I am searching attackers generate a lesser move average (without contempt) and lost not to many games.
Defenders like to play a safe style with a lesser move average are OK (Seer).
I try out now all of the TOP-engines more times.
At last again Berserk 9.0 NN.
But without contempt the move average with 94 moves is clearly to high = 9 over average!
Have a look in Andscacs 0.1 NNSf stats.
Also not OK, move average from white / draw games.
Must cancel the engine in the field or my stats later will be bad.
The basic tourney is important for a comparasion with a test-set of first 50 positions.
Stats are generated with my best opening lines (opening book, most comes from FEOBOS).
So three engines I will delete in the group:
1. Wasp 5.50 NN (2x Wasp in the field).
2. Berserk 9.0 NN (move average is to high).
3. Andscacs 0.1 NNSF
So I think I have to work with 18 programs = 1.700 basis games per engines.
Again, all others in TOP-50 produced different problems:
1. Move average is to high in most of cases "no contempt parameter" (Rebel, Stockfish, Koivisto, Fritz 18, Minic, Clover, Berserk)
2. To many fast lost games, made no sense to use this engines for find positions for a test-set (Halogen, Nemorino, Fritz 18, Minic, Shredder, Zahak, Lc0 CPU, Combusken, Clover)
3. Engines are not strong enough in the field (Examples: Hiarcs, Weiss, Fizbo, Defenchess, DanaSah, Laser, Chiron and a lot of others). With around 50 Elo more Weiss or Hiarcs can be interesting. Also Danasah, Laser and Defenchess can be very interesting.
Best
Frank
OK, field of 18 engines is clear to start.
Opening book vs. Test-Set!
Can be start soon ... each opening position will get later an own ranking!
Code: Select all
***************************************************************
*** Short Games Analyzer Tool V3.1 ***
*** (C) 2022, Stefan Pohl, www.sp-cc.de ***
***************************************************************
*** Evaluated file: games.pgn
***************************************************************
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 1: "Velvet 4.0.1 NN" All games: 2000 (192 wins / 1041 draws / 767 losses)
*** Overall score: 35.63% Overall draw-rate: 52.05%
*** Average game length: All: 85 moves (wins: 74 moves / draws: 85 moves / losses: 88 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 84 moves (wins: 72 moves / draws: 84 moves / losses: 91 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 86 moves (wins: 78 moves / draws: 85 moves / losses: 87 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 2: "Stockfish 11" All games: 2000 (540 wins / 1305 draws / 155 losses)
*** Overall score: 59.63% Overall draw-rate: 65.25%
*** Average game length: All: 89 moves (wins: 80 moves / draws: 93 moves / losses: 93 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 87 moves (wins: 79 moves / draws: 90 moves / losses: 99 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 92 moves (wins: 81 moves / draws: 95 moves / losses: 91 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 3: "Booot 6.5" All games: 1998 (147 wins / 1024 draws / 827 losses)
*** Overall score: 32.98% Overall draw-rate: 51.25%
*** Average game length: All: 87 moves (wins: 82 moves / draws: 86 moves / losses: 88 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 86 moves (wins: 80 moves / draws: 84 moves / losses: 90 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 88 moves (wins: 86 moves / draws: 89 moves / losses: 87 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 4: "Xiphos 0.6" All games: 2000 (146 wins / 1005 draws / 849 losses)
*** Overall score: 32.43% Overall draw-rate: 50.25%
*** Average game length: All: 85 moves (wins: 85 moves / draws: 86 moves / losses: 83 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 85 moves (wins: 83 moves / draws: 85 moves / losses: 86 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 84 moves (wins: 89 moves / draws: 87 moves / losses: 81 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 5: "Dragon 3 NN (Komodo)" All games: 2000 (1050 wins / 949 draws / 1 losses)
*** Overall score: 76.23% Overall draw-rate: 47.45%
*** Average game length: All: 82 moves (wins: 80 moves / draws: 83 moves / losses: 103 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 82 moves (wins: 80 moves / draws: 88 moves / losses: 0 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 82 moves (wins: 82 moves / draws: 81 moves / losses: 103 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 6: "Andscacs 0.1 NNSf" All games: 2000 (514 wins / 1328 draws / 158 losses)
*** Overall score: 58.90% Overall draw-rate: 66.40%
*** Average game length: All: 88 moves (wins: 82 moves / draws: 90 moves / losses: 86 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 101 moves (wins: 81 moves / draws: 115 moves / losses: 87 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 74 moves (wins: 85 moves / draws: 70 moves / losses: 85 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 7: "Tucano 10.00 NN" All games: 2000 (202 wins / 1227 draws / 571 losses)
*** Overall score: 40.78% Overall draw-rate: 61.35%
*** Average game length: All: 82 moves (wins: 91 moves / draws: 80 moves / losses: 83 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 81 moves (wins: 90 moves / draws: 77 moves / losses: 87 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 83 moves (wins: 94 moves / draws: 82 moves / losses: 81 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 8: "Wasp 5.50 NN" All games: 2000 (169 wins / 1093 draws / 738 losses)
*** Overall score: 35.78% Overall draw-rate: 54.65%
*** Average game length: All: 81 moves (wins: 85 moves / draws: 79 moves / losses: 84 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 82 moves (wins: 84 moves / draws: 79 moves / losses: 87 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 81 moves (wins: 87 moves / draws: 79 moves / losses: 82 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 9: "SlowChess Blitz 2.9 NN" All games: 2000 (605 wins / 1301 draws / 94 losses)
*** Overall score: 62.78% Overall draw-rate: 65.05%
*** Average game length: All: 90 moves (wins: 84 moves / draws: 93 moves / losses: 91 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 86 moves (wins: 83 moves / draws: 87 moves / losses: 92 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 94 moves (wins: 86 moves / draws: 97 moves / losses: 91 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 10: "Wasp 5.58 NN dev" All games: 2000 (247 wins / 1239 draws / 514 losses)
*** Overall score: 43.33% Overall draw-rate: 61.95%
*** Average game length: All: 81 moves (wins: 86 moves / draws: 78 moves / losses: 86 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 81 moves (wins: 85 moves / draws: 77 moves / losses: 90 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 82 moves (wins: 88 moves / draws: 78 moves / losses: 85 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 11: "Revenge 3.0 NN exp" All games: 2000 (727 wins / 1209 draws / 64 losses)
*** Overall score: 66.58% Overall draw-rate: 60.45%
*** Average game length: All: 85 moves (wins: 82 moves / draws: 87 moves / losses: 90 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 85 moves (wins: 82 moves / draws: 89 moves / losses: 87 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 85 moves (wins: 83 moves / draws: 85 moves / losses: 90 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 12: "rofChade 3.0 NN" All games: 1998 (549 wins / 1301 draws / 148 losses)
*** Overall score: 60.03% Overall draw-rate: 65.12%
*** Average game length: All: 90 moves (wins: 87 moves / draws: 91 moves / losses: 84 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 89 moves (wins: 86 moves / draws: 91 moves / losses: 86 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 90 moves (wins: 90 moves / draws: 91 moves / losses: 83 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 13: "Rodent 1.0 NNSf" All games: 2000 (212 wins / 1256 draws / 532 losses)
*** Overall score: 42.00% Overall draw-rate: 62.80%
*** Average game length: All: 85 moves (wins: 88 moves / draws: 85 moves / losses: 83 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 84 moves (wins: 89 moves / draws: 83 moves / losses: 87 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 85 moves (wins: 87 moves / draws: 87 moves / losses: 81 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 14: "Fire 8.2" All games: 2000 (290 wins / 1182 draws / 528 losses)
*** Overall score: 44.05% Overall draw-rate: 59.10%
*** Average game length: All: 87 moves (wins: 83 moves / draws: 88 moves / losses: 88 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 87 moves (wins: 81 moves / draws: 89 moves / losses: 89 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 87 moves (wins: 88 moves / draws: 87 moves / losses: 87 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 15: "RubiChess 20220223 NN" All games: 2000 (539 wins / 1276 draws / 185 losses)
*** Overall score: 58.85% Overall draw-rate: 63.80%
*** Average game length: All: 86 moves (wins: 84 moves / draws: 86 moves / losses: 91 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 84 moves (wins: 82 moves / draws: 85 moves / losses: 89 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 87 moves (wins: 88 moves / draws: 86 moves / losses: 92 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 16: "Arasan 23.3 NN" All games: 2000 (367 wins / 1261 draws / 372 losses)
*** Overall score: 49.88% Overall draw-rate: 63.05%
*** Average game length: All: 84 moves (wins: 89 moves / draws: 84 moves / losses: 79 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 84 moves (wins: 88 moves / draws: 83 moves / losses: 81 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 85 moves (wins: 91 moves / draws: 86 moves / losses: 78 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 17: "Igel 3.1.0 NN" All games: 2000 (299 wins / 1329 draws / 372 losses)
*** Overall score: 48.18% Overall draw-rate: 66.45%
*** Average game length: All: 81 moves (wins: 89 moves / draws: 80 moves / losses: 76 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 77 moves (wins: 87 moves / draws: 73 moves / losses: 76 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 85 moves (wins: 94 moves / draws: 86 moves / losses: 76 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 18: "Uralochka 3.37c NN" All games: 2000 (313 wins / 1256 draws / 431 losses)
*** Overall score: 47.05% Overall draw-rate: 62.80%
*** Average game length: All: 91 moves (wins: 86 moves / draws: 93 moves / losses: 88 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 90 moves (wins: 85 moves / draws: 93 moves / losses: 87 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 92 moves (wins: 88 moves / draws: 95 moves / losses: 89 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 19: "Marvin 6.0.0 NN" All games: 2000 (122 wins / 966 draws / 912 losses)
*** Overall score: 30.25% Overall draw-rate: 48.30%
*** Average game length: All: 82 moves (wins: 86 moves / draws: 79 moves / losses: 84 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 81 moves (wins: 85 moves / draws: 79 moves / losses: 86 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 82 moves (wins: 88 moves / draws: 81 moves / losses: 83 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 20: "Berserk 9 NN" All games: 1996 (760 wins / 1198 draws / 38 losses)
*** Overall score: 68.09% Overall draw-rate: 60.02%
*** Average game length: All: 94 moves (wins: 91 moves / draws: 97 moves / losses: 88 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 95 moves (wins: 90 moves / draws: 101 moves / losses: 84 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 93 moves (wins: 92 moves / draws: 94 moves / losses: 88 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
*** Rank 21: "Seer 2.5.0 NN" All games: 2000 (496 wins / 1274 draws / 230 losses)
*** Overall score: 56.65% Overall draw-rate: 63.70%
*** Average game length: All: 85 moves (wins: 94 moves / draws: 83 moves / losses: 80 moves)
*** Avg. eng play white: All: 87 moves (wins: 93 moves / draws: 85 moves / losses: 81 moves)
*** Avg. eng play black: All: 83 moves (wins: 96 moves / draws: 81 moves / losses: 80 moves)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX