Indeed - 50 games isn't enough to draw that conclusion. We can only say that they seem to be pretty well matched.S.Taylor wrote: Thanks!
Now regarding the results, I cannot conclude that either is better.
Komodo 9.01 64-bit 8CPU v Stockfish 110515 64-bit 8CPU (FRC)
Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw
-
- Posts: 3557
- Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:02 pm
Re: Game 50 - a similarly tedious draw. Komodo wins match 7-
-
- Posts: 8514
- Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 3:25 am
- Location: Jerusalem Israel
Re: Game 50 - a similarly tedious draw. Komodo wins match 7-
Indeed. And this boils down to what most experts are saying for many years already, and i myself am already familiar with, from watching games happen and therefore agree.Modern Times wrote:Indeed - 50 games isn't enough to draw that conclusion. We can only say that they seem to be pretty well matched.S.Taylor wrote: Thanks!
Now regarding the results, I cannot conclude that either is better.
But my extra thoughts, hardly does anyone ever comment on.
-
- Posts: 786
- Joined: Sun Apr 16, 2006 9:09 pm
Re: Game 50 - a similarly tedious draw. Komodo wins match 7-
Thanks for this great test, Graham.
Your score after 50 games is roughly consistent with mine, also at long time control. (Although not as long as yours). Both using 8 cores.
Yours:
KOMODO 9.01 - STOCKFISH 110515 26.0 - 24.0 52.00%
Mine:
KOMODO 9.01 - STOCKFISH 230415 BULLET 104.5 – 95.5 52.25%
Kind regards from Barcelona,
Tom.
Your score after 50 games is roughly consistent with mine, also at long time control. (Although not as long as yours). Both using 8 cores.
Yours:
KOMODO 9.01 - STOCKFISH 110515 26.0 - 24.0 52.00%
Mine:
KOMODO 9.01 - STOCKFISH 230415 BULLET 104.5 – 95.5 52.25%
Kind regards from Barcelona,
Tom.
-
- Posts: 41651
- Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2006 10:52 am
- Location: Auckland, NZ
Re: Game 50 - a similarly tedious draw. Komodo wins match 7-
Hi Tom,Tomcass wrote:Thanks for this great test, Graham.
Your score after 50 games is roughly consistent with mine, also at long time control. (Although not as long as yours). Both using 8 cores.
Yours:
KOMODO 9.01 - STOCKFISH 110515 26.0 - 24.0 52.00%
Mine:
KOMODO 9.01 - STOCKFISH 230415 BULLET 104.5 – 95.5 52.25%
Kind regards from Barcelona,
Tom.
Thanks for your efforts too. Always follow your results.
Komodo seems to be edging out Stockfish more often in these matches at present.
I see that Hurnavich (Rybka forum) ran a 100 game match at long time controls and Komodo won by 5 points or so there too.
The Stockfish team have their work cut out.
Regards,
Graham.
gbanksnz at gmail.com