I don't know what the hell is going on with the amount of nodes, if it's the fault of the engine or Arena, but not mine.Laskos wrote: ↑Thu Sep 13, 2018 10:01 am
Wow, that's VERY interesting! So, you get about equal results against SF8 on 4 cores from positions used in AlphaZero paper, and +0 -9 =11 result, or some -170 Elo points from my 3-mover balanced positions? My positions are balanced and collected from GM and IM human games, so they are not some nutty positions from random 2-mover openings of SF framework. I have about 900 3-mover positions in my suite, and I am quite sure it's a good set to test on. The conclusion would be: AlphaZero team choose on purpose openings suitable to AlphaZero to boost significantly the performance, by more than 100 Elo points. That's remarkable, as I didn't expect some regular 3-movers to change dramatically the result. One has to play diverse openings, because, first, other engines might not reply the way Lc0 plays, second, other engines might use a book. In fact CCCC results, which show, like me, Lc0 the level of Fire 7.1, from initial standard opening position, show that other engines do not play the openings as Lc0 would like them to play.
But anyway, I don't understand the total nodes issue, the depth issue (this is not only about initial depth, but the depths reached after say 10s), NPS issue. Your NPS seem very stable from the beginning, I even saw peaks in NPS at 1-2s in a Youtube video, larger than after 10s, while my NPS are increasing slowly, being almost twice higher after 10s search than after less than 1s search. Hash issue as observed by Milos seemed quite plausible to me.
Interesting, and my advice would be to not use AlphaZero openings, they seem to be chosen not quite fairly against SF8.
"Hash issue as observed by Milos seemed quite plausible to me." I have shown that repeating the games doesn't help much lc0, as accidentaly has happened in my last test. You can see from the above score
Lc01711261 - Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2 : 5,5/20 0-9-11 (=0 0= =0 =0 =0 == 00 =0 == 0=) 28%
Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2 - Lc01711261 : 14,5/20 9-0-11 (=1 1= =1 =1 =1 == 11 =1 == 1=) 73%
First two games Lc0 0.5-Sto8 1.5, were replayed in games 3-4 with the same result Lc0 0.5-Sto8 1.5, but different colours,
Games 5-6, Lc0 0.5-Sto8 1.5, replayed in games 7-8 with the same result Lc0 0.5-Sto8 1.5and colours,
Games 9-10, Lc0 0.5-Sto8 1.5, replayed in games 11-12 Lc0 1-Sto8 1, here lc0 improves,
Games 13-14, Lc0 0-Sto8 2, replayed in games 15-16 Lc0 0.5-Sto8 1.5, here lc0 improves,
Games 17-18, Lc0 1-Sto8 1, replayed in games 19-20 Lc0 0.5-Sto8 1.5, here Stockfish8 improves.
"The conclusion would be: AlphaZero team choose on purpose openings suitable to AlphaZero to boost significantly the performance, by more than 100 Elo points."
No, the conclusion is that some initial positions lead more probably than others to tactical play, where lc0 fails. Until now, we don't know about the tactical abilities of AlphaZero. We must see the complete 100 games and the 1200 with the other initial positions. These 12 initial positions were chosen because they were the most played, as they said in their paper:
"12 most popular human openings (played more than 100,000 times in an online database)"
From my experience with lc0, if you put complicated tactical initial positions the better Stochfish scores, if you put starting position or quiet positional position the better lc0 scores.
leela is official(?) better than sf9??
Positionally probably, tactically of course not and globally either.
But it is very interesting to see how with its low NPS, lc0 is able to stop Stockfish deep search in some games.
Recommendation for immature Stockfish fanboys, they just have to look for balanced positions with a lot of tactic so that Stockfish scores much more than lc0, even 100% I can assure.
Now I am testing lc011261 against Stockfish 8, same conditions as before, starting from the 10 Nunn positions
After 12 games of the 20, the score is
Engine Score Lc
1: Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2 8,0/12 ===1==1101=1
2: Lc01711261 4,0/12 ············
You can see some games at youtube:
https://youtu.be/3fogVPj0RRk
https://youtu.be/Fh-QF07oiXQ
[pgn][Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "1"] [White "Lc01711261"] [Black "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Result "*"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "B33"] [Opening "Sicilian"] [Time "09:05:00"] [Variation "Pelikan, Sveshnikov, 11.c3 Bg7 12.exf5 Bxf5"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "unterminated"] [PlyCount "91"] 1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 e6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 Nc6 5. Nb5 Nf6 6. N1c3 d6 7. Bf4 e5 8. Bg5 a6 9. Na3 b5 10. Bxf6 gxf6 11. Nd5 f5 12. c3 Bg7 13. exf5 Bxf5 14. Nc2 { +0.20/10 12} Be6 { -0.46/28 22} 15. g3 { +0.32/10 16} O-O { -0.36/23 9} 16. Bg2 { +0.34/10 7} Rb8 { -0.43/26 19} 17. O-O { +0.39/9 16} a5 { -0.23/25 19} 18. Qh5 { +0.33/10 22} f5 { -0.26/22 1} 19. Rad1 { +0.25/10 26} b4 { -0.26/26 22} 20. Nce3 { +0.19/10 21} Ne7 { -0.27/26 15} 21. Qg5 { +0.64/10 20} Nxd5 { -0.19/26 6} 22. Qxd8 { +0.67/14 9} Rbxd8 { -0.18/27 4} 23. Bxd5 { +0.59/15 5} Bxd5 { -0.17/30 8} 24. Rxd5 { +0.57/15 3} bxc3 { -0.17/29 11} 25. bxc3 { +0.56/13 2} Rc8 { -0.20/28 2} 26. Rxd6 { +0.48/11 10} Rxc3 { 0.00/28 11} 27. Nd5 { +0.47/11 4} Rc2 { 0.00/31 9} 28. a4 { +0.42/11 18} Ra2 { 0.00/32 9} 29. Rc1 { +0.29/12 14} f4 { 0.00/31 8} 30. Nc3 { +0.22/13 13} Rb2 { 0.00/32 5} 31. Ne4 { +0.25/14 4} Rb4 { 0.00/30 14} 32. Ng5 { +0.25/14 3} fxg3 { 0.00/30 8} 33. hxg3 { +0.59/9 9} Rxa4 { +0.05/28 2} 34. Ra6 { +0.43/11 9} h6 { 0.00/32 9} 35. Ne6 { +0.46/9 9} Rf7 { 0.00/33 2} 36. Rc2 { +0.57/8 9} Ra1+ { 0.00/34 10} 37. Kg2 { +0.54/8 11} a4 { 0.00/35 10} 38. Re2 { +0.41/8 17} a3 { 0.00/34 7} 39. Nxg7 { +0.30/9 17} Kxg7 { 0.00/35 2} 40. Ra5 { +0.27/8 15} Rf5 { 0.00/34 7} 41. Raxe5 { +0.53/9 9} Rxe5 { 0.00/41 7} 42. Rxe5 { +0.52/9 4} a2 { 0.00/56 7} 43. Ra5 { +0.55/9 6} h5 { 0.00/57 3} 44. Ra6 { +0.47/10 9} Kf7 { 0.00/67 7} 45. Kf3 { +0.41/10 5} Ke7 { 0.00/64 7} 46. Kf4 { +0.27/10 10} * [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "1"] [White "Lc01711261"] [Black "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "B33"] [Opening "Sicilian"] [Time "09:20:46"] [Variation "Pelikan, Sveshnikov, 11.c3 Bg7 12.exf5 Bxf5"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "normal"] [PlyCount "170"] 1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 e6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 Nc6 5. Nb5 Nf6 6. N1c3 d6 7. Bf4 e5 8. Bg5 a6 9. Na3 b5 10. Bxf6 gxf6 11. Nd5 f5 12. c3 Bg7 13. exf5 Bxf5 14. Nc2 { +0.20/10 13} Be6 { -0.37/28 24} 15. g3 { +0.31/10 14} Rb8 { -0.33/27 9} 16. Bg2 { +0.39/9 18} O-O { -0.33/25 3} 17. O-O { +0.39/10 12} a5 { -0.33/26 18} 18. Qh5 { +0.33/10 23} Kh8 { -0.28/28 80} 19. Nce3 { +0.26/10 23} f5 { -0.24/26 6} 20. Rad1 { +0.25/11 4} b4 { -0.07/25 14} 21. Rd2 { +0.14/10 16} bxc3 { 0.00/27 9} 22. bxc3 { +0.05/11 5} Ne7 { 0.00/26 1} 23. Nxe7 { +0.29/11 13} Qxe7 { -0.08/28 13} 24. Rfd1 { +0.26/14 10} e4 { -0.08/30 7} 25. Rxd6 { +0.49/14 10} f4 { -0.08/29 1} 26. gxf4 { +0.56/15 5} Rxf4 { -0.08/31 7} 27. Qxa5 { +0.58/14 3} Rbf8 { -0.08/31 2} 28. R1d2 { +0.60/14 4} Rxf2 { -0.08/32 18} 29. Rxf2 { +0.60/13 3} Qxd6 { -0.08/33 2} 30. Rxf8+ { +0.60/12 2} Qxf8 { -0.10/34 42} 31. a4 { +0.69/10 11} Bg8 { -0.08/28 11} 32. Nf5 { +0.78/10 10} Qa3 { 0.00/29 4} 33. Bxe4 { +0.74/10 14} Qc1+ { 0.00/29 1} 34. Kg2 { +0.87/9 10} Qg5+ { 0.00/33 9} 35. Kf3 { +0.91/12 12} Qh5+ { 0.00/33 6} 36. Kg3 { +0.72/14 19} Qg5+ { 0.00/36 10} 37. Kf3 { +0.66/15 2} Qh5+ { 0.00/42 8} 38. Ke3 { +0.65/13 1} Qg5+ { 0.00/33 7} 39. Kd3 { +1.05/11 10} Qc1 { 0.00/31 6} 40. Nxg7 { +3.05/12 9} Qf1+ { 0.00/32 5} 41. Ke3 { +3.01/13 11} Qg1+ { 0.00/34 7} 42. Kf3 { +2.91/13 10} Qf1+ { 0.00/34 7} 43. Kg4 { +2.92/14 18} Qg1+ { 0.00/34 8} 44. Kf3 { +2.83/17 16} Qf1+ { 0.00/46 17} 45. Kg4 { +2.67/16 15} Qg1+ { 0.00/39 8} 46. Kf5 { +2.64/20 4} Qf2+ { 0.00/36 9} 47. Kg5 { +2.59/18 1} Qe3+ { 0.00/36 6} 48. Kf5 { +2.52/16 9} Qf2+ { 0.00/43 4} 49. Kg5 { +2.35/17 7} Qe3+ { 0.00/45 5} 50. Kf6 { +2.32/16 1} Qh6+ { 0.00/38 10} 51. Kf5 { +2.26/15 5} Qh3+ { 0.00/39 11} 52. Kf4 { +2.16/15 13} Qxh2+ { 0.00/38 9} 53. Kg4 { +2.06/13 11} Qg1+ { 0.00/38 7} 54. Kf5 { +1.95/14 13} Qf2+ { 0.00/36 5} 55. Kg4 { +1.81/15 14} Qg1+ { 0.00/41 2} 56. Kf3 { +1.77/14 9} Qh1+ { 0.00/38 2} 57. Ke3 { +1.70/14 7} Qg1+ { 0.00/37 2} 58. Ke2 { +1.69/14 6} Qh2+ { 0.00/37 2} 59. Kf3 { +1.67/14 0} Qh1+ { 0.00/45 0} 60. Kf4 { +1.62/12 5} Qh2+ { 0.00/45 6} 61. Kg5 { +1.62/12 0} Qg3+ { 0.00/34 2} 62. Kh6 { +1.40/13 7} Qd6+ { 0.00/32 3} 63. Kg5 { +1.34/14 0} Qg3+ { 0.00/33 0} 64. Kf6 { +1.23/14 3} Qh4+ { 0.00/39 7} 65. Ke5 { +1.15/14 3} Qh2+ { 0.00/42 3} 66. Kd4 { +1.13/12 3} Qf2+ { 0.00/37 3} 67. Kd3 { +1.04/13 1} Qf1+ { 0.00/37 1} 68. Ke3 { +0.98/12 3} Qe1+ { 0.00/42 4} 69. Kf4 { +0.93/10 3} Qh4+ { 0.00/45 1} 70. Ke3 { +0.76/11 3} Qe1+ { 0.00/38 0} 71. Kd4 { +0.68/11 3} Qg1+ { 0.00/40 2} 72. Ke5 { +0.56/9 2} Qg3+ { 0.00/42 3} 73. Kd4 { +0.66/10 4} Qf2+ { 0.00/52 2} 74. Kd3 { +0.68/13 1} Qf1+ { 0.00/47 6} 75. Kc2 { +0.75/12 1} Qe2+ { 0.00/33 1} 76. Kc1 { +0.73/12 1} Qxe4 { 0.00/36 1} 77. Nf5 { +0.68/10 3} Qe1+ { 0.00/37 4} 78. Kc2 { +0.65/11 5} Qe2+ { 0.00/38 4} 79. Kc1 { +0.41/11 5} Qe1+ { 0.00/40 0} 80. Kb2 { +0.24/9 3} Qd2+ { 0.00/42 2} 81. Kb1 { +0.36/9 1} Qe1+ { 0.00/45 6} 82. Kc2 { +0.15/7 3} Qe2+ { 0.00/42 1} 83. Kb1 { +0.10/5 2} Qe1+ { 0.00/42 2} 84. Kb2 { +0.06/4 2} Qf2+ { 0.00/46 2} 85. Kc1 { +0.03/3 5} Qe1+ { 0.00/45 5 3-fold repetition} 1/2-1/2 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "2"] [White "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Black "Lc01711261"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "B33"] [Opening "Sicilian"] [Time "09:39:40"] [Variation "Pelikan, Sveshnikov, 11.c3 Bg7 12.exf5 Bxf5 13.Nc2 O-O"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "normal"] [PlyCount "228"] 1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 e6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 Nc6 5. Nb5 Nf6 6. N1c3 d6 7. Bf4 e5 8. Bg5 a6 9. Na3 b5 10. Bxf6 gxf6 11. Nd5 f5 12. c3 Bg7 13. exf5 Bxf5 14. Nc2 { +0.34/29 23} O-O { -0.13/10 15} 15. Bd3 { +0.39/24 10} Be6 { -0.25/13 12} 16. Nce3 { +0.58/24 8} f5 { -0.30/13 11} 17. O-O { +0.49/25 12} e4 { -0.18/11 16} 18. Nf4 { +0.56/27 15} Bf7 { -0.17/14 8} 19. Bc2 { +0.58/23 2} Qg5 { -0.15/14 6} 20. Qxd6 { +0.43/26 20} Ne5 { -0.13/11 8} 21. Nh3 { +0.35/29 17} Qh5 { -0.09/10 14} 22. a4 { +0.43/23 14} Rad8 { -0.04/12 14} 23. Qxa6 { 0.00/25 17} Nf3+ { +0.50/16 11} 24. Kh1 { +0.02/25 1} f4 { +0.62/18 5} 25. Qxb5 { 0.00/29 9} Qxb5 { +0.68/18 7} 26. axb5 { +0.54/24 5} fxe3 { +0.73/16 2} 27. gxf3 { +0.31/24 3} e2 { +0.77/14 2} 28. Rg1 { +0.04/28 17} exf3 { +0.79/13 1} 29. Ng5 { 0.00/27 2} Bd5 { +0.86/12 2} 30. Nxh7 { 0.00/30 11} Rf7 { +0.90/9 3} 31. Ng5 { 0.00/29 8} Re7 { +1.11/10 8} 32. Rae1 { -0.07/28 23} Kh8 { +1.07/11 7} 33. c4 { -0.12/30 20} Bb7 { +2.49/12 11} 34. c5 { 0.00/28 5} Bd5 { +2.53/12 5} 35. Rg4 { -0.23/31 18} Bxb2 { +2.84/12 9} 36. c6 { -0.23/31 1} Rde8 { +2.10/11 12} 37. Rh4+ { -0.20/31 15} Kg8 { +1.37/15 22} 38. Rg4 { 0.00/35 6} Kf8 { +1.85/14 11} 39. Rf4+ { 0.00/36 7} Kg8 { +1.36/15 4} 40. Rg4 { 0.00/35 1} Kh8 { +0.76/15 3} 41. Rh4+ { 0.00/38 6} Kg7 { +0.89/17 4} 42. Rf4 { -0.10/31 11} Bc3 { +1.31/17 10} 43. Rg1 { 0.00/29 5} Kg8 { +1.66/16 4} 44. Bh7+ { 0.00/31 3} Kh8 { +0.49/18 10} 45. Rh4 { 0.00/33 6} Kg7 { +0.38/20 5} 46. Be4 { 0.00/33 4} e1=Q { +0.34/20 3} 47. Rxe1 { 0.00/33 8} Bxe1 { +0.32/20 2} 48. Bxd5 { 0.00/34 2} Bxf2 { +0.33/19 2} 49. Rh7+ { 0.00/34 5} Kf6 { +0.29/17 3} 50. Rxe7 { 0.00/33 2} Rxe7 { +0.29/17 3} 51. Nxf3 { 0.00/38 6} Bb6 { +0.30/16 2} 52. Bc4 { 0.00/35 6} Kf5 { +0.64/10 12} 53. Kg2 { 0.00/34 1} Kf4 { +0.65/11 7} 54. h4 { 0.00/37 6} Re4 { +0.42/10 12} 55. Bf1 { 0.00/35 1} Re3 { +0.54/12 12} 56. Ng5 { 0.00/37 6} Rg3+ { +0.49/12 9} 57. Kh2 { 0.00/39 1} Rc3 { +0.46/13 14} 58. Kg2 { 0.00/39 8} Kg4 { +0.52/15 13} 59. Be2+ { 0.00/37 6} Kxh4 { +0.51/15 3} 60. Nf3+ { 0.00/38 1} Kg4 { +0.48/15 3} 61. Nd2+ { 0.00/39 6} Kf4 { +0.47/13 8} 62. Nc4 { +0.08/30 4} Bc7 { +0.45/13 20} 63. b6 { +0.08/36 1} Bxb6 { +0.45/11 0} 64. Nxb6 { +0.08/42 6} Rxc6 { +0.45/10 0} 65. Nd5+ { +0.08/41 1} Ke5 { +0.43/8 13} 66. Ne3 { +0.08/39 37} Rc7 { +0.44/7 17} 67. Kf2 { +0.08/37 3} Rf7+ { +0.41/6 17} 68. Bf3 { +0.08/38 19} Kd4 { +0.42/6 12} 69. Ng2 { +0.08/38 5} Rf8 { +0.39/6 14} 70. Ne1 { +0.08/25 10} Rf7 { +0.41/6 13} 71. Kg3 { +0.08/30 3} Ke3 { +0.44/5 4} 72. Ng2+ { +0.08/32 1} Kd4 { +0.33/6 3} 73. Nh4 { +0.08/33 3} Ke5 { +0.34/5 3} 74. Bg2 { +0.08/34 6} Rg7+ { +0.41/5 3} 75. Kf2 { +0.08/37 0} Kf4 { +0.42/6 2} 76. Bd5 { +0.08/35 3} Rh7 { +0.53/6 3} 77. Ng2+ { +0.08/36 4} Ke5 { +0.41/5 2} 78. Ne3 { +0.08/34 3} Kd4 { +0.49/5 3} 79. Bg2 { +0.08/35 2} Rf7+ { +0.53/5 2} 80. Bf3 { +0.08/37 3} Rf8 { +0.40/5 3} 81. Ng2 { +0.08/37 3} Kd3 { +0.38/5 3} 82. Ne1+ { +0.08/35 2} Kd2 { +0.44/6 2} 83. Ng2 { 0.00/44 3} Kd3 { +0.33/6 3} 84. Kg3 { +0.08/22 2} Kd4 { +0.30/5 2} 85. Nf4 { +0.08/30 0} Ke3 { +0.44/5 3} 86. Nd5+ { +0.08/32 3} Kd4 { +0.34/6 2} 87. Ne7 { +0.08/32 2} Rf7 { +0.49/5 2} 88. Ng6 { +0.08/34 4} Rg7 { +0.49/6 2} 89. Bh5 { +0.08/35 1} Ke4 { +0.42/6 3} 90. Kg4 { +0.08/35 6} Ra7 { +0.30/6 3} 91. Nf4 { +0.08/32 3} Rg7+ { +0.34/5 3} 92. Bg6+ { +0.08/32 3} Ke5 { +0.37/6 2} 93. Kf3 { +0.08/30 2} Rg8 { +0.45/5 3} 94. Ke3 { +0.08/30 3} Rg7 { +0.44/5 2} 95. Nd3+ { +0.08/33 3} Kf6 { +0.27/6 3} 96. Be4 { +0.08/38 2} Ra7 { +0.20/5 2} 97. Nf4 { +0.08/29 3} Ra3+ { +0.27/5 3} 98. Bd3 { +0.08/29 2} Ra8 { +0.19/5 2} 99. Bb5 { +0.08/33 3} Ke5 { +0.26/5 2} 100. Nd3+ { +0.08/37 0} Kd6 { +0.24/5 2} 101. Nf2 { +0.08/34 2} Ra5 { +0.28/5 3} 102. Bc4 { +0.08/34 6} Ra1 { +0.21/5 2} 103. Nd3 { +0.08/28 3} Ra4 { +0.26/5 2} 104. Kd4 { 0.00/31 2} Ra8 { +0.15/5 3} 105. Nf4 { 0.00/29 1} Ra3 { +0.19/5 3} 106. Be2 { 0.00/33 2} Ra2 { +0.26/5 2} 107. Bb5 { 0.00/37 2} Ra5 { +0.28/5 3} 108. Bd3 { 0.00/37 5} Ra1 { +0.18/5 2} 109. Ke3 { 0.00/39 1} Ke5 { +0.23/5 3} 110. Ne2 { 0.00/27 4} Ra8 { +0.15/5 2} 111. Nd4 { 0.00/36 3} Ra4 { +0.24/5 2} 112. Nf3+ { 0.00/33 1} Kd5 { +0.05/5 3} 113. Nd2 { 0.00/34 2} Ra3 { +0.03/4 2} 114. Ne4 { 0.00/51 4} Ra8 { 0.00/2 3 50 moves rule} 1/2-1/2 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "3"] [White "Lc01711261"] [Black "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "B89"] [Opening "Sicilian"] [Time "10:01:44"] [Variation "Velimirovic, 9.O-O-O Qc7 10.Bb3 a6"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "normal"] [PlyCount "128"] 1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 Nf6 5. Nc3 d6 6. Bc4 e6 7. Be3 a6 8. Qe2 Qc7 9. O-O-O Be7 10. Bb3 O-O 11. g4 { +0.22/9 13} Nxd4 { +0.13/26 17} 12. Rxd4 { +0.29/10 10} Nd7 { +0.13/26 14} 13. g5 { +0.35/10 14} b5 { 0.00/25 17} 14. f4 { +0.27/9 17} Nc5 { +0.20/25 11} 15. f5 { +0.31/12 9} exf5 { -0.16/23 2} 16. Nd5 { +0.41/13 12} Qd8 { 0.00/24 5} 17. exf5 { +0.40/14 3} Bxf5 { 0.00/27 8} 18. Rf1 { +0.39/12 12} Nxb3+ { 0.00/27 20} 19. axb3 { +0.32/12 2} Bh3 { 0.00/29 25} 20. Rg1 { +0.32/10 11} Be6 { 0.00/29 12} 21. Qf3 { +0.24/10 18} Bxd5 { +0.06/26 6} 22. Rxd5 { +0.15/9 7} Rc8 { +0.07/23 1} 23. Bd4 { +0.17/9 20} Qc7 { +0.16/27 5} 24. c3 { +0.14/10 9} Rfe8 { 0.00/29 18} 25. h4 { +0.12/10 17} Qb7 { 0.00/31 11} 26. h5 { +0.12/9 20} Bf8 { 0.00/33 9} 27. Kb1 { +0.01/10 18} Re6 { +0.07/30 8} 28. h6 { -0.05/10 13} g6 { +0.17/30 21} 29. Rc1 { +0.24/7 18} Rce8 { +0.02/31 25} 30. c4 { +0.12/10 10} bxc4 { +0.16/28 12} 31. bxc4 { +0.11/11 4} Qb4 { +0.16/30 14} 32. Qf4 { +0.04/10 7} Rc8 { +0.19/27 6} 33. Be3 { 0.00/10 4} Qb7 { +0.29/30 13} 34. Bd2 { -0.03/9 8} Rc5 { +0.11/30 11} 35. Qd4 { -0.14/11 11} Rxd5 { +0.09/29 2} 36. cxd5 { -0.24/13 4} Re5 { +0.43/26 5} 37. Rc6 { -0.22/11 2} f5 { 0.00/31 13} 38. Bc3 { +0.38/11 9} a5 { 0.00/27 6} 39. Rc5 { +0.32/9 13} a4 { 0.00/29 2} 40. Ra5 { +0.50/15 6} a3 { 0.00/31 5} 41. Qd3 { +1.00/10 7} Qb3 { 0.00/30 6} 42. Rxa3 { +0.27/12 14} Rxd5 { 0.00/34 7} 43. Rxb3 { +0.12/12 4} Rxd3 { 0.00/36 3} 44. Rb8 { +0.07/14 15} Kf7 { 0.00/37 5} 45. Rb7+ { +0.10/18 3} Be7 { 0.00/37 2} 46. Kc2 { +0.10/16 3} Re3 { 0.00/36 8} 47. Bd4 { +0.19/15 3} Re4 { 0.00/37 7} 48. Bf6 { +0.19/12 1} f4 { 0.00/36 1} 49. Kd3 { +0.24/15 3} d5 { 0.00/37 6} 50. b4 { +0.24/12 1} Re1 { 0.00/35 2} 51. Ra7 { +0.30/12 10} Ke8 { 0.00/33 5} 52. Bxe7 { +0.30/14 5} Rxe7 { 0.00/35 4} 53. Ra8+ { +0.27/13 2} Kd7 { 0.00/33 1} 54. Ra6 { +0.35/12 9} Re3+ { 0.00/36 7} 55. Kd4 { +0.62/10 7} Re4+ { 0.00/37 3} 56. Kxd5 { +0.32/14 14} Rxb4 { 0.00/41 7} 57. Ra7+ { +0.25/13 3} Ke8 { 0.00/42 1} 58. Rxh7 { +0.12/14 9} f3 { 0.00/43 7} 59. Rc7 { +0.05/13 11} f2 { 0.00/40 6} 60. h7 { +0.05/11 0} Rh4 { 0.00/45 7} 61. Ke6 { +0.06/9 0} Re4+ { 0.00/47 1} 62. Kd5 { +0.02/7 5} Rh4 { 0.00/48 4} 63. Ke6 { +0.02/5 1} Re4+ { 0.00/61 3} 64. Kd5 { +0.01/3 4} Rh4 { 0.00/52 3 3-fold repetition} 1/2-1/2 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "4"] [White "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Black "Lc01711261"] [Result "1-0"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "B89"] [Opening "Sicilian"] [Time "10:17:46"] [Variation "Velimirovic, 9.O-O-O Qc7 10.Bb3 a6"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "adjudication"] [PlyCount "148"] 1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 Nf6 5. Nc3 d6 6. Bc4 e6 7. Be3 a6 8. Qe2 Qc7 9. O-O-O Be7 10. Bb3 O-O 11. Nxc6 { -0.04/26 32} bxc6 { -0.14/10 21} 12. Bf4 { 0.00/25 8} a5 { +0.04/7 17} 13. h4 { 0.00/25 10} e5 { -0.03/8 21} 14. Bg5 { +0.17/23 6} Rb8 { 0.00/8 10} 15. f3 { +0.13/24 18} Be6 { +0.10/8 12} 16. g4 { +0.20/24 7} Rb4 { -0.03/9 13} 17. Rhe1 { +0.35/24 19} Rfb8 { +0.19/9 13} 18. Bxe6 { +0.37/23 14} fxe6 { +0.21/12 6} 19. b3 { 0.00/23 1} Kh8 { +0.19/11 5} 20. Kb1 { +0.30/21 6} Qb6 { +0.08/10 13} 21. Be3 { 0.00/26 17} c5 { +0.24/10 12} 22. Rc1 { 0.00/26 14} Qc6 { +0.68/9 11} 23. Ka1 { 0.00/28 9} c4 { +0.43/12 14} 24. g5 { 0.00/27 9} Nd7 { +0.88/9 10} 25. Qd2 { 0.00/27 1} Kg8 { +0.75/7 13} 26. Red1 { +0.05/26 13} g6 { +0.49/8 20} 27. h5 { 0.00/26 17} gxh5 { +0.23/9 11} 28. Rh1 { 0.00/28 9} Nf8 { +0.18/10 7} 29. Rxh5 { 0.00/25 8} R4b7 { +0.14/10 15} 30. Qh2 { +0.43/24 5} Bd8 { +0.04/9 8} 31. Na4 { +0.36/24 4} Rg7 { +0.02/9 13} 32. Nb2 { +0.03/26 31} cxb3 { -0.02/10 17} 33. cxb3 { +0.29/23 5} Qa6 { -0.09/8 9} 34. Rh1 { +0.41/24 20} Rbb7 { +0.16/7 8} 35. Qd2 { +0.12/28 34} Rbd7 { +0.13/8 10} 36. Na4 { +0.10/23 8} Qb5 { +0.30/6 12} 37. Rd1 { +0.13/24 5} Rgf7 { +0.28/7 12} 38. Rh3 { +0.20/23 7} Ng6 { +0.38/8 9} 39. Kb2 { +0.10/21 1} Qc6 { +0.16/7 13} 40. Rc1 { +0.21/25 7} Qb7 { +0.08/7 8} 41. Rc2 { +0.27/24 4} Nf8 { -0.06/7 13} 42. Qd3 { +0.34/24 13} Ng6 { -0.23/7 9} 43. Qc4 { +0.61/24 4} Nf8 { -0.40/9 6} 44. Qc6 { +0.52/26 9} Qb8 { -0.42/10 7} 45. Qa6 { +0.84/23 2} Rc7 { -0.43/9 3} 46. Rd2 { +1.04/24 6} Be7 { -0.79/9 11} 47. Nb6 { +0.76/22 1} Ng6 { -1.13/9 9} 48. Nc4 { +1.08/23 3} a4 { -1.16/7 3} 49. Qxa4 { +0.74/25 13} Qc8 { -1.47/8 3} 50. Nb6 { +1.33/26 4} Qb7 { -2.08/10 3} 51. Qa8+ { +1.63/24 2} Qxa8 { -2.34/10 1} 52. Nxa8 { +1.58/24 0} Rc6 { -2.33/10 2} 53. Nb6 { +1.57/27 9} Nf4 { -2.69/9 5} 54. Rh1 { +1.76/24 1} Ng6 { -2.97/8 2} 55. Rf1 { +1.83/27 14} Bd8 { -3.09/8 2} 56. Nc4 { +2.37/23 2} Bc7 { -2.98/8 1} 57. Rc1 { +2.67/23 1} Rxf3 { -3.77/8 4} 58. b4 { +2.77/24 2} Ra6 { -3.91/9 1} 59. b5 { +2.71/24 0} Ra4 { -4.16/9 1} 60. Kb3 { +2.98/24 2} Ra8 { -5.02/9 2} 61. Rc3 { +3.03/24 0} Rb8 { -5.71/8 4} 62. Kb4 { +3.15/22 2} Ne7 { -4.86/9 4} 63. Bb6 { +3.27/22 1} Bxb6 { -4.05/9 1} 64. Rxf3 { +3.52/24 4} Bc5+ { -4.44/10 1} 65. Ka4 { +3.76/21 1} d5 { -4.74/10 2} 66. Nxe5 { +3.88/23 3} dxe4 { -4.98/10 1} 67. Rf6 { +4.07/23 5} Nd5 { -5.48/8 7} 68. Rc2 { +4.69/23 3} Ra8+ { -5.70/8 2} 69. Kb3 { +4.72/4 0} Nxf6 { -5.13/10 1} 70. gxf6 { +7.55/25 2} Bd6 { -6.48/11 3} 71. Rg2+ { +16.32/25 2} Kf8 { -7.55/11 1} 72. Nd7+ { +16.81/23 0} Kf7 { -9.50/11 4} 73. Rg7+ { +23.31/23 3} Ke8 { -10.55/11 0} 74. Rg8+ { +25.48/20 0} Kxd7 { -13.66/7 8 Arena Adjudication} 1-0 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "5"] [White "Lc01711261"] [Black "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "C19"] [Opening "French"] [Time "10:35:10"] [Variation "Winawer, 6...Ne7 7.Nf3 Qc7 8.a4 b6"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "normal"] [PlyCount "210"] 1. e4 e6 2. d4 d5 3. Nc3 Bb4 4. e5 c5 5. a3 Bxc3+ 6. bxc3 Qc7 7. Nf3 Ne7 8. a4 b6 9. Bb5+ Bd7 10. Bd3 Nbc6 11. O-O h6 { 0.00/29 14} 12. Ba3 { +0.66/8 25} Na5 { -0.05/30 27} 13. Nh4 { +0.67/9 19} O-O { -0.25/26 32} 14. g4 { +1.05/10 12} f6 { -0.20/23 22} 15. f4 { +1.08/11 8} Be8 { -0.32/25 19} 16. Qe2 { +1.49/12 12} fxe5 { -0.10/25 4} 17. fxe5 { +0.84/11 11} Rxf1+ { -0.09/26 12} 18. Rxf1 { +0.59/12 19} c4 { 0.00/30 5} 19. Bf5 { +0.58/11 2} Qd7 { 0.00/32 14} 20. h3 { +0.48/9 22} Nac6 { +0.68/24 6} 21. Kh2 { +0.39/8 15} Rd8 { +0.58/27 15} 22. Bc1 { +0.65/7 23} Kh8 { +0.58/28 9} 23. Qf3 { +0.39/8 21} exf5 { +0.69/24 11} 24. gxf5 { +0.24/10 7} Ng8 { +0.27/27 14} 25. Ba3 { +0.16/10 9} Qc7 { +0.33/27 7} 26. Qg3 { +0.14/11 6} Bh5 { +0.10/28 16} 27. Ng2 { +0.12/10 4} Qf7 { +0.14/28 10} 28. Ne3 { +0.11/9 12} Kh7 { +0.20/26 5} 29. Rg1 { +0.13/9 12} Nge7 { +0.21/28 7} 30. Rf1 { +0.10/8 7} Rh8 { 0.00/28 12} 31. Qh4 { +0.65/9 9} Rg8 { 0.00/29 7} 32. Rf2 { +0.54/11 17} Qe8 { 0.00/27 6} 33. Qf4 { +0.38/9 16} Qb8 { +0.09/25 4} 34. Bd6 { +0.40/7 16} Qc8 { +0.10/29 10} 35. Qh4 { +0.47/9 8} Qe8 { 0.00/27 8} 36. Ba3 { +0.40/8 6} Bf7 { +0.19/27 20} 37. Qf4 { +0.35/8 16} Qc8 { +0.33/24 5} 38. Qf3 { +0.36/7 13} Qc7 { +0.26/28 8} 39. Qf4 { +0.35/7 9} Qb8 { +0.26/31 7} 40. Kh1 { +0.32/7 14} Be8 { +0.26/25 6} 41. Qh4 { +0.33/8 7} Qc7 { +0.26/27 1} 42. Kg1 { +0.30/8 12} Qd8 { +0.25/28 5} 43. Kh2 { +0.34/8 6} a6 { +0.18/26 10} 44. Qf4 { +0.39/8 7} Qd7 { +0.16/28 16} 45. Qg3 { +0.32/7 9} Qb7 { +0.12/26 23} 46. f6 { +0.55/8 5} gxf6 { 0.00/28 5} 47. Ng4 { +0.49/11 0} Rg6 { 0.00/29 4} 48. Nxf6+ { +0.27/11 1} Kh8 { 0.00/22 0} 49. Qf4 { +0.25/9 2} Qc8 { +0.41/24 2} 50. Nh5 { +0.18/9 4} Qe6 { +0.14/28 11} 51. Rf1 { +0.05/10 2} Qg8 { +0.70/26 4} 52. Nf6 { +0.19/9 3} Qf7 { +0.91/27 3} 53. e6 { -0.19/12 2} Qxf6 { +0.93/23 1} 54. Qxf6+ { -0.45/12 1} Rxf6 { +0.97/27 2} 55. Rxf6 { -0.50/11 1} Kg7 { +0.94/28 1} 56. Rf1 { -0.63/9 3} Bg6 { +0.87/28 7} 57. h4 { -0.96/9 7} Bf5 { +1.17/23 2} 58. Rb1 { -0.61/8 3} Nc8 { +1.06/24 5} 59. h5 { -0.81/9 2} Kf6 { +1.20/24 3} 60. Rg1 { -0.93/8 2} Kxe6 { +0.98/23 3} 61. Bc1 { -1.06/8 2} Bxc2 { +1.05/23 2} 62. Bxh6 { -0.99/8 2} b5 { +1.04/24 3} 63. axb5 { -1.06/9 2} axb5 { +0.82/25 2} 64. Rg7 { -0.91/10 3} b4 { +0.66/23 2} 65. cxb4 { -1.04/10 1} Nxd4 { +0.89/22 1} 66. Bf4 { -1.25/10 2} Ne2 { +0.51/24 4} 67. Bg5 { -1.11/10 3} Nc3 { +0.55/25 2} 68. h6 { -1.15/9 5} d4 { +0.74/24 3} 69. h7 { -1.22/11 1} Bxh7 { +0.54/23 3} 70. Rxh7 { -1.25/10 1} Nb5 { +0.16/22 2} 71. Rh5 { -0.52/8 5} Ncd6 { +0.08/27 2} 72. Bf4 { -0.50/10 1} Nf5 { +0.08/29 2} 73. Kg2 { -0.45/11 1} d3 { 0.00/30 3} 74. Kf2 { -0.37/10 2} Nc3 { 0.00/25 0} 75. Rh8 { -0.36/9 2} Nd5 { 0.00/26 2} 76. Bd2 { -0.35/10 2} c3 { 0.00/27 2} 77. Rh3 { +0.27/8 4} cxd2 { +0.08/33 1} 78. Rxd3 { +0.27/8 2} Nd6 { +0.08/34 0} 79. Rxd2 { +0.25/7 4} Ne4+ { +0.08/35 6} 80. Ke2 { +0.11/7 6} Nxd2 { +0.08/34 0} 81. Kxd2 { +0.07/5 2} Nf4 { +0.08/34 7} 82. b5 { +0.15/5 3} Kd7 { +0.08/33 3} 83. Kc3 { +0.13/5 3} Kc7 { +0.08/30 2} 84. Kb4 { +0.11/5 3} Kd6 { +0.08/32 2} 85. Ka5 { +0.20/5 2} Nd3 { +0.08/38 2} 86. Kb6 { +0.19/6 3} Nc5 { +0.08/35 6} 87. Ka5 { +0.17/6 3} Kc7 { +0.08/26 3} 88. Kb4 { +0.11/6 2} Nd3+ { +0.08/25 3} 89. Ka5 { +0.15/6 3} Nf2 { +0.08/30 2} 90. Ka6 { +0.20/6 2} Kb8 { +0.08/36 3} 91. Kb6 { +0.15/7 3} Nd3 { +0.08/28 2} 92. Kc6 { +0.15/6 3} Ne5+ { +0.08/30 3} 93. Kd5 { +0.14/6 3} Nd7 { +0.08/29 0} 94. Kc6 { +0.16/6 2} Nf8 { +0.08/32 2} 95. Kb6 { +0.14/6 3} Ne6 { +0.08/33 3} 96. Ka5 { +0.11/6 3} Ka7 { +0.08/29 1} 97. Kb4 { +0.08/6 2} Kb6 { +0.08/31 6} 98. Kc4 { +0.07/5 3} Kc7 { +0.08/29 2} 99. Kd5 { +0.11/5 2} Kd7 { +0.08/32 2} 100. b6 { +0.20/6 2} Nd8 { +0.08/33 1} 101. Kc5 { +0.18/6 2} Nb7+ { +0.08/34 5} 102. Kb5 { +0.18/6 3} Kd6 { +0.08/33 2} 103. Ka6 { +0.23/7 2} Kc6 { +0.08/37 2} 104. Ka7 { +0.27/5 0} Nc5 { +0.08/35 2} 105. Kb8 { +0.05/3 6} Kxb6 { +0.08/36 4 Insufficient material} 1/2-1/2 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "6"] [White "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Black "Lc01711261"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "C19"] [Opening "French"] [Time "10:56:16"] [Variation "Winawer, 6...Ne7 7.Nf3 Qc7 8.a4 b6"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "normal"] [PlyCount "376"] 1. e4 e6 2. d4 d5 3. Nc3 Bb4 4. e5 c5 5. a3 Bxc3+ 6. bxc3 Qc7 7. Nf3 Ne7 8. a4 b6 9. Bb5+ Bd7 10. Bd3 Nbc6 11. O-O c4 { -0.48/9 14} 12. Be2 { +0.35/26 17} f6 { -0.45/9 8} 13. Re1 { +0.34/25 10} O-O-O { -0.44/8 9} 14. g3 { +0.40/27 14} Kb7 { -0.41/8 11} 15. Bf1 { +0.41/27 21} f5 { -0.28/9 11} 16. Ba3 { +0.33/26 16} Be8 { -0.23/9 7} 17. Ng5 { +0.20/30 13} Qd7 { +0.08/9 11} 18. h4 { +0.19/30 2} h6 { +0.09/9 8} 19. Nh3 { +0.18/30 20} Bf7 { +0.10/8 6} 20. Be2 { +0.10/30 51} Rdg8 { +0.01/8 10} 21. Bc1 { +0.42/29 55} a5 { -0.06/8 25} 22. Be3 { +0.54/25 18} Be8 { 0.00/7 22} 23. Qd2 { +0.44/28 28} Nd8 { +0.13/7 16} 24. Reb1 { +0.41/28 20} Nf7 { +0.33/8 13} 25. h5 { +0.45/26 7} g5 { +0.12/11 20} 26. hxg6 { +0.53/26 11} Ng5 { +0.01/15 12} 27. Nxg5 { +0.46/27 5} hxg5 { +0.01/11 9} 28. g7 { +0.39/25 2} Rxg7 { -0.04/11 6} 29. Bxg5 { +0.44/28 5} Rgh7 { -0.04/10 4} 30. Bf3 { +0.39/30 1} Bh5 { -0.09/9 12} 31. Bg2 { +0.23/30 18} Rg8 { -0.03/8 18} 32. f4 { +0.48/32 2} Be8 { +0.24/7 17} 33. Rf1 { +0.48/32 6} Nc8 { +0.23/6 14} 34. Rfe1 { +0.47/35 6} Qf7 { +0.28/6 15} 35. Qc1 { +0.47/36 4} Bc6 { +0.11/7 17} 36. Kf2 { +0.47/36 0} Qe8 { +0.08/9 7} 37. Qa3 { +0.47/36 4} Rh2 { +0.09/10 6} 38. Rh1 { +0.47/36 1} Rxh1 { +0.09/10 3} 39. Bxh1 { +0.47/41 7} Rh8 { +0.06/8 4} 40. Bh4 { +0.40/41 14} Rh7 { +0.04/7 13} 41. Bf3 { 0.00/36 13} Bd7 { +0.05/6 8} 42. Ra2 { 0.00/34 3} Qg8 { +0.10/6 14} 43. Bf6 { 0.00/35 2} Be8 { +0.54/7 8} 44. Bg2 { 0.00/35 3} Bh5 { +0.56/7 12} 45. Bg5 { 0.00/34 2} Bg4 { +0.50/7 12} 46. Bh4 { 0.00/29 4} Bd1 { +0.41/7 10} 47. Qc1 { 0.00/35 2} Bh5 { +0.39/6 3} 48. Qe3 { 0.00/36 3} Ka6 { +0.65/5 4} 49. Ke1 { 0.00/35 3} Ne7 { +0.67/5 3} 50. Bg5 { 0.00/35 2} Nc8 { +0.67/5 2} 51. Bf1 { 0.00/28 3} Bg4 { +0.99/5 2} 52. Qf2 { 0.00/32 3} Qe8 { +1.44/6 1} 53. Bh4 { 0.00/29 3} b5 { +1.75/8 2} 54. Qd2 { 0.00/32 4} bxa4 { +1.49/8 2} 55. Qc1 { 0.00/33 1} Rb7 { +1.18/7 5} 56. Qa1 { 0.00/30 4} Nb6 { +1.60/6 1} 57. Kd2 { +0.26/25 2} Bh5 { +1.42/5 4} 58. Qc1 { 0.00/30 7} Qf8 { +1.31/5 3} 59. Ra1 { 0.00/34 8} Bf3 { +1.05/5 3} 60. Be2 { 0.00/31 1} Bxe2 { +1.16/7 1} 61. Kxe2 { 0.00/33 0} Rb8 { +0.83/6 4} 62. Kf2 { +0.12/31 1} Rb7 { +1.00/5 3} 63. Ke3 { +0.12/32 2} Rb8 { +0.86/6 3} 64. Qb1 { 0.00/33 5} Rb7 { +1.02/5 2} 65. Qa2 { +0.12/36 1} Rb8 { +0.80/6 3} 66. Rh1 { 0.00/34 4} a3 { +0.99/7 2} 67. Ra1 { 0.00/37 5} Na8 { +0.97/10 2} 68. Qxa3 { 0.00/36 1} Qxa3 { +1.00/10 1} 69. Rxa3 { 0.00/38 2} Nc7 { +1.09/10 1} 70. Ra1 { 0.00/36 2} Rg8 { +1.18/9 2} 71. Ra2 { 0.00/34 2} Nb5 { +1.18/8 4} 72. Kd2 { 0.00/38 0} Re8 { +1.15/9 5} 73. Bf6 { 0.00/38 2} Kb6 { +1.12/9 1} 74. Ra1 { 0.00/41 2} Nc7 { +1.06/8 5} 75. Bh4 { 0.00/37 4} Nb5 { +1.09/7 2} 76. Bg5 { 0.00/43 5} Rh8 { +1.16/8 3} 77. Bh4 { 0.00/40 0} Ra8 { +1.00/8 3} 78. Ra4 { 0.00/42 2} Re8 { +1.22/7 2} 79. Ra1 { 0.00/46 4} Ka6 { +1.21/7 3} 80. Ra4 { 0.00/41 2} Kb6 { +1.07/7 2} 81. Ra1 { 0.00/52 3} Rh8 { +1.08/7 3} 82. Ra4 { 0.00/45 8} Ka6 { +0.95/8 1} 83. Ra2 { 0.00/46 4} Rh6 { +0.89/8 4} 84. Ra1 { 0.00/39 2} Rh5 { +1.00/8 1} 85. Ra2 { 0.00/42 3} Rh8 { +0.99/8 2} 86. Ra1 { 0.00/51 0} Na7 { +0.92/7 4} 87. Ke3 { 0.00/39 5} Nb5 { +0.88/7 2} 88. Kd2 { 0.00/40 0} Kb6 { +0.77/8 3} 89. Ra2 { 0.00/50 5} Ra8 { +0.86/7 2} 90. Ra4 { 0.00/56 2} Rh8 { +0.76/7 3} 91. Ra1 { 0.00/50 2} Rg8 { +0.78/7 3} 92. Ra2 { 0.00/46 4} Rf8 { +0.57/7 3} 93. Be7 { 0.00/36 1} Ra8 { +0.54/8 1} 94. Bc5+ { 0.00/41 4} Kc6 { +0.54/9 4} 95. Ra4 { 0.00/38 1} Kb7 { +0.50/8 1} 96. Be7 { 0.00/37 0} Kc7 { +0.44/8 4} 97. Bb4 { 0.00/35 2} Kb6 { +0.41/9 0} 98. Kc1 { 0.00/34 0} Nc7 { +0.36/9 3} 99. Bc5+ { 0.00/38 3} Kb7 { +0.23/8 3} 100. Kd2 { 0.00/43 2} Nb5 { +0.43/7 2} 101. Be7 { 0.00/51 4} Nc7 { +0.29/7 2} 102. Bd6 { 0.00/41 3} Ne8 { +0.17/7 3} 103. Bf8 { 0.00/41 2} Nc7 { +0.19/7 2} 104. Bc5 { 0.00/61 5} Kc6 { +0.28/7 2} 105. Ke3 { 0.00/38 3} Kb7 { +0.11/6 4} 106. Ba3 { 0.00/35 2} Nb5 { +0.52/7 2} 107. Kd2 { 0.00/36 0} Kb6 { +0.24/7 3} 108. Bc5+ { 0.00/55 2} Kc7 { +0.09/6 2} 109. Bb4 { 0.00/48 3} Kb6 { +0.07/5 1} 110. Ra1 { 0.00/33 2} a4 { +0.23/8 4} 111. Ke3 { 0.00/33 6} a3 { +0.28/9 1} 112. Kf3 { 0.00/32 0} Rh8 { +0.27/9 2} 113. Bxa3 { 0.00/34 3} Nxc3 { +0.63/10 2} 114. Bc5+ { 0.00/30 4} Kb5 { +0.59/11 2} 115. Ra7 { 0.00/31 3} Ne4 { +0.40/11 2} 116. Rb7+ { 0.00/31 1} Ka5 { +0.21/10 3} 117. Bb4+ { 0.00/30 2} Ka4 { +0.21/10 6} 118. Be1 { 0.00/30 3} Rh2 { +0.25/10 2} 119. c3 { 0.00/32 3} Rh1 { +0.66/8 2} 120. Ke2 { 0.00/34 1} Rh6 { +0.49/8 4} 121. Kd1 { 0.00/40 2} Rh5 { +0.78/7 3} 122. Rb6 { 0.00/35 2} Rh1 { +0.43/9 2} 123. Rxe6 { 0.00/33 2} Nxc3+ { +0.76/11 1} 124. Kc2 { 0.00/34 4} Ne4 { +0.43/13 2} 125. Ra6+ { 0.00/33 2} Kb5 { +0.32/15 0} 126. Ra5+ { 0.00/35 1} Kb6 { +0.12/13 3} 127. Ra1 { 0.00/33 2} Rh8 { +0.37/8 5} 128. Kd1 { 0.00/34 2} Kc6 { +0.14/8 4} 129. Ke2 { 0.00/30 2} Kb5 { +0.15/8 1} 130. Ke3 { 0.00/29 2} Kc6 { -0.14/7 3} 131. Ke2 { 0.00/28 3} Kb5 { +0.07/6 3} 132. Rb1+ { 0.00/30 2} Kc6 { +0.05/4 1} 133. Kd1 { 0.00/31 1} Rh1 { +0.95/7 3} 134. Ra1 { 0.00/33 5} Nxg3 { +0.99/8 3} 135. Ra6+ { 0.00/33 2} Kc7 { +1.07/9 2} 136. Ra7+ { 0.00/34 3} Kd8 { +0.76/10 4} 137. Ra6 { 0.00/33 2} Ne4 { +1.62/7 2} 138. Ke2 { 0.00/34 2} c3 { +1.65/7 2} 139. Ra1 { 0.00/35 3} Kc7 { +1.44/7 4} 140. Ra7+ { 0.00/31 2} Kc6 { +1.85/7 3} 141. Ra8 { 0.00/33 2} Rh3 { +1.89/7 2} 142. Rb8 { 0.00/34 3} Kc7 { +1.73/7 3} 143. Ra8 { 0.00/40 2} Kb7 { +1.74/7 3} 144. Ra1 { 0.00/38 4} Kc6 { +1.79/7 1} 145. Ra8 { 0.00/37 7} Rh1 { +1.77/7 3} 146. Rb8 { 0.00/39 5} Rh3 { +1.74/7 4} 147. Rb1 { 0.00/40 4} Rh5 { +1.71/7 3} 148. Rb8 { 0.00/39 2} Kd7 { +1.75/7 2} 149. Rb1 { 0.00/38 2} Kc6 { +1.61/7 3} 150. Kd3 { 0.00/41 4} Rh1 { +1.45/7 2} 151. Ke3 { 0.00/36 2} Nd2 { +1.64/7 2} 152. Rc1 { 0.00/37 3} Ne4 { +1.50/8 1} 153. Rb1 { 0.00/43 0} Kd7 { +1.36/7 4} 154. Rc1 { 0.00/37 2} Kc7 { +1.39/7 3} 155. Kd3 { 0.00/39 2} Kc6 { +1.48/7 2} 156. Rb1 { 0.00/40 5} Rf1 { +1.44/7 2} 157. Ke3 { 0.00/36 2} Rh1 { +1.27/8 3} 158. Kd3 { 0.00/53 0} Kd7 { +1.20/7 3} 159. Rc1 { 0.00/38 2} Rf1 { +1.18/7 2} 160. Ke3 { 0.00/34 2} Kc7 { +1.15/7 3} 161. Ra1 { 0.00/37 3} Rh1 { +1.09/7 3} 162. Rc1 { 0.00/38 2} Rh3+ { +1.44/8 2} 163. Ke2 { 0.00/42 1} Kb6 { +1.45/9 2} 164. Rb1+ { 0.00/37 8} Kc6 { +1.32/9 3} 165. Rb8 { 0.00/52 0} Kd7 { +1.25/8 2} 166. Rb7+ { 0.00/36 4} Kd8 { +1.24/8 4} 167. Rb8+ { 0.00/40 2} Kc7 { +1.16/8 2} 168. Ra8 { 0.00/55 2} Kd7 { +1.19/7 2} 169. Ra7+ { 0.00/40 2} Kc6 { +1.34/8 2} 170. Ra8 { 0.00/35 0} Rh1 { +1.26/8 2} 171. Rb8 { 0.00/44 2} Kd7 { +1.15/8 2} 172. Rb7+ { 0.00/38 8} Ke8 { +1.10/8 4} 173. Rb8+ { 0.00/39 2} Kd7 { +1.08/8 3} 174. Rb7+ { 0.00/51 2} Kc8 { +0.96/8 2} 175. Rb1 { 0.00/36 2} Rh3 { +0.95/7 2} 176. Rc1 { 0.00/41 2} Kd7 { +0.92/7 3} 177. Ra1 { 0.00/42 1} Ke8 { +0.87/6 3} 178. Ra7 { 0.00/37 2} Kd8 { +0.85/7 2} 179. Kd1 { 0.00/33 2} Rh1 { +0.92/7 2} 180. Ke2 { 0.00/37 3} Ng3+ { +1.03/8 2} 181. Kf2 { 0.00/39 2} Ne4+ { +0.76/10 2} 182. Ke2 { 0.00/56 0} Kc8 { +0.73/8 3} 183. Ra1 { 0.00/37 3} Kd7 { +0.66/6 2} 184. Kd3 { 0.00/37 9} Ke8 { +0.56/6 3} 185. Kc2 { 0.00/33 2} Rf1 { +0.65/7 1} 186. Ra8+ { 0.00/33 2} Kd7 { +0.22/6 3} 187. Ra7+ { 0.00/35 0} Kc6 { +0.09/4 3} 188. Ra6+ { 0.00/43 2} Kb5 { 0.00/2 3 50 moves rule} 1/2-1/2 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "7"] [White "Lc01711261"] [Black "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Result "0-1"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "C99"] [Opening "Spanish"] [Time "11:33:27"] [Variation "Closed, Chigorin, 13...Nc6 14.a3"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "adjudication"] [PlyCount "149"] 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 a6 4. Ba4 Nf6 5. O-O b5 6. Bb3 Be7 7. Re1 O-O 8. c3 d6 9. h3 Na5 10. Bc2 c5 11. d4 Qc7 12. Nbd2 cxd4 { -0.36/26 15} 13. cxd4 { +0.42/8 12} Nc6 { -0.25/28 24} 14. a3 { +0.46/9 21} Bd7 { -0.31/26 15} 15. d5 { +0.49/9 10} Nb8 { -0.20/25 6} 16. b4 { +0.48/9 26} a5 { -0.53/29 31} 17. Rb1 { +0.50/10 8} Rc8 { -0.45/29 9} 18. Bd3 { +0.53/9 9} axb4 { -0.43/28 11} 19. axb4 { +0.53/10 7} Ra4 { -0.31/27 7} 20. Nf1 { +0.48/9 8} Bd8 { -0.29/30 26} 21. Qe2 { +0.47/8 19} Na6 { -0.32/27 21} 22. Bxb5 { +0.56/12 13} Rxb4 { -0.17/27 8} 23. Rxb4 { +0.55/13 4} Nxb4 { -0.12/29 6} 24. Bxd7 { +0.54/12 3} Nxd7 { -0.14/31 8} 25. Be3 { +0.79/9 16} Qa5 { -0.03/26 7} 26. Ng3 { +0.73/10 9} g6 { 0.00/32 7} 27. Rb1 { +0.64/9 7} Qa4 { 0.00/30 2} 28. Qf1 { +0.58/9 21} Nc2 { 0.00/32 8} 29. Bh6 { +0.53/9 5} Nc5 { 0.00/32 15} 30. Nd2 { +0.40/9 20} Be7 { 0.00/28 21} 31. Kh2 { +0.41/10 10} Qe8 { 0.00/26 30} 32. Nc4 { +0.68/9 14} Nd4 { 0.00/30 7} 33. f4 { +0.80/8 9} Rb8 { -0.06/30 10} 34. Rc1 { +0.69/8 11} f6 { -0.03/27 7} 35. f5 { +0.78/8 8} g5 { -0.15/27 19} 36. Ra1 { +1.00/9 8} Rb4 { 0.00/31 3} 37. Ra2 { +0.97/8 13} Qb8 { 0.00/27 6} 38. Na5 { +0.99/12 8} Rb1 { 0.00/27 4} 39. Qc4 { +0.61/16 6} Rb2 { +0.10/28 7} 40. Kh1 { +0.07/11 9} Rxa2 { +0.14/28 4} 41. Qxa2 { -0.08/14 4} Qa8 { +0.01/29 8} 42. Qd2 { -0.19/14 3} Kf7 { 0.00/27 1} 43. Kh2 { -0.33/12 10} Ke8 { +0.20/26 7} 44. Qb4 { -0.26/12 15} Qc8 { +0.07/29 11} 45. Nc4 { +0.12/9 15} Qa6 { +0.22/26 2} 46. Qb8+ { +0.29/10 7} Kf7 { +1.00/24 2} 47. Nd2 { +0.26/12 5} Qd3 { +2.62/27 2} 48. Ndf1 { -1.94/10 9} Nxe4 { +2.83/27 1} 49. Qh8 { -1.68/12 6} Nd2 { +3.06/28 3} 50. Nxd2 { -2.18/14 6} Qxd2 { +3.14/25 1} 51. Kg1 { -2.61/14 7} Qe3+ { +4.50/27 5} 52. Kh2 { -2.44/19 2} Qf2 { +4.77/28 3} 53. h4 { -2.47/17 0} Qf4 { +5.29/27 7} 54. Qxh7+ { -2.72/15 5} Ke8 { +5.29/1} 55. Qh8+ { -2.61/16 7} Kd7 { +6.66/25 3} 56. Qa8 { -3.81/12 3} Qxh4+ { +7.04/24 2} 57. Kg1 { -4.33/10} Bd8 { +7.12/20 1} 58. Bf8 { -5.37/11 9} Bb6 { +7.39/25 3} 59. Qb7+ { -6.26/11 3} Bc7 { +7.45/23 0} 60. Nh1 { -6.37/10 4} Qe1+ { +7.89/25 2} 61. Kh2 { -4.85/8 0} g4 { +7.96/25 0} 62. Qa6 { -6.74/12 13} Qh4+ { +10.53/22 2} 63. Kg1 { -7.26/11 0} g3 { +10.83/22 1} 64. Qa4+ { -7.11/13 7} Kc8 { +12.29/25 2} 65. Qa8+ { -6.62/12 2} Bb8 { +12.95/23 1} 66. Nxg3 { -6.86/10 4} Qxg3 { +20.37/25 7} 67. Kh1 { -7.06/9 2} Qh4+ { +M17/40 3} 68. Kg1 { -8.22/8 0} Ne2+ { +M16/42 1} 69. Kf1 { -5.43/8 0} Ng3+ { +M15/45 4} 70. Kg1 { -8.48/9 12} Qh1+ { +M13/48 3} 71. Kf2 { -5.97/9 0} Ne4+ { +M12/49 1} 72. Ke3 { -8.94/9 7} Qe1+ { +M11/50 5} 73. Kd3 { -9.93/10 1} Qd2+ { +M10/51 2} 74. Kc4 { -10.63/9 1} Qc3+ { +M9/64 4} 75. Kb5 { -11.86/9 0 Arena Adjudication} 0-1 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "8"] [White "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Black "Lc01711261"] [Result "1-0"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "C99"] [Opening "Spanish"] [Time "11:50:27"] [Variation "Closed, Chigorin, 13...Bd7 14.Nf1 Rac8 15.Ne3"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "adjudication"] [PlyCount "128"] 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 a6 4. Ba4 Nf6 5. O-O b5 6. Bb3 Be7 7. Re1 O-O 8. c3 d6 9. h3 Na5 10. Bc2 c5 11. d4 Qc7 12. Nbd2 cxd4 { -0.37/8 23} 13. cxd4 { +0.44/26 16} Bd7 { -0.33/9 19} 14. Nf1 { +0.47/26 12} Rac8 { -0.33/9 7} 15. Ne3 { +0.42/27 19} Nc6 { -0.23/10 9} 16. d5 { +0.56/24 8} Nb4 { -0.27/12 11} 17. Bb1 { +0.58/26 11} a5 { -0.29/11 5} 18. a3 { +0.48/25 1} Na6 { -0.32/10 3} 19. b4 { +0.39/28 16} axb4 { -0.38/9 19} 20. axb4 { +0.44/29 9} Qb7 { -0.36/9 8} 21. Bd2 { +0.47/29 13} Nc7 { -0.34/8 9} 22. Bd3 { +0.36/26 3} Ra8 { -0.32/8 7} 23. Nc2 { +0.37/30 18} h6 { -0.27/7 19} 24. Qe2 { +0.33/24 2} Rfb8 { -0.29/7 23} 25. Rxa8 { +0.31/27 25} Rxa8 { -0.14/7 10} 26. Na1 { +0.32/27 9} Ra3 { -0.18/9 10} 27. Rb1 { +0.25/24 2} Nfe8 { -0.26/10 14} 28. Nc2 { +0.23/29 23} Ra2 { -0.12/7 18} 29. Ne3 { +0.24/27 2} Bd8 { -0.13/7 10} 30. Rc1 { +0.20/27 12} Na6 { -0.10/8 9} 31. Bb1 { +0.21/28 26} Ra4 { -0.12/9 11} 32. Bc2 { +0.34/29 4} Ra3 { -0.11/9 5} 33. Rb1 { +0.28/29 12} Nac7 { -0.13/7 16} 34. Bc1 { +0.23/26 1} Ra8 { -0.15/7 11} 35. Bd3 { +0.22/26 9} Rc8 { -0.15/7 11} 36. g4 { +0.33/25 14} Nf6 { +0.02/7 9} 37. Nf5 { +0.46/25 13} Nce8 { -0.01/8 7} 38. Ra1 { +0.22/27 34} Ra8 { -0.07/9 12} 39. Rxa8 { +0.16/29 8} Qxa8 { -0.09/9 3} 40. Kg2 { +0.16/31 6} Qa4 { -0.07/8 7} 41. Bd2 { +0.16/29 1} Bb6 { -0.08/8 7} 42. Nh2 { +0.35/28 12} Bxf5 { -0.02/9 13} 43. gxf5 { +0.68/26 4} Qa2 { 0.00/15 5} 44. Nf1 { +0.53/29 21} Nc7 { 0.00/15 3} 45. Ng3 { +0.44/32 15} Bd4 { +0.05/7 12} 46. Qd1 { +0.60/28 3} Qa3 { -0.04/9 13} 47. Qc2 { +0.47/27 0} Qa7 { -0.20/11 12} 48. Be1 { +0.56/29 2} Qa1 { -0.15/10 4} 49. Kf1 { +0.56/28 4} Qa3 { +0.02/8 6} 50. Be2 { +1.18/25 2} Na6 { -0.50/12 7} 51. Qc8+ { +0.81/27 10} Kh7 { -0.71/14 5} 52. Qf8 { +0.89/24 0} Nxb4 { -1.21/17 6} 53. Qxf7 { +0.72/30 13} Nc2 { -1.32/10 1} 54. Nh5 { +5.36/27 2} Nxh5 { -2.11/10 2} 55. Qg6+ { +5.66/27 1} Kh8 { -10.41/9 9} 56. Bxh5 { +6.47/29 2} Qa8 { -10.30/9 3} 57. Qxd6 { +6.64/28 1} Nxe1 { -5.84/10 5} 58. f6 { +M29/26 3} Nf3 { -6.66/10 7} 59. fxg7+ { +M8/64 2} Kg8 { -7.17/10 3} 60. Qe6+ { +M7/67 0} Kxg7 { -12.19/10 1} 61. Qf7+ { +M6/74 7} Kh8 { -7.60/10 0} 62. Qf6+ { +M5/80 2} Kg8 { -33.40/7 5} 63. Bf7+ { +M4/85 11} Kf8 { -46.98/6 3} 64. Be6+ { +M3/88 12} Ke8 { -30.02/5 Arena Adjudication} 1-0 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "9"] [White "Lc01711261"] [Black "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Result "1-0"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "D36"] [Opening "QGD"] [Time "12:12:13"] [Variation "Exchange, Main Line, 9.Nf3 Re8 10.O-O Nf8 11.h3"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "adjudication"] [PlyCount "106"] 1. d4 d5 2. c4 c6 3. Nf3 e6 4. cxd5 exd5 5. Nc3 Nf6 6. Bg5 Be7 7. Qc2 Nbd7 8. e3 O-O 9. Bd3 Re8 10. O-O Nf8 11. h3 { +0.55/7 15} Ne4 { -0.30/27 31} 12. Bf4 { +0.65/8 12} f5 { -0.34/27 15} 13. Bh2 { +0.62/7 16} Be6 { -0.31/26 6} 14. Ne5 { +0.79/7 16} Bd6 { -0.15/24 9} 15. f3 { +1.19/10 11} Nxc3 { -0.10/24 2} 16. bxc3 { +1.17/10 6} Nd7 { -0.53/29 16} 17. Bxf5 { +1.08/14 13} Bxf5 { -0.59/28 4} 18. Qxf5 { +1.07/14 7} Bxe5 { -0.39/29 7} 19. dxe5 { +1.36/12 10} g6 { -0.37/26 10} 20. Qb1 { +1.37/12 5} Qb6 { -0.43/27 21} 21. f4 { +1.35/11 4} Qxb1 { -0.39/25 2} 22. Raxb1 { +1.42/10 9} b5 { -0.58/29 29} 23. g4 { +1.49/10 5} a5 { -0.49/28 51} 24. Kg2 { +1.57/9 9} Nc5 { -0.35/27 7} 25. f5 { +1.55/10 8} Kg7 { -0.57/22 2} 26. h4 { +1.56/12 11} gxf5 { -0.66/29 37} 27. gxf5 { +1.63/11 10} Nd3 { -0.75/29 24} 28. e6 { +1.75/12 6} Kf6 { -0.86/22 1} 29. Bd6 { +1.80/10 5} Ne5 { -0.83/26 7} 30. Kh3 { +1.98/11 17} Nc4 { -1.06/29 11} 31. Bc5 { +2.34/14 6} Nd2 { -1.20/27 3} 32. Bd4+ { +2.37/13 5} Ke7 { -1.20/1 0} 33. Kg4 { +2.58/13 3} Rg8+ { 0.00/31 5} 34. Kf4 { +3.13/15 8} h5 { 0.00/34 2} 35. Rg1 { +3.31/17 6} Nxb1 { -0.89/36 47} 36. Bc5+ { +3.53/16 2} Kf6 { -4.26/26 8} 37. Rg5 { +3.62/16 1} Nd2 { -5.10/29 11} 38. Rxh5 { +3.99/14 4} Ne4 { -6.12/32 12} 39. Bd4+ { +5.30/13 7} Ke7 { -6.13/1} 40. Rh7+ { +5.73/12 3} Kd8 { -6.40/32 6} 41. f6 { +7.60/11 8} Nxf6 { -6.53/29 1} 42. Bxf6+ { +9.61/9 10} Kc8 { -7.53/32 8} 43. h5 { +9.62/9 8} Re8 { -7.64/23 0} 44. Kf5 { +9.37/9 6} c5 { -8.29/30 14} 45. h6 { +9.82/9 12} b4 { -9.67/30 7} 46. Rg7 { +10.27/9 6} bxc3 { -8.00/21 1} 47. Bxc3 { +11.00/9 8} d4 { -11.53/25 5} 48. exd4 { +11.69/9 9} cxd4 { -13.64/23 3} 49. Bxd4 { +11.59/9 6} Rxe6 { -4.99/23 1} 50. Kxe6 { +13.90/8 9} Ra6+ { -5.36/22 0} 51. Kd5 { +13.33/7 9} Rxh6 { -57.51/38 6} 52. Bc5 { +14.54/7 8} Ra6 { -62.46/27 3} 53. a4 { +15.59/6 14} Kd8 { -M37/30 3 Arena Adjudication} 1-0 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "10"] [White "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Black "Lc01711261"] [Result "1-0"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "D36"] [Opening "QGD"] [Time "12:26:18"] [Variation "Exchange, Main Line, 9.Nf3 Re8 10.O-O Nf8 11.Rae1"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "adjudication"] [PlyCount "94"] 1. d4 d5 2. c4 c6 3. Nf3 e6 4. cxd5 exd5 5. Nc3 Nf6 6. Bg5 Be7 7. Qc2 Nbd7 8. e3 O-O 9. Bd3 Re8 10. O-O Nf8 11. Rae1 { +0.32/26 16} Ne4 { -0.34/8 24} 12. Bxe7 { +0.29/26 10} Qxe7 { -0.32/11 8} 13. Bxe4 { +0.33/27 9} dxe4 { -0.29/12 7} 14. Nd2 { +0.41/29 37} f5 { -0.26/11 4} 15. f3 { +0.42/28 6} exf3 { -0.25/11 5} 16. Nxf3 { +0.25/24 2} Be6 { -0.23/9 4} 17. e4 { +0.20/26 12} fxe4 { -0.21/9 6} 18. Rxe4 { +0.10/28 11} Qd6 { -0.29/8 22} 19. Rfe1 { +0.01/27 3} Re7 { -0.29/9 10} 20. R4e3 { +0.12/24 5} Rae8 { -0.48/9 15} 21. Ne4 { +0.07/26 2} Qd7 { -0.41/12 10} 22. Nc5 { +0.33/28 26} Qd6 { -0.39/11 6} 23. Qc3 { +0.18/31 39} h6 { -0.36/8 14} 24. Ne4 { +0.73/25 4} Qd5 { -0.43/8 14} 25. Qc5 { +0.54/30 18} Qxa2 { +0.10/9 10} 26. Nd6 { +0.10/30 14} Rd8 { -0.28/12 12} 27. Nf5 { +0.39/27 9} Rf7 { -0.48/16 7} 28. Ne7+ { +0.61/23 4} Kh8 { -0.74/16 3} 29. Ne5 { +0.45/23 1} Rf6 { -0.83/15 2} 30. Qc2 { +0.72/27 13} Bf7 { -0.90/15 2} 31. d5 { +0.28/26 14} Qa5 { -0.37/13 9} 32. Ng4 { +0.29/29 13} Rf4 { +0.88/10 10} 33. g3 { +0.11/28 2} Rf3 { -0.14/13 13} 34. Ne5 { +1.05/24 4} Rf6 { -0.11/15 5} 35. dxc6 { +1.18/24 1} Rd2 { -0.14/18 6} 36. Qc1 { +1.38/28 8} Rff2 { -2.22/12 13} 37. Nxf7+ { +1.54/27 8} Kh7 { -1.91/17 7} 38. Qb1+ { +1.47/27 1} g6 { -1.98/18 2} 39. Qe4 { +1.74/26 12} Qc5 { -1.29/14 18} 40. c7 { +2.27/25 9} Qxc7 { -2.03/11 10} 41. Rf1 { +2.27/25 6} Rxf1+ { -2.21/12 5} 42. Kxf1 { +2.27/1} Rxh2 { -1.84/13 7} 43. b3 { +2.57/25 5} Ra2 { -3.48/9 16} 44. Qf3 { +11.62/25 6} Ra1+ { -7.33/9 16} 45. Kg2 { +12.64/27 3} Ra2+ { -9.90/9 14} 46. Kh3 { +13.10/26 1} Qd7+ { -11.54/8 11} 47. g4 { +14.01/28 3} Kg7 { -13.02/8 13 Arena Adjudication} 1-0 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "11"] [White "Lc01711261"] [Black "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "D85"] [Opening "Grünfeld"] [Time "12:38:48"] [Variation "Modern Exchange, 8.Rb1 O-O 9.Be2 cd 10.cd"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "adjudication"] [PlyCount "186"] 1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 d5 4. cxd5 Nxd5 5. e4 Nxc3 6. bxc3 Bg7 7. Nf3 c5 8. Rb1 O-O 9. Be2 cxd4 10. cxd4 Bg4 { -0.50/27 15} 11. Be3 { +0.87/10 15} Qa5+ { -0.20/25 4} 12. Qd2 { +1.10/12 11} Nc6 { -0.27/24 2} 13. Qxa5 { +1.11/13 6} Nxa5 { -0.42/28 13} 14. O-O { +1.14/12 4} b6 { -0.35/28 9} 15. h3 { +1.34/9 13} Bxf3 { -0.48/27 10} 16. gxf3 { +1.46/9 11} Rfd8 { -0.49/27 8} 17. d5 { +1.44/9 8} Nb7 { -0.52/26 2} 18. Rfc1 { +1.43/9 15} Be5 { -0.33/27 8} 19. Rc6 { +1.69/9 21} Bd6 { -0.33/29 11} 20. f4 { +1.47/9 10} Na5 { -0.36/32 28} 21. Rcc1 { +1.65/10 19} Nb7 { -0.42/32 12} 22. Rc6 { +1.63/12 7} Na5 { 0.00/41 7} 23. Rc2 { +1.65/12 5} Rac8 { -0.46/34 16} 24. Rbc1 { +1.54/12 8} Rxc2 { -0.42/30 15} 25. Rxc2 { +1.53/12 3} f6 { -0.47/31 11} 26. Kg2 { +1.59/8 15} Nb7 { -0.33/28 5} 27. Rc6 { +1.46/8 13} Nc5 { -0.40/32 40} 28. f3 { +1.43/8 9} Kg7 { -0.40/30 6} 29. Kf2 { +1.44/7 22} Nb7 { -0.33/30 10} 30. Ba6 { +1.52/8 20} Nc5 { -0.32/35 7} 31. Bb5 { +1.53/7 9} Nb7 { -0.32/33 10} 32. h4 { +1.58/7 10} Na5 { -0.31/28 1} 33. Rc1 { +1.59/8 9} Nb7 { -0.31/33 19} 34. Ke2 { +1.57/8 7} h5 { -0.31/32 1} 35. Rg1 { +1.63/8 11} Kf7 { -0.31/32 6} 36. Bd3 { +1.57/8 9} Nc5 { -0.24/30 4} 37. Bc2 { +1.51/8 6} Rg8 { -0.24/35 7} 38. Rg2 { +1.43/7 17} Rg7 { -0.24/33 7} 39. Rg3 { +1.50/7 15} Rg8 { -0.33/31 12} 40. Rg1 { +1.47/7 7} Rg7 { -0.30/33 10} 41. Rg2 { +1.44/7 14} Rg8 { -0.24/29 5} 42. Rg1 { +1.41/7 11} Rg7 { 0.00/47 3} 43. a4 { +1.36/7 11} Nb7 { -0.40/33 16} 44. Bd3 { +1.43/7 11} Rg8 { -0.42/31 2} 45. Bb5 { +1.42/7 8} Rd8 { -0.31/31 4} 46. Bd3 { +1.29/8 13} Rg8 { 0.00/41 3} 47. Rc1 { +1.28/7 8} Nc5 { -0.30/32 17} 48. Bb5 { +1.33/7 4} Rd8 { -0.42/33 10} 49. Rb1 { +1.28/7 8} Nb7 { -0.44/33 5} 50. Rg1 { +1.31/7 3} Na5 { -0.44/32 2} 51. Bd3 { +1.69/7 2} Rg8 { -0.43/32 5} 52. Bb5 { +1.53/7 3} Rd8 { 0.00/42 6} 53. Ba6 { +1.39/7 3} Nb3 { -0.20/31 14} 54. Bd3 { +1.45/8 1} Nc5 { -0.20/31 4} 55. Bc2 { +1.41/8 2} Rg8 { -0.32/25 1} 56. a5 { +1.32/7 3} Na6 { -0.24/25 3} 57. axb6 { +1.20/8 1} axb6 { -0.36/27 5} 58. Rb1 { +1.14/7 5} Rb8 { -0.38/29 7} 59. Ba4 { +1.30/6 3} Nc7 { -0.23/25 2} 60. Bb3 { +1.26/6 2} b5 { -0.19/25 0} 61. Rc1 { +1.17/7 3} Kg7 { -0.28/27 17} 62. Rc6 { +1.10/6 1} b4 { -0.13/27 2} 63. Kd3 { +1.00/7 2} Nb5 { -0.13/30 10} 64. Kc4 { +0.86/7 4} Na3+ { -0.13/32 1} 65. Kd4 { +1.05/8 2} Rb7 { -0.11/33 5} 66. Kd3 { +1.11/7 3} Nb5 { -0.11/33 5} 67. Ra6 { +0.98/6 3} Rc7 { 0.00/31 1} 68. Rc6 { +0.99/7 1} Rb7 { 0.00/45 3} 69. Rc8 { +0.79/6 3} Na3 { -0.07/30 2} 70. Rc1 { +0.92/7 3} Nb5 { -0.04/30 1} 71. Rc6 { +0.84/6 2} Rb8 { 0.00/41 2} 72. Bc5 { +0.82/7 2} g5 { 0.00/27 5} 73. hxg5 { +0.92/9 3} fxg5 { -0.02/29 3} 74. fxg5 { +0.77/10 2} h4 { 0.00/28 2} 75. Bxd6 { +0.71/9 1} exd6 { 0.00/29 0} 76. Rc2 { +0.06/9 4} h3 { 0.00/29 2} 77. f4 { -0.34/10 3} Rh8 { 0.00/30 0} 78. Rc1 { -0.22/12 1} h2 { +0.08/29 3} 79. Rh1 { -0.20/12 1} Rc8 { 0.00/23 0} 80. Ba4 { +0.01/12 2} b3 { +0.66/24 2} 81. Bxb3 { -1.58/10 4} Rc3+ { +0.67/23 0} 82. Ke2 { -1.36/11 1} Rxb3 { +0.69/29 4} 83. Kf2 { -1.24/10 1} Nc3 { +0.70/31 3} 84. e5 { -1.06/9 2} dxe5 { +0.70/32 1} 85. fxe5 { -0.94/9 2} Nxd5 { +0.70/36 8} 86. Rxh2 { -0.78/7 3} Kg6 { +0.70/32 0} 87. e6 { -0.76/6 5} Kxg5 { +0.70/36 2} 88. Rh7 { -0.80/6 3} Kf6 { +0.71/31 2} 89. e7 { -0.75/5 4} Nxe7 { +0.71/32 0} 90. Ke2 { -0.83/5 3} Ra3 { +0.71/36 11} 91. Rh1 { -0.83/5 2} Nf5 { +0.71/37 2} 92. Rh8 { -0.84/5 2} Ke6 { +0.71/34 3} 93. Kd2 { -0.84/5 3} Ke5 { +0.71/38 2 User Adjudication} 1/2-1/2 [Event "Lc0server11261Stockfish8Nunn_5mas3HT6CPU1024"] [Site "J-PC"] [Date "2018.09.13"] [Round "12"] [White "Stockfish_8_x64_bmi2"] [Black "Lc01711261"] [Result "1-0"] [BlackElo "2200"] [ECO "D85"] [Opening "Grünfeld"] [Time "12:58:30"] [Variation "Modern Exchange, 8.Rb1 O-O 9.Be2 cd 10.cd Qa5+ 11.Qd2"] [WhiteElo "2200"] [TimeControl "300+3"] [Termination "adjudication"] [PlyCount "146"] 1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 d5 4. cxd5 Nxd5 5. e4 Nxc3 6. bxc3 Bg7 7. Nf3 c5 8. Rb1 O-O 9. Be2 cxd4 10. cxd4 Qa5+ { -0.37/10 12} 11. Qd2 { +0.23/27 22} Qxd2+ { -0.21/10 10} 12. Bxd2 { +0.12/31 14} b6 { -0.16/10 7} 13. O-O { +0.19/29 2} Bb7 { -0.24/11 24} 14. d5 { +0.04/31 13} Ba6 { -0.25/11 4} 15. Rfe1 { +0.12/29 2} Bxe2 { -0.22/10 4} 16. Rxe2 { 0.00/31 10} Na6 { -0.21/9 7} 17. Bg5 { 0.00/30 8} Rfe8 { -0.24/9 11} 18. Rd1 { +0.13/31 24} Nc5 { -0.27/9 18} 19. Nd4 { +0.13/32 13} f6 { -0.13/11 9} 20. Bh4 { +0.15/29 9} Rad8 { -0.14/9 14} 21. Nc6 { +0.23/28 7} Rd7 { -0.19/10 10} 22. f4 { +0.30/29 6} Rc8 { -0.02/10 12} 23. Ree1 { +0.32/25 11} Bf8 { +0.02/13 7} 24. Rd4 { +0.25/28 15} h6 { -0.49/8 16} 25. f5 { +0.34/22 5} gxf5 { -0.26/9 10} 26. exf5 { +0.17/23 5} h5 { -0.24/9 6} 27. Bg3 { +0.23/25 9} Kf7 { -0.15/8 8} 28. Kf1 { +0.08/29 30} b5 { -0.14/10 11} 29. Rc1 { +0.02/30 9} Na4 { -0.12/14 7} 30. Rb4 { +0.04/29 2} Rxd5 { -0.17/14 5} 31. Ne5+ { +0.24/27 7} Rxe5 { -0.16/14 3} 32. Rxc8 { +0.31/26 2} Rxf5+ { -0.19/13 1} 33. Rf4 { +0.28/28 14} Rd5 { -0.21/10 2} 34. Be1 { +0.12/23 1} Nb6 { -0.32/11 11} 35. Rc7 { +0.48/25 5} a6 { -0.30/10 5} 36. Ra7 { +0.43/25 3} Rc5 { -0.38/11 14} 37. Rxa6 { +0.59/26 16} Nd5 { -0.38/11 5} 38. Re4 { +0.57/25 1} Rc1 { -0.32/9 20} 39. Ra5 { +0.59/26 8} Rb1 { -0.53/10 18} 40. Ke2 { +0.49/23 2} e5 { -0.67/11 13} 41. Kd3 { +0.46/28 27} Ke6 { -0.86/13 6} 42. Kc2 { +0.91/23 3} Ra1 { -0.94/14 3} 43. Kb2 { +0.76/24 2} Rd1 { -1.01/13 2} 44. Rxb5 { +1.00/26 15} Bh6 { -1.11/11 5} 45. Bb4 { +0.94/26 11} Nxb4 { -1.14/11 6} 46. Rexb4 { +1.00/27 15} Rg1 { -1.15/11 11} 47. Rh4 { +1.06/28 23} Rxg2+ { -1.07/11 9} 48. Kb3 { +1.26/27 4} Bg5 { -1.19/12 4} 49. Rxh5 { +1.19/27 8} e4 { -1.18/14 1} 50. h4 { +1.26/25 0} Rh2 { -0.86/15 5} 51. Rb6+ { +1.14/24 7} Kf7 { -1.86/10 9} 52. a4 { +1.12/27 11} e3 { -2.03/12 11} 53. Rh7+ { +1.39/26 3} Kg6 { -2.05/14 3} 54. Re7 { +1.25/27 1} Rxh4 { -1.98/13 3} 55. a5 { +1.03/29 8} Rh1 { -1.97/12 2} 56. Re4 { +1.19/24 0} Kf5 { -1.28/8 12} 57. Rbb4 { +1.09/28 9} Rh8 { -1.13/14 7} 58. Ra4 { +2.01/26 2} Ra8 { -1.12/17 4} 59. Re7 { +2.27/26 2} Bf4 { -1.15/16 2} 60. Kc2 { +2.79/24 3} Rd8 { -1.33/14 3} 61. Ree4 { +3.37/24 2} Rd2+ { -1.52/11 1} 62. Kc1 { +3.51/23 0} Bg5 { -5.27/10 14} 63. a6 { +4.50/25 2} Rd3 { -6.15/9 12} 64. Kc2 { +5.17/28 6} Rd2+ { -7.42/9 8} 65. Kc3 { +5.39/29 6} Rd7 { -7.93/9 6} 66. Re8 { +5.43/27 1} Ra7 { -8.70/9 8} 67. Kd3 { +5.50/29 2} Bf4 { -9.77/8 10} 68. Ree4 { +5.50/30 0} Bg5 { -7.79/6 3} 69. Reb4 { +9.14/25 2} Rd7+ { -8.42/6 2} 70. Ke2 { +45.70/27 12} Rd2+ { -8.95/7 2} 71. Ke1 { +46.10/28 3} Rh2 { -10.73/6 3} 72. a7 { +114.89/22 2} Rh1+ { -13.68/6 2} 73. Ke2 { +51.55/1} Rh2 { -12.99/6 2 Arena Adjudication} 1-0 [/pgn]