testing engines with fixed depth

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderator: Ras

Togga

Re: glaurung disaster part 2

Post by Togga »

did you run this test with last version of stockfish 1.6.3 ?

i run my test under these conditions:

timecontrol 2min + 2 sec

10 games:

1.d4 d5 2.c4
1.e4 e5
1.g3
1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5
1.e4 c5

reversed colors.

this should be a fair short test. isnt it?
Togga

the glaurung games:

Post by Togga »

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Black "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D30"]
[Opening "QGD"]
[Variation "3.cxd5"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "158"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 {+0.01/13} 3.cxd5
{+0.20/13} exd5 {+0.11/14} 4.e3 {+0.16/14} Nf6 {+0.15/13} 5.Nf3 {+0.24/14} Nc6 {+0.13/13}
6.a3 {+0.32/14} Bd6 {+0.23/13} 7.Bd3 {+0.08/14} O-O {+0.17/14} 8.O-O {+0.20/14} Bg4
{+0.21/13} 9.h3 {0.00/13} Bh5 {+0.27/14} 10.Nc3 {+0.04/13} Qd7 {+0.29/13} 11.Bd2
{-0.04/13} a6 {+0.31/12} 12.Be2 {0.00/13} Rfe8 {+0.31/12} 13.Rc1 {0.00/12} Rab8 {+0.27/12}
14.Qb3 {0.00/13} h6 {+0.25/12} 15.Rfe1 {0.00/13} Qe6 {+0.25/12} 16.Red1 {0.00/14} Bg6
{+0.23/12} 17.Nh4 {0.00/14} Bh7 {+0.27/13} 18.Be1 {0.00/15} Be7 {+0.19/12} 19.Nf3
{0.00/14} Red8 {+0.11/13} 20.Qa2 {0.00/15} Ne4 {+0.13/12} 21.Bd3 {+0.12/13} Bf5
{+0.15/14} 22.Bxe4 {+0.20/14} Bxe4 {+0.03/15} 23.Nxe4 {+0.16/14} Qxe4 {+0.01/15} 24.Qb3
{+0.20/14} Qf5 {0.00/14} 25.Bc3 {+0.12/14} Rd6 {0.00/15} 26.Qc2 {+0.28/14} Qxc2 {0.00/15}
27.Rxc2 {+0.24/13} Re6 {-0.03/14} 28.Ne5 {+0.24/14} Re8 {+0.05/14} 29.b4 {+0.48/14} Rd8
{-0.09/13} 30.Nd3 {+0.56/13} Bd6 {-0.35/13} 31.a4 {+0.76/13} Ne7 {-0.54/14} 32.b5
{+0.96/13} axb5 {-0.88/14} 33.axb5 {+1.01/15} c6 {-1.00/14} 34.bxc6 {+1.17/14} bxc6
{-0.98/15} 35.Ra1 {+1.21/13} Rb8 {-0.84/14} 36.Rb2 {+1.21/15} Rxb2 {-0.92/15} 37.Bxb2
{+1.25/15} Kh7 {-0.94/15} 38.Ba3 {+1.37/15} Kg6 {-1.13/15} 39.Bc5 {+1.45/15} Kf6
{-1.11/14} 40.Kf1 {+1.45/15} h5 {-1.17/15} 41.Ra8 {+1.45/16} Bc7 {-1.23/14} 42.g4
{+1.85/15} hxg4 {-1.41/15} 43.hxg4 {+2.10/15} Ng6 {-1.94/16} 44.Ra7 {+2.30/16} Bh2
{-2.25/15} 45.g5+ {+2.38/15} Kxg5 {-2.23/15} 46.Rxf7 {+2.42/17} Kh6 {-2.43/15} 47.Nb4
{+2.30/16} Nh4 {-2.43/14} 48.Rf8 {+2.62/15} g5 {-2.88/14} 49.Rc8 {+2.74/13} Kg7 {-2.80/14}
50.Nxc6 {+2.74/13} Rf6 {-2.78/14} 51.Be7 {+2.90/14} Rf5 {-2.92/14} 52.f4 {+3.27/12}
gxf4 {-2.84/14} 53.Bxh4 {+3.75/13} fxe3+ {-3.45/15} 54.Ke2 {+4.16/14} Rh5 {-3.66/15}
55.Be7 {+4.28/13} Bf4 {-3.76/14} 56.Bb4 {+4.28/14} Rh2+ {-4.01/13} 57.Kd3 {+4.40/14}
e2 {-4.03/13} 58.Re8 {+4.32/16} Kf6 {-4.07/14} 59.Rf8+ {+4.52/14} Kg5 {-4.29/11}
60.Ne7 {+4.88/13} e1=N+ {-4.56/14} 61.Bxe1 {+4.88/11} Rh3+ {-4.62/15} 62.Kc2
{+4.88/14} Bd6 {-4.80/15} 63.Bd2+ {+4.88/16} Kg4 {-4.70/17} 64.Rf7 {+5.25/18} Bxe7
{-5.17/16} 65.Rxe7 {+6.26/17} Rh8 {-5.78/18} 66.Re5 {+6.66/18} Rd8 {-5.94/18} 67.Kc3
{+6.90/17} Kf3 {-6.23/17} 68.Kb4 {+7.15/18} Rc8 {-6.43/17} 69.Rxd5 {+7.27/18} Ke4
{-6.50/16} 70.Rc5 {+7.75/17} Rd8 {-6.70/17} 71.Bc3 {+7.55/14} Kd3 {-6.80/16} 72.d5
{+8.20/18} Rb8+ {-7.17/16} 73.Rb5 {+9.65/17} Rd8 {-7.54/17} 74.Bf6 {+12.84/15} Rd7
{-8.76/17} 75.Kc5 {+14.10/14} Rc7+ {-10.43/17} 76.Kd6 {+17.49/14} Rc8 {-8.84/15} 77.Rb3+
{+82.77/17} Ke4 {-12.56/17} 78.Ke6 {+83.18/18} Re8+ {-18.11/15} 79.Kf7 {+83.18/19} Ra8
{-80.31/16} {1-0 Arena Adjudication} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "2"]
[White "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Black "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "D30"]
[Opening "QGD"]
[Variation "3.Nf3 Nf6 4.e3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "93"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 {-0.16/14} 3.Nf3
{-0.01/12} Nf6 {-0.20/14} 4.e3 {+0.09/12} Be7 {-0.20/14} 5.Bd3 {+0.13/12} c5 {-0.20/15}
6.O-O {+0.09/11} dxc4 {-0.08/15} 7.Bxc4 {+0.11/14} O-O {-0.20/14} 8.Nc3 {+0.21/13}
Nc6 {-0.16/14} 9.a3 {+0.15/13} cxd4 {-0.08/13} 10.exd4 {+0.25/13} Qc7 {-0.16/13}
11.Bd3 {+0.33/12} a6 {-0.20/13} 12.Qc2 {+0.33/12} Bd7 {-0.24/12} 13.Be3 {+0.45/12}
Rfc8 {-0.16/12} 14.Rac1 {+0.43/12} b5 {-0.24/11} 15.b4 {+0.49/11} a5 {0.00/12}
16.Qb1 {-0.09/12} axb4 {+0.48/13} 17.axb4 {-0.33/13} Qb8 {+0.60/12} 18.Ne4 {-0.35/12}
Nxe4 {+1.01/13} 19.Bxe4 {-0.60/14} f5 {+1.05/14} 20.Bxc6 {-0.62/14} Bxc6 {+0.88/14}
21.Ne5 {-0.76/15} Bd5 {+1.05/14} 22.Bd2 {-0.70/14} Bd6 {+1.05/14} 23.Bf4 {-0.70/14}
Rd8 {+0.96/14} 24.Bg5 {-0.62/13} Re8 {+0.96/14} 25.Bf4 {-0.72/13} Qd8 {+1.01/13}
26.Rc3 {-0.52/13} Qh4 {+0.88/12} 27.Ng6 {-0.86/14} hxg6 {+1.13/12} 28.Bxd6 {-0.78/11}
Qxd4 {+1.13/14} 29.Rg3 {-0.92/13} Qf6 {+1.25/14} 30.Qc1 {-0.96/13} Ra6 {+1.25/13}
31.Qc5 {-0.94/13} Ra1 {+1.97/12} 32.Qxb5 {-1.68/14} Rc8 {+3.35/14} 33.Bc5 {-3.84/13}
f4 {+4.96/14} 34.Rg4 {-3.96/13} Rxf1+ {+5.05/16} 35.Qxf1 {-4.68/15} Ra8 {+5.13/15}
36.h4 {-4.86/16} Ra1 {+5.37/16} 37.Qxa1 {-4.92/16} Qxa1+ {+5.41/12} 38.Kh2 {-4.47/6}
Qe5 {+5.61/15} 39.f3 {-5.05/14} Kf7 {+5.77/15} 40.Bf2 {-5.54/16} Bc4 {+6.38/14}
41.Bb6 {-6.19/14} Bd3 {+7.67/16} 42.Bc5 {-6.50/15} Bf5 {+9.29/17} 43.Rg5 {-7.31/14}
Qe1 {+10.66/14} 44.g3 {-7.84/14} Qe2+ {+12.92/13} 45.Kg1 {-16.96/15} Be4
{+86.02/16} 46.Rg4 {-M7/15} e5 {+M7/11} 47.gxf4 {-M6/9} {0-1 Arena Adjudication} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "3"]
[White "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Black "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "C42"]
[Opening "Russian Game"]
[Variation "Milner-Barry Variation"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "118"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 {+0.64/14} Nf6 {-0.50/12}
3.Nxe5 {+0.44/14} d6 {-0.43/13} 4.Nf3 {+0.48/14} Nxe4 {-0.47/13} 5.Qe2 {+0.44/14} Qe7
{-0.29/13} 6.Nc3 {+0.40/15} Nxc3 {-0.31/14} 7.bxc3 {+0.32/15} Nc6 {+0.01/13} 8.Rb1
{+0.32/13} Rb8 {-0.03/13} 9.d4 {+0.24/13} Be6 {+0.01/13} 10.a4 {+0.36/14} g6 {-0.01/13}
11.Kd1 {+0.44/13} Bg7 {+0.39/14} 12.h4 {+0.16/13} O-O {+0.43/13} 13.h5 {+0.40/12} Bg4
{+0.23/13} 14.hxg6 {+0.56/13} fxg6 {+0.25/12} 15.Qxe7 {+0.44/13} Nxe7 {+0.35/13} 16.Bc4+
{-0.20/13} Kh8 {+0.21/14} 17.Bg5 {+0.12/13} Bxf3+ {+0.23/13} 18.gxf3 {+0.40/10} Nf5
{+0.17/14} 19.Bd3 {+0.16/13} b6 {+0.13/12} 20.Kd2 {0.00/12} c6 {+0.49/12} 21.Rbe1
{+0.08/12} Kg8 {+0.45/13} 22.Rh3 {0.00/13} d5 {+0.49/13} 23.f4 {+0.16/13} Rb7 {+0.41/14}
24.Bxf5 {-0.20/13} Rxf5 {+0.82/13} 25.Re6 {-0.24/13} Rc7 {+0.72/14} 26.Rd6 {-0.20/14}
Bf8 {+0.66/14} 27.Rd8 {-0.08/14} h5 {+0.54/14} 28.Re3 {0.00/15} Kg7 {+0.31/14}
29.Ree8 {0.00/15} Rb7 {+0.17/13} 30.Rdc8 {+0.20/14} c5 {+0.01/13} 31.Rc6 {+0.24/12} Kf7
{-0.15/13} 32.Ree6 {+0.60/13} h4 {-0.35/14} 33.Bxh4 {+0.80/13} cxd4 {-0.54/14} 34.Bg5
{+0.84/12} dxc3+ {-0.52/13} 35.Kxc3 {+0.84/14} Bg7+ {-0.68/13} 36.Kd3 {+1.25/14} d4
{-0.68/15} 37.Rexg6 {+1.09/15} Ra5 {-0.76/15} 38.Bh6 {+1.73/13} Bh8 {-0.76/13} 39.Rg5
{+2.90/13} Ra6 {-2.11/14} 40.Rc8 {+5.45/15} Bf6 {-3.45/11} 41.Rf8+ {+4.80/11} Ke6
{-4.50/15} 42.f5+ {+4.76/13} Ke7 {-4.72/16} 43.Rg6 {+5.45/15} b5 {-4.78/16} 44.Rfg8
{+5.17/14} Rbb6 {-4.39/13} 45.Bf8+ {+5.77/12} Kd7 {-5.43/15} 46.Bc5 {+5.81/12} bxa4
{-5.49/14} 47.Rf8 {+5.85/12} Rbc6 {-5.47/14} 48.Rf7+ {+6.06/12} Kc8 {-5.60/14} 49.Rg8+
{+6.10/12} Bd8 {-5.72/6} 50.Be7 {+6.26/12} Rc7 {-5.82/13} 51.Rxd8+ {+6.10/10} Kb7
{-5.33/6} 52.Rxd4 {+6.10/12} a3 {-5.74/12} 53.Rb4+ {+6.58/12} Kc8 {-6.31/13} 54.Rf8+
{+6.82/13} Kd7 {-5.58/6} 55.Bg5 {+6.90/12} Ra5 {-6.70/12} 56.Rd4+ {+8.72/11} Kc6 {-6.84/9}
57.Rf6+ {+9.77/12} Kb5 {-9.03/14} 58.Re6 {+13.21/13} Rc5 {-10.60/14} 59.Bd2 {+13.97/14}
Ra4 {-12.82/14} {1-0 Arena Adjudication} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "4"]
[White "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Black "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C42"]
[Opening "Russian Game"]
[Variation "French Attack"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "105"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 {+0.49/13} Nf6 {-0.28/13}
3.Nxe5 {+0.58/13} d6 {-0.28/14} 4.Nf3 {+0.35/14} Nxe4 {-0.40/15} 5.Bd3 {+0.33/13} Nf6
{-0.20/15} 6.O-O {+0.15/13} Be7 {-0.24/14} 7.Be2 {+0.09/14} O-O {-0.40/14} 8.d4 {+0.21/14}
d5 {-0.20/13} 9.Nc3 {+0.21/13} Nc6 {-0.20/13} 10.Ne5 {+0.21/13} Bd6 {+0.04/13}
11.Nxc6 {+0.03/13} bxc6 {+0.20/12} 12.Bg5 {+0.19/14} Rb8 {+0.16/15} 13.Rb1 {+0.23/14}
Bf5 {+0.28/13} 14.Bh4 {+0.27/13} Re8 {+0.12/13} 15.Bd3 {+0.29/13} Bg6 {0.00/13}
16.a3 {+0.25/13} Bf4 {0.00/13} 17.Qf3 {+0.23/14} Qd6 {-0.08/13} 18.g3 {+0.21/14} Bd2
{-0.12/14} 19.Bxf6 {+0.74/13} Qxf6 {-0.44/14} 20.Qxf6 {+0.68/15} gxf6 {-0.36/11} 21.Rfd1
{+0.76/15} Bxc3 {-0.28/15} 22.bxc3 {+0.74/15} Rb6 {-0.32/16} 23.Kg2 {+0.80/14} Reb8
{-0.12/16} 24.Rb4 {+0.84/14} a5 {-0.16/16} 25.Ra4 {+0.72/15} Ra8 {-0.28/15} 26.f4
{+0.78/15} Bxd3 {-0.16/16} 27.Rxd3 {+0.74/17} Rb2 {-0.12/17} 28.Rd2 {+0.70/16} Kg7
{-0.24/17} 29.Re2 {+0.68/15} Kg6 {-0.16/17} 30.c4 {+0.64/16} f5 {-0.16/16} 31.Kf3
{+0.78/15} Kf6 {-0.16/17} 32.h3 {+0.74/15} h5 {0.00/17} 33.Kg2 {+0.64/15} Ra2 {0.00/18}
34.Kf2 {+0.56/16} Rb2 {0.00/20} 35.c3 {+0.50/16} Rb3 {0.00/18} 36.Rc2 {+0.49/15} Kg6
{0.00/16} 37.h4 {+0.35/14} Rb1 {0.00/16} 38.cxd5 {+0.27/16} cxd5 {0.00/17} 39.c4
{+0.27/16} c6 {0.00/18} 40.Re2 {+0.15/15} Rb3 {0.00/16} 41.Re5 {+0.17/15} f6 {0.00/16}
42.Re3 {+0.19/15} Rxe3 {+0.20/19} 43.Kxe3 {+0.19/14} Kf7 {+1.89/23} 44.Kf2 {0.00/19}
Ke8 {+4.92/22} 45.Kf3 {-2.41/21} Kd8 {+5.25/20} 46.Ke3 {-3.54/22} Kc7 {+6.18/19}
47.Kd3 {-4.01/19} Kb6 {+6.30/21} 48.Kc2 {-5.23/20} Rg8 {+10.46/18} 49.Kd3 {-6.00/20}
Rxg3+ {+14.14/17} 50.Kd2 {-6.01/20} Rg4 {+21.01/17} 51.Ke3 {-13.05/19} Rxh4
{+27.55/17} 52.Kf3 {-13.11/18} Rg4 {+90.24/17} 53.Ke3 {-15.52/15} {0-1 Arena Adjudication} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "5"]
[White "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Black "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D34"]
[Opening "QGD Tarrasch"]
[Variation "9.Bf4"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "100"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.g3 Nf6 {+0.31/14} 2.Nf3 {-0.16/14} e6
{+0.23/14} 3.Bg2 {-0.20/14} d5 {+0.29/13} 4.O-O {-0.12/14} Be7 {+0.25/14} 5.d4 {+0.12/14}
c5 {+0.21/14} 6.c4 {0.00/14} O-O {+0.25/14} 7.cxd5 {+0.08/14} exd5 {+0.19/14}
8.Nc3 {+0.08/14} Nc6 {-0.05/13} 9.Bf4 {+0.12/13} Bf5 {+0.17/12} 10.dxc5 {+0.12/12}
Bxc5 {-0.05/12} 11.Rc1 {+0.20/13} Bb6 {-0.17/11} 12.Nb5 {+0.20/13} Ne4 {-0.07/12}
13.Nfd4 {0.00/13} Nxd4 {-0.23/12} 14.Nxd4 {+0.04/14} Bd7 {-0.09/13} 15.e3 {0.00/13} Re8
{+0.07/13} 16.Qh5 {0.00/13} Bxd4 {+0.11/13} 17.exd4 {+0.24/13} Bc6 {-0.03/14} 18.Qd1
{+0.32/13} Qb6 {0.00/14} 19.f3 {+0.24/13} Nf6 {0.00/14} 20.Rf2 {+0.36/13} Bd7 {-0.03/14}
21.Rfc2 {+0.44/14} Bf5 {+0.01/14} 22.R2c7 {+0.04/13} Qxb2 {+0.45/14} 23.g4 {+0.68/14}
Bg6 {+0.03/13} 24.h4 {+0.76/13} h6 {-0.03/12} 25.Be5 {+0.88/13} Re6 {-0.03/12}
26.h5 {+0.80/14} Bh7 {-0.27/13} 27.Qb3 {+1.41/14} Qxb3 {-0.45/13} 28.axb3 {+0.96/14}
b6 {-0.70/13} 29.Bh3 {+1.17/15} Ne8 {-0.60/14} 30.Rd7 {+1.21/15} Kf8 {-0.54/14}
31.g5 {+1.65/15} Re7 {-0.78/15} 32.Rxe7 {+1.57/14} Kxe7 {-0.84/15} 33.gxh6 {+1.73/15}
gxh6 {-0.94/14} 34.Kf2 {+1.93/14} Bd3 {-1.21/14} 35.Bf4 {+1.97/14} f5 {-0.98/13}
36.Bxh6 {+2.86/15} Nd6 {-1.76/14} 37.Bf4 {+2.90/14} Bb5 {-2.45/13} 38.Re1+ {+3.35/14}
Kd7 {-2.62/14} 39.Be5 {+4.00/15} Rf8 {-3.19/13} 40.h6 {+5.45/14} Bd3 {-4.07/14}
41.Ke3 {+5.97/15} Bc2 {-4.21/15} 42.h7 {+6.06/12} Nf7 {-5.03/16} 43.Rc1 {+6.94/16}
Nxe5 {-5.21/15} 44.dxe5 {+7.59/15} d4+ {-6.01/16} 45.Kxd4 {+8.64/17} Bxb3 {-6.39/16}
46.Bxf5+ {+14.02/17} Be6 {-6.74/16} 47.Bxe6+ {+14.34/17} Kxe6 {-8.94/12} 48.Rc6+
{+13.25/18} Kd7 {-13.05/17} 49.Kd5 {+24.00/17} Rh8 {-17.15/16} 50.e6+ {+31.71/18} Kd8
{-18.74/17} {1-0 Arena Adjudication} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "6"]
[White "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Black "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "A00"]
[Opening "Benko Opening"]
[Variation "Reversed Alekhine"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "89"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.g3 e5 {+0.20/14} 2.Nf3 {-0.17/14} e4
{+0.28/14} 3.Nd4 {-0.01/13} Nf6 {+0.20/14} 4.d3 {-0.17/13} exd3 {+0.24/14} 5.Qxd3
{0.00/12} d5 {+0.40/13} 6.Bg2 {-0.15/12} Na6 {+0.20/12} 7.O-O {+0.03/11} Be7 {+0.28/13}
8.Bg5 {+0.03/12} Nc5 {+0.32/14} 9.Qc3 {-0.33/13} Nce4 {+0.28/13} 10.Bxe4 {-0.17/13}
Nxe4 {+0.24/13} 11.Bxe7 {-0.23/13} Qxe7 {+0.48/14} 12.Qe3 {-0.17/13} c5 {+0.36/13}
13.Nb5 {-0.35/13} Be6 {+0.48/14} 14.N1c3 {-0.39/13} Nxc3 {+0.96/14} 15.Qxc3 {-0.86/14}
d4 {+1.01/14} 16.Qa3 {-0.84/14} a6 {+2.18/15} 17.Qa5 {-1.07/13} Rc8 {+2.14/16}
18.Na3 {-2.13/15} Bh3 {+2.10/14} 19.Rfd1 {-2.31/14} Qe4 {+2.50/14} 20.f3 {-2.41/15}
Qe3+ {+2.90/16} 21.Kh1 {-2.03/6} O-O {+2.98/16} 22.Qe1 {-2.09/15} Rce8 {+2.82/16}
23.Rd2 {-1.94/14} b5 {+2.86/14} 24.Rc1 {-2.19/14} Re7 {+2.26/15} 25.c3 {-2.84/14} d3
{+2.82/14} 26.Rxd3 {-2.76/16} Qxe2 {+3.07/17} 27.Qxe2 {-2.86/16} Rxe2 {+3.07/14} 28.b3
{-2.90/15} Rfe8 {+3.95/15} 29.Rg1 {-3.60/15} Rxa2 {+3.71/13} 30.Nb1 {-3.19/14} Kf8
{+3.55/14} 31.Nd2 {-3.62/15} Re2 {+3.71/14} 32.Rd1 {-3.92/15} a5 {+4.08/14} 33.g4
{-4.31/14} a4 {+4.96/13} 34.bxa4 {-4.54/13} bxa4 {+5.65/13} 35.Kg1 {-4.98/14} a3
{+5.77/12} 36.c4 {-5.39/13} Rb2 {+7.27/14} 37.Rd8+ {-5.94/13} Ke7 {+7.55/14} 38.Nf1
{-5.94/12} a2 {+8.72/12} 39.Ra8 {-7.54/13} Bxf1 {+8.96/14} 40.Kxf1 {-7.62/13} Rexh2
{+9.81/15} 41.Ra7+ {-8.39/14} Ke6 {+10.22/15} 42.Kg1 {-8.52/14} Rhg2+ {+10.30/13} 43.Kf1
{-9.52/15} Rgf2+ {+10.46/13} 44.Kg1 {-9.49/13} Rxf3 {+10.66/14} 45.Re1+ {-9.68/14} {0-1
Arena Adjudication} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "7"]
[White "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Black "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B12"]
[Opening "Caro-Kann"]
[Variation "Advance Variation, 3...c5"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "98"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.e5 {+0.92/14} c5
{-0.94/12} 4.Nf3 {+0.56/14} e6 {-1.05/13} 5.c3 {+0.72/13} Nc6 {-1.05/12} 6.Bd3 {+0.52/13}
Nh6 {-0.76/13} 7.O-O {+0.68/14} Bd7 {-0.78/13} 8.Na3 {+0.60/12} Qb6 {-0.86/13}
9.dxc5 {+0.68/12} Bxc5 {-0.98/13} 10.b4 {+0.64/13} Bxf2+ {-0.88/12} 11.Rxf2 {+1.25/11}
Ng4 {-0.76/14} 12.Qe2 {+0.92/14} f6 {-0.82/13} 13.exf6 {+1.17/13} gxf6 {-1.39/13}
14.Nd4 {+1.49/13} Nxf2 {-1.37/12} 15.Qxf2 {+1.01/11} e5 {-1.39/12} 16.Bh6 {+1.05/13}
O-O-O {-1.03/13} 17.Nxc6 {+1.13/13} Qxf2+ {-1.03/13} 18.Kxf2 {+1.25/10} Bxc6
{-1.03/12} 19.g3 {+1.29/12} Rdg8 {-1.15/13} 20.Nb5 {+1.69/15} Bxb5 {-1.29/14} 21.Bxb5
{+1.69/13} Kc7 {-1.35/15} 22.Rd1 {+1.53/14} Rgd8 {-1.39/14} 23.Bd3 {+1.57/13} Rd6
{-1.21/13} 24.Ke2 {+1.69/13} Rc6 {-1.37/12} 25.Kd2 {+1.81/14} b6 {-1.45/13} 26.b5
{+1.77/15} Re6 {-1.58/14} 27.Ke2 {+2.06/14} Rd8 {-1.70/14} 28.Rf1 {+2.26/13} Rg8
{-1.98/14} 29.Bc2 {+2.30/14} Kd7 {-2.17/13} 30.Bb3 {+2.90/16} Rg6 {-2.56/14} 31.Bc1
{+3.47/14} Rd6 {-3.07/15} 32.Ba3 {+3.75/15} Rh6 {-3.31/15} 33.Bxd6 {+4.08/16} Kxd6
{-3.60/16} 34.Ke3 {+4.28/16} Kc5 {-3.52/16} 35.Rf2 {+4.36/18} Kxb5 {-3.23/17} 36.Bxd5
{+4.60/17} Kc5 {-3.54/16} 37.Be4 {+4.52/16} Kd6 {-3.68/15} 38.h4 {+5.45/17} Kc7 {-4.11/17}
39.Bf5 {+6.94/20} Kc6 {-4.80/17} 40.Rd2 {+7.35/18} Rh5 {-5.23/17} 41.Ke4 {+8.24/17} b5
{-5.41/17} 42.Bd7+ {+8.40/16} Kb6 {-5.60/17} 43.Bg4 {+9.49/17} Rh6 {-6.84/18} 44.Bf5
{+10.26/19} Kc5 {-8.41/18} 45.Rd7 {+12.32/18} a5 {-8.58/18} 46.Rxh7 {+15.47/18} Rxh7
{-8.82/16} 47.Bxh7 {+16.24/13} Kd6 {-9.76/17} 48.h5 {+19.55/16} Ke7 {-12.15/17} 49.h6
{+17.45/14} Kf8 {-14.05/17} {1-0 Arena Adjudication} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "8"]
[White "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Black "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B13"]
[Opening "Caro-Kann"]
[Variation "Exchange, 4.Nf3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "141"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 {+0.88/13} cxd5
{-0.28/13} 4.Nf3 {+0.64/13} e6 {-0.32/13} 5.Bd3 {+0.41/13} Nf6 {-0.16/14} 6.O-O {+0.39/13}
Nc6 {-0.20/13} 7.Bg5 {+0.35/13} h6 {-0.04/13} 8.Bf4 {+0.29/14} Bd6 {-0.16/14}
9.Bxd6 {+0.35/14} Qxd6 {-0.16/14} 10.Nc3 {+0.35/14} O-O {+0.08/14} 11.Qd2 {+0.33/14}
Bd7 {+0.12/14} 12.Rfe1 {+0.29/13} a6 {0.00/14} 13.a3 {+0.27/13} Rac8 {0.00/14}
14.Rad1 {+0.23/13} Qc7 {+0.04/14} 15.Rdc1 {+0.15/13} Rfe8 {+0.04/13} 16.Rcb1 {+0.11/12}
e5 {+0.20/15} 17.dxe5 {+0.19/14} Nxe5 {+0.12/15} 18.Nxe5 {+0.15/14} Rxe5
{+0.16/10} 19.Rxe5 {+0.17/15} Qxe5 {+0.12/12} 20.Re1 {+0.05/14} Qd6 {+0.04/14} 21.Ne2
{+0.25/13} Qb6 {+0.08/14} 22.Qb4 {+0.41/15} Qxb4 {-0.28/15} 23.axb4 {+0.41/14} Kf8
{-0.20/15} 24.f3 {+0.58/15} Ke7 {-0.20/15} 25.Nd4+ {+0.58/15} Kd6 {-0.20/16} 26.Kf2
{+0.58/16} Nh5 {-0.20/14} 27.g3 {+0.52/14} g6 {-0.32/16} 28.Ra1 {+0.52/14} Ng7 {-0.20/16}
29.c3 {+0.54/15} Ne6 {-0.20/17} 30.Nxe6 {+0.56/15} Kxe6 {-0.28/16} 31.Ke3 {+0.54/16}
Ke5 {-0.28/17} 32.f4+ {+0.54/16} Kd6 {-0.24/17} 33.Kd4 {+0.52/16} Re8 {-0.32/16}
34.b3 {+0.56/15} f5 {-0.24/16} 35.h3 {+0.56/16} Re7 {-0.28/15} 36.Ra5 {+0.62/16} Bc6
{0.00/15} 37.Ra2 {+0.41/16} Re1 {0.00/16} 38.Re2 {+0.31/15} Rh1 {0.00/17} 39.h4
{+0.43/16} h5 {0.00/19} 40.c4 {+0.15/16} Rd1 {0.00/17} 41.c5+ {+0.21/15} Kd7 {0.00/19}
42.Re5 {0.00/17} Kd8 {0.00/18} 43.Ke3 {0.00/17} Kd7 {0.00/18} 44.Kd4 {0.00/17} Kd8
{0.00/20} 45.Re3 {+0.05/18} Kd7 {0.00/19} 46.Ke5 {0.00/19} Kd8 {0.00/18} 47.Be2
{+0.17/16} Rd2 {0.00/18} 48.Bf1 {0.00/17} Rd1 {0.00/19} 49.b5 {0.00/17} axb5 {+1.01/17}
50.Be2 {0.00/17} Rd2 {+1.37/15} 51.Bf1 {-0.21/16} Ke7 {+1.29/18} 52.Re1 {-0.74/16} Rb2
{+1.77/17} 53.Re3 {-0.88/16} b4 {+1.81/16} 54.Be2 {-0.82/18} Rc2 {+1.53/16} 55.Bd3
{-0.94/18} Rc3 {+1.93/18} 56.Kd4+ {-1.50/17} Kf6 {+1.85/20} 57.Be2 {-1.64/18} Rc2
{+1.53/16} 58.Bd3 {-1.74/17} Rb2 {+2.18/18} 59.Rf3 {-2.05/18} Rd2 {+2.78/18} 60.Ke3
{-2.45/19} Rd1 {+3.35/18} 61.Kd4 {-2.62/19} Bb5 {+3.79/19} 62.Re3 {-2.60/16} Rd2
{+4.12/20} 63.Rf3 {-2.72/18} Ke7 {+5.85/17} 64.Re3+ {-3.17/18} Kd7 {+6.06/18} 65.Rf3
{-4.17/19} Kc6 {+4.72/16} 66.Re3 {-5.37/19} Rxd3+ {+22.58/18} 67.Rxd3 {-7.19/20} Bxd3
{+20.44/15} 68.Kxd3 {-7.19/19} Kxc5 {+94.30/20} 69.Ke3 {-18.56/23} d4+ {+94.30/23} 70.Ke2
{-22.84/23} Kd5 {+M14/23} 71.Kd3 {-M13/24} {0-1 Arena Adjudication} 0-1

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "9"]
[White "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Black "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B23"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "Closed, 2...Nc6 3.Bb5 Nd4"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "118"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c5 2.Nc3 {+0.80/14} Nc6 {-0.94/13}
3.Bb5 {+0.60/14} Nd4 {-0.94/13} 4.Nf3 {+0.84/14} e6 {-0.84/13} 5.O-O {+0.52/12} Bd6
{-0.94/14} 6.d3 {+0.48/13} Ne7 {-0.72/13} 7.Be3 {+0.44/13} Qb6 {-0.56/13} 8.Ba4 {+0.44/12}
O-O {-0.54/12} 9.Nd2 {+0.40/14} Bb8 {-0.94/13} 10.Nc4 {+0.08/12} Qd8 {-0.54/14}
11.e5 {+0.36/13} Nef5 {-0.56/12} 12.Re1 {+0.16/11} f6 {-0.05/12} 13.Nd6 {-0.28/11}
Nxe3 {+0.37/13} 14.fxe3 {-0.44/13} Bxd6 {+0.41/14} 15.exd6 {-0.36/14} Nf5 {+0.43/15}
16.Qh5 {-0.44/14} g6 {+0.45/14} 17.Qf3 {-0.36/14} Nxd6 {+0.50/14} 18.Bb3 {-0.44/13}
Nf5 {+0.47/13} 19.Ne4 {-0.68/14} Qe7 {+0.72/14} 20.c3 {-0.56/13} d5 {+0.76/13}
21.Nd2 {-0.32/13} a5 {+0.68/13} 22.a4 {-0.52/13} Qc7 {+0.70/13} 23.e4 {-0.48/11} dxe4
{+0.49/13} 24.Rxe4 {-0.44/12} Qb6 {+0.68/13} 25.Qf2 {-0.48/13} Bd7 {+0.52/13} 26.Rae1
{-0.20/12} Rae8 {+0.70/13} 27.Bc4 {-0.48/12} Qxb2 {+0.47/12} 28.R4e2 {+0.28/14} Nd6
{+0.19/13} 29.Nb3 {+2.10/13} Qxc3 {-1.41/14} 30.Rc2 {+2.50/13} Qxe1+ {-1.74/14} 31.Qxe1
{+2.38/11} b6 {-1.88/15} 32.Qg3 {+2.50/14} Nxc4 {-1.74/14} 33.Rxc4 {+2.46/14} e5
{-1.82/15} 34.Qf3 {+2.46/14} Bf5 {-1.78/14} 35.Qc6 {+3.23/14} h5 {-2.01/14} 36.Nd2
{+3.35/14} Re6 {-2.23/15} 37.Qd5 {+3.31/14} Kg7 {-2.82/14} 38.Ne4 {+3.71/13} Re7
{-2.62/15} 39.Qc6 {+3.91/15} Bxe4 {-3.41/15} 40.dxe4 {+3.91/14} Rb8 {-3.72/15} 41.Rc3
{+4.36/14} Rf7 {-3.74/14} 42.Rb3 {+4.40/14} Rd8 {-3.92/14} 43.Rxb6 {+4.60/13} Rd4
{-4.05/13} 44.Ra6 {+5.01/13} Rd1+ {-4.19/12} 45.Kf2 {+4.36/6} Rd2+ {-4.19/12} 46.Kf1
{+4.92/13} Rd1+ {-4.33/13} 47.Ke2 {+4.92/12} Rd4 {-4.45/14} 48.h3 {+5.21/12} c4 {-4.76/13}
49.Rxa5 {+5.73/13} Kh7 {-5.17/13} 50.Rc5 {+6.30/12} Rfd7 {-5.86/14} 51.Rxc4 {+6.38/13}
R4d2+ {-5.72/13} 52.Ke1 {+6.58/13} R2d6 {-5.82/13} 53.Qb5 {+6.62/13} R6d1+ {-6.13/12}
54.Kf2 {+6.70/13} R7d2+ {-6.13/13} 55.Kg3 {+7.47/12} Kh6 {-6.23/12} 56.Qb6 {+8.44/13}
R2d3+ {-6.94/14} 57.Kh2 {+9.89/14} Rf1 {-9.05/14} 58.Rc6 {+12.60/15} Kg7 {-9.50/14}
59.Qb7+ {+14.02/14} Kh6 {-9.66/14} {1-0 Arena Adjudication} 1-0

[Event "Test"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.03.01"]
[Round "10"]
[White "Glaurung22_win32_ja"]
[Black "Stockfish-1.6.3-32-ja"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B30"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Variation "Rossolimo, 3...e6 4.Nc3"]
[TimeControl "120+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "111"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 {+1.11/14} e6 {-0.80/13}
3.Nc3 {+1.07/13} Nc6 {-0.64/14} 4.Bb5 {+1.19/13} Nd4 {-0.52/14} 5.O-O {+1.00/13} a6
{-0.44/14} 6.Bc4 {+0.80/14} Qc7 {-0.16/13} 7.d3 {+0.84/13} Bd6 {-0.28/14} 8.g3 {+0.54/13}
Ne7 {0.00/14} 9.Nxd4 {+0.39/13} cxd4 {0.00/12} 10.Ne2 {+0.27/14} Nc6 {-0.04/14}
11.Bb3 {+0.17/14} O-O {-0.08/15} 12.Bf4 {+0.11/14} Bxf4 {+0.20/13} 13.Nxf4 {+0.09/14}
d6 {+0.16/15} 14.Rc1 {+0.05/14} Bd7 {+0.36/13} 15.Nh5 {-0.03/13} Qd8 {+0.40/14}
16.Nf4 {-0.23/12} Rc8 {+0.48/13} 17.f3 {-0.25/13} b5 {+0.32/12} 18.Qd2 {-0.13/13} Qg5
{+0.36/13} 19.Qf2 {-0.05/13} Qh6 {+0.20/13} 20.a4 {0.00/14} Na5 {+0.32/13} 21.Ba2
{-0.72/13} Nc6 {+0.20/14} 22.axb5 {0.00/14} axb5 {+0.16/15} 23.Rca1 {+0.05/13} Rca8
{+0.16/14} 24.Rfe1 {+0.15/13} Rfc8 {+0.12/13} 25.h4 {+0.09/14} Qf6 {+0.16/14} 26.Kg2
{+0.07/13} Qd8 {+0.16/14} 27.Qd2 {+0.23/13} Ra7 {+0.24/14} 28.Bb3 {+0.05/14} Na5
{+0.24/14} 29.Qb4 {0.00/13} Rca8 {+0.24/13} 30.Red1 {0.00/13} R7a6 {+0.12/13} 31.Kf2
{0.00/13} Qf8 {+0.12/13} 32.Ne2 {0.00/14} Qb8 {+0.12/14} 33.Rdb1 {0.00/13} R6a7
{+0.04/13} 34.h5 {0.00/13} R7a6 {+0.20/13} 35.h6 {0.00/13} g6 {+0.48/13} 36.Qxd4
{+0.03/13} e5 {+0.36/15} 37.Qe3 {-0.31/15} Nc4 {+0.96/14} 38.Rxa6 {-0.56/15} Nxe3
{+0.76/12} 39.Rxa8 {-0.64/12} Ng4+ {+0.92/14} 40.fxg4 {-0.82/14} Qxa8 {+1.01/13} 41.g5
{-0.98/14} Bg4 {+1.37/14} 42.c3 {-1.11/13} b4 {+1.53/13} 43.Re1 {-1.96/13} Qa7+ {+2.66/12}
44.d4 {-2.47/14} Qa6 {+2.66/14} 45.Bc2 {-2.86/13} Qb5 {+3.15/15} 46.Kf1 {-3.25/12}
exd4 {+5.41/14} 47.cxd4 {-5.17/14} Qc4 {+6.30/16} 48.Bb1 {-5.52/15} Qb3 {+6.26/15}
49.Ng1 {-5.52/13} Qxg3 {+7.19/16} 50.Ba2 {-7.11/14} b3 {+8.32/15} 51.Bb1 {-8.15/15}
Qf4+ {+9.97/15} 52.Kg2 {-8.47/16} Qd2+ {+10.38/14} 53.Kf1 {-7.86/12} Qxb2
{+10.90/16} 54.d5 {-9.27/15} Qd2 {+11.55/14} 55.Ne2 {-9.82/14} Qxg5 {+12.60/15} 56.Ng1
{-10.74/14} {0-1 Arena Adjudication} 0-1
User avatar
hgm
Posts: 28359
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:06 am
Location: Amsterdam
Full name: H G Muller

Re: the glaurung games:

Post by hgm »

The stronger the engine, the weaker it will be when used at fixed depth. Strong egines are strong because they use very massive and accurate pruning of lines that seem not promising, so they have mor etime left to search useful lines, and get deeper in thos. At fixed depth, the pruning offers no advantage at all, because they are not allowed to use the time they save by it to search the main lines deeper. So they just cut away many lines to a dagerously low depth, leading to errors that very weak engines, which do no puning at all, would never make at the same fixed depth. (But the weak engines might be using 100 times as much time at the same depth.)
Togga

Philou 3.1.2 - Glaurung 1:0

Post by Togga »

fixed depth: 9 halfmoves

Philou 3.1.2 - Glaurung22_win32_ja : 6,5/10 6-3-1 (=010101111) 65% +108
jwes
Posts: 778
Joined: Sat Jul 01, 2006 7:11 am

Re: philou

Post by jwes »

Togga wrote:in my test was the engine philou the best engine, better than robbolito at fixed depth.

that means that philou has the best chess AI, the best chess values, the best search.

but philou is very slow:(
More likely is that philou does more extensions and less reductions.
User avatar
hgm
Posts: 28359
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:06 am
Location: Amsterdam
Full name: H G Muller

Re: philou

Post by hgm »

Indeed. Or the least aggressive pruning.
bob
Posts: 20943
Joined: Mon Feb 27, 2006 7:30 pm
Location: Birmingham, AL

Re: glaurung disaster part 2

Post by bob »

Togga wrote:did you run this test with last version of stockfish 1.6.3 ?

i run my test under these conditions:

timecontrol 2min + 2 sec

10 games:

1.d4 d5 2.c4
1.e4 e5
1.g3
1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5
1.e4 c5

reversed colors.

this should be a fair short test. isnt it?
"short" being the operative word. Yes, I used the most recent version.
yanquis1972
Posts: 1766
Joined: Wed Jun 03, 2009 12:14 am

Re: philou

Post by yanquis1972 »

right, robbolito is so strong primarily because it outsearches everyone (couple that with R3s static evaluation & youve got a superengine). limiting its plies is a little silly when its ability to quickly reach high depth is its main point.
Togga

rating list

Post by Togga »

no Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws

62 Stockfish 1.6 w32 1CPU 2980 14 14 1600 65.0% 2872 33.0%

251 Glaurung 2.2 w32 1CPU 2805 11 11 2430 47.6% 2822 32.4%

http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/40_4_Ra ... liste.html
Togga

Re: testing engines with fixed depth

Post by Togga »

thanks for explaing

i was for a moment wondering why robbolito, stockfish and glaurung was so fast at fixed depth games.
philou took much more time for calculating at fixed depth play.

anyway the test can be usefull.