I made a test match between Stockfish 12 (201218) avx2 and ShahsChess 15.1 avx2
My system is
-OS Win10 x64
-RAM 32 GB
-CPU Ryzen 9 3950x 16 x 4.0 GHz
Test params
-Tablebases 6 men syzygy + 5 men Nalimov (only for GUI)
-TC 1min + 2 sec / move
-Opening positions 50 covering the chess opening repertoire
-Games 2 x 50 games with alternated colors.
The result is
SF+NNUE PO 201218syz avx2 : ShahsChess 15.1 avx2 = 20 : 0 (80 draw) 100 games
ShahsChess also used 6 men syxygy
Disillusioning!
You can download the pgn from
wikisend.com
File ID: 392544
Passw: shash
(Where is my original post??)
Stockfish 12dev against ShashChess 15.1
Moderators: hgm, Dann Corbit, Harvey Williamson
-
corres
- Posts: 3657
- Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2015 11:41 am
- Location: hungary
-
Guenther
- Posts: 4586
- Joined: Wed Oct 01, 2008 6:33 am
- Location: Regensburg, Germany
- Full name: Guenther Simon
Re: Stockfish 12dev against ShashChess 15.1
A few remarks. I cannot imagine that the avx2 version of ShashChess 15.1 (Mid October - closest to SF 20101419) is 20 times slower than current SF dev avx2? Can someone do a speedtest for SF dev 20121821 avx2 vs. SF dev 20101419 avx2? Or did you use somehow a smaller non-default net for SF?corres wrote: ↑Tue Dec 29, 2020 10:53 am I made a test match between Stockfish 12 (201218) avx2 and ShahsChess 15.1 avx2
My system is
-OS Win10 x64
-RAM 32 GB
-CPU Ryzen 9 3950x 16 x 4.0 GHz
Test params
-Tablebases 6 men syzygy + 5 men Nalimov (only for GUI)
-TC 1min + 2 sec / move
-Opening positions 50 covering the chess opening repertoire
-Games 2 x 50 games with alternated colors.
The result is
SF+NNUE PO 201218syz avx2 : ShahsChess 15.1 avx2 = 20 : 0 (80 draw) 100 games
ShahsChess also used 6 men syxygy
Disillusioning!
...
I just wanna know how to explain the speed difference shown in your games, which must be the main reason for the result.
I compared SF dev for ssse3 and there sure is a speedup of 20% with current SF dev, but 20 times?? for avx2 seems strange, I know they improved
the speed of nnue usage a lot, but surely not by this?
May be the used GUI had a problem with calculating the speed in kn/s(?), but the average depths in your games for ShashChess are also between 7 and 15! plies behind.
Here is a grep from the infos in the beginning of your games (added as a Specs tag for complying to various tools - also for the plotter)
Code: Select all
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/11: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=53.1 ply; 40.005kN/s; 4.526. 217 TBAs; B=40.3 ply; 1.892kN/s; 557.228 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/139: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.3 ply; 1.381kN/s; 1.026 TBAs; B=37.7 ply; 27.358kN/s; 121.500 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/174: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=45.2 ply; 28.784kN/s; 13.743 TBAs; B=33.5 ply; 1.424kN/s; 37 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/294: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.3 ply; 1.434kN/s; 1.368 TBAs; B=41.4 ply; 27.959kN/s; 404.534 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/336: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=31.4 ply; 30.559kN/s; 6.906. 381 TBAs; B=24.3 ply; 1.431kN/s; 709.566 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/419: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.5 ply; 1.452kN/s; 128.719 TBAs; B=42.7 ply; 27.836kN/s; 5.295.535 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/471: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=40.8 ply; 41.681kN/s; 27.683. 829 TBAs; B=29.4 ply; 1.755kN/s; 1.128.006 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/549: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=25.7 ply; 1.392kN/s; 126 TBAs; B=36.5 ply; 28.397kN/s; 140.980 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/594: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=46.2 ply; 29.918kN/s; 15.077. 374 TBAs; B=29.5 ply; 1.499kN/s; 459.113 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/651: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=26.5 ply; 1.381kN/s; 87 TBAs; B=37.4 ply; 26.895kN/s; 27.812 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/685: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=40.2 ply; 28.497kN/s; 152.830 TBAs; B=27.0 ply; 1.390kN/s; 7.711 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/724: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.1 ply; 1.366kN/s; 3 TBAs; B=36.3 ply; 27.293kN/s; 8.728 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/768: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=37.6 ply; 28.423kN/s; 6.779. 866 TBAs; B=25.7 ply; 1.434kN/s; 210.137 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/825: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.1 ply; 1.425kN/s; 5.504 TBAs; B=42.0 ply; 25.174kN/s; 2.125.682 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/869: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=43.7 ply; 31.335kN/s; 6.221. 636 TBAs; B=29.7 ply; 1.496kN/s; 330.344 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/916: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=30.5 ply; 1.454kN/s; 214 TBAs; B=43.5 ply; 29.586kN/s; 72.918 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1010: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=39.6 ply; 39.098kN/s; 78.303. 485 TBAs; B=26.6 ply; 1.544kN/s; 2.350.088 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1113: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.1 ply; 1.389kN/s; 25.975 TBAs; B=42.3 ply; 28.181kN/s; 3.511.557 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1157: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=42.6 ply; 30.990kN/s; 1.436. 583 TBAs; B=29.8 ply; 1.471kN/s; 47.192 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1223: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.2 ply; 1.423kN/s; 1.536 TBAs; B=37.7 ply; 27.583kN/s; 439.599 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1265: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=42.8 ply; 27.645kN/s; 31.318 TBAs; B=26.9 ply; 1.419kN/s; 21 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1309: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.8 ply; 1.409kN/s; 30 TBAs; B=40.9 ply; 27.690kN/s; 25.729 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1347: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=40.5 ply; 33.940kN/s; 7.545. 057 TBAs; B=27.8 ply; 1.556kN/s; 190.067 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1408: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.1 ply; 1.403kN/s B=38.0 ply; 26.756kN/s; 68 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1436: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=41.1 ply; 30.161kN/s; 2.872. 577 TBAs; B=27.3 ply; 1.501kN/s; 38.681 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1486: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=35.2 ply; 1.680kN/s; 968.468 TBAs; B=50.8 ply; 35.824kN/s; 20.923.736 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1562: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=46.3 ply; 31.912kN/s; 16.919. 537 TBAs; B=29.7 ply; 1.530kN/s; 803.751 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1676: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=25.5 ply; 1.328kN/s B=33.5 ply; 26.594kN/s; 1.537 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1725: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=43.0 ply; 29.861kN/s; 1.500. 566 TBAs; B=29.5 ply; 1.516kN/s; 18.861 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1773: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=30.8 ply; 1.520kN/s; 2.136 TBAs; B=45.5 ply; 27.590kN/s; 139.959 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1808: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=46.8 ply; 34.129kN/s; 28.567. 720 TBAs; B=30.2 ply; 1.545kN/s; 955.019 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1881: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.9 ply; 1.534kN/s; 29.480 TBAs; B=41.6 ply; 31.503kN/s; 3.209.064 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1927: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=41.9 ply; 31.171kN/s; 16.420. 262 TBAs; B=28.1 ply; 1.509kN/s; 776.091 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/1992: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.6 ply; 1.343kN/s B=34.9 ply; 27.162kN/s; 1.206 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2021: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=41.4 ply; 31.262kN/s; 2.474. 026 TBAs; B=28.3 ply; 1.505kN/s; 61.685 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2072: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=31.2 ply; 1.529kN/s; 417.719 TBAs; B=48.3 ply; 32.616kN/s; 10.283.410 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2121: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=33.6 ply; 35.044kN/s; 36.446. 109 TBAs; B=25.6 ply; 1.494kN/s; 647.002 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2192: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.1 ply; 1.394kN/s; 6.207 TBAs; B=36.9 ply; 28.375kN/s; 209.646 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2235: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=40.8 ply; 31.559kN/s; 1.966. 847 TBAs; B=28.0 ply; 1.470kN/s; 66.049 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2290: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.8 ply; 1.471kN/s; 47.094 TBAs; B=43.6 ply; 31.046kN/s; 4.225.285 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2335: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=44.8 ply; 31.136kN/s; 2.883. 848 TBAs; B=28.2 ply; 1.543kN/s; 12.810 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2377: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=24.7 ply; 1.520kN/s; 325.756 TBAs; B=33.3 ply; 35.457kN/s; 4.418.047 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2440: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=35.1 ply; 36.277kN/s; 6.630. 211 TBAs; B=25.8 ply; 1.534kN/s; 675.254 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2516: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=24.9 ply; 1.505kN/s; 683.204 TBAs; B=33.2 ply; 33.100kN/s; 9.467.901 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2600: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=34.6 ply; 34.751kN/s; 5.097. 020 TBAs; B=25.9 ply; 1.520kN/s; 456.839 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2667: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.4 ply; 1.573kN/s; 836.034 TBAs; B=43.2 ply; 31.865kN/s; 18.889.454 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2727: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=33.4 ply; 27.554kN/s; 5.193. 043 TBAs; B=24.0 ply; 1.379kN/s; 150.956 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2852: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.5 ply; 1.420kN/s; 2.279 TBAs; B=37.1 ply; 27.865kN/s; 565.827 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2899: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=42.3 ply; 29.957kN/s; 9.472. 019 TBAs; B=28.0 ply; 1.417kN/s; 248.438 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/2951: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.0 ply; 1.419kN/s; 31.358 TBAs; B=48.4 ply; 29.013kN/s; 1.821.430 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3004: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=39.6 ply; 31.572kN/s; 11.978. 429 TBAs; B=28.8 ply; 1.466kN/s; 419.293 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3079: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.7 ply; 1.459kN/s; 1.427 TBAs; B=41.2 ply; 31.131kN/s; 785.808 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3140: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=35.2 ply; 35.195kN/s; 45.354. 384 TBAs; B=25.3 ply; 1.578kN/s; 2.135.318 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3220: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.6 ply; 1.490kN/s; 18.083 TBAs; B=45.1 ply; 31.395kN/s; 2.906.470 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3261: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=33.8 ply; 38.483kN/s; 73.244. 267 TBAs; B=24.0 ply; 1.489kN/s; 484.521 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3331: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=26.0 ply; 1.500kN/s; 294.836 TBAs; B=40.4 ply; 30.557kN/s; 19.934.160 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3395: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=38.3 ply; 27.816kN/s; 1.930. 450 TBAs; B=27.0 ply; 1.413kN/s; 34.910 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3444: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=26.5 ply; 1.402kN/s; 10.522 TBAs; B=39.3 ply; 28.782kN/s; 1.241.899 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3492: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=48.5 ply; 30.631kN/s; 10.450. 495 TBAs; B=30.6 ply; 1.509kN/s; 211.656 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3553: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=30.1 ply; 1.429kN/s; 10.288 TBAs; B=42.0 ply; 28.323kN/s; 382.967 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3589: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=51.0 ply; 35.113kN/s; 25.282. 725 TBAs; B=31.8 ply; 1.566kN/s; 592.495 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3667: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.3 ply; 1.410kN/s; 75 TBAs; B=42.2 ply; 28.835kN/s; 189.933 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3705: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=33.6 ply; 34.812kN/s; 8.300. 366 TBAs; B=24.6 ply; 1.506kN/s; 551.852 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3774: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.4 ply; 1.444kN/s; 53 TBAs; B=38.4 ply; 28.447kN/s; 40.987 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3814: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=45.0 ply; 30.223kN/s; 236. 874 TBAs; B=32.5 ply; 1.487kN/s; 2.357 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3942: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.5 ply; 1.443kN/s; 9.049 TBAs; B=41.4 ply; 29.389kN/s; 321.573 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/3996: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=62.2 ply; 48.241kN/s; 5.936. 727 TBAs; B=50.7 ply; 2.215kN/s; 1.740.451 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4123: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.2 ply; 1.436kN/s; 68 TBAs; B=39.5 ply; 29.354kN/s; 90.446 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4179: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=32.2 ply; 33.501kN/s; 2.978. 517 TBAs; B=25.1 ply; 1.632kN/s; 283.480 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4248: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=31.3 ply; 1.571kN/s; 232.280 TBAs; B=49.0 ply; 34.854kN/s; 11.010.904 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4295: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=39.9 ply; 39.416kN/s; 35.928. 595 TBAs; B=27.8 ply; 1.661kN/s; 1.082.397 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4362: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.0 ply; 1.490kN/s; 34.066 TBAs; B=42.6 ply; 29.540kN/s; 4.716.768 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4404: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=34.3 ply; 32.044kN/s; 1.133. 309 TBAs; B=23.7 ply; 1.471kN/s; 43.389 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4484: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=24.8 ply; 1.474kN/s; 128 TBAs; B=37.7 ply; 31.978kN/s; 49.464 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4542: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=41.9 ply; 28.543kN/s; 6.481. 265 TBAs; B=27.8 ply; 1.443kN/s; 144.170 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4600: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.0 ply; 1.410kN/s; 172.809 TBAs; B=44.4 ply; 28.145kN/s; 10.893.799 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4654: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=32.6 ply; 31.190kN/s; 6.718. 454 TBAs; B=25.1 ply; 1.493kN/s; 474.482 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4725: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=25.8 ply; 1.465kN/s; 39.971 TBAs; B=37.1 ply; 27.979kN/s; 3.233.152 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4770: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=37.3 ply; 29.125kN/s; 548. 736 TBAs; B=26.7 ply; 1.426kN/s; 3.849 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4829: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.8 ply; 1.437kN/s; 186.853 TBAs; B=44.7 ply; 28.016kN/s; 6.436.615 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4875: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.6 ply; 29.589kN/s; 680. 665 TBAs; B=22.8 ply; 1.383kN/s; 31.196 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/4933: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=23.5 ply; 1.386kN/s; 280.087 TBAs; B=35.0 ply; 27.287kN/s; 16.674.668 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5000: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=39.4 ply; 30.870kN/s; 5.450. 999 TBAs; B=27.7 ply; 1.571kN/s; 280.701 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5063: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=29.3 ply; 1.431kN/s; 182 TBAs; B=42.6 ply; 29.263kN/s; 135.447 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5107: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=40.0 ply; 28.274kN/s; 1.522. 432 TBAs; B=25.3 ply; 1.398kN/s; 29.722 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5181: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=32.2 ply; 1.549kN/s; 318.318 TBAs; B=53.3 ply; 34.288kN/s; 18.100.880 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5235: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=48.7 ply; 33.284kN/s; 3.889. 975 TBAs; B=33.9 ply; 1.498kN/s; 23.252 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5288: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.8 ply; 1.423kN/s; 191 TBAs; B=41.2 ply; 27.944kN/s; 73.854 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5332: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=36.8 ply; 28.411kN/s; 1.339. 733 TBAs; B=27.8 ply; 1.428kN/s; 58.208 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5393: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.3 ply; 1.379kN/s; 7 TBAs; B=41.1 ply; 27.760kN/s; 9.668 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5424: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=39.1 ply; 28.136kN/s; 268. 648 TBAs; B=27.5 ply; 1.454kN/s; 2.493 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5461: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.9 ply; 1.426kN/s; 526 TBAs; B=41.5 ply; 28.725kN/s; 476.221 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5522: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=43.9 ply; 30.627kN/s; 549. 994 TBAs; B=29.8 ply; 1.473kN/s; 1.960 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5618: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=27.2 ply; 1.388kN/s; 62 TBAs; B=37.9 ply; 28.477kN/s; 20.074 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5660: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=34.2 ply; 31.153kN/s; 32.394. 770 TBAs; B=24.4 ply; 1.492kN/s; 420.658 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5740: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=38.2 ply; 1.479kN/s; 2.049 TBAs; B=51.0 ply; 31.305kN/s; 314.293 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5827: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=41.4 ply; 26.535kN/s; 26 TBAs; B=28.5 ply; 1.286kN/s"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5853: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=28.9 ply; 1.500kN/s; 3.193 TBAs; B=41.2 ply; 31.753kN/s; 1.235.646 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5898: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=44.4 ply; 31.027kN/s; 6.777. 280 TBAs; B=29.5 ply; 1.514kN/s; 122.298 TBAs"]
C:\ChessTools\QualityControl\Plot_PGN\PGN\corres.pgn/5959: [Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=25.3 ply; 1.540kN/s; 27.921 TBAs; B=34.9 ply; 34.067kN/s; 196.449 TBAs"]39...b4?? loses on the spot
I filled the hash of ShashChess (sse3 only because of my hardware) with feeding the pgn until the move before the blunder move
and in fact it first wants to play b4 for some time but it changes mind long before depth 40 (game) to a4! which seems to draw.
(the debug below has file high/low stats line removed for readability)
Edit: This was w/o tablebases at all
Code: Select all
StartChildProcess (dir="") UCI2WB ShashChess_151-64 C:\Engines\UCI\ShashChess_151-64
...
75094 >first : usermove 75095 >first : g3g4
75106 <first : 33 50 420 1803597 g3g4 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7g3 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 g3e1 e4f5 e1d2 f5f6 d6d7 f6e5 d7e7 f3e4 d2c3 e5f5 c3d2 e4g2 e7d7 g2h1 d7e7 f5g6 e7d6 g6f6 d6d7 f6f7 d7d6 f7g6 d6e5 h1f3 e5d6 g6f5 d6d7 b3b4 d2b4 f5g5 d7e7 g5g6 b4d2 g4g5
75111 <first : 33 0 0 0 NNUE evaluation using nn-04cf2b4ed1da.nnue enabled
75114 <first : 1 -52 0 42 c7g3
75118 <first : 2 -52 0 57 c7g3 e2d3
75119 <first : 3 -58 0 145 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3
75120 <first : 4 -58 0 177 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3
75122 <first : 5 -50 0 270 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3
75123 <first : 6 -58 0 395 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7g3
75124 <first : 7 -58 0 473 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7g3 c3d3
75126 <first : 8 -58 0 820 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7f4 c3d3 c5b4 d3d4 b4b3
75127 <first : 9 -58 0 1595 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2
75129 <first : 10 -58 0 2465 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 d6b4 c3b4 a3b4 c6d7 b4c5
75131 <first : 11 -60 0 4789 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 d6b4 c3b4 a3b4 c6d7 b4c5 c2b2 c5b4 d7e8 b4c5
75136 <first : 12 -61 0 6313 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 d6b4 c3b4 a3b4 c6d7 b4c5 c2b2 c5b4 d7e8 a4a3 b2a2 b4a4 e8d7
75139 <first : 13 -59 1 13550 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7f4 c3d3 f4c1 b3b4 c5b4 d5d6 c1f4 d6d7 f4c7
75140 <first : 14 -52 2 15970 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f3h1 d7e7 f5g6 e7d7
75142 <first : 15 -53 2 16705 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f3h1 d7e7 f5g6 e7d7 g6f7 d2c3 h1e4 d7d6
75144 <first : 16 -50 2 19406 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f3h1 d7e7 f5g6 e7d7 g6f6 d7d6 h1f3 d6d7 f6f5 d7d6 f5e4
75147 <first : 17 -51 3 22459 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f3e2 d7d6 e2c4 d2f4 b3b4 f4d2 b4b5
75149 <first : 18 -50 3 24213 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2b4 f3h1 b4d2 e5d4 d7d6 d4d3 d2e1 d3e4 e1d2 h1f3
75151 <first : 19 -50 4 31299 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 f5e5 e7d7 e5d4 d7d6 d4d3
75154 <first : 20 -50 5 37261 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 f5e5 e7d7 e5d4 d7d6 d4d3 d2e1 d3e4 e1b4
75167 <first : 21 -47 7 54303 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 b3b4 d2b4 f5g5 e7d7 h1f3 b4d2 g5f5 d2c3 g4g5 c3b2
75183 <first : 22 -49 8 67890 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 f5g6 e7d7 g6f6 d7d6 h1e4 d6d7 e4f5 d7d6 f5e6 d2c1 b3b4 c1d2
75197 <first : 23 -47 10 81129 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 f5g6 e7d7 g6f6 d7d6 h1e4 d6d7 e4f5 d7d6 f5e6 d2c1 b3b4 c1d2 b4b5 d6c5 f6e7
75240 <first : 24 -47 14 111981 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3e1 f3h1 e1d2 e4d3 d2e1 h1g2 d7d6 d3e4 e1c3 e4f5 c3d2 f5f6 d6d7 f6e5 d2c3 e5f5 c3d2
75260 <first : 25 -47 16 128295 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3e1 f3h1 e1d2 e4d3 d2e1 h1g2 d7d6 d3e4 e1c3 e4f5 c3d2 f5f6 d6d7 f6e5 d2c3 e5f5 c3d2 g2f3 d7d6
75283 <first : 26 -47 18 147630 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3e1 f3h1 e1d2 e4d3 d2b4 d3d4 d7d6 d4e4 b4d2 h1f3 d2a5 e4d3 d6d7 d3d4 a5d2 d4c4 d7d6
75341 <first : 27 -46 24 187969 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3e1 f3h1 e1d2 e4d3 d2b4 d3d4 d7d6 d4e4 b4d2 e4f5 d6e7 h1g2 e7d6 f5f6 d6d7 g2h1 d7d6 h1e4
75556 <first : 28 -53 46 303352 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5e1 e4f5 e1d2 f5f6 d6d7 f3h1 d7d6 h1g2 d6d7 f6e5 d7e7 g2f3 d2c3 e5f5 c3d2 f3e2 e7d6 e2c4 d2c1 b3b4 c1d2 b4b5 d2f4 b5b6
78242 <first : 29 -90 314 1406547 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 d6f4 c6b5 f4e5 b5d7 e5f4 d7c6 f4c7 c6f3 a3a2 f3e2 a2a3 e2d3 c7b6 d3b5 b6c7 b5e2 c7f4 e2d1 f4e5 b4b5 e5c7
79291 <first : 30 -67 419 1901497 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 b4b5
84177 <first : 31 -110 908 3735201 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 a4b5 e5d6 f7e8 d6d5 b5a6 d5c6 b4b5 c6c5 e8f7 c5d6
84836 <first : 32 -97 974 4067891 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 a4b5
85625 <first : 33 -85 1053 4461365 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 a4b5 e5d6 f7e8 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7
87293 <first : 34 -80 1219 5154789 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 a4b5 e5d6 f7e8 d6c7 b5a6 d8f6 a6a5 f6d4 a5b5 d4f6 b5a6 f6d4
91689 <first : 35 -87 1659 6962316 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5a6 d8f6 a6a5 f6d4 a5b5 d4f6 b5c4 f6e7
94519 <first : 36 -51 1942 8183387 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 d5d6 a3b3 e5d5 b3c3 d5c6 b6d4 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a4 c3d4 d5f7 d4e5 a4a3 e5d6 f7e8 d6c7 a3a4 c7b6 a4b3 f6d8 b3c4 b6c6 c4c3 c6c7 c3d4 d8e7 d4c4 e7f6
98069 <first : 37 -44 2297 9735619 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 d5d6 a3b3 e5d5 b3c3 d5c6 b6d4 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 d5e6 f6d8 e6a2 d8e7 a2f7 e7d8 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 e7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5a6 d8e7 a6a5 e7f6 a5a4 c7b6
102649 <first : 38 -44 2755 11710095 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 d5d6 a3b3 e5d5 b3c3 d5c6 b6d4 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 d5e6 f6d8 e6f7 d8f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 e7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 a5a4
110708 <first : 39 -36 3561 15164253 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4f6 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5b5 c7d8 f7d5 d8f6 d5e6 f6d8 e6f7 d8e7 b5a4 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 a5a4
114386 <first : 40 -36 3929 16430778 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4f6 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5b5 c7d8 f7d5 d8f6 d5e6 f6d8 e6f7 d8e7 b5a4 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 a5a4 c7d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5a5 f6e7
117902 <first : 41 -44 4280 18094092 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 b4b5 f6d4
123946 <first : 42 -36 4885 20854621 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 a5a4 f6d8 b4b5 c7d6 a4b4 d8b6
136299 <first : 43 -35 6120 25951777 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7c4 e5d6 c4b5 d6e6 a4b3 e6d5 b5a4 d8f6 b3a3 d5e5 a4b5 e5d6 a3b3 d6d5 b5a4 f6d8 b3a3 d5d6
140211 <first : 44 -35 6511 27935018 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7c4 e5d6 c4b5 d6e6 a4b3 e6d5 b5a4 d8f6 b3a3 d5e5 a4c6 e5d6 c6b5 f6d8 b5a4 d6d5 a4c2 d5c6 c2f5 d8e7 a3a4 e7d8[Site "?"]
[Date "2020.07.21"]
[Round "7"]
[White "SF+NNUE PO 201218syz avx2"]
[Black "ShashChess 15.1"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B63"]
[Annotator "0.51;0.46"]
[PlyCount "127"]
[Specs "AMDRyzen 9 3950X 16-Core Processor. W=40.8 ply; 41.681kN/s; 27.683. 829 TBAs; B=29.4 ply; 1.755kN/s; 1.128.006 TBAs"]
1. e4 {book} c5 {book}
2. Nf3 {book} d6 {book}
3. d4 {book} cxd4 {book}
4. Nxd4 {book} Nf6 {book}
5. Nc3 {book} Nc6 {book}
6. Bg5 {book} e6 {0.46/23 5}
7. Qd2 {0.51/30 5} Be7 {0.51/22 2}
8. O-O-O {0.70/29 2} Nxd4 {0.46/23 2}
9. Qxd4 {0.68/28 2} O-O {0.34/24 4}
10. h4 {0.54/30 4} Bd7 {0.29/19 2}
11. Kb1 {0.63/29 4} a6 {0.51/26 15}
12. f3 {0.65/33 11} b5 {0.47/24 2}
13. Bxf6 {0.57/33 3} Bxf6 {0.41/27 4}
14. Qxd6 {0.74/31 2} Be8 {0.71/28 10}
15. Qxd8 {0.63/32 3} Bxd8 {0.69/25 1}
16. a3 {0.67/32 2} Bf6 {0.48/26 4}
17. Ne2 {0.76/34 11} h6 {0.75/27 7}
18. g3 {0.54/35 6} Bc6 {0.67/27 8}
19. c3 {0.60/33 1} Rfd8 {0.59/27 3}
20. Bg2 {0.49/37 10} Rxd1+ {0.55/24 1}
21. Rxd1 {0.54/36 1} Rd8 {0.58/25 2}
22. Kc2 {0.49/36 2} Rxd1 {0.67/25 3}
23. Kxd1 {0.40/35 4} Bd8 {0.76/28 7}
24. Nd4 {0.48/37 3} Bb7 {0.54/24 1}
25. Nb3 {0.45/38 3} Bb6 {0.49/28 8}
26. Ke2 {0.41/37 2} Kf8 {0.50/26 1}
27. f4 {0.41/36 2} Ke7 {0.47/26 3}
28. Bf3 {0.49/40 7} e5 {0.60/28 3}
29. Nc1 {0.41/41 2} f6 {0.62/28 2}
30. Nd3 {0.53/43 7} Kd6 {0.48/28 3}
31. fxe5+ {0.51/41 1} fxe5 {0.48/29 2}
32. Nb4 {0.58/44 2} a5 {0.42/26 2}
33. Nd5 {0.39/51 3} Bxd5 {0.50/26 3}
34. exd5 {0.47/55 3} g5 {0.37/29 4}
35. hxg5 {0.55/52 2} hxg5 {0.26/30 1}
36. b3 {1.28/45 2} e4 {0.34/32 2}
37. Bxe4 {0.55/65 5} Kc5 {0.61/37 11}
38. Bf3 {0.63/59 2} Bc7 {0.62/39 1}
39. g4 {0.63/67 2} b4 {0.68/38 2}
40. axb4+ {3.94/54 1} axb4 {0.87/40 1}
41. Kd3 {6.10/58 7} bxc3 {2.89/39 8}
42. Kxc3 {6.83/33 1} Bh2 {3.18/42 4}
43. Kd3 {6.83/42 1} Bf4 {3.36/27 3}
44. Ke4 {6.98/36 1} Kd6 {3.62/32 1}
45. Be2 {7.25/40 1} Bc1 {3.62/31 0}
46. Ba6 {11.78/41 9} Kc7 {3.70/32 0}
47. Ke5 {14.31/35 5} Bf4+ {3.75/34 1}
48. Ke6 {14.38/30 0} Bd6 {3.62/40 1}
49. Bb7 {16.77/35 3} Ba3 {6.00/34 2}
50. Bc6 {17.56/34 2} Bb4 {8.40/33 3}
51. Ba8 {19.49/34 2} Bd6 {9.74/29 5}
52. Kf6 {21.42/31 2} Bf4 {6.75/26 1}
53. b4 {23.51/32 2} Kd7 {6.09/26 1}
54. b5 {30.66/31 3} Be3 {14.68/29 6}
55. Bc6+ {41.78/31 3} Kd6 {14.68/22 1}
56. Kf5 {48.38/31 2} Ke7 {3.02/23 1}
57. Kg6 {65.15/41 1} Kd6 {17.10/24 2}
58. Kf6 {78.22/37 1} Kc5 {3.18/23 3}
59. Ke6 {91.63/33 0} Bf4 {23.57/21 2}
60. Be8 {152.52/32 1} Bc7 {5.48/22 3}
61. Bg6 {152.56/45 1} Bd8 {16.51/23 3}
62. d6 {152.59/29 1} Kxb5 {50.48/22 2}
63. Kd7 {+M29/51 3} Bb6 {152.62/26 1}
64. Kc8 {+M27/56 1}
1-0[/pgn]
-
Guenther
- Posts: 4586
- Joined: Wed Oct 01, 2008 6:33 am
- Location: Regensburg, Germany
- Full name: Guenther Simon
Re: Stockfish 12dev against ShashChess 15.1
Edit time was over, actually this was with Syzygy 5 men set for all engines in WB
Guenther wrote: ↑Tue Dec 29, 2020 2:36 pm...Code: Select all
StartChildProcess (dir="") UCI2WB ShashChess_151-64 C:\Engines\UCI\ShashChess_151-64 ... 75094 >first : usermove 75095 >first : g3g4 75106 <first : 33 50 420 1803597 g3g4 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7g3 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 g3e1 e4f5 e1d2 f5f6 d6d7 f6e5 d7e7 f3e4 d2c3 e5f5 c3d2 e4g2 e7d7 g2h1 d7e7 f5g6 e7d6 g6f6 d6d7 f6f7 d7d6 f7g6 d6e5 h1f3 e5d6 g6f5 d6d7 b3b4 d2b4 f5g5 d7e7 g5g6 b4d2 g4g5 75111 <first : 33 0 0 0 NNUE evaluation using nn-04cf2b4ed1da.nnue enabled 75114 <first : 1 -52 0 42 c7g3 75118 <first : 2 -52 0 57 c7g3 e2d3 75119 <first : 3 -58 0 145 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 75120 <first : 4 -58 0 177 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 75122 <first : 5 -50 0 270 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 75123 <first : 6 -58 0 395 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7g3 75124 <first : 7 -58 0 473 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7g3 c3d3 75126 <first : 8 -58 0 820 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7f4 c3d3 c5b4 d3d4 b4b3 75127 <first : 9 -58 0 1595 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 75129 <first : 10 -58 0 2465 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 d6b4 c3b4 a3b4 c6d7 b4c5 75131 <first : 11 -60 0 4789 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 d6b4 c3b4 a3b4 c6d7 b4c5 c2b2 c5b4 d7e8 b4c5 75136 <first : 12 -61 0 6313 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 d6b4 c3b4 a3b4 c6d7 b4c5 c2b2 c5b4 d7e8 a4a3 b2a2 b4a4 e8d7 75139 <first : 13 -59 1 13550 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7f4 c3d3 f4c1 b3b4 c5b4 d5d6 c1f4 d6d7 f4c7 75140 <first : 14 -52 2 15970 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f3h1 d7e7 f5g6 e7d7 75142 <first : 15 -53 2 16705 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f3h1 d7e7 f5g6 e7d7 g6f7 d2c3 h1e4 d7d6 75144 <first : 16 -50 2 19406 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f3h1 d7e7 f5g6 e7d7 g6f6 d7d6 h1f3 d6d7 f6f5 d7d6 f5e4 75147 <first : 17 -51 3 22459 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f3e2 d7d6 e2c4 d2f4 b3b4 f4d2 b4b5 75149 <first : 18 -50 3 24213 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2b4 f3h1 b4d2 e5d4 d7d6 d4d3 d2e1 d3e4 e1d2 h1f3 75151 <first : 19 -50 4 31299 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 f5e5 e7d7 e5d4 d7d6 d4d3 75154 <first : 20 -50 5 37261 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 f5e5 e7d7 e5d4 d7d6 d4d3 d2e1 d3e4 e1b4 75167 <first : 21 -47 7 54303 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 b3b4 d2b4 f5g5 e7d7 h1f3 b4d2 g5f5 d2c3 g4g5 c3b2 75183 <first : 22 -49 8 67890 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 f5g6 e7d7 g6f6 d7d6 h1e4 d6d7 e4f5 d7d6 f5e6 d2c1 b3b4 c1d2 75197 <first : 23 -47 10 81129 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3d2 e4f5 d7d6 f3h1 d6e7 f5g6 e7d7 g6f6 d7d6 h1e4 d6d7 e4f5 d7d6 f5e6 d2c1 b3b4 c1d2 b4b5 d6c5 f6e7 75240 <first : 24 -47 14 111981 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3e1 f3h1 e1d2 e4d3 d2e1 h1g2 d7d6 d3e4 e1c3 e4f5 c3d2 f5f6 d6d7 f6e5 d2c3 e5f5 c3d2 75260 <first : 25 -47 16 128295 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3e1 f3h1 e1d2 e4d3 d2e1 h1g2 d7d6 d3e4 e1c3 e4f5 c3d2 f5f6 d6d7 f6e5 d2c3 e5f5 c3d2 g2f3 d7d6 75283 <first : 26 -47 18 147630 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3e1 f3h1 e1d2 e4d3 d2b4 d3d4 d7d6 d4e4 b4d2 h1f3 d2a5 e4d3 d6d7 d3d4 a5d2 d4c4 d7d6 75341 <first : 27 -46 24 187969 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5d2 e4f5 d6d7 f5e5 d2c3 e5e4 c3e1 f3h1 e1d2 e4d3 d2b4 d3d4 d7d6 d4e4 b4d2 e4f5 d6e7 h1g2 e7d6 f5f6 d6d7 g2h1 d7d6 h1e4 75556 <first : 28 -53 46 303352 b5b4 a3b4 a5b4 e2d3 b4c3 d3c3 c7a5 c3d3 c5d6 d3e4 a5e1 e4f5 e1d2 f5f6 d6d7 f3h1 d7d6 h1g2 d6d7 f6e5 d7e7 g2f3 d2c3 e5f5 c3d2 f3e2 e7d6 e2c4 d2c1 b3b4 c1d2 b4b5 d2f4 b5b6 78242 <first : 29 -90 314 1406547 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 c7e5 d5d6 e5d6 f3c6 b3a3 d3c2 d6f4 c6b5 f4e5 b5d7 e5f4 d7c6 f4c7 c6f3 a3a2 f3e2 a2a3 e2d3 c7b6 d3b5 b6c7 b5e2 c7f4 e2d1 f4e5 b4b5 e5c7 79291 <first : 30 -67 419 1901497 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 b4b5 84177 <first : 31 -110 908 3735201 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 a4b5 e5d6 f7e8 d6d5 b5a6 d5c6 b4b5 c6c5 e8f7 c5d6 84836 <first : 32 -97 974 4067891 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 a4b5 85625 <first : 33 -85 1053 4461365 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 a4b5 e5d6 f7e8 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 87293 <first : 34 -80 1219 5154789 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 a4b5 e5d6 f7e8 d6c7 b5a6 d8f6 a6a5 f6d4 a5b5 d4f6 b5a6 f6d4 91689 <first : 35 -87 1659 6962316 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 b5a4 d4f6 a2f7 c3d4 a4b5 d4c3 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5a4 c7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5a6 d8f6 a6a5 f6d4 a5b5 d4f6 b5c4 f6e7 94519 <first : 36 -51 1942 8183387 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 d5d6 a3b3 e5d5 b3c3 d5c6 b6d4 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a4 c3d4 d5f7 d4e5 a4a3 e5d6 f7e8 d6c7 a3a4 c7b6 a4b3 f6d8 b3c4 b6c6 c4c3 c6c7 c3d4 d8e7 d4c4 e7f6 98069 <first : 37 -44 2297 9735619 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 d5d6 a3b3 e5d5 b3c3 d5c6 b6d4 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 d5e6 f6d8 e6a2 d8e7 a2f7 e7d8 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 e7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5a6 d8e7 a6a5 e7f6 a5a4 c7b6 102649 <first : 38 -44 2755 11710095 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 d5d6 a3b3 e5d5 b3c3 d5c6 b6d4 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 d5e6 f6d8 e6f7 d8f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 e7d8 a4a3 c3d4 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 a5a4 110708 <first : 39 -36 3561 15164253 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4f6 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5b5 c7d8 f7d5 d8f6 d5e6 f6d8 e6f7 d8e7 b5a4 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 a5a4 114386 <first : 40 -36 3929 16430778 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4f6 b5a5 f6e5 d6d7 e5c7 a5b5 c7d8 f7d5 d8f6 d5e6 f6d8 e6f7 d8e7 b5a4 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 a5a4 c7d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5a5 f6e7 117902 <first : 41 -44 4280 18094092 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 b4b5 f6d4 123946 <first : 42 -36 4885 20854621 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7e8 e5d6 a4b5 d6c7 b5c5 d8e7 c5c4 c7d6 c4b5 d6c7 b5a5 e7f6 a5a4 f6d8 b4b5 c7d6 a4b4 d8b6 136299 <first : 43 -35 6120 25951777 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7c4 e5d6 c4b5 d6e6 a4b3 e6d5 b5a4 d8f6 b3a3 d5e5 a4b5 e5d6 a3b3 d6d5 b5a4 f6d8 b3a3 d5d6 140211 <first : 44 -35 6511 27935018 a5a4 b3b4 c5c4 e2d2 c4b3 d2d3 b3b2 d3d4 c7b6 d4e5 b2a3 e5d6 a3b2 d6c6 b6d8 d5d6 b2c3 c6b5 a4a3 f3d5 d8f6 d5a2 f6d4 a2f7 d4e5 d6d7 e5f6 b5a5 f6d8 a5a4 c3b2 a4b5 b2c3 f7e6 d8f6 b5a4 f6e7 e6f7 c3d4 a4a3 e7d8 a3a4 d4e5 f7c4 e5d6 c4b5 d6e6 a4b3 e6d5 b5a4 d8f6 b3a3 d5e5 a4c6 e5d6 c6b5 f6d8 b5a4 d6d5 a4c2 d5c6 c2f5 d8e7 a3a4 e7d8