We don't....Henk wrote:How do we know Houdini, Komodo and Gull are not small variations on all Stockfish ideas ?Sedat Canbaz wrote:So we need to test only the first chess program, right ) ?Henk wrote:I don't. Forget about originality. I don't know a fast car with original triangular wheels. Perhaps only the first chess programs ever were original.Sedat Canbaz wrote:As I mentioned before ,Henk wrote:It's fun to see all those tournaments where Ippolit plays against itself.
I don't see Glaurung in your new picture.
In my eyes: all these top chess engines are original wok (exception Ippolit) and we can't say for the mentioned engines: Ippolit (Rybkanian) family
But what I want to say with the current published picture,
All top chess engines are learned/studied from each other....but they also include a lot of own ideas as well !
That's why they play a lot of stronger... and we should count them as original work...!!
Only thing that counts is whether it is legal or not. I mean copying or using ideas of others.
And I wonder, which one is the 1st chess engine ?
But however,
There is one problem: I am afraid that we will not be able to find 100 % original opponent for the 1st chess program )))
Plus, I have serious doubts about that,
The first 100% original chess program will not work on latest decent PC systems ))!!
Dr.D