this is just the first pass, but it's interesting how self play really exaggerates the Elo difference - and it's logical go course when you two engine that think almost exactly a like - any weakening will inflate the rating difference. That is why it's really nice to have CCRL results to see true differences between engine as well as engines within the same engine family. The ratings differences here are obviously exaggerated. SO my next step will take two different older versions of SF to see how they would fit in the group ( runs gaunlant of course with the two engines - against the appropriate opponents depending on where they fit - some strong stronger, some weaker) ), so I can offset accordingly using their CCRL rating.
Got about 10,000 more games to go on this run:
Code: Select all
Rank Name Rating Δ + - # Σ Σ% W L D W% =% OppR
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Honey 2800 3270 0.0 35 35 398 328.0 82.4 269 11 118 67.6 29.6 3012
2 Honey 2700 3179 91.3 31 31 400 276.0 69.0 194 42 164 48.5 41.0 3034
3 Honey 2600 3075 104.0 15 15 2399 1929.0 80.4 1634 175 590 68.1 24.6 2789
4 Honey 2500 2965 109.6 14 14 2400 1571.0 65.5 1212 470 718 50.5 29.9 2817
5 Honey 2400 2828 137.7 12 12 4403 2909.5 66.1 2432 1016 955 55.2 21.7 2636
6 Honey 2300 2661 166.7 12 12 4000 2029.5 50.7 1629 1570 801 40.7 20.0 2629
7 Honey 2200 2487 173.9 11 11 6000 3063.0 51.0 2671 2545 784 44.5 13.1 2436
8 Honey 2100 2291 196.5 13 13 4000 2044.0 51.1 1782 1694 524 44.5 13.1 2261
9 Honey 2000 2068 222.3 13 13 6000 2985.0 49.8 2716 2746 538 45.3 9.0 2060
10 Honey 1900 1857 210.9 14 14 4000 1989.5 49.7 1813 1834 353 45.3 8.8 1860
11 Honey 1800 1634 223.5 12 12 6000 2880.5 48.0 2723 2962 315 45.4 5.2 1686
12 Honey 1700 1442 191.9 13 13 4000 1909.0 47.7 1784 1966 250 44.6 6.2 1489
13 Honey 1600 1256 185.6 11 11 6000 2687.5 44.8 2531 3156 313 42.2 5.2 1345
14 Honey 1500 1142 114.6 12 12 4000 1906.0 47.6 1781 1969 250 44.5 6.2 1171
15 Honey 1400 1068 73.9 10 10 6000 3227.0 53.8 3077 2623 300 51.3 5.0 1033
16 Honey 1300 849 218.5 12 12 4000 1707.0 42.7 1619 2205 176 40.5 4.4 920
17 Honey 1200 797 52.7 12 12 4000 1440.0 36.0 1363 2483 154 34.1 3.9 933
18 Honey 1100 698 99.1 17 17 2000 757.5 37.9 729 1214 57 36.5 2.9 812
19 Honey 1000 533 164.1 19 19 2000 361.0 18.1 338 1616 46 16.9 2.3 853
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Δ = delta from the next higher rated opponent
# = number of games played
Σ = total score, 1 point for win, 1/2 point for draw
ResultSet-EloRating>d
1 Honey 2800 3270 398.0 ( 328.0 : 70.0)
100.0 ( 62.0 : 38.0) Honey 2700 3179
99.0 ( 83.5 : 15.5) Honey 2600 3075
99.0 ( 87.5 : 11.5) Honey 2500 2965
100.0 ( 95.0 : 5.0) Honey 2400 2828
2 Honey 2700 3179 400.0 ( 276.0 : 124.0)
100.0 ( 38.0 : 62.0) Honey 2800 3270
99.0 ( 65.5 : 33.5) Honey 2600 3075
100.0 ( 80.5 : 19.5) Honey 2500 2965
101.0 ( 92.0 : 9.0) Honey 2400 2828
3 Honey 2600 3075 2399.0 (1929.0 : 470.0)
99.0 ( 15.5 : 83.5) Honey 2800 3270
99.0 ( 33.5 : 65.5) Honey 2700 3179
600.0 (411.0 : 189.0) Honey 2500 2965
601.0 (510.5 : 90.5) Honey 2400 2828
500.0 (467.5 : 32.5) Honey 2300 2661
500.0 (491.0 : 9.0) Honey 2200 2487
4 Honey 2500 2965 2400.0 (1571.0 : 829.0)
99.0 ( 11.5 : 87.5) Honey 2800 3270
100.0 ( 19.5 : 80.5) Honey 2700 3179
600.0 (189.0 : 411.0) Honey 2600 3075
601.0 (426.5 : 174.5) Honey 2400 2828
500.0 (442.5 : 57.5) Honey 2300 2661
500.0 (482.0 : 18.0) Honey 2200 2487
5 Honey 2400 2828 4403.0 (2909.5 : 1493.5)
100.0 ( 5.0 : 95.0) Honey 2800 3270
101.0 ( 9.0 : 92.0) Honey 2700 3179
601.0 ( 90.5 : 510.5) Honey 2600 3075
601.0 (174.5 : 426.5) Honey 2500 2965
1000.0 (765.0 : 235.0) Honey 2300 2661
1000.0 (885.0 : 115.0) Honey 2200 2487
500.0 (484.5 : 15.5) Honey 2100 2291
500.0 (496.0 : 4.0) Honey 2000 2068
6 Honey 2300 2661 4000.0 (2029.5 : 1970.5)
500.0 ( 32.5 : 467.5) Honey 2600 3075
500.0 ( 57.5 : 442.5) Honey 2500 2965
1000.0 (235.0 : 765.0) Honey 2400 2828
1000.0 (760.5 : 239.5) Honey 2200 2487
500.0 (459.5 : 40.5) Honey 2100 2291
500.0 (484.5 : 15.5) Honey 2000 2068
7 Honey 2200 2487 6000.0 (3063.0 : 2937.0)
500.0 ( 9.0 : 491.0) Honey 2600 3075
500.0 ( 18.0 : 482.0) Honey 2500 2965
1000.0 (115.0 : 885.0) Honey 2400 2828
1000.0 (239.5 : 760.5) Honey 2300 2661
1000.0 (754.5 : 245.5) Honey 2100 2291
1000.0 (939.5 : 60.5) Honey 2000 2068
500.0 (489.0 : 11.0) Honey 1900 1857
500.0 (498.5 : 1.5) Honey 1800 1634
8 Honey 2100 2291 4000.0 (2044.0 : 1956.0)
500.0 ( 15.5 : 484.5) Honey 2400 2828
500.0 ( 40.5 : 459.5) Honey 2300 2661
1000.0 (245.5 : 754.5) Honey 2200 2487
1000.0 (778.5 : 221.5) Honey 2000 2068
500.0 (469.0 : 31.0) Honey 1900 1857
500.0 (495.0 : 5.0) Honey 1800 1634
9 Honey 2000 2068 6000.0 (2985.0 : 3015.0)
500.0 ( 4.0 : 496.0) Honey 2400 2828
500.0 ( 15.5 : 484.5) Honey 2300 2661
1000.0 ( 60.5 : 939.5) Honey 2200 2487
1000.0 (221.5 : 778.5) Honey 2100 2291
1000.0 (767.0 : 233.0) Honey 1900 1857
1000.0 (929.0 : 71.0) Honey 1800 1634
500.0 (492.5 : 7.5) Honey 1700 1442
500.0 (495.0 : 5.0) Honey 1600 1256
10 Honey 1900 1857 4000.0 (1989.5 : 2010.5)
500.0 ( 11.0 : 489.0) Honey 2200 2487
500.0 ( 31.0 : 469.0) Honey 2100 2291
1000.0 (233.0 : 767.0) Honey 2000 2068
1000.0 (774.5 : 225.5) Honey 1800 1634
500.0 (453.5 : 46.5) Honey 1700 1442
500.0 (486.5 : 13.5) Honey 1600 1256
11 Honey 1800 1634 6000.0 (2880.5 : 3119.5)
500.0 ( 1.5 : 498.5) Honey 2200 2487
500.0 ( 5.0 : 495.0) Honey 2100 2291
1000.0 ( 71.0 : 929.0) Honey 2000 2068
1000.0 (225.5 : 774.5) Honey 1900 1857
1000.0 (737.0 : 263.0) Honey 1700 1442
1000.0 (894.0 : 106.0) Honey 1600 1256
500.0 (464.0 : 36.0) Honey 1500 1142
500.0 (482.5 : 17.5) Honey 1400 1068
12 Honey 1700 1442 4000.0 (1909.0 : 2091.0)
500.0 ( 7.5 : 492.5) Honey 2000 2068
500.0 ( 46.5 : 453.5) Honey 1900 1857
1000.0 (263.0 : 737.0) Honey 1800 1634
1000.0 (720.5 : 279.5) Honey 1600 1256
500.0 (429.5 : 70.5) Honey 1500 1142
500.0 (442.0 : 58.0) Honey 1400 1068
13 Honey 1600 1256 6000.0 (2687.5 : 3312.5)
500.0 ( 5.0 : 495.0) Honey 2000 2068
500.0 ( 13.5 : 486.5) Honey 1900 1857
1000.0 (106.0 : 894.0) Honey 1800 1634
1000.0 (279.5 : 720.5) Honey 1700 1442
1000.0 (647.0 : 353.0) Honey 1500 1142
1000.0 (736.5 : 263.5) Honey 1400 1068
500.0 (439.5 : 60.5) Honey 1300 849
500.0 (460.5 : 39.5) Honey 1200 797
14 Honey 1500 1142 4000.0 (1906.0 : 2094.0)
500.0 ( 36.0 : 464.0) Honey 1800 1634
500.0 ( 70.5 : 429.5) Honey 1700 1442
1000.0 (353.0 : 647.0) Honey 1600 1256
1000.0 (597.5 : 402.5) Honey 1400 1068
500.0 (420.0 : 80.0) Honey 1300 849
500.0 (429.0 : 71.0) Honey 1200 797
15 Honey 1400 1068 6000.0 (3227.0 : 2773.0)
500.0 ( 17.5 : 482.5) Honey 1800 1634
500.0 ( 58.0 : 442.0) Honey 1700 1442
1000.0 (263.5 : 736.5) Honey 1600 1256
1000.0 (402.5 : 597.5) Honey 1500 1142
1000.0 (770.0 : 230.0) Honey 1300 849
1000.0 (798.0 : 202.0) Honey 1200 797
500.0 (442.0 : 58.0) Honey 1100 698
500.0 (475.5 : 24.5) Honey 1000 533
16 Honey 1300 849 4000.0 (1707.0 : 2293.0)
500.0 ( 60.5 : 439.5) Honey 1600 1256
500.0 ( 80.0 : 420.0) Honey 1500 1142
1000.0 (230.0 : 770.0) Honey 1400 1068
1000.0 (574.5 : 425.5) Honey 1200 797
500.0 (342.0 : 158.0) Honey 1100 698
500.0 (420.0 : 80.0) Honey 1000 533
17 Honey 1200 797 4000.0 (1440.0 : 2560.0)
500.0 ( 39.5 : 460.5) Honey 1600 1256
500.0 ( 71.0 : 429.0) Honey 1500 1142
1000.0 (202.0 : 798.0) Honey 1400 1068
1000.0 (425.5 : 574.5) Honey 1300 849
500.0 (311.5 : 188.5) Honey 1100 698
500.0 (390.5 : 109.5) Honey 1000 533
18 Honey 1100 698 2000.0 ( 757.5 : 1242.5)
500.0 ( 58.0 : 442.0) Honey 1400 1068
500.0 (158.0 : 342.0) Honey 1300 849
500.0 (188.5 : 311.5) Honey 1200 797
500.0 (353.0 : 147.0) Honey 1000 533
19 Honey 1000 533 2000.0 ( 361.0 : 1639.0)
500.0 ( 24.5 : 475.5) Honey 1400 1068
500.0 ( 80.0 : 420.0) Honey 1300 849
500.0 (109.5 : 390.5) Honey 1200 797
500.0 (147.0 : 353.0) Honey 1100 698
ResultSet-EloRating>