I was wondering if either Komodo or SF without Database Endgame table are better than the beast GM Carlsen playing endgame. In this position either GM Anand made a blunder somewhere or GM Carslen is the best Endgame player during the last 7 years. Also can either Komodo or SF beat Carsen giving this position just played between Anand vs Carlsen? Black to play Anand took the pawn and the game continued for almost another 30+ moves.
[D]4k3/2p2r2/pp2NPnp/2p5/8/1P5P/P1P5/2KR4 b - - 5 1
Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw
-
Chessqueen
- Posts: 5582
- Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2018 2:16 am
- Location: Moving
- Full name: Jorge Picado
Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
Do NOT worry and be happy, we all live a short life 
-
Dann Corbit
- Posts: 12540
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:57 pm
- Location: Redmond, WA USA
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
It seems very likely that Anand made the best move. If you look at the last ply, you will see a big drop in score and also a huge chunk of time exhausted from a fail low.
Searching: [d]4k3/2p2r2/pp2NPnp/2p5/8/1P5P/P1P5/2KR4 b - - 0 1
Even with 6 man tablebase files, this is an incredibly complex position and Stockfish does not have a certain draw score after an 8 minute search.
As to your original question, the answer is yes, computers are better than Carlsen without tablebase files. The kibitzing computer for TCEC would probably beat him 100 to nothing at 40 moves in 2 hours, even without tablebase files. Tablebase files add a teeny-tiny bit of Elo, but mostly they just make the games a little bit prettier.
It's an interesting position.
Searching: [d]4k3/2p2r2/pp2NPnp/2p5/8/1P5P/P1P5/2KR4 b - - 0 1
Code: Select all
infinite: 0 time: 0 increment: 0 moves to go: 0
1 -0.16 00:00 2412 Rxf6
2 -0.64 00:00 447299 Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8
3 -0.30 00:00 1147K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6
4 -0.55 00:00 1369K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nd5 Re6
5 -0.71 00:00 1835K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4
6 -0.73 00:00 2159K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Ke7 Nc7 Nf4
7 -0.73 00:00 2317K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf7 Rd7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ne2+ Kb2
8 -0.71 00:00 2671K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4
9 -0.60 00:00 3224K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 Nc7 Nxh3 Nd5 Rd6 c4
10 -0.78 00:00 3846K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7
11 -0.80 00:00 3958K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rf1+ Kb2 Kd6 Na8
12 -0.82 00:00 4138K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Kf7 Rd7+ Kg6 Nd5 Rf1+ Kb2 Nf5 Nxb6 h5 a4 h4
13 -0.84 00:00 4351K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ne2+ Kb2 Nd4 Rd2 Nf3 Rf2 h5 Nc7 Rf5 Re2 Kf7 a4 Nxh4
14 -0.69 00:00 4986K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 Ke5
15 -0.59 00:00 5983K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rg1 Nf8 a4 Rf7 Nh5 Kd7 Kd2 Ke6 Kc3 Nh7 Rg6 Nxf6 Rxh6 Ke7 Nxf6 Rxf6 Rxf6 Kxf6
16 -0.48 00:00 6877K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rg1 Nf8 a4 Rf7 Nh5 Kd7 Kd2 Ke6 Kc3 Nh7 Rg6 Nxf6 Rxh6 Ke7 Nxf6 Rxf6 Rxf6 Kxf6
17 -0.59 00:00 8716K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Kd7 Kd2 Nd5 Nxh5 Ke6 a3 Nxf6 Nxf6 Kxf6 Ke3 Kg6 a4 Kh5
18 -0.49 00:00 9461K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Ke2 Nxh4 Ke3 Ng6 Nxh5 Ke8 Nf4 Ne5
19 -0.60 00:00 10594K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Nd5 Nxh5 Ke6 a3 Nxf6 Nxf6 Kxf6 Ke3 Kf5 Kf3 b5 a4 Kg6 axb5 axb5 Ke4 c6 Ke5 c4 bxc4 bxc4
20 -0.37 00:01 13109K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rd2 Nf8 Nf5 h5 f7 Rxd2 Kxd2 Kd7 Ke3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf7 Nxh5 Kg6 Nf4+ Kf5 Nd5 Ne6 c4 Kg5 Ke4 Kg6 Nf4+ Nxf4 Kxf4
21 -0.33 00:01 15464K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Ke3 Nxh4 Kf4 Ng2+ Kg3 Ne3 c4 b5 cxb5 axb5 Kf4 Ng2+ Ke5 h4 Ne6 Ke8
22 -0.30 00:01 20914K Rd7 Rd5 a5 a4 Nf8 Rxd7 Nxd7 Nxc7+ Kf7 Nd5 Ke6 c4 Nxf6 Nxb6 Kd6 Nc8+ Kd7 Na7 Nh5 Nb5 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Kc2 Nxh4 Nc3 Ng6
23 -0.75 00:01 24342K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Ke8 Rxd7 Kxd7 Nxh6 Ke6 f7 Kf6 Kd2 Kg7 Nf5+ Kxf7 Ke3 Ne5 Kf4 Nc6 Ne3 a5 Kg5 Nd4 h4 Nf3+ Kg4 Nd4 a3 Kg6 a4
24 -0.78 00:02 28238K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nxh5 Nxh4 Nf4 Nf5 f7 Ke7 Ne6 Kxf7 Nxc7 Nd6 Nxa6 Ke6 Nc7+ Kd7 Nd5 Kc6 Nf4 b5 a3 Nf5
25 -0.75 00:02 32910K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ke6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh6 Re6 Rh7+ Kd6 Nxb6 Re2+ Ka3 Ke6 Na4
26 -0.69 00:03 47709K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Kc2 Ke5 Kd3 Re6 Rh5+ Kd6 Kc3 Kc6 a3 Ne7 b4 cxb4+ axb4 h3 b5+ Kd6 Nxe7 Rxe7 Rxh3
27 -0.56 00:04 56236K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Kc2 Ke5 Kd3 Re6 Rh5+ Kd6 Kc3 Kc6 a3 Ne7 Kc2 h3 Nxe7+ Rxe7 Rh6+ Kc7 Rxh3 Rf7 Rg3 Rf6 Kc3 Kc6 Re3 Rg6
28 -0.78 00:07 97401K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 Kf5 Nd5 h4 Kf3 Re6 Rb7 Kg5 Rg7 Re1 Rg8 Kf5 Ne3+ Kg5 Re8 h3
29 -0.61 00:08 110959K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ne7 Ne3 Ng6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh6 Re6 Nd5 Kc6 Kc2 Kd6 Nxb6 h3 Na4
30 -0.62 00:10 130932K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ne7 Ne3 Ng6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh7+ Ke6 Ng2 Ke5 Nxh4 Nxh4 Rxh4 Rf6 Ka3 Kd6 Ka4 Kc6 Rh8 Rd6 a3 Re6 b4 cxb4
31 -0.59 00:11 136499K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 h4 Nd5 Kf5 Kf3 Re6 Rg8 Re1 Ne3+ Kg5 Ng4 Rf1+ Nf2 Ra1 a4 Kf5 Nd3
32 -0.59 00:15 199839K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 Kf5 Nd5 Kg4 Kf2 Re6 Rb7 h4 Rh7 Ne5 Rg7+ Kf5 Kg2 Nd3 a4 Nc1 b4 cxb4 Nxb4
33 -0.73 00:22 292973K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Re8 h4 Ke3 h3 Kf2 Kd7 Rb8 h2 Rb7+ Kd8 Kg2 Re6 Kxh2 Ne7 Rxb6 Re2+ Kg3 Nxd5 cxd5 Rxa2 Rc6 Kd7
34 -0.85 00:34 434550K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne4 Ne5 Ng3 Nf3 Nf5 Kd5 Kb2 Ke5 Ng3 Nxh4 Nxh5 Nf5 Kc3 Nd6 Ng3 Kd5 Nf1 b5 Ne3+ Kc6 Ng4 Nf5 Ne5+ Kd5 Nf3 Kc6 Nd2
35 -0.85 00:38 489740K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne4 Ne5 Ng3 Nf3 Nf5 Kd5 Kb2 Ke5 Ng3 Nxh4 Nxh5 Nf5 Kc3 Nd6 Ng3 Kd5 Nf1 b5 Ne3+ Kc6 Ng4 Nf5 Ne5+ Kd5 Nf3 Kc6 Nd2
36 -0.73 00:49 634250K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nxh5 Nxh4 Nf4 Nf5 f7 Ke7 Nd5+ Kxf7 Nxc7 a5 Kd3 Nd6 a4 Kf8 Na8 b5 axb5 Nxb5 Nb6 Ke7 Nc4 Ke6 Nxa5 Nd6 Nc4 Nf5 Kd2 Nd4 Nb6 Nc6 Kd3 Nb4+ Kc3 Kd6 Nc4+ Kd5 Ne3+ Ke4 Kd2 Nc6 Nc4
37 -0.51 00:57 741020K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 a4 a5 Kg4 c3 Nf1 Ng2 Kg5 Nf4 Ne3 Ne6+ Kg4 Nd4 Nd1 Kf6 Nxc3 Kg6
38 -0.69 01:12 934954K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Nd1 Kd5 Kb2 Kc6 Kc1 Ne5 Ne3 b5 Kb2 Ng6 Nf5 Kb6 Kc3 Ka5 axb5 Kxb5 Kd2 Kb4 Kd3 Ne5+ Ke4 Ng6 Kd5
39 -0.84 01:32 1194M Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne2 Ne5 Ng3 b5 Kb2 c4 Nf5 cxb3 cxb3 Kb6 Ka3 bxa4 Kxa4 Kc5 b4+ Kc4 b5 Kc5 Ng3 Kb6 Kb4
40 -0.64 01:46 1380M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 a3 Kxh5 Nd5 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 Kd6 Kf4 Kd7 Nf7 Kxc6
41 -0.82 01:56 1516M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 a3 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 Kd6 Kf4 Nd1 a5 Kd7 Nf7
42 -0.81 02:03 1605M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 Kd4 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 a4 Ne6+ Ke5 Nd8 Kd6 Kf4 Kc5 Ke3 Kb6
43 -0.81 02:12 1719M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 Kd4 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 a4 Kf4 Kc5 Ke5 Kb6 Ne6 Kxa6
44 -0.38 07:51 5837M Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh3 Ke7 Nc7 Kd7 Nb5 Ne1 Rc3 Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Kb7 Kb1 Rf1 Kc1 Nf3+ Kb2 Nd4 Nxd4 cxd4 Rh3 Rf4 Kc1 Rf2 b4 Kc6 Kd1 Kb7 Rg3 Rh2 Rg7+ Kc6 Rg6+ Kb7 a5 bxa5 bxa5 Rxh4 Rb6+ Ka7 Ke2 Rh3 Rd6 Rc3 Kd2 Ra3
As to your original question, the answer is yes, computers are better than Carlsen without tablebase files. The kibitzing computer for TCEC would probably beat him 100 to nothing at 40 moves in 2 hours, even without tablebase files. Tablebase files add a teeny-tiny bit of Elo, but mostly they just make the games a little bit prettier.
It's an interesting position.
Taking ideas is not a vice, it is a virtue. We have another word for this. It is called learning.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
-
Sesse
- Posts: 300
- Joined: Mon Apr 30, 2018 11:51 pm
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
I think it depends on your definition of “better”. I'm fairly certain Stockfish on a fast computer would have a positive endgame score versus Carlsen. I'm not convinced it's as good as him in swindling drawn endgames against other GMs. A computer doesn't really understand the concept of putting the opponent to the test when every move draws.
-
Dann Corbit
- Posts: 12540
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:57 pm
- Location: Redmond, WA USA
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
Crafty had a "swindle" mode starting with version 15.17.Sesse wrote: ↑Thu Jan 24, 2019 12:02 am I think it depends on your definition of “better”. I'm fairly certain Stockfish on a fast computer would have a positive endgame score versus Carlsen. I'm not convinced it's as good as him in swindling drawn endgames against other GMs. A computer doesn't really understand the concept of putting the opponent to the test when every move draws.
Taking ideas is not a vice, it is a virtue. We have another word for this. It is called learning.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
-
Chessqueen
- Posts: 5582
- Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2018 2:16 am
- Location: Moving
- Full name: Jorge Picado
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
In this exact position as it is without Queens, it is very hard for either Komodo or Stockfish to win with the Black peices versus GM Carsen, GM Ding Liren or GM Caurana. the best that these programs can do is to draw without Endgame table. With just Knights and Rooks it is very hard for any program to beat a top GM, what makes it harder for GM is when the Queens are still on the board. If I had $25,000 dollars to throw away I would give it to GM Liren or GM Caruana to play white versus any of these programs.Dann Corbit wrote: ↑Wed Jan 23, 2019 11:45 pm It seems very likely that Anand made the best move. If you look at the last ply, you will see a big drop in score and also a huge chunk of time exhausted from a fail low.
Searching: [d]4k3/2p2r2/pp2NPnp/2p5/8/1P5P/P1P5/2KR4 b - - 0 1Even with 6 man tablebase files, this is an incredibly complex position and Stockfish does not have a certain draw score after an 8 minute search.Code: Select all
infinite: 0 time: 0 increment: 0 moves to go: 0 1 -0.16 00:00 2412 Rxf6 2 -0.64 00:00 447299 Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 3 -0.30 00:00 1147K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 4 -0.55 00:00 1369K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nd5 Re6 5 -0.71 00:00 1835K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 6 -0.73 00:00 2159K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Ke7 Nc7 Nf4 7 -0.73 00:00 2317K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf7 Rd7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ne2+ Kb2 8 -0.71 00:00 2671K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 9 -0.60 00:00 3224K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 Nc7 Nxh3 Nd5 Rd6 c4 10 -0.78 00:00 3846K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 11 -0.80 00:00 3958K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rf1+ Kb2 Kd6 Na8 12 -0.82 00:00 4138K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Kf7 Rd7+ Kg6 Nd5 Rf1+ Kb2 Nf5 Nxb6 h5 a4 h4 13 -0.84 00:00 4351K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ne2+ Kb2 Nd4 Rd2 Nf3 Rf2 h5 Nc7 Rf5 Re2 Kf7 a4 Nxh4 14 -0.69 00:00 4986K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 Ke5 15 -0.59 00:00 5983K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rg1 Nf8 a4 Rf7 Nh5 Kd7 Kd2 Ke6 Kc3 Nh7 Rg6 Nxf6 Rxh6 Ke7 Nxf6 Rxf6 Rxf6 Kxf6 16 -0.48 00:00 6877K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rg1 Nf8 a4 Rf7 Nh5 Kd7 Kd2 Ke6 Kc3 Nh7 Rg6 Nxf6 Rxh6 Ke7 Nxf6 Rxf6 Rxf6 Kxf6 17 -0.59 00:00 8716K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Kd7 Kd2 Nd5 Nxh5 Ke6 a3 Nxf6 Nxf6 Kxf6 Ke3 Kg6 a4 Kh5 18 -0.49 00:00 9461K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Ke2 Nxh4 Ke3 Ng6 Nxh5 Ke8 Nf4 Ne5 19 -0.60 00:00 10594K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Nd5 Nxh5 Ke6 a3 Nxf6 Nxf6 Kxf6 Ke3 Kf5 Kf3 b5 a4 Kg6 axb5 axb5 Ke4 c6 Ke5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 20 -0.37 00:01 13109K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rd2 Nf8 Nf5 h5 f7 Rxd2 Kxd2 Kd7 Ke3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf7 Nxh5 Kg6 Nf4+ Kf5 Nd5 Ne6 c4 Kg5 Ke4 Kg6 Nf4+ Nxf4 Kxf4 21 -0.33 00:01 15464K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Ke3 Nxh4 Kf4 Ng2+ Kg3 Ne3 c4 b5 cxb5 axb5 Kf4 Ng2+ Ke5 h4 Ne6 Ke8 22 -0.30 00:01 20914K Rd7 Rd5 a5 a4 Nf8 Rxd7 Nxd7 Nxc7+ Kf7 Nd5 Ke6 c4 Nxf6 Nxb6 Kd6 Nc8+ Kd7 Na7 Nh5 Nb5 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Kc2 Nxh4 Nc3 Ng6 23 -0.75 00:01 24342K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Ke8 Rxd7 Kxd7 Nxh6 Ke6 f7 Kf6 Kd2 Kg7 Nf5+ Kxf7 Ke3 Ne5 Kf4 Nc6 Ne3 a5 Kg5 Nd4 h4 Nf3+ Kg4 Nd4 a3 Kg6 a4 24 -0.78 00:02 28238K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nxh5 Nxh4 Nf4 Nf5 f7 Ke7 Ne6 Kxf7 Nxc7 Nd6 Nxa6 Ke6 Nc7+ Kd7 Nd5 Kc6 Nf4 b5 a3 Nf5 25 -0.75 00:02 32910K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ke6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh6 Re6 Rh7+ Kd6 Nxb6 Re2+ Ka3 Ke6 Na4 26 -0.69 00:03 47709K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Kc2 Ke5 Kd3 Re6 Rh5+ Kd6 Kc3 Kc6 a3 Ne7 b4 cxb4+ axb4 h3 b5+ Kd6 Nxe7 Rxe7 Rxh3 27 -0.56 00:04 56236K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Kc2 Ke5 Kd3 Re6 Rh5+ Kd6 Kc3 Kc6 a3 Ne7 Kc2 h3 Nxe7+ Rxe7 Rh6+ Kc7 Rxh3 Rf7 Rg3 Rf6 Kc3 Kc6 Re3 Rg6 28 -0.78 00:07 97401K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 Kf5 Nd5 h4 Kf3 Re6 Rb7 Kg5 Rg7 Re1 Rg8 Kf5 Ne3+ Kg5 Re8 h3 29 -0.61 00:08 110959K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ne7 Ne3 Ng6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh6 Re6 Nd5 Kc6 Kc2 Kd6 Nxb6 h3 Na4 30 -0.62 00:10 130932K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ne7 Ne3 Ng6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh7+ Ke6 Ng2 Ke5 Nxh4 Nxh4 Rxh4 Rf6 Ka3 Kd6 Ka4 Kc6 Rh8 Rd6 a3 Re6 b4 cxb4 31 -0.59 00:11 136499K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 h4 Nd5 Kf5 Kf3 Re6 Rg8 Re1 Ne3+ Kg5 Ng4 Rf1+ Nf2 Ra1 a4 Kf5 Nd3 32 -0.59 00:15 199839K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 Kf5 Nd5 Kg4 Kf2 Re6 Rb7 h4 Rh7 Ne5 Rg7+ Kf5 Kg2 Nd3 a4 Nc1 b4 cxb4 Nxb4 33 -0.73 00:22 292973K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Re8 h4 Ke3 h3 Kf2 Kd7 Rb8 h2 Rb7+ Kd8 Kg2 Re6 Kxh2 Ne7 Rxb6 Re2+ Kg3 Nxd5 cxd5 Rxa2 Rc6 Kd7 34 -0.85 00:34 434550K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne4 Ne5 Ng3 Nf3 Nf5 Kd5 Kb2 Ke5 Ng3 Nxh4 Nxh5 Nf5 Kc3 Nd6 Ng3 Kd5 Nf1 b5 Ne3+ Kc6 Ng4 Nf5 Ne5+ Kd5 Nf3 Kc6 Nd2 35 -0.85 00:38 489740K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne4 Ne5 Ng3 Nf3 Nf5 Kd5 Kb2 Ke5 Ng3 Nxh4 Nxh5 Nf5 Kc3 Nd6 Ng3 Kd5 Nf1 b5 Ne3+ Kc6 Ng4 Nf5 Ne5+ Kd5 Nf3 Kc6 Nd2 36 -0.73 00:49 634250K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nxh5 Nxh4 Nf4 Nf5 f7 Ke7 Nd5+ Kxf7 Nxc7 a5 Kd3 Nd6 a4 Kf8 Na8 b5 axb5 Nxb5 Nb6 Ke7 Nc4 Ke6 Nxa5 Nd6 Nc4 Nf5 Kd2 Nd4 Nb6 Nc6 Kd3 Nb4+ Kc3 Kd6 Nc4+ Kd5 Ne3+ Ke4 Kd2 Nc6 Nc4 37 -0.51 00:57 741020K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 a4 a5 Kg4 c3 Nf1 Ng2 Kg5 Nf4 Ne3 Ne6+ Kg4 Nd4 Nd1 Kf6 Nxc3 Kg6 38 -0.69 01:12 934954K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Nd1 Kd5 Kb2 Kc6 Kc1 Ne5 Ne3 b5 Kb2 Ng6 Nf5 Kb6 Kc3 Ka5 axb5 Kxb5 Kd2 Kb4 Kd3 Ne5+ Ke4 Ng6 Kd5 39 -0.84 01:32 1194M Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne2 Ne5 Ng3 b5 Kb2 c4 Nf5 cxb3 cxb3 Kb6 Ka3 bxa4 Kxa4 Kc5 b4+ Kc4 b5 Kc5 Ng3 Kb6 Kb4 40 -0.64 01:46 1380M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 a3 Kxh5 Nd5 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 Kd6 Kf4 Kd7 Nf7 Kxc6 41 -0.82 01:56 1516M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 a3 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 Kd6 Kf4 Nd1 a5 Kd7 Nf7 42 -0.81 02:03 1605M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 Kd4 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 a4 Ne6+ Ke5 Nd8 Kd6 Kf4 Kc5 Ke3 Kb6 43 -0.81 02:12 1719M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 Kd4 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 a4 Kf4 Kc5 Ke5 Kb6 Ne6 Kxa6 44 -0.38 07:51 5837M Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh3 Ke7 Nc7 Kd7 Nb5 Ne1 Rc3 Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Kb7 Kb1 Rf1 Kc1 Nf3+ Kb2 Nd4 Nxd4 cxd4 Rh3 Rf4 Kc1 Rf2 b4 Kc6 Kd1 Kb7 Rg3 Rh2 Rg7+ Kc6 Rg6+ Kb7 a5 bxa5 bxa5 Rxh4 Rb6+ Ka7 Ke2 Rh3 Rd6 Rc3 Kd2 Ra3
As to your original question, the answer is yes, computers are better than Carlsen without tablebase files. The kibitzing computer for TCEC would probably beat him 100 to nothing at 40 moves in 2 hours, even without tablebase files. Tablebase files add a teeny-tiny bit of Elo, but mostly they just make the games a little bit prettier.
It's an interesting position.
Do NOT worry and be happy, we all live a short life
-
Chessqueen
- Posts: 5582
- Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2018 2:16 am
- Location: Moving
- Full name: Jorge Picado
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
You would like to see how useless computer programs are without Queen, simply give White to Komodo and Black to GM Nakamura on this position I bet you that GM Nakamura or Caruana , or Din Liren or GM MVL can get a draw easy with Black:Chessqueen wrote: ↑Fri Jan 25, 2019 2:45 amIn this exact position as it is without Queens, it is very hard for either Komodo or Stockfish to win with the Black peices versus GM Carsen, GM Ding Liren or GM Caurana. the best that these programs can do is to draw without Endgame table. With just Knights and Rooks it is very hard for any program to beat a top GM, what makes it harder for GM is when the Queens are still on the board. If I had $25,000 dollars to throw away I would give it to GM Liren or GM Caruana to play white versus any of these programs.Dann Corbit wrote: ↑Wed Jan 23, 2019 11:45 pm It seems very likely that Anand made the best move. If you look at the last ply, you will see a big drop in score and also a huge chunk of time exhausted from a fail low.
Searching: [d]4k3/2p2r2/pp2NPnp/2p5/8/1P5P/P1P5/2KR4 b - - 0 1Even with 6 man tablebase files, this is an incredibly complex position and Stockfish does not have a certain draw score after an 8 minute search.Code: Select all
infinite: 0 time: 0 increment: 0 moves to go: 0 1 -0.16 00:00 2412 Rxf6 2 -0.64 00:00 447299 Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 3 -0.30 00:00 1147K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 4 -0.55 00:00 1369K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nd5 Re6 5 -0.71 00:00 1835K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 6 -0.73 00:00 2159K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Ke7 Nc7 Nf4 7 -0.73 00:00 2317K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf7 Rd7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ne2+ Kb2 8 -0.71 00:00 2671K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 9 -0.60 00:00 3224K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 Nc7 Nxh3 Nd5 Rd6 c4 10 -0.78 00:00 3846K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 11 -0.80 00:00 3958K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rf1+ Kb2 Kd6 Na8 12 -0.82 00:00 4138K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Kf7 Rd7+ Kg6 Nd5 Rf1+ Kb2 Nf5 Nxb6 h5 a4 h4 13 -0.84 00:00 4351K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ne2+ Kb2 Nd4 Rd2 Nf3 Rf2 h5 Nc7 Rf5 Re2 Kf7 a4 Nxh4 14 -0.69 00:00 4986K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 Ke5 15 -0.59 00:00 5983K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rg1 Nf8 a4 Rf7 Nh5 Kd7 Kd2 Ke6 Kc3 Nh7 Rg6 Nxf6 Rxh6 Ke7 Nxf6 Rxf6 Rxf6 Kxf6 16 -0.48 00:00 6877K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rg1 Nf8 a4 Rf7 Nh5 Kd7 Kd2 Ke6 Kc3 Nh7 Rg6 Nxf6 Rxh6 Ke7 Nxf6 Rxf6 Rxf6 Kxf6 17 -0.59 00:00 8716K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Kd7 Kd2 Nd5 Nxh5 Ke6 a3 Nxf6 Nxf6 Kxf6 Ke3 Kg6 a4 Kh5 18 -0.49 00:00 9461K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Ke2 Nxh4 Ke3 Ng6 Nxh5 Ke8 Nf4 Ne5 19 -0.60 00:00 10594K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Nd5 Nxh5 Ke6 a3 Nxf6 Nxf6 Kxf6 Ke3 Kf5 Kf3 b5 a4 Kg6 axb5 axb5 Ke4 c6 Ke5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 20 -0.37 00:01 13109K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rd2 Nf8 Nf5 h5 f7 Rxd2 Kxd2 Kd7 Ke3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf7 Nxh5 Kg6 Nf4+ Kf5 Nd5 Ne6 c4 Kg5 Ke4 Kg6 Nf4+ Nxf4 Kxf4 21 -0.33 00:01 15464K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Ke3 Nxh4 Kf4 Ng2+ Kg3 Ne3 c4 b5 cxb5 axb5 Kf4 Ng2+ Ke5 h4 Ne6 Ke8 22 -0.30 00:01 20914K Rd7 Rd5 a5 a4 Nf8 Rxd7 Nxd7 Nxc7+ Kf7 Nd5 Ke6 c4 Nxf6 Nxb6 Kd6 Nc8+ Kd7 Na7 Nh5 Nb5 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Kc2 Nxh4 Nc3 Ng6 23 -0.75 00:01 24342K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Ke8 Rxd7 Kxd7 Nxh6 Ke6 f7 Kf6 Kd2 Kg7 Nf5+ Kxf7 Ke3 Ne5 Kf4 Nc6 Ne3 a5 Kg5 Nd4 h4 Nf3+ Kg4 Nd4 a3 Kg6 a4 24 -0.78 00:02 28238K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nxh5 Nxh4 Nf4 Nf5 f7 Ke7 Ne6 Kxf7 Nxc7 Nd6 Nxa6 Ke6 Nc7+ Kd7 Nd5 Kc6 Nf4 b5 a3 Nf5 25 -0.75 00:02 32910K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ke6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh6 Re6 Rh7+ Kd6 Nxb6 Re2+ Ka3 Ke6 Na4 26 -0.69 00:03 47709K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Kc2 Ke5 Kd3 Re6 Rh5+ Kd6 Kc3 Kc6 a3 Ne7 b4 cxb4+ axb4 h3 b5+ Kd6 Nxe7 Rxe7 Rxh3 27 -0.56 00:04 56236K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Kc2 Ke5 Kd3 Re6 Rh5+ Kd6 Kc3 Kc6 a3 Ne7 Kc2 h3 Nxe7+ Rxe7 Rh6+ Kc7 Rxh3 Rf7 Rg3 Rf6 Kc3 Kc6 Re3 Rg6 28 -0.78 00:07 97401K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 Kf5 Nd5 h4 Kf3 Re6 Rb7 Kg5 Rg7 Re1 Rg8 Kf5 Ne3+ Kg5 Re8 h3 29 -0.61 00:08 110959K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ne7 Ne3 Ng6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh6 Re6 Nd5 Kc6 Kc2 Kd6 Nxb6 h3 Na4 30 -0.62 00:10 130932K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ne7 Ne3 Ng6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh7+ Ke6 Ng2 Ke5 Nxh4 Nxh4 Rxh4 Rf6 Ka3 Kd6 Ka4 Kc6 Rh8 Rd6 a3 Re6 b4 cxb4 31 -0.59 00:11 136499K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 h4 Nd5 Kf5 Kf3 Re6 Rg8 Re1 Ne3+ Kg5 Ng4 Rf1+ Nf2 Ra1 a4 Kf5 Nd3 32 -0.59 00:15 199839K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 Kf5 Nd5 Kg4 Kf2 Re6 Rb7 h4 Rh7 Ne5 Rg7+ Kf5 Kg2 Nd3 a4 Nc1 b4 cxb4 Nxb4 33 -0.73 00:22 292973K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Re8 h4 Ke3 h3 Kf2 Kd7 Rb8 h2 Rb7+ Kd8 Kg2 Re6 Kxh2 Ne7 Rxb6 Re2+ Kg3 Nxd5 cxd5 Rxa2 Rc6 Kd7 34 -0.85 00:34 434550K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne4 Ne5 Ng3 Nf3 Nf5 Kd5 Kb2 Ke5 Ng3 Nxh4 Nxh5 Nf5 Kc3 Nd6 Ng3 Kd5 Nf1 b5 Ne3+ Kc6 Ng4 Nf5 Ne5+ Kd5 Nf3 Kc6 Nd2 35 -0.85 00:38 489740K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne4 Ne5 Ng3 Nf3 Nf5 Kd5 Kb2 Ke5 Ng3 Nxh4 Nxh5 Nf5 Kc3 Nd6 Ng3 Kd5 Nf1 b5 Ne3+ Kc6 Ng4 Nf5 Ne5+ Kd5 Nf3 Kc6 Nd2 36 -0.73 00:49 634250K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nxh5 Nxh4 Nf4 Nf5 f7 Ke7 Nd5+ Kxf7 Nxc7 a5 Kd3 Nd6 a4 Kf8 Na8 b5 axb5 Nxb5 Nb6 Ke7 Nc4 Ke6 Nxa5 Nd6 Nc4 Nf5 Kd2 Nd4 Nb6 Nc6 Kd3 Nb4+ Kc3 Kd6 Nc4+ Kd5 Ne3+ Ke4 Kd2 Nc6 Nc4 37 -0.51 00:57 741020K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 a4 a5 Kg4 c3 Nf1 Ng2 Kg5 Nf4 Ne3 Ne6+ Kg4 Nd4 Nd1 Kf6 Nxc3 Kg6 38 -0.69 01:12 934954K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Nd1 Kd5 Kb2 Kc6 Kc1 Ne5 Ne3 b5 Kb2 Ng6 Nf5 Kb6 Kc3 Ka5 axb5 Kxb5 Kd2 Kb4 Kd3 Ne5+ Ke4 Ng6 Kd5 39 -0.84 01:32 1194M Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne2 Ne5 Ng3 b5 Kb2 c4 Nf5 cxb3 cxb3 Kb6 Ka3 bxa4 Kxa4 Kc5 b4+ Kc4 b5 Kc5 Ng3 Kb6 Kb4 40 -0.64 01:46 1380M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 a3 Kxh5 Nd5 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 Kd6 Kf4 Kd7 Nf7 Kxc6 41 -0.82 01:56 1516M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 a3 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 Kd6 Kf4 Nd1 a5 Kd7 Nf7 42 -0.81 02:03 1605M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 Kd4 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 a4 Ne6+ Ke5 Nd8 Kd6 Kf4 Kc5 Ke3 Kb6 43 -0.81 02:12 1719M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 Kd4 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 a4 Kf4 Kc5 Ke5 Kb6 Ne6 Kxa6 44 -0.38 07:51 5837M Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh3 Ke7 Nc7 Kd7 Nb5 Ne1 Rc3 Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Kb7 Kb1 Rf1 Kc1 Nf3+ Kb2 Nd4 Nxd4 cxd4 Rh3 Rf4 Kc1 Rf2 b4 Kc6 Kd1 Kb7 Rg3 Rh2 Rg7+ Kc6 Rg6+ Kb7 a5 bxa5 bxa5 Rxh4 Rb6+ Ka7 Ke2 Rh3 Rd6 Rc3 Kd2 Ra3
As to your original question, the answer is yes, computers are better than Carlsen without tablebase files. The kibitzing computer for TCEC would probably beat him 100 to nothing at 40 moves in 2 hours, even without tablebase files. Tablebase files add a teeny-tiny bit of Elo, but mostly they just make the games a little bit prettier.
It's an interesting position.
[D]1nbqkbn1/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNB1KBNR w - - 0 1
Do NOT worry and be happy, we all live a short life
-
Chessqueen
- Posts: 5582
- Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2018 2:16 am
- Location: Moving
- Full name: Jorge Picado
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
I always wondered if two Rooks were better than a Queen, so I decided to have SF10 play by itself, of course this is only one game but considering that the side with the Queen is the Black side I am convinced that a Queen is more powerful than two Rooks.Chessqueen wrote: ↑Fri Jan 25, 2019 4:12 amYou would like to see how useless computer programs are without Queen, simply give White to Komodo and Black to GM Nakamura on this position I bet you that GM Nakamura or Caruana , or Din Liren or GM MVL can get a draw easy with Black:Chessqueen wrote: ↑Fri Jan 25, 2019 2:45 amIn this exact position as it is without Queens, it is very hard for either Komodo or Stockfish to win with the Black peices versus GM Carsen, GM Ding Liren or GM Caurana. the best that these programs can do is to draw without Endgame table. With just Knights and Rooks it is very hard for any program to beat a top GM, what makes it harder for GM is when the Queens are still on the board. If I had $25,000 dollars to throw away I would give it to GM Liren or GM Caruana to play white versus any of these programs.Dann Corbit wrote: ↑Wed Jan 23, 2019 11:45 pm It seems very likely that Anand made the best move. If you look at the last ply, you will see a big drop in score and also a huge chunk of time exhausted from a fail low.
Searching: [d]4k3/2p2r2/pp2NPnp/2p5/8/1P5P/P1P5/2KR4 b - - 0 1Even with 6 man tablebase files, this is an incredibly complex position and Stockfish does not have a certain draw score after an 8 minute search.Code: Select all
infinite: 0 time: 0 increment: 0 moves to go: 0 1 -0.16 00:00 2412 Rxf6 2 -0.64 00:00 447299 Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 3 -0.30 00:00 1147K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 4 -0.55 00:00 1369K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nd5 Re6 5 -0.71 00:00 1835K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 6 -0.73 00:00 2159K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Ke7 Nc7 Nf4 7 -0.73 00:00 2317K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf7 Rd7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ne2+ Kb2 8 -0.71 00:00 2671K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 9 -0.60 00:00 3224K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 Nc7 Nxh3 Nd5 Rd6 c4 10 -0.78 00:00 3846K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 11 -0.80 00:00 3958K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rf1+ Kb2 Kd6 Na8 12 -0.82 00:00 4138K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Kf7 Rd7+ Kg6 Nd5 Rf1+ Kb2 Nf5 Nxb6 h5 a4 h4 13 -0.84 00:00 4351K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ne2+ Kb2 Nd4 Rd2 Nf3 Rf2 h5 Nc7 Rf5 Re2 Kf7 a4 Nxh4 14 -0.69 00:00 4986K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 Ke5 15 -0.59 00:00 5983K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rg1 Nf8 a4 Rf7 Nh5 Kd7 Kd2 Ke6 Kc3 Nh7 Rg6 Nxf6 Rxh6 Ke7 Nxf6 Rxf6 Rxf6 Kxf6 16 -0.48 00:00 6877K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rg1 Nf8 a4 Rf7 Nh5 Kd7 Kd2 Ke6 Kc3 Nh7 Rg6 Nxf6 Rxh6 Ke7 Nxf6 Rxf6 Rxf6 Kxf6 17 -0.59 00:00 8716K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Kd7 Kd2 Nd5 Nxh5 Ke6 a3 Nxf6 Nxf6 Kxf6 Ke3 Kg6 a4 Kh5 18 -0.49 00:00 9461K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Ke2 Nxh4 Ke3 Ng6 Nxh5 Ke8 Nf4 Ne5 19 -0.60 00:00 10594K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Nd5 Nxh5 Ke6 a3 Nxf6 Nxf6 Kxf6 Ke3 Kf5 Kf3 b5 a4 Kg6 axb5 axb5 Ke4 c6 Ke5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 20 -0.37 00:01 13109K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Rd2 Nf8 Nf5 h5 f7 Rxd2 Kxd2 Kd7 Ke3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf7 Nxh5 Kg6 Nf4+ Kf5 Nd5 Ne6 c4 Kg5 Ke4 Kg6 Nf4+ Nxf4 Kxf4 21 -0.33 00:01 15464K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Ke3 Nxh4 Kf4 Ng2+ Kg3 Ne3 c4 b5 cxb5 axb5 Kf4 Ng2+ Ke5 h4 Ne6 Ke8 22 -0.30 00:01 20914K Rd7 Rd5 a5 a4 Nf8 Rxd7 Nxd7 Nxc7+ Kf7 Nd5 Ke6 c4 Nxf6 Nxb6 Kd6 Nc8+ Kd7 Na7 Nh5 Nb5 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Kc2 Nxh4 Nc3 Ng6 23 -0.75 00:01 24342K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Ke8 Rxd7 Kxd7 Nxh6 Ke6 f7 Kf6 Kd2 Kg7 Nf5+ Kxf7 Ke3 Ne5 Kf4 Nc6 Ne3 a5 Kg5 Nd4 h4 Nf3+ Kg4 Nd4 a3 Kg6 a4 24 -0.78 00:02 28238K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nxh5 Nxh4 Nf4 Nf5 f7 Ke7 Ne6 Kxf7 Nxc7 Nd6 Nxa6 Ke6 Nc7+ Kd7 Nd5 Kc6 Nf4 b5 a3 Nf5 25 -0.75 00:02 32910K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ke6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh6 Re6 Rh7+ Kd6 Nxb6 Re2+ Ka3 Ke6 Na4 26 -0.69 00:03 47709K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Kc2 Ke5 Kd3 Re6 Rh5+ Kd6 Kc3 Kc6 a3 Ne7 b4 cxb4+ axb4 h3 b5+ Kd6 Nxe7 Rxe7 Rxh3 27 -0.56 00:04 56236K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Kc2 Ke5 Kd3 Re6 Rh5+ Kd6 Kc3 Kc6 a3 Ne7 Kc2 h3 Nxe7+ Rxe7 Rh6+ Kc7 Rxh3 Rf7 Rg3 Rf6 Kc3 Kc6 Re3 Rg6 28 -0.78 00:07 97401K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 Kf5 Nd5 h4 Kf3 Re6 Rb7 Kg5 Rg7 Re1 Rg8 Kf5 Ne3+ Kg5 Re8 h3 29 -0.61 00:08 110959K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ne7 Ne3 Ng6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh6 Re6 Nd5 Kc6 Kc2 Kd6 Nxb6 h3 Na4 30 -0.62 00:10 130932K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Rb7 h5 Rh7 h4 Rh5 Ne7 Ne3 Ng6 Kb2 Kd7 Rh7+ Ke6 Ng2 Ke5 Nxh4 Nxh4 Rxh4 Rf6 Ka3 Kd6 Ka4 Kc6 Rh8 Rd6 a3 Re6 b4 cxb4 31 -0.59 00:11 136499K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 h4 Nd5 Kf5 Kf3 Re6 Rg8 Re1 Ne3+ Kg5 Ng4 Rf1+ Nf2 Ra1 a4 Kf5 Nd3 32 -0.59 00:15 199839K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Ke3 Ke5 Nxb6 Kf5 Nd5 Kg4 Kf2 Re6 Rb7 h4 Rh7 Ne5 Rg7+ Kf5 Kg2 Nd3 a4 Nc1 b4 cxb4 Nxb4 33 -0.73 00:22 292973K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Nc7 Nxh4 Rd8+ Ke7 Rb8 Rc6 Nd5+ Kd6 c4 Ng6 Kd2 h5 Re8 h4 Ke3 h3 Kf2 Kd7 Rb8 h2 Rb7+ Kd8 Kg2 Re6 Kxh2 Ne7 Rxb6 Re2+ Kg3 Nxd5 cxd5 Rxa2 Rc6 Kd7 34 -0.85 00:34 434550K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne4 Ne5 Ng3 Nf3 Nf5 Kd5 Kb2 Ke5 Ng3 Nxh4 Nxh5 Nf5 Kc3 Nd6 Ng3 Kd5 Nf1 b5 Ne3+ Kc6 Ng4 Nf5 Ne5+ Kd5 Nf3 Kc6 Nd2 35 -0.85 00:38 489740K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne4 Ne5 Ng3 Nf3 Nf5 Kd5 Kb2 Ke5 Ng3 Nxh4 Nxh5 Nf5 Kc3 Nd6 Ng3 Kd5 Nf1 b5 Ne3+ Kc6 Ng4 Nf5 Ne5+ Kd5 Nf3 Kc6 Nd2 36 -0.73 00:49 634250K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Kd2 Kd7 Ng7 Nf4 h4 Ng6 Nxh5 Nxh4 Nf4 Nf5 f7 Ke7 Nd5+ Kxf7 Nxc7 a5 Kd3 Nd6 a4 Kf8 Na8 b5 axb5 Nxb5 Nb6 Ke7 Nc4 Ke6 Nxa5 Nd6 Nc4 Nf5 Kd2 Nd4 Nb6 Nc6 Kd3 Nb4+ Kc3 Kd6 Nc4+ Kd5 Ne3+ Ke4 Kd2 Nc6 Nc4 37 -0.51 00:57 741020K Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 a4 a5 Kg4 c3 Nf1 Ng2 Kg5 Nf4 Ne3 Ne6+ Kg4 Nd4 Nd1 Kf6 Nxc3 Kg6 38 -0.69 01:12 934954K Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Nd1 Kd5 Kb2 Kc6 Kc1 Ne5 Ne3 b5 Kb2 Ng6 Nf5 Kb6 Kc3 Ka5 axb5 Kxb5 Kd2 Kb4 Kd3 Ne5+ Ke4 Ng6 Kd5 39 -0.84 01:32 1194M Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh2 Ke7 Nc7 Kd6 Nb5+ Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Ne3 Rxf2 Nd1+ Kb1 Nxf2 Nc3 Ng4 Ne2 Ne5 Ng3 b5 Kb2 c4 Nf5 cxb3 cxb3 Kb6 Ka3 bxa4 Kxa4 Kc5 b4+ Kc4 b5 Kc5 Ng3 Kb6 Kb4 40 -0.64 01:46 1380M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 a3 Kxh5 Nd5 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 Kd6 Kf4 Kd7 Nf7 Kxc6 41 -0.82 01:56 1516M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 a3 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 Kd6 Kf4 Nd1 a5 Kd7 Nf7 42 -0.81 02:03 1605M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 Kd4 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 a4 Ne6+ Ke5 Nd8 Kd6 Kf4 Kc5 Ke3 Kb6 43 -0.81 02:12 1719M Rd7 Ng7+ Kd8 Nf5 Rxd1+ Kxd1 h5 Ke2 Kd7 Kf3 Ke6 Ng7+ Kxf6 Nxh5+ Ke5 Kg4 b5 Kg5 Nf8 Ng3 Nh7+ Kh6 Nf8 h4 Ne6 Kg6 Nf4+ Kg5 c4 bxc4 bxc4 Nf1 Ne6+ Kg4 c3 Ne3 Nd4 h5 Kf6 Kf4 Ne6+ Ke4 Kg5 Ke5 Nd8 Nd5 Kxh5 Kd4 c6 Nxc3 Kg4 a4 Kf4 Kc5 Ke5 Kb6 Ne6 Kxa6 44 -0.38 07:51 5837M Rxf6 Nxc7+ Kf8 Nxa6 Nf4 h4 Ng2 Rh1 Rf2 Rh3 Ke7 Nc7 Kd7 Nb5 Ne1 Rc3 Kc6 a4 h5 Kb2 Kb7 Kb1 Rf1 Kc1 Nf3+ Kb2 Nd4 Nxd4 cxd4 Rh3 Rf4 Kc1 Rf2 b4 Kc6 Kd1 Kb7 Rg3 Rh2 Rg7+ Kc6 Rg6+ Kb7 a5 bxa5 bxa5 Rxh4 Rb6+ Ka7 Ke2 Rh3 Rd6 Rc3 Kd2 Ra3
As to your original question, the answer is yes, computers are better than Carlsen without tablebase files. The kibitzing computer for TCEC would probably beat him 100 to nothing at 40 moves in 2 hours, even without tablebase files. Tablebase files add a teeny-tiny bit of Elo, but mostly they just make the games a little bit prettier.
It's an interesting position.
[D]1nbqkbn1/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNB1KBNR w - - 0 1
[pgn][Event "Computer chess game"] [Site "DESKTOP-OFQ3C0P"] [Date "2019.01.25"] [Round "?"] [White "Stockfish_10_x64"] [Black "Stockfish_10_x64"] [Result "*"] [BlackElo "?"] [Time "18:54:55"] [WhiteElo "?"] [TimeControl "300"] [SetUp "1"] [FEN "1nbqkbn1/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNB1KBNR w KQ - 0 1"] [Termination "normal"] [PlyCount "163"] [WhiteType "program"] [BlackType "program"] 1. Nf3 {(Ng1-f3 d7-d5 d2-d3 c7-c5 g2-g3 Nb8-c6 Bf1-g2 g7-g6 O-O Bf8-g7 c2-c4 e7-e6 Nb1-c3 Ng8-e7 Bc1-f4 Ke8-f8 Nf3-d2 b7-b6 Rf1-d1 Kf8-g8 a2-a3 h7-h6 Nd2-f3 e6-e5 c4xd5 e5xf4) -0.10/24 62} d5 {(d7-d5 d2-d3 c7-c5 e2-e4 e7-e6 Bf1-e2 Nb8-c6 Nb1-c3 d5-d4 Nc3-b1 Ng8-e7 Nb1-d2 f7-f6 O-O Ne7-g6 a2-a4 Ke8-f7 Nd2-c4 e6-e5 Bc1-d2 Bc8-e6 Kg1-h1 Ng6-f4) +0.84/21 19} 2. d3 {(d2-d3 Nb8-c6 e2-e4 e7-e5 a2-a3 Ng8-e7 Nb1-d2 Bc8-e6 h2-h3 Ne7-g6 h3-h4 f7-f6 g2-g3 Ke8-f7 Bf1-g2 d5-d4 b2-b4 Ng6-e7 O-O a7-a6 Ra1-b1 Be6-a2 Rb1-a1) 0.00/23 16} c5 {(c7-c5 e2-e4 e7-e6 Bf1-e2 Nb8-c6 O-O Ng8-e7 c2-c3 f7-f6 Bc1-f4 e6-e5 Bf4-g3 Ke8-f7 Nb1-d2 d5-d4 c3xd4 Nc6xd4 Nf3xd4 Qd8xd4 Nd2-c4 b7-b5) +0.76/21 8} 3. g3 {(g2-g3 Nb8-c6 Bf1-g2 g7-g6 O-O Bf8-g7 Nb1-c3 e7-e6 e2-e4 Ng8-e7 a2-a3 Ke8-f8 Bc1-d2 d5xe4 d3xe4 Nc6-d4 Nf3xd4 c5xd4 Nc3-a2 d4-d3 c2xd3 Bg7xb2 Ra1-d1 Bc8-d7 Bd2-e3 Bb2xa3 Be3xa7) -0.13/21 9} Nc6 {(Nb8-c6 Bf1-g2 g7-g6 O-O Bf8-g7 Nb1-a3 Ke8-f8 c2-c3 Qd8-d7 Na3-c2 e7-e5 Ra1-b1 Ng8-f6 Bc1-g5 Nf6-g4 h2-h3 h7-h6 Bg5-h4 Ng4-f6 Bh4xf6 Bg7xf6 Nc2-e3) +0.64/22 13} 4. Bg2 {(Bf1-g2 Ng8-f6 O-O h7-h6 Nb1-a3 e7-e5 e2-e4 d5-d4 Na3-c4 Bf8-d6 a2-a4 Ke8-f8 b2-b3 Bd6-c7 Bc1-a3 b7-b6 Nf3-d2 Kf8-g8 Rf1-b1 Bc8-e6 Rb1-d1 Nf6-h7 Nd2-f3 Bc7-d6 Ba3-b2 Bd6-c7) +0.04/22 11} g6 {(g7-g6 O-O Bf8-g7 Nb1-a3 Ke8-f8 c2-c3 Ng8-f6 Na3-c2 e7-e5 Bc1-e3 b7-b6 Be3-g5 Qd8-d7 Nf3-d2 Nf6-g4 c3-c4 e5-e4 c4xd5 Qd7xd5 Nd2xe4 Bg7xb2 Ra1-b1 Qd5xa2) +0.57/21 2} 5. O-O {(O-O Bf8-g7 a2-a3 Ke8-f8 Nb1-c3 e7-e6 Bc1-d2 a7-a5 Ra1-b1 b7-b6 Nc3-b5 Qd8-d7 Nf3-g5 Ng8-f6 b2-b4 c5xb4 a3xb4 a5xb4 Bd2xb4+ Nc6xb4 Rb1xb4 Bc8-b7) +0.10/20 5} Bg7 {(Bf8-g7 Nb1-d2 Ke8-f8 a2-a3 a7-a5 Ra1-b1 b7-b5 c2-c4 b5xc4 d3xc4 e7-e6 b2-b3 h7-h6 Bc1-b2 Bg7xb2 Rb1xb2 Ng8-f6 h2-h4 Bc8-b7 Rf1-c1 d5-d4 Nf3-h2 Kf8-g7) +0.58/20 5} 6. a3 {(a2-a3 Ke8-f8 Nb1-c3 Ng8-f6 Bc1-d2 a7-a5 Ra1-b1 Bc8-g4 Rf1-e1 Kf8-g8 Rb1-d1 Bg4xf3 Bg2xf3 Nc6-d4 Rd1-c1 Nd4xf3+ e2xf3 e7-e6 Kg1-g2 Nf6-e8 f3-f4) +0.03/19 2} Kf8 {(Ke8-f8 Nb1-c3 e7-e6 Bc1-d2 Ng8-e7 b2-b4 Nc6-d4 Nf3xd4 c5xd4 Nc3-a4 b7-b6 Na4-b2 a7-a6 Rf1-c1 Bc8-d7 h2-h4 e6-e5 c2-c4 d4xc3/ep Bd2xc3 Bd7-e6 Bc3-d2 Kf8-g8 Kg1-h2) +0.48/22 6} 7. Nc3 {(Nb1-c3 Ng8-f6 Bc1-d2 a7-a5 Ra1-b1 Bc8-g4 Rb1-c1 Nf6-e8 h2-h3 Bg4xf3 Bg2xf3 e7-e6 e2-e4 Nc6-d4 Bf3-d1 d5xe4 Nc3xe4 Qd8-b6 Rc1-b1 Ne8-d6) +0.08/19 3} Nf6 {(Ng8-f6 Bc1-d2 a7-a6 Rf1-e1 b7-b6 e2-e4 d5xe4 d3xe4 Bc8-g4 Bd2-e3 Nf6-d7 Ra1-d1 Nc6-d4 Be3xd4 c5xd4 Nc3-e2 d4-d3 c2xd3 Bg7xb2 h2-h3 Bg4xf3 Bg2xf3 Bb2xa3) +0.75/20 6} 8. b4 {(b2-b4 Qd8-d6 Bc1-d2 d5-d4 Nc3-a2 Kf8-g8 b4-b5 Nc6-d8 c2-c4 e7-e5 Nf3-g5 h7-h6 Ng5-e4 Nf6xe4 Bg2xe4 a7-a6 Rf1-b1 a6xb5) +0.11/18 6} Qd6 {(Qd8-d6 Nc3-b5 Qd6-e6 Nb5-c3 b7-b6 Bc1-d2 Qe6-d6 e2-e3 e7-e5 b4-b5 Nc6-e7 e3-e4 d5-d4 Nc3-e2 Kf8-g8 a3-a4 c5-c4 a4-a5 b6xa5 Ra1xa5 c4-c3 Bd2-g5 Qd6-c7 Bg5xf6) +0.37/21 19} 9. Bd2 {(Bc1-d2 e7-e5 b4-b5 Nc6-d4 Nf3xd4 e5xd4 Nc3-a2 Kf8-g8 a3-a4 Qd6-e7 Rf1-e1 Bc8-e6 Na2-c1 c5-c4 Nc1-a2 c4-c3 Bd2-f4 Qe7-a3 Re1-b1 Qa3xa4 Na2-b4 Qa4xb5) +0.16/18 2} e5 {(e7-e5 b4-b5 Nc6-d4 Nf3xd4 e5xd4 Nc3-b1 Bc8-e6 a3-a4 Kf8-g8 Bd2-c1 a7-a5 b5xa6/ep b7xa6 Nb1-d2 Bg7-h6 Nd2-b3 Bh6xc1 Rf1xc1 h7-h6 a4-a5 Kg8-g7) +0.37/19 4} 10. b5 {(b4-b5 Nc6-d4 Nf3xd4 e5xd4 Nc3-a2 Bc8-g4 Rf1-e1 Kf8-g8 a3-a4 Nf6-h5 a4-a5 Qd6-d7 b5-b6 a7-a6 Na2-c1 c5-c4 Bd2-b4 Bg4-e6 Nc1-a2 c4-c3 Bb4-c5 Qd7-a4) 0.00/18 3} Nd4 {(Nc6-d4 Nf3xd4 e5xd4 Nc3-b1 Bc8-e6 a3-a4 h7-h6 Bd2-f4 Qd6-d8 Bf4-c1 a7-a5 b5xa6/ep b7xa6 Nb1-d2 Kf8-g8 Nd2-f3 Nf6-h5 Bc1-d2 c5-c4 Rf1-b1 Qd8-c7 a4-a5 c4-c3 Bd2-c1 g6-g5 Rb1-b6) +0.19/21 6} 11. Nxd4 {(Nf3xd4 e5xd4 Nc3-a2 Kf8-g8 a3-a4 Nf6-h5 a4-a5 Bc8-g4 Rf1-e1 Bg4-e6 Re1-b1 Qd6-d7 Na2-c1 c5-c4 Nc1-a2 Be6-g4 Na2-b4 c4-c3 Bd2-f4 Qd7xb5 Bf4-b8) -0.03/21 2} exd4 {(e5xd4 Nc3-b1 Bc8-e6 a3-a4 h7-h6 Bd2-c1 Kf8-g8 Nb1-d2 g6-g5 Nd2-f3 Nf6-h5 Bc1-d2 f7-f5 h2-h3 f5-f4 g3-g4 Nh5-f6 Rf1-e1 Kg8-f7 Kg1-h2 Be6-d7 Ra1-b1) +0.33/20 1} 12. Na2 {(Nc3-a2 Bc8-g4 Rf1-e1 Kf8-g8 a3-a4 Nf6-h5 Na2-c1 c5-c4 Nc1-a2 Bg4-e6 Bd2-b4 Qd6-c7 Na2-c1 Nh5-f6 Nc1-a2 Nf6-h5) 0.00/19 2} Kg8 {(Kf8-g8 a3-a4 Qd6-e7 Rf1-e1 Bc8-e6 c2-c3 d4xc3 Na2xc3 Qe7-d8 a4-a5 Nf6-e8 Re1-b1 h7-h6 b5-b6 a7-a6 h2-h3 c5-c4 g3-g4 d5-d4 Nc3-e4) +0.39/18 3} 13. a4 {(a3-a4 Qd6-e7 Na2-c1 c5-c4 Rf1-d1 Bc8-e6 Nc1-a2 Be6-g4 Rd1-e1 Qe7-c5 h2-h3 Bg4-e6 Bd2-b4 Qc5-b6 Bb4-d2) +0.01/18 1} Qe7 {(Qd6-e7 Rf1-e1 Bc8-e6 c2-c3 Nf6-g4 Re1-f1 b7-b6 h2-h3 d4xc3 Na2xc3 Ng4-f6 Rf1-c1 Qe7-d8 Kg1-h2 h7-h6 Rc1-d1 g6-g5 e2-e3 d5-d4 e3xd4 c5xd4) +0.37/18 5} 14. Nc1 {(Na2-c1 c5-c4 Rf1-e1 Bc8-e6 Nc1-a2 Nf6-d7 Bd2-b4 Qe7-d8 a4-a5 Qd8-c7 h2-h4 Nd7-f6 Re1-b1 Qc7-e5 Rb1-e1) 0.00/20 2} c4 {(c5-c4 Bd2-g5 Bc8-e6 Nc1-a2 h7-h6 Bg5-f4 Be6-d7 Rf1-e1 a7-a6 e2-e3 d4xe3 Bf4xe3 Nf6-g4 d3-d4 Qe7-a3 b5xa6 b7xa6 Bg2xd5 Qa3xa4) +0.58/18 1} 15. Re1 {(Rf1-e1 Bc8-e6 Nc1-a2 Nf6-d7 h2-h4 h7-h6 Bd2-b4 Qe7-d8 a4-a5 Qd8-c7 Re1-b1 Qc7-e5 Rb1-e1) 0.00/19 1} Nh5 {(Nf6-h5 Nc1-a2 c4-c3 Bd2-c1 Bc8-e6 Bg2-f3 Bg7-e5 Ra1-b1 Qe7-d8 Na2-b4 Be5-g7 e2-e4 d5xe4 Re1xe4 Qd8-a5 g3-g4 Nh5-f6 Re4xd4 Nf6-d7 Rd4-d6 Qa5xa4 Bf3xb7 Qa4xb5) +0.60/21 3} 16. Na2 {(Nc1-a2 c4-c3 Bd2-c1 Bc8-e6 Bg2-f3 Bg7-e5 Bc1-h6 Nh5-g7 Bh6xg7 Kg8xg7 Na2-c1 h7-h5 Nc1-b3 h5-h4 Bf3-g2 h4-h3 Bg2-h1 g6-g5 Re1-b1 f7-f5 a4-a5 f5-f4 Ra1-a4) +0.04/20 2} c3 {(c4-c3 Bd2-c1 Bc8-e6 Bg2-f3 h7-h6 Bf3xh5 g6xh5 Bc1-f4 h5-h4 Na2-c1 h6-h5 Nc1-b3 h4xg3 f2xg3 h5-h4 Kg1-f2 h4-h3 a4-a5 Be6-d7 b5-b6 a7-a6 Re1-b1 Bd7-g4 Rb1-e1 Bg4-e6 Ra1-b1) +0.03/21 8} 17. Bc1 {(Bd2-c1 Bc8-e6 Bg2-f3 Bg7-e5 Bc1-h6 Nh5-g7 Bh6xg7 Kg8xg7 Re1-b1 Qe7-g5 Na2-b4 Be5-d6 a4-a5 Bd6xb4 Rb1xb4 Qg5-d2 Ra1-a2 g6-g5 g3-g4 h7-h5 Rb4xd4 Qd2-e1+ Kg1-g2 h5xg4 Bf3xd5 Qe1xe2 Bd5xe6) +0.07/21 1} Be6 {(Bc8-e6 Bg2-f3 Bg7-e5 Ra1-b1 Qe7-d8 Bc1-h6 Nh5-g7 Bh6xg7 Kg8xg7 Rb1-a1 Qd8-g5 Re1-b1 Be5-d6 Na2-b4 Bd6-e7 a4-a5 Be7xb4 Rb1xb4 Qg5-d2 Ra1-a2 Qd2-e1+ Kg1-g2 h7-h5 Ra2-a4 Qe1-c1 Ra4-a2 h5-h4 g3xh4 Qc1-f4) +0.64/22 6} 18. Bf3 {(Bg2-f3 Bg7-e5 Ra1-b1 Be5-d6 Bc1-h6 Qe7-f6 Bh6-c1) 0.00/21 4} Be5 {(Bg7-e5 Bc1-h6 Qe7-f6 Bh6-c1 Be5-d6 Ra1-b1 Qf6-e7 Bc1-h6 g6-g5 Bf3xh5 Qe7-f6 Bh5-f3 Qf6xh6 Bf3-g2 g5-g4 Re1-d1 Qh6-g5 b5-b6 a7-a6 Na2-c1 h7-h5 Nc1-b3 h5-h4 Nb3xd4 h4-h3 Bg2-h1 Qg5-e5 Nd4xe6 f7xe6) +0.63/22 4} 19. Rb1 {(Ra1-b1 Qe7-d8 Na2-b4 Be5-g7 h2-h3 Bg7-e5 Kg1-g2 Qd8-a5 Nb4xd5 Qa5xa4 Rb1-b3 Kg8-g7 e2-e3 Qa4-a2 e3xd4 Be5xd4 Re1-e2 Qa2-a1 Re2-e1) 0.00/20 4} Qd8 {(Qe7-d8 Na2-b4 Be5-g7 Rb1-a1 Bg7-f8 Nb4-a2 Bf8-d6 Bc1-h6 Qd8-f6 Na2-c1 g6-g5 Bf3xh5 Qf6xh6 Bh5-f3 g5-g4 Bf3-g2 Qh6-d2 Nc1-b3 Qd2xc2 Nb3xd4 Qc2-d2 Re1-c1 Bd6-e5 Rc1-c2 Qd2-h6 e2-e3 Be5xd4 e3xd4 Qh6-f6 Rc2xc3 Qf6xd4) +0.63/22 7} 20. Bh6 {(Bc1-h6 Nh5-g7 Bh6xg7 Kg8xg7 Rb1-a1 Qd8-g5 a4-a5 Be5-d6 Na2-c1 Qg5-d2 Nc1-b3 Qd2xc2 Nb3xd4 Qc2-d2 Nd4-b3 Qd2-b2 Re1-b1 Qb2-c2 Nb3-d4 Qc2-d2 Nd4-b3 Qd2-g5 Rb1-c1 Bd6-b4 d3-d4) -0.09/23 11} Ng7 {(Nh5-g7 Bh6xg7 Kg8xg7 Na2-b4 h7-h5 a4-a5 Qd8xa5 Nb4xd5 h5-h4 Nd5-f4 Be6-d7 Bf3xb7 Be5xf4 g3xf4 Qa5-c7 Bb7-c6 Bd7xc6 b5xc6 Qc7xc6) +0.43/20 3} 21. Bxg7 {(Bh6xg7 Kg8xg7 Rb1-a1 Qd8-g5 a4-a5 h7-h5 Re1-b1 Be5-d6 Na2-c1 Qg5-d2 Nc1-b3 Qd2xc2 Nb3xd4 Qc2-d2 b5-b6 a7-a6 Rb1-c1 Qd2-b2 Rc1-b1 Qb2-d2) 0.00/21 1} Kxg7 {(Kg8xg7 Na2-b4 Qd8-a5 Nb4xd5 Qa5xa4 Re1-c1 Qa4-a3 b5-b6 a7-a6 Nd5-c7 Be6-c8 Rb1-a1 Qa3-e7 Ra1-a4 h7-h5 Nc7-d5 Qe7-d8 e2-e3 Bc8-d7 Ra4-a5 d4xe3 f2xe3 h5-h4 Nd5-f4) +0.37/20 5} 22. Ra1 {(Rb1-a1 Qd8-g5 a4-a5 h7-h5 Re1-b1 h5-h4 Na2-b4 Be5-d6 a5-a6 b7xa6 Nb4-c6 a6xb5 Rb1xb5 h4xg3 h2xg3 Bd6xg3 f2xg3 Qg5xg3+ Kg1-h1 Qg3-h3+ Kh1-g1 Qh3-g3+) 0.00/22 1} Qg5 {(Qd8-g5 a4-a5 h7-h5 a5-a6 b7xa6 Na2-b4 a6xb5 Ra1xa7 Qg5-d2 Re1-a1 Be5-d6 Nb4-c6 Bd6-c5 Ra7-a5 Qd2xc2 Ra5xb5 Bc5-d6 Nc6xd4 Qc2-d2 Rb5-b7 Be6-c8 Rb7-b1 Bd6-e5 Nd4-c6 c3-c2 Nc6xe5) +0.44/23 11} 23. a5 {(a4-a5 h7-h5 a5-a6 b7xa6 b5xa6 h5-h4 Na2-b4 h4xg3 h2xg3 Be5-d6 Nb4-c6 Bd6xg3 f2xg3 Qg5xg3+ Kg1-h1 Qg3-h3+ Kh1-g1) 0.00/22 1} h5 {(h7-h5 a5-a6 b7xa6 b5xa6 Be5-d6 Na2-c1 Bd6-c5 h2-h4 Qg5-e5 Nc1-b3 Bc5-b6 Kg1-g2 Be6-d7 Ra1-b1 Qe5-d6 Re1-h1 f7-f5 Kg2-f1 f5-f4 g3xf4 Qd6xf4 Bf3xd5 Qf4-e5 Bd5-g2) +0.60/19 1} 24. a6 {(a5-a6 b7xa6 b5xa6 h5-h4 Na2-b4 h4xg3 h2xg3 Be5-d6 Nb4-c6 Bd6xg3 f2xg3 Qg5xg3+ Kg1-h1 Qg3-h3+ Kh1-g1 Qh3-g3+) 0.00/23 3} bxa6 {(b7xa6 b5xa6 Be5-d6 Na2-c1 Bd6-c5 h2-h4 Qg5-d8 Nc1-b3 Bc5-b6 Re1-b1 f7-f5 Ra1-a4 f5-f4 g3xf4 Qd8-f6 Ra4-b4 Be6-c8 Rb1-a1 Bc8-d7 Ra1-b1 Qf6-d6 Nb3xd4 Bb6-c5 Nd4-b5 Qd6xa6 Nb5xc3) +0.12/22 5} 25. bxa6 {(b5xa6 Be5-d6 Na2-c1 h5-h4 Nc1-b3 h4xg3 h2xg3 Bd6xg3 f2xg3 Qg5xg3+ Kg1-h1 Qg3-h3+ Kh1-g1) 0.00/23 1} Bd6 {(Be5-d6 Na2-c1 Bd6-c7 Nc1-b3 Bc7-b6 h2-h4 Qg5-d8 Re1-b1 Be6-c8 Ra1-a4 Qd8-d6 Rb1-a1 Bc8-d7 Ra4xd4 g6-g5 e2-e3 Bb6xd4 Nb3xd4 g5xh4 g3xh4 Qd6-f6 Ra1-a5 Bd7-e6 Bf3xd5 Be6xd5 Ra5xd5 Qf6xh4) +0.42/22 4} 26. Nc1 {(Na2-c1 h5-h4 Nc1-b3 h4xg3 h2xg3 Bd6xg3 f2xg3 Qg5xg3+ Kg1-h1 Qg3-h3+ Kh1-g1) 0.00/24 2} Bc7 {(Bd6-c7 Nc1-b3 Bc7-b6 h2-h4 Qg5-d8 Ra1-a4 Qd8-d6 Re1-a1 f7-f6 Bf3-g2 Kg7-h6 Ra4xd4 Bb6xd4 Nb3xd4 g6-g5 e2-e3 g5-g4 Kg1-f1 Kh6-h7 Kf1-g1 Qd6-b6 f2-f4 Qb6-b2 Ra1-a5 Qb2-b6 Ra5-b5 Qb6xa6) +0.40/20 1} 27. Nb3 {(Nc1-b3 Bc7-b6 h2-h4 Qg5-e5 Kg1-g2 Be6-d7 Nb3-a5 Bb6-c7 Re1-h1 f7-f5 Na5-b7 Bd7-c8 Nb7-a5) 0.00/21 2} Bb6 {(Bc7-b6 h2-h4 Qg5-d8 Re1-b1 Be6-c8 Ra1-a4 Qd8-d6 Kg1-f1 Bc8-d7 Ra4xd4 Bb6xd4 Nb3xd4 Bd7-h3+ Kf1-g1 Qd6-c5 e2-e3 Qc5-a5 Rb1-b3 Qa5xa6 Bf3xd5 Qa6-a2 Bd5-c4) +0.44/22 4} 28. h4 {(h2-h4 Qg5-e5 Nb3-a5 g6-g5 Re1-b1 Bb6xa5 Ra1xa5 g5xh4 g3xh4 Qe5-f6 Rb1-b7 Qf6xh4 Rb7xa7 Qh4-g5+ Kg1-h2 Qg5-f4+ Kh2-g2 Qf4-c1 Ra7-b7 h5-h4 a6-a7 h4-h3+ Kg2-h2 Qc1-f4+ Kh2-g1 Qf4-g5+ Kg1-h1 Qg5-c1+) 0.00/22 3} Qd8 {(Qg5-d8 Kg1-g2 Be6-c8 Ra1-a4 Qd8-d7 Re1-a1 g6-g5 h4xg5 h5-h4 g3-g4 Qd7-e7 Nb3xd4 Qe7xg5 Kg2-h3 Qg5-f6 Nd4-f5+ Bc8xf5 g4xf5 Qf6xf5+ Ra4-g4+ Kg7-f8 Kh3-g2 h4-h3+ Kg2-f1 Qf5-h5 Rg4-g3 h3-h2 Kf1-g2) +0.46/19 2} 29. Reb1 {(Re1-b1 g6-g5 h4xg5 Qd8xg5 Kg1-g2 h5-h4 Rb1-h1 h4xg3 Rh1-h5 Qg5-g6 Ra1-g1 Kg7-f8 f2xg3 Kf8-e8 Kg2-f2 Qg6-f6 Rg1-b1 Bb6-c7 Rb1-g1 Bc7-d6 Rh5-h4 Bd6-e5 Rh4-h5 Be5-d6) 0.00/22 2} Bc8 {(Be6-c8 Ra1-a4 g6-g5 Nb3xd4 g5xh4 g3xh4 Qd8-f6 Rb1xb6 Qf6xb6 e2-e3 Qb6-g6+ Kg1-h1 Qg6-f6 Kh1-g1 Kg7-h7 Ra4-a5 Qf6xh4 Ra5xd5 Bc8-g4 Bf3xg4 Qh4xg4+ Kg1-h2 Kh7-g7 Rd5-f5 h5-h4 Rf5-c5) +0.50/19 2} 30. Kf1 {(Kg1-f1 f7-f5 Ra1-a4 f5-f4 g3xf4 Qd8-f6 Bf3-g2 Bc8-g4 Kf1-g1 Bg4xe2 Ra4-b4 Be2-g4 Nb3-c1 Qf6-e7 Rb4xb6 Qe7-e1+ Kg1-h2 Qe1xf2 Rb6-b8 Qf2xh4+ Kh2-g1 Qh4-e1+ Kg1-h2 Qe1-h4+) 0.00/22 7} f5 {(f7-f5 Ra1-a4 Qd8-f6 Bf3-g2 f5-f4 g3xf4 Kg7-f8 Rb1-a1 Bc8-g4 Ra1-b1 Qf6xf4 e2-e3 Qf4-h2 Nb3xd4 Bg4-h3 Bg2xh3 Qh2-h1+ Kf1-e2 Qh1xb1 Bh3-e6) +0.58/17 2} 31. Ra4 {(Ra1-a4 f5-f4 g3xf4 Qd8-f6 Bf3-g2 Qf6xh4 Nb3xd4 Bc8-h3 e2-e3 Bh3xg2+ Kf1xg2 Qh4-g4+ Kg2-h1 Qg4-h3+ Kh1-g1 Qh3-g4+) 0.00/22 1} Qf6 {(Qd8-f6 Bf3-g2 f5-f4 g3xf4 Kg7-h7 Kf1-g1 Kh7-h6 Kg1-f1 Bc8-g4 Rb1-a1 Bg4-d7 Ra4-b4 Qf6-d6 Rb4xb6 Qd6xb6 Ra1-a5 Qb6-f6 Ra5xd5) +0.70/19 1} 32. Bg2 {(Bf3-g2 f5-f4 g3xf4 Qf6xh4 Nb3xd4 Bc8-h3 e2-e3 Bh3xg2+ Kf1xg2 Qh4-g4+ Kg2-f1 Bb6xd4 Ra4xd4 Qg4-h3+ Kf1-g1 Qh3-g4+) 0.00/23 2} f4 {(f5-f4 g3xf4 Kg7-h7 Kf1-g1 Kh7-h6 Rb1-a1 Bc8-g4 Ra4-b4 Bg4xe2 Rb4-b5 Be2-g4 Ra1-b1 Bg4-c8 Rb1-a1 Bc8-d7 Rb5xd5 Bd7-e6 Rd5-g5 Be6xb3 c2xb3 Qf6xf4) +1.14/18 1} 33. gxf4 {(g3xf4 Qf6xh4 Nb3xd4 Bc8-h3 Nd4-e6+ Kg7-h6 Rb1xb6 Qh4-g4 Bg2xh3 Qg4xh3+ Kf1-g1 Qh3-g4+ Kg1-h2 Qg4-h4+ Kh2-g1) 0.00/24 3} Kh7 {(Kg7-h7 Ra4-b4 Bc8xa6 Rb1-a1 Ba6-c8 Ra1-a4 Qf6xf4 e2-e3 Qf4-d6 Rb4xb6 Qd6xb6 Ra4xd4 Bc8-g4 Bg2xd5 Bg4-d1 Rd4-c4 Qb6-d6 Bd5-g2 Bd1xc2 Rc4xc3 Bc2xd3+ Kf1-g1) +1.38/19 2} 34. Rb4 {(Ra4-b4 Bc8xa6) -1.13/23 25} Bxa6 {(Bc8xa6 Rb1-a1 Ba6-c8 Ra1-a4 Qf6xf4 e2-e3 Qf4-d6 Rb4xd4 Bb6xd4 Nb3xd4 a7-a6 Kf1-g1 Kh7-h6 Nd4-e2 Bc8-d7 Ra4-a1 Qd6-f6 Bg2xd5 Qf6xh4 Ne2xc3 Qh4-g5+ Kg1-f1 Bd7-c8 d3-d4 h5-h4) +1.44/21 3} 35. f5 {(f4-f5 g6xf5 Rb1-a1 Ba6-c8 Rb4-a4 f5-f4 Ra4xa7+ Bb6xa7 Ra1xa7+ Kh7-h6 Ra7-a5 Qf6xh4 Nb3xd4 Qh4-f6 Ra5xd5 Qf6-b6 Nd4-b5 Bc8-e6 Rd5-e5 Be6-g4 Re5-d5 Qb6-a5 Bg2-f3 Bg4xf3 e2xf3) -1.08/21 2} gxf5 {(g6xf5 Rb1-a1 Ba6-c8 Rb4-b5 Qf6xh4 Rb5xd5 Bc8-e6 Rd5-b5 Qh4-h2 Rb5xb6 a7xb6 Nb3xd4 Qh2-d6 e2-e3 f5-f4 Nd4xe6 Qd6xe6 Bg2-e4+ Kh7-h6 e3xf4 Qe6-f6 Ra1-b1 Kh6-g7 Rb1-b5 Qf6xf4 Rb5xh5 Qf4-c1+ Kf1-g2 Qc1xc2) +1.47/19 2} 36. Ra1 {(Rb1-a1 Ba6-c8 Rb4-a4 f5-f4 Ra4xa7+ Bb6xa7 Ra1xa7+ Kh7-h6 Ra7-a8 Bc8-g4 Ra8-a4 Qf6xh4 Ra4-a6+ Kh6-g7 Ra6-a7+ Kg7-f6 Nb3xd4 Qh4-g5 Ra7-a6+ Kf6-e7 Ra6-a7+ Ke7-d6 Ra7-a6+ Kd6-c5 Nd4-f3 Qg5-g8 d3-d4+ Kc5-b5 Ra6-d6 Kb5-a4 Nf3-e1) -1.43/20 2} Bc8 {(Ba6-c8 Rb4-a4 Qf6xh4 Ra4xa7+ Bb6xa7 Ra1xa7+ Kh7-g6 Ra7-c7 Qh4-d8 Rc7-c5 Bc8-b7 Nb3xd4 Qd8-f6 Nd4-b5 Qf6-g5 e2-e3 f5-f4 Nb5xc3 f4xe3 Nc3xd5 e3xf2 Bg2-e4+ Kg6-h6 Kf1xf2 Qg5-h4+ Kf2-e3 Qh4-h2 Ke3-d4 Qh2-g1+ Nd5-e3) +1.48/21 3} 37. Rba4 {(Rb4-a4 f5-f4 Ra4xa7+ Bb6xa7 Ra1xa7+ Kh7-h6 Ra7-a8 Bc8-g4 Bg2xd5 Qf6xh4 Ra8-a6+ Kh6-g7 Ra6-a7+ Kg7-f8 Ra7-a8+ Kf8-e7 Ra8-a7+ Ke7-d6 Bd5-g2 f4-f3 Ra7-a6+ Kd6-c7 e2xf3 Bg4-h3 Bg2xh3 Qh4xh3+ Kf1-e2 Qh3-c8) -1.23/21 4} Qxh4 {(Qf6xh4 Ra4xa7+ Bb6xa7 Ra1xa7+ Kh7-h6 Ra7-c7 Qh4-d8 Rc7-c6+ Kh6-h7 Nb3xd4 f5-f4 Rc6-c5 Kh7-g7 Nd4-b3 Bc8-e6 Rc5xc3 h5-h4 d3-d4 Qd8-d6 Bg2-h3 Kg7-f6 Nb3-c5 Be6xh3+ Rc3xh3 Kf6-g5 Rh3-c3 Qd6-g6) +1.27/21 4} 38. Rxa7+ {(Ra4xa7+ Bb6xa7 Ra1xa7+ Kh7-g6 Ra7-c7 Qh4-d8 Rc7-c6+ Kg6-f7 Nb3xd4 f5-f4 Rc6-c5 Bc8-g4 Rc5-b5 Qd8-d6 Kf1-g1 h5-h4 Bg2xd5+ Kf7-f6 Bd5-f3 Qd6xd4 Bf3xg4 Qd4-a4 Rb5-f5+ Kf6-e7 Rf5-e5+ Ke7-d6 Re5-e6+ Kd6-c7 Re6-e7+ Kc7-d6) -1.21/17 1} Bxa7 {(Bb6xa7 Ra1xa7+ Kh7-h6 Ra7-c7 Qh4-d8 Rc7-c6+ Kh6-h7 Nb3xd4 f5-f4 Rc6-c5 Kh7-g7 Nd4-b3 d5-d4 Rc5xh5 Bc8-e6 Nb3-c5 Be6-f7 Bg2-e4 Qd8-b6 Rh5-h7+ Kg7-g8 Nc5-d7 Qb6-e6 Nd7-b8 Qe6-a2 Nb8-d7 Qa2xc2 Nd7-f6+ Kg8-f8 Nf6-d7+ Kf8-e7 Nd7-e5 Qc2-d1+ Kf1-g2) +1.50/19 1} 39. Rxa7+ {(Ra1xa7+ Kh7-h6 Ra7-c7 Qh4-d8 Rc7-c5 f5-f4 Nb3xd4 h5-h4 Bg2-f3 h4-h3 Rc5xd5 Qd8-b6 e2-e3 Qb6-b1+ Kf1-e2 f4xe3 Rd5-c5 Qb1-g1 Ke2xe3 Qg1-e1+ Ke3-f4 Qe1xf2 Rc5-c6+ Kh6-g7 Rc6xc8) -1.09/19 3} Kh6 {(Kh7-h6 Ra7-c7 Qh4-d8 Rc7-c5 f5-f4 Kf1-g1 Bc8-b7 Nb3xd4 Qd8-f6 Nd4-b3 h5-h4 Nb3-a5 Bb7-a8 Kg1-f1 Qf6-f5 Na5-b3 h4-h3 Bg2-f3 Qf5-f6 d3-d4 Qf6-g6 Rc5xc3 h3-h2 Bf3-g2) +1.84/22 7} 40. Rc7 {(Ra7-c7 Qh4-d8 Rc7-c6+ Kh6-h7 Nb3xd4 f5-f4 Rc6-c5 Kh7-g7 Nd4-b3 h5-h4 Rc5xd5 Qd8-f6 Bg2-e4 Bc8-g4 Rd5-c5 h4-h3 Rc5-c7+ Kg7-f8 Rc7-h7 Qf6-e5 Be4-f3 Bg4xf3 e2xf3) -1.10/18 2} Qd8 {(Qh4-d8 Rc7-c5 f5-f4 Kf1-g1 Qd8-h8 Rc5-c6+ Kh6-g5 Bg2xd5 Bc8-g4 Rc6-c4 Qh8-d8 Rc4xd4 Qd8-b6 Rd4-c4 Bg4xe2 Bd5-e4 Kg5-h4 Kg1-g2 Qb6-f6 Nb3-d4 Qf6-g7+ Kg2-h2 Qg7-g4) +1.88/19 1} 41. Rc6+ {(Rc7-c6+ Kh6-h7 Nb3xd4 f5-f4 Rc6-c5 Kh7-g7 Nd4-b3 h5-h4 Rc5xd5 Qd8-f6 Rd5-c5 Bc8-g4 Bg2-e4 h4-h3 Rc5-c7+ Kg7-g8 Be4-d5+ Bg4-e6 Rc7-c6 h3-h2 Rc6xe6 h2-h1Q+ Bd5xh1 Qf6xe6 Nb3-d4 Qe6-h3+ Bh1-g2) -1.21/19 5} Kh7 {(Kh6-h7 Nb3xd4 f5-f4 Bg2-f3 h5-h4 Kf1-g1 Qd8-d7 Kg1-h2 Qd7-a7 Rc6xc8 Qa7xd4 Kh2-g2 Kh7-h6 Bf3-g4 Qd4-b4 Kg2-f3 Qb4-b2 Rc8-c5 Qb2xc2 Rc5xd5 Qc2-a4 Rd5-h5+ Kh6-g7 Rh5xh4) +1.93/20 1} 42. Nxd4 {(Nb3xd4 f5-f4 Kf1-g1 h5-h4 Kg1-h2 h4-h3 Bg2xh3 Qd8-h4 Rc6-c7+ Kh7-g6 Rc7-c6+ Kg6-h5 Rc6xc8 Qh4xf2+ Bh3-g2 Qf2xd4 Bg2-f3+ Kh5-g6 Kh2-g2 Kg6-f6 Rc8-a8 Qd4-e3 Ra8-c8 Qe3-d2 Kg2-f2 Kf6-e5 Rc8-d8 Qd2xc2 Rd8xd5+ Ke5-f6) -1.76/19 3} f4 {(f5-f4 Bg2-f3 h5-h4 Kf1-g1 Qd8-d7 Kg1-h1 Qd7-a7 Rc6xc8 Qa7xd4 Kh1-g2 Kh7-g6 Rc8-g8+ Kg6-f6 Rg8-a8 Qd4-b6 Bf3xd5 h4-h3+ Kg2-f3 Qb6-c5 Bd5-e4 Kf6-g7 Kf3xf4 Qc5xf2+ Kf4-g5 Qf2-g3+ Kg5-h5) +2.10/21 5} 43. Rc5 {(Rc6-c5 Kh7-g7 Bg2-f3 h5-h4 Rc5xd5 Qd8-b6 Nd4-b5 h4-h3 Nb5xc3 Qb6-b2 Nc3-d1 Qb2xc2 e2-e3 Qc2-d2 Rd5-d6 f4xe3 Nd1xe3) -1.58/18 2} Kg7 {(Kh7-g7 Bg2-f3 h5-h4 Rc5xd5 Qd8-b6 Nd4-b5 h4-h3 Kf1-g1 h3-h2+ Kg1-g2 h2-h1Q+ Kg2xh1 Qb6xf2 Nb5-d6 Qf2-h4+ Kh1-g1 Bc8-g4 Nd6-e4 Bg4xf3 e2xf3 Qh4-e1+ Kg1-h2 Qe1-e2+ Kh2-h3 Qe2xf3+ Kh3-h4 Qf3-e2 Rd5-c5 f4-f3 Rc5-g5+ Kg7-f7) +1.77/21 4} 44. Bf3 {(Bg2-f3 h5-h4 Rc5xd5 Qd8-b6 Nd4-b5 h4-h3 Kf1-g1 h3-h2+ Kg1-g2 h2-h1Q+ Kg2xh1 Qb6xf2 Nb5-d6 Qf2-h4+ Kh1-g1 Bc8-g4 Nd6-e4 Bg4xf3 Rd5-g5+ Kg7-f8 e2xf3 Qh4-e1+ Kg1-h2 Qe1-e2+ Kh2-h3 Qe2xc2 Kh3-g4 Qc2xd3 Rg5-c5 c3-c2 Rc5-c8+ Kf8-e7 Kg4xf4) -1.32/18 2} h4 {(h5-h4 Nd4-b3 Bc8-e6 Nb3-d4 Be6-h3+ Kf1-g1 Qd8-b6 Nd4-b3 Bh3-e6 Kg1-h2 Kg7-f6 d3-d4 Qb6-d6 Kh2-g2 Kf6-g5 Kg2-h2 Kg5-f5 Kh2-g2 Be6-f7 Kg2-h2 Qd6-h6 Bf3xd5 Bf7xd5 Rc5xd5+ Kf5-g4) +1.87/20 2} 45. Rxd5 {(Rc5xd5 Qd8-b6 Nd4-b5 h4-h3 Kf1-g1 h3-h2+ Kg1-g2 h2-h1Q+ Kg2xh1 Qb6xf2 Nb5-d6 Qf2-h4+ Kh1-g1 Bc8-g4 Nd6-e4 Bg4xf3 Rd5-g5+ Kg7-f8 Rg5-f5+ Kf8-e8 Rf5-e5+ Ke8-d7 e2xf3 Qh4-e1+ Kg1-h2 Qe1-e2+ Kh2-h3 Qe2xc2 Re5-d5+ Kd7-e6 Rd5-c5 Qc2-d1 Rc5xc3 Qd1xf3+ Kh3-h4) -1.48/20 1} Qb6 {(Qd8-b6 Nd4-b5 h4-h3 Rd5-g5+ Kg7-f8 Rg5-h5 Bc8-e6 Nb5xc3 Qb6-b2 Nc3-d1 Qb2xc2 Kf1-e1 Qc2-b1 e2-e3 Qb1xd3 Rh5-h4 f4xe3 Nd1xe3 Qd3-b1+ Ke1-d2 Qb1-b2+ Kd2-e1 Qb2-e5 Rh4-h5 Qe5-f6 Ke1-e2 Qf6-c3) +2.52/18 1} 46. Nb5 {(Nd4-b5 h4-h3 Kf1-g1 h3-h2+ Kg1-g2 h2-h1Q+ Kg2xh1 Qb6xf2 Nb5-d6 Qf2-h4+ Kh1-g1 Bc8-g4 Nd6-e4 Bg4xf3 Rd5-g5+ Kg7-f8 e2xf3 Qh4-e1+ Kg1-h2 Qe1-e2+ Rg5-g2 Qe2xf3 Rg2-f2 Qf3-g4 Rf2-g2 Qg4-h5+ Kh2-g1 Qh5-d1+ Kg1-h2 Kf8-e7 Rg2-g7+ Ke7-d8 Rg7-g2 Kd8-c7 Rg2-f2 Qd1-g4 Rf2-g2 Qg4-h5+ Kh2-g1 Qh5-d1+ Kg1-h2 Kc7-c6 Rg2-g6+ Kc6-b7 Rg6-g7+ Kb7-c8 Rg7-g2 Qd1-h5+ Kh2-g1) -1.92/23 3} h3 {(h4-h3 Rd5-g5+ Kg7-f8 Rg5-h5 Bc8-e6 Nb5xc3 Qb6-b2 Nc3-d1 Qb2xc2 Kf1-e1 Qc2-b1 Rh5-h8+ Kf8-g7 Rh8-h4 Qb1-b4+ Ke1-f1 Qb4-d2 e2-e3 Be6-d5 Rh4xh3 Bd5xf3 Rh3xf3 Qd2xd1+ Kf1-g2 Qd1xd3 Rf3xf4 Qd3-d6 Rf4-g4+ Kg7-f6) +2.70/19 2} 47. Kg1 {(Kf1-g1 h3-h2+ Kg1-g2 h2-h1Q+ Kg2xh1 Qb6xf2 Nb5-d4 Qf2-e1+ Kh1-h2 Qe1-g3+ Kh2-h1 Bc8-h3 Nd4-b5 Qg3-e1+ Kh1-h2 Qe1-f2+ Kh2-h1 Bh3-e6 Rd5-h5 Be6-f7 Rh5-e5 Kg7-f6 d3-d4 Qf2-h4+ Kh1-g2 Qh4-g3+ Kg2-h1 Bf7-e6 Nb5-d6 Qg3-e1+ Kh1-g2) -2.03/23 5} Kf8 {(Kg7-f8 Nb5-d4 Qb6-b1+ Kg1-h2 Qb1-e1 Rd5-d8+ Kf8-g7 Rd8xc8 Qe1xf2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kg7-h6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-e5 Rc4-e4 Qe5-g5 Re4-b4 Kh6-g7 Rb4-b1 Kg7-f6 Rb1-g1 Qg5-a5 Rg1-g4 Kf6-f5 Rg4-h4 Qa5-a4 Rh4xh3 Qa4xc2) +2.84/21 2} 48. Nd4 {(Nb5-d4 Qb6-b1+ Kg1-h2 Qb1-f1 Rd5-d8+ Kf8-f7 Rd8xc8 Qf1xf2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c4 Qd4-e5 Rc4-c8 Kf7-f6 Rc8-f8+ Kf6-e7 Rf8-c8 Ke7-f7 Rc8-c4 Kf7-f6 Rc4-c8 Qe5-e3 Rc8xc3 Kf6-g5 Rc3-c8) -1.94/18 0} Qb1+ {(Qb6-b1+ Kg1-h2 Qb1-e1 Rd5-d8+ Kf8-g7 Rd8xc8 Qe1xf2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kg7-h6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-e5 Kh1-h2 Qe5-g5 Rc4-c6+ Kh6-g7 Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f6 Rc7-c6+ Kf6-e7 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d6 Rc7-c6+ Kd6-d7 Rc6-a6 Qg5-g3+ Kh2-h1 Qg3-e1+ Kh1-h2 Qe1-f2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2-g3 Ra6-h6 Kd7-e7 Rh6-a6) +3.36/22 3} 49. Kh2 {(Kg1-h2) -1.94/1} Qe1 {(Qb1-e1 Rd5-d8+ Kf8-g7 Rd8xc8 Qe1xf2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kg7-h6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-e5 Rc4-c8 Kh6-g5 Rc8-g8+ Kg5-f6 Rg8-c8 Qe5-a5 Rc8-c6+ Kf6-e7 Kh1-h2 Qa5-g5 Kh2-h1 Qg5-g3 Rc6-h6 Qg3-e1+ Kh1-h2 Qe1-f2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2-g3) +3.58/21 0} 50. Rd8+ {(Rd5-d8+ Kf8-f7 Rd8xc8 Qe1xf2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kf7-f6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-e5 Rc4-e4 Qe5-g5 d3-d4 Qg5-h4 d4-d5 Kf6-g7 Re4-b4 Kg7-g6 d5-d6 Kg6-f6 Rb4-e4 Qh4-e1+ Kh1-h2 Qe1-f2+ Kh2-h1 Kf6-f5 Re4-e8 Qf2-d4 Re8-f8+ Kf5-e6 Kh1-h2 Qd4-f2+ Kh2-h1) -2.59/20 1} Kg7 {(Kf8-g7 Rd8xc8 Qe1xf2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kg7-h6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-e5 Rc4-c8 Kh6-g5 Rc8-g8+ Kg5-f6 Rg8-c8 Qe5-a5 Kh1-h2 Qa5-g5 Rc8-c6+ Kf6-e7 Kh2-h1 Qg5-g3 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-f6 Rc7-c4 Kf6-g7 Rc4-a4 Qg3-e1+ Kh1-h2 Qe1-c1 Ra4-a2 Qc1-b1 Bf3-d5 Kg7-f6 Ra2-a6+ Kf6-e5 Bd5-b3 Qb1-f1 Ra6-a5+ Ke5-d4) +3.64/22 0} 51. Rxc8 {(Rd8xc8 Qe1xf2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kg7-f6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-e5 Rc4-e4 Qe5-g5 d3-d4 Qg5-h4 d4-d5 Kf6-g7 Re4-a4 Kg7-g6 Ra4-a1 Kg6-f6 Ra1-a6+ Kf6-g5 Kh1-h2 Qh4-f2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2-g3 Ra6-a8) -2.37/20 1} Qxf2+ {(Qe1xf2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kg7-h6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-f2 Rc4xf4 Qf2-e3 Rf4-h4+ Kh6-g5 Rh4-g4+ Kg5-f6 Kh1-h2 Qe3-d2 Kh2xh3 Qd2xc2 Rg4-f4+ Kf6-g5 Rf4-g4+ Kg5-f5 Kh3-g3 Qc2-d2 Bf3-e4+ Kf5-f6 Kg3-f3 c3-c2 Rg4-g6+ Kf6-f7 Rg6-c6 c2-c1Q Rc6xc1) +4.25/23 4} 52. Kh1 {(Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kg7-h6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-e5 d3-d4 Qe5-e3 Rc4-c6+ Kh6-g5 Rc6-c5+ Kg5-g6 Rc5-c6+ Kg6-f7 Rc6-c7+ Kf7-f8 d4-d5 Qe3-c1+ Kh1-h2 Qc1xc2 d5-d6 Qc2-d2 Rc7-c5 c3-c2 Rc5-c8+ Kf8-f7 d6-d7 Qd2xd7 Rc8xc2) -3.35/21 1} Qxd4 {(Qf2xd4 Rc8-c7+ Kg7-h6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-f2 Rc4-c6+ Kh6-g5 Rc6-a6 Qf2-e1+ Kh1-h2 Qe1-b1 Ra6-a5+ Kg5-f6 d3-d4 Qb1xc2 Ra5-a6+ Kf6-e7 Ra6-a7+ Ke7-d8 Ra7-a8+ Kd8-c7 Ra8-a7+ Kc7-b6 Ra7-b7+ Kb6-a5 Rb7-c7 Qc2-d2 Rc7-c6 Ka5-b5) +4.48/21 2} 53. Rc7+ {(Rc8-c7+ Kg7-h6) -4.34/23 8} Kh6 {(Kg7-h6 Rc7-c4 Qd4-f2 Rc4xf4 Qf2-e3 Rf4-h4+ Kh6-g5 Rh4-g4+ Kg5-f6 Kh1-h2 Qe3-d2 Kh2xh3 Qd2xc2 Rg4-f4+ Kf6-g5 Rf4-g4+ Kg5-f5 Kh3-h4 Qc2-d2 Bf3-e4+ Kf5-f6 Rg4-g6+ Kf6-e5 Rg6-c6 Qd2xe2) +4.68/19 1} 54. Rc4 {(Rc7-c4 Qd4-e5 Bf3-e4 Kh6-g5 Rc4-a4 Qe5-c5 Ra4-a1 Qc5-e3 Be4-f3 Qe3-d2 Ra1-a2 Qd2-c1+ Kh1-h2 Qc1-b1 Bf3-d5 Kg5-f6 d3-d4 Qb1-e1 Ra2-a6+ Kf6-g5 Bd5-f3 Qe1-f2+ Kh2-h1 Qf2xd4 Ra6-a5+ Kg5-f6 Ra5-a6+ Kf6-e7) -3.83/21 0} Qf2 {(Qd4-f2 Rc4xf4 Qf2-e3 Rf4-h4+ Kh6-g5 Rh4-g4+ Kg5-f5 Kh1-h2 Qe3-c1 Kh2xh3 Qc1xc2 Bf3-e4+ Kf5-f6 Rg4-g6+ Kf6-e5 e2-e3 Qc2-c1 Rg6-g5+ Ke5-e6 Rg5-g6+ Ke6-f7 Rg6-c6 c3-c2 Kh3-g4 Qc1-d1+ Be4-f3 c2-c1Q Bf3xd1) +4.52/21 4} 55. Rxf4 {(Rc4xf4 Qf2-e1+ Kh1-h2 Qe1-d2 Rf4-c4 Qd2xc2 Kh2xh3 Qc2-d2 Kh3-g2 c3-c2 d3-d4 c2-c1Q Rc4xc1 Qd2xc1 Bf3-e4 Qc1-g5+ Kg2-f2) -3.80/14 0} Qe3 {(Qf2-e3 Rf4-h4+ Kh6-g5 Rh4-g4+ Kg5-f5 Kh1-h2 Qe3-c1 Kh2xh3 Qc1xc2 Rg4-c4 Qc2-d2 Rc4-c5+ Kf5-f4 Rc5-c4+ Kf4-e3 Kh3-g2 Qd2-b2 Rc4-e4+ Ke3-d2 Re4-c4 c3-c2 d3-d4 Kd2-e3 d4-d5 c2-c1Q Rc4xc1) +4.85/18 1} 56. Rh4+ {(Rf4-h4+ Kh6-g7 Rh4-g4+ Kg7-f6 Kh1-h2 Qe3-d2 Kh2xh3 Qd2xc2 Rg4-f4+ Kf6-e6 Rf4-e4+ Ke6-f5 Bf3-g4+ Kf5-f6 Re4-e6+ Kf6-f7 Re6-c6 Qc2-d2 Bg4-f3 Kf7-g7 Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f6 Rc7-c6+ Kf6-g5 Kh3-g3) -4.42/21 3} Kg5 {(Kh6-g5 Rh4-g4+ Kg5-f5 Kh1-h2 Qe3-c1 Kh2-g3 Qc1xc2 Rg4-f4+ Kf5-e5 Rf4-e4+ Ke5-d6 Re4-d4+ Kd6-c5 Rd4-c4+ Kc5-b5 Bf3-g4 Qc2-d2 Bg4-d7+ Kb5-a5 Rc4-c5+ Ka5-b4 Rc5-c4+ Kb4-b3) +5.04/17 0} 57. Rh5+ {(Rh4-h5+ Kg5-f6 Rh5xh3 Qe3-c1+ Kh1-g2 Qc1xc2 Rh3-h6+ Kf6-g7 Rh6-b6 Qc2-d2 Rb6-b7+ Kg7-f6 Rb7-b6+ Kf6-e7 Rb6-b7+ Ke7-d6 Rb7-b6+ Kd6-c5 Rb6-c6+ Kc5-b5 Rc6-c7 c3-c2 Rc7-b7+ Kb5-a4 Rb7-c7 c2-c1Q Rc7xc1) -4.27/15 0} Kf6 {(Kg5-f6 Kh1-h2 Qe3-c1 Kh2xh3 Qc1xc2 Rh5-h6+ Kf6-g7 Rh6-c6 Qc2-d2 Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f6 Kh3-g2 c3-c2 Kg2-f2 c2-c1Q Rc7xc1 Qd2xc1 e2-e3 Qc1-d2+ Bf3-e2 Qd2-c2 Kf2-f3 Qc2-c1) +5.15/18 1} 58. Rxh3 {(Rh5xh3 Qe3-c1+ Kh1-g2 Qc1xc2 Rh3-h6+ Kf6-g7 Rh6-c6 Qc2-d2 Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f6 Kg2-f2 c3-c2 Rc7-c6+ Kf6-e7 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d8 Rc7xc2 Qd2xc2 Kf2-e3 Kd8-e7 d3-d4 Qc2-c3+ Ke3-e4 Ke7-d6 Bf3-g4 Qc3-c2+ Ke4-e3 Kd6-d5 Bg4-f3+ Kd5-c4) -4.97/21 3} Qc1+ {(Qe3-c1+ Kh1-g2 Qc1xc2 Rh3-h6+ Kf6-g7 Rh6-c6 Qc2-d2 Kg2-f1 c3-c2 Kf1-f2 Qd2-d1 Rc6-c4 Kg7-f6 Rc4-f4+ Kf6-e7 Rf4-e4+ Ke7-d6 Re4-d4+ Kd6-e5 Rd4-e4+ Ke5-f5 Re4-c4 Qd1-d2 Kf2-g3 c2-c1Q Rc4xc1 Qd2-f4+ Kg3-f2 Qf4xc1) +5.49/20 0} 59. Kg2 {(Kh1-g2 Qc1xc2 Rh3-h6+ Kf6-g7 Rh6-a6 Qc2-b1 Ra6-a7+ Kg7-f6 Ra7-a6+ Kf6-e5 d3-d4+ Ke5xd4 Kg2-f2) -2.95/17 0} Qxc2 {(Qc1xc2 Rh3-h6+ Kf6-g7 Rh6-c6 Qc2-d2 Kg2-f1 c3-c2 Kf1-f2 Qd2-d1 Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f8 Rc7-c6 Kf8-e7 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d8 Rc7-c4 Qd1-d2 Rc4-d4+ Kd8-e7 Rd4-e4+ Ke7-f6 Re4-c4 c2-c1Q Rc4xc1 Qd2xc1 e2-e3 Qc1-d2+ Bf3-e2 Kf6-f5 Kf2-f3 Qd2-e1 e3-e4+ Kf5-e5 Kf3-e3 Qe1-c1+ Ke3-f2) +6.84/21 1} 60. Rh6+ {(Rh3-h6+ Kf6-g7 Rh6-c6 Qc2-d2 Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f6 Rc7-c6+ Kf6-e7 Kg2-f2 c3-c2 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d8 Rc7xc2 Qd2xc2 Kf2-e3 Kd8-e7 d3-d4 Ke7-d6 Ke3-f4 Qc2-c1+ Kf4-e4 Qc1-c3) -5.62/18 0} Kg7 {(Kf6-g7 Rh6-c6 Qc2-d2 Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f6 Rc7-c6+ Kf6-e7 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d8 Rc7-c5 c3-c2 Kg2-f2 Kd8-e7 Rc5-c7+ Ke7-d6 Rc7-c6+ Kd6-d7 Rc6-c4 c2-c1Q Rc4xc1 Qd2xc1 e2-e3 Kd7-e6 Bf3-g4+ Ke6-e5 Bg4-e2 Ke5-f5 Be2-f1 Qc1-d2+ Bf1-e2 Qd2-c2 Kf2-f3 Qc2-c1 Kf3-f2 Qc1-d2 Kf2-f3 Qd2-e1 d3-d4 Qe1-h1+ Kf3-g3 Kf5-e4) +7.19/20 0} 61. Rc6 {(Rh6-c6 Qc2-d2 Bf3-g4 c3-c2 Kg2-f3 c2-c1Q Rc6xc1 Qd2xc1 Kf3-e4 Qc1-c6+ Ke4-e3 Qc6-c3 Ke3-e4 Kg7-f6 d3-d4 Qc3-d2 Bg4-f3 Kf6-g5 Ke4-d5 Kg5-f5 Kd5-c4 Kf5-f4 d4-d5 Kf4-e5 Kc4-b3 Ke5-d6 Kb3-c4 Qd2-e3 Kc4-b4) -5.94/21 2} Qd2 {(Qc2-d2 Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f6 Rc7-c6+ Kf6-e7 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d8 Rc7-c5 c3-c2 Kg2-f2 Kd8-e7 Rc5-c7+ Ke7-d6 Rc7-c6+ Kd6-d7 Rc6xc2 Qd2xc2 Kf2-e3 Qc2-c1+ Ke3-e4 Kd7-e6 d3-d4 Qc1-c2+ Ke4-f4 Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e4 Qc7-c4 Ke4-e3 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc4-c1+ Ke3-e4 Qc1-d2 Ke4-e5) +7.23/23 2} 62. Rc7+ {(Rc6-c7+ Kg7-f8 Rc7-c8+ Kf8-e7 Kg2-f2 c3-c2 Rc8-c7+ Ke7-d6 Rc7-c6+ Kd6-d7 Bf3-e4 Kd7-e7 Be4-g6 c2-c1Q Rc6xc1 Qd2xc1) -4.98/21 0} Kf6 {(Kg7-f6 Rc7-c6+ Kf6-e7 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d8 Rc7-c5 c3-c2 Bf3-g4 Kd8-e7 Kg2-f3 c2-c1Q Rc5xc1 Qd2xc1 d3-d4 Qc1-d1 Kf3-e4 Ke7-f6 Ke4-d5 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qd1-c2 Kd5-e5 Qc2-f5+ Ke5-d6 Qf5-b5 d4-d5 Qb5-b6+ Kd6-e5 Qb6-e3+ Ke5-d6 Qe3-c3 Kd6-e6 Qc3-f6+ Ke6-d7) +7.35/24 0} 63. Rc6+ {(Rc7-c6+ Kf6-e7 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d8 Rc7-c5 c3-c2 Kg2-f2 c2-c1R Rc5xc1 Qd2xc1 e2-e3 Qc1-c2+ Bf3-e2 Kd8-d7 Kf2-e1 Qc2-c3+ Ke1-d1) -4.66/15 0} Ke5 {(Kf6-e5 Rc6-c5+ Ke5-d6 Rc5-c6+ Kd6-d7 Kg2-f2 c3-c2 Rc6xc2 Qd2xc2 Kf2-e3 Qc2-c1+ Ke3-e4 Kd7-e6 d3-d4 Qc1-c2+ Ke4-f4 Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e4 Qc7-c4 Bg4-f3 Qc4-c2+ Ke4-f4 Qc2-c1+ Kf4-e4 Kf6-g5 Ke4-e5 Qc1-c2 Ke5-d6 Kg5-f4 d4-d5 Qc2-c3 Kd6-e6 Qc3-d4) +7.35/25 1} 64. Kg3 {(Kg2-g3 c3-c2 Rc6-c5+ Ke5-f6 Rc5-c6+ Kf6-e7 Rc6-c7+ Ke7-d6 Rc7-c6+ Kd6-d7 Kg3-f2 c2-c1Q Rc6xc1 Qd2xc1 Bf3-g4+ Kd7-e7 e2-e3 Qc1-d2+ Bg4-e2 Qd2-c2 Kf2-e1 Qc2-c1+ Ke1-f2 Qc1-d2 Kf2-f3 Qd2-e1 d3-d4 Qe1-d2 Be2-f1) -7.28/23 1} c2 {(c3-c2 Rc6-c5+ Ke5-d6 Rc5-c6+ Kd6-d7 Rc6xc2 Qd2xc2 Kg3-f4 Kd7-e6 d3-d4 Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e4 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc7-c2+ Ke4-e5 Qc2-f5+ Ke5-d6 Qf5-b5 d4-d5 Qb5-b6+ Kd6-e7 Qb6-g6 Ke7-d7 Qg6-c2 Kd7-d6 Qc2-c3 Kd6-e6 Kg5-f4 Ke6-d6 Qc3-c4 Kd6-d7) +7.44/23 0} 65. Rc5+ {(Rc6-c5+ Ke5-f6 Kg3-f2 Kf6-e6 Rc5-c6+ Ke6-d7 Rc6xc2 Qd2xc2 Kf2-e3 Kd7-d6 d3-d4 Kd6-e6 Ke3-f4 Qc2-c3 Kf4-e4 Ke6-d6 Bf3-h5 Qc3-c2+ Ke4-e3 Kd6-e6 Bh5-g4+ Ke6-d5 Bg4-f3+ Kd5-c4) -7.28/19 0} Kd6 {(Ke5-d6 Rc5-c6+ Kd6-d7 Rc6xc2 Qd2xc2 Kg3-f4 Kd7-e6 d3-d4 Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e3 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc7-c3+ Ke3-e4 Qc3-c2+ Ke4-d5 Kg5-f5 Kd5-d6 Qc2-c3 d4-d5 Kf5-f6 Kd6-d7 Kf6-e5 Kd7-e7 Qc3-b4+ Ke7-d7 Qb4-b7+ Kd7-e8 Ke5-f4 Ke8-f8) +7.57/22 0} 66. Rc6+ {(Rc5-c6+ Kd6-d7 Rc6xc2 Qd2xc2 Kg3-f4 Kd7-d6 d3-d4 Kd6-e6 e2-e3 Qc2-d3 Bf3-g4+ Ke6-f6 Bg4-d7 Qd3-g6 e3-e4 Qg6-g1 d4-d5 Qg1-f2+ Kf4-g4 Qf2-e2+ Kg4-f4 Qe2-d2+ Kf4-f3 Kf6-e5) -7.32/19 0} Kd7 {(Kd6-d7 Rc6xc2 Qd2xc2 Kg3-f4 Kd7-e6 d3-d4 Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e4 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc7-c2+ Ke4-e5 Qc2-f5+ Ke5-d6 Qf5-b5 d4-d5 Qb5-b6+ Kd6-e5 Qb6-f6+ Ke5-e4 Qf6-c3 Bf3-g2 Qc3-c2+ Ke4-e3 Kg5-f5 Bg2-h3+ Kf5-e5 Bh3-e6 Qc2-c1+ Ke3-d3 Qc1-d1+ Kd3-c3 Qd1xe2 Kc3-b3 Qe2-e4 Kb3-c3 Ke5-f6 Kc3-b3) +8.02/25 2} 67. Rxc2 {(Rc6xc2 Qd2xc2 Kg3-f4 Kd7-e6 d3-d4 Qc2-d2+ e2-e3 Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qd2-c2 Kf4-f3 Qc2-c3 Kf3-f2 Qc3-c1 Kf2-f3) -7.26/17 0} Qxc2 {(Qd2xc2 Kg3-f4 Kd7-e6 d3-d4 Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e3 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc7-c2 Bf3-d5 Qc2-c1+ Ke3-d3 Qc1-d1+ Kd3-e3 Qd1-g1+ Ke3-d3 Kg5-f4 Bd5-c4 Qg1-e3+ Kd3-c2 Qe3xd4 Kc2-b3 Qd4-b6+ Kb3-c3 Qb6-c5 Kc3-b3 Kf4-e5 Bc4-d3 Qc5-d4 Bd3-c4 Ke5-f6 Bc4-d3 Kf6-g7 Bd3-c4 Qd4-e4 Bc4-d3 Qe4-f4 Bd3-c4) +8.03/23 0} 68. Kf4 {(Kg3-f4 Qc2-c5 e2-e3 Qc5-c2 Bf3-g4+ Kd7-d6 Bg4-f5 Qc2-g2 Bf5-c8 Qg2-d5 Bc8-a6) -4.84/17 0} Ke6 {(Kd7-e6 Kf4-e4 Qc2-b2 d3-d4 Qb2-c2+ Ke4-f4 Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e4 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc7-c2+ Ke4-e5 Qc2-f5+ Ke5-d6 Qf5-b5 d4-d5 Qb5-b6+ Kd6-e5 Qb6-f6+ Ke5-e4 Qf6-c3 d5-d6 Qc3-c4+ Ke4-e5 Qc4-c5+ Bf3-d5 Qc5-c3+ Ke5-e4 Qc3-c2+ Ke4-e3 Qc2-c5+ Ke3-e4 Qc5xd6 Bd5-c4 Qd6-f4+ Ke4-d5 Qf4-e3 Bc4-b5) +8.14/24 0} 69. d4 {(d3-d4 Qc2-d2+) -8.28/23 2} Kf6 {(Ke6-f6 Bf3-g4 Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e4 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc7-c2+ Ke4-e5 Qc2-f5+ Ke5-d6 Qf5-b5 d4-d5 Qb5-b6+ Kd6-e5 Qb6-f6+ Ke5-e4 Qf6-c3 d5-d6 Qc3-c5 d6-d7 Qc5-d6 Ke4-e3 Qd6xd7 Bf3-e4 Qd7-a7+ Ke3-d2 Qa7-d4+ Be4-d3 Kg5-f4 Kd2-c2 Qd4-b4 Kc2-c1 Kf4-e3) +8.35/22 0} 70. Bg4 {(Bf3-g4 Qc2-d2+ e2-e3 Kf6-e7 Kf4-e4 Qd2-c3 Bg4-e2 Qc3-c2+ Ke4-f3 Ke7-d6 Be2-f1 Qc2-f5+ Kf3-e2) -5.12/16 0} Qc7+ {(Qc2-c7+ Kf4-e4 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc7-c2+ Ke4-e5 Qc2-f5+ Ke5-d6 Qf5-b5 d4-d5 Qb5-b6+ Kd6-e5 Qb6-f6+ Ke5-e4 Qf6-c3 d5-d6 Qc3-c5 d6-d7 Qc5-d6 e2-e3 Qd6xd7 Bf3-e2 Kg5-f6 Be2-c4 Qd7-d6 Bc4-e2 Qd6-e5+ Ke4-d3 Qe5-d5+ Kd3-c3 Kf6-e5 Be2-d3 Qd5-f3 Bd3-c4 Qf3xe3+ Kc3-b2 Qe3-f4) +8.54/21 0} 71. Ke4 {(Kf4-e4 Qc7-c4 Bg4-f3 Kf6-g5 Ke4-e5 Qc4-c3 Ke5-e4 Qc3-d2 d4-d5 Kg5-f6 e2-e3 Kf6-g5 d5-d6 Qd2xd6 Bf3-e2 Kg5-g6 Be2-d3 Qd6-d7 Bd3-e2 Kg6-g7 Be2-c4 Qd7-g4+ Ke4-d3 Qg4-g2 Bc4-b3) -7.82/20 0} Kg5 {(Kf6-g5 Bg4-e6 Qc7-c6+ d4-d5 Qc6-c4+ Ke4-e3 Kg5-f6 Ke3-d2 Qc4-d4+ Kd2-c2 Kf6-g5 Be6-g8 Kg5-f4 Bg8-e6 Qd4-c5+ Kc2-d3 Qc5-e3+ Kd3-c4 Qe3xe2+ Kc4-b4 Kf4-e5 Kb4-c3 Qe2-e3+ Kc3-c4 Qe3-d4+ Kc4-b5 Qd4-d3+ Kb5-b4 Qd3-e4+ Kb4-b5 Qe4-e2+ Kb5-c5) +9.00/21 0} 72. Be6 {(Bg4-e6 Kg5-f6 Be6-g4 Qc7-h7+ Ke4-e3 Qh7-h6+ Ke3-e4 Qh6-g6+ Ke4-f4 Qg6-g5+ Kf4-f3 Qg5-d5+ Kf3-e3 Qd5-c4 Ke3-e4 Kf6-g5 Bg4-f3 Qc4-c3 Ke4-e5 Qc3-e3+ Ke5-d5 Kg5-f4 Kd5-c4 Qe3-d2 d4-d5 Kf4-e5 Kc4-c5 Qd2-c2+ Kc5-b6 Qc2-c3 Kb6-a7) -7.58/19 0} Qc6+ {(Qc7-c6+ d4-d5 Qc6-c4+ Ke4-e3 Kg5-f6 Ke3-d2 Qc4-d4+ Kd2-c1 Qd4-c3+ Kc1-b1 Kf6-e5 Kb1-a2 Qc3-e3 Ka2-b2 Qe3xe2+ Kb2-b3 Qe2-e3+ Kb3-c4 Ke5-d6 Kc4-b4 Qe3-f4+ Kb4-c3 Kd6-e5 Kc3-c2) +11.88/18 0} 73. d5 {(d4-d5 Qc6-c4+ Ke4-e3 Qc4-b4 Ke3-d3 Kg5-f4 e2-e3+ Kf4-f3 e3-e4 Qb4xe4+ Kd3-c3 Qe4-e3+ Kc3-c4 Kf3-f4 Kc4-b5 Qe3-d4 Kb5-c6 Kf4-e5 Kc6-d7 Qd4-b4 Kd7-e8 Ke5-f6 Ke8-d7 Qb4-c3 Kd7-d6 Qc3-d4 Kd6-c6) -8.21/17 0} Qc4+ {(Qc6-c4+ Ke4-e3 Kg5-f6 Ke3-d2 Qc4-d4+ Kd2-c2 Kf6-e5 Kc2-b3 Qd4-d1+ Kb3-b4 Qd1xe2 Kb4-c5 Qe2-d3 Kc5-c6 Qd3-c3+ Kc6-d7 Qc3-c5 Kd7-e8 Ke5-f6 Ke8-d8 Qc5-e7+ Kd8-c8 Qe7-a7 Be6-h3 Qa7-c5+ Kc8-b8 Qc5-b4+ Kb8-a7) +12.11/21 1} 74. Ke3 {(Ke4-e3 Qc4-b4 Ke3-d3 Kg5-f4 e2-e3+ Kf4-f3 e3-e4 Qb4xe4+ Kd3-c3 Qe4-e3+ Kc3-c4 Kf3-f4 Kc4-b4 Qe3-d4+ Kb4-b3 Kf4-e3 Kb3-a2 Qd4-d3 Ka2-a1 Ke3-f4 Ka1-b2 Qd3-e2+ Kb2-c3 Kf4-e5 Kc3-b4 Ke5-d4 Kb4-b3 Kd4-c5 Kb3-c3) -12.11/20 1} Kf6 {(Kg5-f6 Ke3-d2 Kf6-e5 Be6-g8 Qc4-d4+ Kd2-c2 Qd4-e3 Bg8-e6 Qe3xe2+ Kc2-c3 Qe2-e3+ Kc3-c2 Qe3-e4+ Kc2-c3 Qe4-d4+ Kc3-b3 Qd4-d3+ Kb3-b2 Qd3-c4 Kb2-b1 Qc4-b3+ Kb1-a1 Ke5-e4 Be6-g8 Qb3-d1+ Ka1-a2 Qd1-c2+ Ka2-a1 Ke4-e5 Bg8-e6 Qc2-b3 Be6-g8 Qb3-d1+ Ka1-a2 Qd1-e2+ Ka2-a1 Qe2-f1+ Ka1-b2 Qf1-g2+ Kb2-a3 Qg2xg8) +12.20/22 0} 75. Kf3 {(Ke3-f3 Kf6-e5 Kf3-f2 Ke5-e4 Be6-h3 Qc4-d4+ Kf2-g3 Ke4xd5 Bh3-f5 Qd4-e3+ Kg3-g4 Kd5-e5 Bf5-d3 Qe3-f4+ Kg4-h5) -11.98/14 0} Ke5 {(Kf6-e5 e2-e3 Qc4-f1+ Kf3-g4 Qf1-g1+ Kg4-f3 Qg1-d1+ Kf3-g3 Qd1-e2 Be6-g4 Qe2xe3+ Bg4-f3 Qe3-g5+ Bf3-g4 Qg5-f4+ Kg3-h4 Ke5-e4 Kh4-h3 Qf4-e3+ Kh3-g2 Ke4-f4 Bg4-e6 Qe3-g3+ Kg2-h1 Qg3-f2 Be6-c8 Qf2-e1+ Kh1-g2 Qe1-d2+ Kg2-f1 Qd2xd5 Kf1-e2) +60.76/22 1} 76. Kf2 {(Kf3-f2 Qc4-f4+ Kf2-g2 Qf4-e4+ Kg2-f1 Ke5-f4 Kf1-f2 Qe4-e3+ Kf2-e1 Qe3-c1+ Ke1-f2 Qc1-c5+ Kf2-e1 Kf4-e3 Ke1-f1 Qc5-f8+ Kf1-g2 Qf8-f2+ Kg2-h3 Qf2xe2 Kh3-g3 Ke3-e4 d5-d6 Qe2-e3+ Kg3-g4 Qe3-f4+ Kg4-h5 Qf4-e5+ Kh5-h4 Qe5xe6) -12.30/17 0} Qf4+ {(Qc4-f4+ Kf2-g2 Qf4-e4+ Kg2-f2 Ke5-f4 Be6-h3 Qe4-e3+ Kf2-e1 Qe3xh3 Ke1-d2 Qh3-e3+ Kd2-d1 Qe3-b3+ Kd1-d2 Qb3xd5+ Kd2-c3 Kf4-e4 Kc3-b4 Qd5-d4+ Kb4-b3 Qd4-d1+ Kb3-b4 Qd1xe2 Kb4-b3 Qe2-d3+ Kb3-b4 Qd3-d2+ Kb4-c5 Ke4-e5 Kc5-b5 Ke5-d6) +60.95/20 0} 77. Kg2 {(Kf2-g2 Qf4-e4+ Kg2-g3 Qe4-e3+ Kg3-h4 Qe3xe2 Kh4-g5 Qe2-g2+ Kg5-h5 Qg2-f3+ Be6-g4 Qf3xd5) -8.62/16 0} Qe4+ {(Qf4-e4+ Kg2-g3 Qe4-e3+ Kg3-h4 Qe3xe2 Kh4-g5 Qe2-g2+ Be6-g4 Qg2-d2+ Kg5-g6 Qd2xd5 Kg6-h5 Ke5-f4+ Kh5-g6 Kf4xg4 Kg6-f6 Qd5-d6+ Kf6-f7 Kg4-f4 Kf7-g7 Qd6-d7+ Kg7-f6 Qd7-f5+ Kf6-g7 Kf4-e5) +61.40/19 0} 78. Kf2 {(Kg2-f2 Ke5-f4 d5-d6 Qe4xe6 d6-d7 Qe6xd7 e2-e3+ Kf4-e4 Kf2-e2 Qd7-d3+ Ke2-e1 Qd3xe3+ Ke1-d1 Qe3-d3+ Kd1-c1 Qd3-c3+ Kc1-b1 Qc3-d2 Kb1-a1 Ke4-e3 Ka1-b1 Qd2-e2 Kb1-a1) -M16/18 0} Kf4 {(Ke5-f4 Be6-h3 Qe4-e3+ Kf2-e1 Qe3-c3+ Ke1-f1 Kf4-g3 Kf1-g1 Qc3-e3+ Kg1-h1 Qe3-c1+ Bh3-f1 Qc1xf1+) +M7/27 0} 79. Bh3 {(Be6-h3 Qe4-e3+ Kf2-e1 Qe3-c3+ Ke1-f1 Kf4-g3 Kf1-g1 Qc3-e3+ Kg1-h1 Qe3-c1+ Bh3-f1 Qc1xf1+) -M6/21 0} Qe3+ {(Qe4-e3+ Kf2-e1 Qe3-c3+ Ke1-f1 Kf4-g3 Kf1-g1 Qc3-e3+ Kg1-h1 Qe3-c1+ Bh3-f1 Qc1xf1+) +M6/37 0} 80. Ke1 {(Kf2-e1 Qe3-c3+ Ke1-f1 Kf4-g3 Kf1-g1 Qc3-e3+ Kg1-h1 Qe3-c1+ Bh3-f1 Qc1xf1+) -M5/25 0} Qc3+ {(Qe3-c3+ Ke1-f1 Kf4-g3 Kf1-g1 Qc3-e3+ Kg1-h1 Qe3-c1+ Bh3-f1 Qc1xf1+) +M5/40 0} 81. Kf1 {(Ke1-f1 Kf4-g3 Kf1-g1 Qc3-e3+ Kg1-h1 Qe3-c1+ Bh3-f1 Qc1xf1+) -M4/32 0} Kg3 {(Kf4-g3 Kf1-g1 Qc3-e3+ Kg1-h1 Qe3-c1+ Bh3-f1 Qc1xf1+) +M4/55 0} 82. Kg1 {(Kf1-g1 Qc3-e3+ Kg1-h1 Qe3-c1+ Bh3-f1 Qc1xf1+) -M3/37 0 White resigns} [\pgn][/pgn]
Do NOT worry and be happy, we all live a short life
-
Dann Corbit
- Posts: 12540
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:57 pm
- Location: Redmond, WA USA
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
I do not think the queen is more powerful than two rooks.
The problem is that the king lost his most powerful protector, and he is stuck in the middle of the board until he can castle.
It will take a little while to develop enough to castle, and in the meantime, black can quickly develop a threat.
I think that two rooks are stronger than a queen.
But there is a positional problem for your opening position for white.
You can free the queen by moving one pawn. But at least two moves are needed to free a rook, and it is dangerous to develop them early.
But I also prefer black with the queen, early on.
The problem is that the king lost his most powerful protector, and he is stuck in the middle of the board until he can castle.
It will take a little while to develop enough to castle, and in the meantime, black can quickly develop a threat.
I think that two rooks are stronger than a queen.
But there is a positional problem for your opening position for white.
You can free the queen by moving one pawn. But at least two moves are needed to free a rook, and it is dangerous to develop them early.
But I also prefer black with the queen, early on.
Taking ideas is not a vice, it is a virtue. We have another word for this. It is called learning.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
-
Dann Corbit
- Posts: 12540
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:57 pm
- Location: Redmond, WA USA
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
Try this position, which has the same material, but both sides have developed a bit and protected the king.
[d]2bq2k1/pppnnppp/3bp3/1B1p4/8/1PN1PN2/PBPP1PPP/R4RK1 w - -
According to my thinking, it is extremely even early on, but I think with enough games white will come out the winner.
[d]2bq2k1/pppnnppp/3bp3/1B1p4/8/1PN1PN2/PBPP1PPP/R4RK1 w - -
According to my thinking, it is extremely even early on, but I think with enough games white will come out the winner.
Taking ideas is not a vice, it is a virtue. We have another word for this. It is called learning.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
-
Dann Corbit
- Posts: 12540
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:57 pm
- Location: Redmond, WA USA
Re: Are computes without Database endgame better than Carlsen?
Stockfish says that they are even this time, as far as the analyzed plan goes:
Code: Select all
Searching: 2bq2k1/pppnnppp/3bp3/1B1p4/8/1PN1PN2/PBPP1PPP/R4RK1 w - - 0 1
infinite: 0 time: 0 increment: 0 moves to go: 0
1 -0.11 00:00 3648 Ne2
2 -0.50 00:00 23852 Bxd7 Bxd7
3 -0.07 00:00 48601 Bxd7 Bxd7 a4
4 -0.30 00:00 69474 Bxd7 Bxd7 a4 e5
5 -0.52 00:00 101097 Be2 c6 a4 e5 d3
6 -0.19 00:00 124614 Bxd7 Qxd7 d4 b5
7 -0.20 00:00 156070 d4 c6 Bd3 b5 Ne2 h6 a4
8 -0.16 00:00 183154 d4 a6 Bxd7 Bxd7 e4 Bf4 a4 dxe4
9 -0.13 00:00 232105 Bxd7 Bxd7 a4 a6 d4 b5 axb5 axb5 Ne2
10 -0.33 00:00 331881 d4 a6 Bxd7 Bxd7 a4 c5 Ba3 Qa5 Ne2 f6
11 -0.26 00:00 458957 d4 c5 Bxd7 Bxd7 dxc5 Bxc5 a4 a6 Ne2 f6 Bd4 Bd6
12 -0.31 00:00 597822 Bxd7 Bxd7 a4 e5 Ba3 c5 d4 exd4 exd4 b6 Nb5 Bg4 Nxd6 Qxd6
13 -0.44 00:00 908358 Bxd7 Bxd7 a4 e5 Ba3 Bg4 Bxd6 Qxd6 Ne1 Bf5 f4 Qg6 fxe5 Bxc2
14 -0.35 00:00 1060K Bxd7 Bxd7 d4 b5 a4 b4 Nb5 a6 Nxd6 cxd6 Rfc1 f6 h4 Kf7
15 -0.25 00:00 1646K Bxd7 Bxd7 d4 c5 dxc5 Bxc5 Rad1 b5 a3 a5 e4 b4 axb4 axb4 Na4
16 -0.13 00:00 2828K Bxd7 Bxd7 d4 Ng6 a4 c6 e4 f6 h3 Kf7 Rfe1 Bb4 e5 Qa5 Re3 fxe5 dxe5
17 -0.32 00:00 4051K Bxd7 Bxd7 d4 Ng6 a4 c6 Ne2 f6 Ba3 Bc7 c4 dxc4 bxc4 e5 Rfb1 Qc8 Ng3 Be6 c5 exd4 Nxd4
18 -0.18 00:00 4496K Bxd7 Bxd7 d4 Ng6 a4 c6 e4 e5 exd5 cxd5 dxe5 Nxe5 Nxe5 Bxe5 Rad1 Be6 f4 Bf6 f5
19 -0.22 00:00 7136K Bxd7 Bxd7 d4 Ng6 h3 c6 e4 b5 e5 Be7 a4 b4 Ne2 a5 Kh2 h6 Rae1 Qc7 g3 c5 Kg2
20 -0.20 00:00 9319K Bxd7 Bxd7 d4 Ng6 h3 b5 a4 b4 Ne2 c6 Rfc1 f6 c3 e5 cxb4 e4 Nh2 Qe8 Ba3 Qe6 Nf1 Nh4
21 -0.25 00:01 11725K Bxd7 Bxd7 d4 c5 dxc5 Bxc5 e4 Bc6 Rad1 Qa5 exd5 Nxd5 Ne4 Be7 Ne5 Be8 Rfe1 f6 Nd3 Bg6 a3 Qb5 Ra1 e5 h3
22 -0.10 00:05 48277K d4 c6 Be2 Ng6 e4 Nf4 e5 Be7 Rfd1 Nxe2+ Nxe2 b6 h3 a5 a4 Ba6 Re1 b5 Ng3 b4 Kh2 Qc7 Nd2 c5
23 -0.27 00:06 62181K d4 c6 Be2 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Be7 Rfd1 Nxd3 cxd3 b5 h3 a5 Bc1 Ba6 Be3 h6 Rac1 Qa8 Ne2 a4 bxa4 bxa4 Bf4 Bb5 Bg3 Qb7 Kh2
24 -0.22 00:08 77378K d4 c6 Be2 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 a5 Rfc1 b6 Ne2 Bb7 a4 Be7 h3 b5 Rd1 bxa4 bxa4 c5 Rac1
25 -0.22 00:08 79700K d4 c6 Be2 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 a5 Rfc1 b6 Ne2 Bb7 a4 Be7 h3 b5 axb5 cxb5 Rc2 Qb6 Rac1 a4 Rc7
26 -0.12 00:11 107318K d4 c6 Be2 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 a5 h3 b5 Ne2 Be7 Rfd1 h6 Bc1 Qc7 a4 Ba6 Be3 Qb7 axb5 Qxb5 Rab1 Qb7 Nc3 Qb6 Ne2 c5 dxc5
27 -0.12 00:12 117149K Be2 c6 d4 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 a5 Ne2 Be7 Bc1 b5 Rd1 Bb7 a4 Ba6 Be3 h6 h3 Qb8 Rab1 Qb7 Kh2 c5 axb5 Bxb5 Nc3 cxd4 Bxd4
28 -0.15 00:13 128942K Be2 c6 d4 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 a5 Rfd1 Be7 h3 b6 Ne2 Ba6 Bc1 h6 Bf4 Bb7 Rac1 Nb8 g4 Na6 Kg2 Nb4 a3 Na6
29 -0.11 00:18 170244K Be2 c6 d4 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 a5 Rfd1 Be7 h3 b6 Ne2 Ba6 Bc1 h6 Bf4 Bb7 Rac1 Nb8 Kh2 Na6 Bd2 Qa8 g4 Nb4 Bxb4 axb4 Ra1 c5
30 -0.09 00:25 241433K Be2 c6 d4 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 a5 Rfd1 Be7 h3 b5 Bc1 a4 Be3 h6 g4 Bb7 Kg2 Qa5 Ne2 Qa6 Bf4 b4 Be3 Nb6 Rac1 Qa5
31 -0.08 00:30 288225K Be2 c6 d4 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 a5 Rfd1 Be7 Bc1 b6 Ne2 Bb7 h3 Nb8 a4 h6 Ba3 Bxa3 Rxa3 Na6 Ra2 Qe7 g3 Nb4 Rad2 c5 Kg2 Nc6 dxc5 bxc5
32 -0.02 00:42 400948K Be2 c6 d4 Ng6 e4 Bb4 Bd3 Nf4 e5 Nxd3 cxd3 Qa5 Rfc1 Qa6 Rd1 h6 h3 Be7 Kh2 Qb6 Bc1 Nb8 Be3 Na6 Bd2 Nc7 Rac1 Qa6 Be3 Qa5 Bd2 Na6 Ra1 Nb4
33 -0.00 01:04 607544K Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 Nf6 dxc5 Bxc5 Na4 Bd6 Rad1 b5 Bxf6 gxf6 Nc3 Be6 Bd3 Bg4 Be2
34 +0.00 02:21 1320M Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 b5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rad1 h6 a3 Qc7 Nxd5 Nxd5 Rxd5 Bb7 Rdd1 Ne6 Bc1 Bf4 Rfe1 Bxc1 Rxc1 Nf4 Bd3 Nxd3 cxd3 Qa5 a4 Bxf3 gxf3 bxa4 bxa4 Qxa4 Rc8+ Kh7 Rc7 Qf4 Ree7 Qxf3 Rxf7 Qd1+ Kg2 Qg4+ Kh1 Qd1+
35 -0.21 04:35 2566M Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 b5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rad1 Bb7 Rfe1 Qc7 Bd3 Nxd3 cxd3 f6 Rc1 Qd7 Nd4 Ng6 h3 Nh4 Nd1 Be5 Ne3 Ng6 Ng4 Bd6 Red1 Nf4 Rc2 a5 Ne3 a4 Nef5 Be5 bxa4 bxa4 Bc1 Ne6 Nxe6 Qxe6
36 -0.00 05:00 2797M Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 b5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rad1 Bb7 Rfe1 Qc7 Bf1 b4 Ne2 Ne4 Ng3 h6 Bd3 f5 Ne2 g5 h3 Kf7 Bd4 Nc6 Bb2
37 -0.21 05:58 3319M Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 b5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rad1 Bb7 Rfe1 Qc7 Bf1 b4 Ne2 Ne4 Ng3 h6 Bd3 f5 Ne2 g5 h3 Qa5 Be5 Bxe5 Nxe5 Qc5 Bxe4 dxe4 Rd7 Bc8 Rd8+ Kg7 Nc4 Be6 Nd4 Bxc4
38 -0.21 06:05 3396M Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 b5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rad1 Bb7 Rfe1 Qc7 Bf1 b4 Ne2 Ne4 Ng3 h6 Bd3 f5 Ne2 g5 h3 Qa5 h4 Qxa2 Bc1 Bc5 Rf1 gxh4 Be3 Qa5 Nxh4 Qb6 Bxc5 Qxc5 g3 Kf7 Kg2 d4 Kh2 Nc3 Rde1 Nxe2 Rxe2
39 -0.22 07:02 3935M Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 b5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rad1 Bb7 Rfe1 Qc7 Bf1 b4 Ne2 Ne4 Ng3 h6 Bd3 f5 Ne2 g5 h3 Qa5 h4 Qxa2 Bc1 Bc5 Rf1 gxh4 Be3 Bxe3 fxe3 Qa5 Nxh4 Qb6 Nd4 Bc8 Ra1 a5 Bxe4
40 -0.11 07:19 4094M Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 b5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rad1 Bb7 Rfe1 Qc7 Bf1 b4 Ne2 Ne4 Ng3 h6 Bd3 f5 Ne2 g5 h3 Qa5 h4 Qxa2 Bc1 Bc5 Rf1 gxh4 Be3 h3 Bxc5 Nxc5 Ned4 Nxd3 Rxd3 hxg2 Kxg2 Ng6 Re3
41 -0.09 07:58 4462M Be2 a6 e4 c5 exd5 exd5 d4 b5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rad1 Bb7 Rfe1 Qc7 Bf1 b4 Ne2 Ne4 Ng3 h6 Bd3 f5 Ne2 g5 h3 Qa5 h4 Qxa2 Bc1 Bc5 Rf1 gxh4 Be3 h3 Bxc5 Nxc5 Ned4 hxg2 Kxg2 Nxd3 Rxd3 f4 Re1 Nc6 Ne2 Qxc2 Nxf4 Qb2 Rxd5
42 -0.16 17:59 10003M Be2 a6 d4 c5 dxc5 Nxc5 a3 f5 g3 Qc7 Rfd1 b5 Rac1 Qb8 Bf1 Bd7 b4 Ne4 Nd4 e5 Nb3 Be6 Bg2 g5 Rd3 Nf6 Ne2 g4 h3 h5 Rcd1 Kg7 h4 Bg8 Rc3 Ne4 Rcd3 Qc7 Rc1 Kg6 Nc3 Be6 Nxe4 fxe4 Rd2
43 +0.00 19:44 10968M Be2 a6 d4 c5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rfd1 h6 Rac1 f6 Nb1 b5 c4 dxc4 Ba3 Qb6 bxc4 b4 Bxb4 Bxh2+ Kxh2 Qxb4 Nd4 Qb2 Rc2 Qb4
44 +0.00 21:27 11898M Be2 a6 d4 c5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rfd1 h6 Rac1 f6 Nb1 b5 c4 dxc4 Ba3 Qb6 bxc4 b4 Bxb4 Bxh2+ Kxh2 Qxb4 Nd4 Qb2 Rc2 Qb4
45 +0.00 38:12 21220M d4 a6 Be2 c5 dxc5 Nxc5 Rfd1 Nc6 Nb1 Qc7 Nbd2 b5 Rac1 Bb7 c4 dxc4 Ba3 a5 Bxc5 Bxc5 a4 bxa4 bxa4 Ba3 Rc2 Bf8 Bxc4 Nb4 Rcc1 Qb8 Bb5 Na2 Rc2 Nb4
Nodes: 21220980190
Nodes/second: 9256996
Best move: d4
Ponder move: a6
Taking ideas is not a vice, it is a virtue. We have another word for this. It is called learning.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.