LeelaFish w/ Houdini 6 tactical vs LeelaFish w/ SF 2019030520 BMI2

[sincerelybrent]

200 games @ 1' + 1"
Noomen 2-plies TCEC opening book; each engine played both sides
Hash=2497 to each engine
SYZYGY 3-4-5, avail to all engines
Geforce RTX 2070
Intel 8th gen CPUs
Fritz 16 GUI
PGN of the wins


LeelaFish 21 v0.7 nn32930 2CPUs; nnCache = 1000000; CUDNN-fp16
Aux engine: SF 19030520 x64 BMI2; 4CPUs; 1024 MBs hash; threshhold=35; depth=10; boost=20
11 Wins:
B48 White 1. e4 c5
C41 Black 1. e4 d6
B00 White 1. e4 Nc6
B00 White 1. e4 b6
A40 White 1. c4 b6
A13 White 1. Nf3 Nf6
A49 White 1. b3 d6
D02 White 1. b3 Nc6
A25 Black 1. g3 Nc6
A36 Black 1. d3 g6
A00 Black 1. g4 h5


LeelaFish 21 v0.7 nn32930 2CPUs w/ nnCache = 1000000; CUDNN-fp16
Aux engine: Houdini 6.03 Pro x64; 4CPUs; Tactical Mode; 1024 MBs hash; threshhold=35; depth=10; boost=20
8 Wins:
A80 White 1. c3 f5
B03 White 1. e4 Nf6
B00 White 1. e4 b6
E97 White 1. Nf3 d6
B27 White 1. Nc3 g6
A20 White 1. g3 e5
A15 White 1. d3 Nf6
A47 White 1. c3 b6
A80 White 1. c3 f5

[Chessqueen]

200 games @ 1' + 1"
Noomen 2-plies TCEC opening book; each engine played both sides
Hash=2497 to each engine
SYZYGY 3-4-5, avail to all engines
Geforce RTX 2070
Intel 8th gen CPUs
Fritz 16 GUI
PGN of the wins


LeelaFish 21 v0.7 nn32930 2CPUs; nnCache = 1000000; CUDNN-fp16
Aux engine: SF 19030520 x64 BMI2; 4CPUs; 1024 MBs hash; threshhold=35; depth=10; boost=20
11 Wins:
B48 White 1. e4 c5
C41 Black 1. e4 d6
B00 White 1. e4 Nc6
B00 White 1. e4 b6
A40 White 1. c4 b6
A13 White 1. Nf3 Nf6
A49 White 1. b3 d6
D02 White 1. b3 Nc6
A25 Black 1. g3 Nc6
A36 Black 1. d3 g6
A00 Black 1. g4 h5


LeelaFish 21 v0.7 nn32930 2CPUs w/ nnCache = 1000000; CUDNN-fp16
Aux engine: Houdini 6.03 Pro x64; 4CPUs; Tactical Mode; 1024 MBs hash; threshhold=35; depth=10; boost=20
8 Wins:
A80 White 1. c3 f5
B03 White 1. e4 Nf6
B00 White 1. e4 b6
E97 White 1. Nf3 d6
B27 White 1. Nc3 g6
A20 White 1. g3 e5
A15 White 1. d3 Nf6
A47 White 1. c3 b6
A80 White 1. c3 f5

Therefore, the name should be changed to LC0Houdini vs LC0Fish

[Chessqueen]

200 games @ 1' + 1"
Noomen 2-plies TCEC opening book; each engine played both sides
Hash=2497 to each engine
SYZYGY 3-4-5, avail to all engines
Geforce RTX 2070
Intel 8th gen CPUs
Fritz 16 GUI
PGN of the wins


LeelaFish 21 v0.7 nn32930 2CPUs; nnCache = 1000000; CUDNN-fp16
Aux engine: SF 19030520 x64 BMI2; 4CPUs; 1024 MBs hash; threshhold=35; depth=10; boost=20
11 Wins:
B48 White 1. e4 c5
C41 Black 1. e4 d6
B00 White 1. e4 Nc6
B00 White 1. e4 b6
A40 White 1. c4 b6
A13 White 1. Nf3 Nf6
A49 White 1. b3 d6
D02 White 1. b3 Nc6
A25 Black 1. g3 Nc6
A36 Black 1. d3 g6
A00 Black 1. g4 h5


LeelaFish 21 v0.7 nn32930 2CPUs w/ nnCache = 1000000; CUDNN-fp16
Aux engine: Houdini 6.03 Pro x64; 4CPUs; Tactical Mode; 1024 MBs hash; threshhold=35; depth=10; boost=20
8 Wins:
A80 White 1. c3 f5
B03 White 1. e4 Nf6
B00 White 1. e4 b6
E97 White 1. Nf3 d6
B27 White 1. Nc3 g6
A20 White 1. g3 e5
A15 White 1. d3 Nf6
A47 White 1. c3 b6
A80 White 1. c3 f5

Therefore, the name should be changed to LC0Houdini vs LC0Fish

I do have a questions ? Is either of these two programs stronger than AB Houdini 6.0 64 Bit or the latest AB Stockfish ? What I am trying to find out is if the NN inclusion made either of the AB programs stronger?

[sincerelybrent]

...
I do have a questions ? Is either of these two programs stronger than AB Houdini 6.0 64 Bit or the latest AB Stockfish ? What I am trying to find out is if the NN inclusion made either of the AB programs stronger?

It seems so, yes, but not by a lot. I used SF9 as the aux engine for Lc0 20.2 w/ nn32930 vs SF 10. Score was +22/=71/-7 in favor of LFish. 1'+1" TC. 4-plies Super GM opening book

[pohl4711]

With AuxEngine running on 4CPUs, Depth 10 is much to small. For Houdini Depth=14 and for SF Depth=16 should be OK at 1'+1''