100 game match between K13.02 and H6 Pro just finished

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

User avatar
Nordlandia
Posts: 2821
Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 9:38 pm
Location: Sortland, Norway

100 game match between K13.02 and H6 Pro just finished

Post by Nordlandia »

Stats:
TC: 30m+30s
CuteChess GUI
Q9650 4-Core
Probing 5-men Syzygy, automatic 6-piece adjudication
Hash: 1536, 2048 Mb
TCEC draw rules: draw at 35 instead of 40.
Komodo contempt 0
Houdini contempt -2
Openinh book: 50 openings played each color

Image

Time:

Image

Average game duration ~ 1.5 hours

Longest draw:

[pgn][Event "H6 vs K13 100 Game Match (H Contempt -2)"] [Site "Q9650 | Probing 5-men Syzygy"] [Date "2019.07.03"] [Round "8"] [White "komodo-13.02-64bit"] [Black "Houdini 6"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [ECO "B30"] [PlyCount "274"] [EventDate "2019.??.??"] [TimeControl "1800+30"] 1. e4 {book} c5 {book} 2. Nf3 {book} Nc6 {book} 3. Bb5 {book} d6 {book} 4. O-O {book} Bd7 {book} 5. Re1 {book} Nf6 {book} 6. c3 {book} a6 {book} 7. Bf1 {book} Bg4 {book} 8. d4 {0.51/31 78s} cxd4 {-0.24/26 97s} 9. cxd4 {0.50/33 140s} Bxf3 {-0.28/28 159s} 10. gxf3 {0.58/30 87s} d5 {-0.35/29 97s} 11. Nc3 {0.45/31 89s} e6 {-0.24/24 11} 12. Bg5 {0.41/31 69s} Be7 {-0.25/28 73s} 13. Bxf6 {0.34/32 80s } Bxf6 {-0.40/26 21} 14. exd5 {0.60/30 37} Nxd4 {-0.39/29 86s} 15. Re4 { 0.62/32 95s} Nf5 {-0.44/29 89s} 16. dxe6 {0.59/33 73s} O-O {-0.39/27 27} 17. exf7+ {0.59/34 80s} Kh8 {-0.56/31 105s} 18. Qxd8 {0.62/36 90s} Raxd8 {-0.54/29 12} 19. Rd1 {0.60/37 99s} Rxd1 {-0.48/31 60s} 20. Nxd1 {0.71/34 35} g6 { -0.64/32 115s} 21. Ne3 {0.65/35 77s} Nxe3 {-0.63/34 94s} 22. fxe3 {0.84/38 57} Rxf7 {-0.58/32 15} 23. b3 {0.84/37 54} Re7 {-0.64/34 76s} 24. Rxe7 {0.84/41 66s } Bxe7 {-0.64/33 0.005s} 25. Bh3 {0.84/42 55} b5 {-0.65/38 77s} 26. Kf2 { 0.86/40 58} Kg7 {-0.65/37 15} 27. Bc8 {0.86/44 61s} a5 {-0.65/40 85s} 28. Bd7 { 0.76/45 77s} b4 {-0.65/44 80s} 29. f4 {0.77/50 59} g5 {-0.65/48 92s} 30. Kf3 { 0.78/52 60s} gxf4 {-0.65/48 30} 31. exf4 {0.78/54 60s} Kf6 {-0.65/49 127s} 32. Bb5 {0.76/59 63s} Bd8 {-0.65/47 78s} 33. Bd3 {0.76/54 82s} h5 {-0.65/47 88s} 34. Bb5 {0.79/53 50} Kf5 {-0.65/47 58} 35. Bd3+ {0.79/55 56} Kf6 {0.01/99 2.8s} 36. Ke4 {0.80/58 60s} Bb6 {-0.65/47 115s} 37. Be2 {0.79/58 54} Bg1 {-0.65/46 68s} 38. h3 {0.79/56 52} h4 {-0.65/47 11} 39. Kf3 {0.78/58 51} Kf5 {-0.65/47 57 } 40. Bd3+ {0.78/58 46} Kf6 {-0.65/49 60s} 41. Kg4 {0.78/61 49} Bf2 {-0.65/46 35} 42. Be4 {0.68/58 92s} Bg3 {-0.65/50 57} 43. Bg2 {0.67/64 51} Bf2 {-0.65/52 59} 44. Be4 {0.67/60 44} Bg3 {0.01/99 19} 45. Bd5 {0.64/62 53} Bf2 {-0.65/53 118s} 46. Bc6 {0.64/56 72s} Bg3 {-0.65/51 52} 47. Bb7 {0.64/60 37} Bf2 { -0.65/53 107s} 48. Bc8 {0.62/62 42} Be1 {-0.65/50 42} 49. Ba6 {0.62/59 84s} Bf2 {-0.65/53 143s} 50. Bd3 {0.62/59 39} Be3 {-0.65/52 13} 51. Kxh4 {0.76/52 19} Bxf4 {-0.58/43 35} 52. Kg4 {0.69/54 37} Be3 {-0.58/42 7.4s} 53. h4 {0.68/53 36} Bc1 {-0.59/45 40} 54. Be4 {0.68/55 36} Bh6 {-0.58/45 40} 55. Bg2 {0.68/53 34} Be3 {-0.59/44 13} 56. Bc6 {0.67/52 35} Kg6 {-0.59/46 37} 57. Bb7 {0.68/57 37} Kf6 {-0.59/46 79s} 58. Ba6 {0.67/54 36} Bd4 {-0.58/49 66s} 59. Bb5 {0.67/56 36} Be3 {-0.59/49 33} 60. Bd3 {0.67/53 36} Bc1 {0.00/99 27} 61. Kh5 {0.66/52 33} Bf4 {-0.59/49 68s} 62. Bb5 {0.66/54 33} Kf5 {-0.59/51 42} 63. Bd7+ {0.70/55 33} Kf6 {-0.59/51 7.6s} 64. Kg4 {0.70/59 35} Be3 {-0.58/41 93s} 65. h5 {0.58/54 42} Bh6 {-0.51/38 19} 66. Bc6 {0.54/59 32} Ke5 {-0.51/43 28} 67. Bb5 {0.56/57 31} Be3 {-0.51/44 35} 68. Bc6 {0.51/54 30} Bh6 {0.00/86 17} 69. Bb5 {0.47/56 41} Be3 {0.00/93 28} 70. Kf3 {0.48/53 28} Kd4 {-0.51/46 67s} 71. Bd7 {0.48/54 25} Bc1 {-0.51/45 30} 72. Kg4 {0.48/55 28} Ke5 {-0.51/38 37} 73. Bc8 {0.39/59 59} Kf6 {-0.51/41 27} 74. Bb7 {0.41/58 25} Ke5 {-0.51/37 44} 75. Bf3 {0.41/53 25} Be3 {-0.51/43 23} 76. Bd1 {0.42/52 32} Bf4 {-0.51/42 48} 77. Kf3 {0.42/55 34} Kf5 {-0.51/38 9.8s} 78. Bc2+ {0.40/53 26} Ke5 {-0.51/43 27} 79. Bh7 {0.40/57 26 } Bg5 {-0.51/41 65s} 80. Kg4 {0.40/58 27} Bd2 {-0.51/45 41} 81. Bg6 {0.40/56 27 } Bc1 {-0.51/42 19} 82. Kf3 {0.39/57 33} Bf4 {-0.51/47 28} 83. Bf7 {0.39/52 27} Kf5 {-0.51/33 43} 84. Bc4 {0.38/53 39} Bc1 {-0.51/43 30} 85. Be2 {0.36/51 28} Kg5 {-0.40/25 18} 86. Ke4 {0.39/55 36} Bb2 {-0.36/37 22} 87. Kd5 {0.39/56 33} Bc3 {-0.37/43 25} 88. Kc5 {0.40/52 26} Bf6 {-0.37/46 30} 89. Kb5 {0.40/57 26} Bd8 {-0.37/47 22} 90. Ka4 {0.40/56 26} Kh6 {-0.37/46 53} 91. Kb5 {0.37/57 35} Kg5 {0.00/99 8.6s} 92. Ka4 {0.38/57 28} Kh6 {0.00/99 5.7s} 93. Bg4 {0.34/52 28} Kg5 {-0.37/48 56} 94. Bf3 {0.34/55 31} Bc7 {-0.37/47 4.4s} 95. Kb5 {0.34/54 26} Bd8 {-0.37/44 36} 96. Kc6 {0.34/53 25} Bf6 {-0.37/42 14} 97. Kc5 {0.32/50 28} Be7+ {-0.37/45 27} 98. Kb6 {0.32/52 40} Bd8+ {-0.37/46 8.1s} 99. Kb5 {0.32/51 28} Bc7 {-0.37/49 46} 100. Bd1 {0.37/53 26} Kh6 {-0.37/44 27} 101. Be2 { 0.36/56 30} Kg5 {-0.37/46 56} 102. Ka4 {0.32/52 28} Bb6 {-0.37/46 75s} 103. Bf3 {0.32/51 29} Bc7 {0.00/89 17} 104. a3 {0.33/49 28} bxa3 {-0.36/46 51} 105. Kxa3 {0.33/53 14} Kh6 {-0.37/44 30} 106. Ka4 {0.33/55 26} Bb6 {-0.37/43 30} 107. Kb5 {0.33/52 27} Bd8 {-0.37/43 19} 108. Kc6 {0.34/53 28} Be7 {-0.37/44 30} 109. Be2 {0.28/55 33} Bb4 {-0.37/41 8.2s} 110. Bf3 {0.28/57 30} Be7 {0.00/99 6.1s} 111. Kb5 {0.27/57 29} Bd8 {0.00/99 2.6s} 112. Bg4 {0.28/53 27} Bc7 {-0.37/37 62s} 113. Kc5 {0.29/50 30} Kh7 {-0.37/37 28} 114. Kc6 {0.38/51 30} Bf4 {-0.37/32 76s } 115. Kb5 {0.33/56 27} Bd2 {-0.37/36 21} 116. Be6 {0.28/56 45} Kh6 {-0.37/27 47} 117. Bf7 {0.27/55 26} Kh7 {-0.37/30 30} 118. Bd5 {0.28/58 27} Be1 {-0.37/ 32 19} 119. Be4+ {0.26/59 42} Kh6 {-0.31/23 18} 120. Bg6 {0.25/58 56} Bd2 { -0.31/27 26} 121. Ka4 {0.23/57 34} Bc3 {-0.30/28 37} 122. Be8 {0.19/55 29} Bd2 {-0.23/28 19} 123. Bf7 {0.20/55 30} Bb4 {-0.30/38 61s} 124. Kb5 {0.20/55 25} Bc3 {-0.30/20 5.3s} 125. Be8 {0.20/53 26} Bd2 {-0.24/21 25} 126. Bg6 {0.19/55 34} Bb4 {-0.12/33 21} 127. Bf7 {0.11/53 30} Bc3 {0.00/93 19} 128. Kc5 {0.11/51 27} Be1 {-0.11/34 66s} 129. Kb6 {0.12/52 33} Bd2 {-0.08/35 45} 130. Be8 { 0.09/51 27} Bb4 {-0.08/36 22} 131. Bg6 {0.06/49 25} Bd2 {-0.08/35 5.0s} 132. Kc5 {0.06/46 37} Kg5 {-0.07/34 62s} 133. Kc6 {0.00/52 26} Bb4 {-0.04/35 18} 134. Be8 {0.00/57 30} Kh6 {-0.04/34 44} 135. Kd5 {0.00/57 28} Kg5 {0.00/32 3.8s } 136. Kd4 {0.00/59 32} Be1 {0.00/44 34} 137. Bf7 {0.00/59 25} Bb4 { adjudication 0.00/46 25s, Draw by adjudication} 1/2-1/2[/pgn]

Longest win:

[pgn][Event "H6 vs K13 100 Game Match (H Contempt -2)"] [Site "Q9650 | Probing 5-men Syzygy"] [Date "2019.07.04"] [Round "12"] [White "komodo-13.02-64bit"] [Black "Houdini 6"] [Result "1-0"] [ECO "C11"] [PlyCount "142"] [EventDate "2019.??.??"] [TimeControl "1800+30"] 1. e4 {book} e6 {book} 2. d4 {book} d5 {book} 3. Nc3 {book} Nf6 {book} 4. e5 { book} Nfd7 {book} 5. f4 {book} c5 {book} 6. Nf3 {book} Nc6 {book} 7. Be3 {book} Qb6 {-0.01/26 143s} 8. Na4 {0.37/32 96s} Qa5+ {-0.29/29 179s} 9. c3 {0.38/33 114s} cxd4 {-0.53/27 135s} 10. b4 {0.61/31 106s} Qc7 {-0.38/28 47} 11. Nxd4 { 0.67/31 124s} a6 {-0.42/27 103s} 12. Qd2 {0.72/28 75s} g5 {-0.47/25 68s} 13. f5 {0.65/30 133s} exf5 {-0.22/22 33} 14. Nxf5 {0.77/30 96s} Ndxe5 {-0.47/26 114s} 15. Bb6 {0.87/30 76s} Qd7 {-0.39/28 53} 16. Ne3 {0.71/29 72s} d4 {-0.49/28 77s} 17. cxd4 {0.86/31 57} Bxb4 {-0.45/28 63s} 18. Nc3 {0.79/32 87s} Ng4 {-0.64/29 100s} 19. Ned5 {0.70/30 71s} Qxd5 {-0.46/28 45} 20. Nxd5 {0.74/31 79s} Bxd2+ { -0.44/28 74s} 21. Kxd2 {0.82/30 34} O-O {-0.56/30 113s} 22. Be2 {0.82/32 77s} Be6 {-0.41/26 30} 23. Nc7 {0.71/32 70s} Nf6 {-0.48/28 111s} 24. Nxa8 {0.58/32 85s} Rxa8 {-0.49/27 0.10s} 25. Bf3 {0.74/32 82s} g4 {-0.43/28 80s} 26. Bxc6 { 0.68/32 81s} bxc6 {-0.51/27 72s} 27. Bc7 {0.65/32 70s} Ne4+ {-0.53/27 68s} 28. Ke3 {0.73/32 88s} Bd5 {-0.53/27 70s} 29. Rhf1 {0.75/31 66s} Re8 {-0.58/25 71s} 30. Kf4 {0.73/33 76s} h5 {-0.56/27 67s} 31. Rfe1 {0.53/32 94s} Rc8 {-0.41/26 71s} 32. Ba5 {0.55/34 68s} f5 {-0.31/25 71s} 33. Rab1 {0.60/33 72s} Kg7 { -0.48/31 144s} 34. Rb7+ {0.59/35 56} Kg6 {-0.42/31 37} 35. h4 {0.88/34 83s} Bxa2 {-0.39/30 12} 36. Bc7 {0.99/33 63s} Nf6 {-0.25/28 44} 37. Be5 {1.11/32 50} Re8 {-0.52/29 90s} 38. Rc1 {1.13/34 51} Bd5 {-0.47/30 146s} 39. Rc5 {1.26/33 42 } Re6 {-0.80/31 109s} 40. Rb8 {1.29/35 28} Bxg2 {-0.74/28 29} 41. Bxf6 { 1.12/35 51} Rxf6 {-0.77/31 75s} 42. Rg8+ {1.26/31 53} Kf7 {-0.51/28 20} 43. Rg5 {1.28/34 52} Be4 {-0.72/30 66s} 44. Rxh5 {1.22/30 18} g3 {-0.38/25 18} 45. Kxg3 {1.32/32 26} f4+ {-0.38/23 0.001s} 46. Kf2 {1.28/32 46} Rd6 {-0.41/28 37} 47. Rcg5 {1.06/30 32} Bg6 {-0.49/25 82s} 48. Rh8 {0.72/31 45} Rxd4 {-0.49/23 0.023s } 49. h5 {1.38/32 63s} Be4 {-0.16/25 18} 50. h6 {1.13/30 48} Rd2+ {-0.15/24 0. 007s} 51. Ke1 {1.82/29 29} Rh2 {-1.35/27 70s} 52. Rg4 {1.86/30 29} Ke6 { -1.44/27 82s} 53. Rxf4 {1.86/32 29} Bd3 {-1.58/25 41} 54. Rf2 {1.92/29 24} Rh3 {-1.39/21 14} 55. Kd2 {1.95/31 29} Bg6 {-1.52/26 46} 56. Rg2 {2.11/30 54} Bf5 { -1.64/25 30} 57. Re2+ {2.14/30 38} Kf7 {-1.74/25 30} 58. Rf2 {2.32/30 34} Kg6 { -1.77/25 30} 59. Rg2+ {2.35/29 33} Kh5 {-1.83/29 23} 60. Rg1 {3.01/28 34} c5 { -2.18/24 37} 61. Rc1 {3.31/27 31} Rh2+ {-2.52/23 30} 62. Ke3 {3.66/28 37} Bc2 { -2.96/24 30} 63. Kf4 {3.73/28 28} Kg6 {-3.01/23 0.067s} 64. Ke5 {4.01/27 30} Kf7 {-3.61/25 46} 65. Kd6 {4.40/28 46} Kf6 {-4.83/25 44} 66. Rg1 {5.44/27 26} Rd2+ {-5.94/24 30} 67. Kxc5 {5.83/27 18} Rh2 {-6.16/24 0.057s} 68. Ra8 { 6.55/28 31} Bd3 {-8.86/26 60s} 69. Rf8+ {8.82/24 14} Ke7 {-14.51/25 30} 70. Rf3 {12.92/24 24} Rh5+ {-17.63/25 30} 71. Kd4 {16.66/22 24} Bf5 {adjudication -17. 27/25 19s, White wins by adjudication} 1-0[/pgn]

Earliest draw:

[pgn][Event "H6 vs K13 100 Game Match (H Contempt -2)"] [Site "Q9650 | Probing 5-men Syzygy"] [Date "2019.07.04"] [Round "11"] [White "Houdini 6"] [Black "komodo-13.02-64bit"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [ECO "B95"] [PlyCount "33"] [EventDate "2019.??.??"] [TimeControl "1800+30"] 1. e4 {book} c5 {book} 2. Nf3 {book} d6 {book} 3. d4 {book} cxd4 {book} 4. Nxd4 {book} Nf6 {book} 5. Nc3 {book} a6 {book} 6. Bg5 {book} e6 {book} 7. Qf3 { -0.02/27 139s} Nbd7 {0.00/29 83s} 8. Be2 {-0.01/27 214s} Qc7 {0.00/32 61s} 9. a4 {-0.01/25 88s} b6 {0.00/34 66s} 10. O-O {-0.08/27 104s} Be7 {0.00/34 52} 11. Rad1 {-0.02/28 43} Bb7 {-0.05/33 81s} 12. Qg3 {-0.01/26 15} O-O {0.00/34 97s} 13. Bh6 {-0.02/28 56} Ne8 {0.00/33 52} 14. Be3 {-0.02/27 14} Nef6 {0.00/33 114s } 15. Bh6 {-0.02/32 62s} Ne8 {0.00/37 83s} 16. Be3 {-0.02/34 77s} Nef6 { 0.00/36 76s} 17. Bh6 {-0.02/32 58s, Draw by 3-fold repetition} 1/2-1/2 [/pgn]

Earliest win:

[pgn][Event "H6 vs K13 100 Game Match (H Contempt -2)"] [Site "Q9650 | Probing 5-men Syzygy"] [Date "2019.07.02"] [Round "1"] [White "Houdini 6"] [Black "komodo-13.02-64bit"] [Result "1-0"] [ECO "A22"] [PlyCount "82"] [EventDate "2019.??.??"] [TimeControl "1800+30"] 1. c4 {book} e5 {book} 2. Nc3 {book} Nf6 {book} 3. Nf3 {book} Nc6 {book} 4. g3 {book} Bb4 {book} 5. Bg2 {book} O-O {book} 6. O-O {0.00/26 98s} d6 {-0.23/30 83s} 7. d3 {0.06/26 71s} Bxc3 {-0.22/31 182s} 8. bxc3 {0.13/25 39} h6 {-0.15/ 31 88s} 9. e4 {0.22/24 50} a6 {-0.24/30 83s} 10. a4 {0.30/24 45} Na5 {-0.24/30 165s} 11. h3 {0.30/25 54} b6 {-0.15/31 158s} 12. Be3 {0.36/25 61s} Nd7 { -0.21/31 109s} 13. Qe2 {0.45/26 283s} Qe7 {-0.35/29 67s} 14. Rae1 {0.39/26 67s} Rb8 {-0.28/29 80s} 15. Nh4 {0.59/23 40} Nf6 {-0.32/29 72s} 16. f4 {0.73/24 82s} Be6 {-0.39/29 79s} 17. f5 {0.81/26 78s} Bd7 {-0.45/29 81s} 18. g4 {0.85/26 78s} Nb3 {-0.29/30 70s} 19. g5 {0.84/24 81s} hxg5 {-0.20/30 50} 20. Bxg5 {0.83/23 0. 013s} Rfc8 {-0.40/32 130s} 21. Nf3 {1.00/25 72s} Qf8 {-0.29/28 65s} 22. Kh2 { 1.81/24 41} Nh7 {-0.95/27 70s} 23. Be3 {1.86/25 63s} b5 {-1.52/29 90s} 24. cxb5 {2.25/26 250s} axb5 {-1.41/27 28} 25. Rg1 {2.24/24 0.007s} Qd8 {-2.50/28 143s} 26. Bh1 {3.31/23 42} Qf6 {-3.79/27 68s} 27. Rg3 {3.74/25 40} Be8 {-4.98/30 201s } 28. Reg1 {4.74/24 40} g6 {-5.06/28 57} 29. a5 {5.02/26 54} b4 {-5.14/27 41} 30. Qa2 {5.28/24 42} bxc3 {-5.05/26 20} 31. Rb1 {5.48/21 13} Nc1 {-5.18/28 65s} 32. Bxc1 {5.65/24 56} Kh8 {-5.55/28 86s} 33. Rxb8 {5.79/23 48} Rxb8 {-5.81/27 34} 34. Qc4 {5.78/23 0.006s} c2 {-6.04/27 60s} 35. Ng5 {6.51/22 41} Nf8 { -6.99/27 93s} 36. Qxc7 {6.87/23 38} Ra8 {-7.16/25 39} 37. Bd2 {7.08/23 41} c1=N {-6.39/27 48} 38. Qxc1 {7.58/22 36} Qe7 {-8.87/28 56} 39. Bg2 {8.02/23 59} Kg7 {-8.03/24 31} 40. Nf3 {8.53/24 53} Nh7 {-7.76/24 30} 41. Qa3 {9.38/23 44} Kg8 { adjudication -9.29/24 30s, White wins by adjudication} 1-0[/pgn]

Conclusions: Considering Houdini's relative age of 19 months since last release it seems both engines are quite coequal in overall strength. I'll redo the tournament with Houdini contempt at +1 instead of -2, Komodo contempt remain at zero.