Keep it in the Family

Spacious_Mind · Post by **Spacious_Mind** » Fri Feb 12, 2010 1:32 am

I recently played another 5 ply test This time comparing Strelka 3_R with all the Ippolit derivates. I also added Komodo 1.0, Doch13-ja and Stockfish-163-32-ja in order to get little bit of comparison going between some of the other current top amateur engines in the world.

Thanks to Yuri Osipov's correction for proper PLY evaluation with Strelka, I thought this might also be interesting for an idea of Rybka's true strength at 5 Ply (assuming no further enhancements/changes were made by Yuri)

Each engine played each other 20 times for a total combined games of 3800.

Code: Select all

Keep it in the Family Test - Another 5 PLY Test

    Engine                Score      %		S-B
01: Strelka3_R            253.5/380  66.7	47132.
02: Ippolit               199.0/380  52.3	37583.
03: Igorrit_0086v         198.0/380  52.1	37219.
04: FireBird 1.0 beta w32 196.0/380  51.5	36882.
05: Igorrit_0086v2        192.5/380  50.6	36106.
06: IvanHoe_v81_w32       192.5/380  50.6	36093.
07: IvanHoe999970         192.0/380  50.5	36260.
08: Igorrit_0086v_Plus    192.0/380  50.5	35975.
09: RobboLito_0085g3_w32  191.5/380  50.3	35987.
10: Tankist 1.2 32-bit    191.5/380  50.3	35945.
11: FireBird_101_w32      190.5/380  50.1	35869.
12: Igorrit_0086v9_w32    190.0/380  50.0	35941.
13: FireBird_10_w32       187.0/380  49.2	35550.
14: Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 184.5/380  48.5	34707.
15: RobboLito_0085e1_w32  183.5/380  48.2	34631.
16: IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR    182.0/380  47.8	34491.
17: IvanHoe_v73_w32       182.0/380  47.8	34421.
18: Doch13-ja             179.5/380  47.2	33635.
19: Komodo-10-32-ja       171.0/380  45.0	32475.
20: Stockfish-163-32-ja   151.5/380  39.8	28691.


3800 games played / Tournament finished

Surprisingly, at least for me, Strelka 3_R ended up about 100 ELO's +/- 29 stronger at 5 PLY than second placed Ippolit and about 200 ELO Stronger than last placed Stockfish.

However in the head to head matches, Ippolit was the only engine that out performed Strelka.

Here are all the individual results:

Code: Select all

-----------------Doch13-ja-----------------
Doch13-ja - FireBird 1.0 beta w32             : 10.0/20 8-8-4 (0==0010=1101=0100111)  50%    ±0
Doch13-ja - FireBird_10_w32                   : 10.0/20 9-9-2 (0101000=1011=0110101)  50%    ±0
Doch13-ja - FireBird_101_w32                  : 8.0/20 5-9-6 (=110=001001=00=0==10)  40%   -70
Doch13-ja - Igorrit_0086v                     : 8.5/20 6-9-5 (01011=00=01=1000=01=)  43%   -49
Doch13-ja - Igorrit_0086v_Plus                : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (10=11=1==010===101=0)  55%   +35
Doch13-ja - Igorrit_0086v2                    : 11.0/20 9-7-4 (111==011000010==1101)  55%   +35
Doch13-ja - Igorrit_0086v9_w32                : 11.0/20 9-7-4 (11110==0==1110000101)  55%   +35
Doch13-ja - Ippolit                           : 6.0/20 4-12-4 (1100=01==000100000=0)  30%  -147
Doch13-ja - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR                : 11.0/20 9-7-4 (00010=1=0100=1=11111)  55%   +35
Doch13-ja - IvanHoe_v73_w32                   : 12.0/20 9-5-6 (1=1011=100101011====)  60%   +70
Doch13-ja - IvanHoe_v81_w32                   : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (=1=00111010=0==0100=)  45%   -35
Doch13-ja - IvanHoe999970                     : 9.5/20 6-7-7 (11==1=1010010==0=0=0)  48%   -14
Doch13-ja - Komodo-10-32-ja                   : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (10==1=0=10=10101000=)  45%   -35
Doch13-ja - RobboLito_0085e1_w32              : 12.0/20 10-6-4 (11=01001=111=11010=0)  60%   +70
Doch13-ja - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32             : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (=0111000=0010=10===1)  45%   -35
Doch13-ja - RobboLito_0085g3_w32              : 7.5/20 4-9-7 (=010=101==00=0001==0)  38%   -85
Doch13-ja - Stockfish-163-32-ja               : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (101=1=11=101=01=0101)  63%   +92
Doch13-ja - Strelka3_R                        : 3.5/20 2-15-3 (10=00000000000=010=0)  18%  -263
Doch13-ja - Tankist 1.2 32-bit                : 9.0/20 7-9-4 (1=1110100110=00000==)  45%   -35


-----------------FireBird 1.0 beta w32-----------------
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Doch13-ja             : 10.0/20 8-8-4 (1==1101=0010=1011000)  50%    ±0
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - FireBird_10_w32       : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (1===001=0=10=1=0===1)  50%    ±0
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - FireBird_101_w32      : 12.0/20 9-5-6 (=0=10=001=111=1=0111)  60%   +70
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Igorrit_0086v         : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (1=0=0=10000101111==0)  48%   -14
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus    : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (01111011001==10==11=)  63%   +92
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Igorrit_0086v2        : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (=001=101100==010=01=)  45%   -35
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32    : 9.0/20 4-6-10 (0====01=0=1=00=0=11=)  45%   -35
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Ippolit               : 11.5/20 9-6-5 (10=0011=10=1010=111=)  58%   +56
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR    : 12.0/20 8-4-8 (0=01=101==11=11==1=0)  60%   +70
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - IvanHoe_v73_w32       : 11.5/20 7-4-9 (==111011===1=010=0==)  58%   +56
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - IvanHoe_v81_w32       : 10.0/20 7-7-6 (0=0011011==1=00=0=11)  50%    ±0
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - IvanHoe999970         : 10.5/20 5-4-11 (==1=001=1=0011======)  53%   +21
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Komodo-10-32-ja       : 10.5/20 7-6-7 (100=1=1100=01==110==)  53%   +21
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32  : 12.0/20 9-5-6 (00=110==1=1011=1=110)  60%   +70
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 : 11.0/20 5-3-12 (=11====11==0==0==10=)  55%   +35
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32  : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (1===001=011=10=011==)  55%   +35
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja   : 10.0/20 8-8-4 (0010000=1=111001=11=)  50%    ±0
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Strelka3_R            : 6.0/20 2-10-8 (0=0==010000==10=00==)  30%  -147
FireBird 1.0 beta w32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit    : 8.0/20 3-7-10 (01=1==10====0=0=000=)  40%   -70


-----------------FireBird_10_w32-----------------
FireBird_10_w32 - Doch13-ja                   : 10.0/20 9-9-2 (1010111=0100=1001010)  50%    ±0
FireBird_10_w32 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32       : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (0===110=1=01=0=1===0)  50%    ±0
FireBird_10_w32 - FireBird_101_w32            : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (1=011110=011==10=101)  63%   +92
FireBird_10_w32 - Igorrit_0086v               : 6.5/20 2-9-9 (=000===0=1==000=01=0)  33%  -123
FireBird_10_w32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus          : 7.5/20 2-7-11 (=0===0=01=00==0===01)  38%   -85
FireBird_10_w32 - Igorrit_0086v2              : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (=0=0=1==0110==10===1)  50%    ±0
FireBird_10_w32 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32          : 11.5/20 5-2-13 (001===1=1=1==1======)  58%   +56
FireBird_10_w32 - Ippolit                     : 14.5/20 11-2-7 (=1==111011=1011===11)  73%  +173
FireBird_10_w32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR          : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (1100==0==0010=1=0==1)  45%   -35
FireBird_10_w32 - IvanHoe_v73_w32             : 12.0/20 7-3-10 (01=1====1====11010=1)  60%   +70
FireBird_10_w32 - IvanHoe_v81_w32             : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (010==010=01=1==10=1=)  50%    ±0
FireBird_10_w32 - IvanHoe999970               : 8.5/20 3-6-11 (=0===00=0===101==01=)  43%   -49
FireBird_10_w32 - Komodo-10-32-ja             : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (1=110=001=0001=100=1)  48%   -14
FireBird_10_w32 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32        : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (==1==001=1=1=00=10=0)  48%   -14
FireBird_10_w32 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32       : 10.5/20 5-4-11 (==0=0=1=====0=011=11)  53%   +21
FireBird_10_w32 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32        : 7.5/20 3-8-9 (00==10===10000=1==0=)  38%   -85
FireBird_10_w32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja         : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (=00000==0=1=11101011)  48%   -14
FireBird_10_w32 - Strelka3_R                  : 9.5/20 6-7-7 (101===01101=000=0==1)  48%   -14
FireBird_10_w32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit          : 9.0/20 4-6-10 (=110==100===0=0==01=)  45%   -35


-----------------FireBird_101_w32-----------------
FireBird_101_w32 - Doch13-ja                  : 12.0/20 9-5-6 (=001=110110=11=1==01)  60%   +70
FireBird_101_w32 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32      : 8.0/20 5-9-6 (=1=01=110=000=0=1000)  40%   -70
FireBird_101_w32 - FireBird_10_w32            : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (0=100001=100==01=010)  38%   -85
FireBird_101_w32 - Igorrit_0086v              : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (01==110=0==11=1=10=0)  55%   +35
FireBird_101_w32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus         : 10.5/20 7-6-7 (=111==01===01100010=)  53%   +21
FireBird_101_w32 - Igorrit_0086v2             : 10.5/20 7-6-7 (1100=01=101=1====100)  53%   +21
FireBird_101_w32 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32         : 9.0/20 3-5-12 (=0=1=1===1=0==0==0=0)  45%   -35
FireBird_101_w32 - Ippolit                    : 11.5/20 5-2-13 (===1=1=01===11==0===)  58%   +56
FireBird_101_w32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR         : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (==0100=111=1=010===1)  55%   +35
FireBird_101_w32 - IvanHoe_v73_w32            : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (1=001=01==0===0=11=1)  53%   +21
FireBird_101_w32 - IvanHoe_v81_w32            : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (1101==0=1=101==0=10=)  55%   +35
FireBird_101_w32 - IvanHoe999970              : 8.5/20 4-7-9 (=10=0=100==0=0=1=01=)  43%   -49
FireBird_101_w32 - Komodo-10-32-ja            : 10.5/20 9-8-3 (01010===010001111101)  53%   +21
FireBird_101_w32 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32       : 12.5/20 9-4-7 (10=1=01=11101==01==1)  63%   +92
FireBird_101_w32 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32      : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (1=10=01001===01=01==)  50%    ±0
FireBird_101_w32 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32       : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (===00==1=010=11010=1)  50%    ±0
FireBird_101_w32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja        : 13.0/20 10-4-6 (0=11=10==1111=1=1001)  65%  +108
FireBird_101_w32 - Strelka3_R                 : 7.5/20 3-8-9 (=1===10=00=1=0000==0)  38%   -85
FireBird_101_w32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit         : 6.0/20 2-10-8 (=000==10100=000=0===)  30%  -147


-----------------Igorrit_0086v-----------------
Igorrit_0086v - Doch13-ja                     : 11.5/20 9-6-5 (10100=11=10=0111=10=)  58%   +56
Igorrit_0086v - FireBird 1.0 beta w32         : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (0=1=1=01111010000==1)  53%   +21
Igorrit_0086v - FireBird_10_w32               : 13.5/20 9-2-9 (=111===1=0==111=10=1)  68%  +131
Igorrit_0086v - FireBird_101_w32              : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (10==001=1==00=0=01=1)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v - Igorrit_0086v_Plus            : 13.5/20 8-1-11 (1=11=1=111====0==1==)  68%  +131
Igorrit_0086v - Igorrit_0086v2                : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (=11=0100111100=010==)  53%   +21
Igorrit_0086v - Igorrit_0086v9_w32            : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (=0000011==001=1110=1)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v - Ippolit                       : 9.0/20 7-9-4 (=10=0011001=10000=11)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR            : 8.5/20 3-6-11 (0==0==0==11=0==0=0=1)  43%   -49
Igorrit_0086v - IvanHoe_v73_w32               : 9.5/20 3-4-13 (=0=1=0==11==0====0==)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v - IvanHoe_v81_w32               : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (00001101001=00=10===)  38%   -85
Igorrit_0086v - IvanHoe999970                 : 10.0/20 8-8-4 (01100=110010=1110==0)  50%    ±0
Igorrit_0086v - Komodo-10-32-ja               : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (000=10011111==00=10=)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v - RobboLito_0085e1_w32          : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (=====10=10=1=1=10100)  53%   +21
Igorrit_0086v - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32         : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (====10=010101===00=1)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v - RobboLito_0085g3_w32          : 12.5/20 7-2-11 (1===011===1=0==1=11=)  63%   +92
Igorrit_0086v - Stockfish-163-32-ja           : 15.0/20 10-0-10 (=1111==11====1=1=11=)  75%  +191
Igorrit_0086v - Strelka3_R                    : 8.0/20 5-9-6 (0=0100=00001=0===111)  40%   -70
Igorrit_0086v - Tankist 1.2 32-bit            : 10.5/20 7-6-7 (=000==111===111010=0)  53%   +21


-----------------Igorrit_0086v_Plus-----------------
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Doch13-ja                : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (01=00=0==101===010=1)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - FireBird 1.0 beta w32    : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (10000100110==01==00=)  38%   -85
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - FireBird_10_w32          : 12.5/20 7-2-11 (=1===1=10=11==1===10)  63%   +92
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - FireBird_101_w32         : 9.5/20 6-7-7 (=000==10===10011101=)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Igorrit_0086v            : 6.5/20 1-8-11 (0=00=0=000====1==0==)  33%  -123
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Igorrit_0086v2           : 12.5/20 8-3-9 (1===1=1=101==10=110=)  63%   +92
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Igorrit_0086v9_w32       : 8.5/20 2-5-13 (===1===01===000=0===)  43%   -49
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Ippolit                  : 10.0/20 8-8-4 (10001=11=100=01=1010)  50%    ±0
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR       : 12.5/20 9-4-7 (0==11101==010=1=111=)  63%   +92
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - IvanHoe_v73_w32          : 14.0/20 11-3-6 (11=111101==110=1=01=)  70%  +147
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - IvanHoe_v81_w32          : 8.5/20 3-6-11 (=0==0===0==00101=1==)  43%   -49
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - IvanHoe999970            : 14.5/20 10-1-9 (=1=111111=1=01=====1)  73%  +173
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Komodo-10-32-ja          : 7.0/20 6-12-2 (=0000=00011100010101)  35%  -108
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - RobboLito_0085e1_w32     : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (1==0=01101=0=01===1=)  53%   +21
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32    : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (10=11=00=1=0=1110111)  63%   +92
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - RobboLito_0085g3_w32     : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (==101=0010==1===1=00)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Stockfish-163-32-ja      : 14.0/20 13-5-2 (001=11=1101111101011)  70%  +147
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Strelka3_R               : 5.5/20 2-11-7 (10=0=001=0000=0=0=0=)  28%  -164
Igorrit_0086v_Plus - Tankist 1.2 32-bit       : 7.5/20 3-8-9 (1=0==0001===00===010)  38%   -85


-----------------Igorrit_0086v2-----------------
Igorrit_0086v2 - Doch13-ja                    : 9.0/20 7-9-4 (000==100111101==0010)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v2 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32        : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (=110=010011==101=10=)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v2 - FireBird_10_w32              : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (=1=1=0==1001==01===0)  50%    ±0
Igorrit_0086v2 - FireBird_101_w32             : 9.5/20 6-7-7 (0011=10=010=0====011)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v2 - Igorrit_0086v                : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (=00=1011000011=101==)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v2 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus           : 7.5/20 3-8-9 (0===0=0=010==01=001=)  38%   -85
Igorrit_0086v2 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32           : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (01=10=1==1011=001=10)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v2 - Ippolit                      : 11.5/20 8-5-7 (=01=10==01=01==01111)  58%   +56
Igorrit_0086v2 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR           : 9.0/20 4-6-10 (0=01=0====001==1=01=)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v2 - IvanHoe_v73_w32              : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (=1=001011=10=110=0=1)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v2 - IvanHoe_v81_w32              : 9.0/20 4-6-10 (==1=0100=01=00=1====)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v2 - IvanHoe999970                : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (111==001111001==000=)  53%   +21
Igorrit_0086v2 - Komodo-10-32-ja              : 11.5/20 8-5-7 (==11001=10=0110==11=)  58%   +56
Igorrit_0086v2 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32         : 12.0/20 9-5-6 (11=10011=110=10==01=)  60%   +70
Igorrit_0086v2 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32        : 10.5/20 5-4-11 (=0110=0==0===111====)  53%   +21
Igorrit_0086v2 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32         : 8.5/20 3-6-11 (01=1==00=0===1=0==0=)  43%   -49
Igorrit_0086v2 - Stockfish-163-32-ja          : 13.5/20 11-4-5 (1=0=01=110011=11=111)  68%  +131
Igorrit_0086v2 - Strelka3_R                   : 5.5/20 4-13-3 (10=00001010000100=0=)  28%  -164
Igorrit_0086v2 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit           : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (=0111==10=110=100111)  63%   +92


-----------------Igorrit_0086v9_w32-----------------
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Doch13-ja                : 9.0/20 7-9-4 (00001==1==0001111010)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32    : 11.0/20 6-4-10 (1====10=1=0=11=1=00=)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - FireBird_10_w32          : 8.5/20 2-5-13 (110===0=0=0==0======)  43%   -49
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - FireBird_101_w32         : 11.0/20 5-3-12 (=1=0=0===0=1==1==1=1)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Igorrit_0086v            : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (=1111100==110=0001=0)  53%   +21
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus       : 11.5/20 5-2-13 (===0===10===111=1===)  58%   +56
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Igorrit_0086v2           : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (10=01=0==0100=110=01)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Ippolit                  : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (==1100=0=11====10101)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR       : 10.5/20 7-6-7 (=01=1=0=1=0=1100=110)  53%   +21
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - IvanHoe_v73_w32          : 7.5/20 3-8-9 (==000==010=0=0==1=01)  38%   -85
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - IvanHoe_v81_w32          : 11.0/20 6-4-10 (=011==0101===1==10==)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - IvanHoe999970            : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (01=101=10001==0=100=)  45%   -35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Komodo-10-32-ja          : 11.0/20 10-8-2 (00111=001110111100=0)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32     : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (1=1=10=0===0=010=0=1)  48%   -14
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32    : 11.5/20 7-4-9 (=1111=10=00=11=====0)  58%   +56
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32     : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (0=0==011=1011=1==0=1)  55%   +35
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja      : 11.5/20 9-6-5 (1=1==11101=01100100=)  58%   +56
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Strelka3_R               : 8.0/20 4-8-8 (0001===000==1=100==1)  40%   -70
Igorrit_0086v9_w32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit       : 8.0/20 4-8-8 (1=0000=0==101===0=01)  40%   -70


-----------------Ippolit-----------------
Ippolit - Doch13-ja                           : 14.0/20 12-4-4 (0011=10==111011111=1)  70%  +147
Ippolit - FireBird 1.0 beta w32               : 8.5/20 6-9-5 (01=1100=01=0101=000=)  43%   -49
Ippolit - FireBird_10_w32                     : 5.5/20 2-11-7 (=0==000100=0100===00)  28%  -164
Ippolit - FireBird_101_w32                    : 8.5/20 2-5-13 (===0=0=10===00==1===)  43%   -49
Ippolit - Igorrit_0086v                       : 11.0/20 9-7-4 (=01=1100110=01111=00)  55%   +35
Ippolit - Igorrit_0086v_Plus                  : 10.0/20 8-8-4 (01110=00=011=10=0101)  50%    ±0
Ippolit - Igorrit_0086v2                      : 8.5/20 5-8-7 (=10=01==10=10==10000)  43%   -49
Ippolit - Igorrit_0086v9_w32                  : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (==0011=1=00====01010)  45%   -35
Ippolit - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR                  : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (0=0101=10=0==1==01==)  48%   -14
Ippolit - IvanHoe_v73_w32                     : 11.5/20 6-3-11 (1==01=1==1=1=10===0=)  58%   +56
Ippolit - IvanHoe_v81_w32                     : 11.5/20 8-5-7 (=11=10011===10=110=0)  58%   +56
Ippolit - IvanHoe999970                       : 8.0/20 6-10-4 (1=111000=0=0101000=0)  40%   -70
Ippolit - Komodo-10-32-ja                     : 10.0/20 7-7-6 (=10=01=101=01101=00=)  50%    ±0
Ippolit - RobboLito_0085e1_w32                : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (1===0010=11=1==00===)  50%    ±0
Ippolit - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32               : 14.0/20 10-2-8 (11===0==1101=11=1=11)  70%  +147
Ippolit - RobboLito_0085g3_w32                : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (11=0=101=10=01===0=1)  55%   +35
Ippolit - Stockfish-163-32-ja                 : 14.5/20 12-3-5 (111===0101101==11111)  73%  +173
Ippolit - Strelka3_R                          : 11.5/20 9-6-5 (1====1001001=1111001)  58%   +56
Ippolit - Tankist 1.2 32-bit                  : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (101101=10111=0=10==1)  63%   +92


-----------------IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR-----------------
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Doch13-ja                : 9.0/20 7-9-4 (11101=0=1011=0=00000)  45%   -35
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - FireBird 1.0 beta w32    : 8.0/20 4-8-8 (1=10=010==00=00==0=1)  40%   -70
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - FireBird_10_w32          : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (0011==1==1101=0=1==0)  55%   +35
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - FireBird_101_w32         : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (==1011=000=0=101===0)  45%   -35
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Igorrit_0086v            : 11.5/20 6-3-11 (1==1==1==00=1==1=1=0)  58%   +56
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Igorrit_0086v_Plus       : 7.5/20 4-9-7 (1==00010==101=0=000=)  38%   -85
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Igorrit_0086v2           : 11.0/20 6-4-10 (1=10=1====110==0=10=)  55%   +35
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Igorrit_0086v9_w32       : 9.5/20 6-7-7 (=10=0=1=0=1=0011=001)  48%   -14
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Ippolit                  : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (1=1010=01=1==0==10==)  53%   +21
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - IvanHoe_v73_w32          : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (0101===1==0=001110==)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - IvanHoe_v81_w32          : 6.5/20 2-9-9 (0010===00==0=10==0=0)  33%  -123
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - IvanHoe999970            : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (==1=00011=10011====1)  55%   +35
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Komodo-10-32-ja          : 12.0/20 10-6-4 (0=001101111111=0=10=)  60%   +70
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - RobboLito_0085e1_w32     : 8.5/20 5-8-7 (011000=001=1===01=0=)  43%   -49
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32    : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (=000===111=100===10=)  48%   -14
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - RobboLito_0085g3_w32     : 7.5/20 4-9-7 (111=010=00000==0=0==)  38%   -85
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Stockfish-163-32-ja      : 12.0/20 10-6-4 (0=1110100101=01=111=)  60%   +70
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Strelka3_R               : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (=10==101=100=01=1000)  45%   -35
IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR - Tankist 1.2 32-bit       : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (==01=01111=100000=0=)  45%   -35


-----------------IvanHoe_v73_w32-----------------
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Doch13-ja                   : 8.0/20 5-9-6 (0=0100=011010100====)  40%   -70
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32       : 8.5/20 4-7-9 (==000100===0=101=1==)  43%   -49
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - FireBird_10_w32             : 8.0/20 3-7-10 (10=0====0====00101=0)  40%   -70
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - FireBird_101_w32            : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (0=110=10==1===1=00=0)  48%   -14
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Igorrit_0086v               : 10.5/20 4-3-13 (=1=0=1==00==1====1==)  53%   +21
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus          : 6.0/20 3-11-6 (00=000010==001=0=10=)  30%  -147
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Igorrit_0086v2              : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (=0=110100=01=001=1=0)  45%   -35
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32          : 12.5/20 8-3-9 (==111==101=1=1==0=10)  63%   +92
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Ippolit                     : 8.5/20 3-6-11 (0==10=0==0=0=01===1=)  43%   -49
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR          : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (1010===0==1=110001==)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - IvanHoe_v81_w32             : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (010=01=1=0==1===01=1)  53%   +21
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - IvanHoe999970               : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (====1=10=110=0===010)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Komodo-10-32-ja             : 13.5/20 10-3-7 (=1110==111===0=11101)  68%  +131
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32        : 8.5/20 3-6-11 (===010=====001==0=01)  43%   -49
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32       : 13.5/20 9-2-9 (===001111===1=111==1)  68%  +131
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32        : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (1=0==0=1=11==0=101=0)  53%   +21
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja         : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (1=1==1==010===010010)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Strelka3_R                  : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (101000=1=0==1=100000)  38%   -85
IvanHoe_v73_w32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit          : 7.5/20 1-6-13 (==0===0=====0010===0)  38%   -85


-----------------IvanHoe_v81_w32-----------------
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Doch13-ja                   : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (=0=11000101=1==1011=)  55%   +35
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32       : 10.0/20 7-7-6 (1=1100100==0=11=1=00)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - FireBird_10_w32             : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (101==101=10=0==01=0=)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - FireBird_101_w32            : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (0010==1=0=010==1=01=)  45%   -35
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Igorrit_0086v               : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (11110010110=11=01===)  63%   +92
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus          : 11.5/20 6-3-11 (=1==1===1==11010=0==)  58%   +56
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Igorrit_0086v2              : 11.0/20 6-4-10 (==0=1011=10=11=0====)  55%   +35
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32          : 9.0/20 4-6-10 (=100==1010===0==01==)  45%   -35
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Ippolit                     : 8.5/20 5-8-7 (=00=01100===01=001=1)  43%   -49
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR          : 13.5/20 9-2-9 (1101===11==1=01==1=1)  68%  +131
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - IvanHoe_v73_w32             : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (101=10=0=1==0===10=0)  48%   -14
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - IvanHoe999970               : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (=0110100=1=10=01011=)  53%   +21
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Komodo-10-32-ja             : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (1001==101=1==00=1011)  55%   +35
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32        : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (=0001111====0=1=11=0)  55%   +35
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32       : 12.5/20 9-4-7 (01=10=0=11=1=1=11=10)  63%   +92
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32        : 10.5/20 5-4-11 (==0===1011=0==10=1==)  53%   +21
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja         : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (=01001===010===101==)  48%   -14
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Strelka3_R                  : 3.5/20 0-13-7 (=000==0=000000==000=)  18%  -263
IvanHoe_v81_w32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit          : 8.5/20 5-8-7 (1=00=01111=00==000==)  43%   -49


-----------------IvanHoe999970-----------------
IvanHoe999970 - Doch13-ja                     : 10.5/20 7-6-7 (00==0=0101101==1=1=1)  53%   +21
IvanHoe999970 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32         : 9.5/20 4-5-11 (==0=110=0=1100======)  48%   -14
IvanHoe999970 - FireBird_10_w32               : 11.5/20 6-3-11 (=1===11=1===010==10=)  58%   +56
IvanHoe999970 - FireBird_101_w32              : 11.5/20 7-4-9 (=01=1=011==1=1=0=10=)  58%   +56
IvanHoe999970 - Igorrit_0086v                 : 10.0/20 8-8-4 (10011=001101=0001==1)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe999970 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus            : 5.5/20 1-10-9 (=0=000000=0=10=====0)  28%  -164
IvanHoe999970 - Igorrit_0086v2                : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (000==110000110==111=)  48%   -14
IvanHoe999970 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32            : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (10=010=01110==1=011=)  55%   +35
IvanHoe999970 - Ippolit                       : 12.0/20 10-6-4 (0=000111=1=1010111=1)  60%   +70
IvanHoe999970 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR            : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (==0=11100=01100====0)  45%   -35
IvanHoe999970 - IvanHoe_v73_w32               : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (====0=01=001=1===101)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe999970 - IvanHoe_v81_w32               : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (=1001011=0=01=10100=)  48%   -14
IvanHoe999970 - Komodo-10-32-ja               : 12.5/20 8-3-9 (10=1100===1=1=11===1)  63%   +92
IvanHoe999970 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32          : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (=0===0=0=1=1111=0=0=)  50%    ±0
IvanHoe999970 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32         : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (==010====0=101=01=11)  53%   +21
IvanHoe999970 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32          : 8.5/20 6-9-5 (1=000=011=000=10110=)  43%   -49
IvanHoe999970 - Stockfish-163-32-ja           : 13.0/20 10-4-6 (1==10111=01==1=11001)  65%  +108
IvanHoe999970 - Strelka3_R                    : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (1000=0=1000011==11=1)  48%   -14
IvanHoe999970 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit            : 8.5/20 4-7-9 (01==001==0=1=000=1==)  43%   -49


-----------------Komodo-10-32-ja-----------------
Komodo-10-32-ja - Doch13-ja                   : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (01==0=1=01=01010111=)  55%   +35
Komodo-10-32-ja - FireBird 1.0 beta w32       : 9.5/20 6-7-7 (011=0=0011=10==001==)  48%   -14
Komodo-10-32-ja - FireBird_10_w32             : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (0=001=110=1110=011=0)  53%   +21
Komodo-10-32-ja - FireBird_101_w32            : 9.5/20 8-9-3 (10101===101110000010)  48%   -14
Komodo-10-32-ja - Igorrit_0086v               : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (111=01100000==11=01=)  53%   +21
Komodo-10-32-ja - Igorrit_0086v_Plus          : 13.0/20 12-6-2 (=1111=11100011101010)  65%  +108
Komodo-10-32-ja - Igorrit_0086v2              : 8.5/20 5-8-7 (==00110=01=1001==00=)  43%   -49
Komodo-10-32-ja - Igorrit_0086v9_w32          : 9.0/20 8-10-2 (11000=110001000011=1)  45%   -35
Komodo-10-32-ja - Ippolit                     : 10.0/20 7-7-6 (=01=10=010=10010=11=)  50%    ±0
Komodo-10-32-ja - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR          : 8.0/20 6-10-4 (1=110010000000=1=01=)  40%   -70
Komodo-10-32-ja - IvanHoe_v73_w32             : 6.5/20 3-10-7 (=0001==000===1=00010)  33%  -123
Komodo-10-32-ja - IvanHoe_v81_w32             : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (0110==010=0==11=0100)  45%   -35
Komodo-10-32-ja - IvanHoe999970               : 7.5/20 3-8-9 (01=0011===0=0=00===0)  38%   -85
Komodo-10-32-ja - RobboLito_0085e1_w32        : 8.5/20 4-7-9 (=01=0==00=0=0111==0=)  43%   -49
Komodo-10-32-ja - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32       : 7.0/20 3-9-8 (0==0001000===1==0=10)  35%  -108
Komodo-10-32-ja - RobboLito_0085g3_w32        : 5.5/20 2-11-7 (0=0100000=01===0=00=)  28%  -164
Komodo-10-32-ja - Stockfish-163-32-ja         : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (===0111=110000==1==0)  50%    ±0
Komodo-10-32-ja - Strelka3_R                  : 6.0/20 5-13-2 (01010000111000000=0=)  30%  -147
Komodo-10-32-ja - Tankist 1.2 32-bit          : 11.5/20 9-6-5 (=1=10101=1=00011011=)  58%   +56


-----------------RobboLito_0085e1_w32-----------------
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Doch13-ja              : 8.0/20 6-10-4 (00=10110=000=00101=1)  40%   -70
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32  : 8.0/20 5-9-6 (11=001==0=0100=0=001)  40%   -70
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - FireBird_10_w32        : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (==0==110=0=0=11=01=1)  53%   +21
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - FireBird_101_w32       : 7.5/20 4-9-7 (01=0=10=00010==10==0)  38%   -85
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Igorrit_0086v          : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (=====01=01=0=0=01011)  48%   -14
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus     : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (0==1=10010=1=10===0=)  48%   -14
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Igorrit_0086v2         : 8.0/20 5-9-6 (00=01100=001=01==10=)  40%   -70
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32     : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (0=0=01=1===1=101=1=0)  53%   +21
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Ippolit                : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (0===1101=00=0==11===)  50%    ±0
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR     : 11.5/20 8-5-7 (100111=110=0===10=1=)  58%   +56
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - IvanHoe_v73_w32        : 11.5/20 6-3-11 (===101=====110==1=10)  58%   +56
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - IvanHoe_v81_w32        : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (=1110000====1=0=00=1)  45%   -35
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - IvanHoe999970          : 10.0/20 5-5-10 (=1===1=1=0=0000=1=1=)  50%    ±0
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Komodo-10-32-ja        : 11.5/20 7-4-9 (=10=1==11=1=1000==1=)  58%   +56
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32  : 6.0/20 3-11-6 (00=0=10=0000=10=01=0)  30%  -147
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32   : 10.5/20 5-4-11 (==10=01=1=====11=00=)  53%   +21
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja    : 12.0/20 11-7-2 (11=10011101=10110100)  60%   +70
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Strelka3_R             : 7.0/20 4-10-6 (0=00001=1==0==100010)  35%  -108
RobboLito_0085e1_w32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit     : 13.0/20 10-4-6 (=11111=100=1111===00)  65%  +108


-----------------Robbolito_0085f1_IA32-----------------
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Doch13-ja             : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (=1000111=1101=01===0)  55%   +35
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32 : 9.0/20 3-5-12 (=00====00==1==1==01=)  45%   -35
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - FireBird_10_w32       : 9.5/20 4-5-11 (==1=1=0=====1=100=00)  48%   -14
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - FireBird_101_w32      : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (0=01=10110===10=10==)  50%    ±0
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Igorrit_0086v         : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (====01=101010===11=0)  53%   +21
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus    : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (01=00=11=0=1=0001000)  38%   -85
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Igorrit_0086v2        : 9.5/20 4-5-11 (=1001=1==1===000====)  48%   -14
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32    : 8.5/20 4-7-9 (=0000=01=11=00=====1)  43%   -49
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Ippolit               : 6.0/20 2-10-8 (00===1==0010=00=0=00)  30%  -147
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR    : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (=111===000=011===01=)  53%   +21
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - IvanHoe_v73_w32       : 6.5/20 2-9-9 (===110000===0=000==0)  33%  -123
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - IvanHoe_v81_w32       : 7.5/20 4-9-7 (10=01=1=00=0=0=00=01)  38%   -85
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - IvanHoe999970         : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (==101====1=010=10=00)  48%   -14
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Komodo-10-32-ja       : 13.0/20 9-3-8 (1==1110111===0==1=01)  65%  +108
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32  : 14.0/20 11-3-6 (11=1=01=1111=01=10=1)  70%  +147
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - RobboLito_0085g3_w32  : 11.0/20 7-5-8 (==010=11=01100=1===1)  55%   +35
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja   : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (1101==11100=1=1101=0)  63%   +92
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Strelka3_R            : 7.0/20 2-8-10 (00=10=0=0====01=00==)  35%  -108
Robbolito_0085f1_IA32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit    : 11.5/20 7-4-9 (=1==1=1011=1=0001===)  58%   +56


-----------------RobboLito_0085g3_w32-----------------
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Doch13-ja              : 12.5/20 9-4-7 (=101=010==11=1110==1)  63%   +92
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - FireBird 1.0 beta w32  : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (0===110=100=01=100==)  45%   -35
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - FireBird_10_w32        : 12.5/20 8-3-9 (11==01===01111=0==1=)  63%   +92
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - FireBird_101_w32       : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (===11==0=101=00101=0)  50%    ±0
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Igorrit_0086v          : 7.5/20 2-7-11 (0===100===0=1==0=00=)  38%   -85
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Igorrit_0086v_Plus     : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (==010=1101==0===0=11)  53%   +21
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Igorrit_0086v2         : 11.5/20 6-3-11 (10=0==11=1===0=1==1=)  58%   +56
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Igorrit_0086v9_w32     : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (1=1==100=0100=0==1=0)  45%   -35
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Ippolit                : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (00=1=010=01=10===1=0)  45%   -35
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR     : 12.5/20 9-4-7 (000=101=11111==1=1==)  63%   +92
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - IvanHoe_v73_w32        : 9.5/20 5-6-9 (0=1==1=0=00==1=010=1)  48%   -14
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - IvanHoe_v81_w32        : 9.5/20 4-5-11 (==1===0100=1==01=0==)  48%   -14
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - IvanHoe999970          : 11.5/20 9-6-5 (0=111=100=111=01001=)  58%   +56
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Komodo-10-32-ja        : 14.5/20 11-2-7 (1=1011111=10===1=11=)  73%  +173
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - RobboLito_0085e1_w32   : 9.5/20 4-5-11 (==01=10=0=====00=11=)  48%   -14
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32  : 9.0/20 5-7-8 (==101=00=10011=0===0)  45%   -35
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Stockfish-163-32-ja    : 8.5/20 7-10-3 (01=00010010001=011=1)  43%   -49
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Strelka3_R             : 5.5/20 3-12-5 (=00001==0100100=000=)  28%  -164
RobboLito_0085g3_w32 - Tankist 1.2 32-bit     : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (0110=0=01=1==011==0=)  50%    ±0


-----------------Stockfish-163-32-ja-----------------
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Doch13-ja               : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (010=0=00=010=10=1010)  38%   -85
Stockfish-163-32-ja - FireBird 1.0 beta w32   : 10.0/20 8-8-4 (1101111=0=000110=00=)  50%    ±0
Stockfish-163-32-ja - FireBird_10_w32         : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (=11111==1=0=00010100)  53%   +21
Stockfish-163-32-ja - FireBird_101_w32        : 7.0/20 4-10-6 (1=00=01==0000=0=0110)  35%  -108
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Igorrit_0086v           : 5.0/20 0-10-10 (=0000==00====0=0=00=)  25%  -191
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Igorrit_0086v_Plus      : 6.0/20 5-13-2 (110=00=0010000010100)  30%  -147
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Igorrit_0086v2          : 6.5/20 4-11-5 (0=1=10=001100=00=000)  33%  -123
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Igorrit_0086v9_w32      : 8.5/20 6-9-5 (0=0==00010=10011011=)  43%   -49
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Ippolit                 : 5.5/20 3-12-5 (000===1010010==00000)  28%  -164
Stockfish-163-32-ja - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR      : 8.0/20 6-10-4 (1=0001011010=10=000=)  40%   -70
Stockfish-163-32-ja - IvanHoe_v73_w32         : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (0=0==0==101===101101)  50%    ±0
Stockfish-163-32-ja - IvanHoe_v81_w32         : 10.5/20 6-5-9 (=10110===101===010==)  53%   +21
Stockfish-163-32-ja - IvanHoe999970           : 7.0/20 4-10-6 (0==01000=10==0=00110)  35%  -108
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Komodo-10-32-ja         : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (===1000=001111==0==1)  50%    ±0
Stockfish-163-32-ja - RobboLito_0085e1_w32    : 8.0/20 7-11-2 (00=01100010=01001011)  40%   -70
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32   : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (0010==00011=0=0010=1)  38%   -85
Stockfish-163-32-ja - RobboLito_0085g3_w32    : 11.5/20 10-7-3 (10=11101101110=100=0)  58%   +56
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Strelka3_R              : 3.0/20 1-15-4 (=10=0=00000000=00000)  15%  -301
Stockfish-163-32-ja - Tankist 1.2 32-bit      : 9.5/20 8-9-3 (000=0011=1101100=011)  48%   -14


-----------------Strelka3_R-----------------
Strelka3_R - Doch13-ja                        : 16.5/20 15-2-3 (01=11111111111=101=1)  83%  +275
Strelka3_R - FireBird 1.0 beta w32            : 14.0/20 10-2-8 (1=1==101111==01=11==)  70%  +147
Strelka3_R - FireBird_10_w32                  : 10.5/20 7-6-7 (010===10010=111=1==0)  53%   +21
Strelka3_R - FireBird_101_w32                 : 12.5/20 8-3-9 (=0===01=11=0=1111==1)  63%   +92
Strelka3_R - Igorrit_0086v                    : 12.0/20 9-5-6 (1=1011=11110=1===000)  60%   +70
Strelka3_R - Igorrit_0086v_Plus               : 14.5/20 11-2-7 (01=1=110=1111=1=1=1=)  73%  +173
Strelka3_R - Igorrit_0086v2                   : 14.5/20 13-4-3 (01=11110101111011=1=)  73%  +173
Strelka3_R - Igorrit_0086v9_w32               : 12.0/20 8-4-8 (1110===111==0=011==0)  60%   +70
Strelka3_R - Ippolit                          : 8.5/20 6-9-5 (0====0110110=0000110)  43%   -49
Strelka3_R - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR               : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (=01==010=011=10=0111)  55%   +35
Strelka3_R - IvanHoe_v73_w32                  : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (010111=0=1==0=011111)  63%   +92
Strelka3_R - IvanHoe_v81_w32                  : 16.5/20 13-0-7 (=111==1=111111==111=)  83%  +275
Strelka3_R - IvanHoe999970                    : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (0111=1=0111100==00=0)  53%   +21
Strelka3_R - Komodo-10-32-ja                  : 14.0/20 13-5-2 (10101111000111111=1=)  70%  +147
Strelka3_R - RobboLito_0085e1_w32             : 13.0/20 10-4-6 (1=11110=0==1==011101)  65%  +108
Strelka3_R - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32            : 13.0/20 8-2-10 (11=01=1=1====10=11==)  65%  +108
Strelka3_R - RobboLito_0085g3_w32             : 14.5/20 12-3-5 (=11110==1011011=111=)  73%  +173
Strelka3_R - Stockfish-163-32-ja              : 17.0/20 15-1-4 (=01=1=11111111=11111)  85%  +301
Strelka3_R - Tankist 1.2 32-bit               : 16.5/20 14-1-5 (1==11=1111=111=10111)  83%  +275


-----------------Tankist 1.2 32-bit-----------------
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Doch13-ja                : 11.0/20 9-7-4 (0=0001011001=11111==)  55%   +35
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - FireBird 1.0 beta w32    : 12.0/20 7-3-10 (10=0==01====1=1=111=)  60%   +70
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - FireBird_10_w32          : 11.0/20 6-4-10 (=001==011===1=1==10=)  55%   +35
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - FireBird_101_w32         : 14.0/20 10-2-8 (=111==01011=111=1===)  70%  +147
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Igorrit_0086v            : 9.5/20 6-7-7 (=111==000===000101=1)  48%   -14
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Igorrit_0086v_Plus       : 12.5/20 8-3-9 (0=1==1110===11===101)  63%   +92
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Igorrit_0086v2           : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (=1000==01=001=011000)  38%   -85
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Igorrit_0086v9_w32       : 12.0/20 8-4-8 (0=1111=1==010===1=10)  60%   +70
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Ippolit                  : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (010010=01000=1=01==0)  38%   -85
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - IvanHoe_v68_w32_JR       : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (==10=10000=011111=1=)  55%   +35
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - IvanHoe_v73_w32          : 12.5/20 6-1-13 (==1===1=====1101===1)  63%   +92
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - IvanHoe_v81_w32          : 11.5/20 8-5-7 (0=11=10000=11==111==)  58%   +56
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - IvanHoe999970            : 11.5/20 7-4-9 (10==110==1=0=111=0==)  58%   +56
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Komodo-10-32-ja          : 8.5/20 6-9-5 (=0=01010=0=11100100=)  43%   -49
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - RobboLito_0085e1_w32     : 7.0/20 4-10-6 (=00000=011=0000===11)  35%  -108
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Robbolito_0085f1_IA32    : 8.5/20 4-7-9 (=0==0=0100=0=1110===)  43%   -49
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - RobboLito_0085g3_w32     : 10.0/20 6-6-8 (1001=1=10=0==100==1=)  50%    ±0
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Stockfish-163-32-ja      : 10.5/20 9-8-3 (111=1100=0010011=100)  53%   +21
Tankist 1.2 32-bit - Strelka3_R               : 3.5/20 1-14-5 (0==00=0000=000=01000)  18%  -263

Best regards

Nick

gotogo · Post by **gotogo** » Fri Feb 12, 2010 2:49 am

try robbolito 009 it's better than RobboLito_0085g3_w32

yanquis1972 · Post by **yanquis1972** » Fri Feb 12, 2010 2:55 am

very interesting & a good idea for a test, although of course question marks abound. (ie is strelka 3 d5 really equivalent to rybka 'real depth' 5, for one)

i wonder if komodo's low score has to do w/ something either larry or don was saying re the results of an earlier test you ran (komodo vs the doch's), about depth somehow not being equivalent on K compared to doch. why this would be, i'm not sure; perhaps they merely removed some knowledge to speed up search & gain overall strength & covered it with a bit of white lie.

could you run shredder or zappa in a similar tournament, if you have a copy of either? these are both 'slow' knowledge heavy programs which theoretically should perform very well.

Spacious_Mind · Post by **Spacious_Mind** » Fri Feb 12, 2010 3:35 am

gotogo wrote:try robbolito 009 it's better than RobboLito_0085g3_w32

I will have to go find robbolito 009, I do not currently have it. But I suspect that it will also fall somewhere between Ippolit and Ivanhoe v73. All the derivates fall within 5% of each other therefore it will unlikely be different for 009.

If I were to make a guess I would say that so far the differences are just configuration tweaks. Also results in 5 ply most of the time do not show the same results as for example 1 second per move games. I really should do this test again at 1 second per move as a comparison. I wouldn't be surprised though:

1) if the order was totally different,
2) that the derivatives would still perform within 5% of each other meaning within +/- ELO Tolerance.

Best regards

Nick

Spacious_Mind · Post by **Spacious_Mind** » Fri Feb 12, 2010 3:45 am

yanquis1972 wrote:very interesting & a good idea for a test, although of course question marks abound. (ie is strelka 3 d5 really equivalent to rybka 'real depth' 5, for one)

i wonder if komodo's low score has to do w/ something either larry or don was saying re the results of an earlier test you ran (komodo vs the doch's), about depth somehow not being equivalent on K compared to doch. why this would be, i'm not sure; perhaps they merely removed some knowledge to speed up search & gain overall strength & covered it with a bit of white lie.

could you run shredder or zappa in a similar tournament, if you have a copy of either? these are both 'slow' knowledge heavy programs which theoretically should perform very well.

I asked Yuri in the Programmers Forum to confirm if Strelka played Ply correctly and I believe he responded that Strelka did.

I included Doch 13 because of the results of my previous 5 ply test, in order to see if it will again show better results than Komodo, which it did again. I suspect engines are optimized to perform at their best against certain other engines, the results of this may not always mean that they perform their best against all other engines.

I am really a big fan of dedicated computers and old software, therefore I do not keep up with the latest commercial engines... there is a limit to my pocket money

The last Shredder that I have is 10 and Zappa 1.1. I could include them in a future test but I imagine that you are looking for newer versions

Best regards

Nick

Keep it in the Family

Keep it in the Family

Re: Keep it in the Family

Re: Keep it in the Family

Re: Keep it in the Family

Re: Keep it in the Family