Battle of the Forgotten: Bottom 40 engines tournament

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

Carlos777
Posts: 1729
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2009 6:09 pm

Re: Battle of the Forgotten: Bottom 40 engines tournament

Post by Carlos777 »

Bill Rogers wrote:Did any of the ratings change after the tournement? Just currious. I have acouple of chess engines that would have fit right into your tournements.
Bill
Hi Bill,

Yes, there were changes. This is the updated rating list, calculated with BayesElo (prior=0.1 & offset=1600) :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                          Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 RDchess 3.23                 2184   68   68   136   79%  1830    7% 
   2 SCP 2.03ja                   2173   69   69   136   79%  1824    7% 
   3 Simplex 0.0                  2145   66   66   139   78%  1722   13% 
   4 Requiem 0.53                 2135   64   64   136   82%  1798   25% 
   5 Ifrit j2.7                   2121   71   71   138   79%  1661    8% 
   6 KMTChess 1.1                 2119   65   65   141   76%  1719   11% 
   7 Chesley r317 ja              2111   65   65   136   74%  1744   10% 
   8 ECE 0.3                      2100   67   67   136   76%  1769   11% 
   9 JanWillem 1.13               2089   63   63   136   72%  1826   13% 
  10 KKFChess 2.6.6               2081   64   64   136   71%  1826   10% 
  11 Jabba 1.0                    2074   62   62   142   73%  1726   13% 
  12 Ssechess 2.05                2069   62   62   136   69%  1833   13% 
  13 Frank-Walter 1.08            2068   62   62   136   69%  1827   11% 
  14 Sharper 0.17                 2061   63   63   136   68%  1834    7% 
  15 Smallpotato 0.6.1            2058   63   63   136   68%  1834    8% 
  16 PoorLittlePinkus rev1661571  2051   62   62   136   69%  1827   14% 
  17 Faile 1.4                    2035   62   62   136   71%  1801   16% 
  18 Heracles 0.6.16              2029   67   67   136   72%  1756    8% 
  19 Morphy 3.22                  2026   62   62   136   66%  1828   11% 
  20 Micro-Max 4.8w               2017   62   62   136   67%  1746   14% 
  21 SamChess                     2014   61   61   136   64%  1835   13% 
  22 Laurifer 1.0                 2009   60   60   136   63%  1835   10% 
  23 Brainless 20081212           2002   64   64   136   67%  1772   11% 
  24 IACH 0.56z                   1995   68   68   137   69%  1673    6% 
  25 ColChess 8.0                 1995   62   62   136   66%  1802   12% 
  26 Gully 2.16pl1                1994   85   85    78   77%  1674   18% 
  27 Roce 0.0390                  1993   62   62   139   65%  1726   12% 
  28 Sissa 1.00                   1983   60   60   142   64%  1729   13% 
  29 EnginMax 5.11c               1982   65   65   136   66%  1772    4% 
  30 FreeChess 2.17b              1982   93   93    78   77%  1663    5% 
  31 Hopeless 0.49                1980  107  107    78   88%  1537    6% 
  32 Plywood 1.73X                1980   87   87    78   75%  1675   12% 
  33 SnailChess 4.013             1973   97   97    78   83%  1617    9% 
  34 Rival 1.18                   1954   93   93    78   74%  1663    3% 
  35 Monik 2.23                   1952   93   93    78   83%  1617   12% 
  36 Simontacchi 1.8a             1951   63   63   136   66%  1726   14% 
  37 BibiChess 0.5                1951   96   96    78   82%  1564   10% 
  38 Freyr 1.068 ja               1948   87   87    78   72%  1675    9% 
  39 Dabbaba 2.62                 1948  109  109    78   87%  1388    8% 
  40 Sierzant 0.26                1945   81   81    78   73%  1676   26% 
  41 BSC 3.7+f                    1944   86   86    78   72%  1676   10% 
  42 Smash 1.03                   1938  104  104    78   85%  1538    5% 
  43 Marvin 1.30                  1937   87   87    78   74%  1664   12% 
  44 Woodpecker 2.11.x            1937   90   90    78   73%  1664    5% 
  45 Grizzly 1.40.1b              1935   89   89    78   74%  1664    9% 
  46 Kurt 271009                  1934   79   79    78   71%  1676   24% 
  47 Enigma 1.14                  1931   95   95    78   82%  1564   10% 
  48 Etude 0.12                   1927   94   94    78   80%  1565    9% 
  49 SEE 0.6.9                    1921   87   87    78   71%  1664    9% 
  50 Reger 0.09                   1921   92   92    79   75%  1519   14% 
  51 Bubble 1.32                  1921   93   93    78   80%  1565    9% 
  52 ChessterfieldCL i5a          1918  101  101    79   85%  1482    5% 
  53 Celes 0.77c                  1915   91   91    78   79%  1618    9% 
  54 Eagle 0.75                   1913   91   91    78   80%  1565   12% 
  55 MatMoi v7.15.0-cct           1909   81   81    78   68%  1676   15% 
  56 Bace 0.45                    1901   99   99    78   85%  1484   10% 
  57 Sjakk 1.1.3                  1894   92   92    78   74%  1522   12% 
  58 Zzzzzz 3.51ja                1889   82   82    78   70%  1665   17% 
  59 Ranita 2.4                   1888   82   82    78   67%  1677   13% 
  60 Elephant 1.06                1876   87   87    80   75%  1572   10% 
  61 Tamerlane 0.2                1874   90   90    78   74%  1619    5% 
  62 SmallC 90-3                  1873   87   87    78   68%  1666   10% 
  63 Pooky 2.7                    1871  105  105    82   87%  1395    5% 
  64 JARS 1.75a                   1871   98   98    79   84%  1379   13% 
  65 Clueless 1.4                 1868   80   80    80   64%  1681   14% 
  66 Warrior 1.03                 1867   78   78    80   65%  1681   18% 
  67 Newrival 1.8.29              1864   87   87    80   79%  1547   10% 
  68 Brembo 0.62                  1861   91   91    80   70%  1531    8% 
  69 Vicki 0.041a                 1854   90   90    81   81%  1492   11% 
  70 Ajetac 2.73b                 1850   93   93    80   78%  1494    4% 
  71 Myrddin 0.81a2               1850   89   89    83   70%  1510   10% 
  72 Golem 0.4 r45a               1849   65   65   140   60%  1670   13% 
  73 Noonian 3.206                1841   57   57   158   64%  1674   16% 
  74 Cuckoo Chess 1.00            1840   89   89    83   69%  1505    6% 
  75 Carballo 0.3                 1839   87   87    81   80%  1493   15% 
  76 Adamant 1.7                  1837   87   87    83   69%  1526   12% 
  77 Yoda 1.30                    1836   86   86    82   70%  1507   15% 
  78 HeavyChess 0.13              1831   79   79    80   73%  1574   26% 
  79 Beaches 2.32                 1830   60   60   104   55%  1785   14% 
  80 Surprise 4.3-beta 13         1826   83   83    80   70%  1626    8% 
  81 Soldat 0.25b                 1810   83   83    80   77%  1549   16% 
  82 Embracer 1.12                1801   79   79    80   72%  1574   24% 
  83 Hoplite 2.1.1dc              1801   92   92    82   77%  1400   10% 
  84 Simon 1.2                    1797   81   81    80   69%  1626   10% 
  85 Tscp 1.81                    1790   83   83    80   68%  1575   11% 
  86 Storm 0.6                    1790   84   84    80   73%  1549    8% 
  87 Lodocase 240208              1787   83   83    80   72%  1549    6% 
  88 Pulsar 2009-9b               1785   78   78    80   66%  1627   15% 
  89 Chessrikus 1.466             1784   87   87    81   64%  1530   10% 
  90 Robin 0.983                  1780   56   56   158   58%  1676   15% 
  91 Aldebaran 0.7.0              1780   80   80    80   76%  1496   24% 
  92 ChessV 0.94                  1771   92   92    80   76%  1403    9% 
  93 DChess 1.0.2                 1770   86   86    81   73%  1494    9% 
  94 Zoidberg 0.1                 1764   77   77    80   64%  1627   19% 
  95 Dabbaba 2.46                 1763   92   92    83   64%  1497    7% 
  96 Fauce 0.41c                  1763   75   75    80   65%  1627   25% 
  97 Alibaba 1.17                 1762   88   88    81   62%  1530   11% 
  98 ArabianKnight 0.88 2t        1757   67   67   124   63%  1522   20% 
  99 Kanguruh 1.93                1754   65   65   161   77%  1390    7% 
 100 Gargamella 0.50              1749   90   90    83   71%  1425   10% 
 101 Tristram 3.36                1749   81   81    80   68%  1550    9% 
 102 Jester 0.83 DC               1746   92   92    81   73%  1393    6% 
 103 Hoichess 0.10.3 ja           1745   92   92    82   71%  1415    6% 
 104 Cecir 3.5                    1740   81   81    81   71%  1495   19% 
 105 Mint 2.3                     1731   78   78    80   69%  1551   13% 
 106 Cleo 1                       1730   88   88    81   60%  1530   10% 
 107 Milady 2.40                  1729   80   80    81   70%  1495   15% 
 108 GchessIV 0.2.0               1728   54   54   158   53%  1677   27% 
 109 PolarEngine 1.3              1728   55   55   158   52%  1677   18% 
 110 MsKcp 1.4.4 ja               1712   83   83    82   76%  1399   13% 
 111 Marginal 0.1                 1712   88   88    83   75%  1401    5% 
 112 Chenard v2010.01.04          1710   91   91    81   71%  1394    9% 
 113 Beaches 2.26                 1707   81   81    79   68%  1488   13% 
 114 ALChess 1.5b                 1703   55   55   204   65%  1475   10% 
 115 ArcBishop 2.24a              1697   73   73    82   57%  1634   18% 
 116 Simple 0048                  1690   77   77    78   48%  1682   27% 
 117 Elf 1.30                     1690   57   57   157   62%  1558   11% 
 118 RBrChess 2.20                1688   83   83    78   67%  1489    8% 
 119 Mizar 3.0                    1688   84   84    83   74%  1401   11% 
 120 Damas9                       1667   55   55   203   63%  1472    9% 
 121 Minimax                      1656   40   40   315   63%  1498   15% 
 122 Hokus Pokus 0.6.3            1653   45   45   234   57%  1581   13% 
 123 Jupiter 0.01                 1644   46   46   234   47%  1660   13% 
 124 IQ23 0.03                    1641   57   57   158   69%  1393   26% 
 125 Belzebub 0.67                1637   54   54   158   58%  1531   23% 
 126 Philemon 0.5                 1631   30   30   549   54%  1568   17% 
 127 LarsenVB 0.05                1630   60   60   159   67%  1394   11% 
 128 Excelsior 3.16               1629   46   46   234   46%  1660   12% 
 129 RataAeroespacial 0.05        1622   51   51   156   54%  1586   29% 
 130 Zotron 4.46                  1619   74   74    78   59%  1546   28% 
 131 Needle 0.531                 1606   30   30   550   52%  1568   19% 
 132 Predateur 0.1.5              1587   40   40   315   56%  1500   12% 
 133 Pentagon 1.2                 1586   83   83    78   38%  1685   14% 
 134 Vanillachess 2.6g            1584   55   55   156   49%  1587   14% 
 135 TarraschToyEngine 0.906      1583   40   40   312   44%  1633   12% 
 136 Cefap 0.72                   1569   32   32   469   45%  1599   14% 
 137 Blikskottel 0.8              1564   32   32   469   45%  1600   14% 
 138 Rocinante 1.01               1559   30   30   594   49%  1542   11% 
 139 Cilian 4.14se                1558   77   77    78   46%  1574   26% 
 140 Yawce 0.16                   1546   86   86    78   37%  1674    4% 
 141 Minimardi 1.3                1543   35   35   394   50%  1526   14% 
 142 Ozwald 0.43                  1534   44   44   283   52%  1472   14% 
 143 Exacto 0.d                   1533   48   48   234   37%  1663   13% 
 144 RBrChess 2.16                1528   73   73   131   45%  1517    7% 
 145 Piranha 0.5                  1528   33   33   471   46%  1551    7% 
 146 Gedeone 1620                 1516   28   28   671   44%  1563   14% 
 147 Goyaz 0.0.0.7                1512   41   41   312   40%  1607   12% 
 148 StAndersen 1.31c rev2ja      1506   86   86    80   33%  1677   10% 
 149 DimitriWBE 2.01              1501   45   45   238   41%  1581   13% 
 150 Roque 1.1                    1491   36   36   394   44%  1529   12% 
 151 RBrChess 2.19                1487   80   80    80   56%  1394   11% 
 152 Skaki 1.2.3                  1483   77   77    84   38%  1609    7% 
 153 Nero 6.1                     1475   53   53   160   38%  1584   19% 
 154 Frittle 0.5                  1473   34   34   441   44%  1507   23% 
 155 Sinapse 1.0                  1460   83   83    82   28%  1672   22% 
 156 Murderhole 1.0.10            1459   47   47   242   35%  1611    8% 
 157 Rainman 0.75                 1456   86   86    84   31%  1653    7% 
 158 Lovelace 1.0r1               1445   79   79    88   29%  1643   19% 
 159 GFC v2                       1444   83   83    88   51%  1398   13% 
 160 CM Josh Age 8                1437   59   59   168   31%  1639    7% 
 161 Numpty 0.6pr                 1432   60   60   100   54%  1404   23% 
 162 SdBC 0.4.14.0                1432   39   39   323   41%  1503   16% 
 163 Joanna 2002 1.04JA           1423   52   52   166   33%  1578   25% 
 164 JChess 1.0                   1420   36   36   403   42%  1481   14% 
 165 Stan's chess 1.42            1420   62   62   166   27%  1665    8% 
 166 KillerQueen 2.0b3            1415   61   61   166   25%  1665   14% 
 167 MinichessAI 1.19             1402   59   59   164   27%  1640   10% 
 168 Eden 0.013                   1390   47   47   290   41%  1476    6% 
 169 SharpChess2 2.52             1388  119  119    39   42%  1447    3% 
 170 RedQueen 0.2 ja              1369   78   78    80   44%  1397   19% 
 171 RedQueen 0.4 ja              1358   83   83    84   35%  1487    8% 
 172 SharpChess 0.06              1355   94   94    84   22%  1666    8% 
 173 Trex 1.9                     1336   42   42   366   34%  1497   11% 
 174 Avichess 0.9                 1302   63   63   102   38%  1395   12% 
 175 ChessCraft 0.96              1301   63   63   161   27%  1535    9% 
 176 Mystery 2.1                  1299   59   59   162   21%  1585   20% 
 177 Joana_DC no book             1291   99   99    85   32%  1513    8% 
 178 Cheoss 0.649                 1291  165  165    26   31%  1543    8% 
 179 Numpty 0.5pr                 1281  102  102    86   33%  1502    7% 
 180 Tikov 0.6.3                  1254   92   92    82   27%  1494    6% 
 181 Marquis 1.6                  1227   63   63   163   29%  1448   11% 
 182 Qutechess 1.01t rev3 ja      1222   68   68   119   65%  1075   19% 
 183 Hanzo The Razor 1.1.1.1      1209   61   61   159   33%  1398   31% 
 184 DarkFusch 0.09               1208   53   53   235   38%  1356   13% 
 185 Fimbulwinter 5.02            1206   51   51   280   42%  1325    6% 
 186 Pierre 1.7 ja                1199   61   61   158   53%  1165    8% 
 187 Gringo 1.49b                 1174   66   66   156   46%  1254    9% 
 188 Kcchess pre-alpha2 rev 1.13  1168   51   51   234   33%  1373   27% 
 189 Kace 0.82 ja                 1161   63   63   156   53%  1166   12% 
 190 Raffaela 0.14                1161   67   67   156   43%  1310   13% 
 191 Nanook 0.17                  1118   49   49   281   37%  1324   21% 
 192 Xadreco 5.7                  1114   60   60   200   41%  1293    9% 
 193 Strategicdeep 1.25           1099   69   69   156   37%  1282    3% 
 194 Giuchess 1.0b2dc             1096   50   50   238   38%  1253   16% 
 195 Delfi 1000 ELO               1080   53   53   237   37%  1248    8% 
 196 Butterfly 0.1.7_alpha        1074   65   65   156   36%  1312   20% 
 197 Dreamer 0.2.0                1065   52   52   236   37%  1248   14% 
 198 Mfchess 1.3                  1053   61   61   159   39%  1171   14% 
 199 Dika 0.4209                  1050   57   57   234   27%  1358   15% 
 200 Luzhin 0.1                   1021   64   64   156   33%  1245   17% 
 201 Ochess rev2 ja               1019   54   54   236   30%  1281    9% 
 202 Bigbook 3.1                   995   57   57   235   26%  1341    9% 
 203 Youk 1.05                     967   59   59   201   31%  1292   12% 
 204 Belofte 0.2.8                 911   58   58   235   21%  1344   14% 
 205 Pyotr Am 0.6                  903   55   55   237   22%  1284   16% 
 206 Dendron 0.42b ja              884   70   70   156   24%  1317   17% 
 207 Geko 0.43                     876   61   61   202   25%  1294   11% 
 208 Sachy 0.2.01                  851   61   61   200   22%  1298   15% 
 209 Neg 0.3d                      834   63   63   200   22%  1302   12% 
 210 Cheops 1.1                    820   67   67   235   16%  1346    3% 
 211 Prechess 0.7.8                811   71   71   158   20%  1240   10% 
 212 Microchess1976                801   71   71   118   26%  1089   18% 
 213 Tri-OS                        784   71   71   157   18%  1224   11% 
 214 Omar 3.1                      717   73   73   158   15%  1177   11% 
 215 Ram 2.0                       716   74   74   234    9%  1446    9% 
 216 Ace v0.1                      674   70   70   200   13%  1305   13% 
 217 Neurone I                     667   87   87   156   12%  1316    5% 
 218 Cpp1                          629   79   79   156   12%  1246   12% 
 219 Brutus RND                    562   80   80   237    8%  1258    3% 
 220 NSVChess 0.14                 540   99   99   121   11%  1152    3% 
 221 Deep Duke 1.00ja              510  104  104   101   10%  1059    5% 
 222 Pos-1.20                      449  100  100   200    5%  1309    3% 
Regards,
Carlos

PS: Bill, if you wish, I can run a 100 games gauntlets for your engines. Just let me know.
Adam Hair
Posts: 3226
Joined: Wed May 06, 2009 10:31 pm
Location: Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina

Re: Battle of the Forgotten: Bottom 40 engines tournament

Post by Adam Hair »

Carlos777 wrote:
Bill Rogers wrote:Did any of the ratings change after the tournement? Just currious. I have acouple of chess engines that would have fit right into your tournements.
Bill
Hi Bill,

Yes, there were changes. This is the updated rating list, calculated with BayesElo (prior=0.1 & offset=1600) :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                          Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 RDchess 3.23                 2184   68   68   136   79%  1830    7% 
   2 SCP 2.03ja                   2173   69   69   136   79%  1824    7% 
   3 Simplex 0.0                  2145   66   66   139   78%  1722   13% 
   4 Requiem 0.53                 2135   64   64   136   82%  1798   25% 
   5 Ifrit j2.7                   2121   71   71   138   79%  1661    8% 
   6 KMTChess 1.1                 2119   65   65   141   76%  1719   11% 
   7 Chesley r317 ja              2111   65   65   136   74%  1744   10% 
   8 ECE 0.3                      2100   67   67   136   76%  1769   11% 
   9 JanWillem 1.13               2089   63   63   136   72%  1826   13% 
  10 KKFChess 2.6.6               2081   64   64   136   71%  1826   10% 
  11 Jabba 1.0                    2074   62   62   142   73%  1726   13% 
  12 Ssechess 2.05                2069   62   62   136   69%  1833   13% 
  13 Frank-Walter 1.08            2068   62   62   136   69%  1827   11% 
  14 Sharper 0.17                 2061   63   63   136   68%  1834    7% 
  15 Smallpotato 0.6.1            2058   63   63   136   68%  1834    8% 
  16 PoorLittlePinkus rev1661571  2051   62   62   136   69%  1827   14% 
  17 Faile 1.4                    2035   62   62   136   71%  1801   16% 
  18 Heracles 0.6.16              2029   67   67   136   72%  1756    8% 
  19 Morphy 3.22                  2026   62   62   136   66%  1828   11% 
  20 Micro-Max 4.8w               2017   62   62   136   67%  1746   14% 
  21 SamChess                     2014   61   61   136   64%  1835   13% 
  22 Laurifer 1.0                 2009   60   60   136   63%  1835   10% 
  23 Brainless 20081212           2002   64   64   136   67%  1772   11% 
  24 IACH 0.56z                   1995   68   68   137   69%  1673    6% 
  25 ColChess 8.0                 1995   62   62   136   66%  1802   12% 
  26 Gully 2.16pl1                1994   85   85    78   77%  1674   18% 
  27 Roce 0.0390                  1993   62   62   139   65%  1726   12% 
  28 Sissa 1.00                   1983   60   60   142   64%  1729   13% 
  29 EnginMax 5.11c               1982   65   65   136   66%  1772    4% 
  30 FreeChess 2.17b              1982   93   93    78   77%  1663    5% 
  31 Hopeless 0.49                1980  107  107    78   88%  1537    6% 
  32 Plywood 1.73X                1980   87   87    78   75%  1675   12% 
  33 SnailChess 4.013             1973   97   97    78   83%  1617    9% 
  34 Rival 1.18                   1954   93   93    78   74%  1663    3% 
  35 Monik 2.23                   1952   93   93    78   83%  1617   12% 
  36 Simontacchi 1.8a             1951   63   63   136   66%  1726   14% 
  37 BibiChess 0.5                1951   96   96    78   82%  1564   10% 
  38 Freyr 1.068 ja               1948   87   87    78   72%  1675    9% 
  39 Dabbaba 2.62                 1948  109  109    78   87%  1388    8% 
  40 Sierzant 0.26                1945   81   81    78   73%  1676   26% 
  41 BSC 3.7+f                    1944   86   86    78   72%  1676   10% 
  42 Smash 1.03                   1938  104  104    78   85%  1538    5% 
  43 Marvin 1.30                  1937   87   87    78   74%  1664   12% 
  44 Woodpecker 2.11.x            1937   90   90    78   73%  1664    5% 
  45 Grizzly 1.40.1b              1935   89   89    78   74%  1664    9% 
  46 Kurt 271009                  1934   79   79    78   71%  1676   24% 
  47 Enigma 1.14                  1931   95   95    78   82%  1564   10% 
  48 Etude 0.12                   1927   94   94    78   80%  1565    9% 
  49 SEE 0.6.9                    1921   87   87    78   71%  1664    9% 
  50 Reger 0.09                   1921   92   92    79   75%  1519   14% 
  51 Bubble 1.32                  1921   93   93    78   80%  1565    9% 
  52 ChessterfieldCL i5a          1918  101  101    79   85%  1482    5% 
  53 Celes 0.77c                  1915   91   91    78   79%  1618    9% 
  54 Eagle 0.75                   1913   91   91    78   80%  1565   12% 
  55 MatMoi v7.15.0-cct           1909   81   81    78   68%  1676   15% 
  56 Bace 0.45                    1901   99   99    78   85%  1484   10% 
  57 Sjakk 1.1.3                  1894   92   92    78   74%  1522   12% 
  58 Zzzzzz 3.51ja                1889   82   82    78   70%  1665   17% 
  59 Ranita 2.4                   1888   82   82    78   67%  1677   13% 
  60 Elephant 1.06                1876   87   87    80   75%  1572   10% 
  61 Tamerlane 0.2                1874   90   90    78   74%  1619    5% 
  62 SmallC 90-3                  1873   87   87    78   68%  1666   10% 
  63 Pooky 2.7                    1871  105  105    82   87%  1395    5% 
  64 JARS 1.75a                   1871   98   98    79   84%  1379   13% 
  65 Clueless 1.4                 1868   80   80    80   64%  1681   14% 
  66 Warrior 1.03                 1867   78   78    80   65%  1681   18% 
  67 Newrival 1.8.29              1864   87   87    80   79%  1547   10% 
  68 Brembo 0.62                  1861   91   91    80   70%  1531    8% 
  69 Vicki 0.041a                 1854   90   90    81   81%  1492   11% 
  70 Ajetac 2.73b                 1850   93   93    80   78%  1494    4% 
  71 Myrddin 0.81a2               1850   89   89    83   70%  1510   10% 
  72 Golem 0.4 r45a               1849   65   65   140   60%  1670   13% 
  73 Noonian 3.206                1841   57   57   158   64%  1674   16% 
  74 Cuckoo Chess 1.00            1840   89   89    83   69%  1505    6% 
  75 Carballo 0.3                 1839   87   87    81   80%  1493   15% 
  76 Adamant 1.7                  1837   87   87    83   69%  1526   12% 
  77 Yoda 1.30                    1836   86   86    82   70%  1507   15% 
  78 HeavyChess 0.13              1831   79   79    80   73%  1574   26% 
  79 Beaches 2.32                 1830   60   60   104   55%  1785   14% 
  80 Surprise 4.3-beta 13         1826   83   83    80   70%  1626    8% 
  81 Soldat 0.25b                 1810   83   83    80   77%  1549   16% 
  82 Embracer 1.12                1801   79   79    80   72%  1574   24% 
  83 Hoplite 2.1.1dc              1801   92   92    82   77%  1400   10% 
  84 Simon 1.2                    1797   81   81    80   69%  1626   10% 
  85 Tscp 1.81                    1790   83   83    80   68%  1575   11% 
  86 Storm 0.6                    1790   84   84    80   73%  1549    8% 
  87 Lodocase 240208              1787   83   83    80   72%  1549    6% 
  88 Pulsar 2009-9b               1785   78   78    80   66%  1627   15% 
  89 Chessrikus 1.466             1784   87   87    81   64%  1530   10% 
  90 Robin 0.983                  1780   56   56   158   58%  1676   15% 
  91 Aldebaran 0.7.0              1780   80   80    80   76%  1496   24% 
  92 ChessV 0.94                  1771   92   92    80   76%  1403    9% 
  93 DChess 1.0.2                 1770   86   86    81   73%  1494    9% 
  94 Zoidberg 0.1                 1764   77   77    80   64%  1627   19% 
  95 Dabbaba 2.46                 1763   92   92    83   64%  1497    7% 
  96 Fauce 0.41c                  1763   75   75    80   65%  1627   25% 
  97 Alibaba 1.17                 1762   88   88    81   62%  1530   11% 
  98 ArabianKnight 0.88 2t        1757   67   67   124   63%  1522   20% 
  99 Kanguruh 1.93                1754   65   65   161   77%  1390    7% 
 100 Gargamella 0.50              1749   90   90    83   71%  1425   10% 
 101 Tristram 3.36                1749   81   81    80   68%  1550    9% 
 102 Jester 0.83 DC               1746   92   92    81   73%  1393    6% 
 103 Hoichess 0.10.3 ja           1745   92   92    82   71%  1415    6% 
 104 Cecir 3.5                    1740   81   81    81   71%  1495   19% 
 105 Mint 2.3                     1731   78   78    80   69%  1551   13% 
 106 Cleo 1                       1730   88   88    81   60%  1530   10% 
 107 Milady 2.40                  1729   80   80    81   70%  1495   15% 
 108 GchessIV 0.2.0               1728   54   54   158   53%  1677   27% 
 109 PolarEngine 1.3              1728   55   55   158   52%  1677   18% 
 110 MsKcp 1.4.4 ja               1712   83   83    82   76%  1399   13% 
 111 Marginal 0.1                 1712   88   88    83   75%  1401    5% 
 112 Chenard v2010.01.04          1710   91   91    81   71%  1394    9% 
 113 Beaches 2.26                 1707   81   81    79   68%  1488   13% 
 114 ALChess 1.5b                 1703   55   55   204   65%  1475   10% 
 115 ArcBishop 2.24a              1697   73   73    82   57%  1634   18% 
 116 Simple 0048                  1690   77   77    78   48%  1682   27% 
 117 Elf 1.30                     1690   57   57   157   62%  1558   11% 
 118 RBrChess 2.20                1688   83   83    78   67%  1489    8% 
 119 Mizar 3.0                    1688   84   84    83   74%  1401   11% 
 120 Damas9                       1667   55   55   203   63%  1472    9% 
 121 Minimax                      1656   40   40   315   63%  1498   15% 
 122 Hokus Pokus 0.6.3            1653   45   45   234   57%  1581   13% 
 123 Jupiter 0.01                 1644   46   46   234   47%  1660   13% 
 124 IQ23 0.03                    1641   57   57   158   69%  1393   26% 
 125 Belzebub 0.67                1637   54   54   158   58%  1531   23% 
 126 Philemon 0.5                 1631   30   30   549   54%  1568   17% 
 127 LarsenVB 0.05                1630   60   60   159   67%  1394   11% 
 128 Excelsior 3.16               1629   46   46   234   46%  1660   12% 
 129 RataAeroespacial 0.05        1622   51   51   156   54%  1586   29% 
 130 Zotron 4.46                  1619   74   74    78   59%  1546   28% 
 131 Needle 0.531                 1606   30   30   550   52%  1568   19% 
 132 Predateur 0.1.5              1587   40   40   315   56%  1500   12% 
 133 Pentagon 1.2                 1586   83   83    78   38%  1685   14% 
 134 Vanillachess 2.6g            1584   55   55   156   49%  1587   14% 
 135 TarraschToyEngine 0.906      1583   40   40   312   44%  1633   12% 
 136 Cefap 0.72                   1569   32   32   469   45%  1599   14% 
 137 Blikskottel 0.8              1564   32   32   469   45%  1600   14% 
 138 Rocinante 1.01               1559   30   30   594   49%  1542   11% 
 139 Cilian 4.14se                1558   77   77    78   46%  1574   26% 
 140 Yawce 0.16                   1546   86   86    78   37%  1674    4% 
 141 Minimardi 1.3                1543   35   35   394   50%  1526   14% 
 142 Ozwald 0.43                  1534   44   44   283   52%  1472   14% 
 143 Exacto 0.d                   1533   48   48   234   37%  1663   13% 
 144 RBrChess 2.16                1528   73   73   131   45%  1517    7% 
 145 Piranha 0.5                  1528   33   33   471   46%  1551    7% 
 146 Gedeone 1620                 1516   28   28   671   44%  1563   14% 
 147 Goyaz 0.0.0.7                1512   41   41   312   40%  1607   12% 
 148 StAndersen 1.31c rev2ja      1506   86   86    80   33%  1677   10% 
 149 DimitriWBE 2.01              1501   45   45   238   41%  1581   13% 
 150 Roque 1.1                    1491   36   36   394   44%  1529   12% 
 151 RBrChess 2.19                1487   80   80    80   56%  1394   11% 
 152 Skaki 1.2.3                  1483   77   77    84   38%  1609    7% 
 153 Nero 6.1                     1475   53   53   160   38%  1584   19% 
 154 Frittle 0.5                  1473   34   34   441   44%  1507   23% 
 155 Sinapse 1.0                  1460   83   83    82   28%  1672   22% 
 156 Murderhole 1.0.10            1459   47   47   242   35%  1611    8% 
 157 Rainman 0.75                 1456   86   86    84   31%  1653    7% 
 158 Lovelace 1.0r1               1445   79   79    88   29%  1643   19% 
 159 GFC v2                       1444   83   83    88   51%  1398   13% 
 160 CM Josh Age 8                1437   59   59   168   31%  1639    7% 
 161 Numpty 0.6pr                 1432   60   60   100   54%  1404   23% 
 162 SdBC 0.4.14.0                1432   39   39   323   41%  1503   16% 
 163 Joanna 2002 1.04JA           1423   52   52   166   33%  1578   25% 
 164 JChess 1.0                   1420   36   36   403   42%  1481   14% 
 165 Stan's chess 1.42            1420   62   62   166   27%  1665    8% 
 166 KillerQueen 2.0b3            1415   61   61   166   25%  1665   14% 
 167 MinichessAI 1.19             1402   59   59   164   27%  1640   10% 
 168 Eden 0.013                   1390   47   47   290   41%  1476    6% 
 169 SharpChess2 2.52             1388  119  119    39   42%  1447    3% 
 170 RedQueen 0.2 ja              1369   78   78    80   44%  1397   19% 
 171 RedQueen 0.4 ja              1358   83   83    84   35%  1487    8% 
 172 SharpChess 0.06              1355   94   94    84   22%  1666    8% 
 173 Trex 1.9                     1336   42   42   366   34%  1497   11% 
 174 Avichess 0.9                 1302   63   63   102   38%  1395   12% 
 175 ChessCraft 0.96              1301   63   63   161   27%  1535    9% 
 176 Mystery 2.1                  1299   59   59   162   21%  1585   20% 
 177 Joana_DC no book             1291   99   99    85   32%  1513    8% 
 178 Cheoss 0.649                 1291  165  165    26   31%  1543    8% 
 179 Numpty 0.5pr                 1281  102  102    86   33%  1502    7% 
 180 Tikov 0.6.3                  1254   92   92    82   27%  1494    6% 
 181 Marquis 1.6                  1227   63   63   163   29%  1448   11% 
 182 Qutechess 1.01t rev3 ja      1222   68   68   119   65%  1075   19% 
 183 Hanzo The Razor 1.1.1.1      1209   61   61   159   33%  1398   31% 
 184 DarkFusch 0.09               1208   53   53   235   38%  1356   13% 
 185 Fimbulwinter 5.02            1206   51   51   280   42%  1325    6% 
 186 Pierre 1.7 ja                1199   61   61   158   53%  1165    8% 
 187 Gringo 1.49b                 1174   66   66   156   46%  1254    9% 
 188 Kcchess pre-alpha2 rev 1.13  1168   51   51   234   33%  1373   27% 
 189 Kace 0.82 ja                 1161   63   63   156   53%  1166   12% 
 190 Raffaela 0.14                1161   67   67   156   43%  1310   13% 
 191 Nanook 0.17                  1118   49   49   281   37%  1324   21% 
 192 Xadreco 5.7                  1114   60   60   200   41%  1293    9% 
 193 Strategicdeep 1.25           1099   69   69   156   37%  1282    3% 
 194 Giuchess 1.0b2dc             1096   50   50   238   38%  1253   16% 
 195 Delfi 1000 ELO               1080   53   53   237   37%  1248    8% 
 196 Butterfly 0.1.7_alpha        1074   65   65   156   36%  1312   20% 
 197 Dreamer 0.2.0                1065   52   52   236   37%  1248   14% 
 198 Mfchess 1.3                  1053   61   61   159   39%  1171   14% 
 199 Dika 0.4209                  1050   57   57   234   27%  1358   15% 
 200 Luzhin 0.1                   1021   64   64   156   33%  1245   17% 
 201 Ochess rev2 ja               1019   54   54   236   30%  1281    9% 
 202 Bigbook 3.1                   995   57   57   235   26%  1341    9% 
 203 Youk 1.05                     967   59   59   201   31%  1292   12% 
 204 Belofte 0.2.8                 911   58   58   235   21%  1344   14% 
 205 Pyotr Am 0.6                  903   55   55   237   22%  1284   16% 
 206 Dendron 0.42b ja              884   70   70   156   24%  1317   17% 
 207 Geko 0.43                     876   61   61   202   25%  1294   11% 
 208 Sachy 0.2.01                  851   61   61   200   22%  1298   15% 
 209 Neg 0.3d                      834   63   63   200   22%  1302   12% 
 210 Cheops 1.1                    820   67   67   235   16%  1346    3% 
 211 Prechess 0.7.8                811   71   71   158   20%  1240   10% 
 212 Microchess1976                801   71   71   118   26%  1089   18% 
 213 Tri-OS                        784   71   71   157   18%  1224   11% 
 214 Omar 3.1                      717   73   73   158   15%  1177   11% 
 215 Ram 2.0                       716   74   74   234    9%  1446    9% 
 216 Ace v0.1                      674   70   70   200   13%  1305   13% 
 217 Neurone I                     667   87   87   156   12%  1316    5% 
 218 Cpp1                          629   79   79   156   12%  1246   12% 
 219 Brutus RND                    562   80   80   237    8%  1258    3% 
 220 NSVChess 0.14                 540   99   99   121   11%  1152    3% 
 221 Deep Duke 1.00ja              510  104  104   101   10%  1059    5% 
 222 Pos-1.20                      449  100  100   200    5%  1309    3% 
Regards,
Carlos

PS: Bill, if you wish, I can run a 100 games gauntlets for your engines. Just let me know.
200+ engines! Outstanding! I don't think I will be able to get to all of those
engines, even when I take into account 2 or 3 dozen of those engines refuse
to run on my computers.

It is great to have multiple rating lists, due to the fact that no one has
enough resources to test all engines under multiple conditions. Every list
has its limitations, but taken as a whole, a person can determine a lot
about each engine. Your list helps fill in the region where less attention is
given. Thanks again Carlos.
Carlos777
Posts: 1729
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2009 6:09 pm

Re: Battle of the Forgotten: Bottom 40 engines tournament

Post by Carlos777 »

Adam Hair wrote: 200+ engines! Outstanding! I don't think I will be able to get to all of those
engines, even when I take into account 2 or 3 dozen of those engines refuse
to run on my computers.

It is great to have multiple rating lists, due to the fact that no one has
enough resources to test all engines under multiple conditions. Every list
has its limitations, but taken as a whole, a person can determine a lot
about each engine. Your list helps fill in the region where less attention is
given. Thanks again Carlos.
Hi Adam,

Now that I look at it, I never thought to test that many engines in the first place. :D My first intention was to test 1700 ELO engines or lower, but then by ignorance I added some >2000 ELO engines (there was not enough info about some engines, meaning no ELO approximation,) then to give it a more accurate rating, I started testing some >1700 up to 2000 ELO engines and few >2000.
Now, I'd like to complete a 100 games for each engine at least, for those under that mark.
I think the info is useful, for some people who want to try these engines. Although, they should realize that under these conditions, some engines lost on time frequently. I am not sure if at longer time controls, with faster machines they still lose on time. Also, some engines are not well adjusted to incremental time controls.

Thanks for your kind words and looking forward to your next updated rating list.

Best regards,
Carlos