Testing Stockfish vs Houdinis 1.5, 2, 3 and 4

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

felix
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Feb 24, 2014 6:10 pm
Location: Mexicali, República de Baja California

Testing Stockfish. Survivors after 54 rounds

Post by felix »

Code: Select all

Level: Blitz 0:30/0,5
No opening book
Hardware: Intel(R) Core(TM) i3-2310M CPU @ 2.10GHz with 2,7 GB Memory
Operating system: Windows 7 Home Basic Home Edition Service Pack 1 (Build 7601) 32 bit
Table created with: Arena 3.5
Avg: 22 games/hour

The ones with -1 or better continues

    Engine                              Score                                                          Ho
01: Houdini_4.0_Pro_w32-v1x             740,5/1620 ······················································ 
02: Stockfish_14032408_32bit_1395646328 34,0/54    01=111=0=11===0==110=011=1==0111==1==01111011=0===1101 
03: Stockfish_14020813_32bit_1391861277 32,5/54    10111=1====100=00101=01=1=1111==1=111=0=00101=1101=10= 
04: Stockfish_14032911_32bit            32,0/54    11=0110=1100110===11=1010=0=0=0111==0111==111101010=== 
05: Stockfish_14032311_32bit            31,0/54    0=11=1111=1011===1110110=10=01=0=0==0=0000===1=10111=1 
05: Stockfish_14012623_32bit            31,0/54    1==10=0=0=====0111=111=1==1==10101=1====01=1=00===0=11 
05: Stockfish_14032607_32bit            31,0/54    1111=11=1011=1=001===11==011==1=1101==0000100=1001010= 
05: Stockfish_13121006_32bit            31,0/54    11110=1111===1==100=10111=1=010001=011=00=0=0====1=011 
09: Stockfish_13120218_32bit            30,5/54    ====1=01=1010=1=10111001==010=11101010===1===1100====1 
09: Stockfish_14020813_32bit_1391862464 30,5/54    11=1111011=1=01110==11=0==1=0=000=11=====1=100=1000=01 
09: Stockfish_13120223_32bit            30,5/54    =1==01=1=0==1=0==0==11=0=1==110===1=0101==010=101==111 
12: Stockfish_14031409_32bit_1394787454 30,0/54    11=1010=001=1110==101=01=00====10=1==1==0=110=1=1===== 
12: Stockfish_14032300_32bit            30,0/54    11100111011110=0=1010=11==0=10==1======1=0======01===0 
14: Stockfish_14031818_32bit            29,5/54    ===10=0==1111=0==0=1=011=101=1=111=1==0=0=0==101==0100 
14: Houdini_4.0_Pro_w32_contempt_0      29,5/54    ===01=011100=01==1=1======1=0====1=====0=1===1010=1==1 
16: Stockfish_14022008_32bit_1392881233 29,0/54    0=11=11111=1======00=1===1=10=1010==110000100=1000=11= 
16: Stockfish_14031521_32bit            29,0/54    100111===00111==1=====01011=00======11011000=110011=0= 
18: Stockfish_14011818_32bit            28,5/54    1=1=1101=00==01101011=000==0=====0==11101==11===0=0110 
18: Stockfish_14022210_32bit            28,5/54    =1===1======100=011==11=01111000010====011110=1=1000=0 
18: Stockfish_14031523_32bit            28,5/54    =0011==1==11=110100=11101=01====0=0=01=10==101=100==0= 
18: Stockfish_14033014_32bit_1396182012 28,5/54    ==1=1=00==011001111===0011=0=001==1001===1=1==00=011=1 
22: Stockfish_13120712_32bit            28,0/54    011110010=0=11=11=0=00=111=1=00=10=1000====1=00==0=111 
22: Stockfish_14040109_32bit            28,0/54    ======0=1=100110===110=10=0=0===1===01=1=10==1=0=01==1 
24: Stockfish_14030308_32bit_1393833440 27,5/54    =1===0==10===10=====0111====0===10===11===0===0101=001 
24: Stockfish_13112410_32bit            27,5/54    =0=110==1===0===0101==100=1===0=11011==00===0=11010011 
24: Stockfish_14011911_32bit_1390126594 27,5/54    =01=1101=0100=1=1=001111=1001=0=011=1==101000==10=0==0 
24: Stockfish_14021612_32bit_1392549637 27,5/54    ==1==0=======1010==0=10=11=001=11==111110===00==0==00= 
24: Stockfish_13123010_32bit            27,5/54    =0=11=01==001101011=100==101101001000=0111===100101=01 
24: Stockfish_14012708_32bit            27,5/54    =0=1010=1=1001110=01=110101=110======001000101=0110=01 
30: Stockfish_14020919_32bit            27,0/54    1==01=1=1=01=111===001==0==010001=====01=1001=0=0=10== 
31: Stockfish_13123115_32bit            26,5/54    1==01=011110=1=01===011000=1100110===001=00====1=00=01 

felix
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Feb 24, 2014 6:10 pm
Location: Mexicali, República de Baja California

Testing Stockfish vs all my non stockfish engines

Post by felix »

Code: Select all

Level: Blitz 0:30/0,5
No opening book
Hardware: Intel(R) Core(TM) i3-2310M CPU @ 2.10GHz with 2,7 GB Memory
Operating system: Windows 7 Home Basic Home Edition Service Pack 1 (Build 7601) 32 bit
Table created with: Arena 3.5
Avg: 22 games/hour

The ones with -1 or better continues

    Engine                         Score                                                             Ho
01: Houdini_4.0_Pro_w32-v1x        131,0/204 ·························································· 

Continues!

02: Houdini_4.0_Pro_w32_contempt_0 32,0/58   ===01=011100=01==1=1======1=0====1=====0=1===1010=1==1=1== 

Eliminated!

03: Komodo-tcec-32bit              25,0/52   110===1011==110===0=00=0=11=0=0=01111==0=1001010=000       
04: Houdini_3.0_Pro_w32            7,0/16    1101010=0001==0=                                           
05: RobboLito 0.21Q w32 NLP MS     4,0/10    ==1===00=0                                                 
06: DeepSaros_416_w32              1,0/4     ==00                                                       
06: Strelka_5.5x32                 1,0/4     0=0=                                                       
08: Gull 2.9 alpha w32             0,5/4     0=00                                                       
08: Ippolit 0.080b3 x86            0,5/4     0=00                                                       
08: IvanHoe999946h                 0,5/4     0=00                                                       
08: Hannibal1.4bx32                0,5/4     0=00                                                       
08: Houdini_1.5_w32                0,5/4     =000                                                       
08: Critter_1.6a_32bit             0,5/4     0=00                                                       
14: Deep Rybka 4.1 w32             0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Houdini_2.0_x32                0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Cheng4                         0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Fire 3.0 w32                   0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Fruit233f                      0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Gaviota-0.86-win32             0,0/2     00                                                         
14: IvanHoe999950h                 0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Komodo6-32bit                  0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Gaviota-1.0-win32              0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Naum 4.2                       0,0/2     00                                                         
14: PanChess 00.537.w32            0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Protector_Win32                0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Crafty-23.8                    0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Rybkav2.3.2a.mp.w32            0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Spike1.4                       0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Bouquet 1.8 x32                0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Texel32                        0,0/2     00                                                         
14: Toga-30-32-ja                  0,0/2     00                                                         

felix
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Feb 24, 2014 6:10 pm
Location: Mexicali, República de Baja California

Testing stockfish. Results after 92 rounds

Post by felix »

Code: Select all

Level: Blitz 0:30/0,5
No opening book
Hardware: Intel(R) Core(TM) i3-2310M CPU @ 2.10GHz with 2,7 GB Memory
Operating system: Windows 7 Home Basic Home Edition Service Pack 1 (Build 7601) 32 bit
Table created with: Arena 3.5
Avg: 22 games/hour

The ones with -1 or better continues

After 82 rounds I change Houdini contempt to 0 and Learning ON with 1 centipawn. Normal houdini was being crushed for everyone

Things changed a lot.

    Engine                              Score                                                                                                 Ho
01: Houdini_4.0_Pro_w32-v1x             1176,5/2488 ···························································································· 

Continues!

02: Stockfish_14032911_32bit            57,5/92     11=0110=1100110===11=1010=0=0=0111==0111==111101010===1=111011====111==1=111=1===11=1000=1=0 
03: Stockfish_14032408_32bit_1395646328 56,0/92     01=111=0=11===0==110=011=1==0111==1==01111011=0===110100=101011=1=0=11=111=10111000===111=00 
04: Stockfish_14020813_32bit_1391861277 53,0/92     10111=1====100=00101=01=1=1111==1=111=0=00101=1101=10=011=0=0=10=011=011===1=01=10=01=1=0==1 
05: Stockfish_14032607_32bit            52,5/92     1111=11=1011=1=001===11==011==1=1101==0000100=1001010=001=11100===0==1=1=101======0=11=11=10 
05: Stockfish_14032311_32bit            52,5/92     0=11=1111=1011===1110110=10=01=0=0==0=0000===1=10111=10==0=01=10==11=1==1111=111==000====1=0 
07: Stockfish_13121006_32bit            52,0/92     11110=1111===1==100=10111=1=010001=011=00=0=0====1=011011======1=0100=1=1111010=111001=000=1 
08: Stockfish_14033014_32bit_1396182012 51,0/92     ==1=1=00==011001111===0011=0=001==1001===1=1==00=011=1=101111001100=1101=0101=1====1==1===== 
08: Stockfish_14040109_32bit            51,0/92     ======0=1=100110===110=10=0=0===1===01=1=10==1=0=01==100==1===1==10=0=1=011=1111110==1===1== 
10: Stockfish_14031521_32bit            50,0/92     100111===00111==1=====01011=00======11011000=110011=0=011=01=00111==0==01=1==1011==0=1=1=0== 
11: Stockfish_14012623_32bit            49,5/92     1==10=0=0=====0111=111=1==1==10101=1====01=1=00===0=1101011=111===1=0===11===1=100000=00=0=0 
11: Stockfish_14031818_32bit            49,5/92     ===10=0==1111=0==0=1=011=101=1=111=1==0=0=0==101==0100====10=111=0=00=01======110==101===10= 
13: Stockfish_13120223_32bit            48,5/92     =1==01=1=0==1=0==0==11=0=1==110===1=0101==010=101==11101=1110===100==1=====1==0==0000=110=0= 
13: Stockfish_14031523_32bit            48,5/92     =0011==1==11=110100=11101=01====0=0=01=10==101=100==0=01=0==1=11=11=10=11010=00=0=01==0====1 
13: Stockfish_14020813_32bit_1391862464 48,5/92     11=1111011=1=01110==11=0==1=0=000=11=====1=100=1000=01=11=010=0==10=0==01111==0=0==00=0=011= 
16: Stockfish_14032300_32bit            48,0/92     11100111011110=0=1010=11==0=10==1======1=0======01===0=1==11==0=0==110=0=00=1==00==1====10=0 
17: Stockfish_13112410_32bit            47,5/92     =0=110==1===0===0101==100=1===0=11011==00===0=1101001111111=1==0==1=110101=0==0=00010=010=01 
18: Stockfish_14012708_32bit            47,0/92     =0=1010=1=1001110=01=110101=110======001000101=0110=0101=0========111=11011====1=100=0==00=0 
19: Stockfish_13120218_32bit            46,5/92     ====1=01=1010=1=10111001==010=11101010===1===1100====100=1=1==10=10=01=00=1=0===0==1000=0=== 
20: Stockfish_14020919_32bit            45,5/92     1==01=1=1=01=111===001==0==010001=====01=1001=0=0=10==111===1==00111==1===0=0101000===0=0100 

Eliminated!

21: Stockfish_14011818_32bit            45,0/92     1=1=1101=00==01101011=000==0=====0==11101==11===0=01100==00=11=10=00=1=100=101010====10=0=0= 
22: Stockfish_13123010_32bit            42,0/86     =0=11=01==001101011=100==101101001000=0111===100101=0101=100=1=01====10==1==0=00110=00       
23: Stockfish_14022210_32bit            41,0/84     =1===1======100=011==11=01111000010====011110=1=1000=0=010=01=11000110101==000===00=         
24: Stockfish_14022008_32bit_1392881233 37,5/78     0=11=11111=1======00=1===1=10=1010==110000100=1000=11=0==01=101000=010100=1000               
25: Stockfish_14011911_32bit_1390126594 35,5/74     =01=1101=0100=1=1=001111=1001=0=011=1==101000==10=0==01=01100=00101=010=00                   
26: Stockfish_14021612_32bit_1392549637 34,5/72     ==1==0=======1010==0=10=11=001=11==111110===00==0==00=10=1=0=1=0=0=0==00                     
27: Stockfish_14031409_32bit_1394787454 34,0/70     11=1010=001=1110==101=01=00====10=1==1==0=110=1=1=======00=1==0000=000                       
28: Stockfish_14030308_32bit_1393833440 30,5/64     =1===0==10===10=====0111====0===10===11===0===0101=00100101==000                             
29: Stockfish_13120712_32bit            29,5/62     011110010=0=11=11=0=00=111=1=00=10=1000====1=00==0=1111=000000                               
30: Stockfish_13123115_32bit            27,5/58     1==01=011110=1=01===011000=1100110===001=00====1=00=010100                                   



Be careful with your words, once they are said, they can be only forgiven, not forgotten