Mac Engines rating tournament

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

IanO
Posts: 499
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:45 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by IanO »

Nicely done! Let us know when you update your Mac engines page with these strong new engines. I had thought Fire was closed source and Windows only.
Top
User avatar
JuLieN
Posts: 2949
Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 12:16 pm
Location: Bordeaux (France)
Full name: Julien Marcel

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by JuLieN »

IanO wrote:Nicely done! Let us know when you update your Mac engines page with these strong new engines. I had thought Fire was closed source and Windows only.
I did it two hours ago, Ian. :D
http://www.talkchess.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=49241

Fire's development stopped after v.2.2, but the sources are still available on the Internet... if one searches well enough. ;)

I just compiled Igorrit-0.086v4 and launched a gantlet for the night... We'll see if it's an improvement over v2.
"The only good bug is a dead bug." (Don Dailey)
[Blog: http://tinyurl.com/predateur ] [Facebook: http://tinyurl.com/fbpredateur ] [MacEngines: http://tinyurl.com/macengines ]
Top
IanO
Posts: 499
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:45 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by IanO »

JuLieN wrote:
IanO wrote:Nicely done! Let us know when you update your Mac engines page with these strong new engines. I had thought Fire was closed source and Windows only.
I did it two hours ago, Ian. :D
http://www.talkchess.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=49241

Fire's development stopped after v.2.2, but the sources are still available on the Internet... if one searches well enough. ;)

I just compiled Igorrit-0.086v4 and launched a gantlet for the night... We'll see if it's an improvement over v2.
Oh, I see. You only put the links to new engines in the Updates page. I like the new lightning rating list too! Amazing how differently Junior performs at lightning vs. blitz vs. tournament time controls. So the Robbolito family includes: Ivanhoe, Fire, Robbolito, and Black Mamba. And Crab is a personality of Stockfish 1.7.1.

Surprised to see Komodo 1 and 2 and 5, but not Komodo 3 in your rating list. Time for another gauntlet!
Top
User avatar
JuLieN
Posts: 2949
Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 12:16 pm
Location: Bordeaux (France)
Full name: Julien Marcel

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by JuLieN »

Results of Igorrit-0.086v4's gauntlet :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                        ELO   Games   Score   Draws
   1 Igorrit-0.086v4             145     368     70%     32%
   2 IvanHoe-999946f              89      16     62%     62%
   3 Stockfish-4                  66      16     59%     69%
   4 Komodo-5.1                   66      16     59%     69%
   5 Igorrit-0.086v2              66      16     59%     56%
   6 Critter-1.6a                  0      16     50%     38%
   7 BlackMamba-1.4                0      16     50%     50%
   8 Fire-xTreme-2.2               0      16     50%     50%
   9 Firenzina-2.3.1               0      16     50%     50%
  10 Spark-1.0                   -66      16     41%     44%
  11 Robbolito-0085g3l           -89      16     38%     50%
  12 TogaReturns-1.1            -137      16     31%     12%
  13 Hiarcs-14WCSC              -163      16     28%     19%
  14 Gull-1.2                   -221      16     22%     31%
  15 Protector-1.5.0            -255      16     19%     38%
  16 MinkoChess-1.3             -293      16     16%     19%
  17 Texel-1.02                 -338      16     12%     12%
  18 EXchess-7.11b              -338      16     12%     12%
  19 Glaurung-2.2               -394      16      9%      6%
  20 Gaviota-0.86               -470      16      6%     12%
  21 DiscoCheck-4.3             -470      16      6%      0%
  22 DeepShredder-11            -470      16      6%     12%
  23 Crafty-23.6                -470      16      6%     12%
  24 Fruit-2.3.1                -597      16      3%      6%
Link to the PGN (368 games)[/quote]

Igorrit-0.086v4 is quite stronger than Igorrit-0.086v2:

Code: Select all

   # ENGINE                    : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Komodo-5.1                : 3179.7     222.5     268   83.0%
   2 Stockfish-4               : 3175.3     220.0     268   82.1%
   3 Critter-1.6a              : 3131.5     215.5     268   80.4%
   4 IvanHoe-999946f           : 3129.8     143.0     192   74.5%
   5 Fire-xTreme-2.2           : 3119.2     207.0     268   77.2%
   6 Igorrit-0.086v4           : 3109.6     256.5     368   69.7% <--
   7 Firenzina-2.3.1           : 3108.4     132.0     192   68.8%
   8 IvanHoe-Beta-999966       : 3105.8     130.5     152   85.9%
   9 Robbolito-0085g3l         : 3094.9     206.0     268   76.9%
  10 StingSF-3VE               : 3072.5      65.0      76   85.5%
  11 Igorrit-0.086v2           : 3071.6     202.5     268   75.6% <--
IanO wrote: Surprised to see Komodo 1 and 2 and 5, but not Komodo 3 in your rating list. Time for another gauntlet!
Right! Strange forgetting! :shock: It's on it's way.
"The only good bug is a dead bug." (Don Dailey)
[Blog: http://tinyurl.com/predateur ] [Facebook: http://tinyurl.com/fbpredateur ] [MacEngines: http://tinyurl.com/macengines ]
Top
User avatar
JuLieN
Posts: 2949
Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 12:16 pm
Location: Bordeaux (France)
Full name: Julien Marcel

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by JuLieN »

Results of Komodo 3's gauntlet :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                        ELO   Games   Score   Draws
   1 Komodo-3.0                  140     248     69%     35%
   2 Stockfish-4                 137       8     69%     62%
   3 IvanHoe-999946f             137       8     69%     38%
   4 Critter-1.6a                137       8     69%     62%
   5 Fire-xTreme-2.2              89       8     62%     50%
   6 Komodo-5.1                   44       8     56%     62%
   7 StingSF-3VE                   0       8     50%     25%
   8 Robbolito-0085g3l             0       8     50%     50%
   9 BlackMamba-1.4                0       8     50%     50%
  10 Igorrit-0.086v4               0       8     50%     75%
  11 Komodo-2.01                 -44       8     44%     38%
  12 Firenzina-2.3.1             -44       8     44%     38%
  13 Spark-1.0                   -89       8     38%     50%
  14 Komodo-2.03                 -89       8     38%     75%
  15 Igorrit-0.086v2             -89       8     38%     25%
  16 Gull-1.2                    -89       8     38%     75%
  17 Texel-1.02                 -137       8     31%     38%
  18 Hiarcs-12.1                -191       8     25%     50%
  19 Hiarcs-13.1                -255       8     19%     12%
  20 TogaReturns-1.1            -338       8     12%      0%
  21 Protector-1.5.0            -338       8     12%     25%
  22 MinkoChess-1.3             -338       8     12%     25%
  23 Komodo-1.3                 -338       8     12%     25%
  24 Fruit-2.3.1                -338       8     12%     25%
  25 EXchess-7.11b              -338       8     12%     25%
  26 DiscoCheck-4.3             -338       8     12%     25%
  27 DeepShredder-11            -338       8     12%     25%
  28 Hiarcs-14WCSC              -470       8      6%     12%
  29 Glaurung-2.2               -470       8      6%     12%
  30 Crab-1.0b                  -470       8      6%     12%
  31 Gaviota-0.86               -inf       8      0%      0%
  32 Crafty-23.6                -inf       8      0%      0%
Link to the PGN (248 games)

Rating:

Code: Select all

   # ENGINE                    : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Stockfish-4               : 3174.8     225.5     276   81.7%
   2 Komodo-5.1                : 3173.3     227.0     276   82.2%
   3 Critter-1.6a              : 3133.1     221.0     276   80.1%
   4 IvanHoe-999946f           : 3132.1     148.5     200   74.2%
   5 Fire-xTreme-2.2           : 3118.3     212.0     276   76.8%
   6 Komodo-3.0                : 3104.9     171.5     248   69.2% <--
   7 Igorrit-0.086v4           : 3104.8     260.5     376   69.3%
   8 Firenzina-2.3.1           : 3101.4     135.5     200   67.8%
   9 IvanHoe-Beta-999966       : 3096.6     130.5     152   85.9%
  10 Robbolito-0085g3l         : 3090.7     210.0     276   76.1%
  11 StingSF-3VE               : 3076.2      69.0      84   82.1%
  12 Igorrit-0.086v2           : 3062.2     205.5     276   74.5%
  13 BlackMamba-1.4            : 3039.1     203.5     276   73.7%
  14 Komodo-2.01               : 3005.5      68.0      84   81.0%
  15 Komodo-2.03               : 2995.9      67.5      84   80.4%
This gauntlet made Stockfish top Komodo 5.1 in the ratings list...

Next gauntlets: HIARCS 11.2, HIARCS 13.2 and Shredder 12.
"The only good bug is a dead bug." (Don Dailey)
[Blog: http://tinyurl.com/predateur ] [Facebook: http://tinyurl.com/fbpredateur ] [MacEngines: http://tinyurl.com/macengines ]
Top
User avatar
JuLieN
Posts: 2949
Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 12:16 pm
Location: Bordeaux (France)
Full name: Julien Marcel

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by JuLieN »

Results of HIARCS 13.2's gauntlet :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                        ELO   Games   Score   Draws
   1 StingSF-3VE                 inf       8    100%      0%
   2 Igorrit-0.086v4             338       8     88%      0%
   3 Komodo-2.03                 255       8     81%     38%
   4 Igorrit-0.086v2             255       8     81%     12%
   5 Firenzina-2.3.1             255       8     81%     12%
   6 Komodo-3.0                  255       8     81%     38%
   7 Stockfish-4                 191       8     75%     25%
   8 Komodo-5.1                  191       8     75%      0%
   9 IvanHoe-999946f             191       8     75%     50%
  10 Crab-1.0b                   191       8     75%     25%
  11 Robbolito-0085g3l           137       8     69%     12%
  12 Critter-1.6a                 89       8     62%     50%
  13 Gull-1.2                     89       8     62%     25%
  14 TogaReturns-1.1              44       8     56%     62%
  15 Spark-1.0                    44       8     56%     62%
  16 Komodo-2.01                  44       8     56%     12%
  17 Hiarcs-14WCSC                44       8     56%     62%
  18 Gaviota-0.86                 44       8     56%     38%
  19 Fire-xTreme-2.2              44       8     56%     38%
  20 Hiarcs-13.1                   0       8     50%    100%
  21 Hiarcs-13.2                 -35     256     45%     34%
  22 MinkoChess-1.3              -44       8     44%     62%
  23 BlackMamba-1.4              -44       8     44%     12%
  24 Texel-1.02                  -89       8     38%     25%
  25 Protector-1.5.0             -89       8     38%     25%
  26 DeepShredder-11             -89       8     38%     25%
  27 Hiarcs-12.1                -137       8     31%     62%
  28 Crafty-23.6                -137       8     31%     38%
  29 Komodo-1.3                 -191       8     25%     50%
  30 EXchess-7.11b              -191       8     25%     50%
  31 DiscoCheck-4.3             -191       8     25%     25%
  32 Glaurung-2.2               -255       8     19%     12%
  33 Fruit-2.3.1                -338       8     12%     25%
Link to the PGN (256 games)

Rating:

Code: Select all

   # ENGINE                    : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Stockfish-4               : 3167.0     231.5     284   81.5%
   2 Komodo-5.1                : 3164.2     233.0     284   82.0%
   3 IvanHoe-999946f           : 3124.5     154.5     208   74.3%
   4 Critter-1.6a              : 3120.8     226.0     284   79.6%
   5 StingSF-3VE               : 3109.5      77.0      92   83.7%
   6 Fire-xTreme-2.2           : 3105.2     216.5     284   76.2%
   7 Komodo-3.0                : 3102.2     178.0     256   69.5%
   8 Igorrit-0.086v4           : 3100.8     267.5     384   69.7%
   9 Firenzina-2.3.1           : 3097.4     142.0     208   68.3%
  10 IvanHoe-Beta-999966       : 3092.6     130.5     152   85.9%
  11 Robbolito-0085g3l         : 3084.5     215.5     284   75.9%
  12 Igorrit-0.086v2           : 3060.8     212.0     284   74.6%
  13 BlackMamba-1.4            : 3025.6     207.0     284   72.9%
  14 Komodo-2.03               : 3012.8      74.0      92   80.4%
  15 Komodo-2.01               : 2988.7      72.5      92   78.8%
  16 Crab-1.0b                 : 2986.0      71.5      92   77.7%
  17 Gull-1.2                  : 2952.1     106.5     208   51.2%
  18 TogaReturns-1.1           : 2941.4     180.0     284   63.4%
  19 Hiarcs-14WCSC             : 2939.1     180.5     284   63.6%
  20 Spark-1.0                 : 2909.9     168.0     284   59.2%
  21 Protector-1.5.0           : 2900.7     162.5     284   57.2%
  22 Hiarcs-13.2               : 2896.8     115.0     256   44.9% <--
  23 Komodo-1.3                : 2866.7      64.5      92   70.1%
  24 Hiarcs-13.1               : 2843.1      54.5      92   59.2%
  25 Hiarcs-12.1               : 2830.4      67.0      92   72.8%
  26 Texel-1.02                : 2801.4     138.5     284   48.8%
HIARCS 13.2 was 50 Elo points stronger than HIARCS 13.1. Not bad an improvement!
"The only good bug is a dead bug." (Don Dailey)
[Blog: http://tinyurl.com/predateur ] [Facebook: http://tinyurl.com/fbpredateur ] [MacEngines: http://tinyurl.com/macengines ]
Top
User avatar
JuLieN
Posts: 2949
Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 12:16 pm
Location: Bordeaux (France)
Full name: Julien Marcel

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by JuLieN »

Results of Shredder 12's gauntlet :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                        ELO   Games   Score   Draws
   1 Stockfish-4                 inf       8    100%      0%
   2 Crab-1.0b                   338       8     88%     25%
   3 Fire-xTreme-2.2             338       8     88%     25%
   4 Komodo-3.0                  338       8     88%      0%
   5 Robbolito-0085g3l           255       8     81%     38%
   6 Komodo-2.03                 255       8     81%     12%
   7 StingSF-3VE                 191       8     75%     50%
   8 Komodo-5.1                  191       8     75%     25%
   9 MinkoChess-1.3              137       8     69%     12%
  10 Igorrit-0.086v2             137       8     69%     38%
  11 BlackMamba-1.4              137       8     69%     12%
  12 Firenzina-2.3.1             137       8     69%     12%
  13 Komodo-2.01                  89       8     62%     50%
  14 IvanHoe-999946f              89       8     62%     25%
  15 Protector-1.5.0              44       8     56%     38%
  16 Igorrit-0.086v4              44       8     56%     38%
  17 Texel-1.02                    0       8     50%      0%
  18 Komodo-1.3                    0       8     50%     25%
  19 Hiarcs-14WCSC                 0       8     50%     75%
  20 Hiarcs-12.1                   0       8     50%     25%
  21 EXchess-7.11b                 0       8     50%     50%
  22 Critter-1.6a                  0       8     50%     50%
  23 Gull-1.2                      0       8     50%     50%
  24 Hiarcs-13.2                   0       8     50%     50%
  25 Shredder-12                 -36     264     45%     30%
  26 TogaReturns-1.1             -44       8     44%     38%
  27 Fruit-2.3.1                 -44       8     44%     38%
  28 Hiarcs-13.1                 -89       8     38%     25%
  29 DeepShredder-11            -137       8     31%     62%
  30 Crafty-23.6                -191       8     25%     25%
  31 Spark-1.0                  -338       8     12%      0%
  32 Glaurung-2.2               -338       8     12%     25%
  33 Gaviota-0.86               -338       8     12%     25%
  34 DiscoCheck-4.3             -338       8     12%     25%
Link to the PGN (264 games)

0% against Stockfish 4! This is quite frightening!

Rating:

Code: Select all

  19 Hiarcs-14WCSC             : 2931.1     184.5     292   63.2%
  20 Protector-1.5.0           : 2895.9     167.0     292   57.2%
  21 Spark-1.0                 : 2892.9     169.0     292   57.9%
  22 Hiarcs-13.2               : 2892.4     119.0     264   45.1%
  23 Shredder-12               : 2890.8     118.5     264   44.9% <--
  24 Komodo-1.3                : 2867.0      68.5     100   68.5%
  25 Hiarcs-12.1               : 2835.8      71.0     100   71.0%
  26 Hiarcs-13.1               : 2833.9      57.5     100   57.5%
  27 MinkoChess-1.3            : 2801.9     142.0     292   48.6%
  28 Texel-1.02                : 2799.7     142.5     292   48.8%
  29 TogaII-1.4.1              : 2795.2      50.0      76   65.8%
  30 TogaII-3.0                : 2787.4      49.5      76   65.1%
  31 TogaToy-1.0               : 2755.4      51.0      76   67.1%
  32 Hiarcs-11.1               : 2740.8      57.0      76   75.0%
  33 Gaviota-0.86              : 2728.3     126.0     292   43.2%
  34 DeepShredder-11           : 2724.4     129.5     292   44.3%
"The only good bug is a dead bug." (Don Dailey)
[Blog: http://tinyurl.com/predateur ] [Facebook: http://tinyurl.com/fbpredateur ] [MacEngines: http://tinyurl.com/macengines ]
Top
User avatar
JuLieN
Posts: 2949
Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 12:16 pm
Location: Bordeaux (France)
Full name: Julien Marcel

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by JuLieN »

As Deep Junior's results were not at par with it's real strength, because of it's horrible time management making it lose half it's games on time, I decided to remove all of it's game from my game base and do a new gauntlet allowing cutechess's -timemargin argument to allow engines to go 50,000 milliseconds over the time limit per move (50s!). Despite that DJ 13?3 still lost a couple of games on time, but that was all. So here are more realistic results after its gauntlet:

Results of Shredder 12's gauntlet :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                        ELO   Games   Score   Draws
   1 Robbolito-0085g3l           338       8     88%     25%
   2 IvanHoe-999946f             255       8     81%     12%
   3 Igorrit-0.086v2             255       8     81%     12%
   4 BlackMamba-1.4              255       8     81%     12%
   5 Firenzina-2.3.1             255       8     81%     38%
   6 Igorrit-0.086v4             255       8     81%     12%
   7 Stockfish-4                 191       8     75%     25%
   8 StingSF-3VE                 191       8     75%     25%
   9 Fire-xTreme-2.2             191       8     75%     50%
  10 Spark-1.0                   137       8     69%     38%
  11 Komodo-5.1                  137       8     69%     38%
  12 Komodo-1.3                  137       8     69%     12%
  13 DiscoCheck-4.3              137       8     69%     38%
  14 Critter-1.6a                137       8     69%     12%
  15 Crafty-23.6                 137       8     69%     12%
  16 Komodo-3.0                  137       8     69%     38%
  17 Komodo-2.03                  89       8     62%      0%
  18 Gaviota-0.86                 89       8     62%      0%
  19 Fruit-2.3.1                  89       8     62%     25%
  20 DeepShredder-11              89       8     62%     25%
  21 Crab-1.0b                    89       8     62%      0%
  22 Hiarcs-14WCSC                44       8     56%     12%
  23 Komodo-2.01                   0       8     50%     50%
  24 Hiarcs-12.1                   0       8     50%     25%
  25 EXchess-7.11b                 0       8     50%     25%
  26 Gull-1.2                      0       8     50%      0%
  27 Hiarcs-13.2                   0       8     50%     50%
  28 Shredder-12                   0       8     50%     50%
  29 DeepJunior-13.3             -73     272     40%     24% <--
  30 Glaurung-2.2                -89       8     38%     25%
  31 Texel-1.02                 -137       8     31%     12%
  32 Protector-1.5.0            -137       8     31%     38%
  33 Hiarcs-13.1                -137       8     31%     12%
  34 TogaReturns-1.1            -191       8     25%     25%
  35 MinkoChess-1.3             -191       8     25%     25%
Link to the PGN (272 games)

Rating:

Code: Select all

  15 Crab-1.0b                 : 2972.8      83.5     112   74.6%
  16 Komodo-2.01               : 2962.1      87.0     116   75.0%
  17 Gull-1.2                  : 2937.6     120.0     232   51.7%
  18 Hiarcs-14WCSC             : 2929.3     195.0     308   63.3%
  19 TogaReturns-1.1           : 2910.7     184.5     304   60.7%
  20 Komodo-1.3                : 2900.9      81.0     116   69.8%
  21 Spark-1.0                 : 2891.4     179.0     308   58.1%
  22 Hiarcs-13.2               : 2887.5     128.0     280   45.7%
  23 Protector-1.5.0           : 2885.4     171.0     304   56.2%
  24 Shredder-12               : 2877.4     124.5     280   44.5%
  25 DeepJunior-13.3           : 2839.7     111.5     280   39.8% <--
  26 DeepJunior-12.5.043       : 2836.7     110.5     280   39.5%
  27 Hiarcs-12.1               : 2825.4      75.5     112   67.4%
  28 Hiarcs-13.1               : 2814.7      63.5     116   54.7%
  29 Texel-1.02                : 2804.6     146.0     300   48.7%
  30 MinkoChess-1.3            : 2791.2     147.0     308   47.7%
"The only good bug is a dead bug." (Don Dailey)
[Blog: http://tinyurl.com/predateur ] [Facebook: http://tinyurl.com/fbpredateur ] [MacEngines: http://tinyurl.com/macengines ]
Top
User avatar
JuLieN
Posts: 2949
Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 12:16 pm
Location: Bordeaux (France)
Full name: Julien Marcel

Re: Mac Engines rating tournament

Post by JuLieN »

Here's the result of a big "Top 30" round-robin tournaments with the 30 best engines (one version by engine only):

Code: Select all

Rank Name                        ELO   Games   Score   Draws
   1 Komodo-5.1                  300     116     85%     18%
   2 Stockfish-4                 278     116     83%     25%
   3 Fire-xTreme-2.2             243     116     80%     29%
   4 Critter-1.6a                224     116     78%     31%
   5 Robbolito-0085g3l           211     116     77%     23%
   6 IvanHoe-999946f             211     116     77%     34%
   7 Igorrit-0.086v4             164     116     72%     35%
   8 BlackMamba-1.4              160     116     72%     31%
   9 Hiarcs-14WCSC               108     116     65%     25%
  10 Gull-1.2                     70     116     60%     30%
  11 Protector-1.5.0              67     116     59%     34%
  12 Shredder-12                  30     116     54%     24%
  13 Spark-1.0                    15     116     52%     25%
  14 Texel-1.02                    6     116     51%     24%
  15 DeepJunior-13.3              -9     116     49%     27%
  16 MinkoChess-1.3              -15     116     48%     20%
  17 Fruit-2.3.1                 -54     116     42%     22%
  18 OctoChess-r5178             -67     116     41%     28%
  19 DiscoCheck-4.3              -73     116     40%     22%
  20 TogaReturns-1.1             -76     116     39%     27%
  21 Crafty-23.6                 -79     116     39%     24%
  22 Glaurung-2.2                -92     116     37%     22%
  23 Arasan-16.1                -149     116     30%     22%
  24 RedQueen-1.1.4             -157     116     29%     23%
  25 Gaviota-0.86               -160     116     28%     21%
  26 EXchess-7.11b              -179     116     26%     23%
  27 Rodent-1.00                -203     116     24%     18%
  28 Tucano-3.0                 -224     116     22%     19%
  29 Daydreamer-1.75            -224     116     22%     26%
  30 Sloppy-0.2.3               -247     116     19%     22%
Link to the PGN (1740 games)

Rating of the contestants:

Code: Select all

   # ENGINE                    : RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Stockfish-4               : 3172.0     345.5     420   82.3%
   2 Komodo-5.1                : 3166.8     346.0     420   82.4%
   3 IvanHoe-999946f           : 3116.8     260.0     344   75.6%
   4 Fire-xTreme-2.2           : 3114.9     325.5     420   77.5%
   5 Critter-1.6a              : 3112.5     330.5     420   78.7%
  10 Robbolito-0085g3l         : 3091.7     325.0     424   76.7%
  11 Igorrit-0.086v4           : 3084.2     367.5     524   70.1%
  13 BlackMamba-1.4            : 3036.4     310.0     424   73.1%
  17 Hiarcs-14WCSC             : 2949.3     270.5     424   63.8%
  18 Gull-1.2                  : 2940.4     189.5     348   54.5%
  20 Protector-1.5.0           : 2905.6     240.0     420   57.1%
  22 Spark-1.0                 : 2890.1     239.5     424   56.5%
  23 Shredder-12               : 2884.2     187.5     396   47.3%
  24 TogaReturns-1.1           : 2868.1     230.0     420   54.8%
  27 DeepJunior-13.3           : 2843.2     168.0     396   42.4%
  29 Texel-1.02                : 2825.1     205.0     416   49.3%
  31 MinkoChess-1.3            : 2809.0     202.5     424   47.8%
  36 Fruit-2.3.1               : 2746.5     181.5     420   43.2%
  38 Crafty-23.6               : 2723.7     176.5     424   41.6%
  39 DiscoCheck-4.3            : 2722.6     166.0     420   39.5%
  41 Glaurung-2.2              : 2716.3     165.0     420   39.3%
  42 Gaviota-0.86              : 2713.7     164.0     420   39.0%
  43 OctoChess-r5178           : 2701.2     167.0     336   49.7%
  46 EXchess-7.11b             : 2672.3     155.5     424   36.7%
  49 RedQueen-1.1.4            : 2630.3     147.0     340   43.2%
  50 Arasan-16.1               : 2629.9     108.5     264   41.1%
  54 Rodent-1.00               : 2586.6     130.5     336   38.8%
  55 Daydreamer-1.75           : 2582.2     143.0     340   42.1%
  56 Tucano-3.0                : 2566.7      64.5     188   34.3%
  57 Sloppy-0.2.3              : 2538.0     117.5     340   34.6%
(Full ratings list on my site.)

Now for a big "bottom 30" tournament. ;)
"The only good bug is a dead bug." (Don Dailey)
[Blog: http://tinyurl.com/predateur ] [Facebook: http://tinyurl.com/fbpredateur ] [MacEngines: http://tinyurl.com/macengines ]
Top

Return to “Computer Chess Club: Tournaments and Matches”