CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

User avatar
Graham Banks
Posts: 44620
Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2006 10:52 am
Location: Auckland, NZ

CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by Graham Banks »

The latest CCRL Rating Lists and Statistics are available for viewing from the following links:
http://computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/4040.live/ (40/40)
http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/404/ (40/4)
http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/404FRC/ (FRC 40/4)

Please note that the three lists are updated separately to each other.
Also please note the live link will no longer necessarily give you the most updated lists. The links given in each update report will be the ones to use.

The links to the various rating lists can be found just beneath the default Best Versions list.
For example there is a 32-bit Single CPU list.

Our 40 moves in 40 minutes repeating and 40 moves in 4 minutes repeating are both adjusted to the AMD64 X2 4600+ (2.4GHz).

Currently active testers are:
Graham Banks, Ray Banks, Shaun Brewer, Kirill Kryukov, Dom Leste, Denis Mendoza, Wassim Saeed, Charles Smith, George Speight and Gabor Szots.

Be aware that in the early stages of testing, an engine's rating can often fluctuate a lot.
It is strongly advised to look at the many other rating lists available in order to get a more accurate overall picture of an engine's rating relative to others.


40/40 Notes

There are currently over 180,000 games in our 40/40 database.


4CPU 64-bit Engines

Code: Select all

Rank                Engine                 ELO   +    -   Score  AvOp  Games
 1 Rybka 3 64-bit 4CPU                  3232  +18  -18  77.5% -195.1  1231
 2 Naum 4 64-bit 4CPU                   3156  +21  -21  64.2%  -93.3   767
   Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit 4CPU              3110  +30  -29  73.3% -157.9   404
 3 Deep Fritz 11 4CPU                   3096  +29  -29  54.2%  -27.3   335
 4 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 4CPU          3070  +15  -15  58.1%  -51.8  1447
 5 Thinker 5.4C Inert 64-bit 4CPU       3042  +21  -21  54.3%  -28.6   734
 6 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 4CPU        3031  +20  -20  50.5%   -4.4   851
 7 Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 4CPU         3019  +13  -12  51.1%   -9.1  2092
 8 Toga II 1.4.1SE 4CPU                 3005  +16  -16  48.8%  +10.5  1322
 9 Bright 0.4a 4CPU                     2999  +17  -17  49.0%   +7.1  1074
10 Glaurung 2.2 64-bit 4CPU             2998  +21  -21  46.2%  +26.3   758
   Hiarcs 12.1 4CPU                     2983  +61  -64  31.9% +113.8    80
11 Loop 13.6 64-bit 4CPU                2945  +24  -24  51.8%   -8.9   541
12 Deep Junior 10 4CPU                  2912  +14  -14  43.5%  +46.1  1828
13 Crafty 23.0 64-bit 4CPU              2853  +21  -21  38.1%  +84.6   816
   Scorpio 2.1 64-bit 4CPU              2849  +44  -44  46.7%  +21.9   166
The relative ratings of the 2CPU engines that have been well tested are pretty much the same as their 4CPU counterparts.


Single CPU Engines

Code: Select all

Rank                Engine                 ELO   +    -   Score  AvOp  Games
      1 Rybka 3 64-bit                       3158  +15  -15  72.8% -164.1  1776
      2 Naum 4 64-bit                        3057  +22  -22  65.7% -103.5   720
        Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit                   2996  +33  -32  68.7% -120.4   297
      3 Thinker 5.4C Inert 64-bit            2972  +31  -31  51.4%   -8.4   324
      4 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit               2960  +14  -14  50.2%   +0.6  1566
      5 Fritz 11                             2959  +10  -10  54.1%  -27.5  3153
    6-7 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 1CPU        2943  +21  -21  49.1%   +7.5   691
    6-7 Grapefruit 1.0 32-bit                2943  +18  -18  51.9%   -9.5   915
      8 Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 1CPU         2940  +16  -16  49.3%   +4.4  1218
        Toga II 1.4.1SE                      2932  +12  -12  50.1%   +1.8  2386
        Cyclone 3.4                          2927  +21  -21  51.4%   -8.4   682
      9 Hiarcs 12.1                          2919  +21  -21  46.3%  +20.9   729
        TheMadPrune 1.1.25                   2910  +27  -27  51.7%  -12.1   418
     10 Onno 0.12.0 64-bit                   2892  +28  -28  44.8%  +38.1   391
     11 Stockfish 1.2 Default                2891  +25  -25  45.3%  +29.5   491
        Fruit 2.3.1                          2884  +14  -14  50.1%   -0.5  1601
     12 Loop 13.6 32-bit                     2882  +12  -12  49.5%   +2.7  2321
        Glaurung 2.2 64-bit                  2881  +23  -24  36.7%  +94.0   624
     13 Bright 0.4a                          2875  +13  -13  40.8%  +61.8  1896
     14 Spike 1.2 Turin                      2850   +7   -8  44.3%  +35.4  6387
     15 Junior 10                            2843  +13  -13  46.9%  +20.5  2077
     16 Chessmaster 11 Aiglos II             2811  +31  -31  48.1%  +13.3   334
     17 Ktulu 8.0                            2806   +9  -10  41.2%  +58.9  3927
     18 Twisted Logic 20080620               2805  +22  -22  48.6%   +9.2   653
     19 Chess Tiger 2007.1                   2803  +11  -11  44.1%  +39.4  2728
     20 SmarThink 1.00 64-bit                2800  +36  -36  49.6%   +1.2   254
     21 Frenzee Feb08                        2794  +17  -17  47.6%  +16.3  1085
     22 Booot 4.15.0                         2785  +28  -28  44.9%  +32.2   393
     23 Delfi 5.4                            2783  +26  -26  44.9%  +34.4   484
     24 Movei 00.8.438 (10 10 10)            2770  +16  -16  52.7%  -21.9  1329
     25 Alaric 707                           2766  +15  -15  49.3%   +4.4  1552
        CM10th Xperience                     2763  +14  -14  42.4%  +51.3  1767
        CM9000 Enforcer                      2759  +24  -24  45.8%  +25.0   529
        Crafty 23.0 32-bit                   2757  +62  -61  58.5%  -52.5    82
     26 Cyrano 0.6b17                        2756  +23  -23  50.7%   -5.7   624
     27 E.T. Chess 13.01.08                  2747  +18  -18  51.4%  -10.4  1016
     28 Colossus 2008b                       2746  +22  -22  50.7%   -4.5   657
     29 Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1               2740  +13  -13  48.0%  +13.1  1994
     30 Ruffian 2.1.0                        2734  +16  -16  47.5%  +18.9  1261
     31 WildCat 8                            2730  +21  -21  48.0%  +12.7   709
     32 BugChess2 1.6.3                      2726  +22  -22  47.5%  +18.1   709
        Scorpio 2.1                          2722  +85  -89  34.1% +100.2    44
     33 Gandalf 6                            2721  +13  -13  43.2%  +46.7  2121
  34-35 Pharaon 3.5.1                        2713  +14  -14  47.5%  +17.5  1674
  34-35 Pro Deo 1.6                          2713  +22  -22  48.0%  +12.1   670
     36 Chiron 0.8.7                         2707  +24  -24  51.6%  -10.5   579
     37 Hamsters 0.7.1                       2703  +30  -30  48.9%   +8.0   330
     38 Aristarch 4.50                       2699  +14  -14  45.1%  +35.5  1699
     39 Alfil 8.1.1                          2698  +18  -18  51.7%  -16.2  1072
     40 Pseudo 0.7c                          2693  +17  -17  50.2%   -1.0  1157
     41 The Baron 2.23                       2690  +26  -26  52.2%  -18.4   515
     42 Sloppy 0.2.0                         2689  +19  -19  46.2%  +24.9   896
     43 Jonny 2.83                           2679  +17  -17  47.0%  +18.9  1134
     44 Petir 4.9999                         2675  +22  -22  46.8%  +20.8   711
     45 SOS 5.1                              2666  +19  -19  46.4%  +21.8   950
     46 Anaconda 2.0.1                       2658  +30  -30  48.6%   +6.7   362
  47-48 Chronos 1.9.5                        2655  +34  -34  50.7%   -6.9   281
  47-48 Tornado 2.2                          2655  +32  -32  60.4%  -75.9   332
     49 Lemming 0.34                         2650  +36  -36  44.2%  +37.6   240
     50 Ufim 8.02                            2638  +21  -21  48.3%   +8.2   810
        Arasan 11.3                          2637  +68  -67  57.2%  -51.6    69
     51 GarboChess 2.20                      2637  +22  -22  49.6%   +1.5   685
     52 AnMon 5.66                           2631  +32  -32  47.6%  +16.7   332
     53 Hermann 2.4                          2622  +31  -31  50.4%   -2.1   368
     54 Viper 0.1                            2621  +36  -36  46.7%  +21.6   260
     55 Nimzo 8                              2616  +32  -32  42.1%  +56.6   331
     56 Tao 5.6                              2614  +30  -30  49.7%   +1.3   385
     57 Little Goliath Evolution 3.12        2609  +20  -20  45.4%  +30.3   829
     58 DanaSah 4.24                         2605  +29  -29  52.4%  -17.0   397
     59 Rotor 0.4                            2590  +19  -19  52.7%  -18.8   961
  60-61 Pepito 1.59                          2587  +29  -29  50.6%   -5.9   399
  60-61 Yace 0.99.87                         2587  +31  -31  48.1%  +14.0   365
     62 SpiderChess 070603                   2586  +33  -33  47.1%  +23.5   291
     63 Matacz 1.4                           2583  +27  -27  48.4%  +12.0   475
     64 Counter 1.1                          2582  +34  -34  53.1%  -25.1   271
     65 Anatoli 0.35k                        2581  +25  -25  53.6%  -27.5   573
     66 Quark 2.35                           2580  +27  -27  46.7%  +21.0   473
     67 Bruja 1.9                            2575  +35  -35  55.8%  -39.2   257
        Crimson 1.0                          2575  +59  -59  48.0%  +10.4   100
     68 Amyan 1.597                          2574  +23  -23  45.3%  +33.8   649
        BBChess 1.3b                         2571  +43  -43  51.2%   -7.9   169
     69 Trace 1.37a                          2570  +24  -24  48.2%  +10.1   577
     70 Cerebro 3.03d                        2565  +27  -27  51.5%  -11.5   480
     71 Typhoon 1.00-358                     2552  +30  -30  47.1%  +17.7   366
     72 Kiwi 0.6d                            2549  +32  -32  50.0%   -3.8   344
     73 Post Modernist 1016                  2543  +30  -30  46.5%  +22.4   391
     74 Homer 2.01                           2535  +27  -27  49.9%   +0.7   459
        Dirty 0.99 OW5                       2531  +67  -67  50.0%   -0.6    68
     75 Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit                  2531  +26  -26  45.1%  +33.4   489
        Delphil 1.9g                         2530 +119 -118  52.1%   -9.1    24
     76 Pupsi2 0.07                          2527  +32  -32  48.3%  +12.7   332
     77 Muse 0.899b                          2523  +32  -32  46.5%  +26.8   346
     78 KnightDreamer 3.3                    2517  +36  -36  48.0%  +16.1   249
     79 Djinn 0.925x                         2516  +29  -30  45.5%  +29.2   404
     80 RomiChess P3k                        2512  +25  -25  51.1%   -6.2   521
        Brutus 7.02                          2510  +80  -75  71.9% -149.3    57
     81 NanoSzachy 3.4                       2510  +26  -26  52.4%  -20.5   510
     82 Dragon 4.6                           2508  +23  -23  43.9%  +41.3   625
  83-84 Gosu 0.16                            2503  +29  -29  46.9%  +21.8   419
  83-84 Sorgenkind 0.4                       2503  +26  -26  49.9%   +1.1   521
  85-86 Amateur 2.82                         2502  +29  -29  46.6%  +23.8   426
  85-86 Gaia 3.5 32-bit                      2502  +27  -27  48.4%  +11.1   474
     87 Horizon 4.4                          2501  +25  -25  50.8%   -6.6   554
     88 Diablo 0.5.1                         2500  +29  -29  51.9%  -12.0   397
     89 Queen 4.02a                          2499  +28  -28  48.0%  +10.1   434
  90-91 Amy 0.87b                            2498  +34  -34  49.5%   +5.8   292
  90-91 Sage 3.53                            2498  +25  -25  50.1%   +0.6   544
     92 Patzer 3.80                          2493  +31  -31  48.5%  +12.3   364
     93 Comet B68                            2491  +28  -28  44.2%  +42.0   451
        GreKo 6.30                           2486  +52  -53  46.3%  +25.3   123
     94 Phalanx XXII                         2482  +40  -40  47.2%  +22.0   214
  95-96 Philou 2.7.0                         2479  +41  -41  48.8%   +9.3   202
  95-96 Thor's Hammer 2.28                   2479  +31  -31  49.5%   +4.5   364
     97 Tytan 9.3                            2454  +35  -35  49.2%   +8.2   303
     98 LittleThought 1.03 32-bit            2445  +26  -26  46.8%  +24.7   519
     99 Flux 2.2                             2444  +29  -29  47.9%  +13.8   404
    100 Aice 0.99.2                          2440  +28  -29  46.3%  +25.7   423
    101 Asterisk 0.6                         2428  +26  -26  50.3%   -2.0   509
    102 Chezzz 1.0.3                         2426  +40  -40  47.9%  +10.6   210
    103 KnightX 1.92                         2423  +30  -30  50.9%   -6.9   399
    104 Arion 1.7                            2415  +29  -29  52.9%  -23.2   419
    105 Anechka 0.08                         2405  +28  -28  46.4%  +27.2   443
    106 Cheese 1.3                           2404  +32  -32  47.0%  +23.5   338
    107 Popochin 3.2                         2401  +26  -26  45.0%  +34.4   514
    108 Natwarlal 0.14                       2400  +25  -25  46.2%  +26.7   585
    109 Joker 1.1.14                         2399  +26  -26  52.0%  -14.8   520
    110 Ant 2006-F                           2396  +29  -29  46.0%  +27.4   436
    111 Xpdnt 080927                         2392  +34  -33  50.2%   -0.6   315
    112 Averno 0.81                          2390  +34  -34  48.4%  +10.9   307
    113 Bison 8.2.4r                         2383  +28  -28  48.0%  +14.3   458
    114 Zeus 1.29                            2381  +25  -25  50.2%   -1.6   537
        Rodin 2.1b                           2377  +74  -74  53.4%  -15.1    58
    115 Chispa 4.0.3                         2369  +31  -31  51.2%   -8.3   376
        Glass 1.2                            2350 +128 -130  47.2%  +14.7    18
    116 EXchess 5.01b                        2344  +30  -30  46.1%  +23.8   368
    117 AliChess 4.18                        2336  +35  -35  47.7%  +19.3   280
    118 Feuerstein 0.4.6.1                   2334  +39  -38  54.1%  -29.4   229
        Atak 6.5                             2331 +102  -92  73.9% -175.3    44
119-120 Ayito 0.2.994                        2331  +32  -33  44.7%  +35.9   341
119-120 Deuterium 06.08.25.04                2331  +30  -30  45.8%  +29.2   377
        Amundsen 0.80                        2330  +99 -103  39.3%  +63.5    28
        Gibbon 2.52a                         2323  +63  -63  48.8%  +10.5    86
        OliThink 5.1.9                       2321 +138 -145  41.7%  +55.8    18
    121 Uralochka 1.1b                       2314  +30  -30  51.5%   -9.8   411
    122 ChessAlex 2.0r4                      2307  +34  -34  51.6%  -13.4   311
    123 ZCT 0.3.2451                         2302  +29  -29  48.2%  +12.6   410
    124 Sinobyl 1.50                         2298  +33  -33  51.8%  -16.0   328
    125 Atlas 2.20                           2295  +37  -37  50.8%   -9.2   266
        Critter 0.37                         2293 +107 -113  35.7% +107.3    28
    126 Buzz 0.08 32-bit                     2292  +31  -31  51.7%  -11.5   374
    127 Alf 1.09                             2291  +32  -32  50.9%  -10.3   341
    128 Neurosis 2.5                         2287  +36  -36  49.2%   +4.9   253
        OBender 3.2.4.2                      2287  +85  -84  51.1%  -12.5    44
    129 EveAnn 1.63                          2286  +35  -35  45.9%  +26.9   280
    130 RattateChess Bologna 2007            2284  +30  -30  51.5%  -10.0   405
        Mediocre 0.34                        2282  +72  -71  53.5%  -27.1    71
    131 BlackBishop 0.47                     2277  +38  -38  49.8%   +2.0   239
    132 NagaSkaki 5.12                       2268  +35  -35  50.2%   -1.4   272
    133 Lime 66                              2259  +35  -36  50.2%   -2.4   288
    134 Bearded 06-29                        2251  +38  -38  49.2%   +7.1   247
    135 TJchess 0.121                        2248  +31  -32  43.5%  +48.2   370
    136 Prophet 2.0                          2236  +26  -27  46.5%  +25.5   508
    137 Parrot 07.07.22                      2233  +31  -31  49.4%   +4.3   391
    138 Clarabit 1.00                        2225  +32  -32  49.1%   +4.4   338
        Waxman 2008                          2220  +54  -53  62.2%  -89.4   131
    139 Adam 3.1                             2196  +28  -28  45.6%  +31.0   497
    140 Matheus 2.3                          2174  +34  -35  46.9%  +21.8   302
    141 BigLion 2.23x                        2173  +29  -29  43.4%  +45.2   410
    142 FireFly 2.5.4                        2166  +39  -39  50.2%   -6.2   241
    143 Mustang 4.97                         2157  +33  -34  44.8%  +36.6   305
        BikJump 2.01                         2141  +43  -44  46.0%  +29.1   177
    144 Monarch 1.7                          2131  +27  -27  42.8%  +67.3   549
    145 BibiChess 0.5                        2115  +40  -40  46.9%  +21.0   226
    146 Smash 1.0.3                          2068  +32  -32  39.7%  +81.7   379
    147 Marvin 1.3.0                         2065  +30  -31  40.7%  +69.8   405
    148 Rival 1.18                           2056  +32  -32  42.7%  +52.7   351
    149 Micro-Max 4.8 (DM-PII)               2041  +26  -26  48.2%  +14.8   517
    150 ECE 0.3                              2024  +31  -32  41.0%  +68.5   374
    151 Clueless 1.4                         2008  +27  -27  37.6%  +98.8   541
    152 Warrior 1.0.3                        2007  +35  -36  41.3%  +64.4   287
    153 Surprise 4.3b13                      1992  +35  -36  37.3%  +97.1   300

Free Single CPU Engines

Code: Select all

Rank                Engine                 ELO   +    -   Score  AvOp  Games
      1 Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit                   2996  +33  -32  68.7% -120.4   297
      2 Thinker 5.4C Inert 64-bit            2972  +31  -31  51.4%   -8.4   324
      3 Grapefruit 1.0 32-bit                2943  +18  -18  51.9%   -9.5   915
        Toga II 1.4.1SE6                     2928  +19  -19  50.6%   +5.0   866
        Cyclone 3.4                          2927  +21  -21  51.4%   -8.4   682
        TheMadPrune 1.1.25                   2910  +27  -27  51.7%  -12.1   418
      4 Stockfish 1.2 Default                2891  +25  -25  45.3%  +29.5   491
        Fruit 2.3.1                          2884  +14  -14  50.1%   -0.5  1601
        Glaurung 2.2 64-bit                  2881  +23  -24  36.7%  +94.0   624
      5 Bright 0.4a                          2875  +13  -13  40.8%  +61.8  1896
      6 Spike 1.2 Turin                      2850   +7   -8  44.3%  +35.4  6387
      7 Twisted Logic 20080620               2805  +22  -22  48.6%   +9.2   653
      8 Naum 2.0 64-bit                      2804  +22  -22  50.2%   +1.5   649
      9 Frenzee Feb08                        2794  +17  -17  47.6%  +16.3  1085
     10 Booot 4.15.0                         2785  +28  -28  44.9%  +32.2   393
     11 Delfi 5.4                            2783  +26  -26  44.9%  +34.4   484
     12 Movei 00.8.438 (10 10 10)            2770  +16  -16  52.7%  -21.9  1329
     13 Alaric 707                           2766  +15  -15  49.3%   +4.4  1552
        Crafty 23.0 32-bit                   2757  +62  -61  58.5%  -52.5    82
     14 Cyrano 0.6b17                        2756  +23  -23  50.7%   -5.7   624
     15 E.T. Chess 13.01.08                  2747  +18  -18  51.4%  -10.4  1016
     16 Colossus 2008b                       2746  +22  -22  50.7%   -4.5   657
     17 Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1               2740  +13  -13  48.0%  +13.1  1994
     18 Zappa 1.1 64-bit                     2733  +24  -24  45.3%  +32.4   546
     19 WildCat 8                            2730  +21  -21  48.0%  +12.7   709
     20 BugChess2 1.6.3                      2726  +22  -22  47.5%  +18.1   709
        Scorpio 2.1                          2722  +85  -89  34.1% +100.2    44
     21 List 5.12                            2721  +18  -18  49.9%   -0.9  1059
  22-23 Pharaon 3.5.1                        2713  +14  -14  47.5%  +17.5  1674
  22-23 Pro Deo 1.6                          2713  +22  -22  48.0%  +12.1   670
     24 Ruffian 1.0.5                        2711  +20  -20  46.0%  +25.3   804
     25 Hamsters 0.7.1                       2703  +30  -30  48.9%   +8.0   330
     26 Aristarch 4.50                       2699  +14  -14  45.1%  +35.5  1699
     27 Alfil 8.1.1                          2698  +18  -18  51.7%  -16.2  1072
     28 Pseudo 0.7c                          2693  +17  -17  50.2%   -1.0  1157
     29 The Baron 2.23                       2690  +26  -26  52.2%  -18.4   515
     30 Sloppy 0.2.0                         2689  +19  -19  46.2%  +24.9   896
     31 Jonny 2.83                           2679  +17  -17  47.0%  +18.9  1134
     32 SmarThink 0.17a                      2678  +33  -33  47.0%  +16.4   305
     33 Petir 4.9999                         2675  +22  -22  46.8%  +20.8   711
     34 SOS 5.1                              2666  +19  -19  46.4%  +21.8   950
     35 Anaconda 2.0.1                       2658  +30  -30  48.6%   +6.7   362
  36-37 Chronos 1.9.5                        2655  +34  -34  50.7%   -6.9   281
  36-37 Tornado 2.2                          2655  +32  -32  60.4%  -75.9   332
     38 Ufim 8.02                            2638  +21  -21  48.3%   +8.2   810
        Arasan 11.3                          2637  +68  -67  57.2%  -51.6    69
     39 GarboChess 2.20                      2637  +22  -22  49.6%   +1.5   685
     40 AnMon 5.66                           2631  +32  -32  47.6%  +16.7   332
     41 Hermann 2.4                          2622  +31  -31  50.4%   -2.1   368
     42 Viper 0.1                            2621  +36  -36  46.7%  +21.6   260
     43 Tao 5.6                              2614  +30  -30  49.7%   +1.3   385
     44 Little Goliath Evolution 3.12        2609  +20  -20  45.4%  +30.3   829
     45 DanaSah 4.24                         2605  +29  -29  52.4%  -17.0   397
     46 Rotor 0.4                            2590  +19  -19  52.7%  -18.8   961
  47-48 Pepito 1.59                          2587  +29  -29  50.6%   -5.9   399
  47-48 Yace 0.99.87                         2587  +31  -31  48.1%  +14.0   365
     49 SpiderChess 070603                   2586  +33  -33  47.1%  +23.5   291
     50 Matacz 1.4                           2583  +27  -27  48.4%  +12.0   475
     51 Counter 1.1                          2582  +34  -34  53.1%  -25.1   271
     52 Anatoli 0.35k                        2581  +25  -25  53.6%  -27.5   573
     53 Quark 2.35                           2580  +27  -27  46.7%  +21.0   473
     54 Bruja 1.9                            2575  +35  -35  55.8%  -39.2   257
        Crimson 1.0                          2575  +59  -59  48.0%  +10.4   100
     55 Amyan 1.597                          2574  +23  -23  45.3%  +33.8   649
        BBChess 1.3b                         2571  +43  -43  51.2%   -7.9   169
     56 Trace 1.37a                          2570  +24  -24  48.2%  +10.1   577
     57 Cerebro 3.03d                        2565  +27  -27  51.5%  -11.5   480
     58 Typhoon 1.00-358                     2552  +30  -30  47.1%  +17.7   366
     59 Kiwi 0.6d                            2549  +32  -32  50.0%   -3.8   344
     60 Post Modernist 1016                  2543  +30  -30  46.5%  +22.4   391
     61 Homer 2.01                           2535  +27  -27  49.9%   +0.7   459
        Dirty 0.99 OW5                       2531  +67  -67  50.0%   -0.6    68
     62 Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit                  2531  +26  -26  45.1%  +33.4   489
        Delphil 1.9g                         2530 +119 -118  52.1%   -9.1    24
     63 Pupsi2 0.07                          2527  +32  -32  48.3%  +12.7   332
     64 Muse 0.899b                          2523  +32  -32  46.5%  +26.8   346
     65 KnightDreamer 3.3                    2517  +36  -36  48.0%  +16.1   249
     66 Djinn 0.925x                         2516  +29  -30  45.5%  +29.2   404
     67 RomiChess P3k                        2512  +25  -25  51.1%   -6.2   521
        Brutus 7.02                          2510  +80  -75  71.9% -149.3    57
     68 NanoSzachy 3.4                       2510  +26  -26  52.4%  -20.5   510
     69 Dragon 4.6                           2508  +23  -23  43.9%  +41.3   625
  70-71 Gosu 0.16                            2503  +29  -29  46.9%  +21.8   419
  70-71 Sorgenkind 0.4                       2503  +26  -26  49.9%   +1.1   521
  72-73 Amateur 2.82                         2502  +29  -29  46.6%  +23.8   426
  72-73 Gaia 3.5 32-bit                      2502  +27  -27  48.4%  +11.1   474
     74 Horizon 4.4                          2501  +25  -25  50.8%   -6.6   554
     75 Diablo 0.5.1                         2500  +29  -29  51.9%  -12.0   397
     76 Queen 4.02a                          2499  +28  -28  48.0%  +10.1   434
  77-78 Amy 0.87b                            2498  +34  -34  49.5%   +5.8   292
  77-78 Sage 3.53                            2498  +25  -25  50.1%   +0.6   544
     79 Patzer 3.80                          2493  +31  -31  48.5%  +12.3   364
     80 Comet B68                            2491  +28  -28  44.2%  +42.0   451
        GreKo 6.30                           2486  +52  -53  46.3%  +25.3   123
     81 Phalanx XXII                         2482  +40  -40  47.2%  +22.0   214
  82-83 Philou 2.7.0                         2479  +41  -41  48.8%   +9.3   202
  82-83 Thor's Hammer 2.28                   2479  +31  -31  49.5%   +4.5   364
     84 Tytan 9.3                            2454  +35  -35  49.2%   +8.2   303
     85 LittleThought 1.03 32-bit            2445  +26  -26  46.8%  +24.7   519
     86 Flux 2.2                             2444  +29  -29  47.9%  +13.8   404
     87 Aice 0.99.2                          2440  +28  -29  46.3%  +25.7   423
     88 Asterisk 0.6                         2428  +26  -26  50.3%   -2.0   509
     89 Chezzz 1.0.3                         2426  +40  -40  47.9%  +10.6   210
     90 KnightX 1.92                         2423  +30  -30  50.9%   -6.9   399
     91 Arion 1.7                            2415  +29  -29  52.9%  -23.2   419
     92 Anechka 0.08                         2405  +28  -28  46.4%  +27.2   443
     93 Cheese 1.3                           2404  +32  -32  47.0%  +23.5   338
     94 Popochin 3.2                         2401  +26  -26  45.0%  +34.4   514
     95 Natwarlal 0.14                       2400  +25  -25  46.2%  +26.7   585
     96 Joker 1.1.14                         2399  +26  -26  52.0%  -14.8   520
     97 Ant 2006-F                           2396  +29  -29  46.0%  +27.4   436
     98 Xpdnt 080927                         2392  +34  -33  50.2%   -0.6   315
     99 Averno 0.81                          2390  +34  -34  48.4%  +10.9   307
    100 Bison 8.2.4r                         2383  +28  -28  48.0%  +14.3   458
    101 Zeus 1.29                            2381  +25  -25  50.2%   -1.6   537
        Rodin 2.1b                           2377  +74  -74  53.4%  -15.1    58
    102 Chispa 4.0.3                         2369  +31  -31  51.2%   -8.3   376
        Glass 1.2                            2350 +128 -130  47.2%  +14.7    18
    103 EXchess 5.01b                        2344  +30  -30  46.1%  +23.8   368
    104 AliChess 4.18                        2336  +35  -35  47.7%  +19.3   280
    105 Feuerstein 0.4.6.1                   2334  +39  -38  54.1%  -29.4   229
        Atak 6.5                             2331 +102  -92  73.9% -175.3    44
106-107 Ayito 0.2.994                        2331  +32  -33  44.7%  +35.9   341
106-107 Deuterium 06.08.25.04                2331  +30  -30  45.8%  +29.2   377
        Amundsen 0.80                        2330  +99 -103  39.3%  +63.5    28
        Gibbon 2.52a                         2323  +63  -63  48.8%  +10.5    86
        OliThink 5.1.9                       2321 +138 -145  41.7%  +55.8    18
    108 Uralochka 1.1b                       2314  +30  -30  51.5%   -9.8   411
    109 ChessAlex 2.0r4                      2307  +34  -34  51.6%  -13.4   311
    110 ZCT 0.3.2451                         2302  +29  -29  48.2%  +12.6   410
    111 Sinobyl 1.50                         2298  +33  -33  51.8%  -16.0   328
    112 Atlas 2.20                           2295  +37  -37  50.8%   -9.2   266
        Critter 0.37                         2293 +107 -113  35.7% +107.3    28
    113 Buzz 0.08 32-bit                     2292  +31  -31  51.7%  -11.5   374
    114 Alf 1.09                             2291  +32  -32  50.9%  -10.3   341
    115 Neurosis 2.5                         2287  +36  -36  49.2%   +4.9   253
        OBender 3.2.4.2                      2287  +85  -84  51.1%  -12.5    44
    116 EveAnn 1.63                          2286  +35  -35  45.9%  +26.9   280
    117 RattateChess Bologna 2007            2284  +30  -30  51.5%  -10.0   405
        Mediocre 0.34                        2282  +72  -71  53.5%  -27.1    71
    118 BlackBishop 0.47                     2277  +38  -38  49.8%   +2.0   239
    119 NagaSkaki 5.12                       2268  +35  -35  50.2%   -1.4   272
    120 Lime 66                              2259  +35  -36  50.2%   -2.4   288
    121 Bearded 06-29                        2251  +38  -38  49.2%   +7.1   247
    122 TJchess 0.121                        2248  +31  -32  43.5%  +48.2   370
    123 Prophet 2.0                          2236  +26  -27  46.5%  +25.5   508
    124 Parrot 07.07.22                      2233  +31  -31  49.4%   +4.3   391
    125 Clarabit 1.00                        2225  +32  -32  49.1%   +4.4   338
        Waxman 2008                          2220  +54  -53  62.2%  -89.4   131
    126 Adam 3.1                             2196  +28  -28  45.6%  +31.0   497
    127 Matheus 2.3                          2174  +34  -35  46.9%  +21.8   302
    128 BigLion 2.23x                        2173  +29  -29  43.4%  +45.2   410
    129 FireFly 2.5.4                        2166  +39  -39  50.2%   -6.2   241
    130 Mustang 4.97                         2157  +33  -34  44.8%  +36.6   305
        BikJump 2.01                         2141  +43  -44  46.0%  +29.1   177
    131 Monarch 1.7                          2131  +27  -27  42.8%  +67.3   549
    132 BibiChess 0.5                        2115  +40  -40  46.9%  +21.0   226
    133 Smash 1.0.3                          2068  +32  -32  39.7%  +81.7   379
    134 Marvin 1.3.0                         2065  +30  -31  40.7%  +69.8   405
    135 Rival 1.18                           2056  +32  -32  42.7%  +52.7   351
    136 Micro-Max 4.8 (DM-PII)               2041  +26  -26  48.2%  +14.8   517
    137 ECE 0.3                              2024  +31  -32  41.0%  +68.5   374
    138 Clueless 1.4                         2008  +27  -27  37.6%  +98.8   541
    139 Warrior 1.0.3                        2007  +35  -36  41.3%  +64.4   287
    140 Surprise 4.3b13                      1992  +35  -36  37.3%  +97.1   300

Blitz Notes

There are over 452,000 games in the 40/4 database and it is well worth a visit.
Shaun, Gabor, Kirill, Denis and Dom put a lot of work into this list, testing engines in a very well organised and systematic manner.

Code: Select all

Rank                 Engine                   ELO   +    -   Score  AvOp  Games
      1 Rybka 3 64-bit 4CPU                     3265  +11  -11  81.5% -242.2  3614
      2 Naum 4 64-bit 4CPU                      3152  +12  -12  72.4% -164.3  2690
      3 Thinker 5.4c Inert 64-bit 4CPU          3044  +13  -13  55.8%  -44.9  2180
      4 Zappa Mexico 64-bit 4CPU                3041  +10  -10  59.1%  -63.5  4089
      5 Hiarcs 12.1 4CPU                        3036  +12  -12  55.7%  -43.0  2493
      6 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 4CPU           3028  +11  -11  54.7%  -33.9  2802
      7 Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 4CPU            3027   +9   -9  53.4%  -24.4  4700
      8 Deep Fritz 10.1 4CPU                    3015  +15  -15  50.7%   -5.5  1496
      9 Glaurung 2.2 64-bit 4CPU                3007  +11  -11  51.8%  -13.6  2797
  10-11 Bright 0.4a 4CPU                        2997  +13  -13  45.4%  +29.7  2090
  10-11 Toga II 1.4 beta5c 4CPU                 2997  +12  -12  46.9%  +21.7  2394
     12 Loop M1-T 64-bit 4CPU                   2971   +8   -8  47.4%  +16.3  5303
     13 Onno 0.12.0 64-bit                      2935  +14  -14  56.8%  -48.7  1824
     14 Deep Junior 10 4CPU                     2923  +10  -10  46.2%  +26.4  3454
     15 Chessmaster 11 4CPU                     2854  +22  -22  59.2%  -63.4   699
     16 Crafty 23.0 64-bit 4CPU                 2836  +15  -16  30.6% +138.8  1660
     17 Spike 1.2 Turin                         2824   +5   -5  42.8%  +49.7 19220
     18 Ktulu 8.0                               2822  +13  -13  53.4%  -27.5  2087
     19 Scorpio 2.0 32-bit 4CPU                 2821  +17  -18  31.0% +139.0  1254
     20 Chess Tiger 2007.1                      2816   +9   -8  48.0%  +15.3  5044
     21 Delfi 5.4 2CPU                          2806  +16  -16  43.5%  +51.4  1469
     22 Deep Frenzee May07 64-bit 2CPU          2793  +16  -16  40.6%  +71.9  1481
     23 Pharaon 3.5.1 4CPU                      2784  +33  -34  40.5%  +63.7   305
     24 Booot 4.15.0                            2766  +18  -18  51.0%   -4.8  1115
  25-26 BugChess2 1.6.3 64-bit                  2763  +18  -18  48.1%  +15.8  1115
  25-26 SmarThink 1.00 32-bit                   2763  +13  -13  47.0%  +26.0  2273
     27 Alaric 707                              2759   +9   -9  44.1%  +43.4  4921
     28 Colossus 2008b                          2746  +16  -16  45.9%  +30.0  1374
     29 E.T. Chess 13.01.08                     2733  +11  -11  46.8%  +25.6  2973
     30 Movei 00.8.438 (10 10 10)               2731  +11  -11  45.9%  +31.5  3123
     31 WildCat 8                               2730  +14  -14  44.1%  +46.6  1831
     32 Gandalf 6                               2721  +14  -13  38.9%  +86.1  2078
     33 Alfil 8.1.1 Optimized                   2719  +13  -13  44.4%  +43.8  2073
     34 Pro Deo 1.2                             2718  +12  -12  42.9%  +53.4  2659
  35-36 Ruffian 2.1.0                           2715  +18  -18  48.1%  +15.2  1113
  35-36 Sloppy 0.2.0 64-bit                     2715  +14  -14  42.0%  +60.9  1831
     37 Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1                  2711   +7   -8  41.4%  +63.2  7727
     38 GarboChess 2.10 64-bit                  2707  +16  -16  41.7%  +67.3  1533
     39 Lemming 0.34 64-bit                     2702  +16  -16  44.9%  +36.8  1369
     40 Chiron 0.8.7                            2688  +14  -14  48.1%  +13.1  1818
     41 Hamsters 0.7 2CPU                       2684  +20  -20  39.0%  +76.0   862
     42 SOS 5.1                                 2679  +11  -11  46.8%  +22.5  3238
     43 The Baron 2.23 64-bit                   2674  +19  -19  46.1%  +24.9   988
     44 Pseudo 0.7c                             2673  +11  -10  49.8%   -1.0  3477
     45 Aristarch 4.50                          2666  +11  -11  46.1%  +29.4  3121
     46 Arasan 11.3 64-bit 4CPU                 2664  +22  -22  12.5% +338.9  1386
     47 Petir 4.39                              2661  +12  -12  47.4%  +20.3  2416
     48 Jonny 2.83 32-bit                       2650  +12  -12  47.1%  +21.7  2460
     49 Hermann 2.4 64-bit 2CPU                 2643  +18  -18  56.5%  -52.3  1177
     50 Anaconda 2.0.1                          2639  +12  -12  51.2%   -8.6  2445
     51 Ufim 8.02                               2627  +10  -10  52.8%  -22.2  4013
     52 AnMon 5.60                              2611  +12  -12  49.4%   +5.2  2563
  53-55 Little Goliath Evolution 3.12 (TB On)   2608  +16  -16  50.3%   -2.2  1375
  53-55 Trace 1.37a                             2608  +12  -12  49.4%   +4.9  2730
  53-55 Yace 0.99.87                            2608  +15  -15  52.1%  -14.8  1632
     56 Twisted Logic 0.065e35                  2607  +33  -33  42.0%  +61.8   331
     57 Pepito 1.59 32-bit                      2589  +17  -17  50.0%   +0.7  1120
     58 Cerebro 3.01c                           2575  +20  -20  43.6%  +47.3   950
     59 Green Light Chess 3.00                  2573  +15  -15  48.9%   +6.5  1534
     60 Bruja 1.9 64-bit JA No-int-book         2572  +16  -16  49.8%   +1.1  1311
     61 Tao 5.6                                 2567  +15  -15  49.0%   +5.8  1557
  62-63 Abrok 5.0                               2558  +14  -14  49.9%   -2.6  1787
  62-63 Amyan 1.597                             2558  +12  -12  47.7%  +15.9  2822
     64 SpiderChess 070603                      2547  +11  -11  48.4%  +11.7  3262
     65 Matacz 1.3 HT74                         2545  +16  -16  50.2%   -2.1  1309
     66 King of Kings 2.56                      2538  +17  -17  50.1%   -2.4  1248
     67 LambChop 10.99                          2531  +13  -14  49.8%   +1.7  1966
     68 Quark 2.35                              2525  +14  -14  49.6%   +4.0  1961
     69 Nejmet 3.07                             2517  +12  -12  48.5%   +9.9  2564
     70 Kiwi 0.6d                               2516  +16  -16  46.3%  +25.9  1515
  71-72 Dragon 4.6                              2514  +12  -12  46.5%  +26.5  2574
  71-72 Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit                     2514  +14  -14  49.0%   +6.5  1834
     73 Delphil 1.9c                            2512  +19  -19  47.9%  +17.1   960
     74 DanaSah 2.85k                           2508  +35  -34  55.4%  -38.6   286
     75 Patzer 3.80 2CPU                        2504  +24  -24  48.3%  +12.0   629
     76 RomiChess P3k 64-bit                    2502  +20  -20  46.7%  +27.0   937
     77 KnightDreamer 3.3                       2501  +17  -17  50.8%   -6.9  1276
     78 Gaia 3.5 32-bit                         2495  +18  -18  53.7%  -30.0  1258
     79 Francesca MAD 0.13 Nobook               2493  +18  -18  50.3%   -2.4  1116
     80 Comet B50                               2492  +20  -20  43.7%  +45.6   887
     81 Amy 0.8.7b DC                           2490  +17  -17  51.3%  -10.9  1280
     82 Gosu 0.16                               2482  +17  -17  51.7%  -14.5  1333
     83 Muse 0.899b                             2476  +13  -13  53.2%  -27.4  2387
     84 Der Bringer 1.9                         2472  +12  -12  52.2%  -22.0  2629
     85 Djinn 0.925x                            2471  +12  -12  49.2%   +3.0  2545
  86-87 Homer 2.01                              2464  +24  -24  53.9%  -30.5   629
  86-87 Leila 0.53h                             2464  +17  -17  55.9%  -53.4  1341
     88 Crazy Bishop 0052                       2462  +17  -17  55.2%  -48.3  1375
     89 Queen 3.09                              2452  +36  -36  48.5%  +11.4   261
     90 Betsy 6.51 Nobook                       2450  +19  -19  56.2%  -54.3  1119
     91 Amateur 2.82                            2445  +13  -13  51.0%  -13.9  2481
     92 Cheese 1.3                              2442  +20  -20  43.6%  +45.0   957
     93 Phalanx XXII Reborn JA                  2436  +16  -16  53.3%  -35.7  1596
     94 Thor's Hammer 2.28 32-bit               2423  +17  -17  56.0%  -54.1  1484
     95 Arion 1.7                               2420  +17  -17  45.3%  +33.2  1344
     96 Chezzz 1.0.3                            2412  +18  -18  56.7%  -59.0  1216
     97 OliThink 5.1.4 64-bit                   2407  +36  -37  43.6%  +46.9   272
     98 Averno 0.81                             2402  +18  -18  55.1%  -49.0  1253
     99 Resp 0.19 64-bit Nobook                 2399  +19  -19  54.6%  -44.2  1083
    100 Popochin 3.2                            2387  +21  -21  41.6%  +58.2   856
    101 Scidlet 3.61 x64 JA                     2378  +18  -18  51.8%  -23.2  1212
    102 KnightX 1.92                            2368  +18  -18  53.9%  -36.6  1240
    103 Eeyore 1.48                             2365  +19  -19  51.6%  -20.1  1145
104-105 Asterisk 0.6                            2363  +25  -25  43.3%  +48.7   617
104-105 LittleThought 1.03 64-bit 2CPU          2363  +22  -22  38.4%  +85.9   774
    106 GreKo 5.3                               2360  +39  -39  44.3%  +36.4   254
    107 EXchess 5.01 64-bit                     2359  +18  -18  48.8%   +1.8  1216
    108 Anechka 0.08                            2356  +20  -20  42.7%  +54.4   987
    109 Natwarlal 0.14                          2353  +20  -20  39.7%  +76.8   953
    110 Horizon 4.3                             2352  +23  -23  48.6%   +7.5   772
    111 Deuterium 06.07.24.68b                  2346  +31  -33  19.5% +256.9   501
112-113 Ant 2006-F                              2344  +37  -37  37.6%  +91.9   267
112-113 Zeus 1.27                               2344  +44  -43  59.0%  -85.6   216
114-115 Doctor 3.0                              2338  +20  -20  52.0%  -22.6   958
114-115 Esc 1.16                                2338  +21  -21  52.8%  -26.8   894
    116 Sage 2.2a                               2336  +24  -24  48.7%   +4.8   676
    117 Latista 1.50                            2302  +31  -31  45.6%  +34.4   378
    118 Atlas 2.20                              2301  +27  -27  43.0%  +45.9   538
119-120 Chispa 4.0.3                            2272  +19  -19  42.1%  +56.2  1022
119-120 Madeleine 0.2                           2272  +20  -20  42.9%  +50.8   990
    121 BlackBishop 0.98                        2259  +27  -28  25.7% +194.8   588
    122 Neurosis 2.3                            2258  +44  -47  21.7% +228.1   224
    123 InmiChess3.06N                          2239  +21  -21  38.8%  +85.8   957
    124 Lime 66                                 2227  +34  -35  24.2% +202.6   376
    125 Adam 3.0                                2217  +36  -36  41.6%  +59.3   320
    126 Fortress 1.62                           2209  +22  -22  38.0%  +94.2   832
    127 GK 0.90 64-bit                          2175  +24  -24  37.1% +101.1   703
    128 Wing 2.0a                               2172  +36  -37  39.8%  +81.6   303
129-130 Matant 5.02                             2133  +41  -41  48.8%  +10.8   258
129-130 Monarch 1.7                             2133  +37  -37  51.8%   -8.2   272
    131 Bestia 0.90                             2117  +25  -26  30.5% +161.4   701
    132 Bodo 0.2b Nobook                        2113  +26  -27  29.6% +168.1   640
    133 Gibbon 2.01b                            2109  +40  -41  40.2%  +89.9   256
    134 Ax 0.8                                  2105  +24  -24  26.4% +202.2   832
    135 Marvin 1.3.0                            2077  +40  -40  52.2%  -16.4   226
    136 FireFly 2.1.3                           2058  +42  -42  37.4% +106.3   235
    137 Faile 1.4.4                             2047  +20  -20  27.3% +204.4  1316
    138 Feuerstein 0.4.4.2                      2005  +39  -40  35.0% +127.8   280
    139 BamBam                                  2002  +28  -28  45.3%  +46.4   499
    140 Eagle 0.7.5                             1999  +35  -35  54.3%  -35.6   316
    141 Micro-Max 4.8                           1998  +35  -36  43.2%  +61.5   311
    142 Clueless V1.4                           1972  +33  -33  54.3%  -34.0   352
    143 Mustang 3.0                             1933  +41  -41  52.4%  -14.2   209
    144 Soldat 0.25b                            1922  +30  -32  10.5% +391.8   820
    145 Alex 1.78                               1890  +36  -37  31.4% +186.1   353
    146 BikJump v1.3                            1879  +36  -36  39.4%  +79.5   287
    147 Heracles 0.5.9                          1859  +33  -33  54.6%  -35.1   368
    148 Tscp 1.81                               1781  +35  -35  41.7%  +66.1   339
    149 Roce 0.0360                             1766  +32  -32  37.5%  +90.1   381

FRC Notes

Thanks to the much appreciated efforts of Matthias Gemuh, ChessGUI is now able to be used to test all FRC engines, both Winboard/UCI plus Shredder/Arena specific.

There are currently almost 60,000 games in the database.

Code: Select all

Rank            Engine              ELO   +    -   Score  AvOp  Games
    1 Rybka 3 64-bit                3182  +20  -19  79.5% -233.7  1200
    2 Naum 4 64-bit                 3079  +18  -17  69.5% -152.7  1300
    3 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 1CPU 2975  +15  -15  61.1%  -87.2  1700
    4 Shredder 11                   2973  +13  -13  60.9%  -86.0  2400
    5 Hiarcs 12.1                   2932  +13  -13  57.1%  -55.8  2200
    6 Glaurung 2.2 64-bit           2895  +15  -14  59.5%  -81.1  2000
    7 Fruit 051103                  2862  +10  -10  56.8%  -56.7  4100
    8 Loop 10.32f                   2855  +10  -10  55.6%  -47.1  4400
    9 Bright 0.4a                   2821  +15  -15  58.3%  -67.6  1800
   10 Spike 1.2 Turin               2818  +10  -10  52.6%  -23.6  4400
11-12 Frenzee Feb08 64-bit          2669  +15  -15  47.3%  +21.6  2000
11-12 Movei 00.8.438                2669  +10  -10  41.5%  +66.9  4200
   13 The Baron 2.23                2651  +15  -15  48.7%   +8.1  2000
   14 Pharaon 3.5.1                 2645  +10  -10  41.9%  +64.1  5000
   15 Jonny 2.83                    2619  +15  -15  48.9%   +9.1  1800
   16 Hamsters 0.7.1                2615  +14  -14  47.4%  +19.6  2000
   17 Ufim 8.02                     2595  +10  -10  42.3%  +62.0  4500
   18 Hermann 2.4 64-bit            2594  +14  -14  47.2%  +23.3  2200
   19 Tornado 2.2 64-bit            2561  +16  -16  44.2%  +44.0  1700
   20 DanaSah 4.20                  2554  +15  -15  46.7%  +23.7  1900
   21 Aice 0.99.2                   2361  +13  -13  35.5% +115.2  2800
   22 Ayito 0.2.994                 2360  +13  -13  35.6% +116.3  2800
   23 Betsy Fischer                 2325  +19  -19  37.1% +105.6  1400
   24 Chispa 4.0.3                  2272  +18  -18  38.0%  +94.5  1300
   25 Homer 1.02                    2228  +20  -21  39.9%  +77.9  1000
   26 BigLion 2.23x                 1987  +26  -27  34.8% +126.9   900
   27 Taktix 2.23x                  1986  +26  -27  34.8% +128.0   900
   28 ArcBishop80 2.24a             1589  +43  -45  24.7% +252.7   300
   29 BigLion80 2.23x               1552  +44  -46  19.7% +302.0   300

Stats/Presentation Notes

The LOS (likelihood of superiority) stats to the right hand side of each rating list tell you the likelihood in percentage terms of each engine being superior to the engine directly below them.

All games are available for download by engine, by month or by ECO code.
ELO ratings are now saved in all game databases for those engines that have 200 games or more.

Clicking on an engine name will give details as to opponents played plus homepage links where applicable.

Custom lists of engines can be selected for comparison.

An openings report page lists the number of games played by ECO codes with draw percentage and White win percentage. Clicking on a column heading will sort the list by that column.

A future development (no set date yet) will be the optional inclusion of engine logos, flags and continent pictures beside each engine name in the rating lists.
An example of what this will look can be seen here in Kirill's special free engines project - KCEC site
The engine logo will function as a link to selection of all engines from the same family. The country flag will be a link to selection of all engines from the same country. The continent picture is a link to selection of all engines from the same continent.
This feature will be implemented once Kirill can find the time to do it.
gbanksnz at gmail.com
glorfindel

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by glorfindel »

Thank you, I have a couple of questions.

Can we see a list such as the Single-CPU list with only the best version of each engine appearing, and all the others hidden? And does the button "Show selected data!" really work? It always fails for me here.
User avatar
Graham Banks
Posts: 44620
Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2006 10:52 am
Location: Auckland, NZ

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by Graham Banks »

glorfindel wrote:Thank you, I have a couple of questions.

Can we see a list such as the Single-CPU list with only the best version of each engine appearing, and all the others hidden? And does the button "Show selected data!" really work? It always fails for me here.
Hi Christos,

I'm pretty sure the answer is yes to both. I'll get Kirill to explain.

Cheers,
Graham.
gbanksnz at gmail.com
User avatar
Kirill Kryukov
Posts: 518
Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 4:12 am
Full name: Kirill Kryukov

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by Kirill Kryukov »

Hi Christos,
glorfindel wrote:Thank you, I have a couple of questions.

Can we see a list such as the Single-CPU list with only the best version of each engine appearing, and all the others hidden?
Yes you can: Open an index page (like this one), scroll down to the "Custom comparison" section, then find drop down selection titled "Select class of engines to compare:" - it will show there "None" at first. Change it to "Single-CPU engines" (select from the list). Then scroll down some more until you see the button "Compare them!" - click on it.
glorfindel wrote:And does the button "Show selected data!" really work? It always fails for me here.
It's supposed to be working, yes.

I know that most readers would prefer a single big button "Don't bug me with details, just show me the selection I want to see" in the middle of the page. Sorry, we are still beta-testing this new feature, and also the required USB mindreader devices are still not very common.

Best wishes,
Kirill
Norm Pollock
Posts: 1077
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 4:15 pm
Location: Long Island, NY, USA

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by Norm Pollock »

The question I have is whether the engines, in the 40/40 database, face enough variety of opposition. There are 634 engines on the list.

I looked at the number of games for each engine compared to the number of distinct opponents. It seems that the engines that have a large number of games also have a large variety of opponents. But I do not know what is a good rule for variety. Does CCRL have any variety guidelines?

Code: Select all


          Name                 #Games   #Opponents

Adam 3.1                         497         74
Aice 0.99.2                      423         91
Alaric 0702b                     342         99
Alaric 704                       326         60
Alaric 707                      1552        133
Alf 1.09                         341         60
Alfil 6.10                       255         71
Alfil 7.6                        222         58
Alfil 8.1.1                     1072        133
AliChess 4.06                    248         60
AliChess 4.08                    276         60
AliChess 4.16                    239         61
AliChess 4.18                    280         49
Amateur 2.82                     426        105
Amundsen 0.65.1                  238         41
Amundsen 0.80                     28         20
Amy 0.87b                        292         45
Amyan 1.597                      649        105
AnMon 5.60                      1241        136
AnMon 5.66                       332         38
Anaconda 2.0.1                   362         52
Anatoli 0.35k                    573         94
Anechka 0.08                     443        109
Ant 2006-F                       436        105
Arasan 10.0                      286         68
Arasan 10.1                      336         55
Arasan 10.2                      390         28
Arasan 10.3                      369         39
Arasan 10.4                      542         64
Arasan 11.3                       69         24
Arasan 9.2                       234         42
Arasan 9.5                       254         64
Arion 1.7                        419         82
Aristarch 4.50                  1699        101
Aristarch 4.51                   221         45
Asterisk 0.6                     509         94
Atak 6.0                         225         39
Atak 6.2                         206         44
Atak 6.5                          44         14
Atlas 2.20                       266         67
Averno 0.81                      307         76
Ayito 0.2.994                    341         69
BBChess 1.3a                     472         72
BBChess 1.3b                     169         33
Bearded 06-29                    247         47
BibiChess 0.5                    226         32
BigLion 2.23w                    260         31
BigLion 2.23x                    410         57
BikJump 1.8                      258         44
BikJump 2.01                     177         29
Bison 8.2.4r                     458         85
BlackBishop 0.47                 239         38
Booot 4.10.1                     238         43
Booot 4.11.1                     299         74
Booot 4.12.0                     236         79
Booot 4.12.1                     260         61
Booot 4.13.0                     238         75
Booot 4.13.1                     411         74
Booot 4.14.0                     848         76
Booot 4.15.0                     393         40
Bright 0.2b                      587         55
Bright 0.2b 2CPU                 207         29
Bright 0.2c                      436         49
Bright 0.2c 2CPU                 298         40
Bright 0.2c 4CPU                 875         43
Bright 0.3a                      763         61
Bright 0.3a 2CPU                 284         32
Bright 0.3a 4CPU                1005         40
Bright 0.3b                      582         38
Bright 0.3b 2CPU                 266         14
Bright 0.3b 4CPU                 113          2
Bright 0.3d                      875         43
Bright 0.3d 2CPU                 306          9
Bright 0.3d 4CPU                 885         16
Bright 0.4a                     1896         66
Bright 0.4a 2CPU                 196         28
Bright 0.4a 4CPU                1074         19
Bruja 1.9                        257         45
Brutus 5.4                       210         44
Brutus 6.0                       240         31
Brutus 6.1                       223         53
Brutus 7.02                       57         19
BugChess2 1.4.1                  247         43
BugChess2 1.5.1                  249         54
BugChess2 1.5.2                  443         81
BugChess2 1.6.2                  277         55
BugChess2 1.6.3                  709         68
Buzz 0.07                        354         56
Buzz 0.08 32-bit                 374         57
CM10th Default                  1452        121
CM10th Guardian                  388        103
CM10th Lazarus                   402         88
CM10th Magic II                 1184         96
CM10th Ogre                      341        102
CM10th Paralyse                 1326        138
CM10th Pestilence                446        125
CM10th Warrior                   369         94
CM10th Xperience                1767        115
CM9000 Assassin                  247         50
CM9000 Enforcer                  529         88
Cerebro 3.01c                    367         62
Cerebro 3.03d                    480         70
Cheese 1.1b                      292         45
Cheese 1.2                       234         50
Cheese 1.3                       338         66
Chess Tiger 15                  1139         55
Chess Tiger 15 Gambit            347         43
Chess Tiger 2004                 656         22
Chess Tiger 2007                1880        112
Chess Tiger 2007 Gambit          345         82
Chess Tiger 2007.1              2728        137
ChessAlex 2.0r4                  311         68
Chessmaster 11                  1598        109
Chessmaster 11 2CPU              260          7
Chessmaster 11 Aiglos II         334         46
Chessmaster 11 Archangel         349         48
Chessmaster 11 Leonidas          270         31
Chessmaster 11 Toxic             285         57
Chezzz 1.0.3                     210         14
Chiron 0.8.7                     579        105
Chispa 4.0.3                     376         84
Chronos 1.9.4                    242         39
Chronos 1.9.5                    281         50
Clarabit 1.00                    338         56
Clueless 1.4                     541         44
Colossus 2006d                   276         43
Colossus 2006f                   660         74
Colossus 2007a                   271         36
Colossus 2007b                   234         59
Colossus 2007c                   303         68
Colossus 2007d                   701         99
Colossus 2008a                   302         38
Colossus 2008b                   657         72
Comet B68                        451        116
Counter 0.8                      216         50
Counter 1.0                      214         49
Counter 1.1                      271         39
Crafty 20.11 32-bit              272         76
Crafty 20.13 32-bit              254         70
Crafty 20.14 32-bit              296         76
Crafty 21.5 32-bit               324         76
Crafty 21.5 64-bit               147         44
Crafty 21.6 32-bit               295         51
Crafty 22.0 32-bit               272         24
Crafty 22.1 32-bit               439         62
Crafty 22.10 32-bit              154         37
Crafty 22.4 32-bit               220         47
Crafty 22.8 32-bit               221         26
Crafty 22.8 64-bit                98          3
Crafty 23.0 32-bit                82         24
Crafty 23.0 64-bit 4CPU          816         19
Crimson 1.0                      100         27
Critter 0.37                      28         21
Cyclone 1.0                      322         29
Cyclone 1.0 2CPU                 300         22
Cyclone 2.2                      382         22
Cyclone 2.2 2CPU                  54         21
Cyclone 2.3 2CPU                  44         20
Cyclone 3.1 2CPU                  61         23
Cyclone 3.4                      682         23
Cyclone 3.4 2CPU                  67          6
Cyrano 0.2f                      230         48
Cyrano 0.3                       290         61
Cyrano 0.5                       266         32
Cyrano 0.6b17                    624         74
DanaSah 2.44                     296         66
DanaSah 2.73                     211         43
DanaSah 2.85                     209         56
DanaSah 3.63                     490        108
DanaSah 4.24                     397         55
Deep Fritz 10 2CPU               227          9
Deep Fritz 10 4CPU               824         23
Deep Fritz 10.1 4CPU            1114         27
Deep Fritz 11 4CPU               335          9
Deep Fritz 8 2CPU                909         30
Deep Junior 10 2CPU              746         37
Deep Junior 10 4CPU             1828         46
Deep Junior 9 2CPU              1105         34
Deep Shredder 10 32-bit 2CPU     891         38
Deep Shredder 10 64-bit 2CPU     232         18
Deep Shredder 10 64-bit 4CPU    1135         31
Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 1CPU    1218         52
Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 2CPU     892         38
Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 4CPU    2092         45
Deep Shredder 9 2CPU            1087         33
Deep Sjeng 2.5 1CPU              226         35
Deep Sjeng 2.7 1CPU             1443         48
Deep Sjeng 2.7 4CPU             1001         27
Deep Sjeng 3.0 1CPU              766         23
Deep Sjeng 3.0 64-bit 1CPU       725         18
Deep Sjeng 3.0 64-bit 4CPU       617         15
Deep Sjeng WC2008 1CPU           853         44
Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 1CPU     691         21
Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 4CPU     851         17
Delfi 4.6                        334         54
Delfi 5.0                        807         73
Delfi 5.1                        477         70
Delfi 5.2                        777         83
Delfi 5.4                        484         54
Delfi 5.4 2CPU                   403          9
Delphil 1.6c                     258         72
Delphil 1.8                      435         93
Delphil 1.9c                     258         41
Delphil 1.9f                     264         42
Delphil 1.9g                      24         11
Deuterium 06.08.25.04            377         78
Diablo 0.5.1                     397         90
Dirty 0.99 OW5                    68         16
Dirty 0.99n                      234         30
Dirty 0.99z                      208         29
Djinn 0.925x                     404        107
Dragon 4.6                       625         90
E.T. Chess 13.01.08             1016        100
E.T. Chess 18.11.05              423         99
ECE 0.3                          374         34
EXchess 5.01b                    368         80
EveAnn 1.62                      277         54
EveAnn 1.63                      280         68
Feuerstein 0.4.4.2               405         44
Feuerstein 0.4.5.1               236         36
Feuerstein 0.4.5.2               239         46
Feuerstein 0.4.6                 210         26
Feuerstein 0.4.6.1               229         52
FireFly 2.5.4                    241         22
Flux 2.2                         404         87
Frenzee 1.1                      262         61
Frenzee 2.0                      307         80
Frenzee 3.0                      545        112
Frenzee Dec07                    437         53
Frenzee Feb08                   1085         79
Fritz 10                        1434         67
Fritz 11                        3153         84
Fritz 8 Bilbao                   478         63
Fritz 9                         2221         86
Fruit 051103                     724         74
Fruit 2.1                        516        102
Fruit 2.2.1                     2093         90
Fruit 2.3.1                     1601        150
Gaia 3.5 32-bit                  474         86
Gandalf 6                       2121        136
GarboChess 0.21                  245         51
GarboChess 2.20                  685         95
Gibbon 2.01b                     285         63
Gibbon 2.42c                     444         76
Gibbon 2.52a                      86         25
Glass 0.1.0c                     197         21
Glass 1.2                         18         15
Glaurung 1.0.2 32-bit           1102         55
Glaurung 1.1 32-bit              322         77
Glaurung 1.2.1 32-bit           1448         92
Glaurung 1.2.1 64-bit            656         25
Glaurung 1.2.1 64-bit 2CPU       628         44
Glaurung 1.2.1 64-bit 4CPU       948         23
Glaurung 1.2.1 Avalanche 32-bit     341         60
Glaurung 1.2.1 Avalanche 64-bit 2CPU     218         20
Glaurung 1.2.1 Beren 64-bit      238          8
Glaurung 1.2.1 Crusader 32-bit     344         73
Glaurung 2 epsilon/5 32-bit      401         68
Glaurung 2 epsilon/5 64-bit      197         42
Glaurung 2 epsilon/5 64-bit 2CPU     620         23
Glaurung 2.0.1 32-bit           1222         51
Glaurung 2.0.1 64-bit           1063         52
Glaurung 2.0.1 64-bit 2CPU       333         30
Glaurung 2.0.1 64-bit 4CPU      1182         37
Glaurung 2.1 32-bit             1002         52
Glaurung 2.1 32-bit 2CPU          65         20
Glaurung 2.1 64-bit              701         29
Glaurung 2.1 64-bit 2CPU         281         12
Glaurung 2.1 64-bit 4CPU         892         16
Glaurung 2.2 32-bit              419         43
Glaurung 2.2 32-bit 2CPU          96         24
Glaurung 2.2 64-bit              624         18
Glaurung 2.2 64-bit 2CPU         118         24
Glaurung 2.2 64-bit 4CPU         758         15
Gosu 0.16                        419         97
Grapefruit 1.0 32-bit            915         28
Grapefruit 1.0 32-bit 2CPU        61          9
Grapefruit 1.0 64-bit 2CPU        61         10
Grapefruit 1.0a3                 269         33
Grapefruit 1.0b 2CPU               1          1
GreKo 5.2.5                      207         47
GreKo 5.5                        215         43
GreKo 5.9                        377         33
GreKo 6.25                       197         33
GreKo 6.30                       123         31
Hamsters 0.0.6                   353         83
Hamsters 0.2                     224         59
Hamsters 0.4                     264         49
Hamsters 0.5                     273         75
Hamsters 0.6                     912         89
Hamsters 0.7                     246         49
Hamsters 0.7.1                   330         52
Hermann 1.9                      215         58
Hermann 2.0                      404         78
Hermann 2.3                      354         41
Hermann 2.4                      368         56
Hiarcs 10                       1576         62
Hiarcs 10 Hypermodern            891         35
Hiarcs 11                        519         49
Hiarcs 11 2CPU                   394         19
Hiarcs 11 4CPU                   282          8
Hiarcs 11.1                     1482         69
Hiarcs 11.1 2CPU                 937         31
Hiarcs 11.1 4CPU                1120         26
Hiarcs 11.2                      913         51
Hiarcs 11.2 2CPU                 639         19
Hiarcs 11.2 4CPU                 489         16
Hiarcs 12                       1848         60
Hiarcs 12 2CPU                   392         19
Hiarcs 12 4CPU                  1399         30
Hiarcs 12 Sharpen PV On         1252         41
Hiarcs 12 Sharpen PV On 4CPU     722         14
Hiarcs 12.1                      729         39
Hiarcs 12.1 4CPU                  80          2
Hiarcs 9                         784         28
Hiarcs Paderborn 2007            599         26
Hiarcs Paderborn 2007 4CPU       478         11
Hiarcs X50                      1171         71
Hiarcs X50 Hypermodern           420         39
Hiarcs X54 32-bit                351         72
Hiarcs X54 64-bit                334         40
Hiarcs X54 Hypermodern 32-bit     325         69
Homer 2.0                        223         53
Homer 2.01                       459         89
Horizon 4.3                      345         68
Horizon 4.4                      554         69
Joker 1.1.06                     241         48
Joker 1.1.14                     520         87
Jonny 2.83                      1134         90
Junior 10                       2077         77
Junior 10.1                      511         37
Junior 9                        1238         54
Kiwi 0.6d                        344         85
KnightDreamer 3.3                249         18
KnightX 1.92                     399         74
Ktulu 7.1                        980         40
Ktulu 7.5                       1421         58
Ktulu 8.0                       3927        201
Lemming 0.24                     307         38
Lemming 0.34                     240         12
Lime 62                          396         65
Lime 66                          288         43
List 5.12                       1059         60
Little Goliath Evolution 3.12     829        138
LittleThought 1.00 32-bit        216         51
LittleThought 1.03 32-bit        519         73
Loop 10.32f                      931         71
Loop 12.32                       422         63
Loop 13.5 32-bit                 410         53
Loop 13.5 64-bit 2CPU            540         16
Loop 13.6 32-bit                2321         94
Loop 13.6 64-bit 2CPU            409         42
Loop 13.6 64-bit 4CPU            541         21
Loop M1-T 64-bit                 366         46
Loop M1-T 64-bit 2CPU            720         30
Loop M1-T 64-bit 4CPU           2104         45
LoopList 6.00                    332         79
LoopMP 12.32 2CPU                694         25
Marvin 1.3.0                     405         40
Matacz 1.1                       252         58
Matacz 1.3                       384         77
Matacz 1.4                       475         46
Matheus 2.3                      302         42
Mediocre 0.334                   353         73
Mediocre 0.34                     71         14
Micro-Max 4.8                    338         35
Micro-Max 4.8 (DM-PII)           517         10
Monarch 1.7                      549         80
Movei 00.8.295                   317         73
Movei 00.8.358                   260         44
Movei 00.8.403                   314         88
Movei 00.8.438                   953         87
Movei 00.8.438 (10 10 10)       1329        135
Muse 0.899b                      346         73
Mustang 4.97                     305         55
NagaSkaki 4.00                   248         50
NagaSkaki 5.12                   272         56
NanoSzachy 2.8                   220         41
NanoSzachy 2.9                   221         51
NanoSzachy 3.0                   231         44
NanoSzachy 3.1                   204         41
NanoSzachy 3.4                   510         64
Natwarlal 0.12                   222         41
Natwarlal 0.14                   585        116
Naum 1.91 32-bit                1171         88
Naum 1.91 64-bit                 973         31
Naum 2.0 32-bit                 1199         93
Naum 2.0 64-bit                  649         33
Naum 2.1 32-bit                  868         71
Naum 2.1 64-bit 2CPU             574         31
Naum 2.1 64-bit 4CPU             700         16
Naum 2.2 32-bit                 1104         59
Naum 2.2 64-bit                  523         50
Naum 2.2 64-bit 2CPU             580         19
Naum 2.2 64-bit 4CPU            1048         25
Naum 3 32-bit                    689         23
Naum 3 64-bit                    711         25
Naum 3 64-bit 2CPU               635         15
Naum 3 64-bit 4CPU               897         21
Naum 3.1 32-bit                 1347         43
Naum 3.1 64-bit                 1049         24
Naum 3.1 64-bit 2CPU             390         13
Naum 3.1 64-bit 4CPU            1024         22
Naum 3.1 64-bit PL10             300          6
Naum 3.1 64-bit PTnormal         536         10
Naum 4 32-bit                    661         20
Naum 4 64-bit                    720         23
Naum 4 64-bit 2CPU               101          2
Naum 4 64-bit 4CPU               767         16
Naum 4 64-bit PL-5               372         17
Naum 4 64-bit PL5                412         17
Neurosis 2.3                     258         59
Neurosis 2.4                     378         64
Neurosis 2.5                     253         21
Nimzo 8                          331         67
OBender 2.11.5                   219         25
OBender 3.10.1                   282         29
OBender 3.2.4                    329         54
OBender 3.2.4.2                   44         12
OliThink 5.1.9                    18         17
Onno 0.12.0 64-bit               391         11
Parrot 07.01.16                  231         45
Parrot 07.07.22                  391         66
Patzer 3.80                      364         89
Pepito 1.59                      399         48
Petir 3.95                       268         52
Petir 3.99d                      362         66
Petir 4.39                       393         43
Petir 4.9999                     711        120
Phalanx XXII                     214         28
Pharaon 3.3                      258         55
Pharaon 3.5.1                   1674        130
Pharaon 3.5.1 2CPU               368         48
Philou 2.7.0                     202         49
Popochin 2.7                     276         64
Popochin 2.9                     210         49
Popochin 3.0                     214         51
Popochin 3.1                     244         49
Popochin 3.2                     514         84
Post Modernist 1016              391         99
Pro Deo 1.1                      323         73
Pro Deo 1.1 Silver               348         75
Pro Deo 1.2                     1179         94
Pro Deo 1.2 Mx4                  270         65
Pro Deo 1.6                      670        100
Prophet 2.0                      508         70
Pseudo 0.7c                     1157        137
Pupsi 0.19                       243         57
Pupsi2 0.06                      298         41
Pupsi2 0.07                      332         33
Quark 2.35                       473         99
Queen 4.02a                      434         79
RattateChess Bologna 2007        405         63
Rival 1.18                       351         38
Rodin 1.17                       123         25
Rodin 2.1b                        58         21
RomiChess P3k                    521         85
Rotor 0.1a                       227         38
Rotor 0.2                        309         45
Rotor 0.3                        254         25
Rotor 0.4                        961         70
Ruffian 1.0.5                    804         29
Ruffian 2.1.0                   1261        164
Rybka 1.0 32-bit                1404         69
Rybka 1.0 64-bit                1388         43
Rybka 1.1 32-bit                1161         48
Rybka 1.1 64-bit                 665         21
Rybka 1.2 32-bit                1177         71
Rybka 1.2 64-bit                 821         26
Rybka 2.1 32-bit                 708         69
Rybka 2.1 32-bit (C+1 OSO)       413         13
Rybka 2.1 32-bit 2CPU            509         17
Rybka 2.1 64-bit 2CPU            572         14
Rybka 2.1 64-bit 4CPU            250         23
Rybka 2.2n2 32-bit              1217         51
Rybka 2.2n2 32-bit 2CPU          601         39
Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit               297         37
Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit 2CPU          745         44
Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit 4CPU          404         12
Rybka 2.3.2a 32-bit             1624         54
Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit             2778         73
Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 2CPU        1275         42
Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 4CPU        1629         35
Rybka 3 32-bit                  1166         30
Rybka 3 32-bit 2CPU                8          1
Rybka 3 64-bit                  1776         40
Rybka 3 64-bit 2CPU              552         12
Rybka 3 64-bit 4CPU             1231         23
Rybka 3 Dynamic 64-bit           288          9
Rybka 3 Human 64-bit             288          9
Rybka 3 Human 64-bit 4CPU        213         10
SOS 5.1                          950        138
Sage 2.2a                        227         51
Sage 3.53                        544         73
Scorpio 1.7                      272         85
Scorpio 1.8                      861         66
Scorpio 1.81                     330         59
Scorpio 1.84                     427         73
Scorpio 1.9                      394         72
Scorpio 1.9 32-bit 2CPU          209         42
Scorpio 1.91                    1485         92
Scorpio 2.0                      982         92
Scorpio 2.0 2CPU                  87          4
Scorpio 2.0 4CPU                 314         38
Scorpio 2.02b                    379         48
Scorpio 2.02b 2CPU                11          2
Scorpio 2.05b                    198         51
Scorpio 2.1                       44         11
Scorpio 2.1 64-bit 4CPU          166          4
Shredder 10                     2039        107
Shredder 11                     2116         78
Shredder 9                      1162         44
Sinobyl 1.50                     328         65
Sloppy 0.1.0                     323         56
Sloppy 0.1.1                     274         63
Sloppy 0.2.0                     896         79
Slow Chess Blitz WV2            1080         64
Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1          1994        145
SmarThink 0.17a                  305         56
SmarThink 1.00 32-bit           1531         99
SmarThink 1.00 64-bit            254         65
Smash 1.0.3                      379         55
Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit              489        109
Sorgenkind 0.4                   521         76
SpiderChess 070603               291         77
Spike 1.0a                       871         28
Spike 1.1                       1622         99
Spike 1.2 Turin                 6387        249
Stockfish 1.01                   284         36
Stockfish 1.1a 2CPU               69         21
Stockfish 1.1a 64-bit             96          3
Stockfish 1.2 Default            491         36
Stockfish 1.2a Default 2CPU       20          5
Stockfish 1.2a Optimistic 2CPU      12          2
Surprise 4.3b13                  300         33
TJchess 0.121                    370         58
Tao 5.6                          385         40
The Baron 1.7.0                  301         63
The Baron 1.8.1                  550        100
The Baron 2.23                   515         63
TheMadPrune 1.1.25               418         34
TheMadPrune 1.1.25 2CPU           58         21
Thinker 4.7a                     331         70
Thinker 5.1d Passive             469         38
Thinker 5.2I Passive 64-bit 4CPU     243          5
Thinker 5.2e Passive             477         31
Thinker 5.2k Passive 2CPU         93         22
Thinker 5.2m Passive 2CPU         91         21
Thinker 5.3b Inert 32-bit        600         31
Thinker 5.3b Inert 32-bit 2CPU     204         28
Thinker 5.3b Inert 64-bit        567         16
Thinker 5.3b Passive 64-bit      320         10
Thinker 5.4C Inert 32-bit        201         22
Thinker 5.4C Inert 64-bit        324          9
Thinker 5.4C Inert 64-bit 4CPU     734         13
Thinker 5.4a Inert 32-bit        519         23
Thinker 5.4a Inert 32-bit 2CPU      45         10
Thinker 5.4a Inert 64-bit        372         10
Thinker 5.4a Inert 64-bit 2CPU     177         20
Thinker 5.4a Inert 64-bit 4CPU     560         13
Thor's Hammer 2.28               364         82
Toga II 1.1a                    1050         63
Toga II 1.2 32-bit               385         73
Toga II 1.2.1a                  2789        131
Toga II 1.3 Beta3b               517         17
Toga II 1.3.1                   2977         89
Toga II 1.3.4                    543         77
Toga II 1.4 beta4 4CPU           477         11
Toga II 1.4 beta5c               534         42
Toga II 1.4 beta5c 2CPU          551         21
Toga II 1.4 beta5c 4CPU         1000         37
Toga II 1.4.1SE                 2386         79
Toga II 1.4.1SE 2CPU             309         31
Toga II 1.4.1SE 4CPU            1322         29
Toga II 1.4.1SE3 4CPU             65          2
Toga II 1.4.1SE6                 866         66
Toga II 1.4.1SE6 2CPU             85         24
Toga II 1.4.3JD beta 4CPU         96          3
Toga II 3.1.2SE                  865         35
Tornado 1.0                      374         91
Tornado 2.1.41a                  412         44
Tornado 2.2                      332         46
Trace 1.35                       280         51
Trace 1.36                       356         99
Trace 1.37a                      577        129
Twisted Logic 0.065e35           246         57
Twisted Logic 0.065e37           252         56
Twisted Logic 0.080b26           207         67
Twisted Logic 0.085              319         71
Twisted Logic 0.099x             252         73
Twisted Logic 20070915           285         56
Twisted Logic 20071202x          400         59
Twisted Logic 20080404x          373         50
Twisted Logic 20080620           653         58
Typhoon 1.00-285                 212         47
Typhoon 1.00-314                 221         50
Typhoon 1.00-348                 206         61
Typhoon 1.00-358                 366         68
Tytan 9.3                        303         58
Ufim 7.01                        251         65
Ufim 8.00                        246         50
Ufim 8.02                        810        128
Uralochka 1.1b                   411         75
Viper 0.1                        260         68
Warrior 1.0.3                    287         30
Waxman 2008                      131         20
WildCat 6                        681         63
WildCat 7                       1492        105
WildCat 8                        709         84
Xpdnt 080927                     315         45
Yace 0.99.87                     365         40
ZCT 0.3.2451                     410         75
Zap!Chess Paderborn 32-bit       733         30
Zap!Chess Paderborn 64-bit 2CPU     371         12
Zap!Chess Paderborn 64-bit 4CPU     558         19
Zap!Chess Paderborn SE 32-bit     275         76
Zap!Chess Reykjavik 32-bit       275         25
Zap!Chess Zanzibar 32-bit        853         45
Zap!Chess Zanzibar 64-bit        429         13
Zap!Chess Zanzibar 64-bit 2CPU     201         16
Zap!Chess Zanzibar 64-bit 4CPU     679         14
Zappa 1.1 32-bit                 386        109
Zappa 1.1 64-bit                 546         24
Zappa Mexico 32-bit              873         35
Zappa Mexico 64-bit             1105         42
Zappa Mexico 64-bit 2CPU         447         25
Zappa Mexico 64-bit 4CPU        1204         31
Zappa Mexico II 32-bit          1378         61
Zappa Mexico II 64-bit          1566         36
Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 2CPU      379         18
Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 4CPU     1447         35
Zeus 1.27                        233         46
Zeus 1.28                        346         70
Zeus 1.29                        537         87

User avatar
Matthias Gemuh
Posts: 3245
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:10 am

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by Matthias Gemuh »

Norm Pollock wrote:The question I have is whether the engines, in the 40/40 database, face enough variety of opposition. There are 634 engines on the list.

I looked at the number of games for each engine compared to the number of distinct opponents. It seems that the engines that have a large number of games also have a large variety of opponents. But I do not know what is a good rule for variety. Does CCRL have any variety guidelines?

I have always thought that all testers test engines of their own choices, bound only by the range of engine strength.

Matthias.
My engine was quite strong till I added knowledge to it.
http://www.chess.hylogic.de
Norm Pollock
Posts: 1077
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 4:15 pm
Location: Long Island, NY, USA

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by Norm Pollock »

Matthias Gemuh wrote:
Norm Pollock wrote:The question I have is whether the engines, in the 40/40 database, face enough variety of opposition. There are 634 engines on the list.

I looked at the number of games for each engine compared to the number of distinct opponents. It seems that the engines that have a large number of games also have a large variety of opponents. But I do not know what is a good rule for variety. Does CCRL have any variety guidelines?

I have always thought that all testers test engines of their own choices, bound only by the range of engine strength.

Matthias.
Without guidelines you get outlier situations that, imho, should not be included in the rating list until there is more variety of opposition:

Code: Select all

Bright 0.3b 4CPU                 113          2
Crafty 22.8 64-bit                98          3
Naum 4 64-bit 2CPU               101          2
Scorpio 2.1 64-bit 4CPU          166          4
Stockfish 1.1a 64-bit             96          3
Thinker 5.2I Passive 64-bit 4CPU     243          5
Toga II 1.4.1SE3 4CPU             65          2
Toga II 1.4.3JD beta 4CPU         96          3
krazyken

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by krazyken »

A quick look at this list suggests that increasing the number of CPUs is decreasing the variety of opponents. I'd guess the multi CPU versions are not seeing very many single CPU opponents.
User avatar
Dr.Wael Deeb
Posts: 9773
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:44 pm
Location: Amman,Jordan

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by Dr.Wael Deeb »

krazyken wrote:A quick look at this list suggests that increasing the number of CPUs is decreasing the variety of opponents. I'd guess the multi CPU versions are not seeing very many single CPU opponents.
I see no reason why MP engines don't play a non MP ones if they are in the same Elo range :!: :?:
Dr.D
_No one can hit as hard as life.But it ain’t about how hard you can hit.It’s about how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward.How much you can take and keep moving forward….
User avatar
Graham Banks
Posts: 44620
Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2006 10:52 am
Location: Auckland, NZ

Re: CCRL update (15th May 2009)

Post by Graham Banks »

Matthias Gemuh wrote:
Norm Pollock wrote:The question I have is whether the engines, in the 40/40 database, face enough variety of opposition. There are 634 engines on the list.

I looked at the number of games for each engine compared to the number of distinct opponents. It seems that the engines that have a large number of games also have a large variety of opponents. But I do not know what is a good rule for variety. Does CCRL have any variety guidelines?

I have always thought that all testers test engines of their own choices, bound only by the range of engine strength.

Matthias.
Matthias is correct. Freedom to test what one wishes, but trying to select opponents within a 200-250 elo range.
Some members like to carry out systematic testing, but some (including myself) like to run tournaments in addition to gauntlets.

Cheers,
Graham.
gbanksnz at gmail.com