CCRL 40/40 lists updated (2nd February 2013)

[Graham Banks]

The latest CCRL Rating Lists and Statistics are available for viewing from the following links:
http://computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/4040/ (40/40)
http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/404/ (40/4)
http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/404FRC/ (FRC 40/4)

Please note that the three lists are updated separately to each other. The 40/40 and 40/4 lists are updated once every two weeks and alternately to each other. The FRC list is updated when a new engine or engine version is being/has been tested.

The links to the various rating lists can be found just beneath the default Best Versions list (as in this screenshot). Specific 32-bit rating lists are denoted as such to the right of the default list in each category. The default lists contain the 64-bit engines.



Our 40 moves in 40 minutes repeating and 40 moves in 4 minutes repeating are both adjusted to the AMD64 X2 4600+ (2.4GHz).

Be aware that in the early stages of testing, an engine's rating can often fluctuate a lot.
It is strongly advised to look at the many other rating lists available in order to get a more accurate overall picture of an engine's rating relative to others.

The LOS (likelihood of superiority) stats to the right hand side of each rating list tell you the likelihood in percentage terms of each engine being superior to the engine directly below them.

All games are available for download by engine, by month or by ECO code. The download databases by month or ECO code are only updated monthly, but the total games database in its entirety is always available.
The current ELO ratings are saved in all game databases for those engines that have 200 games or more.

Clicking on an engine name will give details as to opponents played plus homepage links where applicable.

Custom lists of engines can be selected for comparison.

An openings report page lists the number of games played by ECO codes with draw percentage and White win percentage. Clicking on a column heading will sort the list by that column.


Games submitted for this update
Bouquet 1.6 32-bit -> 395
Gull II 32-bit -> 272
Chiron 1.5 64-bit -> 236
RobboLito 0.21Q 64-bit -> 196
Bouquet 1.6 64-bit -> 182
Bouquet 1.6 64-bit 4CPU -> 166
RobboLito 0.21Q 32-bit -> 90
Pupsi2 0.09 -> 75
Atlas 3.25 64-bit -> 75
DanaSah 5.00 -> 75
Sting SF 2 32-bit -> 53
Pepito 1.59 64-bit -> 48
Green Light Chess 3.01.2.2 -> 48
Bruja 1.9.1 64-bit -> 48
Delphil 2.9g 64-bit -> 48
iCE 0.3 -> 48
LittleThought 1.052 64-bit -> 48
Cheese 1.4 64-bit -> 48
GreKo 9.7 64-bit -> 48
Dorky 4.3 64-bit -> 48
AnMon 5.66 -> 48
Komodo 5 64-bit -> 46
BlackMamba 1.2b 64-bit -> 46
RedQueen 1.1.3 64-bit -> 46
Hannibal 1.3 64-bit -> 46
Gull II 64-bit -> 46
Critter 1.6a 64-bit -> 46
FireFly 2.5.13 64-bit -> 44
Vitruvius 1.11C 64-bit -> 44
Butcher 1.64 64-bit -> 44
EveAnn 1.67 -> 44
TJchess 1.1 64-bit -> 44
Gibbon 2.57a 64-bit -> 44
IvanHoe 9.46h 64-bit -> 44
Tigran 2.3 64-bit -> 44
Capivara LK 0.08b03a 64-bit -> 44
Shallow 1.0 64-bit -> 44
Rybka 4.1 64-bit -> 44
Waxman 2011 -> 44
Naum 4.2 64-bit -> 44
Strelka 5.5 64-bit -> 44
Gaviota 0.86 64-bit -> 44
Vajolet 1.62.1 -> 44
Myrddin 0.86 64-bit -> 44
ChessKiss 1.7 64-bit -> 44
DiscoCheck 4.0.1 64-bit -> 40
Houdini 1.5a 32-bit -> 36
Octochess r4741 64-bit -> 35
Alfil 13.1 64-bit -> 35
Godel 2.3.7 64-bit -> 35
Philou 3.7.1 64-bit -> 35
Komodo 3 32-bit -> 35
Dirty 5Sep2012 64-bit -> 34
Spike 1.4 Leiden -> 34
Cheng3 1.07 64-bit -> 34
Deuterium 12.01.30.1070 64-bit -> 34
ProDeo 1.83c -> 34
Rybka 2.3.2a 32-bit -> 34
Arasan 15.1 64-bit -> 33
Quazar 0.4 32-bit -> 32
DeepSaros 2.3j 32-bit -> 32
Strelka 5.5 32-bit -> 30
Stockfish 2.3.1 32-bit -> 30
Komodo 5 32-bit -> 30
IvanHoe 9.46h 32-bit -> 29
Stockfish 2.3.1 64-bit -> 29
Stockfish 2.2.2 32-bit -> 28
Shredder 12 32-bit OA On -> 28
Sting SF 2 64-bit -> 28
GreKo 9.8 64-bit -> 27
GarboChess 3.0 64-bit -> 27
NanoSzachy 4.0 64-bit -> 27
Francesca MAD 0.19 -> 27
Glass 1.9 64-bit -> 27
Tucano 1.04 -> 27
Rotor 0.7a -> 27
Hermann 2.8 64-bit -> 27
Pawny 0.3.1 64-bit -> 27
Critter 1.4 32-bit -> 27
Deep Junior 13.3 32-bit 1CPU -> 26
DeepSaros 3.0 32-bit -> 26
Strelka 5.1 32-bit -> 26
Hannibal 1.3 32-bit -> 26
Toga Returns 1.1 4CPU -> 25
Critter 1.6a 32-bit -> 24
DiscoCheck 3.7.1 64-bit -> 24
Tornado 4.88 64-bit 4CPU -> 24
Hiarcs 14 4CPU -> 24
IvanHoe 9.46h 64-bit 4CPU -> 24
Bright 0.5c 4CPU -> 24
RobboLito 0.21Q 64-bit 4CPU -> 24
Chiron 1.5 32-bit -> 24
Arasan 15.1 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
Critter 1.6a 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
MinkoChess 1.3 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
Jonny 4.00 4CPU -> 23
Naum 4.2 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
Scorpio 2.7.5 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
BugChess2 1.9 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
Rybka 4.1 32-bit -> 23
Rybka 4.1 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
Vitruvius 1.11C 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
Sting SF 2 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
Houdini 3 64-bit 4CPU -> 23
Naum 4.2 32-bit -> 22
Houdini 3 32-bit -> 22
Hiarcs 14 -> 22
Vitruvius 1.11C 32-bit -> 22
Stockfish 2.3.1 64-bit 4CPU -> 22
Shredder 12 32-bit OA Off -> 22
Alfil 13.1 64-bit 4CPU -> 18
Delphil 2.9g 64-bit 4CPU -> 18
Pharaon 3.5.1 4CPU -> 18
RedQueen 1.1.3 64-bit 4CPU -> 18
Nebula 1.5 64-bit 4CPU -> 18
Thinker 5.4D Inert 64-bit 4CPU -> 18
Gaviota 0.86 64-bit 4CPU -> 17
Crafty 23.5 64-bit 4CPU -> 17
Octochess r4741 64-bit 4CPU -> 17
Loop 13.6 (Loop 2007) 64-bit 4CPU -> 17
DeepSaros 3.3b 64-bit -> 15
Scorpio 2.7.5 64-bit -> 13
Bobcat 3.25 64-bit -> 13
Crafty 23.5 64-bit -> 13
Naraku 1.4 -> 13
Texel 1.01 64-bit -> 13
Frenzee 3.5.19 64-bit -> 13
Toga Returns 1.1 -> 13
Tornado 4.88 64-bit -> 13
EXchess 6.71b 64-bit -> 13
MinkoChess 1.3 64-bit -> 12
BugChess2 1.9 64-bit -> 12
Nemo 1.0.1 64-bit -> 11
Gaviota 0.85.1 64-bit -> 9
Spike 1.4 Leiden 4CPU -> 7
Hannibal 1.3 64-bit 4CPU -> 7
Gull II 64-bit 4CPU -> 7
Chiron 1.5 64-bit 4CPU -> 7
Protector 1.4.0 64-bit 4CPU -> 7
Deep Junior 13.3 64-bit 4CPU -> 7
Crafty 23.4 64-bit 4CPU -> 6
Deep Sjeng c't 2010 -> 2
Hannibal 1.2 32-bit -> 2

[elcabesa]

where the 44 Vajolet games come from? I'm rather carefull searching for Vajolet games, but i missed them

[Adam Hair]

Hi Marco,

These games were played by Charles Smith. Here is a link to the Vajolet 1.62.1 games that Charles submitted to the CCRL 40/40 list:

http://www.mediafire.com/?uuc3wuho19emv8l

Adam

[Graham Banks]

Hi Marco,

These games were played by Charles Smith. Here is a link to the Vajolet 1.62.1 games that Charles submitted to the CCRL 40/40 list:

http://www.mediafire.com/?uuc3wuho19emv8l

Adam

Another 44 games will be played when my Amateur Division 7 comes up in about three weeks time, and Charles is running a further tournament with 36 rounds too.

[elcabesa]

as soon as Vajolet will reach 200 games I'll release vejolet 2.0 it should be a lot stronger, comparable with Cheng 1.07 2700 elo point

[Graham Banks]

as soon as Vajolet will reach 200 games I'll release vejolet 2.0 it should be a lot stronger, comparable with Cheng 1.07 2700 elo point

Thanks for being considerate Marco. I'll try and speed things along as best I can by running a gauntlet as well.
As soon as I've finished my EveAnn gauntlets, I'll run some Vajolet games.

[elcabesa]

don't worry and don't run too many games I can wait

[Norm Pollock]

Hi Graham,

I was checking the 40/40 database and I came upon these two old games with abnormal terminations. One game was aborted for insufficient material when there was sufficient material, and the other game ended due to a time forfeit. In these two games, the results were fair. But allowing games into your database with abnormal terminations opens the door to having games with unfair results.

best,
Norm

Code: Select all

[Event "CCRL 40/40"]
[Site "CCRL"]
[Date "2006.03.07"]
[Round "12.1.635"]
[White "Gandalf 6"]
[Black "Chess Tiger 2004"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C29"]
[Opening "Vienna gambit"]
[Variation "Breyer variation"]
[PlyCount "161"]
[WhiteElo "2632"]
[BlackElo "2600"]

1. e4 {+0.00/1 0s} e5 {+0.00/1 0s} 2. Nc3 {+0.00/1 0s} Nf6 {+0.00/1 0s} 3. f4
{+0.00/1 0s} d5 {+0.00/1 0s} 4. fxe5 {+0.00/1 0s} Nxe4 {+0.00/1 0s} 5. Nf3
{+0.00/1 0s} Be7 {+0.00/1 0s} 6. d4 {+0.00/1 0s} O-O {+0.00/1 0s} 7. Bd3
{+0.00/1 0s} f5 {+0.00/1 0s} 8. exf6 {+0.12/13 190s} Bxf6 {+0.00/1 0s} 9. O-O
{+0.00/1 0s} Nc6 {+0.00/1 0s} 10. Be3 {+0.00/1 0s} Bf5 {+0.00/1 0s} 11. Qe1
{+0.00/1 0s} Bg6 {+0.00/1 0s} 12. Nd2 {-0.09/13 225s} Nxc3 {-0.16/16 105s} 13.
bxc3 {-0.22/14 90s} Bxd3 {-0.20/17 202s} 14. cxd3 {-0.03/14 21s} Qd6 {-0.16/15
100s} 15. Nf3 {+0.00/15 165s} Rf7 {-0.14/16 100s} 16. Bf2 {-0.06/14 69s} Raf8
{-0.24/17 105s} 17. Bg3 {+0.06/14 109s} Qa3 {-0.16/17 199s} 18. Qc1 {+0.00/13
62s} Qa5 {-0.30/16 97s} 19. Qb2 {+0.12/12 72s} Ne7 {-0.26/16 96s} 20. Ne5
{+0.32/13 81s} Bxe5 {-0.28/15 23s} 21. dxe5 {+0.22/13 249s} Nf5 {+0.00/15 151s}
22. Bf2 {+0.38/13 73s} b6 {+0.02/15 152s} 23. Rae1 {+0.41/14 77s} Qa4 {+0.14/15
197s} 24. Qe2 {+0.41/13 77s} Qe8 {+0.15/16 148s} 25. g4 {+0.41/16 86s} Ne7
{-0.04/17 101s} 26. e6 {+0.48/16 81s} Rf6 {-0.10/18 168s} 27. Bg3 {+0.48/15
100s} Rxf1+ {-0.12/18 77s} 28. Rxf1 {+0.48/14 20s} Rxf1+ {+0.00/18 81s} 29.
Kxf1 {+0.38/16 120s} Ng6 {+0.04/17 129s} 30. Bxc7 {+0.32/15 82s} Qe7 {+0.16/16
71s} 31. Bg3 {+0.38/15 70s} Nf8 {+0.17/16 83s} 32. Bf2 {+0.25/15 261s} Qxe6
{+0.02/17 150s} 33. Qxe6+ {+0.25/14 51s} Nxe6 {+0.06/16 10s} 34. Ke2 {+0.16/17
71s} Kf7 {+0.10/18 70s} 35. h4 {+0.16/16 67s} Nd8 {+0.06/18 70s} 36. c4
{+0.12/15 48s} dxc4 {-0.02/19 70s} 37. dxc4 {+0.16/17 116s} Nc6 {-0.14/19 70s}
38. c5 {+0.16/17 88s} bxc5 {-0.16/19 70s} 39. Bxc5 {+0.19/16 94s} Ke6 {+0.06/19
70s} 40. Ke3 {+0.12/17 49s} Kd5 {+0.00/20 70s} 41. Ba3 {+0.00/21 1182s} Ne5
{+0.00/19 69s} 42. Kf4 {+0.00/21 1034s} Ng6+ {+0.02/21 192s} 43. Kg5 {+0.00/22
776s} Ke4 {+0.00/23 75s} 44. Bb2 {+0.00/19 7s} Ne5 {+0.00/24 75s} 45. Kh5
{+0.00/18 8s} Kf4 {+0.00/23 81s} 46. g5 {+0.00/17 6s} Ke4 {+0.04/22 75s} 47. a4
{+0.00/17 7s} Kf5 {+0.00/24 75s} 48. Bc3 {+0.00/17 8s} g6+ {+0.00/24 75s} 49.
Kh6 {+0.22/6 0s} Nf3 {-0.90/26 135s} 50. Kxh7 {+0.00/18 28s} Nxh4 {-0.78/26
70s} 51. Bd4 {-0.03/17 6s} a6 {-0.92/26 145s} 52. Bf6 {-0.09/17 5s} Nf3
{-1.04/25 84s} 53. Kh6 {-0.06/18 6s} Nd2 {-0.12/24 71s} 54. Bd8 {-0.06/18 6s}
Ne4 {-1.62/26 134s} 55. Be7 {+0.00/19 9s} Nc3 {-0.50/26 394s} 56. Bf6 {+0.00/19
6s} Ne2 {-0.14/26 122s} 57. Bg7 {+0.00/19 6s} Ng3 {-0.62/26 51s} 58. Bf6
{+0.00/19 6s} Nf1 {-0.10/26 57s} 59. Kg7 {+0.00/20 9s} Nd2 {-0.12/25 52s} 60.
Bd8 {+0.00/19 7s} Ne4 {-1.10/25 75s} 61. Kh6 {+0.00/19 6s} Nc5 {-0.04/24 47s}
62. Bf6 {+0.00/19 6s} Nb7 {-0.21/25 91s} 63. Be7 {+0.00/20 5s} Na5 {-0.12/27
59s} 64. Bd6 {+0.00/19 3s} Nc4 {-1.48/25 63s} 65. Be7 {+0.00/20 9s} Nb6
{-0.04/26 237s} 66. Bf6 {+0.00/19 5s} Nd5 {-0.04/25 36s} 67. Bd4 {+0.00/19 6s}
Nf4 {-0.04/24 36s} 68. Bc5 {+0.00/19 7s} Ne2 {-0.04/24 40s} 69. Be3 {+0.00/19
6s} Nc3 {-2.64/24 54s} 70. Bb6 {+0.00/20 9s} Na2 {-0.06/25 33s} 71. Ba5
{+0.00/20 5s} Nc1 {-0.06/27 33s} 72. Bc3 {+0.00/19 3s} Nb3 {-0.08/26 33s} 73.
Bb2 {+0.00/19 4s} Nd2 {-0.96/27 34s} 74. Bf6 {+0.00/20 5s} Nf3 {-0.06/25 39s}
75. Bd8 {+0.00/18 3s} Ne5 {-0.50/24 30s} 76. Kg7 {+0.00/19 4s} Nd3 {-0.19/24
36s} 77. Kh6 {+0.00/19 10s} Nb2 {-0.14/24 30s} 78. a5 {+0.00/20 3s} Nc4
{-0.06/25 33s} 79. Kg7 {+0.00/20 5s} Ne5 {-0.04/24 39s} 80. Kf8 {+0.00/19 2s}
Ke6 {+0.00/24 30s Game aborted due game timeout} 81. Ke8 {+0.00/28 1201s Draw !
Insufficient material.} 1/2-1/2

[Event "CCRL 40/40"]
[Site "CCRL"]
[Date "2009.08.05"]
[Round "192.1.3"]
[White "WChess 1.06"]
[Black "Averno 0.81"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D11"]
[Opening "QGD Slav"]
[Variation "3.Nf3"]
[PlyCount "201"]
[WhiteElo "2339"]
[BlackElo "2317"]

1. Nf3 d5 2. d4 c6 3. c4 e6 4. e3 Bd6 5. Bd3 f5 6. O-O Nf6 7. b3 Qe7 8. Bb2 O-O
9. Qc1 b6 10. Ba3 Bb7 11. cxd5 cxd5 12. Bxd6 Qxd6 13. Qa3 {(Qa3) +0.46/12 48s}
Qxa3 {(d6a3) -0.01/14 49s} 14. Nxa3 {(Nxa3) +0.34/12 17s} a6 {(a7a6) -0.01/ 14
51s} 15. Rac1 {(Rac1) +0.03/12 42s} Nc6 {(b8c6) +0.05/13 48s} 16. Ng5 {(Ng5)
+0.19/12 49s} Rae8 {(a8e8) +0.06/13 51s} 17. f4 {(f4) +0.07/11 33s} h6 {(h7h6)
+0.18/14 36s} 18. Nf3 {(Nf3) -0.03/12 34s} Rc8 {(e8c8) +0.22/14 46s} 19. Ne5
{(Ne5) +0.11/12 52s} Nxe5 {(c6e5) +0.26/1552} 20. fxe5 {(fxe5) +0.11/14 51s}
Ng4 {(f6g4) +0.22/15 47s} 21. Rxc8 {(Rxc8) +0.30/14 51s} Rxc8 {(f8c8)
+0.21/1649} 22. Nc2 {(Nc2) +0.46/14 50s} Rc3 {(c8c3) +0.21/15 35s} 23. Rd1
{(Rd1) +0.30/14 50s} h5 {(h6h5) +0.21/ 15 54s} 24. h3 {(h3) +0.80/13 32s} Nh6
{(g4h6) +0.22/1433} 25. Kf2 {(Kf2) +0.65/13 52s} Nf7 {(h6f7) +0.19/13 40s} 26.
h4 {(h4) +0.69/12 35s} Nh6 {(f7h6) +0.10/13 42s} 27. Ke2 {(Ke2) +0.88/13 47s}
Ng4 {(h6g4) +0.00/14 57s} 28. Rc1 {(Rc1) +0.84/13 54s} a5 {(a6a5) +0.20/14 57s}
29. Kd2 {(Kd2) +0.84/13 52s} Rc8 {(c3c8) +0.21/14 57s} 30. Rf1 {(Rf1) +0.84/13
53s} Nh2 {(g4h2) +0.00/14 57s} 31. Rb1 {(Rb1) +0.96/14 53s} Ng4 {(h2g4)
-0.04/13 38s} 32. b4 {(b4) +1.03/13 53s} a4 {(a5a4) -0.08/14 59s} 33. Rc1
{(Rc1) +1.38/13 55s} Nf2 {(g4f2) -0.30/14 75s} 34. Bb5 {(Bb5) +1.26/14 53s} Rc7
{(c8c7) -0.24/14 57s} 35. Bxa4 {(Bxa4) +1.30/14 53s} Ne4+ {(f2e4) -0.30/15 57s}
36. Ke1 {(Ke1) +1.34/14 52s} Ba6 {(b7a6) -0. +0.21/16 57s} 37. b5 {(b5)
+0.96/15 52s} Bc8 {(a6c8) +0.00/15 42s} 38. Bb3 {(Bb3) +0.46/14 45s} Rc3
{(c7c3) +0.00/15 32s} 39. Rb1 {(Rb1) +0.30/14 55s} Rd3 {(c3d3) +0.00/15 70s}
40. Rd1 {(Rd1) +0.42/14 55s} Rc3 {(d3c3) +0.00/14 8s} 41. Ke2 {(Ke2) +0.30/14
39s} Bd7 {(c8d7) +0.15/ 15 96s} 42. Na3 {(Na3) +0.38/13 24s} Rc7 {(c3c7)
+0.17/14 52s} 43. Kf3 {(Kf3) +0.53/13 39s} Ra7 {(c7a7) +0. +0.19/14 68s} 44.
Nb1 {(Nb1) +0.50/13 31s} Bxb5 {(d7b5) +0.20/14 73s} 45. Rc1 {(Rc1) +0.53/13
39s} Kf7 {(g8f7) +0.23/14 78s} 46. Kf4 {(Kf4) +0.73/13 39s} Kg6 {(f7g6)
+0.21/14 74s} 47. Nc3 {(Nc3) +0.65/13 37s} Rc7 {(a7c7) +0.21/15 64s} 48. Ne2
{(Ne2) +0.61/14 40s} Rxc1 {(c7c1) +0.21/14 66s} 49. Nxc1 {(Nxc1) +0.61/14 14s}
Nc3 {(e4c3) +0.16/14 54s} 50. Bc2 {(Bc2) +0.61/15 36s} Bc4 {(b5c4) +0.16/14
38s} 51. a3 {(a3) +0.61/15 39s} Bf1 {(c4f1) +0.17/14 68s} 52. Kf3 {(Kf3)
+0.61/15 33s} Kf7 {(g6f7) +0.19/13 61s} 53. Nb3 {(Nb3) +0.57/15 40s} Be2+
{(f1e2) +0.30/14 59s} 54. Kf2 {(Kf2) +0.57/15 40s} Bd1 {(e2d1) +0.39/13 30s}
55. Bxd1 {(Bxd1) +0.69/17 40s} Nxd1+ {(c3d1) +0.39/12 14s} 56. Ke2 {(Ke2)
+0.23/18 43s} Nb2 {(d1b2) +0.39/14 66s} 57. Na1 {(Na1) +0.07/17 37s} Nc4
{(b2c4) +0.42/14 47s} 58. Nc2 {(Nc2) +0.03/17 40s} g6 {(g7g6) +0.42/14 55s} 59.
Ke1 {(Ke1) +0.00/17 40s} g5 {(g6g5) +0.48/13 27s} 60. g3 {(g3) +0.19/17 40s} g4
{(g5g4) +0.48/13 44s} 61. Ke2 {(Ke2) +0.00/18 40s} b5 {(b6b5) +0.48/14 44s} 62.
Kd3 {(Kd3) +0.00/18 28s} Ke7 {(f7e7) +0.60/14 40s} 63. Kc3 {(Kc3) -0.03/18 41s}
Kd7 {(e7d7) +0.39/14 46s} 64. Kd3 {(Kd3) +0.00/17 25s} Ke8 {(d7e8) +0.33/13
27s} 65. Ke2 {(Ke2) +0.00/18 26s} Kf8 {(e8f8) +0.33/14 29s} 66. Ke1 {(Ke1)
+0.00/18 32s} Ke7 {(f8e7) +0.39/13 17s} 67. Ke2 {(Ke2) -0.03/18 39s} Kd8
{(e7d8) +0.39/14 25s} 68. Kd1 {(Kd1) -0.03/18 42s} Kc8 {(d8c8) +0.39/13 12s}
69. Ke2 {(Ke2) +0.00/18 42s} Kc7 {(c8c7) +0.39/13 20s} 70. Kd3 {(Kd3) +0.00/17
35s} Nb2+ {(c4b2) +0.30/13 20s} 71. Kd2 {(Kd2) +0.00/18 43s} Kd7 {(c7d7)
+0.33/13 17s} 72. Ke1 {(Ke1) +0.00/18 27s} Nc4 {(b2c4) +0.30/14 16s} 73. Ke2
{(Ke2) +0.00/18 33s} Ke8 {(d7e8) +0.30/13 8s} 74. Kd3 {(Kd3) +0.00/18 35s} Nb2+
{(c4b2) +0.30/13 14s} 75. Kc3 {(Kc3) +0.53/19 28s} Nd1+ {(b2d1) +0.45/14 11s}
76. Kb4 {(Kb4) +0.42/19 49s} Kd7 {(e8d7) +0.25/14 12s} 77. Kxb5 {(Kxb5)
+0.57/18 50s} Kc7 {(d7c7) +0.00/14 24s} 78. Kb4 {(Kb4) +0.69/18 55s} Nf2
{(d1f2) -0.04/148} 79. Ne1 {(Ne1) +0.50/18 48s} Ne4 {(f2e4) -0.10/13 5s} 80.
Ng2 {(Ng2) +1.46/17 73s} Kd7 {(c7d7) -0.07/12 6s} 81. Nf4 {(Nf4) +1.53/17 37s}
Nxg3 {(e4g3) +0.00/15591} 82. Kc3 {(Kc3) +0.88/16 38s} Nf1 {(g3f1) +0.12/14
79s} 83. Kd3 {(Kd3) +1.03/16 30s} Nh2 {(f1h2) +0.21/14 82s} 84. a4 {(a4)
+1.03/16 27s} Nf3 {(h2f3) -0.03/14 74s} 85. Ke2 {(Ke2) +1.07/15 38s} Ng1+
{(f3g1) -1.02/14 340s} 86. Kf2 {(Kf2) +2.26/17 47s} Nf3 {(g1f3) -1.38/14 37s}
87. Kg3 {(Kg3) +2.26/16 37s} Nd2 {(f3d2) -1.80/14 168s} 88. Nxh5 {(Nxh5)
+2.84/15 27s} Ne4+ {(d2e4) -1.75/13 92s} 89. Kg2 {(Kg2) +3.65/16 34s} Nc3
{(e4c3) -2.25/13 50s} 90. Nf4 {(Nf4) +3.96/16 38s} Nxa4 {(c3a4) -2.25/12 5s}
91. h5 {(h5) +5.15/16 40s} Ke7 {(d7e7) -3.80/13 24s} 92. Nxe6 {(Nxe6) +5.53/16
38s} Kf7 {(e7f7) -4.75/ 12 13s} 93. Nc7 {(Nc7) +5.96/15 42s} Nb6 {(a4b6)
-3.25/9 1s} 94. e6+ {(e6+) +6.65/15 38s} Kf6 {(f7f6) -4.20/11 6s} 95. Ne8+
{(Ne8+) +7.69/16 25s} Kg5 {(f6g5) -5.45/11 3s} 96. Nd6 {(Nd6) +8.34/17 25s} Kf6
{(g5f6) -6.40/10 1s} 97. h6 {(h6) +8.50/16 32s} Kxe6 {(f6e6) -6.40/9 1s} 98.
Ne8 {(Ne8) +8.38/15 21s} Kf7 {(e6f7) -6.40/8 1s} 99. h7 {(h7) +9.26/15 23s}
Kxe8 {(f7e8) -7.40/8 1s} 100. h8=Q+ {(h8Q+) +9.19/14 40s 1-0 Black forfeits on
time} Kd7 {(e8d7) -7.40/7 0s} 101. Qf6 {(Qf6) +9.53/13 23s} 1-0

[Graham Banks]

Hi Graham,

I was checking the 40/40 database and I came upon these two old games with abnormal terminations. One game was aborted for insufficient material when there was sufficient material, and the other game ended due to a time forfeit. In these two games, the results were fair. But allowing games into your database with abnormal terminations opens the door to having games with unfair results.

best,
Norm

Thanks Norm.
I'll draw these to Ray's attention.

The first needs to be scrapped altogether.
The second can be edited to a White win.