Current comparison FGRL Stockfish 6 - Komodo 8

[fastgm]

Code: Select all

   TC        SF6  -  K8
60 + 0.60  : 3376 - 3316 / +60 (20000 games)
240 + 2.40 : 3221 - 3187 / +34  (3000 games)
10 minutes : 3177 - 3125 / +52  (3000 games) 
30 minutes : 3245 - 3188 / +57   (720 games)

More at:
http://www.fastgm.de

[lkaufman]

The description implies that 10 and 30 minutes are played without increment, but the website says that 10 minute is played with increment but 30 minute without. Could you please clarify that? I'm trying to determine whether Komodo has a problem playing without increment.

[fastgm]

The description is only an abbreviation for the 10 minute rating list.
The website contains the correct informations.

10 minutes = 10 minutes + 6 seconds increment per move
30 minutes = 30 minutes without increment

Andreas

[beram]

So after 5 months release of Komodo 8, after an unhappy result, you hide in excuses about time management problem for Komodo 8 ?
Not very convincing.
To fresh up our memory here is an earlier similar finding that there isn't a decline in result at longer TC, for SF(dev21114) against K8

http://www.talkchess.com/forum/viewtopi ... 70&t=53844

Code: Select all

F 211114 – Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s       i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu Fritzmark 5,1                            
1   Stockfish 211114 64 BMI2   +49  +30/=54/-16 57.00%   57.0/100 
2   Komodo 8 64-bit            -49  +16/=54/-30 43.00%   43.0/100 

SF 2111 – Komodo 8, Rapid 15m+10s i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu Fritzmark 5,1 (5x longer TC)                                                            
1   Stockfish 211114 64 BMI2   +70  +30/=60/-10 60.00%   60.0/100 
2   Komodo 8 64-bit            -70  +10/=60/-30 40.00%   40.0/100 

SF 2111 – Komodo 8, Rapid 30m+20s   i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu Fritzmark 5,1 (10x longer TC) 
1   Stockfish 211114 64 BMI2   +67  +24/=71/-5 59.50%   59.5/100 
2   Komodo 8 64-bit            -67  +5/=71/-24 40.50%   40.5/100

[Sedat Canbaz]

Code: Select all

   TC        SF6  -  K8
60 + 0.60  : 3376 - 3316 / +60 (20000 games)
240 + 2.40 : 3221 - 3187 / +34  (3000 games)
10 minutes : 3177 - 3125 / +52  (3000 games) 
30 minutes : 3245 - 3188 / +57   (720 games)

More at:
http://www.fastgm.de

Hello Andreas,

I am impressed again by your work, statistics...great job !

Btw,
Your used TC: 240 + 2.40's Elo difference is very close to my 3m+1s
For example, yours is 34 Elo, where mine is 31 Elo, those numbers show the stability of our both testings... )


Keep up the good work,
Sedat