8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 3:15 am

8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Dan Cooper »

Intel 5960X @ 4.5Ghz
ChessGUI
8192MB Hash
6-piece Nalimov/Syzygy EGTB on SSD
Private opening book (variable 2-17 move book-exit)
4 cycles (224 games)

Contempt changes
All engines with contempt set to 0

Participants
Komodo 9.3
Stockfish 7 Beta 2
Houdini 4 Pro
Fire 4
Andscacs .85
Protector 1.9
Gull 090116
Nirvana 2.2

This will be the format and engines going forward. Komodo and Stockfish versions will rotate each tournament so as to not play games against different versions of themselves.

Games viewable via TLCV/Livius Client
LIZARDTEST.DDNS.NET 16016
Last edited by Dan Cooper on Thu Jan 28, 2016 5:04 am, edited 2 times in total.
Top
Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 3:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Dan Cooper »

Standings after round 7 of 56

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1.   KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C0 S131                    7     6.5    * = 1 1 1 1 1 1 
   2.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C0                  7     4.5    = * = = 1 = = 1 
   3.   FIRE 4 X64                                   7     3.5    0 = * = 1 = = = 
   4.   NIRVANACHESS 2.2                             7     3.0    0 = = * = = = = 
   5.   ANDSCACS 0.85                                7     3.0    0 0 0 = * = 1 1 
   6.   PROTECTOR 1.9.0                              7     3.0    0 = = = = * = = 
   7.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                            7     2.5    0 = = = 0 = * = 
   8.   GULL 090116 BMI2 X64                         7     2.0    0 0 = = 0 = = * 

Total games = 28


   # PLAYER                         : RATING  ERROR   POINTS  PLAYED    (%)   CFS(next)
   1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C0 S131      : 3512.9  174.0      6.5       7   92.9%      99
   2 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C0    : 3208.7  167.8      4.5       7   64.3%      77
   3 Nirvanachess 2.2               : 3130.0  122.6      3.0       7   42.9%      68
   4 Fire 4 x64                     : 3092.4  103.6      3.5       7   50.0%      65
   5 Andscacs 0.85                  : 3054.4  140.8      3.0       7   42.9%      57
   6 Protector 1.9.0                : 3038.6   90.8      3.0       7   42.9%      70
   7 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0  118.4      2.5       7   35.7%      74
   8 Gull 090116 BMI2 x64           : 2941.4  154.9      2.0       7   28.6%     ---
Komodo 9.3 starts off with an impressive 6.5/7!
Top
Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 3:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Dan Cooper »

Standings after round 14 of 56.

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1.   KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C0 S131                   14    11.5    ** == 1= 1= 1= 11 11 11 
   2.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C0                 14     9.0    == ** == =1 == 1= =1 1= 
   3.   FIRE 4 X64                                  14     8.0    0= == ** == == 1= =1 =1 
   4.   NIRVANACHESS 2.2                            14     6.5    0= =0 == ** == == =1 == 
   5.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                           14     6.5    0= == == == ** 0= =1 == 
   6.   ANDSCACS 0.85                               14     6.0    00 0= 0= == 1= ** =0 11 
   7.   PROTECTOR 1.9.0                             14     4.5    00 =0 =0 =0 =0 =1 ** == 
   8.   GULL 090116 BMI2 X64                        14     4.0    00 0= =0 == == 00 == ** 

Total games = 56

   # PLAYER                         : RATING  ERROR    POINTS  PLAYED     (%)   CFS(next)
   1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C0 S131      : 3273.5  146.4      11.5      14   82.1%      94    
   2 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C0    : 3124.6   98.8       9.0      14   64.3%      77    
   3 Fire 4 x64                     : 3073.7   89.9       8.0      14   57.1%      88    
   4 Nirvanachess 2.2               : 3000.0   83.2       6.5      14   46.4%      50    
   5 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0   83.1       6.5      14   46.4%      66    
   6 Andscacs 0.85                  : 2975.5   82.9       6.0      14   42.9%      87    
   7 Protector 1.9.0                : 2899.2   97.6       4.5      14   32.1%      65    
   8 Gull 090116 BMI2 x64           : 2872.1  101.5       4.0      14   28.6%     ---
Top
Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 3:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Dan Cooper »

Standings after round 21 of 56.

Komodo 9.3 has a commanding lead.
Stockfish 7 lost on time to Fire.

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1.   KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C0 S131                   21    16.0    *** ==1 1=1 11= 1== 1== 11= 11= 
   2.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C0                 21    12.5    ==0 *** ==0 1== =1= ==1 =11 1== 
   3.   FIRE 4 X64                                  21    12.0    0=0 ==1 *** 1== === === =1= =11 
   4.   ANDSCACS 0.85                               21    10.0    00= 0== 0== *** === 1=1 =0= 11= 
   5.   NIRVANACHESS 2.2                            21     9.5    0== =0= === === *** ==0 =1= === 
   6.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                           21     9.5    0== ==0 === 0=0 ==1 *** =1= === 
   7.   PROTECTOR 1.9.0                             21     7.5    00= =00 =0= =1= =0= =0= *** === 
   8.   GULL 090116 BMI2 X64                        21     7.0    00= 0== =00 00= === === === *** 

Total games = 84

   # PLAYER                         : RATING  ERROR    POINTS  PLAYED     (%)   CFS(next)
   1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C0 S131      : 3217.1   96.3      16.0      21   76.2%      97    
   2 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C0    : 3094.7   75.0      12.5      21   59.5%      61    
   3 Fire 4 x64                     : 3078.2   73.3      12.0      21   57.1%      88    
   4 Andscacs 0.85                  : 3015.7   66.0      10.0      21   47.6%      51    
   5 Nirvanachess 2.2               : 3014.8   67.8       9.5      21   45.2%      61    
   6 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0   67.2       9.5      21   45.2%      89    
   7 Protector 1.9.0                : 2934.7   72.0       7.5      21   35.7%      62    
   8 Gull 090116 BMI2 x64           : 2918.2   81.8       7.0      21   33.3%     ---
Top
Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 3:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Dan Cooper »

Standings after round 28 of 56

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1.   KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C0 S131                   28    20.5    **** ==10 1=11 1=== 1=== 11=1 11== 11=1 
   2.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C0                 28    17.5    ==01 **** ==0= ==1= =1== 1==1 =11= 1==1 
   3.   FIRE 4 X64                                  28    14.5    0=00 ==1= **** ==== ==== 1==0 =1== =11= 
   4.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                           28    14.0    0=== ==0= ==== **** ==11 0=01 =1== ==== 
   5.   NIRVANACHESS 2.2                            28    12.5    0=== =0== ==== ==00 **** ==== =1=1 ===0 
   6.   ANDSCACS 0.85                               28    11.5    00=0 0==0 0==1 1=10 ==== **** =0=0 11=0 
   7.   PROTECTOR 1.9.0                             28    11.0    00== =00= =0== =0== =0=0 =1=1 **** ==== 
   8.   GULL 090116 BMI2 X64                        28    10.5    00=0 0==0 =00= ==== ===1 00=1 ==== **** 

Total games = 112


   # PLAYER                         : RATING  ERROR    POINTS  PLAYED     (%)   CFS(next)
   1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C0 S131      : 3160.1   81.9      20.5      28   73.2%      91    
   2 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C0    : 3082.6   69.3      17.5      28   62.5%      91    
   3 Fire 4 x64                     : 3011.6   66.7      14.5      28   51.8%      59    
   4 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0   67.1      14.0      28   50.0%      75    
   5 Nirvanachess 2.2               : 2965.1   66.8      12.5      28   44.6%      68    
   6 Andscacs 0.85                  : 2941.6   65.1      11.5      28   41.1%      59    
   7 Protector 1.9.0                : 2929.7   67.7      11.0      28   39.3%      59    
   8 Gull 090116 BMI2 x64           : 2917.7   68.2      10.5      28   37.5%     ---
Top
User avatar
Graham Banks
Posts: 41423
Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2006 10:52 am
Location: Auckland, NZ

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Graham Banks »

Nice lead for Komodo. The second half should be interesting. :)
gbanksnz at gmail.com
Top
Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 3:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Dan Cooper »

Standings after round 35 of 56

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1     2     3     4     5     6     7     8     
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1.   KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C0 S131                   35    25.0    ***** ==10= 1==== 1=111 11==1 11=1= 1==== 11=1= 
   2.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C0                 35    21.0    ==01= ***** ==1== ==0== =11=0 1==11 =1==1 1==10 
   3.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                           35    18.0    0==== ==0== ***** ====1 =1=== 0=010 ==111 ===== 
   4.   FIRE 4 X64                                  35    17.0    0=000 ==1== ====0 ***** =1==0 1==0= ====1 =11== 
   5.   PROTECTOR 1.9.0                             35    16.0    00==0 =00=1 =0=== =0==1 ***** =1=11 =0=0= ====1 
   6.   ANDSCACS 0.85                               35    15.0    00=0= 0==00 1=101 0==1= =0=00 ***** ===== 11=01 
   7.   NIRVANACHESS 2.2                            35    14.5    0==== =0==0 ==000 ====0 =1=1= ===== ***** ===0= 
   8.   GULL 090116 BMI2 X64                        35    13.5    00=0= 0==01 ===== =00== ====0 00=10 ===1= ***** 

Total games = 140


   # PLAYER                         : RATING  ERROR    POINTS  PLAYED     (%)   CFS(next)
   1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C0 S131      : 3136.6   72.6      25.0      35   71.4%      94    
   2 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C0    : 3056.5   64.0      21.0      35   60.0%      87    
   3 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0   62.2      18.0      35   51.4%      66    
   4 Fire 4 x64                     : 2981.2   60.0      17.0      35   48.6%      65    
   5 Protector 1.9.0                : 2962.5   62.7      16.0      35   45.7%      63    
   6 Nirvanachess 2.2               : 2945.7   65.5      14.5      35   41.4%      51    
   7 Andscacs 0.85                  : 2944.3   65.0      15.0      35   42.9%      71    
   8 Gull 090116 BMI2 x64           : 2915.8   66.3      13.5      35   38.6%     ---
Stockfish lost on time again.
Protector with the upset of the tournament so far.

[pgn]
[Event "Top 8 Octo RR 2016 #2"]
[Site "KMLHT"]
[Date "2016.02.06"]
[Round "32.3"]
[White "Protector 1.9.0"]
[Black "Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C0"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "A05"]
[PlyCount "131"]
[EventDate "2016.??.??"]
[TimeControl "40/2400:40/2400:40/2400"]

{Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-5960X CPU @ 4.50GHz} 1. Nf3 {0/1 0s} Nf6 {0/1 0s} 2. c4 {
0/1 0s} c5 {0/1 0s} 3. d4 {0/1 0s} e6 {0/1 0s} 4. d5 {0/1 0s} exd5 {0/1 0s} 5.
cxd5 {0/1 0s} d6 {0/1 0s} 6. Nc3 {0/1 0s} g6 {0/1 0s} 7. e4 {0/1 0s} Bg7 {
0/1 0s} 8. Nd2 {0/1 0s} O-O {0/1 0s} 9. Be2 {0/1 0s} Re8 {0/1 0s} 10. O-O {
0/1 0s} Na6 {0/1 0s} 11. f3 {0/1 0s} Nc7 {0/1 0s} 12. a4 {0/1 0s} Nd7 {0/1 0s}
13. Kh1 {0/1 0s} b6 {0/1 0s} 14. Nc4 {0/1 0s} Ne5 {0/1 0s} 15. Ne3 {0/1 0s} Rb8
{-35/30 3:17m} 16. Bd2 {151 76/22 (Ra3)} Qe7 {-39/29 3:3m (Qe7)} 17. f4 {
75 69/21 (Rb1)} Nd7 {-38/31 1:55m (Nd7)} 18. Bd3 {82 76/24 (Bd3)} Ba6 {
-58/30 1:15m (Ba6)} 19. Bxa6 {75 67/25 (Bxa6)} Nxa6 {-66/28 13s (Nxa6)} 20.
Nc4 {73 88/24 (Nc4)} Red8 {-73/33 5:17m (Rf8)} 21. Qf3 {77 111/26 (Qf3)} Nb4
{-72/34 1:31m (Nb4)} 22. Nb5 {66 103/24} a6 {-92/29 15s (a6)} 23. Na7 {103 105/
27 (Na7)} Nf6 {-91/34 50s (Nf6)} 24. Bxb4 {73 107/27 (Bxb4)} cxb4 {-87/34
21s (cxb4)} 25. Nc6 {70 97/28 (Nc6)} Qxe4 {-96/34 46s (Qxe4)} 26. Nxb8 {
77 99/26 (Nxb8)} Qxf3 {-104/33 55s (Rxb8)} 27. Rxf3 {146 92/29 (Rxf3)} Rxb8 {
-91/33 15s (Rxb8)} 28. Nxd6 {63 107/27 (Nxd6)} Rd8 {-99/36 5:51m (Nxd5)} 29.
Nc4 {67 98/29 (Nc4)} Rxd5 {-108/35 36s (Rxd5)} 30. g3 {406 119/28 (g3)} Nd7 {
-109/30 9s (Rc5)} 31. Rff1 {70 151/27 (a5)} Rc5 {-125/32 50s (Rc5)} 32. Rac1 {
102 143/29 (Rac1)} Rc7 {-120/35 1:34m (Rc7)} 33. Rfd1 {60 151/30 (Kg2)} a5 {
-125/35 2:47m (a5)} 34. b3 {69 153/30 (Kg2)} Bf8 {-130/33 1:5m (Bf8)} 35. Rd5
{152/27 53s (Kg2)} Rb7 {-127/33 39s (Be7)} 36. Rb5 {135 151/29 (Rb5)} Rc7 {
-127/31 20s (Rc7)} 37. Kg2 {63 151/28 (Kg2)} h5 {-129/35 3:4m (Kg7)} 38. f5 {
60 157/26 (Rd5)} Kg7 {-139/31 29s (Be7)} 39. h4 {81 152/25 (fxg6)} Be7 {
-141/31 38s (Be7)} 40. fxg6 {183/27 42s (fxg6)} fxg6 {-213/31 1:50m (fxg6)} 41.
Rd5 {213/25 53s (Rd5)} Kg8 {-222/33 58s (Kf6)} 42. Re1 {218/24 40s (Re1)} Bf8 {
-228/34 58s (Bc5)} 43. Rf1 {228/24 39s (Rf1)} Be7 {-243/34 1:13m (Be7)} 44. Rf3
{262/26 45s (Rf3)} Bf8 {-276/36 5:1m (Bf8)} 45. Rd4 {309/27 55s (Rd2)} Bc5 {
-285/35 1:51m (Bc5)} 46. Rdf4 {336/29 42s (Rd1)} Rc8 {-313/33 1:12m (Rc8)} 47.
g4 {72 372/27 (g4)} hxg4 {-343/37 2:36m (Rf8)} 48. Rxg4 {361 479/30 (Rxg4)}
Rc6 {-397/36 1:30m (Re8)} 49. h5 {501/27 45s (h5)} Kg7 {-411/30 10s (Bf8)} 50.
Rgf4 {518/27 34s (Rd3)} Kg8 {-420/33 51s (Nf8)} 51. h6 {61 544/27 (Rg3)} Re6 {
-443/31 1:57m (Re6)} 52. Rf7 {71 556/27 (Rf7)} Nf8 {-465/24 28s (Nf8)} 53.
Rxf8+ {554/27 35s (Rb7)} Bxf8 {-497/33 1:20m (Bxf8)} 54. h7+ {565/26 44s (h7)}
Kxh7 {-519/30 9s (Kxh7)} 55. Rxf8 {92 592/27 (Rxf8)} Re2+ {-582/34 2:44m (Re2)
} 56. Rf2 {94 596/27 (Rf2)} Re1 {-617/26 12s (Re6)} 57. Rf6 {61 647/25 (Nxb6)
} Re2+ {-735/28 40s (Rb1)} 58. Kf1 {683/24 50s (Kf1)} Re8 {-1065/30 2:13m (Ra2)
} 59. Rxb6 {81 756/24 (Rxb6)} Ra8 {-1169/29 59s (Rf8)} 60. Rb5 {798/23 37s
(Rb5)} Rf8+ {-1294/28 48s (Rf8)} 61. Ke2 {912/26 56s (Kg2)} Rf4 {-2511/31 3:
46m (Kh6)} 62. Rxa5 {939/28 34s (Nxa5)} Kh6 {-3801/28 50s (Re4)} 63. Rb5 {
345 1386/30 (Rb5)} g5 {-6373/34 56s (Rf8)} 64. a5 {1736/22 26s (a5)} Re4+ {
-12337/32 42s (Re4)} 65. Kf3 {234 30878/23 (Kd3)} Rf4+ {-12343/38 25s (Rf4)}
66. Kg3 {GUI adjudication} 1-0
[/pgn]
Top
Jouni
Posts: 3283
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Jouni »

SF doesn't lose with time. BTW is STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C0 slow abrok compile?
Jouni
Top
Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 3:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Dan Cooper »

Jouni wrote:SF doesn't lose with time.
Apparently it does.
Top
Dan Cooper
Posts: 184
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2015 3:15 am

Re: 8 CPU, 8 engine, 40/40 2016 tournament #2

Post by Dan Cooper »

Standings after round 42 of 56

Code: Select all

 RANK   ENGINE                                    GAMES  POINTS   1      2      3      4      5      6      7      8      
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1.   KOMODO 9.3 64-BIT C0 S131                   42    29.5    ****** ==10== 1===== 1=111= 1===== 11==1= 11=1=1 11=1=1 
   2.   STOCKFISH 7BETA2 64 BMI2 C0                 42    25.0    ==01== ****** ==1=== ==0=== =1==1= =11=01 1==11= 1==10= 
   3.   HOUDINI 4 PRO X64                           42    21.5    0===== ==0=== ****** ====10 ==111= =1===1 0=010= ====== 
   4.   FIRE 4 X64                                  42    21.0    0=000= ==1=== ====01 ****** ====1= =1==00 1==0=1 =11=== 
   5.   NIRVANACHESS 2.2                            42    19.5    0===== =0==0= ==000= ====0= ****** =1=1=1 =====1 ===0=1 
   6.   PROTECTOR 1.9.0                             42    18.5    00==0= =00=10 =0===0 =0==11 =0=0=0 ****** =1=11= ====1= 
   7.   ANDSCACS 0.85                               42    16.5    00=0=0 0==00= 1=101= 0==1=0 =====0 =0=00= ****** 11=010 
   8.   GULL 090116 BMI2 X64                        42    16.5    00=0=0 0==01= ====== =00=== ===1=0 ====0= 00=101 ****** 

Total games = 168


   # PLAYER                         : RATING  ERROR    POINTS  PLAYED     (%)   CFS(next)
   1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit C0 S131      : 3129.8   65.6      29.5      42   70.2%      95    
   2 Stockfish 7Beta2 64 BMI2 C0    : 3054.8   58.6      25.0      42   59.5%      89    
   3 Houdini 4 Pro x64              : 3000.0   56.2      21.5      42   51.2%      57    
   4 Fire 4 x64                     : 2992.2   56.6      21.0      42   50.0%      70    
   5 Nirvanachess 2.2               : 2969.0   56.8      19.5      42   46.4%      64    
   6 Protector 1.9.0                : 2953.4   56.4      18.5      42   44.0%      77    
   7 Gull 090116 BMI2 x64           : 2921.8   58.0      16.5      42   39.3%      50    
   8 Andscacs 0.85                  : 2921.8   58.0      16.5      42   39.3%     ---
Will likely be replaying Stockfish-Protector and Fire-Gull openings for fairness reasons.
Top

Return to “Computer Chess Club: Tournaments and Matches”