Father versus Deepblue in the ocean. September 04/2019.. Open letter to Garry Kasparov
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2019 12:17 am
September 04, 2019
Open letter to Garry Kasparov.
Deep blue was a part of a crucial moment in the history of mankind. The great and great Gary Kasparov faced the power of the machine and economic corporations. The role played by the world champion was extraordinary. Today I wonder if the valuation parameters between game and game were modified. If the answer was affirmative, only that is sufficient reason to disqualify to the computer and remove or dispose of the title doping.
The doping would then be the intervention of the human by changing the lines of play in the course of the confrontation.
I believe that all chess programmers have a moral responsibility to humanity. Scientists and computer programmers of chess must tell us through the study of the games if the value system between them has differences.
I would like to have a deep blue today in front of me; I know it would be a lot of scrap metal. The problem is that IBM shares would fall to their worst historical value.
Please scientific sirs: Help us. Were the valuation systems changed in that historic match? If the answer is, YES THEY WERE, "if they were", and they were not automatically changed by the machine, that match for me was a terrible fraud and ambush against the always great and virtuous Garry Kasparov, who was then a victim of ambush.
Sincerely,
Pablo Ignacio Restrepo
Father and Grand-Father playchess.com player
Trying playserver.chessbase.com Connected Login Welcome, Grand-Father! Server Time = 21:36 (UTC+2h), 2857 users online 8 pm ( CET) – Wednesday-Blitz 5+0, 9 rounds. More Information see Tournaments -> Room Official B -> Info Your local weather: [WTH_2CLOUD_NORAIN], Temperature: 26°C, Wind: NEE 0Bft. Rated (Classic) 1m+3s No. of players receiving your offer: 5 Rated (Classic)
Intel(R) Core(TM) i9-7920X CPU @ 2.90GHz 2904MHz, (12 cores, 24 threads) New Elo: 2069 (+31),
[pgn][Event "Rated game, 5 min"]
[Site "Engine Room"]
[Date "2019.09.04"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Grand-Father"]
[Black "Deepblueocean"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D00"]
[WhiteElo "1912"]
[BlackElo "2457"]
[PlyCount "413"]
[EventDate "2019.09.04"]
[SourceTitle "playchess.com"]
[TimeControl "300"]
1. d4 {2} d5 {B 0} 2. e3 {1} Nf6 {B 0} 3. c3 {0} Bf5 {B 0} 4. f4 {1} e6 {B 0}
5. Bd3 {1} c5 {B 0} 6. Nf3 {8} Bd6 {B 0} 7. O-O {1} O-O {B 0} 8. Qe2 {4} Nc6 {
-1.07/27 15} 9. a3 {19 (b3)} c4 {-1.78/24 3} 10. Bc2 {2 (Bxf5)} Na5 {-1.39/29
26} 11. Qd1 {13} Rc8 {-1.45/31 0} 12. Re1 {2 (h3)} Bxc2 {-1.69/27 3} 13. Qxc2 {
2} Ne4 {-1.74/28 1} 14. Nbd2 {2} f5 {-1.87/27 3} 15. Rb1 {1} h6 {-1.80/26 4}
16. Nf1 {1 (Qa4)} g5 {-1.93/29 6} 17. g3 {1 (Ng3)} g4 {-2.55/26 3} 18. Nh4 {
1 (N3d2)} Nb3 {-2.85/29 3} 19. Re2 {2 (Nd2)} Qe8 {-3.16/31 8} 20. Rg2 {4 (Nd2)}
b5 {-3.27/35 25} 21. Bd2 {1 (Nd2)} Be7 {-3.44/33 7} 22. Be1 {1} a5 {-3.38/35 2}
23. Kh1 {3 (Nd2)} Kf7 {-3.31/32 9} 24. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Qd8 {-3.76/33 8} 25. Qd1 {
1 (Re2)} h5 {-3.78/32 4} 26. Kh1 {1} Rg8 {-3.79/33 2} 27. Qe2 {1 (Qc2)} Bf6 {
-3.79/37 9} 28. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Ke8 {-3.80/34 3} 29. Qc2 {1 (Qd1)} Kd7 {-3.87/32
2} 30. Kh1 {1 (Re2)} Kc7 {-3.87/35 5} 31. Kg1 {4 (Re2)} Qe7 {-3.87/35 3} 32.
Kh1 {1 (Re2)} Rg7 {-3.87/34 3} 33. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Kb7 {-3.87/35 3} 34. Kh1 {
0 (Rd1)} Rgg8 {-3.87/36 3} 35. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Rb8 {-3.87/37 5} 36. Kh1 {2 (Re2)}
Rbc8 {-3.87/35 3} 37. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rg7 {-3.87/36 3} 38. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rcg8 {
-3.87/36 3} 39. Kg1 {0} Qd8 {-3.87/36 3} 40. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Qd7 {-3.87/34 3} 41.
Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Qd8 {-3.87/36 3} 42. Kh1 {1 (Re2)} Qe7 {-3.87/37 2} 43. Kg1 {
1 (Rd1)} Kb6 {-3.87/36 2} 44. Kh1 {1 (Re2)} Qd8 {-3.87/37 2} 45. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)}
Rh8 {-3.87/37 2} 46. Kh1 {1 (Rd1)} Rhg8 {-3.87/39 4} 47. Kg1 {1} Qe7 {-3.87/37
3} 48. Kh1 {2 (Re2)} Kc7 {-3.87/40 3} 49. Kg1 {3 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.87/34 2} 50.
Kh1 {3 (Qd1)} Kc7 {-3.87/39 4} 51. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.87/38 2} 52. Kh1 {
0 (Re2)} Qd8 {-3.87/38 3} 53. Kg1 {0 (Re2)} Rh8 {-3.87/37 3} 54. Kh1 {0 (Qd1)}
Rhg8 {-3.87/38 2} 55. Kg1 {0} Kb6 {-3.87/38 1} 56. Kh1 {0 (Qd1)} Qe7 {-3.87/39
5} 57. Kg1 {0} Rh7 {-3.87/36 3} 58. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rhg7 {-3.87/39 2} 59. Kg1 {
0 (Rd1)} Qd8 {-3.87/37 1} 60. Kh1 {0 (Re2)} Kc7 {-3.87/38 1} 61. Kg1 {0} Be7 {
-3.87/35 1} 62. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.87/38 3} 63. Kg1 {0 (Qe2)} Kc7 {-3.87/40
2} 64. Kh1 {0} Bf6 {-3.87/34 0} 65. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Qe7 {-3.87/34 1} 66. Kh1 {
0 (Rd1)} Kd6 {-3.87/36 2} 67. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rb8 {-3.87/30 2} 68. Kh1 {0 (Qd1)}
Ra8 {-3.87/31 1} 69. Kg1 {0 (Nd2)} Kc7 {-3.87/32 1} 70. Kh1 {0 (Re2)} Kb7 {
-3.87/35 1} 71. Kg1 {0 (Nd2)} Rh8 {-3.65/34 9} 72. Kh1 {0} Rc8 {-3.50/32 1} 73.
Kg1 {1 (Re2)} Rh8 {-3.40/28 1} 74. Kh1 {0} a4 {-3.28/30 1} 75. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)}
Ka7 {-3.28/30 2} 76. Rd1 {1} Kb6 {-3.28/28 0} 77. Qe2 {1 (Nd2)} Rhg8 {-3.28/32
1} 78. Kh1 {3 (Qc2)} Kc7 {-3.28/28 1} 79. Kg1 {1 (Qc2)} Kc6 {-3.28/33 1} 80.
Kh1 {0 (Qc2)} Rc8 {-3.28/33 1} 81. Kg1 {0} Kb6 {-3.28/34 0} 82. Kh1 {1 (Nd2)}
Qd8 {-3.28/32 1} 83. Kg1 {0 (Nd2)} Rcc7 {-3.28/32 1} 84. Rb1 {1 (Nd2)} Kc6 {
-3.28/29 0} 85. Kh1 {1 (Rd1)} Kd7 {-3.28/26 1} 86. Kg1 {0 (Rg1)} Rg8 {-3.28/29
0} 87. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Ke8 {-3.28/27 1} 88. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Kd7 {-3.28/32 0} 89.
Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kc6 {-3.28/33 1} 90. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb6 {-3.28/32 1} 91. Kh1 {
1 (Rd1)} Ra7 {-3.28/28 0} 92. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rh7 {-3.28/31 0} 93. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)}
Rh6 {-3.28/27 0} 94. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Qe7 {-3.28/32 0} 95. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kc6 {
-3.28/30 0} 96. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Rh7 {-3.28/37 1} 97. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.28/31
1} 98. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rf7 {-3.28/31 0} 99. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rff8 {-3.28/28 0} 100.
Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Rc8 {-3.28/31 0} 101. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kc6 {-3.28/26 0} 102. Kg1 {
0 (Rd1)} Kb6 {-3.28/33 0} 103. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rg7 {-3.28/29 0} 104. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)
} Qc7 {-3.28/29 0} 105. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.28/30 0} 106. Kg1 {0} Qe7 {
-3.28/37 0} 107. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rc7 {-3.28/28 0} 108. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rc8 {
-3.28/32 0} 109. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Qd7 {-3.28/33 0} 110. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Rcg8 {
-3.28/35 1} 111. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Ka7 {-3.28/29 0} 112. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Qd8 {
-3.28/32 0} 113. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.28/29 0} 114. Kg1 {4 (Rd1)} Rc7 {
-3.28/32 0} 115. Kh1 {1 (Rd1)} Rc8 {-3.28/28 0} 116. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rc7 {
-3.28/32 0} 117. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Nd6 {-3.28/23 0} 118. Kg1 {0 (Rg1)} Kc6 {
-3.17/24 1} 119. Qc2 {2 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.06/28 0} 120. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Ka7 {
-3.06/28 1} 121. Kg1 {0 (Re2)} Rcg7 {-3.06/27 0} 122. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Ne4 {
-2.95/28 1} 123. Kg1 {1 (Qd1)} Bxh4 {0} 124. gxh4 {-2.95/24 0} Kb6 {-2.94/28 0}
125. Bg3 {0 (Ng3)} Qe7 {-3.06/20 0} 126. Re1 {2 (Be1)} Rh7 {-2.95/19 0} 127.
Ree2 {0 (Rd1)} Rhh8 {-3.06/18 0} 128. Qb1 {1 (Be1)} Kc7 {-2.95/19 0} 129. Rc2 {
2 (Be1)} Kb7 {-2.95/23 0} 130. Kh1 {2 (Be1)} Rd8 {-2.97/10 0} 131. Kg1 {0 (Be1)
} Ra8 {-2.95/16 0} 132. Qe1 {1 (Be1)} Qf6 {-2.95/13 0} 133. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rag8
{-2.95/10 0} 134. Kg1 {1} Rh7 {-2.95/36 0} 135. Kh1 {0 (Qb1)} Rc8 {-2.95/13 0}
136. Kg1 {1} Rg7 {-2.95/36 0} 137. Kh1 {0 (Qb1)} Qd8 {-2.95/16 0} 138. Kg1 {0}
Qe8 {-2.95/33 0} 139. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Ka7 {-2.95/14 0} 140. Kg1 {0} Qf7 {-2.95/
36 0} 141. Kh1 {4 (Qd1)} Qe7 {-2.95/17 0} 142. Kg1 {1} Ka8 {-2.95/35 0} 143.
Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rcg8 {-2.95/16 0} 144. Kg1 {0 (Qd1)} Ka7 {-2.95/21 0} 145. Kh1 {
0 (Qd1)} Kb6 {-2.95/18 0} 146. Kg1 {0} Rd8 {-2.95/37 0} 147. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rgg8
{-2.95/13 0} 148. Kg1 {1 (Qd1)} Rg7 {-2.95/15 0} 149. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Rdg8 {
-2.95/18 0} 150. Kg1 {1} Rh7 {-2.95/38 0} 151. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rhh8 {-2.95/14 0}
152. Kg1 {1 (Qd1)} Rg7 {-2.95/21 0} 153. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Qe8 {-2.95/18 0} 154.
Kg1 {1} Kb7 {-2.95/36 0} 155. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Qd8 {-2.95/15 0} 156. Kg1 {1} Rgh7
{-2.95/36 0} 157. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Rg8 {-2.95/17 0} 158. Kg1 {1} Rf7 {-2.95/34 0}
159. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Qe7 {-2.95/16 0} 160. Kg1 {1} Rc8 {-2.94/32 0} 161. Kh1 {
1 (Qd1)} Rc7 {-2.94/14 0} 162. Kg1 {1} Rg7 {-2.94/31 0} 163. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rc8
{-2.94/14 0} 164. Kg1 {1} Rd8 {-2.94/25 0} 165. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Rh8 {-2.94/13 0}
166. Kg1 {1} Ka7 {-2.73/25 0} 167. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Rgg8 {-2.84/10 0} 168. Kg1 {1}
Kb6 {-2.73/23 0} 169. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Qd8 {-2.94/10 0} 170. Kg1 {1} Rg6 {-2.05/
23 0} 171. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rg7 {-2.26/10 0} 172. Kg1 {1} Na5 {-2.05/27 0} 173.
Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} b4 {-1.94/20 0} 174. cxb4 {1} Nb7 {-1.93/36 0} 175. Rc3 {0 (Qd1)}
Nxc3 {-3.05/12 0} 176. bxc3 {1} Qd7 {-2.63/29 0} 177. Qc1 {1 (Rb2)} Rb8 {
-2.63/28 0} 178. Re2 {1 (Rb2)} Nd6 {-2.72/18 0} 179. Kg2 {1} Kc7 {-2.72/33 0}
180. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Rgg8 {-2.72/24 0} 181. Kg2 {0 (Re1)} Rbf8 {-2.72/20 0} 182.
Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Kb7 {-2.72/13 0} 183. Kg2 {0 (Re1)} Qe7 {-2.72/23 0} 184. Kg1 {
1 (Re1)} Ra8 {-2.72/18 0} 185. Kg2 {0} Kc6 {-2.72/39 0} 186. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Kb6
{-2.72/26 0} 187. Kg2 {1} Qd7 {-2.72/41 0} 188. Kg1 {1 (Re1)} Nb5 {-2.72/17 0}
189. Kg2 {2 (Nd2)} Qc6 {-2.72/24 0} 190. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Rgf8 {-2.72/18 0} 191.
Rd2 {1 (Re1)} Nd6 {-2.72/17 0} 192. Re2 {1} Rg8 {-2.72/41 0} 193. Rc2 {1 (Nd2)}
Qd7 {-2.72/14 0} 194. Re2 {1} Kb7 {-2.72/41 0} 195. Rd2 {1 (Kg2)} Rab8 {
-2.72/16 0} 196. Rc2 {0 (Re2)} Rbc8 {-2.72/22 0} 197. Re2 {1} Qe7 {-2.72/42 0}
198. Rc2 {1 (Nd2)} Nb5 {-2.72/18 0} 199. Ra2 {2 (Re2)} Qd7 {-2.72/21 0} 200.
Rc2 {1 (Re2)} Rh8 {-2.72/22 0} 201. Ra2 {1 (Re2)} Nd6 {-2.72/21 0} 202. Rc2 {
1 (Re2)} Rb8 {-2.72/22 0} 203. Ra2 {1 (Re2)} Ne4 {-2.72/21 0} 204. Rc2 {2 (Nd2)
} Ra8 {-2.72/22 0} 205. Ra2 {1 (Re2)} Qe7 {-2.72/20 0} 206. Qc2 {1 (Re2)} Kb6 {
-2.72/13 0} 207. Qxe4 {2 (Lag: Av=0.78s, max=1.3s) (Nd2)} 1-0
[/pgn]
Open letter to Garry Kasparov.
Deep blue was a part of a crucial moment in the history of mankind. The great and great Gary Kasparov faced the power of the machine and economic corporations. The role played by the world champion was extraordinary. Today I wonder if the valuation parameters between game and game were modified. If the answer was affirmative, only that is sufficient reason to disqualify to the computer and remove or dispose of the title doping.
The doping would then be the intervention of the human by changing the lines of play in the course of the confrontation.
I believe that all chess programmers have a moral responsibility to humanity. Scientists and computer programmers of chess must tell us through the study of the games if the value system between them has differences.
I would like to have a deep blue today in front of me; I know it would be a lot of scrap metal. The problem is that IBM shares would fall to their worst historical value.
Please scientific sirs: Help us. Were the valuation systems changed in that historic match? If the answer is, YES THEY WERE, "if they were", and they were not automatically changed by the machine, that match for me was a terrible fraud and ambush against the always great and virtuous Garry Kasparov, who was then a victim of ambush.
Sincerely,
Pablo Ignacio Restrepo
Father and Grand-Father playchess.com player
Trying playserver.chessbase.com Connected Login Welcome, Grand-Father! Server Time = 21:36 (UTC+2h), 2857 users online 8 pm ( CET) – Wednesday-Blitz 5+0, 9 rounds. More Information see Tournaments -> Room Official B -> Info Your local weather: [WTH_2CLOUD_NORAIN], Temperature: 26°C, Wind: NEE 0Bft. Rated (Classic) 1m+3s No. of players receiving your offer: 5 Rated (Classic)
Intel(R) Core(TM) i9-7920X CPU @ 2.90GHz 2904MHz, (12 cores, 24 threads) New Elo: 2069 (+31),
[pgn][Event "Rated game, 5 min"]
[Site "Engine Room"]
[Date "2019.09.04"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Grand-Father"]
[Black "Deepblueocean"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D00"]
[WhiteElo "1912"]
[BlackElo "2457"]
[PlyCount "413"]
[EventDate "2019.09.04"]
[SourceTitle "playchess.com"]
[TimeControl "300"]
1. d4 {2} d5 {B 0} 2. e3 {1} Nf6 {B 0} 3. c3 {0} Bf5 {B 0} 4. f4 {1} e6 {B 0}
5. Bd3 {1} c5 {B 0} 6. Nf3 {8} Bd6 {B 0} 7. O-O {1} O-O {B 0} 8. Qe2 {4} Nc6 {
-1.07/27 15} 9. a3 {19 (b3)} c4 {-1.78/24 3} 10. Bc2 {2 (Bxf5)} Na5 {-1.39/29
26} 11. Qd1 {13} Rc8 {-1.45/31 0} 12. Re1 {2 (h3)} Bxc2 {-1.69/27 3} 13. Qxc2 {
2} Ne4 {-1.74/28 1} 14. Nbd2 {2} f5 {-1.87/27 3} 15. Rb1 {1} h6 {-1.80/26 4}
16. Nf1 {1 (Qa4)} g5 {-1.93/29 6} 17. g3 {1 (Ng3)} g4 {-2.55/26 3} 18. Nh4 {
1 (N3d2)} Nb3 {-2.85/29 3} 19. Re2 {2 (Nd2)} Qe8 {-3.16/31 8} 20. Rg2 {4 (Nd2)}
b5 {-3.27/35 25} 21. Bd2 {1 (Nd2)} Be7 {-3.44/33 7} 22. Be1 {1} a5 {-3.38/35 2}
23. Kh1 {3 (Nd2)} Kf7 {-3.31/32 9} 24. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Qd8 {-3.76/33 8} 25. Qd1 {
1 (Re2)} h5 {-3.78/32 4} 26. Kh1 {1} Rg8 {-3.79/33 2} 27. Qe2 {1 (Qc2)} Bf6 {
-3.79/37 9} 28. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Ke8 {-3.80/34 3} 29. Qc2 {1 (Qd1)} Kd7 {-3.87/32
2} 30. Kh1 {1 (Re2)} Kc7 {-3.87/35 5} 31. Kg1 {4 (Re2)} Qe7 {-3.87/35 3} 32.
Kh1 {1 (Re2)} Rg7 {-3.87/34 3} 33. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Kb7 {-3.87/35 3} 34. Kh1 {
0 (Rd1)} Rgg8 {-3.87/36 3} 35. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Rb8 {-3.87/37 5} 36. Kh1 {2 (Re2)}
Rbc8 {-3.87/35 3} 37. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rg7 {-3.87/36 3} 38. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rcg8 {
-3.87/36 3} 39. Kg1 {0} Qd8 {-3.87/36 3} 40. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Qd7 {-3.87/34 3} 41.
Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Qd8 {-3.87/36 3} 42. Kh1 {1 (Re2)} Qe7 {-3.87/37 2} 43. Kg1 {
1 (Rd1)} Kb6 {-3.87/36 2} 44. Kh1 {1 (Re2)} Qd8 {-3.87/37 2} 45. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)}
Rh8 {-3.87/37 2} 46. Kh1 {1 (Rd1)} Rhg8 {-3.87/39 4} 47. Kg1 {1} Qe7 {-3.87/37
3} 48. Kh1 {2 (Re2)} Kc7 {-3.87/40 3} 49. Kg1 {3 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.87/34 2} 50.
Kh1 {3 (Qd1)} Kc7 {-3.87/39 4} 51. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.87/38 2} 52. Kh1 {
0 (Re2)} Qd8 {-3.87/38 3} 53. Kg1 {0 (Re2)} Rh8 {-3.87/37 3} 54. Kh1 {0 (Qd1)}
Rhg8 {-3.87/38 2} 55. Kg1 {0} Kb6 {-3.87/38 1} 56. Kh1 {0 (Qd1)} Qe7 {-3.87/39
5} 57. Kg1 {0} Rh7 {-3.87/36 3} 58. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rhg7 {-3.87/39 2} 59. Kg1 {
0 (Rd1)} Qd8 {-3.87/37 1} 60. Kh1 {0 (Re2)} Kc7 {-3.87/38 1} 61. Kg1 {0} Be7 {
-3.87/35 1} 62. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.87/38 3} 63. Kg1 {0 (Qe2)} Kc7 {-3.87/40
2} 64. Kh1 {0} Bf6 {-3.87/34 0} 65. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Qe7 {-3.87/34 1} 66. Kh1 {
0 (Rd1)} Kd6 {-3.87/36 2} 67. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rb8 {-3.87/30 2} 68. Kh1 {0 (Qd1)}
Ra8 {-3.87/31 1} 69. Kg1 {0 (Nd2)} Kc7 {-3.87/32 1} 70. Kh1 {0 (Re2)} Kb7 {
-3.87/35 1} 71. Kg1 {0 (Nd2)} Rh8 {-3.65/34 9} 72. Kh1 {0} Rc8 {-3.50/32 1} 73.
Kg1 {1 (Re2)} Rh8 {-3.40/28 1} 74. Kh1 {0} a4 {-3.28/30 1} 75. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)}
Ka7 {-3.28/30 2} 76. Rd1 {1} Kb6 {-3.28/28 0} 77. Qe2 {1 (Nd2)} Rhg8 {-3.28/32
1} 78. Kh1 {3 (Qc2)} Kc7 {-3.28/28 1} 79. Kg1 {1 (Qc2)} Kc6 {-3.28/33 1} 80.
Kh1 {0 (Qc2)} Rc8 {-3.28/33 1} 81. Kg1 {0} Kb6 {-3.28/34 0} 82. Kh1 {1 (Nd2)}
Qd8 {-3.28/32 1} 83. Kg1 {0 (Nd2)} Rcc7 {-3.28/32 1} 84. Rb1 {1 (Nd2)} Kc6 {
-3.28/29 0} 85. Kh1 {1 (Rd1)} Kd7 {-3.28/26 1} 86. Kg1 {0 (Rg1)} Rg8 {-3.28/29
0} 87. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Ke8 {-3.28/27 1} 88. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Kd7 {-3.28/32 0} 89.
Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kc6 {-3.28/33 1} 90. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb6 {-3.28/32 1} 91. Kh1 {
1 (Rd1)} Ra7 {-3.28/28 0} 92. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rh7 {-3.28/31 0} 93. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)}
Rh6 {-3.28/27 0} 94. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Qe7 {-3.28/32 0} 95. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kc6 {
-3.28/30 0} 96. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Rh7 {-3.28/37 1} 97. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.28/31
1} 98. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rf7 {-3.28/31 0} 99. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rff8 {-3.28/28 0} 100.
Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Rc8 {-3.28/31 0} 101. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kc6 {-3.28/26 0} 102. Kg1 {
0 (Rd1)} Kb6 {-3.28/33 0} 103. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rg7 {-3.28/29 0} 104. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)
} Qc7 {-3.28/29 0} 105. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.28/30 0} 106. Kg1 {0} Qe7 {
-3.28/37 0} 107. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Rc7 {-3.28/28 0} 108. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rc8 {
-3.28/32 0} 109. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Qd7 {-3.28/33 0} 110. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Rcg8 {
-3.28/35 1} 111. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Ka7 {-3.28/29 0} 112. Kg1 {1 (Rd1)} Qd8 {
-3.28/32 0} 113. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.28/29 0} 114. Kg1 {4 (Rd1)} Rc7 {
-3.28/32 0} 115. Kh1 {1 (Rd1)} Rc8 {-3.28/28 0} 116. Kg1 {0 (Rd1)} Rc7 {
-3.28/32 0} 117. Kh1 {0 (Rd1)} Nd6 {-3.28/23 0} 118. Kg1 {0 (Rg1)} Kc6 {
-3.17/24 1} 119. Qc2 {2 (Rd1)} Kb7 {-3.06/28 0} 120. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Ka7 {
-3.06/28 1} 121. Kg1 {0 (Re2)} Rcg7 {-3.06/27 0} 122. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Ne4 {
-2.95/28 1} 123. Kg1 {1 (Qd1)} Bxh4 {0} 124. gxh4 {-2.95/24 0} Kb6 {-2.94/28 0}
125. Bg3 {0 (Ng3)} Qe7 {-3.06/20 0} 126. Re1 {2 (Be1)} Rh7 {-2.95/19 0} 127.
Ree2 {0 (Rd1)} Rhh8 {-3.06/18 0} 128. Qb1 {1 (Be1)} Kc7 {-2.95/19 0} 129. Rc2 {
2 (Be1)} Kb7 {-2.95/23 0} 130. Kh1 {2 (Be1)} Rd8 {-2.97/10 0} 131. Kg1 {0 (Be1)
} Ra8 {-2.95/16 0} 132. Qe1 {1 (Be1)} Qf6 {-2.95/13 0} 133. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rag8
{-2.95/10 0} 134. Kg1 {1} Rh7 {-2.95/36 0} 135. Kh1 {0 (Qb1)} Rc8 {-2.95/13 0}
136. Kg1 {1} Rg7 {-2.95/36 0} 137. Kh1 {0 (Qb1)} Qd8 {-2.95/16 0} 138. Kg1 {0}
Qe8 {-2.95/33 0} 139. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Ka7 {-2.95/14 0} 140. Kg1 {0} Qf7 {-2.95/
36 0} 141. Kh1 {4 (Qd1)} Qe7 {-2.95/17 0} 142. Kg1 {1} Ka8 {-2.95/35 0} 143.
Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rcg8 {-2.95/16 0} 144. Kg1 {0 (Qd1)} Ka7 {-2.95/21 0} 145. Kh1 {
0 (Qd1)} Kb6 {-2.95/18 0} 146. Kg1 {0} Rd8 {-2.95/37 0} 147. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rgg8
{-2.95/13 0} 148. Kg1 {1 (Qd1)} Rg7 {-2.95/15 0} 149. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Rdg8 {
-2.95/18 0} 150. Kg1 {1} Rh7 {-2.95/38 0} 151. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rhh8 {-2.95/14 0}
152. Kg1 {1 (Qd1)} Rg7 {-2.95/21 0} 153. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Qe8 {-2.95/18 0} 154.
Kg1 {1} Kb7 {-2.95/36 0} 155. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Qd8 {-2.95/15 0} 156. Kg1 {1} Rgh7
{-2.95/36 0} 157. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Rg8 {-2.95/17 0} 158. Kg1 {1} Rf7 {-2.95/34 0}
159. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Qe7 {-2.95/16 0} 160. Kg1 {1} Rc8 {-2.94/32 0} 161. Kh1 {
1 (Qd1)} Rc7 {-2.94/14 0} 162. Kg1 {1} Rg7 {-2.94/31 0} 163. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rc8
{-2.94/14 0} 164. Kg1 {1} Rd8 {-2.94/25 0} 165. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Rh8 {-2.94/13 0}
166. Kg1 {1} Ka7 {-2.73/25 0} 167. Kh1 {1 (Qb1)} Rgg8 {-2.84/10 0} 168. Kg1 {1}
Kb6 {-2.73/23 0} 169. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Qd8 {-2.94/10 0} 170. Kg1 {1} Rg6 {-2.05/
23 0} 171. Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} Rg7 {-2.26/10 0} 172. Kg1 {1} Na5 {-2.05/27 0} 173.
Kh1 {1 (Qd1)} b4 {-1.94/20 0} 174. cxb4 {1} Nb7 {-1.93/36 0} 175. Rc3 {0 (Qd1)}
Nxc3 {-3.05/12 0} 176. bxc3 {1} Qd7 {-2.63/29 0} 177. Qc1 {1 (Rb2)} Rb8 {
-2.63/28 0} 178. Re2 {1 (Rb2)} Nd6 {-2.72/18 0} 179. Kg2 {1} Kc7 {-2.72/33 0}
180. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Rgg8 {-2.72/24 0} 181. Kg2 {0 (Re1)} Rbf8 {-2.72/20 0} 182.
Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Kb7 {-2.72/13 0} 183. Kg2 {0 (Re1)} Qe7 {-2.72/23 0} 184. Kg1 {
1 (Re1)} Ra8 {-2.72/18 0} 185. Kg2 {0} Kc6 {-2.72/39 0} 186. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Kb6
{-2.72/26 0} 187. Kg2 {1} Qd7 {-2.72/41 0} 188. Kg1 {1 (Re1)} Nb5 {-2.72/17 0}
189. Kg2 {2 (Nd2)} Qc6 {-2.72/24 0} 190. Kg1 {1 (Nd2)} Rgf8 {-2.72/18 0} 191.
Rd2 {1 (Re1)} Nd6 {-2.72/17 0} 192. Re2 {1} Rg8 {-2.72/41 0} 193. Rc2 {1 (Nd2)}
Qd7 {-2.72/14 0} 194. Re2 {1} Kb7 {-2.72/41 0} 195. Rd2 {1 (Kg2)} Rab8 {
-2.72/16 0} 196. Rc2 {0 (Re2)} Rbc8 {-2.72/22 0} 197. Re2 {1} Qe7 {-2.72/42 0}
198. Rc2 {1 (Nd2)} Nb5 {-2.72/18 0} 199. Ra2 {2 (Re2)} Qd7 {-2.72/21 0} 200.
Rc2 {1 (Re2)} Rh8 {-2.72/22 0} 201. Ra2 {1 (Re2)} Nd6 {-2.72/21 0} 202. Rc2 {
1 (Re2)} Rb8 {-2.72/22 0} 203. Ra2 {1 (Re2)} Ne4 {-2.72/21 0} 204. Rc2 {2 (Nd2)
} Ra8 {-2.72/22 0} 205. Ra2 {1 (Re2)} Qe7 {-2.72/20 0} 206. Qc2 {1 (Re2)} Kb6 {
-2.72/13 0} 207. Qxe4 {2 (Lag: Av=0.78s, max=1.3s) (Nd2)} 1-0
[/pgn]