TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 40 games

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 40 games

Post by Vinvin »

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name               Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Stockfish 160913   198  229  205     4   75%   118   50% 
   2 Spike 1.4          193  218  197     5   70%    79   20% 
   3 Bouquet 1.8a       167  231  215     4   63%   128   25% 
   4 Rybka 4.1           72  183  184     5   50%    50   60% 
   5 Critter 1.6a        68  229  204     4   75%   -67   50% 
   6 Hiarcs 14           62  228  203     4   75%   -40   50% 
   7 Jonny 6             60  196  206     4   38%   128   75% 
   8 Spark 1             60  209  209     4   50%    87   50% 
   9 Shredder 12         53  205  196     4   63%    -2   75% 
  10 Equinox 2b          50  201  226     4   25%   122   50% 
  11 Naum 4.5            33  189  189     4   50%    22  100% 
  12 Gull 2.2            10  268  214     4   88%  -142   25% 
  13 Komodo 1092        -14  267  225     4   75%  -137    0% 
  14 Exchess 7.15b      -92  212  266     4   13%    90   25% 
  15 Houdini 3         -105  187  187     5   50%  -126   60% 
  16 Tornado 5         -176  206  232     4   25%   -44   50% 
  17 Toga II 140913    -189  204  230     4   25%   -60   50% 
  18 Junior 13.3       -189  183  198     5   30%  -111   60% 
  19 Onno 1.27         -261  213  267     4   13%   -75   25% 
and with SCID :

Code: Select all

                     Rtng    Score       1    2    3    4    5    Perf Chg
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1: Gull 2.2         3075   3.5 /  4   19b+ ....  4w+  9w= 14w+   3328 +10  (+3 -0 =1)
 2: Spike 1.4        2936   3.5 /  5   18b+ 11b+ 13b+  7b=  3b-   3061  +8  (+3 -1 =1)
 3: Stockfish 160913 3099   3.0 /  4   13b=  7b+ .... 17w=  2w+   3151  +2  (+2 -0 =2)
 4: Komodo 1092      3090   3.0 /  4   15b+ 19b+  1b- ....  9w+   3167  +4  (+3 -1 =0)
 5: Hiarcs 14        2986   3.0 /  4   14w+  6w=  8w= 18b+ ....   3098  +5  (+2 -0 =2)
 6: Critter 1.6a     3073   3.0 /  4   12b=  5b= 16b+ 15b+ ....   3107  +1  (+2 -0 =2)
 7: Bouquet 1.8a     3071   2.5 /  4   ....  3w- 17w+  2w= 10w+   3136  +3  (+2 -1 =1)
 8: Shredder 12      2949   2.5 /  4   10w= 12w=  5b= 16b+ ....   3067  +7  (+1 -0 =3)
 9: Houdini 3        3141   2.5 /  5   16b= 15b= 19b+  1b=  4b-   2937 -14  (+1 -1 =3)
10: Rybka 4.1        3090   2.5 /  5    8b= 18b+ 11b= 13b=  7b-   2890 -13  (+1 -1 =3)
11: Spark 1          2899   2.0 /  4   17w+  2w- 10w= 12w= ....   3009  +6  (+1 -1 =2)
12: Naum 4.5         2979   2.0 /  4    6w=  8b= 18b= 11b= ....   2903  -4  (+0 -0 =4)
13: Jonny 6          2798   1.5 /  4    3w= 17w=  2w- 10w= ....   2952  +8  (+0 -1 =3)
14: Junior 13.3      2907   1.5 /  5    5b- 16b= 15b= 19b=  1b-   2767  -9  (+0 -2 =3)
15: Toga II 140913   2858   1.0 /  4    4w-  9w= 14w=  6w- ....   2859  +0  (+0 -2 =2)
16: Tornado 5        2835   1.0 /  4    9w= 14w=  6w-  8w- ....   2823  +0  (+0 -2 =2)
17: Equinox 2b       3040   1.0 /  4   11b- 13b=  7b-  3b= ....   2772 -14  (+0 -2 =2)
18: Exchess 7.15b    2701   0.5 /  4    2w- 10w- 12w=  5w- ....   2662  -1  (+0 -3 =1)
19: Onno 1.27        2831   0.5 /  4    1w-  4w-  9w- 14w= ....   2728  -4  (+0 -3 =1)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
40 games: +8 =19 -13
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 45 games

Post by Vinvin »

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name               Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Gull 2.2           131  271  215     4   88%   -22   25% 
   2 Komodo 1092        112  272  226     4   75%   -14    0% 
   3 Spike 1.4          103  221  197     5   70%   -14   20% 
   4 Hiarcs 14           95  221  189     5   80%   -34   40% 
   5 Stockfish 160913    92  232  208     4   75%    12   50% 
   6 Bouquet 1.8a        72  232  215     4   63%    33   25% 
   7 Critter 1.6a        66  201  185     5   70%   -42   60% 
   8 Shredder 12         24  186  178     5   60%   -21   80% 
   9 Naum 4.5            21  185  178     5   60%   -29   80% 
  10 Houdini 3            2  191  191     5   50%   -16   60% 
  11 Rybka 4.1           -6  187  187     5   50%   -27   60% 
  12 Spark 1            -33  191  200     5   40%    31   40% 
  13 Equinox 2b         -59  204  229     4   25%    15   50% 
  14 Jonny 6            -69  182  198     5   30%    30   60% 
  15 Toga II 140913     -83  182  199     5   30%    22   60% 
  16 Junior 13.3        -96  184  200     5   30%   -20   60% 
  17 Onno 1.27         -108  190  221     5   20%    43   40% 
  18 Exchess 7.15b     -130  190  222     5   20%    16   40% 
  19 Tornado 5         -134  183  200     5   30%   -27   60% 
and with SCID :

Code: Select all

                     Rtng    Score       1    2    3    4    5    Perf Chg
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1: Hiarcs 14        2991   4.0 /  5   15w+  3w=  7w= 18b+ 12b+   3144  +9  (+3 -0 =2)
 2: Gull 2.2         3075   3.5 /  4   19b+ ....  5w+ 10w= 15w+   3328 +10  (+3 -0 =1)
 3: Critter 1.6a     3073   3.5 /  5    8b=  1b= 16b+ 13b+ 19b=   3046  -2  (+2 -0 =3)
 4: Spike 1.4        2936   3.5 /  5   18b+ 12b+ 14b+  9b=  6b-   3061  +8  (+3 -1 =1)
 5: Komodo 1092      3090   3.0 /  4   13b+ 19b+  2b- .... 10w+   3167  +4  (+3 -1 =0)
 6: Stockfish 160913 3099   3.0 /  4   14b=  9b+ .... 17w=  4w+   3151  +2  (+2 -0 =2)
 7: Shredder 12      2949   3.0 /  5   11w=  8w=  1b= 16b+ 13b=   3021  +5  (+1 -0 =4)
 8: Naum 4.5         2979   3.0 /  5    3w=  7b= 18b= 12b= 14b+   2954  -2  (+1 -0 =4)
 9: Bouquet 1.8a     3071   2.5 /  4   ....  6w- 17w+  4w= 11w+   3136  +3  (+2 -1 =1)
10: Houdini 3        3141   2.5 /  5   16b= 13b= 19b+  2b=  5b-   2937 -14  (+1 -1 =3)
11: Rybka 4.1        3090   2.5 /  5    7b= 18b+ 12b= 14b=  9b-   2890 -13  (+1 -1 =3)
12: Spark 1          2899   2.0 /  5   17w+  4w- 11w=  8w=  1w-   2934  +3  (+1 -2 =2)
13: Toga II 140913   2858   1.5 /  5    5w- 10w= 15w=  3w-  7w=   2882  +2  (+0 -2 =3)
14: Jonny 6          2798   1.5 /  5    6w= 17w=  4w- 11w=  8w-   2878  +5  (+0 -2 =3)
15: Junior 13.3      2907   1.5 /  5    1b- 16b= 13b= 19b=  2b-   2767  -9  (+0 -2 =3)
16: Tornado 5        2835   1.5 /  5   10w= 15w=  3w-  7w- 18w=   2804  -2  (+0 -2 =3)
17: Equinox 2b       3040   1.0 /  4   12b- 14b=  9b-  6b= ....   2772 -14  (+0 -2 =2)
18: Exchess 7.15b    2701   1.0 /  5    4w- 11w-  8w=  1w- 16b=   2714  +1  (+0 -3 =2)
19: Onno 1.27        2831   1.0 /  5    2w-  5w- 10w- 15w=  3w=   2815  -1  (+0 -3 =2)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
45 games: +8 =22 -15
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo after 68 games

Post by Vinvin »

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo      Diff     +       -      Games  Score     Oppo.  Draws  
   1 Stockfish 160913   153.97     0.00  184.67  184.67        7  78.57%    38.99  42.86% 
   2 Bouquet 1.8a       113.48   -40.48  194.26  194.26        6  66.67%    60.53  33.33% 
   3 Komodo 1092        111.32    -2.16  200.59  200.59        7  78.57%   -32.02  14.29% 
   4 Gull 2.2            85.83   -25.49  191.21  191.21        6  75.00%   -10.43  50.00% 
   5 Spike 1.4           70.64   -15.19  183.35  183.35        7  57.14%    14.31  28.57% 
   6 Hiarcs 14           65.27    -5.37  174.88  174.88        8  62.50%    -0.85  25.00% 
   7 Rybka 4.1           60.93    -4.34  160.91  160.91        8  56.25%    14.31  62.50% 
   8 Critter 1.6a        42.77   -18.16  160.51  160.51        8  56.25%   -14.22  62.50% 
   9 Naum 4.5            23.43   -19.34  155.65  155.65        8  50.00%    10.83  75.00% 
  10 Shredder 12          4.67   -18.77  157.03  157.03        8  50.00%    -6.90  75.00% 
  11 Houdini 3            2.43    -2.24  173.40  173.40        7  57.14%   -38.08  57.14% 
  12 Equinox 2b         -11.06   -13.48  168.35  168.35        7  35.71%    43.92  71.43% 
  13 Jonny 6            -49.78   -38.73  179.72  179.72        7  35.71%    30.93  42.86% 
  14 Spark 1            -65.21   -15.42  173.19  173.19        7  42.86%   -10.50  57.14% 
  15 Exchess 7.15b     -102.19   -36.98  178.12  178.12        7  35.71%   -25.96  42.86% 
  16 Junior 13.3       -104.49    -2.31  176.76  176.76        7  28.57%   -19.59  57.14% 
  17 Onno 1.27         -119.26   -14.76  174.65  174.65        7  28.57%     5.76  57.14% 
  18 Toga II 140913    -136.05   -16.79  174.94  174.94        7  28.57%   -15.81  57.14% 
  19 Tornado 5         -146.69   -10.63  173.16  173.16        7  28.57%   -38.83  57.14% 
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 72 games

Post by Vinvin »

= 8 rounds of 9 games

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name               Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Stockfish 160913   168  196  170     7   79%    52   43% 
   2 Bouquet 1.8a       127  198  175     7   71%    40   29% 
   3 Komodo 1092        100  221  183     7   79%   -46   14% 
   4 Gull 2.2            85  196  169     7   79%   -38   43% 
   5 Spike 1.4           85  186  178     7   57%    27   29% 
   6 Rybka 4.1           73  159  155     8   56%    25   63% 
   7 Hiarcs 14           69  179  168     8   63%     3   25% 
   8 Critter 1.6a        36  160  156     8   56%   -24   63% 
   9 Naum 4.5            31  152  153     8   50%    19   75% 
  10 Equinox 2b           4  160  169     7   36%    60   71% 
  11 Shredder 12          0  154  154     8   50%   -13   75% 
  12 Houdini 3          -10  174  168     7   57%   -52   57% 
  13 Jonny 6            -25  166  170     8   44%    15   38% 
  14 Spark 1            -42  162  163     8   50%   -25   50% 
  15 Exchess 7.15b     -117  162  179     8   31%   -15   38% 
  16 Junior 13.3       -119  167  183     7   29%   -31   57% 
  17 Tornado 5         -152  157  176     8   25%   -19   50% 
  18 Onno 1.27         -154  157  176     8   25%    -8   50% 
  19 Toga II 140913    -158  157  176     8   25%   -22   50% 
and with SCID :

Code: Select all

                    Rtng    Score       1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    Perf Chg
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1: Stockfish 160913 3106   5.5 /  7   13b=  4b+ .... 14w=  8w+  6w= 10w+  5w+   3215  +8  (+4 -0 =3)
 2: Gull 2.2         3075   5.5 /  7   17b+ ....  3w+  9w= 16w+  7w= 11w= 15w+   3189  +9  (+4 -0 =3)
 3: Komodo 1092      3096   5.5 /  7   18b+ 17b+  2b- ....  9w+ 16w=  7w+ 11w+   3205  +8  (+5 -1 =1)
 4: Bouquet 1.8a     3076   5.0 /  7   ....  1w- 14w+  8w=  6w+ 10w=  5w+ 19w+   3154  +7  (+4 -1 =2)
 5: Hiarcs 14        2994   5.0 /  8   16w+  7w= 11w= 15b+ 12b+ 13b+  4b-  1b-   3032  +4  (+4 -2 =2)
 6: Rybka 4.1        3090   4.5 /  8   11b= 15b+ 12b= 13b=  4b-  1b= 14b=  8b+   2983 -12  (+2 -1 =5)
 7: Critter 1.6a     3073   4.5 /  8   10b=  5b= 19b+ 18b+ 17b=  2b=  3b-  9b=   3017  -6  (+2 -1 =5)
 8: Spike 1.4        2936   4.0 /  7   15b+ 12b+ 13b+  4b=  1b- 14b= ....  6w-   3006  +7  (+3 -2 =2)
 9: Houdini 3        3141   4.0 /  7   19b= 18b= 17b+  2b=  3b- .... 16w+  7w=   3002 -13  (+2 -1 =4)
10: Naum 4.5         2979   4.0 /  8    7w= 11b= 15b= 12b= 13b+  4b=  1b- 14b=   2953  -3  (+1 -1 =6)
11: Shredder 12      2949   4.0 /  8    6w= 10w=  5b= 19b+ 18b= 17b=  2b=  3b-   2968  +2  (+1 -1 =6)
12: Spark 1          2899   4.0 /  8   14w+  8w-  6w= 10w=  5w- 19w= 18b= 17b+   2944  +6  (+2 -2 =4)
13: Jonny 6          2805   3.5 /  8    1w= 14w=  8w-  6w= 10w-  5w- 19w+ 18w+   2934 +14  (+2 -3 =3)
14: Equinox 2b       3040   2.5 /  7   12b- 13b=  4b-  1b= ....  8w=  6w= 10w=   2879 -16  (+0 -2 =5)
15: Exchess 7.15b    2713   2.5 /  8    8w-  6w- 10w=  5w- 19b= 18b+ 17b=  2b-   2799  +8  (+1 -4 =3)
16: Junior 13.3      2907   2.0 /  7    5b- 19b= 18b= 17b=  2b-  3b=  9b- ....   2815  -8  (+0 -3 =4)
17: Onno 1.27        2832   2.0 /  8    2w-  3w-  9w- 16w=  7w= 11w= 15w= 12w-   2786  -4  (+0 -4 =4)
18: Toga II 140913   2858   2.0 /  8    3w-  9w= 16w=  7w- 11w= 15w- 12w= 13b-   2753 -10  (+0 -4 =4)
19: Tornado 5        2835   2.0 /  8    9w= 16w=  7w- 11w- 15w= 12b= 13b-  4b-   2749  -8  (+0 -4 =4)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
72 games: +18 =35 -19
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 80 games

Post by Vinvin »

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                Elo    +/- Games  Score   Draws
   1 Stockfish 160913   166.6   182    8  81.25%  37.50%
   2 Bouquet 1.8a       128.4   185    8  75.00%  25.00%
   3 Komodo 1092        113.8   197    8  81.25%  12.50%
   4 Hiarcs 14           92.1   171    9  66.67%  22.22%
   5 Gull 2.2            69.2   171    8  75.00%  50.00%
   6 Spike 1.4           68.7   171    8  56.25%  37.50%
   7 Rybka 4.1           66.1   162    8  56.25%  62.50%
   8 Naum 4.5            32.6   148    9  50.00%  77.78%
   9 Critter 1.6a        28.3   153    9  55.56%  66.67%
  10 Houdini 3           17.7   168    8  62.50%  50.00%
  11 Shredder 12        -20.0   153    9  44.44%  66.67%
  12 Equinox 2b         -21.3   163    8  31.25%  62.50%
  13 Spark 1            -25.8   157    9  50.00%  55.56%
  14 Jonny 6            -30.6   172    8  43.75%  37.50%
  15 Junior 13.3        -97.6   166    8  31.25%  62.50%
  16 Exchess 7.15b     -125.9   169    9  27.78%  33.33%
  17 Tornado 5         -150.4   168    9  22.22%  44.44%
  18 Onno 1.27         -154.2   170    8  25.00%  50.00%
  19 Toga II 140913    -157.6   167    9  22.22%  44.44%  
and with SCID :

Code: Select all

                     Rtng    Score     S K G B H H C R S N S S J E J E O T T   Perf Chg
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1: Stockfish 160913 3108   6.5 /  8   X . . 1 1 . . = 1 1 . . = = . . . . 1   3217  +9  (+5 -0 =3)
 2: Komodo 1092      3097   6.5 /  8   . X 0 . . 1 1 . . . . 1 . . = 1 1 1 .   3197  +8  (+6 -1 =1)
 3: Gull 2.2         3075   6.0 /  8   . 1 X . . = = . . . = = . . 1 1 1 . .   3144  +6  (+4 -0 =4)
 4: Bouquet 1.8a     3078   6.0 /  8   0 . . X 1 . . 1 = = . . . 1 . . . 1 1   3171  +9  (+5 -1 =2)
 5: Hiarcs 14        2994   6.0 /  9   0 . . 0 X . = . . . 1 = 1 1 1 1 . . .   3073  +9  (+5 -2 =2)
 6: Houdini 3        3141   5.0 /  8   . 0 = . . X = . . . . 1 . . 1 . 1 = =   3046 -10  (+3 -1 =4)
 7: Critter 1.6a     3073   5.0 /  9   . 0 = . = = X . . = . . . . = . = 1 1   3010  -8  (+2 -1 =6)
 8: Rybka 4.1        3090   4.5 /  8   = . . 0 . . . X 1 . = = = = . 1 . . .   2983 -12  (+2 -1 =5)
 9: Spike 1.4        2936   4.5 /  8   0 . . = . . . 0 X = 1 . 1 = . 1 . . .   3001  +8  (+3 -2 =3)
10: Naum 4.5         2979   4.5 /  9   0 . . = . . = . = X = = 1 = . = . . .   2951  -4  (+1 -1 =7)
11: Spark 1          2899   4.5 /  9   . . = . 0 . . = 0 = X . . 1 . . 1 = =   2958  +8  (+2 -2 =5)
12: Shredder 12      2949   4.0 /  9   . 0 = . = 0 . = . = . X . . . . = = 1   2944  +0  (+1 -2 =6)
13: Jonny 6          2805   3.5 /  8   = . . . 0 . . = 0 0 . . X = . . . 1 1   2934 +14  (+2 -3 =3)
14: Equinox 2b       3040   2.5 /  8   = . . 0 0 . . = = = 0 . = X . . . . .   2841 -22  (+0 -3 =5)
15: Junior 13.3      2907   2.5 /  8   . = 0 . 0 0 = . . . . . . . X . = = =   2844  -6  (+0 -3 =5)
16: Exchess 7.15b    2713   2.5 /  9   . 0 0 . 0 . . 0 0 = . . . . . X = 1 =   2788  +8  (+1 -5 =3)
17: Onno 1.27        2832   2.0 /  8   . 0 0 . . 0 = . . . 0 = . . = = X . .   2786  -4  (+0 -4 =4)
18: Toga II 140913   2858   2.0 /  9   . 0 . 0 . = 0 . . . = = 0 . = 0 . X .   2741 -12  (+0 -5 =4)
19: Tornado 5        2835   2.0 /  9   0 . . 0 . = 0 . . . = 0 0 . = = . . X   2741  -9  (+0 -5 =4)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
80 games: +22 =38 -20
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 95 games

Post by Vinvin »

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo      Diff   +/-    Games  Score     Oppo.  Draws    Win  
   1 Komodo 1092        155.73     0.00  194.97      9  83.33%   -38.64  11.11%  77.78%
   2 Stockfish 160913   152.99    -2.73  181.27      9  83.33%   -12.81  33.33%  66.67%
   3 Bouquet 1.8a       117.92   -35.07  182.21      9  77.78%   -17.10  22.22%  66.67%
   4 Hiarcs 14          107.05   -10.88  156.56     11  68.18%    -2.16  27.27%  54.55%
   5 Gull 2.2           101.19    -5.85  169.82      9  77.78%   -22.97  44.44%  55.56%
   6 Houdini 3           67.86   -33.33  161.17     10  70.00%   -38.97  40.00%  50.00%
   7 Critter 1.6a        43.63   -24.22  146.66     10  55.00%    -3.25  70.00%  20.00%
   8 Rybka 4.1           42.40    -1.23  145.40     10  55.00%     4.95  70.00%  20.00%
   9 Naum 4.5            17.63   -24.77  142.08     10  50.00%     1.09  80.00%  10.00%
  10 Spike 1.4          -13.97   -31.60  162.78     10  45.00%    -0.23  30.00%  30.00%
  11 Shredder 12        -21.63    -7.65  143.33     11  40.91%     6.83  63.64%   9.09%
  12 Equinox 2b         -34.36   -12.73  158.85      9  38.89%    19.34  55.56%  11.11%
  13 Junior 13.3        -34.68    -0.32  155.18     10  45.00%   -12.78  50.00%  20.00%
  14 Spark 1            -52.26   -17.58  149.74     11  40.91%     1.62  45.45%  18.18%
  15 Jonny 6            -67.86   -15.61  157.58     10  40.00%    -5.27  40.00%  20.00%
  16 Tornado 5         -129.80   -61.94  157.48     11  27.27%     0.15  36.36%   9.09%
  17 Onno 1.27         -141.54   -11.74  158.14     10  25.00%    15.39  50.00%   0.00%
  18 Toga II 140913    -154.33   -12.79  167.03     10  20.00%    20.57  40.00%   0.00%
  19 Exchess 7.15b     -155.97    -1.64  163.11     11  22.73%     1.59  27.27%   9.09%
and with SCID :

Code: Select all

                     Rtng    Score     SKHGBHRCNSJSSJETOET   Perf Chg
----------------------------------------------------------------------
 1: Stockfish 160913 3110   7.5 /  9   X|1|1|=|11|||==1||1   3227 +11  (+6 -0 =3)
 2: Komodo 1092      3100   7.5 /  9   |X|0|1|1||=11|||111   3214 +10  (+7 -1 =1)
 3: Hiarcs 14        2996   7.5 / 11   0|X|0|==|11=111||1|   3093 +14  (+6 -2 =3)
 4: Gull 2.2         3075   7.0 /  9   |1|X|=|=||1==1||11|   3155  +8  (+5 -0 =4)
 5: Bouquet 1.8a     3080   7.0 /  9   0|1|X|1|==||||111|1   3182 +10  (+6 -1 =2)
 6: Houdini 3        3141   7.0 / 10   |0|=|X|=||111||=11=   3079  -7  (+5 -1 =4)
 7: Rybka 4.1        3090   5.5 / 10   =|=|0|X|=1|====||1|   2986 -14  (+2 -1 =7)
 8: Critter 1.6a     3073   5.5 / 10   |0==|=|X=|==|||1=|1   3001 -10  (+2 -1 =7)
 9: Naum 4.5         2979   5.0 / 10   0|||=|==X=|==1=||=|   2965  -2  (+1 -1 =8)
10: Spike 1.4        2936   4.5 / 10   0|0|=|0|=X||11=0|1|   2914  -3  (+3 -4 =3)
11: Junior 13.3      2911   4.5 / 10   |=00|0|=||X1|||==1=   2918  +1  (+2 -3 =5)
12: Shredder 12      2949   4.5 / 11   |0==|0===|0X|||1=|=   2923  -3  (+1 -3 =7)
13: Spark 1          2899   4.5 / 11   |00=|0=|=0||X|1=1|=   2923  +4  (+2 -4 =5)
14: Jonny 6          2805   4.0 / 10   =|00||=|00|||X=1=|1   2900 +13  (+2 -4 =4)
15: Equinox 2b       3040   3.5 /  9   =|0|0|=|==||0=X1|||   2886 -20  (+1 -3 =5)
16: Tornado 5        2835   3.0 / 11   0|||0=|0|1=0=00X|=|   2790  -6  (+1 -6 =4)
17: Onno 1.27        2832   2.5 / 10   |0|000|=||==0=||X=|   2779  -6  (+0 -5 =5)
18: Exchess 7.15b    2713   2.5 / 11   |000|00|=00||||==X1   2749  +4  (+1 -7 =3)
19: Toga II 140913   2858   2.0 / 10   00||0=|0||===0|||0X   2736 -13  (+0 -6 =4)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
95 games: +31 =42 -22
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 108 games

Post by Vinvin »

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo   +/-   Games  Score     Oppo.  Draws
   1 Komodo 1092        199.81  187     11  86.36%   -26.87   9.09%
   2 Stockfish 160913   180.55  175     11  86.36%   -19.11  27.27%
   3 Gull 2.2           113.96  159     11  72.73%    11.70  36.36%
   4 Hiarcs 14           80.83  151     12  62.50%    -1.32  25.00%
   5 Bouquet 1.8a        76.24  163     11  63.64%    12.44  18.18%
   6 Critter 1.6a        55.16  143     11  59.09%   -13.14  63.64%
   7 Rybka 4.1           44.24  143     11  59.09%   -15.33  63.64%
   8 Houdini 3           41.68  156     11  63.64%   -32.86  36.36%
   9 Naum 4.5            33.45  139     11  54.55%     4.10  72.73%
  10 Spike 1.4          -12.97  158     11  50.00%   -22.96  27.27%
  11 Junior 13.3        -13.51  151     11  50.00%   -16.60  45.45%
  12 Shredder 12        -16.68  144     11  40.91%    12.28  63.64%
  13 Jonny 6            -42.93  151     12  41.67%    14.88  33.33%
  14 Spark 1            -73.21  147     12  37.50%    -1.29  41.67%
  15 Equinox 2b         -82.53  149     11  36.36%   -12.21  54.55%
  16 Onno 1.27         -114.84  149     12  29.17%    22.91  41.67%
  17 Tornado 5         -147.76  154     12  25.00%    -0.63  33.33%
  18 Toga II 140913    -157.89  153     12  20.83%    12.33  41.67%
  19 Exchess 7.15b     -163.60  161     12  20.83%    10.18  25.00%
and with SCID :

Code: Select all

                    Rtng  Score    S K G H B H R C N J S J S S E O T T E Perf Chg
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1: Stockfish160913 3117 9.5 / 11  X . 1 1 1 . = . 1 . 1 = . . = 1 1 1 . 3263 +15 (+8 -0 =3)
 2: Komodo 1092     3107 9.5 / 11  . X 0 . 1 1 . 1 . = . 1 1 1 . 1 . 1 1 3250 +15 (+9 -1 =1)
 3: Gull 2.2        3076 8.0 / 11  0 1 X . 1 = . = . 1 . 1 = = . 1 . . 1 3140  +8 (+6 -1 =4)
 4: Hiarcs 14       2996 7.5 / 12  0 . . X 0 . = = 0 1 1 1 = 1 1 . . . 1 3057 +10 (+6 -3 =3)
 5: Bouquet 1.8a    3080 7.0 / 11  0 0 0 1 X . 1 . = . = . . . 1 1 1 1 . 3087  +1 (+6 -3 =2)
 6: Houdini 3       3141 7.0 / 11  . 0 = . . X . = . 1 . 0 1 1 . 1 = = 1 3021 -17 (+5 -2 =4)
 7: Rybka 4.1       3090 6.5 / 11  = . . = 0 . X . = . 1 = = = = . 1 . 1 3004 -13 (+3 -1 =7)
 8: Critter 1.6a    3073 6.5 / 11  . 0 = = . = . X = = . . = . . = 1 1 1 3008 -10 (+3 -1 =7)
 9: Naum 4.5        2979 6.0 / 11  0 . . 1 = . = = X . = 1 = = = . . . = 3003  +3 (+2 -1 =8)
10: Junior 13.3     2917 5.5 / 11  . = 0 0 . 0 . = . X . . 1 1 . = = = 1 2949  +6 (+3 -3 =5)
11: Spike 1.4       2936 5.5 / 11  0 . . 0 = . 0 . = . X 1 . 1 = . 0 1 1 2941  +1 (+4 -4 =3)
12: Jonny 6         2811 5.0 / 12  = 0 0 0 . 1 = . 0 . 0 X . . = = 1 1 . 2940 +20 (+3 -5 =4)
13: Shredder 12     2949 4.5 / 11  . 0 = = . 0 = = = 0 . . X . . = 1 = . 2923  -3 (+1 -3 =7)
14: Spark 1         2899 4.5 / 12  . 0 = 0 . 0 = . = 0 0 . . X 1 1 = = . 2895  +0 (+2 -5 =5)
15: Equinox 2b      3040 4.0 / 11  = . . 0 0 . = . = . = = . 0 X 0 1 = . 2842 -31 (+1 -4 =6)
16: Onno 1.27       2832 3.5 / 12  0 0 0 . 0 0 . = . = . = = 0 1 X . . = 2831  +0 (+1 -6 =5)
17: Tornado 5       2835 3.0 / 12  0 . . . 0 = 0 0 . = 1 0 0 = 0 . X . = 2783  -7 (+1 -7 =4)
18: Toga II 140913  2858 2.5 / 12  0 0 . . 0 = . 0 . = 0 0 = = = . . X 0 2748 -14 (+0 -7 =5)
19: Exchess 7.15b   2713 2.5 / 12  . 0 0 0 . 0 0 0 = 0 0 . . . . = = 1 X 2738  +4 (+1 -8 =3)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
108 games: +41 =43 -24
Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 1438 games

Post by Vinvin »

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo   +/- Games Score    Draws  
   1 Komodo 1092        153.78  149   15  76.67%   20.00% 
   2 Stockfish 160913   128.20  140   15  70.00%   33.33% 
   3 Gull 2.2           111.15  133   15  70.00%   46.67% 
   4 Rybka 4.1           86.71  130   15  66.67%   53.33% 
   5 Hiarcs 14           79.68  141   15  66.67%   26.67% 
   6 Critter 1.6a        76.92  127   15  63.33%   60.00% 
   7 Bouquet 1.8a        71.12  138   15  60.00%   26.67% 
   8 Houdini 3           56.62  139   14  64.29%   42.86% 
   9 Naum 4.5            47.83  129   15  60.00%   53.33% 
  10 Spike 1.4            1.10  138   14  50.00%   42.86% 
  11 Shredder 12        -13.82  125   15  46.67%   66.67% 
  12 Jonny 6            -16.51  132   16  46.88%   31.25% 
  13 Equinox 2b         -32.77  126   15  40.00%   66.67% 
  14 Junior 13.3        -33.46  135   15  46.67%   40.00% 
  15 Spark 1            -80.75  133   15  36.67%   46.67% 
  16 Onno 1.27         -130.74  136   16  25.00%   37.50% 
  17 Tornado 5         -141.32  140   15  26.67%   40.00% 
  18 Toga II 140913    -175.96  140   16  18.75%   37.50% 
  19 Exchess 7.15b     -187.76  148   15  20.00%   26.67% 
and with SCID :

Code: Select all

                     Rtng    Score  K G S R H C H B N J S S J E S T O E T  Perf 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1: Komodo 1092      3113  11.5/15  X 0 1 0 . 1 1 1 . 1 = 1 = = 1 . 1 1 1  3180 (+10 -2 =3)
 2: Gull 2.2         3076  10.5/15  1 X 0 = . = = 1 1 1 = = 1 = = . 1 1 .  3127 (+7 -1 =7)
 3: Stockfish 160913 3117  10.5/15  0 1 X = 1 = = 1 1 = 1 . 0 = . 1 1 . 1  3131 (+8 -2 =5)
 4: Rybka 4.1        3090  10.0/15  1 = = X = . . 0 = = 1 = . = = 1 1 1 1  3072 (+6 -1 =8)
 5: Hiarcs 14        2996  10.0/15  . . 0 = X = . 0 0 1 1 = 1 1 1 = 1 1 1  3062 (+8 -3 =4)
 6: Critter 1.6a     3073   9.5/15  0 = = . = X = = = 1 . = = . 1 1 = 1 1  3047 (+5 -1 =9)
 7: Houdini 3        3141   9.0/14  0 = = . . = X 1 . 0 . 1 1 = 1 = 1 1 =  3055 (+6 -2 =6)
 8: Bouquet 1.8a     3080   9.0/15  0 0 0 1 1 = 0 X = . = = 1 1 . 1 1 . 1  3067 (+7 -4 =4)
 9: Naum 4.5         2990   9.0/15  . 0 0 = 1 = . = X 1 = = . = = 1 1 = 1  3021 (+5 -2 =8)
10: Jonny 6          2824   7.5/16  0 0 = = 0 0 1 . 0 X 0 = 1 = . 1 = 1 1  2955 (+5 -6 =5)
11: Spike 1.4        2936   7.0/14  = = 0 0 0 . . = = 1 X . . = 1 0 = 1 1  2955 (+4 -4 =6)
12: Shredder 12      2949   7.0/15  0 = . = = = 0 = = = . X 0 . = 1 = 1 =  2937 (+2 -3 =10)
13: Junior 13.3      2917   7.0/15  = 0 1 . 0 = 0 0 . 0 . 1 X = 1 = = 1 =  2946 (+4 -5 =6)
14: Equinox 2b       3040   6.0/15  = = = = 0 . = 0 = = = . = X 0 1 0 . =  2903 (+1 -4 =10)
15: Spark 1          2899   5.5/15  0 = . = 0 0 0 . = . 0 = 0 1 X = 1 = =  2873 (+2 -6 =7)
16: Tornado 5        2835   4.0/15  . . 0 0 = 0 = 0 0 0 1 0 = 0 = X . = =  2795 (+1 -8 =6)
17: Onno 1.27        2832   4.0/16  0 0 0 0 0 = 0 0 0 = = = = 1 0 . X = .  2799 (+1 -9 =6)
18: Exchess 7.15b    2713   3.0/15  0 0 . 0 0 0 0 . = 0 0 0 0 . = = = X 1  2713 (+1 -10 =4)
19: Toga II 140913   2858   3.0/16  0 . 0 0 0 0 = 0 0 0 0 = = = = = . 0 X  2726 (+0 -10 =6)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
143 games: +55 =60 -28


Vinvin
Posts: 5312
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

TCEC stage2 ranking with Bayeselo and SCID, after 162 games

Post by Vinvin »

Still 9 games to play

With Bayeselo :

Code: Select all

Rank Name               Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws
   1 Komodo 1092        169  147  128    17   76%    -1   24%
   2 Stockfish 160913   147  140  125    17   74%    -3   29%
   3 Hiarcs 14          102  135  125    17   68%   -10   29%
   4 Bouquet 1.8a        88  135  126    17   65%    -4   24%
   5 Critter 1.6a        81  120  114    17   65%    -9   59%
   6 Gull 2.2            80  125  118    17   65%     6   47%
   7 Houdini 3           75  125  119    17   65%   -10   47%
   8 Rybka 4.1           74  120  114    17   65%    -9   59%
   9 Naum 4.5            19  120  119    17   53%    -1   47%
  10 Junior 13.3         -4  123  123    17   50%    -1   41%
  11 Jonny 6            -21  123  125    17   47%    -4   35%
  12 Equinox 2b         -22  112  116    17   41%    13   71%
  13 Spike 1.4          -23  121  124    17   44%     3   41%
  14 Shredder 12        -26  113  116    17   44%     3   65%
  15 Spark 1            -93  118  125    17   35%    -3   47%
  16 Onno 1.27         -119  118  128    18   31%     7   39%
  17 Tornado 5         -145  123  135    17   26%    -1   41%
  18 Toga II 140913    -175  122  139    17   21%     6   41%
  19 Exchess 7.15b     -205  129  155    17   18%    13   24%
and with SCID :

Code: Select all

                     Rtng    Score     K S H G H R C B N J J S S E S O T T E   Perf Chg
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 1: Komodo 1092      3113  13.0 / 17   X 1 = 0 1 0 1 1 1 = 1 1 = = 1 1 . 1 1   3174 +12  (+11 -2 =4)
 2: Stockfish 160913 3117  12.5 / 17   0 X 1 1 = = = 1 1 0 = 1 1 = . 1 1 1 1   3152  +7  (+10 -2 =5)
 3: Hiarcs 14        3000  11.5 / 17   = 0 X 1 . = = 0 0 1 1 = 1 1 1 1 = 1 1   3089 +19  (+9 -3 =5)
 4: Gull 2.2         3076  11.0 / 17   1 0 0 X = = = 1 1 1 1 = = = = 1 = . 1   3081  +0  (+7 -2 =8)
 5: Houdini 3        3141  11.0 / 17   0 = . = X = = 1 1 1 0 1 = = 1 1 = = 1   3072 -15  (+7 -2 =8)
 6: Rybka 4.1        3090  11.0 / 17   1 = = = = X . 0 = = = = 1 = = 1 1 1 1   3067  -5  (+6 -1 =10)
 7: Critter 1.6a     3073  11.0 / 17   0 = = = = . X = = = 1 = 1 = 1 = 1 1 1   3066  -2  (+6 -1 =10)
 8: Bouquet 1.8a     3080  11.0 / 17   0 0 1 0 0 1 = X = 1 . = = 1 1 1 1 1 1   3083  +0  (+9 -4 =4)
 9: Naum 4.5         2990   9.0 / 17   0 0 1 0 0 = = = X . 1 = = = = 1 1 1 =   2991  +0  (+5 -4 =8)
10: Junior 13.3      2922   8.5 / 17   = 1 0 0 0 = = 0 . X 0 1 1 = 1 = = = 1   2972 +12  (+5 -5 =7)
11: Jonny 6          2825   8.0 / 17   0 = 0 0 1 = 0 . 0 1 X = 0 = = = 1 1 1   2950 +29  (+5 -6 =6)
12: Shredder 12      2949   7.5 / 17   0 0 = = 0 = = = = 0 = X . = = = 1 = 1   2929  -3  (+2 -4 =11)
13: Spike 1.4        2936   7.5 / 17   = 0 0 = = 0 0 = = 0 1 . X = 1 = 0 1 1   2928  -2  (+4 -6 =7)
14: Equinox 2b       3040   7.0 / 17   = = 0 = = = = 0 = = = = = X 0 0 1 = .   2914 -31  (+1 -4 =12)
15: Spark 1          2899   6.0 / 17   0 . 0 = 0 = 0 0 = 0 = = 0 1 X 1 = = =   2856  -9  (+2 -7 =8)
16: Onno 1.27        2832   5.5 / 18   0 0 0 0 0 0 = 0 0 = = = = 1 0 X 1 = =   2835  +2  (+2 -9 =7)
17: Tornado 5        2835   4.5 / 17   . 0 = = = 0 0 0 0 = 0 0 1 0 = 0 X = =   2784 -10  (+1 -9 =7)
18: Toga II 140913   2858   3.5 / 17   0 0 0 . = 0 0 0 0 = 0 = 0 = = = = X 0   2739 -22  (+0 -10 =7)
19: Exchess 7.15b    2713   3.0 / 17   0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 = 0 0 0 0 . = = = 1 X   2704  +0  (+1 -12 =4)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
162 games: +58 =69 -35