Houdini 3 vs Komodo 1133 vs Stockfish 021113

[Adam Hair]

After 450 games:

Code: Select all

Stockfish 021113     +142=199-109      53.7%
Houdini 3            +109=199-142      46.3%

Ordo 0.8 ratings:

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER              : RATING  ERROR   POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Stockfish 021113    :   13.2   11.5    241.5     450   53.7%
   2 Houdini 3           :  -13.2   11.5    208.5     450   46.3%

[Adam Hair]

end of match:

Code: Select all

Stockfish 021113      +162=217-121    54.1%
Houdini 3             +121=217-162    45.9 %

Ordo 0.8 ratings:

Code: Select all

   
   # PLAYER              : RATING  ERROR   POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Stockfish 021113    :   14.8   11.0    270.5     500   54.1%
   2 Houdini 3           :  -14.8   11.0    229.5     500   45.9%

[beram]

Hi Adam,

I have about the same for a test in 100 games SF 0111 4cpu against Houdini 3 on my AMD X6 1090T 3200 Mhz

Code: Select all

Stockfish 011113 - Houdini 3, TC 3m 2s, 4cpu, ponder off 

1   Stockfish 011113 64 SSE4.2  +31/=46/-23 54.00%   54.0/100
2   Houdini 3 x64               +23/=46/-31 46.00%   46.0/100

[Adam Hair]

Hi Adam,

I have about the same for a test in 100 games SF 0111 4cpu against Houdini 3 on my AMD X6 1090T 3200 Mhz

Code: Select all

Stockfish 011113 - Houdini 3, TC 3m 2s, 4cpu, ponder off 

1   Stockfish 011113 64 SSE4.2  +31/=46/-23 54.00%   54.0/100
2   Houdini 3 x64               +23/=46/-31 46.00%   46.0/100

Hi Bram,

I think that it is very likely that Stockfish has surpassed Houdini 3, and Houdini 4 may find itself behind Stockfish when it is released.

Thanks for sharing your results.

[Adam Hair]

Instead of using Komodo 6, Don has allowed me to use Komodo 1133 (thanks Don!).

After 155 games against Houdini 3:

Code: Select all

Komodo 1133      +46 =62 -47  49.7 %
Houdini 3        +47 =62 -46  50.3 %

Ordo 0.8 ratings:

Code: Select all

   
   # PLAYER              : RATING  ERROR   POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Stockfish 021113    :   20.8   19.8    270.5     500   54.1%
   2 Houdini 3           :   -9.0   15.4    307.5     655   46.9%
   3 Komodo 1133         :  -11.8   27.9     77.0     155   49.7%

[beram]

Hi Adam,

I have about the same for a test in 100 games SF 0111 4cpu against Houdini 3 on my AMD X6 1090T 3200 Mhz

Code: Select all

Stockfish 011113 - Houdini 3, TC 3m 2s, 4cpu, ponder off 

1   Stockfish 011113 64 SSE4.2  +31/=46/-23 54.00%   54.0/100
2   Houdini 3 x64               +23/=46/-31 46.00%   46.0/100

Hi Bram,

I think that it is very likely that Stockfish has surpassed Houdini 3, and Houdini 4 may find itself behind Stockfish when it is released.

Thanks for sharing your results.

Well first thing is true, but if Houdini 4 is indeed 40-50 ELO better, than it will still be 1 before SF 4 dev

Btw Robert Houdart has already stated that he thinks it is only than a matter of time that Stockfish will reign if the test framework will continue developing SF in the way it did the last months