FGRL, 16 Cores vs RTX 2070 - 1. Stockfish 14.1, 50. SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8, 56. Koivisto 7.5, 67. Berserk 7 NN

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Dann Corbit, Harvey Williamson

fastgm
Posts: 818
Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 6:57 pm

FGRL, 16 Cores vs RTX 2070 - 1. Stockfish 14.1, 50. SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8, 56. Koivisto 7.5, 67. Berserk 7 NN

Post by fastgm »

New: 1. Stockfish 14.1, 50. SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8, 56. Koivisto 7.5, 67. Berserk 7 NN

Code: Select all

   # Engine                              :    Elo  Error   Games    Points    (%)      W      D      L     D(%)   CFS
 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1 Stockfish 14.1                      :   3565      8    2500    1431.5   57.26    385   2093     22   83.72    94
   2 Stockfish 14                        :   3557      7    2750    1551.5   56.42    391   2321     38   84.40   100
   3 Fat Fritz 2 (in SF)                 :   3543      6    4000    2265.0   56.63    626   3278     96   81.95    80
   4 Stockfish 210131                    :   3539      7    2500    1363.5   54.54    289   2149     62   85.96    66
   5 Dragon by Komodo Chess 2.5          :   3537      7    2500    1335.5   53.42    257   2157     86   86.28    55
   6 Stockfish 13                        :   3536      7    3750    2097.5   55.93    542   3111     97   82.96   100
   7 Lc0 0.28.0 610062                   :   3518      6    5000    3254.0   65.08   1711   3086    203   61.72    57
   8 Stockfish 12                        :   3518      5    5750    3190.5   55.49    880   4621    249   80.37    64
   9 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J94-80            :   3516      6    6000    4333.5   72.22   2848   2971    181   49.52    51
  10 Lc0 0.27.0 68864                    :   3516      5    8750    5979.5   68.34   3525   4909    316   56.10    59
  11 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J94-130           :   3515      5   11750    8207.0   69.85   5044   6326    380   53.84    57
  12 Lc0 0.27.0 68550                    :   3515      5    9250    6405.5   69.25   3859   5093    298   55.06    71
  13 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J98.1-16          :   3513      4   12000    8379.0   69.83   5150   6458    392   53.82    70
  14 Lc0 0.26.3 66625                    :   3511      4   12000    8359.0   69.66   5128   6462    410   53.85    62
  15 Lc0 0.26.3 66750                    :   3510      4   12000    8347.5   69.56   5104   6487    409   54.06    65
  16 Lc0 0.26.3 67630                    :   3509      5   11000    7664.5   69.68   4734   5861    405   53.28    59
  17 Lc0 0.27.0 67890                    :   3509      5   10250    7118.5   69.45   4363   5511    376   53.77    62
  18 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J92-260           :   3507      7    5250    3756.5   71.55   2472   2569    209   48.93    55
  19 Stockfish 200813 82215d0fd0df       :   3507      8    2500    1477.5   59.10    541   1873     86   74.92    55
  20 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J96-28            :   3506      5   12000    8290.0   69.08   4998   6584    418   54.87    67
  21 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J92-330           :   3504      6    5750    4112.5   71.52   2698   2829    223   49.20    66
  22 Lc0 0.26.3 RC2 384x30-J92-130       :   3502      8    4000    3051.5   76.29   2190   1723     87   43.08    57
  23 Dragon by Komodo Chess 1.0          :   3501      5    5750    3006.5   52.29    690   4633    427   80.57    72
  24 Dragon by Komodo Chess 2.0          :   3499      7    2750    1330.5   48.38    203   2255    292   82.00    71
  25 Stockfish NNUE SV20200725-1313      :   3496      8    2500    1475.0   59.00    520   1910     70   76.40    74
  26 Lc0 0.26.3 66511                    :   3492      5    9500    6505.5   68.48   3910   5191    399   54.64    92
  27 Lc0 0.26.3 65681                    :   3486      7    4250    3013.5   70.91   1972   2083    195   49.01    89
  28 Lc0 0.25.1 LS 15                    :   3480      6    6000    4320.0   72.00   2928   2784    288   46.40    64
  29 Dragon by Komodo Chess 2.5 MCTS     :   3478      8    2500    1131.0   45.24    135   1992    373   79.68    69
  30 Lc0 0.24.1 LS 14.3                  :   3475      6    6000    4292.0   71.53   2870   2844    286   47.40    61
  31 Lc0 0.26.2 384x30-J92-220           :   3474      8    3750    2745.0   73.20   1877   1736    137   46.29    74
  32 Lc0 0.24.1 LS 14.2                  :   3470      9    3250    2472.5   76.08   1799   1347    104   41.45    77
  33 Fire 8 NN.MC.2                      :   3465      7    2750    1203.5   43.76    148   2111    491   76.76    54
  34 Lc0 0.26.1 384x30-J92-115           :   3465      8    3750    2772.5   73.93   1915   1715    120   45.73    68
  35 Lc0 0.24.0 LS 14                    :   3462      9    3500    2677.0   76.49   1964   1426    110   40.74    88
  36 Lc0k 0.23.2 256x20-T40-1541         :   3456      5    7750    5415.5   69.88   3537   3757    456   48.48    86
  37 Lc0 0.26.1 384x30-T60-4585          :   3451      8    3250    2295.5   70.63   1509   1573    168   48.40    64
  38 Lc0 0.24.1 LS 13                    :   3448      9    3000    2187.5   72.92   1508   1359    133   45.30    68
  39 Stockfish NNUE GK200627             :   3446      8    2500    1305.5   52.22    321   1969    210   78.76    67
  40 Lc0 0.26.1 384x30-T60-4619          :   3443      7    4250    3038.0   71.48   2010   2056    184   48.38    56
  41 Stockfish 200502 C0                 :   3442      8    2500    1301.5   52.06    383   1837    280   73.48    64
  42 Lc0 0.26.1 64498                    :   3441      7    4750    3252.5   68.47   2068   2369    313   49.87    74
  43 Stockfish 12 Classic                :   3437      7    2500    1013.5   40.54    144   1739    617   69.56    82
  44 Lc0 0.24.1 384x30-T60-3010          :   3432      7    5000    3477.5   69.55   2256   2443    301   48.86    61
  45 Lc0 0.25.1 63681                    :   3431      6    5250    3573.5   68.07   2248   2651    351   50.50    53
  46 Fat Fritz 1.1                       :   3431      8    4000    2921.0   73.03   2066   1710    224   42.75    76
  47 Stockfish 11 C0                     :   3428      5    6750    3390.0   50.22    851   5078    821   75.23    58
  48 Lc0 0.22.0 42850                    :   3427      7    4500    3173.5   70.52   2142   2063    295   45.84    51
  49 Lc0 0.22.0 T40B.4-160               :   3427      7    4500    3173.0   70.51   2131   2084    285   46.31    54
  50 SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8              :   3426      8    2500     956.5   38.26     75   1763    662   70.52    73
  51 Stockfish 11                        :   3423      7    4000    2157.5   53.94    777   2761    462   69.03    65
  52 Lc0 0.25.1 63305                    :   3421      7    4750    3176.5   66.87   1926   2501    323   52.65    81
  53 Lc0 0.25.1 63305 (Kayra4)           :   3417      8    3250    2285.5   70.32   1477   1617    156   49.75    53
  54 Lc0 0.25.1 3972_20k_TCEC            :   3416      8    3500    2418.5   69.10   1513   1811    176   51.74    79
  55 Lc0k 0.23.2 62172                   :   3412      6    4750    3160.0   66.53   1924   2472    354   52.04    51
  56 Koivisto 7.5                        :   3412      8    2500     910.0   36.40     72   1676    752   67.04    81
  57 Lc0 LS-LS 12.2                      :   3406      8    3750    2680.5   71.48   1809   1743    198   46.48    54
  58 Dragon by Komodo Chess 2.0 MCTS     :   3406      8    2500     899.0   35.96     70   1658    772   66.32    54
  59 Lc0 0.22.0 J13B.2-188               :   3405      7    4500    3068.0   68.18   1955   2226    319   49.47    69
  60 Lc0 0.25.1 703042                   :   3403      7    4750    3073.5   64.71   1917   2313    520   48.69    72
  61 Lc0 LS-LS 12.1                      :   3400      8    3000    2056.0   68.53   1299   1514    187   50.47    53
  62 Lc0k 0.23.2 384x30-T40-2036         :   3399      7    4250    2905.0   68.35   1923   1964    363   46.21    76
  63 Ethereal 13.25 NNUE                 :   3395      8    2750     949.5   34.53     68   1763    919   64.11    93
  64 Fat Fritz 1.0                       :   3386      8    3000    2012.0   67.07   1311   1402    287   46.73    60
  65 SlowChess Blitz NN 2.7              :   3385      8    2750     913.5   33.22     71   1685    994   61.27    60
  66 Lc0 0.27.0 741622                   :   3383      8    2500    1317.0   52.68    602   1430    468   57.20    62
  67 Berserk 7 NN                        :   3382      8    2500     815.0   32.60     61   1508    931   60.32    58
  68 Lc0 0.22.0 32930                    :   3380      7    4500    2942.0   65.38   1821   2242    437   49.82    67
  69 Lc0 0.22.0 LS 12 preview            :   3378      9    2750    1876.0   68.22   1258   1236    256   44.95    53
  70 Scorpio 3.0.12 NN-ens-net-20x256    :   3378      8    2500    1299.0   51.96    497   1604    399   64.16    54
  71 Stockfish 10                        :   3377      8    2750    1337.5   48.64    428   1819    503   66.15    74
  72 Lc0 0.23.2 61950                    :   3374      7    3750    2482.0   66.19   1550   1864    336   49.71    74
  73 Lc0 0.23.2 58613+                   :   3371      8    3500    2268.5   64.81   1426   1685    389   48.14    65
  74 Lc0 0.22.0 384x30-T40-1573          :   3368      9    2750    1846.0   67.13   1220   1252    278   45.53    79
  75 SlowChess Blitz NN 2.6              :   3363      9    2500     767.5   30.70     50   1435   1015   57.40    83
  76 RubiChess 2.2 NNUE                  :   3357      9    2750     823.5   29.95     50   1547   1153   56.25    59
  77 Lc0 0.25.1 3972_20k_TCEC+           :   3356      9    2500    1646.5   65.86    944   1405    151   56.20    84
  78 Komodo 14.1                         :   3351      5    6000    1965.0   32.75    265   3400   2335   56.67    66
  79 Ethereal 13.00 NNUE                 :   3349      9    2500     725.0   29.00     48   1354   1098   54.16    67
  80 Komodo 14                           :   3346      5    6000    2229.0   37.15    400   3658   1942   60.97    89
  81 Lc0 0.22.0 11260                    :   3340      9    2750    1755.5   63.84   1044   1423    283   51.75    89
  82 Igel 3.0.5                          :   3332      9    2750     743.0   27.02     30   1426   1294   51.85    67
  83 RubiChess 2.1 NNUE                  :   3329      9    2750     735.0   26.73     42   1386   1322   50.40    71
  84 Komodo 13.3                         :   3325      7    3750    1379.0   36.77    294   2170   1286   57.87    52
  85 Houdini 6.03                        :   3325      4   13000    4495.0   34.58    894   7202   4904   55.40    90
  86 Koivisto 6.0                        :   3318      9    2750     703.5   25.58     32   1343   1375   48.84    56
  87 Berserk 6.0                         :   3317     10    2500     632.0   25.28     37   1190   1273   47.60    80
  88 Komodo 13.2.5                       :   3312      7    4500    1749.5   38.88    503   2493   1504   55.40    77
  89 Pedone 3.1                          :   3308     10    2500     613.0   24.52     37   1152   1311   46.08    57
  90 Fire 8.1                            :   3306      9    2750     669.0   24.33     49   1240   1461   45.09    70
  91 Nemorino 6.00                       :   3303      9    3000     800.0   26.67     75   1450   1475   48.33    68
  92 Igel 3.0.0                          :   3300     10    2750     653.0   23.75     25   1256   1469   45.67    74
  93 Ethereal 12.75                      :   3296      6    6500    1738.0   26.74    172   3132   3196   48.18    75
  94 Dragon by Komodo Chess 1.0 MCTS     :   3292     10    2500     575.5   23.02     22   1107   1371   44.28    59
  95 SlowChess Blitz NN 2.5              :   3290      8    4000     992.0   24.80    123   1738   2139   43.45    93
  96 Scorpio 3.07 NN-ens-net-20x256      :   3281      8    2500    1466.5   58.66    855   1223    422   48.92    98
  97 Ethereal 12.50                      :   3269      8    3000     806.5   26.88     84   1445   1471   48.17    98
  98 Ethereal 12.25                      :   3258      8    3500     954.5   27.27    145   1619   1736   46.26    60
  99 RubiChess 2.0 NNUE                  :   3256      9    3500     757.0   21.63     53   1408   2039   40.23    73
 100 Igel 2.8.0 NNUE                     :   3253      7    4750    1049.0   22.08     76   1946   2728   40.97    60
 101 SlowChess Blitz Classic 2.4         :   3251      8    4000     827.5   20.69     66   1523   2411   38.08    58
 102 Komodo 14.1 MCTS                    :   3250     12    2500     478.0   19.12     32    892   1576   35.68    61
 103 Berserk 4.5.1                       :   3248     11    2500     471.0   18.84     28    886   1586   35.44    75
 104 Igel 2.9.0                          :   3243      9    4000     812.0   20.30     45   1534   2421   38.35    53
 105 Seer 2.3.0                          :   3242     12    2500     454.0   18.16     13    882   1605   35.28   100
 106 Ethereal 12.00                      :   3223      7    5250    1300.0   24.76    213   2174   2863   41.41    58
 107 SlowChess Blitz Classic 2.3         :   3222      9    4000     834.5   20.86     82   1505   2413   37.63    86
 108 Xiphos 0.6                          :   3217      5   11500    2635.0   22.91    326   4618   6556   40.16    91
 109 SlowChess Blitz Classic 2.2         :   3210      9    3500     780.5   22.30    102   1357   2041   38.77    51
 110 Ethereal 11.75                      :   3210      7    4500    1196.0   26.58    210   1972   2318   43.82    69
 111 Booot 6.5                           :   3206     12    2500     383.5   15.34     21    725   1754   29.00    82
 112 Fire 7.1                            :   3200      5   11500    2452.0   21.32    382   4140   6978   36.00    97
 113 Minic 3.13                          :   3186     14    2500     353.0   14.12     10    686   1804   27.44    88
 114 Weiss 2.0                           :   3174     13    2500     329.0   13.16     23    612   1865   24.48    84
 115 RofChade 2.3                        :   3167      6    9000    1519.0   16.88    148   2742   6110   30.47   100
 116 Booot 6.4                           :   3142      7    7500    1212.5   16.17    127   2171   5202   28.95    86
 117 Laser 1.7                           :   3137      7    7750    1401.0   18.08    201   2400   5149   30.97    82
 118 Schooner 2.2                        :   3131     10    4250     592.5   13.94     50   1085   3115   25.53    80
 119 Andscacs 0.95                       :   3126      7    7250    1262.0   17.41    205   2114   4931   29.16   100
 120 Deep Shredder 13                    :   3104      9    5000     818.0   16.36    114   1408   3478   28.16    84
 121 Booot 6.3.1                         :   3098      9    4750     767.0   16.15    118   1298   3334   27.33    93
 122 Arasan 23.0                         :   3084     16    2500     211.0    8.44      8    406   2086   16.24   ---

White advantage = 58.86 +/- 0.45
Draw rate (equal opponents) = 76.19 % +/- 0.14

Games        : 280.750 (finished)

White Wins   :  86.843 (30.9 %)
Black Wins   :  50.920 (18.1 %)
Draws        : 142.987 (50.9 %)

White Score  : 56.4 %
Black Score  : 43.6 %
http://www.fastgm.de

Download: http://fastgm.de/downloads.html
Madeleine Birchfield
Posts: 512
Joined: Tue Sep 29, 2020 4:29 pm
Location: Dublin, Ireland
Full name: Madeleine Birchfield

Re: FGRL, 16 Cores vs RTX 2070 - 1. Stockfish 14.1, 50. SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8, 56. Koivisto 7.5, 67. Berserk 7 NN

Post by Madeleine Birchfield »

Slowchess 2.8 above Stockfish 11 in this list as well.
menniepals
Posts: 265
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:31 pm
Location: Houston, Texas

Re: FGRL, 16 Cores vs RTX 2070 - 1. Stockfish 14.1, 50. SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8, 56. Koivisto 7.5, 67. Berserk 7 NN

Post by menniepals »

Thank you
fastgm
Posts: 818
Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 6:57 pm

Re: FGRL, 16 Cores vs RTX 2070 - 1. Stockfish 14.1, 50. SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8, 56. Koivisto 7.5, 67. Berserk 7 NN

Post by fastgm »

Without Lc0

Code: Select all

   # Engine                              :    Elo  Error   Games    Points    (%)      W      D      L     D(%)   CFS
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1 Stockfish 14.1                      :   3565      8    2500    1431.5   57.26    385   2093     22   83.72    94
   2 Fat Fritz 2 (in SF)                 :   3543      6    4000    2265.0   56.63    626   3278     96   81.95    80
   3 Dragon by Komodo Chess 2.5          :   3537      7    2500    1335.5   53.42    257   2157     86   86.28    55
   4 Dragon by Komodo Chess 2.5 MCTS     :   3478      8    2500    1131.0   45.24    135   1992    373   79.68    69
   5 Fire 8 NN.MC.2                      :   3465      7    2750    1203.5   43.76    148   2111    491   76.76    54
   6 SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8              :   3426      8    2500     956.5   38.26     75   1763    662   70.52    73
   7 Koivisto 7.5                        :   3412      8    2500     910.0   36.40     72   1676    752   67.04    81
   8 Ethereal 13.25 NNUE                 :   3395      8    2750     949.5   34.53     68   1763    919   64.11    93
   9 Berserk 7 NN                        :   3382      8    2500     815.0   32.60     61   1508    931   60.32    58
  10 Scorpio 3.0.12 NN-ens-net-20x256    :   3378      8    2500    1299.0   51.96    497   1604    399   64.16    54
  11 RubiChess 2.2 NNUE                  :   3357      9    2750     823.5   29.95     50   1547   1153   56.25    59
  12 Igel 3.0.5                          :   3332      9    2750     743.0   27.02     30   1426   1294   51.85    67
  13 Houdini 6.03                        :   3325      4   13000    4495.0   34.58    894   7202   4904   55.40    90
  14 Pedone 3.1                          :   3308     10    2500     613.0   24.52     37   1152   1311   46.08    57
  15 Nemorino 6.00                       :   3303      9    3000     800.0   26.67     75   1450   1475   48.33    68
  16 Seer 2.3.0                          :   3242     12    2500     454.0   18.16     13    882   1605   35.28   100
  17 Xiphos 0.6                          :   3217      5   11500    2635.0   22.91    326   4618   6556   40.16    91
  18 Booot 6.5                           :   3206     12    2500     383.5   15.34     21    725   1754   29.00    82
  19 Minic 3.13                          :   3186     14    2500     353.0   14.12     10    686   1804   27.44    88
  20 Weiss 2.0                           :   3174     13    2500     329.0   13.16     23    612   1865   24.48    84
  21 RofChade 2.3                        :   3167      6    9000    1519.0   16.88    148   2742   6110   30.47   100
  22 Laser 1.7                           :   3137      7    7750    1401.0   18.08    201   2400   5149   30.97    82
  23 Schooner 2.2                        :   3131     10    4250     592.5   13.94     50   1085   3115   25.53    80
  24 Andscacs 0.95                       :   3126      7    7250    1262.0   17.41    205   2114   4931   29.16   100
  25 Deep Shredder 13                    :   3104      9    5000     818.0   16.36    114   1408   3478   28.16    84
  26 Arasan 23.0                         :   3084     16    2500     211.0    8.44      8    406   2086   16.24   ---
Jouni
Posts: 3229
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm

Re: FGRL, 16 Cores vs RTX 2070 - 1. Stockfish 14.1, 50. SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8, 56. Koivisto 7.5, 67. Berserk 7 NN

Post by Jouni »

IMHO testing SF against 10 Lc0 doesn't make sense:

Code: Select all

 Lc0 0.28.0 610062                      :    250 (  41,  208,  1),  58.0 :    +47,    5,  100.0
 Lc0 0.27.0 68864                       :    250 (  26,  222,  2),  54.8 :    +49,    4,  100.0
 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J94-130              :    250 (  41,  207,  2),  57.8 :    +50,    4,  100.0
 Lc0 0.27.0 68550                       :    250 (  36,  210,  4),  56.4 :    +50,    4,  100.0
 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J98.1-16             :    250 (  44,  203,  3),  58.2 :    +52,    4,  100.0
 Lc0 0.26.3 66625                       :    250 (  41,  207,  2),  57.8 :    +54,    4,  100.0
 Lc0 0.26.3 66750                       :    250 (  41,  208,  1),  58.0 :    +55,    4,  100.0
 Lc0 0.26.3 67630                       :    250 (  41,  208,  1),  58.0 :    +56,    4,  100.0
 Lc0 0.27.0 67890                       :    250 (  36,  213,  1),  57.0 :    +56,    4,  100.0
 Lc0 0.26.3 384x30-J96-28               :    250 (  38,  207,  5),  56.6 :    +59,    4,  100.0
Jouni
fastgm
Posts: 818
Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2013 6:57 pm

Re: FGRL, 16 Cores vs RTX 2070 - 1. Stockfish 14.1, 50. SlowChess Blitz NN 2.8, 56. Koivisto 7.5, 67. Berserk 7 NN

Post by fastgm »

Jouni wrote: Sat Dec 04, 2021 8:57 am IMHO testing SF against 10 Lc0 doesn't make sense:
But that is the point of this rating list. Traditional chess engines vs. Lc0
For other tests see my other rating lists.