started my fixed nodes leagues

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

I did a mistake when I included Koivisto9 32768 nodes that already played in my previous tournament.
Did another tournament of strong against weak in order to get a better rating list of all engines.

Results:

Code: Select all

Result:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                            games    wins   draws  losses   score    elo    +    -
  1. Berserk 13 131072 nodes            40      36       4       0    38.0    272  173  124
  2. Seer 2.8.0 131072 nodes            40      36       3       1    37.5    267  173  125
  3. Black Marlin 9.0 131072 nodes      40      35       5       0    37.5    243  158  118
  4. Caissa 1.18 131072 nodes           40      34       6       0    37.0    217  146  113
  5. PlentyChess 1.0.0 131072 nodes     40      34       6       0    37.0    217  146  113
  6. Velvet v7.3.0 262144 nodes         40      34       6       0    37.0    215  146  113
  7. Rubi20240112 131072nodes           40      32       8       0    36.0    171  129  105
  8. Igel 3.5.0 65536 nodes             40      32       7       1    35.5    166  129  105
  9. Stockfish 16.1 32768nodes          40      30      10       0    35.0    135  118   99
 10. Igel 3.5.0 131072 nodes            40      29      11       0    34.5    119  113   97
 11. Berserk 13 65536 nodes             40      29       9       2    33.5    111  114   98
 12. Stockfish 16.1 16384nodes          40      29       9       2    33.5    111  114   98
 13. Obsidian 11.0 65536nodes           40      29       9       2    33.5    106  114   98
 14. Clover 6.1 131072 nodes            40      29       9       2    33.5    105  114   98
 15. Viridithas 12.0.0 131072 nodes     40      29       8       3    33.0    100  114   98
 16. Alexandria-6.1.0 131072 nodes      40      27      13       0    33.5     89  106   93
 17. Obsidian 11.0 131072nodes          40      28      10       2    33.0     88  110   96
 18. Caissa 1.18 65536 nodes            40      28       9       3    32.5     87  110   96
 19. Alexandria-6.1.0 65536 nodes       40      27      10       3    32.0     73  107   94
 20. Stash v35.0 1048576 nodes          40      28       7       5    31.5     73  111   97
 21. Velvet v7.3.0 131072 nodes         40      26      13       1    32.5     71  104   92
 22. Black Marlin 9.0 65536 nodes       40      26      13       1    32.5     68  103   92
 23. Koivisto 9.0 131072 nodes          40      25      15       0    32.5     59  101   90
 24. Koivisto 9.0 65536 nodes           40      25      12       3    31.0     48  101   91
 25. Clover 6.1 65536 nodes             40      25      12       3    31.0     47  101   91
 26. Seer 2.8.0 65536 nodes             40      25      12       3    31.0     44  102   92
 27. Rubi20240112 65536nodes            40      24      14       2    31.0     43   98   89
 28. Altair 7.0.0 131072 nodes          40      26       9       5    30.5     39  104   94
 29. Viridithas 12.0.0 65536 nodes      40      24      13       3    30.5     37   98   89
 30. PlentyChess 1.0.0 65536 nodes      40      24      13       3    30.5     28   99   90
 31. Stockfish 16.1 8192nodes           74      14      32      28    30.0     21   62   63
 32. Caissa 1.18 32768 nodes            40      23      11       6    28.5      1   98   90
 33. PlentyChess 1.0.0 32768 nodes      40      22      14       4    29.0     -2   95   88
 34. Berserk 13 32768 nodes             40      19      19       2    28.5     -9   89   84
 35. Velvet v7.3.0 65536 nodes          74      10      28      36    24.0    -32   64   67
 36. Igel 3.5.0 32768 nodes             74       9      29      36    23.5    -42   64   67
 37. Clover 6.1 32768 nodes             74       5      32      37    21.0    -60   63   66
 38. Seer 2.8.0 32768 nodes             40      16      17       7    24.5    -74   87   85
 39. Black Marlin 9.0 32768 nodes       74       5      29      40    19.5    -76   64   68
 40. Altair 7.0.0 65536 nodes           40      16      17       7    24.5    -78   87   84
 41. Alexandria-6.1.0 32768 nodes       74      11      19      44    20.5    -80   68   72
 42. Obsidian 11.0 32768nodes           74       7      25      42    19.5    -85   66   70
 43. Berserk 13 16384 nodes             74       5      24      45    17.0   -107   67   72
 44. Rubi20240112 32768nodes            40      13      16      11    21.0   -121   87   86
 45. Viridithas 12.0.0 32768 nodes      74       4      21      49    14.5   -136   69   76
 46. Rubi20240112 16384nodes            74       2      23      49    13.5   -148   69   76
 47. Stash v35.0 524288 nodes           40      13      14      13    20.0   -151   87   87
 48. PlentyChess 1.0.0 16384 nodes      74       2      21      51    12.5   -159   71   78
 49. Caissa 1.18 16384 nodes            74       3      18      53    12.0   -172   73   81
 50. Stash v35.0 262144 nodes           74       6      11      57    11.5   -195   77   88
 51. Koivisto 9.0 16384 nodes           74       4      14      56    11.0   -200   76   86
 52. Altair 7.0.0 32768 nodes           74       2      15      57     9.5   -210   77   88
 53. Stockfish 16.1 4096nodes           74       0      17      57     8.5   -222   76   87
 54. Seer 2.8.0 16384 nodes             74       3      12      59     9.0   -233   79   92
 55. Clover 6.1 16384 nodes             74       0      14      60     7.0   -255   80   94
 56. Velvet v7.1.0 32768 nodes          74       4       5      65     6.5   -302   91  112
 57. Stash v35.0 131072 nodes           74       4       4      66     6.0   -318   94  117

Cross table:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                               score   games         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10        11        12        13        14        15        16        17        18        19        20        21        22        23        24        25        26        27        28        29        30        31        32        33        34        35        36        37        38        39        40        41        42        43        44        45        46        47        48        49        50        51        52        53        54        55        56        57
  1. Berserk 13 131072 nodes             38.0      40         x                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          11                                      =1        11        =1                  11                  1=        11        11                  11        11                  1=        11        11        11        11        11        11        11        11        11
  2. Seer 2.8.0 131072 nodes             37.5      40                   x                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                11                                      1=        =1        11                  11                  11        11        11                  11        10                  11        =1        11        11        11        11        11        11        11        11
  3. Black Marlin 9.0 131072 nodes       37.5      40                             x                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      1=                                      11        =1        11                  11                  11        11        =1                  11        =1                  11        11        11        11        11        =1        11        11        11        11
  4. Caissa 1.18 131072 nodes            37.0      40                                       x                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            1=                                      1=        11        11                  11                  11        =1        1=                  =1        11                  11        11        11        11        11        11        11        11        1=        11
  5. PlentyChess 1.0.0 131072 nodes      37.0      40                                                 x                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1=                                      ==        11        1=                  11                  11        11        11                  11        1=                  11        11        11        11        11        11        =1        11        11        11
  6. Velvet v7.3.0 262144 nodes          37.0      40                                                           x                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        11                                      11        11        11                  =1                  =1        1=        11                  1=        11                  11        1=        1=        11        11        11        11        11        11        11
  7. Rubi20240112 131072nodes            36.0      40                                                                     x                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              =1                                      11        11        11                  11                  1=        1=        =1                  1=        11                  11        =1        11        11        1=        1=        11        11        11        11
  8. Igel 3.5.0 65536 nodes              35.5      40                                                                               x                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    01                                      ==        =1        =1                  11                  =1        11        =1                  11        11                  11        11        11        =1        11        11        11        11        11        11
  9. Stockfish 16.1 32768nodes           35.0      40                                                                                         x                                                                                                                                                                                                                          11                                      =1        1=        1=                  11                  11        =1        =1                  1=        11                  =1        =1        11        1=        =1        11        11        11        11        11
 10. Igel 3.5.0 131072 nodes             34.5      40                                                                                                   x                                                                                                                                                                                                                ==                                      =1        =1        11                  1=                  11        11        1=                  1=        11                  11        1=        11        11        1=        11        11        11        1=        =1
 11. Berserk 13 65536 nodes              33.5      40                                                                                                             x                                                                                                                                                                                                      ==                                      =1        11        11                  1=                  1=        10        11                  11        11                  1=        =1        11        =1        11        11        11        1=        01        11
 12. Stockfish 16.1 16384nodes           33.5      40                                                                                                                       x                                                                                                                                                                                            ==                                      11        11        11                  1=                  =1        1=        11                  11        =1                  11        10        11        11        1=        =1        1=        11        11        10
 13. Obsidian 11.0 65536nodes            33.5      40                                                                                                                                 x                                                                                                                                                                                  ==                                      =0        01        11                  11                  11        =1        1=                  11        11                  =1        1=        11        11        =1        11        11        =1        11        11
 14. Clover 6.1 131072 nodes             33.5      40                                                                                                                                           x                                                                                                                                                                        11                                      1=        =0        01                  =1                  1=        11        =1                  11        11                  ==        11        =1        11        11        11        11        1=        11        11
 15. Viridithas 12.0.0 131072 nodes      33.0      40                                                                                                                                                     x                                                                                                                                                              10                                      =0        =1        =1                  =1                  01        =1        11                  11        11                  1=        ==        11        11        11        11        11        11        11        11
 16. Alexandria-6.1.0 131072 nodes       33.5      40                                                                                                                                                               x                                                                                                                                                    1=                                      =1        ==        1=                  ==                  11        11        11                  =1        11                  11        =1        =1        11        11        =1        11        1=        =1        11
 17. Obsidian 11.0 131072nodes           33.0      40                                                                                                                                                                         x                                                                                                                                          0=                                      11        ==        1=                  11                  11        11        =1                  11        ==                  11        =1        01        11        1=        11        11        11        11        =1
 18. Caissa 1.18 65536 nodes             32.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                   x                                                                                                                                11                                      11        1=        1=                  =0                  01        =1        1=                  ==        1=                  11        11        01        11        11        11        11        =1        11        11
 19. Alexandria-6.1.0 65536 nodes        32.0      40                                                                                                                                                                                             x                                                                                                                      01                                      ==        1=        1=                  ==                  11        00        =1                  1=        1=                  11        11        1=        11        11        11        11        11        11        11
 20. Stash v35.0 1048576 nodes           31.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                       x                                                                                                            01                                      =1        =0        ==                  10                  01        =1        11                  11        11                  11        11        11        =1        01        11        11        11        1=        11
 21. Velvet v7.3.0 131072 nodes          32.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                 x                                                                                                  ==                                      =1        11        =1                  1=                  1=        11        1=                  11        11                  ==        =1        11        11        11        ==        01        =1        11        11
 22. Black Marlin 9.0 65536 nodes        32.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                           x                                                                                        1=                                      01        1=        1=                  ==                  1=        11        1=                  11        ==                  =1        11        1=        =1        11        1=        11        11        11        11
 23. Koivisto 9.0 131072 nodes           32.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     x                                                                              ==                                      11        11        1=                  ==                  11        =1        1=                  11        1=                  11        11        1=        1=        ==        =1        =1        =1        11        11
 24. Koivisto 9.0 65536 nodes            31.0      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               x                                                                    0=                                      11        =1        ==                  ==                  11        ==        =1                  1=        11                  0=        11        01        11        11        11        11        =1        11        11
 25. Clover 6.1 65536 nodes              31.0      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         x                                                          1=                                      01        ==        =1                  1=                  00        =1        1=                  11        =1                  11        11        1=        =1        =1        11        1=        11        11        11
 26. Seer 2.8.0 65536 nodes              31.0      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   x                                                1=                                      11        =0        11                  1=                  ==        11        11                  10        =1                  1=        11        =1        1=        =1        1=        =1        11        01        11
 27. Rubi20240112 65536nodes             31.0      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             x                                      =1                                      1=        ==        ==                  1=                  01        01        1=                  =1        =1                  ==        =1        11        11        11        11        =1        11        11        11
 28. Altair 7.0.0 131072 nodes           30.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       x                            =0                                      11        01        10                  =1                  11        10        =1                  1=        1=                  1=        11        1=        01        =1        11        11        11        11        1=
 29. Viridithas 12.0.0 65536 nodes       30.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 x                  ==                                      ==        00        ==                  1=                  11        ==        10                  11        11                  =1        11        11        =1        1=        1=        11        11        11        11
 30. PlentyChess 1.0.0 65536 nodes       30.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           x        01                                      11        11        ==                  =1                  =1        =0        11                  ==        ==                  =1        11        11        01        1=        11        =1        =1        11        11
 31. Stockfish 16.1 8192nodes            30.0      74        00        00        0=        0=        0=        00        =0        10        00        ==        ==        ==        ==        00        01        0=        1=        00        10        10        ==        0=        ==        1=        0=        0=        =0        =1        ==        10         x        0=        0=        ==                                      1=                  11                                      =1                            11                                                                                                    
 32. Caissa 1.18 32768 nodes             28.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1=         x                            00        =1        ==                  0=                  01        =0        11                  ==        11                  11        11        1=        11        11        11        =1        11        11        =0
 33. PlentyChess 1.0.0 32768 nodes       29.0      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1=                   x                  =0        =1        =1                  11                  0=        11        00                  ==        1=                  =1        =1        11        1=        11        ==        11        1=        11        11
 34. Berserk 13 32768 nodes              28.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ==                             x        0=        =1        ==                  1=                  ==        ==        1=                  1=        =1                  =1        11        0=        =1        1=        =1        11        11        11        11
 35. Velvet v7.3.0 65536 nodes           24.0      74        =0        0=        00        0=        ==        00        00        ==        =0        =0        =0        00        =1        0=        =1        =0        00        00        ==        =0        =0        10        00        00        10        00        0=        00        ==        00                  11        =1        1=         x                            1=                  1=                                      ==                            =0                                                                                                    
 36. Igel 3.5.0 32768 nodes              23.5      74        00        =0        =0        00        00        00        00        =0        0=        =0        00        00        10        =1        =0        ==        ==        0=        0=        =1        00        0=        00        =0        ==        =1        ==        10        11        00                  =0        =0        =0                   x                  0=                  1=                                      ==                            =1                                                                                                    
 37. Clover 6.1 32768 nodes              21.0      74        =0        00        00        00        0=        00        00        =0        0=        00        00        00        00        10        =0        0=        0=        0=        0=        ==        =0        0=        0=        ==        =0        00        ==        01        ==        ==                  ==        =0        ==                             x        1=                  1=                                      0=                            1=                                                                                                    
 38. Seer 2.8.0 32768 nodes              24.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    0=                                      0=        1=        0=         x        =1                  1=        ==        ==                  01        ==                  11        ==        11        10        01        11        ==        =1        11        10
 39. Black Marlin 9.0 32768 nodes        19.5      74        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        0=        0=        0=        00        =0        =0        ==        00        =1        ==        01        0=        ==        ==        ==        0=        0=        0=        =0        0=        =0                  1=        00        0=                                      =0         x        ==                                      10                            10                                                                                                    
 40. Altair 7.0.0 65536 nodes            24.5      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    00                                      0=        0=        0=                  ==         x        ==        1=        =0                  =1        =1                  11        =1        01        =1        1=        1=        1=        =1        11        11
 41. Alexandria-6.1.0 32768 nodes        20.5      74        0=        00        00        00        00        =0        0=        =0        00        00        0=        =0        00        0=        10        00        00        10        00        10        0=        0=        00        00        11        ==        10        00        00        =0                  10        1=        ==                                      0=                  ==         x                            1=                            11                                                                                                    
 42. Obsidian 11.0 32768nodes            19.5      74        00        00        00        =0        00        0=        0=        00        =0        00        01        0=        =0        00        =0        00        00        =0        11        =0        00        00        =0        ==        =0        00        10        01        ==        =1                  =1        00        ==                                      ==                  0=                   x                  ==                            0=                                                                                                    
 43. Berserk 13 16384 nodes              17.0      74        00        00        =0        0=        00        00        =0        =0        =0        0=        00        00        0=        =0        00        00        =0        0=        =0        00        0=        0=        0=        =0        0=        00        0=        =0        01        00                  00        11        0=                                      ==                  =1                             x        =1                            0=                                                                                                    
 44. Rubi20240112 32768nodes             21.0      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    =0                                      ==        ==        1=                  01                  0=        ==        =0         x        1=        1=                  1=        00        10        0=        11        =1        01        11        =0        10
 45. Viridithas 12.0.0 32768 nodes       14.5      74        00        00        00        =0        00        0=        0=        00        0=        0=        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        ==        0=        00        00        00        00        0=        00        01        =0        0=        00        ==                  ==        ==        0=                                      10                  =0                                      0=         x                  11                                                                                                    
 46. Rubi20240112 16384nodes             13.5      74        00        01        =0        00        0=        00        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        00        ==        0=        0=        00        00        ==        0=        00        =0        =0        =0        0=        00        ==                  00        0=        =0                                      ==                  =0                                      0=                   x        =1                                                                                                    
 47. Stash v35.0 524288 nodes            20.0      40                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    00                                      =1        =0        0=                  01                  00        1=        1=                  00        =0         x        =0        =1        11        1=        11        ==        =0        ==        01        11
 48. PlentyChess 1.0.0 16384 nodes       12.5      74        0=        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        0=        00        =0        ==        0=        00        00        00        00        00        ==        =0        00        1=        00        0=        ==        0=        =0        =0                  00        =0        =0                                      00                  00                                      0=                            =1         x                                                                                          
 49. Caissa 1.18 16384 nodes             12.0      74        00        =0        00        00        00        0=        =0        00        =0        0=        =0        01        0=        00        ==        =0        =0        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00                  00        =0        00                                      ==                  =0                                      11                            =0                   x                                                                                
 50. Stash v35.0 262144 nodes            11.5      74        00        00        00        00        00        0=        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        =0        10        10        0=        00        00        0=        0=        10        0=        =0        00        0=        00        00                  0=        00        1=                                      00                  10                                      01                            00                             x                                                                      
 51. Koivisto 9.0 16384 nodes            11.0      74        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        =0        0=        00        =0        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        =0        0=        00        =0        0=        00        10        =0        10                  00        0=        =0                                      01                  =0                                      1=                            0=                                       x                                                            
 52. Altair 7.0.0 32768 nodes             9.5      74        00        00        00        00        00        00        0=        00        =0        0=        00        0=        =0        00        00        00        0=        00        00        10        00        00        ==        00        =0        =0        00        =0        0=        0=                  00        00        0=                                      10                  0=                                      00                            00                                                 x                                                  
 53. Stockfish 16.1 4096nodes             8.5      74        00        00        =0        00        00        00        0=        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        00        ==        0=        =0        00        00        0=        00        00        0=        00                  00        ==        =0                                      00                  0=                                      =0                            ==                                                           x                                        
 54. Seer 2.8.0 16384 nodes               9.0      74        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        00        00        00        0=        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        10        00        =0        00        0=        =0        =0        00        00        =0                  =0        00        00                                      ==                  0=                                      10                            =1                                                                     x                              
 55. Clover 6.1 16384 nodes               7.0      74        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        0=        00        =0        0=        00        0=        00        =0        00        00        =0        00        =0        =0        00        00        00        00        00        =0                  00        0=        00                                      =0                  =0                                      00                            ==                                                                               x                    
 56. Velvet v7.1.0 32768 nodes            6.5      74        00        00        00        0=        00        00        00        00        00        0=        10        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        0=        00        00        00        00        00        10        00        00        00        00                  00        00        00                                      00                  00                                      =1                            10                                                                                         x          
 57. Stash v35.0 131072 nodes             6.0      74        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        01        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        0=        00        00                  =1        00        00                                      01                  00                                      01                            00                                                                                                   x

Tech:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tech (average nodes, depths, time/m per move, others per game), counted for computing moves only, ignored moves with zero nodes:
  #  name                              nodes/m         NPS  depth/m   time/m    moves     time
  1. Berserk 13 131072 nodes               97K     1016203     24.6      0.1     62.9      6.0
  2. Seer 2.8.0 131072 nodes               93K      675482     15.6      0.1     55.0      7.6
  3. Black Marlin 9.0 131072 nodes         99K      858754     16.5      0.1     66.5      7.7
  4. Caissa 1.18 131072 nodes             103K     1180055     22.7      0.1     70.0      6.1
  5. PlentyChess 1.0.0 131072 nodes        95K      777351     22.4      0.1     65.4      8.0
  6. Velvet v7.3.0 262144 nodes           255K     1230149     20.2      0.2     64.5     13.4
  7. Rubi20240112 131072nodes             125K      955726     19.9      0.1     61.3      8.0
  8. Igel 3.5.0 65536 nodes                44K      377584     16.6      0.1     72.5      8.5
  9. Stockfish 16.1 32768nodes             32K      579121     21.6      0.1     65.9      3.7
 10. Igel 3.5.0 131072 nodes               92K      390900     18.1      0.2     71.0     16.8
 11. Berserk 13 65536 nodes                49K      951258     22.1      0.1     77.4      4.0
 12. Stockfish 16.1 16384nodes             16K      574782     19.2      0.0     68.1      1.9
 13. Obsidian 11.0 65536nodes              47K      737254     18.8      0.1     78.2      5.0
 14. Clover 6.1 131072 nodes               98K     1219322     18.9      0.1     74.8      6.0
 15. Viridithas 12.0.0 131072 nodes       111K      911693     19.4      0.1     67.0      8.2
 16. Alexandria-6.1.0 131072 nodes         98K      923117     20.1      0.1     70.9      7.6
 17. Obsidian 11.0 131072nodes             98K      799372     21.3      0.1     75.5      9.3
 18. Caissa 1.18 65536 nodes               52K     1212845     20.2      0.0     65.9      2.8
 19. Alexandria-6.1.0 65536 nodes          49K      923951     18.5      0.1     78.1      4.1
 20. Stash v35.0 1048576 nodes           1000K     2106861     29.4      0.5     78.1     37.1
 21. Velvet v7.3.0 131072 nodes           129K     1262693     17.1      0.1     73.6      7.5
 22. Black Marlin 9.0 65536 nodes          48K      815231     14.0      0.1     67.5      4.0
 23. Koivisto 9.0 131072 nodes            130K     1516086     18.8      0.1     83.0      7.1
 24. Koivisto 9.0 65536 nodes              65K     1425478     17.2      0.0     71.5      3.3
 25. Clover 6.1 65536 nodes                47K     1111746     15.8      0.0     78.6      3.3
 26. Seer 2.8.0 65536 nodes                47K      662273     14.5      0.1     67.1      4.8
 27. Rubi20240112 65536nodes               62K      926425     17.4      0.1     72.9      4.9
 28. Altair 7.0.0 131072 nodes             99K      907300     18.1      0.1     77.9      8.5
 29. Viridithas 12.0.0 65536 nodes         56K      913458     17.3      0.1     75.6      4.6
 30. PlentyChess 1.0.0 65536 nodes         47K      770650     19.3      0.1     70.0      4.3
 31. Stockfish 16.1 8192nodes               8K      533878     14.6      0.0     78.3      1.2
 32. Caissa 1.18 32768 nodes               26K     1274690     18.7      0.0     68.1      1.4
 33. PlentyChess 1.0.0 32768 nodes         23K      798689     17.0      0.0     74.5      2.2
 34. Berserk 13 32768 nodes                24K      761291     18.3      0.0     74.7      2.3
 35. Velvet v7.3.0 65536 nodes             65K     1339921     14.4      0.0     74.4      3.6
 36. Igel 3.5.0 32768 nodes                22K      410524     13.6      0.1     71.2      3.8
 37. Clover 6.1 32768 nodes                23K     1147192     13.2      0.0     77.3      1.6
 38. Seer 2.8.0 32768 nodes                23K      611765     12.9      0.0     70.2      2.7
 39. Black Marlin 9.0 32768 nodes          24K      785261     12.0      0.0     77.0      2.3
 40. Altair 7.0.0 65536 nodes              48K      842094     15.6      0.1     69.3      3.9
 41. Alexandria-6.1.0 32768 nodes          23K      723307     15.2      0.0     74.3      2.3
 42. Obsidian 11.0 32768nodes              22K      580407     14.0      0.0     74.7      2.8
 43. Berserk 13 16384 nodes                12K      728351     16.1      0.0     73.3      1.2
 44. Rubi20240112 32768nodes               31K      888593     15.4      0.0     88.4      3.1
 45. Viridithas 12.0.0 32768 nodes         32K      863356     14.1      0.0     75.2      2.8
 46. Rubi20240112 16384nodes               15K      952962     14.1      0.0     74.4      1.2
 47. Stash v35.0 524288 nodes             503K     2225496     24.5      0.2     82.0     18.5
 48. PlentyChess 1.0.0 16384 nodes         11K      741359     14.4      0.0     71.8      1.1
 49. Caissa 1.18 16384 nodes               13K     1160968     15.2      0.0     63.7      0.7
 50. Stash v35.0 262144 nodes             245K     1994021     23.1      0.1     73.9      9.1
 51. Koivisto 9.0 16384 nodes              16K     1147627     13.8      0.0     63.1      0.9
 52. Altair 7.0.0 32768 nodes              23K      620593     14.7      0.0     60.8      2.2
 53. Stockfish 16.1 4096nodes               4K      386506     13.6      0.0     72.2      0.8
 54. Seer 2.8.0 16384 nodes                11K      623135     10.8      0.0     67.3      1.2
 55. Clover 6.1 16384 nodes                11K     1016975     10.4      0.0     64.9      0.7
 56. Velvet v7.1.0 32768 nodes             33K     1546587     12.5      0.0     71.7      1.5
 57. Stash v35.0 131072 nodes             121K     1957502     21.7      0.1     66.4      4.1
     all ---                               73K     1162149     16.7      0.1     71.5      4.6
Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER                            :  RATING  POINTS  PLAYED   (%)
   1 Berserk 13 131072 nodes           :  3115.0    92.5     114    81
   2 Rubi20240112 131072nodes          :  3078.8    89.0     114    78
   3 Stockfish 16.1 32768nodes         :  3073.9    88.5     114    78
   4 Velvet v7.3.0 262144 nodes        :  3059.5    87.0     114    76
   5 PlentyChess 1.0.0 131072 nodes    :  3054.8    86.5     114    76
   6 Seer 2.8.0 131072 nodes           :  3040.9    85.0     114    75
   7 Caissa 1.18 131072 nodes          :  3036.4    84.5     114    74
   8 Igel 3.5.0 131072 nodes           :  3014.4    82.0     114    72
   9 Stockfish 16.1 16384nodes         :  2997.4    80.0     114    70
  10 Clover 6.1 131072 nodes           :  2997.4    80.0     114    70
  11 Obsidian 11.0 131072nodes         :  2972.7    77.0     114    68
  12 Alexandria-6.1.0 131072 nodes     :  2964.7    76.0     114    67
  13 Black Marlin 9.0 131072 nodes     :  2964.7    76.0     114    67
  14 Berserk 13 65536 nodes            :  2960.7    75.5     114    66
  15 Seer 2.8.0 65536 nodes            :  2952.8    74.5     114    65
  16 Velvet v7.3.0 131072 nodes        :  2952.8    74.5     114    65
  17 Viridithas 12.0.0 131072 nodes    :  2937.2    72.5     114    64
  18 Igel 3.5.0 65536 nodes            :  2929.4    71.5     114    63
  19 Koivisto 9.0 131072 nodes         :  2929.4    71.5     114    63
  20 Obsidian 11.0 65536nodes          :  2921.8    70.5     114    62
  21 PlentyChess 1.0.0 65536 nodes     :  2918.0    70.0     114    61
  22 Caissa 1.18 65536 nodes           :  2918.0    70.0     114    61
  23 Rubi20240112 65536nodes           :  2918.0    70.0     114    61
  24 Berserk 13 32768 nodes            :  2884.2    65.5     114    57
  25 Koivisto 9.0 65536 nodes          :  2869.4    63.5     114    56
  26 Altair 7.0.0 131072 nodes         :  2865.7    63.0     114    55
  27 Alexandria-6.1.0 65536 nodes      :  2862.0    62.5     114    55
  28 Clover 6.1 65536 nodes            :  2847.4    60.5     114    53
  29 Viridithas 12.0.0 65536 nodes     :  2829.1    58.0     114    51
  30 Stash v35.0 1048576 nodes         :  2821.8    57.0     114    50
  31 Black Marlin 9.0 65536 nodes      :  2818.1    56.5     114    50
  32 PlentyChess 1.0.0 32768 nodes     :  2796.1    53.5     114    47
  33 Stockfish 16.1 8192nodes          :  2778.8    98.0     168    58
  34 Seer 2.8.0 32768 nodes            :  2759.1    48.5     114    43
  35 Caissa 1.18 32768 nodes           :  2759.1    48.5     114    43
  36 Velvet v7.3.0 65536 nodes         :  2758.1    94.5     168    56
  37 Altair 7.0.0 65536 nodes          :  2744.1    46.5     114    41
  38 Obsidian 11.0 32768nodes          :  2743.4    92.0     168    55
  39 Rubi20240112 32768nodes           :  2732.7    45.0     114    39
  40 Black Marlin 9.0 32768 nodes      :  2731.7    90.0     168    54
  41 Clover 6.1 32768 nodes            :  2731.7    90.0     168    54
  42 Igel 3.5.0 32768 nodes            :  2717.1    87.5     168    52
  43 Alexandria-6.1.0 32768 nodes      :  2711.3    86.5     168    51
  44 Stash v35.0 524288 nodes          :  2701.8    41.0     114    36
  45 Viridithas 12.0.0 32768 nodes     :  2696.6    84.0     168    50
  46 Koivisto 9.0 32768 nodes          :  2682.0    81.5     168    49
  47 Berserk 13 16384 nodes            :  2670.3    79.5     168    47
  48 Rubi20240112 16384nodes           :  2643.8    75.0     168    45
  49 PlentyChess 1.0.0 16384 nodes     :  2637.9    74.0     168    44
  50 Stash v35.0 262144 nodes          :  2637.9    74.0     168    44
  51 SmarThink 1.98 524288 nodes       :  2630.5    59.5      94    63
  52 SmarThink 1.98 1048576 nodes      :  2626.0    59.0      94    63
  53 Velvet v7.3.0 32768 nodes         :  2608.0    57.0      94    61
  54 Caissa 1.18 16384 nodes           :  2602.0    68.0     168    40
  55 Seer 2.8.0 16384 nodes            :  2577.7    64.0     168    38
  56 Altair 7.0.0 32768 nodes          :  2565.4    62.0     168    37
  57 Stockfish 16.1 4096nodes          :  2562.3    61.5     168    37
  58 Koivisto 9.0 16384 nodes          :  2556.1    60.5     168    36
  59 Clover 6.1 16384 nodes            :  2546.7    59.0     168    35
  60 Stash v35.0 131072 nodes          :  2543.5    58.5     168    35
  61 Obsidian 11.0 16384nodes          :  2538.2    49.0      94    52
  62 Igel 3.5.0 16384 nodes            :  2533.9    48.5      94    52
  63 Viridithas 12.0.0 16384 nodes     :  2525.3    47.5      94    51
  64 Alexandria-6.1.0 16384 nodes      :  2525.3    47.5      94    51
  65 Black Marlin 9.0 16384 nodes      :  2516.7    46.5      94    49
  66 Altair 7.0.0 16384 nodes          :  2499.4    44.5      94    47
  67 Velvet v7.1.0 32768 nodes         :  2480.2     6.5      74     9
  68 Alexandria-6.1.0 8192 nodes       :  2473.5    41.5      94    44
  69 Berserk 13 8192 nodes             :  2469.1    41.0      94    44
  70 SmarThink 1.98 262144 nodes       :  2433.8    37.0      94    39
  71 Seer 2.8.0 8192 nodes             :  2406.1   120.0     194    62
  72 Viridithas 12.0.0 8192 nodes      :  2400.3   119.0     194    61
  73 PlentyChess 1.0.0 8192 nodes      :  2383.3    31.5      94    34
  74 SmarThink 1.98 131072 nodes       :  2383.3    31.5      94    34
  75 SmarThink 1.98 65536 nodes        :  2378.6    31.0      94    33
  76 Blunder 8.5.5 1048576  nodes      :  2377.3   115.0     194    59
  77 Velvet v7.3.0 16384 nodes         :  2371.6   114.0     194    59
  78 Stash v35.0 65536 nodes           :  2354.3    28.5      94    30
  79 Black Marlin 9.0 8192 nodes       :  2345.9   109.5     194    56
  80 Caissa 1.18 8192 nodes            :  2345.9   109.5     194    56
  81 Rubi20240112 8192nodes            :  2329.0   106.5     194    55
  82 Koivisto 9.0 8192 nodes           :  2300.9   101.5     194    52
  83 Obsidian 11.0 8192nodes           :  2295.3   100.5     194    52
  84 Stockfish 16.1 2048nodes          :  2295.3   100.5     194    52
  85 Igel 3.5.0 8192 nodes             :  2284.2    86.0     122    70
  86 Altair 7.0.0 8192 nodes           :  2275.6    97.0     194    50
  87 Clover 6.1 8192 nodes             :  2272.1    84.5     122    69
  88 Movei00_8_438 1048576 nodes       :  2270.0    96.0     194    49
  89 Blunder 8.5.5 524288  nodes       :  2256.3    82.5     122    68
  90 Blunder 8.5.5 262144  nodes       :  2252.5    82.0     122    67
  91 Viridithas 12.0.0 4096 nodes      :  2233.3    79.5     122    65
  92 Stash v35.0 32768 nodes           :  2229.5    79.0     122    65
  93 SmarThink 1.98 32768 nodes        :  2229.5    79.0     122    65
  94 Velvet v7.3.0 8192 nodes          :  2229.5    79.0     122    65
  95 Seer 2.8.0 4096 nodes             :  2218.2    77.5     122    64
  96 Caissa 1.18 4096 nodes            :  2214.5    77.0     122    63
  97 Movei00_8_438 524288 nodes        :  2210.7    76.5     122    63
  98 Berserk 13 4096 nodes             :  2196.0    74.5     122    61
  99 PlentyChess 1.0.0 4096 nodes      :  2181.3    72.5     122    59
 100 Alexandria-6.1.0 4096 nodes       :  2177.7    72.0     122    59
 101 SmarThink 1.98 8192 nodes         :  2134.5    66.0     122    54
 102 SmarThink 1.98 16384 nodes        :  2123.8    64.5     122    53
 103 Movei00_8_438 262144 nodes        :  2123.8    64.5     122    53
 104 Altair 7.0.0 4096 nodes           :  2116.7    63.5     122    52
 105 Obsidian 11.0 4096nodes           :  2116.7    63.5     122    52
 106 Blunder 8.5.5 65536  nodes        :  2106.0    62.0     122    51
 107 Blunder 8.5.5 131072  nodes       :  2102.4    61.5     122    50
 108 Koivisto 9.0 4096 nodes           :  2098.9    61.0     122    50
 109 Viridithas 12.0.0 2048 nodes      :  2077.4    58.0     122    48
 110 Stash v35.0 16384 nodes           :  2067.8   140.5     214    66
 111 Black Marlin 9.0 4096 nodes       :  2045.2   136.5     214    64
 112 Stockfish 16.1 1024nodes          :  2042.8   116.5     142    82
 113 Movei00_8_438 131072 nodes        :  2034.1    52.0     122    43
 114 Igel 3.5.0 4096 nodes             :  2034.0   134.5     214    63
 115 Velvet v7.3.0 4096 nodes          :  2031.2   134.0     214    63
 116 Velvet v7.3.0 2048 nodes          :  2028.4   133.5     214    62
 117 PlentyChess 1.0.0 2048 nodes      :  2014.5   131.0     214    61
 118 Caissa 1.18 2048 nodes            :  1981.3   125.0     214    58
 119 Rubi20240112 4096nodes            :  1978.5   124.5     214    58
 120 Clover 6.1 4096 nodes             :  1978.5   124.5     214    58
 121 Seer 2.8.0 2048 nodes             :  1967.5   122.5     214    57
 122 Movei00_8_438 65536 nodes         :  1961.9   121.5     214    57
 123 SmarThink 1.98 4096 nodes         :  1945.4   118.5     214    55
 124 Alexandria-6.1.0 2048 nodes       :  1937.1   117.0     214    55
 125 Movei00_8_438 32768 nodes         :  1934.4   116.5     214    54
 126 Velvet v7.3.0 1024 nodes          :  1929.5   103.5     142    73
 127 Blunder 8.5.5 32768  nodes        :  1917.8   113.5     214    53
 128 Lc0 v0.30.0 1 node                :  1917.8   102.0     142    72
 129 Velvet v7.3.0 512 nodes           :  1906.1   100.5     142    71
 130 Altair 7.0.0 2048 nodes           :  1895.7   109.5     214    51
 131 Berserk 13 2048 nodes             :  1884.5   107.5     214    50
 132 PlentyChess 1.0.0 1024 nodes      :  1883.4    97.5     142    69
 133 Viridithas 12.0.0 1024 nodes      :  1832.1    90.5     142    64
 134 Koivisto 9.0 2048 nodes           :  1825.7    97.0     214    45
 135 Obsidian 11.0 2048nodes           :  1820.0    96.0     214    45
 136 Altair 7.0.0 1024 nodes           :  1814.3    88.0     142    62
 137 Blunder 8.5.5 16384  nodes        :  1802.9    93.0     214    43
 138 Stash v35.0 8192 nodes            :  1794.3    91.5     214    43
 139 Rubi20240112 2048nodes            :  1779.9    89.0     214    42
 140 SmarThink 1.98 2048 nodes         :  1779.9    89.0     214    42
 141 Movei00_8_438 16384 nodes         :  1779.9    89.0     214    42
 142 Black Marlin 9.0 2048 nodes       :  1756.6    85.0     214    40
 143 Alexandria-6.1.0 1024 nodes       :  1754.6    79.5     142    56
 144 Igel 3.5.0 2048 nodes             :  1744.8    83.0     214    39
 145 Caissa 1.18 1024 nodes            :  1737.2    77.0     142    54
 146 Altair 7.0.0 512 nodes            :  1733.7    76.5     142    54
 147 SmarThink 1.98 1024 nodes         :  1716.3    74.0     142    52
 148 Stockfish 16.1 512 nodes          :  1709.4    73.0     142    51
 149 Clover 6.1 2048 nodes             :  1698.9    71.5     142    50
 150 Berserk 13 1024 nodes             :  1677.9    68.5     142    48
 151 Viridithas 12.0.0 512 nodes       :  1649.7    64.5     142    45
 152 Movei00_8_438 8192 nodes          :  1642.6    63.5     142    45
 153 Seer 2.8.0 1024 nodes             :  1631.8    62.0     142    44
 154 Koivisto 9.0 1024 nodes           :  1610.2    59.0     142    42
 155 Obsidian 11.0 1024nodes           :  1599.2    57.5     142    40
 156 Alexandria-6.1.0 512 nodes        :  1595.6    57.0     142    40
 157 Blunder 8.5.5 8192  nodes         :  1588.2    56.0     142    39
 158 SmarThink 1.98 512 nodes          :  1584.5    55.5     142    39
 159 Rubi20240112 1024nodes            :  1562.0    52.5     142    37
 160 Stash v35.0 4096 nodes            :  1546.7    50.5     142    36
 161 Blunder 8.5.5 4096  nodes         :  1539.0    49.5     142    35
 162 Rubi20240112 512nodes             :  1519.4    47.0     142    33
 163 Berserk 13 512 nodes              :  1519.4    47.0     142    33
 164 Caissa 1.18 512 nodes             :  1519.4    47.0     142    33
 165 Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes             :  1499.3    44.5     142    31
 166 Clover 6.1 1024 nodes             :  1474.5    41.5     142    29
 167 Seer 2.8.0 512 nodes              :  1466.0    40.5     142    29
 168 Movei00_8_438 4096 nodes          :  1466.0    40.5     142    29
 169 Koivisto 9.0 512 nodes            :  1457.4    39.5     142    28
 170 Blunder 8.5.5 2048  nodes         :  1448.7    38.5     142    27
 171 Stash v35.0 2048 nodes            :  1439.8    37.5     142    26
 172 Black Marlin 9.0 1024 nodes       :  1412.5    34.5     142    24
 173 Igel 3.5.0 512 nodes              :  1398.3    33.0     142    23
 174 Obsidian 11.0 512 nodes           :  1373.8    30.5     142    21
 175 Black Marlin 9.0 512 nodes        :  1358.5    29.0     142    20
 176 Movei00_8_438 2048 nodes          :  1342.7    27.5     142    19
 177 Movei00_8_438 1024 nodes          :  1204.2    16.5     142    12
 178 Stash v35.0 1024 nodes            :  1196.5    16.0     142    11
 179 Blunder 8.5.5 512 nodes           :  1180.7    15.0     142    11
 180 Blunder 8.5.5 1024  nodes         :  1155.5    13.5     142    10
 181 Movei00_8_438 512 nodes           :  1108.6    11.0     142     8
 182 Stash v35.0 512 nodes             :  1000.0     6.5     142     5

White advantage = 34.67
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 50.00 %

Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

Stockfish won a tournament with 1M nodes per move no opening book.

Code: Select all

Result:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                       games    wins   draws  losses   score    elo    +    -
  1. Stockfish 16.1                18       7      11       0    12.5     90  110  103
  2. Berserk 13                    18       4      14       0    11.0     46  103  100
  3. RubiChess 20240112 (avx2)     18       5      11       2    10.5     42  106  103
  4. Obsidian 11.0                 18       5       9       4     9.5     16  108  107
  5. Caissa 1.18 AVX2              18       1      17       0     9.5     11   97   97
  6. Seer 2.8.0                    18       2      14       2     9.0     -2  100  100
  7. Viridithas 12.0.0             18       2      13       3     8.5    -12  101  102
  8. Clover 6.1                    18       1      12       5     7.0    -50  102  106
  9. Igel 3.5.0                    18       1      12       5     7.0    -51  102  105
 10. Velvet v7.3.0                 18       0      11       7     5.5    -89  103  110

Cross table:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                          score   games         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10
  1. Stockfish 16.1                 12.5      18         x        ==        ==        11        ==        1=        =1        =1        1=        1=
  2. Berserk 13                     11.0      18        ==         x        11        ==        ==        ==        =1        ==        =1        ==
  3. RubiChess 20240112 (avx2)      10.5      18        ==        00         x        ==        ==        1=        ==        1=        1=        11
  4. Obsidian 11.0                   9.5      18        00        ==        ==         x        0=        =0        1=        1=        1=        11
  5. Caissa 1.18 AVX2                9.5      18        ==        ==        ==        1=         x        ==        ==        ==        ==        ==
  6. Seer 2.8.0                      9.0      18        0=        ==        0=        =1        ==         x        ==        1=        ==        ==
  7. Viridithas 12.0.0               8.5      18        =0        =0        ==        0=        ==        ==         x        ==        ==        11
  8. Clover 6.1                      7.0      18        =0        ==        0=        0=        ==        0=        ==         x        01        ==
  9. Igel 3.5.0            7.0      18        0=        =0        0=        0=        ==        ==        ==        10         x        ==
 10. Velvet v7.3.0                   5.5      18        0=        ==        00        00        ==        ==        00        ==        ==         x

Tech:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tech (average nodes, depths, time/m per move, others per game), counted for computing moves only, ignored moves with zero nodes:
  #  name                         nodes/m         NPS  depth/m   time/m    moves     time
  1. Stockfish 16.1                  987K      416318     33.3      2.4     75.3    178.6
  2. Berserk 13                      798K      874556     33.0      0.9     94.5     86.3
  3. RubiChess 20240112 (avx2)       965K      729734     23.7      1.3     81.0    107.1
  4. Obsidian 11.0                   745K      392409     28.1      1.9     99.4    188.8
  5. Caissa 1.18 AVX2                791K      903507     25.4      0.9     77.4     67.8
  6. Seer 2.8.0                      654K      457898     22.4      1.4     92.3    131.9
  7. Viridithas 12.0.0               801K      710701     25.5      1.1    102.1    115.2
  8. Clover 6.1                      757K      890931     26.8      0.8     91.6     77.8
  9. Igel 3.5.0                       758K      372494     25.8      2.0     90.8    184.7
 10. Velvet v7.3.0                   991K      893431     22.5      1.1     95.8    106.3
     all ---                         801K      593533     26.6      1.4     90.0    124.4
Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

Stockfish16.1 won another tournament this time 10M nodes per move for all engines
Caissa and Rubi are also undefeated.

Used 256 mbytes hash for all engines when previous tournament was with 80 mbytes hash for all engines.

Code: Select all

 
Result:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                       games    wins   draws  losses   score    elo    +    -
  1. Stockfish 16.1                18       4      14       0    11.0     50  102   99
  2. Caissa 1.18 AVX2              18       3      15       0    10.5     34  100   98
  3. RubiChess 20240112 (avx2)     18       2      16       0    10.0     24   98   97
  4. Berserk 13                    18       4      11       3     9.5     14  105  104
  5. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes         18       1      17       0     9.5     13   97   96
  6. Obsidian 11.0                 18       2      15       1     9.5     13   99   98
  7. Clover 6.1                    18       1      16       1     9.0      1   98   98
  8. Seer 2.8.0                    18       1      15       2     8.5    -10   98   99
  9. Viridithas 12.0.0             18       1      12       5     7.0    -49  101  105
 10. Velvet v7.3.0                 18       0      11       7     5.5    -90  103  110

Cross table:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                          score   games         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10
  1. Stockfish 16.1                 11.0      18         x        ==        ==        ==        ==        ==        ==        1=        11        1=
  2. Caissa 1.18 AVX2               10.5      18        ==         x        ==        1=        ==        ==        ==        1=        =1        ==
  3. RubiChess 20240112 (avx2)      10.0      18        ==        ==         x        =1        ==        ==        ==        ==        ==        1=
  4. Berserk 13                      9.5      18        ==        0=        =0         x        ==        10        1=        ==        =1        =1
  5. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes           9.5      18        ==        ==        ==        ==         x        ==        ==        ==        ==        =1
  6. Obsidian 11.0                   9.5      18        ==        ==        ==        01        ==         x        ==        ==        ==        1=
  7. Clover 6.1                      9.0      18        ==        ==        ==        0=        ==        ==         x        ==        =1        ==
  8. Seer 2.8.0                      8.5      18        0=        0=        ==        ==        ==        ==        ==         x        ==        =1
  9. Viridithas 12.0.0               7.0      18        00        =0        ==        =0        ==        ==        =0        ==         x        1=
 10. Velvet v7.3.0                   5.5      18        0=        ==        0=        =0        =0        0=        ==        =0        0=         x

Tech:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tech (average nodes, depths, time/m per move, others per game), counted for computing moves only, ignored moves with zero nodes:
  #  name                         nodes/m         NPS  depth/m   time/m    moves     time
  1. Stockfish 16.1                 9892K      620187     45.6     16.0     75.9   1211.3
  2. Caissa 1.18 AVX2               7393K     1045483     34.3      7.1     67.9    480.4
  3. RubiChess 20240112 (avx2)      9602K     1011627     33.1      9.5     89.3    847.9
  4. Berserk 13                     8362K     1202312     44.6      7.0     92.9    646.5
  5. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes          7578K      477333     33.9     15.9     79.7   1265.6
  6. Obsidian 11.0                  7429K      567275     37.2     13.1     95.0   1244.2
  7. Clover 6.1                     8193K     1291115     36.8      6.3     74.9    475.6
  8. Seer 2.8.0                     6909K      668725     32.4     10.3     73.2    756.5
  9. Viridithas 12.0.0              8111K      912431     32.0      8.9     92.4    821.3
 10. Velvet v7.3.0                  9886K     1187276     28.3      8.3     80.9    674.0
     all ---                        8155K      815352     35.9     10.2     82.2    842.3
Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

another tournament.
I did not want stockfish or berserk to win so upgraded some weaker engines.

Code: Select all

Result:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                            games    wins   draws  losses   score    elo    +    -
  1. Obsidian 11.0 262144nodes          76      34      39       3    53.5    122   63   60
  2. Alexandria-6.1.0 262144 nodes      76      36      31       9    51.5    113   64   62
  3. Clover 6.1 262144 nodes            76      31      41       4    51.5    105   61   59
  4. Berserk 13 131072 nodes            76      32      39       5    51.5    105   62   60
  5. Stockfish 16.1 32768nodes          76      31      40       5    51.0    105   61   59
  6. Rubi20240112 131072nodes           76      30      41       5    50.5     99   61   59
  7. Koivisto 9.0 262144 nodes          76      27      40       9    47.0     70   60   59
  8. Black Marlin 9.0 262144 nodes      76      30      33      13    46.5     68   62   61
  9. PlentyChess 1.0.0 131072 nodes     76      29      34      13    46.0     67   62   60
 10. Velvet v7.3.0 262144 nodes         76      25      40      11    45.0     59   60   59
 11. Viridithas 12.0.0 262144 nodes     76      23      44       9    45.0     54   59   58
 12. Igel 3.5.0 131072 nodes            76      22      45       9    44.5     52   59   58
 13. Clover 6.1 131072 nodes            76      23      41      12    43.5     44   60   59
 14. Stockfish 16.1 16384nodes          76      24      38      14    43.0     42   60   60
 15. Caissa 1.18 131072 nodes           76      20      46      10    43.0     38   58   58
 16. Seer 2.8.0 131072 nodes            76      22      41      13    42.5     36   60   59
 17. Obsidian 11.0 131072nodes          76      19      41      16    39.5     14   59   59
 18. Seer 2.8.0 65536 nodes             76      19      38      19    38.0      6   60   60
 19. Berserk 13 65536 nodes             76      18      41      17    38.5      5   59   59
 20. Alexandria-6.1.0 131072 nodes      76      15      45      16    37.5     -5   58   58
 21. Rubi20240112 65536nodes            76      16      42      18    37.0     -5   59   59
 22. Obsidian 11.0 65536nodes           76      14      45      17    36.5    -10   58   58
 23. Koivisto 9.0 131072 nodes          76      14      45      17    36.5    -12   58   59
 24. Viridithas 12.0.0 131072 nodes     76      16      40      20    36.0    -12   59   59
 25. Velvet v7.3.0 131072 nodes         76      16      39      21    35.5    -18   60   60
 26. Altair 7.0.0 262144 nodes          76      16      37      23    34.5    -24   60   60
 27. Igel 3.5.0 65536 nodes             76      10      46      20    33.0    -35   58   58
 28. PlentyChess 1.0.0 65536 nodes      76      19      28      29    33.0    -41   62   63
 29. Black Marlin 9.0 131072 nodes      76      17      32      27    33.0    -42   60   61
 30. Caissa 1.18 65536 nodes            76      14      36      26    32.0    -45   60   61
 31. Berserk 13 32768 nodes             76       9      43      24    30.5    -59   59   60
 32. Altair 7.0.0 131072 nodes          76       9      37      30    27.5    -81   60   62
 33. Clover 6.1 65536 nodes             76       7      39      30    26.5    -90   60   62
 34. Stash v35.0 2097144 nodes          76      15      23      38    26.5   -101   64   67
 35. Viridithas 12.0.0 65536 nodes      76       8      33      35    24.5   -103   61   64
 36. Alexandria-6.1.0 65536 nodes       76       9      31      36    24.5   -110   62   65
 37. Koivisto 9.0 65536 nodes           76      11      27      38    24.5   -113   63   66
 38. Stash v35.0 1048576 nodes          76      10      23      43    21.5   -145   65   69
 39. Black Marlin 9.0 65536 nodes       76       5      30      41    20.0   -152   63   67

Cross table:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                               score   games         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10        11        12        13        14        15        16        17        18        19        20        21        22        23        24        25        26        27        28        29        30        31        32        33        34        35        36        37        38        39
  1. Obsidian 11.0 262144nodes           53.5      76         x        ==        =1        ==        =1        ==        11        11        11        ==        1=        ==        ==        =0        =1        ==        ==        =1        01        11        ==        11        0=        1=        =1        ==        1=        11        1=        11        1=        11        ==        ==        =1        11        11        ==        11
  2. Alexandria-6.1.0 262144 nodes       51.5      76        ==         x        0=        0=        ==        1=        01        01        0=        1=        1=        ==        =1        11        01        0=        1=        =1        ==        =1        =0        =1        11        10        1=        11        =1        11        =1        11        ==        =1        ==        11        =1        1=        11        11        11
  3. Clover 6.1 262144 nodes             51.5      76        =0        1=         x        ==        ==        =0        ==        1=        1=        ==        ==        ==        0=        =1        ==        =1        =1        =1        =1        11        ==        =1        ==        11        ==        11        ==        11        01        =1        =1        =1        11        11        ==        11        =1        =1        11
  4. Berserk 13 131072 nodes             51.5      76        ==        1=        ==         x        11        ==        1=        =1        =1        1=        0=        11        ==        0=        1=        11        ==        1=        =1        11        ==        ==        =1        =1        10        =1        1=        11        11        =1        01        ==        ==        =1        =1        ==        11        =0        =1
  5. Stockfish 16.1 32768nodes           51.0      76        =0        ==        ==        00         x        ==        =1        01        ==        ==        ==        ==        1=        1=        1=        ==        1=        1=        1=        =1        1=        1=        ==        1=        ==        1=        =1        11        1=        11        01        =1        =1        1=        =1        11        11        1=        11
  6. Rubi20240112 131072nodes            50.5      76        ==        0=        =1        ==        ==         x        1=        =0        ==        1=        ==        0=        ==        ==        ==        =1        =1        11        =1        =1        =1        =1        ==        01        1=        11        ==        1=        11        ==        =1        =1        11        01        11        =1        ==        11        11
  7. Koivisto 9.0 262144 nodes           47.0      76        00        10        ==        0=        =0        0=         x        =0        =1        =1        1=        ==        ==        ==        ==        =1        ==        11        ==        ==        =1        ==        =0        ==        1=        =1        ==        10        11        ==        11        11        11        11        1=        1=        11        1=        1=
  8. Black Marlin 9.0 262144 nodes       46.5      76        00        10        0=        =0        10        =1        =1         x        0=        =0        10        10        =0        =1        =0        0=        1=        ==        ==        ==        1=        ==        1=        ==        =1        =1        11        =1        =1        ==        11        11        1=        =1        11        =1        1=        11        11
  9. PlentyChess 1.0.0 131072 nodes      46.0      76        00        1=        0=        =0        ==        ==        =0        1=         x        1=        ==        ==        =0        =1        ==        10        0=        0=        =0        0=        1=        =0        11        ==        10        =1        11        1=        11        11        ==        ==        =1        11        1=        11        11        11        11
 10. Velvet v7.3.0 262144 nodes          45.0      76        ==        0=        ==        0=        ==        0=        =0        =1        0=         x        00        =0        ==        ==        =1        ==        =1        ==        1=        ==        =1        1=        01        1=        11        ==        1=        01        11        ==        ==        ==        11        01        1=        11        1=        11        11
 11. Viridithas 12.0.0 262144 nodes      45.0      76        0=        0=        ==        1=        ==        ==        0=        01        ==        11         x        ==        11        =1        01        ==        =1        ==        ==        ==        ==        =1        ==        1=        1=        ==        ==        01        1=        11        00        ==        =1        11        ==        0=        =1        11        1=
 12. Igel 3.5.0 131072 nodes             44.5      76        ==        ==        ==        00        ==        1=        ==        01        ==        =1        ==         x        ==        =0        ==        1=        01        00        1=        =1        1=        ==        =1        =1        0=        ==        ==        =0        ==        ==        1=        1=        11        11        =1        =1        =1        11        =1
 13. Clover 6.1 131072 nodes             43.5      76        ==        =0        1=        ==        0=        ==        ==        =1        =1        ==        00        ==         x        10        ==        00        ==        =1        00        0=        11        =1        1=        0=        ==        11        ==        =1        1=        =1        ==        =1        ==        0=        11        =1        11        11        1=
 14. Stockfish 16.1 16384nodes           43.0      76        =1        00        =0        1=        0=        ==        ==        =0        =0        ==        =0        =1        01         x        ==        1=        0=        ==        1=        0=        =1        ==        0=        ==        01        1=        11        1=        1=        1=        =1        10        =1        11        ==        =0        11        =1        11
 15. Caissa 1.18 131072 nodes            43.0      76        =0        10        ==        0=        0=        ==        ==        =1        ==        =0        10        ==        ==        ==         x        ==        01        ==        =0        ==        ==        =1        ==        1=        11        ==        ==        1=        =0        ==        11        0=        1=        1=        11        1=        =1        1=        11
 16. Seer 2.8.0 131072 nodes             42.5      76        ==        1=        =0        00        ==        =0        =0        1=        01        ==        ==        0=        11        0=        ==         x        11        ==        =1        =0        =1        1=        =1        =1        ==        =1        =1        1=        ==        01        11        1=        ==        ==        =1        1=        1=        00        0=
 17. Obsidian 11.0 131072nodes           39.5      76        ==        0=        =0        ==        0=        =0        ==        0=        1=        =0        =0        10        ==        1=        10        00         x        0=        11        ==        1=        ==        0=        =0        ==        1=        ==        =1        =1        1=        1=        =1        01        =1        1=        1=        =0        11        ==
 18. Seer 2.8.0 65536 nodes              38.0      76        =0        =0        =0        0=        0=        00        00        ==        1=        ==        ==        11        =0        ==        ==        ==        1=         x        =1        ==        01        0=        =1        =1        =1        ==        ==        =0        1=        0=        ==        =0        11        10        11        10        01        10        1=
 19. Berserk 13 65536 nodes              38.5      76        10        ==        =0        =0        0=        =0        ==        ==        =1        0=        ==        0=        11        0=        =1        =0        00        =0         x        01        ==        =1        0=        =1        ==        ==        1=        1=        1=        =1        =1        1=        1=        0=        =1        ==        10        =0        =1
 20. Alexandria-6.1.0 131072 nodes       37.5      76        00        =0        00        00        =0        =0        ==        ==        1=        ==        ==        =0        1=        1=        ==        =1        ==        ==        10         x        0=        ==        0=        ==        =1        01        =1        ==        ==        =0        ==        11        =1        10        ==        1=        ==        1=        =1
 21. Rubi20240112 65536nodes             37.0      76        ==        =1        ==        ==        0=        =0        =0        0=        0=        =0        ==        0=        00        =0        ==        =0        0=        10        ==        1=         x        =1        ==        =0        =1        10        =1        ==        0=        01        ==        11        0=        11        ==        ==        1=        11        1=
 22. Obsidian 11.0 65536nodes            36.5      76        00        =0        =0        ==        0=        =0        ==        ==        =1        0=        =0        ==        =0        ==        =0        0=        ==        1=        =0        ==        =0         x        =1        ==        1=        1=        1=        0=        =0        10        ==        0=        =1        11        1=        ==        ==        11        =1
 23. Koivisto 9.0 131072 nodes           36.5      76        1=        00        ==        =0        ==        ==        =1        0=        00        10        ==        =0        0=        1=        ==        =0        1=        =0        1=        1=        ==        =0         x        1=        0=        ==        ==        11        1=        ==        ==        0=        ==        0=        ==        00        1=        =1        1=
 24. Viridithas 12.0.0 131072 nodes      36.0      76        0=        01        00        =0        0=        10        ==        ==        ==        0=        0=        =0        1=        ==        0=        =0        =1        =0        =0        ==        =1        ==        0=         x        =0        10        ==        ==        =1        0=        0=        ==        11        =1        11        1=        0=        11        =1
 25. Velvet v7.3.0 131072 nodes          35.5      76        =0        0=        ==        01        ==        0=        0=        =0        01        00        0=        1=        ==        10        00        ==        ==        =0        ==        =0        =0        0=        1=        =1         x        ==        0=        1=        1=        =1        =0        1=        10        ==        =1        =1        01        11        ==
 26. Altair 7.0.0 262144 nodes           34.5      76        ==        00        00        =0        0=        00        =0        =0        =0        ==        ==        ==        00        0=        ==        =0        0=        ==        ==        10        01        0=        ==        01        ==         x        1=        0=        11        0=        11        =1        1=        1=        10        =1        11        ==        =1
 27. Igel 3.5.0 65536 nodes              33.0      76        0=        =0        ==        0=        =0        ==        ==        00        00        0=        ==        ==        ==        00        ==        =0        ==        ==        0=        =0        =0        0=        ==        ==        1=        0=         x        =1        1=        10        =1        ==        =1        11        =1        01        =0        ==        ==
 28. PlentyChess 1.0.0 65536 nodes       33.0      76        00        00        00        00        00        0=        01        =0        0=        10        10        =1        =0        0=        0=        0=        =0        =1        0=        ==        ==        1=        00        ==        0=        1=        =0         x        =0        11        ==        1=        =1        10        11        11        1=        10        1=
 29. Black Marlin 9.0 131072 nodes       33.0      76        0=        =0        10        00        0=        00        00        =0        00        00        0=        ==        0=        0=        =1        ==        =0        0=        0=        ==        1=        =1        0=        =0        0=        00        0=        =1         x        ==        1=        11        ==        11        ==        11        =1        11        11
 30. Caissa 1.18 65536 nodes             32.0      76        00        00        =0        =0        00        ==        ==        ==        00        ==        00        ==        =0        0=        ==        10        0=        1=        =0        =1        10        01        ==        1=        =0        1=        01        00        ==         x        ==        1=        ==        10        10        =1        =0        1=        1=
 31. Berserk 13 32768 nodes              30.5      76        0=        ==        =0        10        10        =0        00        00        ==        ==        11        0=        ==        =0        00        00        0=        ==        =0        ==        ==        ==        ==        1=        =1        00        =0        ==        0=        ==         x        =0        =0        =0        =1        ==        =1        =1        ==
 32. Altair 7.0.0 131072 nodes           27.5      76        00        =0        =0        ==        =0        =0        00        00        ==        ==        ==        0=        =0        01        1=        0=        =0        =1        0=        00        00        1=        1=        ==        0=        =0        ==        0=        00        0=        =1         x        01        =0        =0        ==        1=        0=        =1
 33. Clover 6.1 65536 nodes              26.5      76        ==        ==        00        ==        =0        00        00        0=        =0        00        =0        00        ==        =0        0=        ==        10        00        0=        =0        1=        =0        ==        00        01        0=        =0        =0        ==        ==        =1        10         x        ==        1=        ==        =1        0=        ==
 34. Stash v35.0 2097144 nodes           26.5      76        ==        00        00        =0        0=        10        00        =0        00        10        00        00        1=        00        0=        ==        =0        01        1=        01        00        00        1=        =0        ==        0=        00        01        00        01        =1        =1        ==         x        10        11        =1        ==        00
 35. Viridithas 12.0.0 65536 nodes       24.5      76        =0        =0        ==        =0        =0        00        0=        00        0=        0=        ==        =0        00        ==        00        =0        0=        00        =0        ==        ==        0=        ==        00        =0        01        =0        00        ==        01        =0        =1        0=        01         x        1=        01        10        =1
 36. Alexandria-6.1.0 65536 nodes        24.5      76        00        0=        00        ==        00        =0        0=        =0        00        00        1=        =0        =0        =1        0=        0=        0=        01        ==        0=        ==        ==        11        0=        =0        =0        10        00        00        =0        ==        ==        ==        00        0=         x        10        01        10
 37. Koivisto 9.0 65536 nodes            24.5      76        00        00        =0        00        00        ==        00        0=        00        0=        =0        =0        00        00        =0        0=        =1        10        01        ==        0=        ==        0=        1=        10        00        =1        0=        =0        =1        =0        0=        =0        =0        10        01         x        =1        =1
 38. Stash v35.0 1048576 nodes           21.5      76        ==        00        =0        =1        0=        00        0=        00        00        00        00        00        00        =0        0=        11        00        01        =1        0=        00        00        =0        00        00        ==        ==        01        00        0=        =0        1=        1=        ==        01        10        =0         x        0=
 39. Black Marlin 9.0 65536 nodes        20.0      76        00        00        00        =0        00        00        0=        00        00        00        0=        =0        0=        00        00        1=        ==        0=        =0        =0        0=        =0        0=        =0        ==        =0        ==        0=        00        0=        ==        =0        ==        11        =0        01        =0        1=         x

Tech:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tech (average nodes, depths, time/m per move, others per game), counted for computing moves only, ignored moves with zero nodes:
  #  name                              nodes/m         NPS  depth/m   time/m    moves     time
  1. Obsidian 11.0 262144nodes            201K      887032     22.4      0.2     87.4     19.8
  2. Alexandria-6.1.0 262144 nodes        202K     1173499     22.7      0.2     82.4     14.2
  3. Clover 6.1 262144 nodes              196K     1317994     20.4      0.1     76.2     11.3
  4. Berserk 13 131072 nodes              100K      991217     23.4      0.1     86.9      8.7
  5. Stockfish 16.1 32768nodes             33K      752432     19.3      0.0     84.5      3.7
  6. Rubi20240112 131072nodes             125K     1042906     18.7      0.1     79.9      9.6
  7. Koivisto 9.0 262144 nodes            260K     1707029     21.2      0.2     84.7     12.9
  8. Black Marlin 9.0 262144 nodes        201K      905505     19.2      0.2     84.1     18.6
  9. PlentyChess 1.0.0 131072 nodes        97K      838405     19.8      0.1     84.0      9.7
 10. Velvet v7.3.0 262144 nodes           259K     1422374     18.5      0.2     82.9     15.1
 11. Viridithas 12.0.0 262144 nodes       219K     1007731     19.5      0.2     73.9     16.0
 12. Igel 3.5.0 131072 nodes               94K      457101     18.4      0.2     79.0     16.2
 13. Clover 6.1 131072 nodes               98K     1296191     18.4      0.1     81.7      6.2
 14. Stockfish 16.1 16384nodes             16K      720221     16.6      0.0     85.9      1.9
 15. Caissa 1.18 131072 nodes             105K     1332198     21.3      0.1     81.6      6.4
 16. Seer 2.8.0 131072 nodes               96K      833684     17.7      0.1     87.6     10.1
 17. Obsidian 11.0 131072nodes             98K      808446     18.9      0.1     92.1     11.2
 18. Seer 2.8.0 65536 nodes                47K      798727     15.3      0.1     86.1      5.1
 19. Berserk 13 65536 nodes                49K      931424     20.1      0.1     68.9      3.6
 20. Alexandria-6.1.0 131072 nodes         99K     1091423     19.7      0.1     76.5      7.0
 21. Rubi20240112 65536nodes               62K     1030991     16.8      0.1     78.8      4.7
 22. Obsidian 11.0 65536nodes              47K      801644     16.6      0.1     89.7      5.3
 23. Koivisto 9.0 131072 nodes            130K     1656756     18.7      0.1     80.8      6.4
 24. Viridithas 12.0.0 131072 nodes       109K     1060312     17.9      0.1     89.3      9.2
 25. Velvet v7.3.0 131072 nodes           130K     1440097     16.5      0.1     88.7      8.0
 26. Altair 7.0.0 262144 nodes            205K     1015045     20.2      0.2     86.3     17.4
 27. Igel 3.5.0 65536 nodes                46K      460177     16.4      0.1     93.9      9.4
 28. PlentyChess 1.0.0 65536 nodes         47K      808811     18.1      0.1     82.4      4.8
 29. Black Marlin 9.0 131072 nodes        100K      910805     17.6      0.1     87.4      9.6
 30. Caissa 1.18 65536 nodes               52K     1331071     18.7      0.0     78.4      3.1
 31. Berserk 13 32768 nodes                24K      861089     17.7      0.0     83.5      2.3
 32. Altair 7.0.0 131072 nodes             99K      930200     17.5      0.1     76.6      8.2
 33. Clover 6.1 65536 nodes                47K     1233460     14.9      0.0     82.1      3.1
 34. Stash v35.0 2097144 nodes           1997K     2270323     29.3      0.9     84.1     74.0
 35. Viridithas 12.0.0 65536 nodes         57K     1063329     16.4      0.1     87.0      4.7
 36. Alexandria-6.1.0 65536 nodes          48K      987043     17.4      0.0     73.4      3.5
 37. Koivisto 9.0 65536 nodes              65K     1629074     17.0      0.0     72.8      2.9
 38. Stash v35.0 1048576 nodes            993K     2268996     27.0      0.4     80.8     35.3
 39. Black Marlin 9.0 65536 nodes          48K      844117     13.8      0.1     82.2      4.7
     all ---                              173K     1347809     19.0      0.1     82.7     10.9
Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

I will make leagues based on rating(the number of players were too small so I added 3 participants(stockfish11 and Fridolin3)

league1: rating 1000-1300

Code: Select all

Result:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                       games    wins   draws  losses   score    elo    +    -
  1. Movei00_8_438 1024 nodes      16      11       3       2    12.5    166  148  127
  2. Stash v35.0 1024 nodes        16       9       2       5    10.0     76  136  128
  3. Stockfish 11 512 nodes        16       9       1       6     9.5     61  141  135
  4. Blunder 8.5.5 1024  nodes     16       8       2       6     9.0     44  132  127
  5. Fridolin 3.10 1024 nodes      16       9       0       7     9.0     39  136  131
  6. Blunder 8.5.5 512 nodes       16       8       1       7     8.5     19  136  133
  7. Stash v35.0 512 nodes         16       4       2      10     5.0   -111  126  140
  8. Movei00_8_438 512 nodes       16       3       3      10     4.5   -128  128  143
  9. Fridolin 3.10 512 nodes       16       4       0      12     4.0   -165  134  160

Cross table:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                          score   games         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9
  1. Movei00_8_438 1024 nodes       12.5      16         x        =1        10        =1        11        10        11        =1        11
  2. Stash v35.0 1024 nodes         10.0      16        =0         x        01        10        01        11        =1        10        11
  3. Stockfish 11 512 nodes          9.5      16        01        10         x        11        11        01        01        0=        01
  4. Blunder 8.5.5 1024  nodes       9.0      16        =0        01        00         x        10        =0        11        11        11
  5. Fridolin 3.10 1024 nodes        9.0      16        00        10        00        01         x        10        11        11        11
  6. Blunder 8.5.5 512 nodes         8.5      16        01        00        10        =1        01         x        11        01        01
  7. Stash v35.0 512 nodes           5.0      16        00        =0        10        00        00        00         x        =1        11
  8. Movei00_8_438 512 nodes         4.5      16        =0        01        1=        00        00        10        =0         x        00
  9. Fridolin 3.10 512 nodes         4.0      16        00        00        10        00        00        10        00        11         x

Tech:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tech (average nodes, depths, time/m per move, others per game), counted for computing moves only, ignored moves with zero nodes:
  #  name                         nodes/m         NPS  depth/m   time/m    moves     time
  1. Movei00_8_438 1024 nodes          1K       86057      2.7      0.0     49.5      0.5
  2. Stash v35.0 1024 nodes            1K      103554      7.5      0.0     55.5      0.6
  3. Stockfish 11 512 nodes            1K       51359      6.3      0.0     55.8      0.6
  4. Blunder 8.5.5 1024  nodes         1K       56256      3.3      0.0     44.2      0.4
  5. Fridolin 3.10 1024 nodes          1K       99557      2.8      0.0     57.0      0.6
  6. Blunder 8.5.5 512 nodes           0K       27732      2.6      0.0     59.4      0.6
  7. Stash v35.0 512 nodes             1K       52167      7.5      0.0     39.2      0.4
  8. Movei00_8_438 512 nodes           0K       49077      2.3      0.0     56.6      0.6
  9. Fridolin 3.10 512 nodes           1K       50349      2.8      0.0     52.6      0.5
     all ---                           0K       64190      4.1      0.0     52.2      0.5
Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

league 2: rating 1300-1600

Code: Select all

 155 Obsidian 11.0 1024nodes           :  1599.2    57.5     142    40
 156 Alexandria-6.1.0 512 nodes        :  1595.6    57.0     142    40
 157 Blunder 8.5.5 8192  nodes         :  1588.2    56.0     142    39
 158 SmarThink 1.98 512 nodes          :  1584.5    55.5     142    39
 159 Rubi20240112 1024nodes            :  1562.0    52.5     142    37
 160 Stash v35.0 4096 nodes            :  1546.7    50.5     142    36
 161 Blunder 8.5.5 4096  nodes         :  1539.0    49.5     142    35
 162 Rubi20240112 512nodes             :  1519.4    47.0     142    33
 163 Berserk 13 512 nodes              :  1519.4    47.0     142    33
 164 Caissa 1.18 512 nodes             :  1519.4    47.0     142    33
 165 Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes             :  1499.3    44.5     142    31
 166 Clover 6.1 1024 nodes             :  1474.5    41.5     142    29
 167 Seer 2.8.0 512 nodes              :  1466.0    40.5     142    29
 168 Movei00_8_438 4096 nodes          :  1466.0    40.5     142    29
 169 Koivisto 9.0 512 nodes            :  1457.4    39.5     142    28
 170 Blunder 8.5.5 2048  nodes         :  1448.7    38.5     142    27
 171 Stash v35.0 2048 nodes            :  1439.8    37.5     142    26
 172 Black Marlin 9.0 1024 nodes       :  1412.5    34.5     142    24
 173 Igel 3.5.0 512 nodes              :  1398.3    33.0     142    23
 174 Obsidian 11.0 512 nodes           :  1373.8    30.5     142    21
 175 Black Marlin 9.0 512 nodes        :  1358.5    29.0     142    20
 176 Movei00_8_438 2048 nodes          :  1342.7    27.5     142    19

[code]
Result:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                         games    wins   draws  losses   score    elo    +    -
  1. Blunder 8.5.5 8192  nodes       42      29       4       9    31.0    179  104   93
  2. SmarThink 1.98 512 nodes        42      28       6       8    31.0    178  101   92
  3. Obsidian 11.0 1024nodes         42      27       0      15    27.0    114  102   95
  4. Stash v35.0 4096 nodes          42      24       6      12    27.0    105   94   89
  5. Alexandria-6.1.0 512 nodes      42      25       3      14    26.5     99   97   92
  6. Berserk 13 512 nodes            42      22       5      15    24.5     63   92   89
  7. Blunder 8.5.5 4096  nodes       42      23       3      16    24.5     60   94   90
  8. Rubi20240112 1024nodes          42      19       8      15    23.0     26   90   88
  9. Caissa 1.18 512 nodes           42      22       1      19    22.5     23   95   93
 10. Rubi20240112 512nodes           42      19       4      19    21.0      1   91   91
 11. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes           42      19       4      19    21.0     -3   91   91
 12. Seer 2.8.0 512 nodes            42      17       6      19    20.0    -20   90   90
 13. Movei00_8_438 4096 nodes        42      17       4      21    19.0    -33   89   91
 14. Koivisto 9.0 512 nodes          42      17       4      21    19.0    -40   90   92
 15. Stash v35.0 2048 nodes          42      16       5      21    18.5    -44   89   91
 16. Clover 6.1 1024 nodes           42      15       6      21    18.0    -48   90   92
 17. Blunder 8.5.5 2048  nodes       42      15       5      22    17.5    -59   90   93
 18. Igel 3.5.0 512 nodes            42      13       6      23    16.0    -88   89   93
 19. Obsidian 11.0 512 nodes         42      12       6      24    15.0   -102   89   94
 20. Movei00_8_438 2048 nodes        42      11       5      26    13.5   -134   89   96
 21. Black Marlin 9.0 1024 nodes     42      10       6      26    13.0   -138   90   97
 22. Black Marlin 9.0 512 nodes      42      12       3      27    13.5   -140   93  100

Cross table:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                            score   games         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10        11        12        13        14        15        16        17        18        19        20        21        22
  1. Blunder 8.5.5 8192  nodes        31.0      42         x        0=        01        1=        10        11        11        10        00        01        11        01        10        11        11        =1        11        11        11        11        1=        11
  2. SmarThink 1.98 512 nodes         31.0      42        1=         x        00        =1        11        1=        11        01        01        11        11        01        11        01        11        =0        11        ==        11        11        01        11
  3. Obsidian 11.0 1024nodes          27.0      42        10        11         x        01        10        11        00        10        11        01        00        10        11        10        11        01        10        11        01        11        11        01
  4. Stash v35.0 4096 nodes           27.0      42        0=        =0        10         x        00        11        11        =0        11        01        0=        10        11        11        11        01        =1        10        1=        11        11        01
  5. Alexandria-6.1.0 512 nodes       26.5      42        01        00        01        11         x        =0        11        01        01        =1        11        01        11        11        00        10        11        01        =1        11        10        01
  6. Berserk 13 512 nodes             24.5      42        00        0=        00        00        =1         x        11        1=        01        11        11        =1        11        11        10        =1        00        00        01        11        11        01
  7. Blunder 8.5.5 4096  nodes        24.5      42        00        00        11        00        00        00         x        11        11        1=        01        10        =1        1=        10        11        11        11        00        11        11        10
  8. Rubi20240112 1024nodes           23.0      42        01        10        01        =1        10        0=        00         x        11        01        10        1=        =1        01        =0        01        0=        01        1=        11        0=        11
  9. Caissa 1.18 512 nodes            22.5      42        11        10        00        00        10        10        00        00         x        00        10        10        01        11        11        =1        10        11        11        01        10        11
 10. Rubi20240112 512nodes            21.0      42        10        00        10        10        =0        00        0=        10        11         x        11        =0        1=        00        10        11        00        11        11        10        10        01
 11. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes            21.0      42        00        00        11        1=        00        00        10        01        01        00         x        =0        01        01        11        01        11        01        1=        10        11        1=
 12. Seer 2.8.0 512 nodes             20.0      42        10        10        01        01        10        =0        01        0=        01        =1        =1         x        00        00        0=        00        11        11        10        11        0=        01
 13. Movei00_8_438 4096 nodes         19.0      42        01        00        00        00        00        00        =0        =0        10        0=        10        11         x        00        01        11        1=        10        01        11        11        11
 14. Koivisto 9.0 512 nodes           19.0      42        00        10        01        00        00        00        0=        10        00        11        10        11        11         x        00        01        10        10        =1        1=        1=        10
 15. Stash v35.0 2048 nodes           18.5      42        00        00        00        00        11        01        01        =1        00        01        00        1=        10        11         x        =0        0=        11        00        1=        11        10
 16. Clover 6.1 1024 nodes            18.0      42        =0        =1        10        10        01        =0        00        10        =0        00        10        11        00        10        =1         x        10        =0        01        00        10        11
 17. Blunder 8.5.5 2048  nodes        17.5      42        00        00        01        =0        00        11        00        1=        01        11        00        00        0=        01        1=        01         x        01        11        0=        11        00
 18. Igel 3.5.0 512 nodes             16.0      42        00        ==        00        01        10        11        00        10        00        00        10        00        01        01        00        =1        10         x        10        =0        =1        =1
 19. Obsidian 11.0 512 nodes          15.0      42        00        00        10        0=        =0        10        11        0=        00        00        0=        01        10        =0        11        10        00        01         x        =1        00        01
 20. Movei00_8_438 2048 nodes         13.5      42        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        10        01        01        00        00        0=        0=        11        1=        =1        =0         x        11        11
 21. Black Marlin 9.0 1024 nodes      13.0      42        0=        10        00        00        01        00        00        1=        01        01        00        1=        00        0=        00        01        00        =0        11        00         x        1=
 22. Black Marlin 9.0 512 nodes       13.5      42        00        00        10        10        10        10        01        00        00        10        0=        10        00        01        01        00        11        =0        10        00        0=         x

Tech:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tech (average nodes, depths, time/m per move, others per game), counted for computing moves only, ignored moves with zero nodes:
  #  name                           nodes/m         NPS  depth/m   time/m    moves     time
  1. Blunder 8.5.5 8192  nodes           5K      274689      5.9      0.0     58.9      1.1
  2. SmarThink 1.98 512 nodes            1K      134260      5.5      0.0     54.7      0.5
  3. Obsidian 11.0 1024nodes             1K       67096      8.0      0.0     63.7      0.6
  4. Stash v35.0 4096 nodes              4K      389646     10.9      0.0     61.5      0.6
  5. Alexandria-6.1.0 512 nodes          0K       21190      4.5      0.0     63.4      1.1
  6. Berserk 13 512 nodes                0K       24590      5.9      0.0     71.9      0.9
  7. Blunder 8.5.5 4096  nodes           2K      159642      5.1      0.0     57.9      0.9
  8. Rubi20240112 1024nodes              1K       55699      7.4      0.0     58.4      1.0
  9. Caissa 1.18 512 nodes               0K       41016      4.7      0.0     52.0      0.5
 10. Rubi20240112 512nodes               1K       29944      6.1      0.0     58.6      1.0
 11. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes               1K       66029      6.5      0.0     62.5      0.7
 12. Seer 2.8.0 512 nodes                0K       28803      5.0      0.0     61.0      0.9
 13. Movei00_8_438 4096 nodes            3K      313429      4.5      0.0     62.2      0.6
 14. Koivisto 9.0 512 nodes              1K       34380      5.5      0.0     64.8      1.0
 15. Stash v35.0 2048 nodes              2K      202879      9.8      0.0     60.7      0.6
 16. Clover 6.1 1024 nodes               1K       64414      5.0      0.0     59.2      0.6
 17. Blunder 8.5.5 2048  nodes           1K       82877      4.1      0.0     57.1      0.8
 18. Igel 3.5.0 512 nodes                0K       33144      5.3      0.0     61.9      0.6
 19. Obsidian 11.0 512 nodes             0K       33004      5.5      0.0     59.8      0.6
 20. Movei00_8_438 2048 nodes            2K      161560      3.5      0.0     54.8      0.6
 21. Black Marlin 9.0 1024 nodes         1K       62633      5.2      0.0     63.3      0.6
 22. Black Marlin 9.0 512 nodes          1K       61312      5.2      0.0     58.1      0.6
     all ---                             1K      102140      5.9      0.0     60.3      0.8
Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

league 2 against league 1:

Code: Select all

Result:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                         games    wins   draws  losses   score    elo    +    -
  1. Stash v35.0 4096 nodes          18      17       1       0    17.5    225  292  173
  2. Rubi20240112 512nodes           18      17       0       1    17.0    217  292  174
  3. SmarThink 1.98 512 nodes        18      17       0       1    17.0    216  292  174
  4. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes           18      16       2       0    17.0    164  233  157
  5. Movei00_8_438 4096 nodes        18      16       2       0    17.0    161  233  157
  6. Blunder 8.5.5 2048  nodes       18      16       1       1    16.5    160  234  158
  7. Alexandria-6.1.0 512 nodes      18      16       1       1    16.5    153  234  158
  8. Blunder 8.5.5 4096  nodes       18      16       1       1    16.5    151  233  157
  9. Caissa 1.18 512 nodes           18      16       1       1    16.5    150  234  158
 10. Koivisto 9.0 512 nodes          18      15       1       2    15.5     94  202  150
 11. Obsidian 11.0 1024nodes         18      15       1       2    15.5     93  201  149
 12. Blunder 8.5.5 8192  nodes       18      15       1       2    15.5     87  201  148
 13. Stash v35.0 2048 nodes          18      15       0       3    15.0     77  202  150
 14. Rubi20240112 1024nodes          18      14       2       2    15.0     56  181  143
 15. Black Marlin 9.0 1024 nodes     18      14       2       2    15.0     48  180  142
 16. Seer 2.8.0 512 nodes            18      14       1       3    14.5     43  182  145
 17. Obsidian 11.0 512 nodes         18      14       0       4    14.0     24  181  144
 18. Berserk 13 512 nodes            18      13       0       5    13.0    -23  169  143
 19. Clover 6.1 1024 nodes           18      12       3       3    13.5    -31  154  132
 20. Igel 3.5.0 512 nodes            18      11       4       3    13.0    -54  145  128
 21. Movei00_8_438 2048 nodes        18      12       1       5    12.5    -57  156  136
 22. Stockfish 11 512 nodes          44      13       1      30    13.5    -66   90   98
 23. Stash v35.0 1024 nodes          44       7       5      32     9.5   -136   91  103
 24. Black Marlin 9.0 512 nodes      18      10       0       8    10.0   -158  145  139
 25. Blunder 8.5.5 512 nodes         44       7       3      34     8.5   -161   94  108
 26. Blunder 8.5.5 1024  nodes       44       6       2      36     7.0   -193   98  116
 27. Fridolin 3.10 1024 nodes        44       5       3      36     6.5   -203   99  118
 28. Movei00_8_438 1024 nodes        44       5       2      37     6.0   -221  102  123
 29. Movei00_8_438 512 nodes         44       3       4      37     5.0   -233  100  122
 30. Stash v35.0 512 nodes           44       1       4      39     3.0   -285  107  136
 31. Fridolin 3.10 512 nodes         44       3       1      40     3.5   -300  112  145

Cross table:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                            score   games         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10        11        12        13        14        15        16        17        18        19        20        21        22        23        24        25        26        27        28        29        30        31
  1. Stash v35.0 4096 nodes           17.5      18         x                                                                                                                                                                                                                11        11                  11        11        11        1=        11        11        11
  2. Rubi20240112 512nodes            17.0      18                   x                                                                                                                                                                                                      11        11                  01        11        11        11        11        11        11
  3. SmarThink 1.98 512 nodes         17.0      18                             x                                                                                                                                                                                            11        01                  11        11        11        11        11        11        11
  4. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes            17.0      18                                       x                                                                                                                                                                                  11        1=                  11        11        1=        11        11        11        11
  5. Movei00_8_438 4096 nodes         17.0      18                                                 x                                                                                                                                                                        11        11                  11        1=        11        11        11        =1        11
  6. Blunder 8.5.5 2048  nodes        16.5      18                                                           x                                                                                                                                                              =1        11                  11        11        11        11        11        11        10
  7. Alexandria-6.1.0 512 nodes       16.5      18                                                                     x                                                                                                                                                    11        11                  11        11        =1        10        11        11        11
  8. Blunder 8.5.5 4096  nodes        16.5      18                                                                               x                                                                                                                                          10        11                  =1        11        11        11        11        11        11
  9. Caissa 1.18 512 nodes            16.5      18                                                                                         x                                                                                                                                11        10                  11        11        11        11        =1        11        11
 10. Koivisto 9.0 512 nodes           15.5      18                                                                                                   x                                                                                                                      11        =1                  11        01        01        11        11        11        11
 11. Obsidian 11.0 1024nodes          15.5      18                                                                                                             x                                                                                                            11        =0                  01        11        11        11        11        11        11
 12. Blunder 8.5.5 8192  nodes        15.5      18                                                                                                                       x                                                                                                  10        11                  01        11        11        11        11        1=        11
 13. Stash v35.0 2048 nodes           15.0      18                                                                                                                                 x                                                                                        10        01                  11        01        11        11        11        11        11
 14. Rubi20240112 1024nodes           15.0      18                                                                                                                                           x                                                                              11        11                  1=        11        11        01        11        11        0=
 15. Black Marlin 9.0 1024 nodes      15.0      18                                                                                                                                                     x                                                                    01        11                  11        1=        01        11        11        =1        11
 16. Seer 2.8.0 512 nodes             14.5      18                                                                                                                                                               x                                                          11        11                  11        11        01        1=        01        11        01
 17. Obsidian 11.0 512 nodes          14.0      18                                                                                                                                                                         x                                                01        10                  11        11        11        11        10        10        11
 18. Berserk 13 512 nodes             13.0      18                                                                                                                                                                                   x                                      01        11                  11        01        10        00        11        11        11
 19. Clover 6.1 1024 nodes            13.5      18                                                                                                                                                                                             x                            10        01                  11        11        1=        10        ==        11        11
 20. Igel 3.5.0 512 nodes             13.0      18                                                                                                                                                                                                       x                  00        ==                  10        11        11        11        1=        =1        11
 21. Movei00_8_438 2048 nodes         12.5      18                                                                                                                                                                                                                 x        00        11                  =0        01        01        11        11        11        11
 22. Stockfish 11 512 nodes           13.5      44        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        01        00        00        00        01        01        00        10        00        10        10        01        11        11         x                  11                                                                      
 23. Stash v35.0 1024 nodes            9.5      44        00        00        10        0=        00        00        00        00        01        =0        =1        00        10        00        00        00        01        00        10        ==        00                   x        01                                                                      
 24. Black Marlin 9.0 512 nodes       10.0      18                                                                                                                                                                                                                          00        10         x        00        00        11        11        10        11        11
 25. Blunder 8.5.5 512 nodes           8.5      44        00        10        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        10        10        00        0=        00        00        00        00        00        01        =1                            11         x                                                            
 26. Blunder 8.5.5 1024  nodes         7.0      44        00        00        00        00        0=        00        00        00        00        10        00        00        10        00        0=        00        00        10        00        00        10                            11                   x                                                  
 27. Fridolin 3.10 1024 nodes          6.5      44        00        00        00        0=        00        00        =0        00        00        10        00        00        00        00        10        10        00        01        0=        00        10                            00                             x                                        
 28. Movei00_8_438 1024 nodes          6.0      44        0=        00        00        00        00        00        01        00        00        00        00        00        00        10        00        0=        00        11        01        00        00                            00                                       x                              
 29. Movei00_8_438 512 nodes           5.0      44        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        00        00        00        10        01        00        ==        0=        00                            01                                                 x                    
 30. Stash v35.0 512 nodes             3.0      44        00        00        00        00        =0        00        00        00        00        00        00        0=        00        00        =0        00        01        00        00        =0        00                            00                                                           x          
 31. Fridolin 3.10 512 nodes           3.5      44        00        00        00        00        00        01        00        00        00        00        00        00        00        1=        00        10        00        00        00        00        00                            00                                                                     x

Tech:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tech (average nodes, depths, time/m per move, others per game), counted for computing moves only, ignored moves with zero nodes:
  #  name                           nodes/m         NPS  depth/m   time/m    moves     time
  1. Stash v35.0 4096 nodes              4K      407851     11.1      0.0     43.3      0.4
  2. Rubi20240112 512nodes               1K       31647      6.1      0.0     50.8      0.8
  3. SmarThink 1.98 512 nodes            1K      136415      5.3      0.0     45.6      0.5
  4. Igel 3.5.0 1024 nodes               1K       67703      6.5      0.0     75.3      0.8
  5. Movei00_8_438 4096 nodes            3K      322413      4.2      0.0     52.9      0.5
  6. Blunder 8.5.5 2048  nodes           1K       87782      4.2      0.0     62.4      0.8
  7. Alexandria-6.1.0 512 nodes          0K       18438      4.2      0.0     56.5      1.1
  8. Blunder 8.5.5 4096  nodes           2K      160387      4.4      0.0     35.0      0.5
  9. Caissa 1.18 512 nodes               0K       41003      4.8      0.0     53.3      0.5
 10. Koivisto 9.0 512 nodes              1K       41821      7.0      0.0     67.6      0.9
 11. Obsidian 11.0 1024nodes             1K       67793      9.1      0.0     58.4      0.6
 12. Blunder 8.5.5 8192  nodes           5K      322714      5.9      0.0     42.9      0.6
 13. Stash v35.0 2048 nodes              2K      206269      9.0      0.0     58.6      0.6
 14. Rubi20240112 1024nodes              1K       55604      7.5      0.0     44.4      0.8
 15. Black Marlin 9.0 1024 nodes         1K       62996      5.4      0.0     54.7      0.5
 16. Seer 2.8.0 512 nodes                0K       36607      5.0      0.0     54.3      0.7
 17. Obsidian 11.0 512 nodes             0K       32036      7.3      0.0     58.8      0.6
 18. Berserk 13 512 nodes                0K       25158      5.7      0.0     59.3      0.7
 19. Clover 6.1 1024 nodes               1K       68533      5.0      0.0     43.9      0.4
 20. Igel 3.5.0 512 nodes                0K       33634      5.2      0.0     82.2      0.8
 21. Movei00_8_438 2048 nodes            2K      161356      3.4      0.0     51.4      0.5
 22. Stockfish 11 512 nodes              1K       51136      7.4      0.0     58.1      0.6
 23. Stash v35.0 1024 nodes              1K      103029      8.5      0.0     57.5      0.6
 24. Black Marlin 9.0 512 nodes          1K       60968      5.3      0.0     67.1      0.7
 25. Blunder 8.5.5 512 nodes             0K       21312      2.3      0.0     44.6      0.6
 26. Blunder 8.5.5 1024  nodes           1K       42554      3.0      0.0     55.5      0.8
 27. Fridolin 3.10 1024 nodes            1K       70496      4.1      0.0     58.9      0.8
 28. Movei00_8_438 1024 nodes            1K       81888      3.2      0.0     60.2      0.6
 29. Movei00_8_438 512 nodes             1K       50291      2.3      0.0     64.8      0.6
 30. Stash v35.0 512 nodes               1K       52144      6.5      0.0     51.0      0.5
 31. Fridolin 3.10 512 nodes             1K       33349      2.3      0.0     45.5      0.7
     all ---                             0K       77143      5.2      0.0     55.3      0.7
Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

25 participants of league 3 that I will play later(1600-1900):

Alexandria 1024
Altair 2048,1024,512
Berserk 2048,1024
Blunder 16384
BlackMarlin 2048
Caissa 1024
Clover 2048
Igel 2048
Koivisto 2048,1024
Movei 16384,8192
Obsidian 2048
PlentyChess 1024
Rubi 2048
Viridithas 1024,512
Seer 1024
Stash 8192
smarthink 2048,1024
Stockfish 512
Uri Blass
Posts: 10418
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: started my fixed nodes leagues

Post by Uri Blass »

results of league 3 1600-1900.

Note that I practically played most of these games in the past but I decdied to have league of different engines with no promotions and also connection matches between different leagues that are close by everbody play everybody.

It may be interesting if more games between weak and strong are going to change rating difference and I will see later.
First I make only league games and match between 2 leagues that include only 600 elo rating points.

Code: Select all

Result:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                          games    wins   draws  losses   score    elo    +    -
  1. PlentyChess 1.0.0 1024 nodes     48      31       6      11    34.0    156   93   86
  2. Viridithas 12.0.0 1024 nodes     48      26      10      12    31.0     97   87   82
  3. Obsidian 11.0 2048nodes          48      28       4      16    30.0     94   90   85
  4. Berserk 13 2048 nodes            48      28       3      17    29.5     92   90   86
  5. Movei00_8_438 16384 nodes        48      25       9      14    29.5     82   86   82
  6. Altair 7.0.0 2048 nodes          48      27       4      17    29.0     78   90   86
  7. Koivisto 9.0 2048 nodes          48      25       7      16    28.5     65   86   83
  8. Altair 7.0.0 1024 nodes          48      26       4      18    28.0     64   89   86
  9. Blunder 8.5.5 16384  nodes       48      23       8      17    27.0     40   85   83
 10. Stash v35.0 8192 nodes           48      25       2      21    26.0     34   89   87
 11. Igel 3.5.0 2048 nodes            48      23       6      19    26.0     30   85   84
 12. SmarThink 1.98 2048 nodes        48      24       4      20    26.0     25   87   86
 13. Black Marlin 9.0 2048 nodes      48      21       8      19    25.0     16   84   84
 14. Viridithas 12.0.0 512 nodes      48      21       5      22    23.5    -10   85   86
 15. Alexandria-6.1.0 1024 nodes      48      16      13      19    22.5    -20   79   80
 16. Rubi20240112 2048nodes           48      21       3      24    22.5    -27   87   88
 17. Movei00_8_438 8192 nodes         48      18       6      24    21.0    -42   84   86
 18. SmarThink 1.98 1024 nodes        48      18       6      24    21.0    -46   84   86
 19. Caissa 1.18 1024 nodes           48      19       4      25    21.0    -47   86   88
 20. Berserk 13 1024 nodes            48      16       7      25    19.5    -66   83   86
 21. Stockfish 16.1 512 nodes         48      13      11      24    18.5    -78   82   85
 22. Altair 7.0.0 512 nodes           48      15       6      27    18.0    -90   84   88
 23. Clover 6.1 2048 nodes            48      15       5      28    17.5   -102   85   90
 24. Seer 2.8.0 1024 nodes            48      11       8      29    15.0   -134   84   90
 25. Koivisto 9.0 1024 nodes          48       7       7      34    10.5   -211   87   99

Cross table:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  #  name                             score   games         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10        11        12        13        14        15        16        17        18        19        20        21        22        23        24        25
  1. PlentyChess 1.0.0 1024 nodes      34.0      48         x        00        11        =1        ==        10        10        11        11        =0        11        01        01        11        =1        11        11        10        01        11        10        11        10        1=        11
  2. Viridithas 12.0.0 1024 nodes      31.0      48        11         x        10        11        00        =1        1=        01        00        10        11        11        11        =1        ==        10        11        00        10        ==        ==        11        10        1=        11
  3. Obsidian 11.0 2048nodes           30.0      48        00        01         x        01        01        01        0=        0=        11        11        10        10        1=        10        1=        11        01        01        01        11        10        11        11        01        11
  4. Berserk 13 2048 nodes             29.5      48        =0        00        10         x        =1        10        11        01        00        10        10        01        01        11        11        =0        10        11        10        11        11        11        10        11        10
  5. Movei00_8_438 16384 nodes         29.5      48        ==        11        10        =0         x        11        10        01        0=        01        11        01        10        10        =1        01        1=        =0        01        01        =1        =1        01        11        11
  6. Altair 7.0.0 2048 nodes           29.0      48        01        =0        10        01        00         x        10        10        =0        11        10        11        =1        11        11        11        00        00        11        01        10        11        01        =1        11
  7. Koivisto 9.0 2048 nodes           28.5      48        01        0=        1=        00        01        01         x        00        01        01        =1        11        0=        01        11        01        =0        11        01        10        =1        1=        11        11        11
  8. Altair 7.0.0 1024 nodes           28.0      48        00        10        1=        10        10        01        11         x        11        01        0=        11        10        00        11        11        00        01        10        0=        10        11        11        =1        01
  9. Blunder 8.5.5 16384  nodes        27.0      48        00        11        00        11        1=        =1        10        00         x        0=        01        01        11        =0        10        00        1=        11        =1        11        =1        00        01        =1        11
 10. Stash v35.0 8192 nodes            26.0      48        =1        01        00        01        10        00        10        10        1=         x        00        11        00        00        10        00        11        11        10        11        01        10        11        11        11
 11. Igel 3.5.0 2048 nodes             26.0      48        00        00        01        01        00        01        =0        1=        10        11         x        00        =0        11        10        11        =1        11        1=        10        01        00        =1        11        11
 12. SmarThink 1.98 2048 nodes         26.0      48        10        00        01        10        10        00        00        00        10        00        11         x        01        11        ==        01        11        11        01        10        11        11        =1        01        =1
 13. Black Marlin 9.0 2048 nodes       25.0      48        10        00        0=        10        01        =0        1=        01        00        11        =1        10         x        01        00        01        11        ==        11        01        =1        =0        11        10        01
 14. Viridithas 12.0.0 512 nodes       23.5      48        00        =0        01        00        01        00        10        11        =1        11        00        00        10         x        =0        11        11        11        10        0=        01        10        01        10        1=
 15. Alexandria-6.1.0 1024 nodes       22.5      48        =0        ==        0=        00        =0        00        00        00        01        01        01        ==        11        =1         x        01        11        01        0=        11        1=        1=        0=        10        1=
 16. Rubi20240112 2048nodes            22.5      48        00        01        00        =1        10        00        10        00        11        11        00        10        10        00        10         x        00        =1        01        11        10        01        10        11        =1
 17. Movei00_8_438 8192 nodes          21.0      48        00        00        10        01        0=        11        =1        11        0=        00        =0        00        00        00        00        11         x        11        10        0=        =1        10        11        10        01
 18. SmarThink 1.98 1024 nodes         21.0      48        01        11        10        00        =1        11        00        10        00        00        00        00        ==        00        10        =0        00         x        11        1=        10        1=        10        01        11
 19. Caissa 1.18 1024 nodes            21.0      48        10        01        10        01        10        00        10        01        =0        01        0=        10        00        01        1=        10        01        00         x        11        00        10        1=        10        01
 20. Berserk 13 1024 nodes             19.5      48        00        ==        00        00        10        10        01        1=        00        00        01        01        10        1=        00        00        1=        0=        00         x        10        11        01        11        1=
 21. Stockfish 16.1 512 nodes          18.5      48        01        ==        01        00        =0        01        =0        01        =0        10        10        00        =0        10        0=        01        =0        01        11        01         x        00        =0        0=        1=
 22. Altair 7.0.0 512 nodes            18.0      48        00        00        00        00        =0        00        0=        00        11        01        11        00        =1        01        0=        10        01        0=        01        00        11         x        10        =1        10
 23. Clover 6.1 2048 nodes             17.5      48        01        01        00        01        10        10        00        00        10        00        =0        =0        00        10        1=        01        00        01        0=        10        =1        01         x        10        01
 24. Seer 2.8.0 1024 nodes             15.0      48        0=        0=        10        00        00        =0        00        =0        =0        00        00        10        01        01        01        00        01        10        01        00        1=        =0        01         x        =1
 25. Koivisto 9.0 1024 nodes           10.5      48        00        00        00        01        00        00        00        10        00        00        00        =0        10        0=        0=        =0        10        00        10        0=        0=        01        10        =0         x

Tech:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tech (average nodes, depths, time/m per move, others per game), counted for computing moves only, ignored moves with zero nodes:
  #  name                            nodes/m         NPS  depth/m   time/m    moves     time
  1. PlentyChess 1.0.0 1024 nodes         1K       74647      6.3      0.0     69.3      0.7
  2. Viridithas 12.0.0 1024 nodes         1K       54560      6.2      0.0     62.7      1.2
  3. Obsidian 11.0 2048nodes              1K      130852      9.6      0.0     56.8      0.6
  4. Berserk 13 2048 nodes                1K       92287      9.3      0.0     67.5      1.0
  5. Movei00_8_438 16384 nodes           13K      874292      6.2      0.0     73.2      1.1
  6. Altair 7.0.0 2048 nodes              1K       71579      6.6      0.0     63.9      1.2
  7. Koivisto 9.0 2048 nodes              2K      113510      9.1      0.0     64.5      1.2
  8. Altair 7.0.0 1024 nodes              1K       58818      6.1      0.0     63.0      1.3
  9. Blunder 8.5.5 16384  nodes          10K      387838      7.4      0.0     71.2      1.9
 10. Stash v35.0 8192 nodes               8K      761140     13.9      0.0     66.8      0.7
 11. Igel 3.5.0 2048 nodes                1K      129827      8.1      0.0     64.9      0.7
 12. SmarThink 1.98 2048 nodes            4K      360987      7.1      0.0     54.1      0.5
 13. Black Marlin 9.0 2048 nodes          1K      124987      6.4      0.0     68.2      0.7
 14. Viridithas 12.0.0 512 nodes          1K       42087      4.4      0.0     76.6      1.3
 15. Alexandria-6.1.0 1024 nodes          1K       56595      6.4      0.0     79.4      1.1
 16. Rubi20240112 2048nodes               2K       96408      8.9      0.0     65.3      1.3
 17. Movei00_8_438 8192 nodes             6K      633137      5.0      0.0     60.9      0.6
 18. SmarThink 1.98 1024 nodes            2K      199566      6.2      0.0     58.8      0.6
 19. Caissa 1.18 1024 nodes               1K       80372      6.8      0.0     62.2      0.6
 20. Berserk 13 1024 nodes                1K       48884      7.9      0.0     68.7      0.9
 21. Stockfish 16.1 512 nodes             1K       51124      8.4      0.0     84.3      0.8
 22. Altair 7.0.0 512 nodes               1K       40700      4.8      0.0     62.5      1.2
 23. Clover 6.1 2048 nodes                1K      119247      5.9      0.0     61.5      0.7
 24. Seer 2.8.0 1024 nodes                1K       44039      6.2      0.0     64.1      1.2
 25. Koivisto 9.0 1024 nodes              1K       60057      7.4      0.0     58.4      1.0
     all ---                              2K      177367      7.2      0.0     65.9      1.0