A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

User avatar
xr_a_y
Posts: 1871
Joined: Sat Nov 25, 2017 2:28 pm
Location: France

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by xr_a_y »

MikeB wrote: Mon Jan 07, 2019 3:51 pm Keep up the good work!
Wow thanks for those games !
User avatar
xr_a_y
Posts: 1871
Joined: Sat Nov 25, 2017 2:28 pm
Location: France

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by xr_a_y »

Wow in the second game, Minic is totally blind to the king side attack in preparation at move 26 (and 27)... some king safety evaluation too be added !

Code: Select all

# FEN 2rq1rk1/3bppb1/2p5/1pNnPPp1/p1pP2P1/P1P2QB1/1P6/4RRK1 b - - 0 26
#
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: msecPerMove     86400000
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: msecInTC        -1
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: msecInc         -1
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: nbMoveInTC      -1
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: msecUntilNextTC -1
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: currentNbMoves  26
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: Search Sync
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: Wait for workers to be ready
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: ...ok
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: Calling main thread search
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: Search launched 0
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: Search called
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: requested time  86400000
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: requested depth 40
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: Init stat
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: Init killers
# Info  2019-01-07 20:36:33-361: Init history
1 329 0 103 8 102 0	f8e8  EBF: 103
2 318 0 509 11 508 0	d7e8 c5e4  EBF: 4.94175
3 309 0 1172 12 390 0	d7e8 c5e4 e7e6  EBF: 2.30255
4 274 0 2468 16 308 0	d5c7 c5d7 d8d7 f5f6  EBF: 2.1058
5 274 0 3031 16 336 0	d5c7 c5d7 d8d7 f5f6 e7f6  EBF: 1.22812
6 272 1 6732 16 354 0	g8h7 f3h1 g7h6 h1h3 e7e6 f5e6 d7e6  EBF: 2.22105
7 259 2 9120 17 364 0	g8h7 f3h1 g7h6 h1h3 e7e6 c5d7 d8d7 f5f6  EBF: 1.35472
8 244 6 23976 18 363 1	c8a8 f3h1 d5f4 g3f4 g5f4 h1h5 a8c8 c5d7  EBF: 2.62895
9 287 12 49124 19 386 2	g7h6 f3h1 g8g7 e5e6 d7e8 e6f7 e8f7 g3e5 d5f6 h1f3  EBF: 2.04888
10 250 22 91005 21 404 4	g7h6 f3h1 g8g7 f5f6 e7f6 e5f6 g7h7 h1h5 d7e8 g3e5 e8d7 c5d7  EBF: 1.85256
11 242 41 182850 24 437 8	c8a8 e5e6 d7c8 f3e4 a8a5 g3f2 d8c7 e6f7 f8f7 c5e6 c8e6 f5e6  EBF: 2.00923
12 230 65 318256 24 488 13	c8a8 e5e6 d7c8 f3e4 d8e8 f1f2 g7f6 f2f1 e8d8 g3e5 f6e5 d4e5 f7e6  EBF: 1.74053
13 230 129 733920 27 568 24	c8a8 e5e6 d7c8 f3e4 d8e8 f1f2 g7f6 f2f1 e8d8 g3e5 f6e5 d4e5 f7e6  EBF: 2.30607
14 230 171 996764 27 581 32	c8a8 e5e6 d7c8 f3e4 d8e8 f1f2 f7f6 e4f3 e8d8 e1d1 f8e8 f3e2 d8b6 c5d7  EBF: 1.35814
15 218 543 3662240 31 674 149	d7e8 f3f2 d8b6 f2h2 b6a5 h2d2 f7f6 c5e6 f8f7 e6g7 g8g7 e5e6 f7f8 e1d1 c8d8 d2f2 a5b6 f1e1 g7h7 f2h2 h7g7 h2f2  EBF: 3.67413
16 218 585 4024164 32 687 163	d7e8 f3f2 d8b6 f2h2 b6a5 h2d2 f7f6 c5e6 f8f7 e6g7 g8g7 e5e6 f7f8 e1d1 c8d8 f1e1  EBF: 1.09883
17 220 1051 7651881 34 728 342	d7e8 f3f2 d8b6 f2d2 f7f6 d2h2 b6a5 c5e6 f8f7 e6g7 g8g7 e5e6 f7f8 h2f2 a5b6 f2f3 g7g8 f1f2  EBF: 1.90148
18 206 1664 12747585 36 765 596	d7e8 f3f2 c8a8 f2h2 d8b6 h2d2 f7f6 c5e6 f8f7 d2h2 g7f8 e6f8 f7f8 h2h6 a8d8 e5e6 c6c5 g3f2 c5d4 f2d4 b6c7 f1f2  EBF: 1.66594
19 204 3030 24080715 37 794 1063	d7e8 f3f2 c8a8 f2h2 d8b6 h2d2 f7f6 c5e6 f8f7 d2h2 g7f8 e6f8 f7f8 h2h6 a8d8 e5e6 c6c5 g3f2 c5d4  EBF: 1.88904
20 205 3566 28427379 38 796 1249	d7e8 f3f2 c8a8 f2h2 e8d7 c5e4 f7f6 e5e6 d7c8 e4c5 d8e8 h2g2 a8a7 g2h2 d5b6 h2h3 c8b7 f1f2 e8c8 c5b7 a7b7 h3h5  EBF: 1.1805
User avatar
CMCanavessi
Posts: 1142
Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2017 4:06 pm
Location: Argentina

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by CMCanavessi »

I'm running a little tournament (5 x double round robin) with Minic 0.29 as one of the 12 competing engines, will report results when more games have been played, it just started:

Code: Select all

    Engine                    Score AsRoJuFrPhScFrKiNeEmMiWy    S-B
01: Asymptote v0.3 x64        3.5/4 · =       1       1   1    2,00
02: RomiChess P3n x64         2.0/3 = ·         =     1        2,25
03: Jumbo 0.6.64 x64          2.0/2     ·   1     1            2,00
04: Francesca M.A.D. 0.19 x32 2.0/3       · = =         1      1,00
05: Pharaon 3.5.1 x32         1.0/3     0 = · =                1,50
05: Schooner v1.8 x64         1.0/3 0     = = ·                1,50
07: FrankWalter 2.2.8 x64     1.0/2   =         ·   =          1,25
08: Kingfisher v1.1 x64       1.0/2     0         · 1          0,50
09: Nemeton 1.8 x32           0.5/2             = 0 ·          0,50
10: Embla 2.0.5 x64           0.0/2 0 0               ·        0,00
10: Minic 0.29 x64            0.0/1       0             ·      0,00
10: WyldChess 1.51 x64        0.0/1 0                     ·    0,00

14 of 528 games played
Name of the tournament: 189 - Qualy League
Depending on the performance of these engines (which were NOT in my rating list, except RomiChess, Pharaon, Schooner and Wyldchess) I may include some in my next leagues season.
Follow my tournament and some Leela gauntlets live at http://twitch.tv/ccls
User avatar
xr_a_y
Posts: 1871
Joined: Sat Nov 25, 2017 2:28 pm
Location: France

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by xr_a_y »

That's great, thanks.
User avatar
CMCanavessi
Posts: 1142
Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2017 4:06 pm
Location: Argentina

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by CMCanavessi »

Tough competition!!

Code: Select all

    Engine                    Score    Ph  Wy  Sc  Ju  As  Ne  Fr  Fr  Ki  Ro  Mi  Em    S-B
01: Pharaon 3.5.1 x32         23.0/29 ··· 01  =11 011 111 111 =01 01  =1= 11  111 11   311,50
02: WyldChess 1.51 x64        20.0/29 10  ··· ==  011 011 =11 111 ==  =1  === === 111  258,75
03: Schooner v1.8 x64         19.0/29 =00 ==  ··· 1== 010 11  =10 1=1 111 =1  011 11   245,25
04: Jumbo 0.6.64 x64          17.5/29 100 100 0== ··· 1=  10  =1  1=0 101 1=1 1=  111  213,25
05: Asymptote v0.3 x64        16.0/29 000 100 101 0=  ··· 000 11  10  11  =01 111 111  182,25
06: Nemeton 1.8 x32           16.0/29 000 =00 00  01  111 ··· 10  =0= 01= 111 11  111  176,75
07: Francesca M.A.D. 0.19 x32 15.0/29 =10 000 =01 =0  00  01  ··· =11 =1= 11  100 111  180,50
08: FrankWalter 2.2.8 x64     14.5/29 10  ==  0=0 0=1 01  =1= =00 ··· 10  =10 =10 111  178,75
09: Kingfisher v1.1 x64       11.5/29 =0= =0  000 010 00  10= =0= 01  ··· 1=0 101 11   141,50
10: RomiChess P3n x64         11.0/29 00  === =0  0=0 =10 000 00  =01 0=1 ··· 10  111  122,75
11: Minic 0.29 x64            10.0/29 000 === 100 0=  000 00  011 =01 010 01  ··· =1   132,75
12: Embla 2.0.5 x64           0.5/29  00  000 00  000 000 000 000 000 00  000 =0  ···    5,00

174 of 528 games played
Name of the tournament: 189 - Qualy League
So far, 3 draws vs WyldChess and a win vs. Schooner are the best games.

Currently at 2337 elo in my rating list

Code: Select all

 213 Nemeton 1.7 x32                          :  2355.0     216  107   39   70    59    18  2280.8    50    48.3
 214 Myrddin 0.87 x64                         :  2354.0     414  172   72  170    50    17  2363.7    87    72.1
 215 Bumblebee 1.0.36898e1 x64                :  2348.8     588  149   83  356    32    14  2512.7   157   131.8
 216 Zevra v2.0 r172 x64                      :  2338.1     209   96   38   75    55    18  2291.6    48    46.3
 217 Minic 0.29 x64                           :  2337.1      28    7    5   16    34    18  2460.7    11    10.8
 218 Galjoen 0.38 x64                         :  2331.6     338  129   74  135    49    22  2364.5    89    70.6
 219 Absolute Zero 2.4.7.2 x64                :  2318.8     528  128   72  328    31    14  2507.4   158   138.4
 220 Sungorus 1.4 x64                         :  2316.2     362  124   73  165    44    20  2378.8    86    73.9
 221 Dimitri 3.93 x32                         :  2308.6     388  140   63  185    44    16  2367.8   123   110.7
Follow my tournament and some Leela gauntlets live at http://twitch.tv/ccls
User avatar
xr_a_y
Posts: 1871
Joined: Sat Nov 25, 2017 2:28 pm
Location: France

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by xr_a_y »

Many good opponents ! What is TC used ?
ljgw
Posts: 68
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:23 am
Full name: Laurens Winkelhagen

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by ljgw »

CMCanavessi wrote: Tue Jan 08, 2019 1:03 pm Tough competition!!

Code: Select all

    Engine                    Score    Ph  Wy  Sc  Ju  As  Ne  Fr  Fr  Ki  Ro  Mi  Em    S-B
01: Pharaon 3.5.1 x32         23.0/29 ··· 01  =11 011 111 111 =01 01  =1= 11  111 11   311,50
02: WyldChess 1.51 x64        20.0/29 10  ··· ==  011 011 =11 111 ==  =1  === === 111  258,75
03: Schooner v1.8 x64         19.0/29 =00 ==  ··· 1== 010 11  =10 1=1 111 =1  011 11   245,25
04: Jumbo 0.6.64 x64          17.5/29 100 100 0== ··· 1=  10  =1  1=0 101 1=1 1=  111  213,25
05: Asymptote v0.3 x64        16.0/29 000 100 101 0=  ··· 000 11  10  11  =01 111 111  182,25
06: Nemeton 1.8 x32           16.0/29 000 =00 00  01  111 ··· 10  =0= 01= 111 11  111  176,75
07: Francesca M.A.D. 0.19 x32 15.0/29 =10 000 =01 =0  00  01  ··· =11 =1= 11  100 111  180,50
08: FrankWalter 2.2.8 x64     14.5/29 10  ==  0=0 0=1 01  =1= =00 ··· 10  =10 =10 111  178,75
09: Kingfisher v1.1 x64       11.5/29 =0= =0  000 010 00  10= =0= 01  ··· 1=0 101 11   141,50
10: RomiChess P3n x64         11.0/29 00  === =0  0=0 =10 000 00  =01 0=1 ··· 10  111  122,75
11: Minic 0.29 x64            10.0/29 000 === 100 0=  000 00  011 =01 010 01  ··· =1   132,75
12: Embla 2.0.5 x64           0.5/29  00  000 00  000 000 000 000 000 00  000 =0  ···    5,00

174 of 528 games played
Name of the tournament: 189 - Qualy League
So far, 3 draws vs WyldChess and a win vs. Schooner are the best games.

Currently at 2337 elo in my rating list

Code: Select all

 213 Nemeton 1.7 x32                          :  2355.0     216  107   39   70    59    18  2280.8    50    48.3
 214 Myrddin 0.87 x64                         :  2354.0     414  172   72  170    50    17  2363.7    87    72.1
 215 Bumblebee 1.0.36898e1 x64                :  2348.8     588  149   83  356    32    14  2512.7   157   131.8
 216 Zevra v2.0 r172 x64                      :  2338.1     209   96   38   75    55    18  2291.6    48    46.3
 217 Minic 0.29 x64                           :  2337.1      28    7    5   16    34    18  2460.7    11    10.8
 218 Galjoen 0.38 x64                         :  2331.6     338  129   74  135    49    22  2364.5    89    70.6
 219 Absolute Zero 2.4.7.2 x64                :  2318.8     528  128   72  328    31    14  2507.4   158   138.4
 220 Sungorus 1.4 x64                         :  2316.2     362  124   73  165    44    20  2378.8    86    73.9
 221 Dimitri 3.93 x32                         :  2308.6     388  140   63  185    44    16  2367.8   123   110.7
Great to see FrankWalter complete here at this level, thanks for including him:-)

--Laurens
Author of JanWillem (C, WB, inactive) and FrankWalter (Java, WB, https://github.com/ljgw/frankwalter)
User avatar
CMCanavessi
Posts: 1142
Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2017 4:06 pm
Location: Argentina

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by CMCanavessi »

TC is 1 minute + 1 second, ponder is ON for engines that support it, 1 thread, 2 move book, random openings with NO reverse games.

Updated standings and ratings:

Code: Select all

    Engine                    Score      Ph    Wy    Ju    Sc    As    Fr    Fr    Ro    Ne    Mi    Ki    Em    S-B
01: Pharaon 3.5.1 x32         36.5/48 ····· 011=  0110= =110  111=  0110  =0111 11==  11111 11111 =1=1  1111   789,75
02: WyldChess 1.51 x64        32.5/48 100=  ····· 0111  ===1  011== ===1  111=  ===== =11=1 ===1  =110  11111  694,00
03: Jumbo 0.6.64 x64          31.5/48 1001= 1000  ····· 0==1= 1===  1=01= =111  1=10  1011  1=11  1011= 1111   677,25
04: Schooner v1.8 x64         30.5/48 =001  ===0  1==0= ····· 010=1 1=1=  =1010 =111  1111  01110 111=  1101   668,75
05: Asymptote v0.3 x64        28.0/48 000=  100== 0===  101=0 ····· 10=0  111=  =010  0001  11111 1111  11111  548,00
06: FrankWalter 2.2.8 x64     24.5/48 1001  ===0  0=10= 0=0=  01=1  ····· =00=  =1000 =1==0 =101  1011  11111  502,00
07: Francesca M.A.D. 0.19 x32 24.0/48 =1000 000=  =000  =0101 000=  =11=  ····· 11==  01=1  1001= =1==1 1111   482,75
08: RomiChess P3n x64         22.0/48 00==  ===== 0=01  =000  =101  =0111 00==  ····· 000=  1000  0=1=1 11111  449,50
09: Nemeton 1.8 x32           22.0/48 00000 =00=0 0100  0000  1110  =0==1 10=0  111=  ····· 1110  01=01 1111   425,25
10: Minic 0.29 x64            17.5/48 00000 ===0  0=00  10001 00000 =010  0110= 0111  0001  ····· 0101  =111   351,25
11: Kingfisher v1.1 x64       17.0/48 =0=0  =001  0100= 000=  0000  0100  =0==0 1=0=0 10=10 1010  ····· 11=1   349,25
12: Embla 2.0.5 x64           2.0/48  0000  00000 0000  0010  00000 00000 0000  00000 0000  =000  00=0  ·····   47,75

288 of 528 games played
Name of the tournament: 189 - Qualy League

Code: Select all

 192 Asymptote v0.3 x64                       :  2522.3      48   23   10   15    58    21  2439.1    11    10.9
 193 Dimitri 4.00 x32                         :  2503.4     334   90   60  184    36    18  2626.7   104    84.0
 194 Coiled 0.4 x64                           :  2491.7     367  115   76  176    42    21  2571.3   105    91.3
 195 Monolith 0.3 x64                         :  2479.2     342  144   72  126    53    21  2418.7    91    74.2
>196 FrankWalter 2.2.8 x64                    :  2476.7      54   21   15   18    53    28  2441.4    11    10.3
 197 Francesca M.A.D. 0.19 x32                :  2462.3      48   17   14   17    50    29  2450.3    11    10.9
 198 Fruit 1.5 x32                            :  2460.1     340  144   68  128    52    20  2441.1    46    42.5
 199 Betsabe II 1.84 x32                      :  2454.6     436  133   63  240    38    14  2564.2   109    88.2
 200 Orion 0.5 x64                            :  2445.0     348   79   56  213    31    16  2618.7   107    86.9
 201 Nemeton 1.8 x32                          :  2442.6     312  169   55   88    63    18  2336.4    50    48.7
 202 RubiChess 0.8.1 x64                      :  2439.6     232  103   40   89    53    17  2418.8    83    72.5
 203 Betsabe II 1.75 x32                      :  2438.0     306  133   46  127    51    15  2406.6   108    97.8
 204 RomiChess P3n x64                        :  2425.3     562  160  127  275    40    23  2508.7   163   140.3
 205 Topple v0.2.0 x64                        :  2412.7     348   71   49  228    27    14  2619.7   107    86.9
 206 Galjoen 0.39.2 x64                       :  2406.3     256   74   58  124    40    23  2494.3    71    64.1
 207 Zevra v2.1.1 r216 x64                    :  2375.2     208   79   38   91    47    18  2398.2    52    52.0
 208 Fruit 1.0 x32                            :  2371.4     242  119   41   82    58    17  2313.3    40    37.2
 209 Orion 0.4 x64                            :  2370.4     442  169   74  199    47    17  2394.5   125   110.0
>210 Minic 0.29 x64                           :  2363.6      48   14    7   27    36    15  2464.2    11    10.9
 211 MadChess 2.2 x64                         :  2362.7     590  151   96  343    34    16  2511.6   157   131.7
 212 Nemeton 1.61 x32                         :  2361.3     576  152   80  344    33    14  2514.3   154   128.8
 213 Nemeton 1.7 x32                          :  2354.3     216  107   39   70    59    18  2280.1    50    48.3
 214 Myrddin 0.87 x64                         :  2353.6     416  173   72  171    50    17  2363.1    87    72.1
 215 Kingfisher v1.1 x64                      :  2348.4      54   11   16   27    35    30  2459.6    11    10.3
Follow my tournament and some Leela gauntlets live at http://twitch.tv/ccls
User avatar
xr_a_y
Posts: 1871
Joined: Sat Nov 25, 2017 2:28 pm
Location: France

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by xr_a_y »

Ok those are 2 domains where Minic is not good. I'll activate pondering soon (this is usualy worh 40-60 elo) and work on sudden death TC because current heuristic isn't smart enougth. I guess some "emergency time" management shall be added also.

Thanks for this tourney !
User avatar
CMCanavessi
Posts: 1142
Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2017 4:06 pm
Location: Argentina

Re: A complete 2000 lines of code engine

Post by CMCanavessi »

Tournament ended and considering the opposition, Minic did quite well...

Code: Select all

    Engine                    Score         Wy       Ph       Ju       Sc       As       Fr       Ro       Fr       Ne       Mi       Ki       Em    S-B
01: WyldChess 1.51 x64        64.0/88 ········ 100=1=10 011111== ===1110= 011===11 111=1101 =====0=1 ===1=111 =11=1111 ===11111 =110=11= 11111111  2567,0
02: Pharaon 3.5.1 x32         63.5/88 011=0=01 ········ 0110==10 =1101000 111=11=1 =0111=11 11====1= 0110=111 11111011 11111011 =1=11101 11111111  2517,7
03: Jumbo 0.6.64 x64          52.5/88 100000== 1001==01 ········ 0==1=1=1 1===0111 =111=010 1=100000 1=01==00 1011=001 1=1110=1 1011=111 11111111  2044,7
04: Schooner v1.8 x64         52.0/88 ===0001= =0010111 1==0=0=0 ········ 010=1010 =1010==0 =1111110 1=1==011 11111=== 01110==0 111===1= 11011=1=  2116,7
05: Asymptote v0.3 x64        49.5/88 100===00 000=00=0 0===1000 101=0101 ········ 111==0=1 =010=11= 10=00100 00011111 1111101= 1111111= 111111=1  1857,2
06: Francesca M.A.D. 0.19 x32 47.5/88 000=0010 =1000=00 =000=101 =0101==1 000==1=0 ········ 11===1=0 =11=0=11 01=10111 1001=111 =1==1100 11111111  1796,5
07: RomiChess P3n x64         46.5/88 =====1=0 00====0= 0=011111 =0000001 =101=00= 00===0=1 ········ =0111111 000=0111 10001=0= 0=1=111= 11111111  1821,5
08: FrankWalter 2.2.8 x64     42.0/88 ===0=000 1001=000 0=10==11 0=0==100 01=11011 =00=1=00 =1000000 ········ =1==0=10 =101=0=0 101111=0 11111111  1603,2
09: Nemeton 1.8 x32           39.5/88 =00=0000 00000100 0100=110 00000=== 11100000 10=01000 111=1000 =0==1=01 ········ 11100101 01=01111 11111111  1420,7
10: Minic 0.29 x64            37.0/88 ===00000 00000100 0=0001=0 10001==1 0000010= 0110=000 01110=1= =010=1=1 00011010 ········ 010111=1 =1110111  1398,5
11: Kingfisher v1.1 x64       28.0/88 =001=00= =0=00010 0100=000 000===0= 0000000= =0==0011 1=0=000= 010000=1 10=10000 101000=0 ········ 11=1=1==  1109,2
12: Embla 2.0.5 x64           6.0/88  00000000 00000000 00000000 00100=0= 000000=0 00000000 00000000 00000000 00000000 =0001000 00=0=0== ········  240,25

528 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: 189 - Qualy League
Rating went up to ~2410 too, which is nice.

I'm running another tournament with Minic in it now, but that will take much longer as the number of engines is way higher, and so far Minic is doing really well.

Code: Select all

    Engine                    Score  DrGaMiFrFrTJFrBePlCoTCAbRuOrGrSuDiAbIfEeNeArZeJaGiSiBeGaEvKi    S-B
01: Drosophila 1.5 x64        11.0/14 · =         1   1   0     1   1     1 1 1   1   =   0   1 1   73,00
01: Galjoen 0.39.2 x64        11.0/15 = ·         1   1 0 0 1     1 1         1 0 1 1       1 1 =   73,00
03: Minic 0.29 x64            10.5/15     · 0 =     0 =   1 1 = 0     1 1 1 1         1   1     1   68,75
04: Fruit 1.0 x32             9.5/15      1 · 1 =   0       1 1 =     = 1 0 1       1 1 0 0         72,00
05: Francesca M.A.D. 0.19 x32 9.0/15      = 0 · 1   0 0   1 1 1 =     0 = = 1         1   1         66,00
06: TJchess 1.3 x64           9.0/15        = 0 · = 1 1   =   1 =     0 = 0 1         1   =     1   63,25
07: FrankWalter 2.2.8 x64     9.0/15  0 0       = ·     1   =     0 =         1 = 0 1   1   1 1 1   51,75
08: Betsabe II 1.84 x32       8.5/14      1 1 1 0   ·       0 1 0 1   0 1           0   1 1 =       63,25
09: Plisk 0.2.7_d x64         8.5/15  0 0 =   1 0     · 1     0   1 =         1 =   0   1   1 1     56,00
10: Coiled 0.4 x64            8.5/14    1         0   0 · 0 0       1     1 1 1 = 0   1       1 1   53,50
11: TCB 0052 x32              8.0/15  1 1 0   0 =       1 ·       0 0         0 1 1 1   0   1 =     58,25
12: Abrok 5.0 x32             8.0/15    0 0 0 0   = 1   1   · = =   1 = =     1   =           1     56,25
13: RubiChess 0.8.1 x64       8.0/15      = 0 0 0   0 1     = · =     1 0 1 =         1 1 1         54,25
14: Orion 0.5 x64             7.5/14  0   1 = = =   1       = = · =   = 1           0   1   0       59,75
15: Gromit3 3.0.0 x32         7.5/14    0         1 0 0   1     = ·   0   1 0 0   1   1   1     1   47,25
16: Sungorus 1.4 x64          7.5/14  0 0         =   = 0 1 0       ·     1   1 1 0         1 = 1   44,00
17: Dimitri 3.93 x32          6.5/14      0 = 1 1   1       = 0 = 1   · 0   0       0   1 0         52,00
18: Absolute Zero 2.4.7.2 x64 6.5/14      0 0 = =   0       = 1 0     1 ·   1       1 0 0 1         45,00
19: Ifrit m1.8 x64            6.5/15  0   0 1 = 1       0     0   0 0     ·   0 0   1   1   1 1     41,50
20: Eeyore 1.52 x64           6.5/14  0   0 0 0 0       0     =   1   1 0   ·   1   1   1   1       39,00
21: Nemeton 1.7 x32           6.5/15  0 0         0   0 0 1 0     1 0     1   · = 1         = = 1   37,50
22: Ares 1.005.2.1 x64        6.0/14    1         =   = = 0         0     1 0 = · =   =   =   0 =   43,75
23: Zevra v2.1.1 r216 x64     6.0/15  0 0         1     1 0 =     0 1         0 = · 1   0   0 = =   41,25
24: Jazz Orchestra 840 x64    6.0/15    0   0     0 1 1   0     1     1 0 0 0     0 · 0   1     1   39,00
25: Giraffe 20161023 x64      6.0/14  =   0 0 0 0       0     0   0     1       =   1 · 1   1 1     33,50
26: Simplex 0.9.8 x64         5.5/15        1     0 0 0   1   0 0     0 1 0 0     1   0 · =     1   35,50
27: Bearded Neural v44.5 x64  5.0/14  1   0 1 0 =   0         0   0   1 0       =   0   = · =       39,00
28: Gaia 3.5 x64              3.5/14    0         0 = 0   0     1   0     0 0 =   1   0   = ·   0   23,50
29: EveAnn 1.72 x32           3.5/14  0 0         0   0 0 = 0       =     0   = 1 =   0       · =   21,50
30: Kingfisher v1.1 x64       3.0/15  0 = 0     0 0     0         0 0         0 = = 0   0   1 = ·   16,75

218 of 1740 games played
Name of the tournament: 190 - Qualy League
Follow my tournament and some Leela gauntlets live at http://twitch.tv/ccls