Stockfish 4 v Houdini 3 at long time control

[jundery]

 
               I do not remember another match that I have run where Houdini was this far behind.

Regarding general qestions as to if Houdini 3 has now been overtaken in elo, I would now like to know if it is only better than houdini because it was tuned specifically vs houdini, or if it really is, besides that.

Stockfish is tuned to beat previous versions of itself see http://tests.stockfishchess.org/tests for the self testing that is used to decide if a change makes it into Stockfish.

[Carlos Ylich]

Great Work Pal. Congratulations!

[Tomcass]

This is an excellent test, Pal. Thanks for your great work.

Regards,

Tom.

[PawnStormZ]

 
                   Thanks Carlos.  Glad that you are enjoying the match.
 
 

[PawnStormZ]

 
                   Thanks Tom.  I guess from other posts that I have read around the forum, these results so far are not that much of a surprise.  It seems that SF has equaled or surpassed Houdini even at the long games.
 
 

[PawnStormZ]

   
                   People always say that 50 short-time games do not prove anything, so I guess 50 long ones do not mean a lot either.  But still, Houdini has never been this far down in a match of mine (at any time-control) so something is different here!
 
                   Stockfish must be much better than it was is the only thing that I can think of, and the results that others are getting confirm this.
 
                   I was planning to go to 100 (or even 200) unless people think that it is already proven by 50 and there is no point.  Of course, maybe the games themselves are interesting even if the match result is decided.
 

[M ANSARI]

Interesting match! It really seems that Houdini is simply getting out searched! I am still not sure if SF has a better evaluation than Houdini 3, but it certainly seems that it is searching the important moves deeper and faster! This probably means that SF will be gaining quite a few more ELO's very quickly once the evaluation is improved.

[PawnStormZ]

 
                                       Standings after game 52
 
                                 Stockfish 4    31.0    + 17  = 28    - 7
                                 Houdini 3      21.0      + 7  = 28  - 17
 
[pgn]
[Event ""]
[Site "ChessPalace"]
[Date "2013.09.09"]
[Round "24.1"]
[White "Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2"]
[Black "Houdini 3 x64"]
[Result "1-0"]
[Time "7:12:44 PM"]
[TimeControl "40/7200:20/3600:1800+10"]
[PlyCount "235"]
[Number "47"]
[Termination "checkmate"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]
[Variant "normal"]


1.e4 { Eval = 0, Depth = 1, mt = 00:00 } c6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
2.d4 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } d5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 3.e5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Bf5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 4.Nf3 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
e6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 5.Be2 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Nd7 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 6.c3 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
h6 { ev=-1,d=26,mt = 04:38 } 7.O-O { ev=44,d=26,mt = 02:55 }
Ne7 { ev=-5,d=24,mt = 03:17 } 8.Nbd2 { ev=42,d=29,mt = 04:46 }
Qc7 { ev=-4,d=23,mt = 05:53 } 9.Re1 { ev=44,d=28,mt = 02:23 }
Bh7 { ev=-2,d=23,mt = 03:55 } 10.b3 { ev=38,d=28,mt = 04:58 }
O-O-O { ev=-7,d=25,mt = 03:33 } 11.b4 { ev=52,d=29,mt = 02:35 }
Kb8 { ev=-17,d=25,mt = 11:54 } 12.Nb3 { ev=44,d=29,mt = 02:34 }
g5 { ev=-15,d=25,mt = 02:42 } 13.a4 { ev=58,d=28,mt = 02:43 }
g4 { ev=-18,d=24,mt = 02:54 } 14.Nh4 { ev=78,d=28,mt = 02:38 }
h5 { ev=-20,d=25,mt = 02:16 } 15.Bg5 { ev=62,d=30,mt = 03:43 }
Re8 { ev=-27,d=26,mt = 04:24 } 16.a5 { ev=56,d=28,mt = 02:59 }
a6 { ev=-33,d=26,mt = 03:15 } 17.Qd2 { ev=60,d=31,mt = 04:10 }
Rg8 { ev=-30,d=25,mt = 03:32 } 18.f4 { ev=72,d=27,mt = 05:39 }
Rg7 { ev=-35,d=25,mt = 02:46 } 19.Nc5 { ev=96,d=34,mt = 03:44 }
Nc8 { ev=-57,d=25,mt = 03:22 } 20.f5 { ev=96,d=33,mt = 03:10 }
Nxc5 { ev=-63,d=25,mt = 05:02 } 21.bxc5 { ev=105,d=35,mt = 03:59 }
Na7 { ev=-61,d=26,mt = 02:45 } 22.Bd3 { ev=96,d=32,mt = 03:24 }
Rg8 { ev=-60,d=26,mt = 02:29 } 23.Bf6 { ev=96,d=37,mt = 03:11 }
Nb5 { ev=-62,d=27,mt = 02:53 } 24.g3 { ev=96,d=38,mt = 03:31 }
Rc8 { ev=-65,d=27,mt = 04:40 } 25.Rec1 { ev=115,d=33,mt = 05:50 }
Qd7 { ev=-60,d=28,mt = 10:05 } 26.Rf1 { ev=103,d=33,mt = 04:52 }
Rc7 { ev=-97,d=26,mt = 08:52 } 27.Bg5 { ev=133,d=33,mt = 02:37 }
Rc8 { ev=-65,d=22,mt = 03:14 } 28.Rf2 { ev=139,d=33,mt = 04:30 }
Qc7 { ev=-91,d=24,mt = 01:55 } 29.Be3 { ev=125,d=32,mt = 02:15 }
Re8 { ev=-56,d=24,mt = 01:17 } 30.Re1 { ev=115,d=31,mt = 02:48 }
Ka8 { ev=-68,d=24,mt = 02:23 } 31.Rd1 { ev=103,d=30,mt = 02:23 }
Ka7 { ev=-60,d=24,mt = 01:42 } 32.Rb1 { ev=103,d=30,mt = 03:14 }
Ka8 { ev=-45,d=24,mt = 01:56 } 33.Rc1 { ev=119,d=31,mt = 03:49 }
Ka7 { ev=-58,d=24,mt = 03:33 } 34.Rd1 { ev=117,d=31,mt = 02:32 }
Ka8 { ev=-45,d=24,mt = 02:05 } 35.Re1 { ev=103,d=31,mt = 07:04 }
Ka7 { ev=-49,d=23,mt = 00:49 } 36.Rc1 { ev=117,d=30,mt = 06:15 }
Kb8 { ev=-76,d=24,mt = 01:52 } 37.Ra1 { ev=103,d=29,mt = 01:26 }
Ka8 { ev=-73,d=24,mt = 00:50 } 38.Bg5 { ev=145,d=30,mt = 01:47 }
Rb8 { ev=-78,d=24,mt = 01:10 } 39.Bh6 { ev=137,d=32,mt = 01:57 }
Rh8 { ev=-87,d=26,mt = 01:12 } 40.Bxf8 { ev=151,d=33,mt = 02:11 }
Rbxf8 { ev=-82,d=26,mt = 00:36 } 41.Raf1 { ev=151,d=35,mt = 02:59 }
Rd8 { ev=-128,d=26,mt = 02:46 } 42.Bxb5 { ev=137,d=35,mt = 04:38 }
cxb5 { ev=-83,d=29,mt = 03:51 } 43.fxe6 { ev=133,d=34,mt = 02:50 }
fxe6 { ev=-81,d=28,mt = 00:00 } 44.Rf7 { ev=141,d=35,mt = 03:56 }
Qxa5 { ev=-82,d=28,mt = 02:40 } 45.Qb2 { ev=115,d=32,mt = 02:49 }
Qa4 { ev=-71,d=28,mt = 13:23 } 46.Ng2 { ev=129,d=32,mt = 03:15 }
Bd3 { ev=-49,d=28,mt = 02:40 } 47.Ra1 { ev=92,d=34,mt = 05:29 }
Qc2 { ev=-49,d=26,mt = 00:00 } 48.Qxc2 { ev=74,d=35,mt = 08:41 }
Bxc2 { ev=-43,d=25,mt = 00:18 } 49.c6 { ev=98,d=34,mt = 03:16 }
Rb8 { ev=-30,d=27,mt = 03:47 } 50.Nf4 { ev=125,d=33,mt = 09:22 }
Bf5 { ev=-24,d=26,mt = 03:11 } 51.Rxf5 { ev=94,d=30,mt = 01:59 }
exf5 { ev=-36,d=25,mt = 00:35 } 52.c7 { ev=88,d=31,mt = 02:53 }
Rbe8 { ev=-37,d=28,mt = 02:13 } 53.Nxd5 { ev=88,d=30,mt = 01:17 }
Ka7 { ev=-49,d=28,mt = 05:37 } 54.Rb1 { ev=88,d=30,mt = 01:15 }
Re6 { ev=-25,d=27,mt = 04:54 } 55.Nf4 { ev=96,d=31,mt = 02:54 }
Ree8 { ev=-49,d=28,mt = 04:50 } 56.d5 { ev=64,d=30,mt = 00:45 }
Rxe5 { ev=-43,d=28,mt = 02:59 } 57.d6 { ev=36,d=30,mt = 01:08 }
Rc5 { ev=-63,d=27,mt = 02:09 } 58.Re1 { ev=187,d=28,mt = 00:53 }
Rc8 { ev=-52,d=27,mt = 01:33 } 59.Kf2 { ev=195,d=28,mt = 00:24 }
a5 { ev=-63,d=26,mt = 01:41 } 60.Rd1 { ev=167,d=29,mt = 00:18 }
R5xc7 { ev=-63,d=25,mt = 00:01 } 61.dxc7 { ev=163,d=29,mt = 00:32 }
Rxc7 { ev=-44,d=24,mt = 00:39 } 62.Nd5 { ev=191,d=31,mt = 01:02 }
Rc5 { ev=-71,d=28,mt = 05:05 } 63.Ke3 { ev=183,d=32,mt = 03:27 }
a4 { ev=-77,d=26,mt = 00:32 } 64.Kd4 { ev=232,d=33,mt = 01:51 }
Rc4+ { ev=-66,d=28,mt = 00:31 } 65.Kd3 { ev=210,d=34,mt = 01:06 }
Rc5 { ev=-70,d=26,mt = 00:37 } 66.Ne3 { ev=226,d=35,mt = 01:19 }
h4 { ev=-131,d=24,mt = 00:39 } 67.Rf1 { ev=284,d=30,mt = 01:12 }
hxg3 { ev=-125,d=25,mt = 00:32 } 68.hxg3 { ev=307,d=32,mt = 02:06 }
Rc8 { ev=-154,d=25,mt = 00:37 } 69.Rxf5 { ev=321,d=30,mt = 00:42 }
Kb6 { ev=-202,d=26,mt = 02:26 } 70.Nc2 { ev=337,d=31,mt = 00:57 }
Rc5 { ev=-226,d=24,mt = 00:35 } 71.Rf6+ { ev=353,d=31,mt = 01:04 }
Ka5 { ev=-228,d=26,mt = 00:56 } 72.Rf8 { ev=375,d=31,mt = 00:39 }
Rg5 { ev=-246,d=21,mt = 01:25 } 73.Ra8+ { ev=391,d=31,mt = 01:00 }
Kb6 { ev=-246,d=20,mt = 00:00 } 74.Nd4 { ev=438,d=30,mt = 01:47 }
Rh5 { ev=-277,d=25,mt = 03:04 } 75.Rg8 { ev=438,d=31,mt = 00:11 }
Ka7 { ev=-288,d=24,mt = 00:27 } 76.Rxg4 { ev=438,d=33,mt = 00:34 }
Rc5 { ev=-289,d=24,mt = 00:22 } 77.Rf4 { ev=507,d=32,mt = 01:12 }
Rg5 { ev=-330,d=24,mt = 00:37 } 78.g4 { ev=515,d=32,mt = 00:30 }
Kb6 { ev=-340,d=26,mt = 00:39 } 79.Rf6+ { ev=523,d=35,mt = 00:33 }
Ka5 { ev=-371,d=27,mt = 00:41 } 80.Rf5 { ev=551,d=36,mt = 00:20 }
Rxg4 { ev=-409,d=26,mt = 00:21 } 81.Rxb5+ { ev=646,d=35,mt = 00:38 }
Ka6 { ev=-409,d=25,mt = 00:00 } 82.Kc4 { ev=644,d=36,mt = 00:29 }
Ka7 { ev=-431,d=29,mt = 00:23 } 83.Ra5+ { ev=832,d=37,mt = 01:29 }
Kb8 { ev=-450,d=29,mt = 00:33 } 84.Rxa4 { ev=906,d=38,mt = 00:41 }
Kc7 { ev=-472,d=28,mt = 00:23 } 85.Ra2 { ev=945,d=39,mt = 00:45 }
Kb6 { ev=-472,d=30,mt = 00:20 } 86.Rf2 { ev=1349,d=38,mt = 00:38 }
Ka6 { ev=-481,d=29,mt = 00:20 } 87.Kb4 { ev=1307,d=34,mt = 00:09 }
b6 { ev=-497,d=29,mt = 00:20 } 88.Rf7 { ev=1834,d=37,mt = 00:07 }
Re4 { ev=-549,d=28,mt = 00:19 } 89.Rd7 { ev=8292,d=36,mt = 00:09 }
Re1 { ev=-631,d=30,mt = 00:20 } 90.Nc6 { ev=8292,d=40,mt = 00:12 }
Re4+ { ev=-752,d=26,mt = 00:07 } 91.Kb3 { ev=8695,d=40,mt = 00:10 }
b5 { ev=-760,d=31,mt = 00:20 } 92.Nd4 { ev=8695,d=40,mt = 00:34 }
Kb6 { ev=-2100,d=37,mt = 01:57 } 93.Kb4 { ev=8700,d=39,mt = 01:12 }
Rh4 { ev=-1732,d=35,mt = 00:00 } 94.Rd6+ { ev=9983,d=40,mt = 00:28 }
Kb7 { ev=-1732,d=26,mt = 00:06 } 95.Kxb5 { ev=14644,d=37,mt = 02:47 }
Rh3 { ev=-1724,d=25,mt = 00:03 } 96.c4 { ev=13595,d=29,mt = 01:38 }
Rh1 { ev=-1741,d=24,mt = 00:00 } 97.c5 { ev=13089,d=29,mt = 00:56 }
Rb1+ { ev=-1735,d=23,mt = 00:06 } 98.Kc4 { ev=30947,d=23,mt = 00:08 }
Rf1 { ev=-31039,d=29,mt = 00:41 } 99.c6+ { ev=30955,d=22,mt = 00:03 }
Ka6 { ev=-31035,d=32,mt = 00:22 } 100.Rd7 { ev=30957,d=25,mt = 00:16 }
Rg1 { ev=-31031,d=33,mt = 01:57 } 101.Rb7 { ev=30959,d=24,mt = 00:05 }
Rg6 { ev=-31029,d=34,mt = 00:15 } 102.Kc5 { ev=30953,d=25,mt = 00:10 }
Rg5+ { ev=-31027,d=35,mt = 00:19 } 103.Kd6 { ev=30955,d=25,mt = 00:15 }
Rg6+ { ev=-31025,d=34,mt = 00:23 } 104.Ne6 { ev=30957,d=24,mt = 00:30 }
Rg1 { ev=-31023,d=33,mt = 00:19 } 105.Nc5+ { ev=30971,d=23,mt = 00:11 }
Ka5 { ev=-635,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 106.c7 { ev=30973,d=21,mt = 00:04 }
Rd1+ { ev=-918,d=9,mt = 00:00 } 107.Ke7 { ev=30975,d=25,mt = 00:12 }
Re1+ { ev=-918,d=9,mt = 00:00 } 108.Ne6 { ev=30979,d=26,mt = 00:10 }
Rc1 { ev=-918,d=9,mt = 00:00 } 109.Kd6 { ev=30981,d=25,mt = 00:07 }
Ka6 { ev=-31017,d=28,mt = 00:01 } 110.Rb1 { ev=30983,d=28,mt = 00:09 }
Rxb1 { ev=-31015,d=26,mt = 00:00 } 111.c8=Q+ { ev=30985,d=28,mt = 00:03 }
Kb5 { ev=-31013,d=24,mt = 00:00 } 112.Nd4+ { ev=30987,d=33,mt = 00:10 }
Ka5 { ev=-31011,d=22,mt = 00:00 } 113.Qc5+ { ev=30989,d=52,mt = 00:08 }
Ka4 { ev=-31009,d=20,mt = 00:00 } 114.Qc2+ { ev=30991,d=90,mt = 00:24 }
Kb4 { ev=-31007,d=18,mt = 00:00 } 115.Kd5 { ev=30993,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
Ka5 { ev=-31005,d=16,mt = 00:00 } 116.Qxb1 { ev=30995,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
Ka6 { ev=-31003,d=14,mt = 00:00 } 117.Qb8 { ev=30997,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
Ka5 { ev=-31001,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 118.Qb5+ { ev=30999,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
1-0


[Event ""]
[Site "ChessPalace"]
[Date "2013.09.10"]
[Round "24.2"]
[White "Houdini 3 x64"]
[Black "Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2"]
[Result "1-0"]
[Time "6:02:39 AM"]
[TimeControl "40/7200:20/3600:1800+10"]
[PlyCount "147"]
[Number "48"]
[Termination "checkmate"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]
[Variant "normal"]


1.e4 { Eval = 0, Depth = 1, mt = 00:00 } c6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
2.d4 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } d5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 3.e5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Bf5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 4.Nf3 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
e6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 5.Be2 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Nd7 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 6.c3 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Ne7 { ev=-38,d=27,mt = 04:01 } 7.O-O { ev=21,d=24,mt = 05:28 }
Ng6 { ev=-38,d=27,mt = 02:32 } 8.Ne1 { ev=39,d=24,mt = 04:52 }
c5 { ev=-40,d=28,mt = 03:34 } 9.g4 { ev=37,d=25,mt = 02:35 }
Bxb1 { ev=-52,d=28,mt = 02:43 } 10.Rxb1 { ev=37,d=23,mt = 00:00 }
Ne7 { ev=-58,d=28,mt = 03:47 } 11.dxc5 { ev=38,d=24,mt = 09:00 }
Nxc5 { ev=-28,d=28,mt = 03:17 } 12.Be3 { ev=28,d=26,mt = 04:04 }
Nd7 { ev=-30,d=28,mt = 04:15 } 13.Nd3 { ev=30,d=25,mt = 03:25 }
Nc6 { ev=-22,d=27,mt = 03:47 } 14.f4 { ev=30,d=23,mt = 03:08 }
Qc7 { ev=-32,d=27,mt = 03:09 } 15.Qe1 { ev=33,d=23,mt = 04:36 }
Be7 { ev=-14,d=26,mt = 03:34 } 16.Rd1 { ev=30,d=23,mt = 04:47 }
Bd8 { ev=-32,d=26,mt = 05:14 } 17.Rf3 { ev=36,d=22,mt = 04:37 }
Be7 { ev=-44,d=27,mt = 08:29 } 18.Qf2 { ev=44,d=22,mt = 02:43 }
Qa5 { ev=-60,d=27,mt = 09:20 } 19.a3 { ev=58,d=23,mt = 02:29 }
Nb6 { ev=-70,d=27,mt = 09:19 } 20.f5 { ev=70,d=24,mt = 02:41 }
exf5 { ev=-123,d=26,mt = 03:47 } 21.gxf5 { ev=113,d=24,mt = 08:20 }
O-O-O { ev=-109,d=25,mt = 01:50 } 22.e6 { ev=93,d=22,mt = 04:03 }
Nc4 { ev=-111,d=26,mt = 01:52 } 23.b4 { ev=116,d=22,mt = 03:01 }
Qxa3 { ev=-151,d=26,mt = 02:32 } 24.exf7 { ev=106,d=23,mt = 03:14 }
Rhf8 { ev=-137,d=27,mt = 01:47 } 25.Nf4 { ev=103,d=23,mt = 02:13 }
Rxf7 { ev=-139,d=28,mt = 02:32 } 26.Nxd5 { ev=103,d=21,mt = 00:00 }
N4e5 { ev=-163,d=28,mt = 02:46 } 27.Rh3 { ev=93,d=23,mt = 03:16 }
Qa2 { ev=-129,d=30,mt = 03:18 } 28.Bh5 { ev=107,d=24,mt = 04:18 }
Qxf2+ { ev=-131,d=32,mt = 02:51 } 29.Bxf2 { ev=102,d=22,mt = 00:00 }
g6 { ev=-139,d=33,mt = 01:42 } 30.fxg6 { ev=83,d=26,mt = 02:35 }
hxg6 { ev=-131,d=32,mt = 02:48 } 31.Nxe7+ { ev=80,d=27,mt = 02:55 }
Nxe7 { ev=-133,d=30,mt = 01:44 } 32.Rxd8+ { ev=88,d=27,mt = 04:34 }
Kxd8 { ev=-133,d=32,mt = 00:38 } 33.Bd1 { ev=78,d=26,mt = 02:45 }
a6 { ev=-127,d=31,mt = 02:35 } 34.Bg3 { ev=78,d=27,mt = 02:38 }
Nd7 { ev=-143,d=30,mt = 02:36 } 35.Bb3 { ev=87,d=27,mt = 03:05 }
Rf6 { ev=-137,d=31,mt = 02:10 } 36.Bh4 { ev=88,d=27,mt = 03:27 }
Rf4 { ev=-129,d=34,mt = 07:11 } 37.Kg2 { ev=84,d=27,mt = 03:14 }
Nf6 { ev=-137,d=31,mt = 01:38 } 38.Bg3 { ev=83,d=28,mt = 04:07 }
Rf5 { ev=-155,d=32,mt = 02:30 } 39.Be6 { ev=77,d=28,mt = 05:42 }
Rh5 { ev=-171,d=33,mt = 02:37 } 40.Kf3 { ev=80,d=26,mt = 01:29 }
Nc6 { ev=-175,d=30,mt = 01:17 } 41.Rxh5 { ev=89,d=28,mt = 03:09 }
Nxh5 { ev=-200,d=39,mt = 02:55 } 42.Bh4+ { ev=93,d=26,mt = 02:33 }
Kc7 { ev=-206,d=40,mt = 02:45 } 43.Bb3 { ev=85,d=28,mt = 04:51 }
Ng7 { ev=-230,d=32,mt = 02:30 } 44.Kf4 { ev=166,d=26,mt = 03:01 }
Kd6 { ev=-270,d=35,mt = 02:45 } 45.Kg5 { ev=208,d=26,mt = 03:18 }
Nf5 { ev=-270,d=38,mt = 08:56 } 46.Bf2 { ev=238,d=26,mt = 03:32 }
Ne5 { ev=-317,d=39,mt = 15:32 } 47.h3 { ev=247,d=25,mt = 03:34 }
Ke7 { ev=-361,d=31,mt = 01:58 } 48.Bd5 { ev=276,d=24,mt = 00:53 }
Nd3 { ev=-474,d=35,mt = 04:47 } 49.Kxg6 { ev=404,d=23,mt = 01:20 }
Nxf2 { ev=-664,d=36,mt = 02:31 } 50.Kxf5 { ev=439,d=22,mt = 00:12 }
Nd1 { ev=-1030,d=36,mt = 02:43 } 51.c4 { ev=438,d=21,mt = 00:03 }
Ne3+ { ev=-1038,d=37,mt = 05:09 } 52.Ke5 { ev=437,d=20,mt = 00:01 }
Nd1 { ev=-1418,d=33,mt = 02:12 } 53.h4 { ev=552,d=19,mt = 00:02 }
Nf2 { ev=-5771,d=33,mt = 02:13 } 54.h5 { ev=656,d=18,mt = 00:01 }
Ng4+ { ev=-1094,d=26,mt = 00:23 } 55.Kf5 { ev=653,d=17,mt = 00:00 }
Ne3+ { ev=-2351,d=28,mt = 00:17 } 56.Kg5 { ev=865,d=16,mt = 00:00 }
b5 { ev=-13595,d=32,mt = 01:05 } 57.h6 { ev=903,d=15,mt = 00:00 }
bxc4 { ev=-8929,d=24,mt = 00:37 } 58.h7 { ev=904,d=14,mt = 00:00 }
Nxd5 { ev=-31039,d=20,mt = 00:10 } 59.h8=Q { ev=874,d=13,mt = 00:00 }
Nc7 { ev=-13590,d=28,mt = 00:17 } 60.Qc3 { ev=1002,d=12,mt = 00:00 }
Ne8 { ev=-8924,d=21,mt = 00:08 } 61.Qxc4 { ev=1002,d=11,mt = 00:00 }
Nd6 { ev=-31025,d=25,mt = 01:07 } 62.Qxa6 { ev=1002,d=10,mt = 00:00 }
Ke6 { ev=-31021,d=27,mt = 01:15 } 63.b5 { ev=1002,d=9,mt = 00:00 }
Ke5 { ev=-31021,d=27,mt = 01:08 } 64.b6 { ev=1027,d=9,mt = 00:00 }
Ne4+ { ev=-31019,d=30,mt = 00:57 } 65.Kg6 { ev=1015,d=9,mt = 00:00 }
Nc5 { ev=-31017,d=35,mt = 00:56 } 66.Qc4 { ev=30983,d=27,mt = 00:04 }
Nb7 { ev=-31015,d=48,mt = 00:59 } 67.Qc7+ { ev=30985,d=25,mt = 00:02 }
Kd4 { ev=-31013,d=71,mt = 00:55 } 68.Qxb7 { ev=30987,d=23,mt = 00:00 }
Kc5 { ev=-31011,d=100,mt = 00:04 } 69.Qc7+ { ev=30989,d=21,mt = 00:00 }
Kd4 { ev=-31009,d=100,mt = 00:00 } 70.b7 { ev=30991,d=19,mt = 00:00 }
Kd5 { ev=-31007,d=100,mt = 00:00 } 71.b8=Q { ev=30993,d=17,mt = 00:00 }
Kd4 { ev=-31005,d=100,mt = 00:00 } 72.Qb3 { ev=30995,d=15,mt = 00:00 }
Ke4 { ev=-31003,d=100,mt = 00:00 } 73.Qcc4+ { ev=30997,d=13,mt = 00:00 }
Ke5 { ev=-31001,d=100,mt = 00:00 } 74.Qg3+ { ev=30999,d=11,mt = 00:00 }
1-0


[Event ""]
[Site "ChessPalace"]
[Date "2013.09.10"]
[Round "25.1"]
[White "Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2"]
[Black "Houdini 3 x64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[Time "11:36:47 AM"]
[TimeControl "40/7200:20/3600:1800+10"]
[PlyCount "238"]
[Number "49"]
[Termination "GUI adjudication"]
[BlackType "program"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[Variant "normal"]


1.e4 { Eval = 0, Depth = 1, mt = 00:00 } c6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
2.d4 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } d5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 3.e5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Bf5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 4.Nf3 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
e6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 5.Be2 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Ne7 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 6.O-O { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
h6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 7.Nbd2 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Nd7 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 8.Nb3 { ev=50,d=29,mt = 03:35 }
Qc7 { ev=-12,d=24,mt = 04:35 } 9.Bd2 { ev=50,d=24,mt = 02:48 }
O-O-O { ev=-16,d=25,mt = 05:13 } 10.Ba5 { ev=90,d=28,mt = 03:21 }
b6 { ev=-21,d=26,mt = 05:04 } 11.Bd2 { ev=94,d=29,mt = 03:25 }
Kb7 { ev=-22,d=26,mt = 19:52 } 12.a4 { ev=92,d=30,mt = 04:32 }
a5 { ev=-20,d=25,mt = 03:11 } 13.Rc1 { ev=90,d=30,mt = 06:44 }
g5 { ev=-23,d=25,mt = 02:34 } 14.c4 { ev=84,d=30,mt = 03:55 }
dxc4 { ev=-12,d=25,mt = 04:22 } 15.Bxc4 { ev=76,d=30,mt = 11:38 }
Nd5 { ev=-16,d=24,mt = 02:53 } 16.Qe2 { ev=74,d=30,mt = 13:07 }
Be7 { ev=-13,d=22,mt = 02:22 } 17.Ne1 { ev=88,d=27,mt = 04:12 }
f6 { ev=-19,d=22,mt = 03:44 } 18.Nf3 { ev=78,d=26,mt = 02:55 }
Nb8 { ev=-8,d=23,mt = 03:03 } 19.Rfe1 { ev=70,d=27,mt = 02:33 }
Rhg8 { ev=-15,d=23,mt = 03:09 } 20.Qd1 { ev=60,d=28,mt = 04:41 }
g4 { ev=18,d=23,mt = 04:41 } 21.Nh4 { ev=54,d=28,mt = 02:22 }
Bh7 { ev=18,d=22,mt = 00:00 } 22.g3 { ev=22,d=28,mt = 08:11 }
fxe5 { ev=14,d=23,mt = 03:17 } 23.Rxe5 { ev=50,d=28,mt = 02:37 }
Bf6 { ev=14,d=22,mt = 02:32 } 24.Re2 { ev=50,d=27,mt = 01:53 }
Bxh4 { ev=13,d=22,mt = 03:02 } 25.gxh4 { ev=28,d=27,mt = 01:43 }
Bf5 { ev=13,d=24,mt = 02:46 } 26.Re5 { ev=0,d=28,mt = 02:10 }
h5 { ev=37,d=25,mt = 03:51 } 27.Bg5 { ev=0,d=30,mt = 02:29 }
Rd7 { ev=23,d=26,mt = 08:47 } 28.Qe1 { ev=0,d=30,mt = 01:53 }
Rf8 { ev=20,d=24,mt = 03:50 } 29.Nd2 { ev=0,d=31,mt = 02:46 }
Na6 { ev=6,d=25,mt = 02:01 } 30.Ne4 { ev=0,d=33,mt = 02:53 }
Nab4 { ev=-5,d=24,mt = 06:52 } 31.Bh6 { ev=0,d=33,mt = 02:46 }
Ra8 { ev=4,d=23,mt = 03:19 } 32.Bd2 { ev=0,d=31,mt = 04:33 }
Rad8 { ev=-12,d=22,mt = 01:31 } 33.Qe2 { ev=38,d=26,mt = 01:25 }
Rf7 { ev=-18,d=23,mt = 01:28 } 34.Ng3 { ev=48,d=27,mt = 01:33 }
Rdf8 { ev=-26,d=23,mt = 01:38 } 35.Bh6 { ev=54,d=28,mt = 02:06 }
Rd8 { ev=-31,d=25,mt = 02:14 } 36.Bg5 { ev=70,d=29,mt = 01:37 }
Rdf8 { ev=-31,d=25,mt = 01:10 } 37.Nxh5 { ev=58,d=30,mt = 01:42 }
Bg6 { ev=-30,d=23,mt = 01:21 } 38.Ng3 { ev=70,d=29,mt = 02:21 }
Rxf2 { ev=-30,d=24,mt = 01:21 } 39.Qxg4 { ev=44,d=29,mt = 03:33 }
Bf5 { ev=-30,d=25,mt = 01:41 } 40.Nxf5 { ev=119,d=27,mt = 01:02 }
R8xf5 { ev=-28,d=24,mt = 01:57 } 41.h5 { ev=155,d=27,mt = 03:41 }
Nc2 { ev=-27,d=20,mt = 02:15 } 42.Bxd5 { ev=86,d=30,mt = 02:57 }
cxd5 { ev=-25,d=19,mt = 00:00 } 43.h6 { ev=38,d=31,mt = 11:50 }
Ka6 { ev=-34,d=26,mt = 04:04 } 44.b3 { ev=38,d=32,mt = 04:55 }
R5f3 { ev=-38,d=26,mt = 04:32 } 45.h3 { ev=105,d=31,mt = 03:07 }
Rf8 { ev=-37,d=26,mt = 03:01 } 46.Bh4 { ev=101,d=32,mt = 02:59 }
Rd2 { ev=-47,d=27,mt = 02:31 } 47.Be1 { ev=105,d=35,mt = 03:17 }
Nxe1 { ev=-41,d=29,mt = 04:46 } 48.Rxc7 { ev=50,d=36,mt = 03:49 }
Nf3+ { ev=-34,d=28,mt = 00:00 } 49.Qxf3 { ev=50,d=37,mt = 02:28 }
Rxf3 { ev=-33,d=27,mt = 00:19 } 50.Rg5 { ev=50,d=37,mt = 03:25 }
Rxb3 { ev=-29,d=26,mt = 00:14 } 51.Rf7 { ev=66,d=38,mt = 02:09 }
Rd1+ { ev=-29,d=32,mt = 05:54 } 52.Kg2 { ev=50,d=39,mt = 01:49 }
Rd2+ { ev=-29,d=30,mt = 00:04 } 53.Rf2 { ev=0,d=42,mt = 01:59 }
Rxf2+ { ev=-31,d=30,mt = 00:37 } 54.Kxf2 { ev=0,d=43,mt = 00:35 }
Rxh3 { ev=-13,d=37,mt = 08:07 } 55.Rg6 { ev=0,d=45,mt = 01:00 }
Kb7 { ev=-20,d=38,mt = 13:52 } 56.Kg2 { ev=0,d=44,mt = 02:02 }
Rh5 { ev=-16,d=35,mt = 01:50 } 57.Rxe6 { ev=0,d=45,mt = 01:47 }
b5 { ev=-16,d=33,mt = 00:00 } 58.axb5 { ev=0,d=44,mt = 02:19 }
a4 { ev=-12,d=35,mt = 02:04 } 59.Ra6 { ev=0,d=48,mt = 02:15 }
a3 { ev=-12,d=33,mt = 00:00 } 60.Rxa3 { ev=0,d=51,mt = 01:21 }
Rxh6 { ev=-1,d=33,mt = 00:06 } 61.Ra1 { ev=0,d=60,mt = 01:07 }
Rh4 { ev=-1,d=44,mt = 00:45 } 62.Ra6 { ev=0,d=69,mt = 01:04 }
Rxd4 { ev=-1,d=43,mt = 00:45 } 63.Kf2 { ev=0,d=71,mt = 01:00 }
Rb4 { ev=-1,d=42,mt = 00:39 } 64.Ke3 { ev=0,d=76,mt = 01:04 }
Rxb5 { ev=-1,d=43,mt = 00:40 } 65.Ra3 { ev=0,d=74,mt = 01:04 }
Rb4 { ev=12,d=33,mt = 00:47 } 66.Kd2 { ev=0,d=82,mt = 00:57 }
Kc6 { ev=12,d=33,mt = 00:48 } 67.Rc3+ { ev=0,d=75,mt = 00:56 }
Kd6 { ev=32,d=37,mt = 01:25 } 68.Ra3 { ev=0,d=78,mt = 00:57 }
Rh4 { ev=32,d=36,mt = 00:40 } 69.Rb3 { ev=0,d=77,mt = 00:51 }
Rh2+ { ev=32,d=42,mt = 00:42 } 70.Kc1 { ev=0,d=69,mt = 00:51 }
Ke5 { ev=60,d=38,mt = 00:39 } 71.Ra3 { ev=0,d=70,mt = 00:48 }
Ke4 { ev=61,d=39,mt = 00:41 } 72.Kd1 { ev=0,d=78,mt = 00:48 }
Rf2 { ev=62,d=38,mt = 00:35 } 73.Rb3 { ev=0,d=66,mt = 00:48 }
d4 { ev=62,d=38,mt = 00:39 } 74.Ra3 { ev=0,d=71,mt = 00:53 }
Rb2 { ev=60,d=37,mt = 00:34 } 75.Rg3 { ev=0,d=69,mt = 00:48 }
Ke5 { ev=60,d=38,mt = 00:35 } 76.Ra3 { ev=0,d=75,mt = 00:45 }
Rg2 { ev=60,d=38,mt = 00:33 } 77.Rb3 { ev=0,d=77,mt = 00:41 }
Ke4 { ev=60,d=39,mt = 00:32 } 78.Ra3 { ev=0,d=72,mt = 00:42 }
Rf2 { ev=60,d=37,mt = 00:41 } 79.Rb3 { ev=0,d=81,mt = 00:43 }
Rh2 { ev=59,d=38,mt = 00:49 } 80.Ra3 { ev=0,d=72,mt = 00:40 }
Rg2 { ev=59,d=37,mt = 00:31 } 81.Rb3 { ev=0,d=69,mt = 00:42 }
Rg1+ { ev=59,d=37,mt = 00:31 } 82.Kc2 { ev=0,d=87,mt = 00:40 }
Re1 { ev=59,d=37,mt = 00:32 } 83.Kd2 { ev=0,d=81,mt = 00:39 }
Rh1 { ev=54,d=37,mt = 00:36 } 84.Ra3 { ev=0,d=86,mt = 00:39 }
Rg1 { ev=57,d=34,mt = 00:32 } 85.Rb3 { ev=0,d=87,mt = 00:36 }
Ra1 { ev=56,d=36,mt = 00:55 } 86.Rg3 { ev=0,d=68,mt = 00:38 }
Ra2+ { ev=51,d=36,mt = 00:38 } 87.Kd1 { ev=0,d=68,mt = 00:37 }
Kd5 { ev=47,d=37,mt = 00:33 } 88.Rb3 { ev=0,d=65,mt = 00:34 }
Kc4 { ev=45,d=36,mt = 00:35 } 89.Rf3 { ev=0,d=74,mt = 00:33 }
Kc5 { ev=47,d=35,mt = 00:29 } 90.Rb3 { ev=0,d=73,mt = 00:34 }
Rg2 { ev=41,d=36,mt = 00:30 } 91.Ra3 { ev=0,d=78,mt = 00:30 }
Rh2 { ev=32,d=35,mt = 00:33 } 92.Rb3 { ev=0,d=68,mt = 00:29 }
Kc4 { ev=32,d=36,mt = 00:32 } 93.Ra3 { ev=0,d=76,mt = 00:32 }
Rf2 { ev=20,d=35,mt = 00:26 } 94.Rg3 { ev=0,d=77,mt = 00:29 }
Rf1+ { ev=22,d=36,mt = 00:34 } 95.Kc2 { ev=0,d=66,mt = 00:28 }
Rf5 { ev=28,d=37,mt = 00:28 } 96.Ra3 { ev=0,d=77,mt = 00:27 }
Rf2+ { ev=20,d=35,mt = 00:27 } 97.Kc1 { ev=0,d=69,mt = 00:27 }
Kb4 { ev=22,d=36,mt = 00:53 } 98.Rd3 { ev=0,d=73,mt = 00:27 }
Kc5 { ev=23,d=34,mt = 00:44 } 99.Ra3 { ev=0,d=68,mt = 00:28 }
Rh2 { ev=23,d=35,mt = 00:25 } 100.Rb3 { ev=0,d=75,mt = 00:30 }
Kd5 { ev=21,d=33,mt = 00:25 } 101.Ra3 { ev=0,d=81,mt = 00:26 }
Ke5 { ev=14,d=34,mt = 00:32 } 102.Rb3 { ev=0,d=79,mt = 00:28 }
Ke4 { ev=16,d=33,mt = 00:23 } 103.Kd1 { ev=0,d=84,mt = 00:31 }
Rh1+ { ev=15,d=34,mt = 00:25 } 104.Kc2 { ev=0,d=92,mt = 00:24 }
Rh7 { ev=15,d=28,mt = 00:28 } 105.Ra3 { ev=0,d=85,mt = 00:26 }
Rf7 { ev=15,d=29,mt = 00:36 } 106.Rb3 { ev=0,d=64,mt = 00:24 }
Rc7+ { ev=10,d=32,mt = 00:23 } 107.Kd1 { ev=0,d=92,mt = 00:24 }
Ra7 { ev=7,d=32,mt = 00:36 } 108.Rg3 { ev=0,d=74,mt = 00:23 }
Kd5 { ev=10,d=31,mt = 00:22 } 109.Rb3 { ev=0,d=73,mt = 00:22 }
Kc4 { ev=4,d=31,mt = 00:22 } 110.Rf3 { ev=0,d=62,mt = 00:21 }
Ra2 { ev=1,d=31,mt = 00:23 } 111.Rg3 { ev=0,d=75,mt = 00:21 }
d3 { ev=0,d=34,mt = 00:32 } 112.Rg8 { ev=0,d=67,mt = 00:20 }
Kc3 { ev=0,d=34,mt = 00:21 } 113.Rc8+ { ev=0,d=80,mt = 00:07 }
Kd4 { ev=0,d=39,mt = 00:35 } 114.Rb8 { ev=0,d=90,mt = 00:21 }
Rg2 { ev=0,d=37,mt = 00:20 } 115.Ra8 { ev=0,d=71,mt = 00:22 }
Ke3 { ev=0,d=37,mt = 00:27 } 116.Re8+ { ev=0,d=72,mt = 00:08 }
Kf4 { ev=-1,d=37,mt = 00:21 } 117.Ra8 { ev=0,d=69,mt = 00:21 }
Rh2 { ev=-1,d=37,mt = 00:21 } 118.Rb8 { ev=0,d=68,mt = 00:19 }
Rc2 { ev=0,d=38,mt = 00:22 } 119.Ra8 { ev=0,d=64,mt = 00:19 }
Rb2 { ev=0,d=38,mt = 00:23 }
1/2-1/2


[Event ""]
[Site "ChessPalace"]
[Date "2013.09.10"]
[Round "25.2"]
[White "Houdini 3 x64"]
[Black "Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2"]
[Result "0-1"]
[Time "6:40:12 PM"]
[TimeControl "40/7200:20/3600:1800+10"]
[PlyCount "154"]
[Number "50"]
[Termination "checkmate"]
[BlackType "program"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[Variant "normal"]


1.e4 { Eval = 0, Depth = 1, mt = 00:00 } c6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
2.d4 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } d5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 3.e5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Bf5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 4.Nf3 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
e6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 5.Be2 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Ne7 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 6.O-O { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
h6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 7.Nbd2 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Nd7 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 8.Nb3 { ev=24,d=25,mt = 21:49 }
Bg6 { ev=-40,d=27,mt = 02:34 } 9.Nh4 { ev=24,d=26,mt = 02:20 }
Bh7 { ev=-40,d=29,mt = 02:58 } 10.Be3 { ev=24,d=25,mt = 02:53 }
Qc7 { ev=-36,d=29,mt = 02:49 } 11.f4 { ev=29,d=25,mt = 02:25 }
O-O-O { ev=-44,d=28,mt = 03:28 } 12.a4 { ev=21,d=24,mt = 03:35 }
c5 { ev=-26,d=29,mt = 03:11 } 13.a5 { ev=20,d=22,mt = 02:27 }
c4 { ev=16,d=29,mt = 02:49 } 14.Nc1 { ev=5,d=25,mt = 02:40 }
Nc6 { ev=12,d=29,mt = 04:09 } 15.a6 { ev=15,d=24,mt = 04:38 }
Be7 { ev=20,d=29,mt = 05:58 } 16.Nf3 { ev=-2,d=24,mt = 07:01 }
b5 { ev=28,d=29,mt = 03:45 } 17.c3 { ev=0,d=23,mt = 08:09 }
f6 { ev=28,d=29,mt = 08:39 } 18.Qe1 { ev=-6,d=22,mt = 03:21 }
g5 { ev=86,d=28,mt = 06:04 } 19.exf6 { ev=-46,d=21,mt = 02:57 }
Nxf6 { ev=92,d=30,mt = 07:18 } 20.Ne5 { ev=-39,d=24,mt = 05:10 }
Rdf8 { ev=90,d=29,mt = 02:18 } 21.Na2 { ev=-41,d=23,mt = 02:00 }
Be4 { ev=96,d=29,mt = 02:49 } 22.Qd2 { ev=-38,d=24,mt = 01:58 }
Bd6 { ev=109,d=30,mt = 03:08 } 23.Nb4 { ev=-38,d=24,mt = 02:21 }
Nxb4 { ev=117,d=30,mt = 09:39 } 24.cxb4 { ev=-37,d=22,mt = 00:00 }
Qb6 { ev=103,d=29,mt = 02:00 } 25.g3 { ev=-44,d=22,mt = 05:33 }
Bf5 { ev=115,d=28,mt = 04:28 } 26.b3 { ev=-59,d=23,mt = 04:59 }
Ne4 { ev=125,d=25,mt = 03:04 } 27.Qc1 { ev=-59,d=21,mt = 00:00 }
Bh3 { ev=113,d=26,mt = 02:50 } 28.bxc4 { ev=-74,d=22,mt = 03:39 }
bxc4 { ev=131,d=26,mt = 01:27 } 29.Bxc4 { ev=-52,d=23,mt = 05:05 }
dxc4 { ev=123,d=29,mt = 02:12 } 30.Qxc4+ { ev=-35,d=22,mt = 01:49 }
Bc7 { ev=121,d=29,mt = 03:52 } 31.Qd3 { ev=-29,d=23,mt = 04:05 }
gxf4 { ev=133,d=29,mt = 02:29 } 32.Rxf4 { ev=-60,d=24,mt = 04:03 }
Ng5 { ev=139,d=30,mt = 02:42 } 33.Qc4 { ev=-62,d=23,mt = 02:07 }
Rxf4 { ev=189,d=32,mt = 02:27 } 34.Bxf4 { ev=-58,d=21,mt = 00:00 }
Bf5 { ev=187,d=31,mt = 02:23 } 35.Bxg5 { ev=-91,d=26,mt = 03:57 }
hxg5 { ev=230,d=31,mt = 00:57 } 36.Re1 { ev=-95,d=26,mt = 02:51 }
Rd8 { ev=206,d=32,mt = 03:44 } 37.Nc6 { ev=-95,d=24,mt = 00:00 }
Rd6 { ev=179,d=32,mt = 04:17 } 38.b5 { ev=-88,d=25,mt = 02:17 }
Rxc6 { ev=309,d=32,mt = 02:18 } 39.bxc6 { ev=-172,d=25,mt = 02:42 }
Bh3 { ev=309,d=32,mt = 02:09 } 40.Qc5 { ev=-165,d=25,mt = 00:45 }
Qb2 { ev=313,d=32,mt = 01:54 } 41.Qf8+ { ev=-165,d=24,mt = 00:00 }
Bd8 { ev=313,d=12,mt = 00:00 } 42.Qf2 { ev=-195,d=27,mt = 03:46 }
Qc3 { ev=339,d=33,mt = 10:34 } 43.c7 { ev=-195,d=27,mt = 03:15 }
Kxc7 { ev=319,d=34,mt = 05:54 } 44.Rd1 { ev=-193,d=28,mt = 15:28 }
Bf5 { ev=319,d=33,mt = 02:18 } 45.Kg2 { ev=-208,d=24,mt = 01:52 }
Kd7 { ev=347,d=32,mt = 02:56 } 46.h3 { ev=-249,d=25,mt = 02:41 }
Bc7 { ev=371,d=32,mt = 03:31 } 47.Re1 { ev=-241,d=25,mt = 01:48 }
Qd3 { ev=393,d=31,mt = 05:51 } 48.Kh2 { ev=-263,d=25,mt = 03:37 }
Bb6 { ev=414,d=31,mt = 02:14 } 49.Qe3 { ev=-257,d=26,mt = 01:45 }
Qxe3 { ev=490,d=35,mt = 02:24 } 50.Rxe3 { ev=-233,d=25,mt = 00:00 }
Bxd4 { ev=505,d=34,mt = 02:18 } 51.Ra3 { ev=-248,d=27,mt = 03:41 }
e5 { ev=561,d=36,mt = 02:03 } 52.Kg2 { ev=-313,d=29,mt = 06:24 }
Ke6 { ev=676,d=37,mt = 02:57 } 53.h4 { ev=-314,d=29,mt = 04:14 }
Bg4 { ev=824,d=31,mt = 01:05 } 54.Rb3 { ev=-337,d=26,mt = 01:15 }
e4 { ev=1915,d=31,mt = 04:11 } 55.hxg5 { ev=-955,d=27,mt = 02:03 }
e3 { ev=2042,d=32,mt = 00:34 } 56.g6 { ev=-1204,d=28,mt = 01:30 }
Kf6 { ev=2365,d=33,mt = 02:10 } 57.Rb4 { ev=-1226,d=30,mt = 02:20 }
e2 { ev=7708,d=32,mt = 00:48 } 58.Rxd4 { ev=-1334,d=29,mt = 01:41 }
e1=Q { ev=8899,d=33,mt = 01:04 } 59.Rxg4 { ev=-1540,d=25,mt = 00:27 }
Qe2+ { ev=9816,d=35,mt = 04:59 } 60.Kh3 { ev=-2288,d=32,mt = 02:12 }
Qd1 { ev=14864,d=34,mt = 04:50 } 61.Rf4+ { ev=-2024,d=24,mt = 00:45 }
Kxg6 { ev=8914,d=29,mt = 00:23 } 62.Rg4+ { ev=-2023,d=23,mt = 00:00 }
Kh6 { ev=13585,d=31,mt = 09:11 } 63.Rb4 { ev=-2023,d=22,mt = 00:02 }
Qd7+ { ev=13585,d=28,mt = 06:59 } 64.g4 { ev=-1989,d=21,mt = 00:04 }
Kg5 { ev=30951,d=25,mt = 00:14 } 65.Rb2 { ev=-1994,d=20,mt = 00:03 }
Qd3+ { ev=30965,d=26,mt = 00:57 } 66.Kg2 { ev=-1949,d=19,mt = 00:00 }
Qd5+ { ev=30975,d=25,mt = 00:55 } 67.Kh3 { ev=-1892,d=18,mt = 00:00 }
Qf3+ { ev=30979,d=28,mt = 00:27 } 68.Kh2 { ev=-480,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Kh4 { ev=30981,d=32,mt = 00:32 } 69.Rg2 { ev=-31017,d=28,mt = 00:00 }
Qf4+ { ev=30983,d=41,mt = 00:33 } 70.Kg1 { ev=-31015,d=26,mt = 00:00 }
Kh3 { ev=30985,d=51,mt = 03:36 } 71.Ra2 { ev=-31013,d=24,mt = 00:00 }
Qf3 { ev=30987,d=69,mt = 00:30 } 72.Ra3 { ev=-31011,d=22,mt = 00:00 }
Qxa3 { ev=30989,d=89,mt = 03:29 } 73.Kf2 { ev=-31009,d=20,mt = 00:00 }
Qd3 { ev=30991,d=93,mt = 02:14 } 74.g5 { ev=-31007,d=18,mt = 00:00 }
Kg4 { ev=30993,d=100,mt = 00:03 } 75.g6 { ev=-31005,d=16,mt = 00:00 }
Qd2+ { ev=30995,d=98,mt = 01:20 } 76.Kg1 { ev=-31003,d=14,mt = 00:00 }
Kf3 { ev=30997,d=100,mt = 00:00 } 77.g7 { ev=-31001,d=12,mt = 00:00 }
Qg2+ { ev=30999,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
0-1


[Event ""]
[Site "ChessPalace"]
[Date "2013.09.11"]
[Round "26.1"]
[White "Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2"]
[Black "Houdini 3 x64"]
[Result "1-0"]
[Time "6:03:43 AM"]
[TimeControl "40/7200:20/3600:1800+10"]
[PlyCount "179"]
[Number "51"]
[Termination "checkmate"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]
[Variant "normal"]


1.c4 { Eval = 0, Depth = 1, mt = 00:00 } c6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
2.e4 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } d5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 3.exd5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
cxd5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 4.d4 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Nf6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 5.Nc3 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Nc6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 6.Nf3 { ev=4,d=26,mt = 02:57 }
Bg4 { ev=-6,d=25,mt = 03:27 } 7.Bg5 { ev=28,d=26,mt = 03:24 }
e6 { ev=-8,d=24,mt = 02:35 } 8.cxd5 { ev=26,d=28,mt = 03:35 }
exd5 { ev=-8,d=24,mt = 02:54 } 9.Qe2+ { ev=20,d=28,mt = 06:39 }
Be6 { ev=-6,d=25,mt = 04:06 } 10.Bxf6 { ev=32,d=29,mt = 02:25 }
gxf6 { ev=-4,d=26,mt = 04:30 } 11.Qe3 { ev=24,d=29,mt = 21:10 }
a6 { ev=-7,d=26,mt = 03:41 } 12.a3 { ev=44,d=27,mt = 03:39 }
Qd6 { ev=-2,d=25,mt = 02:33 } 13.Bd3 { ev=36,d=28,mt = 03:57 }
h5 { ev=-14,d=26,mt = 02:49 } 14.Nh4 { ev=48,d=28,mt = 01:54 }
O-O-O { ev=-10,d=26,mt = 02:44 } 15.Nf5 { ev=44,d=28,mt = 03:29 }
Qc7 { ev=-9,d=25,mt = 05:32 } 16.O-O { ev=48,d=28,mt = 02:19 }
Kb8 { ev=-5,d=24,mt = 02:35 } 17.Ne2 { ev=36,d=29,mt = 02:34 }
h4 { ev=-11,d=22,mt = 02:36 } 18.b4 { ev=44,d=29,mt = 05:49 }
Ne7 { ev=1,d=24,mt = 04:26 } 19.Nxe7 { ev=42,d=30,mt = 02:01 }
Bh6 { ev=-16,d=25,mt = 03:08 } 20.Qf3 { ev=38,d=29,mt = 01:58 }
Qxe7 { ev=0,d=24,mt = 01:04 } 21.h3 { ev=36,d=29,mt = 01:51 }
Rhg8 { ev=-10,d=24,mt = 04:03 } 22.Kh1 { ev=56,d=29,mt = 06:14 }
f5 { ev=-9,d=25,mt = 04:10 } 23.Rab1 { ev=54,d=29,mt = 02:34 }
Rc8 { ev=-11,d=24,mt = 02:44 } 24.Rb3 { ev=58,d=29,mt = 08:00 }
Ka7 { ev=-11,d=24,mt = 02:59 } 25.b5 { ev=48,d=29,mt = 01:28 }
a5 { ev=-21,d=27,mt = 04:11 } 26.b6+ { ev=42,d=30,mt = 01:53 }
Kb8 { ev=-17,d=28,mt = 03:58 } 27.Rd1 { ev=58,d=31,mt = 02:23 }
Rc6 { ev=-15,d=26,mt = 02:45 } 28.Nc3 { ev=105,d=29,mt = 02:12 }
Qd6 { ev=-24,d=27,mt = 08:25 } 29.Bb5 { ev=202,d=33,mt = 02:55 }
Rcc8 { ev=-24,d=25,mt = 00:00 } 30.Qe2 { ev=197,d=34,mt = 04:03 }
Rg6 { ev=-147,d=26,mt = 11:15 } 31.Qe1 { ev=202,d=33,mt = 01:22 }
Rcg8 { ev=-134,d=25,mt = 02:09 } 32.Bf1 { ev=216,d=33,mt = 05:19 }
Bd7 { ev=-135,d=25,mt = 02:14 } 33.Nb5 { ev=216,d=32,mt = 01:34 }
Qe6 { ev=-135,d=24,mt = 00:00 } 34.Qxa5 { ev=197,d=32,mt = 02:37 }
Qxb6 { ev=-150,d=23,mt = 03:01 } 35.Qc3 { ev=206,d=32,mt = 01:19 }
Qc6 { ev=-162,d=22,mt = 04:21 } 36.Qb4 { ev=228,d=28,mt = 01:17 }
Bg5 { ev=-180,d=24,mt = 05:39 } 37.a4 { ev=276,d=28,mt = 01:23 }
Bc8 { ev=-197,d=25,mt = 02:56 } 38.Rdb1 { ev=292,d=29,mt = 01:56 }
Bd8 { ev=-230,d=25,mt = 02:25 } 39.a5 { ev=305,d=30,mt = 01:01 }
Qd7 { ev=-240,d=25,mt = 01:35 } 40.a6 { ev=303,d=30,mt = 00:30 }
Be7 { ev=-243,d=24,mt = 02:13 } 41.a7+ { ev=325,d=30,mt = 12:43 }
Ka8 { ev=-109,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 42.Qd2 { ev=333,d=32,mt = 04:44 }
Bg5 { ev=-242,d=26,mt = 09:54 } 43.Qe2 { ev=333,d=32,mt = 02:01 }
Re6 { ev=-200,d=22,mt = 02:54 } 44.Qc2 { ev=331,d=31,mt = 03:21 }
Rc6 { ev=-268,d=24,mt = 04:41 } 45.Nc3 { ev=379,d=28,mt = 01:52 }
Qe6 { ev=-298,d=25,mt = 14:07 } 46.Bb5 { ev=387,d=30,mt = 03:05 }
Rc7 { ev=-314,d=25,mt = 01:53 } 47.Be2 { ev=412,d=32,mt = 04:20 }
Bf4 { ev=-307,d=23,mt = 02:28 } 48.Qa2 { ev=412,d=32,mt = 05:53 }
Bd7 { ev=-314,d=24,mt = 02:14 } 49.Qb2 { ev=424,d=28,mt = 01:53 }
Qc6 { ev=-445,d=26,mt = 05:55 } 50.Bb5 { ev=529,d=32,mt = 03:34 }
Qg6 { ev=-562,d=23,mt = 01:12 } 51.Bf1 { ev=595,d=35,mt = 01:24 }
Qc6 { ev=-585,d=25,mt = 01:07 } 52.Na4 { ev=612,d=35,mt = 00:40 }
Qxa4 { ev=-585,d=24,mt = 00:00 } 53.Rxb7 { ev=618,d=34,mt = 00:31 }
Qxa7 { ev=-601,d=27,mt = 03:56 } 54.Rxa7+ { ev=660,d=34,mt = 00:43 }
Rxa7 { ev=-497,d=25,mt = 02:52 } 55.Qb3 { ev=717,d=35,mt = 04:08 }
Bc6 { ev=-568,d=24,mt = 01:34 } 56.Qc2 { ev=725,d=35,mt = 04:16 }
Rc8 { ev=-630,d=22,mt = 01:40 } 57.Qxf5 { ev=719,d=28,mt = 00:24 }
Rb8 { ev=-629,d=21,mt = 00:01 } 58.Bb5 { ev=822,d=31,mt = 02:25 }
Bxb5 { ev=-675,d=23,mt = 00:58 } 59.Qxf4 { ev=727,d=24,mt = 00:25 }
Rd7 { ev=-687,d=23,mt = 01:50 } 60.Qh6 { ev=949,d=28,mt = 00:31 }
f6 { ev=-745,d=21,mt = 00:36 } 61.Qxf6 { ev=1072,d=29,mt = 00:34 }
Ka7 { ev=-683,d=23,mt = 01:37 } 62.Ra1+ { ev=1305,d=31,mt = 02:32 }
Kb7 { ev=-784,d=21,mt = 00:26 } 63.Qxh4 { ev=1533,d=32,mt = 04:06 }
Bc6 { ev=-912,d=24,mt = 04:46 } 64.Rb1+ { ev=1804,d=27,mt = 00:30 }
Ka7 { ev=-1314,d=27,mt = 04:00 } 65.Rxb8 { ev=2161,d=30,mt = 01:20 }
Kxb8 { ev=-1279,d=25,mt = 00:38 } 66.g4 { ev=2567,d=29,mt = 02:13 }
Ba4 { ev=-1179,d=26,mt = 00:27 } 67.g5 { ev=3460,d=29,mt = 01:15 }
Bc2 {2checkmate]
[S25.2ite 38Houdini 3 x64 ev=-1411,d=26,mt = 03:14 } 68.g6 { ev=3941,d=29,mt = 01:10 }
Be4+ { ev=-1477,d=23,mt = 00:24 } 69.Kh2 { ev=2600,d=22,mt = 00:19 }
Ka7 { ev=-1816,d=24,mt = 00:41 } 70.Qf6 { ev=3303,d=23,mt = 00:41 }
Rb7 { ev=-2148,d=27,mt = 00:39 } 71.g7 { ev=7706,d=24,mt = 00:49 }
Bh7 { ev=-2148,d=26,mt = 00:00 } 72.Qf8 { ev=9155,d=25,mt = 00:48 }
Rb8 { ev=-2094,d=27,mt = 00:40 } 73.f4 { ev=10167,d=24,mt = 01:04 }
Rb2+ { ev=-2128,d=21,mt = 01:12 } 74.Kg3 { ev=13920,d=26,mt = 05:31 }
Rb3+ { ev=-2128,d=19,mt = 00:00 } 75.Kg4 { ev=5660,d=21,mt = 04:10 }
Rb1 { ev=-2675,d=25,mt = 01:12 } 76.f5 { ev=9034,d=16,mt = 00:08 }
Rg1+ { ev=-14491,d=24,mt = 01:01 } 77.Kf4 { ev=13851,d=22,mt = 03:03 }
Rf1+ { ev=-31031,d=22,mt = 00:39 } 78.Ke5 { ev=11445,d=22,mt = 00:15 }
Ka6 { ev=-31023,d=26,mt = 00:39 } 79.f6 { ev=11445,d=20,mt = 00:25 }
Kb5 { ev=-31021,d=27,mt = 00:18 } 80.f7 { ev=30973,d=16,mt = 00:16 }
Rxf7 { ev=-31017,d=30,mt = 00:18 } 81.Qxf7 { ev=30979,d=18,mt = 00:11 }
Kb4 { ev=-31015,d=26,mt = 00:00 } 82.Qxd5 { ev=30981,d=19,mt = 00:16 }
Kc3 { ev=-31015,d=26,mt = 00:01 } 83.g8=Q { ev=30983,d=19,mt = 00:06 }
Bxg8 { ev=-31013,d=24,mt = 00:00 } 84.Qxg8 { ev=30987,d=43,mt = 00:14 }
Kc2 { ev=-31011,d=22,mt = 00:00 } 85.Qc4+ { ev=30989,d=100,mt = 00:10 }
Kb2 { ev=-31009,d=20,mt = 00:00 } 86.d5 { ev=30991,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
Ka3 { ev=-31007,d=18,mt = 00:00 } 87.Qb5 { ev=30993,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
Ka2 { ev=-31005,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 88.Kd4 { ev=30995,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
Ka3 { ev=-31003,d=14,mt = 00:00 } 89.Kc3 { ev=30997,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
Ka2 { ev=-31001,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 90.Qb2+ { ev=30999,d=100,mt = 00:00 }
1-0


[Event ""]
[Site "ChessPalace"]
[Date "2013.09.11"]
[Round "26.2"]
[White "Houdini 3 x64"]
[Black "Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[Time "12:58:28 PM"]
[TimeControl "40/7200:20/3600:1800+10"]
[PlyCount "133"]
[Number "52"]
[Termination "GUI adjudication"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]
[Variant "normal"]


1.c4 { Eval = 0, Depth = 1, mt = 00:00 } c6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
2.e4 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } d5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 3.exd5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
cxd5 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 4.d4 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Nf6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 5.Nc3 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 }
Nc6 { ev=0,d=1,mt = 00:00 } 6.Nf3 { ev=17,d=25,mt = 09:11 }
Bg4 { ev=-26,d=30,mt = 10:02 } 7.Bg5 { ev=14,d=24,mt = 03:19 }
Ne4 { ev=-4,d=29,mt = 04:22 } 8.cxd5 { ev=15,d=25,mt = 02:27 }
Nxg5 { ev=0,d=31,mt = 02:45 } 9.dxc6 { ev=15,d=24,mt = 00:00 }
bxc6 { ev=0,d=32,mt = 00:45 } 10.Be2 { ev=6,d=27,mt = 04:14 }
Nxf3+ { ev=0,d=32,mt = 04:53 } 11.Bxf3 { ev=7,d=25,mt = 00:01 }
Bxf3 { ev=0,d=34,mt = 03:29 } 12.Qxf3 { ev=11,d=27,mt = 02:49 }
Rc8 { ev=0,d=33,mt = 03:34 } 13.O-O { ev=11,d=26,mt = 03:56 }
e6 { ev=0,d=33,mt = 02:46 } 14.Qg3 { ev=7,d=26,mt = 02:55 }
Qc7 { ev=0,d=34,mt = 03:11 } 15.Qg5 { ev=7,d=27,mt = 03:26 }
h6 { ev=0,d=34,mt = 02:53 } 16.Qe5 { ev=0,d=28,mt = 02:47 }
Qxe5 { ev=0,d=35,mt = 03:29 } 17.dxe5 { ev=1,d=26,mt = 00:00 }
Rb8 { ev=8,d=35,mt = 03:38 } 18.Rab1 { ev=6,d=30,mt = 08:06 }
g5 { ev=12,d=33,mt = 03:28 } 19.Rfe1 { ev=-2,d=27,mt = 02:55 }
Bb4 { ev=20,d=32,mt = 05:42 } 20.Rec1 { ev=-6,d=28,mt = 04:20 }
O-O { ev=12,d=30,mt = 03:05 } 21.Ne4 { ev=-8,d=28,mt = 03:00 }
Rfd8 { ev=12,d=29,mt = 02:13 } 22.g3 { ev=-7,d=28,mt = 03:53 }
Rd4 { ev=36,d=32,mt = 03:32 } 23.Nf6+ { ev=-8,d=28,mt = 02:47 }
Kg7 { ev=30,d=34,mt = 07:57 } 24.Rxc6 { ev=-12,d=28,mt = 03:24 }
Kg6 { ev=16,d=33,mt = 08:40 } 25.b3 { ev=-6,d=29,mt = 04:32 }
Be7 { ev=18,d=34,mt = 02:18 } 26.Ra6 { ev=0,d=30,mt = 03:09 }
Bxf6 { ev=18,d=34,mt = 02:31 } 27.exf6 { ev=0,d=28,mt = 00:00 }
Rb7 { ev=10,d=34,mt = 02:26 } 28.Rb2 { ev=-5,d=30,mt = 07:12 }
Rc7 { ev=18,d=33,mt = 02:27 } 29.b4 { ev=-5,d=29,mt = 05:03 }
Rd1+ { ev=22,d=33,mt = 02:56 } 30.Kg2 { ev=-5,d=27,mt = 00:00 }
h5 { ev=14,d=36,mt = 02:21 } 31.b5 { ev=-5,d=30,mt = 04:06 }
g4 { ev=14,d=36,mt = 02:19 } 32.f3 { ev=-5,d=28,mt = 02:58 }
Kxf6 { ev=14,d=35,mt = 02:18 } 33.Ra4 { ev=-4,d=30,mt = 05:16 }
gxf3+ { ev=14,d=31,mt = 01:59 } 34.Kxf3 { ev=-4,d=27,mt = 02:46 }
Rd3+ { ev=14,d=34,mt = 02:06 } 35.Kg2 { ev=-4,d=29,mt = 03:15 }
Rd5 { ev=14,d=32,mt = 02:46 } 36.Rf4+ { ev=-4,d=28,mt = 07:41 }
Kg5 { ev=4,d=32,mt = 02:32 } 37.a4 { ev=-4,d=28,mt = 02:26 }
f5 { ev=8,d=35,mt = 02:08 } 38.Rbf2 { ev=-4,d=28,mt = 02:00 }
Rdc5 { ev=6,d=32,mt = 01:52 } 39.Rd4 { ev=-4,d=29,mt = 02:12 }
Kf6 { ev=8,d=34,mt = 02:16 } 40.Rd6 { ev=-4,d=29,mt = 03:40 }
h4 { ev=8,d=36,mt = 03:27 } 41.Re2 { ev=-4,d=31,mt = 03:07 }
Re7 { ev=0,d=34,mt = 05:16 } 42.Rc6 { ev=-4,d=30,mt = 02:20 }
Rd5 { ev=0,d=35,mt = 03:44 } 43.Rec2 { ev=-4,d=29,mt = 02:32 }
hxg3 { ev=8,d=33,mt = 04:14 } 44.hxg3 { ev=-4,d=32,mt = 03:13 }
Rd4 { ev=8,d=38,mt = 02:33 } 45.a5 { ev=-4,d=32,mt = 03:15 }
Ra4 { ev=4,d=36,mt = 03:00 } 46.a6 { ev=-4,d=31,mt = 02:40 }
Ra5 { ev=0,d=36,mt = 02:58 } 47.Rc7 { ev=-4,d=33,mt = 02:29 }
Rxb5 { ev=0,d=45,mt = 02:33 } 48.Rxe7 { ev=-3,d=36,mt = 03:10 }
Kxe7 { ev=0,d=47,mt = 00:46 } 49.Rc7+ { ev=-2,d=36,mt = 02:29 }
Kd6 { ev=0,d=50,mt = 03:39 } 50.Rxa7 { ev=-2,d=36,mt = 02:53 }
Rb2+ { ev=0,d=50,mt = 02:17 } 51.Kf3 { ev=-2,d=37,mt = 02:46 }
Rb3+ { ev=0,d=55,mt = 02:36 } 52.Kf4 { ev=-2,d=39,mt = 03:07 }
Ra3 { ev=0,d=47,mt = 02:35 } 53.Ra8 { ev=-2,d=39,mt = 03:05 }
Kd5 { ev=0,d=49,mt = 02:17 } 54.Rd8+ { ev=-2,d=38,mt = 02:56 }
Kc5 { ev=0,d=51,mt = 02:15 } 55.Ke5 { ev=-2,d=40,mt = 03:32 }
Rxa6 { ev=0,d=56,mt = 02:58 } 56.Re8 { ev=-1,d=43,mt = 02:54 }
Ra3 { ev=0,d=60,mt = 02:15 } 57.Rc8+ { ev=-1,d=46,mt = 03:37 }
Kb4 { ev=0,d=63,mt = 02:51 } 58.Kxe6 { ev=-1,d=47,mt = 03:18 }
Rxg3 { ev=0,d=72,mt = 04:01 } 59.Kxf5 { ev=-1,d=51,mt = 03:07 }
Rg1 { ev=0,d=80,mt = 02:38 } 60.Rb8+ { ev=-1,d=56,mt = 02:46 }
Ka3 { ev=0,d=82,mt = 03:07 } 61.Ke5 { ev=-1,d=45,mt = 00:36 }
Ra1 { ev=0,d=88,mt = 01:08 } 62.Kd4 { ev=-1,d=44,mt = 00:36 }
Rc1 { ev=0,d=80,mt = 01:08 } 63.Kd3 { ev=-1,d=47,mt = 00:40 }
Ra1 { ev=0,d=83,mt = 01:05 } 64.Kd2 { ev=-1,d=45,mt = 00:35 }
Rf1 { ev=0,d=80,mt = 01:07 } 65.Kc3 { ev=-1,d=47,mt = 00:38 }
Rc1+ { ev=0,d=100,mt = 00:52 } 66.Kd2 { ev=-1,d=53,mt = 00:37 }
Ra1 { ev=0,d=93,mt = 01:07 } 67.Rb7 { ev=-1,d=46,mt = 00:35 }
1/2-1/2
[/pgn]
 

[shrapnel]

Hi
One thing I've noted is that in nearly all the games Stockfish won, Houdini 3 is on Default Contempt 1, which is quite disastrous actually, against an approximately equally strong Engine.
Another is that most of the Stockfish wins have been with White !
Run your LTC Tests with Houdini 3 on Contempt 0 and then see what happens ! Stockfish will be lucky to get even one win, Black or White ! I've confirmed this on my System.
So, I for one am not totally convinced that Stockfish has really become stronger than Houdini 3 ; in Middle Game proper, yes, I feel Stockfish is indeed stronger, but I strongly feel Stockish is still weak in late Opening - early Middle-Game phase.
When Stockfish starts beating Houdini 3 regularly at Contempt 0, THEN I will acknowledge that Stockfish is truly stronger than Houdini 3 !!!
Till that day, in my book, Houdini 3 still RULEZ !!

[S.Taylor]

Hi
One thing I've noted is that in nearly all the games Stockfish won, Houdini 3 is on Default Contempt 1, which is quite disastrous actually, against an approximately equally strong Engine.
Another is that most of the Stockfish wins have been with White !
Run your LTC Tests with Houdini 3 on Contempt 0 and then see what happens ! Stockfish will be lucky to get even one win, Black or White ! I've confirmed this on my System.
So, I for one am not totally convinced that Stockfish has really become stronger than Houdini 3 ; in Middle Game proper, yes, I feel Stockfish is indeed stronger, but I strongly feel Stockish is still weak in late Opening - early Middle-Game phase.
When Stockfish starts beating Houdini 3 regularly at Contempt 0, THEN I will acknowledge that Stockfish is truly stronger than Houdini 3 !!!
Till that day, in my book, Houdini 3 still RULEZ !!

This would be an important observation.
(i never like to see the top engine have a relative weakness in a partiicular position compared to other engines, as then i can't rely on it fully for analysis).