FCP: SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10 vs. 49 opp. EXPERIMENT

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

Frank Quisinsky
Posts: 6816
Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 7:16 pm
Location: Gutweiler, Germany
Full name: Frank Quisinsky

Re: After round 39/50 (78%) = 3218.83 Elo, +18.91 (Nr.1)

Post by Frank Quisinsky »

Hi Jörg,

and the end of Contempt Topic after three years for myself. I am ready in a short time with my list and need really a break. Each day to work on the book and to checked the games was a lot of work in the last three years.

Stockfish and Komodo ... are to strong for me and only with such little tricks I can find out a bit. Possible only with a strong book I have now.

Enough ... 20 days ... 4 test-runs only ... and chess vacation in the near!

Best
Frank

Maybe the others can do a bit with all the information I found out, also about Contempt in the last years.
Frank Quisinsky
Posts: 6816
Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 7:16 pm
Location: Gutweiler, Germany
Full name: Frank Quisinsky

Re: Stats ... ratings with and without Contempt!

Post by Frank Quisinsky »

For the Rating List place 01-25 = Naum 4.6 x64 with 2885 Elo.
For the Rating List place 25-50 = Zappa Mexico II x64 with 2752 Elo.

Have a look here (extract from FCP-Rating List, each one against each other):

Code: Select all

   # Player                       :      Elo  Games  Score%   won  draw  lost  Points  Draw%  Error   OppAvg   OppE   OppD
   18 Naum 4.6 x64                :  2885.00   2450    55.6   796  1134   520  1363.0   46.3  10.15  2843.91  10.68   49.0
   36 Zappa Mexico II x64         :  2751.95   2450    38.7   403  1092   955   949.0   44.6  10.03  2846.63  10.68   49.0

The final results:

Code: Select all

  Place 01-25
   # Player                       :      Elo  Games  Score%   won  draw  lost  Points  Draw%  Error   OppAvg   OppE   OppD
    1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10   :  3233.11   1200    82.7   792   401     7   992.5   33.4  17.20  2941.22  13.63   24.0  + 15,64
    1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64       :  3217.47   1200    81.3   763   426    11   976.0   35.5  16.87  2942.83  13.63   24.0
	
  Place 26-50	
  # Player                        :      Elo  Games  Score%   won  draw  lost  Points  Draw%  Error   OppAvg   OppE   OppD
    1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10   :  3190.45   1250    92.8  1071   179     0  1160.5   14.3  25.09  2734.19  13.91   25.0  + 25,12
    1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64       :  3165.33   1250    91.8  1045   204     1  1147.0   16.3  23.38  2735.95  13.90   25.0
In both cases 25 lesser draw games!
= 50 (the final result was 50 lesser draw games)

1.
SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10, places 1-25:
The Contempt = 10 version!

Code: Select all

   # Player                       :      Elo  Games  Score%  won  draw  lost  Points  Draw%  Error   OppAvg   OppE   OppD
   1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10    :  3233.11   1200    82.7  792   401     7   992.5   33.4  17.20  2941.22  13.63   24.0
   2 Komodo 10 x64                :  3195.84   1200    79.4  740   426    34   953.0   35.5  16.11  2942.77  13.68   24.0
   3 Houdini 4 STD B x64          :  3076.61   1200    66.5  537   522   141   798.0   43.5  13.99  2947.74  13.76   24.0
   4 Fire 4 x64                   :  3033.92   1200    61.1  434   599   167   733.5   49.9  13.89  2949.52  13.77   24.0
   5 GullChess 3.0 BMI2 x64       :  3031.66   1200    60.8  424   612   164   730.0   51.0  14.12  2949.61  13.76   24.0
   6 Fizbo 1.8 BMI2 x64           :  3007.23   1200    57.6  386   611   203   691.5   50.9  13.31  2950.63  13.79   24.0
   7 Equinox 3.30 x64             :  3004.41   1200    57.3  366   642   192   687.0   53.5  13.14  2950.75  13.80   24.0
   8 Andscacs 0.872 BMI2 x64      :  2995.66   1200    56.1  365   616   219   673.0   51.3  13.03  2951.11  13.80   24.0
   9 Critter 1.6a x64             :  2978.63   1200    53.8  336   619   245   645.5   51.6  13.04  2951.82  13.80   24.0
  10 Fritz 15 x64                 :  2977.70   1200    53.7  333   622   245   644.0   51.8  12.92  2951.86  13.81   24.0
  11 Nirvanachess 2.3 POP x64     :  2962.94   1200    51.7  279   682   239   620.0   56.8  13.31  2952.48  13.79   24.0
  12 Hannibal 1.7 x64             :  2962.63   1200    51.6  309   621   270   619.5   51.8  13.11  2952.49  13.80   24.0
  13 Chiron 3 x64                 :  2947.62   1200    49.6  283   624   293   595.0   52.0  13.14  2953.12  13.80   24.0
  14 Texel 1.06 x64               :  2933.53   1200    47.7  268   608   324   572.0   50.7  13.36  2953.70  13.79   24.0
  15 Protector 1.9.0 x64          :  2928.93   1200    47.0  236   657   307   564.5   54.8  13.47  2953.89  13.79   24.0
  16 iCE 3.0 v658 POP x64         :  2921.26   1200    46.0  256   592   352   552.0   49.3  13.79  2954.21  13.77   24.0
  17 Booot 6.0.2 POP x64          :  2901.82   1200    43.4  212   617   371   520.5   51.4  13.01  2955.02  13.80   24.0
  18 Hakkapeliitta TCEC v2 x64    :  2887.82   1200    41.5  244   508   448   498.0   42.3  13.70  2955.61  13.78   24.0
  19 Naum 4.6 x64                 :  2885.00   1200    41.1  194   599   407   493.5   49.9  13.20  2955.72  13.80   24.0
  20 SmarThink 1.96 SSE4 x64      :  2873.67   1200    39.6  219   513   468   475.5   42.8  13.03  2956.20  13.80   24.0
  21 Vajolet2 2.2 POP x64         :  2830.58   1200    34.1  149   520   531   409.0   43.3  14.07  2957.99  13.76   24.0
  22 Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64         :  2828.24   1200    33.8  145   521   534   405.5   43.4  13.86  2958.09  13.77   24.0
  23 Pedone 1.4.1 BMI2 x64        :  2816.09   1200    32.3  109   557   534   387.5   46.4  14.38  2958.60  13.75   24.0
  24 Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32           :  2815.41   1200    32.2  130   513   557   386.5   42.8  13.90  2958.62  13.77   24.0
  25 Sjeng c't 2010 w32           :  2792.08   1200    29.4  111   484   605   353.0   40.3  14.26  2959.60  13.75   24.0

White advantage = 34.75 +/- 2.10
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 56.82 % +/- 0.47

2.
SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64, places 1-25:

Code: Select all

   # Player                       :      Elo  Games  Score%  won  draw  lost  Points  Draw%  Error   OppAvg   OppE   OppD
   1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64        :  3217.47   1200    81.3  763   426    11   976.0   35.5  16.87  2942.83  13.63   24.0
   2 Komodo 10 x64                :  3199.49   1200    79.7  744   425    31   956.5   35.4  16.15  2943.58  13.66   24.0
   3 Houdini 4 STD B x64          :  3080.21   1200    66.8  538   528   134   802.0   44.0  13.99  2948.55  13.75   24.0
   4 Fire 4 x64                   :  3034.89   1200    61.1  434   599   167   733.5   49.9  13.93  2950.44  13.76   24.0
   5 GullChess 3.0 BMI2 x64       :  3032.33   1200    60.8  424   611   165   729.5   50.9  14.18  2950.55  13.75   24.0
   6 Fizbo 1.8 BMI2 x64           :  3007.33   1200    57.5  386   608   206   690.0   50.7  13.25  2951.59  13.78   24.0
   7 Equinox 3.30 x64             :  3002.95   1200    56.9  366   634   200   683.0   52.8  13.11  2951.77  13.79   24.0
   8 Andscacs 0.872 BMI2 x64      :  2996.42   1200    56.0  365   615   220   672.5   51.3  13.01  2952.04  13.79   24.0
   9 Critter 1.6a x64             :  2980.65   1200    53.9  335   624   241   647.0   52.0  13.04  2952.70  13.79   24.0
  10 Fritz 15 x64                 :  2979.72   1200    53.8  333   625   242   645.5   52.1  12.96  2952.74  13.80   24.0
  11 Hannibal 1.7 x64             :  2964.68   1200    51.8  308   626   266   621.0   52.2  13.05  2953.37  13.79   24.0
  12 Nirvanachess 2.3 POP x64     :  2962.23   1200    51.4  279   676   245   617.0   56.3  13.31  2953.47  13.78   24.0
  13 Chiron 3 x64                 :  2948.77   1200    49.6  283   624   293   595.0   52.0  13.22  2954.03  13.79   24.0
  14 Texel 1.06 x64               :  2936.54   1200    47.9  268   614   318   575.0   51.2  13.28  2954.54  13.78   24.0
  15 Protector 1.9.0 x64          :  2931.04   1200    47.2  236   660   304   566.0   55.0  13.53  2954.77  13.77   24.0
  16 iCE 3.0 v658 POP x64         :  2922.45   1200    46.0  256   592   352   552.0   49.3  13.79  2955.13  13.76   24.0
  17 Booot 6.0.2 POP x64          :  2903.67   1200    43.5  211   621   368   521.5   51.8  13.03  2955.91  13.79   24.0
  18 Hakkapeliitta TCEC v2 x64    :  2892.50   1200    42.0  245   517   438   503.5   43.1  13.67  2956.37  13.77   24.0
  19 Naum 4.6 x64                 :  2885.00   1200    41.0  194   595   411   491.5   49.6  13.17  2956.69  13.79   24.0
  20 SmarThink 1.96 SSE4 x64      :  2877.46   1200    40.0  220   519   461   479.5   43.3  13.10  2957.00  13.79   24.0
  21 Vajolet2 2.2 POP x64         :  2831.56   1200    34.0  149   519   532   408.5   43.3  14.11  2958.91  13.75   24.0
  22 Senpai 1.0 SSE42 x64         :  2828.22   1200    33.6  145   517   538   403.5   43.1  13.83  2959.05  13.76   24.0
  23 Pedone 1.4.1 BMI2 x64        :  2820.14   1200    32.6  109   565   526   391.5   47.1  14.24  2959.39  13.74   24.0
  24 Hiarcs 14 WCSC w32           :  2818.45   1200    32.4  130   518   552   389.0   43.2  13.96  2959.46  13.75   24.0
  25 Sjeng c't 2010 w32           :  2791.31   1200    29.2  111   478   611   350.0   39.8  14.32  2960.59  13.74   24.0

White advantage = 34.51 +/- 2.11
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 56.83 % +/- 0.47

3.
SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10, places 26-50:
The Contempt = 10 version!

Code: Select all

   # Player                           :      Elo  Games  Score%   won  draw  lost  Points  Draw%  Error   OppAvg   OppE   OppD
   1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10        :  3190.45   1250    92.8  1071   179     0  1160.5   14.3  25.09  2734.19  13.91   25.0
   2 Cheng 4.39 x64                   :  2799.15   1250    57.3   430   573   247   716.5   45.8  14.42  2749.85  14.34   25.0
   3 Arasan 19.1 POP x64              :  2791.58   1250    56.3   416   575   259   703.5   46.0  13.86  2750.15  14.36   25.0
   4 Shredder 12 x64                  :  2788.68   1250    55.9   420   557   273   698.5   44.6  13.53  2750.26  14.38   25.0
   5 Junior 13.3.00 x64               :  2783.77   1250    55.2   417   546   287   690.0   43.7  13.95  2750.46  14.36   25.0
   6 Spike 1.4 Leiden w32             :  2779.16   1250    54.6   403   558   289   682.0   44.6  14.48  2750.65  14.34   25.0
   7 Wasp 1.25 BMI2 x64               :  2778.58   1250    54.5   385   592   273   681.0   47.4  13.99  2750.67  14.36   25.0
   8 Quazar 0.4 x64                   :  2772.55   1250    53.6   390   561   299   670.5   44.9  14.12  2750.91  14.35   25.0
   9 DiscoCheck 5.2.1 x64             :  2769.98   1250    53.3   409   514   327   666.0   41.1  13.83  2751.01  14.37   25.0
  10 Bobcat 7.6 x64                   :  2762.54   1250    52.2   354   598   298   653.0   47.8  13.27  2751.31  14.39   25.0
  11 Deuterium 14.3.34.130 POP x64    :  2756.84   1250    51.4   339   608   303   643.0   48.6  13.96  2751.54  14.36   25.0
  12 Zappa Mexico II x64              :  2752.00   1250    50.8   335   599   316   634.5   47.9  14.20  2751.73  14.35   25.0
  13 Spark 1.0 x64                    :  2751.72   1250    50.7   350   568   332   634.0   45.4  13.57  2751.74  14.38   25.0
  14 TogaII 280513 Intel w32          :  2733.81   1250    48.2   337   531   382   602.5   42.5  13.58  2752.46  14.38   25.0
  15 Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64              :  2731.82   1250    47.9   332   534   384   599.0   42.7  13.91  2752.54  14.36   25.0
  16 Crafty 25.0.1 JA POP x64         :  2722.71   1250    46.6   296   574   380   583.0   45.9  13.60  2752.90  14.37   25.0
  17 Rodent II 0.9.33 x64             :  2717.30   1250    45.9   287   573   390   573.5   45.8  13.40  2753.12  14.38   25.0
  18 Dirty 03NOV2015 POP x64          :  2716.21   1250    45.7   288   567   395   571.5   45.4  14.22  2753.16  14.35   25.0
  19 Atlas 3.80 x64                   :  2714.73   1250    45.5   285   568   397   569.0   45.4  14.13  2753.22  14.35   25.0
  20 EXchess 7.92b x64                :  2709.02   1250    44.7   257   604   389   559.0   48.3  13.93  2753.45  14.36   25.0
  21 Murka 3 x64                      :  2704.73   1250    44.1   260   583   407   551.5   46.6  13.67  2753.62  14.37   25.0
  22 DisasterArea 1.65 POP x64        :  2696.11   1250    42.9   244   585   421   536.5   46.8  13.95  2753.97  14.36   25.0
  23 Nemo 1.01 Beta POP x64           :  2692.31   1250    42.4   247   566   437   530.0   45.3  14.30  2754.12  14.35   25.0
  24 Rhetoric 1.4.3 POP x64           :  2657.50   1250    37.6   219   503   528   470.5   40.2  14.09  2755.51  14.35   25.0
  25 Octochess r5506 DC x64           :  2656.30   1250    37.5   198   541   511   468.5   43.3  13.81  2755.56  14.37   25.0
  26 Laser 1.1 POP x64                :  2615.76   1250    32.2   146   513   591   402.5   41.0  14.07  2757.18  14.36   25.0

White advantage = 30.41 +/- 2.11
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 48.38 % +/- 0.41

4.
SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64, places 26-50:

Code: Select all

   # Player                           :      Elo  Games  Score%   won  draw  lost  Points  Draw%  Error   OppAvg   OppE   OppD
   1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64            :  3165.33   1250    91.8  1045   204     1  1147.0   16.3  23.38  2735.95  13.90   25.0
   2 Cheng 4.39 x64                   :  2803.10   1250    57.7   430   582   238   721.0   46.6  14.42  2750.44  14.25   25.0
   3 Arasan 19.1 POP x64              :  2792.63   1250    56.2   416   574   260   703.0   45.9  13.89  2750.86  14.27   25.0
   4 Shredder 12 x64                  :  2791.47   1250    56.1   420   562   268   701.0   45.0  13.45  2750.91  14.29   25.0
   5 Junior 13.3.00 x64               :  2786.57   1250    55.4   417   551   282   692.5   44.1  13.97  2751.10  14.27   25.0
   6 Spike 1.4 Leiden w32             :  2781.39   1250    54.7   403   561   286   683.5   44.9  14.43  2751.31  14.25   25.0
   7 Wasp 1.25 BMI2 x64               :  2779.38   1250    54.4   385   590   275   680.0   47.2  14.01  2751.39  14.27   25.0
   8 Quazar 0.4 x64                   :  2773.36   1250    53.6   390   559   301   669.5   44.7  14.05  2751.63  14.27   25.0
   9 DiscoCheck 5.2.1 x64             :  2773.08   1250    53.5   409   520   321   669.0   41.6  13.88  2751.64  14.28   25.0
  10 Bobcat 7.6 x64                   :  2763.66   1250    52.2   354   597   299   652.5   47.8  13.27  2752.02  14.30   25.0
  11 Deuterium 14.3.34.130 POP x64    :  2757.97   1250    51.4   339   607   304   642.5   48.6  13.92  2752.25  14.27   25.0
  12 Spark 1.0 x64                    :  2754.27   1250    50.9   351   570   329   636.0   45.6  13.58  2752.39  14.29   25.0
  13 Zappa Mexico II x64              :  2752.00   1250    50.6   335   594   321   632.0   47.5  14.13  2752.48  14.27   25.0
  14 TogaII 280513 Intel w32          :  2736.39   1250    48.4   337   535   378   604.5   42.8  13.61  2753.11  14.29   25.0
  15 Gaviota 1.0 AVX x64              :  2732.13   1250    47.8   332   530   388   597.0   42.4  13.87  2753.28  14.28   25.0
  16 Crafty 25.0.1 JA POP x64         :  2724.46   1250    46.7   296   575   379   583.5   46.0  13.62  2753.59  14.29   25.0
  17 Dirty 03NOV2015 POP x64          :  2717.68   1250    45.7   288   567   395   571.5   45.4  14.10  2753.86  14.27   25.0
  18 Rodent II 0.9.33 x64             :  2717.64   1250    45.7   287   569   394   571.5   45.5  13.43  2753.86  14.29   25.0
  19 Atlas 3.80 x64                   :  2717.35   1250    45.7   285   572   393   571.0   45.8  14.11  2753.87  14.27   25.0
  20 EXchess 7.92b x64                :  2710.51   1250    44.7   257   604   389   559.0   48.3  13.93  2754.14  14.27   25.0
  21 Murka 3 x64                      :  2705.36   1250    44.0   260   580   410   550.0   46.4  13.67  2754.35  14.28   25.0
  22 DisasterArea 1.65 POP x64        :  2697.61   1250    42.9   244   585   421   536.5   46.8  13.95  2754.66  14.27   25.0
  23 Nemo 1.01 Beta POP x64           :  2694.11   1250    42.4   247   567   436   530.5   45.4  14.27  2754.80  14.26   25.0
  24 Rhetoric 1.4.3 POP x64           :  2660.53   1250    37.8   219   508   523   473.0   40.6  14.05  2756.14  14.27   25.0
  25 Octochess r5506 DC x64           :  2657.85   1250    37.5   198   541   511   468.5   43.3  13.79  2756.25  14.28   25.0
  26 Laser 1.1 POP x64                :  2618.29   1250    32.3   146   516   588   404.0   41.3  13.98  2757.83  14.27   25.0

White advantage = 30.02 +/- 2.10
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 48.40 % +/- 0.41
Frank Quisinsky
Posts: 6816
Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 7:16 pm
Location: Gutweiler, Germany
Full name: Frank Quisinsky

Re: In my opinion ...

Post by Frank Quisinsky »

In my opinion the following question is not important ...
Without contempt vs. stronger or with Contempt vs. weaker opponents!

The result is the same ...

With Contempt = 10 is Stockfish around 15-20 Elo stronger, that is exactly the result I wrote in my first message (Logical after the last "Fight for Place 1". I wrote ... "Stockfish now with full power with Contempt = 10"!

Sorry, but I know the results before, so I am very sure here.
Enough ... enough is enough, means ... I have enough from Contempt!

Have a nice night!

Best
Frank
Carlos777
Posts: 1791
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2009 6:09 pm

Re: Comparsion ... how contempt is working, nice to see!

Post by Carlos777 »

Frank Quisinsky wrote: Hint:
All pages are now updated, if you like you can make your own stats. Please download the complete database or the database for statistics or under download games by players the Stockfish games.
Hi Frank,

Thanks for the hint. I was not aware that the games could be downloaded.

I selected the games of Stockfish with and withoud contempt versus the top 15 opponents. I got this:

Code: Select all

   # Player                       :      Elo  Games  Score%  won  draw  lost  Points  Draw%  Error   OppAvg   OppE   OppN
   1 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10    :  3249.73    750    78.7  437   307     6   590.5   40.9  15.18  3009.66  38.72     30
   2 SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64        :  3239.67    750    77.8  426   315     9   583.5   42.0  22.03  3009.66  38.72     30
As expected, the difference between both is shorter against stronger opposition.

Which is interesting, is that SF C=10 gets the advantage against the strongest (Komodo and Houdini), I thought SF without contempt would do better (although, the number of games per match is relatively small.)

Code: Select all

Head to head statistics:

 1) SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64 C10 3249.73 :    750 (+437,=307,-6),  78.7 %

    vs.                               :  games (   +,   =, -),   (%) :     Diff,     SD, CFS (%)
    Komodo 10 x64                     :     50 (  17,  32, 1),  66.0 :   +40.03,  11.80,  100.0
    Houdini 4 STD B x64               :     50 (  29,  20, 1),  78.0 :  +173.92,  15.14,  100.0
    Fizbo 1.8 BMI2 x64                :     50 (  23,  26, 1),  72.0 :  +200.56,  18.48,  100.0
    GullChess 3.0 BMI2 x64            :     50 (  22,  28, 0),  72.0 :  +213.01,  18.48,  100.0
    Fire 4 x64                        :     50 (  27,  23, 0),  77.0 :  +222.64,  23.80,  100.0
    Equinox 3.30 x64                  :     50 (  25,  24, 1),  74.0 :  +229.21,  23.26,  100.0
    Andscacs 0.872 BMI2 x64           :     50 (  30,  20, 0),  80.0 :  +242.74,  27.68,  100.0
    Critter 1.6a x64                  :     50 (  30,  19, 1),  79.0 :  +249.73,  24.53,  100.0
    Hannibal 1.7 x64                  :     50 (  36,  13, 1),  85.0 :  +264.18,  18.96,  100.0
    Texel 1.06 x64                    :     50 (  35,  15, 0),  85.0 :  +271.68,  30.06,  100.0
    Nirvanachess 2.3 POP x64          :     50 (  28,  22, 0),  78.0 :  +275.50,  25.59,  100.0
    Protector 1.9.0 x64               :     50 (  35,  15, 0),  85.0 :  +287.27,  19.99,  100.0
    Fritz 15 x64                      :     50 (  34,  16, 0),  84.0 :  +291.31,  24.59,  100.0
    Chiron 3 x64                      :     50 (  33,  17, 0),  83.0 :  +303.79,  21.52,  100.0
    iCE 3.0 v658 POP x64              :     50 (  33,  17, 0),  83.0 :  +335.41,  16.90,  100.0

 2) SF 18Sep2016 BMI2 x64     3239.67 :    750 (+426,=315,-9),  77.8 %

    vs.                               :  games (   +,   =, -),   (%) :     Diff,     SD, CFS (%)
    Komodo 10 x64                     :     50 (  14,  31, 5),  59.0 :   +29.98,   9.97,   99.9
    Houdini 4 STD B x64               :     50 (  22,  26, 2),  70.0 :  +163.86,  12.49,  100.0
    Fizbo 1.8 BMI2 x64                :     50 (  26,  23, 1),  75.0 :  +190.51,  17.73,  100.0
    GullChess 3.0 BMI2 x64            :     50 (  23,  27, 0),  73.0 :  +202.96,  16.77,  100.0
    Fire 4 x64                        :     50 (  27,  23, 0),  77.0 :  +212.59,  29.97,  100.0
    Equinox 3.30 x64                  :     50 (  33,  16, 1),  82.0 :  +219.15,  19.74,  100.0
    Andscacs 0.872 BMI2 x64           :     50 (  31,  19, 0),  81.0 :  +232.69,  20.04,  100.0
    Critter 1.6a x64                  :     50 (  26,  24, 0),  76.0 :  +239.67,  31.43,  100.0
    Hannibal 1.7 x64                  :     50 (  32,  18, 0),  82.0 :  +254.13,  19.50,  100.0
    Texel 1.06 x64                    :     50 (  29,  21, 0),  79.0 :  +261.62,  29.69,  100.0
    Nirvanachess 2.3 POP x64          :     50 (  34,  16, 0),  84.0 :  +265.45,  29.64,  100.0
    Protector 1.9.0 x64               :     50 (  32,  18, 0),  82.0 :  +277.22,  22.33,  100.0
    Fritz 15 x64                      :     50 (  31,  19, 0),  81.0 :  +281.26,  29.43,  100.0
    Chiron 3 x64                      :     50 (  33,  17, 0),  83.0 :  +293.73,  28.91,  100.0
    iCE 3.0 v658 POP x64              :     50 (  33,  17, 0),  83.0 :  +325.36,  21.36,  100.0
Thanks for sharing all these games.

Regards,
Carlos
Frank Quisinsky
Posts: 6816
Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 7:16 pm
Location: Gutweiler, Germany
Full name: Frank Quisinsky

Re: Comparsion ... how contempt is working, nice to see!

Post by Frank Quisinsky »

Hi Carlos,

thanks for your stats.
Honestly, I am very chess tired so far and happy if I come from my professional work and can read the stats, so I must not create it.

In my interest is that all the available games on my site will be used from programmers and other people with interest.

Thanks again!
Have a good time ...

Best
Frank

PS: For testing Stockfish and Komodo we need more stronger opponents. But I am sure that in two years 30 engines have more as 2.900 Elo and 20 engines have more as 3.000 Elo ... in comparing to Elo calculations I am using (means if Naum 4.6 have 2.885).