PHCEL and LC0

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Harvey Williamson, bob

Forum rules
This textbox is used to restore diagrams posted with the [d] tag before the upgrade.
User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Wed May 02, 2018 7:11 pm

First test 15+10.
[pgn][Event "rubi006, Blic:15'+10""]
[Site "Prague"]
[Date "2018.05.02"]
[Round "1"]
[White "ProDeo 2.6"]
[Black "lczero v0.7"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "D45"]
[Annotator "0.35;0.04"]
[PlyCount "80"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]

1. d4 {B 0} d5 {B 0} 2. Nf3 {B 0} Nf6 {B 0} 3. c4 {B 0} c6 {B 0} 4. e3 {B 0} e6
{B 0} 5. Nc3 {B 0} a6 {B 0} 6. b3 {B 0} Bb4 {B 0} 7. Bd2 {B 0} Nbd7 {B 0} 8.
Bd3 {0.35/16 37} O-O {B 0} 9. O-O {B 0} Bd6 {B 0 Oba mimo knihovnu} 10. Qc2 {
0.32/14 20} e5 {0.04/21 24 (Ve8)} 11. cxd5 {0.40/18 25} cxd5 {0.05/21 12} 12.
e4 {0.39/17 34} exd4 {0.12/21 8} 13. Nxd5 {0.25/17 32} Nxd5 {0.12/21 5} 14.
exd5 {0.23/14 4} Nf6 {0.13/22 19} 15. Rfe1 {0.17/16 18} Bg4 {0.10/22 22} 16.
Ne5 {-0.01/17 28 (Jxd4)} Rc8 {0.04/21 23} 17. Qb2 {0.01/18 29} Rc5 {-0.05/22
23 (Sxe5)} 18. Bg5 {0.00/16 20 (Jc4)} Bxe5 {0.06/21 34} 19. Rxe5 {0.02/14 3}
Rxd5 {-0.08/21 14} 20. Rae1 {0.00/17 20 (f4)} Rxe5 {-0.37/21 22} 21. Rxe5 {-0.
17/15 4} h6 {-0.37/21 16} 22. Bxf6 {-0.13/18 18 (Sh4)} Qxf6 {-0.29/20 22} 23.
Qxd4 {-0.15/18 23 (Ve4)} Rd8 {-0.65/21 28} 24. Qe3 {-0.08/17 20} Bd7 {-0.65/22
40} 25. Qe1 {-0.03/17 38 (Se2)} Bc6 {-0.66/21 27 (b5)} 26. Re3 {-0.08/18 60}
Qb2 {-0.46/22 44} 27. Re2 {-0.21/18 26 (h3)} Qa3 {-0.74/21 28} 28. Bc2 {-0.21/
17 29 (Sb1)} g6 {-0.62/21 32} 29. Qb1 {-0.12/16 21} Rd4 {-0.59/22 41 (Dd6)} 30.
Bxg6 {0.00/18 18 (h3)} Qd6 {-0.37/22 29} 31. Bc2 {0.15/17 21 (Sxf7+)} Rg4 {-0.
48/21 26} 32. f4 {0.15/16 15 (f3)} Qd4+ {-1.21/21 47} 33. Kh1 {0.00/17 19} Rxf4
{-0.82/22 28} 34. Qg1 {0.00/18 17 (h3)} Qf6 {-4.29/21 25 (Vh4)} 35. Bd3 {0.00/
18 18 (Ve1)} h5 {-1.45/21 37 (Kg7)} 36. Re1 {0.00/17 23} Rg4 {-1.50/22 25} 37.
Re2 {0.00/19 24} Qc3 {-1.45/23 42 (Vf4)} 38. Qb1 {0.12/17 54 (De3)} Rf4 {-1.42/
22 45 (Dd4)} 39. h3 {0.06/16 13} Qf6 {-1.27/22 22} 40. Qg1 {0.15/18 26 (Kg1)}
h4 {-0.93/21 27 (Kg7)} 1/2-1/2 after 212 moves.[/pgn]
Nice game between 25th and 40th.

User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Sat May 05, 2018 6:03 pm

ProDeo 2.6 - LCzero 0.8gpu id 237 +13=5-14 - my book KingGambit (normal, use 15, max 30) 2m+2s

ProDeo 2.6 - LCzero 0.8gpu id 237 +9=6-9 - my book AlbinGambit (normal, use 15, max 30) 12m+5s

All games

http://www.phcel.cz/LC0/LCZ.rar

Blunders
[D]r4rk1/ppp3pp/3q4/3bNp2/2PP4/1Q6/PP4PP/4RRK1 b - c3 0 21
21.-Be4?? 22.Rxe4+-

[D]rnb1kbnr/ppp2p1p/8/3p4/4qpNP/8/PPPPQ1P1/RNB1KB1R w KQkq d6 0 8
8.Nc3?? Bxg4 -+


[pgn][Event "ProDeo-LZ0237_Albin_12m+5s"]
[Site "Prague"]
[Date "2018.05.04"]
[Round "23"]
[White "ProDeo 2.6"]
[Black "LCzero v0.8-id237"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "D07"]
[Annotator "0.39;0.19"]
[PlyCount "138"]
[TimeControl "720+5"]

{Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-8550U CPU @ 1.80GHz W=16.6 plies; 2 808kN/s;
Albin_Mega2015_2200plus.ctg B=20.2 plies; 1kN/s; Albin_Mega2015_2200plus.ctg}
1. d4 {B 0} d5 {B 0} 2. c4 {B 0} e5 {B 0} 3. dxe5 {B 0} d4 {B 0} 4. a3 {B 0}
Nc6 {B 0} 5. e3 {B 0} Nge7 {B 0} 6. Nf3 {B 0} Bg4 {B 0} 7. Be2 {B 0} dxe3 {B 0}
8. Qxd8+ {B 0} Rxd8 {B 0} 9. Bxe3 {B 0 Oba mimo knihovnu} Bxf3 {0.19/19 14} 10.
Bxf3 {0.39/16 4} Nxe5 {0.30/20 9} 11. Bxb7 {0.00/18 30} Nxc4 {0.42/20 9} 12. b4
{0.07/17 18 (Sxa7)} Nxe3 {-0.03/19 14} 13. fxe3 {0.09/14 2} c6 {-0.05/21 21
(g6)} 14. Nd2 {0.21/16 16} Rd7 {-0.06/21 16 (Kd7)} 15. Nc4 {0.40/18 21 (Sa6)}
g6 {1.84/19 14 (h5)} 16. Ke2 {0.48/17 20 (Kf2)} Rc7 {1.40/19 14 (Sg7)} 17. Nd6+
{1.26/18 16} Kd7 {1.30/20 7} 18. Nxf7 {1.57/19 35} Rg8 {1.50/20 7} 19. Rhd1+ {
1.13/18 25 (Sa6)} Nd5 {1.17/19 12} 20. Bxc6+ {1.15/17 14 (e4)} Kxc6 {0.56/20 12
} 21. Nd8+ {1.35/17 12} Kd6 {0.22/20 11} 22. e4 {1.16/18 20} Rc2+ {0.19/20 1}
23. Kf1 {0.93/18 30 (Kf3)} Bh6 {-2.00/19 15} 24. Rxd5+ {1.02/16 5 (Jf7+)} Ke7 {
-2.60/20 14} 25. Rad1 {1.14/17 22} Rf8+ {-1.86/20 4} 26. Ke1 {1.22/15 13 (Kg1)}
Rff2 {-0.39/20 11 (Vxg2)} 27. Nc6+ {1.64/17 23} Kf7 {0.47/20 9} 28. Rd7+ {1.76/
16 15} Kg8 {0.10/20 8} 29. Rd8+ {1.80/17 12} Kg7 {0.12/21 13 (Kf7)} 30. Nd4 {
1.37/16 22 (V8d7+)} Ra2 {-1.24/20 18} 31. Rd7+ {0.19/16 27} Kg8 {-1.27/20 9}
32. Ra1 {0.00/17 34 (Vd3)} Rab2 {-2.04/19 19} 33. Rb1 {0.00/18 19 (Jf3)} Ra2 {
-1.82/20 17} 34. Rd8+ {0.00/18 19 (Jf3)} Kf7 {-1.93/20 19} 35. Ra1 {0.00/17 15
(Vb3)} Rab2 {-2.50/20 19} 36. Rb1 {0.00/19 11 (Jf3)} Ra2 {-1.49/21 19} 37. Rd7+
{0.00/17 14 (Vb3)} Ke8 {-3.20/20 17 (Kg8)} 38. Rxh7 {-0.35/17 16} Rxg2 {-3.27/
21 9} 39. Rh8+ {-0.70/16 11 (Jf3)} Kf7 {-3.46/20 11} 40. Nf3 {-2.32/15 21} Bf4
{-3.64/21 15 (Se3)} 41. Rh7+ {-1.41/16 32} Ke6 {-4.10/21 16 (Kg8)} 42. Rh3 {-1.
96/15 9 (b5)} g5 {-5.37/20 16} 43. Rh6+ {-2.81/15 12} Ke7 {-6.27/20 12 (Kf7)}
44. Rh7+ {-2.14/14 12} Kf6 {-6.90/20 9} 45. e5+ {-2.62/16 16 (Vxa7)} Bxe5 {-8.
86/19 17} 46. Rc1 {-3.05/15 10 (Vh6+)} Bf4 {-7.98/19 16} 47. Rc6+ {-3.42/16 14}
Kf5 {-8.70/20 9} 48. Nd4+ {-3.42/15 7 (Vd7)} Ke4 {-11.38/20 16} 49. Nc2 {-4.16/
17 11 (Kf1)} Raxc2 {-11.96/21 30} 50. Rxc2 {-5.14/16 9} Rxc2 {-12.01/20 3} 51.
Kf1 {-5.35/17 10 (Kd1)} g4 {-19.80/19 18 (Vxh2)} 52. Rd7 {-14.17/20 12} Rxh2 {
-23.61/20 23 (Kf3)} 53. Ke1 {-10.51/17 7} g3 {-22.53/20 24 (Kf3)} 54. Rg7 {-10.
60/16 7 (Ve7+)} g2 {-26.51/20 22 (Kf3)} 55. Rg8 {#2731/16 3 (Kf2)} Be3 {-31.09/
20 16 (Kf3)} 56. Re8+ {-16.89/18 8} Kf3 {-30.75/21 23 (Kd4)} 57. Rf8+ {#2725/
18 2} Bf4 {-31.15/21 11} 58. Rxf4+ {#2735/16 1} Ke3 {-29.15/22 23 (Kxf4)} 59.
Re4+ {#2733/20 2} Kxe4 {-28.48/23 22} 60. Kf2 {-17.30/14 0} g1=Q+ {-28.43/23
23 (Kf4)} 61. Kxg1 {-6.92/7 0} Rb2 {-29.59/22 14 (Va2)} 62. Kf1 {#2753/20 15}
Ke3 {-30.64/21 7} 63. b5 {#2753/17 1} Rxb5 {-31.97/20 13 (Va2)} 64. Kg2 {-#6/0
0} Rg5+ {-#6/0 0} 65. Kh3 {-#5/0 0} Kf3 {-#5/0 0} 66. Kh2 {-#4/0 0} a5 {-#4/0 0
} 67. a4 {-#3/0 0} Rf5 {-#3/0 0} 68. Kg1 {-#2/0 0} Kg3 {-#2/0 0} 69. Kh1 {-#1/
0 0} Rf1# {-#1/0 0} 0-1[/pgn]

User avatar
AdminX
Posts: 5133
Joined: Mon Mar 13, 2006 1:34 pm
Location: Acworth, GA
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by AdminX » Sat May 05, 2018 6:26 pm

Did you find any interesting twist for black in the Albin or the King's Gambit? Looking forward to viewing those games. 8-)
"Good decisions come from experience, and experience comes from bad decisions."
__________________________________________________________________
Ted Summers

User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Fri May 11, 2018 8:40 am

LCZ 0.8_id253 - Spike 1.4, 12m+5s
LCZ PH-TestBook2017.ctg, Spike SpikeGambitBook (cca 2006/7).
+0=3-5. games
Do not push him! And tactical mistakes are being severely punished. They did not change the sides, my fault. Repeat the weekend.

User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Sun May 13, 2018 9:42 pm

[PGN][Event "rubi006, Blic:12'+5""]
[Site "Prague"]
[Date "2018.05.13"]
[Round "4"]
[White "LCzero v0.8-id253"]
[Black "Spike 1.4"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B05"]
[PlyCount "85"]

1. e4 Nf6 2. e5 Nd5 3. d4 d6 4. Nf3 Bg4 5. Be2 e6 6. O-O Be7 7. h3 Bh5 8. c4
Nb6 9. exd6 cxd6 10. a4 a5 11. Qb3 O-O 12. Qb5 Bg6 13. Bf4 Nc6 14. Nc3 Nb4 15.
Rfd1 f6 16. c5 N6d5 17. Nxd5 exd5 18. Bd2 Be8 19. Qxb7 Bc6 20. Qb6 Qd7 21. Bxb4
Bd8 22. Qxc6 Qxc6 23. Bb5 Qc8 24. Ba3 dxc5 25. dxc5 Bc7 26. c6 Rd8 27. Nd4 Bb8
28. Bc5 Qc7 29. g3 Qf7 30. Rac1 Be5 31. Bb6 Rdc8 32. Nf5 Kh8 33. Ne3 Bxb2 34.
Rc2 d4 35. Rxb2 dxe3 36. Bxe3 Rf8 37. Rd7 Qg6 38. c7 Qe4 39. Rbd2 Qb7 40. Re7
Rg8 41. Rdd7 Rac8 42. Bh6 Qxc7 43. Rxc7 1-0[/PGN]
Spike my OddBook 2006/7. LC0 PH-Test2017.

User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Mon May 14, 2018 7:15 am

Rubinus wrote:
Fri May 11, 2018 8:40 am
LCZ 0.8_id253 - Spike 1.4, 12m+5s
LCZ PH-TestBook2017.ctg, Spike SpikeGambitBook (cca 2006/7).
+0=3-5. games
Do not push him! And tactical mistakes are being severely punished. They did not change the sides, my fault. Repeat the weekend.
+0=5-11

User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Mon May 14, 2018 7:16 am

LCZ 0.8_id253 - Spike 1.4, 12m+5s
LCZ PH-TestBook2017.ctg, Spike SpikeOddBook (cca 2006/7).
+2=6-8. games. OddBook - unortoxes openings.
Best LCZ game Nr. 4!

User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Tue May 15, 2018 5:45 pm

LCZ 0.8_id253 - Spike 1.4, 12m+5s
LCZ PH-TestBook2017.ctg, Spike SpikeFrenchBook (cca 2006/7).
+2=4-10. games.
Interesting games for viewers.

After first 10 rounds swissB ELO guess LC0-0.8-id253 -> 2859 (gpu version, i7, 4cpu - Lenovo Ideapad 720).

User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Thu May 17, 2018 6:52 am

LCZ 0.10_id300 - Spike 1.4, 12m+5s
LCZ PH-TestBook2017.ctg, Spike SpikeCaroKannBook (cca 2006/7).
So far +1=2-7.

Is not version 0.10 tactically weaker than 0.8? After playing four more games against Spike, I get such a vague impression. This would explain the failure of the networks until they all installed 0.10.

And swissB 2+2 0.8, great:
Rybka 2.3 LK-LCzero v0.8-id253
1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 d6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 Nf6 5. Nc3 a6 6. Be2 e6 7. O-O Nbd7 8.
Qd3 Be7 9. Qg3 O-O 10. Bh6 Ne8 11. Be3 Qc7 12. h4 Nef6 13. Bh6 Ne8 14. Bg5 Nef6
15. h5 Kh8 16. h6 Rg8 17. Qh4 b5 18. hxg7+ Rxg7 19. a3 Bb7 20. Kh1 Qc5 21. Nf3
Rag8 22. Be3 Qc7 23. Rg1 Nc5 24. Bg5 Rg6 25. Bd3 Bd8 26. Raf1 e5 27. Bxf6+ Rxf6
28. Nh2 Rf4 29. Qh5 Rh4 30. Qd1 f5 31. g3 Rh3 32. f3 Qg7 33. Qe1 Qh6 34. Rg2 f4
35. g4 Bh4 36. Qd2 Bg3 37. Rfg1 Ne6 38. Rxg3 fxg3 39. Qxh6 Rxh6 40. Rxg3 Nf4
41. Kg1 Rh3 42. Nf1 h5 43. Rxh3 Nxh3+ 44. Kg2 hxg4 45. fxg4 Nf4+ 46. Kg3 Kg7
47. Ne3 Rh8 48. Nf5+ Kf6 49. Nh4 Kg5 50. Nf3+ Kf6 51. Nh4 Bc6 52. Bf1 Rh6 53.
Bd3 Rh8 54. Bf1 Rh7 55. Bd3 Kg5 56. Nf3+ Kf6 57. Nh4 Kg5 58. Nf3+ Kg6 59. Nh4+
Kf6 60. Bf1 Rh8 61. Nf5 Rh1 62. Ne3 Kg5 63. Ncd1 Rg1+ 64. Kf2 Rh1 65. Kg3 Rh8
66. Nf2 Bd7 67. Nh3+ Nxh3 68. Bxh3 Bc6 69. Bg2 Bd7 70. Bh3 Be6 71. Bg2 Rc8 72.
c3 Rf8 73. Nf5 Rd8 74. Ne3 Rf8 75. Nf5 Rd8 76. Ne3 Bd7 77. Bf3 Bc6 78. Nf5 Rd7
79. Ne3 Rh7 80. Nf5 Ra7 81. Ne3 Rd7 82. Bg2 Bb7 83. Bh1 Rf7 84. Nf5 Rd7 85. Ne3
Bc8 86. Nf5 Rd8 87. Ne3 Rh8 88. Bf3 Be6 89. Bg2 Rh4 90. Bf3 Rh6 91. Be2 Rh1 92.
Bd1 Bd7 93. Kg2 Rh7 94. Kg3 Bc6 95. Bf3 Rd7 96. Bg2 a5 97. Bf3 a4 98. Bg2 Rh7
99. Nf5 Bd7 100. Bf1 Bc6 101. Bg2 Rf7 102. Bh1 Rd7 103. Ne3 Rf7 104. Nf5 Rd7
105. Ne3 Rh7 106. Bg2 Bd7 107. Nf5 Bxf5 108. gxf5 Rh4 109. Bf3 Rf4 110. Bg2
Rg4+ 111. Kf2 Kf4 112. Bh1 Rh4 113. Bf3 Rh2+ 114. Bg2 Kg4 115. f6 Rh6 116. Bf3+
Kf4 117. f7 Rf6 118. Bh5 Kxe4+ 119. Ke2 d5 120. Bg6+ Kf4 121. Kd2 e4 122. Bh5
Kg5 123. Be2 Rxf7 124. Bxb5 Rb7 125. Bxa4 Rxb2+ 126. Ke3 Kf5 127. Bd1 Ke5 128.
a4 Ra2 129. a5 Rxa5 130. Kf2 Ra2+ 131. Ke3 Rh2 132. Ba4 Rh3+ 133. Ke2 Rxc3 134.
Be8 Rc2+ 135. Kd1 Ra2 136. Bf7 e3 137. Ke1 Rh2 138. Be8 Ke4 139. Bc6 Rh1+ 140.
Ke2 Rh2+ 141. Ke1 Rb2 142. Be8 Kd3 143. Bg6+ Kd4 144. Bh7 Kc3 145. Bf5 d4 146.
Bg4 d3 147. Kf1 Rf2+ 148. Kg1 Kd4 149. Be6 d2 150. Bb3 Re2 151. Bc2 Kc3 152.
Bd1 Re1+ 153. Kh2 Rxd1 154. Kg2 e2 155. Kf3 Rf1+ 156. Kg3 d1=B 157. Kh3 e1=Q
158. Kg2 Bf3+ 159. Kh2 Qh4# 0-1

User avatar
Rubinus
Posts: 953
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Prague
Contact:

Re: PHCEL and LC0

Post by Rubinus » Tue May 22, 2018 7:08 am

LCZero 0.10-id300 - Spike 1.4_SpikeCaroKannBook_12m+5s +2=3-11
games
Bad id...
SpikeCaroKannBook

New:
LCZero 0.10-id323 - Spike 1.4_SpikePircBook_12m+5s so far +3=6-4. Hope. Game 1 - interesting concept.
[White "Spike 1.4"]
[Black "LCzero v0.10-id323"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C67"]
[PlyCount "177"]

1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 Nf6 4. O-O Nxe4 5. d4 Nd6 6. Bxc6 dxc6 7. dxe5 Nf5
8. Qxd8+ Kxd8 9. Nc3 Ke8 10. b3 a5 11. Bb2 Be7 12. Rad1 h5 13. a4 Rh6 14. Bc1
Rg6 15. Ne2 Nh4 16. Ne1 b5 17. g3 Nf5 18. Nd3 b4 19. Ndf4 Rh6 20. h4 Bb7 21.
Rfe1 Rd8 22. c4 bxc3 23. Nxc3 Nd4 24. Rxd4 Rxd4 25. Nfe2 Rb4 26. Bxh6 gxh6 27.
Rb1 Bc8 28. Nf4 Bxh4 29. Nxh5 Bg5 30. Na2 Rd4 31. Nc3 Kf8 32. Nf6 Bf5 33. Ne2
Rd8 34. Rb2 c5 35. f4 Bxf6 36. exf6 Kg8 37. Kf2 Kh7 38. Nc3 Kg6 39. Nb5 c6 40.
Na3 Be6 41. Nc4 Bxc4 42. bxc4 Rd4 43. Rb6 Rxc4 44. Rxc6 Rxa4 45. Rxc5 Ra1 46.
Rc6 a4 47. Kf3 h5 48. Ra6 a3 49. Kg2 Kh6 50. Ra5 a2 51. Kh2 Kg6 52. Ra6 Kh7 53.
Ra4 Kh6 54. Ra5 Kg6 55. Ra6 Kf5 56. Kg2 Ke4 57. Ra4+ Kd5 58. Kh2 Ke6 59. Ra6+
Kd7 60. Kg2 Kc7 61. Ra7+ Kd6 62. Kh2 Ke6 63. Ra6+ Kf5 64. Kg2 h4 65. Ra5+ Kxf6
66. gxh4 Kg6 67. f5+ Kh5 68. Ra4 Kh6 69. Ra5 Kh7 70. Ra4 Kg8 71. Ra8+ Kh7 72.
Ra4 Kh8 73. Ra8+ Kg7 74. Ra6 Kh8 75. Ra4 Kh7 76. Ra6 Kg8 77. Ra8+ Kg7 78. Ra6
f6 79. Ra8 Kh6 80. Rh8+ Kg7 81. Ra8 Kh7 82. Ra6 Kg8 83. Ra7 Kf8 84. h5 Kg8 85.
Kh2 Kh8 86. Kg2 Kg8 87. h6 Kh8 88. h7 Rb1 89. Rxa2 1/2-1/2

Post Reply