the point of my post was the color -- something your carefully formatted text table fails to convey. ;)
Sorry, Thomas :)
A pity that <code> doesn't allow color too.
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Mon Nov 27, 2017 2:57 pm
by Scally
Hi,
Has anyone managed to compile Andscacs for Linux on the RaspBerry Pi. I keep getting missing file for Windows.h?
Thanks,
Al.
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Mon Nov 27, 2017 3:07 pm
by cdani
Scally wrote:
Has anyone managed to compile Andscacs for Linux on the RaspBerry Pi. I keep getting missing file for Windows.h?
In debug.h change:
//#define WINDOWS <--comment this one
#define LINUX <-- activate this one
Then change the sleep as told previously in this trhead, as is waking up threads too often in linux.
Anyway no idea if it will compile for raspberry pi.
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Mon Nov 27, 2017 3:49 pm
by Scally
Hi Daniel,
I had read the thread several times, but I’m used to commenting out in Linux using the # key, not //, so removed the # in front of the ‘#define LINUX’ instead.
The compile gets further now, but I’ve still a bit to sort out for the RPi.
Thanks,
Al.
Re: Andscacs - New version 0.921 with source
Posted: Mon Nov 27, 2017 4:33 pm
by cdani
The # in C is not a comment, is a required part of the syntax. When I told uncomment I mean leaving like
#define LINUX
thus removing the final n that I have put in the line.