Positional / Material only engines

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

JohnWoe
Posts: 491
Joined: Sat Mar 02, 2013 11:31 pm

Positional / Material only engines

Post by JohnWoe »

Since Sapeli has different variables for material and positional scores. I decided to test how would Sapeli do w/ just material / positional stuff.

Comment these lines off if you want to test these. If these are useful to some I can make UCI options for them.
Material only: https://github.com/SamuraiDangyo/Sapeli ... li.c#L2373
Positional only: https://github.com/SamuraiDangyo/Sapeli ... li.c#L2371

tc = 40/1

Positional only:
Score of Sapeli 1.17 vs Fairy-Max 5.0b: 7 - 90 - 3 [0.085] 100
Elo difference: -412.80 +/- 133.12
Finished match

Material only:
Score of Sapeli 1.17 vs Fairy-Max 5.0b: 20 - 63 - 17 [0.285] 100
Elo difference: -159.78 +/- 68.36
Finished match

Full:
Score of Sapeli 1.17 vs Fairy-Max 5.0b: 77 - 7 - 16 [0.850] 100
Elo difference: 301.33 +/- 82.56
Finished match

Material only Sapeli. Sapeli starts with a4! Truly horrible game...
[pgn] [Event "Computer Chess Game"] [Site "pc"] [Date "2019.06.04"] [Round "1"] [White "Sapeli 1.17"] [Black "Fairy-Max 5.0b"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [TimeControl "40/60"] [Annotator "1. +0,00 1... +0,24"] 1. a4 {+0,00/7} d6 {+0,24/7 0,8} 2. b3 {+0,00/7 1,9} Nf6 {+0,21/7 1,5} 3. Ra3 {+0,00/7 1,9} c5 {+0,16/7 1,2} 4. e3 {+0,00/8 1,8} Be6 {-0,01/7 2,1} 5. Qe2 {+0,00/7 1,7} Nc6 {+0,03/7 1,1} 6. f4 {+0,00/7 1,7} Qd7 {+0,03/7 0,9} 7. d3 {+0,00/7 1,6} O-O-O {+0,04/7 1,2} 8. h3 {+0,00/7 1,6} Bf5 {-0,16/7 1,0} 9. e4 {+0,17/9 1,5} Nd4 {-0,85/7 0,9} 10. Qd1 {+0,17/10 1,5} Nxe4 {-0,69/8 1,4} 11. dxe4 {+0,17/10 1,4} Bxe4 {-0,70/8 1,7} 12. Ra2 {+0,17/9 1,4} Qe6 {-0,54/7 1,2} 13. Kf2 {+0,17/10 1,4} Nxb3 {-0,55/7 1,5} 14. Be3 {+0,17/9 1,4} Nd4 {-0,46/8 2,1} 15. Nc3 {+0,17/8 1,4} Nf5 {-0,48/8 2,4} 16. Bc1 {+0,17/8 1,4} h5 {-0,53/7 1,6} 17. Bd2 {+0,17/7 1,4} Nd4 {-0,51/7 2,1} 18. Be3 {+0,17/8 1,4} Nf5 {-0,37/7 1,1} 19. Bc1 {+0,17/8 1,4} Bc6 {-0,54/7 1,6} 20. Nge2 {+0,17/7 1,4} g6 {-0,32/7 1,8} 21. Ra3 {+0,17/6 1,4} Bd7 {-0,42/7 1,6} 22. Qd2 {+0,17/7 1,4} Bg7 {-0,35/7 1,6} 23. Nb5 {+0,17/7 1,4} a6 {-0,43/7 0,9} 24. Nbc3 {+0,16/9 1,4} Bc6 {-0,37/6 0,7} 25. Nd1 {+0,16/8 1,4} Qe4 {-0,29/6 0,8} 26. Ra2 {+0,14/9 1,4} Bf6 {-0,16/6 0,8} 27. Ndc3 {+0,16/9 1,4} Qe6 {-0,10/7 3} 28. Ra1 {+0,16/9 1,4} Bh4+ {-0,09/7 6} 29. Kg1 {+0,16/11 1,4} Bf6 {-0,31/7 1,8} 30. Ra3 {+0,16/9 1,4} Rde8 {-0,37/7 3} 31. Nb1 {+0,16/9 1,4} Nd4 {-0,31/6 0,8} 32. Nec3 {+0,17/8 1,4} Nf5 {-0,37/6 0,5} 33. Kh2 {+0,17/7 1,4} Bh4 {-0,42/6 1,0} 34. Ne2 {+0,16/9 1,4} Bf2 {-0,30/7 2,4} 35. Bb2 {+0,17/9 1,4} Rh7 {-0,29/6 0,3} 36. Bc1 {+0,00/9 1,4} h4 {+0,28/7 0,4} 37. a5 {-0,94/9 1,4} Ng3 {+0,42/8 0,4} 38. Nxg3 {-0,94/10 1,4} hxg3+ {+0,46/9 0,8} 39. Rxg3 Bxg3+ {+0,49/8 0,5} 40. Kxg3 {-0,94/11 2,0} Qf6 {+0,36/8 0,6} 41. Kh2 {-0,95/9 2,1} Rhh8 {+0,27/7 1,3} 42. Be2 {-0,94/10 2,0} e5 {+0,22/8 4} 43. Bb2 {-0,94/9 1,9} Re7 {+0,24/6 2,4} 44. Qe3 {-0,94/7 1,9} Qe6 {+0,22/7 1,2} 45. fxe5 {+0,09/8 1,8} f6 {-0,30/6 0,8} 46. Qg3 {+0,09/9 1,7} dxe5 {-0,29/7 1,8} 47. Ba3 {+0,09/9 1,7} Rc7 {-0,45/7 0,8} 48. Qxg6 {+0,10/9 1,6} Qd6 {-0,51/7 1,1} 49. Bg4+ {+0,10/8 1,6} Kb8 {-0,76/8 1,2} 50. Rf1 {+0,10/8 1,5} e4+ {-0,49/8 2,1} 51. g3 {+1,16/10 1,5} e3 {-0,55/8 1,4} 52. Qxf6 {+1,17/9 1,4} Qxf6 {-0,62/9 1,1} 53. Rxf6 {+1,18/11 1,4} Rg7 {-0,71/9 2,0} 54. Bb2 {+1,18/10 1,4} Rxg4 {-0,15/9 0,7} 55. Rxc6 {+1,17/10 1,4} Re4 {-0,05/9 0,8} 56. Bxh8 {+1,18/10 1,4} bxc6 {-0,10/13 4} 57. Bc3 {+0,09/10 1,4} e2 {+0,07/13 1,7} 58. Be1 {+0,10/13 1,4} Ra4 {+0,11/12 1,1} 59. Nd2 {+1,18/11 1,4} Rxa5 {-0,46/13 0,9} 60. Kg2 {+1,19/12 1,4} Ra3 {-0,53/14 1,3} 61. Nb3 {+1,19/12 1,4} Ra2 {-0,33/12 1,0} 62. Nxc5 {+1,20/11 1,4} Rxc2 {-0,45/13 1,1} 63. Nxa6+ {+1,20/12 1,4} Kb7 {-1,85/16 2,3} 64. Nb4 {+2,30/12 1,4} Rb2 {-1,84/15 1,7} 65. Nd3 {+2,30/11 1,4} Ra2 {-1,81/14 0,9} 66. Kf2 {+2,30/10 1,4} Kb6 {-1,78/13 1,0} 67. Kf3 {+2,30/10 1,4} Kc7 {-1,78/13 1,1} 68. Nc5 {+2,30/10 1,4} Kd6 {-1,71/13 0,7} 69. Ne4+ {+2,30/11 1,4} Ke5 {-1,74/14 0,8} 70. Nd2 {+2,30/10 1,4} c5 {-1,18/13 0,9} 71. h4 {+2,30/10 1,4} c4 {-0,78/13 0,8} 72. Nxc4+ {+2,31/12 1,4} Kd4 {-1,56/15 0,8} 73. Nd2 {+2,31/12 1,4} Kd3 {-2,54/14 1,4} 74. Ne4 {+2,31/13 1,4} Ra3 {-2,51/14 1,2} 75. Nf6 {+3,41/11 1,4} Ra8 {-1,77/14 1,1} 76. Nd5 {+2,30/10 1,4} Re8 {-1,27/15 1,3} 77. Kf2 {+2,31/11 1,4} Kc2 {-1,75/15 1,2} 78. h5 {+2,31/12 1,4} Re5 {-1,69/15 1,0} 79. Ne3+ {+2,31/13 1,4} Kd3 {-1,78/16 2,7} 80. Ng2 {+2,31/13 1,4} Kc2 {-1,95/15 1,4} 81. h6 {+2,31/12 2,1} Re7 {-1,94/15 1,7} 82. Ne3+ {+2,31/11 2,0} Kd3 {-1,85/16 1,0} 83. Nd5 {+2,31/12 1,9} Rh7 {-1,91/16 1,4} 84. Kf3 {+2,31/11 1,9} Kc4 {-1,88/15 0,9} 85. Nf4 {+2,31/11 1,8} Rxh6 {-1,89/15 1,1} 86. Kxe2 {+2,31/10 1,7} Kd4 {-1,91/12 0,9} 87. Ba5 {+2,31/9 1,7} Ke4 {-1,91/12 1,2} 88. Nd3 {+2,31/10 1,6} Rc6 {-1,95/13 2,2} 89. Nf2+ {+2,31/10 1,6} Kd4 {-2,02/13 1,7} 90. Bd2 {+2,31/9 1,5} Rc2 {-1,91/13 1,1} 91. g4 {+2,31/10 1,5} Ra2 {-1,90/13 1,3} 92. Nd3 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ke4 {-1,87/13 0,9} 93. Nc5+ {+2,31/10 1,4} Kd5 {-1,88/13 1,1} 94. Nd7 {+0,00/10 1,4} Ke6 {-1,92/12 1,0} 95. Nf8+ {+2,31/11 1,4} Kf7 {-0,20/14 1,1} 96. Nh7 {+0,00/14 1,4} Kg6 {-0,14/15 1,5} 97. Nf8+ {+0,00/15 1,4} Kf7 {+0,00/17 1,7} 98. Nd7 {+0,00/14 1,4} Ke6 {+0,00/16 1,8} 99. Nb6 {+2,31/12 1,4} Rb2 {-1,96/12 1,6} 100. Na4 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ra2 {-2,00/13 1,1} 101. Nc3 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ra3 {-1,91/12 1,7} 102. Ne4 {+2,31/9 1,4} Ke5 {-1,82/12 1,1} 103. Nf2 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ra2 {-1,91/13 2,3} 104. Kd3 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ra3+ {-1,85/13 1,7} 105. Kc2 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ra2+ {-1,85/13 1,6} 106. Kc1 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ra3 {-1,92/12 1,0} 107. Kd1 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ra1+ {-1,93/13 1,6} 108. Bc1 {+2,31/11 1,4} Kd4 {-2,03/13 1,2} 109. Nh3 {+1,11/10 1,4} Ke4 {-2,00/12 0,9} 110. Ng5+ {+2,31/11 1,4} Kd4 {-1,92/12 1,0} 111. Kc2 {+2,31/10 1,4} Ra7 {-1,87/12 2,5} 112. Nf3+ {+2,31/10 1,4} Ke4 {-1,84/13 1,2} 113. Nd2+ {+1,20/10 1,4} Kf4 {-1,37/13 1,6} 114. g5 {+1,20/12 1,4} Kxg5 {-1,32/12 1,0} 115. Nb3+ {+1,20/11 1,4} Kf5 {-1,31/13 1,7} 116. Nd4+ {+1,20/11 1,4} Ke4 {-1,16/13 1,5} 117. Nb5 {+1,20/12 1,4} Ra6 {-1,25/13 1,7} 118. Kd2 {+1,20/11 1,4} Rh6 {-1,21/12 1,5} 119. Nc3+ {+1,20/11 1,4} Kd4 {-1,19/13 0,9} 120. Ne2+ {+0,00/13 1,4} Ke4 {-1,19/12 0,9} 121. Ng3+ {+0,00/13 2,1} Kf3 {-1,16/14 1,8} 122. Nf5 {+0,00/13 2,0} Rh5 {-1,10/13 1,1} 123. Ne7 {+0,00/12 1,9} Ke4 {-1,13/12 1,1} 124. Ba3 {+1,20/12 1,9} Rh2+ {-1,19/13 1,2} 125. Kc1 {+1,20/12 1,8} Rh1+ {-1,23/13 1,5} 126. Kb2 {+0,00/12 1,7} Rh3 {-1,26/13 1,8} 127. Bc5 {+1,20/11 1,7} Ke5 {-1,16/13 1,2} 128. Bb4 {+1,20/9 1,6} Ke6 {-1,14/13 1,4} 129. Nc6 {+1,20/11 1,6} Kd5 {-1,10/13 1,8} 130. Na5 {+0,00/12 1,5} Rh2+ {-1,21/12 1,1} 131. Kc3 {+0,00/12 1,5} Rg2 {-1,16/13 2,1} 132. Kb3 {+0,00/11 1,4} Rg3+ {-1,19/13 1,6} 133. Kc2 {+0,00/12 1,4} Rh3 {-1,20/13 1,8} 134. Be7 {+1,20/11 1,4} Rh2+ {-1,17/13 1,9} 135. Kc1 {+1,20/11 1,4} Re2 {-1,18/13 2,4} 136. Bf6 {+1,20/11 1,4} Rf2 {-1,17/13 1,1} 137. Bg7 {+1,20/12 1,4} Rg2 {-1,19/13 1,5} 138. Bf8 {+0,00/12 1,4} Rg8 {-1,20/13 2,0} 139. Be7 {+0,00/13 1,4} Rg7 {-1,17/13 2,1} 140. Bf6 {+1,20/11 1,4} Rg6 {-1,17/13 1,2} 141. Bd8 {+0,00/12 1,4} Rg8 {-1,19/12 1,0} 142. Bh4 {+0,00/13 1,4} Rh8 {-1,21/13 2,7} 143. Bg3 {+1,20/11 1,4} Ke4 {-1,20/13 2,8} 144. Kb1 {+1,20/10 1,4} Rh3 {-1,15/12 1,1} 145. Bc7 {+0,00/11 1,4} Rh7 {-1,22/12 1,1} 146. Bd8 {+1,20/11 1,4} Rh2 {-1,25/12 1,7} 147. Nc4 {+1,20/10 1,4} Kd4 {-1,16/12 1,3} 148. Na3 {+1,20/11 1,4} Kd3 {-1,26/11 1,0} 149. Bf6 {+1,20/10 1,4} Rh6 {-1,11/13 1,6} 150. Be5 {+0,00/11 1,4} Ke4 {-1,08/13 1,8} 151. Bg7 {+1,20/11 1,4} Rg6 {-1,18/13 2,1} 152. Bf8 {+0,00/12 1,4} Kd3 {-1,25/12 0,9} 153. Bc5 {+0,00/13 1,4} Rc6 {-1,13/12 1,3} 154. Be7 {+0,00/14 1,4} Re6 {-1,13/13 1,4} 155. Bd8 {+0,00/11 1,4} Rd6 {-1,17/13 1,5} 156. Bh4 {+0,00/13 1,4} Rh6 {-1,16/13 1,2} 157. Bg3 {+0,00/10 1,4} Rh3 {-1,16/13 2,1} 158. Bd6 {+0,00/10 1,4} Rh6 {-1,13/13 1,3} 159. Bf4 {+0,00/11 1,4} Rh4 {-1,11/14 2,0} 160. Be5 {+0,00/14 1,4} Rh5 {-1,06/13 1,2} 161. Bc7 {+0,00/15 2,1} Rh7 {-0,34/14 1,2} 162. Ba5 {+0,00/16 2,0} Ra7 {-0,29/15 1,4} 163. Bb4 {+0,00/16 1,9} Rb7 {-0,23/15 1,1} 164. Nc2 {+0,00/20 1,9} Rb8 {-0,15/15 1,2} {Draw by fifty move rule} 1/2-1/2 [/pgn]