Test Position (for a change!)

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderator: Ras

Marc MP

Test Position (for a change!)

Post by Marc MP »

[d]q1bQ1nk1/5rbp/6p1/np2p3/4P3/1P2BPN1/1K4P1/1NR4R b - - 0 1

According to Polugayevsky & Damsky in "The Art of Defense", black's best move is here: Nc4+!, so that black eventually gains a draw here (despite being a full rook down after this further sacrifice). Will your favorite engine find Nc4+? Is the game really drawn afterwards (I need a confirmation)?

What about your second favorite engine? ( :-) i.e. something different from Rybka 3.0!)
Top
Marc MP

Re: Test Position (for a change!)

Post by Marc MP »

Marc MP wrote:[d]q1bQ1nk1/5rbp/6p1/np2p3/4P3/1P2BPN1/1K4P1/1NR4R b - - 0 1

According to Polugayevsky & Damsky in "The Art of Defense", black's best move is here: Nc4+!, so that black eventually gains a draw here (despite being a full rook down after this further sacrifice). Will your favorite engine find Nc4+? Is the game really drawn afterwards (I need a confirmation)?

What about your second favorite engine? ( :-) i.e. something different from Rybka 3.0!)
The position is from Timman-Kasparov Bugojno 1984: http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1069988
Top
Dann Corbit
Posts: 12818
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:57 pm
Location: Redmond, WA USA

Re: Test Position (for a change!)

Post by Dann Corbit »

Marc MP wrote:
Marc MP wrote:[d]q1bQ1nk1/5rbp/6p1/np2p3/4P3/1P2BPN1/1K4P1/1NR4R b - - 0 1

According to Polugayevsky & Damsky in "The Art of Defense", black's best move is here: Nc4+!, so that black eventually gains a draw here (despite being a full rook down after this further sacrifice). Will your favorite engine find Nc4+? Is the game really drawn afterwards (I need a confirmation)?

What about your second favorite engine? ( :-) i.e. something different from Rybka 3.0!)
The position is from Timman-Kasparov Bugojno 1984: http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1069988
All programs seem to like Nc4+! but none of them see a clear draw (most evaluate black as down about one pawn or so). I guess it will take a really deep analysis to get good answers.

Rybka 3:
18 03:45 47.429.571 215.482 -0.80 Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 h7h5 Ke2f2 h5h4 Ng3e2 Qa1h1 Rc2c1 Qh1h2 Qb6d8 Kg8f7 Qd8d1 h4h3 Qd1g1 Qh2xg1+

Shredder:
19/50 03:00 557.982.779 3.095.175 -1.02 Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5 Rd7b7+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Ng3e2 Bc8e6 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Be3c1 g6g5 Qc5e3 h7h6

Zappa:
17/54 02:34 478.071.092 3.108.678 -0.92 Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Nf1h2 Bc8e6 Rc1c2 Qb3a4 Rh1b1 Be6b3 Rb1xb3 Qa4xb3 Qf2e2 h7h5 Be3c5 Qb3a4

Glaurung:
21 01:28 460.576.548 5.205.195 -1.56 Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b8+ Kb2a1 Qb8b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Nc3a2 Rd6a6 Qh4f2 c4c3 Nf1g3 Bc8e6 Rc1c2 Nf8d7 Rh1b1 Qb3a3 Be3c1 Qa3a4 Bc1e3

Hiarcs:
18/41 02:11 237.154.628 1.815.384 -0.90 Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d5 Qh4f2 Rd5a5+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6 Nf1g3 Nf8d7 Rc1c2 Ra5a3 Be3c1 Ra3a8 Rc2b2

Crafty (the sign here is from white's point of view -- chewing on a fail high for black though):
19 02:16 1.013.077.020 7.449.095 +2.18 1. ... Nc4+!!

Older Rybka (2.3.2.a):
21 03:29 67.029.986 327.590 -0.33 Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4e7

Scorpio was not happy with this position:
20 02:46 502.281.872 3.025.794 -2.92 Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Bc8-e6 Rh1-d1 Qd6-b4 Nc3-d5
Top
User avatar
Eelco de Groot
Posts: 4697
Joined: Sun Mar 12, 2006 2:40 am
Full name:   Eelco de Groot

Re: Test Position (for a change!)

Post by Eelco de Groot »

For some reason Ancalagon thinks even after six minutes, plydepth 17, that having the exchange is worth at least four and a half pawns for White. It is even Black that gains an advanced passed pawn -Edit: True, he has to sell his car, sorry horse to do this and keep some credit with the bank, that kind of slipped past me - and it is White that has no King position that is worth its name, for the White King its an Housing Crisis endgame already but Black still has a luxurious castle to live in.

But at least the program finds Timman's required Nc4+ at ply thirteen and Black's score is even going up to being about two mortgaged pawns in the red 8-)

Edit: reached 19 plies deep: Now Black is just down 1⅓ pawn!

[d]q1bQ1nk1/5rbp/6p1/np2p3/4P3/1P2BPN1/1K4P1/1NR4R b - -

Engine: Ancalagon 1.08 Testversion 002 (Athlon 2009 MHz, 256 MB)
by Tord Romstad

2.00 0:00 -6.39 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 (415) 1

3.00 0:00 -6.39 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 (586) 1

4.00 0:00 -7.21 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Nc3 (1.222) 3

5.00 0:00 -5.80 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Rd7 4.Qxc8 Qxc8
5.Rxc8 (3.187) 9

6.00 0:00 -4.88 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Qd7 4.Rxc8 Kh8
5.Qxd7 Rxd7 (12.674) 35

7.00 0:00 -4.90 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Qd7 4.Rxc8 Kh8
5.Nc3 (23.448) 59

8.00 0:00 -5.03 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Qd7 4.Rxc8 Kh8
5.Nc3 b4 (46.368) 98

9.00 0:00 -5.01 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Qe6 4.Qxc8 Kh8
5.Nd2 h6 6.Rc7 (101.342) 158

10.00 0:00 -5.00 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Qe6 4.Qxc8 Kh8
5.Nd2 h6 6.Rc7 Rd7 (157.662) 197

11.00 0:01 -5.54 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Qe6 4.Qxc8 Kh8
5.Qxe6 Nxe6 6.Nc3 Rb7 7.Nd5 Rd7
8.Rc8+ Bf8 (273.499) 243

11.02 0:01 -5.29 1...Bb7 2.Qxa8 Bxa8 3.Nc3 b4 4.Nb5 Bc6
5.Na7 Be8 6.Ra1 Nc6 7.Nb5 (436.202) 271

12.01 0:02 -5.72 1...Bb7 2.Qxa8 Bxa8 3.Na3 h5 4.Nxh5 gxh5
5.Rxh5 b4 6.Nc4 Nxc4+ 7.bxc4 Rd7
8.Ra1 Rd3 9.Rxa8 Rxe3 (880.060) 301

12.02 0:03 -5.37 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Bf6 4.Rxc6 Bxd8
5.Rxc8 Ne6 6.Rb8 b4 7.Rxb4 h5 8.Nc3 (1.126.890) 310

13.01 0:05 -5.41 1...Nc6 2.Rxc6 Qxc6 3.Rc1 Bf6 4.Rxc6 Bxd8
5.Rxc8 Ne6 6.Rb8 b4 7.Rxb4 Rc7 8.Nc3 Kf7 (1.749.302) 315

13.06 0:27 -5.19 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Qb3 6.Nf1 Qa3+ 7.Na2 h5 8.Rxc4 Ba6
9.Rc3 Rd1+ 10.Bc1 (8.434.215) 303

14.01 0:40 -4.98 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Qb3 6.Nf1 Rd3 7.Nd2 Qa3+ 8.Na2 Be6
9.Nxc4 Bxc4 10.Rxc4 Rxe3 (12.138.734) 300

15.01 1:15 -4.74 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Qb3 6.Nf1 Rd3 7.Qe1 h5 8.Bc5 Ne6
9.Nd2 Qb7 10.Be3 (22.818.715) 300

16.01 2:48 -4.49 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Qb3 6.Nf1 Rd3 7.Qe1 h5 8.Na2 Qa4
9.Qb4 Qxb4 10.Nxb4 Ra3+ 11.Na2 Be6 (50.934.786) 302

17.01 6:24 -4.52 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Qb3 6.Nf1 Rd3 7.Qe1 h5 8.Na2 Qa4
9.Qb4 Qxb4 10.Nxb4 Ra3+ 11.Na2 Be6
12.Kb2 Rb3+ 13.Kc2 (114.779.494) 298

18.01 12:53 -2.19 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Rd3 6.Nf1 Qa6+ 7.Na2 c3 8.Rc2 Be6
9.Bc1 Bb3 10.Qf2 h6 11.Ne3 Bxc2
12.Qxc2 Rxe3 13.Bxe3 (236.801.672) 306

19.01 24:16 -1.29 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Rd3 6.Nf1 Qa6+ 7.Na2 c3 8.Rc2 Be6
9.Bc1 Bb3 10.Qf2 h6 11.Ne3 Ne6
12.Nd5 Bxc2 13.Qxc2 (448.314.108) 307
Top
rightrook
Posts: 1452
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:45 pm

Re: Test Position (for a change!)

Post by rightrook »

Hi...Junior 10 plays Nc4+ less than one second..

Hiarcs11.2 less than 2 seconds..

Ruffian1.0.5.....about one sec.

regards

Robert
Top
User avatar
Eelco de Groot
Posts: 4697
Joined: Sun Mar 12, 2006 2:40 am
Full name:   Eelco de Groot

Re: Test Position (for a change!)

Post by Eelco de Groot »

And here is the deep analysis from Ancalagon, 22 plies took a while, maybe it is not enough to convince Marc that it is a draw. It seems likely though, and the magnitude of an evaluation is not really any kind of proof anyway, not even if it is somehow "calibrated" there is still a lot of room for statistical error possible in just a final sum of heuristics travelling up or down the searchtree. Reasonably happy with the consistency in the PV output here.

[d]q1bQ1nk1/5rbp/6p1/np2p3/4P3/1P2BPN1/1K4P1/1NR4R b - -

Engine: Ancalagon 1.08 Testversion 002 (Athlon 2009 MHz, 256 MB)
by Tord Romstad
.
.
.
19.01 24:16 -1.29 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Rd3 6.Nf1 Qa6+ 7.Na2 c3 8.Rc2 Be6
9.Bc1 Bb3 10.Qf2 h6 11.Ne3 Ne6
12.Nd5 Bxc2 13.Qxc2 (448.314.108) 307

20.01 62:32 -1.68 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Rc2 Rb7+
5.Kc1 Qa1 6.Kd2 Rxb1 7.Rxb1 Qxb1
8.Ne2 Bb7 9.Nc3 Qf1 10.Qf2 Qa1
11.Qe1 Qa3 12.Kd1 Qd6+ 13.Kc1 Ne6 (1.160.322.854) 309

21.01 138:35 -1.68 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Rc2 Rb7+
5.Kc1 Qa1 6.Kd2 Rxb1 7.Rxb1 Qxb1
8.Ne2 Bb7 9.Nc3 Qf1 10.Qf2 Qa1
11.Qe1 Qa3 12.Qf1 Qb3 13.Kc1 Qa3+
14.Kb1 Qb4+ (2.627.726.569) 315

22.01 441:56 -1.09 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Rc2 Rb7+
5.Kc1 Qa1 6.Kd2 Rxb1 7.Rxb1 Qxb1
8.Ne2 Qb4+ 9.Kd1 Ne6 10.Nc3 Bf8
11.g3 Bc5 12.Bxc5 Qxc5 13.Ne2 Qf2
14.Qe7 Qxf3 (8.516.268.594) 321

best move: Na5-c4 time: 482:18.656 min n/s: 321.805 nodes: 9.312.600.000
Debugging is twice as hard as writing the code in the first
place. Therefore, if you write the code as cleverly as possible, you
are, by definition, not smart enough to debug it.
-- Brian W. Kernighan
Top
Marc MP

Re: Test Position (for a change!)

Post by Marc MP »

Eelco de Groot wrote:And here is the deep analysis from Ancalagon, 22 plies took a while, maybe it is not enough to convince Marc that it is a draw. It seems likely though, and the magnitude of an evaluation is not really any kind of proof anyway, not even if it is somehow "calibrated" there is still a lot of room for statistical error possible in just a final sum of heuristics travelling up or down the searchtree. Reasonably happy with the consistency in the PV output here.

[d]q1bQ1nk1/5rbp/6p1/np2p3/4P3/1P2BPN1/1K4P1/1NR4R b - -

Engine: Ancalagon 1.08 Testversion 002 (Athlon 2009 MHz, 256 MB)
by Tord Romstad
.
.
.
19.01 24:16 -1.29 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Nc3 Qb7+
5.Ka1 Rd3 6.Nf1 Qa6+ 7.Na2 c3 8.Rc2 Be6
9.Bc1 Bb3 10.Qf2 h6 11.Ne3 Ne6
12.Nd5 Bxc2 13.Qxc2 (448.314.108) 307

20.01 62:32 -1.68 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Rc2 Rb7+
5.Kc1 Qa1 6.Kd2 Rxb1 7.Rxb1 Qxb1
8.Ne2 Bb7 9.Nc3 Qf1 10.Qf2 Qa1
11.Qe1 Qa3 12.Kd1 Qd6+ 13.Kc1 Ne6 (1.160.322.854) 309

21.01 138:35 -1.68 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Rc2 Rb7+
5.Kc1 Qa1 6.Kd2 Rxb1 7.Rxb1 Qxb1
8.Ne2 Bb7 9.Nc3 Qf1 10.Qf2 Qa1
11.Qe1 Qa3 12.Qf1 Qb3 13.Kc1 Qa3+
14.Kb1 Qb4+ (2.627.726.569) 315

22.01 441:56 -1.09 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4 bxc4 4.Rc2 Rb7+
5.Kc1 Qa1 6.Kd2 Rxb1 7.Rxb1 Qxb1
8.Ne2 Qb4+ 9.Kd1 Ne6 10.Nc3 Bf8
11.g3 Bc5 12.Bxc5 Qxc5 13.Ne2 Qf2
14.Qe7 Qxf3 (8.516.268.594) 321

best move: Na5-c4 time: 482:18.656 min n/s: 321.805 nodes: 9.312.600.000
Apparently Nc4+ is indeed best, but Glaurung 2.1 coudn't find a confirmed draw after it. I let it run overnight after 1...Nc4+ 2.bxc4 Rd7 3.Qh4:

[d]q1b2nk1/3r2bp/6p1/1p2p3/2P1P2Q/4BPN1/1K4P1/1NR4R b - - 2 1

Code: Select all

...

00:37:32.6	-0,88	21	874035932	bxc4 Rc2 Rb7+ Kc1 Qa1 Kd2 Rxb1 Rxb1 Qxb1 Qd8 Be6 Qb6 Qa1 Ke2 Qa4 Rc3 Bf6 Qd6 Qe8 Qc7 Nd7 Rxc4 Bh4 Qc8 Bxc4+ Qxc4+ Qf7 

01:31:02.3	-1,00	22	2022150477	bxc4 Rc2 Rb7+ Kc1 Qa1 Kd2 Rxb1 Rxb1 Qxb1 Qd8 Be6 Qb6 Qa1 Ke2 Qa4 Rc3 Bf6 Qd6 Qe8 Kf2 Nd7 Ne2 Bh4+ g3 Bf6 Ra3 

04:07:18.7	-1,05	23	1169787473	bxc4 Rc2 Rb7+ Kc1 Qa1 Kd2 Rxb1 Rxb1 Qxb1 Qe7 Be6 Qa3 Qb8 Ke2 Qb5 Rb2 Qe8 Rb7 Nd7 Qa6 Bf6 Qc6 Kf7 Kf2 Kg8 Qc7 

09:17:07.2	-1,09	24	3629037161	bxc4 Rc2 Rb7+ Kc1 Qa1 Kd2 Rxb1 Rxb1 Qxb1 Qe7 Be6 Qa3 Qb8 Ke2 Qb5 Rb2 Qe8 Rb7 Nd7 Qa6 h6 Rc7 Nb8 Qa8 Qd8 Qa7 Nd7
Top
Dann Corbit
Posts: 12818
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:57 pm
Location: Redmond, WA USA

Re: Test Position (for a change!)

Post by Dann Corbit »

Marc MP wrote:
Marc MP wrote:[d]q1bQ1nk1/5rbp/6p1/np2p3/4P3/1P2BPN1/1K4P1/1NR4R b - - 0 1

According to Polugayevsky & Damsky in "The Art of Defense", black's best move is here: Nc4+!, so that black eventually gains a draw here (despite being a full rook down after this further sacrifice). Will your favorite engine find Nc4+? Is the game really drawn afterwards (I need a confirmation)?

What about your second favorite engine? ( :-) i.e. something different from Rybka 3.0!)
The position is from Timman-Kasparov Bugojno 1984: http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1069988
Opinions vary. I guess (with no real proof) that it is a draw.

Code: Select all

Analysis from Q:\epd\sub\tkb.epd   
8/15/2008 1:03:22 AM Level: 4000 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Bright-0.3a

1) Nc4+; id "Timman-Kas 
    Searching move: Na5-c4
    Best move (Bright-0.3a): Na5-c4
    identical moves! Found in: 00:03
     2/10	00:00	       1.210	1.210	-2.10	Na5c6 Qd8d5 Bc8d7
     3/10	00:00	       1.514	1.514	-2.10	Na5c6 Qd8d5 Bc8d7
     4/10	00:00	       4.811	4.811	-1.96	Na5c6 Qd8d6 Bc8d7 Nb1a3 Nf8e6 Na3xb5
     5/11	00:00	       9.269	9.269	-2.03	Na5c6 Qd8e8 Rf7d7 Nb1a3 b5b4
     6/21	00:00	      22.394	22.394	-2.14	Na5c6 Qd8e8 Rf7c7 Be3c5 Qa8a6 Bc5xf8 Bg7xf8
     7/24	00:00	     121.776	3.928	-3.50	Na5c6 Rc1xc6 Qa8xc6 Rh1c1 Rf7d7 Qd8xc8 Qc6d6 Nb1c3 Qd6b4
     7/24	00:00	     163.192	5.264	-2.75	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Be3h6 Bg7xh6 Rh1xh6 b5b4 Rc1c5 Na5c6
     8/24	00:00	     194.281	4.133	-2.53	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1c3 b5b4 Rc1a1 b4xc3+ Kb2xc3 Rf7c7+ Kc3b2 Ba8d5 Ra1xa5
     9/24	00:00	     267.565	4.247	-2.63	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1c3 b5b4 Rc1a1 b4xc3+ Kb2xc3 Rf7c7+ Kc3b2 Ba8d5 Ra1xa5 Bd5e6
    10/26	00:00	     644.469	5.155	-2.63	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1c3 b5b4 Nc3a4 Na5c6 Be3h6 Bg7xh6 Rh1xh6 Nf8e6
    11/30	00:00	   1.353.339	6.179	-2.63	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1c3 b5b4 Nc3a4 Ba8b7 Na4c5 Bb7c6 Be3h6 Bg7f6 Bh6xf8 Rf7xf8
    12/34	00:00	   3.135.103	6.477	-2.77	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1a3 b5b4 Na3c2 Na5c6 Be3h6 Nf8e6 Bh6xg7 Kg8xg7 Nc2e3 Rf7d7
    13/38	00:01	   9.109.225	6.712	-3.16	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rh1d1 Na5c6 Rd1d6 Nc6d4 Be3xd4 e5xd4 Rc1c5 b5b4 Nb1d2 Rf7a7 e4e5 Ra7e7
    13/49	00:03	  24.973.142	6.534	-2.50	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Nc3a2 Rd6a6 Qh4f2 Nf8e6
    14/49	00:05	  35.319.674	6.600	-2.76	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Ng3f1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Rd3a3 Rc1c2 Qa6a4 Ka1b1 Ra3b3+ Rc2b2
    15/49	00:07	  50.922.605	6.688	-2.68	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Ng3f1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6 Qh4f2 c4c3 Qf2c2 Nf8d7 Rc1b1 Qa6a3
    16/50	00:15	 105.717.090	6.709	-2.68	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Ng3f1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6 Qh4f2 c4c3 Qf2c2 Nf8d7 Rc1b1 Qa6a3
    17/51	00:28	 189.712.201	6.555	-2.62	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Ng3f1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Rd3a3 Rc1c2 Qa6a4 Be3c1 Ra3xf3 Rc2xc4 Qa4xc4 g2xf3 Qc4d4+ Bc1b2 Qd4d1+ Na2c1 Qd1xf3
    18/64	01:13	 475.110.476	6.482	-2.62	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Ng3f1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Rd3a3 Rc1c2 Qa6a4 Be3c1 Ra3xf3 Rc2xc4 Qa4xc4 g2xf3 Qc4d4+ Bc1b2 Qd4d1+ Na2c1 Qd1xf3
    19/72	03:50	1.478.222.158	6.422	-2.72	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b8+ Kb2a1 Bg7f6 Qh4xf6 Rd7d6 Qf6xf8+ Kg8xf8 Be3c5 Kf8g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Ng3e2 Qd6a3+ Nc3a2 Qa3c5 g2g4 Bc8d7 Rc1d1 Bd7c6
    20/72	09:54	3.870.405,115	6.511	-2.77	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b8+ Kb2a1 Bg7f6 Qh4xf6 Rd7d6 Qf6xf8+ Kg8xf8 Be3c5 Kf8g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Ng3e2 Qd6a3+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6 Rc1b1 Qa3d3 Rb1b7+ Be6d7 Na2c3 Qd3d2
    21/72	17:19	2.491.440,900	2.395	-2.56	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Nc3a2 Rd6a6 Qh4f2 Bc8e6 Nf1h2 c4c3 Rc1c2 Nf8d7 Nh2g4 Be6c4 Ng4h6+ Kg8h8 g2g4 Ra6a8
    22/88	39:27	2.696.173,983	1.138	-2.22	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a8+ Nc3a2 Rd7d3 Rh1e1 Bc8e6 Qh4e7 Rd3a3 Re1e2 c4c3 Rc1c2 Be6c4 Ka1b1 Ra3b3+ Kb1c1 Rb3b7 Qe7d6 Rb7d7 Qd6c5 Bc4xe2 Ng3xe2
   8/15/2008 2:10:08 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:06:40, Rated time: 00:03

1 of 1 matching moves
8/15/2008 2:10:08 AM, Total time: 1:06:46 AM
Rated time: 00:03 = 3 Seconds

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Analysis from Q:\epd\sub\tkb.epd   
8/15/2008 1:03:22 AM Level: 40 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Rybka 3

1) Nc4+; id "Timman-Kas 
    Searching move: Na5-c4
    Best move (Rybka 3): Na5-c4
    identical moves! Found in: 00:08
   Rybka 3 by Vasik Rajlich, Larry Kaufman
      2	00:08	         344	352.256	-1.58	Na5c6
      3	00:08	         691	707.584	-1.67	Na5c6
      4	00:08	       1.121	1.147.904	-1.50	Na5c6
      5	00:08	       1.718	1.759.232	-1.59	Na5c6 Qd8e8
      6	00:08	       5.812	350.087	-2.38	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1a3 b5b4
      7	00:08	       8.877	284.064	-2.32	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1a3 b5b4 Na3b5 Ba8c6 Be3b6
      8	00:08	      16.198	263.281	-2.32	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1a3 b5b4 Na3b5 Ba8c6 Be3b6
      8+	00:08	      22.682	244.488	-2.12	Na5c4+
      8+	00:08	      32.500	264.126	-1.92	Na5c4+
   Max CPUs set to 4
      8+	00:10	      83.822	31.979	-1.52	Na5c4+
      8	00:11	     173.038	57.924	-0.93	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7
      9+	00:11	     234.024	72.442	-0.73	Na5c4+
      9+	00:11	     324.857	90.715	-0.53	Na5c4+
      9	00:12	     458.274	111.811	-0.41	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qg5d8 Qb1b3 Rc2c1
     10	00:12	     612.598	129.687	-0.49	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qg5d8 Qb1b3 Rc2c1 Bc8d7 Kd2e2 c4c3 Qd8c7 Bd7b5+ Ke2f2 Bb5c4 Ng3e2 c3c2 Qc7a5
     11	00:13	     860.884	152.279	-0.49	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qg5d8 Qb1b3 Rc2c1 Bc8d7 Kd2e2 c4c3 Qd8c7 Bd7b5+ Ke2f2 Bb5c4 Ng3e2 c3c2 Qc7a5
     12	00:16	   1.602.057	188.109	-0.41	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qg5d8 Qb1b3 Rc2c1 Bc8d7 Kd2e2 c4c3 Qd8c7 Bd7b5+ Ke2f2 Bb5c4 Ng3e2 Qb3a2 Rc1c2 Qa2xc2 Qc7xc4+ Kg8h8 g2g3 h7h5
     13	00:33	   5.371.500	220.087	-0.66	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 Bg7f6 Ke2f2 Qa1a4 Rc2c1 Kg8f7
     14	01:00	  11.968.840	232.228	-0.60	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 Bg7f6 Qb6d6 Kg8f7 Qd6c7+ Kf7g8 Ke2f2 Bf6h4 Qc7d6
     15	01:38	  20.489.728	232.930	-0.60	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 Bg7f6 Qb6d6 Kg8f7 Qd6c7+ Kf7g8 Ke2f2 Bf6h4 Qc7d6
     16	02:57	  39.069.635	235.711	-0.60	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 Bg7f6 Qb6d6 Kg8f7 Qd6c7+ Kf7g8 Ke2f2 Bf6h4 Qc7d6
     17	06:27	  87.588.798	236.356	-0.65	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 Bg7f6 Qb6d6 Kg8f7 Qd6d2 Qa1a3 Ng3f1 Qa3a4 Qd2c1 Qa4a6 Ke2f2
     18	17:51	 245.839.374	236.672	-0.84	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 Qa1a4 Rc2c1 Qa4a3 Ke2f2 Bg7f6 Ng3e2 Bf6h4+ Kf2f1
     19	40:41	 561.162.170	236.091	-0.91	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 Qa1a4 Rc2c1 Qa4a3 Ke2f2 Bg7f6 Ng3e2 Bf6e7 Qb6a7 Qa3b4 Rc1d1 g6g5 Qa7c7 Nf8g6
   8/15/2008 3:17:31 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:06:40, Rated time: 00:08

1 of 1 matching moves
8/15/2008 3:17:32 AM, Total time: 2:14:09 AM
Rated time: 00:08 = 8 Seconds

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Analysis from Q:\epd\sub\tkb.epd   
8/15/2008 1:03:22 AM Level: 40 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Rybkav2.3.2a

1) Nc4+; id "Timman-Kas 
    Searching move: Na5-c4
    Best move (Rybkav2.3.2a.mp.x64): Na5-c4
    identical moves! Found in: 00:00
      5	00:00	       4.723	4.836.352	-1.48	Na5c6 Qd8e8
      6	00:00	      27.828	606.295	-2.64	Na5c6 Rc1xc6 Qa8xc6 Rh1c1
      6	00:00	      59.461	553.527	-1.67	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4
      7	00:00	      69.246	567.263	-1.69	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5
      8	00:00	     119.014	556.485	-1.26	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1a3 Rd7b7+ Kb2a2
      9	00:00	     170.012	530.769	-1.06	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1xc4 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Bc8e6 Rc4c2
     10	00:00	     255.178	539.880	-0.63	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Nc3a2
     11	00:00	     322.044	527.636	-0.58	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8e8 Qa8c6 Nb1a3 Rd7d2+ Be3xd2 Qc6xe8 c4xb5 Nf8e6 Ng3e2
     12	00:00	     415.553	544.847	-0.52	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8e8 Qa8c6 Nb1a3 Rd7d2+ Be3xd2 Qc6xe8 c4xb5 Nf8e6 Ng3e2 Bc8b7
     13	00:01	     545.173	550.007	-0.55	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8e8 Qa8c6 Nb1a3 Rd7d2+ Be3xd2 Qc6xe8 c4xb5 Nf8e6 Ng3e2 Bc8b7 Bd2b4
     14	00:01	     920.052	574.821	-0.47	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8e8 Qa8c6 Nb1a3 Rd7d2+ Be3xd2 Qc6xe8 c4xb5 Nf8e6 Ng3e2 Qe8f8 Na3c4
     15	00:03	   1.710.968	594.110	-0.42	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8e8 Qa8c6 Nb1a3 Rd7d2+ Be3xd2 Qc6xe8 c4xb5 Nf8e6 Ng3e2 Qe8f8 Rh1d1
     16	00:10	   5.858.430	573.905	-0.29	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     17	00:14	   7.976.728	563.594	-0.26	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     18	00:22	  12.260.074	567.503	-0.25	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     19	00:34	  17.707.587	529.773	-0.33	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     20	00:59	  28.359.356	493.373	-0.35	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     21	01:47	  50.857.120	485.849	-0.35	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     22	03:39	 100.487.365	469.601	-0.38	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     23	06:52	 191.262.539	475.516	-0.37	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     24	15:46	 424.767.016	459.832	-0.39	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     25	29:54	 832.727.287	475.331	-0.38	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
     26	1:06:04	1.773.384.047	458.074	-0.43	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8
   8/15/2008 4:24:20 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:06:40, Rated time: 00:00

1 of 1 matching moves
8/15/2008 4:24:21 AM, Total time: 3:20:59 AM
Rated time: 00:00 = 0 Seconds

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Analysis from Q:\epd\sub\tkb.epd   
8/15/2008 1:03:22 AM Level: 40 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Shredder

1) Nc4+; id "Timman-Kas 
    Searching move: Na5-c4
    Best move (Shredder): Na5-c4
    identical moves! Found in: 00:00
     2/2	00:00	          38	2.533	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
     3/3	00:00	         428	28.533	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
     4/4	00:00	       1.960	130.666	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
     5/5	00:00	       2.564	170.933	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
     6/6	00:00	       6.928	223.483	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
     7/7	00:00	      12.392	399.741	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
     8/8	00:00	      29.703	958.161	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
     9/9	00:00	      44.580	1.438.064	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    10/10	00:00	      80.691	1.716.829	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    11/11	00:00	     181.581	2.327.961	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    12/12	00:00	     361.962	2.585.442	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    13/13	00:00	     682.287	2.740.108	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    14/14	00:00	   1.430.054	2.960.774	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    15/15	00:01	   3.414.056	3.040.121	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    16/16	00:02	   6.879.133	3.062.837	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    17/17	00:04	  13.465.304	3.138.765	-1.02	Na5c4+ b3xc4
    18/53	01:35	 302.139.100	3.158.468	-0.92	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5 Rd7b7+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Kd1e2 Qb1c2+ Be3d2 Qc2d3+ Ke2e1 Bc8e6 Qc5e3 Qd3xe3+ Bd2xe3 c4c3 Ng3e2
    19/50	02:53	 548.558.099	3.162.775	-0.96	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5 Rd7b7+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Be3c1 Qb1b3+ Kd1e1 Bc8b7 Ng3e2 Nf8e6 Qc5d6 c4c3
    20/53	05:19	1.003.558.558	3.141.431	-0.96	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5 Rd7b7+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Kd1e2 Qb1c2+ Be3d2 Qc2d3+ Ke2e1 Bc8e6 Qc5e3 Nf8d7 Qe3xd3 c4xd3 Bd2e3 h7h5 Ke1d2
    21/56	11:52	2.216.705,295	3.112.304	-1.03	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5 Rd7b7+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Be3c1 Bc8e6
    22/56	23:28	4.346.222,202	3.085.572	-1.03	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5 Rd7b7+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Kd1e2 Qb1c2+ Be3d2 Qc2d3+ Ke2e1 Bc8e6 Qc5e3 Be6d7
    23/61	52:49	9.571.928,778	3.020.170	-1.07	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5 Rd7b7+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Kd1e2 Qb1c2+ Be3d2 Qc2d3+ Ke2e1 Bc8e6 Ng3e2 Nf8d7 Qc5c6 Nd7f8 Bd2c1 Be6d7 Qc6c5
   8/15/2008 5:31:11 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:06:40, Rated time: 00:00

1 of 1 matching moves
8/15/2008 5:31:12 AM, Total time: 4:27:50 AM
Rated time: 00:00 = 0 Seconds

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Analysis from Q:\epd\sub\tkb.epd   
8/15/2008 1:03:22 AM Level: 40 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Glaurung

1) Nc4+; id "Timman-Kas 
    Searching move: Na5-c4
    Best move (Glaurung): Na5-c4
    identical moves! Found in: 00:01
      2	00:00	         331	1.924	-1.62	Na5c6 Qd8e8
      3	00:00	         793	4.610	-1.84	Na5c6 Qd8d5 Bc8d7 Qd5xb5
      4	00:00	       1.527	8.877	-2.26	Na5c6 Qd8d5 Bc8d7 Nb1a3
      5	00:00	       3.352	17.925	-1.59	Na5c6 Qd8d5 Bc8d7 Nb1a3 b5b4
      6	00:00	      10.494	56.117	-3.34	Na5c6 Rc1xc6 Qa8xc6 Rh1c1 Rf7d7 Qd8xf8+ Bg7xf8 Rc1xc6
      6	00:00	      18.100	89.162	-2.48	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rc1c8 Ba8c6 Nb1c3
      7	00:00	      26.742	122.109	-2.39	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rc1c8 Ba8b7 Rc8d8 Rf7d7 Rd8xd7 Nf8xd7
      8	00:00	      55.743	238.217	-2.31	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rc1c5 Ba8c6 Rh1c1 Bc6d7 Rc5c7
      9	00:00	     107.874	383.893	-2.34	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rc1c8 Ba8b7 Rc8e8 b5b4 Re8d8 Bb7c6
     10	00:00	     201.116	586.344	-2.98	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1c3 b5b4 Rc1a1 b4xc3+ Kb2xc3 Rf7c7+ Kc3b2 Na5xb3 Ra1xa8
     11	00:00	     559.194	896.144	-3.04	Bc8b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1c3 b5b4 Rc1a1 b4xc3+ Kb2xc3 Rf7c7+ Kc3b2 Na5xb3 Ra1xa8 Nb3d4 Be3xd4 e5xd4
     11	00:01	   1.218.211	1.014.330	-2.17	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 b5xc4 Qb6c5 Rd7b7+ Kb2c3 Qa8b8 Kc3d2 Rb7b2+ Kd2e1 Rb2xb1 Qc5xc4+ Nf8e6
     12	00:02	   2.253.691	1.077.805	-1.18	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1xc4 h7h6 Qg5h4 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a2 Nb1d2 Bc8e6 Be3xh6 Bg7xh6 Qh4xh6 Be6xc4 Nd2xc4 Qa2xc4+ Kc1d1
     13	00:03	   3.816.762	1.112.110	-1.18	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1xc4 h7h6 Qg5h4 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a2 Nb1d2 Bc8e6 Be3xh6 Bg7xh6 Qh4xh6 Be6xc4 Nd2xc4 Qa2xc4+ Kc1d1
     14	00:09	  10.700.541	1.154.693	-2.23	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8a5 Ng3f1 Bc8a6 Rc1c2 h7h5 Qh4e1 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa5a1+ Kc1d2 Rb7d7+ Kd2e2
     15	00:17	  20.691.706	1.186.383	-2.31	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8a5 Ng3f1 Bc8a6 Rc1c2 h7h5 Qh4e1 Nf8e6 Kb2b1 Rd7b7+ Rc2b2 Rb7xb2+ Kb1xb2
     16	00:31	  38.157.242	1.201.348	-2.40	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Ng3f1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6 Qh4f2 c4c3 Qf2e2 Qa6a3 Rc1c2 Be6c4
     17	00:55	  66.971.899	1.211.700	-2.31	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Ng3f1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6 Qh4f2 c4c3 Qf2e2 Qa6a3 Rc1c2 Be6c4 Nf1g3
     18	02:04	 148.848.218	1.198.079	-1.87	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8a5 Ng3f1 Nf8e6 Nc3d5 Ne6d4 Qh4xh7+ Kg8f8 Be3xd4 e5xd4 Kb2c2 d4d3+ Kc2d1 c4c3 Nf1e3 Qa5a4+ Ne3c2 d3xc2+ Rc1xc2
     19	04:15	 307.741.540	1.206.091	-1.87	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8a5 Ng3f1 Nf8e6 Qh4xh7+ Kg8f8 Nc3d5 Ne6d4 Be3xd4 e5xd4 Kb2c2 d4d3+ Kc2d1 c4c3 Nf1e3 Qa5a4+ Ne3c2 d3xc2+ Rc1xc2
     20	08:33	 623.747.858	1.214.642	-1.73	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8a5 Ng3f1 Nf8e6 Qh4xh7+ Kg8f8 Nc3d5 Ne6d4 Be3xd4 e5xd4 Kb2c2 d4d3+ Kc2d1 c4c3 Nf1e3 Qa5a2 Ne3c2 d3xc2+ Kd1e1
     21	19:32	1.431.007.649	1.220.618	-1.28	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8a5 Ng3f1 Nf8e6 Kb2c2 Ne6d4+ Be3xd4 e5xd4 Nc3d5 Qa5a4+ Kc2d2 c4c3+ Kd2e1 Qa4a3 Qh4g5 d4d3 Ke1f2 Qa3b2+ Nf1d2 Bg7d4+ Kf2g3 Rd7f7 Nd5e7+ Rf7xe7 Qg5xe7 Qb2xd2 Qe7xh7+ Kg8f8 Qh7xg6
     22	48:54	3.586.786,806	1.222.215	-1.29	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8a5 Kb2c2 Qa5a3 Rc1b1 Rd7d3 Be3d2 Bc8d7 Rb1b7 Bd7a4+ Kc2b1 Rd3xc3 Bd2xc3 Qa3xc3 Rb7b2 Qc3a3 Qh4d8 c4c3 Qd8d5+ Kg8h8
   8/15/2008 6:38:00 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:06:40, Rated time: 00:01

1 of 1 matching moves
8/15/2008 6:38:01 AM, Total time: 5:34:39 AM
Rated time: 00:01 = 1 Seconds

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Analysis from Q:\epd\sub\tkb.epd   
8/15/2008 1:03:22 AM Level: 40 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Hiarcs

1) Nc4+; id "Timman-Kas 
    Searching move: Na5-c4
    Best move (Hiarcs): Na5-c4
    identical moves! Found in: 00:01
    10/31	00:00	     739.291	1.432.722	-2.09	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Be3c5
    11/31+	00:01	     863.976	1.454.505	-1.84	Na5c4+
    11/31	00:01	   1.073.595	1.527.162	-1.58	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Be3c5 Qb7b3 Ng3e2 Bc8d7
    12/31+	00:01	   1.545.370	1.570.497	-1.33	Na5c4+
    12/33	00:02	   3.149.141	1.681.335	-0.69	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Rc2xc4 Bc8a6 Rc4c2
    13/34	00:03	   5.753.885	1.747.307	-0.60	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Rc2xc4 Bc8e6 Rc4c2 Be6b3
    14/36	00:06	  10.295.263	1.802.707	-0.52	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Kd2e2 Bc8e6 Ke2f2 Rb1xh1 Qh4xh1 Qa1a4 Rc2c3
    15/38	00:11	  20.897.528	1.817.334	-0.52	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Kd2e2 Bc8e6 Ke2f2 Rb1xh1 Qh4xh1 Qa1a4 Qh1c1 Nf8d7
    16/41	00:37	  63.043.117	1.678.196	-0.41	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 Rd7b7 Qb6c5 b5xc4+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Kd1e2 Qb1c2+ Ke2f1 Bc8e6 Kf1g1 h7h5 Qc5e7 c4c3 Kg1h2 Qc2b2
    17/41	01:10	 119.952.556	1.715.936	-0.30	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 Rd7b7 Qb6c5 b5xc4+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Ng3e2 Bc8e6 Kd1e1 Rb1b2 Ne2c3 Qa2b3 Ke1f1 Rb2c2 Rc1xc2 Qb3xc2
    18/41	02:09	 223.058.035	1.726.014	-0.32	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 Rd7b7 Qb6c5 b5xc4+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Ng3e2 Bc8e6 Kd1e1 Qa2b3 Rc1xb1
    19/41	04:30	 469.335.821	1.740.846	-0.42	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8b6 Rd7b7 Qb6c5 b5xc4+ Kb2c2 Qa8a2+ Kc2d1 Rb7xb1 Rc1xb1 Qa2xb1+ Be3c1 Bc8e6 Ng3e2 Nf8d7 Qc5c6
    20/41-	12:32	1.360.034.956	1.807.384	-0.67	Na5c4+
    20/41	15:45	1.723.897.392	1.824.425	-0.68	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Rd7d3 Ng3f1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6 Rc1c2 Qa6a4 Qh4f2 Nf8d7 Qf2e2 Bg7f8 Rc2c1 Qa4a3
    21/41	32:18	3.535.011,511	1.824.418	-0.46	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Bc8e6 Qd8b6 Qb1a1 Kd2e2 h7h5 Qb6b2 Qa1xb2
   8/15/2008 7:44:51 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:06:40, Rated time: 00:01

1 of 1 matching moves
8/15/2008 7:44:52 AM, Total time: 6:41:30 AM
Rated time: 00:01 = 1 Seconds

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Analysis from Q:\epd\sub\tkb.epd   
8/15/2008 1:03:22 AM Level: 40 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Scorpio

1) Nc4+; id "Timman-Kas 
    Searching move: Na5-c4
    Best move (Scorpio): Na5-c4
    identical moves! Found in: 00:00
      2	00:00	         340	340	-0.53	Na5-c6 Qd8-d5
      2	00:00	         508	508	-0.53	Na5-c6 Qd8-d5
      3	00:00	         580	580	-1.08	Na5-c6 Qd8-d5 Bg7-h8
      3	00:00	       1.559	1.559	-1.31	Na5-c6 Qd8-d5 Bc8-d7 Qd5xb5
      3	00:00	       1.649	1.649	-1.31	Na5-c6 Qd8-d5 Bc8-d7 Qd5xb5
      4	00:00	       2.345	2.345	-1.80	Na5-c6 Qd8-d5 Bc8-d7 Nb1-a3
      4	00:00	       3.825	3.825	-1.80	Na5-c6 Qd8-d5 Bc8-d7 Nb1-a3
      5	00:00	       6.082	608.200	-3.93	Na5-c6 Qd8-e8 Rf7-d7 Nb1-a3
      5	00:00	      11.384	1.138.400	-3.93	Na5-c6 Rc1xc6 Qa8xc6 Rh1-c1 Rf7-d7 Qd8xc8
      5	00:00	      13.659	1.365.900	-3.41	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rc1-c8 Ba8-b7 Rc8-d8
      5	00:00	      15.456	1.545.600	-3.41	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rc1-c8 Ba8-b7 Rc8-d8
      6	00:00	      17.427	1.742.700	-3.36	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rc1-c8 Ba8-b7 Rc8-d8 Rf7-d7
      6	00:00	      30.360	1.012.000	-3.36	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Rc1-c8 Ba8-b7 Rc8-d8 Rf7-d7
      7	00:00	      41.505	1.383.500	-3.47	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-c4 Na5-c6 Rh1-d1
      7	00:00	      62.686	1.567.150	-3.47	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-c4 Na5-c6 Rh1-d1
      8	00:00	      96.015	2.400.375	-3.47	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-c4 Na5-c6 Rh1-d1
      8	00:00	     139.508	1.992.971	-3.47	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-c4 Na5-c6 Rh1-d1
      9	00:00	     176.685	1.963.166	-3.47	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-c4 Na5-c6 Rh1-d1
      9	00:00	     322.290	2.148.600	-3.47	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-c4 Na5-c6 Rh1-d1
     10	00:00	     459.728	2.298.640	-3.39	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-c3 Ba8-c6 Rc1-a1 Na5-b7 Ra1-a6 Rf7-c7 Ra6-a8
     10	00:00	     716.323	2.310.719	-3.39	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-c3 Ba8-c6 Rc1-a1 Na5-b7 Ra1-a6 Rf7-c7 Ra6-a8
     11	00:00	     893.090	2.413.756	-3.50	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-b5 Ba8-c6 Nb5-d6 Rf7-e7 Rh1-d1 Nf8-e6
     11	00:00	   1.380.334	2.421.638	-3.50	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-b5 Ba8-c6 Nb5-d6 Rf7-e7 Rh1-d1 Nf8-e6
     12	00:00	   1.725.241	2.537.119	-3.50	Bc8-b7 Qd8xa8 Bb7xa8 Nb1-a3 b5-b4 Na3-b5 Ba8-c6 Nb5-d6 Rf7-d7 Be3-c5 Nf8-e6 Bc5xb4 Ne6-d4
     12	00:00	   2.523.956	2.575.465	-3.00	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-e8 Qa8-c6 Nb1-d2 b5xc4 f3-f4 e5xf4 Rc1-c3 f4xg3
     12	00:01	   3.048.617	2.650.971	-3.06	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-b7 Kb2-a1 Qb7-b3 Be3-g1 Rd7-b7
     12	00:01	   3.749.689	2.659.353	-3.06	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-b7 Kb2-a1 Qb7-b3 Be3-g1 Rd7-b7
     13	00:01	   4.770.247	2.710.367	-3.00	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-g5 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Nf8-e6 Qg5-h4 Bg7-f8 Rc1-a1 Qa8-b8 Kb2-c1
     13	00:02	   6.297.572	2.738.074	-3.00	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-g5 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Nf8-e6 Qg5-h4 Bg7-f8 Rc1-a1 Qa8-b8 Kb2-c1
     14	00:03	   8.717.562	2.812.116	-2.70	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-a5 Nc3-d5 Qa5-b5 Kb2-c2 Qb5-b3 Kc2-d2 Qb3-d3 Kd2-e1 Rd7xd5 e4xd5 Qd3xe3 Ng3-e2 Bc8-a6 Rc1-d1
     14	00:04	  12.104.349	2.757.254	-2.70	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-a5 Nc3-d5 Qa5-b5 Kb2-c2 Qb5-b3 Kc2-d2 Qb3-d3 Kd2-e1 Rd7xd5 e4xd5 Qd3xe3 Ng3-e2 Bc8-a6 Rc1-d1
     15	00:05	  14.521.082	2.797.896	-2.70	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-a5 Nc3-d5 Qa5-b5 Kb2-c2 Qb5-b3 Kc2-d2 Qb3-d3 Kd2-e1 Rd7xd5 e4xd5 Qd3xe3 Ng3-e2 Bc8-a6 Rc1-d1
     15	00:07	  20.974.412	2.792.864	-2.70	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-a5 Nc3-d5 Qa5-b5 Kb2-c2 Qb5-b3 Kc2-d2 Qb3-d3 Kd2-e1 Rd7xd5 e4xd5 Qd3xe3 Ng3-e2 Bc8-a6 Rc1-d1
     16	00:12	  35.599.455	2.966.621	-3.20	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-a5 Ng3-f1 Rd7-b7 Kb2-c2 g6-g5 Qh4xg5 h7-h6 Qg5-h4 Qa5-d5 e4xd5
     16	00:19	  55.754.802	2.934.463	-2.97	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-a5 Ng3-f1 g6-g5 Qh4-f2 Rd7-d3 Be3-c5 Bc8-e6 Bc5-a3
     16	00:19	  55.754.845	2.934.465	-2.97	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-a5 Ng3-f1 g6-g5 Qh4-f2 Rd7-d3 Be3-c5 Bc8-e6 Bc5-a3
     17	00:26	  76.014.659	2.923.640	-2.72	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Bc8-d7
     17	00:34	 102.217.793	2.920.508	-2.72	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Bc8-d7
     18	00:47	 140.895.020	2.997.766	-2.86	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 h7-h6 Nc3-d5
     18	01:05	 197.261.548	3.034.793	-2.86	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 h7-h6 Nc3-d5
     19	01:38	 298.444.548	3.045.352	-2.92	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Bc8-e6 Rh1-d1 Qd6-b4 Nc3-d5
     19	02:11	 403.325.823	3.078.823	-2.92	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Bc8-e6 Rh1-d1 Qd6-b4 Nc3-d5
     20	03:17	 611.575.476	3.104.444	-2.92	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Bc8-e6 Rh1-d1 Qd6-b4 Nc3-d5
     20	04:29	 838.819.610	3.106.739	-2.92	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Bc8-e6 Rh1-d1 Qd6-b4 Nc3-d5
     21	06:02	1.084.064.753	2.986.404	-2.92	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Qd6-b6 Rc2-a2 Qb6-d4 Ng3-e2 Qd4-f2
     21	08:17	1.512.729.020	3.043.720	-2.92	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Qd6-b6 Rc2-a2 Qb6-d4 Ng3-e2 Qd4-f2
     22	11:18	2.092.054.739	3.085.626	-2.90	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Qd6-a3 Ka1-b1 Qa3-b4 Kb1-c1 Qb4-e7 Kc1-d1 Qe7-g5 Ng3-f1
     22	16:27	1.207.902.627	-5.376	-2.90	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Qd6-a3 Ka1-b1 Qa3-b4 Kb1-c1 Qb4-e7 Kc1-d1 Qe7-g5 Ng3-f1
     23	23:35	 105.799.836	74.770	-2.90	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2 Qd6-a3
     23	35:10	1.978.691.933	-1.424	-2.90	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Bg7-f6 Qh4xf6 Qa8-b8 Kb2-a1 Rd7-d6 Qf6xf8 Kg8xf8 Be3-c5 Kf8-g7 Bc5xd6 Qb8xd6 Rc1-c2
     24	42:19	 618.057.882	-6.599	-2.40	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-b7 Kb2-a1 Qb7-b3 Ng3-f1 Rd7-d5 Qh4-f2 Rd5-a5 Nc3-a2 Bc8-e6 Rc1-b1 Qb3-a4 Be3-c1 c4-c3 Qf2-g1
     24	53:36	1.534.921.059	477.276	-2.50	Na5-c4 b3xc4 Rf7-d7 Qd8-h4 b5xc4 Nb1-c3 Qa8-b7 Kb2-a1 Qb7-b3 Ng3-f1 Rd7-d5 Qh4-f2 Rd5-a5 Nc3-a2 Bc8-e6 Nf1-g3 Ra5xa2 Qf2xa2 Qb3xe3 Ng3-e2 Bg7-f6 Rh1-d1 Bf6-e7 Rc1xc4 Be6xc4 Qa2xc4 Kg8-h8
   8/15/2008 8:51:41 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:06:42, Rated time: 00:00

1 of 1 matching moves
8/15/2008 8:51:42 AM, Total time: 7:48:20 AM
Rated time: 00:00 = 0 Seconds

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Analysis from Q:\epd\sub\tkb.epd   
8/15/2008 1:03:22 AM Level: 40 Seconds
Analyzing engine: Zappa

1) Nc4+; id "Timman-Kas 
    Searching move: Na5-c4
    Best move (Zappa): Na5-c4
    identical moves! Found in: 00:01
     9/29	00:01	     703.982	2.256.353	-1.74	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1xc4 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Bc8e6 Nb1d2 h7h6
     9/29	00:01	     777.811	2.267.671	-1.74	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Rc1xc4 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Bc8e6 Nb1d2 h7h6
    10/32	00:01	   1.534.887	2.588.342	-1.48	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Rd7b7 Qg5d8 Rb7b3
    10/32	00:01	   1.703.287	2.538.431	-1.48	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8g5 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Rd7b7 Qg5d8 Rb7b3
    11/42	00:02	   5.704.759	2.949.720	-1.06	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6
    11/42	00:02	   6.035.301	2.931.181	-1.06	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 Bc8e6
    12/42	00:03	   9.354.813	3.013.793	-1.17	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Qf2c2 Qb3a3 Ka1b1 Bc8e6
    12/42	00:03	  10.143.121	3.024.186	-1.17	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Qf2c2 Qb3a3 Ka1b1 Bc8e6
    13/42	00:05	  15.529.052	3.081.773	-1.17	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Qf2c2 Qb3a3 Ka1b1 Bc8e6
    13/42	00:05	  16.862.945	3.088.451	-1.17	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Qf2c2 Qb3a3 Ka1b1 Bc8e6
    14/46	00:08	  26.633.038	3.161.567	-1.17	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Qf2c2 Qb3a3 Ka1b1 Bc8e6
    14/46	00:09	  29.616.900	3.174.713	-1.17	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Qf2c2 Qb3a3 Ka1b1 Bc8e6
    15/49	00:19	  62.293.522	3.230.657	-1.06	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Nf1g3 Bc8e6 Rc1c2 Nf8d7 Rh1b1 Qb3c4 Qf2e2 Qc4a4
    15/49	00:21	  68.712.593	3.248.208	-1.06	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7b3 Ng3f1 Rd7d6 Qh4f2 Rd6a6+ Nc3a2 c4c3 Nf1g3 Bc8e6 Rc1c2 Nf8d7 Rh1b1 Qb3c4 Qf2e2 Qc4a4
    16/52	00:57	 180.135.510	3.179.292	-0.90	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bg7f6 Qh4h6 Nf8e6 Rc1c2 Ne6d4 Rc2f2 c4c3 Rh1b1 Rd7a7 Be3xd4 e5xd4 Rb1b8
    16/52	01:00	 193.452.725	3.199.364	-0.90	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bg7f6 Qh4h6 Nf8e6 Rc1c2 Ne6d4 Rc2f2 c4c3 Rh1b1 Rd7a7 Be3xd4 e5xd4 Rb1b8
    17/54	02:13	 425.524.822	3.203.047	-0.73	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bg7f6 Qh4h6 Nf8e6 Ng3h5 Bf6h8 Rc1c2 Ne6d4 Rc2f2 c4c3 Rh1b1 Rd7a7 Be3xd4 e5xd4
    17/54	02:20	 449.669.917	3.212.387	-0.73	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bg7f6 Qh4h6 Nf8e6 Ng3h5 Bf6h8 Rc1c2 Ne6d4 Rc2f2 c4c3 Rh1b1 Rd7a7 Be3xd4 e5xd4
    18/56	03:59	 758.121.977	3.166.560	-0.73	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bg7f6 Qh4h6 Nf8e6 Ng3h5 Bf6h8 Rc1c2 Ne6d4 Rc2f2 c4c3 Rh1b1 Rd7a7 Be3xd4 e5xd4
    18/56	04:13	 803.988.881	3.178.186	-0.73	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bg7f6 Qh4h6 Nf8e6 Ng3h5 Bf6h8 Rc1c2 Ne6d4 Rc2f2 c4c3 Rh1b1 Rd7a7 Be3xd4 e5xd4
    19/58	08:22	1.579.038.100	3.147.381	-0.73	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bg7f6 Qh4h6 Nf8e6 Ng3h5 Bf6h8 Rc1c2 Ne6d4 Rc2f2 c4c3 Rh1b1 Rd7a7 Be3xd4 e5xd4
    19/58	09:02	1.712.285.798	3.160.960	-0.73	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Nb1c3 Qa8b7+ Kb2a1 Qb7a6+ Nc3a2 Bg7f6 Qh4h6 Nf8e6 Ng3h5 Bf6h8 Rc1c2 Ne6d4 Rc2f2 c4c3 Rh1b1 Rd7a7 Be3xd4 e5xd4
    20/60	25:00	4.835.017,077	3.222.413	-0.52	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Qb1b3 Ng3e2 Bc8e6 Rc2c3 Qb3b1 Rc3c1 Qb1b4+ Ne2c3 Qb4b2+ Rc1c2 Qb2b3 Rc2c1 Qb3b2+
    20/60	26:19	5.103.525,025	3.232.423	-0.52	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Qb1b3 Ng3e2 Bc8e6 Rc2c3 Qb3b1 Rc3c1 Qb1b4+ Ne2c3 Qb4b2+ Rc1c2 Qb2b3 Rc2c1 Qb3b2+
    21/62	49:58	9.728.269,389	3.245.463	-0.55	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Qb1b3 Ng3e2 Bc8e6 Rc2c3 Qb3b1 Rc3c1 Qb1b4+ Ne2c3 Qb4b2+ Rc1c2 Qb2b3 Rc2a2 Be6d7 Qd8b6 Bg7h6 Qb6xb3
    21/62	52:38	10.264.137,067	3.250.692	-0.55	Na5c4+ b3xc4 Rf7d7 Qd8h4 b5xc4 Rc1c2 Rd7b7+ Kb2c1 Qa8a1 Kc1d2 Rb7xb1 Rh1xb1 Qa1xb1 Qh4d8 Qb1b3 Ng3e2 Bc8e6 Rc2c3 Qb3b1 Rc3c1 Qb1b4+ Ne2c3 Qb4b2+ Rc1c2 Qb2b3 Rc2a2 Be6d7 Qd8b6 Bg7h6 Qb6xb3
   8/15/2008 9:58:29 AM, Time for this analysis: 01:06:40, Rated time: 00:01

1 of 1 matching moves
8/15/2008 9:58:30 AM, Total time: 8:55:08 AM
Rated time: 00:01 = 1 Seconds
Top

Return to “Computer Chess Club: General Topics”