What a move 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderators: Harvey Williamson, Dann Corbit, hgm

Forum rules
This textbox is used to restore diagrams posted with the [d] tag before the upgrade.
Lyudmil Tsvetkov
Posts: 6052
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2012 10:41 am

Re: 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017: SUMMARY

Post by Lyudmil Tsvetkov » Thu Jun 15, 2017 4:27 pm

Jeroen wrote:LOL, you are one funny guy :). When the going gets tough, you are starting to shout.

It is YOU who claims a lot of things, without backing them up with proper analysis. My conclusion is, that you are not interested in the truth, but only to prove 'you are right'. It doesn't matter how, you just post something, sometimes even without checking. The best example is your 11.a3 Bxa3 12.Rxa3 Qxa3 13.c5 a5??, which you claimed (after only ONE SECOND of SF analysis) was a "forced draw" and instead lost instantly.

Furthermore, in your first posting about this subject, you just claim that Aronian's 11.a3 is bad, 11.c5 is clearly better (without proper analysis, something Aronian surely has done) and thus, you know better than Aronian. Talking about arrogance. And when people show you that you are wrong, you suddenly refrain from answering, or discussing the variation that was shown to you.

I might as well give the readers a summary, as the thread becomes a little bit unreadable, especially regarding the analysis:

1. 11.a3! is surely the most clear cut move in the position, white gets an advantage in all lines. Best now is 11... Bd6, as shown by both Komodo and Stockfish, but then 12.e4 is pleasant for white.

2. 11.a3! Bxa3?! as played by Carlsen, is extremely risky. 12.Rxa3 Qxa3 13.c5 and now:

A) 13... a5?? ("draw", Lyudmil) loses instantly. SF quickly over +2.
B) 13... e5? ("draw", Lyudmil) is also bad. SF quickly over +1.
C) 13... b6 (played by Carlsen), also the top move of the engines, after a deep search. SF scores it at +0.82, d=45 on my quad. It might be the best practical chance to muddy in the waters.
D) 13... Ne4 (Lyudmil's next proposal), surely a good candidate move. But instead of analysing it until the end, we get the message "draw, not enough material left". Nonsense, there are two rooks, two minor pieces and 11 pawns left and it surely is not "an easy draw".

3. 11.c5 ("clearly better for white", Lyudmil, when he first posted it, this was repeated several times, later downgraded to "complicated" and/or "it is tricky"). So far nothing conclusive about this line yet, so why enter this unclear territory when 11.a3! gives the advantage, with a high chance of success? From a human standpoint the choice is 100% clear.

4. 11.c5 e5 12.a3 (?!) Bxc3 13.Bxc3 e4 14.Nd2 Nf8 15.Re1 Bg4 16.f3 exf3 17.gxf3 Bh3 ("white is better, SF will need some 10 moves to get the same conclusion", Lyudmil) is just better for black, many analysis given here. SF simply piles up the pressure on the K-side and white can only defend. On my request to give better variations on the ones I posted: no reply.
is that difficult to understand sometimes people are indeed busy?

I already demonstrated the position is a DRAW, please see relevant post, so you should definitely apologise.

do not time to read everything you and Possioto have written, just 2 quick remarks:

- so far all you have done is post SF output, what are so proud about?
- concerning the f3 ef3 gf3 line, SF scores are certainly bogus, I can show you much better lines for white, but there are so many variations that the analysis certainly can never be exhaustive. On the other hand, you posted just 2, mostly irrelevant and very short line, with a lot of SF/your stupid moves.
- your b6 also certainly loses, just again very rich position with a lot of variations for a fully exhaustive analysis.

so, far, I have:
- made an already interesting thread even more interesting, creating an useful discussion
- posted valuable remarks, most of which, if not all, are true
- posted twice or 3 times as much output as the 5 persons of you scalding me
- done all that, while busy with a lot more meanigful things, overall I have spent an hoyr and a half analysing this, and still performed better than all of you!

so I really do not understand why you do not thank me, instead of throwing a fury of invectives?

and once again, the position is a DRAW, so please apologise.

PS. again, I am waiting for something substantial of you, couple of pages of analysis, with definite proofs, and not just bare claims.
where is your analysis?

Lyudmil Tsvetkov
Posts: 6052
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2012 10:41 am

Re: What a move 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017

Post by Lyudmil Tsvetkov » Thu Jun 15, 2017 4:29 pm

Jeroen wrote:
if I want , and if spare the time, I can tottaly annihalate any possible claim by you, but I simply do not want to waste my time in pointless discussions.
You cannot "annihilate" anything, because you aren't searching for the truth in these positions and you have great difficulty in accepting this.

You also don't want to "waste time on pointless discussions", because it is sure that you will lose them.

Dear Lyudmil, you are not superior to Aronian. You are not superior to the top engines. You are not superior to a forum with a lot of chess players and users with big hardware. If you make wrong claims, they will be uncovered. Accept the fact. You made a LOT of wrong claims.

Time to look into the mirror.
dear Jeroen, DRAW!

Lyudmil Tsvetkov
Posts: 6052
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2012 10:41 am

For Possioto and Noomen enjoyment!

Post by Lyudmil Tsvetkov » Thu Jun 15, 2017 5:09 pm

I ran a 10 game shootout with Komodo 10.1 from the starting position, and white won 3 games, while 7 were drawn.

so, if anything, my assessment is at least 2+ times better than yours.

you trust engines, do not you?

below the 10 games:

[pgn]
[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1-0"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "85"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.94/18 0} 3. Kf3
{0.89/19 1} Ra3+ {0.86/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.85/21 4} Kc8 {0.78/19 2} 5. Rb1 {0.87/
17 1} Kc7 {0.85/18 1} 6. Kf4 {0.96/18 1} g5+ {0.90/17 1 (Ra5)} 7. Kg4 {0.98/18
0} Nf6+ {0.95/19 1} 8. Kf3 {1.00/18 0} h5 {1.00/20 3 (Ng8)} 9. h4 {1.01/22 2
(Rh1)} gxh4 {1.03/21 1} 10. Rh1 {1.03/22 1} Ng4 {0.99/22 1} 11. e5 {1.10/22 2}
f6 {1.04/23 2} 12. exf6 {1.16/22 1} Nxf6 {1.07/23 2} 13. Rxh4 {1.28/23 2} Kd8 {
1.15/22 2} 14. Rh1 {1.19/23 3} Kd7 {1.19/23 1} 15. Rb1 {1.19/21 0} Kc7 {1.16/
22 2} 16. Re1 {1.19/21 1} Kd7 {1.13/23 1} 17. Rh1 {1.13/22 1} Kd8 {1.15/22 1}
18. Kf4 {1.15/22 1} Ra2 {1.16/21 1} 19. Kg3 {1.23/21 3} Kc7 {1.32/19 1 (Ra3)}
20. Rh4 {1.32/20 1} Ra3 {1.32/21 2 (Kb7)} 21. Rf4 {1.38/21 1} Ng4 {1.38/19 0}
22. Kf3 {1.43/20 1} Kd8 {1.44/19 1} 23. Rf8+ {1.43/19 1} Ke7 {1.39/19 1} 24.
Rc8 {1.49/19 0} e5 {1.42/18 1} 25. dxe5 {1.51/18 1} Ke6 {1.50/19 1} 26. Rxc6+ {
1.59/19 1} Kxe5 {1.42/19 1} 27. Rg6 {1.57/21 1} Nxe3 {1.70/20 1} 28. fxe3 {1.
49/21 1} h4 {1.49/22 1} 29. Rg4 {1.55/21 1} Kd5 {1.74/21 1} 30. Rxh4 {1.94/22 1
} Kxc5 {1.97/21 0} 31. Rf4 {2.06/22 1} Kd6 {2.06/20 1} 32. g4 {2.11/20 0} Ra7 {
2.13/22 1} 33. g5 {2.06/24 1} Rg7 {2.13/24 1} 34. Kg4 {2.25/25 3 (Rf5)} Ke5 {
2.37/19 0} 35. Kh5 {3.22/20 1} Rh7+ {3.43/21 1} 36. Kg6 {3.47/22 0} Rh3 {3.88/
22 2} 37. Rf8 {4.13/22 1} Rg3 {4.22/23 1 (Kd6)} 38. Re8+ {4.34/21 0} Kd5 {4.58/
22 1} 39. Kf6 {4.59/22 0} Rg2 {5.15/23 2} 40. g6 {5.19/22 0} Kd6 {5.87/23 2
(Rf2+)} 41. g7 {6.23/19 0} Rf2+ {7.76/19 1} 42. Kg6 {7.78/19 0} Rg2+ {7.79/19 0
} 43. Kh7 {7.79/20 0} 1-0

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "183"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.80/19 1} 3. Kf3
{0.94/20 1} Ra3+ {0.75/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.73/18 1} Kc8 {0.76/18 1} 5. Rb2 {0.78/
16 0} e5 {0.71/18 1} 6. Ke2 {0.77/18 1} exd4 {0.77/18 1} 7. Bxd4 {0.84/17 0} g5
{0.77/19 2 (f6)} 8. f3 {0.87/17 1} h5 {0.73/18 1 (Ra5)} 9. Rd2 {0.79/20 3 (Kf2)
} h4 {0.73/20 2} 10. h3 {0.73/21 1} Ra5 {0.70/21 1} 11. Rc2 {0.70/19 0} Ra3 {
0.70/21 1} 12. Be3 {0.70/23 1} f6 {0.70/24 1} 13. Rd2 {0.70/25 1} Ne5 {0.61/22
1} 14. Bd4 {0.61/21 1} Kc7 {0.61/21 1} 15. Rc2 {0.61/23 2} Kb7 {0.61/24 1} 16.
Rb2+ {0.61/25 1} Kc7 {0.61/24 1} 17. Rd2 {0.61/23 0} Ra4 {0.61/25 1 (Nc4)} 18.
Kf2 {0.61/25 1} Nc4 {0.61/26 1} 19. Rd1 {0.66/24 1} Ne5 {0.60/22 0} 20. Kf1 {
0.61/23 1 (Bxe5+)} Rc4 {0.59/24 1} 21. Rd2 {0.62/24 1} Ra4 {0.61/25 1} 22. Kg1
{0.61/22 1 (Bxe5+)} Rc4 {0.61/26 1} 23. Kf1 {0.59/23 1 (Kf2)} Ra4 {0.58/23 1}
24. Kg1 {0.61/26 1 (Bf2)} Ra7 {0.61/24 1 (Rc4)} 25. Rd1 {0.61/25 1} Ra4 {0.61/
25 1} 26. Kh1 {0.61/24 3} Rc4 {0.58/23 1} 27. Rd2 {0.57/23 0} Rb4 {0.56/22 0
(Rc1+)} 28. Bg1 {0.65/23 2 (Kh2)} Nf7 {0.65/23 1 (Rb1)} 29. Bf2 {0.71/22 1} Ne5
{0.58/23 1} 30. Rd6 {0.83/22 1} Rb1+ {0.80/20 1} 31. Bg1 {0.83/22 1} Nd7 {0.84/
21 1} 32. Kh2 {0.84/22 1} Rc1 {0.82/21 1} 33. Re6 {0.89/21 1} Rd1 {0.95/22 2
(Rc2)} 34. Bf2 {0.73/21 1 (Be3)} Rd2 {0.67/21 1} 35. Be1 {0.77/20 1} Rc2 {0.84/
20 2} 36. Ba5+ {0.66/21 1} Kb7 {0.52/21 1} 37. Bd8 {0.71/20 0} Rxc5 {0.59/21 1}
38. Bxf6 {0.61/19 1} Nxf6 {0.53/18 0} 39. Rxf6 {0.58/20 1} Rb5 {0.52/19 1} 40.
Rf5 {0.52/19 0} Kb6 {0.58/21 2} 41. e5 {0.54/19 0} c5 {0.50/21 1} 42. e6 {0.73/
20 1} Kc6 {0.69/20 0} 43. Re5 {0.77/19 0} Rb8 {0.77/19 0} 44. Kg1 {0.74/20 0}
Re8 {0.65/19 1 (Kd6)} 45. Kf2 {0.58/21 1} Re7 {0.53/20 1} 46. Ke2 {0.59/20 1
(Ke3)} Kd6 {0.61/20 1} 47. Rxg5 {0.64/19 0} Rxe6+ {0.59/21 1} 48. Kd1 {0.72/21
1} Rh6 {0.70/20 1} 49. Rg4 {0.70/19 0} Kd5 {0.62/19 0} 50. Kc2 {0.56/19 1} Ra6
{0.46/18 0} 51. Kb3 {0.43/19 1} Re6 {0.43/19 0} 52. Rxh4 {0.43/17 0} Re3+ {0.
42/18 0} 53. Kc2 {0.48/20 1} Re2+ {0.47/18 0} 54. Kd3 {0.42/20 1} Rxg2 {0.41/
18 0} 55. Rh5+ {0.43/17 0} Kd6 {0.42/19 1 (Kc6)} 56. h4 {0.41/20 1} Rh2 {0.41/
18 0 (Rf2)} 57. Rh8 {0.39/19 1 (Ke3)} Ke5 {0.38/19 0} 58. Ke3 {0.41/19 0} c4 {
0.40/19 0 (Kd5)} 59. h5 {0.41/19 0} c3 {0.42/19 0} 60. Rc8 {0.43/20 0 (h6)} c2
{0.43/20 0} 61. h6 {0.42/19 0} Kd5 {0.40/21 0} 62. Rc3 {0.39/21 0} Ke5 {0.40/
21 0} 63. h7 {0.40/21 0} Rxh7 {0.42/21 0} 64. Rxc2 {0.44/21 1 (Rc5+)} Re7 {0.
44/22 0} 65. Rc5+ {0.44/22 0} Kd6+ {0.42/22 0} 66. Kd4 {0.42/22 0} Re1 {0.41/
23 0} 67. Rc8 {0.41/23 0} Ke7 {0.40/24 0} 68. Rc6 {0.39/24 0} Kf7 {0.39/25 0}
69. Rh6 {0.39/21 0 (Ra6)} Kg7 {0.38/24 0} 70. Rb6 {0.38/22 0 (Ra6)} Kf7 {0.38/
24 0 (Re7)} 71. Rh6 {0.38/22 0 (Rb7+)} Re8 {0.38/25 0} 72. Kd5 {0.38/21 0} Re1
{0.37/23 0} 73. Ra6 {0.36/23 0} Re3 {0.35/21 0} 74. f4 {0.34/22 0} Re8 {0.34/
24 0} 75. Rc6 {0.34/24 0 (Rb6)} Re2 {0.34/25 0} 76. Rb6 {0.34/23 0} Re1 {0.28/
24 0} 77. Ra6 {0.28/22 0 (Rh6)} Re8 {0.28/24 0} 78. Rc6 {0.28/23 0 (Ra5)} Re1 {
0.28/24 0} 79. Rb6 {0.28/24 0} Re2 {0.28/24 0 (Re8)} 80. Rh6 {0.28/19 0 (Kd4)}
Re1 {0.28/24 0 (Re3)} 81. Kd4 {0.28/23 0} Re6 {0.28/21 0} 82. Rh5 {0.27/22 0}
Kf6 {0.26/24 0} 83. Rd5 {0.26/24 0} Re1 {0.26/25 0} 84. Rc5 {0.26/21 0} Ke6 {
0.26/24 0} 85. Rg5 {0.26/20 0 (Rb5)} Kf6 {0.26/24 0} 86. Ra5 {0.26/19 0 (Kd3)}
Ke6 {0.26/23 0 (Re7)} 87. Rc5 {0.26/22 0} Kf6 {0.26/25 0} 88. Rg5 {0.26/20 0
(Rb5)} Rf1 {0.24/22 0 (Kf7)} 89. Ke4 {0.24/21 0 (Ke3)} Re1+ {0.24/22 0} 90. Kd4
{0.24/21 0 (Kf3)} Rf1 {0.24/24 0} 91. Ke3 {0.24/23 0} Re1+ {0.21/24 0} 92. Kf2
{0.21/23 0} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "266"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.80/19 1} 3. Kf3
{0.94/20 1} Ra3+ {0.75/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.73/18 1} Kc8 {0.76/18 1} 5. Rb2 {0.78/
16 0} e5 {0.71/18 1} 6. Ke2 {0.77/18 1} exd4 {0.74/19 2} 7. Bxd4 {0.80/19 0} f6
{0.80/18 1} 8. f3 {0.84/18 1} Ra5 {0.80/18 1} 9. Rc2 {0.78/19 1} Nf8 {0.78/18 1
} 10. Kd3 {0.81/17 1} Kd7 {0.74/19 2 (Ne6)} 11. Be3 {0.73/18 2 (Kc4)} Ke7 {0.
78/18 1} 12. Kc4 {0.83/19 2} Ne6 {0.79/19 1} 13. Rb2 {0.85/18 1} Ra4+ {0.83/19
2} 14. Kd3 {0.78/19 2} Ra5 {0.76/20 1} 15. Kc4 {0.77/21 2 (Rb7+)} Ra4+ {0.75/
21 3} 16. Kd3 {0.82/17 0 (Kb3)} g5 {0.70/17 1 (Kd8)} 17. h3 {0.68/18 2 (g3)}
Ra3+ {0.65/19 2} 18. Kd2 {0.62/21 4 (Ke2)} Kf7 {0.70/20 1} 19. Rb7+ {0.66/20 1}
Ke8 {0.60/20 1} 20. Rb2 {0.64/19 1 (Rh7)} Kf7 {0.55/20 3} 21. Rb7+ {0.61/18 1
(g3)} Ke8 {0.53/20 1} 22. Rb6 {0.53/20 1} Ra2+ {0.53/21 1} 23. Ke1 {0.54/20 1}
Kd7 {0.54/20 1 (Ra1+)} 24. Rb7+ {0.49/20 1} Ke8 {0.49/20 1} 25. Rb8+ {0.49/21 1
} Kf7 {0.49/20 0} 26. Kf1 {0.51/21 1} Ra1+ {0.36/19 1 (Ra3)} 27. Kf2 {0.41/19 0
} Ra2+ {0.48/19 1} 28. Kg1 {0.47/20 1} Ra1+ {0.40/20 1} 29. Kh2 {0.45/20 1} Ra3
{0.48/20 1} 30. Rb7+ {0.55/20 1} Ke8 {0.53/20 0} 31. Bf2 {0.51/21 1} Ra2 {0.51/
20 0} 32. Bg3 {0.54/20 1} Nd4 {0.44/20 1} 33. Bd6 {0.44/19 0} Nxf3+ {0.45/19 1}
34. Kg3 {0.52/19 0} Nd4 {0.48/20 1} 35. Re7+ {0.51/21 1} Kd8 {0.41/21 1} 36.
Rf7 {0.55/22 2} Re2 {0.44/21 1} 37. Rxf6 {0.66/20 1} Rxe4 {0.70/19 1} 38. Rxh6
{0.72/20 1} Nf5+ {0.46/21 2} 39. Kf3 {0.53/20 0} Re3+ {0.54/18 0} 40. Kf2 {0.
62/20 0} Rd3 {0.60/20 0} 41. Rg6 {0.55/20 1} Rd2+ {0.55/18 0} 42. Kg1 {0.63/20
1} Nxd6 {0.65/19 1} 43. cxd6 {0.65/19 0} Rd5 {0.69/17 0 (Kd7)} 44. Rg7 {0.71/
19 0} c5 {0.68/21 1} 45. Rc7 {0.66/19 1} g4 {0.80/17 0} 46. hxg4 {0.80/19 0}
Rxd6 {0.79/20 1 (Rg5)} 47. Rxc5 {0.78/20 0} Ke7 {0.74/21 0} 48. Rf5 {0.88/19 0
(Kf2)} Rd4 {0.90/21 0} 49. g5 {0.92/22 0} Ke6 {0.92/22 0} 50. Rf6+ {0.92/23 0}
Ke7 {0.87/23 0} 51. Ra6 {0.86/24 0} Rg4 {0.85/23 0 (Kf7)} 52. g6 {0.84/26 1}
Kf8 {0.84/24 0} 53. Kf2 {0.84/26 0} Kg7 {0.84/26 0} 54. Kf3 {0.83/27 0} Rd4 {
0.84/26 0} 55. Re6 {0.83/27 0} Rb4 {0.83/26 0} 56. g3 {0.83/26 0} Rd4 {0.82/25
0} 57. Rb6 {0.86/26 0 (Ra6)} Ra4 {0.82/24 0} 58. Rd6 {0.82/26 0 (Kg2)} Rc4 {0.
84/26 0} 59. Ra6 {0.81/28 0} Rc3+ {0.81/25 0 (Rb4)} 60. Kf4 {0.81/27 0} Rc4+ {
0.78/23 0} 61. Kf5 {0.78/26 0} Rc5+ {0.78/27 0} 62. Kg4 {0.78/28 0} Rc4+ {0.77/
27 0} 63. Kh5 {0.77/27 0} Rc5+ {0.76/25 0} 64. Kg4 {0.76/27 0 (Kh4)} Rc4+ {0.
76/28 0} 65. Kh5 {0.75/28 0 (Kh3)} Rc5+ {0.75/29 0} 66. Kh4 {0.74/23 0} Rc4+ {
0.74/26 0} 67. Kh3 {0.74/24 0} Rb4 {0.74/27 0} 68. Re6 {0.80/24 0} Rc4 {0.74/
24 0} 69. Rd6 {0.70/23 0} Ra4 {0.66/24 0} 70. Rc6 {0.66/26 0} Rb4 {0.66/22 0}
71. Kg2 {0.66/24 0} Rb3 {0.83/20 0 (Rb5)} 72. Ra6 {0.77/21 0} Rc3 {0.73/21 0
(Kh6)} 73. Re6 {0.66/23 0} Ra3 {0.66/24 0} 74. Kh3 {0.66/21 0} Ra4 {0.65/22 0}
75. Rb6 {0.63/23 0} Ra5 {0.59/19 0} 76. Re6 {0.54/20 0 (Kg4)} Ra4 {0.53/19 0}
77. Rb6 {0.53/22 0 (g4)} Ra5 {0.52/21 0 (Ra3)} 78. Rc6 {0.52/23 0 (Kg4)} Ra4 {
0.52/22 0} 79. g4 {0.52/20 0 (Kg2)} Ra3+ {0.51/18 0} 80. Kh4 {0.51/20 0} Kh6 {
0.47/21 0} 81. Re6 {0.45/21 0} Ra1 {0.45/21 0} 82. Rb6 {0.45/23 0 (Kg3)} Rh1+ {
0.45/23 0} 83. Kg3 {0.45/5 0} Rg1+ {0.44/21 0} 84. Kf3 {0.44/22 0} Rf1+ {0.44/
22 0} 85. Kg2 {0.44/19 0} Rd1 {0.44/19 0} 86. Rc6 {0.43/20 0} Rd7 {0.43/18 0}
87. g7+ {0.43/17 0} Kxg7 {0.43/21 0} 88. Kg3 {0.43/21 0} Rd3+ {0.42/22 0} 89.
Kh4 {0.42/23 0} Rd5 {0.42/24 0} 90. Ra6 {0.42/24 0} Rb5 {0.41/22 0} 91. Rd6 {
0.41/22 0} Ra5 {0.41/23 0} 92. Rb6 {0.41/20 0} Rc5 {0.41/22 0} 93. Re6 {0.40/
22 0} Rb5 {0.40/22 0} 94. Rd6 {0.39/22 0 (Ra6)} Rc5 {0.38/22 0 (Ra5)} 95. Ra6 {
0.37/18 0 (Rb6)} Kf7 {0.37/22 0} 96. Rb6 {0.37/22 0 (Ra7+)} Kg7 {0.37/23 0} 97.
Rb7+ {0.37/23 0} Kh6 {0.37/20 0 (Kg6)} 98. Rb8 {0.37/20 0} Rc6 {0.37/21 0 (Kg7)
} 99. Rd8 {0.37/22 0} Kg7 {0.37/22 0} 100. Rd7+ {0.35/23 0} Kg6 {0.35/23 0}
101. Ra7 {0.35/23 0} Rc5 {0.34/21 0} 102. Ra6+ {0.34/18 0 (Re7)} Kg7 {0.34/19 0
} 103. Rb6 {0.34/21 0} Kf7 {0.34/22 0} 104. Rb7+ {0.34/20 0} Kg6 {0.33/22 0}
105. Ra7 {0.32/20 0} Rc6 {0.32/22 0} 106. Rb7 {0.32/20 0 (Rd7)} Kh6 {0.31/18 0}
107. Ra7 {0.32/19 0 (Re7)} Kg6 {0.32/16 0} 108. Rd7 {0.31/19 0 (Ra8)} Rc5 {0.
31/20 0} 109. Rd1 {0.31/21 0} Kg7 {0.31/17 0} 110. Re1 {0.31/20 0} Kf6 {0.31/
17 0 (Rc6)} 111. Rb1 {0.32/18 0} Kg7 {0.31/20 0} 112. Rb6 {0.31/19 0 (Rb8)} Kf7
{0.29/18 0} 113. Rb1 {0.29/18 0 (Rb8)} Kg6 {0.29/19 0} 114. Rb7 {0.29/19 0
(Ra1)} Rc6 {0.29/20 0} 115. Ra7 {0.28/20 0 (Rb5)} Kh6 {0.28/21 0 (Rc5)} 116.
Ra8 {0.27/20 0 (Re7)} Rc5 {0.27/19 0} 117. Ra6+ {0.27/17 0 (Re8)} Kg7 {0.27/19
0} 118. Ra1 {0.27/20 0} Kh6 {0.27/19 0} 119. Re1 {0.27/15 0 (Ra4)} Kg7 {0.27/
13 0} 120. Ra1 {0.27/16 0 (Re7+)} Kh6 {0.27/13 0} 121. Rd1 {0.27/17 0 (Rf1)}
Kg6 {0.27/15 0 (Rc6)} 122. Rd8 {0.27/18 0} Kg7 {0.27/16 0} 123. Rd6 {0.26/15 0
(Rb8)} Kf7 {0.25/13 0} 124. Rd1 {0.27/17 0 (Kg3)} Kg6 {0.27/19 0} 125. Rd4 {0.
26/19 0} Kf7 {0.27/16 0} 126. Rb4 {0.27/17 0} Kg7 {0.27/18 0} 127. Ra4 {0.26/
16 0} Rc6 {0.25/14 0} 128. Ra1 {0.26/14 0} Rh6+ {0.26/16 0} 129. Kg3 {0.27/16 0
} Rc6 {0.26/16 0} 130. Ra2 {0.20/16 0} Rc5 {0.20/16 0} 131. Kh4 {0.18/16 0} Kh6
{0.15/14 0} 132. Ra8 {0.15/17 0} Rc6 {0.14/18 0 (Kg7)} 133. Ra4 {0.14/16 0
(Ra5)} Kg6 {0.14/14 0} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "249"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.80/19 1} 3. Kf3
{0.94/20 1} Ra3+ {0.75/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.73/18 1} Kc8 {0.76/18 1} 5. Rb2 {0.78/
16 0} e5 {0.71/18 1} 6. Ke2 {0.77/18 1} exd4 {0.77/18 1} 7. Bxd4 {0.84/17 0} g5
{0.77/19 2 (f6)} 8. f3 {0.87/17 1} h5 {0.73/18 1 (Ra5)} 9. Rd2 {0.79/20 3 (Kf2)
} h4 {0.73/20 2} 10. h3 {0.73/21 1} Ra5 {0.70/21 1} 11. Rc2 {0.70/19 0} Ra3 {
0.70/21 1} 12. Be3 {0.70/23 1} f6 {0.70/24 1} 13. Rd2 {0.70/25 1} Ne5 {0.61/22
1} 14. Bd4 {0.61/21 1} Kc7 {0.61/21 1} 15. Rc2 {0.61/23 2} Kb7 {0.61/24 1} 16.
Rb2+ {0.61/25 1} Kc7 {0.61/24 1} 17. Rd2 {0.61/23 0} Ra4 {0.61/25 1 (Nc4)} 18.
Kf2 {0.61/25 1} Nc4 {0.61/26 1} 19. Rd1 {0.66/24 1} Ne5 {0.60/22 0} 20. Kf1 {
0.61/23 1 (Bxe5+)} Rc4 {0.59/24 1} 21. Rd2 {0.62/24 1} Ra4 {0.61/25 1} 22. Kg1
{0.61/22 1 (Bxe5+)} Rc4 {0.61/26 1} 23. Kf1 {0.59/23 1 (Kf2)} Ra4 {0.58/23 1}
24. Kg1 {0.61/26 1 (Bf2)} Ra7 {0.61/24 1 (Rc4)} 25. Rd1 {0.61/25 1} Ra4 {0.61/
25 1} 26. Kh1 {0.61/24 3} Rc4 {0.57/22 0} 27. Kg1 {0.56/22 0 (Kh2)} Nd7 {0.54/
23 1} 28. Rd2 {0.60/25 1 (Kf2)} Ne5 {0.60/24 1} 29. Kf2 {0.59/26 2} Ra4 {0.60/
23 0} 30. Ke2 {0.60/23 0 (Kf1)} Ra3 {0.59/23 1} 31. Bxe5+ {0.66/24 1 (Rb2)}
fxe5 {0.64/25 1} 32. Rd6 {0.66/25 1} Ra2+ {0.59/24 1} 33. Kf1 {0.63/25 1} Ra1+
{0.70/24 1} 34. Kf2 {0.68/24 0} Ra2+ {0.61/23 1} 35. Kg1 {0.63/23 1} Rc2 {0.62/
24 1 (Ra1+)} 36. Rg6 {0.60/24 1} Rc1+ {0.62/24 1} 37. Kh2 {0.64/23 0} Rxc5 {0.
59/24 1} 38. Rxg5 {0.59/22 0} Kd6 {0.57/23 3} 39. Rg6+ {0.51/21 1 (Rh5)} Kd7 {
0.52/22 1} 40. Rg4 {0.49/21 1 (Rh6)} Ra5 {0.50/21 0} 41. Rxh4 {0.50/22 1} c5 {
0.51/23 1} 42. Rh6 {0.49/23 1} Kc7 {0.48/21 1} 43. Kg3 {0.49/22 0} c4 {0.50/23
1} 44. Kf2 {0.48/22 0} Ra2+ {0.48/23 0} 45. Ke3 {0.48/23 0} Rxg2 {0.50/22 0}
46. Re6 {0.50/23 0} Rg5 {0.50/21 0} 47. Ra6 {0.49/19 0 (Kd2)} Rg2 {0.48/21 1}
48. Ra5 {0.47/21 0} Kd6 {0.47/22 1} 49. Rd5+ {0.51/22 0} Ke6 {0.50/23 0} 50.
Rd2 {0.47/23 1} Rg1 {0.47/24 0} 51. h4 {0.47/21 0 (Rc2)} Re1+ {0.47/21 0} 52.
Re2 {0.47/24 0} Rh1 {0.49/25 1} 53. Rc2 {0.49/27 1} Rxh4 {0.49/25 0} 54. Rxc4 {
0.49/27 0} Rh2 {0.49/27 0} 55. Rc6+ {0.49/24 0} Ke7 {0.49/26 0} 56. Rg6 {0.49/
23 0 (Rb6)} Ra2 {0.49/25 0 (Rc2)} 57. Rb6 {0.50/26 1} Kd7 {0.50/25 0} 58. Rb5 {
0.50/24 0} Kd6 {0.51/26 1} 59. Rd5+ {0.51/26 0} Ke6 {0.51/26 0} 60. Rd8 {0.51/
24 0 (Rd2)} Ra1 {0.51/25 0 (Ra3+)} 61. Kf2 {0.51/25 0} Ke7 {0.51/25 0 (Ra3)}
62. Rh8 {0.50/24 0 (Rb8)} Kd6 {0.51/23 0 (Ke6)} 63. Rb8 {0.50/24 1} Kd7 {0.49/
24 0 (Ke6)} 64. Rb6 {0.46/24 0 (Kg2)} Ra8 {0.46/21 0 (Ke7)} 65. Ke2 {0.47/21 0}
Ra1 {0.47/24 0 (Ra2+)} 66. Rg6 {0.47/24 0} Ra2+ {0.47/24 0} 67. Kd3 {0.47/23 0}
Ra3+ {0.47/22 0} 68. Ke2 {0.47/23 0 (Kc4)} Ra2+ {0.47/24 0} 69. Kf1 {0.47/22 0}
Ke7 {0.47/24 0} 70. Rg2 {0.47/24 0} Ra1+ {0.48/22 0} 71. Kf2 {0.48/23 0} Kd6 {
0.48/24 0} 72. Rg5 {0.48/24 0 (Rg8)} Ra8 {0.46/22 0 (Ke6)} 73. Kg3 {0.46/20 0}
Rb8 {0.46/21 0} 74. f4 {0.46/21 0} exf4+ {0.46/22 0} 75. Kxf4 {0.47/19 0} Rf8+
{0.46/22 0} 76. Rf5 {0.46/18 0} Ra8 {0.46/20 0} 77. Rf6+ {0.46/22 0} Ke7 {0.46/
23 0} 78. Rg6 {0.46/21 0 (Rb6)} Rh8 {0.46/21 0} 79. Ke5 {0.46/20 0 (Kf5)} Rh5+
{0.46/23 0} 80. Kd4 {0.46/23 0} Ra5 {0.46/22 0} 81. Ke3 {0.46/22 0} Ra1 {0.46/
23 0 (Rh5)} 82. Rh6 {0.46/22 0 (Kf4)} Rf1 {0.46/23 0} 83. Kd4 {0.46/23 0} Ra1 {
0.46/23 0} 84. Ke5 {0.46/19 0 (Rc6)} Ra5+ {0.46/23 0} 85. Kf4 {0.46/22 0} Rb5 {
0.45/19 0} 86. Rg6 {0.45/21 0} Rh5 {0.45/21 0} 87. Ra6 {0.45/20 0 (Rg5)} Rh4+ {
0.45/21 0 (Rb5)} 88. Ke3 {0.44/22 0 (Ke5)} Rh1 {0.44/23 0} 89. Kd4 {0.45/22 0}
Rb1 {0.44/20 0} 90. Rh6 {0.45/20 0 (Rc6)} Rb5 {0.44/22 0} 91. Rc6 {0.44/19 0}
Rb4+ {0.44/20 0 (Rb3)} 92. Kd5 {0.41/18 0} Rb7 {0.44/20 0} 93. Rh6 {0.44/19 0}
Rb5+ {0.45/20 0} 94. Kd4 {0.43/19 0} Rb3 {0.44/21 0 (Ra5)} 95. Ke5 {0.43/20 0}
Rb5+ {0.43/21 0} 96. Kd4 {0.43/21 0 (Kf4)} Ra5 {0.43/20 0} 97. Rc6 {0.43/20 0
(Ke3)} Ra7 {0.43/22 0} 98. Rb6 {0.43/18 0 (Ke5)} Ra5 {0.42/20 0} 99. Rc6 {0.43/
19 0 (Kc4)} Ra3 {0.43/22 0} 100. Kd5 {0.43/19 0} Ra7 {0.42/21 0} 101. Re6+ {0.
43/20 0} Kf7 {0.43/22 0} 102. Rd6 {0.42/20 0} Ra5+ {0.42/20 0 (Ke7)} 103. Kd4 {
0.43/17 0} Ke7 {0.41/20 0 (Ra1)} 104. Rd5 {0.42/17 0} Ra1 {0.41/19 0} 105. Rb5
{0.41/19 0} Kd6 {0.41/20 0 (Ke6)} 106. Rb6+ {0.43/16 0} Ke7 {0.41/19 0 (Kd7)}
107. Ke3 {0.41/19 0} Rf1 {0.41/19 0 (Ra5)} 108. Rc6 {0.40/20 0} Rh1 {0.41/20 0}
109. Kf4 {0.41/19 0} Rh4+ {0.40/19 0 (Rh5)} 110. Ke5 {0.40/19 0} Rh5+ {0.40/21
0} 111. Kd4 {0.40/19 0} Rb5 {0.40/21 0} 112. Rc5 {0.40/18 0} Rb6 {0.40/16 0}
113. Rh5 {0.39/18 0} Rb1 {0.40/19 0} 114. Rh7+ {0.34/16 0} Kd6 {0.40/19 0} 115.
Rh6+ {0.40/14 0} Kd7 {0.40/18 0} 116. Ra6 {0.41/12 0 (Rg6)} Rb5 {0.35/18 0}
117. Rg6 {0.35/16 0} Ke7 {0.33/19 0 (Rb1)} 118. Ke3 {0.33/15 0} Kf7 {0.31/19 0}
119. Ra6 {0.30/16 0} Ke7 {0.29/19 0} 120. Kf4 {0.31/13 0} Kd7 {0.28/15 0} 121.
Rh6 {0.28/12 0 (Rf6)} Rb1 {0.04/14 0} 122. e5 {0.03/14 0} Rf1+ {0.03/14 0} 123.
Kg4 {0.03/15 0} Rg1+ {0.02/17 0} 124. Kf4 {0.02/14 0 (Kf5)} Rf1+ {0.02/15 0}
125. Kg4 {0.02/16 0 (Ke4)} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "*"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "304"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.80/19 1} 3. Kf3
{0.94/20 1} Ra3+ {0.75/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.73/18 1} Kc8 {0.76/18 1} 5. Rb2 {0.78/
16 0} e5 {0.71/18 1} 6. Ke2 {0.77/18 1} exd4 {0.74/19 2} 7. Bxd4 {0.80/19 0} f6
{0.80/18 1} 8. f3 {0.84/18 1} Ra5 {0.80/18 1} 9. Rc2 {0.78/19 1} Nf8 {0.78/18 1
} 10. Kd3 {0.81/17 1} Kd7 {0.74/19 2 (Ne6)} 11. Be3 {0.73/18 2 (Kc4)} Ke7 {0.
78/18 1} 12. Kc4 {0.83/19 2} Ne6 {0.79/19 1} 13. Rb2 {0.85/18 1} Ra4+ {0.83/19
2} 14. Kd3 {0.78/19 2} Ra5 {0.76/20 1} 15. Kc4 {0.77/21 2 (Rb7+)} Ra4+ {0.75/
21 3} 16. Kd3 {0.82/17 0 (Kb3)} g5 {0.70/17 1 (Kd8)} 17. h3 {0.68/18 2 (g3)}
Ra3+ {0.65/19 2} 18. Kd2 {0.62/21 4 (Ke2)} Kf7 {0.70/20 1} 19. Rb7+ {0.66/20 1}
Ke8 {0.60/20 1} 20. Rb2 {0.64/19 1 (Rh7)} Kf7 {0.55/20 3} 21. Rb7+ {0.61/18 1
(g3)} Ke8 {0.53/20 1} 22. Rb6 {0.53/20 1} Ra2+ {0.53/21 1} 23. Ke1 {0.54/20 1}
Kd7 {0.54/20 1 (Ra1+)} 24. Rb7+ {0.49/20 1} Ke8 {0.49/20 1} 25. Rb8+ {0.49/21 1
} Kf7 {0.49/20 0} 26. Kf1 {0.51/21 1} Ra1+ {0.36/19 1 (Ra3)} 27. Kf2 {0.41/19 0
} Ra2+ {0.48/19 1} 28. Kg1 {0.47/20 1} Ra1+ {0.40/20 1} 29. Kh2 {0.45/20 1} Ra3
{0.48/20 1} 30. Rb7+ {0.55/20 1} Ke8 {0.53/20 0} 31. Bf2 {0.51/21 1} Ra2 {0.51/
20 0} 32. Bg3 {0.54/20 1} Nd4 {0.44/20 1} 33. Bd6 {0.44/19 0} Nxf3+ {0.45/19 1}
34. Kg3 {0.52/19 0} Nd4 {0.48/20 1} 35. Re7+ {0.51/21 1} Kd8 {0.41/21 1} 36.
Rf7 {0.55/22 2} Re2 {0.44/21 1} 37. Rxf6 {0.66/20 1} Rxe4 {0.70/19 1} 38. Rxh6
{0.72/20 1} Nf5+ {0.46/21 1} 39. Kf3 {0.53/20 0} Re3+ {0.54/18 0} 40. Kf2 {0.
62/20 0} Rd3 {0.60/20 0} 41. Rg6 {0.55/20 1} Rd2+ {0.55/18 0} 42. Kg1 {0.63/20
1} Nxd6 {0.65/19 1} 43. cxd6 {0.65/19 0} Rd5 {0.69/17 0 (Kd7)} 44. Rg7 {0.71/
19 0} c5 {0.68/21 1} 45. Rc7 {0.66/19 1} g4 {0.80/17 0} 46. hxg4 {0.80/19 0}
Rxd6 {0.79/20 1 (Rg5)} 47. Rxc5 {0.78/20 0} Ke7 {0.74/20 0} 48. Kf2 {0.74/22 0}
Rd2+ {0.74/20 0 (Kf6)} 49. Kf3 {0.74/22 0} Kf6 {0.74/24 0} 50. Rb5 {0.74/24 0
(Rf5+)} Kg6 {0.74/25 0} 51. Kg3 {0.74/25 0 (Rf5)} Ra2 {0.74/24 0} 52. Rc5 {0.
74/24 0 (Rf5)} Rd2 {0.74/25 0} 53. Rf5 {0.74/25 0 (Ra5)} Rd3+ {0.74/24 0} 54.
Rf3 {0.74/27 0} Rd2 {0.74/25 0} 55. Rf2 {0.74/26 0} Rd1 {0.74/26 0} 56. Re2 {
0.73/23 0} Kf6 {0.73/24 0} 57. Re4 {0.72/24 1 (Kf3)} Rd2 {0.72/25 0} 58. Kf3 {
0.72/22 0 (Re3)} Kg6 {0.72/21 0} 59. Re2 {0.71/24 0 (Re5)} Rd4 {0.71/23 0} 60.
Kg3 {0.71/25 0} Kg5 {0.71/24 0} 61. Re5+ {0.71/22 0} Kg6 {0.71/23 0} 62. Rc5 {
0.71/24 0 (Kf3)} Rd1 {0.71/22 0} 63. Ra5 {0.70/22 0} Rf1 {0.70/24 0 (Rh1)} 64.
Rd5 {0.70/22 0 (Re5)} Re1 {0.70/23 0} 65. Rd8 {0.69/20 0 (Rf5)} Kg5 {0.69/21 0
(Ra1)} 66. Rd5+ {0.69/21 0 (Rg8+)} Kg6 {0.69/19 0} 67. Kf2 {0.68/21 0} Ra1 {0.
68/22 0} 68. Rf5 {0.68/23 0 (Rd3)} Ra3 {0.69/24 0} 69. Re5 {0.68/24 0} Rd3 {0.
68/19 0} 70. g3 {0.68/23 0} Rd4 {0.68/21 0 (Ra3)} 71. Kf3 {0.65/23 0} Rd1 {0.
63/21 0} 72. Kg2 {0.61/21 0} Ra1 {0.61/23 0} 73. Rb5 {0.59/19 0 (Rc5)} Ra3 {0.
59/22 0 (Kf6)} 74. Rf5 {0.58/22 0 (Kh3)} Ra2+ {0.57/23 0} 75. Kh3 {0.57/25 0}
Rd2 {0.57/25 0} 76. Re5 {0.57/23 0 (Rc5)} Rd1 {0.57/20 0 (Kf6)} 77. Re8 {0.57/
23 0} Kh6 {0.57/24 0} 78. Rg8 {0.57/25 0 (Rf8)} Kh7 {0.57/25 0} 79. Rg5 {0.57/
24 0 (Rb8)} Kh6 {0.57/27 0} 80. Rb5 {0.57/25 0 (Rf5)} Kg6 {0.57/23 0} 81. Rc5 {
0.57/25 0} Rh1+ {0.57/23 0} 82. Kg2 {0.63/5 0} Rd1 {0.57/22 0} 83. Rh5 {0.57/
24 0} Rd2+ {0.57/21 0} 84. Kh3 {0.57/25 0} Rd4 {0.57/23 0 (Rd1)} 85. Rc5 {0.57/
20 0 (Ra5)} Rd1 {0.56/20 0} 86. Ra5 {0.55/20 0 (Rc8)} Rh1+ {0.55/20 0} 87. Kg2
{0.55/5 0} Rd1 {0.55/20 0} 88. g5 {0.55/21 0} Kh5 {0.51/17 0} 89. Kf3 {0.45/19
1 (Rb5)} Rf1+ {0.37/17 0} 90. Kg2 {0.48/17 0 (Ke3)} Rd1 {0.45/19 0} 91. Kf2 {
0.41/18 0} Rd6 {0.39/18 0 (Rd2+)} 92. Kf3 {0.39/19 0} Rd3+ {0.39/19 0} 93. Kf4
{0.39/19 0} Rd4+ {0.39/18 0} 94. Ke3 {0.39/20 0} Rd6 {0.39/20 0} 95. g6+ {0.38/
17 0} Kxg6 {0.37/18 0} 96. Kf3 {0.37/19 0} Rd4 {0.38/17 0 (Rd3+)} 97. Rb5 {0.
37/19 0} Rd3+ {0.37/20 0} 98. Kg2 {0.37/20 0} Rd4 {0.37/21 0} 99. Kh3 {0.37/19
0} Ra4 {0.37/16 0 (Kf6)} 100. Rb6+ {0.37/18 0} Kg5 {0.37/19 0} 101. Rc6 {0.37/
20 0} Rd4 {0.37/21 0} 102. Rc5+ {0.37/20 0} Kf6 {0.37/20 0} 103. Rb5 {0.37/20 0
} Ra4 {0.37/20 0} 104. Rb8 {0.37/18 0} Kg5 {0.37/20 0} 105. Rg8+ {0.37/19 0}
Kf6 {0.37/20 0} 106. Rf8+ {0.36/20 0} Kg6 {0.36/20 0 (Kg5)} 107. Rc8 {0.36/14 0
} Kf6 {0.36/17 0 (Rd4)} 108. Rc6+ {0.37/17 0} Kg5 {0.36/19 0} 109. Rc5+ {0.36/
15 0} Kg6 {0.37/19 0 (Kf6)} 110. Rb5 {0.37/15 0 (Re5)} Kf6 {0.37/17 0} 111. Rd5
{0.37/17 0} Kg6 {0.37/19 0} 112. Rc5 {0.37/19 0} Kf6 {0.37/18 0} 113. Rc1 {0.
37/17 0} Kg5 {0.36/18 0} 114. Rc6 {0.37/15 0 (Rb1)} Rb4 {0.37/18 0} 115. Rc5+ {
0.37/13 0} Kf6 {0.37/15 0} 116. Rh5 {0.36/16 0} Kg7 {0.36/12 0} 117. Ra5 {0.37/
17 0 (g4)} Kf6 {0.36/14 0} 118. Ra6+ {0.36/17 0} Kg5 {0.36/15 0} 119. Ra8 {0.
36/17 0} Kg6 {0.36/13 0 (Rd4)} 120. Ra5 {0.36/15 0 (Rg8+)} Kf6 {0.36/16 0} 121.
Kg2 {0.35/14 0} Kg6 {0.35/14 0} 122. Rc5 {0.35/14 0} Rb3 {0.35/15 0} 123. Ra5 {
0.37/13 0 (Rc8)} Rb4 {0.35/16 0} 124. Rd5 {0.34/12 0} Rb3 {0.36/15 0} 125. Kh3
{0.36/2 0} Rb4 {0.36/15 0} 126. Rd8 {0.36/12 0} Kf6 {0.35/14 0} 127. Rf8+ {0.
34/11 0} Kg6 {0.34/15 0} 128. Rd8 {0.34/8 0 (Rg8+)} Kf6 {0.31/15 0 (Kg5)} 129.
Rg8 {0.34/11 0 (Rd6+)} Kf7 {0.31/16 0} 130. Rc8 {0.31/7 0} Kg6 {0.30/13 0 (Kf6)
} 131. Rc5 {0.36/5 0 (Rc1)} Kf6 {0.30/14 0 (Rb2)} 132. Rd5 {0.36/4 0 (Ra5)} Kg6
{0.30/11 0 (Rb3)} 133. Re5 {0.30/10 0} Kf6 {0.30/8 0} 134. Ra5 {0.30/11 0} Kg6
{0.29/11 0} 135. Ra8 {0.27/11 0} Kg5 {0.27/11 0} 136. Rc8 {0.29/8 0 (Re8)} Kf6
{0.28/11 0} 137. Rc5 {0.36/5 0 (g4)} Kg6 {0.29/10 0 (Rb1)} 138. Rc8 {0.27/11 0
(Rc1)} Kf6 {0.29/11 0 (Kg5)} 139. g4 {0.29/11 0} Rb1 {0.29/10 0} 140. Kh4 {0.
29/8 0} Rh1+ {0.26/11 0} 141. Kg3 {0.26/5 0} Rg1+ {0.27/11 0} 142. Kf4 {0.26/8
0} Rf1+ {0.26/13 0} 143. Kg3 {0.26/10 0 (Ke3)} Rg1+ {0.26/13 0} 144. Kf3 {0.26/
8 0} Rf1+ {0.26/11 0} 145. Kg2 {0.26/12 0} Rd1 {0.28/10 0} 146. Rc5 {0.26/10 0}
Kg6 {0.29/10 0 (Rd3)} 147. Kf2 {0.28/11 0} Kf6 {0.28/3 0} 148. Rf5+ {0.28/12 0}
Kg6 {0.28/12 0} 149. Rh5 {0.27/12 0} Rd3 {0.27/6 0} 150. Ra5 {0.27/6 0} Kf6 {
0.26/13 0} 151. Rc5 {0.32/4 0 (Rf5+)} Kg6 {0.26/8 0 (Kg7)} 152. Ra5 {0.26/5 0
(Rh5)} Kf6 {0.26/14 0 Komodo 10.1 64-bit: no move} *

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1-0"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "67"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.94/18 0} 3. Kf3
{0.89/19 1} Ra3+ {0.86/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.85/21 4} Kc8 {0.77/18 1} 5. Rb2 {0.85/
18 0} g5 {0.71/18 1} 6. g3 {0.87/19 2 (g4)} f5 {0.83/20 2} 7. exf5 {1.07/19 2
(e5)} exf5 {0.98/18 0} 8. h4 {1.11/19 1} Nf6 {0.95/20 2} 9. Kg2 {1.03/20 1}
gxh4 {1.10/20 1} 10. gxh4 {1.19/20 2} Ra4 {1.18/20 1} 11. Bxh6 {1.28/21 2} Rxd4
{1.31/21 1} 12. f3 {1.31/21 1} Rd8 {1.37/20 3} 13. Re2 {1.37/21 2} Rh8 {1.47/
20 1} 14. Bg5 {1.52/21 2} Nd5 {1.60/20 1} 15. Re5 {1.46/20 1} Kb7 {1.65/20 1}
16. Rxf5 {1.71/20 1} Ka6 {1.70/18 0} 17. Re5 {1.68/20 1} Rg8 {1.89/20 4} 18.
Kg3 {1.89/22 1} Kb5 {1.89/22 1} 19. f4 {1.96/18 1} Kxc5 {2.00/18 2} 20. h5 {2.
12/17 0} Kd4 {2.21/18 2} 21. Kf3 {2.39/19 2} c5 {2.35/18 1 (Rf8)} 22. Re4+ {2.
31/17 0} Kc3 {2.51/19 2} 23. Re1 {2.63/20 2} Rh8 {2.72/18 1 (Rf8)} 24. h6 {2.
72/19 2} Kc4 {2.72/20 2} 25. f5 {2.92/18 2 (Rd1)} Kb5 {2.91/16 1 (Nb4)} 26. Re6
{3.21/16 1} Nc7 {3.00/16 1} 27. Rg6 {3.21/16 0} Ne8 {3.18/17 1 (c4)} 28. Ke4 {
3.32/16 0} c4 {3.36/19 1} 29. Kd4 {3.36/18 0} c3 {3.52/20 1} 30. Kxc3 {3.64/20
0} Kc5 {3.88/22 1} 31. Kd3 {4.45/22 2} Kd5 {4.51/22 0} 32. Bf4 {4.82/22 1} Rf8
{6.07/22 2} 33. h7 {6.91/21 0} Rh8 {8.03/23 1} 34. Rg8 {8.37/23 1} 1-0

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "110"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.80/19 1} 3. Kf3
{0.94/20 1} Ra3+ {0.75/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.73/18 1} Kc8 {0.76/18 1} 5. Rb2 {0.78/
16 0} e5 {0.71/18 1} 6. Ke2 {0.77/18 1} exd4 {0.77/18 1} 7. Bxd4 {0.84/17 0} g5
{0.77/19 2 (f6)} 8. f3 {0.87/17 1} h5 {0.73/18 1 (Ra5)} 9. Rd2 {0.79/20 3 (Kf2)
} h4 {0.73/20 2} 10. h3 {0.73/21 1} Ra5 {0.70/21 1} 11. Rc2 {0.70/19 0} Ra3 {
0.70/21 1} 12. Be3 {0.70/23 2} f6 {0.70/24 1} 13. Rd2 {0.70/25 1} Ne5 {0.61/22
1} 14. Bd4 {0.61/21 1} Kc7 {0.61/21 1} 15. Rc2 {0.61/23 2} Kb7 {0.61/24 1} 16.
Rb2+ {0.61/25 1} Kc7 {0.61/24 1} 17. Rd2 {0.61/23 1} Ra4 {0.61/25 1 (Nc4)} 18.
Kf2 {0.61/25 1} Nc4 {0.61/26 1} 19. Rd1 {0.66/24 1} Ne5 {0.60/22 0} 20. Kf1 {
0.61/23 1 (Bxe5+)} Rc4 {0.59/24 1} 21. Rd2 {0.62/24 1} Ra4 {0.61/25 1} 22. Kg1
{0.61/22 1 (Bxe5+)} Rc4 {0.61/26 1} 23. Kf1 {0.59/23 1 (Kf2)} Ra4 {0.58/23 1}
24. Kg1 {0.61/26 1 (Bf2)} Ra7 {0.61/24 1 (Rc4)} 25. Rd1 {0.61/25 1} Ra4 {0.61/
25 1} 26. Kh1 {0.61/24 3} Rc4 {0.57/22 0} 27. Kg1 {0.56/21 0 (Kh2)} Rc2 {0.56/
24 1 (Nd7)} 28. Kf1 {0.56/22 1 (Ra1)} Nd7 {0.55/20 0} 29. Kg1 {0.55/23 2 (Be3)}
Ne5 {0.56/20 1 (Kc8)} 30. Kf1 {0.56/24 2 (Be3)} Nd7 {0.56/19 0} 31. Be3 {0.49/
20 1} Nxc5 {0.47/20 1} 32. e5 {0.48/20 0} fxe5 {0.53/20 1} 33. Bxg5 {0.58/19 1}
Rc4 {0.57/19 1} 34. Bd8+ {0.63/19 2} Kb7 {0.57/19 1} 35. Be7 {0.70/17 1} Ne6 {
0.48/18 2 (Ka6)} 36. Bf6 {0.61/18 1} c5 {0.55/20 1} 37. Bxe5 {0.64/21 1} Nf4 {
0.51/21 1} 38. Bxf4 {0.54/19 0} Rxf4 {0.51/20 0} 39. Rd6 {0.59/20 0} Rb4 {0.44/
20 1} 40. Rg6 {0.48/20 1} Rb2 {0.46/22 2 (Rb6)} 41. Rg4 {0.53/20 0} Rb1+ {0.47/
21 1} 42. Kf2 {0.48/20 0} Rb2+ {0.52/21 1} 43. Ke3 {0.47/18 0} Kc6 {0.41/19 1}
44. f4 {0.46/20 1} Kd5 {0.45/20 1} 45. Rxh4 {0.49/18 0} Rxg2 {0.44/19 1} 46.
Rh5+ {0.47/18 1} Kc6 {0.43/19 1} 47. h4 {0.46/19 0} c4 {0.50/20 1} 48. Rg5 {0.
50/20 1} Rh2 {0.50/22 1} 49. h5 {0.50/22 0} c3 {0.50/21 1} 50. Kd4 {0.37/20 0}
Rh4 {0.19/22 1} 51. Kxc3 {0.05/21 1} Rxf4 {0.05/18 0} 52. Kd3 {0.05/21 0} Ra4 {
0.05/22 0} 53. Ke3 {0.03/19 0} Kd6 {0.03/21 0} 54. Kf3 {0.03/18 0 (Kd2)} Ke6 {
0.03/22 0} 55. Rc5 {0.02/20 0 (Kg3)} Kf6 {0.01/21 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1-0"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "87"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.94/18 0} 3. Kf3
{0.89/19 1} Ra3+ {0.86/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.85/21 4} Kc8 {0.78/18 1} 5. Rb1 {0.79/
18 1} Kc7 {0.73/18 1} 6. Kf4 {0.92/18 2 (h3)} Ra5 {0.85/19 2 (g5+)} 7. Rc1 {0.
93/18 1 (h4)} Nf6 {0.87/18 4} 8. h4 {0.96/19 1} Ra4 {0.93/17 1 (Ra3)} 9. Rd1 {
1.01/18 1} Ra3 {0.92/19 2} 10. g4 {0.98/19 0 (g3)} h5 {0.95/20 1} 11. gxh5 {0.
99/23 1} Nxh5+ {0.93/21 0} 12. Kg4 {0.94/23 1} Nf6+ {0.93/22 1} 13. Kf3 {0.93/
24 1} Nh5 {0.93/23 1} 14. Rg1 {0.93/21 0} Kd8 {0.94/21 1 (Kc8)} 15. Rg5 {1.00/
21 1} g6 {0.98/23 1} 16. Rg1 {1.00/22 0} Kc7 {1.00/22 1} 17. Rb1 {0.96/22 2}
Nf6 {0.96/23 1 (Ra4)} 18. Re1 {0.97/22 1 (Kf4)} Nh5 {1.00/22 1 (Ra4)} 19. Kg4 {
0.97/21 1 (Rg1)} Ra2 {0.96/24 2} 20. Kg5 {1.30/24 2} Kc8 {1.47/20 1 (Kd7)} 21.
Rb1 {1.50/20 1} Ra4 {1.64/20 1} 22. Rb6 {1.70/21 1} Kc7 {1.64/21 1} 23. Kh6 {
1.74/20 1} Ra1 {1.70/21 1} 24. Rb3 {1.82/22 3} Kc8 {1.85/19 1 (Ra8)} 25. Kh7 {
1.86/21 1} Rh1 {1.84/20 1} 26. Bg5 {1.89/20 1} f6 {1.80/21 1} 27. Bd2 {1.94/20
2 (Be3)} Rxh4 {1.97/19 2 (Rg1)} 28. Kxg6 {2.05/19 0} Rh2 {2.11/20 3} 29. Bh6 {
2.24/18 0} Rh4 {2.43/18 1} 30. Rf3 {2.63/19 1} Kd7 {2.70/19 1 (Kb7)} 31. e5 {
2.87/20 1} fxe5 {3.01/20 1} 32. dxe5 {3.06/22 1} Re4 {3.07/22 1} 33. Rf7+ {3.
07/21 1} Kc8 {3.08/21 1 (Kd8)} 34. Kxh5 {3.16/21 1} Rxe5+ {3.16/18 0} 35. Kg6 {
3.29/22 2} Rxc5 {3.35/21 0} 36. Be3 {3.37/22 1} Ra5 {3.40/21 1} 37. Kf6 {3.41/
22 1} e5 {3.41/23 1} 38. Re7 {3.42/22 0} c5 {3.42/22 0} 39. Rxe5 {3.55/21 1
(Kxe5)} Ra6+ {3.91/17 1} 40. Ke7 {4.06/19 0} Ra7+ {4.52/19 1} 41. Ke8 {4.70/19
0} Rg7 {5.08/20 1} 42. f4 {6.50/19 1} Rg8+ {7.52/18 1} 43. Kf7 {8.08/19 0 (Ke7)
} Rg2 {8.23/18 0} 44. Ke7 {9.12/18 0} 1-0

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "95"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.80/19 1} 3. Kf3
{0.94/20 1} Ra3+ {0.75/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.73/18 1} Kc8 {0.76/18 1} 5. Rb2 {0.78/
16 0} e5 {0.71/18 1} 6. Ke2 {0.77/18 1} exd4 {0.74/19 2} 7. Bxd4 {0.80/19 0} f6
{0.80/18 1} 8. f3 {0.84/18 1} Ra5 {0.80/18 1} 9. Rc2 {0.78/19 1} Nf8 {0.78/18 1
} 10. Kd3 {0.81/17 1} Kd7 {0.74/19 2 (Ne6)} 11. Be3 {0.73/18 2 (Kc4)} Ke7 {0.
78/18 1} 12. Kc4 {0.83/19 2} Ne6 {0.79/19 1} 13. Rb2 {0.85/18 1} Ra4+ {0.83/19
2} 14. Kd3 {0.78/19 2} Ra5 {0.76/20 1} 15. Kc4 {0.77/21 2 (Rb7+)} Ra4+ {0.75/
21 3} 16. Kd3 {0.82/17 0 (Kb3)} g5 {0.70/17 1 (Kd8)} 17. h3 {0.68/18 2 (g3)}
Ra3+ {0.65/19 2} 18. Kd2 {0.62/21 4 (Ke2)} Kf7 {0.70/20 1} 19. Rb7+ {0.66/20 1}
Ke8 {0.60/20 1} 20. Rb2 {0.64/20 1 (Rh7)} Ra5 {0.61/19 2 (Kf7)} 21. Kd1 {0.64/
18 1 (Rb6)} h5 {0.58/19 1} 22. Rb6 {0.59/18 0} Kd7 {0.48/18 1 (Ra1+)} 23. Rb7+
{0.48/18 1} Ke8 {0.48/20 1} 24. Rb2 {0.50/19 1} Ke7 {0.42/18 1 (Kd7)} 25. Rb7+
{0.54/17 1 (Rc2)} Ke8 {0.41/19 1} 26. Kc2 {0.42/20 2} Nxc5 {0.41/17 1} 27. Rh7
{0.37/17 1} Ne6 {0.31/17 0} 28. Kb3 {0.31/18 1} Rb5+ {0.28/19 1} 29. Kc2 {0.29/
19 1 (Kc3)} h4 {0.23/19 1 (Ra5)} 30. Bc1 {0.30/18 0} f5 {0.26/17 1} 31. Kd3 {
0.26/18 1} Rb3+ {0.14/17 1} 32. Kc4 {0.16/18 0} Rb5 {0.18/19 0} 33. Ba3 {0.15/
19 1} Nf4 {0.07/17 1} 34. Rg7 {0.12/17 1} Nxg2 {0.11/17 1} 35. Rxg5 {0.14/18 1}
Ne3+ {0.00/18 1} 36. Kc3 {0.00/18 0} fxe4 {0.04/19 1} 37. Rg8+ {0.07/19 0} Kf7
{0.08/18 1} 38. Rf8+ {0.08/18 0} Kg7 {0.01/18 1 (Ke6)} 39. fxe4 {0.01/19 0}
Nd1+ {0.01/18 0} 40. Kd4 {0.01/19 0} Rb3 {0.01/19 1} 41. Be7 {0.01/19 1} Rxh3 {
0.01/19 0} 42. Rf4 {0.01/19 1} Nc3 {0.01/19 1} 43. Rg4+ {0.01/20 1} Kf7 {0.01/
21 1} 44. Bxh4 {0.01/21 0} c5+ {0.01/21 1} 45. Kxc5 {0.01/22 1} Re3 {0.01/22 0}
46. Kd4 {0.01/22 0} Rxe4+ {0.01/24 0} 47. Rxe4 {0.01/26 0} Nxe4 {0.01/27 0} 48.
Kxe4 {0.01/28 0} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Komodo1164-bit, Blitz 1m) "]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Stockfish 8 64 POPCNT"]
[Black "owner"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "99"]

1. Bf4 {0.96/15 2} Ra1+ {0.74/18 2} 2. Ke2 {0.97/19 2} Ra2+ {0.80/19 1} 3. Kf3
{0.94/20 1} Ra3+ {0.75/18 1} 4. Be3 {0.73/18 1} Kc8 {0.76/18 1} 5. Rb2 {0.78/
16 0} e5 {0.71/18 1} 6. Ke2 {0.77/18 1} exd4 {0.74/19 2} 7. Bxd4 {0.80/19 0} f6
{0.80/18 1} 8. f3 {0.84/18 1} Ra5 {0.80/18 1} 9. Rc2 {0.78/19 1} Nf8 {0.78/18 1
} 10. Kd3 {0.81/17 1} Kd7 {0.74/19 2 (Ne6)} 11. Be3 {0.73/18 2 (Kc4)} Ke7 {0.
78/18 1} 12. Kc4 {0.83/19 2} Ne6 {0.79/19 1} 13. Rb2 {0.85/18 1} Ra4+ {0.83/19
2} 14. Kd3 {0.78/19 2} Ra5 {0.76/20 1} 15. Kc4 {0.77/21 2 (Rb7+)} Ra4+ {0.75/
21 3} 16. Kd3 {0.82/17 0 (Kb3)} g5 {0.70/17 1 (Kd8)} 17. h3 {0.68/18 2 (g3)}
Ra3+ {0.65/19 2} 18. Kd2 {0.62/21 4 (Ke2)} Kf7 {0.70/20 1} 19. Rb7+ {0.66/20 1}
Ke8 {0.60/20 1} 20. Rb2 {0.64/20 1 (Rh7)} Ra5 {0.61/19 2 (Kf7)} 21. Kd1 {0.64/
18 1 (Rb6)} h5 {0.58/19 1} 22. Rb6 {0.59/18 0} Kd7 {0.48/18 1 (Ra1+)} 23. Rb7+
{0.48/18 1} Ke8 {0.48/20 1} 24. Rb2 {0.50/19 1} Ke7 {0.42/18 1 (Kd7)} 25. Rb7+
{0.54/17 1 (Rc2)} Ke8 {0.41/19 1} 26. Kc2 {0.42/20 2} Nxc5 {0.41/17 1} 27. Rh7
{0.37/17 1} Ne6 {0.28/18 1} 28. Kb3 {0.25/17 1} Rb5+ {0.25/19 1} 29. Kc3 {0.34/
18 1} Ra5 {0.25/19 2 (h4)} 30. Bd2 {0.27/19 1} h4 {0.30/18 1} 31. Kb2 {0.25/20
1 (Kc4)} Rb5+ {0.25/19 0} 32. Kc2 {0.24/20 1} f5 {0.18/20 2} 33. Kd3 {0.14/18 1
} fxe4+ {0.11/18 1} 34. Kxe4 {0.15/20 1} Nc5+ {0.11/19 1} 35. Ke5 {0.24/18 0}
Nd7+ {0.11/18 0} 36. Kd4 {0.06/18 0} Nf8 {0.04/19 1} 37. Ra7 {0.12/19 1 (Rh6)}
Ne6+ {0.11/18 0} 38. Ke4 {0.04/19 1} Rb2 {0.03/19 1} 39. Kd3 {0.03/20 1} Rb5 {
0.03/19 1} 40. Ke4 {0.03/19 1 (Bc3)} Rb2 {0.02/20 1} 41. Kd3 {0.03/18 0 (Bc3)}
Rb5 {0.02/19 0} 42. Bc3 {0.02/20 1} Rd5+ {0.02/20 1} 43. Ke3 {0.02/21 1} Nf4 {
0.03/21 0} 44. Ke4 {0.03/21 0} Nxg2 {0.03/20 0} 45. Bf6 {0.03/19 0} Nf4 {0.03/
21 1} 46. Bxg5 {0.02/22 1} Rxg5 {0.02/23 1} 47. Kxf4 {0.03/24 0} Rg3 {0.03/24 0
} 48. Rc7 {0.03/24 0} Rxh3 {0.03/23 0} 49. Rxc6 {0.00/21 1} Kf7 {0.00/21 0} 50.
Rh6 {0.00/25 1 (Rc1)} 1/2-1/2

[/pgn]

fastgm
Posts: 622
Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 4:57 pm
Contact:

Re: What a move 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017

Post by fastgm » Thu Jun 15, 2017 8:36 pm

[d]r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - -

This position is also already lost. Here my analyzes:

29.Bf4 f5 30.exf5 exf5 31.Bd6 g5 32.g3 g4 33.Rc7 Ra4 34.Rxc6 Rxd4 35.Ra6 Kc8 (35....Ke8 36.c6! Rxd6 37.c7 +-) 36.Bf4 Kb7 37.Rxh6 +-

29.Bf4 f5 30.exf5 exf5 31.Bd6 and Stockfish is already over +3
31...g5 32.Rc7 Ra4 33.Rxc6 Rxd4 34.Bc7+ Ke7 35. Rxh6 Nxc5 36.Be5 Rd5 37.Bf6+ Kf7 38.Bxg5 Ne4 39.Be3 Nf6 40.h3

49/70 01:40 6.934.425k 69.140k +4,56 40.h3 Rb5 41.g3 Rb4 42.Kg2 Ra4 43.Bg5 Ne4 44.Bf4 Nf6 45.Be5 Ne4 46.h4 Ra5 47.Bd4 Rd5 48.Be3 Nf6 49.Bg5 Ne4 50.Rb6 Rc5 51.Rb7+ Ke6 52.Be3 Rd5 53.Rb4 Nf6 54.Rb6+ Kf7 55.Bg5 Ne4 56.Rh6 Ra5 57.Be3 Nc5 58.Rb6 Nd3 59.Rd6 Ra3 60.h5 Ne1+ 61.Kh3 Nf3 62.h6 Ra8 63.Rb6 Re8 64.Bc1 Rd8 65.Kg2 Ne1+ 66.Kf1 Nd3 67.Bg5 Re8 68.Rb7+ Kg6 69.Rg7+ Kh5 70.h7 Rh8 71.Be3 Nb4

fastgm
Posts: 622
Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 4:57 pm
Contact:

Re: What a move 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017

Post by fastgm » Thu Jun 15, 2017 9:10 pm

Maybe the best chance for black is to trade rooks after 26...Rb8:
[d]1r3k2/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3P4/4P3/3B1PPP/6K1 w - - 1 27

27.Rxb8 Nxb8 28.Kf1 Nd7 29.Ba5 Nf6 30.Bc7 Nd5 31.Bd6+ Ke8 32.Ke2
but Stockfish is here also already over +3:

53/78 11:16 70.424.959k 104.159k -3,04 32. ... Nf6 33.h4 Ne4 34.Be5 f6 35.f3 Nc3+ 36.Kd3 Nb5 37.Bg3 g6 38.Bb8 Ke7 39.e4 Kd8 40.g4 Kc8 41.Bd6 Kd7 42.Bg3 h5 43.Bf4 Na3 44.Bd2 Kc7 45.g5 fxg5 46.Bxg5 Kb7 47.Bf6 Kc7 48.Kc3 Nb5+ 49.Kb4 Kd7 50.Be5 Na7 51.Kc4 Nc8 52.Bf4 Ne7 53.Kd3 Nc8 54.Bg5 Na7 55.Kc4 Nb5 56.Bf4 Na3+ 57.Kb3 Nb5 58.Be5 Na7 59.Kb4 Nc8 60.Kc4 Ne7 61.Bf6 Nc8 62.d5 exd5+ 63.exd5 cxd5+ 64.Kxd5 Ke8 65.Be5 Ke7 66.Bf4

Jeroen
Posts: 501
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:49 pm

Re: 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017: SUMMARY

Post by Jeroen » Fri Jun 16, 2017 2:55 am

so, far, I have:
- made an already interesting thread even more interesting, creating an useful discussion
- posted valuable remarks, most of which, if not all, are true
- posted twice or 3 times as much output as the 5 persons of you scalding me
- done all that, while busy with a lot more meanigful things, overall I have spent an hoyr and a half analysing this, and still performed better than all of you!
Time to say goodbye to you, after this posting full of nonsense. Apparently you skipped the one move losers you suggested here, like your last one, a rook ending with h- and f-pawns, which was instantly losing. So far about "valuable remarks, most of which, if not all, true".

For some reason you think you are the non-plus-ultra in chess, better than Aronian, better than Aronian+engine, better than chess players with an objective view+strong hardware, better than the top engines. Clearly, you leave in your own created dreamworld. Good luck with that.

Jeroen
Posts: 501
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:49 pm

Re: For Possioto and Noomen enjoyment!

Post by Jeroen » Fri Jun 16, 2017 3:04 am

From the output it is easy to see these are all fast blitz games. Both engines just think for 1 or 2 seconds.

It is not the fist time you use 1 second engine analysis to support your bad claims. Perhaps you could use 0.1 seconds, if the result is not to your liking? Maybe then you get 10 draws out of 10.

Lyudmil Tsvetkov
Posts: 6052
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2012 10:41 am

Re: For Possioto and Noomen enjoyment!

Post by Lyudmil Tsvetkov » Fri Jun 16, 2017 4:35 am

Jeroen wrote:From the output it is easy to see these are all fast blitz games. Both engines just think for 1 or 2 seconds.

It is not the fist time you use 1 second engine analysis to support your bad claims. Perhaps you could use 0.1 seconds, if the result is not to your liking? Maybe then you get 10 draws out of 10.
Sf score with the same shootout: 3 white wins, 7 draws, precisely the same as Komodo
mix of engines score shootout on this position, including Houdini 3, Andscacs, etc.: 2 white wins, 8 draws

So, basically, we get more or less consistent results: draw rate is higher than 70%.

I would be happy, if someone runs 1000+ statistically relevant games at LTC, but am very much afraid draw score will only rise, as defense is generally easier with longer time.

Why shun away from the truth, Jeroen?

Lyudmil Tsvetkov
Posts: 6052
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2012 10:41 am

Re: 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017: SUMMARY

Post by Lyudmil Tsvetkov » Fri Jun 16, 2017 4:37 am

Jeroen wrote:
so, far, I have:
- made an already interesting thread even more interesting, creating an useful discussion
- posted valuable remarks, most of which, if not all, are true
- posted twice or 3 times as much output as the 5 persons of you scalding me
- done all that, while busy with a lot more meanigful things, overall I have spent an hoyr and a half analysing this, and still performed better than all of you!
Time to say goodbye to you, after this posting full of nonsense. Apparently you skipped the one move losers you suggested here, like your last one, a rook ending with h- and f-pawns, which was instantly losing. So far about "valuable remarks, most of which, if not all, true".

For some reason you think you are the non-plus-ultra in chess, better than Aronian, better than Aronian+engine, better than chess players with an objective view+strong hardware, better than the top engines. Clearly, you leave in your own created dreamworld. Good luck with that.
I do not see what is your problem.

we are discussing a chess position, and discussions are always prone to alternatives.

so far, a3 clearly leads to a draw, what is so apocalyptical about that?

Lyudmil Tsvetkov
Posts: 6052
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2012 10:41 am

Re: What a move 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017

Post by Lyudmil Tsvetkov » Fri Jun 16, 2017 4:41 am

fastgm wrote:[d]r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - -

This position is also already lost. Here my analyzes:

29.Bf4 f5 30.exf5 exf5 31.Bd6 g5 32.g3 g4 33.Rc7 Ra4 34.Rxc6 Rxd4 35.Ra6 Kc8 (35....Ke8 36.c6! Rxd6 37.c7 +-) 36.Bf4 Kb7 37.Rxh6 +-

29.Bf4 f5 30.exf5 exf5 31.Bd6 and Stockfish is already over +3
31...g5 32.Rc7 Ra4 33.Rxc6 Rxd4 34.Bc7+ Ke7 35. Rxh6 Nxc5 36.Be5 Rd5 37.Bf6+ Kf7 38.Bxg5 Ne4 39.Be3 Nf6 40.h3

49/70 01:40 6.934.425k 69.140k +4,56 40.h3 Rb5 41.g3 Rb4 42.Kg2 Ra4 43.Bg5 Ne4 44.Bf4 Nf6 45.Be5 Ne4 46.h4 Ra5 47.Bd4 Rd5 48.Be3 Nf6 49.Bg5 Ne4 50.Rb6 Rc5 51.Rb7+ Ke6 52.Be3 Rd5 53.Rb4 Nf6 54.Rb6+ Kf7 55.Bg5 Ne4 56.Rh6 Ra5 57.Be3 Nc5 58.Rb6 Nd3 59.Rd6 Ra3 60.h5 Ne1+ 61.Kh3 Nf3 62.h6 Ra8 63.Rb6 Re8 64.Bc1 Rd8 65.Kg2 Ne1+ 66.Kf1 Nd3 67.Bg5 Re8 68.Rb7+ Kg6 69.Rg7+ Kh5 70.h7 Rh8 71.Be3 Nb4
this time you are certainly acting incorrect, Andreas.

you have chosen yourself a line going some 10 moves deep, that is certainly having a lot of gaps, and then, based on the position you liked, you simply switched on SF.

sorry, but that is more than ludicrous.

many engine matches have confirmed the position is much more drawn as otherwise, please see relevant post.

if you like, you might conduct a big test with LTC, to see what the actual state of affairs is.

Post Reply