1080 games
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_717569
12/18/2013 5:43:12 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 39 31 30 216 56.2 % -4 56.9 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 15 30 30 216 52.3 % -2 58.3 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 12 29 29 216 51.9 % -1 62.0 %
4 Komodo6-64bit : 10 30 30 216 51.6 % -1 57.9 %
5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 9 29 29 216 51.4 % -1 61.1 %
6 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 7 30 29 216 51.2 % -1 59.7 %
7 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 4 30 30 216 50.7 % -0 57.9 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 0 32 32 216 50.0 % 0 53.7 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -32 29 29 216 44.9 % 4 60.2 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -65 31 31 216 39.8 % 7 54.6 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 39 216 (+ 60,=123,- 33), 56.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 9,= 13,- 2), 64.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 5,= 18,- 1), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 2,= 18,- 4), 45.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 9,= 8,- 7), 54.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 6,= 9,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 5,= 18,- 1), 58.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 10,= 12,- 2), 66.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 7,= 14,- 3), 58.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 7,= 13,- 4), 56.2 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 15 216 (+ 50,=126,- 40), 52.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 8,= 14,- 2), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 3,= 14,- 7), 41.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 8,= 13,- 3), 60.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 6,= 18,- 0), 62.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 2,= 19,- 3), 47.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 2,= 18,- 4), 45.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 8,= 10,- 6), 54.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 6,= 11,- 7), 47.9 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 7,= 9,- 8), 47.9 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 12 216 (+ 45,=134,- 37), 51.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 4,= 19,- 1), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 1,= 18,- 5), 41.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 7,= 17,- 0), 64.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 5,= 15,- 4), 52.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 4,= 15,- 5), 47.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 5,= 16,- 3), 54.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 8,= 13,- 3), 60.4 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 6,= 10,- 8), 45.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 5,= 11,- 8), 43.8 %
4 Komodo6-64bit : 10 216 (+ 49,=125,- 42), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 5,= 17,- 2), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 4,= 13,- 7), 43.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 10,= 12,- 2), 66.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 3,= 15,- 6), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 7,= 13,- 4), 56.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 3,= 18,- 3), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 8,= 11,- 5), 56.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 1,= 17,- 6), 39.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 8,= 9,- 7), 52.1 %
5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 9 216 (+ 45,=132,- 39), 51.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 6,= 15,- 3), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 9,= 9,- 6), 56.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 7,= 13,- 4), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 6,= 11,- 7), 47.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 4,= 19,- 1), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 3,= 16,- 5), 45.8 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 3,= 13,- 8), 39.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 4,= 18,- 2), 54.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 3,= 18,- 3), 50.0 %
6 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 7 216 (+ 46,=129,- 41), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 7,= 14,- 3), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 7,= 8,- 9), 45.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 8,= 13,- 3), 60.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 5,= 15,- 4), 52.1 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 1,= 19,- 4), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 5,= 15,- 4), 52.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 6,= 13,- 5), 52.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 3,= 19,- 2), 52.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 4,= 13,- 7), 43.8 %
7 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 4 216 (+ 47,=125,- 44), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 10,= 10,- 4), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 4,= 18,- 2), 54.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 8,= 11,- 5), 56.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 4,= 15,- 5), 47.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 7,= 11,- 6), 52.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 4,= 15,- 5), 47.9 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 4,= 12,- 8), 41.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 0,= 18,- 6), 37.5 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 6,= 15,- 3), 56.2 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 0 216 (+ 50,=116,- 50), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 4,= 16,- 4), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 2,= 12,- 10), 33.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 7,= 9,- 8), 47.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 8,= 12,- 4), 58.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 5,= 13,- 6), 47.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 8,= 13,- 3), 60.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 3,= 13,- 8), 39.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 7,= 11,- 6), 52.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 6,= 17,- 1), 60.4 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -32 216 (+ 32,=130,- 54), 44.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 2,= 13,- 9), 35.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 24 (+ 11,= 12,- 1), 70.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 4,= 10,- 10), 37.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 3,= 14,- 7), 41.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 3,= 15,- 6), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 1,= 19,- 4), 43.8 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 4,= 16,- 4), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 2,= 14,- 8), 37.5 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 2,= 17,- 5), 43.8 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -65 216 (+ 27,=118,- 71), 39.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 24 (+ 1,= 12,- 11), 29.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 24 (+ 1,= 18,- 5), 41.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 24 (+ 5,= 11,- 8), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 24 (+ 3,= 13,- 8), 39.6 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 24 (+ 4,= 13,- 7), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 24 (+ 0,= 17,- 7), 35.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 24 (+ 8,= 9,- 7), 52.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 24 (+ 3,= 13,- 8), 39.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 24 (+ 2,= 12,- 10), 33.3 %
Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
Moderator: Ras
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
1260 games
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_723569
12/21/2013 7:40:08 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 39 28 28 252 56.2 % -4 56.7 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 15 27 27 252 52.4 % -2 59.5 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 14 26 26 252 52.2 % -1 63.1 %
4 Komodo6-64bit : 7 28 28 252 51.2 % -1 57.1 %
5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 7 27 26 252 51.2 % -1 61.9 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 6 28 28 252 51.0 % -1 58.3 %
7 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : -1 28 28 252 49.8 % 0 58.3 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -4 29 29 252 49.4 % 0 55.2 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -27 27 27 252 45.6 % 3 61.1 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -56 28 29 252 41.1 % 6 56.0 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 39 252 (+ 70,=143,- 39), 56.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 9,= 17,- 2), 62.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 5,= 22,- 1), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 3,= 19,- 6), 44.6 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 11,= 9,- 8), 55.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 7,= 12,- 9), 46.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 6,= 20,- 2), 57.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 13,= 13,- 2), 69.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 16,- 4), 57.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 8,= 15,- 5), 55.4 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 15 252 (+ 57,=150,- 45), 52.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 16,- 4), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 4,= 16,- 8), 42.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 10,= 14,- 4), 60.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 6,= 21,- 1), 58.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 4,= 21,- 3), 51.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 3,= 21,- 4), 48.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 14,- 6), 53.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 7,= 14,- 7), 50.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 7,= 13,- 8), 48.2 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 14 252 (+ 52,=159,- 41), 52.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 23,- 1), 55.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 2,= 20,- 6), 42.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 7,= 21,- 0), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 7,= 17,- 4), 55.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 5,= 16,- 7), 46.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 6,= 19,- 3), 55.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 9,= 16,- 3), 60.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 6,= 14,- 8), 46.4 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 6,= 13,- 9), 44.6 %
4 Komodo6-64bit : 7 252 (+ 57,=144,- 51), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 7,= 18,- 3), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 5,= 15,- 8), 44.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 11,= 14,- 3), 64.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 4,= 17,- 7), 44.6 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 8,= 15,- 5), 55.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 4,= 20,- 4), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 9,= 13,- 6), 55.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 1,= 19,- 8), 37.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 13,- 7), 51.8 %
5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 7 252 (+ 51,=156,- 45), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 16,- 4), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 9,= 12,- 7), 53.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 7,= 17,- 4), 55.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 8,= 12,- 8), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 5,= 22,- 1), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 3,= 19,- 6), 44.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 3,= 17,- 8), 41.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 21,- 3), 51.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 4,= 20,- 4), 50.0 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 6 252 (+ 55,=147,- 50), 51.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 11,= 13,- 4), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 6,= 19,- 3), 55.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 9,= 14,- 5), 57.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 4,= 19,- 5), 48.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 8,= 12,- 8), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 17,- 7), 44.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 5,= 15,- 8), 44.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 1,= 21,- 6), 41.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 7,= 17,- 4), 55.4 %
7 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: -1 252 (+ 52,=147,- 53), 49.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 7,= 16,- 5), 53.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 8,= 9,- 11), 44.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 9,= 14,- 5), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 5,= 19,- 4), 51.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 1,= 22,- 5), 42.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 7,= 16,- 5), 53.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 7,= 15,- 6), 51.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 3,= 21,- 4), 48.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 5,= 15,- 8), 44.6 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -4 252 (+ 55,=139,- 58), 49.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 20,- 4), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 2,= 13,- 13), 30.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 9,= 10,- 9), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 8,= 15,- 5), 55.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 6,= 15,- 7), 48.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 8,= 17,- 3), 58.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 3,= 16,- 9), 39.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 7,= 14,- 7), 50.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 8,= 19,- 1), 62.5 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -27 252 (+ 38,=154,- 60), 45.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 2,= 17,- 9), 37.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 11,= 15,- 2), 66.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 4,= 13,- 11), 37.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 5,= 16,- 7), 46.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 4,= 16,- 8), 42.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 1,= 23,- 4), 44.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 4,= 20,- 4), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 16,- 8), 42.9 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 3,= 18,- 7), 42.9 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -56 252 (+ 33,=141,- 78), 41.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 2,= 15,- 11), 33.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 1,= 22,- 5), 42.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 5,= 14,- 9), 42.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 5,= 14,- 9), 42.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 4,= 17,- 7), 44.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 0,= 21,- 7), 37.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 9,= 10,- 9), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 14,- 10), 39.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 3,= 14,- 11), 35.7 %
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_723569
12/21/2013 7:40:08 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 39 28 28 252 56.2 % -4 56.7 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 15 27 27 252 52.4 % -2 59.5 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 14 26 26 252 52.2 % -1 63.1 %
4 Komodo6-64bit : 7 28 28 252 51.2 % -1 57.1 %
5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 7 27 26 252 51.2 % -1 61.9 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 6 28 28 252 51.0 % -1 58.3 %
7 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : -1 28 28 252 49.8 % 0 58.3 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -4 29 29 252 49.4 % 0 55.2 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -27 27 27 252 45.6 % 3 61.1 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -56 28 29 252 41.1 % 6 56.0 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 39 252 (+ 70,=143,- 39), 56.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 9,= 17,- 2), 62.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 5,= 22,- 1), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 3,= 19,- 6), 44.6 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 11,= 9,- 8), 55.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 7,= 12,- 9), 46.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 6,= 20,- 2), 57.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 13,= 13,- 2), 69.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 16,- 4), 57.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 8,= 15,- 5), 55.4 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 15 252 (+ 57,=150,- 45), 52.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 16,- 4), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 4,= 16,- 8), 42.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 10,= 14,- 4), 60.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 6,= 21,- 1), 58.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 4,= 21,- 3), 51.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 3,= 21,- 4), 48.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 14,- 6), 53.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 7,= 14,- 7), 50.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 7,= 13,- 8), 48.2 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 14 252 (+ 52,=159,- 41), 52.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 23,- 1), 55.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 2,= 20,- 6), 42.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 7,= 21,- 0), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 7,= 17,- 4), 55.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 5,= 16,- 7), 46.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 6,= 19,- 3), 55.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 9,= 16,- 3), 60.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 6,= 14,- 8), 46.4 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 6,= 13,- 9), 44.6 %
4 Komodo6-64bit : 7 252 (+ 57,=144,- 51), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 7,= 18,- 3), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 5,= 15,- 8), 44.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 11,= 14,- 3), 64.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 4,= 17,- 7), 44.6 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 8,= 15,- 5), 55.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 4,= 20,- 4), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 9,= 13,- 6), 55.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 1,= 19,- 8), 37.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 13,- 7), 51.8 %
5 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 7 252 (+ 51,=156,- 45), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 8,= 16,- 4), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 9,= 12,- 7), 53.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 7,= 17,- 4), 55.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 8,= 12,- 8), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 5,= 22,- 1), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 3,= 19,- 6), 44.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 3,= 17,- 8), 41.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 21,- 3), 51.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 4,= 20,- 4), 50.0 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 6 252 (+ 55,=147,- 50), 51.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 11,= 13,- 4), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 6,= 19,- 3), 55.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 9,= 14,- 5), 57.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 4,= 19,- 5), 48.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 8,= 12,- 8), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 17,- 7), 44.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 5,= 15,- 8), 44.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 1,= 21,- 6), 41.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 7,= 17,- 4), 55.4 %
7 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: -1 252 (+ 52,=147,- 53), 49.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 7,= 16,- 5), 53.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 8,= 9,- 11), 44.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 9,= 14,- 5), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 5,= 19,- 4), 51.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 1,= 22,- 5), 42.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 7,= 16,- 5), 53.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 7,= 15,- 6), 51.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 3,= 21,- 4), 48.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 5,= 15,- 8), 44.6 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -4 252 (+ 55,=139,- 58), 49.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 20,- 4), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 2,= 13,- 13), 30.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 9,= 10,- 9), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 8,= 15,- 5), 55.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 6,= 15,- 7), 48.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 8,= 17,- 3), 58.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 3,= 16,- 9), 39.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 7,= 14,- 7), 50.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 8,= 19,- 1), 62.5 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -27 252 (+ 38,=154,- 60), 45.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 2,= 17,- 9), 37.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 28 (+ 11,= 15,- 2), 66.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 4,= 13,- 11), 37.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 5,= 16,- 7), 46.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 4,= 16,- 8), 42.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 1,= 23,- 4), 44.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 4,= 20,- 4), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 16,- 8), 42.9 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 3,= 18,- 7), 42.9 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -56 252 (+ 33,=141,- 78), 41.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 28 (+ 2,= 15,- 11), 33.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 (+ 1,= 22,- 5), 42.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 28 (+ 5,= 14,- 9), 42.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 28 (+ 5,= 14,- 9), 42.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 28 (+ 4,= 17,- 7), 44.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 28 (+ 0,= 21,- 7), 37.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 28 (+ 9,= 10,- 9), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 28 (+ 4,= 14,- 10), 39.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 28 (+ 3,= 14,- 11), 35.7 %
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
1440 games
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_746527
12/24/2013 1:17:40 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 39 26 26 288 56.2 % -4 58.3 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 17 26 26 288 52.8 % -2 59.0 %
3 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 15 25 25 288 52.4 % -2 61.1 %
4 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 9 24 24 288 51.4 % -1 63.9 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 7 26 26 288 51.0 % -1 58.3 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 4 26 26 288 50.7 % -0 59.0 %
7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 1 27 27 288 50.2 % -0 53.8 %
8 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 0 26 26 288 50.0 % 0 59.0 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -33 25 25 288 44.8 % 4 60.4 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -60 27 27 288 40.5 % 7 55.2 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 39 288 (+ 78,=168,- 42), 56.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 11,= 19,- 2), 64.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 6,= 25,- 1), 57.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 11,= 13,- 8), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 8,= 15,- 9), 48.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 6,= 23,- 3), 54.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 13,= 16,- 3), 65.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 17 288 (+ 67,=170,- 51), 52.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 11,= 17,- 4), 60.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 11,= 16,- 5), 59.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 7,= 24,- 1), 59.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 4,= 24,- 4), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 3,= 24,- 5), 46.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 17,- 6), 54.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 10,= 14,- 8), 53.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 7,= 16,- 9), 46.9 %
3 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 15 288 (+ 63,=176,- 49), 52.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 20,- 4), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 9,= 15,- 8), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 11,= 12,- 9), 53.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 25,- 1), 57.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 24,- 3), 53.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 5,= 23,- 4), 51.6 %
4 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 9 288 (+ 56,=184,- 48), 51.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 27,- 1), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 3,= 23,- 6), 45.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 8,= 24,- 0), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 7,= 21,- 4), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 18,- 8), 46.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 10,= 17,- 5), 57.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 6,= 17,- 9), 45.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 16,- 10), 43.8 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 7 288 (+ 63,=168,- 57), 51.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 20,- 4), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 13,= 16,- 3), 65.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 4,= 19,- 9), 42.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 9,= 17,- 6), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 4,= 23,- 5), 48.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 10,= 16,- 6), 56.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 1,= 23,- 8), 39.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 16,- 7), 53.1 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 4 288 (+ 61,=170,- 57), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 12,= 16,- 4), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 9,= 12,- 11), 46.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 21,- 7), 45.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 18,- 8), 46.9 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 1,= 24,- 7), 40.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 19,- 4), 57.8 %
7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 1 288 (+ 67,=155,- 66), 50.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 7,= 21,- 4), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 3,= 16,- 13), 34.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 12,= 11,- 9), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 8,= 18,- 6), 53.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 7,= 17,- 8), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 17,- 10), 42.2 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 14,- 10), 46.9 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 8,= 23,- 1), 60.9 %
8 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 0 288 (+ 59,=170,- 59), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 19,- 5), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 8,= 13,- 11), 45.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 10,= 16,- 6), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 1,= 25,- 6), 42.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 18,- 6), 53.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 8,= 17,- 7), 51.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 24,- 4), 50.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 17,- 9), 45.3 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -33 288 (+ 42,=174,- 72), 44.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 2,= 19,- 11), 35.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 14,= 15,- 3), 67.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 4,= 16,- 12), 37.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 5,= 19,- 8), 45.3 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 4,= 20,- 8), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 1,= 27,- 4), 45.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 4,= 21,- 7), 45.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 17,- 11), 39.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 4,= 20,- 8), 43.8 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -60 288 (+ 37,=159,- 92), 40.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 3,= 15,- 14), 32.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 1,= 25,- 6), 42.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 16,- 10), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 0,= 24,- 8), 37.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 11,- 12), 45.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 16,- 11), 40.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 3,= 16,- 13), 34.4 %
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_746527
12/24/2013 1:17:40 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 39 26 26 288 56.2 % -4 58.3 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 17 26 26 288 52.8 % -2 59.0 %
3 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 15 25 25 288 52.4 % -2 61.1 %
4 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 9 24 24 288 51.4 % -1 63.9 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 7 26 26 288 51.0 % -1 58.3 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 4 26 26 288 50.7 % -0 59.0 %
7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 1 27 27 288 50.2 % -0 53.8 %
8 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 0 26 26 288 50.0 % 0 59.0 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -33 25 25 288 44.8 % 4 60.4 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -60 27 27 288 40.5 % 7 55.2 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 39 288 (+ 78,=168,- 42), 56.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 11,= 19,- 2), 64.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 6,= 25,- 1), 57.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 11,= 13,- 8), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 8,= 15,- 9), 48.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 6,= 23,- 3), 54.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 13,= 16,- 3), 65.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 17 288 (+ 67,=170,- 51), 52.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 11,= 17,- 4), 60.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 11,= 16,- 5), 59.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 7,= 24,- 1), 59.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 4,= 24,- 4), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 3,= 24,- 5), 46.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 17,- 6), 54.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 10,= 14,- 8), 53.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 7,= 16,- 9), 46.9 %
3 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 15 288 (+ 63,=176,- 49), 52.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 20,- 4), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 9,= 15,- 8), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 11,= 12,- 9), 53.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 25,- 1), 57.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 24,- 3), 53.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 5,= 23,- 4), 51.6 %
4 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 9 288 (+ 56,=184,- 48), 51.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 27,- 1), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 3,= 23,- 6), 45.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 8,= 24,- 0), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 7,= 21,- 4), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 18,- 8), 46.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 10,= 17,- 5), 57.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 6,= 17,- 9), 45.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 16,- 10), 43.8 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 7 288 (+ 63,=168,- 57), 51.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 20,- 4), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 13,= 16,- 3), 65.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 4,= 19,- 9), 42.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 9,= 17,- 6), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 4,= 23,- 5), 48.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 10,= 16,- 6), 56.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 1,= 23,- 8), 39.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 16,- 7), 53.1 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 4 288 (+ 61,=170,- 57), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 12,= 16,- 4), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 9,= 12,- 11), 46.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 21,- 7), 45.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 18,- 8), 46.9 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 1,= 24,- 7), 40.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 19,- 4), 57.8 %
7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 1 288 (+ 67,=155,- 66), 50.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 7,= 21,- 4), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 3,= 16,- 13), 34.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 12,= 11,- 9), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 8,= 18,- 6), 53.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 7,= 17,- 8), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 17,- 10), 42.2 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 14,- 10), 46.9 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 8,= 23,- 1), 60.9 %
8 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 0 288 (+ 59,=170,- 59), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 19,- 5), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 8,= 13,- 11), 45.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 10,= 16,- 6), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 1,= 25,- 6), 42.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 18,- 6), 53.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 8,= 17,- 7), 51.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 24,- 4), 50.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 17,- 9), 45.3 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -33 288 (+ 42,=174,- 72), 44.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 2,= 19,- 11), 35.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 14,= 15,- 3), 67.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 4,= 16,- 12), 37.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 5,= 19,- 8), 45.3 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 4,= 20,- 8), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 1,= 27,- 4), 45.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 4,= 21,- 7), 45.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 17,- 11), 39.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 4,= 20,- 8), 43.8 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -60 288 (+ 37,=159,- 92), 40.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 3,= 15,- 14), 32.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 1,= 25,- 6), 42.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 16,- 10), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 0,= 24,- 8), 37.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 11,- 12), 45.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 16,- 11), 40.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 3,= 16,- 13), 34.4 %
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
1710 games
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_856695
12/28/2013 2:19:22 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 31 24 23 342 55.0 % -3 59.1 %
2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 17 23 22 342 52.8 % -2 62.9 %
3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 17 23 23 342 52.6 % -2 60.2 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 12 23 23 342 51.9 % -1 61.1 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 6 24 24 342 51.0 % -1 58.2 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 6 23 23 342 50.9 % -1 59.6 %
7 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 3 24 24 342 50.4 % -0 58.8 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 2 25 25 342 50.3 % -0 55.0 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -37 22 23 342 44.2 % 4 62.6 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -57 24 24 342 40.9 % 6 56.1 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 31 342 (+ 87,=202,- 53), 55.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 12,= 24,- 2), 63.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 7,= 29,- 2), 56.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 6,= 25,- 7), 48.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 11,= 15,- 12), 48.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 10,= 18,- 10), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 6,= 28,- 4), 52.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 13,= 20,- 5), 60.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 11,= 21,- 6), 56.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 11,= 22,- 5), 57.9 %
2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 17 342 (+ 73,=215,- 54), 52.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 7,= 30,- 1), 57.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 4,= 28,- 6), 47.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 11,= 27,- 0), 64.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 8,= 26,- 4), 55.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 8,= 20,- 10), 47.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 8,= 25,- 5), 53.9 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 12,= 20,- 6), 57.9 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 7,= 20,- 11), 44.7 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 8,= 19,- 11), 46.1 %
3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 17 342 (+ 77,=206,- 59), 52.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 13,= 20,- 5), 60.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 6,= 21,- 11), 43.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 12,= 21,- 5), 59.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 8,= 28,- 2), 57.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 6,= 28,- 4), 52.6 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 4,= 29,- 5), 48.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 11,= 20,- 7), 55.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 10,= 19,- 9), 51.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 7,= 20,- 11), 44.7 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 12 342 (+ 73,=209,- 60), 51.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 9,= 25,- 4), 56.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 10,= 18,- 10), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 10,= 21,- 7), 53.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 13,= 15,- 10), 53.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 7,= 29,- 2), 56.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 5,= 25,- 8), 46.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 8,= 20,- 10), 47.4 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 5,= 29,- 4), 51.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 6,= 27,- 5), 51.3 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 6 342 (+ 75,=199,- 68), 51.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 9,= 24,- 5), 55.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 5,= 22,- 11), 42.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 17,= 18,- 3), 68.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 5,= 22,- 11), 42.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 10,= 21,- 7), 53.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 5,= 27,- 6), 48.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 11,= 19,- 8), 53.9 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 2,= 26,- 10), 39.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 11,= 20,- 7), 55.3 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 6 342 (+ 72,=204,- 66), 50.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 13,= 21,- 4), 61.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 7,= 25,- 6), 51.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 10,= 22,- 6), 55.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 7,= 24,- 7), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 10,= 15,- 13), 46.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 4,= 26,- 8), 44.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 8,= 21,- 9), 48.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 2,= 28,- 8), 42.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 11,= 22,- 5), 57.9 %
7 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 3 342 (+ 72,=201,- 69), 50.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 10,= 23,- 5), 56.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 12,= 15,- 11), 51.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 11,= 20,- 7), 55.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 7,= 24,- 7), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 2,= 29,- 7), 43.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 10,= 20,- 8), 52.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 9,= 21,- 8), 51.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 4,= 28,- 6), 47.4 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 7,= 21,- 10), 46.1 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 2 342 (+ 78,=188,- 76), 50.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 7,= 27,- 4), 53.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 5,= 20,- 13), 39.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 14,= 14,- 10), 55.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 9,= 21,- 8), 51.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 8,= 21,- 9), 48.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 10,= 20,- 8), 52.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 6,= 20,- 12), 42.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 9,= 19,- 10), 48.7 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 10,= 26,- 2), 60.5 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -37 342 (+ 44,=214,- 84), 44.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 2,= 24,- 12), 36.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 14,= 20,- 4), 63.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 4,= 21,- 13), 38.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 5,= 23,- 10), 43.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 4,= 25,- 9), 43.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 1,= 30,- 7), 42.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 4,= 27,- 7), 46.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 5,= 20,- 13), 39.5 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 5,= 24,- 9), 44.7 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -57 342 (+ 44,=192,-106), 40.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 4,= 20,- 14), 36.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 2,= 29,- 7), 43.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 6,= 22,- 10), 44.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 7,= 20,- 11), 44.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 7,= 21,- 10), 46.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 0,= 27,- 11), 35.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 10,= 14,- 14), 44.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 5,= 21,- 12), 40.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 3,= 18,- 17), 31.6 %
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_856695
12/28/2013 2:19:22 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 31 24 23 342 55.0 % -3 59.1 %
2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 17 23 22 342 52.8 % -2 62.9 %
3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 17 23 23 342 52.6 % -2 60.2 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 12 23 23 342 51.9 % -1 61.1 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 6 24 24 342 51.0 % -1 58.2 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 6 23 23 342 50.9 % -1 59.6 %
7 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 3 24 24 342 50.4 % -0 58.8 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 2 25 25 342 50.3 % -0 55.0 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -37 22 23 342 44.2 % 4 62.6 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -57 24 24 342 40.9 % 6 56.1 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 31 342 (+ 87,=202,- 53), 55.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 12,= 24,- 2), 63.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 7,= 29,- 2), 56.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 6,= 25,- 7), 48.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 11,= 15,- 12), 48.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 10,= 18,- 10), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 6,= 28,- 4), 52.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 13,= 20,- 5), 60.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 11,= 21,- 6), 56.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 11,= 22,- 5), 57.9 %
2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 17 342 (+ 73,=215,- 54), 52.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 7,= 30,- 1), 57.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 4,= 28,- 6), 47.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 11,= 27,- 0), 64.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 8,= 26,- 4), 55.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 8,= 20,- 10), 47.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 8,= 25,- 5), 53.9 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 12,= 20,- 6), 57.9 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 7,= 20,- 11), 44.7 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 8,= 19,- 11), 46.1 %
3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 17 342 (+ 77,=206,- 59), 52.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 13,= 20,- 5), 60.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 6,= 21,- 11), 43.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 12,= 21,- 5), 59.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 8,= 28,- 2), 57.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 6,= 28,- 4), 52.6 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 4,= 29,- 5), 48.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 11,= 20,- 7), 55.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 10,= 19,- 9), 51.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 7,= 20,- 11), 44.7 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 12 342 (+ 73,=209,- 60), 51.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 9,= 25,- 4), 56.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 10,= 18,- 10), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 10,= 21,- 7), 53.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 13,= 15,- 10), 53.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 7,= 29,- 2), 56.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 5,= 25,- 8), 46.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 8,= 20,- 10), 47.4 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 5,= 29,- 4), 51.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 6,= 27,- 5), 51.3 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 6 342 (+ 75,=199,- 68), 51.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 9,= 24,- 5), 55.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 5,= 22,- 11), 42.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 17,= 18,- 3), 68.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 5,= 22,- 11), 42.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 10,= 21,- 7), 53.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 5,= 27,- 6), 48.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 11,= 19,- 8), 53.9 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 2,= 26,- 10), 39.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 11,= 20,- 7), 55.3 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 6 342 (+ 72,=204,- 66), 50.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 13,= 21,- 4), 61.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 7,= 25,- 6), 51.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 10,= 22,- 6), 55.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 7,= 24,- 7), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 10,= 15,- 13), 46.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 4,= 26,- 8), 44.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 8,= 21,- 9), 48.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 2,= 28,- 8), 42.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 11,= 22,- 5), 57.9 %
7 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 3 342 (+ 72,=201,- 69), 50.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 10,= 23,- 5), 56.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 12,= 15,- 11), 51.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 11,= 20,- 7), 55.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 7,= 24,- 7), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 2,= 29,- 7), 43.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 10,= 20,- 8), 52.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 9,= 21,- 8), 51.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 4,= 28,- 6), 47.4 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 7,= 21,- 10), 46.1 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 2 342 (+ 78,=188,- 76), 50.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 7,= 27,- 4), 53.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 5,= 20,- 13), 39.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 14,= 14,- 10), 55.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 9,= 21,- 8), 51.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 8,= 21,- 9), 48.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 10,= 20,- 8), 52.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 6,= 20,- 12), 42.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 9,= 19,- 10), 48.7 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 10,= 26,- 2), 60.5 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -37 342 (+ 44,=214,- 84), 44.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 2,= 24,- 12), 36.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 38 (+ 14,= 20,- 4), 63.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 4,= 21,- 13), 38.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 5,= 23,- 10), 43.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 4,= 25,- 9), 43.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 1,= 30,- 7), 42.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 4,= 27,- 7), 46.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 5,= 20,- 13), 39.5 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 5,= 24,- 9), 44.7 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -57 342 (+ 44,=192,-106), 40.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 38 (+ 4,= 20,- 14), 36.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 38 (+ 2,= 29,- 7), 43.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 38 (+ 6,= 22,- 10), 44.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 38 (+ 7,= 20,- 11), 44.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 38 (+ 7,= 21,- 10), 46.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 38 (+ 0,= 27,- 11), 35.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 38 (+ 10,= 14,- 14), 44.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 38 (+ 5,= 21,- 12), 40.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 38 (+ 3,= 18,- 17), 31.6 %
-
Ozymandias
- Posts: 1537
- Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2009 2:30 am
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
Houdini's implementation of Syzygy bases looks to be working better than Stockfish's.
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
The uncertainty in Elo is still a bit large, but it also might have something to do with this version of SF not having a way to adjust the probe depth (newer Ronald de Man development versions now have a way to adjust it).Ozymandias wrote:Houdini's implementation of Syzygy bases looks to be working better than Stockfish's.
To make conditions as equal as possible, I set Houdini EGTB Syzygy probe depth to 2, which is the minimum. However, SF still gets many more Syzygy TB hits than Houdini for the same positions, so the excessive SF TB hits might not be ideal.
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
1890 games
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_866565
12/30/2013 2:59:30 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 27 22 22 378 54.4 % -3 59.0 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 20 22 22 378 53.2 % -2 60.8 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 19 21 21 378 53.0 % -2 63.2 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 13 22 22 378 52.1 % -1 61.4 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 10 23 23 378 51.6 % -1 58.7 %
6 Komodo6-64bit : 4 23 23 378 50.7 % -0 57.9 %
7 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 2 22 22 378 50.3 % -0 61.4 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -2 24 24 378 49.6 % 0 54.2 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -41 21 22 378 43.5 % 5 62.2 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -53 22 23 378 41.7 % 6 57.9 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 27 378 (+ 94,=223,- 61), 54.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 13,= 27,- 2), 63.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 7,= 32,- 3), 54.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 6,= 29,- 7), 48.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 12,= 18,- 12), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 12,= 19,- 11), 51.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 6,= 31,- 5), 51.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 14,= 21,- 7), 58.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 13,= 22,- 7), 57.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 11,= 24,- 7), 54.8 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 20 378 (+ 86,=230,- 62), 53.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 15,= 22,- 5), 61.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 7,= 22,- 13), 42.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 13,= 24,- 5), 59.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 9,= 31,- 2), 58.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 6,= 32,- 4), 52.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 4,= 33,- 5), 48.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 23,- 7), 56.0 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 12,= 21,- 9), 53.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 8,= 22,- 12), 45.2 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 19 378 (+ 81,=239,- 58), 53.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 8,= 33,- 1), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 5,= 31,- 6), 48.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 12,= 30,- 0), 64.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 8,= 30,- 4), 54.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 8,= 22,- 12), 45.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 8,= 29,- 5), 53.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 15,= 21,- 6), 60.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 7,= 23,- 12), 44.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 10,= 20,- 12), 47.6 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 13 378 (+ 81,=232,- 65), 52.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 10,= 27,- 5), 56.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 11,= 19,- 12), 48.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 11,= 23,- 8), 53.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 16,= 16,- 10), 57.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 7,= 32,- 3), 54.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 5,= 29,- 8), 46.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 10,= 22,- 10), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 5,= 33,- 4), 51.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 6,= 31,- 5), 51.2 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 10 378 (+ 84,=222,- 72), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 13,= 23,- 6), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 12,= 18,- 12), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 11,= 23,- 8), 53.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 8,= 27,- 7), 51.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 3,= 32,- 7), 45.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 22,- 8), 54.8 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 12,= 22,- 8), 54.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 4,= 32,- 6), 47.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 9,= 23,- 10), 48.8 %
6 Komodo6-64bit : 4 378 (+ 82,=219,- 77), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 25,- 5), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 7,= 24,- 11), 45.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 17,= 21,- 4), 65.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 5,= 25,- 12), 41.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 10,= 23,- 9), 51.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 5,= 31,- 6), 48.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 20,- 10), 52.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 2,= 28,- 12), 38.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 22,- 8), 54.8 %
7 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 2 378 (+ 74,=232,- 72), 50.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 14,= 24,- 4), 61.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 7,= 29,- 6), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 10,= 26,- 6), 54.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 7,= 27,- 8), 48.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 10,= 16,- 16), 42.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 4,= 30,- 8), 45.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 8,= 24,- 10), 47.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 2,= 31,- 9), 41.7 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 12,= 25,- 5), 58.3 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -2 378 (+ 85,=205,- 88), 49.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 7,= 30,- 5), 52.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 7,= 21,- 14), 41.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 16,= 16,- 10), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 10,= 24,- 8), 52.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 8,= 22,- 12), 45.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 10,= 22,- 10), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 6,= 21,- 15), 39.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 9,= 21,- 12), 46.4 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 12,= 28,- 2), 61.9 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -41 378 (+ 47,=235,- 96), 43.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 2,= 27,- 13), 36.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 14,= 24,- 4), 61.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 4,= 24,- 14), 38.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 6,= 23,- 13), 41.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 5,= 27,- 10), 44.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 1,= 33,- 8), 41.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 5,= 30,- 7), 47.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 5,= 22,- 15), 38.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 5,= 25,- 12), 41.7 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -53 378 (+ 48,=219,-111), 41.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 4,= 24,- 14), 38.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 3,= 32,- 7), 45.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 6,= 26,- 10), 45.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 8,= 23,- 11), 46.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 8,= 23,- 11), 46.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 0,= 30,- 12), 35.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 10,= 16,- 16), 42.9 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 5,= 24,- 13), 40.5 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 4,= 21,- 17), 34.5 %
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_866565
12/30/2013 2:59:30 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 27 22 22 378 54.4 % -3 59.0 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 20 22 22 378 53.2 % -2 60.8 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 19 21 21 378 53.0 % -2 63.2 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 13 22 22 378 52.1 % -1 61.4 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 10 23 23 378 51.6 % -1 58.7 %
6 Komodo6-64bit : 4 23 23 378 50.7 % -0 57.9 %
7 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 2 22 22 378 50.3 % -0 61.4 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -2 24 24 378 49.6 % 0 54.2 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -41 21 22 378 43.5 % 5 62.2 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -53 22 23 378 41.7 % 6 57.9 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 27 378 (+ 94,=223,- 61), 54.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 13,= 27,- 2), 63.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 7,= 32,- 3), 54.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 6,= 29,- 7), 48.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 12,= 18,- 12), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 12,= 19,- 11), 51.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 6,= 31,- 5), 51.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 14,= 21,- 7), 58.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 13,= 22,- 7), 57.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 11,= 24,- 7), 54.8 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 20 378 (+ 86,=230,- 62), 53.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 15,= 22,- 5), 61.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 7,= 22,- 13), 42.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 13,= 24,- 5), 59.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 9,= 31,- 2), 58.3 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 6,= 32,- 4), 52.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 4,= 33,- 5), 48.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 23,- 7), 56.0 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 12,= 21,- 9), 53.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 8,= 22,- 12), 45.2 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 19 378 (+ 81,=239,- 58), 53.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 8,= 33,- 1), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 5,= 31,- 6), 48.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 12,= 30,- 0), 64.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 8,= 30,- 4), 54.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 8,= 22,- 12), 45.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 8,= 29,- 5), 53.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 15,= 21,- 6), 60.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 7,= 23,- 12), 44.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 10,= 20,- 12), 47.6 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 13 378 (+ 81,=232,- 65), 52.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 10,= 27,- 5), 56.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 11,= 19,- 12), 48.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 11,= 23,- 8), 53.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 16,= 16,- 10), 57.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 7,= 32,- 3), 54.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 5,= 29,- 8), 46.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 10,= 22,- 10), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 5,= 33,- 4), 51.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 6,= 31,- 5), 51.2 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 10 378 (+ 84,=222,- 72), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 13,= 23,- 6), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 12,= 18,- 12), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 11,= 23,- 8), 53.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 8,= 27,- 7), 51.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 3,= 32,- 7), 45.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 22,- 8), 54.8 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 12,= 22,- 8), 54.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 4,= 32,- 6), 47.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 9,= 23,- 10), 48.8 %
6 Komodo6-64bit : 4 378 (+ 82,=219,- 77), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 25,- 5), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 7,= 24,- 11), 45.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 17,= 21,- 4), 65.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 5,= 25,- 12), 41.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 10,= 23,- 9), 51.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 5,= 31,- 6), 48.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 20,- 10), 52.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 2,= 28,- 12), 38.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 12,= 22,- 8), 54.8 %
7 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 2 378 (+ 74,=232,- 72), 50.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 14,= 24,- 4), 61.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 7,= 29,- 6), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 10,= 26,- 6), 54.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 7,= 27,- 8), 48.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 10,= 16,- 16), 42.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 4,= 30,- 8), 45.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 8,= 24,- 10), 47.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 2,= 31,- 9), 41.7 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 12,= 25,- 5), 58.3 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -2 378 (+ 85,=205,- 88), 49.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 7,= 30,- 5), 52.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 7,= 21,- 14), 41.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 16,= 16,- 10), 57.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 10,= 24,- 8), 52.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 8,= 22,- 12), 45.2 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 10,= 22,- 10), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 6,= 21,- 15), 39.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 9,= 21,- 12), 46.4 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 12,= 28,- 2), 61.9 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -41 378 (+ 47,=235,- 96), 43.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 2,= 27,- 13), 36.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 42 (+ 14,= 24,- 4), 61.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 4,= 24,- 14), 38.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 6,= 23,- 13), 41.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 5,= 27,- 10), 44.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 1,= 33,- 8), 41.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 5,= 30,- 7), 47.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 5,= 22,- 15), 38.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 5,= 25,- 12), 41.7 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -53 378 (+ 48,=219,-111), 41.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 42 (+ 4,= 24,- 14), 38.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 42 (+ 3,= 32,- 7), 45.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 42 (+ 6,= 26,- 10), 45.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 42 (+ 8,= 23,- 11), 46.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 42 (+ 8,= 23,- 11), 46.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 42 (+ 0,= 30,- 12), 35.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 42 (+ 10,= 16,- 16), 42.9 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 42 (+ 5,= 24,- 13), 40.5 %
Komodo6-64bit : 42 (+ 4,= 21,- 17), 34.5 %
-
ernest
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:30 pm
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
Too bad your presentation is a mess! 
Use "Code" for your table, you will get something cleaner:
Use "Code" for your table, you will get something cleaner:
Code: Select all
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 27 22 22 378 54.4 % -3 59.0 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 20 22 22 378 53.2 % -2 60.8 %
3 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 19 21 21 378 53.0 % -2 63.2 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 13 22 22 378 52.1 % -1 61.4 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 10 23 23 378 51.6 % -1 58.7 %
6 Komodo6-64bit : 4 23 23 378 50.7 % -0 57.9 %
7 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 2 22 22 378 50.3 % -0 61.4 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -2 24 24 378 49.6 % 0 54.2 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -41 21 22 378 43.5 % 5 62.2 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -53 22 23 378 41.7 % 6 57.9 % -
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
As requested, a cleaner presentation
Code: Select all
1980 games
12/31/2013 9:50:14 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 29 22 22 396 54.5 % -3 59.6 %
2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 20 21 21 396 53.2 % -2 63.9 %
3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 20 21 21 396 53.2 % -2 61.4 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 14 21 21 396 52.3 % -2 61.1 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 8 22 22 396 51.3 % -1 58.6 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 2 21 21 396 50.3 % -0 61.6 %
7 Komodo6-64bit : 0 22 22 396 50.0 % 0 58.1 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -1 23 23 396 49.9 % 0 54.8 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -39 21 21 396 43.8 % 4 62.9 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -53 22 22 396 41.7 % 6 58.6 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 29 396 (+ 98,=236,- 62), 54.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 13,= 29,- 2), 62.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 8,= 33,- 3), 55.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 6,= 31,- 7), 48.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 12,= 20,- 12), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 13,= 20,- 11), 52.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 7,= 31,- 6), 51.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 14,= 23,- 7), 58.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 14,= 23,- 7), 58.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 11,= 26,- 7), 54.5 %
2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 20 396 (+ 84,=253,- 59), 53.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 8,= 35,- 1), 58.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 6,= 31,- 7), 48.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 12,= 32,- 0), 63.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 9,= 31,- 4), 55.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 8,= 24,- 12), 45.5 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 8,= 31,- 5), 53.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 15,= 23,- 6), 60.2 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 7,= 25,- 12), 44.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 11,= 21,- 12), 48.9 %
3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 20 396 (+ 89,=243,- 64), 53.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 15,= 24,- 5), 61.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 7,= 23,- 14), 42.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 14,= 25,- 5), 60.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 9,= 33,- 2), 58.0 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 7,= 33,- 4), 53.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 4,= 35,- 5), 48.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 12,= 25,- 7), 55.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 13,= 22,- 9), 54.5 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 8,= 23,- 13), 44.3 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 14 396 (+ 86,=242,- 68), 52.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 10,= 29,- 5), 55.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 11,= 20,- 13), 47.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 12,= 23,- 9), 53.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 17,= 17,- 10), 58.0 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 7,= 34,- 3), 54.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 5,= 31,- 8), 46.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 11,= 22,- 11), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 5,= 35,- 4), 51.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 8,= 31,- 5), 53.4 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 8 396 (+ 87,=232,- 77), 51.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 14,= 23,- 7), 58.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 12,= 20,- 12), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 12,= 24,- 8), 54.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 8,= 28,- 8), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 3,= 34,- 7), 45.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 12,= 24,- 8), 54.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 12,= 22,- 10), 52.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 4,= 33,- 7), 46.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 10,= 24,- 10), 50.0 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 2 396 (+ 77,=244,- 75), 50.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 15,= 25,- 4), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 7,= 31,- 6), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 10,= 28,- 6), 54.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 8,= 28,- 8), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 10,= 17,- 17), 42.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 4,= 31,- 9), 44.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 8,= 25,- 11), 46.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 2,= 33,- 9), 42.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 13,= 26,- 5), 59.1 %
7 Komodo6-64bit : 0 396 (+ 83,=230,- 83), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 12,= 26,- 6), 56.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 7,= 26,- 11), 45.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 17,= 23,- 4), 64.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 5,= 26,- 13), 40.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 10,= 24,- 10), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 5,= 31,- 8), 46.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 12,= 21,- 11), 51.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 2,= 30,- 12), 38.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 13,= 23,- 8), 55.7 %
8 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -1 396 (+ 89,=217,- 90), 49.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 7,= 32,- 5), 52.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 7,= 23,- 14), 42.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 16,= 18,- 10), 56.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 11,= 25,- 8), 53.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 10,= 22,- 12), 47.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 11,= 22,- 11), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 6,= 23,- 15), 39.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 9,= 22,- 13), 45.5 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 12,= 30,- 2), 61.4 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -39 396 (+ 49,=249,- 98), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 2,= 29,- 13), 37.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 44 (+ 14,= 26,- 4), 61.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 4,= 25,- 15), 37.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 7,= 23,- 14), 42.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 5,= 29,- 10), 44.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 1,= 35,- 8), 42.0 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 5,= 32,- 7), 47.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 5,= 24,- 15), 38.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 6,= 26,- 12), 43.2 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -53 396 (+ 49,=232,-115), 41.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 44 (+ 4,= 26,- 14), 38.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 44 (+ 3,= 33,- 8), 44.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 44 (+ 6,= 28,- 10), 45.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 44 (+ 8,= 24,- 12), 45.5 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 44 (+ 9,= 23,- 12), 46.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 44 (+ 0,= 32,- 12), 36.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 44 (+ 10,= 18,- 16), 43.2 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 44 (+ 5,= 25,- 14), 39.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 44 (+ 4,= 23,- 17), 35.2 %-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Houdini 4, Stockfish-DD, Komodo-TCEC: EGTBs on and off
One Month Anniversary! 2160 Games so far, enjoy
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_876885
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_876885
Code: Select all
2160 games
1/3/2014 6:20:02 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 28 21 20 432 54.4 % -3 60.6 %
2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 21 20 20 432 53.4 % -2 63.2 %
3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 19 20 20 432 53.0 % -2 61.1 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 16 20 20 432 52.5 % -2 61.6 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 9 21 21 432 51.5 % -1 59.5 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 1 20 20 432 50.2 % -0 62.5 %
7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -4 22 22 432 49.4 % 0 55.3 %
8 Komodo6-64bit : -4 21 21 432 49.4 % 0 58.1 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -38 20 20 432 44.0 % 4 62.0 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -50 21 21 432 42.1 % 6 59.3 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 28 432 (+104,=262,- 66), 54.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 16,= 30,- 2), 64.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 8,= 37,- 3), 55.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 6,= 35,- 7), 49.0 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 13,= 22,- 13), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 13,= 24,- 11), 52.1 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 7,= 34,- 7), 50.0 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 15,= 25,- 8), 57.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 14,= 26,- 8), 56.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 12,= 29,- 7), 55.2 %
2 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 21 432 (+ 94,=273,- 65), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 10,= 37,- 1), 59.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 7,= 34,- 7), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 13,= 35,- 0), 63.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 9,= 35,- 4), 55.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 9,= 27,- 12), 46.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 8,= 33,- 7), 51.0 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 17,= 25,- 6), 61.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 9,= 25,- 14), 44.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 12,= 22,- 14), 47.9 %
3 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 19 432 (+ 97,=264,- 71), 53.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 16,= 26,- 6), 60.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 8,= 26,- 14), 43.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 15,= 28,- 5), 60.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 10,= 34,- 4), 56.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 7,= 37,- 4), 53.1 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 4,= 39,- 5), 49.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 14,= 25,- 9), 55.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 14,= 25,- 9), 55.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 9,= 24,- 15), 43.8 %
4 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 16 432 (+ 94,=266,- 72), 52.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 13,= 30,- 5), 58.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 11,= 24,- 13), 47.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 12,= 25,- 11), 51.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 17,= 20,- 11), 56.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 7,= 38,- 3), 54.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 7,= 33,- 8), 49.0 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 11,= 25,- 12), 49.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 5,= 39,- 4), 51.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 11,= 32,- 5), 56.2 %
5 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 9 432 (+ 94,=257,- 81), 51.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 15,= 25,- 8), 57.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 13,= 22,- 13), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 14,= 26,- 8), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 10,= 30,- 8), 52.1 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 3,= 38,- 7), 45.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 12,= 27,- 9), 53.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 12,= 26,- 10), 52.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 4,= 37,- 7), 46.9 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 11,= 26,- 11), 50.0 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 1 432 (+ 82,=270,- 80), 50.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 15,= 28,- 5), 60.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 7,= 35,- 6), 51.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 10,= 31,- 7), 53.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 8,= 30,- 10), 47.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 11,= 20,- 17), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 4,= 35,- 9), 44.8 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 10,= 27,- 11), 49.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 4,= 34,- 10), 43.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 13,= 30,- 5), 58.3 %
7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : -4 432 (+ 94,=239,- 99), 49.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 7,= 34,- 7), 50.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 8,= 25,- 15), 42.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 18,= 19,- 11), 57.3 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 11,= 27,- 10), 51.0 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 10,= 26,- 12), 47.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 12,= 25,- 11), 51.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 6,= 25,- 17), 38.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 9,= 25,- 14), 44.8 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 13,= 33,- 2), 61.5 %
8 Komodo6-64bit : -4 432 (+ 88,=251,- 93), 49.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 12,= 29,- 7), 55.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 7,= 29,- 12), 44.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 17,= 26,- 5), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 5,= 30,- 13), 41.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 11,= 26,- 11), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 5,= 32,- 11), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 14,= 22,- 12), 52.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 2,= 33,- 13), 38.5 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 15,= 24,- 9), 56.2 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -38 432 (+ 56,=268,-108), 44.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 2,= 30,- 16), 35.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 48 (+ 15,= 29,- 4), 61.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 5,= 28,- 15), 39.6 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 8,= 25,- 15), 42.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 5,= 30,- 13), 41.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 1,= 37,- 10), 40.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 7,= 34,- 7), 50.0 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 6,= 26,- 16), 39.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 7,= 29,- 12), 44.8 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -50 432 (+ 54,=256,-122), 42.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 48 (+ 4,= 29,- 15), 38.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 48 (+ 3,= 37,- 8), 44.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 48 (+ 7,= 31,- 10), 46.9 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 48 (+ 8,= 26,- 14), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 48 (+ 11,= 25,- 12), 49.0 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 48 (+ 0,= 35,- 13), 36.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 48 (+ 11,= 19,- 18), 42.7 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 48 (+ 5,= 28,- 15), 39.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 48 (+ 5,= 26,- 17), 37.5 %