Test position rating list

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

Engin
Posts: 1001
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2009 7:40 pm
Location: Germany
Full name: Engin Üstün

Re: Test position rating list

Post by Engin »

filter out of the wrong solutions from all positions and of course doubled positions too.
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: Test position rating list

Post by Vinvin »

Engin wrote:it doesnt matter how easy or hard it is, for weaker engines are even easiers positions hard, of course for top engines easy.

yes the WAC.epd is very easy, but are there all positions easy ?

most of us are using engines for analyse not for playing against them !

so it is very important to have a engine that can solve and find good moves quickly.

what is about BT2830 or STS ? i dont think that is very easy positions.
Here's the wac.epd analyzed by Stockfish_15031208_x64_modern
3 seconds/positions , I7-6*4GHz

Code: Select all

  1) Qg3-g6             a2-a3    
  2) .. Rb3xb2          Kf6-e6   
  3) Re3-g3             Re3-g3  * 0 Seconds
  4) Qh6xh7             Qh6xh7  * 0 Seconds
  5) .. Qc6-c4          Qc6-c4  * 0 Seconds
  6) Rb6-b7             Rb6-b7  * 0 Seconds
  7) .. Ng4-e3          Ng4-e3  * 0 Seconds
  8) Re7-f7             Re7-f7  * 0 Seconds
  9) .. Bd6-h2          Bd6-h2  * 0 Seconds
 10) Rh4xh7             Rh4xh7  * 0 Seconds
 11) Bf3xc6             Bf3xc6  * 0 Seconds
 12) .. Qg4xf3          Qg4xf3  * 0 Seconds
 13) Qf1xf8             Qf1xf8  * 0 Seconds
 14) Qh3xh7             Qh3xh7  * 0 Seconds
 15) Rb8xb7             Rb8xb7  * 0 Seconds
 16) Ne2-c3             Ne2-c3  * 0 Seconds
 17) Nc4-e5             Nc4-e5  * 0 Seconds
 18) Ra8-h8             Ra8-h8  * 0 Seconds
 19) c5-c6              c5-c6   * 0 Seconds
 20) .. Bd7-b5          Bd7-b5  * 0 Seconds
 21) Qd2-h6             Qd2-h6  * 0 Seconds
 22) Bc4-a2, Ng5xf7     Ng5xf7  * 0 Seconds
 23) g2-g4              g2-g4   * 0 Seconds
 24) .. Bg7-d4          Bg7-d4  * 0 Seconds
 25) .. Qg4-h4          Qg4-h4  * 0 Seconds
 26) .. Bd7-f5          Bd7-f5  * 0 Seconds
 27) Qa3-f8             Qa3-f8  * 0 Seconds
 28) .. Qb4-e1          Qb4-e1  * 0 Seconds
 29) c5-c6              c5-c6   * 0 Seconds
 30) Ne4xd6             Ne4xd6  * 0 Seconds
 31) Qb7xa8, d5-d6, d5xe6  d5xe6   * 0 Seconds
 32) Qd1-d8             Qd1-d8  * 0 Seconds
 33) Qe4-e5, Qe4-f4     Qe4-e5  * 0 Seconds
 34) .. Bd4-g1          Bd4-g1  * 0 Seconds
 35) Rh4xh7             Rh4xh7  * 0 Seconds
 36) .. Re7-e1          Re7-e1  * 0 Seconds
 37) .. Nc6xd4          Nc6xd4  * 0 Seconds
 38) Rd2-d8             Rd2-d8  * 0 Seconds
 39) Nc3-a4             Nc3-a4  * 0 Seconds
 40) .. Rd8-c8          Rd8-c8  * 0 Seconds
 41) Kb5-a5, Kb5-c5, b6-b7  Kb5-a5  * 0 Seconds
 42) Bb4-a5             Bb4-a5  * 0 Seconds
 43) Ba3-e7, Qd5xa8     Ba3-e7  * 0 Seconds
 44) .. d5xc4           d5xc4   * 0 Seconds
 45) .. Qf1xa1          Qf1xa1  * 0 Seconds
 46) Nc3-b5             Nc3-b5  * 0 Seconds
 47) .. Nc6xd4          Nc6xd4  * 0 Seconds
 48) .. Rb8-b4          Rb8-b4  * 0 Seconds
 49) Qh5xh7             Qh5xh7  * 0 Seconds
 50) Rb7xb6             Rb7xb6  * 0 Seconds
 51) Rf4-g4             Rf4-g4  * 0 Seconds
 52) Re1-e7             Re1-e7  * 0 Seconds
 53) .. Re3-e1          Re3-e1  * 0 Seconds
 54) .. Qh5-h1          Qh5-h1  * 0 Seconds
 55) Qd4xg7             Qd4xg7  * 0 Seconds
 56) .. Bc5xf2          Bc5xf2  * 0 Seconds
 57) Rf3-f8             Rf3-f8  * 0 Seconds
 58) Qd3-d1             Qd3-d1  * 0 Seconds
 59) Nc3-d5             Nc3-d5  * 0 Seconds
 60) Qh3-h8             Qh3-h8  * 0 Seconds
 61) Qf3-f7             Qf3-f7  * 0 Seconds
 62) .. Rg6xg3          Rg6xg3  * 0 Seconds
 63) Ne5xf7             Ne5xf7  * 0 Seconds
 64) g2-g4              g2-g4   * 0 Seconds
 65) Nd5-e7             Nd5-e7  * 0 Seconds
 66) .. Qc7xe5          Qc7xe5  * 0 Seconds
 67) Re5xd5             Re5xd5  * 0 Seconds
 68) Qe2xe3             Qe2xe3  * 0 Seconds
 69) f2-f3, h2-h3       h2-h3   * 0 Seconds
 70) .. Nb4-a2          Nb4-a2  * 0 Seconds
 71) Nb5xa7             Nb5xa7  * 0 Seconds
 72) e5-e6              e5-e6   * 0 Seconds
 73) Qe2-d2             Qe2-d2  * 0 Seconds
 74) .. Qf4-f1          Qf4-f1  * 0 Seconds
 75) .. Qd7-d6          Qd7-d6  * 0 Seconds
 76) Bg5xf6             Bg5xf6  * 0 Seconds
 77) .. Nf5-g3          Nf5-g3  * 0 Seconds
 78) Ne4-g5             Ne4-g5  * 0 Seconds
 79) .. Qh3xh2          Qh3xh2  * 0 Seconds
 80) Rd1-a1             Rd1-a1  * 0 Seconds
 81) .. Be7-d6          Be7-d6  * 0 Seconds
 82) Be4-h7             Be4-h7  * 0 Seconds
 83) Qd4xd7             Qd4xd7  * 0 Seconds
 84) Qd5-g8             Qd5-g8  * 0 Seconds
 85) Nc5-a6             Nc5-a6  * 0 Seconds
 86) .. Nf6-g4          Nf6-g4  * 0 Seconds
 87) .. Re6xe5          Re6xe5  * 0 Seconds
 88) .. Rg6xg2          Rg6xg2  * 0 Seconds
 89) .. g7-g5           g7-g5   * 0 Seconds
 90) Nf5xg7             Nf5xg7  * 0 Seconds
 91) .. Bb3-e6          Bb3-e6  * 0 Seconds
 92) .. Be6xg4          Be6xg4  * 0 Seconds
 93) Bc1-h6             Bc1-h6  * 0 Seconds
 94) .. e5-e4           e5-e4   * 0 Seconds
 95) Nf6-g4             Nf6-g4  * 0 Seconds
 96) Qh4-d8             Qh4-d8  * 0 Seconds
 97) Qg2-a8             Qg2-a8  * 0 Seconds
 98) .. Nc5xe4          Nc5xe4  * 0 Seconds
 99) Re5-h5             Re5-h5  * 0 Seconds
100) b5-b6              b5-b6   * 0 Seconds
101) .. Bd4-c3          Bd4-c3  * 0 Seconds
102) Qc8xf8             Qc8xf8  * 0 Seconds
103) Qh6xg6             Qh6xg6  * 0 Seconds
104) Qe2xh5             Qe2xh5  * 0 Seconds
105) .. Qh5xh4          Qh5xh4  * 0 Seconds
106) .. Ne4-f2          Ne4-f2  * 0 Seconds
107) Nd4-b5             Nd4-b5  * 0 Seconds
108) Qc5-e5             Qc5-e5  * 0 Seconds
109) .. c4-c3           c4-c3   * 0 Seconds
110) .. Ba7-e3          Ba7-e3  * 0 Seconds
111) .. Qg1-f1          Qg1-f1  * 0 Seconds
112) Re1xe6             Re1xe6  * 0 Seconds
113) .. Qd8xf6          Qd8xf6  * 0 Seconds
114) Bd3xh7             Bd3xh7  * 0 Seconds
115) Ne8-d6             Ne8-d6  * 0 Seconds
116) .. Rd8-d2          Rd8-d2  * 0 Seconds
117) .. Nd6-e4          Nd6-e4  * 0 Seconds
118) Rf4-h4             Rf4-h4  * 0 Seconds
119) .. Qd8xd3          Qd8xd3  * 0 Seconds
120) g5-g6              Rh1-g1   
121) .. Bc6xf3          Bc6xf3  * 0 Seconds
122) .. Rd1xf1          Rd1xf1  * 0 Seconds
123) .. Bb7xd5, Re7-c7  Bb7xd5  * 0 Seconds
124) .. g4-g3           g4-g3   * 0 Seconds
125) .. Bb6xd4          Bb6xd4  * 0 Seconds
126) Rf6xc6             Rf6xc6  * 0 Seconds
127) Rb2xb7             Rb2xb7  * 0 Seconds
128) Qf7-g6             Qf7-g6  * 0 Seconds
129) .. Bb7-f3          Bb7-f3  * 0 Seconds
130) .. Qg7-h6, Qg7-h8  Qg7-h6  * 0 Seconds
131) Re1-e8             Re1-e8  * 0 Seconds
132) .. Re5-e1          Re5-e1  * 0 Seconds
133) Bg3-h4             Bg3-h4  * 0 Seconds
134) .. Rd8-d1          Rd8-d1  * 0 Seconds
135) .. Ne6-d4          Ne6-d4  * 0 Seconds
136) Rc1-c8             Rc1-c8  * 0 Seconds
137) Rd1-d7             Rd1-d7  * 0 Seconds
138) h4-h5              h4-h5   * 0 Seconds
139) Ne4-f6             Ne4-f6  * 0 Seconds
140) Rc3-c7             Rc3-c7  * 0 Seconds
141) Qc1xf4             Qc1xf4  * 0 Seconds
142) Re1-e8, f5-f6      f5-f6   * 0 Seconds
143) Rg6xh6             Rg6xh6  * 0 Seconds
144) .. d4-d3           d4-d3   * 0 Seconds
145) Re1-e8             Re1-e8  * 0 Seconds
146) Bf5-c8, Bf5-d3     Bf5-d3  * 0 Seconds
147) .. Nf6xg4          Nf6xg4  * 0 Seconds
148) Rg1xg7             Rg1xg7  * 0 Seconds
149) .. Be4xg2          Be4xg2  * 0 Seconds
150) .. Bd6-a3, Bd6-f8, e4-e3  e4-e3   * 0 Seconds
151) Na4-c3             Na4-c3  * 0 Seconds
152) Nc3-e4             Nc3-e4  * 0 Seconds
153) .. Nb5xd4          Nb5xd4  * 0 Seconds
154) Qf2xf7             Qf2xf7  * 0 Seconds
155) d5-d6              d5-d6   * 0 Seconds
156) Qh3xh6             Qh3xh6  * 0 Seconds
157) Nd5-e7             Nd5-e7  * 0 Seconds
158) Re7xg7             Re7xg7  * 0 Seconds
159) Ng5-e6             Ng5-e6  * 0 Seconds
160) Qg4xd7             Qg4xd7  * 0 Seconds
161) Qh4xd8             Qh4xd8  * 0 Seconds
162) Bc4-d5             Bc4-d5  * 0 Seconds
163) .. Qf3-g2          Qf3-g2  * 0 Seconds
164) Rc2xc4             Rc2xc4  * 0 Seconds
165) Re3-e2             Re3-e2  * 0 Seconds
166) .. d5-d4           d5-d4   * 0 Seconds
167) .. Rf2xg2          Rf2xg2  * 0 Seconds
168) .. Qd7-d2          Qd7-d2  * 0 Seconds
169) .. Bg7-h6          Bg7-h6  * 0 Seconds
170) Qa2xc4             Qa2xc4  * 0 Seconds
171) Be3-h6             Be3-h6  * 0 Seconds
172) .. Qe5-e1          Qe5-e1  * 0 Seconds
173) Qe3-h6             Qe3-h6  * 0 Seconds
174) .. Nf4xg2          Nf4xg2  * 0 Seconds
175) Nf4-h5             Nf4-h5  * 0 Seconds
176) .. Rh8xh2          Rh8xh2  * 0 Seconds
177) .. Qe7-a3          Qe7-a3  * 0 Seconds
178) Nf4xe6             Nf4xe6  * 0 Seconds
179) .. Qf2-g1          Qf2-g1  * 0 Seconds
180) .. Nf6xd5          Nf6xd5  * 0 Seconds
181) .. Nf6-g4          Nf6-g4  * 0 Seconds
182) Qd1-h5             Qd1-h5  * 0 Seconds
183) Bg5-f6             Bg5-f6  * 0 Seconds
184) Qf6-e7             Qf6-e7  * 0 Seconds
185) Qh5xh7             Qh5xh7  * 0 Seconds
186) Bh6-f8             Bh6-f8  * 0 Seconds
187) .. Nf4-h3          Nf4-h3  * 0 Seconds
188) Qf6-g7             Qf6-g7  * 0 Seconds
189) Re7-e8             Re7-e8  * 0 Seconds
190) .. Bd7-h3          Bd7-h3  * 0 Seconds
191) Qe2-c4             Qe2-c4  * 0 Seconds
192) .. Nb4-d3          Nb4-d3  * 0 Seconds
193) .. Qb3xe3          Qb3xe3  * 0 Seconds
194) Nf5-h6             Nf5-h6  * 0 Seconds
195) g2-g3              g2-g3   * 0 Seconds
196) .. Nc6-b4          Nc6-b4  * 0 Seconds
197) .. Qf2-f1          Qf2-f1  * 0 Seconds
198) .. Rd8-d3          Rd8-d3  * 0 Seconds
199) Bb5xc6, Rf1-d1     Rc1-d1   
200) Bb2xf6             Bb2xf6  * 0 Seconds
201) Ra1-a7             Ra1-a7  * 0 Seconds
202) .. Rc2xa2          Rc2xa2  * 0 Seconds
203) Qg5-h6             Qg5-h6  * 0 Seconds
204) Re1xe5             Re1xe5  * 0 Seconds
205) Qd2xg5             Qd2xg5  * 0 Seconds
206) .. Rd6-c6          Rd6-c6  * 0 Seconds
207) Qg4xg7             Qg4xg7  * 0 Seconds
208) Bh5-f7             Bh5-f7  * 0 Seconds
209) Re1xe5             Re1xe5  * 0 Seconds
210) Rd1-h1             Rd1-h1  * 0 Seconds
211) Qh5xf7             Qh5xf7  * 0 Seconds
212) Qh8xg7             Qh8xg7  * 0 Seconds
213) Rh5xh7             Rh5xh7  * 0 Seconds
214) Ne4-g5             Ne4-g5  * 0 Seconds
215) Qd3-h7             Qd3-h7  * 0 Seconds
216) Ne5xf7             Ne5xf7  * 0 Seconds
217) Qd4-d7             Qd4-d7  * 0 Seconds
218) Bg5-h6             Bg5-h6  * 0 Seconds
219) .. Qf7-f1          Qf7-f1  * 0 Seconds
220) .. Qe2xf1          Qe2xf1  * 0 Seconds
221) Rd1-d8             Rd1-d8  * 0 Seconds
222) Bh4-f6             Bh4-f6  * 0 Seconds
223) Nc3xe4             Nc3xe4  * 0 Seconds
224) .. Rd6-h6, e5-e4   Rd6-h6  * 0 Seconds
225) .. Qe7-h4          Qe7-h4  * 0 Seconds
226) Ne5-f7             Ne5-f7  * 0 Seconds
227) .. d6-d5           d6-d5   * 0 Seconds
228) Bd3xe4             Bd3xe4  * 0 Seconds
229) .. Rh5xh4, b5-b4   Rh5-h8   
230) .. Rb7-b4          Rb7-h7   
231) Bc1-g5             Bc1-g5  * 0 Seconds
232) Qa6-b5, Rb8xe8     Qa6-b5  * 0 Seconds
233) .. Nd4-b3          Nd4-b3  * 0 Seconds
234) Rh3-b3             Rh3-b3  * 0 Seconds
235) Qe6xf7, Re7xf7     Re7xf7  * 0 Seconds
236) .. Rc3-c1          Rc3-c1  * 0 Seconds
237) .. Rc2-c1          Rc2-c1  * 0 Seconds
238) Bg2xb7             Bg2xb7  * 0 Seconds
239) .. Qf2-f1          Qf2-f1  * 0 Seconds
240) Qc2xc6             Qc2xc6  * 0 Seconds
241) Qh3xh7             Qh3xh7  * 0 Seconds
242) Rd1xd7             Rd1xd7  * 0 Seconds
243) Qf2-e2             Qf2-e2  * 1 Second
244) Qe3xc5             Qe3xc5  * 0 Seconds
245) Qd3xg6             Qd3xg6  * 0 Seconds
246) Qg4-h5             Qg4-h5  * 0 Seconds
247) Rb1xb5             Rb1xb5  * 0 Seconds
248) .. Qd6-c5          Qd6-c5  * 0 Seconds
249) c4-c5, d4-d5       d4-d5   * 0 Seconds
250) Re3-e8             Re3-e8  * 0 Seconds
251) Qd4-e5, Qd4-f4     Qd4-e5  * 0 Seconds
252) .. Re8-e2          Re8-e2  * 0 Seconds
253) Qe3-e8             Qe3-e8  * 0 Seconds
254) .. Nf4xh3          Nf4xh3  * 0 Seconds
255) Rf6xg6             Rf6xg6  * 0 Seconds
256) Nd4-f5             Nd4-f5  * 0 Seconds
257) Rd1xd4             Rd1xd4  * 0 Seconds
258) Bh5xg6             Bh5xg6  * 0 Seconds
259) Qd1-h5             Qd1-h5  * 0 Seconds
260) Qd5-e6             Qd5-e6  * 0 Seconds
261) .. Nf3-d4          Nf3-d4  * 0 Seconds
262) .. Rg6-h6          Rg6-h6  * 0 Seconds
263) Qf7-g8             Qf7-g8  * 0 Seconds
264) .. Ra8-b8          Ra8-b8  * 0 Seconds
265) e5xf6              e5xf6   * 0 Seconds
266) .. Rh8xh2          Rh8xh2  * 0 Seconds
267) Nd5-c7             Nd5-c7  * 0 Seconds
268) Re2-e8             Re2-e8  * 0 Seconds
269) a3xb4              a3xb4   * 0 Seconds
270) Qd4-g4             Qd4-g4  * 0 Seconds
271) Re6-d6             Re6-d6  * 0 Seconds
272) Be3xc5             Be3xc5  * 0 Seconds
273) .. Ne4-g3          Rd3-h3   
274) Rg6-b6             Rg6-b6  * 0 Seconds
275) .. Nf4xg2, b7-b5   Nd7-c5   
276) Qd1-d5             Qd1-d5  * 0 Seconds
277) .. Rg8-g3, Rg8xg2  Rg8xg2  * 0 Seconds
278) Bc4-f7             Bc4-f7  * 0 Seconds
279) Ne3xf5             Ne3xf5  * 0 Seconds
280) .. Bf8xa3          Bf8xa3  * 0 Seconds
281) Rc7xh7             Rc7xh7  * 0 Seconds
282) Rh1-h8             Rh1-h8  * 0 Seconds
283) Nh3-g5             Nh3-g5  * 0 Seconds
284) Nd4-f5             Nd4-f5  * 0 Seconds
285) Qg2xg7             Qg2xg7  * 0 Seconds
286) .. Rd8xd5          Rd8xd5  * 0 Seconds
287) Qd1-h5             Qd1-h5  * 0 Seconds
288) Nh5-f6             Nh5-f6  * 0 Seconds
289) .. Qe6-e5          Qe6-e5  * 0 Seconds
290) .. Nf4-e2          Nf4-e2  * 0 Seconds
291) h2-h3              h2-h3   * 0 Seconds
292) d5-d6              d5-d6   * 0 Seconds
293) Nf3-g5             Rf1-b1   
294) Bd6-f8, Nd4-f5, Qg4-f4  Qg4-f4  * 0 Seconds
295) Rd1xd5             Rd1xd5  * 0 Seconds
296) .. Rd8-d4, Rd8-f8  Rd8-d4  * 0 Seconds
297) .. Bc6xg2, Bd6xh2  Bc6xg2  * 0 Seconds
298) Qd8-h8             Qd8-h8  * 0 Seconds
299) Nc5-a4             Nc5-a4  * 0 Seconds
300) g5-g6              g5-g6   * 0 Seconds
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: Test position rating list

Post by Vinvin »

Engin wrote:it doesnt matter how easy or hard it is, for weaker engines are even easiers positions hard, of course for top engines easy.

yes the WAC.epd is very easy, but are there all positions easy ?

most of us are using engines for analyse not for playing against them !

so it is very important to have a engine that can solve and find good moves quickly.

what is about BT2830 or STS ? i dont think that is very easy positions.
BS2830, 15 sec/position by Stockfish_15031208_x64_modern

Code: Select all

  Use seconds per move      : 15 Seconds per move
   Analysis Lines            : Minimum search depth=12
   Activate abort analysis   : False
  1) .. Qd3xf3          Qd3xf3  * 0 Seconds
  2) .. f7-f5           f7-f5   * 3 Seconds
  3) .. Bc8-h3          Bc8-h3  * 1 Second
  4) Nf5-d4             Nf5-d4  * 0 Seconds
  5) Re1xe6             Qg4-h3   
  6) f2-f3              f2-f3   * 0 Seconds
  7) b2-b4              b2-b4   * 2 Seconds
  8) .. Bg4-h5          Bg4-h5  * 0 Seconds
  9) Nc3-b1             Nc3-d1   
 10) Bb4-d2             Bb4-d2  * 3 Seconds
 11) e5xf6              Qa4-b3   
 12) Bc1-b2             Bc1-b2  * 0 Seconds
 13) O-O-O              O-O-O   * 0 Seconds
 14) Ne5xf7             Ne5xf7  * 0 Seconds
 15) Kh2-g3             Qf6-f4   
 16) .. Rd2xb2          Bb6-d8   
 17) Nc5-e6             Nc5-e6  * 9 Seconds
 18) .. g6-g5           Kf3-g4   
 19) Bc3-e1             Bc3-d2   
 20) .. O-O             O-O     * 4 Seconds
 21) Nc3-e4             Nc3-e4  * 0 Seconds
 22) .. Qd8xd3          Bf6-d4   
 23) .. Rf8xf3          Rf8xf3  * 3 Seconds
 24) Kb1-a1             Kb1-a1  * 0 Seconds
 25) .. Ra8-f8          Qc5-e7   
 26) .. Qb7-d5          Qb7-d5  * 0 Seconds
 27) d4-d5              d4-d5   * 5 Seconds
18 of 27 matching moves
18/03/15 23:32:02, Total time: 00:07:12 Rated time: 02:45 = 165 Seconds
SF miss 15) Kh2-g3 and 18) .. g6-g5 other are probably mistakes in the set.
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: Test position rating list

Post by Vinvin »

Vinvin wrote:
Engin wrote:

Code: Select all

...
18 of 27 matching moves
18/03/15 23:32:02, Total time: 00:07:12 Rated time: 02:45 = 165 Seconds
SF miss 15) Kh2-g3 and 18) .. g6-g5 other are probably mistakes in the set.
16) .. Rd2xb2 is the best move too. SF needs between 10 and 20 seconds to find the move.
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: Test position rating list

Post by Vinvin »

Not the "gem13ed" is from here : http://www.stmintz.com/ccc/index.php?id=157815
Dann Corbit wrote:I would like a copy of:
gem13ed.pgn
maxeuwe.pgn

if possible. I seem to be missing those from my collection.
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: Test position rating list

Post by Vinvin »

"Note" instead of "Not" :-)
Vinvin wrote:Not the "gem13ed" is from here : http://www.stmintz.com/ccc/index.php?id=157815
Dann Corbit wrote:I would like a copy of:
gem13ed.pgn
maxeuwe.pgn

if possible. I seem to be missing those from my collection.
IWB
Posts: 1539
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 2:02 pm

Re: Test position rating list

Post by IWB »

Hello Engin,

Are you really sure you want to use a position test to get engine rankings? I know it is tempting to get a fast result, but it is always terribly wrong - sooner or later.

I know you can can read german, have a look here:

http://computerschach.de/Files/2005/Was ... testen.pdf

It is an articel of Lars Bremer and already ~10 years old but it still is very true. Think about it. Whatever test you create today, it might be wrong with the next engine you add ... and then you look at the normal list and adjust your test accordingly ...

Have fun reading it, it is some knd of "satire" as well.

Bye
Ingo