As 'copied' is the contrary of 'original', anything non-original is obviously a copy of some sort. So the question is "in what sense?". What aspects of a program need to be copied to consider it a violation of the rule?Rebel wrote:Rule #2
Each program must be the original work of the entering developers. Programming teams whose code is derived from or including game-playing code written by others must name all other authors, or the source of such code, in their submission details. Programs which are discovered to be close derivatives of others (e.g., by playing nearly all moves the same), may be declared invalid by the Tournament Director after seeking expert advice.
Now tell me, what else does the word derivative mean other than copying? And it was confirmed by David in the email I quoted earlier.
As I and others pointed out, copying in the sense of copyright law has a very strict and limited meaning, which does not cover copying of functionality, but only of the source text, with the caveat that changes that can be made automatically (such as compiling) will not be considered new works, but simply other forms of the original work.
The concept of 'derivative' is broader, and does include functional equivalence. As the explanation in the rule itself explicitly states ("playing nearly all moves the same").
So as the rule explicitly states, 'derivative' is not limited to 'infringement of copyright', but also covers functional equivalence. Obviously within reason: the 'functional equivalence' that programs both play Chess, rather than Checkers would not be cause for concern.
Well, Bob is here, so you can ask him yourself. I don't see why this would be relevant one way or the other. Containing the same table might be a rule #2 violation, if the contents of the table would not be dictated by the rules of the game, but I think that Rybka 1.0 did not participate in any WCCC, so it had every right to violate rule #2.Ask Bob why he endlessly has been complaining that (according to him) Rybka 1.0 contained a Crafty rotated bit-board table which later (when 2 programmers looked into it) he had to retract because it wasn't true but that's besides the point.
Chess games are creative and unique work of the players. Yet they cannot be copyrighted, as ChessBase found out in court.Point is, PST's are not just some numbers, it is the creative and unique work of a programmer and thus protected by copyright.
Actually all inventions are creative and unique work of the inventor. Yet if they are not patented, everyone can start manufacturing and selling them. Why do you think patents exist, if this was automatically covered by copyright law? You grossly estimate the jurisdiction of copyright law.

