Survival of the Fittest 3

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderator: Ras

enhorning
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 10:05 pm

Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by enhorning »

These contestants enter - the ones at the bottom after 420 games will get knocked out and not be part of the next tournament.

Code: Select all

Rating Program - version - cores
2686   Toga II 3.0 [4c]
2682   Hiarcs 14 [1c]
2662   Quazar 0.4 [1c]
2626   Crafty 23.6 [4c]
2621   MinkoChess 1.3 [4c]
2620   Scorpio 2.7.6 JA [4c]
2620   Glaurung 2.2 [4c]
2607   Boot 5.2.0 [1c]
2604   Tornado 4.88 [4c]
2596   OctoChess r5190 [4c]
2595   Doch 1.3.4 JA [1c]
2586   Thinker 5.4d Passive [4c]
2585   Murka 3 [1c]
2575   ExChess 7.18 [4c]
2565   Texel 1.02 [1c]
2549   Gaviota 0.86 [4c]
2540   Arasan 16.2 [4c]
2511   DiscoCheck 5.0 [1c]
2477   GnuChess 5.50 [1c]
2465   Twisted Logic 20100131x [1c]
2455   Bison 9.11 [1c]
The eight newcomers are Hiarcs 14 (on only 1 core, just because it's one of my favourite programs, so I'm going to allow it both a 1-core and 4-core version over time), Doch 1.3.4 JA, Thinker 5.4d Passive (Active didn't fare very well - let's see if Passive can do better), Arasan 16.2 (16.1 get knocked out in the first tournament, scoring 18/40, just a couple of points below the 50% limit), DiscoCheck 5.0, GnuChess 5.50, Twisted Logic 20100131x, and Bison 9.11.

The tournament is a double round robin (420 games total), and time Control will be 6 minutes + 4 seconds increment / move. The programs that support multiple cores are allowed to use 4 cores out of my 6 available. Hash is set fairly low - only 256 MB - for the same reason that 2 cores are unused: so that me using the computer while games are running won't interfere with the engines.

5 men Gaviota, Nalimov, Scorpio and 4 men Shredder TBs/BBs are installed and enabled for the programs that support them (except Minkochess, which often forfeited on time once a TB position was on the actual board).

I am using a file containing about 60 short openings (max 8 plies, but often shorter): https://www.dropbox.com/s/ft3oee8fubdp3 ... ariety.pgn - this file was created by taking lines that were played in at least 0.5% of games between 2600+ players (using the ChessTempo database), and for which Aquarium's CAP evaluation was within [0.00 - 0.22], i.e. up to 3 steps away from the root value. So, my hope is that this would give lines that are playable both according to human and engine opinion.

Suggestion for programs to include in future tournaments are always welcome :)4c
Top
User avatar
michiguel
Posts: 6401
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 8:30 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois, USA

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by michiguel »

enhorning wrote:These contestants enter - the ones at the bottom after 420 games will get knocked out and not be part of the next tournament.

Code: Select all

Rating Program - version - cores
2686   Toga II 3.0 [4c]
2682   Hiarcs 14 [1c]
2662   Quazar 0.4 [1c]
2626   Crafty 23.6 [4c]
2621   MinkoChess 1.3 [4c]
2620   Scorpio 2.7.6 JA [4c]
2620   Glaurung 2.2 [4c]
2607   Boot 5.2.0 [1c]
2604   Tornado 4.88 [4c]
2596   OctoChess r5190 [4c]
2595   Doch 1.3.4 JA [1c]
2586   Thinker 5.4d Passive [4c]
2585   Murka 3 [1c]
2575   ExChess 7.18 [4c]
2565   Texel 1.02 [1c]
2549   Gaviota 0.86 [4c]
2540   Arasan 16.2 [4c]
2511   DiscoCheck 5.0 [1c]
2477   GnuChess 5.50 [1c]
2465   Twisted Logic 20100131x [1c]
2455   Bison 9.11 [1c]
The eight newcomers are Hiarcs 14 (on only 1 core, just because it's one of my favourite programs, so I'm going to allow it both a 1-core and 4-core version over time), Doch 1.3.4 JA, Thinker 5.4d Passive (Active didn't fare very well - let's see if Passive can do better), Arasan 16.2 (16.1 get knocked out in the first tournament, scoring 18/40, just a couple of points below the 50% limit), DiscoCheck 5.0, GnuChess 5.50, Twisted Logic 20100131x, and Bison 9.11.

The tournament is a double round robin (420 games total), and time Control will be 6 minutes + 4 seconds increment / move. The programs that support multiple cores are allowed to use 4 cores out of my 6 available. Hash is set fairly low - only 256 MB - for the same reason that 2 cores are unused: so that me using the computer while games are running won't interfere with the engines.

5 men Gaviota, Nalimov, Scorpio and 4 men Shredder TBs/BBs are installed and enabled for the programs that support them (except Minkochess, which often forfeited on time once a TB position was on the actual board).

I am using a file containing about 60 short openings (max 8 plies, but often shorter): https://www.dropbox.com/s/ft3oee8fubdp3 ... ariety.pgn - this file was created by taking lines that were played in at least 0.5% of games between 2600+ players (using the ChessTempo database), and for which Aquarium's CAP evaluation was within [0.00 - 0.22], i.e. up to 3 steps away from the root value. So, my hope is that this would give lines that are playable both according to human and engine opinion.

Suggestion for programs to include in future tournaments are always welcome :)4c
Will Gaviota be able to get again 50%? :-)
Less and less likely...

Miguel
Top
jdart
Posts: 4423
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 5:23 am
Location: http://www.arasanchess.org

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by jdart »

Crafty 23.7 is up on Bob's site now, although only as source I think.

--Jon
Top
enhorning
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 10:05 pm

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by enhorning »

jdart wrote:Crafty 23.7 is up on Bob's site now, although only as source I think.
If somebody makes a windows 64-bit compile, I could add that for the next tournament.

I use http://www.computer-chess.org/doku.php? ... ngine_list to try to keep track of engine updates, but that isn't listing this new Crafty yet. I can't even get through to the crafty ftp site to look at the change log.
Top
jdart
Posts: 4423
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 5:23 am
Location: http://www.arasanchess.org

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by jdart »

Try http:

http://www.cis.uab.edu/hyatt/crafty/source/

--Jon
Top
enhorning
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 10:05 pm

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by enhorning »

Early results after 62 games:

Code: Select all

    Engine                       Score QuBoGaMuToHiOcGnExDoMiToArScCrThBiGlDiTwTe    S-B
01: Quazar 0.4 [1c]              5.0/6 · 1 0       1   1             1     1       15.00
02: Booot 5.2.0 [1c]             4.0/6 0 ·   1 1         = 1             =         12.25
03: Gaviota 0.86 [4c]            4.0/6 1   ·           1   0 0             1 1     11.50
04: Murka 3 [1c]                 3.5/7   0   ·   1   0         0 1 =   1           10.25
04: Tornado 4.88 [4c]            3.5/6   0     · = =             1 1 =             10.25
06: Hiarcs14 [1c]                3.5/6       0 = ·   1   0     1               1    9.25
06: Octochess r5190 [4c]         3.5/6 0       =   ·     0 1 1           1          9.25
08: Gnuchess 5.50 [1c]           3.5/5       1   0   ·         1       =       1    8.75
09: ExChess 7.18 [4c]            3.5/7 0   0           ·   0 1           1 = 1      6.75
10: Doch 1.34 JA [1c]            3.0/6   =       1 1     ·       = 0   0           10.50
11: MinkoChess 1.3 [4c]          3.0/6   0 1       0   1   ·     =   =             10.25
12: Toga II 3.0 [4c]             3.0/6     1       0   0     ·       =     = 1      7.50
13: Arasan 16.2 [4c]             3.0/6       1   0   0         ·   0   1       1    7.00
14: Scorpio 2.7.6 [4c]           3.0/6       0 0         = =     ·       1     1    5.50
15: Crafty 23.6 [4c]             2.5/5       = 0         1     1   ·           0    7.75
16: Thinker 5.4d Passive [4c]    2.5/7 0       =           = =       ·   0 = =      6.25
17: Bison 9.11 w32               2.5/5       0       =   1     0       ·       1    5.75
18: Glaurung 2.2 [4c]            1.5/5   =         0   0         0   1   ·          4.50
18: DiscoCheck 5.0.1 [1c]        1.5/6 0   0           =     =       =     · 0      4.50
20: Twisted Logic 20100131x [1c] 1.5/5     0           0     0       =     1 ·      2.75
21: Texel 1.02 [1c]              1.0/6           0   0         0 0 1   0       ·    2.50

62 of 420 games played
PGN can be downloaded from: https://www.dropbox.com/s/wj6ogzz6xa4xo ... al%203.pgn
Top
enhorning
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 10:05 pm

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by enhorning »

Standings after 100 games (23.8% through):

Code: Select all

Survival 3
Rank Engine                     Rating  Score   %     Qu Mi To Bo Cr Do Oc Hi Ex Gl Ga Sc To Gn Mu Ar Th Di Tw Te Bi  S-B
01   Quazar 0.4 [1c]              2662  8.5/10  85.0  ·        1  =     1  1  1     0  1              1  1        1   37.25 
02   MinkoChess 1.3 [4c]          2621  7.0/10  70.0     ·     0  1     0  1  1     1  =     1        =           1   31.00 
03   Tornado 4.88 [4c]            2604  6.0/10  60.0        ·  0  1     =  =           1     0     1  =        =  1   24.75 
04   Booot 5.2.0 [1c]             2607  5.5/10  55.0  0  1  1  ·     =           =  =     =     1        =  0         28.50 
05   Crafty 23.6 [4c]             2626  5.5/10  55.0  =  0  0     ·  1           =        1     =  1        1  0      26.25 
06   Doch 1.34 JA [1c]            2595  5.5/10  55.0           =  0  ·  1  1           =     1  =  =           =  0   25.00 
07   Octochess r5190 [4c]         2596  5.0/10  50.0  0  1  =        0  ·     =  1  1     1              0  0         26.50 
08   Hiarcs14 [1c]                2682  5.0/10  50.0  0  0  =        0     ·     =        1  1  0  1           1      21.50 
09   ExChess 7.18 [4c]            2575  5.0/9   55.5  0  0              =     ·  1  0     1           1  =  1         20.75 
10   Glaurung 2.2 [4c]            2620  5.0/10  50.0           =  =     0  =  0  ·     0     1     =  1           1   20.50 
11   Gaviota 0.86 [4c]            2549  4.5/9   50.0  1  0     =        0     1     ·     0           0  1  1         23.25 
12   Scorpio 2.7.6 [4c]           2620  4.5/10  45.0  0  =  0        =           1     ·  0     0        =  1  1      19.50 
13   Toga II 3.0 [4c]             2686  4.5/10  45.0           =  0     0  0  0     1  1  ·           =  =  1         18.75 
14   Gnuchess 5.50 [1c]           2477  4.5/9   50.0     0  1        0     0     0           ·  1  1           1  =   18.25 
15   Murka 3 [1c]                 2585  4.0/9   44.4           0  =  =     1           1     0  ·  0           0  1   17.50 
16   Arasan 16.2 [4c]             2540  4.0/9   44.4        0     0  =     0     =           0  1  ·           1  1   14.75 
17   Thinker 5.4d Passive [4c]    2586  3.5/9   38.8  0  =  =                 0  0  1     =           ·  =  =         16.75 
18   DiscoCheck 5.0.1 [1c]        2511  3.5/9   38.8  0        =        1     =     0  =  =           =  ·  0         16.50 
19   Twisted Logic 20100131x [1c] 2465  3.5/9   38.8           1  0     1     0     0  0  0           =  1  ·         15.75 
20   Texel 1.02 [1c]              2565  3.0/9   33.3        =     1  =     0           0     0  1  0           ·  0   15.25 
21   Bison 9.11 [1c]              2455  2.5/9   27.7  0  0  0        1           0           =  0  0           1  ·   10.75 

100 of 420 games played
Pgn can be downloaded from: https://www.dropbox.com/s/wj6ogzz6xa4xo ... al%203.pgn
Top
enhorning
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 10:05 pm

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by enhorning »

Standings after 160 games (38.1%) out of 420:

Code: Select all

    Engine                       Score  QuMiHiToGaCrDoBoScTwThToGnArOcGlDiExTeMuBi    S-B
01: Quazar 0.4 [1c]              12.5/16 ·   1 0 0 = = 1 1   1   1 1 1   1 1 1 = 1   86.00
02: MinkoChess 1.3 [4c]          11.5/16   · 1 1 1 1 0 0 =   =   1 1 0 1   1 1 = 1   82.50
03: Hiarcs14 [1c]                10.0/16 0 0 · = 0   0     1 1 1 1 1 1 = 1 1 1 0     69.00
04: Tornado 4.88 [4c]            9.5/15  1 0 = ·   1 1 0 1   =   0 1 = 1     = = 1   70.50
05: Gaviota 0.86 [4c]            8.5/15  1 0 1   · =   = = 1 0 0 1 0 0   1 1     1   65.00
06: Crafty 23.6 [4c]             8.5/16  = 0   0 = · 1 =   1 0 1   1 = = = 1 0 =     63.00
07: Doch 1.34 JA [1c]            8.0/15  = 1 1 0   0 · = =     = 1 = 1 =     = = 0   65.00
08: Booot 5.2.0 [1c]             8.0/15  0 1   1 = = = · = 0 0 =     1 = = =   1     62.50
09: Scorpio 2.7.6 [4c]           7.5/15  0 =   0 =   = = · 1 0 0     1 1 = 1 1 0     54.25
10: Twisted Logic 20100131x [1c] 7.5/15      0   0 0   1 0 · = 0 1 = 1   1 0 = 1 1   46.50
11: Thinker 5.4d Passive [4c]    7.0/15  0 = 0 = 1 1   1 1 = · =     0 0 = 0     =   55.00
12: Toga II 3.0 [4c]             7.0/16      0   1 0 = = 1 1 = · 0 0 0   = 0 0 1 1   46.75
13: Gnuchess 5.50 [1c]           7.0/15  0 0 0 1 0   0     0   1 · 1   0 = 1 1 1 =   46.25
14: Arasan 16.2 [4c]             7.0/15  0 0 0 0 1 0 =     =   1 0 ·   = =   1 1 1   44.25
15: Octochess r5190 [4c]         6.5/15  0 1 0 = 1 = 0 0 0 0 1 1     · 1 0 =         52.75
16: Glaurung 2.2 [4c]            6.5/15    0 = 0   = = = 0   1   1 = 0 ·   0 0 1 1   43.25
17: DiscoCheck 5.0.1 [1c]        6.5/15  0   0   0 =   = = 0 = = = = 1   · = =   1   41.75
18: ExChess 7.18 [4c]            6.5/15  0 0 0   0 0   = 0 1 1 1 0   = 1 = ·     1   41.50
19: Texel 1.02 [1c]              6.0/15  0 0 0 =   1 =   0 =   1 0 0   1 =   · 1 0   43.25
20: Murka 3 [1c]                 5.5/15  = = 1 =   = = 0 1 0   0 0 0   0     0 · 1   45.50
21: Bison 9.11 [1c]              3.0/15  0 0   0 0   1     0 = 0 = 0   0 0 0 1 0 ·   21.00

160 of 420 games played
PGN-file can be downloaded from: https://www.dropbox.com/s/wj6ogzz6xa4xo ... al%203.pgn
Top
enhorning
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 10:05 pm

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by enhorning »

Standings at the half-way point, 210 games out of 420:

Code: Select all

    Engine                       Score  QuMiGaHiCrBoDoToScExToGnTwThTeMuArOcGlDiBi    S-B
01: Quazar 0.4 [1c]              15.5/20 · = 0 1 = 1 = 0 1 1 = 1 1 1 1 = 1 1 1 1 1  144.00
02: MinkoChess 1.3 [4c]          13.0/20 = · 1 1 1 0 0 1 = 1 = 1 0 = 1 = 1 0 1 = 1  126.50
03: Gaviota 0.86 [4c]            12.5/20 1 0 · 1 = = 1 1 = 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1  123.25
04: Hiarcs14 [1c]                12.0/20 0 0 0 · = = 0 = 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 = 1 1  106.00
05: Crafty 23.6 [4c]             11.5/20 = 0 = = · = 1 0 1 1 1 = 1 0 0 = 1 = = = 1  109.75
06: Booot 5.2.0 [1c]             11.5/20 0 1 = = = · = 1 = = = = 0 0 = 1 1 1 = = 1  108.25
07: Doch 1.34 JA [1c]            11.0/20 = 1 0 1 0 = · 0 = = = 1 = 1 = = = 1 = 1 0  110.25
08: Tornado 4.88 [4c]            11.0/20 1 0 0 = 1 0 1 · 1 0 0 0 = = = = 1 = 1 1 1  103.50
09: Scorpio 2.7.6 [4c]           10.5/20 0 = = 1 0 = = 0 · 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 = 1   96.25
10: ExChess 7.18 [4c]            10.5/20 0 0 0 0 0 = = 1 0 · 1 0 1 1 = 1 1 = 1 = 1   91.00
11: Toga II 3.0 [4c]             10.0/20 = = 1 0 0 = = 1 1 0 · 0 1 = 0 1 0 0 1 = 1   96.75
12: Gnuchess 5.50 [1c]           10.0/20 0 0 0 0 = = 0 1 1 1 1 · 0 0 1 1 1 1 0 = =   92.75
13: Twisted Logic 20100131x [1c] 9.5/20  0 1 0 0 0 1 = = 0 0 0 1 · = = 1 = 1 0 1 1   85.75
14: Thinker 5.4d Passive [4c]    9.0/20  0 = 1 0 1 1 0 = 1 0 = 1 = · 1 0 0 0 0 = =   92.00
15: Texel 1.02 [1c]              9.0/20  0 0 1 0 1 = = = 0 = 1 0 = 0 · 1 0 1 1 = 0   89.00
16: Murka 3 [1c]                 8.5/20  = = 0 1 = 0 = = 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 · 0 1 0 1 1   81.00
17: Arasan 16.2 [4c]             8.5/20  0 0 1 0 0 0 = 0 0 0 1 0 = 1 1 1 · = = = 1   74.00
18: Octochess r5190 [4c]         8.0/20  0 1 1 0 = 0 0 = 0 = 1 0 0 1 0 0 = · 1 0 1   76.25
19: Glaurung 2.2 [4c]            8.0/20  0 0 0 = = = = 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 = 0 · = 1   71.00
20: DiscoCheck 5.0.1 [1c]        7.5/20  0 = 0 0 = = 0 0 = = = = 0 = = 0 = 1 = · 1   66.75
21: Bison 9.11 [1c]              3.0/20  0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 = 0 = 1 0 0 0 0 0 ·   29.50

210 of 420 games played
Toga is not doing well, compared to the first two rounds. Still, only half through the tournament, so a lot could change.

PGN with the games can be downloaded from: https://www.dropbox.com/s/wj6ogzz6xa4xo ... al%203.pgn

Accumulated bayeselo from my Survival tournaments:

Code: Select all

Rank Name                           Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws
   1 Quazar 0.4 [1c]               2764   57   57   100   71%  2600   27%
   2 Toga II 3.0 [4c]              2738   55   55   100   68%  2601   32%
   3 Hiarcs 14 [1c]                2721  121  121    20   60%  2643   20%
   4 Crafty 23.6 [4c]              2705   54   54   100   64%  2603   37%
   5 Scorpio 2.7.6 [4c]            2686   54   54   100   61%  2604   34%
   6 MinkoChess 1.3 [4c]           2686   53   53   100   61%  2604   42%
   7 Doch 1.34 JA [1c]             2685  110  110    20   55%  2645   50%
   8 Tornado 4.88 [4c]             2668   69   69    60   57%  2622   33%
   9 Booot 5.2.0 [1c]              2664   53   53   100   58%  2605   36%
  10 Octochess r5190 [4c]          2652   52   52   100   57%  2606   39%
  11 ExChess 7.18 [4c]             2648   55   55   100   56%  2606   28%
  12 Glaurung 2.2 [4c]             2647   68   68    60   53%  2623   33%
  13 Gnuchess 5.50 [1c]            2642  120  120    20   50%  2647   20%
  14 Murka 3 [1c]                  2642   54   54   100   55%  2606   33%
  15 Twisted Logic 20100131x [1c]  2629  118  118    20   48%  2648   25%
  16 Texel 1.02 [1c]               2627   54   54   100   53%  2607   29%
  17 Gaviota 0.86 [4c]             2620   55   55   100   53%  2607   27%
  18 Thinker 5.4d Passive [4c]     2613  118  118    20   45%  2649   30%
  19 Nemo 1.0.1 beta [1c]          2608   61   61    80   51%  2597   30%
  20 Arasan 16.2 [4c]              2594  117  117    20   43%  2650   25%
  21 Ice 1.0 v1619 [1c]            2586   85   85    40   46%  2614   28%
  22 DiscoCheck 5.0.1 [1c]         2579  108  108    20   38%  2651   55%
  23 BugChess2 1.9 [4c]            2566   61   61    80   46%  2599   26%
  24 Arasan 16.1 [4c]              2558   82   82    40   45%  2584   35%
  25 Fruit 2.3.1 [1c]              2554   83   83    40   46%  2585   38%
  26 Shredder Classic 4 [1c]       2541   83   83    40   44%  2585   38%
  27 Cheng4 0.35a [4c]             2530   88   88    40   38%  2617   25%
  28 Dirty 20Apr2013 [1c]          2512   83   83    40   34%  2618   43%
  29 Rodent 1.1 [1c]               2465   90   90    40   30%  2620   20%
  30 Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1 [1c]   2441   90   90    40   30%  2590   25%
  31 Thinker 5.4d Active [4c]      2439   89   89    40   25%  2621   30%
  32 Deuterium 13.1.31.113 [1c]    2427   87   87    40   28%  2591   30%
  33 Ruffian 1.05 [1c]             2425   88   88    40   26%  2591   33%
  34 NirvanaChess 1.2 [1c]         2414   92   92    40   23%  2623   25%
  35 Pro Deo 1.85 [1c]             2396   95   95    40   26%  2592   18%
  36 Bison 9.11 [1c]               2381  142  142    20   15%  2660   10%
  37 Jonny 4 [4c]                  2298  106  106    40   15%  2597   15%
Top
enhorning
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 10:05 pm

Re: Survival of the Fittest 3

Post by enhorning »

Standings after 320 games out of 420:

Code: Select all

    Engine                       Score   Qu Mi To Hi Ga Bo Cr Do Gn Sc Th Ex Te To Mu Ar Oc Di Tw Gl Bi    S-B
01: Quazar 0.4 [1c]              21.5/31 ·· =  =  1= 00 1= =1 =  10 11 10 11 1  0  =  1  11 10 1  1  11  305.75
02: MinkoChess 1.3 [4c]          20.0/31 =  ·· =  11 10 0= 11 0  1= =1 =1 1= 1  1  =  10 0= =  0  1  11  296.50
03: Toga II 3.0 [4c]             18.5/31 =  =  ·· 01 11 =1 01 =  0  1= =0 0= 0  1  1  0  01 == 11 1  11  262.50
04: Hiarcs 14 [1c]               18.5/31 0= 00 10 ·· 0  =  =  01 1= 0  1  1  11 =1 01 10 1  1  1= =1 1   261.50
05: Gaviota 0.86 [4c]            18.0/30 11 01 00 1  ·· =0 =  1  1  =0 0= 11 0  1  1  0  0= 11 1= 1  1   271.00
06: Booot 5.2.0 [1c]             17.5/31 0= 1= =0 =  =1 ·· =  =0 =  =  0  =0 =  11 1= 1  1  =1 01 == 1   255.50
07: Crafty 23.6 [4c]             17.5/31 =0 00 10 =  =  =  ·· 10 =  1  0  1  01 01 == 11 =  =1 11 == 1   245.25
08: Doch 1.34 JA [1c]            17.0/30 =  1  =  10 0  =1 01 ·· 11 =0 1  =  =0 0  =1 =0 11 1  =  =  01  253.50
09: Gnuchess 5.50 [1c]           17.0/30 01 0= 1  0= 0  =  =  00 ·· 1  0  1  11 11 1= 11 1  =  0  01 ==  248.00
10: Scorpio 2.7.6 [4c]           16.0/31 00 =0 0= 1  =1 =  0  =1 0  ·· 0  1  1= 01 00 1  1  == 1= 1= 1   227.25
11: Thinker 5.4d Passive [4c]    15.5/30 01 =0 =1 0  1= 1  1  0  1  1  ·· 01 1  == 0  0  01 == == 0= =   243.00
12: ExChess 7.18 [4c]            15.5/30 00 0= 1= 0  00 =1 0  =  0  0  10 ·· =  1  1  1  =0 =1 11 11 1   210.50
13: Texel 1.02 [1c]              15.0/30 0  0  1  00 1  =  10 =1 00 0= 0  =  ·· == 11 01 1  =  =  11 01  209.25
14: Tornado 4.88 [4c]            15.0/31 1  0  0  =0 0  00 10 1  00 10 == 0  == ·· =0 11 =1 1  =  1  11  200.25
15: Murka 3 [1c]                 13.5/30 =  =  0  10 0  0= == =0 0= 11 1  0  00 =1 ·· 01 1  1  0  0  1=  196.25
16: Arasan 16.2 [4c]             13.0/30 0  01 1  01 1  0  00 =1 00 0  1  0  10 00 10 ·· =  =  =  =1 1=  185.50
17: Octochess r5190 [4c]         12.0/31 00 1= 10 0  1= 0  =  00 0  0  10 =1 0  =0 0  =  ·· 00 01 11 1   175.00
18: DiscoCheck 5.0.1 [1c]        12.0/30 01 =  == 0  00 =0 =0 0  =  == == =0 =  0  0  =  11 ·· 01 =  1   174.75
19: Twisted Logic 20100131x [1c] 11.5/30 0  1  00 0= 0= 10 00 =  1  0= == 00 =  =  1  =  10 10 ·· 0  1   168.25
20: Glaurung 2.2 [4c]            11.0/31 0  0  0  =0 0  == == =  10 0= 1= 00 00 0  1  =0 00 =  1  ·· 11  147.50
21: Bison 9.11 [1c]              4.5/30  00 00 00 0  0  0  0  10 == 0  =  0  10 00 0= 0= 0  0  0  00 ··   70.00

320 of 420 games played
PGN-file with games can be downloaded from: https://www.dropbox.com/s/wj6ogzz6xa4xo ... al%203.pgn
Top

Return to “Computer Chess Club: Tournaments and Matches”