8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Dann Corbit, Harvey Williamson

Forum rules
This textbox is used to restore diagrams posted with the [d] tag before the upgrade.
Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 2:15 am

8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Dan Cooper » Fri Jan 01, 2016 11:00 pm

Intel 5960X @ 4.5Ghz
ChessGUI
8192MB Hash
6-piece Nalimov/Syzygy EGTB on SSD
Private opening book (variable 2-17 move book-exit)
4 cycles (224 games)

Contempt changes
Stockfish 7 Beta = 5
Stockfish 291115 YBW = 5
Houdini 4 = 0

Participants
Komodo 9.3
Komodo 9.2
Stockfish 7 Beta 2
Stockfish 291115 YBW KP build
Houdini 4 Pro x64
Fire 4
Equinox 3.3
Hannibal 1.5

Games viewable via TLCV/Livius Client
LIZARDTEST.DDNS.NET 16016

beram
Posts: 1187
Joined: Wed Jan 06, 2010 2:11 pm

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by beram » Sat Jan 02, 2016 11:04 am

Great tournament, nice that you broadcast it

Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 2:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Dan Cooper » Sat Jan 02, 2016 10:34 pm

Due to a crash, Equinox 3.3 is being replaced with Texel 1.06a34.

User avatar
Graham Banks
Posts: 35088
Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2006 9:52 am
Location: Auckland, NZ

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Graham Banks » Sat Jan 02, 2016 10:35 pm

Dan Cooper wrote:Due to a crash, Equinox 3.3 is being replaced with Texel 1.06a34.
Oops - just after I told you that Equinox should be okay. :oops:
gbanksnz at gmail.com

Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 2:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Dan Cooper » Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:25 pm

Standings after round 7 of 56

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1    KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C10 S131                   7     5.0    *  =  1  =  =  =  1  1  
   2.   FIRE 4 X64                                   7     5.0    =  *  =  =  =  1  1  1  
   3.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C5                  7     4.5    0  =  *  =  1  =  1  1  
   4.   STOCKFISH 291115 YBW KP C5                   7     4.0    =  =  =  *  =  =  =  1  
   5.   KOMODO 9.2 64-BIT C15 S74                    7     3.5    =  =  0  =  *  =  1  =  
   6.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                            7     3.5    =  0  =  =  =  *  =  1  
   7.   TEXEL 1 06A34 64-BIT                         7     1.5    0  0  0  0  =  0  1  *  
   8.   HANNIBAL 1 5 X64                             7     1.0    0  0  0  =  0  =  *  0  
   
   
   # PLAYER                         : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Fire 4 x64                     : 3168.2       5.0       7   71.4%
   2 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C10 S131     : 3157.1       5.0       7   71.4%
   3 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C5    : 3113.9       4.5       7   64.3%
   4 Stockfish 291115 YBW KP C5     : 3056.7       4.0       7   57.1%
   5 Komodo 9.2 64-bit C15 S74      : 3000.4       3.5       7   50.0%
   6 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0       3.5       7   50.0%
   7 Texel 1.06a34 64-bit           : 2758.1       1.5       7   21.4%
   8 Hannibal 1.5 x64               : 2738.1       1.0       7   14.3%


Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 2:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Dan Cooper » Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:26 pm

Big win of the 1st stage goes to Komodo 9.3 over Stockfish 7.

[pgn]
[Event "Top 8 Octo RR 2016 #1"]
[Site "KMLHT"]
[Date "2016.01.03"]
[Round "5.4"]
[White "Komodo 9.3 64-bit C10 S131"]
[Black "Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C5"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "E81"]
[PlyCount "134"]
[EventDate "2016.??.??"]
[TimeControl "40/2400:40/2400:40/2400"]

{Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-5960X CPU @ 4.50GHz} 1. d4 {0/1 0s} Nf6 {0/1 0s} 2. c4 {
0/1 0s} g6 {0/1 0s} 3. Nc3 {0/1 0s} Bg7 {0/1 0s} 4. e4 {0/1 0s} d6 {0/1 0s} 5.
f3 {0/1 0s} O-O {0/1 0s} 6. Be3 {0/1 0s} c5 {0/1 0s} 7. Nge2 {0/1 0s} Nc6 {
0/1 0s} 8. d5 {0/1 0s} Ne5 {0/1 0s} 9. Ng3 {0/1 0s} e6 {0/1 0s} 10. Be2 {
28/27 38s} exd5 {-32/29 37s (exd5)} 11. cxd5 {42/26 33s (cxd5)} a6 {-25/30 40s
(a6)} 12. a4 {71 42/29 (a4)} Bd7 {-32/32 2:21m (Bd7)} 13. h3 {107 33/30 (Qd2)
} b5 {-24/28 40s (b5)} 14. O-O {38/28 47s (O-O)} Nc4 {-12/32 2:43m (Re8)} 15.
Bxc4 {48/27 30s (Bxc4)} bxc4 {-31/27 21s (bxc4)} 16. e5 {109 44/29 (Qd2)} Qe7
{-4/30 38s (Qe7)} 17. f4 {81 39/29 (f4)} dxe5 {-4/30 13s (dxe5)} 18. f5 {
46/27 55s (fxe5)} Rab8 {-26/28 1:50m (Rab8)} 19. fxg6 {155 52/29 (Rf2)} fxg6 {
-11/29 1:3m (fxg6)} 20. Qe2 {58/28 58s (Qe2)} e4 {-16/27 38s (e4)} 21. Rae1 {
85 46/29 (a5)} Rb4 {-24/29 59s (Rb4)} 22. Bg5 {82 58/29 (Bg5)} Qe5 {-22/32 2:
21m (Qe8)} 23. Bf4 {55/28 45s (Bf4)} Qe7 {-39/31 1:27m (Qe7)} 24. Qd2 {62/28
28s (Qd2)} Bf5 {-39/29 24s (Bf5)} 25. Rf2 {101 69/29 (a5)} Rf7 {-28/29 1:44m
(Rf7)} 26. Bh6 {123 73/31 (a5)} Qe5 {-41/31 2:0m (Qe5)} 27. Bxg7 {80/27 24s
(Bxg7)} Rxg7 {-45/30 17s (Rxg7)} 28. Nf1 {71/29 39s (Qe3)} Rgb7 {-56/30 1:27m
(Rgb7)} 29. Qc1 {74/29 41s (Qc1)} Rb8 {-68/32 3:26m (Rb8)} 30. Ne3 {95/30 59s
(Ne3)} Bd7 {-75/33 44s (Bd7)} 31. Ref1 {99/30 56s (Rd1)} Rf8 {-106/32 2:33m
(Nh5)} 32. d6 {136/29 44s (d6)} Rbb8 {-101/32 35s (Rbb8)} 33. Nxc4 {141/30 38s
(Nxc4)} Qe6 {-119/31 17s (Qe6)} 34. b3 {81 141/32 (b3)} Nd5 {-100/34 50s (Nd5)
} 35. Nxd5 {91 152/31 (Rxf8)} Qxd5 {-128/32 1:26m (Qxd5)} 36. Rd1 {137 175/32
(Rd1)} Qh5 {-138/28 10s (Qh5)} 37. Rxf8+ {166/30 44s (Rxf8)} Rxf8 {-149/33 1:
50m (Rxf8)} 38. Qd2 {73 170/32 (Qd2)} Qf5 {-162/32 1:35m (h6)} 39. Nb6 {
181/30 38s (Nb6)} Rf7 {-146/33 1:8m (Rf7)} 40. Qe3 {144 184/32 (Qe3)} h5 {
-149/31 23s (Qe5)} 41. Rd5 {72 199/33 (Rd5)} Qf1+ {-176/33 3:19m (Qf1)} 42.
Kh2 {199/33 0s (Kh2)} Qf6 {-193/31 31s (Qf6)} 43. Qg3 {61 221/32 (Qg3)} h4 {
-192/35 1:29m (h4)} 44. Qe5 {229/32 31s (Qe5)} Kg7 {-191/36 1:0m (Kg7)} 45.
Rxc5 {239/32 47s (Rxc5)} Bf5 {-220/34 2:32m (Qxe5)} 46. Qxf6+ {263/31 42s (Kg1)
} Rxf6 {-261/32 1:33m (Kxf6)} 47. Rc7+ {333/29 33s (Rc7)} Kf8 {-316/34 2:40m
(Kf8)} 48. Rc6 {361/31 50s (Rc6)} Be6 {-346/35 4:4m (Rf7)} 49. a5 {60 454/32
(d7)} Rf7 {-309/30 57s (Rf7)} 50. b4 {470/32 39s (Nc4)} g5 {-455/33 1:46m (Bf5)
} 51. Rc5 {520/33 52s (Rc5)} Rf5 {-508/35 2:34m (Rf5)} 52. d7 {554/34 35s (d7)}
Ke7 {-526/34 45s (Ke7)} 53. Rc8 {564/36 34s (Rc8)} Bxd7 {-544/33 20s (Bxd7)}
54. Rc7 {595/33 28s (Rc7)} e3 {-550/33 30s (e3)} 55. Rxd7+ {609/34 25s (Rxd7)}
Ke8 {-560/30 15s (Ke6)} 56. Rd1 {624/36 51s (Rd1)} e2 {-569/32 44s (Rb5)} 57.
Re1 {86 730/34 (Re1)} Re5 {-576/27 9s (Re5)} 58. Kg1 {806/34 44s (Nc4)} Kd8 {
-665/30 1:16m (Kf7)} 59. Kf2 {245 799/36 (Na4)} Re4 {-696/31 1:5m (g4)} 60.
Nd5 {888/36 22s (Nd5)} Re5 {-784/31 2:35m (Rd4)} 61. Nc3 {968/34 21s (Nc3)}
Rf5+ {-800/30 33s (Kc7)} 62. Ke3 {987/36 27s (Kxe2)} Rf1 {-839/31 1:36m (Rf4)}
63. Kxe2 {62 1076/38 (Kxe2)} Rf4 {-862/32 26s (Rf8)} 64. Rd1+ {64 1224/38
(Nd5)} Kc8 {-1174/36 3:14m (Kc8)} 65. Nd5 {109 25000/39 (Rc1)} Rf8 {-1289/31
41s (Re4)} 66. Rf1 {228 25000/40 (Rf1)} Re8+ {-1329/29 32s (Re8)} 67. Kd3 {
25000/42 39s (Kd3)} Re5 {GUI adjudication} 1-0

[/pgn]

Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 2:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Dan Cooper » Thu Jan 07, 2016 5:09 pm

Standings after round 14 of 56

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1    KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C10 S131                  14     9.5    **  1=  ==  =1  =1  ==  1=  1=  
   2.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C5                 14     9.0    0=  **  1=  ==  =1  =1  1=  1=  
   3.   KOMODO 9.2 64-BIT C15 S74                   14     8.5    ==  0=  **  ==  =1  =1  1=  =1  
   4.   STOCKFISH 291115 YBW KP C5                  14     8.0    =0  ==  ==  **  ==  =1  ==  11  
   5.   FIRE 4 X64                                  14     7.5    =0  =0  =0  ==  **  1=  1=  11  
   6.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                           14     5.5    ==  =0  =0  =0  0=  **  =0  11  
   7.   HANNIBAL 1 5 X64                            14     5.0    0=  0=  0=  ==  0=  =1  **  0=  
   8.   TEXEL 1 06A34 64-BIT                        14     3.0    0=  0=  =0  00  00  00  1=  **  

Total games = 56


   # PLAYER                         : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C10 S131     : 3196.6       9.5      14   67.9%
   2 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C5    : 3170.9       9.0      14   64.3%
   3 Komodo 9.2 64-bit C15 S74      : 3145.9       8.5      14   60.7%
   4 Stockfish 291115 YBW KP C5     : 3121.4       8.0      14   57.1%
   5 Fire 4 x64                     : 3097.2       7.5      14   53.6%
   6 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0       5.5      14   39.3%
   7 Hannibal 1.5 x64               : 2974.7       5.0      14   35.7%
   8 Texel 1.06a34 64-bit           : 2861.8       3.0      14   21.4%


Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 2:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Dan Cooper » Thu Jan 07, 2016 5:40 pm

So far so good for the new opening book.

55% draws.
No 10 results.
Normal starting evals at book-exit.

Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 2:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Dan Cooper » Mon Jan 11, 2016 1:59 am

Standings after round 21 of 56

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

   1.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C5                 21    14.5    ***  0==  1=1  ===  =1=  =11  1=1  1=1  
   2.   KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C10 S131                  21    14.0    1==  ***  ==0  =1=  =11  ===  1=1  1=1  
   3.   KOMODO 9.2 64-BIT C15 S74                   21    13.5    ==1  0=0  ***  ===  =11  =11  1==  =11  
   4.   STOCKFISH 291115 YBW KP C5                  21    13.0    =0=  ===  ===  ***  ==1  =11  ===  111  
   5.   FIRE 4 X64                                  21     9.5    =00  =0=  =00  ==0  ***  1==  1==  11=  
   6.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                           21     8.5    ===  =00  =00  =00  0==  ***  =01  111  
   7.   HANNIBAL 1 5 X64                            21     7.0    0=0  0=0  0==  ===  0==  =10  ***  0==  
   8.   TEXEL 1 06A34 64-BIT                        21     4.0    0=0  0=0  =00  000  00=  000  1==  ***  

Total games = 84

   # PLAYER                         : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C5    : 3206.2      14.5      21   69.0%
   2 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C10 S131     : 3185.0      14.0      21   66.7%
   3 Komodo 9.2 64-bit C15 S74      : 3167.5      13.5      21   64.3%
   4 Stockfish 291115 YBW KP C5     : 3153.0      13.0      21   61.9%
   5 Fire 4 x64                     : 3035.0       9.5      21   45.2%
   6 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0       8.5      21   40.5%
   7 Hannibal 1.5 x64               : 2963.0       7.0      21   33.3%
   8 Texel 1.06a34 64-bit           : 2826.2       4.0      21   19.0%



Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 2:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #1

Post by Dan Cooper » Mon Jan 11, 2016 2:02 am

Fire has predictably fallen back to the pack.
It's still a tight race at the top.
Every engine has suffered at least one loss.
51.1% draw rate for the tournament so far.
Hopefully no 10 results on the next 28 return matches.

Post Reply