Komodo 11.3.1 vs Houdini 6.03 revisited Contempt -5

[Hurnavich]

Game 48

[pgn][Event "Komodo 11.3.1 C-5 vs Houdini 6.03, Bl"]
[Site "Hurnavich-PC"]
[Date "2018.03.10"]
[Round "48"]
[White "Houdini 6.03 x64 C/0"]
[Black "Komodo 11.3.1 64-bit C-5"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "E21"]
[Annotator "0.07;0.12"]
[PlyCount "117"]
[TimeControl "300+2"]

{AMD Phenom(tm) II X6 1100T Processor 3625 MHz W=23.6 plies; 10,588kN/s; 1,
735,076 TBAs B=25.9 plies; 6,604kN/s; 2,348,613 TBAs} 1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3.
Nf3 b6 4. Nc3 Bb4 {Both last book move} 5. Bd2 {0.07/21 12} O-O {0.12/24 10} 6.
e3 {0.00/22 8} Bxc3 {0.14/25 8 (d5)} 7. Bxc3 {0.03/21 5} Ne4 {0.19/25 10} 8.
Rc1 {0.08/22 6} Nxc3 {0.09/27 29 (d6)} 9. Rxc3 {0.15/23 6} d6 {0.13/27 21} 10.
Bd3 {0.19/23 8} Nd7 {0.17/25 22 (Bb7)} 11. O-O {0.22/22 7} Bb7 {0.14/24 8} 12.
d5 {0.21/22 11 (e4)} a5 {0.00/24 7 (Rc8)} 13. e4 {0.29/21 7} e5 {0.10/25 12}
14. Bc2 {0.29/21 12 (Nd2)} Nc5 {0.07/25 13 (Rc8)} 15. Nd2 {0.33/23 8 (Qe2)} Bc8
{0.02/27 11} 16. Qe2 {0.11/24 21} Qh4 {0.00/26 7 (Bd7)} 17. b3 {0.13/24 14 (h3)
} Nd7 {0.02/27 28 (f5)} 18. Re3 {0.14/24 16 (Qe3)} Qh6 {0.00/30 5} 19. Rh3 {0.
17/24 23 (Bd1)} Qf4 {0.00/33 5} 20. g3 {0.12/26 24 (Rf3)} Qg5 {-0.11/25 6} 21.
Qe1 {0.31/21 8 (Re1)} h6 {-0.28/24 7 (Nc5)} 22. Kh1 {0.52/20 4 (Nb1)} Bb7 {-0.
07/24 12 (Qd8)} 23. f4 {0.59/22 7} Qe7 {0.00/23 9} 24. f5 {0.70/22 8 (Nf3)} c6
{0.08/22 6} 25. g4 {0.46/22 13} Rac8 {0.03/24 15 (f6)} 26. g5 {1.52/21 4 (dxc6)
} hxg5 {1.44/26 39 (Qxg5)} 27. Qe2 {1.29/25 13} g6 {1.45/24 7} 28. Qg2 {1.66/
25 10} Kg7 {1.23/25 4} 29. Nf3 {1.26/26 12} Rh8 {1.27/26 6} 30. fxg6 {1.30/23
1 (Nxg5)} Rxh3 {1.47/25 7} 31. Nxg5 {1.51/25 4} Nf6 {1.34/26 5} 32. Qxh3 {1.44/
26 12} Rh8 {1.31/25 4} 33. Qg2 {1.20/21 1} fxg6 {1.38/26 5} 34. Ne6+ {1.58/23 5
} Kf7 {1.19/26 5} 35. Bd1 {1.58/23 0} Bc8 {1.38/26 4} 36. Bg4 {1.59/26 5} Ke8 {
1.33/26 4} 37. Bh3 {1.59/26 7} Qf7 {1.30/25 5} 38. dxc6 {1.61/26 6 (Qf2)} Ke7 {
1.42/26 3} 39. Ng5 {1.72/27 5} Bxh3 {1.45/27 2} 40. Qf3 {1.55/29 11} Qf8 {1.59/
27 4 (Qg7)} 41. Nxh3 {1.79/27 3} Ne8 {1.62/27 4} 42. Qxf8+ {1.97/26 3} Rxf8 {
1.73/29 4} 43. Rxf8 {2.10/28 3} Kxf8 {1.75/28 2} 44. Ng5 {2.14/26 1} Ke7 {1.78/
30 3} 45. Kg2 {2.24/27 5} Nc7 {2.17/29 9 (Kd8)} 46. Nf3 {2.32/28 5} b5 {2.29/
27 2} 47. cxb5 {2.53/25 3} Nxb5 {2.39/27 2} 48. Nh4 {2.67/26 4} Kf7 {2.62/26 5
(Kf6)} 49. Kf2 {2.84/24 3} Nc7 {2.65/27 3 (Kf6)} 50. Ke3 {3.13/25 3} Nb5 {3.33/
25 8 (Ne6)} 51. a4 {3.97/24 3 (h3)} Nc7 {3.85/27 2} 52. Kd3 {4.27/23 3} g5 {4.
30/27 2 (d5)} 53. Nf3 {4.74/22 3 (Ng2)} g4 {3.83/23 2} 54. Nd2 {5.27/23 3 (Nh4)
} Ke7 {3.92/25 2} 55. Nc4 {6.18/21 3} Kd8 {4.58/27 3 (d5)} 56. Nxd6 {7.65/21 3
(Nxa5)} Ne6 {6.72/24 2} 57. Nb7+ {7.82/19 2} Kc7 {8.14/24 2 (Kc8)} 58. Nxa5 {
14.63/20 7} Nc5+ {8.95/25 2} 59. Kc4 {15.86/19 1} 1-0[/pgn]

[Hurnavich]

Game 49

[pgn][Event "Komodo 11.3.1 C-5 vs Houdini 6.03, Bl"]
[Site "Hurnavich-PC"]
[Date "2018.03.10"]
[Round "49"]
[White "Komodo 11.3.1 64-bit C-5"]
[Black "Houdini 6.03 x64 C/0"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A42"]
[Annotator "0.38;0.39"]
[PlyCount "200"]
[TimeControl "300+2"]

{AMD Phenom(tm) II X6 1100T Processor 3625 MHz W=30.3 plies; 7,304kN/s; 18,
466,596 TBAs B=27.0 plies; 10,862kN/s; 7,895,860 TBAs} 1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3.
Nc3 Bg7 4. Nf3 d6 {Both last book move} 5. e4 {0.38/25 18} Bg4 {0.39/24 12
(Nbd7)} 6. Be3 {0.45/26 19 (Be2)} Nc6 {0.29/23 6 (0-0)} 7. Be2 {0.29/25 12}
Bxf3 {0.31/24 8 (e5)} 8. Bxf3 {0.38/27 10} e5 {0.29/25 6} 9. d5 {0.35/27 11}
Nd4 {0.30/25 7} 10. Bxd4 {0.40/26 10} exd4 {0.27/25 14} 11. Qxd4 {0.29/26 11}
O-O {0.31/24 9} 12. Qe3 {0.42/27 28} a6 {0.34/24 15 (Nd7)} 13. O-O {0.39/24 8}
Re8 {0.29/22 14} 14. Rac1 {0.40/24 14} Qb8 {0.40/22 20 (Re7)} 15. Rc2 {0.39/25
15 (b3)} Nd7 {0.48/24 33} 16. a3 {0.51/25 17 (Bg4)} Re7 {0.47/22 29 (Qa7)} 17.
g3 {0.60/24 7} Qf8 {0.47/22 11} 18. Bg2 {0.60/24 6 (b4)} f5 {0.52/21 12} 19. f4
{0.65/23 11 (b4)} Rae8 {0.41/20 8} 20. c5 {0.58/24 7} Kh8 {0.55/21 10 (Qf6)}
21. Rd1 {0.75/24 7 (b4)} fxe4 {0.31/23 4} 22. cxd6 {0.72/28 21} cxd6 {0.41/22 2
} 23. Bh3 {0.81/24 6} Nc5 {0.52/24 8 (Rc8)} 24. b4 {0.95/24 5} Nd3 {0.68/24 11}
25. Ne2 {0.83/25 6} a5 {0.65/25 21} 26. bxa5 {0.79/24 6} Ra8 {0.66/26 42 (Bf6)}
27. Nc1 {0.87/23 5} Nc5 {0.72/27 6} 28. Nb3 {0.68/24 6} Nxb3 {0.65/25 3} 29.
Qxb3 {0.76/25 6} Qd8 {0.67/24 1} 30. Qb4 {0.82/24 7} Re8 {0.68/25 4} 31. Kg2 {
0.89/26 6 (a6)} Qxa5 {0.52/21 3} 32. Qxd6 {0.69/27 9 (Be6)} Bf8 {0.47/24 4} 33.
Qd7 {0.64/27 7} Qxa3 {0.53/25 4} 34. Bg4 {0.62/26 9} Re7 {0.58/26 9 (h5)} 35.
Qb5 {0.58/27 6} h5 {0.50/23 5} 36. Be2 {0.63/27 5} Qd6 {0.57/25 5} 37. Qb3 {0.
74/27 10} Kh7 {0.58/24 6} 38. Rc4 {0.50/27 5} Ra3 {0.57/22 1} 39. Qc2 {0.57/27
8} Ra5 {0.59/25 4} 40. Qd2 {0.53/24 4 (Rxe4)} Ra8 {0.45/20 2} 41. Rb4 {0.57/24
5} Bg7 {0.53/22 5} 42. Rb5 {0.59/24 4} Rc8 {0.62/24 5} 43. Qb4 {0.56/25 4} Qxb4
{0.55/23 1} 44. Rxb4 {0.57/27 4} Rc2 {0.50/23 2 (Bf8)} 45. d6 {0.59/28 4} Rd7 {
0.50/22 0} 46. Rxe4 {0.58/30 3} Bf8 {0.49/24 3} 47. Kh3 {0.58/30 4} Rc6 {0.69/
21 2} 48. Rb1 {0.58/30 3 (Rf1)} Rcxd6 {0.50/25 2} 49. Reb4 {0.59/30 2} Kh6 {0.
51/27 3 (Rd2)} 50. Rxb7 {0.58/32 3} Rxb7 {0.51/26 1} 51. Rxb7 {0.59/32 4} Rd2 {
0.51/27 7} 52. Bf3 {0.59/32 2} Rd3 {0.52/28 4} 53. Be4 {0.58/30 3} Rd4 {0.52/
26 0} 54. Bg2 {0.58/31 5} Bc5 {0.52/27 3 (Bd6)} 55. Rb8 {0.59/29 2} Rd2 {0.52/
26 3 (Bd6)} 56. Rc8 {0.55/28 3} Bd6 {0.52/26 3 (Bd4)} 57. Rg8 {0.58/29 3 (Be4)}
Rd4 {0.52/27 2 (Kh7)} 58. Bc6 {0.58/32 3 (Rh8+)} Be7 {0.47/26 2 (Kh7)} 59. Re8
{0.57/30 3} Bf6 {0.46/20 0} 60. Be4 {0.57/30 2} Kg7 {0.46/26 4} 61. Bc2 {0.50/
30 10 (Bb1)} h4 {0.38/27 7 (Rd2)} 62. Re6 {0.39/24 2} Kf7 {0.21/20 1} 63. Bb3 {
0.36/25 2} Kg7 {0.12/19 0} 64. Re8 {0.27/25 2} Rb4 {0.23/22 5 (Rd8)} 65. Rg8+ {
0.71/27 1 (Bd5)} Kh7 {0.41/23 0} 66. Rf8 {0.72/29 2 (Ba2)} Rxb3 {0.62/29 5
(hxg3)} 67. Rxf6 {0.68/35 2} hxg3 {0.62/31 0 (Kg7)} 68. hxg3 {0.68/40 2} Kg7 {
0.62/34 2} 69. Re6 {0.62/36 2} Rf3 {0.62/34 2 (Rb4)} 70. Kh4 {0.63/38 2 (Kg2)}
Ra3 {0.62/37 3 (Kh6)} 71. g4 {0.56/39 5} Ra2 {0.62/35 2 (Ra4)} 72. g5 {0.75/38
1 (Re5)} Ra1 {0.32/29 1} 73. Re7+ {0.75/38 1} Kf8 {0.32/31 1} 74. Rd7 {0.61/38
3 (Rb7)} Rh1+ {0.32/34 2} 75. Kg3 {0.56/37 1} Rg1+ {0.32/34 2} 76. Kf2 {0.56/
36 1} Rb1 {0.32/31 1} 77. Kf3 {0.50/37 2 (Rd8+)} Rb3+ {0.32/29 3 (Re1)} 78. Ke4
{0.50/37 1} Rb4+ {0.32/29 1} 79. Ke5 {0.50/37 1 (Rd4)} Rb5+ {0.32/28 5 (Rb1)}
80. Rd5 {0.44/38 2 (Ke6)} Rb7 {0.32/27 3 (Rb1)} 81. Rd1 {0.44/39 2 (Rd6)} Kg7 {
0.32/27 2 (Rb4)} 82. Ke4 {0.43/37 1 (Rd3)} Rb4+ {0.32/26 2 (Rb3)} 83. Kf3 {0.
38/40 2 (Rd4)} Rb2 {0.31/26 2 (Ra4)} 84. Rd7+ {0.39/35 1 (Kg4)} Kg8 {0.31/27 2
(Kf8)} 85. Rc7 {0.39/35 1 (Rd3)} Rb3+ {0.31/20 1 (Kf8)} 86. Ke4 {0.38/35 2
(Kg4)} Rb4+ {0.27/22 2} 87. Ke3 {0.27/36 3} Rb3+ {0.21/21 2} 88. Ke4 {0.27/36
2 (Kd4)} Rb4+ {0.00/99 0} 89. Ke5 {0.26/36 2} Rb5+ {0.11/21 3} 90. Ke6 {0.26/
35 1 (Kd4)} Rb8 {0.09/26 2 (Rb1)} 91. Rc1 {0.26/38 2 (Rc4)} Kg7 {0.00/27 1
(Kf8)} 92. Kd5 {0.26/37 1} Rd8+ {0.08/29 2 (Rb4)} 93. Ke4 {0.18/38 4} Rb8 {0.
07/30 2 (Re8+)} 94. Kf3 {0.18/36 2 (Rc4)} Rb3+ {0.00/32 3 (Rb4)} 95. Kg4 {0.18/
40 1} Rb8 {0.00/36 2 (Rb4)} 96. Rc7+ {0.17/35 2} Kg8 {0.00/37 0 (Kf8)} 97. Kg3
{0.17/36 2 (Re7)} Rb3+ {0.00/39 3 (Rb4)} 98. Kg2 {0.13/35 2 (Kh4)} Rb1 {0.00/
40 2 (Rb4)} 99. Rd7 {0.12/36 1 (Kg3)} Rb8 {0.00/38 3 (Kf8)} 100. Kg3 {0.11/36
2 (Rd3)} Rb3+ {0.00/40 2 (Rb1) Draw accepted} 1/2-1/2[/pgn]

[Hurnavich]

Game 50

[pgn][Event "Komodo 11.3.1 C-5 vs Houdini 6.03, Bl"]
[Site "Hurnavich-PC"]
[Date "2018.03.10"]
[Round "50"]
[White "Houdini 6.03 x64 C/0"]
[Black "Komodo 11.3.1 64-bit C-5"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "E91"]
[Annotator "0.42;0.43"]
[PlyCount "121"]
[TimeControl "300+2"]

{AMD Phenom(tm) II X6 1100T Processor 3625 MHz W=22.4 plies; 11,277kN/s; 190,
822 TBAs B=24.4 plies; 6,955kN/s; 91,228 TBAs} 1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 Bg7
4. Nf3 d6 {Both last book move} 5. e4 {0.42/23 14} Bg4 {0.43/25 10 (0-0)} 6.
Be2 {0.67/22 5} O-O {0.47/27 20 (Nfd7)} 7. O-O {0.48/24 25 (Be3)} Nfd7 {0.49/
27 11 (Bxf3)} 8. Be3 {0.43/21 2} c5 {0.55/27 15 (Nc6)} 9. d5 {0.82/19 4} Nb6 {
0.62/26 14} 10. Ng5 {1.02/21 5} Bxe2 {0.66/25 11} 11. Qxe2 {1.02/22 11} h6 {0.
68/24 10} 12. Nh3 {0.93/22 11 (Nf3)} N8d7 {0.67/24 8 (Qe8)} 13. Rac1 {0.99/22 5
} a6 {0.69/24 16} 14. f4 {0.83/19 4} Qc7 {0.77/25 13 (Rb8)} 15. b3 {1.09/20 5
(Nf2)} Rac8 {0.80/25 20 (Rae8)} 16. Rf3 {1.39/19 9 (f5)} Rce8 {0.98/24 13 (Rb8)
} 17. f5 {1.50/24 10 (Nf2)} Ne5 {1.14/26 18} 18. Rg3 {1.42/25 12} Nbd7 {1.14/
27 8} 19. Nf4 {1.42/25 9 (Qd2)} g5 {1.15/25 4 (Kh7)} 20. Nh5 {1.70/21 6} Kh7 {
1.21/26 5 (f6)} 21. Nxg7 {2.48/24 7 (Rh3)} Kxg7 {2.44/26 7} 22. Bxg5 {2.58/25 5
} hxg5 {2.48/28 11} 23. Rxg5+ {2.62/25 7} Kf6 {2.47/26 7} 24. Qe3 {2.73/24 7}
Rh8 {2.40/27 9} 25. Ne2 {2.73/23 0} e6 {2.32/25 7 (Qc8)} 26. fxe6 {2.51/25 20}
Ke7 {2.36/25 10} 27. Rf1 {2.86/24 6} Reg8 {2.41/25 6} 28. exd7 {2.77/25 13
(Qf4)} Qa5 {2.26/23 4} 29. Ng3 {3.03/22 5 (a4)} Kxd7 {2.51/26 8} 30. Rxe5 {3.
03/21 0 (a4)} dxe5 {2.93/25 8} 31. Rxf7+ {3.28/23 6} Kc8 {3.12/26 6} 32. Rf2 {
3.19/24 26} Kb8 {3.13/27 5} 33. h3 {3.36/23 9 (Nf5)} Qd8 {2.89/25 6} 34. Kh2 {
3.27/26 9} b6 {3.25/24 9} 35. Qc3 {3.61/23 4 (Nf5)} Re8 {3.30/25 9 (Qd6)} 36.
Nf5 {3.78/22 4} Rh7 {3.46/24 10 (Qf6)} 37. Rf3 {3.82/24 6 (d6)} Qf6 {3.38/22 5
(Ka8)} 38. g4 {3.88/23 8 (Rg3)} Reh8 {3.41/25 14 (Qg5)} 39. Rg3 {3.94/24 8
(Qd2)} Qg5 {3.35/24 4} 40. Qe3 {3.97/27 6} Qg6 {3.60/24 3} 41. g5 {4.01/23 2}
Ka7 {3.76/25 10} 42. Qc3 {4.14/23 4 (Kg2)} a5 {3.83/25 3 (Ka8)} 43. Kg2 {4.16/
25 5} Rf7 {3.83/27 4 (Re8)} 44. Qxe5 {4.53/25 8 (Qd3)} Qh5 {3.16/22 3} 45. Qf4
{4.73/23 3 (Kh2)} Qe2+ {3.76/22 4} 46. Kh1 {4.92/24 4} Qxa2 {3.98/22 4 (Re8)}
47. g6 {5.21/20 3} Rf6 {4.05/23 9 (Rb7)} 48. g7 {5.63/21 5 (h4)} Rg8 {3.85/11 2
} 49. h4 {5.92/20 6} Qa1+ {4.26/23 3} 50. Rg1 {6.43/20 3} Qc3 {4.69/25 3 (Qa2)}
51. Qc7+ {6.31/23 11 (Qg3)} Ka6 {4.89/24 2} 52. Qg3 {6.49/21 4} Qc2 {4.90/25 3}
53. Qf3 {6.74/22 3} Rf7 {5.32/24 7 (Qb2)} 54. h5 {7.14/21 4} Rf6 {5.91/23 5}
55. Rg2 {7.34/21 3 (d6)} Qc1+ {5.83/24 4 (Qb1+)} 56. Kh2 {7.69/19 3} Rf7 {6.10/
24 1 (Ka7)} 57. Qg4 {7.69/21 4} Ka7 {6.06/22 2 (a4)} 58. Qg5 {8.27/20 4} Qb1 {
6.56/22 2} 59. Qe3 {8.27/19 0} Rgxg7 {6.87/22 2} 60. Nxg7 {8.92/20 3} Rf1 {7.
00/22 2} 61. h6 {8.92/19 0} 1-0[/pgn]

[Hurnavich]

{Previous match result both engines contempt 0

Match win to Houdini 6.03

W+9/=38/-3} [42elo difference]

present match contempt 0 for Houdini contempt -5 for Komodo

Match win to Houdini 6.03

Houdini 6.03 W+9/D=36/L-5 [28elo difference]

Improvement for Komodo at -5 contempt against Houdini.

[Nordlandia]

Do you consider conducting similar match with higher contempt value?

Is -8 or -10 possible?

[Hurnavich]

Hi, i will think about it

[fauzi]

Thank you for the games Hurnavich,
can you please post a single pgn file for all the games also here?
Again thanks