little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: bob, hgm, Harvey Williamson

Forum rules
This textbox is used to restore diagrams posted with the [d] tag before the upgrade.
User avatar
mclane
Posts: 16181
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 5:40 pm
Location: US of Europe, germany
Full name: Thorsten Czub
Contact:

little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by mclane » Tue Sep 18, 2007 1:50 pm

in all tournaments on all machines:
all engines 1 core, pb off


if you have problems to read the tables in a proper way, click on the following link:

http://f50.parsimony.net/forum200336/messages/8775.htm


it has been found out that under Arena1.99beta4 zappa-mexico cannot access tablebases. under shredder or cb-gui it works.

with the update of zappa the tablesbase problems under arena have been partly fixed. thank you.
It seems the 64-bit version still is not working with tablebases under ARENAbeta4 while the 32bit version is working.


Intel6300

c:

Code: Select all

    Motor                                   Punkte    Ry   Fr   Hi   Fr   Fr   Fr   Fr   To   Fr   Lo   Sp   Gl   Na   Al   Ch   Ph   Co   Pr   Fr   Za    S-B
01: Rybka v2.2.x64                          50,5/69 ···· 1111 111= 0111 ==0= 1=== =011 0111 ===0 ===0 1110 =11= =1== 111= 1==1 1111 111= 1111 1          1616,2
02: Fruit2.3.3g [focus1_pruningmore]        44,5/70 0000 ···· 11== 1=1= =1== 0==0 0=== 00== 11== 1111 1101 1=10 1101 1==1 =11= 111= 111= 101= =    1     1387,7
03: Hiarcs11.2SPUCI                         43,0/69 000= 00== ···· 0=0= 11=1 11== 1=01 1010 10== 11=0 =11= 11== ===1 1=11 =010 1111 =111 1111 0          1345,7
04: Fruit-051103 [claudio fabiano]          43,0/70 1000 0=0= 1=1= ···· 00=0 0=1= 1=01 ==0= =1=1 =1=0 1=== 11== 11=0 ==11 1111 1101 1111 11=1 0    1     1313,0
05: Fruit2.3.3g                             42,5/70 ==1= =0== 00=0 11=1 ···· 1=00 =111 0=01 ==== 10=0 01=1 1==1 1011 010= 01=1 1=11 1=11 =11= 1    1     1329,0
06: Fruit2.3.3g [nppoff_focus1_pruningmore] 42,0/70 0=== 1==1 00== 1=0= 0=11 ···· 00=1 01== 1=== 1=== =11= 11=0 111= =1== =1=1 ==01 0=11 1=11 =    =     1348,2
07: Fruit-061115a [002]                     40,0/69 =100 1=== 0=10 0=10 =000 11=0 ···· 1=1= 1=== ===0 111= 1=11 010= =1== =1=0 111= 1101 ==11      =     1278,5
08: TogaII134(DM1-Compile)                  40,0/70 1000 11== 0101 ==1= 1=10 10== 0=0= ···· 1==0 ===0 =10= =01= 1=10 ==10 11=0 1=11 1110 111= =    1     1252,7
09: Fruit070327 [marc lacrosse]             38,5/68 ===1 00== 01== =0=0 ==== 0=== 0=== 0==1 ···· ==11 =010 0==? 1111 11=1 1==1 0=01 1111 1110      =     1232,5
10: LoopMP 12.32                            38,5/69 ===1 0000 00=1 =0=1 01=1 0=== ===1 ===1 ==00 ···· 010= 11=0 ==10 0==1 1110 1111 =1=1 1111 =          1203,5
11: Spike1.2                                32,5/70 0001 0010 =00= 0=== 10=0 =00= 000= =01= =101 101= ···· 11== =110 =0=1 0=1= 1=10 101= 1=11 0    0     1022,2
12: Glaurung_Lodz_2007                      30,5/68 =00= 0=01 00== 00== 0==0 00=1 0=00 =10= 1==? 00=1 00== ···· =101 ==00 1111 =1=1 =1== 0111 =          940,50
13: Naum2.0_x64                             29,5/69 =0== 0010 ===0 00=1 0100 000= 101= 0=01 0000 ==01 =001 =010 ···· 1101 ==== 0==1 =1=1 =111      0     928,50
14: Alaric707                               28,0/69 000= 0==0 0=00 ==00 101= =0== =0== ==01 00=0 1==0 =1=0 ==11 0010 ···· 0011 1001 100= 1110      =     891,75
15: ChessTiger2007.1 UCI                    27,0/70 0==0 =00= =101 0000 10=0 =0=0 =0=1 00=1 0==0 0001 1=0= 0000 ==== 1100 ···· 11=1 0=01 =11= 0    =     848,00
16: Pharaon                                 20,5/69 0000 000= 0000 0010 0=00 ==10 000= 0=00 1=10 0000 0=01 =0=0 1==0 0110 00=0 ···· 1=01 1011      =     606,00
17: Colossus2007c                           20,5/70 000= 000= =000 0000 0=00 1=00 0010 0001 0000 =0=0 010= =0== =0=0 011= 1=10 0=10 ···· 011= =    =     602,50
18: ProDeo1.5                               12,5/69 0000 010= 0000 00=0 =00= 0=00 ==00 000= 0001 0000 0=00 1000 =000 0001 =00= 0100 100= ···· 0          418,00
19: Fruit2.3.3g [tc001]                     9,0/14  0    =    1    1    0    =         =         =    1    =              1         =    1    ···· 1     271,50
20: Zappa_mexico_x64                        5,5/14       0         0    0    =    =    0    =         1         1    =    =    =    =         0    ····  170,25

638 Partien von 760 gespielt
Name des Turniers: test
Ort/ Land: SCW, Germany
Spielstufe: Turnier 40/10
The results here for Zappa look not very convincing.


k:

Code: Select all

    Motor                            Punkte    Ry   Fr   Fr   Fr   Lo   Hi   Fr   To   To   Sp   Ch   Gl   Na   Co   Pr   Fr   Za   Fr    S-B
01: Rybka v2.2.x64                   41,5/57 ···· 0011 =1== ===0 ==1= 11== ==10 11== 1111 1111 1=10 1111 11== 11== 1111      =          1117,7
02: Fruit2.3.3g                      37,0/58 1100 ···· 1=00 0=== 010= =0=1 =1=1 1111 ===1 1100 1110 =01= 1=11 1101 111= 1    1          961,50
03: Fruit-051103                     36,0/57 =0== 0=11 ···· 10=1 ==11 110= ==0= ==01 01=1 1010 11=1 101= 11=1 =11= 10=1      1          979,00
04: Fruit233f [npp]                  34,5/58 ===1 1=== 01=0 ···· ==00 0=1= =10= 0=1= 1=1= ===1 =0=1 01=0 1111 11=1 1=11 0         1     913,00
05: LoopMP 12.32                     34,0/59 ==0= 101= ==00 ==11 ···· =1=1 ==01 =1=0 =01= 1001 0=11 001= ===1 ==11 1==1 1    1    =     888,75
06: Hiarcs11.2SPUCI                  32,0/58 00== =1=0 001= 1=0= =0=0 ···· ==01 0110 0=== ==10 =111 11=0 =1== 1110 1111 =         1     819,25
07: Fruit-061115a [004]              31,5/58 ==01 =0=0 ==1= =01= ==10 ==10 ···· 1==1 0==1 010= 0==1 =10= 1=10 11== 1101 =         =     855,25
08: TogaII131(DM1-Compile)           30,5/58 00== 0000 ==10 1=0= =0=1 1001 0==0 ···· 01=1 1=11 =00= 1==1 =1== 1110 1=11 =         1     775,00
09: TogaII134(DM1-Compile)           28,5/57 0000 ===0 10=0 0=0= =10= 1=== 1==0 10=0 ···· =101 11== =110 =10= 1=1= 011=      1          747,25
10: Spike1.2                         27,5/58 0000 0011 0101 ===0 0110 ==01 101= 0=00 =010 ···· 01== ==== 11== ==11 0=10 1         1     712,50
11: ChessTiger2007.1 UCI             27,5/59 0=01 0001 00=0 =1=0 1=00 =000 1==0 =11= 00== 10== ···· ==== ==1= =011 1011 =    1    1     688,50
12: Glaurung_Lodz_2007               25,5/57 0000 =10= 010= 10=1 110= 00=1 =01= 0==0 =001 ==== ==== ···· ===0 1=== 10=1      =          704,50
13: Naum2.0                          20,0/58 00== 0=00 00=0 0000 ===0 =0== 0=01 =0== =01= 00== ==0= ===1 ···· =1== ==10      0    =     532,25
14: Colossus2007c                    16,5/58 00== 0010 =00= 00=0 ==00 0001 00== 0001 0=0= ==00 =100 0=== =0== ···· ===1 0         0     462,75
15: ProDeo1.5                        15,0/57 0000 000= 01=0 0=00 0==0 0000 0010 0=00 100= 1=01 0100 01=0 ==01 ===0 ····      0          412,50
16: Fruit2.3.3g [tc002]              5,0/11       0         1    0    =    =    =         0    =              1         ···· 0    1     114,75
17: Zappa_mexico_x64                 4,5/11  =    0    0         0                   0         0    =    1         1    1    ···· =      75,00
18: Fruit2.3.3g [focus1_pruningmore] 3,0/11                 0    =    0    =    0         0    0         =    1         0    =    ····   61,50

450 Partien von 612 gespielt
Name des Turniers: Ct2007.1
Ort/ Land: SCW, Deutschland
Spielstufe: Turnier 40/10
The results here are not much better.
As it seems zappa_mexico is not that much strong.
i wonder how they want to fight rybka with that, but maybe
the program is much better on faster hardware ?

AMD Athlon2400+

Code: Select all

    Motor                                   Punkte  Ry Fr Fr Fr Hi To Fr Za Fr Fr Ch Gl Sp Al Lo Na Pr Co    S-B
01: Rybkav2.2.w32                           26,5/34 ·· 10 1= =1 01 11 == 1= =1 == 11 11 11 =1 11 == 11 11  421,50
02: Fruit-061115a [002]                     22,5/34 01 ·· =1 =1 1= == 0= =1 == == == == =1 10 =1 11 11 11  358,00
03: Fruit2.3.3g [focus2_nppoff_pruningmore] 22,0/34 0= =0 ·· 1= 11 10 01 10 =0 =1 =1 =1 == 11 11 1= 1= =1  346,50
04: Fruit2.3.3i                             20,5/34 =0 =0 0= ·· 1= 01 =1 1= 01 == =0 11 =1 11 =1 =0 =1 11  317,75
05: Hiarcs11.2SPUCI                         20,5/34 10 0= 00 0= ·· 10 10 =0 0= 11 =1 == =1 =1 11 11 11 11  305,50
06: TogaII131(DM2-Compile)                  19,5/34 00 == 01 10 01 ·· 00 11 == 00 1= 11 == 1= =1 11 == 11  298,00
07: Fruit2.3.3g [focus1_pruningmore]        19,0/34 == 1= 10 =0 01 11 ·· 01 =0 0= 00 10 1= 1= =1 10 1= 11  305,00
08: Zappa_mexico                            18,5/34 0= =0 01 0= =1 00 10 ·· 11 =0 1= =0 == 1= 10 11 11 =1  286,75
09: Fruit070327 [marc lacrosse]             18,0/34 =0 == =1 10 1= == =1 00 ·· 10 00 01 == =1 =1 =1 10 1=  292,50
10: Fruit2.3.3h                             17,0/34 == == =0 == 00 11 1= =1 01 ·· 0= 0= =1 0= 0= =0 1= 11  279,50
11: ChessTiger2007.1 UCI                    17,0/34 00 == =0 =1 =0 0= 11 0= 11 1= ·· =0 =1 =0 11 0= =0 =1  276,00
12: Glaurung_Lodz_2007                      15,0/34 00 == =0 00 == 00 01 =1 10 1= =1 ·· == 00 =1 10 01 1=  236,50
13: Spike1.2                                14,5/34 00 =0 == =0 =0 == 0= == == =0 =0 == ·· 11 10 == =1 ==  225,00
14: Alaric707                               13,0/34 =0 01 00 00 =0 0= 0= 0= =0 1= =1 11 00 ·· =0 == 0= 11  201,75
15: LoopMP 12.32                            13,0/34 00 =0 00 =0 00 =0 =0 01 =0 1= 00 =0 01 =1 ·· =1 11 1=  184,75
16: Naum 2.0                                12,5/34 == 00 0= =1 00 00 01 00 =0 =1 1= 01 == == =0 ·· 0= ==  208,00
17: ProDeo 1.5                              10,5/34 00 00 0= =0 00 == 0= 00 01 0= =1 10 =0 1= 00 1= ·· =0  166,00
18: Colossus2007c                           6,5/34  00 00 =0 00 00 00 00 =0 0= 00 =0 0= == 00 0= == =1 ··   94,50

306 Partien gespielt / Turnier beendet
Name des Turniers: Mai
Ort/ Land: ORION8, Germany
Spielstufe: Blitz 15/2
Hardware: Mobile AMD Athlon(tm) XP 2400+ 1800 MHz
this tournament is now finished and shows also 2 new fruit versions h+i.

AMD Sempron3000+

Code: Select all

    Motor                              Punkte  Ry Fr Fr Fr Fr To Fr Lo Za Fr Hi Pr Na Sp Al Ch Gl Co    S-B
01: Rybkav2.2.w32                      21,5/31 ·· 1  == =  1= =0 =1 == 1= =  =1 1= 1= 11 11 11 =0 =1  311,75
02: Fruit2.3.3g [f2_nppoff_pmoretc001] 20,5/30 0  ·· 10 == 1  =1 == 11 =1 == == 1= 1  10 0  11 11 11  287,25
03: Fruit-2.3.3ex                      19,5/30 == 01 ·· =  =1 =  == == 01 =1 1= == 11 1  01 11 == 1   288,25
04: Fruit233f [003]                    19,0/31 =  == =  ·· 0= 01 =0 01 10 == 1= 11 1= == =  1= 11 11  261,25
05: Fruit-051103                       18,5/33 0= 0  =0 1= ·· 01 0= 1= 10 00 =1 =0 11 1= 1= 1= =1 11  253,00
06: TogaII134(DM2-Compile)             17,5/31 =1 =0 =  10 10 ·· =1 10 1= 10 =  0= == 10 1  =0 11 =1  257,25
07: Fruit-061115a [001]                17,5/31 =0 == == =1 1= =0 ·· =  0= == =1 0  0= 11 01 1  1= 11  250,50
08: LoopMP 12.32                       16,0/30 == 00 == 10 0= 01 =  ·· =  10 == 1  =0 10 11 =  11 1=  225,75
09: Zappa_mexico                       15,5/30 0= =0 10 01 01 0= 1= =  ·· 10 0= 1  01 =  10 10 11 1   227,25
10: Fruit2.3.3g [tc003]                15,0/30 =  == =0 == 11 01 == 01 01 ·· 0= == 0  01 1  0= 0  11  227,25
11: Hiarcs11.2SPUCI                    14,5/30 =0 == 0= 0= =0 =  =0 == 1= 1= ·· 1  01 =  01 01 11 0   218,00
12: ProDeo1.5                          14,5/30 0= 0= == 00 =1 1= 1  0  0  == 0  ·· 1= 11 10 01 10 10  213,50
13: Naum2.0                            14,0/31 0= 0  00 0= 00 == 1= =1 10 1  10 0= ·· == 10 == =  11  193,00
14: Spike1.2                           13,0/31 00 01 0  == 0= 01 00 01 =  10 =  00 == ·· 01 =1 01 11  176,75
14: Alaric707                          13,0/30 00 1  10 =  0= 0  10 00 01 0  10 01 01 10 ·· 00 11 11  176,75
16: ChessTiger2007.1UCI                12,0/31 00 00 00 0= 0= =1 0  =  01 1= 10 10 == =0 11 ·· 0  01  171,50
17: Glaurung_Lodz_2007                 9,5/31  =1 00 == 00 =0 00 0= 00 00 1  00 01 =  10 00 1  ·· 1=  138,75
18: Colossus2007c                      5,0/31  =0 00 0  00 00 =0 00 0= 0  00 1  01 00 00 00 10 0= ··   73,25

276 Partien von 306 gespielt
Name des Turniers: Arena Turnier
Ort/ Land: SCW, Deutschland
Spielstufe: Blitz 5/20
Hardware: AMD Sempron(tm) Prozessor 3000+ 1800 MHz


will be updated soon !
Last edited by mclane on Fri Sep 21, 2007 2:47 pm, edited 6 times in total.

Jouni
Posts: 2005
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:15 pm

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by Jouni » Tue Sep 18, 2007 8:31 pm

But old Rybka :(

Jouni

User avatar
mclane
Posts: 16181
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 5:40 pm
Location: US of Europe, germany
Full name: Thorsten Czub
Contact:

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by mclane » Tue Sep 18, 2007 8:36 pm

the stronger version IMO

Jouni
Posts: 2005
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:15 pm

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by Jouni » Wed Sep 19, 2007 6:36 pm

I think this is not "IMO" thing, but look at CEGT rating list is enough:

11 Rybka 2.3.2a 1CPU 2977
16 Rybka 2.2 32-bit 2941

Jouni

User avatar
mclane
Posts: 16181
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 5:40 pm
Location: US of Europe, germany
Full name: Thorsten Czub
Contact:

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by mclane » Tue Sep 25, 2007 10:21 am

Code: Select all

    Motor                              Punkte  Ry Fr Fr To Za Hi Na To Lo Pr Ch Sp Al Co Gl Co    S-B
01: Rybkav2.2.w32                      21,0/30 ·· 1= =1 =0 1= =1 1= == == 1= 11 11 11 =1 =0 =1  306,00
02: Fruit2.3.3g [f2_nppoff_pmoretc001] 19,5/30 0= ·· == =1 =1 == 1= 00 11 1= 11 10 00 11 11 11  269,25
03: Fruit-061115a [001]                19,0/30 =0 == ·· =0 0= =1 0= 11 == 01 11 11 01 11 1= 11  257,75
04: TogaII134(DM2-Compile)             18,0/30 =1 =0 =1 ·· 1= == == == 10 0= =0 10 11 1= 11 =1  257,75
05: Zappa_mexico                       17,5/30 0= =0 1= 0= ·· 0= 01 11 == 1= 10 =1 10 11 11 10  242,25
06: Hiarcs11.2SPUCI                    17,0/30 =0 == =0 == 1= ·· 01 == == 11 01 == 01 =1 11 01  238,75
07: Naum2.0                            16,5/30 0= 0= 1= == 10 10 ·· 01 =1 0= == == 10 =1 =1 11  230,75
08: TogaII131(DM2-Compile)             16,0/30 == 11 00 == 00 == 10 ·· 1= =1 01 =0 11 0= 1= 1=  231,00
09: LoopMP 12.32                       16,0/30 == 00 == 01 == == =0 0= ·· 1= =0 10 11 =1 11 1=  218,50
10: ProDeo1.5                          13,5/30 0= 0= 10 1= 0= 00 1= =0 0= ·· 01 11 10 01 10 10  195,25
11: ChessTiger2007.1UCI                13,5/30 00 00 00 =1 01 10 == 10 =1 10 ·· =0 11 10 01 01  190,25
12: Spike1.2                           13,5/30 00 01 00 01 =0 == == =1 01 00 =1 ·· 01 10 01 11  186,50
13: Alaric707                          13,0/30 00 11 10 00 01 10 01 00 00 01 00 10 ·· 01 11 11  178,00
14: Colossus2007d                      10,0/30 =0 00 00 0= 00 =0 =0 1= =0 10 01 01 10 ·· 10 10  137,75
15: Glaurung_Lodz_2007                 8,5/30  =1 00 0= 00 00 00 =0 0= 00 01 10 10 00 01 ·· 1=  119,00
16: Colossus2007c                      7,5/30  =0 00 00 =0 01 10 00 0= 0= 01 10 00 00 01 0= ··  111,25

240 Partien gespielt / Turnier beendet
Name des Turniers: Arena Turnier
Ort/ Land: SCW, Deutschland
Spielstufe: Blitz 5/20
Hardware: AMD Sempron(tm) Prozessor 3000+ 1800 MHz
Colossus d better than c (2.5 points better).

Uri Blass
Posts: 8590
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 11:37 pm
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by Uri Blass » Tue Sep 25, 2007 12:26 pm

CCRL 40/40 comparison

Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 4CPU 3116 +26 −25 73.5% −158.8 37.5% 546
69.0%
Rybka 2.2 64-bit 4CPU 3106 +30 −29 73.2% −156.6 38.7% 403
66.2%

1-0

Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 2CPU 3097 +25 −25 77.9% −190.0 36.3% 603
56.6%
Rybka 2.2 64-bit 2CPU 3052 +23 −23 73.0% −164.1 35.0% 697
53.8%

2-0
Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 3071 +20 −20 76.3% −188.6 32.5% 956
86.4%
Rybka 2.2 64-bit 2998 +35 −34 70.0% −128.2 47.9% 267
61.4%

3-0
Rybka 2.3.2a 32-bit 3013 +23 −23 75.0% −171.0 36.5% 695
Rybka 2.2 32-bit 2987 +18 −17 70.4% −140.3 36.6% 1150

4-0
CEGT 40/20

2 Rybka 2.3.2a x64 2CPU WM-2007 3055 14 14 1708 74.5 % 2869 35.9 %
5 Rybka 2.2 x64 2CPU 3015 14 14 1487 71.6 % 2855 37.1 %

5-0

12 Rybka 2.3.2a w32 1CPU 2974 14 14 1687 70.0 % 2827 36.8 %
18 Rybka 2.2 w32 1CPU 2938 17 17 1184 69.0 % 2799 34.4 %

6-0

cegt 40/4

1 Rybka 2.3.2 mp x64 2CPU 3030 24 23 650 75.0 % 2839 31.8 %
2 Rybka 2.2 mp x64 2CPU w/Fix 2991 19 19 1060 76.1 % 2790 27.8 %


7-0

11 Rybka 2.3.2a w32 1CPU 2933 20 19 889 73.3 % 2757 34.0 %
16 Rybka 2.2 32-bit 2899 14 14 1682 70.6 % 2747 31.0 %

8-0

final comparison
2.3.2a beat 2.2 8-0

Uri

Tony Thomas

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by Tony Thomas » Tue Sep 25, 2007 6:31 pm

Uri, I want to hear his comeback story.

User avatar
George Bodkin
Posts: 160
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 7:46 pm
Location: Selden, NY

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by George Bodkin » Tue Sep 25, 2007 8:58 pm

Will the Fruit Version be made available to all.

Thanks GEORGE

User avatar
mclane
Posts: 16181
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 5:40 pm
Location: US of Europe, germany
Full name: Thorsten Czub
Contact:

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by mclane » Wed Sep 26, 2007 9:29 am

i think they will if one version was found out as strongest.

see also new tournament finished after 924 games...

http://f50.parsimony.net/forum200336/messages/8801.htm

User avatar
mclane
Posts: 16181
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 5:40 pm
Location: US of Europe, germany
Full name: Thorsten Czub
Contact:

Re: little tournaments (new fruit version, new zappa mexico)

Post by mclane » Wed Sep 26, 2007 4:31 pm

new fruit version.

also new results from colossus d.

http://f50.parsimony.net/forum200336/messages/8804.htm

as it seems the new versions of fruit 2.3.3g and 2.3.3i and now 2.3.3j
are very strong.

Post Reply