Yes Stockfish played white in all games. I just launched the second match with Komodo as white.hgm wrote:So Stockfish was always playing with white here?
You would have to repeat it with Stockfish playing black, to determine if the results reflect a genuine strength difference between the engines in this end-game, or are due to the initial material imbalance. And it would be better to play them with reversed colors (or with black having the first move) too, to average out the first-move advantage.
After that you could repeat the experiment with equal Pawns, to determine the fraction of a Pawn to which the excess score percentage translates.
I mostly use Fairy-Max self-play for this type of experiments. And I discovered a very funny thing there: having white does not give the same score as having black and the first move. Apart from the first move advantage, Fairy-Max is intrinsically stronger with white than with black! So when I want to test a certain imbalance I typically play both with reversed colors and giving the initial move to the other side. (This helps to get more game diversity as well.) This seems to be a consequence of the direction in which it scans the board to generate moves. I don't expect Stockfish or Komodo to have such an asymmetry, as their move sorting should largely mask it. (Fairy-Max doesn't do any real move sorting.)
Odds setup BB vs NNP
Moderator: Ras
-
Nordlandia
- Posts: 2845
- Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 9:38 pm
- Location: Sortland, Norway
Re: Odds setup BB vs NNP
-
Nordlandia
- Posts: 2845
- Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 9:38 pm
- Location: Sortland, Norway
Re: Odds setup BB vs NNP
Old-Desktop Computer, Blitz 4m+4s 2016
Stockfish White:
1 Stockfish 150216b 64 +244 +121/=79/-0 80.25% 160.5/200
2 Komodo 9.3 64-bit -244 +0/=79/-121 19.75% 39.5/200
Komodo White:
1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit +255 +126/=73/-1 81.25% 162.5/200
2 Stockfish 150216b 64 -255 +1/=73/-126 18.75% 37.5/200
WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S, Blitz 4m+4s 2016
1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit +3 +126/=152/-122 50.50% 202.0/400
2 Stockfish 150216b 64 -3 +122/=152/-126 49.50% 198.0/400
The results is almost identical.
Longest game:
[pgn][Event "WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S, Blitz 4m+4s"]
[Site "WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S"]
[Date "2016.02.22"]
[Round "198"]
[White "Komodo 9.3 64-bit"]
[Black "Stockfish 150216b 64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[Annotator "-0.49;-0.65"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "1n2k1n1/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPP1/2B1KB2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "389"]
[EventDate "2016.??.??"]
[EventType "blitz"]
[TimeControl "240+4"]
{Pentium(R) Dual-Core CPU E5200 @ 2.50GHz 2493 MHz W=28.5 plies; 2 083kN/s;
5 997 772 TBAs B=35.4 plies; 2 636kN/s; 2 185 072 TBAs} 1. e4 {-0.49/20 9}
c5 {-0.65/27 59} 2. f3 {-0.47/21 7 (d3)} (2. d3 Nc6 3. c3 {-0.67/29 Stockfish
5 64 SSE4.2}) 2... Nc6 {-0.74/21 4 (Nf6)} (2... Nf6 3. c3 Nc6 {-0.67/27 Komodo
9.3 64-bit}) 3. b3 {-0.49/21 12 (d3)} (3. a3 e6 4. c3 {-0.66/26 Stockfish 7 64
POPCNT}) 3... e5 {-0.75/22 5 (e6)} (3... Nf6 4. c3 h5 {-0.87/21 Deep Fritz 14
x64}) 4. c3 {-0.45/22 9 (Kf2)} (4. c3 {-0.70/28 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 4...
Nge7 {-0.77/22 11 (d6)} (4... Nf6 5. Ba3 d6 {-0.76/23 Fritz 11 SE}) 5. a3 {
-0.53/22 14 (Kf2)} (5. a3 d6 6. b4 {-0.46/23 Komodo 6 64-bit}) 5... a5 {
-0.77/23 4 (d6)} (5... d5 6. b4 cxb4 {-0.81/24 Deep Fritz 13}) 6. a4 {-0.56/23
21 (Kf2)} (6. Ke2 Kd8 {-0.70/26 Stockfish 7 64}) 6... f6 {-0.77/25 11 (f5)} (
6... h5 7. g3 f6 {-0.62/29 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 7. Bb5 {-0.59/23 13 (Kf2)} (7.
Bc4 h5 8. g3 {-0.77/22 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 7... h5 {-0.79/23 8 (g5)} (7... h5
8. Bc4 b6 {-0.73/31 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 8. Bc4 {-0.66/25 14 (g3)} (8. Kf2 {
-0.70/31 Stockfish 6 64}) 8... b6 {-0.79/26 9 (g5)} (8... Ng6 9. g3 Nf8 {
-0.63/29 Komodo 9.1 32-bit}) 9. Kf2 {-0.71/27 30} (9. Kf2 g5 10. Ba3 {-0.83/32
Stockfish 7 64}) 9... g5 {-0.79/26 5 (Nd8)} 10. g3 {-0.70/25 10} (10. g3 Ng6
11. d3 {-0.91/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 10... Nc8 {-0.83/26 3 (Kf8)} (10... Nd8
11. d3 Ne6 {-0.91/22 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 11. Ba6 {-0.52/23 15 (Be2)} Nd6 {
-0.84/25 5} (11... N8e7 12. Be2 d5 {-0.57/25 Houdini 3 x64}) 12. Be2 {-0.61/23
6 (Bb2)} (12. Be2 Ke7 13. Ba3 {-0.88/34 Stockfish 7 64}) 12... Kf8 {-0.84/26 5
(Kf7)} (12... Kf7 13. d3 Ne8 {-0.68/24 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 13. d3 {-0.61/23
4 (Bb2)} (13. d3 Kg7 14. f4 {-0.65/24 Fritz 13}) 13... Nf7 {-0.89/26 15 (Kf7)}
(13... Kf7 14. Bf1 Kg6 {-0.62/30 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 14. f4 {-0.63/25 13} (14.
f4 g4 15. Ke3 {-0.50/29 Houdini 4 Pro x64}) 14... g4 {-0.90/28 12} (14... g4
15. Bd2 Nfd8 {-0.93/34 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 15. Bf1 {-0.63/28 11 (Bd1)} (15.
Ke3 Ke7 16. Bf1 {-0.65/25 Deep Fritz 13}) 15... Nfd8 {-0.96/28 7 (Ke7)} (15...
Ke7 16. Bg2 d6 {-0.70/23 Deep Fritz 13}) 16. Bg2 {-0.69/26 5 (Ke2)} (16. Ke2
Ne6 17. fxe5 {-0.90/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 16... Ke7 {-0.96/30 4 (Ke8)} (16...
exf4 17. Bxf4 {-0.63/25 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 17. Be3 {-0.68/24 7 (Ke3)} (17. Ke3
Ne6 18. fxe5 {-0.87/43 Stockfish 7}) 17... Ne6 {-0.96/31 15} (17... Ne6 18.
fxe5 fxe5 {-0.87/39 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 18. fxe5 {-0.66/26 4} (18. fxe5
fxe5 19. Bc1 {-0.88/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 18... fxe5 {-0.96/34 4} (18... fxe5
19. Bd2 Kf6 {-0.73/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 19. Bd2 {-0.65/29 6} Kd6 {-0.96/34 3
(Kf6)} (19... Ned8 20. Bf1 Kf6 {-0.70/33 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 20. Be3 {-0.65/29
4 (Ke3)} (20. Bf1 Ncd8 21. Ke2 {-0.86/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 20... Ned8 {
-0.96/38 4 (Ncd8)} (20... Ne7 21. Bf1 Kc7 {-0.84/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 21.
Bd2 {-0.64/28 4 (Bg5)} Ke6 {-0.96/39 4} (21... Ne6 22. Bf1 Ke7 {-0.67/36
Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 22. Be3 {-0.64/27 3} (22. Bf1 Kf6 23. Ke2 {-0.87/27 Deep
Fritz 14 x64}) 22... Kf7 {-0.96/38 4 (Kf6)} (22... Kf7 23. Bg5 Ne6 {-0.83/37
Stockfish 290116 64 BMI2}) 23. Bd2 {-0.65/28 6} (23. Ke1 Ne6 24. Kd2 {-0.87/40
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 23... Kf6 {-0.96/36 1 (Ne6)} (23... Kf6 24. Bf1 Ne6 {
-0.94/48 Stockfish 7 64}) 24. Bf1 {-0.65/29 11 (Be3)} (24. Be3 Ne6 25. Bf1 {
-0.74/42 Stockfish 6 x64}) 24... Ne6 {-0.96/38 9 (Kg6)} (24... Ke6 25. Ke3 Kd6
{-0.50/28 Houdini 3 Pro x64}) 25. Ke3 {-0.67/28 11 (Bg2)} (25. Be3 Nc7 26. Bg2
{-0.77/24 Deep Rybka 4 x64}) 25... Ne7 {-0.96/35 6 (Na7)} 26. Bg2 {-0.67/27 5}
(26. Kf2 Nc6 27. Ke2 {-0.86/42 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 26... Kg5 {-0.96/34 2
(Ng5)} (26... Ng7 27. Kf2 d6 {-0.71/26 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 27. Ke2+ {-0.67/27 9}
(27. Ke2+ Kg6 28. Kf2 {-0.74/34 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 27... Kg6 {-0.96/39 5} (
27... Kf6 28. Be3 Nc6 {0.93/26 Fritz 13}) 28. Kf2 {-0.67/27 5} Kf7 {-0.96/39 6
(Kg7)} (28... Kf6 29. Bf1 Nc6 {-0.86/40 Stockfish 7 64}) 29. Ke2 {-0.70/26 4} (
29. Bf1 Nc6 30. Be2 {-0.86/40 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 29... Nc6 {-0.96/36 3
(Ng6)} (29... Nc6 30. Kf2 d6 {-0.80/39 Stockfish 7 64}) 30. Bf1 {-0.70/27 4
(Kf2)} Kg6 {-0.96/36 15} (30... Kg6 31. Kf2 Ne7 {-0.52/27 Houdini 4 x64A}) 31.
Kf2 {-0.69/28 8 (Ke3)} (31. Kf2 Ng5 32. Bc1 {-0.90/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 31...
Ng5 {-0.96/38 6 (Ncd8)} (31... Ne7 32. Be2 Kf7 {0.48/27 Houdini 3 x64}) 32. Bg2
{-0.70/27 5 (Be3)} (32. Bg2 Kf6 33. Ke3 {-0.76/26 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 32...
Nf7 {-0.96/40 5 (Nd8)} (32... Ne6 33. Bf1 Kf7 {-0.87/45 Stockfish 7 64}) 33.
Bf1 {-0.71/27 4 (Ke3)} (33. Ke3 Kf6 34. Bc1 {-0.86/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 33...
Kf6 {-0.96/42 7} (33... Ne7 34. Bg2 Ng5 {-0.78/29 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 34. Ke3 {
-0.78/28 12 (Bg2)} (34. Ke2 Ncd8 35. Ke3 {-0.86/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 34...
Nd6 {-0.96/40 6 (Ng5)} 35. Bg2 {-0.78/28 5 (Kf2)} (35. Be1 Nf7 36. Bd2 {
-0.74/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 35... Kg5 {-0.96/37 5 (Ke7)} (35... Nf7 36. Kf2
Ng5 {-0.78/37 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 36. Ke2+ {-0.77/32 27 (Kf2+)} (36. Bf1 Kf6
37. Be2 {-0.86/48 Stockfish 7 64}) 36... Kg6 {-0.96/40 6} (36... Kf6 37. Be3
Nf7 {-0.83/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 37. Ke3 {-0.73/30 7 (Kf2)} (37. Bf1 Nd8
38. Kf2 {-0.86/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 37... Nb7 {-0.96/38 6 (Kf6)} (37... Nf7
38. Be1 Ng5 {-0.77/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on
SSD}) 38. Bf1 {-0.73/32 7} (38. Ke2 Nbd8 39. Be3 {-0.90/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64})
38... Kf6 {-0.96/37 3} (38... Nbd8 39. Kf2 Ne6 {-0.65/38 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
39. Kf2 {-0.73/32 10 (Bg2)} (39. Be2 Nbd8 40. Kf2 {-0.85/43 Stockfish 7 64})
39... Kf7 {-0.96/36 5 (Nd6)} (39... Nbd8 40. Bc1 Nf7 {-0.84/26 Deep Fritz 14
x64}) 40. Ke2 {-0.73/31 8 (Be3)} (40. Ke3 Kf6 41. Ke2 {-0.70/37 Komodo 9.3
64-bit}) 40... Nd6 {-0.96/36 5 (Ke6)} (40... Kf6 41. Be3 Nbd8 {-0.67/34 Komodo
9.3 64-bit}) 41. Bg2 {-0.73/32 5} Nc8 {-0.96/36 5 (Ke6)} (41... Ke6 42. Be3 Kf6
{-0.73/27 Komodo 6 64-bit}) 42. Be1 {-0.73/32 4 (Kd1)} Ke7 {-0.96/40 6 (Kf6)}
43. Bd2 {-0.73/33 3} (43. Bd2 Nd6 44. Bf1 {-0.86/46 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
43... Nd6 {-0.96/40 2} (43... Kf6 44. Bf1 Nd8 {-0.49/31 Houdini 3 Pro x64}) 44.
Bg5+ {-0.73/32 6 (Kf2)} Ke6 {-0.96/42 6} (44... Ke6 45. Bf1 Nf7 {-0.87/28
Houdini 3 x64}) 45. Bd2 {-0.73/32 5 (Be3)} (45. Kd1 Nf7 46. Bd2 {-0.78/45
Stockfish 6 64}) 45... Kf7 {-0.96/39 6 (Nf7)} (45... Kf6 46. Ke3 Nf7 {-0.73/27
Komodo 8 64-bit}) 46. Kf2 {-0.73/33 7 (Be3)} (46. Bf1 Kg6 47. Ke3 {-0.94/46
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 46... Nc8 {-0.96/39 4 (Ke7)} (46... Ke6 47. Bf1 Nf7 {
-0.86/47 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 47. Bf1 {-0.73/32 5 (Be3)} (47. Bg5 Kg6 48.
Be3 {-0.54/27 Fritz 11 SE}) 47... Kg6 {-0.96/36 5 (Ke7)} (47... Nd8 48. Bg5 Ne6
{-0.67/34 Komodo 9.3 32-bit}) 48. Be2 {-0.73/32 5 (Be3)} (48. Bg2 Nd6 49. Ke2 {
-0.64/29 Fritz 12}) 48... Nd6 {-0.96/37 4 (Kf6)} 49. Bf1 {-0.73/28 5 (Bd1)} (
49. Ke3 Kf6 50. Bc1 {-0.81/27 Fritz 13}) 49... Kf6 {-0.96/40 5} (49... Kf6 50.
Bc1 Nf7 {-0.84/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 50. Ke2 {-0.74/30 6 (Bg2)} (50. Ke2 Nf7
51. Bg2 {-0.83/24 Deep Fritz 14}) 50... Ne8 {-0.96/37 4 (Nd8)} 51. Ke3 {
-0.74/31 6 (Kf2)} Ke6 {-0.96/38 5 (Ke7)} (51... Kg5 52. Ke2+ Kg6 {-0.77/28
Komodo 8 64-bit}) 52. Bc1 {-0.74/30 9 (Kf2)} (52. Kf2 Kd6 53. Be2 {-0.80/49
Stockfish 7 64}) 52... Nd6 {-0.96/32 11 (Nc7)} (52... Nc7 53. Bg2 Kf6 {-0.84/
27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 53. Bd2 {-0.74/32 7 (Bb2)} Kf7 {-0.96/35 20 (Ke7)} (
53... Kf6 54. Ke2 Nd8 {-0.88/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 54. Be2 {-0.74/29 3} (54.
Bg2 Ke6 55. Bc1 {-0.76/27 Deep Rybka 4 w32}) 54... Kf8 {-0.96/35 7 (Kf6)} (
54... Kf6 55. Kf2 Nf7 {-0.77/27 Komodo 8 32-bit}) 55. Bc1 {-0.74/30 5 (Bd1)} (
55. Bf1 Nf7 56. Ke2 {-0.92/30 Gull 3 x64}) 55... Nb7 {-0.89/32 11 (Ke7)} (55...
Ke7 56. Kf2 Nf7 {-0.89/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 56. Bb2 {-0.74/29 5 (Kf2)} (56.
Bd1 Kf7 57. Ke2 {-0.90/38 Stockfish 4 64}) 56... Kf7 {-0.89/29 7 (Ke7)} (56...
Kf7 57. Bc1 Nbd8 {-0.87/39 Stockfish 7}) 57. Bf1 {-0.74/27 7 (Bc1)} (57. Bf1
Ke6 58. Bg2 {-1.00/26 Fritz 13 SE}) 57... Nbd8 {-0.89/31 16 (Ke6)} (57... Ke6
58. Kf2 d6 {-0.74/24 Deep Rybka 4 x64}) 58. Bc1 {-0.72/27 9} (58. Bc1 Kf6 59.
Be2 {-0.86/42 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 58... Kf6 {-0.89/32 5 (Ne6)} (58... Ke6
59. Bb2 d5 {-0.74/27 Deep Fritz 13}) 59. Bd2 {-0.73/24 1 (Kf2)} (59. Ke2 Ne6
60. Be3 {-0.83/41 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 59... Kg6 {-0.89/30 3 (Ne6)} (59...
Ne6 60. Bc1 Ncd8 {-0.84/24 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 60. Ke2 {-0.62/25 3 (Kf2)} (60.
Be2 Kf6 61. Bf1 {-0.86/43 Stockfish 5 64}) 60... Kf7 {-0.89/32 3 (Kg7)} (60...
Ne6 61. Ke3 Ne7 {-0.86/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 61. Ke3 {-0.61/26 2} (61. Be3 Ne7
62. b4 {-0.89/26 Fritz 13}) 61... Ke7 {-0.89/33 1 (Kg7)} (61... Ne6 62. Bc1 Kg6
{-0.85/26 Deep Fritz 13}) 62. Bg2 {-0.62/27 2 (Bc1)} (62. Ke2 Kd6 63. Be3 {
-0.88/28 Fritz 13}) 62... d6 {-0.89/33 4 (Kf8)} 63. Kf2 {-0.62/28 4 (Ke2)} Kf6
{-0.89/37 3} 64. Be3 {-0.62/27 2} (64. Ke3 Ne7 65. Bf1 {-0.73/25 Komodo 6
64-bit}) 64... Ne6 {-0.89/38 2} (64... Ne6 65. Bd2 c4 {-0.85/32 Komodo 9.3
64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 65. Bf1 {-0.69/29 14} (65.
Bd2 Nb8 66. Bf1 {-0.73/34 Stockfish 6 x64}) 65... Ke7 {-0.89/40 6 (c4)} (65...
Ne7 66. Bg2 Ng8 {-0.75/23 Deep Rybka 4 w32}) 66. Bd2 {-0.68/24 1 (Be2)} (66.
Bd2 Kf7 67. Be2 {-0.85/46 Stockfish 7 64}) 66... Nc7 {-0.89/35 4 (Kf7)} (66...
Kd7 67. Bg2 Ke8 {-0.83/39 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 67. Be1 {-0.65/25 1 (Ke3)} (
67. Be3 Kd7 68. Be2 {-0.89/46 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 67... Kd7 {-0.89/36 4
(Kf6)} (67... Kf6 68. Bd2 Nd8 {-0.94/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 68. Ke3 {-0.64/27
4 (Bd2)} (68. Kg2 Ne6 69. Kf2 {-0.87/41 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 68... Ke6 {
-0.89/38 4} (68... Ne6 69. Bd2 Kc7 {-0.73/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 69. Bd2 {
-0.63/26 1 (Be2)} (69. Bg2 d5 70. exd5+ {-0.96/28 Deep Fritz 13}) 69... Kf6 {
-0.89/37 4} (69... Kd7 70. Bg2 Ne7 {-0.86/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 70. Kf2 {
-0.64/27 2} (70. Kf2 Ne6 71. Ke3 {-0.70/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 70... Ne7 {
-0.89/35 4} (70... Ne6 71. Ke3 Ne7 {-0.73/33 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 71. Bg2 {
-0.70/28 10 (Ke3)} (71. Ke2 Ne6 {-0.79/24 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 71... Kg6 {-0.89/
33 4 (Ne6)} (71... Ne6 72. Ke3 Nc6 {-0.78/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 72. Bf1 {
-0.69/25 3 (Ke3)} (72. Bh1 Ne6 73. Bg2 {-0.83/24 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 72... Ne6
{-0.89/34 3} (72... Kf6 73. Bg2 Ne6 {-0.82/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 73. Be2 {
-0.69/25 2 (Bg2)} (73. Bg2 Kf7 74. Bf1 {-0.70/26 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 73... Kf6 {
-0.89/33 5} (73... Ng5 74. b4 cxb4 {-0.86/24 Deep Fritz 14}) 74. Bf1 {-0.67/27
3} Kf7 {-0.89/35 3} 75. Ke2 {-0.63/24 3 (Bg2)} (75. Ke2 Kf6 76. Kf2 {-0.49/28
Houdini 3 Pro x64}) 75... Kg6 {-0.89/34 4 (Kg7)} (75... Ke8 76. Kf2 Kd7 {
-0.85/41 Stockfish 7 64}) 76. Kf2 {-0.68/25 2} (76. Kf2 Ng5 77. Bg2 {-0.69/25
Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 76... Nc6 {-0.89/35 2 (Ng5)} (76... Kf6 77. Be1 Ng5 {
-0.54/27 Houdini 4 x64A}) 77. Kg2 {-0.70/25 4 (Be2)} Kf6 {-0.89/34 4} 78. Kf2 {
-0.70/28 7} Ke7 {-0.89/36 3 (Ng5)} (78... Ng5 79. Bg2 Nd8 {-0.83/42 Stockfish
290116 64 BMI2}) 79. Ke2 {-0.69/27 3 (Be2)} (79. Ke3 Kf7 80. Ke2 {-0.74/26
Komodo 6 64-bit}) 79... Ke8 {-0.89/35 3 (Kf7)} (79... Kf6 80. Ke3 Ne7 {-0.63/
35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 80. Ke3 {
-0.69/29 4 (Kf2)} (80. Ke3 Kf7 81. Be2 {-0.71/35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 80... Kd7
{-0.89/36 3 (Kf7)} (80... Kd7 81. Kf2 Nc7 {-0.57/27 Fritz 11 SE}) 81. Ke2 {
-0.69/27 2 (Be2)} (81. Kf2 Ne7 82. Be3 {-0.66/35 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 81... Kc7
{-0.89/32 4 (Ncd8)} (81... c4 82. b4 axb4 {-1.09/20 Deep Fritz 14}) 82. Ke3 {
-0.69/27 2 (Kf2)} (82. Be3 Ncd8 83. Bd2 {-0.88/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 82...
Ncd8 {-0.89/36 6} (82... Kd7 83. Be2 Nf8 {-0.80/45 Stockfish 7 64}) 83. Bg2 {
-0.69/28 7 (Be2)} (83. Ke2 Nc6 84. Ke3 {-0.91/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 83...
Kc6 {-0.89/35 4 (Kd7)} (83... Nc6 84. Bf1 Kd7 {-0.86/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
84. Ke2 {-0.69/29 4 (Kf2)} (84. Bf1 Kd7 85. Be2 {-0.73/24 Deep Rybka 4 x64})
84... Nf7 {-0.89/32 3 (Kd7)} (84... Kc7 85. Kf2 Nc6 {-0.85/41 Stockfish 7 64})
85. Ke3 {-0.73/28 14 (Kf2)} (85. Kf2 Nfd8 86. Bf1 {-0.83/44 Stockfish 7 64
POPCNT}) 85... Kc7 {-0.89/34 4 (Nfg5)} (85... Nfg5 86. Ke2 Nh3 {-0.80/29
Komodo 9.1 32-bit}) 86. Kf2 {-0.76/23 4} (86. Bh1 Kc6 87. Bg2 {-0.82/41
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 86... Kd7 {-0.89/36 1} 87. Bf1 {-0.76/23 3 (Ke3)} (87.
Bf1 Nfd8 88. Be2 {-0.84/45 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 87... Nfd8 {-0.89/38 5 (Kc6)
} 88. Bg2 {-0.76/24 2} (88. Be2 Nc6 89. Bd1 {-0.89/45 Stockfish 7}) 88... Nc6 {
-0.89/38 2 (Kc8)} (88... Ke7 89. Bf1 Nf7 {-0.73/33 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 89. Bf1
{-0.76/27 3} (89. Bf1 Ke7 90. Be2 {-0.86/44 Stockfish 7 64}) 89... Ne7 {
-0.89/35 3 (Ned8)} (89... Ncd8 90. Bg2 Nf7 {-0.82/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 90.
Be2 {-0.76/25 3} (90. Bg2 Kc6 91. Be3 {-0.73/35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 90... Kc7 {
-0.89/36 5 (Nd8)} (90... Nc6 91. Bf1 Nb8 {-0.81/41 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 91.
Bf1 {-0.76/25 1} (91. Ke3 Kd7 92. Bd1 {-0.94/46 Stockfish 7 64}) 91... Kc6 {
-0.89/37 3 (Nd8)} (91... Nc6 92. Ke3 Nb8 {-0.82/47 Stockfish 7 64}) 92. Ke2 {
-0.76/25 3 (Ke3)} (92. Be2 Ng8 93. Ke3 {-0.85/24 Houdini 3 x64}) 92... Kd7 {
-0.89/36 4 (Ng6)} 93. Be3 {-0.76/29 4 (Kf2)} (93. Kf2 Ng8 94. Bg2 {-0.84/42
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 93... Kc7 {-0.89/35 3} (93... Ng8 94. Kf2 Nf6 {-0.84/
38 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 94. Bd2 {-0.76/30 4} (94. Ke1 Ng6 95. Kf2 {-0.82/27
Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 94... Kb7 {-0.89/36 3 (Nd8)} (94... Kd7 95. Kf2 Nc6 {
-0.71/41 Stockfish 6 64}) 95. Ke3 {-0.76/30 6} Nc6 {-0.89/33 8} (95... Kc7 96.
Kf2 Ng6 {-0.66/31 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 96. Be2 {-0.76/29 3 (Kf2)} (96. Be2 Kc7
97. Bd1 {-0.87/47 Stockfish 7 64}) 96... Ned8 {-0.89/36 4 (Ncd8)} (96... Kc7
97. Kf2 Kd8 {-0.86/48 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 97. Kf2 {-0.76/28 7} (97. Kf2 Ne6
98. Ke3 {-0.83/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 97... Kc7 {-0.89/37 1} (97... Ne6 98. Bf1
Ncd8 {-0.73/39 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 98. Bf1 {-0.76/30 3 (Bg5)} (98. Bd1 Ne6 99.
Bc1 {-0.66/28 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 98... Nb8 {-0.89/35 4 (Kd7)} (98... Ne6 99. Be3
Ncd8 {-0.84/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 99. Ke3 {-0.75/27 3 (Bg2)} (99. Ke1 Ne6 100.
Ke2 {-0.74/27 Fritz 13}) 99... Ne6 {-0.82/34 34} (99... Nbc6 100. Be2 Ne6 {
-0.87/51 Stockfish 7 64}) 100. Be2 {-0.71/28 2 (Ke2)} (100. Ke2 Nd7 101. Kf2 {
-0.76/38 Stockfish 4 64}) 100... Kc8 {-0.89/32 18 (Kd7)} (100... Nc6 101. Kf2 {
-0.66/32 Komodo 9.3 32-bit}) 101. Kf2 {-0.68/28 2 (Be1)} (101. Bf1 Kd7 102. Ke2
{-0.80/28 Fritz 13}) 101... Nc6 {-0.80/29 6 (Kd7)} (101... Nd7 102. Bf1 Kd8 {
-0.75/27 Deep Fritz 13}) 102. Bd1 {-0.73/26 5 (Ke1)} Kd7 {-0.89/26 3} (102...
Nb8 103. Bc1 Nd7 {-0.88/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 103. Be2 {-0.65/24 3 (Bc2)} (
103. Bh6 Ncd8 104. Be3 {-0.51/32 Houdini 3 x64}) 103... Ke8 {-0.78/27 9 (Ncd8)}
(103... Nc7 104. Bf1 Ke6 {-0.92/27 Fritz 13 SE}) 104. Ke3 {-0.59/24 4 (Bf1)} (
104. Ke3 Kf7 105. Bf1 {-0.71/27 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 104... Kd8 {-0.75/27 4 (Kf7)}
(104... Ke7 105. Bf1 Ncd8 {-0.87/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 105. Bf1 {-0.65/24 7
(Kf2)} (105. Bf1 Ke7 106. Kf2 {-0.74/25 Deep Rybka 4 w32}) 105... Kc7 {-0.71/
26 4 (Ne7)} (105... Ke7 106. Ke2 Kf6 {-0.68/26 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 106. Kf2 {
-0.58/23 3} (106. Be2 Nb8 107. Kf2 {-0.83/43 Stockfish 290116 64 BMI2}) 106...
Nb8 {-0.72/25 4 (Kc8)} (106... Kd7 107. Bg2 Kc8 {-0.79/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
107. Be2 {-0.52/22 5 (Be1)} (107. Ke3 Nd7 108. Ke2 {-0.71/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}
) 107... Kd7 {-0.72/27 2} (107... Nd7 108. Bd1 Nf6 {-0.86/26 Deep Fritz 14})
108. Bf1 {-0.53/23 6} (108. Bf1 Nc6 109. Bg2 {-0.61/26 Fritz 12}) 108... Kc6 {
-0.72/28 1 (Ke7)} (108... Nc7 109. Bg2 Ke6 {-0.94/27 Fritz 13}) 109. Ke2 {
-0.48/20 2} (109. Be3 Nd7 110. Ke2 {-0.66/34 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 109... b5 {
-0.72/30 3 (Nd7)} (109... Nd7 110. Bc1 Nf6 {-0.69/29 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 110.
axb5+ {-0.45/25 3} (110. axb5+ Kxb5 111. Kf2 {-0.77/39 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
110... Kxb5 {-0.72/31 1} (110... Kxb5 111. Kd1 Kb6 {-0.73/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}
) 111. Ke3 {-0.46/26 3} (111. Ke3 Kb6 112. Kf2 {-0.77/42 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}
) 111... Kc6 {-0.72/32 3} (111... Kb6 112. Be2 Na6 {-0.48/27 Komodo 8 32-bit})
112. Ke2 {-0.46/23 3} (112. Be2 Kc7 113. Bc1 {-0.52/35 Stockfish 6 x64}) 112...
Nd7 {-0.72/32 9} (112... Nd7 113. Be3 Kc7 {-0.62/29 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 113.
Be3 {-0.46/24 2 (Ke3)} (113. Kd1 Nf6 114. Be3 {-0.72/33 Stockfish 7 64}) 113...
Nf6 {-0.72/30 3} 114. Bd2 {-0.45/25 5} (114. Bd2 Nd7 115. Ke3 {-0.73/41
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 114... Kc7 {-0.72/30 4 (Ne8)} (114... Nd7 115. Bc1 Nb6
{-0.54/25 Deep Fritz 13}) 115. Kf2 {-0.45/24 6 (Be3)} (115. Ke3 Ng8 116. Be2 {
-0.58/24 Deep Rybka 4 x64}) 115... Nd7 {-0.72/31 2 (Kb6)} (115... Kc6 116. Be2
Ne8 {-0.46/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 116.
Ke3 {-0.45/25 3 (Be2)} (116. Be2 Nf6 117. Ke3 {-0.31/28 Houdini 3 x64}) 116...
Nb8 {-0.72/32 2 (Kc6)} (116... Kb7 117. Be2 Nb8 {-0.74/42 Stockfish 7 64}) 117.
Ke2 {-0.46/27 4} (117. Kf2 Kc6 118. Ke3 {-0.33/29 Houdini 4 x64A}) 117... Kc6 {
-0.72/32 3 (Kb6)} (117... Kb6 118. Kf2 Kb7 {-0.46/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 118.
Ke3 {-0.47/27 6 (Kf2)} (118. Kf2 Nd7 119. Be2 {-0.59/27 Fritz 13}) 118... Kb6 {
-0.72/33 3} (118... Nd7 119. Ke2 Nf6 {-0.72/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 119. Ke2 {
-0.46/27 4 (Bg2)} (119. Be2 Nc6 120. Bd1 {-0.80/47 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT})
119... Nc6 {-0.72/30 3 (Na6)} (119... Kc6 120. Kd1 Nd7 {-0.72/38 Stockfish 7})
120. Be3 {-0.46/27 4 (Bg2)} (120. Ke1 Ncd8 121. Be2 {-0.76/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64
}) 120... Kc7 {-0.72/31 3 (Na7)} (120... Kc7 121. Kd2 Nb8 {-0.69/36 Stockfish
7 64 POPCNT}) 121. Bd2 {-0.47/28 3} (121. Kf2 Kb6 122. Be2 {-0.45/37 Komodo 9.
3 64-bit}) 121... Kd7 {-0.72/31 2 (Na7)} 122. Ke3 {-0.46/27 3} (122. Ke3 Ncd8
123. Be2 {-0.74/46 Stockfish 5 64}) 122... Ke7 {-0.72/31 3 (Na7)} (122... Ng5
123. Kf2 Nf7 {-0.73/23 Deep Fritz 14}) 123. Be2 {-0.46/28 3 (Bg2)} (123. Bc1
Ng5 124. Ke2 {-0.63/22 Deep Rybka 4 w32}) 123... Kf6 {-0.72/32 3 (Kd8)} (123...
Kd7 124. Kf2 Kc7 {-0.72/43 Stockfish 7 64}) 124. Bd1 {-0.46/26 4 (Bf1)} (124.
Kf2 Ncd8 125. Bd1 {-0.73/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 124... Kg5 {-0.72/34 3 (Na7)} (
124... Ke7 125. Ke2 Kd8 {-0.69/42 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 125. Ke2+ {-0.47/27
3 (Kf2+)} (125. Kf2+ Kf6 126. Kf1 {-0.73/24 Deep Fritz 14}) 125... Kg6 {
-0.72/38 3} (125... Kf6 126. Ke3 Nf8 {-0.43/27 Komodo 6 64-bit}) 126. Ke3 {
-0.46/30 7} (126. Kf2 Kf6 127. Kf1 {-0.74/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 126... Ned8 {
-0.72/33 3 (Kf6)} (126... Kg5 127. Kf2+ Kf6 {-0.58/42 Stockfish 6 64}) 127. Ke2
{-0.46/29 3 (Kf2)} (127. Be2 Ne6 128. Kf2 {-0.58/42 Stockfish 6 x64}) 127...
Kf6 {-0.72/37 3 (Nf7)} (127... Kf7 128. Ke3 Ne6 {-0.45/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
128. Bc2 {-0.45/27 3 (Kf2)} Ne6 {-0.72/36 4 (Ke7)} 129. Bd1 {-0.46/29 6} Kf7 {
-0.72/36 3 (Ke7)} (129... Ne7 130. Kf2 Nc8 {-0.46/33 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 130.
Ke3 {-0.47/30 4 (Kf2)} (130. Ke3 Ne7 131. Kf2 {-0.42/30 Komodo 9.1 32-bit})
130... Nc7 {-0.72/36 3} (130... Ke7 131. Kf2 Kd7 {-0.77/39 Stockfish 290116 64
BMI2}) 131. Kf2 {-0.47/31 5} (131. Kf2 Ne6 132. Bc1 {-0.46/29 Deep Fritz 13})
131... Kf6 {-0.72/37 2 (Ke6)} (131... Ne6 132. Be3 Ned8 {-0.75/26 Deep Fritz
14 x64}) 132. Be2 {-0.47/32 4 (Ke3)} (132. Be3 Nb5 133. Bd2 {-0.33/29 Houdini
3 Pro x64}) 132... Ke7 {-0.72/38 3} (132... Ne6 133. Bc1 Ncd8 {-0.72/26
Houdini 3 x64}) 133. Bf1 {-0.47/28 5 (Bd1)} (133. Bf1 Kf6 134. Be2 {-0.42/27
Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 133... Kd7 {-0.72/37 5 (Kf7)} (133... Na7 134. Be2 Kf6 {
-0.47/28 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 134. Ke3 {-0.47/26 2 (Be2)} (134. Be2 Na7 135. Ke1 {
-0.45/32 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 134... Ke6 {-0.72/35 3 (Nb5)} (134... Nb5 135. Ke2
Ne7 {-0.34/26 Fritz 11 SE}) 135. Be1 {-0.47/28 3 (Kf2)} (135. Be2 Nb5 136. Kf2
{-0.43/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 135...
Kf6 {-0.72/35 3} (135... Ke7 136. Kf2 Kf6 {-0.73/24 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 136.
Be2 {-0.46/28 3 (Bd2)} (136. Bd2 Ne6 137. Be2 {-0.72/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64})
136... Ne6 {-0.72/33 3} (136... Nd8 137. Bd2 Nde6 {-0.30/28 Houdini 3 Pro x64})
137. Bd2 {-0.46/24 2 (Kf2)} Ned8 {-0.72/36 4 (Ke7)} (137... Ne7 138. Kf2 Ng5 {
-0.48/26 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 138. Bd1 {-0.47/28 3 (Kf2)} (138. Bf1 Ne6 139. Ke2 {
-0.74/42 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 138... Ke7 {-0.72/40 3 (Nf7)} (138... Ne6 139.
Be1 Kf7 {-0.73/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 139. Be2 {-0.47/31 5 (Kf2)} (139. Be2 Nf7
140. Bd1 {-0.42/36 Komodo 9.3 32-bit}) 139... Ne6 {-0.72/39 5 (Nf7)} 140. Kf2 {
-0.46/28 6} (140. Kf2 Kd8 141. Bd1 {-0.74/47 Stockfish 5 64}) 140... Kd7 {
-0.72/39 9} 141. Ke3 {-0.47/29 6 (Bf1)} (141. Bd1 Kc7 142. Ke3 {-0.74/46
Stockfish 7 64}) 141... Ne7 {-0.72/35 5 (Kd8)} (141... Kc7 142. Bd1 Kb6 {
-0.38/26 Fritz 11 SE}) 142. Bd1 {-0.46/29 6 (Kf2)} (142. Be1 Nc6 143. Bd1 {
-0.65/40 Stockfish 7 64}) 142... Kc7 {-0.61/30 8} (142... Nc6 143. Bc2 Kc8 {
-0.74/45 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 143. Be2 {-0.47/28 3 (b4)} (143. Kf2 Kd8 144.
Bc1 {-0.75/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 143... Kb6 {-0.72/35 3} (143... Ng8 144. Bd1
Nf6 {-0.61/27 Fritz 13}) 144. Bd1 {-0.46/27 2 (Kf2)} Nc6 {-0.71/33 6} (144...
Nc6 145. Kf2 Ncd8 {-0.72/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 145. Be2 {-0.46/29 4} (145. Kf2
Kc7 146. Ke3 {-0.66/42 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 145... Kc7 {-0.71/33 1} (145...
Kc7 146. Bd1 Kd7 {-0.78/48 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 146. Bd1 {-0.46/30 9 (Kf2)}
(146. Kf2 Na7 147. Bf1 {-0.48/38 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 146... Kb7 {-0.67/32 7} (
146... Ng5 147. Ke2 Nf7 {-0.43/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 147. Be2 {-0.47/30 3} (
147. Bc1 Kc7 148. Bd2 {-0.74/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 147... Kb6 {-0.67/28 3
(Kc8)} (147... Kc8 148. Bc1 Kd7 {-0.74/24 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 148. Bf1 {
-0.46/26 3 (Bd1)} Na7 {-0.62/27 8} (148... Kc7 149. Ke2 Kd8 {-0.76/25 Deep
Fritz 14 x64}) 149. Be2 {-0.44/25 2 (Be1)} (149. Ke2 Nb5 150. Kd1 {-0.52/26
Komodo 6 64-bit}) 149... Nb5 {-0.57/27 5} (149... Nb5 150. Be1 Nec7 {-0.44/36
Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 150. Be1 {-0.47/25 4} (150. Be1 Nec7 151. Kd2 {-0.58/25
Deep Rybka 4 x64}) 150... Nec7 {-0.53/27 8} (150... Na7 151. Bd2 Nc6 {-0.54/39
Stockfish 4 64}) 151. Kd2 {-0.36/24 5 (Kf2)} (151. Kd2 Ne8 152. Bf2 {-0.49/27
Deep Fritz 13}) 151... Ka7 {-0.53/26 3 (Kc6)} (151... Ne6 152. Ke3 Nec7 {
-0.73/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 152. Bf1 {-0.29/22 2 (Kc1)} (152. Bf2 Kb6 153. Bf1
{-0.33/27 Fritz 11 SE}) 152... Kb7 {-0.45/27 10} (152... Kb6 153. Bf2 Ne6 {
0.58/27 Fritz 13}) 153. Kd1 {-0.39/24 7 (Kc2)} (153. Be2 Kb6 154. Bd1 {-0.32/
30 Houdini 4 x64A}) 153... Ne6 {-0.46/24 4 (Kc6)} (153... Ne6 154. Be2 Nbc7 {
-0.72/33 Stockfish 7}) 154. Bd2 {-0.38/22 2 (Bg2)} (154. Kd2 Kc6 155. Be2 {
-0.54/38 Stockfish 6 64}) 154... Na7 {-0.56/26 7 (Kc6)} (154... Nbc7 155. Kc2
Ne8 {-0.69/34 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 155. Be2 {-0.27/24 8 (Kc1)} (155. Be3 Nc6
156. Kd2 {-0.59/28 Fritz 13}) 155... Nc8 {-0.56/26 2} (155... Nc6 156. Bc1 Ne7
{-0.77/37 Stockfish 290116 64 BMI2}) 156. Ke1 {-0.28/23 3 (Be3)} (156. Ke1 Na7
157. Bd1 {-0.50/35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 156... Nb6 {-0.43/25 8} (156... Na7 157.
Kf2 Kb6 {-0.74/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 157. Bd1 {-0.47/22 4} Ka6 {-0.33/26
4 (a4)} (157... Nd8 158. Ke2 Ka6 {-0.63/34 Stockfish 7 64}) 158. Be2 {-0.44/23
8 (Kf2)} a4 {-0.34/24 2} (158... Kb5 159. Bd1 Nd7 {-0.62/27 Fritz 13 SE}) 159.
bxa4 {-0.47/22 1} (159. bxa4 c4 160. d4 {-0.61/27 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 159...
c4 {-0.65/25 2} (159... c4 {-1.02/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 160. d4 {-0.47/24 3} (
160. d4 exd4 161. cxd4 {-0.64/39 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 160... exd4 {-0.53/25
1} (160... exd4 161. cxd4 Nxd4 {-0.74/26 Gull 3 x64}) 161. cxd4 {-0.37/24 2} (
161. cxd4 Nxd4 162. a5 {-0.74/42 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 161... Nxd4 {-0.52/30
5} (161... Nxd4 162. a5 {-0.49/37 Stockfish 7 64}) 162. a5 {-0.36/25 2} (162.
a5 Nxe2 163. Kxe2 {-0.50/36 Stockfish 7 64}) 162... Nxe2 {-0.39/27 1} 163. Kxe2
{-0.36/25 2} (163. Kxe2 {-0.50/36 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 163... Na4 {-0.53/28
3} 164. Bb4 {-0.36/25 2} (164. Bb4 Kb5 165. Bxd6 {-1.33/24 Deep Rybka 4 w32})
164... Kb5 {-0.36/27 2} (164... Kb5 165. Bxd6 Kxa5 {-0.63/28 Deep Fritz 13})
165. Bxd6 {-0.57/25 3} Kxa5 {-0.35/32 8} (165... Kxa5 166. e5 Kb5 {-0.89/23
Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 166. e5 {-0.48/27 3} (166. e5 Kb5 167. e6 {-0.50/32 Komodo
8 64-bit}) 166... Kb5 {-0.35/32 2} (166... Nc3+ 167. Ke3 Nb5 {0.00/39
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 167. e6 {-0.40/28 3} (167. e6 Kc6 168. Ba3 {-0.90/27
Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 167... Kc6 {-0.35/32 5} (167... Kc6 168. Ba3 Nb6 {-0.59/41
Stockfish 5 64}) 168. Bb8 {-0.36/30 8} (168. Bb8 Nc5 169. e7 {-0.34/23 Komodo
8 64-bit}) 168... Nc5 {-0.28/33 6} (168... Nc5 169. e7 Kd7 {-0.63/40 Stockfish
5 64 SSE4.2}) 169. e7 {-0.33/30 2} Kd7 {-0.28/35 1} (169... Kd7 170. Kd2 {
-0.03/44 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 170. Kd2
{-0.31/33 4} (170. Kd2 Kxe7 {-0.63/32 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 170... c3+ {
-0.28/36 2 (Kxe7)} (170... Kxe7 171. Kc3 Ne4+ {-0.48/42 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
171. Kxc3 {-0.16/29 2} (171. Kxc3 Kxe7 172. Kd4 {-0.53/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64})
171... Kxe7 {-0.28/38 1} (171... Kxe7 172. Kd4 Nd7 {-0.21/68 Stockfish 7 64})
172. Kd4 {-0.16/36 4 (Kc4)} (172. Kd4 Nd7 173. Ba7 {-0.65/32 Houdini 3 x64})
172... Nd7 {-0.28/42 2} (172... Nd7 173. Ba7 Kf6 {-0.44/33 Fritz 12}) 173. Ba7
{-0.16/37 2 (Bc7)} (173. Ba7 Ke6 174. Ke4 {-0.08/51 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 173...
Ke6 {-0.28/50 3} (173... Kf6 174. Ke4 Nf8 {-0.50/28 Deep Fritz 14}) 174. Ke4 {
-0.08/35 2} (174. Ke4 Kf6 175. Bd4+ {-0.27/31 Houdini 3 x64}) 174... Kf6 {
-0.28/50 1} (174... Kf6 175. Bd4+ Kg5 {-0.17/50 Stockfish 7 64}) 175. Bd4+ {
-0.08/38 3 (Be3)} (175. Bd4+ Kg6 176. Kf4 {-0.53/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 175...
Kg6 {-0.28/54 4} (175... Kg6 176. Kf4 Nf8 {-0.18/42 Komodo 9.1 32-bit}) 176.
Be3 {-0.08/37 3 (Kf4)} (176. Kf4 Nf8 177. Bb6 {-0.34/35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
176... Nf6+ {-0.28/53 3 (Nb8)} (176... Nf6+ 177. Ke5 Ne8 {-0.71/33 Deep Rybka
4 x64}) 177. Ke5 {-0.07/37 2} Ne8 {-0.28/54 1 (Nh7)} (177... Ne8 178. Bd2 Ng7 {
-0.24/50 Stockfish 7 64}) 178. Bb6 {-0.06/37 4 (Bd4)} (178. Bb6 Nf6 179. Ba5 {
-0.43/33 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 178... Ng7 {-0.28/54 3} (178... Nf6 179. Be3 Nd7+
{-0.21/73 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 179. Be3 {-0.05/38 5 (Kf4)} (179. Bf2 Nf5
180. Ke6 {-0.50/32 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 179... Nf5 {-0.28/50 3} (179... Nf5 180.
Bf4 Ne7 {0.00/115 Stockfish 290116 64 BMI2}) 180. Bf4 {-0.06/36 3} (180. Bf4
Ne7 181. Be3 {-0.30/29 Komodo 6 64-bit}) 180... Ne7 {-0.28/51 1} (180... Ne7
181. Ke4 h4 {-0.28/39 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 181. Be3 {0.00/36 3 (Kd4)} (181. Be3
Nc6+ 182. Ke6 {0.00/46 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 181... Nc6+ {-0.28/46 3 (Kf7)} (
181... Nc6+ 182. Kf4 {-0.26/29 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 182. Ke4 {0.00/39 3 (Kd5)} (
182. Ke6 Nd8+ 183. Ke5 {0.00/42 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 182... Kf6 {-0.28/46 3
(Nd8)} (182... Nd8 183. Kf4 Ne6+ {-0.43/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 183. Bf2 {
0.00/38 3 (Kd5)} (183. Kf4 Kg6 184. Bb6 {-0.25/38 Komodo 9.3 32-bit}) 183...
Nb4 {-0.28/50 3 (Ke6)} (183... Kg6 184. Be1 Nd8 {0.00/38 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 184.
Bd4+ {0.00/38 3} Kg6 {-0.28/52 1 (Ke6)} 185. Bc3 {0.00/39 4} (185. Bf2 Nc6 186.
Be3 {-0.18/36 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 185... Na6 {-0.28/53 4} 186. Ke5 {0.00/40 4
(Bd4)} (186. Ba5 Nc5+ 187. Kf4 {-0.54/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 186... Nc5 {
-0.28/51 3} (186... Nc5 187. Bd4 Nd3+ {-0.50/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 187. Bd4 {
0.00/38 3} (187. Bd2 Nb7 188. Bb4 {0.00/78 Stockfish 7 64}) 187... Nd7+ {
-0.28/62 4 (Nd3+)} (187... Nd3+ 188. Ke6 Nc1 {-0.09/45 Stockfish 7 64}) 188.
Kf4 {0.00/47 4} (188. Kf4 Nf8 189. Bg1 {-0.05/50 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 188...
Nf8 {-0.28/64 1 (Nf6)} (188... Nb8 189. Bb2 Nc6 {0.00/64 Stockfish 7}) 189. Ke5
{0.00/45 6} (189. Bb6 Ne6+ 190. Ke5 {-0.21/34 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 189... Nh7 {
-0.28/67 29} (189... h4 190. gxh4 Kh5 {-0.28/33 Komodo 8 32-bit}) 190. Bc5 {
0.00/44 5 (Kf4)} (190. Bb2 Ng5 191. Bc3 {0.00/113 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
190... Ng5 {0.00/43 7} (190... Nf6 191. Bf2 Ng8 {-0.51/28 Deep Fritz 14}) 191.
Be3 {0.00/45 4} (191. Bb6 h4 192. gxh4 {-0.34/37 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 191... h4
{0.00/50 3 (Nf7+)} (191... Nf3+ 192. Ke6 Ne1 {-0.05/48 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
192. gxh4 {0.00/56 5} (192. gxh4 {0.00/127 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 192... Nf3+
{0.00/63 1} 193. Kf4 {0.00/63 2} Nxh4 {0.00/98 2} 194. Kxg4 {0.00/30 4} Nf5 {
0.00/28 3} 195. Bc1 {0.00/39 6 (Kf4) Draw accepted} 1/2-1/2
[/pgn]
Shortest game:
[pgn][Event "WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S, Blitz 4m+4s"]
[Site "WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S"]
[Date "2016.02.21"]
[Round "90"]
[White "Komodo 9.3 64-bit"]
[Black "Stockfish 150216b 64"]
[Result "0-1"]
[Annotator "-0.49;-0.73"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "1n2k1n1/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPP1/2B1KB2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "48"]
[EventDate "2016.??.??"]
[EventType "blitz"]
[TimeControl "240+4"]
{Pentium(R) Dual-Core CPU E5200 @ 2.50GHz 2493 MHz W=23.3 plies; 1 961kN/s;
91 810 TBAs B=26.1 plies; 2 608kN/s; 17 291 TBAs} 1. d4 {-0.49/21 18} f5 {
-0.73/24 11} 2. e3 {-0.58/22 12} Nf6 {-0.67/23 5} 3. Bd3 {-0.59/22 15 (c3)} g6
{-0.69/24 15} 4. f3 {-0.59/24 31 (b4)} Nc6 {-0.80/25 11} 5. c4 {-0.56/23 5} d6
{-0.81/24 4 (e5)} 6. Kd2 {-0.57/24 10 (Kf2)} Kf7 {-0.87/25 9 (e5)} 7. Kc3 {
-0.61/24 14} e5 {-0.84/29 14} 8. d5 {-0.66/24 8} Ne7 {-0.89/26 1 (Nb8)} 9. e4 {
-0.57/23 9} f4 {-0.91/27 9 (fxe4)} 10. Kd2 {-0.90/21 15 (b4)} c5 {-0.93/26 6
(g5)} 11. Ke1 {-0.91/22 11 (a3)} h5 {-0.95/24 9 (g5)} 12. a3 {-0.96/21 14} g5 {
-1.04/24 6} 13. Kf2 {-1.35/21 12 (b4)} g4 {-1.22/26 7} 14. Kg1 {-2.15/23 26
(b4)} g3 {-1.33/28 5 (Ng6)} 15. Bd2 {-3.12/23 14 (b4)} h4 {-1.82/28 8} 16. b4 {
-3.36/26 16} Ng6 {-3.12/28 27} 17. a4 {-3.42/25 5 (Bc3)} h3 {-3.73/25 5} 18.
Bf1 {-4.27/24 13} hxg2 {-4.15/27 7 (b6)} 19. Bxg2 {-3.56/23 4} Nh7 {-4.42/24 3
(b6)} 20. a5 {-5.29/23 14} Ng5 {-5.02/26 10 (Nh4)} 21. bxc5 {-5.97/24 8 (Kf1)}
dxc5 {-5.64/25 5} 22. Kh1 {-6.77/25 10 (Kf1)} Nh4 {-6.39/28 11} 23. Bc3 {
-7.94/26 17} Ngxf3 {-7.35/30 15 (Nhxf3)} 24. Bxf3 {-8.05/24 7 (Bf1)} Nxf3 {
-8.76/30 12} 0-1
[/pgn]
Stockfish White:
1 Stockfish 150216b 64 +244 +121/=79/-0 80.25% 160.5/200
2 Komodo 9.3 64-bit -244 +0/=79/-121 19.75% 39.5/200
Komodo White:
1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit +255 +126/=73/-1 81.25% 162.5/200
2 Stockfish 150216b 64 -255 +1/=73/-126 18.75% 37.5/200
WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S, Blitz 4m+4s 2016
1 Komodo 9.3 64-bit +3 +126/=152/-122 50.50% 202.0/400
2 Stockfish 150216b 64 -3 +122/=152/-126 49.50% 198.0/400
The results is almost identical.
Longest game:
[pgn][Event "WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S, Blitz 4m+4s"]
[Site "WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S"]
[Date "2016.02.22"]
[Round "198"]
[White "Komodo 9.3 64-bit"]
[Black "Stockfish 150216b 64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[Annotator "-0.49;-0.65"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "1n2k1n1/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPP1/2B1KB2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "389"]
[EventDate "2016.??.??"]
[EventType "blitz"]
[TimeControl "240+4"]
{Pentium(R) Dual-Core CPU E5200 @ 2.50GHz 2493 MHz W=28.5 plies; 2 083kN/s;
5 997 772 TBAs B=35.4 plies; 2 636kN/s; 2 185 072 TBAs} 1. e4 {-0.49/20 9}
c5 {-0.65/27 59} 2. f3 {-0.47/21 7 (d3)} (2. d3 Nc6 3. c3 {-0.67/29 Stockfish
5 64 SSE4.2}) 2... Nc6 {-0.74/21 4 (Nf6)} (2... Nf6 3. c3 Nc6 {-0.67/27 Komodo
9.3 64-bit}) 3. b3 {-0.49/21 12 (d3)} (3. a3 e6 4. c3 {-0.66/26 Stockfish 7 64
POPCNT}) 3... e5 {-0.75/22 5 (e6)} (3... Nf6 4. c3 h5 {-0.87/21 Deep Fritz 14
x64}) 4. c3 {-0.45/22 9 (Kf2)} (4. c3 {-0.70/28 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 4...
Nge7 {-0.77/22 11 (d6)} (4... Nf6 5. Ba3 d6 {-0.76/23 Fritz 11 SE}) 5. a3 {
-0.53/22 14 (Kf2)} (5. a3 d6 6. b4 {-0.46/23 Komodo 6 64-bit}) 5... a5 {
-0.77/23 4 (d6)} (5... d5 6. b4 cxb4 {-0.81/24 Deep Fritz 13}) 6. a4 {-0.56/23
21 (Kf2)} (6. Ke2 Kd8 {-0.70/26 Stockfish 7 64}) 6... f6 {-0.77/25 11 (f5)} (
6... h5 7. g3 f6 {-0.62/29 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 7. Bb5 {-0.59/23 13 (Kf2)} (7.
Bc4 h5 8. g3 {-0.77/22 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 7... h5 {-0.79/23 8 (g5)} (7... h5
8. Bc4 b6 {-0.73/31 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 8. Bc4 {-0.66/25 14 (g3)} (8. Kf2 {
-0.70/31 Stockfish 6 64}) 8... b6 {-0.79/26 9 (g5)} (8... Ng6 9. g3 Nf8 {
-0.63/29 Komodo 9.1 32-bit}) 9. Kf2 {-0.71/27 30} (9. Kf2 g5 10. Ba3 {-0.83/32
Stockfish 7 64}) 9... g5 {-0.79/26 5 (Nd8)} 10. g3 {-0.70/25 10} (10. g3 Ng6
11. d3 {-0.91/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 10... Nc8 {-0.83/26 3 (Kf8)} (10... Nd8
11. d3 Ne6 {-0.91/22 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 11. Ba6 {-0.52/23 15 (Be2)} Nd6 {
-0.84/25 5} (11... N8e7 12. Be2 d5 {-0.57/25 Houdini 3 x64}) 12. Be2 {-0.61/23
6 (Bb2)} (12. Be2 Ke7 13. Ba3 {-0.88/34 Stockfish 7 64}) 12... Kf8 {-0.84/26 5
(Kf7)} (12... Kf7 13. d3 Ne8 {-0.68/24 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 13. d3 {-0.61/23
4 (Bb2)} (13. d3 Kg7 14. f4 {-0.65/24 Fritz 13}) 13... Nf7 {-0.89/26 15 (Kf7)}
(13... Kf7 14. Bf1 Kg6 {-0.62/30 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 14. f4 {-0.63/25 13} (14.
f4 g4 15. Ke3 {-0.50/29 Houdini 4 Pro x64}) 14... g4 {-0.90/28 12} (14... g4
15. Bd2 Nfd8 {-0.93/34 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 15. Bf1 {-0.63/28 11 (Bd1)} (15.
Ke3 Ke7 16. Bf1 {-0.65/25 Deep Fritz 13}) 15... Nfd8 {-0.96/28 7 (Ke7)} (15...
Ke7 16. Bg2 d6 {-0.70/23 Deep Fritz 13}) 16. Bg2 {-0.69/26 5 (Ke2)} (16. Ke2
Ne6 17. fxe5 {-0.90/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 16... Ke7 {-0.96/30 4 (Ke8)} (16...
exf4 17. Bxf4 {-0.63/25 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 17. Be3 {-0.68/24 7 (Ke3)} (17. Ke3
Ne6 18. fxe5 {-0.87/43 Stockfish 7}) 17... Ne6 {-0.96/31 15} (17... Ne6 18.
fxe5 fxe5 {-0.87/39 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 18. fxe5 {-0.66/26 4} (18. fxe5
fxe5 19. Bc1 {-0.88/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 18... fxe5 {-0.96/34 4} (18... fxe5
19. Bd2 Kf6 {-0.73/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 19. Bd2 {-0.65/29 6} Kd6 {-0.96/34 3
(Kf6)} (19... Ned8 20. Bf1 Kf6 {-0.70/33 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 20. Be3 {-0.65/29
4 (Ke3)} (20. Bf1 Ncd8 21. Ke2 {-0.86/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 20... Ned8 {
-0.96/38 4 (Ncd8)} (20... Ne7 21. Bf1 Kc7 {-0.84/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 21.
Bd2 {-0.64/28 4 (Bg5)} Ke6 {-0.96/39 4} (21... Ne6 22. Bf1 Ke7 {-0.67/36
Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 22. Be3 {-0.64/27 3} (22. Bf1 Kf6 23. Ke2 {-0.87/27 Deep
Fritz 14 x64}) 22... Kf7 {-0.96/38 4 (Kf6)} (22... Kf7 23. Bg5 Ne6 {-0.83/37
Stockfish 290116 64 BMI2}) 23. Bd2 {-0.65/28 6} (23. Ke1 Ne6 24. Kd2 {-0.87/40
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 23... Kf6 {-0.96/36 1 (Ne6)} (23... Kf6 24. Bf1 Ne6 {
-0.94/48 Stockfish 7 64}) 24. Bf1 {-0.65/29 11 (Be3)} (24. Be3 Ne6 25. Bf1 {
-0.74/42 Stockfish 6 x64}) 24... Ne6 {-0.96/38 9 (Kg6)} (24... Ke6 25. Ke3 Kd6
{-0.50/28 Houdini 3 Pro x64}) 25. Ke3 {-0.67/28 11 (Bg2)} (25. Be3 Nc7 26. Bg2
{-0.77/24 Deep Rybka 4 x64}) 25... Ne7 {-0.96/35 6 (Na7)} 26. Bg2 {-0.67/27 5}
(26. Kf2 Nc6 27. Ke2 {-0.86/42 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 26... Kg5 {-0.96/34 2
(Ng5)} (26... Ng7 27. Kf2 d6 {-0.71/26 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 27. Ke2+ {-0.67/27 9}
(27. Ke2+ Kg6 28. Kf2 {-0.74/34 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 27... Kg6 {-0.96/39 5} (
27... Kf6 28. Be3 Nc6 {0.93/26 Fritz 13}) 28. Kf2 {-0.67/27 5} Kf7 {-0.96/39 6
(Kg7)} (28... Kf6 29. Bf1 Nc6 {-0.86/40 Stockfish 7 64}) 29. Ke2 {-0.70/26 4} (
29. Bf1 Nc6 30. Be2 {-0.86/40 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 29... Nc6 {-0.96/36 3
(Ng6)} (29... Nc6 30. Kf2 d6 {-0.80/39 Stockfish 7 64}) 30. Bf1 {-0.70/27 4
(Kf2)} Kg6 {-0.96/36 15} (30... Kg6 31. Kf2 Ne7 {-0.52/27 Houdini 4 x64A}) 31.
Kf2 {-0.69/28 8 (Ke3)} (31. Kf2 Ng5 32. Bc1 {-0.90/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 31...
Ng5 {-0.96/38 6 (Ncd8)} (31... Ne7 32. Be2 Kf7 {0.48/27 Houdini 3 x64}) 32. Bg2
{-0.70/27 5 (Be3)} (32. Bg2 Kf6 33. Ke3 {-0.76/26 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 32...
Nf7 {-0.96/40 5 (Nd8)} (32... Ne6 33. Bf1 Kf7 {-0.87/45 Stockfish 7 64}) 33.
Bf1 {-0.71/27 4 (Ke3)} (33. Ke3 Kf6 34. Bc1 {-0.86/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 33...
Kf6 {-0.96/42 7} (33... Ne7 34. Bg2 Ng5 {-0.78/29 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 34. Ke3 {
-0.78/28 12 (Bg2)} (34. Ke2 Ncd8 35. Ke3 {-0.86/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 34...
Nd6 {-0.96/40 6 (Ng5)} 35. Bg2 {-0.78/28 5 (Kf2)} (35. Be1 Nf7 36. Bd2 {
-0.74/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 35... Kg5 {-0.96/37 5 (Ke7)} (35... Nf7 36. Kf2
Ng5 {-0.78/37 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 36. Ke2+ {-0.77/32 27 (Kf2+)} (36. Bf1 Kf6
37. Be2 {-0.86/48 Stockfish 7 64}) 36... Kg6 {-0.96/40 6} (36... Kf6 37. Be3
Nf7 {-0.83/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 37. Ke3 {-0.73/30 7 (Kf2)} (37. Bf1 Nd8
38. Kf2 {-0.86/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 37... Nb7 {-0.96/38 6 (Kf6)} (37... Nf7
38. Be1 Ng5 {-0.77/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on
SSD}) 38. Bf1 {-0.73/32 7} (38. Ke2 Nbd8 39. Be3 {-0.90/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64})
38... Kf6 {-0.96/37 3} (38... Nbd8 39. Kf2 Ne6 {-0.65/38 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
39. Kf2 {-0.73/32 10 (Bg2)} (39. Be2 Nbd8 40. Kf2 {-0.85/43 Stockfish 7 64})
39... Kf7 {-0.96/36 5 (Nd6)} (39... Nbd8 40. Bc1 Nf7 {-0.84/26 Deep Fritz 14
x64}) 40. Ke2 {-0.73/31 8 (Be3)} (40. Ke3 Kf6 41. Ke2 {-0.70/37 Komodo 9.3
64-bit}) 40... Nd6 {-0.96/36 5 (Ke6)} (40... Kf6 41. Be3 Nbd8 {-0.67/34 Komodo
9.3 64-bit}) 41. Bg2 {-0.73/32 5} Nc8 {-0.96/36 5 (Ke6)} (41... Ke6 42. Be3 Kf6
{-0.73/27 Komodo 6 64-bit}) 42. Be1 {-0.73/32 4 (Kd1)} Ke7 {-0.96/40 6 (Kf6)}
43. Bd2 {-0.73/33 3} (43. Bd2 Nd6 44. Bf1 {-0.86/46 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
43... Nd6 {-0.96/40 2} (43... Kf6 44. Bf1 Nd8 {-0.49/31 Houdini 3 Pro x64}) 44.
Bg5+ {-0.73/32 6 (Kf2)} Ke6 {-0.96/42 6} (44... Ke6 45. Bf1 Nf7 {-0.87/28
Houdini 3 x64}) 45. Bd2 {-0.73/32 5 (Be3)} (45. Kd1 Nf7 46. Bd2 {-0.78/45
Stockfish 6 64}) 45... Kf7 {-0.96/39 6 (Nf7)} (45... Kf6 46. Ke3 Nf7 {-0.73/27
Komodo 8 64-bit}) 46. Kf2 {-0.73/33 7 (Be3)} (46. Bf1 Kg6 47. Ke3 {-0.94/46
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 46... Nc8 {-0.96/39 4 (Ke7)} (46... Ke6 47. Bf1 Nf7 {
-0.86/47 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 47. Bf1 {-0.73/32 5 (Be3)} (47. Bg5 Kg6 48.
Be3 {-0.54/27 Fritz 11 SE}) 47... Kg6 {-0.96/36 5 (Ke7)} (47... Nd8 48. Bg5 Ne6
{-0.67/34 Komodo 9.3 32-bit}) 48. Be2 {-0.73/32 5 (Be3)} (48. Bg2 Nd6 49. Ke2 {
-0.64/29 Fritz 12}) 48... Nd6 {-0.96/37 4 (Kf6)} 49. Bf1 {-0.73/28 5 (Bd1)} (
49. Ke3 Kf6 50. Bc1 {-0.81/27 Fritz 13}) 49... Kf6 {-0.96/40 5} (49... Kf6 50.
Bc1 Nf7 {-0.84/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 50. Ke2 {-0.74/30 6 (Bg2)} (50. Ke2 Nf7
51. Bg2 {-0.83/24 Deep Fritz 14}) 50... Ne8 {-0.96/37 4 (Nd8)} 51. Ke3 {
-0.74/31 6 (Kf2)} Ke6 {-0.96/38 5 (Ke7)} (51... Kg5 52. Ke2+ Kg6 {-0.77/28
Komodo 8 64-bit}) 52. Bc1 {-0.74/30 9 (Kf2)} (52. Kf2 Kd6 53. Be2 {-0.80/49
Stockfish 7 64}) 52... Nd6 {-0.96/32 11 (Nc7)} (52... Nc7 53. Bg2 Kf6 {-0.84/
27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 53. Bd2 {-0.74/32 7 (Bb2)} Kf7 {-0.96/35 20 (Ke7)} (
53... Kf6 54. Ke2 Nd8 {-0.88/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 54. Be2 {-0.74/29 3} (54.
Bg2 Ke6 55. Bc1 {-0.76/27 Deep Rybka 4 w32}) 54... Kf8 {-0.96/35 7 (Kf6)} (
54... Kf6 55. Kf2 Nf7 {-0.77/27 Komodo 8 32-bit}) 55. Bc1 {-0.74/30 5 (Bd1)} (
55. Bf1 Nf7 56. Ke2 {-0.92/30 Gull 3 x64}) 55... Nb7 {-0.89/32 11 (Ke7)} (55...
Ke7 56. Kf2 Nf7 {-0.89/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 56. Bb2 {-0.74/29 5 (Kf2)} (56.
Bd1 Kf7 57. Ke2 {-0.90/38 Stockfish 4 64}) 56... Kf7 {-0.89/29 7 (Ke7)} (56...
Kf7 57. Bc1 Nbd8 {-0.87/39 Stockfish 7}) 57. Bf1 {-0.74/27 7 (Bc1)} (57. Bf1
Ke6 58. Bg2 {-1.00/26 Fritz 13 SE}) 57... Nbd8 {-0.89/31 16 (Ke6)} (57... Ke6
58. Kf2 d6 {-0.74/24 Deep Rybka 4 x64}) 58. Bc1 {-0.72/27 9} (58. Bc1 Kf6 59.
Be2 {-0.86/42 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 58... Kf6 {-0.89/32 5 (Ne6)} (58... Ke6
59. Bb2 d5 {-0.74/27 Deep Fritz 13}) 59. Bd2 {-0.73/24 1 (Kf2)} (59. Ke2 Ne6
60. Be3 {-0.83/41 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 59... Kg6 {-0.89/30 3 (Ne6)} (59...
Ne6 60. Bc1 Ncd8 {-0.84/24 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 60. Ke2 {-0.62/25 3 (Kf2)} (60.
Be2 Kf6 61. Bf1 {-0.86/43 Stockfish 5 64}) 60... Kf7 {-0.89/32 3 (Kg7)} (60...
Ne6 61. Ke3 Ne7 {-0.86/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 61. Ke3 {-0.61/26 2} (61. Be3 Ne7
62. b4 {-0.89/26 Fritz 13}) 61... Ke7 {-0.89/33 1 (Kg7)} (61... Ne6 62. Bc1 Kg6
{-0.85/26 Deep Fritz 13}) 62. Bg2 {-0.62/27 2 (Bc1)} (62. Ke2 Kd6 63. Be3 {
-0.88/28 Fritz 13}) 62... d6 {-0.89/33 4 (Kf8)} 63. Kf2 {-0.62/28 4 (Ke2)} Kf6
{-0.89/37 3} 64. Be3 {-0.62/27 2} (64. Ke3 Ne7 65. Bf1 {-0.73/25 Komodo 6
64-bit}) 64... Ne6 {-0.89/38 2} (64... Ne6 65. Bd2 c4 {-0.85/32 Komodo 9.3
64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 65. Bf1 {-0.69/29 14} (65.
Bd2 Nb8 66. Bf1 {-0.73/34 Stockfish 6 x64}) 65... Ke7 {-0.89/40 6 (c4)} (65...
Ne7 66. Bg2 Ng8 {-0.75/23 Deep Rybka 4 w32}) 66. Bd2 {-0.68/24 1 (Be2)} (66.
Bd2 Kf7 67. Be2 {-0.85/46 Stockfish 7 64}) 66... Nc7 {-0.89/35 4 (Kf7)} (66...
Kd7 67. Bg2 Ke8 {-0.83/39 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 67. Be1 {-0.65/25 1 (Ke3)} (
67. Be3 Kd7 68. Be2 {-0.89/46 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 67... Kd7 {-0.89/36 4
(Kf6)} (67... Kf6 68. Bd2 Nd8 {-0.94/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 68. Ke3 {-0.64/27
4 (Bd2)} (68. Kg2 Ne6 69. Kf2 {-0.87/41 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 68... Ke6 {
-0.89/38 4} (68... Ne6 69. Bd2 Kc7 {-0.73/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 69. Bd2 {
-0.63/26 1 (Be2)} (69. Bg2 d5 70. exd5+ {-0.96/28 Deep Fritz 13}) 69... Kf6 {
-0.89/37 4} (69... Kd7 70. Bg2 Ne7 {-0.86/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 70. Kf2 {
-0.64/27 2} (70. Kf2 Ne6 71. Ke3 {-0.70/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 70... Ne7 {
-0.89/35 4} (70... Ne6 71. Ke3 Ne7 {-0.73/33 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 71. Bg2 {
-0.70/28 10 (Ke3)} (71. Ke2 Ne6 {-0.79/24 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 71... Kg6 {-0.89/
33 4 (Ne6)} (71... Ne6 72. Ke3 Nc6 {-0.78/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 72. Bf1 {
-0.69/25 3 (Ke3)} (72. Bh1 Ne6 73. Bg2 {-0.83/24 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 72... Ne6
{-0.89/34 3} (72... Kf6 73. Bg2 Ne6 {-0.82/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 73. Be2 {
-0.69/25 2 (Bg2)} (73. Bg2 Kf7 74. Bf1 {-0.70/26 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 73... Kf6 {
-0.89/33 5} (73... Ng5 74. b4 cxb4 {-0.86/24 Deep Fritz 14}) 74. Bf1 {-0.67/27
3} Kf7 {-0.89/35 3} 75. Ke2 {-0.63/24 3 (Bg2)} (75. Ke2 Kf6 76. Kf2 {-0.49/28
Houdini 3 Pro x64}) 75... Kg6 {-0.89/34 4 (Kg7)} (75... Ke8 76. Kf2 Kd7 {
-0.85/41 Stockfish 7 64}) 76. Kf2 {-0.68/25 2} (76. Kf2 Ng5 77. Bg2 {-0.69/25
Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 76... Nc6 {-0.89/35 2 (Ng5)} (76... Kf6 77. Be1 Ng5 {
-0.54/27 Houdini 4 x64A}) 77. Kg2 {-0.70/25 4 (Be2)} Kf6 {-0.89/34 4} 78. Kf2 {
-0.70/28 7} Ke7 {-0.89/36 3 (Ng5)} (78... Ng5 79. Bg2 Nd8 {-0.83/42 Stockfish
290116 64 BMI2}) 79. Ke2 {-0.69/27 3 (Be2)} (79. Ke3 Kf7 80. Ke2 {-0.74/26
Komodo 6 64-bit}) 79... Ke8 {-0.89/35 3 (Kf7)} (79... Kf6 80. Ke3 Ne7 {-0.63/
35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 80. Ke3 {
-0.69/29 4 (Kf2)} (80. Ke3 Kf7 81. Be2 {-0.71/35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 80... Kd7
{-0.89/36 3 (Kf7)} (80... Kd7 81. Kf2 Nc7 {-0.57/27 Fritz 11 SE}) 81. Ke2 {
-0.69/27 2 (Be2)} (81. Kf2 Ne7 82. Be3 {-0.66/35 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 81... Kc7
{-0.89/32 4 (Ncd8)} (81... c4 82. b4 axb4 {-1.09/20 Deep Fritz 14}) 82. Ke3 {
-0.69/27 2 (Kf2)} (82. Be3 Ncd8 83. Bd2 {-0.88/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 82...
Ncd8 {-0.89/36 6} (82... Kd7 83. Be2 Nf8 {-0.80/45 Stockfish 7 64}) 83. Bg2 {
-0.69/28 7 (Be2)} (83. Ke2 Nc6 84. Ke3 {-0.91/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 83...
Kc6 {-0.89/35 4 (Kd7)} (83... Nc6 84. Bf1 Kd7 {-0.86/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
84. Ke2 {-0.69/29 4 (Kf2)} (84. Bf1 Kd7 85. Be2 {-0.73/24 Deep Rybka 4 x64})
84... Nf7 {-0.89/32 3 (Kd7)} (84... Kc7 85. Kf2 Nc6 {-0.85/41 Stockfish 7 64})
85. Ke3 {-0.73/28 14 (Kf2)} (85. Kf2 Nfd8 86. Bf1 {-0.83/44 Stockfish 7 64
POPCNT}) 85... Kc7 {-0.89/34 4 (Nfg5)} (85... Nfg5 86. Ke2 Nh3 {-0.80/29
Komodo 9.1 32-bit}) 86. Kf2 {-0.76/23 4} (86. Bh1 Kc6 87. Bg2 {-0.82/41
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 86... Kd7 {-0.89/36 1} 87. Bf1 {-0.76/23 3 (Ke3)} (87.
Bf1 Nfd8 88. Be2 {-0.84/45 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 87... Nfd8 {-0.89/38 5 (Kc6)
} 88. Bg2 {-0.76/24 2} (88. Be2 Nc6 89. Bd1 {-0.89/45 Stockfish 7}) 88... Nc6 {
-0.89/38 2 (Kc8)} (88... Ke7 89. Bf1 Nf7 {-0.73/33 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 89. Bf1
{-0.76/27 3} (89. Bf1 Ke7 90. Be2 {-0.86/44 Stockfish 7 64}) 89... Ne7 {
-0.89/35 3 (Ned8)} (89... Ncd8 90. Bg2 Nf7 {-0.82/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 90.
Be2 {-0.76/25 3} (90. Bg2 Kc6 91. Be3 {-0.73/35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 90... Kc7 {
-0.89/36 5 (Nd8)} (90... Nc6 91. Bf1 Nb8 {-0.81/41 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 91.
Bf1 {-0.76/25 1} (91. Ke3 Kd7 92. Bd1 {-0.94/46 Stockfish 7 64}) 91... Kc6 {
-0.89/37 3 (Nd8)} (91... Nc6 92. Ke3 Nb8 {-0.82/47 Stockfish 7 64}) 92. Ke2 {
-0.76/25 3 (Ke3)} (92. Be2 Ng8 93. Ke3 {-0.85/24 Houdini 3 x64}) 92... Kd7 {
-0.89/36 4 (Ng6)} 93. Be3 {-0.76/29 4 (Kf2)} (93. Kf2 Ng8 94. Bg2 {-0.84/42
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 93... Kc7 {-0.89/35 3} (93... Ng8 94. Kf2 Nf6 {-0.84/
38 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 94. Bd2 {-0.76/30 4} (94. Ke1 Ng6 95. Kf2 {-0.82/27
Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 94... Kb7 {-0.89/36 3 (Nd8)} (94... Kd7 95. Kf2 Nc6 {
-0.71/41 Stockfish 6 64}) 95. Ke3 {-0.76/30 6} Nc6 {-0.89/33 8} (95... Kc7 96.
Kf2 Ng6 {-0.66/31 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 96. Be2 {-0.76/29 3 (Kf2)} (96. Be2 Kc7
97. Bd1 {-0.87/47 Stockfish 7 64}) 96... Ned8 {-0.89/36 4 (Ncd8)} (96... Kc7
97. Kf2 Kd8 {-0.86/48 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 97. Kf2 {-0.76/28 7} (97. Kf2 Ne6
98. Ke3 {-0.83/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 97... Kc7 {-0.89/37 1} (97... Ne6 98. Bf1
Ncd8 {-0.73/39 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 98. Bf1 {-0.76/30 3 (Bg5)} (98. Bd1 Ne6 99.
Bc1 {-0.66/28 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 98... Nb8 {-0.89/35 4 (Kd7)} (98... Ne6 99. Be3
Ncd8 {-0.84/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 99. Ke3 {-0.75/27 3 (Bg2)} (99. Ke1 Ne6 100.
Ke2 {-0.74/27 Fritz 13}) 99... Ne6 {-0.82/34 34} (99... Nbc6 100. Be2 Ne6 {
-0.87/51 Stockfish 7 64}) 100. Be2 {-0.71/28 2 (Ke2)} (100. Ke2 Nd7 101. Kf2 {
-0.76/38 Stockfish 4 64}) 100... Kc8 {-0.89/32 18 (Kd7)} (100... Nc6 101. Kf2 {
-0.66/32 Komodo 9.3 32-bit}) 101. Kf2 {-0.68/28 2 (Be1)} (101. Bf1 Kd7 102. Ke2
{-0.80/28 Fritz 13}) 101... Nc6 {-0.80/29 6 (Kd7)} (101... Nd7 102. Bf1 Kd8 {
-0.75/27 Deep Fritz 13}) 102. Bd1 {-0.73/26 5 (Ke1)} Kd7 {-0.89/26 3} (102...
Nb8 103. Bc1 Nd7 {-0.88/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 103. Be2 {-0.65/24 3 (Bc2)} (
103. Bh6 Ncd8 104. Be3 {-0.51/32 Houdini 3 x64}) 103... Ke8 {-0.78/27 9 (Ncd8)}
(103... Nc7 104. Bf1 Ke6 {-0.92/27 Fritz 13 SE}) 104. Ke3 {-0.59/24 4 (Bf1)} (
104. Ke3 Kf7 105. Bf1 {-0.71/27 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 104... Kd8 {-0.75/27 4 (Kf7)}
(104... Ke7 105. Bf1 Ncd8 {-0.87/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 105. Bf1 {-0.65/24 7
(Kf2)} (105. Bf1 Ke7 106. Kf2 {-0.74/25 Deep Rybka 4 w32}) 105... Kc7 {-0.71/
26 4 (Ne7)} (105... Ke7 106. Ke2 Kf6 {-0.68/26 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 106. Kf2 {
-0.58/23 3} (106. Be2 Nb8 107. Kf2 {-0.83/43 Stockfish 290116 64 BMI2}) 106...
Nb8 {-0.72/25 4 (Kc8)} (106... Kd7 107. Bg2 Kc8 {-0.79/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
107. Be2 {-0.52/22 5 (Be1)} (107. Ke3 Nd7 108. Ke2 {-0.71/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}
) 107... Kd7 {-0.72/27 2} (107... Nd7 108. Bd1 Nf6 {-0.86/26 Deep Fritz 14})
108. Bf1 {-0.53/23 6} (108. Bf1 Nc6 109. Bg2 {-0.61/26 Fritz 12}) 108... Kc6 {
-0.72/28 1 (Ke7)} (108... Nc7 109. Bg2 Ke6 {-0.94/27 Fritz 13}) 109. Ke2 {
-0.48/20 2} (109. Be3 Nd7 110. Ke2 {-0.66/34 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 109... b5 {
-0.72/30 3 (Nd7)} (109... Nd7 110. Bc1 Nf6 {-0.69/29 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 110.
axb5+ {-0.45/25 3} (110. axb5+ Kxb5 111. Kf2 {-0.77/39 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
110... Kxb5 {-0.72/31 1} (110... Kxb5 111. Kd1 Kb6 {-0.73/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}
) 111. Ke3 {-0.46/26 3} (111. Ke3 Kb6 112. Kf2 {-0.77/42 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}
) 111... Kc6 {-0.72/32 3} (111... Kb6 112. Be2 Na6 {-0.48/27 Komodo 8 32-bit})
112. Ke2 {-0.46/23 3} (112. Be2 Kc7 113. Bc1 {-0.52/35 Stockfish 6 x64}) 112...
Nd7 {-0.72/32 9} (112... Nd7 113. Be3 Kc7 {-0.62/29 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 113.
Be3 {-0.46/24 2 (Ke3)} (113. Kd1 Nf6 114. Be3 {-0.72/33 Stockfish 7 64}) 113...
Nf6 {-0.72/30 3} 114. Bd2 {-0.45/25 5} (114. Bd2 Nd7 115. Ke3 {-0.73/41
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 114... Kc7 {-0.72/30 4 (Ne8)} (114... Nd7 115. Bc1 Nb6
{-0.54/25 Deep Fritz 13}) 115. Kf2 {-0.45/24 6 (Be3)} (115. Ke3 Ng8 116. Be2 {
-0.58/24 Deep Rybka 4 x64}) 115... Nd7 {-0.72/31 2 (Kb6)} (115... Kc6 116. Be2
Ne8 {-0.46/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 116.
Ke3 {-0.45/25 3 (Be2)} (116. Be2 Nf6 117. Ke3 {-0.31/28 Houdini 3 x64}) 116...
Nb8 {-0.72/32 2 (Kc6)} (116... Kb7 117. Be2 Nb8 {-0.74/42 Stockfish 7 64}) 117.
Ke2 {-0.46/27 4} (117. Kf2 Kc6 118. Ke3 {-0.33/29 Houdini 4 x64A}) 117... Kc6 {
-0.72/32 3 (Kb6)} (117... Kb6 118. Kf2 Kb7 {-0.46/34 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 118.
Ke3 {-0.47/27 6 (Kf2)} (118. Kf2 Nd7 119. Be2 {-0.59/27 Fritz 13}) 118... Kb6 {
-0.72/33 3} (118... Nd7 119. Ke2 Nf6 {-0.72/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 119. Ke2 {
-0.46/27 4 (Bg2)} (119. Be2 Nc6 120. Bd1 {-0.80/47 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT})
119... Nc6 {-0.72/30 3 (Na6)} (119... Kc6 120. Kd1 Nd7 {-0.72/38 Stockfish 7})
120. Be3 {-0.46/27 4 (Bg2)} (120. Ke1 Ncd8 121. Be2 {-0.76/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64
}) 120... Kc7 {-0.72/31 3 (Na7)} (120... Kc7 121. Kd2 Nb8 {-0.69/36 Stockfish
7 64 POPCNT}) 121. Bd2 {-0.47/28 3} (121. Kf2 Kb6 122. Be2 {-0.45/37 Komodo 9.
3 64-bit}) 121... Kd7 {-0.72/31 2 (Na7)} 122. Ke3 {-0.46/27 3} (122. Ke3 Ncd8
123. Be2 {-0.74/46 Stockfish 5 64}) 122... Ke7 {-0.72/31 3 (Na7)} (122... Ng5
123. Kf2 Nf7 {-0.73/23 Deep Fritz 14}) 123. Be2 {-0.46/28 3 (Bg2)} (123. Bc1
Ng5 124. Ke2 {-0.63/22 Deep Rybka 4 w32}) 123... Kf6 {-0.72/32 3 (Kd8)} (123...
Kd7 124. Kf2 Kc7 {-0.72/43 Stockfish 7 64}) 124. Bd1 {-0.46/26 4 (Bf1)} (124.
Kf2 Ncd8 125. Bd1 {-0.73/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 124... Kg5 {-0.72/34 3 (Na7)} (
124... Ke7 125. Ke2 Kd8 {-0.69/42 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 125. Ke2+ {-0.47/27
3 (Kf2+)} (125. Kf2+ Kf6 126. Kf1 {-0.73/24 Deep Fritz 14}) 125... Kg6 {
-0.72/38 3} (125... Kf6 126. Ke3 Nf8 {-0.43/27 Komodo 6 64-bit}) 126. Ke3 {
-0.46/30 7} (126. Kf2 Kf6 127. Kf1 {-0.74/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 126... Ned8 {
-0.72/33 3 (Kf6)} (126... Kg5 127. Kf2+ Kf6 {-0.58/42 Stockfish 6 64}) 127. Ke2
{-0.46/29 3 (Kf2)} (127. Be2 Ne6 128. Kf2 {-0.58/42 Stockfish 6 x64}) 127...
Kf6 {-0.72/37 3 (Nf7)} (127... Kf7 128. Ke3 Ne6 {-0.45/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
128. Bc2 {-0.45/27 3 (Kf2)} Ne6 {-0.72/36 4 (Ke7)} 129. Bd1 {-0.46/29 6} Kf7 {
-0.72/36 3 (Ke7)} (129... Ne7 130. Kf2 Nc8 {-0.46/33 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 130.
Ke3 {-0.47/30 4 (Kf2)} (130. Ke3 Ne7 131. Kf2 {-0.42/30 Komodo 9.1 32-bit})
130... Nc7 {-0.72/36 3} (130... Ke7 131. Kf2 Kd7 {-0.77/39 Stockfish 290116 64
BMI2}) 131. Kf2 {-0.47/31 5} (131. Kf2 Ne6 132. Bc1 {-0.46/29 Deep Fritz 13})
131... Kf6 {-0.72/37 2 (Ke6)} (131... Ne6 132. Be3 Ned8 {-0.75/26 Deep Fritz
14 x64}) 132. Be2 {-0.47/32 4 (Ke3)} (132. Be3 Nb5 133. Bd2 {-0.33/29 Houdini
3 Pro x64}) 132... Ke7 {-0.72/38 3} (132... Ne6 133. Bc1 Ncd8 {-0.72/26
Houdini 3 x64}) 133. Bf1 {-0.47/28 5 (Bd1)} (133. Bf1 Kf6 134. Be2 {-0.42/27
Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 133... Kd7 {-0.72/37 5 (Kf7)} (133... Na7 134. Be2 Kf6 {
-0.47/28 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 134. Ke3 {-0.47/26 2 (Be2)} (134. Be2 Na7 135. Ke1 {
-0.45/32 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 134... Ke6 {-0.72/35 3 (Nb5)} (134... Nb5 135. Ke2
Ne7 {-0.34/26 Fritz 11 SE}) 135. Be1 {-0.47/28 3 (Kf2)} (135. Be2 Nb5 136. Kf2
{-0.43/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 135...
Kf6 {-0.72/35 3} (135... Ke7 136. Kf2 Kf6 {-0.73/24 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 136.
Be2 {-0.46/28 3 (Bd2)} (136. Bd2 Ne6 137. Be2 {-0.72/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64})
136... Ne6 {-0.72/33 3} (136... Nd8 137. Bd2 Nde6 {-0.30/28 Houdini 3 Pro x64})
137. Bd2 {-0.46/24 2 (Kf2)} Ned8 {-0.72/36 4 (Ke7)} (137... Ne7 138. Kf2 Ng5 {
-0.48/26 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 138. Bd1 {-0.47/28 3 (Kf2)} (138. Bf1 Ne6 139. Ke2 {
-0.74/42 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 138... Ke7 {-0.72/40 3 (Nf7)} (138... Ne6 139.
Be1 Kf7 {-0.73/26 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 139. Be2 {-0.47/31 5 (Kf2)} (139. Be2 Nf7
140. Bd1 {-0.42/36 Komodo 9.3 32-bit}) 139... Ne6 {-0.72/39 5 (Nf7)} 140. Kf2 {
-0.46/28 6} (140. Kf2 Kd8 141. Bd1 {-0.74/47 Stockfish 5 64}) 140... Kd7 {
-0.72/39 9} 141. Ke3 {-0.47/29 6 (Bf1)} (141. Bd1 Kc7 142. Ke3 {-0.74/46
Stockfish 7 64}) 141... Ne7 {-0.72/35 5 (Kd8)} (141... Kc7 142. Bd1 Kb6 {
-0.38/26 Fritz 11 SE}) 142. Bd1 {-0.46/29 6 (Kf2)} (142. Be1 Nc6 143. Bd1 {
-0.65/40 Stockfish 7 64}) 142... Kc7 {-0.61/30 8} (142... Nc6 143. Bc2 Kc8 {
-0.74/45 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 143. Be2 {-0.47/28 3 (b4)} (143. Kf2 Kd8 144.
Bc1 {-0.75/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 143... Kb6 {-0.72/35 3} (143... Ng8 144. Bd1
Nf6 {-0.61/27 Fritz 13}) 144. Bd1 {-0.46/27 2 (Kf2)} Nc6 {-0.71/33 6} (144...
Nc6 145. Kf2 Ncd8 {-0.72/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 145. Be2 {-0.46/29 4} (145. Kf2
Kc7 146. Ke3 {-0.66/42 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 145... Kc7 {-0.71/33 1} (145...
Kc7 146. Bd1 Kd7 {-0.78/48 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 146. Bd1 {-0.46/30 9 (Kf2)}
(146. Kf2 Na7 147. Bf1 {-0.48/38 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 146... Kb7 {-0.67/32 7} (
146... Ng5 147. Ke2 Nf7 {-0.43/36 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 147. Be2 {-0.47/30 3} (
147. Bc1 Kc7 148. Bd2 {-0.74/25 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 147... Kb6 {-0.67/28 3
(Kc8)} (147... Kc8 148. Bc1 Kd7 {-0.74/24 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 148. Bf1 {
-0.46/26 3 (Bd1)} Na7 {-0.62/27 8} (148... Kc7 149. Ke2 Kd8 {-0.76/25 Deep
Fritz 14 x64}) 149. Be2 {-0.44/25 2 (Be1)} (149. Ke2 Nb5 150. Kd1 {-0.52/26
Komodo 6 64-bit}) 149... Nb5 {-0.57/27 5} (149... Nb5 150. Be1 Nec7 {-0.44/36
Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 150. Be1 {-0.47/25 4} (150. Be1 Nec7 151. Kd2 {-0.58/25
Deep Rybka 4 x64}) 150... Nec7 {-0.53/27 8} (150... Na7 151. Bd2 Nc6 {-0.54/39
Stockfish 4 64}) 151. Kd2 {-0.36/24 5 (Kf2)} (151. Kd2 Ne8 152. Bf2 {-0.49/27
Deep Fritz 13}) 151... Ka7 {-0.53/26 3 (Kc6)} (151... Ne6 152. Ke3 Nec7 {
-0.73/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 152. Bf1 {-0.29/22 2 (Kc1)} (152. Bf2 Kb6 153. Bf1
{-0.33/27 Fritz 11 SE}) 152... Kb7 {-0.45/27 10} (152... Kb6 153. Bf2 Ne6 {
0.58/27 Fritz 13}) 153. Kd1 {-0.39/24 7 (Kc2)} (153. Be2 Kb6 154. Bd1 {-0.32/
30 Houdini 4 x64A}) 153... Ne6 {-0.46/24 4 (Kc6)} (153... Ne6 154. Be2 Nbc7 {
-0.72/33 Stockfish 7}) 154. Bd2 {-0.38/22 2 (Bg2)} (154. Kd2 Kc6 155. Be2 {
-0.54/38 Stockfish 6 64}) 154... Na7 {-0.56/26 7 (Kc6)} (154... Nbc7 155. Kc2
Ne8 {-0.69/34 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 155. Be2 {-0.27/24 8 (Kc1)} (155. Be3 Nc6
156. Kd2 {-0.59/28 Fritz 13}) 155... Nc8 {-0.56/26 2} (155... Nc6 156. Bc1 Ne7
{-0.77/37 Stockfish 290116 64 BMI2}) 156. Ke1 {-0.28/23 3 (Be3)} (156. Ke1 Na7
157. Bd1 {-0.50/35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 156... Nb6 {-0.43/25 8} (156... Na7 157.
Kf2 Kb6 {-0.74/43 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 157. Bd1 {-0.47/22 4} Ka6 {-0.33/26
4 (a4)} (157... Nd8 158. Ke2 Ka6 {-0.63/34 Stockfish 7 64}) 158. Be2 {-0.44/23
8 (Kf2)} a4 {-0.34/24 2} (158... Kb5 159. Bd1 Nd7 {-0.62/27 Fritz 13 SE}) 159.
bxa4 {-0.47/22 1} (159. bxa4 c4 160. d4 {-0.61/27 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 159...
c4 {-0.65/25 2} (159... c4 {-1.02/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 160. d4 {-0.47/24 3} (
160. d4 exd4 161. cxd4 {-0.64/39 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 160... exd4 {-0.53/25
1} (160... exd4 161. cxd4 Nxd4 {-0.74/26 Gull 3 x64}) 161. cxd4 {-0.37/24 2} (
161. cxd4 Nxd4 162. a5 {-0.74/42 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 161... Nxd4 {-0.52/30
5} (161... Nxd4 162. a5 {-0.49/37 Stockfish 7 64}) 162. a5 {-0.36/25 2} (162.
a5 Nxe2 163. Kxe2 {-0.50/36 Stockfish 7 64}) 162... Nxe2 {-0.39/27 1} 163. Kxe2
{-0.36/25 2} (163. Kxe2 {-0.50/36 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 163... Na4 {-0.53/28
3} 164. Bb4 {-0.36/25 2} (164. Bb4 Kb5 165. Bxd6 {-1.33/24 Deep Rybka 4 w32})
164... Kb5 {-0.36/27 2} (164... Kb5 165. Bxd6 Kxa5 {-0.63/28 Deep Fritz 13})
165. Bxd6 {-0.57/25 3} Kxa5 {-0.35/32 8} (165... Kxa5 166. e5 Kb5 {-0.89/23
Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 166. e5 {-0.48/27 3} (166. e5 Kb5 167. e6 {-0.50/32 Komodo
8 64-bit}) 166... Kb5 {-0.35/32 2} (166... Nc3+ 167. Ke3 Nb5 {0.00/39
Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 167. e6 {-0.40/28 3} (167. e6 Kc6 168. Ba3 {-0.90/27
Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 167... Kc6 {-0.35/32 5} (167... Kc6 168. Ba3 Nb6 {-0.59/41
Stockfish 5 64}) 168. Bb8 {-0.36/30 8} (168. Bb8 Nc5 169. e7 {-0.34/23 Komodo
8 64-bit}) 168... Nc5 {-0.28/33 6} (168... Nc5 169. e7 Kd7 {-0.63/40 Stockfish
5 64 SSE4.2}) 169. e7 {-0.33/30 2} Kd7 {-0.28/35 1} (169... Kd7 170. Kd2 {
-0.03/44 Komodo 9.3 64-bit + Powerbook 2016 + Full syzygy TB on SSD}) 170. Kd2
{-0.31/33 4} (170. Kd2 Kxe7 {-0.63/32 Komodo TCECr 64-bit}) 170... c3+ {
-0.28/36 2 (Kxe7)} (170... Kxe7 171. Kc3 Ne4+ {-0.48/42 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
171. Kxc3 {-0.16/29 2} (171. Kxc3 Kxe7 172. Kd4 {-0.53/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64})
171... Kxe7 {-0.28/38 1} (171... Kxe7 172. Kd4 Nd7 {-0.21/68 Stockfish 7 64})
172. Kd4 {-0.16/36 4 (Kc4)} (172. Kd4 Nd7 173. Ba7 {-0.65/32 Houdini 3 x64})
172... Nd7 {-0.28/42 2} (172... Nd7 173. Ba7 Kf6 {-0.44/33 Fritz 12}) 173. Ba7
{-0.16/37 2 (Bc7)} (173. Ba7 Ke6 174. Ke4 {-0.08/51 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 173...
Ke6 {-0.28/50 3} (173... Kf6 174. Ke4 Nf8 {-0.50/28 Deep Fritz 14}) 174. Ke4 {
-0.08/35 2} (174. Ke4 Kf6 175. Bd4+ {-0.27/31 Houdini 3 x64}) 174... Kf6 {
-0.28/50 1} (174... Kf6 175. Bd4+ Kg5 {-0.17/50 Stockfish 7 64}) 175. Bd4+ {
-0.08/38 3 (Be3)} (175. Bd4+ Kg6 176. Kf4 {-0.53/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 175...
Kg6 {-0.28/54 4} (175... Kg6 176. Kf4 Nf8 {-0.18/42 Komodo 9.1 32-bit}) 176.
Be3 {-0.08/37 3 (Kf4)} (176. Kf4 Nf8 177. Bb6 {-0.34/35 Komodo 9.3 64-bit})
176... Nf6+ {-0.28/53 3 (Nb8)} (176... Nf6+ 177. Ke5 Ne8 {-0.71/33 Deep Rybka
4 x64}) 177. Ke5 {-0.07/37 2} Ne8 {-0.28/54 1 (Nh7)} (177... Ne8 178. Bd2 Ng7 {
-0.24/50 Stockfish 7 64}) 178. Bb6 {-0.06/37 4 (Bd4)} (178. Bb6 Nf6 179. Ba5 {
-0.43/33 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 178... Ng7 {-0.28/54 3} (178... Nf6 179. Be3 Nd7+
{-0.21/73 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 179. Be3 {-0.05/38 5 (Kf4)} (179. Bf2 Nf5
180. Ke6 {-0.50/32 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 179... Nf5 {-0.28/50 3} (179... Nf5 180.
Bf4 Ne7 {0.00/115 Stockfish 290116 64 BMI2}) 180. Bf4 {-0.06/36 3} (180. Bf4
Ne7 181. Be3 {-0.30/29 Komodo 6 64-bit}) 180... Ne7 {-0.28/51 1} (180... Ne7
181. Ke4 h4 {-0.28/39 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 181. Be3 {0.00/36 3 (Kd4)} (181. Be3
Nc6+ 182. Ke6 {0.00/46 Komodo 9.1 64-bit}) 181... Nc6+ {-0.28/46 3 (Kf7)} (
181... Nc6+ 182. Kf4 {-0.26/29 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 182. Ke4 {0.00/39 3 (Kd5)} (
182. Ke6 Nd8+ 183. Ke5 {0.00/42 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 182... Kf6 {-0.28/46 3
(Nd8)} (182... Nd8 183. Kf4 Ne6+ {-0.43/27 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 183. Bf2 {
0.00/38 3 (Kd5)} (183. Kf4 Kg6 184. Bb6 {-0.25/38 Komodo 9.3 32-bit}) 183...
Nb4 {-0.28/50 3 (Ke6)} (183... Kg6 184. Be1 Nd8 {0.00/38 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 184.
Bd4+ {0.00/38 3} Kg6 {-0.28/52 1 (Ke6)} 185. Bc3 {0.00/39 4} (185. Bf2 Nc6 186.
Be3 {-0.18/36 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 185... Na6 {-0.28/53 4} 186. Ke5 {0.00/40 4
(Bd4)} (186. Ba5 Nc5+ 187. Kf4 {-0.54/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 186... Nc5 {
-0.28/51 3} (186... Nc5 187. Bd4 Nd3+ {-0.50/28 Deep Fritz 14 x64}) 187. Bd4 {
0.00/38 3} (187. Bd2 Nb7 188. Bb4 {0.00/78 Stockfish 7 64}) 187... Nd7+ {
-0.28/62 4 (Nd3+)} (187... Nd3+ 188. Ke6 Nc1 {-0.09/45 Stockfish 7 64}) 188.
Kf4 {0.00/47 4} (188. Kf4 Nf8 189. Bg1 {-0.05/50 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2}) 188...
Nf8 {-0.28/64 1 (Nf6)} (188... Nb8 189. Bb2 Nc6 {0.00/64 Stockfish 7}) 189. Ke5
{0.00/45 6} (189. Bb6 Ne6+ 190. Ke5 {-0.21/34 Komodo 8 64-bit}) 189... Nh7 {
-0.28/67 29} (189... h4 190. gxh4 Kh5 {-0.28/33 Komodo 8 32-bit}) 190. Bc5 {
0.00/44 5 (Kf4)} (190. Bb2 Ng5 191. Bc3 {0.00/113 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
190... Ng5 {0.00/43 7} (190... Nf6 191. Bf2 Ng8 {-0.51/28 Deep Fritz 14}) 191.
Be3 {0.00/45 4} (191. Bb6 h4 192. gxh4 {-0.34/37 Komodo 9.3 64-bit}) 191... h4
{0.00/50 3 (Nf7+)} (191... Nf3+ 192. Ke6 Ne1 {-0.05/48 Stockfish 5 64 SSE4.2})
192. gxh4 {0.00/56 5} (192. gxh4 {0.00/127 Stockfish 7 64 POPCNT}) 192... Nf3+
{0.00/63 1} 193. Kf4 {0.00/63 2} Nxh4 {0.00/98 2} 194. Kxg4 {0.00/30 4} Nf5 {
0.00/28 3} 195. Bc1 {0.00/39 6 (Kf4) Draw accepted} 1/2-1/2
[/pgn]
Shortest game:
[pgn][Event "WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S, Blitz 4m+4s"]
[Site "WIN-7CNAVJUHP4S"]
[Date "2016.02.21"]
[Round "90"]
[White "Komodo 9.3 64-bit"]
[Black "Stockfish 150216b 64"]
[Result "0-1"]
[Annotator "-0.49;-0.73"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "1n2k1n1/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPP1/2B1KB2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "48"]
[EventDate "2016.??.??"]
[EventType "blitz"]
[TimeControl "240+4"]
{Pentium(R) Dual-Core CPU E5200 @ 2.50GHz 2493 MHz W=23.3 plies; 1 961kN/s;
91 810 TBAs B=26.1 plies; 2 608kN/s; 17 291 TBAs} 1. d4 {-0.49/21 18} f5 {
-0.73/24 11} 2. e3 {-0.58/22 12} Nf6 {-0.67/23 5} 3. Bd3 {-0.59/22 15 (c3)} g6
{-0.69/24 15} 4. f3 {-0.59/24 31 (b4)} Nc6 {-0.80/25 11} 5. c4 {-0.56/23 5} d6
{-0.81/24 4 (e5)} 6. Kd2 {-0.57/24 10 (Kf2)} Kf7 {-0.87/25 9 (e5)} 7. Kc3 {
-0.61/24 14} e5 {-0.84/29 14} 8. d5 {-0.66/24 8} Ne7 {-0.89/26 1 (Nb8)} 9. e4 {
-0.57/23 9} f4 {-0.91/27 9 (fxe4)} 10. Kd2 {-0.90/21 15 (b4)} c5 {-0.93/26 6
(g5)} 11. Ke1 {-0.91/22 11 (a3)} h5 {-0.95/24 9 (g5)} 12. a3 {-0.96/21 14} g5 {
-1.04/24 6} 13. Kf2 {-1.35/21 12 (b4)} g4 {-1.22/26 7} 14. Kg1 {-2.15/23 26
(b4)} g3 {-1.33/28 5 (Ng6)} 15. Bd2 {-3.12/23 14 (b4)} h4 {-1.82/28 8} 16. b4 {
-3.36/26 16} Ng6 {-3.12/28 27} 17. a4 {-3.42/25 5 (Bc3)} h3 {-3.73/25 5} 18.
Bf1 {-4.27/24 13} hxg2 {-4.15/27 7 (b6)} 19. Bxg2 {-3.56/23 4} Nh7 {-4.42/24 3
(b6)} 20. a5 {-5.29/23 14} Ng5 {-5.02/26 10 (Nh4)} 21. bxc5 {-5.97/24 8 (Kf1)}
dxc5 {-5.64/25 5} 22. Kh1 {-6.77/25 10 (Kf1)} Nh4 {-6.39/28 11} 23. Bc3 {
-7.94/26 17} Ngxf3 {-7.35/30 15 (Nhxf3)} 24. Bxf3 {-8.05/24 7 (Bf1)} Nxf3 {
-8.76/30 12} 0-1
[/pgn]
-
Nordlandia
- Posts: 2845
- Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 9:38 pm
- Location: Sortland, Norway
Re: Odds setup BB vs NNP
[d]rn1qk1nr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/1PPPPPPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 0 1
Analysis by Stockfish 210216 64 BMI2:
1.e4 c5 2.d4 cxd4 3.Qxd4 Nf6 4.Rxa7 Nc6 5.Rxa8 Qxa8 6.Qe3 0-0 7.Bd3 Ne5 8.0-0 Rc8 9.f3 d6 10.Bd2 Nxd3 11.cxd3 Rc2 12.Bc3 Qa6 13.Rf2 Qa1+ 14.Rf1 Qa6
= (0.00) Depth: 29/41 00:00:41 576MN
100 games à la 5+5 may be enough to give some visual indications if the bishop pair is capable to compensate for the a-pawn deficit.
Analysis by Stockfish 210216 64 BMI2:
1.e4 c5 2.d4 cxd4 3.Qxd4 Nf6 4.Rxa7 Nc6 5.Rxa8 Qxa8 6.Qe3 0-0 7.Bd3 Ne5 8.0-0 Rc8 9.f3 d6 10.Bd2 Nxd3 11.cxd3 Rc2 12.Bc3 Qa6 13.Rf2 Qa1+ 14.Rf1 Qa6
= (0.00) Depth: 29/41 00:00:41 576MN
100 games à la 5+5 may be enough to give some visual indications if the bishop pair is capable to compensate for the a-pawn deficit.
-
hgm
- Posts: 28515
- Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:06 am
- Location: Amsterdam
- Full name: H G Muller
Re: Odds setup BB vs NNP
Indeed, it does not seem wo matter much which of the two plays with the Bishops. So they are truly equally strong. That leaves the conclusion that NNP in the end-game is significantly better than BB, in the presence of many Pawns, leading to an 80% score at this level of play.
To describe this quantitatively, it would be necessary to repeat the experiment with BB vs NN and equal Pawns. If that would lead to an 80% victory for the Bishop side, it would show that BB is exactly half a Pawn stronger than NN. If BB would triumph over NN only by 65%, it would be only 33cP stronger.
The position with all pieces present and only the imbalance-under-test deleted would give you opening values; as a rule the same advantage results in a much less extreme score, as much more can happen to swing the balance. But that also holds for pure Pawn odds, so when you convert the score percentage to centi-Pawns, you might still get the same value.
To describe this quantitatively, it would be necessary to repeat the experiment with BB vs NN and equal Pawns. If that would lead to an 80% victory for the Bishop side, it would show that BB is exactly half a Pawn stronger than NN. If BB would triumph over NN only by 65%, it would be only 33cP stronger.
The position with all pieces present and only the imbalance-under-test deleted would give you opening values; as a rule the same advantage results in a much less extreme score, as much more can happen to swing the balance. But that also holds for pure Pawn odds, so when you convert the score percentage to centi-Pawns, you might still get the same value.