Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderators: hgm, Harvey Williamson, bob

User avatar
Laskos
Posts: 7959
Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 8:21 pm

Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by Laskos » Wed Jun 14, 2017 7:07 pm

I tried to gauge FIDE ratings of engines at Tournament Time Control, FIDE ratings of engines at fast Blitz, and Computer ratings of engines. I used Ordo and its settings. Database is CCRL 40/40 Pure List.

1/ FIDE ratings at Tournament Time Control on 4 core machine:

Code: Select all


   # PLAYER                            : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED     (%)

   1 Komodo 11.01 64-bit 4CPU          : 3272.8     153.5     210    73.1
   2 Stockfish 8 64-bit 4CPU           : 3264.5     454.0     632    71.8
   3 Houdini 5.01 64-bit 4CPU          : 3257.5     341.0     508    67.1
   4 Deep Shredder 13 64-bit 4CPU      : 3191.3     217.0     386    56.2
   5 Fire 5 64-bit 4CPU                : 3178.8     221.0     408    54.2
   6 Fizbo 1.9 64-bit 4CPU             : 3166.2     190.5     372    51.2
   7 Andscacs 0.89 64-bit 4CPU         : 3152.3     174.0     354    49.2
   8 Chiron 4 64-bit 4CPU              : 3129.8     158.0     372    42.5
   9 Gull 3 64-bit 4CPU                : 3114.7     341.0     721    47.3
  10 Equinox 3.20 64-bit 4CPU          : 3112.4     301.0     654    46.0
  11 Fritz 15 64-bit 4CPU              : 3107.2     305.5     692    44.1
  12 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 4CPU          : 3105.5     414.5     837    49.5
  13 Bouquet 1.8 64-bit 4CPU           : 3099.0     219.5     434    50.6
  14 Hannibal 1.7 64-bit 4CPU          : 3098.4     258.5     619    41.8
  15 NirvanaChess 2.3 64-bit 4CPU      : 3093.2     164.5     367    44.8
  16 Rybka 4 64-bit 4CPU               : 3087.8     359.0     629    57.1
  17 Texel 1.06 64-bit 4CPU            : 3085.5     183.5     397    46.2
  18 Protector 1.9.0 64-bit 4CPU       : 3080.6     120.0     249    48.2
  19 BlackMamba 2.0 64-bit 4CPU        : 3077.4     133.5     274    48.7
  20 Naum 4.6 64-bit 4CPU              : 3049.6     174.5     380    45.9
  21 Hiarcs 14 4CPU                    : 3018.6     112.0     272    41.2
  22 Deep Junior 13 64-bit 4CPU        : 3004.2     159.0     306    52.0
  23 Spike 1.4 Leiden 4CPU             : 2999.1     270.0     533    50.7
  24 Senpai 1.0 64-bit 4CPU            : 2999.1     120.5     261    46.2
  25 Spark 1.0 64-bit 4CPU             : 2962.2     165.0     348    47.4
  26 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 4CPU       : 2960.9     316.0     617    51.2
  27 Arasan 20.1 64-bit                : 2938.0     144.0     236    61.0
  28 Onno 1.2.70 64-bit 4CPU           : 2937.7     108.0     227    47.6
  29 Thinker 5.4c Inert 64-bit 4CPU    : 2936.2     178.5     370    48.2
  30 Alfil 15.8 64-bit                 : 2931.6     151.0     255    59.2
  31 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 4CPU     : 2925.1     165.0     355    46.5
  32 Hakkapeliitta 3.0 64-bit          : 2922.7     251.0     443    56.7
  33 Vajolet2 2.2 64-bit               : 2922.7     117.0     209    56.0
  34 Pedone 1.5 64-bit                 : 2914.5     119.0     222    53.6
  35 Laser 1.3 64-bit                  : 2910.7     131.5     238    55.3
  36 Crafty 25.2 64-bit                : 2910.0     140.5     266    52.8
  37 Cheng 4.39 64-bit                 : 2906.8     320.0     596    53.7
  38 SmarThink 1.70 64-bit             : 2905.4     204.5     364    56.2
  39 Toga II 1.4.1SE 4CPU              : 2905.0     162.5     359    45.3
  40 Nemorino 2.00 64-bit              : 2904.7     124.5     238    52.3
  41 Bobcat 8.0 64-bit                 : 2899.8     199.0     366    54.4
  42 Wasp 2.01 64-bit                  : 2894.3     149.0     268    55.6
  43 Booot 5.2.0 64-bit                : 2894.1     215.0     389    55.3
  44 Quazar 0.4 64-bit                 : 2892.9     366.5     666    55.0
  45 Bright 0.4a 4CPU                  : 2892.8     177.0     375    47.2
  46 Rodent II 0.9.64 64-bit           : 2891.6     120.5     240    50.2
  47 EXchess 7.97b 64-bit              : 2881.8     220.0     404    54.5
  48 DiscoCheck 5.2.1 64-bit           : 2879.5     260.5     521    50.0
  49 Deuterium 14.3.34.130 64-bit      : 2877.7     351.5     721    48.8
  50 iCE 2.0 64-bit                    : 2875.4     206.5     406    50.9
  51 ChessBrainVB 3.20                 : 2872.4     140.5     267    52.6
  52 Dirty 30Apr2017 64-bit            : 2861.9     112.0     232    48.3
  53 Gaviota 1.0 64-bit                : 2855.0     268.5     572    46.9
  54 Loop M1-T 64-bit 4CPU             : 2853.4     123.0     343    35.9
  55 MinkoChess 1.3 64-bit             : 2852.6     166.0     343    48.4
  56 Nemo 1.0.1 64-bit                 : 2851.0     291.5     611    47.7
  57 Atlas 3.80 64-bit                 : 2848.6     288.5     598    48.2
  58 DisasterArea 1.65 64-bit          : 2847.5     187.5     395    47.5
  59 Tornado 8.0 64-bit                : 2846.9     205.5     400    51.4
  60 GnuCheese 1.00 64-bit             : 2831.0     230.0     410    56.1
  61 Scorpio 2.7.7 64-bit              : 2826.9     223.0     437    51.0
  62 Murka 3 64-bit                    : 2825.3     177.5     414    42.9
  63 Amoeba 2.4 64-bit                 : 2819.9     145.0     304    47.7
  64 Pawny 1.2 64-bit                  : 2815.8     225.5     446    50.6
  65 The Baron 3.29 64-bit             : 2813.5     152.5     304    50.2
  66 Rhetoric 1.4.3 64-bit             : 2812.0     237.5     495    48.0
  67 Zurichess Luzern 64-bit           : 2808.1     113.0     266    42.5
  68 Naraku 1.4                        : 2803.5     174.5     344    50.7
  69 Ktulu 9                           : 2803.4     173.0     279    62.0
  70 Frenzee 3.5.19 64-bit             : 2797.3     267.0     558    47.8
  71 BugChess2 1.9 64-bit              : 2794.0     305.0     603    50.6
  72 Twisted Logic 20100131x 64-bit    : 2793.8     161.0     297    54.2
  73 Octochess r5190 64-bit            : 2792.9     143.0     304    47.0
  74 Bison 9.11 64-bit                 : 2787.0     204.0     403    50.6
  75 ProDeo 2.2                        : 2774.7     145.5     274    53.1
  76 Carballo 1.7 64-bit               : 2768.1     134.5     243    55.3
  77 Chronos 1.9.9 64-bit              : 2765.0     206.0     424    48.6
  78 Tucano 6.00 64-bit                : 2764.7     216.0     437    49.4
  79 Godel 3.4.9 64-bit                : 2764.1     275.5     544    50.6
  80 Chess Tiger 2007.1                : 2752.7     327.5     586    55.9
  81 Delfi 5.4                         : 2742.5     245.0     439    55.8
  82 Cheese 1.8 64-bit                 : 2739.4     197.0     375    52.5
  83 Arminius 2017-01-01 64-bit        : 2736.0     185.5     334    55.5
  84 Chessmaster 11 Aiglos II          : 2729.7     106.5     234    45.5
  85 Daydreamer 1.75 64-bit            : 2729.1     160.5     332    48.3
  86 Djinn 1.021 64-bit                : 2724.5     227.0     455    49.9
  87 Philou 3.7.1 64-bit               : 2720.5     248.5     472    52.6
  88 RedQueen 1.1.97 64-bit            : 2717.6     157.0     323    48.6
  89 Alaric 707                        : 2716.3     316.5     617    51.3
  90 Movei 00.8.438 (10 10 10)         : 2712.2     300.5     629    47.8
  91 Floyd 0.9 64-bit                  : 2711.4     202.5     404    50.1
  92 WyldChess 1.4 64-bit              : 2709.5     170.0     302    56.3
  93 Gandalf 6                         : 2708.5     307.0     561    54.7
  94 Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1            : 2707.7     359.5     664    54.1
  95 WildCat 7                         : 2707.7     184.5     343    53.8
  96 NoraGrace 2.0 64-bit              : 2706.5     230.5     439    52.5
  97 E.T. Chess 13.01.08               : 2706.5     277.0     544    50.9
  98 Rodin 8.0                         : 2703.5     193.0     377    51.2
  99 Sjakk 2.2 64-bit                  : 2701.8     237.0     458    51.7
 100 Sloppy 0.2.2 64-bit               : 2701.4     182.0     343    53.1
 101 Ruffian 2.1.0                     : 2700.0     293.5     558    52.6
 102 Pharaon 3.5.1                     : 2696.2     304.0     567    53.6
 103 GreKo 2015-ML 64-bit              : 2695.5     126.5     254    49.8
 104 Nebula 2.0 64-bit                 : 2695.2     177.5     351    50.6
 105 Cyrano 0.6b17 32-bit              : 2695.2     227.0     466    48.7
 106 Colossus 2008b                    : 2692.1     277.5     574    48.3
 107 Rotor 0.8                         : 2691.5     155.0     317    48.9
 108 Hamsters 0.7.1                    : 2691.2     271.5     538    50.5
 109 Phalanx XXV                       : 2691.0     229.0     443    51.7
 110 Ethereal 8.12 64-bit              : 2690.4     169.5     318    53.3
 111 Donna 4.0 64-bit                  : 2688.8     212.5     422    50.4
 112 Aristarch 4.50                    : 2685.5     350.5     657    53.3
 113 DanaSah 6.50                      : 2684.1     166.0     334    49.7
 114 N2 0.4 64-bit                     : 2678.7     279.5     530    52.7
 115 Muse 0.953 64-bit                 : 2678.6     182.5     352    51.8
 116 Amyan 1.72                        : 2675.5     225.5     421    53.6
 117 Pseudo 0.7c                       : 2675.1     328.5     651    50.5
 118 Glass 2.0 64-bit                  : 2675.1     178.5     379    47.1
 119 GarboChess 3.0 64-bit             : 2669.5     194.5     394    49.4
 120 Jellyfish 1.1 64-bit              : 2668.6     248.0     507    48.9
 121 Jonny 2.83 32-bit                 : 2665.4     187.5     398    47.1
 122 Brutus 8.05 64-bit                : 2664.9     115.0     232    49.6
 123 Capivara LK 0.09b02f 64-bit       : 2661.4     181.5     371    48.9
 124 K2 0.87                           : 2660.4     149.5     329    45.4
 125 Gogobello 1.1 64-bit              : 2658.8     137.0     247    55.5
 126 Coiled 0.4 64-bit                 : 2658.3     191.5     374    51.2
 127 GNU Chess 5.07.153b 64-bit        : 2657.8     156.0     273    57.1
 128 SOS 5.1                           : 2656.4     221.5     453    48.9
 129 JikChess 0.02 64-bit              : 2653.6     262.5     520    50.5
 130 Petir 4.999999                    : 2653.3     193.0     421    45.8
 131 Ghost 3 64-bit                    : 2651.7     155.0     300    51.7
 132 Francesca MAD 0.19                : 2648.6     150.5     306    49.2
 133 nanoSzachy 4.1 64-bit             : 2644.6     264.5     524    50.5
 134 Marvin 2.0.0 64-bit               : 2642.1     182.5     285    64.0
 135 chess22k 1.3 64-bit               : 2631.2     164.5     276    59.6
 136 Fridolin 2.0 64-bit               : 2630.3     256.5     545    47.1
 137 Maverick 1.5 64-bit               : 2627.1     270.0     553    48.8
 138 Ufim 8.02                         : 2626.1     198.5     425    46.7
 139 AnMon 5.60                        : 2626.0     183.5     393    46.7
 140 ECE X2                            : 2624.3     171.5     330    52.0
 141 Dorky 4.5 64-bit                  : 2622.9     226.5     452    50.1
 142 Shield 1.3.1 64-bit               : 2622.4     178.5     344    51.9
 143 CyberPagno 3.0 64-bit             : 2622.3     170.0     334    50.9
 144 Tao 5.6                           : 2621.1     193.5     416    46.5
 145 LittleThought 1.052 64-bit        : 2620.4     178.5     336    53.1
 146 Delphil 3.2 64-bit                : 2619.0     195.0     407    47.9
 147 Little Goliath Evolution 3.12     : 2617.6     200.5     441    45.5
 148 Schooner 1.7.0 64-bit             : 2610.9     175.5     316    55.5
 149 Pupsi2 0.09                       : 2610.2     116.0     246    47.2
 150 Xpdnt 091007                      : 2609.5     151.0     295    51.2
 151 Pepito 1.59 32-bit                : 2606.0     129.0     259    49.8
 152 Giraffe 20150908 64-bit           : 2603.8     112.5     222    50.7
 153 Yace 0.99.87                      : 2603.3     120.5     246    49.0
 154 Hermann 2.5 32-bit                : 2602.1     155.5     333    46.7
 155 pikoSzachy 4.1                    : 2602.1     140.0     262    53.4
 156 Eeyore 1.52 64-bit                : 2599.7     201.5     366    55.1
 157 Matacz 1.4                        : 2598.7     214.5     399    53.8
 158 Cerebro 3.03d                     : 2597.9     153.5     306    50.2
 159 MadChess 2.1 64-bit               : 2596.1     174.5     330    52.9
 160 Anatoli 0.35k                     : 2595.6     217.5     441    49.3
 161 Betsabe II 1.66                   : 2590.4     184.0     390    47.2
 162 Bagatur 1.4d 64-bit               : 2590.2     204.5     422    48.5
 163 Quark 2.35                        : 2589.8     162.5     342    47.5
 164 Trace 1.37a                       : 2584.5     153.0     318    48.1
 165 Counter 1.2                       : 2582.9     157.5     316    49.8
 166 Nemeton 1.5                       : 2582.7     166.0     354    46.9
 167 Bumblebee 1.0.36898e1 64-bit      : 2582.1     200.5     449    44.7
 168 Lozza 1.17 64-bit                 : 2577.6     239.0     516    46.3
 169 PostModernist 1016                : 2576.3     165.0     317    52.1
 170 Patzer 3.80                       : 2573.4     129.5     252    51.4
 171 Bruja 1.9.1 32-bit                : 2572.8     129.5     263    49.2
 172 TJchess 1.3 64-bit                : 2572.1     182.5     405    45.1
 173 Abrok 5.0                         : 2571.8      95.5     200    47.8
 174 Hussar 0.4                        : 2570.2     140.0     275    50.9
 175 Cmcchess 2.6 64-bit               : 2570.1     155.0     340    45.6
 176 Shallow r694 64-bit               : 2568.7     141.0     308    45.8
 177 Homer 2.01                        : 2568.0     191.0     369    51.8
 178 Diablo 0.5.1                      : 2566.0     193.0     389    49.6
 179 Kiwi 0.6d 32-bit                  : 2565.0     126.0     255    49.4
 180 Dragon 4.6                        : 2561.0     149.5     298    50.2
 181 Typhoon 1.00-358                  : 2558.8     176.5     375    47.1
 182 Ifrit m1.8 64-bit                 : 2556.6     117.5     265    44.3
 183 Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit               : 2555.3     105.0     215    48.8
 184 RomiChess P3k 32-bit              : 2555.0     180.5     369    48.9
 185 Queen 4.03                        : 2553.2     215.0     437    49.2
 186 Simplex 0.9.8 64-bit              : 2549.3     154.0     330    46.7
 187 Orion 0.3.0 64-bit                : 2549.0     125.5     289    43.4
 188 Gosu 0.16                         : 2547.4     141.5     297    47.6
 189 Alex 2.14a 64-bit                 : 2545.2     175.0     372    47.0
 190 Horizon 4.4                       : 2544.3     188.5     400    47.1
 191 Sorgenkind 0.4                    : 2543.7     323.0     648    49.8
 192 Comet B68                         : 2541.9     132.5     279    47.5
 193 Ares 1.004                        : 2540.4     262.5     501    52.4
 194 Myrddin 0.87 64-bit               : 2540.4     122.0     299    40.8
 195 Amy 0.87b                         : 2540.1     150.0     314    47.8
 196 Amateur 2.82                      : 2538.8     135.5     288    47.0
 197 OliThink 5.3.2 64-bit             : 2536.2     159.5     354    45.1
 198 Sage 3.53                         : 2531.3     203.5     426    47.8
 199 Waxman 2016                       : 2530.9      98.5     223    44.2
 200 Gaia 3.5 32-bit                   : 2529.6     129.5     291    44.5
 201 Flux 2.2.1                        : 2524.6     122.5     246    49.8
 202 Plisk 0.2.7d 32-bit               : 2524.5     141.0     258    54.7
 203 Asterisk 0.6                      : 2518.1     120.5     242    49.8
 204 Aice 0.99.2                       : 2514.8     131.5     295    44.6
 205 Amundsen 0.80                     : 2509.8     158.5     317    50.0
 206 Arion 1.7                         : 2507.4     138.0     302    45.7
 207 Jumbo 0.4.17 64-bit               : 2506.7      95.5     222    43.0
 208 EveAnn 1.72                       : 2505.4      98.5     226    43.6
 209 Butcher 1.61 32-bit               : 2494.3     105.5     202    52.2
 210 Joker 1.1.14                      : 2492.8     116.5     233    50.0
 211 Chaturanga 2.4.3                  : 2488.3     127.0     245    51.8
 212 Natwarlal 0.14                    : 2483.9     101.5     236    43.0
 213 Fischerle 0.9.80 SE 64-bit        : 2479.5      83.5     221    37.8
 214 AliChess 4.25                     : 2477.7     126.5     262    48.3
 215 Popochin 3.2                      : 2473.8     185.0     407    45.5
 216 Sungorus 1.4 32-bit               : 2461.5     168.5     344    49.0
 217 RattateChess 1.0 Nosferatu        : 2459.2     144.0     294    49.0
 218 Feuerstein 0.4.6.1                : 2455.8     207.0     386    53.6
 219 Atak 6.8                          : 2446.6     140.0     303    46.2
 220 Dolphin 1.0                       : 2445.7     151.0     307    49.2
 221 Gibbon 2.52a                      : 2439.5     230.5     440    52.4
 222 Adam 3.3                          : 2438.9     108.0     204    52.9
 223 BlackBishop 1.0                   : 2435.1     194.5     374    52.0
 224 Beowulf 2.4a 32-bit               : 2430.9     178.5     356    50.1
 225 Neurosis 2.5                      : 2429.7     192.5     370    52.0
 226 OBender 3.2.4.2                   : 2423.7     113.5     220    51.6
 227 NagaSkaki 5.12                    : 2421.2     159.5     304    52.5
 228 Uralochka 1.1b                    : 2412.0     125.5     284    44.2
 229 KMTChess 1.2.1 32-bit             : 2412.0     177.0     362    48.9
 230 Kurt 0.9.2 32-bit                 : 2398.8     152.0     274    55.5
 231 Prophet 2.0 32-bit                : 2398.7     144.5     261    55.4
 232 KnockOut 0.7.1                    : 2398.0     318.5     574    55.5
 233 Parrot 07.07.22                   : 2382.9     118.0     227    52.0
 234 BikJump 2.01 32-bit               : 2366.9     236.5     430    55.0
 235 Clarabit 1.00 32-bit              : 2366.7     159.0     328    48.5
 236 FireFly 2.5.6 32-bit              : 2355.5     155.0     327    47.4
 237 PLP 1661571                       : 2354.0     175.5     342    51.3
 238 Jabba 1.0 32-bit                  : 2348.4     181.0     352    51.4
 239 Protej 0.5.7                      : 2344.6     151.5     310    48.9
 240 BigLion 2.23x                     : 2338.7     169.0     352    48.0
 241 Bubble 1.5                        : 2326.3     125.0     282    44.3
 242 Slibo 0.5.1                       : 2322.8     156.0     334    46.7
 243 ChessMind 0.82                    : 2308.2     139.5     290    48.1
 244 BibiChess 0.5                     : 2307.8     116.0     232    50.0
 245 Schola 1.1.0 32-bit               : 2303.7     139.5     297    47.0
 246 Monarch 1.7                       : 2302.0     156.5     339    46.2
 247 Heracles 0.6.16                   : 2298.5     148.0     307    48.2
 248 MatMoi 7.15.0-cct 32-bit          : 2282.6     121.0     279    43.4
 249 Rival 1.18                        : 2278.8     129.0     269    48.0
 250 Micro-Max 4.8 (DM-PII)            : 2268.9     173.5     333    52.1
 251 Reger 0.09                        : 2260.3     120.0     309    38.8
 252 GChess IV 0.2.0                   : 2255.9     107.0     248    43.1
 253 Smash 1.0.3                       : 2253.1     107.0     262    40.8
 254 Clueless 1.4                      : 2249.9     162.5     373    43.6
 255 Warrior 1.0.3                     : 2248.5     151.0     335    45.1
 256 Surprise 4.3b13                   : 2245.2     113.5     265    42.8
 257 Predateur 2.2 64-bit              : 2222.6      85.5     216    39.6

White advantage = 15.91
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 38.24 %

User avatar
Laskos
Posts: 7959
Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 8:21 pm

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by Laskos » Wed Jun 14, 2017 7:08 pm

2/ FIDE ratings at fast Blitz Time Control on 4 core machine:

Code: Select all


   # PLAYER                            : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED     (%)

   1 Komodo 11.01 64-bit 4CPU          : 3663.8     153.5     210    73.1
   2 Stockfish 8 64-bit 4CPU           : 3652.7     454.0     632    71.8
   3 Houdini 5.01 64-bit 4CPU          : 3643.4     341.0     508    67.1
   4 Deep Shredder 13 64-bit 4CPU      : 3555.1     217.0     386    56.2
   5 Fire 5 64-bit 4CPU                : 3538.4     221.0     408    54.2
   6 Fizbo 1.9 64-bit 4CPU             : 3521.7     190.5     372    51.2
   7 Andscacs 0.89 64-bit 4CPU         : 3503.0     174.0     354    49.2
   8 Chiron 4 64-bit 4CPU              : 3473.1     158.0     372    42.5
   9 Gull 3 64-bit 4CPU                : 3453.0     341.0     721    47.3
  10 Equinox 3.20 64-bit 4CPU          : 3449.9     301.0     654    46.0
  11 Fritz 15 64-bit 4CPU              : 3443.0     305.5     692    44.1
  12 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 4CPU          : 3440.7     414.5     837    49.5
  13 Bouquet 1.8 64-bit 4CPU           : 3432.1     219.5     434    50.6
  14 Hannibal 1.7 64-bit 4CPU          : 3431.2     258.5     619    41.8
  15 NirvanaChess 2.3 64-bit 4CPU      : 3424.3     164.5     367    44.8
  16 Rybka 4 64-bit 4CPU               : 3417.1     359.0     629    57.1
  17 Texel 1.06 64-bit 4CPU            : 3414.0     183.5     397    46.2
  18 Protector 1.9.0 64-bit 4CPU       : 3407.5     120.0     249    48.2
  19 BlackMamba 2.0 64-bit 4CPU        : 3403.2     133.5     274    48.7
  20 Naum 4.6 64-bit 4CPU              : 3366.2     174.5     380    45.9
  21 Hiarcs 14 4CPU                    : 3324.7     112.0     272    41.2
  22 Deep Junior 13 64-bit 4CPU        : 3305.6     159.0     306    52.0
  23 Spike 1.4 Leiden 4CPU             : 3298.8     270.0     533    50.7
  24 Senpai 1.0 64-bit 4CPU            : 3298.8     120.5     261    46.2
  25 Spark 1.0 64-bit 4CPU             : 3249.6     165.0     348    47.4
  26 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 4CPU       : 3247.9     316.0     617    51.2
  27 Arasan 20.1 64-bit                : 3217.3     144.0     236    61.0
  28 Onno 1.2.70 64-bit 4CPU           : 3216.9     108.0     227    47.6
  29 Thinker 5.4c Inert 64-bit 4CPU    : 3214.9     178.5     370    48.2
  30 Alfil 15.8 64-bit                 : 3208.8     151.0     255    59.2
  31 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 4CPU     : 3200.1     165.0     355    46.5
  32 Hakkapeliitta 3.0 64-bit          : 3197.0     251.0     443    56.7
  33 Vajolet2 2.2 64-bit               : 3196.9     117.0     209    56.0
  34 Pedone 1.5 64-bit                 : 3186.0     119.0     222    53.6
  35 Laser 1.3 64-bit                  : 3180.9     131.5     238    55.3
  36 Crafty 25.2 64-bit                : 3180.0     140.5     266    52.8
  37 Cheng 4.39 64-bit                 : 3175.7     320.0     596    53.7
  38 SmarThink 1.70 64-bit             : 3173.8     204.5     364    56.2
  39 Toga II 1.4.1SE 4CPU              : 3173.4     162.5     359    45.3
  40 Nemorino 2.00 64-bit              : 3172.9     124.5     238    52.3
  41 Bobcat 8.0 64-bit                 : 3166.3     199.0     366    54.4
  42 Wasp 2.01 64-bit                  : 3159.0     149.0     268    55.6
  43 Booot 5.2.0 64-bit                : 3158.8     215.0     389    55.3
  44 Quazar 0.4 64-bit                 : 3157.1     366.5     666    55.0
  45 Bright 0.4a 4CPU                  : 3157.1     177.0     375    47.2
  46 Rodent II 0.9.64 64-bit           : 3155.5     120.5     240    50.2
  47 EXchess 7.97b 64-bit              : 3142.4     220.0     404    54.5
  48 DiscoCheck 5.2.1 64-bit           : 3139.3     260.5     521    50.0
  49 Deuterium 14.3.34.130 64-bit      : 3136.9     351.5     721    48.8
  50 iCE 2.0 64-bit                    : 3133.9     206.5     406    50.9
  51 ChessBrainVB 3.20                 : 3129.9     140.5     267    52.6
  52 Dirty 30Apr2017 64-bit            : 3115.8     112.0     232    48.3
  53 Gaviota 1.0 64-bit                : 3106.6     268.5     572    46.9
  54 Loop M1-T 64-bit 4CPU             : 3104.5     123.0     343    35.9
  55 MinkoChess 1.3 64-bit             : 3103.5     166.0     343    48.4
  56 Nemo 1.0.1 64-bit                 : 3101.4     291.5     611    47.7
  57 Atlas 3.80 64-bit                 : 3098.1     288.5     598    48.2
  58 DisasterArea 1.65 64-bit          : 3096.7     187.5     395    47.5
  59 Tornado 8.0 64-bit                : 3095.8     205.5     400    51.4
  60 GnuCheese 1.00 64-bit             : 3074.6     230.0     410    56.1
  61 Scorpio 2.7.7 64-bit              : 3069.2     223.0     437    51.0
  62 Murka 3 64-bit                    : 3067.1     177.5     414    42.9
  63 Amoeba 2.4 64-bit                 : 3059.9     145.0     304    47.7
  64 Pawny 1.2 64-bit                  : 3054.4     225.5     446    50.6
  65 The Baron 3.29 64-bit             : 3051.4     152.5     304    50.2
  66 Rhetoric 1.4.3 64-bit             : 3049.3     237.5     495    48.0
  67 Zurichess Luzern 64-bit           : 3044.1     113.0     266    42.5
  68 Naraku 1.4                        : 3038.0     174.5     344    50.7
  69 Ktulu 9                           : 3037.9     173.0     279    62.0
  70 Frenzee 3.5.19 64-bit             : 3029.7     267.0     558    47.8
  71 BugChess2 1.9 64-bit              : 3025.3     305.0     603    50.6
  72 Twisted Logic 20100131x 64-bit    : 3025.0     161.0     297    54.2
  73 Octochess r5190 64-bit            : 3023.9     143.0     304    47.0
  74 Bison 9.11 64-bit                 : 3016.0     204.0     403    50.6
  75 ProDeo 2.2                        : 2999.6     145.5     274    53.1
  76 Carballo 1.7 64-bit               : 2990.8     134.5     243    55.3
  77 Chronos 1.9.9 64-bit              : 2986.6     206.0     424    48.6
  78 Tucano 6.00 64-bit                : 2986.2     216.0     437    49.4
  79 Godel 3.4.9 64-bit                : 2985.5     275.5     544    50.6
  80 Chess Tiger 2007.1                : 2970.3     327.5     586    55.9
  81 Delfi 5.4                         : 2956.6     245.0     439    55.8
  82 Cheese 1.8 64-bit                 : 2952.6     197.0     375    52.5
  83 Arminius 2017-01-01 64-bit        : 2948.0     185.5     334    55.5
  84 Chessmaster 11 Aiglos II          : 2939.6     106.5     234    45.5
  85 Daydreamer 1.75 64-bit            : 2938.8     160.5     332    48.3
  86 Djinn 1.021 64-bit                : 2932.7     227.0     455    49.9
  87 Philou 3.7.1 64-bit               : 2927.3     248.5     472    52.6
  88 RedQueen 1.1.97 64-bit            : 2923.5     157.0     323    48.6
  89 Alaric 707                        : 2921.7     316.5     617    51.3
  90 Movei 00.8.438 (10 10 10)         : 2916.3     300.5     629    47.8
  91 Floyd 0.9 64-bit                  : 2915.2     202.5     404    50.1
  92 WyldChess 1.4 64-bit              : 2912.6     170.0     302    56.3
  93 Gandalf 6                         : 2911.3     307.0     561    54.7
  94 Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1            : 2910.3     359.5     664    54.1
  95 WildCat 7                         : 2910.3     184.5     343    53.8
  96 NoraGrace 2.0 64-bit              : 2908.7     230.5     439    52.5
  97 E.T. Chess 13.01.08               : 2908.7     277.0     544    50.9
  98 Rodin 8.0                         : 2904.7     193.0     377    51.2
  99 Sjakk 2.2 64-bit                  : 2902.4     237.0     458    51.7
 100 Sloppy 0.2.2 64-bit               : 2901.8     182.0     343    53.1
 101 Ruffian 2.1.0                     : 2900.0     293.5     558    52.6
 102 Pharaon 3.5.1                     : 2894.9     304.0     567    53.6
 103 GreKo 2015-ML 64-bit              : 2894.0     126.5     254    49.8
 104 Nebula 2.0 64-bit                 : 2893.6     177.5     351    50.6
 105 Cyrano 0.6b17 32-bit              : 2893.6     227.0     466    48.7
 106 Colossus 2008b                    : 2889.4     277.5     574    48.3
 107 Rotor 0.8                         : 2888.7     155.0     317    48.9
 108 Hamsters 0.7.1                    : 2888.3     271.5     538    50.5
 109 Phalanx XXV                       : 2888.0     229.0     443    51.7
 110 Ethereal 8.12 64-bit              : 2887.2     169.5     318    53.3
 111 Donna 4.0 64-bit                  : 2885.0     212.5     422    50.4
 112 Aristarch 4.50                    : 2880.6     350.5     657    53.3
 113 DanaSah 6.50                      : 2878.9     166.0     334    49.7
 114 N2 0.4 64-bit                     : 2871.6     279.5     530    52.7
 115 Muse 0.953 64-bit                 : 2871.4     182.5     352    51.8
 116 Amyan 1.72                        : 2867.4     225.5     421    53.6
 117 Pseudo 0.7c                       : 2866.8     328.5     651    50.5
 118 Glass 2.0 64-bit                  : 2866.7     178.5     379    47.1
 119 GarboChess 3.0 64-bit             : 2859.3     194.5     394    49.4
 120 Jellyfish 1.1 64-bit              : 2858.2     248.0     507    48.9
 121 Jonny 2.83 32-bit                 : 2853.9     187.5     398    47.1
 122 Brutus 8.05 64-bit                : 2853.2     115.0     232    49.6
 123 Capivara LK 0.09b02f 64-bit       : 2848.6     181.5     371    48.9
 124 K2 0.87                           : 2847.2     149.5     329    45.4
 125 Gogobello 1.1 64-bit              : 2845.1     137.0     247    55.5
 126 Coiled 0.4 64-bit                 : 2844.4     191.5     374    51.2
 127 GNU Chess 5.07.153b 64-bit        : 2843.8     156.0     273    57.1
 128 SOS 5.1                           : 2841.9     221.5     453    48.9
 129 JikChess 0.02 64-bit              : 2838.1     262.5     520    50.5
 130 Petir 4.999999                    : 2837.8     193.0     421    45.8
 131 Ghost 3 64-bit                    : 2835.6     155.0     300    51.7
 132 Francesca MAD 0.19                : 2831.4     150.5     306    49.2
 133 nanoSzachy 4.1 64-bit             : 2826.2     264.5     524    50.5
 134 Marvin 2.0.0 64-bit               : 2822.8     182.5     285    64.0
 135 chess22k 1.3 64-bit               : 2808.2     164.5     276    59.6
 136 Fridolin 2.0 64-bit               : 2807.1     256.5     545    47.1
 137 Maverick 1.5 64-bit               : 2802.7     270.0     553    48.8
 138 Ufim 8.02                         : 2801.4     198.5     425    46.7
 139 AnMon 5.60                        : 2801.3     183.5     393    46.7
 140 ECE X2                            : 2799.1     171.5     330    52.0
 141 Dorky 4.5 64-bit                  : 2797.1     226.5     452    50.1
 142 Shield 1.3.1 64-bit               : 2796.5     178.5     344    51.9
 143 CyberPagno 3.0 64-bit             : 2796.4     170.0     334    50.9
 144 Tao 5.6                           : 2794.7     193.5     416    46.5
 145 LittleThought 1.052 64-bit        : 2793.9     178.5     336    53.1
 146 Delphil 3.2 64-bit                : 2792.1     195.0     407    47.9
 147 Little Goliath Evolution 3.12     : 2790.2     200.5     441    45.5
 148 Schooner 1.7.0 64-bit             : 2781.3     175.5     316    55.5
 149 Pupsi2 0.09                       : 2780.2     116.0     246    47.2
 150 Xpdnt 091007                      : 2779.3     151.0     295    51.2
 151 Pepito 1.59 32-bit                : 2774.6     129.0     259    49.8
 152 Giraffe 20150908 64-bit           : 2771.7     112.5     222    50.7
 153 Yace 0.99.87                      : 2771.1     120.5     246    49.0
 154 Hermann 2.5 32-bit                : 2769.5     155.5     333    46.7
 155 pikoSzachy 4.1                    : 2769.4     140.0     262    53.4
 156 Eeyore 1.52 64-bit                : 2766.3     201.5     366    55.1
 157 Matacz 1.4                        : 2765.0     214.5     399    53.8
 158 Cerebro 3.03d                     : 2763.8     153.5     306    50.2
 159 MadChess 2.1 64-bit               : 2761.4     174.5     330    52.9
 160 Anatoli 0.35k                     : 2760.9     217.5     441    49.3
 161 Betsabe II 1.66                   : 2753.9     184.0     390    47.2
 162 Bagatur 1.4d 64-bit               : 2753.6     204.5     422    48.5
 163 Quark 2.35                        : 2753.1     162.5     342    47.5
 164 Trace 1.37a                       : 2746.1     153.0     318    48.1
 165 Counter 1.2                       : 2743.8     157.5     316    49.8
 166 Nemeton 1.5                       : 2743.6     166.0     354    46.9
 167 Bumblebee 1.0.36898e1 64-bit      : 2742.8     200.5     449    44.7
 168 Lozza 1.17 64-bit                 : 2736.8     239.0     516    46.3
 169 PostModernist 1016                : 2735.1     165.0     317    52.1
 170 Patzer 3.80                       : 2731.2     129.5     252    51.4
 171 Bruja 1.9.1 32-bit                : 2730.3     129.5     263    49.2
 172 TJchess 1.3 64-bit                : 2729.5     182.5     405    45.1
 173 Abrok 5.0                         : 2729.1      95.5     200    47.8
 174 Hussar 0.4                        : 2726.9     140.0     275    50.9
 175 Cmcchess 2.6 64-bit               : 2726.8     155.0     340    45.6
 176 Shallow r694 64-bit               : 2724.9     141.0     308    45.8
 177 Homer 2.01                        : 2724.0     191.0     369    51.8
 178 Diablo 0.5.1                      : 2721.3     193.0     389    49.6
 179 Kiwi 0.6d 32-bit                  : 2720.0     126.0     255    49.4
 180 Dragon 4.6                        : 2714.7     149.5     298    50.2
 181 Typhoon 1.00-358                  : 2711.7     176.5     375    47.1
 182 Ifrit m1.8 64-bit                 : 2708.8     117.5     265    44.3
 183 Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit               : 2707.1     105.0     215    48.8
 184 RomiChess P3k 32-bit              : 2706.6     180.5     369    48.9
 185 Queen 4.03                        : 2704.2     215.0     437    49.2
 186 Simplex 0.9.8 64-bit              : 2699.1     154.0     330    46.7
 187 Orion 0.3.0 64-bit                : 2698.7     125.5     289    43.4
 188 Gosu 0.16                         : 2696.6     141.5     297    47.6
 189 Alex 2.14a 64-bit                 : 2693.6     175.0     372    47.0
 190 Horizon 4.4                       : 2692.4     188.5     400    47.1
 191 Sorgenkind 0.4                    : 2691.6     323.0     648    49.8
 192 Comet B68                         : 2689.2     132.5     279    47.5
 193 Ares 1.004                        : 2687.2     262.5     501    52.4
 194 Myrddin 0.87 64-bit               : 2687.1     122.0     299    40.8
 195 Amy 0.87b                         : 2686.7     150.0     314    47.8
 196 Amateur 2.82                      : 2685.1     135.5     288    47.0
 197 OliThink 5.3.2 64-bit             : 2681.6     159.5     354    45.1
 198 Sage 3.53                         : 2675.0     203.5     426    47.8
 199 Waxman 2016                       : 2674.5      98.5     223    44.2
 200 Gaia 3.5 32-bit                   : 2672.8     129.5     291    44.5
 201 Flux 2.2.1                        : 2666.1     122.5     246    49.8
 202 Plisk 0.2.7d 32-bit               : 2665.9     141.0     258    54.7
 203 Asterisk 0.6                      : 2657.5     120.5     242    49.8
 204 Aice 0.99.2                       : 2653.1     131.5     295    44.6
 205 Amundsen 0.80                     : 2646.3     158.5     317    50.0
 206 Arion 1.7                         : 2643.2     138.0     302    45.7
 207 Jumbo 0.4.17 64-bit               : 2642.3      95.5     222    43.0
 208 EveAnn 1.72                       : 2640.5      98.5     226    43.6
 209 Butcher 1.61 32-bit               : 2625.7     105.5     202    52.2
 210 Joker 1.1.14                      : 2623.7     116.5     233    50.0
 211 Chaturanga 2.4.3                  : 2617.7     127.0     245    51.8
 212 Natwarlal 0.14                    : 2611.9     101.5     236    43.0
 213 Fischerle 0.9.80 SE 64-bit        : 2606.1      83.5     221    37.8
 214 AliChess 4.25                     : 2603.6     126.5     262    48.3
 215 Popochin 3.2                      : 2598.4     185.0     407    45.5
 216 Sungorus 1.4 32-bit               : 2582.0     168.5     344    49.0
 217 RattateChess 1.0 Nosferatu        : 2579.0     144.0     294    49.0
 218 Feuerstein 0.4.6.1                : 2574.4     207.0     386    53.6
 219 Atak 6.8                          : 2562.1     140.0     303    46.2
 220 Dolphin 1.0                       : 2560.9     151.0     307    49.2
 221 Gibbon 2.52a                      : 2552.7     230.5     440    52.4
 222 Adam 3.3                          : 2551.8     108.0     204    52.9
 223 BlackBishop 1.0                   : 2546.8     194.5     374    52.0
 224 Beowulf 2.4a 32-bit               : 2541.2     178.5     356    50.1
 225 Neurosis 2.5                      : 2539.7     192.5     370    52.0
 226 OBender 3.2.4.2                   : 2531.6     113.5     220    51.6
 227 NagaSkaki 5.12                    : 2528.3     159.5     304    52.5
 228 Uralochka 1.1b                    : 2516.1     125.5     284    44.2
 229 KMTChess 1.2.1 32-bit             : 2516.0     177.0     362    48.9
 230 Kurt 0.9.2 32-bit                 : 2498.3     152.0     274    55.5
 231 Prophet 2.0 32-bit                : 2498.2     144.5     261    55.4
 232 KnockOut 0.7.1                    : 2497.3     318.5     574    55.5
 233 Parrot 07.07.22                   : 2477.1     118.0     227    52.0
 234 BikJump 2.01 32-bit               : 2455.9     236.5     430    55.0
 235 Clarabit 1.00 32-bit              : 2455.6     159.0     328    48.5
 236 FireFly 2.5.6 32-bit              : 2440.7     155.0     327    47.4
 237 PLP 1661571                       : 2438.7     175.5     342    51.3
 238 Jabba 1.0 32-bit                  : 2431.2     181.0     352    51.4
 239 Protej 0.5.7                      : 2426.1     151.5     310    48.9
 240 BigLion 2.23x                     : 2418.3     169.0     352    48.0
 241 Bubble 1.5                        : 2401.7     125.0     282    44.3
 242 Slibo 0.5.1                       : 2397.1     156.0     334    46.7
 243 ChessMind 0.82                    : 2377.6     139.5     290    48.1
 244 BibiChess 0.5                     : 2377.1     116.0     232    50.0
 245 Schola 1.1.0 32-bit               : 2371.6     139.5     297    47.0
 246 Monarch 1.7                       : 2369.4     156.5     339    46.2
 247 Heracles 0.6.16                   : 2364.7     148.0     307    48.2
 248 MatMoi 7.15.0-cct 32-bit          : 2343.5     121.0     279    43.4
 249 Rival 1.18                        : 2338.4     129.0     269    48.0
 250 Micro-Max 4.8 (DM-PII)            : 2325.2     173.5     333    52.1
 251 Reger 0.09                        : 2313.7     120.0     309    38.8
 252 GChess IV 0.2.0                   : 2307.8     107.0     248    43.1
 253 Smash 1.0.3                       : 2304.1     107.0     262    40.8
 254 Clueless 1.4                      : 2299.8     162.5     373    43.6
 255 Warrior 1.0.3                     : 2298.0     151.0     335    45.1
 256 Surprise 4.3b13                   : 2293.6     113.5     265    42.8
 257 Predateur 2.2 64-bit              : 2263.5      85.5     216    39.6

White advantage = 21.21
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 38.24 %

User avatar
Laskos
Posts: 7959
Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 8:21 pm

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by Laskos » Wed Jun 14, 2017 7:11 pm

3/ Computer ratings at 40/40 on 4 core machine:

Code: Select all


   # PLAYER                            : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED     (%)

   1 Komodo 11.01 64-bit 4CPU          : 3664.3     153.5     210    73.1
   2 Stockfish 8 64-bit 4CPU           : 3650.3     454.0     632    71.8
   3 Houdini 5.01 64-bit 4CPU          : 3638.5     341.0     508    67.1
   4 Deep Shredder 13 64-bit 4CPU      : 3527.0     217.0     386    56.2
   5 Fire 5 64-bit 4CPU                : 3505.9     221.0     408    54.2
   6 Fizbo 1.9 64-bit 4CPU             : 3484.9     190.5     372    51.2
   7 Andscacs 0.89 64-bit 4CPU         : 3461.3     174.0     354    49.2
   8 Chiron 4 64-bit 4CPU              : 3423.5     158.0     372    42.5
   9 Gull 3 64-bit 4CPU                : 3398.2     341.0     721    47.3
  10 Equinox 3.20 64-bit 4CPU          : 3394.3     301.0     654    46.0
  11 Fritz 15 64-bit 4CPU              : 3385.5     305.5     692    44.1
  12 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 4CPU          : 3382.6     414.5     837    49.5
  13 Bouquet 1.8 64-bit 4CPU           : 3371.7     219.5     434    50.6
  14 Hannibal 1.7 64-bit 4CPU          : 3370.6     258.5     619    41.8
  15 NirvanaChess 2.3 64-bit 4CPU      : 3361.9     164.5     367    44.8
  16 Rybka 4 64-bit 4CPU               : 3352.8     359.0     629    57.1
  17 Texel 1.06 64-bit 4CPU            : 3348.9     183.5     397    46.2
  18 Protector 1.9.0 64-bit 4CPU       : 3340.7     120.0     249    48.2
  19 BlackMamba 2.0 64-bit 4CPU        : 3335.3     133.5     274    48.7
  20 Naum 4.6 64-bit 4CPU              : 3288.5     174.5     380    45.9
  21 Hiarcs 14 4CPU                    : 3236.2     112.0     272    41.2
  22 Deep Junior 13 64-bit 4CPU        : 3212.1     159.0     306    52.0
  23 Spike 1.4 Leiden 4CPU             : 3203.5     270.0     533    50.7
  24 Senpai 1.0 64-bit 4CPU            : 3203.4     120.5     261    46.2
  25 Spark 1.0 64-bit 4CPU             : 3141.4     165.0     348    47.4
  26 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 4CPU       : 3139.2     316.0     617    51.2
  27 Arasan 20.1 64-bit                : 3100.6     144.0     236    61.0
  28 Onno 1.2.70 64-bit 4CPU           : 3100.1     108.0     227    47.6
  29 Thinker 5.4c Inert 64-bit 4CPU    : 3097.6     178.5     370    48.2
  30 Alfil 15.8 64-bit                 : 3089.8     151.0     255    59.2
  31 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 4CPU     : 3078.9     165.0     355    46.5
  32 Hakkapeliitta 3.0 64-bit          : 3074.9     251.0     443    56.7
  33 Vajolet2 2.2 64-bit               : 3074.9     117.0     209    56.0
  34 Pedone 1.5 64-bit                 : 3061.1     119.0     222    53.6
  35 Laser 1.3 64-bit                  : 3054.7     131.5     238    55.3
  36 Crafty 25.2 64-bit                : 3053.5     140.5     266    52.8
  37 Cheng 4.39 64-bit                 : 3048.1     320.0     596    53.7
  38 SmarThink 1.70 64-bit             : 3045.7     204.5     364    56.2
  39 Toga II 1.4.1SE 4CPU              : 3045.1     162.5     359    45.3
  40 Nemorino 2.00 64-bit              : 3044.5     124.5     238    52.3
  41 Bobcat 8.0 64-bit                 : 3036.3     199.0     366    54.4
  42 Wasp 2.01 64-bit                  : 3027.0     149.0     268    55.6
  43 Booot 5.2.0 64-bit                : 3026.7     215.0     389    55.3
  44 Quazar 0.4 64-bit                 : 3024.6     366.5     666    55.0
  45 Bright 0.4a 4CPU                  : 3024.6     177.0     375    47.2
  46 Rodent II 0.9.64 64-bit           : 3022.6     120.5     240    50.2
  47 EXchess 7.97b 64-bit              : 3006.0     220.0     404    54.5
  48 DiscoCheck 5.2.1 64-bit           : 3002.1     260.5     521    50.0
  49 Deuterium 14.3.34.130 64-bit      : 2999.0     351.5     721    48.8
  50 iCE 2.0 64-bit                    : 2995.3     206.5     406    50.9
  51 ChessBrainVB 3.20                 : 2990.2     140.5     267    52.6
  52 Dirty 30Apr2017 64-bit            : 2972.5     112.0     232    48.3
  53 Gaviota 1.0 64-bit                : 2960.9     268.5     572    46.9
  54 Loop M1-T 64-bit 4CPU             : 2958.2     123.0     343    35.9
  55 MinkoChess 1.3 64-bit             : 2956.9     166.0     343    48.4
  56 Nemo 1.0.1 64-bit                 : 2954.2     291.5     611    47.7
  57 Atlas 3.80 64-bit                 : 2950.2     288.5     598    48.2
  58 DisasterArea 1.65 64-bit          : 2948.3     187.5     395    47.5
  59 Tornado 8.0 64-bit                : 2947.2     205.5     400    51.4
  60 GnuCheese 1.00 64-bit             : 2920.5     230.0     410    56.1
  61 Scorpio 2.7.7 64-bit              : 2913.7     223.0     437    51.0
  62 Murka 3 64-bit                    : 2910.9     177.5     414    42.9
  63 Amoeba 2.4 64-bit                 : 2901.8     145.0     304    47.7
  64 Pawny 1.2 64-bit                  : 2894.9     225.5     446    50.6
  65 The Baron 3.29 64-bit             : 2891.1     152.5     304    50.2
  66 Rhetoric 1.4.3 64-bit             : 2888.5     237.5     495    48.0
  67 Zurichess Luzern 64-bit           : 2881.9     113.0     266    42.5
  68 Naraku 1.4                        : 2874.2     174.5     344    50.7
  69 Ktulu 9                           : 2874.1     173.0     279    62.0
  70 Frenzee 3.5.19 64-bit             : 2863.7     267.0     558    47.8
  71 BugChess2 1.9 64-bit              : 2858.1     305.0     603    50.6
  72 Twisted Logic 20100131x 64-bit    : 2857.9     161.0     297    54.2
  73 Octochess r5190 64-bit            : 2856.4     143.0     304    47.0
  74 Bison 9.11 64-bit                 : 2846.5     204.0     403    50.6
  75 ProDeo 2.2                        : 2825.7     145.5     274    53.1
  76 Carballo 1.7 64-bit               : 2814.6     134.5     243    55.3
  77 Chronos 1.9.9 64-bit              : 2809.4     206.0     424    48.6
  78 Tucano 6.00 64-bit                : 2808.9     216.0     437    49.4
  79 Godel 3.4.9 64-bit                : 2808.0     275.5     544    50.6
  80 Chess Tiger 2007.1                : 2788.7     327.5     586    55.9
  81 Delfi 5.4                         : 2771.5     245.0     439    55.8
  82 Cheese 1.8 64-bit                 : 2766.4     197.0     375    52.5
  83 Arminius 2017-01-01 64-bit        : 2760.6     185.5     334    55.5
  84 Chessmaster 11 Aiglos II          : 2750.0     106.5     234    45.5
  85 Daydreamer 1.75 64-bit            : 2749.0     160.5     332    48.3
  86 Djinn 1.021 64-bit                : 2741.2     227.0     455    49.9
  87 Philou 3.7.1 64-bit               : 2734.4     248.5     472    52.6
  88 RedQueen 1.1.97 64-bit            : 2729.6     157.0     323    48.6
  89 Alaric 707                        : 2727.4     316.5     617    51.3
  90 Movei 00.8.438 (10 10 10)         : 2720.6     300.5     629    47.8
  91 Floyd 0.9 64-bit                  : 2719.2     202.5     404    50.1
  92 WyldChess 1.4 64-bit              : 2715.9     170.0     302    56.3
  93 Gandalf 6                         : 2714.2     307.0     561    54.7
  94 Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1            : 2713.0     359.5     664    54.1
  95 WildCat 7                         : 2713.0     184.5     343    53.8
  96 NoraGrace 2.0 64-bit              : 2711.0     230.5     439    52.5
  97 E.T. Chess 13.01.08               : 2710.9     277.0     544    50.9
  98 Rodin 8.0                         : 2705.9     193.0     377    51.2
  99 Sjakk 2.2 64-bit                  : 2703.0     237.0     458    51.7
 100 Sloppy 0.2.2 64-bit               : 2702.3     182.0     343    53.1
 101 Ruffian 2.1.0                     : 2700.0     293.5     558    52.6
 102 Pharaon 3.5.1                     : 2693.5     304.0     567    53.6
 103 GreKo 2015-ML 64-bit              : 2692.4     126.5     254    49.8
 104 Nebula 2.0 64-bit                 : 2691.9     177.5     351    50.6
 105 Cyrano 0.6b17 32-bit              : 2691.9     227.0     466    48.7
 106 Colossus 2008b                    : 2686.7     277.5     574    48.3
 107 Rotor 0.8                         : 2685.7     155.0     317    48.9
 108 Hamsters 0.7.1                    : 2685.3     271.5     538    50.5
 109 Phalanx XXV                       : 2684.8     229.0     443    51.7
 110 Ethereal 8.12 64-bit              : 2683.8     169.5     318    53.3
 111 Donna 4.0 64-bit                  : 2681.1     212.5     422    50.4
 112 Aristarch 4.50                    : 2675.5     350.5     657    53.3
 113 DanaSah 6.50                      : 2673.3     166.0     334    49.7
 114 N2 0.4 64-bit                     : 2664.2     279.5     530    52.7
 115 Muse 0.953 64-bit                 : 2663.9     182.5     352    51.8
 116 Amyan 1.72                        : 2658.8     225.5     421    53.6
 117 Pseudo 0.7c                       : 2658.0     328.5     651    50.5
 118 Glass 2.0 64-bit                  : 2658.0     178.5     379    47.1
 119 GarboChess 3.0 64-bit             : 2648.7     194.5     394    49.4
 120 Jellyfish 1.1 64-bit              : 2647.2     248.0     507    48.9
 121 Jonny 2.83 32-bit                 : 2641.8     187.5     398    47.1
 122 Brutus 8.05 64-bit                : 2640.9     115.0     232    49.6
 123 Capivara LK 0.09b02f 64-bit       : 2635.1     181.5     371    48.9
 124 K2 0.87                           : 2633.3     149.5     329    45.4
 125 Gogobello 1.1 64-bit              : 2630.6     137.0     247    55.5
 126 Coiled 0.4 64-bit                 : 2629.8     191.5     374    51.2
 127 GNU Chess 5.07.153b 64-bit        : 2629.0     156.0     273    57.1
 128 SOS 5.1                           : 2626.6     221.5     453    48.9
 129 JikChess 0.02 64-bit              : 2621.9     262.5     520    50.5
 130 Petir 4.999999                    : 2621.4     193.0     421    45.8
 131 Ghost 3 64-bit                    : 2618.7     155.0     300    51.7
 132 Francesca MAD 0.19                : 2613.4     150.5     306    49.2
 133 nanoSzachy 4.1 64-bit             : 2606.8     264.5     524    50.5
 134 Marvin 2.0.0 64-bit               : 2602.6     182.5     285    64.0
 135 chess22k 1.3 64-bit               : 2584.1     164.5     276    59.6
 136 Fridolin 2.0 64-bit               : 2582.7     256.5     545    47.1
 137 Maverick 1.5 64-bit               : 2577.2     270.0     553    48.8
 138 Ufim 8.02                         : 2575.5     198.5     425    46.7
 139 AnMon 5.60                        : 2575.4     183.5     393    46.7
 140 ECE X2                            : 2572.6     171.5     330    52.0
 141 Dorky 4.5 64-bit                  : 2570.1     226.5     452    50.1
 142 Shield 1.3.1 64-bit               : 2569.3     178.5     344    51.9
 143 CyberPagno 3.0 64-bit             : 2569.2     170.0     334    50.9
 144 Tao 5.6                           : 2567.1     193.5     416    46.5
 145 LittleThought 1.052 64-bit        : 2566.1     178.5     336    53.1
 146 Delphil 3.2 64-bit                : 2563.7     195.0     407    47.9
 147 Little Goliath Evolution 3.12     : 2561.3     200.5     441    45.5
 148 Schooner 1.7.0 64-bit             : 2550.1     175.5     316    55.5
 149 Pupsi2 0.09                       : 2548.8     116.0     246    47.2
 150 Xpdnt 091007                      : 2547.7     151.0     295    51.2
 151 Pepito 1.59 32-bit                : 2541.7     129.0     259    49.8
 152 Giraffe 20150908 64-bit           : 2538.1     112.5     222    50.7
 153 Yace 0.99.87                      : 2537.3     120.5     246    49.0
 154 Hermann 2.5 32-bit                : 2535.3     155.5     333    46.7
 155 pikoSzachy 4.1                    : 2535.1     140.0     262    53.4
 156 Eeyore 1.52 64-bit                : 2531.2     201.5     366    55.1
 157 Matacz 1.4                        : 2529.5     214.5     399    53.8
 158 Cerebro 3.03d                     : 2528.1     153.5     306    50.2
 159 MadChess 2.1 64-bit               : 2525.1     174.5     330    52.9
 160 Anatoli 0.35k                     : 2524.3     217.5     441    49.3
 161 Betsabe II 1.66                   : 2515.5     184.0     390    47.2
 162 Bagatur 1.4d 64-bit               : 2515.2     204.5     422    48.5
 163 Quark 2.35                        : 2514.6     162.5     342    47.5
 164 Trace 1.37a                       : 2505.7     153.0     318    48.1
 165 Counter 1.2                       : 2502.9     157.5     316    49.8
 166 Nemeton 1.5                       : 2502.6     166.0     354    46.9
 167 Bumblebee 1.0.36898e1 64-bit      : 2501.6     200.5     449    44.7
 168 Lozza 1.17 64-bit                 : 2493.9     239.0     516    46.3
 169 PostModernist 1016                : 2491.8     165.0     317    52.1
 170 Patzer 3.80                       : 2486.9     129.5     252    51.4
 171 Bruja 1.9.1 32-bit                : 2485.8     129.5     263    49.2
 172 TJchess 1.3 64-bit                : 2484.7     182.5     405    45.1
 173 Abrok 5.0                         : 2484.2      95.5     200    47.8
 174 Hussar 0.4                        : 2481.4     140.0     275    50.9
 175 Cmcchess 2.6 64-bit               : 2481.3     155.0     340    45.6
 176 Shallow r694 64-bit               : 2479.0     141.0     308    45.8
 177 Homer 2.01                        : 2477.8     191.0     369    51.8
 178 Diablo 0.5.1                      : 2474.4     193.0     389    49.6
 179 Kiwi 0.6d 32-bit                  : 2472.8     126.0     255    49.4
 180 Dragon 4.6                        : 2466.0     149.5     298    50.2
 181 Typhoon 1.00-358                  : 2462.3     176.5     375    47.1
 182 Ifrit m1.8 64-bit                 : 2458.6     117.5     265    44.3
 183 Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit               : 2456.4     105.0     215    48.8
 184 RomiChess P3k 32-bit              : 2455.9     180.5     369    48.9
 185 Queen 4.03                        : 2452.8     215.0     437    49.2
 186 Simplex 0.9.8 64-bit              : 2446.3     154.0     330    46.7
 187 Orion 0.3.0 64-bit                : 2445.9     125.5     289    43.4
 188 Gosu 0.16                         : 2443.2     141.5     297    47.6
 189 Alex 2.14a 64-bit                 : 2439.4     175.0     372    47.0
 190 Horizon 4.4                       : 2437.9     188.5     400    47.1
 191 Sorgenkind 0.4                    : 2436.9     323.0     648    49.8
 192 Comet B68                         : 2433.8     132.5     279    47.5
 193 Ares 1.004                        : 2431.3     262.5     501    52.4
 194 Myrddin 0.87 64-bit               : 2431.3     122.0     299    40.8
 195 Amy 0.87b                         : 2430.8     150.0     314    47.8
 196 Amateur 2.82                      : 2428.7     135.5     288    47.0
 197 OliThink 5.3.2 64-bit             : 2424.3     159.5     354    45.1
 198 Sage 3.53                         : 2416.0     203.5     426    47.8
 199 Waxman 2016                       : 2415.4      98.5     223    44.2
 200 Gaia 3.5 32-bit                   : 2413.2     129.5     291    44.5
 201 Flux 2.2.1                        : 2404.7     122.5     246    49.8
 202 Plisk 0.2.7d 32-bit               : 2404.5     141.0     258    54.7
 203 Asterisk 0.6                      : 2393.9     120.5     242    49.8
 204 Aice 0.99.2                       : 2388.3     131.5     295    44.6
 205 Amundsen 0.80                     : 2379.8     158.5     317    50.0
 206 Arion 1.7                         : 2375.8     138.0     302    45.7
 207 Jumbo 0.4.17 64-bit               : 2374.7      95.5     222    43.0
 208 EveAnn 1.72                       : 2372.4      98.5     226    43.6
 209 Butcher 1.61 32-bit               : 2353.7     105.5     202    52.2
 210 Joker 1.1.14                      : 2351.2     116.5     233    50.0
 211 Chaturanga 2.4.3                  : 2343.6     127.0     245    51.8
 212 Natwarlal 0.14                    : 2336.3     101.5     236    43.0
 213 Fischerle 0.9.80 SE 64-bit        : 2328.9      83.5     221    37.8
 214 AliChess 4.25                     : 2325.7     126.5     262    48.3
 215 Popochin 3.2                      : 2319.2     185.0     407    45.5
 216 Sungorus 1.4 32-bit               : 2298.5     168.5     344    49.0
 217 RattateChess 1.0 Nosferatu        : 2294.7     144.0     294    49.0
 218 Feuerstein 0.4.6.1                : 2288.9     207.0     386    53.6
 219 Atak 6.8                          : 2273.4     140.0     303    46.2
 220 Dolphin 1.0                       : 2271.9     151.0     307    49.2
 221 Gibbon 2.52a                      : 2261.5     230.5     440    52.4
 222 Adam 3.3                          : 2260.5     108.0     204    52.9
 223 BlackBishop 1.0                   : 2254.0     194.5     374    52.0
 224 Beowulf 2.4a 32-bit               : 2247.1     178.5     356    50.1
 225 Neurosis 2.5                      : 2245.1     192.5     370    52.0
 226 OBender 3.2.4.2                   : 2234.9     113.5     220    51.6
 227 NagaSkaki 5.12                    : 2230.8     159.5     304    52.5
 228 Uralochka 1.1b                    : 2215.3     125.5     284    44.2
 229 KMTChess 1.2.1 32-bit             : 2215.2     177.0     362    48.9
 230 Kurt 0.9.2 32-bit                 : 2192.9     152.0     274    55.5
 231 Prophet 2.0 32-bit                : 2192.8     144.5     261    55.4
 232 KnockOut 0.7.1                    : 2191.6     318.5     574    55.5
 233 Parrot 07.07.22                   : 2166.1     118.0     227    52.0
 234 BikJump 2.01 32-bit               : 2139.4     236.5     430    55.0
 235 Clarabit 1.00 32-bit              : 2138.9     159.0     328    48.5
 236 FireFly 2.5.6 32-bit              : 2120.1     155.0     327    47.4
 237 PLP 1661571                       : 2117.6     175.5     342    51.3
 238 Jabba 1.0 32-bit                  : 2108.1     181.0     352    51.4
 239 Protej 0.5.7                      : 2101.7     151.5     310    48.9
 240 BigLion 2.23x                     : 2091.8     169.0     352    48.0
 241 Bubble 1.5                        : 2070.9     125.0     282    44.3
 242 Slibo 0.5.1                       : 2065.1     156.0     334    46.7
 243 ChessMind 0.82                    : 2040.5     139.5     290    48.1
 244 BibiChess 0.5                     : 2039.8     116.0     232    50.0
 245 Schola 1.1.0 32-bit               : 2032.9     139.5     297    47.0
 246 Monarch 1.7                       : 2030.1     156.5     339    46.2
 247 Heracles 0.6.16                   : 2024.2     148.0     307    48.2
 248 MatMoi 7.15.0-cct 32-bit          : 1997.5     121.0     279    43.4
 249 Rival 1.18                        : 1991.0     129.0     269    48.0
 250 Micro-Max 4.8 (DM-PII)            : 1974.4     173.5     333    52.1
 251 Reger 0.09                        : 1959.8     120.0     309    38.8
 252 GChess IV 0.2.0                   : 1952.4     107.0     248    43.1
 253 Smash 1.0.3                       : 1947.7     107.0     262    40.8
 254 Clueless 1.4                      : 1942.3     162.5     373    43.6
 255 Warrior 1.0.3                     : 1939.9     151.0     335    45.1
 256 Surprise 4.3b13                   : 1934.5     113.5     265    42.8
 257 Predateur 2.2 64-bit              : 1896.4      85.5     216    39.6

White advantage = 26.78
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 38.24 %

mjlef
Posts: 1306
Joined: Thu Mar 30, 2006 12:08 pm
Contact:

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by mjlef » Wed Jun 14, 2017 8:44 pm

Interesting.

What programs do you have with results against humans? It must have been a long time ago. Were there enough games to get a reasonable rating? If the data is online, I would love to take a look.

Mark

Gusev
Posts: 1475
Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2013 1:51 pm

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by Gusev » Wed Jun 14, 2017 8:49 pm

Would it be reasonable to set the rating of Deep Rybka 3 on a dual-core laptop from 2008 to be approximately equal to that of Nakamura back then (~2700)?

Werewolf
Posts: 906
Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 8:24 pm

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by Werewolf » Wed Jun 14, 2017 9:44 pm

Gusev wrote:Would it be reasonable to set the rating of Deep Rybka 3 on a dual-core laptop from 2008 to be approximately equal to that of Nakamura back then (~2700)?
No. Rybka 3 would be way above Nakamura on a dual core laptop. Deep Fritz 10 (which was actually a buggy version) was at least as good as Kramnik, and Rybka 3 is quite a lot stronger.

User avatar
lucasart
Posts: 2957
Joined: Mon May 31, 2010 11:29 am
Contact:

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by lucasart » Thu Jun 15, 2017 2:10 am

How did you get these numbers? There are no reliable data points between human FIDE ratings and computer ratings. Even the top engines from 15 years ago were well above the best human GM, so you numbers are completely overestimating the human ability…

If human GMs were to compete in CCR 40/40 standard, I doubt even Carlsen would even get 2600 elo.

Of course, in blitz, and especially in Chess960, humans would get totally destroyed by even the average amateur engine nowadays. Even something like Maverick would beat Carlsen, and crush him in Chess960.
Theory and practice sometimes clash. And when that happens, theory loses. Every single time.

User avatar
Laskos
Posts: 7959
Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 8:21 pm

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by Laskos » Thu Jun 15, 2017 5:09 am

lucasart wrote:How did you get these numbers? There are no reliable data points between human FIDE ratings and computer ratings. Even the top engines from 15 years ago were well above the best human GM, so you numbers are completely overestimating the human ability…
No, Junior 8, Shredder 8, Fritz 8 on strong hardware, equivalent to our 4 core machine of today, were on a par with Kasparov and Kramnik in 2003 (14 years ago) in "FIDE Man vs Machine Contest".

http://en.chessbase.com/post/kasparov-v ... n-3-3-draw
in 2003:
Kasparov-Junior 8: 3-3
Kramnik-Fritz 8+: 3-3

I used anchors and rating compression.

User avatar
Laskos
Posts: 7959
Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 8:21 pm

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by Laskos » Thu Jun 15, 2017 5:14 am

Gusev wrote:Would it be reasonable to set the rating of Deep Rybka 3 on a dual-core laptop from 2008 to be approximately equal to that of Nakamura back then (~2700)?
In these conditions Deep Rybka 3 is probably way above 2900 FIDE Tournament TC.

User avatar
Laskos
Posts: 7959
Joined: Wed Jul 26, 2006 8:21 pm

Re: Adjusted ratings from CCRL 40/40

Post by Laskos » Thu Jun 15, 2017 5:40 am

mjlef wrote:Interesting.

What programs do you have with results against humans? It must have been a long time ago. Were there enough games to get a reasonable rating? If the data is online, I would love to take a look.

Mark
It is a bit complicated. First for anchors I took not the "Pure List", in which most anchors are absent, but the full CCRL, CEGT and SSDF lists. Then, I have pretty good memory of numbers and results. I remembered the results of Rebel, Chess Tiger, early Juniors, etc., participating in various human chess tournaments (for example I remember one in Israel). Also, for lower ratings, 1990s human tournaments in which often programs were allowed. For "Pure List", in which only the best versions appear, I extrapolated these results from broader engine rating lists, considering the scaling with time and hardware.

For blitz, I remembered the ratings of some programs and the results on Playchess Engine Room and ICC (say 3+1 and 5+1). Hiarcs, for example, at blitz was way above 3100 on Playchess in blitz in 2006 IIRC, and the rating was even deflated.

Post Reply