Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.
Moderator: Ras
abik
Posts: 823Joined: Fri Dec 01, 2006 10:46 pmLocation: Mountain View, CA, USAFull name: Aart Bik
Post by abik Wed Jun 05, 2013 4:15 am
Five seconds-per-move tournament in Group A played from both sides of all positions in the
Silversuite gambit opening suite . The Komodo DEV engine crashed in a few fixed positions, and the games had to be adjudicated, unfortunately.
Games available at the
tournament site .
This concludes my 2013 Android engines tournament.
Congratulations to Richard Vida for Critter's victory, his second Android tournament victory!
Code: Select all
1 2 3 4 5
1 Critter 1.6a * 27.5-22.5 38.0-12.0 38.0-12.0 48.0- 2.0 151.5/200
2 Stockfish 2.3.1 22.5-27.5 * 42.0-8.0 37.5-12.5 45.5- 4.5 147.5/200
3 Toga II 3.0 12.0-38.0 8.0-42.0 * 43.0- 7.0 39.0-11.0 102.0/200
4 Komodo DEV 12.0-38.0 12.5-37.5 7.0-43.0 * 31.0-19.0 62.5/200
5 MinkoChess arm 2.0-48.0 4.5-45.5 11.0-39.0 19.0-31.0 36.5/200
abik
Posts: 823Joined: Fri Dec 01, 2006 10:46 pmLocation: Mountain View, CA, USAFull name: Aart Bik
Post by abik Wed Jun 05, 2013 5:04 am
Estimated ELO ratings of the engines, based on all qualification and tournament games (computed by the Chessbase ELO tool).
Code: Select all
1 Critter 1.6a 32-bit 2891
2 Stockfish 2.3.1 2854
3 Toga II 3.0 2763
4 Gaviota v0.86 2689
5 Komodo DEV 2670
6 Toga II 1.4.1SE 2650
7 DiscoCheck 4.0.1 2635
8 Arasan 15.2 JA 2601
9 MinkoChess arm 2593
10 Texel 1.01 32-bit 2575
11 crafty-235-android-ja 2568
12 Arasan 15.1 2564
13 Rotor 0.7 2549
14 Arasan 14.0.1 2535
15 Rodent 0.18.0 2527
16 cheng3 1.07 JA 2524
17 Daydreamer 1.75 JA 2505
18 scorpio-27-ja 2487
19 Pepito v1.59 2479
20 GarboChess 3 2467
21 Rotor 0.8 2465
22 sloppy-023-ja 2445
23 betsabe-II-130--ja 2429
24 danasah-488-ja 2422
25 phalanx-xxii-ja 2421
26 tucano104-ab 2406
27 typhoon-android-ja 2404
28 GNU Chess 6.0.2 2383
29 RedQueen 1.1.2 2367
30 greko98-ab 2363
31 Sungorus 1.4 JA 2350
32 TJchess 1.01U 2349
33 Jazz 6.40 JA 2344
34 natwarlal-014-ja 2316
35 scidlet-261b2-ja 2316
36 myrddin-086-ja 2316
37 kmtchess-121-ja 2305
38 gk-090-ja 2232
39 sjeng-112-ja 2224
40 BikJump v2.1P 2209
41 ZCT-0.3.2500 2184
42 AdroitChess 0.3 2136
43 tscp181-ab 2103
44 Diablo 0.5.1 2103
45 exchess-054-beta-ja 2101
46 zzzzzz-351-ja 2093
47 fairymax48l-ab 2076
48 surprise-43-b13-ja 2054
49 myrddin0.85j 2041
50 umax48w 2019
51 VIRUTOR CHESS 1973
52 Chess for Android 1909
53 toledo-nanochess-2010-ja 1813
54 Simplex 0.9.8 1725
55 olithink-531-ja 1724
jd1
Posts: 269Joined: Wed Oct 24, 2012 2:07 am
Post by jd1 Wed Jun 05, 2013 5:27 am
abik wrote: Five seconds-per-move tournament in Group A played from both sides of all positions in the
Silversuite gambit opening suite . The Komodo DEV engine crashed in a few fixed positions, and the games had to be adjudicated, unfortunately.
Games available at the
tournament site .
This concludes my 2013 Android engines tournament.
Congratulations to Richard Vida for Critter's victory, his second Android tournament victory!
Code: Select all
1 2 3 4 5
1 Critter 1.6a * 27.5-22.5 38.0-12.0 38.0-12.0 48.0- 2.0 151.5/200
2 Stockfish 2.3.1 22.5-27.5 * 42.0-8.0 37.5-12.5 45.5- 4.5 147.5/200
3 Toga II 3.0 12.0-38.0 8.0-42.0 * 43.0- 7.0 39.0-11.0 102.0/200
4 Komodo DEV 12.0-38.0 12.5-37.5 7.0-43.0 * 31.0-19.0 62.5/200
5 MinkoChess arm 2.0-48.0 4.5-45.5 11.0-39.0 19.0-31.0 36.5/200
Thanks for running this, Aart, and congratulations to Richard! I wonder what was wrong with Komodo - even the old Komodo 3 beats Toga II 3.0 (very) easily on my Samsung Galaxy.
Jerry
michiguel
Posts: 6401Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 8:30 pmLocation: Chicago, Illinois, USA
Post by michiguel Wed Jun 05, 2013 5:49 am
abik wrote: Estimated ELO ratings of the engines, based on all qualification and tournament games (computed by the Chessbase ELO tool).
Code: Select all
1 Critter 1.6a 32-bit 2891
2 Stockfish 2.3.1 2854
3 Toga II 3.0 2763
4 Gaviota v0.86 2689
5 Komodo DEV 2670
6 Toga II 1.4.1SE 2650
7 DiscoCheck 4.0.1 2635
8 Arasan 15.2 JA 2601
9 MinkoChess arm 2593
10 Texel 1.01 32-bit 2575
11 crafty-235-android-ja 2568
12 Arasan 15.1 2564
13 Rotor 0.7 2549
14 Arasan 14.0.1 2535
15 Rodent 0.18.0 2527
16 cheng3 1.07 JA 2524
17 Daydreamer 1.75 JA 2505
18 scorpio-27-ja 2487
19 Pepito v1.59 2479
20 GarboChess 3 2467
21 Rotor 0.8 2465
22 sloppy-023-ja 2445
23 betsabe-II-130--ja 2429
24 danasah-488-ja 2422
25 phalanx-xxii-ja 2421
26 tucano104-ab 2406
27 typhoon-android-ja 2404
28 GNU Chess 6.0.2 2383
29 RedQueen 1.1.2 2367
30 greko98-ab 2363
31 Sungorus 1.4 JA 2350
32 TJchess 1.01U 2349
33 Jazz 6.40 JA 2344
34 natwarlal-014-ja 2316
35 scidlet-261b2-ja 2316
36 myrddin-086-ja 2316
37 kmtchess-121-ja 2305
38 gk-090-ja 2232
39 sjeng-112-ja 2224
40 BikJump v2.1P 2209
41 ZCT-0.3.2500 2184
42 AdroitChess 0.3 2136
43 tscp181-ab 2103
44 Diablo 0.5.1 2103
45 exchess-054-beta-ja 2101
46 zzzzzz-351-ja 2093
47 fairymax48l-ab 2076
48 surprise-43-b13-ja 2054
49 myrddin0.85j 2041
50 umax48w 2019
51 VIRUTOR CHESS 1973
52 Chess for Android 1909
53 toledo-nanochess-2010-ja 1813
54 Simplex 0.9.8 1725
55 olithink-531-ja 1724
Not bad at all for the bird...
Miguel
abik
Posts: 823Joined: Fri Dec 01, 2006 10:46 pmLocation: Mountain View, CA, USAFull name: Aart Bik
Post by abik Wed Jun 05, 2013 6:21 pm
jd1 wrote: Thanks for running this, Aart, and congratulations to Richard! I wonder what was wrong with Komodo - even the old Komodo 3 beats Toga II 3.0 (very) easily on my Samsung Galaxy.
One is glad to be of service!
The Komodo engine used was a private development version that Don very kindly allowed me to use. I feel bad that it crashed in a few positions, but there was really not much I could do about it. I am sure that the production version of Komodo will do much better, so don't draw too many conclusions from the development version's performance.
