Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.
Moderators: hgm , Rebel , chrisw
fastgm
Posts: 818Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 6:57 pm
Post by fastgm Thu Feb 01, 2018 11:22 pm
First result after
1000 games :
Code: Select all
# Engine : Elo Error Games Points (%) W D L D(%) CFS
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Stockfish 9 64 : 3395 35 1000 935.0 93.50 881 108 11 10.80 83
2 asmFish 171004 x64 : 3377 8 15516 14425.5 92.97 13480 1891 145 12.19 95
3 Houdini 6 x64 : 3367 9 15516 14369.5 92.61 13448 1843 225 11.88 100
4 Komodo 11.2 64-bit : 3334 8 15516 14183.5 91.41 13195 1977 344 12.74 55
5 Stockfish 8 64 : 3333 8 15500 14172.5 91.44 13077 2191 232 14.14 100
6 Fire 6.1 x64 : 3151 6 15516 12689.0 81.78 10979 3420 1117 22.04 100
7 Deep Shredder 13 x64 : 3129 6 15516 12452.5 80.26 10645 3615 1256 23.30 100
8 Fizbo 2 : 3049 6 15516 11475.5 73.96 9852 3247 2417 20.93 99
9 Roc 0.8 x64 : 3040 6 15516 11358.0 73.20 9419 3878 2219 24.99 97
10 Andscacs 0.92 : 3032 6 15516 11258.5 72.56 9350 3817 2349 24.60 51
11 Gull 3 x64 : 3032 6 15516 11256.5 72.55 9248 4017 2251 25.89 100
12 Fritz 16 : 3009 6 15516 10940.0 70.51 8947 3986 2583 25.69 100
13 Critter 1.6a 64-bit : 2993 5 15516 10702.5 68.98 8495 4415 2606 28.45 51
14 Equinox 3.30 x64mp : 2993 5 15516 10701.5 68.97 8528 4347 2641 28.02 62
15 Chiron 4 64bit : 2992 6 15516 10684.0 68.86 8704 3960 2852 25.52 97
16 Mars 3.35 x64 : 2985 5 15516 10579.0 68.18 8445 4268 2803 27.51 100
17 Booot 6.2 x64 : 2962 5 15516 10239.5 65.99 7983 4513 3020 29.09 84
18 Nirvanachess 2.4 : 2958 5 15516 10181.5 65.62 7943 4477 3096 28.85 100
19 Texel 1.07 : 2934 5 15516 9802.0 63.17 7825 3954 3737 25.48 85
20 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 : 2930 5 15516 9740.5 62.78 7544 4393 3579 28.31 99
21 Senpai 2.0 : 2921 5 15516 9595.5 61.84 7431 4329 3756 27.90 91
22 Hannibal 1.7 x64 : 2916 5 15516 9514.5 61.32 7304 4421 3791 28.49 100
23 iCE 3.0 v658 x64 : 2900 5 15516 9261.0 59.69 7124 4274 4118 27.55 95
24 Protector 1.9.0 : 2894 5 15516 9161.5 59.05 6915 4493 4108 28.96 85
25 Laser 1.5 : 2890 5 15517 9096.5 58.62 6977 4239 4301 27.32 100
26 Nemorino 4.00 : 2881 5 15517 8935.5 57.59 6646 4579 4292 29.51 100
27 Pedone 1.7 : 2859 5 15517 8570.5 55.23 6236 4669 4612 30.09 100
28 Sting SF 8.9 64bit : 2837 5 15516 8191.0 52.79 6032 4318 5166 27.83 63
29 SmarThink 1.97 : 2835 5 15516 8170.0 52.66 6424 3492 5600 22.51 77
30 Arasan 20.3 : 2833 5 15516 8124.0 52.36 5998 4252 5266 27.40 100
31 Naum 4.6 : 2819 5 15516 7893.0 50.87 5709 4368 5439 28.15 59
32 Vajolet2 2.5 : 2818 5 15517 7878.5 50.77 5655 4447 5415 28.66 100
33 Wasp 2.6 : 2779 5 15516 7196.5 46.38 4910 4573 6033 29.47 100
34 Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC : 2758 5 15516 6840.0 44.08 4793 4094 6629 26.39 53
35 Bobcat v8.0 : 2758 5 15516 6836.0 44.06 4654 4364 6498 28.13 80
36 Rodent III 0.240 : 2755 5 15517 6783.0 43.71 4514 4538 6465 29.25 66
37 Hakkapeliitta 3.0 x64 : 2753 5 15516 6756.0 43.54 4990 3532 6994 22.76 87
38 Alfil 15.8.16 : 2749 5 15516 6684.0 43.08 4584 4200 6732 27.07 100
39 Amoeba 2.7 : 2725 5 15516 6269.5 40.41 4104 4331 7081 27.91 87
40 Demolito 2017-08-26 : 2721 5 15516 6200.5 39.96 4099 4203 7214 27.09 84
41 Crafty 25.2 : 2717 5 15516 6141.0 39.58 4251 3780 7485 24.36 79
42 Spark 1.0 : 2714 5 15516 6091.0 39.26 3993 4196 7327 27.04 88
43 Cheng 4.39 : 2710 5 15516 6018.5 38.79 4098 3841 7577 24.76 94
44 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 : 2704 5 15516 5921.5 38.16 3945 3953 7618 25.48 68
45 Toga II 4.0 : 2703 5 15517 5893.5 37.98 3952 3883 7682 25.02 100
46 DiscoCheck 5.2 : 2679 5 15516 5501.5 35.46 3617 3769 8130 24.29 99
47 Ethereal 8.61 : 2670 5 15516 5356.0 34.52 3409 3894 8213 25.10 73
48 Spike 1.4 : 2668 5 15516 5318.0 34.27 3445 3746 8325 24.14 70
49 Quazar 0.4 x64 : 2666 5 15516 5287.0 34.07 3395 3784 8337 24.39 52
50 Murka 3 x64 : 2666 5 15516 5284.0 34.06 3293 3982 8241 25.66 100
51 Daydreamer 2.0.0-pre2 : 2638 5 15516 4845.5 31.23 3012 3667 8837 23.63 84
52 Gaviota v1.0 : 2635 5 15516 4789.5 30.87 3104 3371 9041 21.73 55
53 Fruit reloaded 3.2.1 x64 : 2634 5 15517 4782.0 30.82 2878 3808 8831 24.54 100
54 MinkoChess 1.3 x64 : 2613 5 15516 4459.0 28.74 2676 3566 9274 22.98 97
55 Deuterium v14.3.34.130 : 2606 6 15516 4345.0 28.00 2580 3530 9406 22.75 100
56 Loop 2007 64-Bit : 2561 6 15516 3697.5 23.83 2071 3253 10192 20.97 100
57 Tornado 8.0 : 2543 5 15516 3460.5 22.30 2039 2843 10634 18.32 96
58 RuyDos 1.0.29 : 2536 6 15516 3368.5 21.71 1888 2961 10667 19.08 96
59 Deep Junior Yokohama : 2529 6 15516 3276.0 21.11 2031 2490 10995 16.05 64
60 Pawny 1.2 x64 : 2528 6 15516 3258.0 21.00 1783 2950 10783 19.01 69
61 Octochess r5190 : 2526 6 15516 3231.0 20.82 1710 3042 10764 19.61 97
62 The Baron 3.41 64-bits : 2518 6 15517 3131.0 20.18 1763 2736 11018 17.63 98
63 Jonny 4.00 : 2510 6 15516 3029.0 19.52 1746 2566 11204 16.54 100
64 Cheese 1.9.1 64 bits : 2479 6 15516 2662.0 17.16 1439 2446 11631 15.76 ---
White advantage = 34.69 +/- 0.49
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 34.93 % +/- 0.09.
fastgm
Posts: 818Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 6:57 pm
Post by fastgm Fri Feb 02, 2018 7:13 am
After
3500 games :
Code: Select all
# Engine : Elo Error Games Points (%) W D L D(%) CFS
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Stockfish 9 64 : 3403 20 3500 3279.0 93.69 3097 364 39 10.40 99
2 asmFish 171004 x64 : 3377 9 15557 14446.0 92.86 13487 1918 152 12.33 95
3 Houdini 6 x64 : 3367 9 15557 14389.5 92.50 13453 1873 231 12.04 100
4 Stockfish 8 64 : 3333 8 15500 14172.5 91.44 13077 2191 232 14.14 52
5 Komodo 11.2 64-bit : 3333 8 15556 14193.5 91.24 13197 1993 366 12.81 100
6 Fire 6.1 x64 : 3151 6 15557 12697.5 81.62 10979 3437 1141 22.09 100
7 Deep Shredder 13 x64 : 3129 6 15556 12460.0 80.10 10647 3626 1283 23.31 100
8 Fizbo 2 : 3049 6 15557 11484.0 73.82 9856 3256 2445 20.93 99
9 Roc 0.8 x64 : 3040 6 15557 11367.0 73.07 9420 3894 2243 25.03 97
10 Andscacs 0.92 : 3032 6 15557 11261.5 72.39 9351 3821 2385 24.56 50
11 Gull 3 x64 : 3032 5 15556 11261.0 72.39 9249 4024 2283 25.87 100
12 Fritz 16 : 3009 5 15557 10942.0 70.33 8947 3990 2620 25.65 100
13 Critter 1.6a 64-bit : 2993 5 15556 10705.5 68.82 8496 4419 2641 28.41 51
14 Equinox 3.30 x64mp : 2993 5 15556 10704.0 68.81 8528 4352 2676 27.98 63
15 Chiron 4 64bit : 2992 5 15556 10686.0 68.69 8704 3964 2888 25.48 96
16 Mars 3.35 x64 : 2985 5 15556 10583.5 68.03 8445 4277 2834 27.49 100
17 Booot 6.2 x64 : 2962 5 15556 10242.5 65.84 7983 4519 3054 29.05 84
18 Nirvanachess 2.4 : 2958 5 15557 10185.5 65.47 7943 4485 3129 28.83 100
19 Texel 1.07 : 2934 5 15557 9804.5 63.02 7825 3959 3773 25.45 85
20 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 : 2930 5 15556 9742.5 62.63 7544 4397 3615 28.27 99
21 Senpai 2.0 : 2921 5 15557 9597.5 61.69 7431 4333 3793 27.85 92
22 Hannibal 1.7 x64 : 2916 5 15556 9515.0 61.17 7304 4422 3830 28.43 100
23 iCE 3.0 v658 x64 : 2900 5 15556 9261.5 59.54 7124 4275 4157 27.48 96
24 Protector 1.9.0 : 2894 5 15556 9161.5 58.89 6915 4493 4148 28.88 85
25 Laser 1.5 : 2890 5 15557 9098.5 58.48 6978 4241 4338 27.26 100
26 Nemorino 4.00 : 2881 5 15557 8936.5 57.44 6646 4581 4330 29.45 100
27 Pedone 1.7 : 2859 5 15557 8574.0 55.11 6236 4676 4645 30.06 100
28 Sting SF 8.9 64bit : 2837 5 15557 8191.5 52.65 6032 4319 5206 27.76 63
29 SmarThink 1.97 : 2835 5 15556 8171.0 52.53 6424 3494 5638 22.46 77
30 Arasan 20.3 : 2833 5 15557 8126.5 52.24 5999 4255 5303 27.35 100
31 Naum 4.6 : 2819 5 15556 7894.5 50.75 5709 4371 5476 28.10 60
32 Vajolet2 2.5 : 2818 5 15557 7878.5 50.64 5655 4447 5455 28.59 100
33 Wasp 2.6 : 2779 5 15557 7197.5 46.27 4910 4575 6072 29.41 100
34 Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC : 2758 5 15556 6841.5 43.98 4793 4097 6666 26.34 54
35 Bobcat v8.0 : 2758 5 15556 6836.0 43.94 4654 4364 6538 28.05 81
36 Rodent III 0.240 : 2755 5 15557 6783.5 43.60 4514 4539 6504 29.18 65
37 Hakkapeliitta 3.0 x64 : 2754 5 15556 6759.0 43.45 4990 3538 7028 22.74 88
38 Alfil 15.8.16 : 2749 5 15557 6685.0 42.97 4584 4202 6771 27.01 100
39 Amoeba 2.7 : 2725 5 15557 6270.0 40.30 4104 4332 7121 27.85 86
40 Demolito 2017-08-26 : 2721 5 15557 6202.5 39.87 4099 4207 7251 27.04 84
41 Crafty 25.2 : 2717 5 15556 6142.5 39.49 4252 3781 7523 24.31 79
42 Spark 1.0 : 2714 5 15556 6091.0 39.16 3993 4196 7367 26.97 87
43 Cheng 4.39 : 2710 5 15556 6020.0 38.70 4098 3844 7614 24.71 95
44 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 : 2704 5 15556 5922.5 38.07 3945 3955 7656 25.42 67
45 Toga II 4.0 : 2703 5 15557 5894.5 37.89 3953 3883 7721 24.96 100
46 DiscoCheck 5.2 : 2679 5 15556 5502.0 35.37 3617 3770 8169 24.24 99
47 Ethereal 8.61 : 2670 5 15557 5356.0 34.43 3409 3894 8254 25.03 73
48 Spike 1.4 : 2668 5 15556 5319.0 34.19 3445 3748 8363 24.09 70
49 Quazar 0.4 x64 : 2666 5 15556 5287.5 33.99 3395 3785 8376 24.33 52
50 Murka 3 x64 : 2666 5 15556 5285.0 33.97 3293 3984 8279 25.61 100
51 Daydreamer 2.0.0-pre2 : 2638 5 15556 4846.0 31.15 3012 3668 8876 23.58 83
52 Gaviota v1.0 : 2635 5 15556 4790.5 30.80 3104 3373 9079 21.68 55
53 Fruit reloaded 3.2.1 x64 : 2634 5 15557 4783.0 30.75 2878 3810 8869 24.49 100
54 MinkoChess 1.3 x64 : 2613 5 15556 4459.5 28.67 2676 3567 9313 22.93 98
55 Deuterium v14.3.34.130 : 2606 5 15556 4345.0 27.93 2580 3530 9446 22.69 100
56 Loop 2007 64-Bit : 2561 5 15556 3698.5 23.78 2071 3255 10230 20.92 100
57 Tornado 8.0 : 2543 5 15556 3460.5 22.25 2039 2843 10674 18.28 96
58 RuyDos 1.0.29 : 2536 6 15557 3369.0 21.66 1888 2962 10707 19.04 96
59 Deep Junior Yokohama : 2529 6 15556 3276.5 21.06 2031 2491 11034 16.01 64
60 Pawny 1.2 x64 : 2528 6 15557 3258.0 20.94 1783 2950 10824 18.96 69
61 Octochess r5190 : 2526 6 15556 3231.5 20.77 1710 3043 10803 19.56 97
62 The Baron 3.41 64-bits : 2518 6 15557 3131.5 20.13 1763 2737 11057 17.59 97
63 Jonny 4.00 : 2510 6 15556 3029.0 19.47 1746 2566 11244 16.50 100
64 Cheese 1.9.1 64 bits : 2479 6 15557 2662.5 17.11 1439 2447 11671 15.73 ---
White advantage = 34.74 +/- 0.49
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 34.95 % +/- 0.09.
fastgm
Posts: 818Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 6:57 pm
Post by fastgm Fri Feb 02, 2018 8:22 pm
Halfway after
7750 games :
Code: Select all
# Engine : Elo Error Games Points (%) W D L D(%) CFS
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Stockfish 9 64 : 3402 13 7750 7260.0 93.68 6856 808 86 10.43 100
2 asmFish 171004 x64 : 3377 9 15625 14477.0 92.65 13492 1970 163 12.61 94
3 Houdini 6 x64 : 3368 9 15625 14424.5 92.32 13467 1915 243 12.26 100
4 Stockfish 8 64 : 3334 8 15500 14172.5 91.44 13077 2191 232 14.14 58
5 Komodo 11.2 64-bit : 3332 8 15625 14216.0 90.98 13202 2028 395 12.98 100
6 Fire 6.1 x64 : 3151 6 15625 12709.0 81.34 10980 3458 1187 22.13 100
7 Deep Shredder 13 x64 : 3129 6 15625 12473.0 79.83 10649 3648 1328 23.35 100
8 Fizbo 2 : 3049 5 15625 11495.5 73.57 9859 3273 2493 20.95 99
9 Roc 0.8 x64 : 3040 6 15625 11378.0 72.82 9421 3914 2290 25.05 98
10 Gull 3 x64 : 3032 6 15625 11268.5 72.12 9250 4037 2338 25.84 50
11 Andscacs 0.92 : 3032 6 15625 11268.0 72.12 9352 3832 2441 24.52 100
12 Fritz 16 : 3009 5 15625 10948.5 70.07 8948 4001 2676 25.61 100
13 Critter 1.6a 64-bit : 2993 5 15625 10711.5 68.55 8497 4429 2699 28.35 53
14 Equinox 3.30 x64mp : 2993 6 15625 10707.5 68.53 8528 4359 2738 27.90 61
15 Chiron 4 64bit : 2992 5 15625 10691.0 68.42 8704 3974 2947 25.43 96
16 Mars 3.35 x64 : 2985 5 15625 10591.0 67.78 8446 4290 2889 27.46 100
17 Booot 6.2 x64 : 2962 5 15625 10244.5 65.56 7984 4521 3120 28.93 82
18 Nirvanachess 2.4 : 2958 5 15625 10191.0 65.22 7944 4494 3187 28.76 100
19 Texel 1.07 : 2934 5 15625 9809.5 62.78 7827 3965 3833 25.38 86
20 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 : 2930 5 15625 9748.0 62.39 7545 4406 3674 28.20 99
21 Senpai 2.0 : 2921 5 15625 9602.5 61.46 7432 4341 3852 27.78 91
22 Hannibal 1.7 x64 : 2916 5 15625 9519.5 60.92 7305 4429 3891 28.35 100
23 iCE 3.0 v658 x64 : 2901 5 15625 9268.0 59.32 7124 4288 4213 27.44 96
24 Protector 1.9.0 : 2894 5 15625 9165.0 58.66 6915 4500 4210 28.80 85
25 Laser 1.5 : 2890 5 15625 9102.0 58.25 6978 4248 4399 27.19 100
26 Nemorino 4.00 : 2881 5 15625 8939.5 57.21 6647 4585 4393 29.34 100
27 Pedone 1.7 : 2859 5 15625 8577.5 54.90 6236 4683 4706 29.97 100
28 Sting SF 8.9 64bit : 2837 5 15625 8193.0 52.44 6032 4322 5271 27.66 63
29 SmarThink 1.97 : 2835 5 15625 8173.0 52.31 6424 3498 5703 22.39 77
30 Arasan 20.3 : 2833 5 15625 8128.0 52.02 5999 4258 5368 27.25 100
31 Naum 4.6 : 2819 5 15625 7896.5 50.54 5709 4375 5541 28.00 59
32 Vajolet2 2.5 : 2819 5 15625 7882.0 50.44 5655 4454 5516 28.51 100
33 Wasp 2.6 : 2779 5 15625 7198.5 46.07 4910 4577 6138 29.29 100
34 Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC : 2758 5 15625 6842.5 43.79 4793 4099 6733 26.23 53
35 Bobcat v8.0 : 2758 5 15625 6837.5 43.76 4654 4367 6604 27.95 81
36 Rodent III 0.240 : 2755 5 15625 6784.5 43.42 4514 4541 6570 29.06 66
37 Hakkapeliitta 3.0 x64 : 2754 5 15625 6760.0 43.26 4990 3540 7095 22.66 88
38 Alfil 15.8.16 : 2749 5 15625 6687.0 42.80 4584 4206 6835 26.92 100
39 Amoeba 2.7 : 2725 5 15625 6271.0 40.13 4104 4334 7187 27.74 87
40 Demolito 2017-08-26 : 2721 5 15625 6203.5 39.70 4099 4209 7317 26.94 82
41 Crafty 25.2 : 2718 5 15625 6146.0 39.33 4255 3782 7588 24.20 80
42 Spark 1.0 : 2714 5 15625 6092.5 38.99 3993 4199 7433 26.87 87
43 Cheng 4.39 : 2710 5 15625 6020.0 38.53 4098 3844 7683 24.60 94
44 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 : 2704 5 15625 5923.0 37.91 3945 3956 7724 25.32 67
45 Toga II 4.0 : 2703 5 15625 5896.5 37.74 3953 3887 7785 24.88 100
46 DiscoCheck 5.2 : 2679 5 15625 5503.0 35.22 3617 3772 8236 24.14 99
47 Ethereal 8.61 : 2670 5 15625 5358.0 34.29 3409 3898 8318 24.95 74
48 Spike 1.4 : 2668 5 15625 5319.0 34.04 3445 3748 8432 23.99 69
49 Quazar 0.4 x64 : 2666 5 15625 5288.5 33.85 3395 3787 8443 24.24 51
50 Murka 3 x64 : 2666 5 15625 5287.5 33.84 3293 3989 8343 25.53 100
51 Daydreamer 2.0.0-pre2 : 2638 5 15625 4847.0 31.02 3012 3670 8943 23.49 83
52 Gaviota v1.0 : 2635 5 15625 4790.5 30.66 3104 3373 9148 21.59 55
53 Fruit reloaded 3.2.1 x64 : 2634 5 15625 4783.5 30.61 2878 3811 8936 24.39 100
54 MinkoChess 1.3 x64 : 2613 5 15625 4460.0 28.54 2676 3568 9381 22.84 98
55 Deuterium v14.3.34.130 : 2606 5 15625 4346.0 27.81 2580 3532 9513 22.60 100
56 Loop 2007 64-Bit : 2561 5 15625 3700.0 23.68 2071 3258 10296 20.85 100
57 Tornado 8.0 : 2543 6 15625 3460.5 22.15 2039 2843 10743 18.20 96
58 RuyDos 1.0.29 : 2536 6 15625 3369.5 21.56 1888 2963 10774 18.96 95
59 Deep Junior Yokohama : 2529 6 15625 3276.5 20.97 2031 2491 11103 15.94 62
60 Pawny 1.2 x64 : 2528 6 15625 3259.5 20.86 1783 2953 10889 18.90 69
61 Octochess r5190 : 2526 5 15625 3233.0 20.69 1710 3046 10869 19.49 98
62 The Baron 3.41 64-bits : 2518 6 15625 3132.5 20.05 1763 2739 11123 17.53 97
63 Jonny 4.00 : 2510 6 15625 3029.5 19.39 1746 2567 11312 16.43 100
64 Cheese 1.9.1 64 bits : 2479 6 15625 2662.5 17.04 1439 2447 11739 15.66 ---
White advantage = 34.79 +/- 0.48
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 34.98 % +/- 0.09.
fastgm
Posts: 818Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 6:57 pm
Post by fastgm Sat Feb 03, 2018 9:22 pm
Final result:
Stockfish 9 64 (
+71 to Stockfish 8)
http://www.fastgm.de Code: Select all
# Engine : Elo Error Games Points (%) W D L D(%) CFS
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Stockfish 9 64 : 3408 9 15500 14544.5 93.84 13756 1577 167 10.17 100
2 asmFish 171004 x64 : 3379 9 15500 14402.0 92.92 13460 1884 156 12.15 96
3 Houdini 6 x64 : 3368 9 15500 14345.0 92.55 13429 1832 239 11.82 100
4 Komodo 11.2 64-bit : 3334 8 15500 14150.5 91.29 13183 1935 382 12.48 100
5 Fire 6.1 x64 : 3151 6 15500 12674.0 81.77 10976 3396 1128 21.91 100
6 Deep Shredder 13 x64 : 3128 6 15500 12427.5 80.18 10645 3565 1290 23.00 100
7 Fizbo 2 : 3048 6 15500 11453.5 73.89 9841 3225 2434 20.81 97
8 Roc 0.8 x64 : 3040 6 15500 11352.5 73.24 9420 3865 2215 24.94 98
9 Andscacs 0.92 : 3032 6 15500 11243.0 72.54 9350 3786 2364 24.43 54
10 Gull 3 x64 : 3031 5 15500 11237.0 72.50 9249 3976 2275 25.65 100
11 Fritz 16 : 3009 5 15500 10924.0 70.48 8941 3966 2593 25.59 100
12 Critter 1.6a 64-bit : 2993 5 15500 10695.5 69.00 8497 4397 2606 28.37 50
13 Equinox 3.30 x64mp : 2993 5 15500 10695.5 69.00 8526 4339 2635 27.99 69
14 Chiron 4 64bit : 2991 5 15500 10669.0 68.83 8704 3930 2866 25.35 95
15 Mars 3.35 x64 : 2985 5 15500 10577.0 68.24 8446 4262 2792 27.50 100
16 Booot 6.2 x64 : 2962 5 15500 10230.0 66.00 7984 4492 3024 28.98 84
17 Nirvanachess 2.4 : 2958 5 15500 10172.5 65.63 7942 4461 3097 28.78 100
18 Texel 1.07 : 2934 5 15500 9796.5 63.20 7827 3939 3734 25.41 85
19 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 : 2930 5 15500 9733.5 62.80 7543 4381 3576 28.26 99
20 Senpai 2.0 : 2921 5 15500 9598.0 61.92 7433 4330 3737 27.94 94
21 Hannibal 1.7 x64 : 2915 5 15500 9500.5 61.29 7303 4395 3802 28.35 100
22 iCE 3.0 v658 x64 : 2900 5 15500 9247.0 59.66 7123 4248 4129 27.41 94
23 Protector 1.9.0 : 2894 5 15500 9152.5 59.05 6914 4477 4109 28.88 88
24 Laser 1.5 : 2890 5 15500 9083.5 58.60 6978 4211 4311 27.17 100
25 Nemorino 4.00 : 2880 5 15500 8927.0 57.59 6647 4560 4293 29.42 100
26 Pedone 1.7 : 2859 5 15500 8563.5 55.25 6235 4657 4608 30.05 100
27 Sting SF 8.9 64bit : 2836 5 15500 8180.5 52.78 6030 4301 5169 27.75 59
28 SmarThink 1.97 : 2835 5 15500 8166.0 52.68 6423 3486 5591 22.49 78
29 Arasan 20.3 : 2832 5 15500 8119.5 52.38 5997 4245 5258 27.39 100
30 Naum 4.6 : 2819 5 15500 7887.5 50.89 5709 4357 5434 28.11 59
31 Vajolet2 2.5 : 2818 5 15500 7873.5 50.80 5655 4437 5408 28.63 100
32 Wasp 2.6 : 2778 5 15500 7189.5 46.38 4908 4563 6029 29.44 100
33 Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC : 2758 5 15500 6833.5 44.09 4792 4083 6625 26.34 54
34 Bobcat v8.0 : 2757 5 15500 6828.0 44.05 4654 4348 6498 28.05 82
35 Rodent III 0.240 : 2754 5 15500 6772.0 43.69 4514 4516 6470 29.14 61
36 Hakkapeliitta 3.0 x64 : 2753 5 15500 6754.5 43.58 4987 3535 6978 22.81 88
37 Alfil 15.8.16 : 2749 5 15500 6681.5 43.11 4584 4195 6721 27.06 100
38 Amoeba 2.7 : 2724 5 15500 6263.0 40.41 4102 4322 7076 27.88 87
39 Demolito 2017-08-26 : 2720 5 15500 6197.0 39.98 4098 4198 7204 27.08 82
40 Crafty 25.2 : 2717 5 15500 6141.0 39.62 4256 3770 7474 24.32 82
41 Spark 1.0 : 2714 5 15500 6087.5 39.27 3994 4187 7319 27.01 89
42 Cheng 4.39 : 2709 5 15500 6011.5 38.78 4098 3827 7575 24.69 94
43 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 : 2704 5 15500 5919.0 38.19 3945 3948 7607 25.47 68
44 Toga II 4.0 : 2702 5 15500 5892.0 38.01 3953 3878 7669 25.02 100
45 DiscoCheck 5.2 : 2679 5 15500 5500.5 35.49 3616 3769 8115 24.32 99
46 Ethereal 8.61 : 2670 5 15500 5353.0 34.54 3408 3890 8202 25.10 74
47 Spike 1.4 : 2667 5 15500 5313.5 34.28 3445 3737 8318 24.11 68
48 Murka 3 x64 : 2666 5 15500 5286.0 34.10 3293 3986 8221 25.72 50
49 Quazar 0.4 x64 : 2666 5 15500 5285.5 34.10 3395 3781 8324 24.39 100
50 Daydreamer 2.0.0-pre2 : 2638 5 15500 4842.5 31.24 3012 3661 8827 23.62 82
51 Gaviota v1.0 : 2634 5 15500 4786.0 30.88 3104 3364 9032 21.70 53
52 Fruit reloaded 3.2.1 x64 : 2634 5 15500 4781.5 30.85 2878 3807 8815 24.56 100
53 MinkoChess 1.3 x64 : 2613 5 15500 4456.5 28.75 2675 3563 9262 22.99 98
54 Deuterium v14.3.34.130 : 2605 5 15500 4342.5 28.02 2580 3525 9395 22.74 100
55 Loop 2007 64-Bit : 2561 5 15500 3700.5 23.87 2071 3259 10170 21.03 100
56 Tornado 8.0 : 2543 6 15500 3457.0 22.30 2038 2838 10624 18.31 95
57 RuyDos 1.0.29 : 2536 6 15500 3368.5 21.73 1889 2959 10652 19.09 96
58 Deep Junior Yokohama : 2529 5 15500 3276.5 21.14 2031 2491 10978 16.07 64
59 Pawny 1.2 x64 : 2527 6 15500 3258.5 21.02 1783 2951 10766 19.04 70
60 Octochess r5190 : 2525 6 15500 3231.0 20.85 1710 3042 10748 19.63 97
61 The Baron 3.41 64-bits : 2517 6 15500 3128.5 20.18 1763 2731 11006 17.62 97
62 Jonny 4.00 : 2509 6 15500 3028.5 19.54 1746 2565 11189 16.55 100
63 Cheese 1.9.1 64 bits : 2478 6 15500 2661.5 17.17 1439 2445 11616 15.77 ---
White advantage = 34.64 +/- 0.50
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 34.85 % +/- 0.09
Games : 488.250 (finished)
White Wins : 201.153 (41.2 %)
Black Wins : 169.774 (34.8 %)
Draws : 117.323 (24.0 %)
White Score : 53.2 %
Black Score : 46.8 %.
CMCanavessi
Posts: 1142Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2017 4:06 pmLocation: Argentina
Post by CMCanavessi Sat Feb 03, 2018 9:32 pm
That's amazing, +40 to H6...
CheckersGuy
Posts: 273Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2016 9:49 pm
Post by CheckersGuy Sun Feb 04, 2018 3:18 am
I remember when everyone was complaining ( ok, at least some ppl were) that the dev version was only marginally stronger than SF8 and there seemed to be some regression with some of the patches back then.
Happy to see that everything worked out and we had a couple of really good patches now. Hope to see similiar work this year
Jouni
Posts: 3286Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm
Post by Jouni Sun Feb 04, 2018 5:34 pm
There is already +26 ELO patch:
Total: 2260 W: 848 L: 679 D: 733
But only for MV node
.
Jouni
leavenfish
Posts: 282Joined: Mon Sep 02, 2013 8:23 am
Post by leavenfish Sun Feb 04, 2018 6:21 pm
CheckersGuy wrote: I remember when everyone was complaining ( ok, at least some ppl were) that the dev version was only marginally stronger than SF8 and there seemed to be some regression with some of the patches back then.
Happy to see that everything worked out and we had a couple of really good patches now. Hope to see similiar work this year
But those complaints are much closer to reality in a way: Take away contempt...and the 'apples to apples' comparsion leans toward 'marginally stronger'.
Contempt is a 'trick' of sorts for gameplay you might say.
Komodo and
Houdini made use of that previously,
Stockfish simply did not.
Now, let a
non-contempt SF analyse the same positions as a
contempt SF and you have something altogether different. I suppose one could make the argument that Non-Contempt is geared a bit more towards the reality of a position...Contempt is geared towards 'game play' where you play upon the chance to exploit the complicated nature of successive positions that unfold during
gameplay ...and one sides (SF) inherent ability to calculate a bit better than most engines.
Whitness all those draws SF 8 gave up in TCEC vs 'weaker' engines...while K and H scored more wins.
Vizvezdenec
Posts: 52Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2018 1:30 am
Post by Vizvezdenec Sun Feb 04, 2018 6:29 pm
the difference is that sf contempt of 20 doesn't lose any elo vs 0 in selfplay, and even is speculated to give some elo...
Ovyron
Posts: 4556Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2007 4:30 am
Post by Ovyron Sun Feb 04, 2018 7:41 pm
leavenfish wrote: Now, let a non-contempt SF analyse the same positions as a contempt SF and you have something altogether different.
What's the purpose of analysis? To find the best move? And contempt SF is providing better move choices than non-contempt SF, so people analyzing with Contempt=0 are fools that can't accept the new paradigm.
.