Komodo 5 running for the IPON
Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw
-
lkaufman
- Posts: 5960
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 am
- Location: Maryland USA
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
I told Don when your test started that I would be satisfied if we reach 3010 on your list. Since it came out 3009, do I have to be unsatisfied?
-
IWB
- Posts: 1539
- Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 2:02 pm
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
Not at all!lkaufman wrote:I told Don when your test started that I would be satisfied if we reach 3010 on your list. Since it came out 3009, do I have to be unsatisfied?
In the IPON-RRRL it is even 3011, so in average your guess was perfect!
Regards
Ingo
-
michiguel
- Posts: 6401
- Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 8:30 pm
- Location: Chicago, Illinois, USA
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
Ordo run (I changed the formatting, so Adam Hair may like it betterIWB wrote:Sorry for the delay but finaly the result for Komodo 5 is online.
http://www.inwoba.de
The IPON-RRRL will be updated soon.
Bye
Ingo
)With 100 simulations to estimate the error, Komodo improved
27.4 +/- 9.5 (1 Sigma)
The difference with Houdini 1.5 is
7.9 +/- 11.7 (1 Sigma)
and with Houding 2
16.0 +/- 10.4 (1 Sigma)
SD above are taken from the matrix error file, head to head error
Code: Select all
RANK ENGINE : RATING ERROR POINTS PLAYED (%)
0 Houdini 2.0 STD : 3041.8 7.5 4221.5 5400 78.2%
1 Houdini 1.5a : 3033.7 6.7 3162.5 4000 79.1%
2 Komodo 5 : 3025.8 8.2 2138.0 2850 75.0%
3 Critter 1.4a : 3002.4 6.9 3419.5 4450 76.8%
4 Komodo 4 : 2998.4 6.3 3653.0 4850 75.3%
5 Critter 1.6a : 2989.7 7.0 2216.5 3150 70.4%
6 Komodo 3 : 2986.8 7.8 2075.5 2800 74.1%
7 Stockfish 2.2.2 JA : 2978.2 6.3 3514.5 4800 73.2%
8 Deep Rybka 4.1 : 2977.2 4.9 4412.0 6200 71.2%
9 Deep Rybka 4 : 2976.6 6.2 3627.0 4900 74.0%
10 Critter 1.2 : 2976.5 8.0 2232.0 3100 72.0%
11 Houdini 1.03a : 2974.7 8.4 2520.0 3200 78.8%
12 Komodo 2.03 DC : 2969.5 7.6 1985.5 2700 73.5%
13 Stockfish 2.1.1 JA : 2960.6 6.8 2426.5 3500 69.3%
14 Critter 1.01 : 2941.1 7.3 1970.0 2800 70.4%
15 Stockfish 2.01 JA : 2940.7 7.6 2246.0 3100 72.5%
16 Stockfish 1.9.1 JA : 2919.0 6.8 2131.0 3000 71.0%
17 Rybka 3 mp : 2918.3 6.7 3228.0 4200 76.9%
18 Critter 0.90 : 2911.0 6.8 2327.5 3400 68.5%
19 Stockfish 1.7.1 JA : 2903.3 7.3 2131.0 2900 73.5%
20 Rybka 3 32b : 2859.4 10.7 1191.5 1700 70.1%
21 Stockfish 1.6.x JA : 2843.6 7.5 1792.5 2600 68.9%
22 Komodo 1.3 JA : 2839.1 6.1 1946.0 3300 59.0%
23 Naum 4.2 : 2833.2 4.1 5268.0 9300 56.6%
24 Deep Fritz 13 32b : 2833.2 6.3 1621.5 3300 49.1%
25 Chiron 1.1a : 2832.8 5.6 2664.5 4950 53.8%
26 Critter 0.80 : 2824.9 6.7 1795.5 2800 64.1%
27 Fritz 13 32b : 2819.3 5.2 2308.0 4300 53.7%
28 Komodo 1.2 JA : 2809.5 5.1 2175.0 3700 58.8%
29 Rybka 2.3.2a mp : 2805.0 6.2 2172.5 3500 62.1%
30 Deep Shredder 12 : 2800.0 3.9 5568.0 10400 53.5%
31 Hannibal 1.2 : 2797.4 5.9 1632.5 3600 45.3%
32 Gull 1.2 : 2795.2 4.7 3072.5 6300 48.8%
33 Critter 0.70 : 2791.7 8.5 1107.0 1900 58.3%
34 Gull 1.1 : 2791.4 6.8 1675.5 3100 54.0%
35 Naum 4.1 : 2789.7 8.6 1465.0 2300 63.7%
36 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 32b: 2789.0 4.4 3537.0 7300 48.5%
37 Komodo 1.0 JA : 2785.1 6.8 1756.5 2900 60.6%
38 Spike 1.4 32b : 2782.4 4.7 3018.5 6400 47.2%
39 Deep Fritz 12 32b : 2778.2 4.9 3268.5 6300 51.9%
40 Naum 4 : 2775.9 7.2 1628.5 2700 60.3%
41 Rybka 2.2n2 mp : 2775.3 7.8 1311.5 2100 62.5%
42 Gull 1.0a : 2766.9 7.5 1254.0 2300 54.5%
43 Stockfish 1.5.1 JA : 2762.2 9.6 1128.5 1900 59.4%
44 Rybka 1.2f : 2761.3 7.3 1578.5 2400 65.8%
45 Protector 1.4.0 : 2757.1 4.9 2887.0 6500 44.4%
46 spark-1.0 : 2756.8 5.0 3091.5 7000 44.2%
47 Hannibal 1.1 : 2747.8 5.7 2142.0 4900 43.7%
48 HIARCS 13.2 MP 32b : 2746.1 5.0 2922.5 6800 43.0%
49 Deep Junior 13 : 2745.3 6.4 1452.5 3600 40.3%
50 Deep Junior 13.3 : 2745.2 6.7 1131.0 3000 37.7%
51 Fritz 12 32b : 2740.4 7.8 1091.0 2000 54.5%
52 Quazar 0.4 : 2735.0 5.9 1500.0 3900 38.5%
53 HIARCS 13.1 MP 32b : 2727.9 5.9 1734.5 3600 48.2%
54 Deep Junior 12.5 : 2726.7 5.4 1963.0 4850 40.5%
55 Deep Fritz 11 32b : 2720.7 9.5 744.5 1300 57.3%
56 Doch64 1.2 JA : 2710.5 9.0 820.5 1600 51.3%
57 spark-0.4 : 2709.1 6.1 1458.0 3100 47.0%
58 Stockfish 1.4 JA : 2708.2 10.2 849.0 1700 49.9%
59 Zappa Mexico II : 2706.2 3.5 5070.0 11700 43.3%
60 Shredder Bonn 32b : 2705.1 8.4 1119.0 2200 50.9%
61 Critter 0.60 : 2693.8 7.2 1072.0 2200 48.7%
62 Protector 1.3.2 JA : 2693.7 5.1 2361.5 5300 44.6%
63 MinkoChess 1.3 : 2690.2 6.0 1134.5 3600 31.5%
64 Deep Shredder 11 : 2684.9 7.2 1412.0 2700 52.3%
65 Doch64 09.980 JA : 2682.1 10.5 710.0 1500 47.3%
66 Deep Junior 12 : 2674.7 6.1 1356.0 3600 37.7%
67 Onno-1-1-1 : 2674.4 5.7 1923.0 4300 44.7%
68 Hannibal 1.0a : 2674.1 5.9 1600.0 4200 38.1%
69 Deep Onno 1-2-70 : 2673.0 4.2 2806.5 7700 36.4%
70 Naum 3.1 : 2672.6 6.4 1514.5 3000 50.5%
71 Zappa Mexico I : 2672.2 7.2 1221.0 2200 55.5%
72 Rybka 1.0 Beta : 2671.2 7.3 1023.5 2300 44.5%
73 Spark-0.3 VC(a) : 2668.0 6.3 1625.0 3600 45.1%
74 Onno-1-0-0 : 2665.3 10.7 594.5 1200 49.5%
75 Deep Sjeng WC2008 : 2663.0 4.4 2434.5 5600 43.5%
76 Toga II 1.4 beta5c BB : 2659.3 3.9 3255.5 8300 39.2%
77 Deep Junior 11.2 : 2658.0 7.5 1176.0 2900 40.6%
78 Strelka 2.0 B : 2653.8 5.5 1778.5 5500 32.3%
79 Hiarcs 12.1 MP 32b : 2650.1 5.5 2427.5 5600 43.3%
80 Tornado 4.88 : 2648.1 7.9 803.0 2400 33.5%
81 Deep Sjeng 3.0 : 2647.5 9.8 601.5 1400 43.0%
82 Umko 1.2 : 2647.4 6.6 1016.5 3300 30.8%
83 Critter 0.52b : 2636.4 7.0 1097.0 2600 42.2%
84 Shredder Classic 4 32b : 2636.3 7.8 922.5 1800 51.2%
85 Deep Junior 11.1a : 2626.3 7.7 1153.0 2800 41.2%
86 Naum 2.2 32b : 2624.7 9.6 614.0 1300 47.2%
87 Nemo 1.0.1 : 2619.7 7.8 708.0 2700 26.2%
88 Umko 1.1 : 2619.6 7.4 1146.0 3900 29.4%
89 Deep Junior 2010 : 2617.4 7.1 1210.0 3100 39.0%
90 Glaurung 2.2 JA : 2616.5 6.5 1027.5 2600 39.5%
91 Rybka 1.0 Beta 32b : 2616.4 10.2 506.0 1100 46.0%
92 HIARCS 11.2 32b : 2611.4 9.0 827.0 1900 43.5%
93 Fruit 05/11/03 32b : 2608.8 5.3 1774.0 4400 40.3%
94 Loop 2007 : 2601.9 4.2 2456.0 7900 31.1%
95 Toga II 1.2.1a : 2598.6 9.3 716.5 1600 44.8%
96 Jonny 4.00 32b : 2598.1 5.6 1389.5 5200 26.7%
97 ListMP 11 : 2594.3 8.0 987.5 2600 38.0%
98 LoopMP 12 32b : 2592.2 10.4 635.0 1500 42.3%
99 Tornado 4.80 : 2590.4 8.1 681.5 2700 25.2%
100 Deep Shredder 10 : 2588.4 6.2 1754.0 4400 39.9%
101 Twisted Logic 20100131x: 2584.1 6.7 1140.0 3500 32.6%
102 Crafty 23.3 JA : 2579.4 4.8 1290.5 5200 24.8%
103 Spike 1.2 Turin 32b : 2561.7 3.9 2349.5 7700 30.5%
104 Deep Sjeng 2.7 32b : 2537.5 9.0 465.5 1400 33.2%
105 Crafty 23.1 JA : 2526.2 6.7 1002.0 3800 26.4%-
Adam Hair
- Posts: 3226
- Joined: Wed May 06, 2009 10:31 pm
- Location: Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
michiguel wrote:Ordo run (I changed the formatting, so Adam Hair may like it betterIWB wrote:Sorry for the delay but finaly the result for Komodo 5 is online.
http://www.inwoba.de
The IPON-RRRL will be updated soon.
Bye
Ingo
With 100 simulations to estimate the error, Komodo improved
27.4 +/- 9.5 (1 Sigma)
The difference with Houdini 1.5 is
7.9 +/- 11.7 (1 Sigma)
and with Houding 2
16.0 +/- 10.4 (1 Sigma)
SD above are taken from the matrix error file, head to head error
Code: Select all
RANK ENGINE : RATING ERROR POINTS PLAYED (%) 0 Houdini 2.0 STD : 3041.8 7.5 4221.5 5400 78.2% 1 Houdini 1.5a : 3033.7 6.7 3162.5 4000 79.1% 2 Komodo 5 : 3025.8 8.2 2138.0 2850 75.0% 3 Critter 1.4a : 3002.4 6.9 3419.5 4450 76.8% 4 Komodo 4 : 2998.4 6.3 3653.0 4850 75.3% 5 Critter 1.6a : 2989.7 7.0 2216.5 3150 70.4% 6 Komodo 3 : 2986.8 7.8 2075.5 2800 74.1% 7 Stockfish 2.2.2 JA : 2978.2 6.3 3514.5 4800 73.2% 8 Deep Rybka 4.1 : 2977.2 4.9 4412.0 6200 71.2% 9 Deep Rybka 4 : 2976.6 6.2 3627.0 4900 74.0% 10 Critter 1.2 : 2976.5 8.0 2232.0 3100 72.0% 11 Houdini 1.03a : 2974.7 8.4 2520.0 3200 78.8% 12 Komodo 2.03 DC : 2969.5 7.6 1985.5 2700 73.5% 13 Stockfish 2.1.1 JA : 2960.6 6.8 2426.5 3500 69.3% 14 Critter 1.01 : 2941.1 7.3 1970.0 2800 70.4% 15 Stockfish 2.01 JA : 2940.7 7.6 2246.0 3100 72.5% 16 Stockfish 1.9.1 JA : 2919.0 6.8 2131.0 3000 71.0% 17 Rybka 3 mp : 2918.3 6.7 3228.0 4200 76.9% 18 Critter 0.90 : 2911.0 6.8 2327.5 3400 68.5% 19 Stockfish 1.7.1 JA : 2903.3 7.3 2131.0 2900 73.5% 20 Rybka 3 32b : 2859.4 10.7 1191.5 1700 70.1% 21 Stockfish 1.6.x JA : 2843.6 7.5 1792.5 2600 68.9% 22 Komodo 1.3 JA : 2839.1 6.1 1946.0 3300 59.0% 23 Naum 4.2 : 2833.2 4.1 5268.0 9300 56.6% 24 Deep Fritz 13 32b : 2833.2 6.3 1621.5 3300 49.1% 25 Chiron 1.1a : 2832.8 5.6 2664.5 4950 53.8% 26 Critter 0.80 : 2824.9 6.7 1795.5 2800 64.1% 27 Fritz 13 32b : 2819.3 5.2 2308.0 4300 53.7% 28 Komodo 1.2 JA : 2809.5 5.1 2175.0 3700 58.8% 29 Rybka 2.3.2a mp : 2805.0 6.2 2172.5 3500 62.1% 30 Deep Shredder 12 : 2800.0 3.9 5568.0 10400 53.5% 31 Hannibal 1.2 : 2797.4 5.9 1632.5 3600 45.3% 32 Gull 1.2 : 2795.2 4.7 3072.5 6300 48.8% 33 Critter 0.70 : 2791.7 8.5 1107.0 1900 58.3% 34 Gull 1.1 : 2791.4 6.8 1675.5 3100 54.0% 35 Naum 4.1 : 2789.7 8.6 1465.0 2300 63.7% 36 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 32b: 2789.0 4.4 3537.0 7300 48.5% 37 Komodo 1.0 JA : 2785.1 6.8 1756.5 2900 60.6% 38 Spike 1.4 32b : 2782.4 4.7 3018.5 6400 47.2% 39 Deep Fritz 12 32b : 2778.2 4.9 3268.5 6300 51.9% 40 Naum 4 : 2775.9 7.2 1628.5 2700 60.3% 41 Rybka 2.2n2 mp : 2775.3 7.8 1311.5 2100 62.5% 42 Gull 1.0a : 2766.9 7.5 1254.0 2300 54.5% 43 Stockfish 1.5.1 JA : 2762.2 9.6 1128.5 1900 59.4% 44 Rybka 1.2f : 2761.3 7.3 1578.5 2400 65.8% 45 Protector 1.4.0 : 2757.1 4.9 2887.0 6500 44.4% 46 spark-1.0 : 2756.8 5.0 3091.5 7000 44.2% 47 Hannibal 1.1 : 2747.8 5.7 2142.0 4900 43.7% 48 HIARCS 13.2 MP 32b : 2746.1 5.0 2922.5 6800 43.0% 49 Deep Junior 13 : 2745.3 6.4 1452.5 3600 40.3% 50 Deep Junior 13.3 : 2745.2 6.7 1131.0 3000 37.7% 51 Fritz 12 32b : 2740.4 7.8 1091.0 2000 54.5% 52 Quazar 0.4 : 2735.0 5.9 1500.0 3900 38.5% 53 HIARCS 13.1 MP 32b : 2727.9 5.9 1734.5 3600 48.2% 54 Deep Junior 12.5 : 2726.7 5.4 1963.0 4850 40.5% 55 Deep Fritz 11 32b : 2720.7 9.5 744.5 1300 57.3% 56 Doch64 1.2 JA : 2710.5 9.0 820.5 1600 51.3% 57 spark-0.4 : 2709.1 6.1 1458.0 3100 47.0% 58 Stockfish 1.4 JA : 2708.2 10.2 849.0 1700 49.9% 59 Zappa Mexico II : 2706.2 3.5 5070.0 11700 43.3% 60 Shredder Bonn 32b : 2705.1 8.4 1119.0 2200 50.9% 61 Critter 0.60 : 2693.8 7.2 1072.0 2200 48.7% 62 Protector 1.3.2 JA : 2693.7 5.1 2361.5 5300 44.6% 63 MinkoChess 1.3 : 2690.2 6.0 1134.5 3600 31.5% 64 Deep Shredder 11 : 2684.9 7.2 1412.0 2700 52.3% 65 Doch64 09.980 JA : 2682.1 10.5 710.0 1500 47.3% 66 Deep Junior 12 : 2674.7 6.1 1356.0 3600 37.7% 67 Onno-1-1-1 : 2674.4 5.7 1923.0 4300 44.7% 68 Hannibal 1.0a : 2674.1 5.9 1600.0 4200 38.1% 69 Deep Onno 1-2-70 : 2673.0 4.2 2806.5 7700 36.4% 70 Naum 3.1 : 2672.6 6.4 1514.5 3000 50.5% 71 Zappa Mexico I : 2672.2 7.2 1221.0 2200 55.5% 72 Rybka 1.0 Beta : 2671.2 7.3 1023.5 2300 44.5% 73 Spark-0.3 VC(a) : 2668.0 6.3 1625.0 3600 45.1% 74 Onno-1-0-0 : 2665.3 10.7 594.5 1200 49.5% 75 Deep Sjeng WC2008 : 2663.0 4.4 2434.5 5600 43.5% 76 Toga II 1.4 beta5c BB : 2659.3 3.9 3255.5 8300 39.2% 77 Deep Junior 11.2 : 2658.0 7.5 1176.0 2900 40.6% 78 Strelka 2.0 B : 2653.8 5.5 1778.5 5500 32.3% 79 Hiarcs 12.1 MP 32b : 2650.1 5.5 2427.5 5600 43.3% 80 Tornado 4.88 : 2648.1 7.9 803.0 2400 33.5% 81 Deep Sjeng 3.0 : 2647.5 9.8 601.5 1400 43.0% 82 Umko 1.2 : 2647.4 6.6 1016.5 3300 30.8% 83 Critter 0.52b : 2636.4 7.0 1097.0 2600 42.2% 84 Shredder Classic 4 32b : 2636.3 7.8 922.5 1800 51.2% 85 Deep Junior 11.1a : 2626.3 7.7 1153.0 2800 41.2% 86 Naum 2.2 32b : 2624.7 9.6 614.0 1300 47.2% 87 Nemo 1.0.1 : 2619.7 7.8 708.0 2700 26.2% 88 Umko 1.1 : 2619.6 7.4 1146.0 3900 29.4% 89 Deep Junior 2010 : 2617.4 7.1 1210.0 3100 39.0% 90 Glaurung 2.2 JA : 2616.5 6.5 1027.5 2600 39.5% 91 Rybka 1.0 Beta 32b : 2616.4 10.2 506.0 1100 46.0% 92 HIARCS 11.2 32b : 2611.4 9.0 827.0 1900 43.5% 93 Fruit 05/11/03 32b : 2608.8 5.3 1774.0 4400 40.3% 94 Loop 2007 : 2601.9 4.2 2456.0 7900 31.1% 95 Toga II 1.2.1a : 2598.6 9.3 716.5 1600 44.8% 96 Jonny 4.00 32b : 2598.1 5.6 1389.5 5200 26.7% 97 ListMP 11 : 2594.3 8.0 987.5 2600 38.0% 98 LoopMP 12 32b : 2592.2 10.4 635.0 1500 42.3% 99 Tornado 4.80 : 2590.4 8.1 681.5 2700 25.2% 100 Deep Shredder 10 : 2588.4 6.2 1754.0 4400 39.9% 101 Twisted Logic 20100131x: 2584.1 6.7 1140.0 3500 32.6% 102 Crafty 23.3 JA : 2579.4 4.8 1290.5 5200 24.8% 103 Spike 1.2 Turin 32b : 2561.7 3.9 2349.5 7700 30.5% 104 Deep Sjeng 2.7 32b : 2537.5 9.0 465.5 1400 33.2% 105 Crafty 23.1 JA : 2526.2 6.7 1002.0 3800 26.4%
I do like it
-
Adam Hair
- Posts: 3226
- Joined: Wed May 06, 2009 10:31 pm
- Location: Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
michiguel wrote:Ordo run (I changed the formatting, so Adam Hair may like it betterIWB wrote:Sorry for the delay but finaly the result for Komodo 5 is online.
http://www.inwoba.de
The IPON-RRRL will be updated soon.
Bye
Ingo
With 100 simulations to estimate the error, Komodo improved
27.4 +/- 9.5 (1 Sigma)
The difference with Houdini 1.5 is
7.9 +/- 11.7 (1 Sigma)
and with Houding 2
16.0 +/- 10.4 (1 Sigma)
SD above are taken from the matrix error file, head to head error
Code: Select all
RANK ENGINE : RATING ERROR POINTS PLAYED (%) 0 Houdini 2.0 STD : 3041.8 7.5 4221.5 5400 78.2% 1 Houdini 1.5a : 3033.7 6.7 3162.5 4000 79.1% 2 Komodo 5 : 3025.8 8.2 2138.0 2850 75.0% 3 Critter 1.4a : 3002.4 6.9 3419.5 4450 76.8% 4 Komodo 4 : 2998.4 6.3 3653.0 4850 75.3% 5 Critter 1.6a : 2989.7 7.0 2216.5 3150 70.4% 6 Komodo 3 : 2986.8 7.8 2075.5 2800 74.1% 7 Stockfish 2.2.2 JA : 2978.2 6.3 3514.5 4800 73.2% 8 Deep Rybka 4.1 : 2977.2 4.9 4412.0 6200 71.2% 9 Deep Rybka 4 : 2976.6 6.2 3627.0 4900 74.0% 10 Critter 1.2 : 2976.5 8.0 2232.0 3100 72.0% 11 Houdini 1.03a : 2974.7 8.4 2520.0 3200 78.8% 12 Komodo 2.03 DC : 2969.5 7.6 1985.5 2700 73.5% 13 Stockfish 2.1.1 JA : 2960.6 6.8 2426.5 3500 69.3% 14 Critter 1.01 : 2941.1 7.3 1970.0 2800 70.4% 15 Stockfish 2.01 JA : 2940.7 7.6 2246.0 3100 72.5% 16 Stockfish 1.9.1 JA : 2919.0 6.8 2131.0 3000 71.0% 17 Rybka 3 mp : 2918.3 6.7 3228.0 4200 76.9% 18 Critter 0.90 : 2911.0 6.8 2327.5 3400 68.5% 19 Stockfish 1.7.1 JA : 2903.3 7.3 2131.0 2900 73.5% 20 Rybka 3 32b : 2859.4 10.7 1191.5 1700 70.1% 21 Stockfish 1.6.x JA : 2843.6 7.5 1792.5 2600 68.9% 22 Komodo 1.3 JA : 2839.1 6.1 1946.0 3300 59.0% 23 Naum 4.2 : 2833.2 4.1 5268.0 9300 56.6% 24 Deep Fritz 13 32b : 2833.2 6.3 1621.5 3300 49.1% 25 Chiron 1.1a : 2832.8 5.6 2664.5 4950 53.8% 26 Critter 0.80 : 2824.9 6.7 1795.5 2800 64.1% 27 Fritz 13 32b : 2819.3 5.2 2308.0 4300 53.7% 28 Komodo 1.2 JA : 2809.5 5.1 2175.0 3700 58.8% 29 Rybka 2.3.2a mp : 2805.0 6.2 2172.5 3500 62.1% 30 Deep Shredder 12 : 2800.0 3.9 5568.0 10400 53.5% 31 Hannibal 1.2 : 2797.4 5.9 1632.5 3600 45.3% 32 Gull 1.2 : 2795.2 4.7 3072.5 6300 48.8% 33 Critter 0.70 : 2791.7 8.5 1107.0 1900 58.3% 34 Gull 1.1 : 2791.4 6.8 1675.5 3100 54.0% 35 Naum 4.1 : 2789.7 8.6 1465.0 2300 63.7% 36 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 32b: 2789.0 4.4 3537.0 7300 48.5% 37 Komodo 1.0 JA : 2785.1 6.8 1756.5 2900 60.6% 38 Spike 1.4 32b : 2782.4 4.7 3018.5 6400 47.2% 39 Deep Fritz 12 32b : 2778.2 4.9 3268.5 6300 51.9% 40 Naum 4 : 2775.9 7.2 1628.5 2700 60.3% 41 Rybka 2.2n2 mp : 2775.3 7.8 1311.5 2100 62.5% 42 Gull 1.0a : 2766.9 7.5 1254.0 2300 54.5% 43 Stockfish 1.5.1 JA : 2762.2 9.6 1128.5 1900 59.4% 44 Rybka 1.2f : 2761.3 7.3 1578.5 2400 65.8% 45 Protector 1.4.0 : 2757.1 4.9 2887.0 6500 44.4% 46 spark-1.0 : 2756.8 5.0 3091.5 7000 44.2% 47 Hannibal 1.1 : 2747.8 5.7 2142.0 4900 43.7% 48 HIARCS 13.2 MP 32b : 2746.1 5.0 2922.5 6800 43.0% 49 Deep Junior 13 : 2745.3 6.4 1452.5 3600 40.3% 50 Deep Junior 13.3 : 2745.2 6.7 1131.0 3000 37.7% 51 Fritz 12 32b : 2740.4 7.8 1091.0 2000 54.5% 52 Quazar 0.4 : 2735.0 5.9 1500.0 3900 38.5% 53 HIARCS 13.1 MP 32b : 2727.9 5.9 1734.5 3600 48.2% 54 Deep Junior 12.5 : 2726.7 5.4 1963.0 4850 40.5% 55 Deep Fritz 11 32b : 2720.7 9.5 744.5 1300 57.3% 56 Doch64 1.2 JA : 2710.5 9.0 820.5 1600 51.3% 57 spark-0.4 : 2709.1 6.1 1458.0 3100 47.0% 58 Stockfish 1.4 JA : 2708.2 10.2 849.0 1700 49.9% 59 Zappa Mexico II : 2706.2 3.5 5070.0 11700 43.3% 60 Shredder Bonn 32b : 2705.1 8.4 1119.0 2200 50.9% 61 Critter 0.60 : 2693.8 7.2 1072.0 2200 48.7% 62 Protector 1.3.2 JA : 2693.7 5.1 2361.5 5300 44.6% 63 MinkoChess 1.3 : 2690.2 6.0 1134.5 3600 31.5% 64 Deep Shredder 11 : 2684.9 7.2 1412.0 2700 52.3% 65 Doch64 09.980 JA : 2682.1 10.5 710.0 1500 47.3% 66 Deep Junior 12 : 2674.7 6.1 1356.0 3600 37.7% 67 Onno-1-1-1 : 2674.4 5.7 1923.0 4300 44.7% 68 Hannibal 1.0a : 2674.1 5.9 1600.0 4200 38.1% 69 Deep Onno 1-2-70 : 2673.0 4.2 2806.5 7700 36.4% 70 Naum 3.1 : 2672.6 6.4 1514.5 3000 50.5% 71 Zappa Mexico I : 2672.2 7.2 1221.0 2200 55.5% 72 Rybka 1.0 Beta : 2671.2 7.3 1023.5 2300 44.5% 73 Spark-0.3 VC(a) : 2668.0 6.3 1625.0 3600 45.1% 74 Onno-1-0-0 : 2665.3 10.7 594.5 1200 49.5% 75 Deep Sjeng WC2008 : 2663.0 4.4 2434.5 5600 43.5% 76 Toga II 1.4 beta5c BB : 2659.3 3.9 3255.5 8300 39.2% 77 Deep Junior 11.2 : 2658.0 7.5 1176.0 2900 40.6% 78 Strelka 2.0 B : 2653.8 5.5 1778.5 5500 32.3% 79 Hiarcs 12.1 MP 32b : 2650.1 5.5 2427.5 5600 43.3% 80 Tornado 4.88 : 2648.1 7.9 803.0 2400 33.5% 81 Deep Sjeng 3.0 : 2647.5 9.8 601.5 1400 43.0% 82 Umko 1.2 : 2647.4 6.6 1016.5 3300 30.8% 83 Critter 0.52b : 2636.4 7.0 1097.0 2600 42.2% 84 Shredder Classic 4 32b : 2636.3 7.8 922.5 1800 51.2% 85 Deep Junior 11.1a : 2626.3 7.7 1153.0 2800 41.2% 86 Naum 2.2 32b : 2624.7 9.6 614.0 1300 47.2% 87 Nemo 1.0.1 : 2619.7 7.8 708.0 2700 26.2% 88 Umko 1.1 : 2619.6 7.4 1146.0 3900 29.4% 89 Deep Junior 2010 : 2617.4 7.1 1210.0 3100 39.0% 90 Glaurung 2.2 JA : 2616.5 6.5 1027.5 2600 39.5% 91 Rybka 1.0 Beta 32b : 2616.4 10.2 506.0 1100 46.0% 92 HIARCS 11.2 32b : 2611.4 9.0 827.0 1900 43.5% 93 Fruit 05/11/03 32b : 2608.8 5.3 1774.0 4400 40.3% 94 Loop 2007 : 2601.9 4.2 2456.0 7900 31.1% 95 Toga II 1.2.1a : 2598.6 9.3 716.5 1600 44.8% 96 Jonny 4.00 32b : 2598.1 5.6 1389.5 5200 26.7% 97 ListMP 11 : 2594.3 8.0 987.5 2600 38.0% 98 LoopMP 12 32b : 2592.2 10.4 635.0 1500 42.3% 99 Tornado 4.80 : 2590.4 8.1 681.5 2700 25.2% 100 Deep Shredder 10 : 2588.4 6.2 1754.0 4400 39.9% 101 Twisted Logic 20100131x: 2584.1 6.7 1140.0 3500 32.6% 102 Crafty 23.3 JA : 2579.4 4.8 1290.5 5200 24.8% 103 Spike 1.2 Turin 32b : 2561.7 3.9 2349.5 7700 30.5% 104 Deep Sjeng 2.7 32b : 2537.5 9.0 465.5 1400 33.2% 105 Crafty 23.1 JA : 2526.2 6.7 1002.0 3800 26.4%
I do like it
-
lkaufman
- Posts: 5960
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 am
- Location: Maryland USA
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
Maybe next time you can save the trouble of running the test just by asking me for my prediction!
-
IWB
- Posts: 1539
- Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 2:02 pm
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
Some are already thinking that I am not playing a single game and all is a fake (but then my capability of prediction is not too bad. isn't it). With your proposal I would save a lot of energy, money and for sure some treeslkaufman wrote:Maybe next time you can save the trouble of running the test just by asking me for my prediction!
Best
Ingo
-
IWB
- Posts: 1539
- Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 2:02 pm
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
This is the latest IPON with mm 1 1, scale 1, prior 0.1.
That IS a difference to the online version.
And this is the IPON RRRL:
The error bars are much bigger (in %), is that as it should be?
I have to get used to this values ...
Bye
Ingo[/code]
Code: Select all
1 Houdini 2.0 STD 3084 11 10 5400 78% 2789 26%
2 Houdini 1.5a 3074 12 12 4000 79% 2769 26%
3 Komodo 5 3062 14 13 2850 75% 2822 33%
4 Critter 1.4a 3031 11 11 4450 77% 2765 32%
5 Komodo 4 3029 11 11 4850 75% 2777 30%
6 Critter 1.6a 3018 12 12 3150 70% 2829 40%
7 Komodo 3 3017 14 14 2800 74% 2774 31%
8 Stockfish 2.2.2 JA 3003 11 10 4800 73% 2777 35%
9 Deep Rybka 4 3003 11 10 4900 74% 2763 33%
10 Deep Rybka 4.1 3002 9 9 6200 71% 2796 37%
11 Critter 1.2 3000 13 12 3100 72% 2784 37%
12 Houdini 1.03a 2999 14 13 3200 79% 2709 30%
13 Komodo 2.03 DC 2999 14 14 2700 74% 2762 30%
14 Stockfish 2.1.1 JA 2986 12 12 3500 69% 2794 36%
15 Critter 1.01 2963 13 13 2800 70% 2765 36%
16 Stockfish 2.01 JA 2961 13 12 3100 72% 2744 35%
17 Rybka 3 mp 2937 12 11 4200 77% 2676 31%
18 Stockfish 1.9.1 JA 2936 13 13 3000 71% 2735 36%
19 Critter 0.90 2928 12 12 3400 68% 2752 36%
20 Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 2917 13 13 2900 73% 2689 33%
21 Rybka 3 32b 2871 17 16 1700 70% 2683 35%
22 Stockfish 1.6.x JA 2849 13 13 2600 69% 2672 37%
23 Komodo 1.3 JA 2846 12 12 3300 59% 2760 37%
24 Chiron 1.1a 2840 10 10 4950 54% 2802 40%
25 Deep Fritz 13 32b 2840 12 12 3300 49% 2847 40%
26 Naum 4.2 2837 7 7 9300 57% 2775 40%
27 Critter 0.80 2830 13 13 2800 64% 2696 36%
28 Fritz 13 32b 2823 11 10 4300 54% 2788 40%
29 Komodo 1.2 JA 2811 11 11 3700 59% 2728 40%
30 Rybka 2.3.2a mp 2804 12 11 3500 62% 2694 40%
31 Deep Shredder 12 2800 7 7 10400 54% 2766 38%
32 Hannibal 1.2 2797 11 11 3600 45% 2839 40%
33 Gull 1.2 2794 9 9 6300 49% 2805 36%
34 Gull 1.1 2790 12 12 3100 54% 2751 38%
35 Critter 0.70 2790 15 15 1900 58% 2711 36%
36 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 32b 2786 8 8 7300 48% 2800 39%
37 Naum 4.1 2786 14 14 2300 64% 2660 40%
38 Komodo 1.0 JA 2780 12 12 2900 61% 2683 42%
39 Spike 1.4 32b 2779 9 9 6400 47% 2805 39%
40 Deep Fritz 12 32b 2773 9 9 6300 52% 2755 38%
41 Rybka 2.2n2 mp 2772 15 14 2100 62% 2658 40%
42 Naum 4 2771 13 13 2700 60% 2677 40%
43 Gull 1.0a 2761 14 14 2300 55% 2718 39%
44 Rybka 1.2f 2757 14 14 2400 66% 2611 36%
45 Stockfish 1.5.1 JA 2755 15 15 1900 59% 2670 38%
46 spark-1.0 2747 9 8 7000 44% 2803 38%
47 Protector 1.4.0 2747 9 9 6500 44% 2801 37%
48 Hannibal 1.1 2739 10 10 4900 44% 2797 39%
49 HIARCS 13.2 MP 32b 2734 8 9 6800 43% 2801 36%
50 Deep Junior 13 2732 11 12 3600 40% 2824 36%
51 Deep Junior 13.3 2730 12 13 3000 38% 2849 33%
52 Fritz 12 32b 2730 15 15 2000 55% 2687 40%
53 Quazar 0.4 2720 11 11 3900 38% 2830 38%
54 HIARCS 13.1 MP 32b 2712 11 11 3600 48% 2731 37%
55 Deep Junior 12.5 2709 10 10 4850 40% 2804 33%
56 Deep Fritz 11 32b 2708 18 18 1300 57% 2640 39%
57 Doch64 1.2 JA 2692 16 16 1600 51% 2680 41%
58 spark-0.4 2690 12 12 3100 47% 2718 39%
59 Stockfish 1.4 JA 2689 16 16 1700 50% 2690 38%
60 Zappa Mexico II 2687 7 7 11700 43% 2752 36%
61 Shredder Bonn 32b 2687 14 14 2200 51% 2679 36%
62 Protector 1.3.2 JA 2671 10 10 5300 45% 2723 38%
63 Critter 0.60 2671 14 14 2200 49% 2683 37%
64 MinkoChess 1.3 2668 11 12 3600 32% 2845 37%
65 Deep Shredder 11 2664 13 13 2700 52% 2642 36%
66 Doch64 09.980 JA 2656 17 17 1500 47% 2681 38%
67 Naum 3.1 2650 12 12 3000 50% 2642 39%
68 Hannibal 1.0a 2648 11 11 4200 38% 2762 33%
69 Onno-1-1-1 2647 10 10 4300 45% 2697 40%
70 Zappa Mexico I 2647 14 14 2200 56% 2598 41%
71 Deep Onno 1-2-70 2647 8 9 7700 36% 2779 36%
72 Deep Junior 12 2646 12 12 3600 38% 2766 30%
73 Rybka 1.0 Beta 2644 14 14 2300 45% 2700 35%
74 Spark-0.3 VC(a) 2640 11 11 3600 45% 2684 40%
75 Onno-1-0-0 2638 19 19 1200 50% 2641 41%
76 Deep Sjeng WC2008 2634 9 9 5600 43% 2695 37%
77 Toga II 1.4 beta5c BB 2630 8 8 8300 39% 2734 37%
78 Strelka 2.0 B 2626 10 10 5500 32% 2799 33%
79 Deep Junior 11.2 2624 13 13 2900 41% 2718 31%
80 Umko 1.2 2618 12 13 3300 31% 2810 34%
81 Hiarcs 12.1 MP 32b 2616 9 9 5600 43% 2680 38%
82 Tornado 4.88 2616 14 14 2400 33% 2780 33%
83 Deep Sjeng 3.0 2614 18 18 1400 43% 2681 34%
84 Shredder Classic 4 32b 2601 15 15 1800 51% 2590 38%
85 Critter 0.52b 2601 13 13 2600 42% 2674 39%
86 Naum 2.2 32b 2591 18 18 1300 47% 2613 45%
87 Deep Junior 11.1a 2589 13 13 2800 41% 2672 34%
88 Umko 1.1 2583 11 12 3900 29% 2787 33%
89 Nemo 1.0.1 2581 14 14 2700 26% 2821 30%
90 Rybka 1.0 Beta 32b 2579 19 20 1100 46% 2614 37%
91 Glaurung 2.2 JA 2577 13 13 2600 40% 2672 38%
92 Deep Junior 2010 2576 12 13 3100 39% 2680 31%
93 HIARCS 11.2 32b 2570 15 15 1900 44% 2630 38%
94 Fruit 05/11/03 32b 2569 10 10 4400 40% 2657 41%
95 Loop 2007 2562 8 9 7900 31% 2751 33%
96 Jonny 4.00 32b 2555 10 10 5200 27% 2795 28%
97 Toga II 1.2.1a 2554 16 16 1600 45% 2603 41%
98 ListMP 11 2551 13 13 2600 38% 2664 37%
99 LoopMP 12 32b 2546 17 17 1500 42% 2616 38%
100 Tornado 4.80 2546 14 15 2700 25% 2804 26%
101 Deep Shredder 10 2540 10 10 4400 40% 2636 33%
102 Twisted Logic 20100131x 2535 12 12 3500 33% 2707 30%
103 Crafty 23.3 JA 2534 10 11 5200 25% 2796 27%
104 Spike 1.2 Turin 32b 2511 8 8 7700 31% 2701 33%
105 Deep Sjeng 2.7 32b 2479 18 18 1400 33% 2636 36%
106 Crafty 23.1 JA 2466 12 12 3800 26% 2703 28% And this is the IPON RRRL:
Code: Select all
1 Houdini 2.0 STD 3099 14 13 2850 77% 2823 28%
2 Komodo 5 3071 13 12 2850 75% 2824 33%
3 Critter 1.6a 3026 13 12 2850 71% 2827 40%
4 Stockfish 2.2.2 JA 3016 12 12 2850 70% 2827 39%
5 Deep Rybka 4.1 3006 13 12 2850 69% 2828 40%
6 Deep Fritz 13 32b 2847 12 12 2850 51% 2836 40%
7 Naum 4.2 2844 12 12 2850 51% 2836 42%
8 Chiron 1.1a 2844 12 12 2850 51% 2836 42%
9 Deep Shredder 12 2800 12 12 2850 46% 2839 41%
10 Gull 1.2 2799 12 12 2850 46% 2839 39%
11 Hannibal 1.2 2796 12 12 2850 45% 2839 41%
12 Deep Sjeng c't 2010 32b 2791 12 12 2850 45% 2839 41%
13 Spike 1.4 32b 2776 12 12 2850 43% 2840 41%
14 spark-1.0 2756 12 12 2850 41% 2841 40%
15 Protector 1.4.0 2744 12 12 2850 40% 2841 38%
16 HIARCS 13.2 MP 32b 2731 12 13 2850 39% 2842 37%
17 Deep Junior 13.3 2730 12 13 2850 39% 2842 33%
18 Quazar 0.4 2715 12 13 2850 37% 2843 37%
19 Zappa Mexico II 2675 12 13 2850 33% 2845 34%
20 MinkoChess 1.3 2665 12 13 2850 32% 2846 37%The error bars are much bigger (in %), is that as it should be?
I have to get used to this values ...
Bye
Ingo[/code]
-
lkaufman
- Posts: 5960
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 am
- Location: Maryland USA
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
The error bars should be about 20% larger, because the spread of the ratings is about 20% wider.
Larry
Larry
-
Albert Silver
- Posts: 3019
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:57 pm
- Location: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Re: Komodo 5 running for the IPON
I had no idea you used trees to run your tests. I am as mad as hell.IWB wrote:Some are already thinking that I am not playing a single game and all is a fake (but then my capability of prediction is not too bad. isn't it). With your proposal I would save a lot of energy, money and for sure some treeslkaufman wrote:Maybe next time you can save the trouble of running the test just by asking me for my prediction!
Best
Ingo
Albert
"Tactics are the bricks and sticks that make up a game, but positional play is the architectural blueprint."