EDIT: Ignore the actual Elo ratings I just used an offset of 3000 in bayeselo so the ratings will not match the CCRL list.
Results to date
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045 27 27 400 59% 2992 44%
2 Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021 29 29 350 56% 2988 45%
3 Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018 29 29 350 54% 2993 49%
4 Stockfish 131113 64 Sz 1CPU 3018 35 35 250 55% 2987 44%
5 Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014 29 29 350 54% 2993 48%
6 Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 2996 31 31 300 48% 3007 46%
7 Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996 25 25 450 49% 3000 48%
8 Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985 27 27 400 47% 3002 46%
9 Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960 27 27 400 43% 3006 47%
10 Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949 26 26 450 40% 3006 48%
Code: Select all
Ho Ho St St St Ko Ho Ko Ko St
Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 87 92 90 94 99 99 99 99 99
Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 12 57 56 64 89 91 97 99 99
Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 7 42 50 57 85 88 95 99 99
Stockfish 131113 64 Sz 1CPU 9 43 49 56 81 85 94 99 99
Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 5 35 42 43 80 83 93 99 99
Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 0 10 14 18 19 50 70 95 99
Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 0 8 11 14 16 49 73 97 99
Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 0 2 4 5 6 29 26 90 97
Komodo CCT 64-bit 0 0 0 0 0 4 2 9 73
Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 26
Code: Select all
1 Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045 400.0 (235.0 : 165.0)
50.0 ( 26.0 : 24.0) Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 27.5 : 22.5) Stockfish 131113 64 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 26.0 : 24.0) Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014
50.0 ( 30.5 : 19.5) Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 32.5 : 17.5) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 33.0 : 17.0) Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985
50.0 ( 30.5 : 19.5) Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960
50.0 ( 29.0 : 21.0) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
2 Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021 350.0 (194.5 : 155.5)
50.0 ( 24.5 : 25.5) Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 27.0 : 23.0) Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014
50.0 ( 27.0 : 23.0) Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 27.0 : 23.0) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 25.5 : 24.5) Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985
50.0 ( 31.5 : 18.5) Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960
50.0 ( 32.0 : 18.0) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
3 Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018 350.0 (190.0 : 160.0)
50.0 ( 24.0 : 26.0) Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045
50.0 ( 25.5 : 24.5) Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021
50.0 ( 27.0 : 23.0) Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 28.5 : 21.5) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 25.5 : 24.5) Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985
50.0 ( 29.0 : 21.0) Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960
50.0 ( 30.5 : 19.5) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
4 Stockfish 131113 64 Sz 1CPU 3018 250.0 (138.0 : 112.0)
50.0 ( 22.5 : 27.5) Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045
50.0 ( 29.0 : 21.0) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 28.0 : 22.0) Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985
50.0 ( 29.0 : 21.0) Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960
50.0 ( 29.5 : 20.5) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
5 Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014 350.0 (187.5 : 162.5)
50.0 ( 24.0 : 26.0) Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045
50.0 ( 23.0 : 27.0) Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021
50.0 ( 25.5 : 24.5) Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 24.0 : 26.0) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 30.5 : 19.5) Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985
50.0 ( 29.0 : 21.0) Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960
50.0 ( 31.5 : 18.5) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
6 Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 2996 300.0 (144.0 : 156.0)
50.0 ( 19.5 : 30.5) Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045
50.0 ( 23.0 : 27.0) Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021
50.0 ( 23.0 : 27.0) Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 24.5 : 25.5) Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014
50.0 ( 25.0 : 25.0) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 29.0 : 21.0) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
7 Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996 450.0 (221.0 : 229.0)
50.0 ( 17.5 : 32.5) Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045
50.0 ( 23.0 : 27.0) Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021
50.0 ( 21.5 : 28.5) Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 21.0 : 29.0) Stockfish 131113 64 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 26.0 : 24.0) Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014
50.0 ( 25.0 : 25.0) Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 28.0 : 22.0) Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985
50.0 ( 29.5 : 20.5) Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960
50.0 ( 29.5 : 20.5) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
8 Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985 400.0 (188.0 : 212.0)
50.0 ( 17.0 : 33.0) Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045
50.0 ( 24.5 : 25.5) Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021
50.0 ( 24.5 : 25.5) Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 22.0 : 28.0) Stockfish 131113 64 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 19.5 : 30.5) Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014
50.0 ( 22.0 : 28.0) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 26.0 : 24.0) Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960
50.0 ( 32.5 : 17.5) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
9 Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960 400.0 (170.5 : 229.5)
50.0 ( 19.5 : 30.5) Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045
50.0 ( 18.5 : 31.5) Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021
50.0 ( 21.0 : 29.0) Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 21.0 : 29.0) Stockfish 131113 64 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 21.0 : 29.0) Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014
50.0 ( 20.5 : 29.5) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 24.0 : 26.0) Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985
50.0 ( 25.0 : 25.0) Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949
10 Stockfish 4 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 2949 450.0 (181.5 : 268.5)
50.0 ( 21.0 : 29.0) Houdini 4 x64 sz 1CPU 3045
50.0 ( 18.0 : 32.0) Houdini 4 x64 1CPU 3021
50.0 ( 19.5 : 30.5) Stockfish DD 64 SSE42 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 20.5 : 29.5) Stockfish 131113 64 Sz 1CPU 3018
50.0 ( 18.5 : 31.5) Stockfish DD 64 SSE4.2 1CPU 3014
50.0 ( 21.0 : 29.0) Komodo TCEC 64-bit 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 20.5 : 29.5) Houdini 3 x64 1CPU 2996
50.0 ( 17.5 : 32.5) Komodo 6 64-bit 1CPU 2985
50.0 ( 25.0 : 25.0) Komodo CCT 64-bit 2960
ignoring ratings/for analysis I would love to see a UCI option in all engines that allows us to turn on the knowledge.
It's a shame that knowledge seems to hurt performance on average although in individual positions make the difference between the engine appearing dumb/intelligent.
Anyway I will be repeating most of the pairings for the 40-40 list - let see if 10x the think time alters the rankings.
Shaun
* Nunn v2 25 positions colours reversed (50 games) for CCRL 3(6) games from each paring have to be removed as they go beyond 12 moves.
P.S. If anyone wants the games let me know and I will provide a link