15+10 surprising good results with rook odds of stockfish

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

Uri Blass
Posts: 10915
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

15+10 surprising good results with rook odds of stockfish

Post by Uri Blass »

When I am not surprised that stockfish could beat the weak engines dreamer and hokpok_063
I am surprised that Stockfish could draw in this time control against Rybka1betax64 and Movei.

[pgn][Event "My Tournament"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2021.05.17"]
[Round "1"]
[White "stockfish_21051510_x64_avx2"]
[Black "Movei v0.08.438"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/1NBQKBNR w Kkq - 0 1"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "216"]
[WhiteType "human"]
[BlackType "human"]

1. e4 {-6.22/34 88s} e5 {+5.08/14 24s} 2. Nf3 {-6.17/31 8.3s} Nf6 {+5.07/14
43s} 3. d4 {-6.21/34 59s} Nxe4 {+5.00/14 40s} 4. Bd3 {-6.37/35 90s} d5
{+4.88/14 38s} 5. Nxe5 {-6.59/33 33s} Bd6 {+4.87/13 48s} 6. O-O {-6.41/27
9.7s} O-O {+4.89/13 31s} 7. Nd2 {-6.45/28 13s} f5 {+5.12/13 24s} 8. Ndf3
{-6.48/30 41s} Be6 {+5.15/13 22s} 9. c3 {-6.59/29 71s} Nd7 {+5.14/13 20s}
10. Bf4 {-6.51/31 21s} Re8 {+5.06/13 37s} 11. Bc2 {-6.28/29 33s} Rc8
{+5.30/13 35s} 12. g3 {-6.36/31 76s} c5 {+5.26/13 47s} 13. Nd3 {-6.36/29
9.5s} c4 {+5.56/14 31s} 14. Nde5 {-6.44/33 16s} Ndf6 {+5.51/13 38s} 15. Ne1
{-6.55/32 96s} g5 {+5.51/13 26s} 16. Bc1 {-6.25/26 10s} Qb6 {+5.65/13 23s}
17. Kg2 {-6.32/28 14s} g4 {+5.28/14 39s} 18. a4 {-6.44/31 21s} Kh8
{+6.01/13 29s} 19. Kg1 {-6.50/32 28s} Rc7 {+6.02/12 31s} 20. Ng2 {-6.67/32
74s} Bc8 {+5.95/13 47s} 21. Nf4 {-6.44/32 67s} Rce7 {+6.23/14 28s} 22. Bxe4
{-6.18/30 7.7s} fxe4 {+6.12/14 21s} 23. Re1 {-6.42/36 103s} Rf8 {+6.22/13
20s} 24. Qc2 {-6.44/31 25s} Bf5 {+6.05/15 49s} 25. Be3 {-6.00/27 9.2s} Qa6
{+5.99/13 28s} 26. b3 {-5.87/32 91s} cxb3 {+5.81/14 26s} 27. Qxb3 {-5.78/24
4.0s} Qa5 {+5.83/14 19s} 28. Rb1 {-5.38/27 6.7s} Rd8 {+5.41/13 20s} 29. Qa2
{-5.80/31 54s} Bd7 {+5.52/14 32s} 30. Rxb7 {-5.51/25 2.5s} Qxc3 {+5.26/14
16s} 31. Ne2 {-5.75/29 16s} Qe1+ {+5.59/14 13s} 32. Kg2 {-5.50/22 0.60s}
Bxe5 {+4.99/14 61s} 33. dxe5 {-4.66/28 13s} Rxe5 {+4.67/14 16s} 34. Qb2
{-4.54/26 2.2s} Rf5 {+5.65/14 18s} 35. Rxa7 {-5.09/31 31s} Kg8 {+5.51/13
16s} 36. Nd4 {-5.15/26 7.2s} Rf3 {+5.53/14 11s} 37. Rc7 {-5.34/27 2.5s}
Bxa4 {+5.40/14 31s} 38. Nc2 {-5.48/29 5.5s} Qe2 {+5.17/12 11s} 39. Qe5
{-4.52/28 2.6s} Bd7 {+5.08/13 14s} 40. Nd4 {-4.69/29 10s} Qb2 {+5.20/13
13s} 41. Kg1 {-4.48/28 6.4s} Ra8 {+5.74/13 16s} 42. Rxd7 {-4.26/30 3.9s}
Qa1+ {+5.26/13 14s} 43. Kg2 {-4.78/32 12s} Nxd7 {+4.19/13 12s} 44. Qxd5+
{-4.82/33 6.3s} Rf7 {+4.27/13 9.4s} 45. Nf5 {-5.09/32 10s} Ra6 {+4.99/13
14s} 46. Qxe4 {-5.01/33 7.6s} Qd1 {+5.14/13 15s} 47. Nh6+ {-4.05/34 4.2s}
Kf8 {+4.90/13 13s} 48. Nxf7 {-3.48/28 6.8s} Ra1 {+4.82/13 14s} 49. Qb4+
{-0.26/32 5.3s} Kxf7 {+4.28/13 17s} 50. Qc4+ {-0.13/37 9.7s} Ke7 {+5.47/12
8.0s} 51. Bg5+ {0.00/56 5.5s} Kf8 {+4.50/15 9.1s} 52. Bh6+ {0.00/59 5.5s}
Ke8 {+4.28/15 6.9s} 53. Qe6+ {0.00/59 6.7s} Kd8 {+4.28/4 0.002s} 54. Bg5+
{0.00/61 6.1s} Kc7 {+4.26/15 6.8s} 55. Bf4+ {0.00/61 7.3s} Kb7 {+4.16/15
7.6s} 56. Qe4+ {0.00/64 7.7s} Ka7 {+4.10/15 8.6s} 57. Be3+ {0.00/64 8.5s}
Nb6 {+4.16/13 11s} 58. Bxb6+ {0.00/66 7.9s} Kxb6 {+3.75/14 11s} 59. Qb4+
{0.00/70 9.1s} Kc6 {+4.09/14 6.6s} 60. Qc4+ {0.00/73 7.6s} Kd6 {+3.94/14
6.8s} 61. Qf4+ {0.00/72 7.4s} Kc5 {+3.31/14 24s} 62. Qc7+ {0.00/74 9.0s}
Kd4 {+3.32/13 13s} 63. Qd7+ {0.00/74 12s} Kc3 {+3.35/14 11s} 64. Qc7+
{0.00/73 12s} Kb2 {+3.37/14 12s} 65. Qe5+ {0.00/73 15s} Kb1 {+3.40/13 8.2s}
66. Qb5+ {0.00/72 10s} Kc1 {+3.49/13 8.0s} 67. Qc4+ {0.00/74 8.5s} Kb2
{+3.51/13 12s} 68. Qb5+ {0.00/74 8.5s} Qb3 {+3.53/13 12s} 69. Qe2+ {0.00/72
7.4s} Ka3 {+3.54/12 7.7s} 70. Qa6+ {0.00/75 28s} Qa4 {+4.03/14 12s} 71.
Qd3+ {0.00/74 7.3s} Kb4 {+2.92/12 7.3s} 72. Qd4+ {0.00/71 7.4s} Kb5
{+2.74/12 14s} 73. Qe5+ {0.00/72 18s} Kc4 {+2.92/13 13s} 74. Qe4+ {0.00/72
6.1s} Kc5 {+2.23/14 6.2s} 75. Qe5+ {0.00/72 6.3s} Kb6 {0.00/15 5.8s} 76.
Qb8+ {0.00/69 7.0s} Kc6 {+3.78/13 6.6s} 77. Qc8+ {0.00/69 6.5s} Kd6
{+2.23/13 12s} 78. Qd8+ {0.00/69 12s} Kc5 {+3.55/12 6.4s} 79. Qe7+ {0.00/68
8.8s} Kd4 {+3.68/13 10s} 80. Qe3+ {0.00/75 11s} Kd5 {+4.11/12 5.8s} 81.
Qg5+ {0.00/74 70s} Kc6 {0.00/15 6.3s} 82. Qf6+ {0.00/70 2.1s} Kd7 {0.00/16
6.9s} 83. Qf5+ {0.00/67 4.0s} Ke8 {0.00/16 9.9s} 84. Qe6+ {0.00/68 3.4s}
Kf8 {0.00/16 7.1s} 85. Qf5+ {0.00/70 3.8s} Ke7 {0.00/15 8.1s} 86. Qg5+
{0.00/71 4.4s} Ke6 {+2.87/13 7.6s} 87. Qg8+ {0.00/73 5.7s} Kf6 {+2.65/13
14s} 88. Qf8+ {0.00/73 6.3s} Ke5 {0.00/16 8.0s} 89. Qe7+ {0.00/74 5.2s} Kf5
{0.00/16 8.0s} 90. Qf7+ {0.00/71 5.8s} Ke4 {0.00/17 8.4s} 91. Qf4+ {0.00/73
7.1s} Kd3 {0.00/18 7.8s} 92. Qe3+ {0.00/74 11s} Kc2 {0.00/18 8.1s} 93. Qe2+
{0.00/71 6.1s} Kc3 {0.00/18 6.0s} 94. Qe3+ {0.00/71 6.3s} Kb2 {0.00/17
7.3s} 95. Qe2+ {0.00/72 7.5s} Qc2 {0.00/17 8.5s} 96. Qb5+ {0.00/74 8.7s}
Ka2 {0.00/16 6.6s} 97. Qa5+ {0.00/74 8.5s} Kb1 {0.00/16 6.2s} 98. Qe1+
{0.00/69 7.5s} Kb2 {0.00/18 11s} 99. Qb4+ {0.00/75 26s} Kc1 {0.00/18 12s}
100. Qe1+ {0.00/73 6.3s} Qd1 {0.00/18 7.0s} 101. Qc3+ {0.00/72 6.8s} Kb1
{0.00/18 8.0s} 102. Qb4+ {0.00/72 6.5s} Ka2 {0.00/19 9.9s} 103. Qc4+
{0.00/70 31s} Ka3 {0.00/19 9.5s} 104. Qc5+ {0.00/80 5.2s} Kb3 {0.00/20
8.7s} 105. Qb5+ {0.00/77 8.9s} Kc3 {0.00/19 12s} 106. Qc5+ {0.00/82 6.4s}
Kd3 {0.00/19 14s} 107. Qb5+ {0.00/81 6.1s} Ke4 {0.00/20 15s} 108. Qc4+
{0.00/98 8.2s} Kf5 {0.00/63 0.001s, Draw by fifty moves rule} 1/2-1/2
[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "My Tournament"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2021.05.17"]
[Round "1"]
[White "stockfish_21051510_x64_avx2"]
[Black "Rybka v1.0 Beta.x64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/1NBQKBNR w Kkq - 0 1"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "189"]
[WhiteType "human"]
[BlackType "human"]

1. e4 {-6.22/34 88s} Na6 {+4.68/12 51s} 2. Nf3 {-5.45/28 19s} c6 {+4.68/12
59s} 3. d4 {-5.32/29 33s} Qa5+ {+4.68/14 22s} 4. Nc3 {-5.10/31 47s} b5
{+4.68/14 253s} 5. Nd2 {-5.18/29 32s} Qc7 {+4.68/13 58s} 6. a4 {-5.23/32
65s} bxa4 {+4.64/13 56s} 7. Be2 {-5.40/31 44s} Nb4 {+4.94/15 16s} 8. O-O
{-5.55/29 18s} e6 {+4.97/14 14s} 9. Re1 {-5.98/35 161s} d5 {+4.94/15 122s}
10. Nf3 {-6.07/28 10s} Rb8 {+5.41/14 14s} 11. Bf1 {-6.17/35 159s} Qa5
{+5.09/15 25s} 12. Bf4 {-5.82/31 14s} Rb7 {+5.41/15 21s} 13. Qd2 {-6.00/32
21s} a3 {+5.12/13 11s} 14. Ra1 {-5.94/32 7.1s} dxe4 {+5.10/16 22s} 15. Nxe4
{-5.61/30 14s} axb2 {+4.74/15 12s} 16. Rxa5 {-5.73/33 18s} b1=Q {+4.73/15
4.7s} 17. Nd6+ {-6.13/32 29s} Bxd6 {+4.73/16 25s} 18. Bxd6 {-6.08/30 10s}
Nd5 {+4.81/15 17s} 19. c4 {-5.59/29 12s} Ndf6 {+5.09/14 17s} 20. Qg5
{-3.75/30 12s} g6 {+5.04/15 19s} 21. Qe5 {-4.32/37 83s} Qc2 {+4.37/14 14s}
22. Ra1 {-3.01/26 9.3s} h6 {+4.63/14 13s} 23. d5 {-2.99/32 31s} cxd5
{+4.23/15 19s} 24. Qd4 {-2.99/34 32s} Qb2 {+4.27/16 41s} 25. Qc5 {-3.36/38
20s} Kd8 {+4.29/15 9.3s} 26. Be5 {-2.84/30 13s} Qb4 {+3.50/17 27s} 27. Qd4
{-2.73/33 13s} Ke7 {+3.25/16 16s} 28. c5 {-2.27/30 11s} Qxd4 {+2.76/16
8.9s} 29. Nxd4 {-2.90/38 30s} Bd7 {+2.76/17 9.7s} 30. c6 {-2.94/36 13s}
Bxc6 {+2.76/17 4.8s} 31. Nxc6+ {-3.05/32 10s} Kf8 {+2.76/18 16s} 32. Na5
{-2.64/40 84s} Rb6 {+2.82/16 14s} 33. Rc1 {-2.33/30 5.0s} Kg7 {+2.82/16
20s} 34. Rc8 {-2.44/32 9.6s} Rb1 {+2.82/17 16s} 35. h4 {-2.40/33 18s} a6
{+2.82/16 9.8s} 36. f3 {-1.79/28 3.9s} Re1 {+2.76/17 34s} 37. Bc3 {-0.95/29
6.1s} Rd1 {+2.74/18 8.5s} 38. Be5 {-0.81/28 7.0s} g5 {+2.25/18 51s} 39. h5
{-0.62/31 6.8s} Re1 {+1.88/17 7.0s} 40. Bc3 {-1.43/34 19s} Rb1 {+1.75/17
9.8s} 41. Kf2 {-0.38/33 5.9s} g4 {+1.38/17 13s} 42. fxg4 {-0.28/35 8.1s}
Rb6 {+1.34/16 2.6s} 43. Be5 {-0.13/37 7.3s} Rb4 {+0.58/17 9.0s} 44. Bd3
{-0.13/38 8.0s} Rxg4 {+0.35/17 8.5s} 45. Rc7 {-0.13/38 6.5s} Rg5 {+0.33/17
15s} 46. Nc6 {-0.13/39 7.3s} Ne7 {+0.29/18 17s} 47. Rxe7 {-0.13/43 9.6s}
Rc8 {+0.26/18 12s} 48. Bg6 {-0.13/42 7.6s} Rxg6 {+0.27/18 6.0s} 49. hxg6
{-0.12/42 11s} Kxg6 {+0.28/18 5.9s} 50. Rc7 {-0.12/42 18s} Rxc7 {+0.26/18
5.7s} 51. Bxc7 {-0.13/43 7.9s} Ne8 {+0.23/18 10s} 52. Bg3 {-0.21/38 6.6s}
h5 {+0.22/19 14s} 53. Kf3 {-0.13/40 8.8s} f6 {+0.27/19 8.4s} 54. Bb8
{-0.12/37 7.1s} Kf7 {+0.28/19 10.0s} 55. Ke2 {-0.12/40 8.3s} Ng7 {+0.28/19
15s} 56. Bc7 {-0.12/39 11s} e5 {+0.44/20 12s} 57. Nb4 {-0.12/38 8.1s} d4
{+0.40/20 11s} 58. Nxa6 {-0.12/40 12s} Ne6 {+0.34/19 13s} 59. Bb6 {-0.08/38
7.3s} Nf4+ {+0.46/18 12s} 60. Kf3 {-0.04/39 7.3s} Nd5 {+0.41/20 12s} 61.
Bd8 {-0.04/40 13s} d3 {+0.53/21 9.3s} 62. Nc5 {0.00/41 12s} Ke8 {+0.49/22
11s} 63. Ba5 {0.00/47 8.9s} f5 {+0.49/22 11s} 64. Bd2 {0.00/50 7.8s} Ke7
{+0.55/21 11s} 65. Bg5+ {0.00/52 13s} Kd6 {+0.75/19 3.1s} 66. Nxd3 {0.00/54
7.7s} e4+ {+0.73/21 3.3s} 67. Ke2 {0.00/54 9.5s} exd3+ {+0.73/23 3.5s} 68.
Kxd3 {0.00/56 8.2s} Ke5 {+0.73/24 5.1s} 69. g3 {0.00/55 11s} f4 {+0.74/26
8.6s} 70. Bxf4+ {0.00/54 15s} Nxf4+ {+0.72/22 13s} 71. gxf4+ {0.00/57 73s}
Kxf4 {+0.72/24 3.5s} 72. Ke2 {0.00/45 22s} Ke4 {+0.72/30 9.1s} 73. Kf2
{0.00/47 13s} Kf5 {+0.71/38 11s} 74. Kg3 {0.00/45 11s} Kg5 {+0.71/25 8.3s}
75. Kf3 {0.00/49 1.1s} h4 {+0.77/23 13s} 76. Ke2 {0.00/51 1.7s} Kg4
{+0.71/22 10s} 77. Kf1 {0.00/45 3.4s} Kg3 {+0.71/22 11s} 78. Kg1 {0.00/46
10s} Kf3 {+0.64/20 15s} 79. Kh2 {0.00/46 4.8s} Kg4 {+0.64/20 20s} 80. Kg1
{0.00/44 4.9s} Kf4 {+0.71/21 10s} 81. Kf2 {0.00/48 5.3s} Ke5 {+0.64/19 17s}
82. Kg1 {0.00/41 6.6s} Ke6 {+0.52/20 39s} 83. Kf1 {0.00/45 6.2s} Ke7
{+0.64/20 41s} 84. Kg2 {0.00/45 20s} Kf6 {+0.52/18 6.5s} 85. Kh2 {0.00/46
27s} Kg6 {+0.71/19 7.1s} 86. Kg1 {0.00/46 4.0s} Kg5 {+0.34/18 14s} 87. Kf1
{0.00/50 29s} h3 {+0.64/20 30s} 88. Kg1 {0.00/47 1.5s} Kh5 {+0.58/19 16s}
89. Kh2 {0.00/44 2.5s} Kh4 {+0.46/19 6.0s} 90. Kg1 {0.00/50 15s} Kg5
{+0.46/19 7.7s} 91. Kh2 {0.00/47 2.4s} Kg4 {+0.16/18 6.8s} 92. Kg1 {0.00/50
6.0s} Kg3 {+0.10/19 12s} 93. Kh1 {0.00/51 18s} Kf4 {+0.03/20 7.9s} 94. Kh2
{0.00/52 9.6s} Ke3 {+0.10/19 12s} 95. Kxh3 {0.00/46 5.4s, Draw by
insufficient mating material Insufficient material} 1/2-1/2
[/pgn]
lkaufman
Posts: 6259
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 am
Location: Maryland USA
Full name: Larry Kaufman

Re: 15+10 surprising good results with rook odds of stockfish

Post by lkaufman »

Uri Blass wrote: Mon May 17, 2021 1:00 pm When I am not surprised that stockfish could beat the weak engines dreamer and hokpok_063
I am surprised that Stockfish could draw in this time control against Rybka1betax64 and Movei.

[pgn][Event "My Tournament"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2021.05.17"]
[Round "1"]
[White "stockfish_21051510_x64_avx2"]
[Black "Movei v0.08.438"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/1NBQKBNR w Kkq - 0 1"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "216"]
[WhiteType "human"]
[BlackType "human"]

1. e4 {-6.22/34 88s} e5 {+5.08/14 24s} 2. Nf3 {-6.17/31 8.3s} Nf6 {+5.07/14
43s} 3. d4 {-6.21/34 59s} Nxe4 {+5.00/14 40s} 4. Bd3 {-6.37/35 90s} d5
{+4.88/14 38s} 5. Nxe5 {-6.59/33 33s} Bd6 {+4.87/13 48s} 6. O-O {-6.41/27
9.7s} O-O {+4.89/13 31s} 7. Nd2 {-6.45/28 13s} f5 {+5.12/13 24s} 8. Ndf3
{-6.48/30 41s} Be6 {+5.15/13 22s} 9. c3 {-6.59/29 71s} Nd7 {+5.14/13 20s}
10. Bf4 {-6.51/31 21s} Re8 {+5.06/13 37s} 11. Bc2 {-6.28/29 33s} Rc8
{+5.30/13 35s} 12. g3 {-6.36/31 76s} c5 {+5.26/13 47s} 13. Nd3 {-6.36/29
9.5s} c4 {+5.56/14 31s} 14. Nde5 {-6.44/33 16s} Ndf6 {+5.51/13 38s} 15. Ne1
{-6.55/32 96s} g5 {+5.51/13 26s} 16. Bc1 {-6.25/26 10s} Qb6 {+5.65/13 23s}
17. Kg2 {-6.32/28 14s} g4 {+5.28/14 39s} 18. a4 {-6.44/31 21s} Kh8
{+6.01/13 29s} 19. Kg1 {-6.50/32 28s} Rc7 {+6.02/12 31s} 20. Ng2 {-6.67/32
74s} Bc8 {+5.95/13 47s} 21. Nf4 {-6.44/32 67s} Rce7 {+6.23/14 28s} 22. Bxe4
{-6.18/30 7.7s} fxe4 {+6.12/14 21s} 23. Re1 {-6.42/36 103s} Rf8 {+6.22/13
20s} 24. Qc2 {-6.44/31 25s} Bf5 {+6.05/15 49s} 25. Be3 {-6.00/27 9.2s} Qa6
{+5.99/13 28s} 26. b3 {-5.87/32 91s} cxb3 {+5.81/14 26s} 27. Qxb3 {-5.78/24
4.0s} Qa5 {+5.83/14 19s} 28. Rb1 {-5.38/27 6.7s} Rd8 {+5.41/13 20s} 29. Qa2
{-5.80/31 54s} Bd7 {+5.52/14 32s} 30. Rxb7 {-5.51/25 2.5s} Qxc3 {+5.26/14
16s} 31. Ne2 {-5.75/29 16s} Qe1+ {+5.59/14 13s} 32. Kg2 {-5.50/22 0.60s}
Bxe5 {+4.99/14 61s} 33. dxe5 {-4.66/28 13s} Rxe5 {+4.67/14 16s} 34. Qb2
{-4.54/26 2.2s} Rf5 {+5.65/14 18s} 35. Rxa7 {-5.09/31 31s} Kg8 {+5.51/13
16s} 36. Nd4 {-5.15/26 7.2s} Rf3 {+5.53/14 11s} 37. Rc7 {-5.34/27 2.5s}
Bxa4 {+5.40/14 31s} 38. Nc2 {-5.48/29 5.5s} Qe2 {+5.17/12 11s} 39. Qe5
{-4.52/28 2.6s} Bd7 {+5.08/13 14s} 40. Nd4 {-4.69/29 10s} Qb2 {+5.20/13
13s} 41. Kg1 {-4.48/28 6.4s} Ra8 {+5.74/13 16s} 42. Rxd7 {-4.26/30 3.9s}
Qa1+ {+5.26/13 14s} 43. Kg2 {-4.78/32 12s} Nxd7 {+4.19/13 12s} 44. Qxd5+
{-4.82/33 6.3s} Rf7 {+4.27/13 9.4s} 45. Nf5 {-5.09/32 10s} Ra6 {+4.99/13
14s} 46. Qxe4 {-5.01/33 7.6s} Qd1 {+5.14/13 15s} 47. Nh6+ {-4.05/34 4.2s}
Kf8 {+4.90/13 13s} 48. Nxf7 {-3.48/28 6.8s} Ra1 {+4.82/13 14s} 49. Qb4+
{-0.26/32 5.3s} Kxf7 {+4.28/13 17s} 50. Qc4+ {-0.13/37 9.7s} Ke7 {+5.47/12
8.0s} 51. Bg5+ {0.00/56 5.5s} Kf8 {+4.50/15 9.1s} 52. Bh6+ {0.00/59 5.5s}
Ke8 {+4.28/15 6.9s} 53. Qe6+ {0.00/59 6.7s} Kd8 {+4.28/4 0.002s} 54. Bg5+
{0.00/61 6.1s} Kc7 {+4.26/15 6.8s} 55. Bf4+ {0.00/61 7.3s} Kb7 {+4.16/15
7.6s} 56. Qe4+ {0.00/64 7.7s} Ka7 {+4.10/15 8.6s} 57. Be3+ {0.00/64 8.5s}
Nb6 {+4.16/13 11s} 58. Bxb6+ {0.00/66 7.9s} Kxb6 {+3.75/14 11s} 59. Qb4+
{0.00/70 9.1s} Kc6 {+4.09/14 6.6s} 60. Qc4+ {0.00/73 7.6s} Kd6 {+3.94/14
6.8s} 61. Qf4+ {0.00/72 7.4s} Kc5 {+3.31/14 24s} 62. Qc7+ {0.00/74 9.0s}
Kd4 {+3.32/13 13s} 63. Qd7+ {0.00/74 12s} Kc3 {+3.35/14 11s} 64. Qc7+
{0.00/73 12s} Kb2 {+3.37/14 12s} 65. Qe5+ {0.00/73 15s} Kb1 {+3.40/13 8.2s}
66. Qb5+ {0.00/72 10s} Kc1 {+3.49/13 8.0s} 67. Qc4+ {0.00/74 8.5s} Kb2
{+3.51/13 12s} 68. Qb5+ {0.00/74 8.5s} Qb3 {+3.53/13 12s} 69. Qe2+ {0.00/72
7.4s} Ka3 {+3.54/12 7.7s} 70. Qa6+ {0.00/75 28s} Qa4 {+4.03/14 12s} 71.
Qd3+ {0.00/74 7.3s} Kb4 {+2.92/12 7.3s} 72. Qd4+ {0.00/71 7.4s} Kb5
{+2.74/12 14s} 73. Qe5+ {0.00/72 18s} Kc4 {+2.92/13 13s} 74. Qe4+ {0.00/72
6.1s} Kc5 {+2.23/14 6.2s} 75. Qe5+ {0.00/72 6.3s} Kb6 {0.00/15 5.8s} 76.
Qb8+ {0.00/69 7.0s} Kc6 {+3.78/13 6.6s} 77. Qc8+ {0.00/69 6.5s} Kd6
{+2.23/13 12s} 78. Qd8+ {0.00/69 12s} Kc5 {+3.55/12 6.4s} 79. Qe7+ {0.00/68
8.8s} Kd4 {+3.68/13 10s} 80. Qe3+ {0.00/75 11s} Kd5 {+4.11/12 5.8s} 81.
Qg5+ {0.00/74 70s} Kc6 {0.00/15 6.3s} 82. Qf6+ {0.00/70 2.1s} Kd7 {0.00/16
6.9s} 83. Qf5+ {0.00/67 4.0s} Ke8 {0.00/16 9.9s} 84. Qe6+ {0.00/68 3.4s}
Kf8 {0.00/16 7.1s} 85. Qf5+ {0.00/70 3.8s} Ke7 {0.00/15 8.1s} 86. Qg5+
{0.00/71 4.4s} Ke6 {+2.87/13 7.6s} 87. Qg8+ {0.00/73 5.7s} Kf6 {+2.65/13
14s} 88. Qf8+ {0.00/73 6.3s} Ke5 {0.00/16 8.0s} 89. Qe7+ {0.00/74 5.2s} Kf5
{0.00/16 8.0s} 90. Qf7+ {0.00/71 5.8s} Ke4 {0.00/17 8.4s} 91. Qf4+ {0.00/73
7.1s} Kd3 {0.00/18 7.8s} 92. Qe3+ {0.00/74 11s} Kc2 {0.00/18 8.1s} 93. Qe2+
{0.00/71 6.1s} Kc3 {0.00/18 6.0s} 94. Qe3+ {0.00/71 6.3s} Kb2 {0.00/17
7.3s} 95. Qe2+ {0.00/72 7.5s} Qc2 {0.00/17 8.5s} 96. Qb5+ {0.00/74 8.7s}
Ka2 {0.00/16 6.6s} 97. Qa5+ {0.00/74 8.5s} Kb1 {0.00/16 6.2s} 98. Qe1+
{0.00/69 7.5s} Kb2 {0.00/18 11s} 99. Qb4+ {0.00/75 26s} Kc1 {0.00/18 12s}
100. Qe1+ {0.00/73 6.3s} Qd1 {0.00/18 7.0s} 101. Qc3+ {0.00/72 6.8s} Kb1
{0.00/18 8.0s} 102. Qb4+ {0.00/72 6.5s} Ka2 {0.00/19 9.9s} 103. Qc4+
{0.00/70 31s} Ka3 {0.00/19 9.5s} 104. Qc5+ {0.00/80 5.2s} Kb3 {0.00/20
8.7s} 105. Qb5+ {0.00/77 8.9s} Kc3 {0.00/19 12s} 106. Qc5+ {0.00/82 6.4s}
Kd3 {0.00/19 14s} 107. Qb5+ {0.00/81 6.1s} Ke4 {0.00/20 15s} 108. Qc4+
{0.00/98 8.2s} Kf5 {0.00/63 0.001s, Draw by fifty moves rule} 1/2-1/2
[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "My Tournament"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2021.05.17"]
[Round "1"]
[White "stockfish_21051510_x64_avx2"]
[Black "Rybka v1.0 Beta.x64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/1NBQKBNR w Kkq - 0 1"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "189"]
[WhiteType "human"]
[BlackType "human"]

1. e4 {-6.22/34 88s} Na6 {+4.68/12 51s} 2. Nf3 {-5.45/28 19s} c6 {+4.68/12
59s} 3. d4 {-5.32/29 33s} Qa5+ {+4.68/14 22s} 4. Nc3 {-5.10/31 47s} b5
{+4.68/14 253s} 5. Nd2 {-5.18/29 32s} Qc7 {+4.68/13 58s} 6. a4 {-5.23/32
65s} bxa4 {+4.64/13 56s} 7. Be2 {-5.40/31 44s} Nb4 {+4.94/15 16s} 8. O-O
{-5.55/29 18s} e6 {+4.97/14 14s} 9. Re1 {-5.98/35 161s} d5 {+4.94/15 122s}
10. Nf3 {-6.07/28 10s} Rb8 {+5.41/14 14s} 11. Bf1 {-6.17/35 159s} Qa5
{+5.09/15 25s} 12. Bf4 {-5.82/31 14s} Rb7 {+5.41/15 21s} 13. Qd2 {-6.00/32
21s} a3 {+5.12/13 11s} 14. Ra1 {-5.94/32 7.1s} dxe4 {+5.10/16 22s} 15. Nxe4
{-5.61/30 14s} axb2 {+4.74/15 12s} 16. Rxa5 {-5.73/33 18s} b1=Q {+4.73/15
4.7s} 17. Nd6+ {-6.13/32 29s} Bxd6 {+4.73/16 25s} 18. Bxd6 {-6.08/30 10s}
Nd5 {+4.81/15 17s} 19. c4 {-5.59/29 12s} Ndf6 {+5.09/14 17s} 20. Qg5
{-3.75/30 12s} g6 {+5.04/15 19s} 21. Qe5 {-4.32/37 83s} Qc2 {+4.37/14 14s}
22. Ra1 {-3.01/26 9.3s} h6 {+4.63/14 13s} 23. d5 {-2.99/32 31s} cxd5
{+4.23/15 19s} 24. Qd4 {-2.99/34 32s} Qb2 {+4.27/16 41s} 25. Qc5 {-3.36/38
20s} Kd8 {+4.29/15 9.3s} 26. Be5 {-2.84/30 13s} Qb4 {+3.50/17 27s} 27. Qd4
{-2.73/33 13s} Ke7 {+3.25/16 16s} 28. c5 {-2.27/30 11s} Qxd4 {+2.76/16
8.9s} 29. Nxd4 {-2.90/38 30s} Bd7 {+2.76/17 9.7s} 30. c6 {-2.94/36 13s}
Bxc6 {+2.76/17 4.8s} 31. Nxc6+ {-3.05/32 10s} Kf8 {+2.76/18 16s} 32. Na5
{-2.64/40 84s} Rb6 {+2.82/16 14s} 33. Rc1 {-2.33/30 5.0s} Kg7 {+2.82/16
20s} 34. Rc8 {-2.44/32 9.6s} Rb1 {+2.82/17 16s} 35. h4 {-2.40/33 18s} a6
{+2.82/16 9.8s} 36. f3 {-1.79/28 3.9s} Re1 {+2.76/17 34s} 37. Bc3 {-0.95/29
6.1s} Rd1 {+2.74/18 8.5s} 38. Be5 {-0.81/28 7.0s} g5 {+2.25/18 51s} 39. h5
{-0.62/31 6.8s} Re1 {+1.88/17 7.0s} 40. Bc3 {-1.43/34 19s} Rb1 {+1.75/17
9.8s} 41. Kf2 {-0.38/33 5.9s} g4 {+1.38/17 13s} 42. fxg4 {-0.28/35 8.1s}
Rb6 {+1.34/16 2.6s} 43. Be5 {-0.13/37 7.3s} Rb4 {+0.58/17 9.0s} 44. Bd3
{-0.13/38 8.0s} Rxg4 {+0.35/17 8.5s} 45. Rc7 {-0.13/38 6.5s} Rg5 {+0.33/17
15s} 46. Nc6 {-0.13/39 7.3s} Ne7 {+0.29/18 17s} 47. Rxe7 {-0.13/43 9.6s}
Rc8 {+0.26/18 12s} 48. Bg6 {-0.13/42 7.6s} Rxg6 {+0.27/18 6.0s} 49. hxg6
{-0.12/42 11s} Kxg6 {+0.28/18 5.9s} 50. Rc7 {-0.12/42 18s} Rxc7 {+0.26/18
5.7s} 51. Bxc7 {-0.13/43 7.9s} Ne8 {+0.23/18 10s} 52. Bg3 {-0.21/38 6.6s}
h5 {+0.22/19 14s} 53. Kf3 {-0.13/40 8.8s} f6 {+0.27/19 8.4s} 54. Bb8
{-0.12/37 7.1s} Kf7 {+0.28/19 10.0s} 55. Ke2 {-0.12/40 8.3s} Ng7 {+0.28/19
15s} 56. Bc7 {-0.12/39 11s} e5 {+0.44/20 12s} 57. Nb4 {-0.12/38 8.1s} d4
{+0.40/20 11s} 58. Nxa6 {-0.12/40 12s} Ne6 {+0.34/19 13s} 59. Bb6 {-0.08/38
7.3s} Nf4+ {+0.46/18 12s} 60. Kf3 {-0.04/39 7.3s} Nd5 {+0.41/20 12s} 61.
Bd8 {-0.04/40 13s} d3 {+0.53/21 9.3s} 62. Nc5 {0.00/41 12s} Ke8 {+0.49/22
11s} 63. Ba5 {0.00/47 8.9s} f5 {+0.49/22 11s} 64. Bd2 {0.00/50 7.8s} Ke7
{+0.55/21 11s} 65. Bg5+ {0.00/52 13s} Kd6 {+0.75/19 3.1s} 66. Nxd3 {0.00/54
7.7s} e4+ {+0.73/21 3.3s} 67. Ke2 {0.00/54 9.5s} exd3+ {+0.73/23 3.5s} 68.
Kxd3 {0.00/56 8.2s} Ke5 {+0.73/24 5.1s} 69. g3 {0.00/55 11s} f4 {+0.74/26
8.6s} 70. Bxf4+ {0.00/54 15s} Nxf4+ {+0.72/22 13s} 71. gxf4+ {0.00/57 73s}
Kxf4 {+0.72/24 3.5s} 72. Ke2 {0.00/45 22s} Ke4 {+0.72/30 9.1s} 73. Kf2
{0.00/47 13s} Kf5 {+0.71/38 11s} 74. Kg3 {0.00/45 11s} Kg5 {+0.71/25 8.3s}
75. Kf3 {0.00/49 1.1s} h4 {+0.77/23 13s} 76. Ke2 {0.00/51 1.7s} Kg4
{+0.71/22 10s} 77. Kf1 {0.00/45 3.4s} Kg3 {+0.71/22 11s} 78. Kg1 {0.00/46
10s} Kf3 {+0.64/20 15s} 79. Kh2 {0.00/46 4.8s} Kg4 {+0.64/20 20s} 80. Kg1
{0.00/44 4.9s} Kf4 {+0.71/21 10s} 81. Kf2 {0.00/48 5.3s} Ke5 {+0.64/19 17s}
82. Kg1 {0.00/41 6.6s} Ke6 {+0.52/20 39s} 83. Kf1 {0.00/45 6.2s} Ke7
{+0.64/20 41s} 84. Kg2 {0.00/45 20s} Kf6 {+0.52/18 6.5s} 85. Kh2 {0.00/46
27s} Kg6 {+0.71/19 7.1s} 86. Kg1 {0.00/46 4.0s} Kg5 {+0.34/18 14s} 87. Kf1
{0.00/50 29s} h3 {+0.64/20 30s} 88. Kg1 {0.00/47 1.5s} Kh5 {+0.58/19 16s}
89. Kh2 {0.00/44 2.5s} Kh4 {+0.46/19 6.0s} 90. Kg1 {0.00/50 15s} Kg5
{+0.46/19 7.7s} 91. Kh2 {0.00/47 2.4s} Kg4 {+0.16/18 6.8s} 92. Kg1 {0.00/50
6.0s} Kg3 {+0.10/19 12s} 93. Kh1 {0.00/51 18s} Kf4 {+0.03/20 7.9s} 94. Kh2
{0.00/52 9.6s} Ke3 {+0.10/19 12s} 95. Kxh3 {0.00/46 5.4s, Draw by
insufficient mating material Insufficient material} 1/2-1/2
[/pgn]
Looking at the silly opening move 1...Na6 and the weird play of Rybka 1 in your 1+1 rook odds event, I remembered that early Rybka versions (at least Rybka 1, maybe 2?) had a bug that showed up in lines where the score exceeded 512 cp either way; it would play almost randomly. Probably rook odds is close enough to this line for this bug to cause serious problems. I recall that even amateur players could give Rybka 1 two pieces or queen handicap and win, even though in normal chess it was stronger than the world champion! Anyway I think it is unsuitable for use in handicap tournaments because of this bug. It was corrected at least by version 2.3.2a, probably by 2.2.
Komodo rules!
Uri Blass
Posts: 10915
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: 15+10 surprising good results with rook odds of stockfish

Post by Uri Blass »

Another surprise.

Stockfish without a rook beat Fruit at 15+10 so it seems that the problem is not only with Rybka so I am not sure if against engines knight odd is smaller than rook a1 odd.

[pgn][Event "?"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2021.05.17"]
[Round "?"]
[White "stockfish_21051510_x64_avx2"]
[Black "Fruit2.2.1"]
[Result "1-0"]
[FEN "rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/1NBQKBNR w Kkq - 0 1"]
[GameDuration "00:58:30"]
[GameEndTime "2021-05-17T17:37:15.280 שעון קיץ ירושלים"]
[GameStartTime "2021-05-17T16:38:45.171 שעון קיץ ירושלים"]
[PlyCount "187"]
[SetUp "1"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]

1. e4 {-6.22/34 88s} Nf6 {+4.46/16 40s} 2. e5 {-5.73/27 6.6s} Nd5 {+4.36/16 29s}
3. d4 {-5.75/30 18s} c5 {+4.43/16 49s} 4. dxc5 {-5.32/30 25s}
Qa5+ {+4.45/16 43s} 5. c3 {-5.40/27 10s} e6 {+4.33/16 33s} 6. Nf3 {-5.48/26 13s}
Bxc5 {+4.27/16 81s} 7. a3 {-5.21/30 12s} Nc6 {+4.23/16 44s} 8. b4 {-5.32/33 49s}
Qb6 {+4.09/17 36s} 9. Qc2 {-5.42/30 14s} Bf8 {+3.96/17 41s}
10. c4 {-5.15/28 16s} Nde7 {+3.83/17 53s} 11. Bb2 {-5.50/32 46s}
Ng6 {+4.27/15 18s} 12. b5 {-5.37/36 110s} Nce7 {+4.28/15 23s}
13. Bd3 {-5.64/35 88s} Nf4 {+4.26/16 29s} 14. Bf1 {-5.72/32 9.7s}
Nf5 {+4.36/15 39s} 15. h4 {-5.75/36 70s} a6 {+4.31/14 31s}
16. Bc1 {-5.59/29 16s} Nd4 {+4.52/15 18s} 17. Nxd4 {-5.48/31 13s}
Qxd4 {+4.40/16 22s} 18. Bb2 {-5.04/32 15s} Qc5 {+4.46/17 29s}
19. Qe4 {-5.64/33 38s} Ng6 {+4.30/17 42s} 20. h5 {-4.96/29 13s}
Ne7 {+4.30/17 27s} 21. Nc3 {-5.05/31 25s} Qb6 {+4.18/16 37s}
22. Bd3 {-5.03/33 65s} Nf5 {+4.09/15 30s} 23. Qf4 {-5.25/32 12s}
Qa5 {+4.25/15 22s} 24. O-O {-5.20/33 14s} Bxa3 {+4.09/15 18s}
25. Ba1 {-5.69/39 132s} Bb4 {+4.61/14 16s} 26. Rc1 {-5.78/34 15s}
axb5 {+4.59/14 15s} 27. Bxf5 {-5.90/36 44s} exf5 {+4.52/14 20s}
28. Nd5 {-5.18/35 42s} Bd2 {+4.60/14 16s} 29. Qg3 {-5.55/37 20s}
Bh6 {+4.40/14 12s} 30. Bc3 {-5.21/35 12s} Qd8 {+4.12/15 23s}
31. e6 {-5.30/32 12s} f4 {+4.07/15 34s} 32. exf7+ {-5.36/33 13s}
Kxf7 {+4.07/15 21s} 33. Qd3 {-5.78/37 31s} bxc4 {+4.04/15 27s}
34. Qf5+ {0.00/43 10s} Kg8 {+4.11/15 11s} 35. Nb6 {0.00/45 13s}
Qxb6 {+3.45/17 29s} 36. Re1 {0.00/50 12s} Qe6 {+3.31/18 10s}
37. Rxe6 {0.00/51 10s} dxe6 {+3.09/19 11s} 38. Qc5 {0.00/52 12s}
Bd7 {+2.32/20 21s} 39. Qe7 {0.00/54 17s} Be8 {+2.29/20 17s}
40. Qxb7 {0.00/53 12s} Rd8 {+0.89/20 18s} 41. Qe7 {0.00/55 14s}
Rb8 {+0.50/20 18s} 42. Be5 {0.00/56 15s} Ra8 {+0.23/20 17s}
43. Qb7 {0.00/58 14s} Rd8 {+0.16/19 12s} 44. Qe7 {0.00/59 11s}
Rd1+ {0.00/19 18s} 45. Kh2 {0.00/52 0.58s} Bf7 {0.00/20 19s}
46. Qc7 {0.00/56 9.4s} Be8 {0.00/20 18s} 47. Qe7 {0.00/58 9.7s}
Bf7 {0.00/22 11s} 48. Qc7 {0.00/61 11s} Bxh5 {0.00/19 11s}
49. Qc8+ {0.00/41 9.0s} Kf7 {0.00/19 16s} 50. Qxh8 {0.00/43 8.8s}
Be2 {0.00/16 13s} 51. Qc8 {+0.48/33 10s} f3 {0.00/15 16s}
52. Qb7+ {+1.18/37 9.1s} Ke8 {-0.21/16 12s} 53. g4 {+1.27/41 21s}
Bg5 {-0.21/15 9.9s} 54. Qxg7 {+1.37/32 6.7s} h6 {-0.36/16 9.3s}
55. Qh7 {+1.40/37 12s} Rf1 {-0.38/14 8.1s} 56. Qa7 {+0.87/41 30s}
Be7 {-1.03/15 17s} 57. Bg3 {+2.48/32 6.6s} Rd1 {-1.19/16 14s}
58. Qb8+ {+2.62/38 29s} Kf7 {-1.41/17 8.4s} 59. Qf4+ {+2.99/34 5.7s}
Kg7 {-1.44/18 10s} 60. Qc7 {+3.50/33 6.1s} Kf8 {-1.44/19 13s}
61. Qe5 {+3.48/35 6.3s} Kf7 {-1.44/18 7.9s} 62. Qh5+ {+4.06/35 6.8s}
Kg7 {-1.44/18 15s} 63. Be5+ {+4.17/37 8.0s} Bf6 {-2.24/17 9.7s}
64. Bf4 {+4.40/37 7.6s} Bg5 {-2.24/17 13s} 65. Bxg5 {+4.55/36 7.6s}
hxg5 {-2.98/17 16s} 66. Qxg5+ {+4.58/38 8.7s} Kf7 {-2.98/19 15s}
67. Qf4+ {+4.63/36 7.1s} Kg6 {-3.00/19 11s} 68. Qe5 {+5.01/38 7.4s}
Bd3 {-2.98/14 11s} 69. Qxe6+ {+5.55/29 12s} Kg5 {-2.98/15 15s}
70. Kg3 {+7.01/33 24s} Rb1 {-3.31/17 14s} 71. Kxf3 {+7.56/29 4.8s}
Rg1 {-3.32/16 12s} 72. Qe5+ {+8.90/30 7.3s} Kg6 {-4.14/16 7.8s}
73. Kf4 {+9.09/33 23s} Rf1 {-3.49/16 14s} 74. Qe6+ {+9.60/27 6.2s}
Kg7 {-3.50/15 12s} 75. Kg3 {+9.94/28 6.7s} Bg6 {-4.72/16 51s}
76. Qxc4 {+13.80/28 15s} Rg1+ {-4.87/16 7.0s} 77. Kf4 {+58.83/44 9.0s}
Bf7 {-4.87/16 8.8s} 78. Qd4+ {+62.20/40 8.8s} Kh7 {-6.07/19 27s}
79. Kg5 {+M39/47 7.6s} Re1 {-7.96/18 9.8s} 80. f4 {+M29/57 14s}
Re8 {-8.34/18 9.9s} 81. f5 {+M27/61 4.5s} Rb8 {-10.70/17 11s}
82. Kf6 {+M25/60 6.5s} Rf8 {-10.81/18 5.3s} 83. Qd6 {+M23/68 6.9s}
Kg8 {-10.88/17 12s} 84. Kg5 {+M21/71 7.1s} Rc8 {-M20/16 6.6s}
85. Kh6 {+M19/72 8.6s} Re8 {-M18/19 6.7s} 86. g5 {+M17/76 7.5s}
Re1 {-M16/32 6.4s} 87. Qb8+ {+M15/114 7.8s} Re8 {-M14/58 7.4s}
88. Qb7 {+M13/146 7.9s} Re2 {-M12/55 7.1s} 89. g6 {+M11/205 32s}
Rh2+ {-M10/53 6.9s} 90. Kg5 {+M9/245 0.045s} Rh5+ {-M8/53 8.1s}
91. Kxh5 {+M7/245 0.14s} Be8 {-M6/54 8.5s} 92. Qe7 {+M5/245 0.036s}
Bb5 {-M4/50 7.4s} 93. Qh7+ {+M3/245 0.004s} Kf8 {-M2/4 0.001s}
94. Qf7# {+M1/245 0.003s, White mates} 1-0

[/pgn]
lkaufman
Posts: 6259
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 am
Location: Maryland USA
Full name: Larry Kaufman

Re: 15+10 surprising good results with rook odds of stockfish

Post by lkaufman »

Uri Blass wrote: Mon May 17, 2021 4:39 pm Another surprise.

Stockfish without a rook beat Fruit at 15+10 so it seems that the problem is not only with Rybka so I am not sure if against engines knight odd is smaller than rook a1 odd.

[pgn][Event "?"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2021.05.17"]
[Round "?"]
[White "stockfish_21051510_x64_avx2"]
[Black "Fruit2.2.1"]
[Result "1-0"]
[FEN "rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/1NBQKBNR w Kkq - 0 1"]
[GameDuration "00:58:30"]
[GameEndTime "2021-05-17T17:37:15.280 שעון קיץ ירושלים"]
[GameStartTime "2021-05-17T16:38:45.171 שעון קיץ ירושלים"]
[PlyCount "187"]
[SetUp "1"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]

1. e4 {-6.22/34 88s} Nf6 {+4.46/16 40s} 2. e5 {-5.73/27 6.6s} Nd5 {+4.36/16 29s}
3. d4 {-5.75/30 18s} c5 {+4.43/16 49s} 4. dxc5 {-5.32/30 25s}
Qa5+ {+4.45/16 43s} 5. c3 {-5.40/27 10s} e6 {+4.33/16 33s} 6. Nf3 {-5.48/26 13s}
Bxc5 {+4.27/16 81s} 7. a3 {-5.21/30 12s} Nc6 {+4.23/16 44s} 8. b4 {-5.32/33 49s}
Qb6 {+4.09/17 36s} 9. Qc2 {-5.42/30 14s} Bf8 {+3.96/17 41s}
10. c4 {-5.15/28 16s} Nde7 {+3.83/17 53s} 11. Bb2 {-5.50/32 46s}
Ng6 {+4.27/15 18s} 12. b5 {-5.37/36 110s} Nce7 {+4.28/15 23s}
13. Bd3 {-5.64/35 88s} Nf4 {+4.26/16 29s} 14. Bf1 {-5.72/32 9.7s}
Nf5 {+4.36/15 39s} 15. h4 {-5.75/36 70s} a6 {+4.31/14 31s}
16. Bc1 {-5.59/29 16s} Nd4 {+4.52/15 18s} 17. Nxd4 {-5.48/31 13s}
Qxd4 {+4.40/16 22s} 18. Bb2 {-5.04/32 15s} Qc5 {+4.46/17 29s}
19. Qe4 {-5.64/33 38s} Ng6 {+4.30/17 42s} 20. h5 {-4.96/29 13s}
Ne7 {+4.30/17 27s} 21. Nc3 {-5.05/31 25s} Qb6 {+4.18/16 37s}
22. Bd3 {-5.03/33 65s} Nf5 {+4.09/15 30s} 23. Qf4 {-5.25/32 12s}
Qa5 {+4.25/15 22s} 24. O-O {-5.20/33 14s} Bxa3 {+4.09/15 18s}
25. Ba1 {-5.69/39 132s} Bb4 {+4.61/14 16s} 26. Rc1 {-5.78/34 15s}
axb5 {+4.59/14 15s} 27. Bxf5 {-5.90/36 44s} exf5 {+4.52/14 20s}
28. Nd5 {-5.18/35 42s} Bd2 {+4.60/14 16s} 29. Qg3 {-5.55/37 20s}
Bh6 {+4.40/14 12s} 30. Bc3 {-5.21/35 12s} Qd8 {+4.12/15 23s}
31. e6 {-5.30/32 12s} f4 {+4.07/15 34s} 32. exf7+ {-5.36/33 13s}
Kxf7 {+4.07/15 21s} 33. Qd3 {-5.78/37 31s} bxc4 {+4.04/15 27s}
34. Qf5+ {0.00/43 10s} Kg8 {+4.11/15 11s} 35. Nb6 {0.00/45 13s}
Qxb6 {+3.45/17 29s} 36. Re1 {0.00/50 12s} Qe6 {+3.31/18 10s}
37. Rxe6 {0.00/51 10s} dxe6 {+3.09/19 11s} 38. Qc5 {0.00/52 12s}
Bd7 {+2.32/20 21s} 39. Qe7 {0.00/54 17s} Be8 {+2.29/20 17s}
40. Qxb7 {0.00/53 12s} Rd8 {+0.89/20 18s} 41. Qe7 {0.00/55 14s}
Rb8 {+0.50/20 18s} 42. Be5 {0.00/56 15s} Ra8 {+0.23/20 17s}
43. Qb7 {0.00/58 14s} Rd8 {+0.16/19 12s} 44. Qe7 {0.00/59 11s}
Rd1+ {0.00/19 18s} 45. Kh2 {0.00/52 0.58s} Bf7 {0.00/20 19s}
46. Qc7 {0.00/56 9.4s} Be8 {0.00/20 18s} 47. Qe7 {0.00/58 9.7s}
Bf7 {0.00/22 11s} 48. Qc7 {0.00/61 11s} Bxh5 {0.00/19 11s}
49. Qc8+ {0.00/41 9.0s} Kf7 {0.00/19 16s} 50. Qxh8 {0.00/43 8.8s}
Be2 {0.00/16 13s} 51. Qc8 {+0.48/33 10s} f3 {0.00/15 16s}
52. Qb7+ {+1.18/37 9.1s} Ke8 {-0.21/16 12s} 53. g4 {+1.27/41 21s}
Bg5 {-0.21/15 9.9s} 54. Qxg7 {+1.37/32 6.7s} h6 {-0.36/16 9.3s}
55. Qh7 {+1.40/37 12s} Rf1 {-0.38/14 8.1s} 56. Qa7 {+0.87/41 30s}
Be7 {-1.03/15 17s} 57. Bg3 {+2.48/32 6.6s} Rd1 {-1.19/16 14s}
58. Qb8+ {+2.62/38 29s} Kf7 {-1.41/17 8.4s} 59. Qf4+ {+2.99/34 5.7s}
Kg7 {-1.44/18 10s} 60. Qc7 {+3.50/33 6.1s} Kf8 {-1.44/19 13s}
61. Qe5 {+3.48/35 6.3s} Kf7 {-1.44/18 7.9s} 62. Qh5+ {+4.06/35 6.8s}
Kg7 {-1.44/18 15s} 63. Be5+ {+4.17/37 8.0s} Bf6 {-2.24/17 9.7s}
64. Bf4 {+4.40/37 7.6s} Bg5 {-2.24/17 13s} 65. Bxg5 {+4.55/36 7.6s}
hxg5 {-2.98/17 16s} 66. Qxg5+ {+4.58/38 8.7s} Kf7 {-2.98/19 15s}
67. Qf4+ {+4.63/36 7.1s} Kg6 {-3.00/19 11s} 68. Qe5 {+5.01/38 7.4s}
Bd3 {-2.98/14 11s} 69. Qxe6+ {+5.55/29 12s} Kg5 {-2.98/15 15s}
70. Kg3 {+7.01/33 24s} Rb1 {-3.31/17 14s} 71. Kxf3 {+7.56/29 4.8s}
Rg1 {-3.32/16 12s} 72. Qe5+ {+8.90/30 7.3s} Kg6 {-4.14/16 7.8s}
73. Kf4 {+9.09/33 23s} Rf1 {-3.49/16 14s} 74. Qe6+ {+9.60/27 6.2s}
Kg7 {-3.50/15 12s} 75. Kg3 {+9.94/28 6.7s} Bg6 {-4.72/16 51s}
76. Qxc4 {+13.80/28 15s} Rg1+ {-4.87/16 7.0s} 77. Kf4 {+58.83/44 9.0s}
Bf7 {-4.87/16 8.8s} 78. Qd4+ {+62.20/40 8.8s} Kh7 {-6.07/19 27s}
79. Kg5 {+M39/47 7.6s} Re1 {-7.96/18 9.8s} 80. f4 {+M29/57 14s}
Re8 {-8.34/18 9.9s} 81. f5 {+M27/61 4.5s} Rb8 {-10.70/17 11s}
82. Kf6 {+M25/60 6.5s} Rf8 {-10.81/18 5.3s} 83. Qd6 {+M23/68 6.9s}
Kg8 {-10.88/17 12s} 84. Kg5 {+M21/71 7.1s} Rc8 {-M20/16 6.6s}
85. Kh6 {+M19/72 8.6s} Re8 {-M18/19 6.7s} 86. g5 {+M17/76 7.5s}
Re1 {-M16/32 6.4s} 87. Qb8+ {+M15/114 7.8s} Re8 {-M14/58 7.4s}
88. Qb7 {+M13/146 7.9s} Re2 {-M12/55 7.1s} 89. g6 {+M11/205 32s}
Rh2+ {-M10/53 6.9s} 90. Kg5 {+M9/245 0.045s} Rh5+ {-M8/53 8.1s}
91. Kxh5 {+M7/245 0.14s} Be8 {-M6/54 8.5s} 92. Qe7 {+M5/245 0.036s}
Bb5 {-M4/50 7.4s} 93. Qh7+ {+M3/245 0.004s} Kf8 {-M2/4 0.001s}
94. Qf7# {+M1/245 0.003s, White mates} 1-0

[/pgn]
Well I've done enough extensive tests to prove that rook odds is clearly a larger handicap than knight odds in general between engines, but it may be that certain engines play better with or without a rook than with or without a knight. Most likely it's just a question of the tiny sample size, but I'm surprised that SF won a single game from Fruit 2.2.1 at rook handicap.
Komodo rules!